49TH CONGRESS,   HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES.         Ex. Doc. 1,
   2d ession.                                    Ipt. 2, vol. II.


                  ANNUAL REPORT

                              OF THE




CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,
                 UNITED STATES ARMY,


                              TO THE




        SECRETARY OF WAR,
                               FOR




                      THE YEAR 1886.




                 IN   THREE            PARTS.




                        PART           I.




                      WASHINGTON:
             GOVERNMENT       PRINTING OFFICE.
                              1886.
ERRATA FOR ANNUAL REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGI-
            NEERS, U. S. ARMY, FOR 1886.

Page 541.-Heading       Improvement of navigation in the Back Cove, Portsmouth
             Harbor, New Hampshire,          should read-             Improvement of navi-
             gation in the channel of Back Cove, Portland, Maine.
Page 555.-In estimate, fourth line, change          $2        to      $1
Page 1161.-First line, after the word       presumably,           insert        interested
Page 1165.-Fourth line   from bottom,  change        30   feet      to      80 feet
Page 1171.-Paragraph 2, first line change        1870        to      1876,
Page 1176.-Seventh line from bottom, change            4       to      5
Page 1208.-Fifteenth line from bottom, change             $15,154.83         to       $15,164.83.
Page 1230.-Third paragraph from bottom, third line, change                  those short crises
              to     three short rises
Page 1231.-Second table, 6th column, box heading,              29 feet        should be        26
              feet
             First table, 9th column, box heading               29 feet        should be        26
              feet
Page 1246.-Ending fourth paragraph       insert,      Major      Stickney    in   his  report  of
              1884, saying " the detailed plans for locks not being completed, no
              new estimate is presented, but it is probable that the cost of such
              locks as are deemed suitable for the work will increase the estimate
              somewhat."
Page 1252.-End of fourteenth line, change          0.0 feet       to       0.05 feet
            Fifteenth line, change       8.5      to      .85
            Twenty-first line, change 25        to      .25
Page 1257.-Last paragraph, second line, change             74.07       to      7,407
Page 1258.-Ninth line, change       feet     to      inch
Page 1263.-To follow improvement of bayou Courtableau, Louisiana, insert :
                    Appropriations for this work have been as follows:
                      June 14, 1880 .....---..............                    .....................            $7,500
                      March 3, 1881 ........................................                                    7,500
                      July 5, 1884........ .... .....                  ...... .... ..... .....      -   ....-- 4, 000

                                  To tal .-               ....---- -......-----
                                                  ------......     ---...... -....---- ......----.. ----....   19, 000.
Page 1267.-Fifth paragraph, third line, change       $100,00      to    $109,000;
Page 1274.-Fifth paragraph, second line, change          instrument    to      invest-
              ment.
Page 1277.-Fourth paragraph, eleventh line,       be subjected     should be       not
              subjected.
Page 1278.-Fourth paragraph, sixth line, change         188.40   to     10,840
            Eighth paragraph, seventh line, change          rest  to     crest
Page 1279.-Sixth paragraph, fourth line, change        664,364    to    66,436.4
Page 1283.-For last paragraph insert:
            Generally considered there has been a deepening since 1881 of from 1
              to 2J feet over the whole area between the jetties, the greatest scour
              having taken place in the deepest water. The improvement in depth
              has extended for a distance of 2,000 feet beyond the end of the east
              jetty, though to a less degree than within. Beyond this there is a
              small area where no change has occurred, while beyond this again
              there has been a shoaling of four-tenths of a foot in the line of the
              channel and out to a depth of 12 feet.
            Behind the west jetty the water has shoaled from 1 to 4 feet, the great-
              est shoaling being found near the shore. From a point 1,000 feet
              beyond the " Clifton " and between the new channel and the founda-
              tion of the west jetty, laid in 1883, there has been a shoaling which
              extends out to the 12-foot depth. The decrease in depth is greatest
              near the jetty, and diminishes gradually toward the eastward. The
              bottom over this area is hard sand, and it is evident that the shoal-
              ing has been due to the banking up of the westerly sand*drift against
              the west jetty ; for in 1884 this sand bottom was found to extend 1j
              miles to the eastward of the west jetty, while now sand is only found
              in isolated spots farther to the eastward than 1,800 feet from the
              west jetty, and at certain points it completely covers the foundation
              and has overflowed to the west of the jetty.
                                                    2
Page 1284.-Omit paragraph (second from bottom) beginning with                   Behind the
             west jetty, &c.
Page 12'7.-Fourth paragraph, second line, change          700      to      7,000
Page 1325.-Fifth and sixth lines, change      $14,451       to     '$14,541
Page 1327.-Four lines from bottom, change        720      to     750
Page 1329.-Fourth paragraph, fourth line, change         4,027,636        to      4,027.636.
           Fourth paragraph, seventh line, change        14,566,616       to     14,566.616.
Page 1332.-Fifth paragraph, third line, change        station No. 1          to      station
             No. 4
Page 1334.-Under heading    Improvement    of  Harbor    at  Brazos     Santiago,    Texas,
             change      appropriated 1885-'86      to      appropriated 1880-'86
Page 1341.-Paragraph next to the last, second line, change           1885       to      1884
Iage 1342.-Fortieth line, change     727,049.10      to      725,049.10
Page 1344.-Paragraph 2, tenth line, change      drains       to       draws
Page 1345.-Paragraph 6, sixteenth line, change         1879     to       1877
Page 1358.-Under commercial statistics, after the words lumber and timber feet
             B. M., change      100,000    to      1,100,000
Page 1363.-Six lines from bottom, change       1880      to      1883.
Page 1372.-Paragraph 5, eleventh line, change           two hundred and thirty
             to     three hundred and twenty
Page 1400.-Paragraph 5, last line, change      $12,000       to      $2,000.
Page 1421.-Above money statement insert:
                                              ABSTRACT    OF APPROPRIATIONS.

               By   act   approved June 18, 1878.................                        ..... ....           $250,000
               By   act   approved March 3, 1879* ........................                                     100,000
               By   act   approved June 14, 1880 ...........................                                   150, 000
               By   act   approved March 3, 1881 ...........              ..............                       200,000
               By   act   passed August 2, 1882       -_....-.................._....                           250,000
               By   act   approved July 5, 1884.... ..................                              .          250, 000

                      Total ...............                    ...........--   .................              1,200, 000
Page   1422.-Eleventh line from bottom change         4     to   3
Page   1447.-Third paragraph, ninth line, change         1854    to     1864,
Page   1451.-Sixth paragraph, sixth line, after      cubic yard     insert                                      of rock
Page   1455.-Last paragraph, first line, change      Dutch     to     Duck
Page   1461.-First table, fifth column, opposite 1880, insert   $4
             First table, sixth column, opposite 1860, change     $52,052.00                                     to
               $6,052.00
Page 1462.-Second taple, second column, fifth line, change                                         6,397.50      to
               3,697.50
Page 1463.-Under the head of Comparison of estimates, &c., eighth column, fourth
             line, change      8,968.98      to    8,986.98
Page 1491.-Immediately above the last line insert               expended during the
             fiscal year ending June 30, 1886, including outstanding liabilities,
             $2,469.46.
Page 1551.-Contract was awarded to John J. Shipman, and was executed under
             date of September 26, 1885,        transpose to precede A A 12.
Page 1594.-Fourth paragraph, second line, change           Dano       to    Dana
Page 1595.-Eighth paragraph after Schoonmaker change               chief    to     civil
           Eighth paragraph, end of fourth line, insert          the
           Second paragraph from bottom, second line, after              guard     insert
              crib
Page 1596.-To follow seventh paragraph: The following is from the records kept
              at the lock for the year.
           Ninth paragraph from bottom, second line, between the words up and
              the     insert     till
           Fifth paragraph from bottom, second line, change              lowering      to
                   lowered
Page 1597.-Fifth line, change       2,426,300     to     3,426,300
           Seventh paragraph from bottom, third line, after the word            anything
               insert   of importance
Page 1598.-Fourth paragraph, first line, change         belted      to     bolted
           Fifth paragraph, first line, change        Kiolin     to      Kirlin
         * Beginning seventh paragraph, change               for several       to     the
              several
Page 1613.-Last line, change       73.2     to     32.7
Page 1614.-Second paragraph, second line, after the word         water insert
             It was maintained 250 days to lock No. 5, and was suspended 47
                days by ice and high water,
        * Twenty thousand dollars set aside for testing Adam's Flume.
                                                              3
  Page 1614.-Fifth paragraph, third line, between the and lowest                    insert next to
                 the
  Page 1620.-Third table, fourth column, first line, change                 $744,400         to
                 $774,400
  Page 1635.-Eighth paragraph, fifth line, change            $5,726.52         to       $6,726.52.
  Page 1638.-Fourth paragraph, fourth line, insert              feet after 6 and             inches
                 after .12
  Page 1697.--Last paragraph, first line, change        2.8 inches        to       2 feet 8 inches
  Page 1705.-Between twenty-fifth and twenty sixth lines                  insert Coal shipped
                 out by rail, cars 2,400
  Page 1762.-Last paragraph, first line, change          1886       to        1866.
  Page 1764.-In first paragraph, under heading "Improvement of Muskegon Harbor,
                Michigan," change the word            stream         to       channel in first
               line.
  Page 1767.--Fourth paragraph from bottom, third line, change                   45       to      4.5
  Page 1768.-Third paragraph from bottom, last line, after 1868,                  insert       1869,
                end crib and after condition insert          123 feet crib work of irregular
                width built previous to 1866, re-superstructured in 1884, in good con-
                dition, and 46 feet of crib work 20 feet wide, built in 1868, re-super-
               structed in 1884, in good condition.
  Page 1769.-Eighth paragraph, change           1886      to      1866
  Page 1774.-Second paragraph, fourth line, change             90 feet       to        30 feet
  Page 1778.-Ninth paragraph, fourth line, after the words                  paid for          insert
               leaving 46,527 cubic yards which was paid for
  Page 1781.-Under Money Statement, tenth line, to follow project,                            insert
               modified as proposed
  Page 1783.-In second table, third box-heading, Hercules powder, change                       1,000
               pounds      to     4,000 pounds.
  Page 1792.-Next to last line, change       1856      to       1855,
  Page 1794.-Second paragraph, third line,
                                         line, change       .1866
                                                                1866 to to       1868
             Fourth paragraph, seventh line, change             the      slopes         to      side
               slopes
  Page 1796.-Eighth paragraph, second line, change              1881       to        1871
  Page 1801.-Third paragraph, second line, change                  constructed           to      ob-
               structed
  Page 1802.-Fifth paragraph, seventh line, after            practically          insert       com-
               pleted
  Page 1823.-Sixth line from bottom, change          223,872        to       323,872
  Page 1824.-Fourth line from bottom, change           58,000        to       85,000
  Page 1833.-Second table, abstract of bids for supplies opened April 2, 1886, should
               be as follows :
Abstracts of bids for supplies required for the harbor of refuge, Lake Huron, received and
  opened by Lieut. Col. O. M. Poe, Corps of Engineers, on April 2, 1886, in accordance with
  advertisement dated March 23, 1886.

No.                  Names and residences of bidders.                                     Painters' Shi           chandHardware.
                                                                                          supplies.            lery.

1    H. D. Edwards & Co., Detroit, Mich * ..........                           .$...........
                                                                                        $45 81          ............               .....
2    Farrand Williams & Co., Detroit, Mich.....................                              50 36      ...              ....
3    J. P. Donaldson & Co., Detroit, Mich.......................                             52 10...
4    T. H. Hinchman & Son, Detroit, Mich........................                              54 20......................
5    James E. Davis & Co., Detroit, Mich......................                               54 02 .... ..................
1    H. D. Edwards & Co., Detroit, Mich* ...............................                                     $189 45..........
2    J. P. Donaldson & Co., Detroir, Mich..................................                                      198 50 ......
1
2
      James L. Fisher, Detroit, Mich. ...                       .......    ............                 ...........               $42 35
      T. B. Rayl & Co., Detroit, Mich .........         ................                                 ............              44 50

                                          * Recommended for acceptance.

  Page 1836.-Fourth paragraph from bottom, change        20,000     to    20
  Page 1860.-Seventh paragraph, second line, change            $114,133.64    to .
               $114,183.64
  Page 1872.-In abstract of contract, second column, third, fourth, and fifth lines,
               between the words       per    and    foot     insert     M
  Page 1884.-Under second heading Commercial Statistics, amount of revenue col-
               lected should be    $156,663.71
  Page 1891.-Sixth paragraph from bottom, fourth line, change 1886        to    1885,
             Fourth paragraph from bottom, change         500    to    568
  Page 1893.-Third paragraph, fourth line, after    pier head      insert    in 1869
                                     CONTENTS.
                     [Alphabetical Index will be found at the end of each Part.]




                                                   PART                 I.

EXTRACT FROM REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF WAR.......................                                         XVii
OFFICERS OF THE CORPS OF ENGINEERS .--...-----..............................                                  3


                    SEA-COAST AND LAKE FRONTIER DEFENSES.

General discussion .---.....    ................          ......-----....--.......................---         4

ESTIMATES OF APPROPRIATIONS FOR 1887-'88................................                                      5
NORTHERN FRONTIER.-Ft. Wayne, Mich., 5; Ft. Porter, N. Y., Ft. Niagara, N. Y., 6;
  Ft. Ontario, N. Y., Ft. Montgomery, N. Y., 7. THE PENOBSCOT, ME.-Ft. Knox, 7.
  THE KENNEBEC, ME.-Ft. Popham, 8. PORTLAND, ME.-Ft. Gorges, Ft. Preble,
  8; Ft. Scammel, battery on Portland Head, 9; batteries on Cow Id., batteries on
  Great Hog Id., 10.        PORTSMOUTH, N.            H., AND NAVY-YARD AT KITTERY, ME.-Ft.
  McClary, Ft. Constitution, 10; battery on Gerrish's Id., battery on Jerry's Point, 11.
  BOSTON AND NAVY-YARD AT CHARLESTOWN, MASS.-Ft. Warren, battery at Long
  Id. Head, Ft. Winthrop, 12; Ft. Independence, 13. NEW BEDFORD, MASS.-Fort
  at Clark's Point, 14. NARRAGANSETT BAY, R. I.-Ft.*Adams, 14; defenses of Dutch
  Id., 15. NEW LONDON HARBOR ANDLNAVY-YARD, CONN.-Ft. Trumbull, 15; Ft.
  Griswold, 16.      NEW HAVEN,                CONN.-Ft. Hale, 17.                      NEW YORK AND NAVY-YARD
  AT BROOKLYN.-Ft. Schuyler, fort at Willets Point, 17; defenses of Governor's Id.,
  sea-wall on Governor's Id., 18; Ft. Wood, Ft. Hamilton and additional batteries,
  19; mortar battery at Ft. Hamilton, Ft. Lafayette, Ft. Wadsworth, 20; fort on
  site of Ft. Tompkins, Glacis Gun Battery (n. of fort on site of Ft. Tompkins), 21;
  Glacis Mortar Battery (s. of fort on site of Ft. Tompkins), Battery Hudson, 22;
  South Mortar Battery, North Cliff Battery, 23; South Cliff Battery, Two-gun Bat-
  tery near fort on site of Ft. Tompkins, fort at Sandy Hook, 24. PHILADELPHIA AND
  LEAGUE ISLAND NAVY-YARD.-Ft. Mifflin, mortar battery at Ft. Mifflin, 25; site for
  defenses at Red Bank, Ft. Delaware, 26; battery at Finn's Point, mortar battery at
  Finn's Point, fort opposite Ft. Delaware, 27; mortar battery opposite Ft. Delaware,
  28. BALTIMORE, MD.-Ft. McHenry, 28; Ft. Carroll, 29. WASHINGTON, D. C.-
  Ft. Foote, 29; Ft. Washington, obstructions of the Potomac, 30. HAMPTON ROADS
  AND GOSPORT NAVY-YARD, VA.-Ft. Monroe, 30; artesian well at Ft. Monroe, Ft.
  Wool, 32. BEAUFORT HARBOR, N. C.-Ft. Macon, 33. WILMINGTON, N. C. Ft.
  Caswell, 34. CHARLESTON, S. C.-Ft. Moultrie, Ft. Sumter, 34; Ft. Johnson, 35;
  Castle Pinckney, :36. SAVANNAH, GA.-Ft. Oglethorpe, Ft. Pulaski, 36; new fort on
  Tybee Id., 37. CUMBERLAND SOUND.-Ft. Clinch, 37. SAINT AUGUSTINE, FLA.-
  Ft. Marion. 38. KEY WEST, FLA.-Ft. Taylor and batteries, 38. HARBOR OF DRY
  TORTUGAS, FLA.-Ft.           Jefferson, 39.        PENSACOLA HARBOR AND NAVY-YARD. FLA.-
  Ft. Pickens, Ft. Barrancas and redoubt, 40; Ft. McRee. 41. MOBILE, ALA.-Ft.
  Morgan, Ft. Gaines, 41. MISsISSIPPI SOUND.-Fort on Ship Island, 42. NEW OR-
  LEANS. LA.-Ft. Pike, 42; Ft. Macomb, Tower Dupr6, Battery Bienvenue, tower at
  Proctorsville, 43; Ft. Jackson, Ft. St. Philip, Ft. Livingston, 44. GALVESTON,
  TEx.-Batteries at the entrance to the harbor of Galveston, 45. SAN DIEGO HAR-
  BOR, CALIFORNIA.--Fort at                San Diego, 45.          SAN FRANCISCO, NAVY-YARD AT MARE
  ISLAND, AND ARSENAL AT BENICIA, CAL.-Ft. Winfield Scott, 45; fort at Lime
  Point, 46; fort on Alcatraz Id., Ft. Mason, batteries on Angel Id., 47. DEFENSES
  OF THE COLUMBIA, OREG., AND WASH.-Ft. Stevens, Ft. Canby, 47.
II                                                        CONTENTS.

                                         THE BOARD OF ENGINEERS.
  Officers constituting Board, Fortifications., 49; Rivers and Harbors, 49; Coastdefenses,
Torpedo defense, 50; Estimatefor service of torpedoes, 51.
POST OF WILLETS POINT AND ENGINEER SCHOOL OF APPLICATION.. 52
BATTALION OF ENGINEERS AND DEPOT AT WILLETS POINT, NEW YORK
                           HARBOR ..----------------------------- 53

                                RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.
GENERAL STATEMENT .............-------.........----...........                       ................----   ---.   53


                             ATLANTIC COAST AND GULF OF MEXICO.
IN   CHARGE OF MAJ. JARED A.                        SMITH, CORPS OF ENGINEERS-

Lubec Channel, Me., 54; Bangor Harbor and Penobscot River, Me., Moose-a-bec Bar,
  Me., 55; Belfast Harbor, Me., Rockland Harbor, Me., 56; Portland Harbor, Me.,
  Kennebunk River, Me., 57; breakwater at mouth of Saco River, Me., Saco River,
  Me., Portsmouth Harbor, N. H., 58; Cocheco River, N. H., harbor of refuge at Little
  Harbor, N. H., 59; examination and survey, 60.
IN CHARGE OF MAJ. GEORGE L. GILLESPIE, CORPS OF ENGINEERS-
Newburyport Harbor, Mass.,60; Merrimac River, Mass., 61 ; Scituate Harbor, Mass., 62;
Boston Harbor, Mass., 63; Plymouth Harbor, Mass., 64; Provincetown Harbor,
Mass., Lynn Harbor, Mass., 65; Malden River, Mass., 66; harbor of refuge at Sandy
Bay, Cape Ann, Mass., 67.
IN CHARGE OF LIEUT. COL. GEORGE H.                                 ELLIOT, CORPS OF ENGINEERS-

Harbor of refuge at Hyannis, Mass., harborof refuge at Nantucket, Mass., 68; Wood, s
Holl Harbor, Mass., 69; Westport Harbor, Mass., Wareham Harbor, Mass., 70;
Taunton River, Mass., 72; Pawtucket River, R. I., 73; Providence River and Narra-
gansett Bay, R. I., 74; Green Jacket Shoal, Providence River, R. I., Warren River.
R. I., Newport Harbor, R. I., 75 ; harbor of refuge at Block Island, R. I., 77; Little
Narragansett Bay, R. I., harbor of refuge at Stonington., Conn., 78; Pawcatuck
River, R. I., and Conn., removing sunken vessels or craft obstructing or endanger-
ing navigation, 80.
IN CHARGE OF LIEUT. COL. D. C. HOUSTON, CORPS OF ENGINEERS--

Connecticut River, Mass. and Conn., 81; Thames River, Conn., 82; New London Har-
bor, Conn., Clinton Harbor, Conn., 83; New Haven Harbor, Con., Breakwater at
New Haven, Conn., 84; Milford Harbor, Conn., Housatonic River, Conn., 85; Bridge-
port Harbor, Conn., 86; Black Rock Harbor, Conn., Southport Harbor, Conn., 87;
Norwalk Harbor, Conn., Port Chester Harbor, N. Y., 88; New Rochelle Harbor, N. Y.,
Echo Harbor, New Rochelle, N, Y., 89; Mamaroneck Harbor, N. Y., Greenport Har-
bor, N. Y., Port Jefferson Harbor, N. Y., 90; Flushing Bay, N. Y., East Chester Creek,
N. Y., 91.
IN    CHARGE OF LIEUT. COL. WALTER MCFARLAND, CORPS OF ENGINEERS--
Hudson River, N. Y., 92; harbor at Saugerties, N. Y., 93; harbor at Rondout, N. Y.,
Harlem River, N. Y., 94; removing obstructions in East River and Hell Gate, N. Y.,
95; Newtown Creek, N. Y., 96; Buttermilk Chanel, N. Y., 97; Gowanus Bay, N. Y.,
Gedney's Channel, N. Y., 98; Sheepshead Bay, N. Y., 100; Canarsie Bay, N. Y.,
101; Sumpawanus Inlet, N. Y., Manasquan River, N. J., 102; Shrewsbury River,
N. J., 103; harbor at Keyport, N. J., Mattawan Creek, N. J., 105; Cheesequakes
Creek, N. J., Raritan Bay, N. J., 106; Raritan River, N. J., 107; South River, N. J.,
108; Woodbridge Creek, N. J., Rahway River, N. J., 109; Elizabeth River, N. J.,
channel between Staten Island and New Jersey, 110; Passaic River, N. J., 111.
IN CHARGE OF LIEUT. COL. HENRY M.                                ROBERT, CORPS OF ENGINEERS-

Delaware River from Trenton, N. J., to its mouth, 113; Delaware River at Schooner
Ledge, Delaware River near Cherry Island Flats, 115; Frankford Creek, Pa., Schuyl-
kill River, Pa., 116; ice-harbor at Marcus Hook, Pa., 117; ice-harbor at the head
of Delaware Bay, Del., construction of iron pier in Delaware Bay, near Lewes, Del.,
118; Delaware Breakwater Harbor, Del., 119; Rancocas River, N. J., 120; Wood-
bury Creek, N. J., Mantua Creek, N. J., Raccoon River, N. J., 121; Salem River,
N. J., Cohansey Creek, N. J., 122; removal of wrecks from Delaware Bay and River.
removing sunken vessels or craft obstructing or endangering navigation, United
States commission advisory to the board of harbor commissioners of Philadelphia,
Pa., 123.
                                           CONTENTS.                                           III

IN CHARGE OF MR. WILLIAM F.             SMITH, U. S. AGENT-
Maurice River, N. J., Wilmington Harbor, Del., 124; ice-harbor at New Castle, Del.,
125; Duck Creek, Del., Saint Jones River, Del., 126; Mispillion Creek, Del., 127;
Broadkiln River, Del., Broad Creek, Del., from its mouth to Laurel, 128; Indian
River, Del., Susquehanna River above and below Havre de Grace, Md., 129; Chester
River at Kent Island Narrows, Md., Chester River from Spry's Landing to Crump-
ton, Md., 130; Corsica Creek, Md., Cjoptank River, Md., 131; Wicomico River,
Md., Upper Thoroughfare, between Deil's Island and the ma illl nd, Md., 132.

IN    CHARGE   OF LIEUT.   COL. WILLIAM          P.   CRAIGHIILL, CORI'S OF ENGINEE:RS-

Patapsco River and channel leading to Baltimore Md., 133; harbor at Annapolis, Md.,
  134; removing sunken vessels or craft obstructing or endangering navigation, 135.

IN    CHARGE   OF MAJ. PETER C.          HAINS,       CORPS OF ENGINEERS,   BVT. LIEUT. COL.,
U. S. A.-
Harbors at Washington and Georgetown, D. C., 135; Potomac River at Washington,
D. C., 136; James River, Va., 137; Shenandoah River, W. Va., 139.

IN    CHARGE OF MR. S.     T.    ABERT, U.     S. AGENT-
Channel at Mount Vernon, Va., 139; Neabsco Creek, Va. ; Breton Bay, Leonardtown,
Md., 140; Nomini Creek, Va.; harbor at entrance of Saint Jerome's Creek, Md.,
141; Rappahannock River, Va.; Totusky River, Va., 142; Urbana Creek, Va.;
Mattaponi River, Va., 143; Pamunky River, Va.; York River, Va., 144; Chicka-
hominy River, Va., 145; Staunton River, Va., 145, 146; Dan River, between Mad-
ison, N. C., and Danville, Va., 146; Roanoke River, N. C.; French Broad River,
N. C., 147; examination aqueduct bridge, 148.

IN    CHARGE OF CAPT. F.        A.   HINMAN,     CORPS OF ENGINEERS-
Harbor at Norfolk, Va., 148; approach to Norfolk Harbor and the (Norfolk) Navy-
Yard, between Lambert's Point and Fort Norfolk, Va., 149; Appomattox River,
Va., 150; Nottaway River, Va., 151; Blackwater River, Va., Archer's Hope River,
Va., 152; North Landing River, Va. and N. C., 153; Edenton Bay, N. C., Currituck
Sound, Coanjok Bay, and North River Bar, N. C., 154; Meherrin River, N. C., 155;
Pamplico and Tar rivers, N. C., 156; Yadkin River, N. C., 157; Scuppernong River,
N. C., 158; removing sunken vessels or craft obstructing or endangering naviga-
tion, 159.

IN CHARGE OF CAPT. WILLIAM H.                BIXBY,     CORPS OF ENGINEERS-
Contentnea Creek, N. C., 159; Trent River, N. C., 160; Neuse River, N. C., 162; in-
land navigation from New Berne to Beaufort Harbor, via Clubfoot, I-Iarlowe, and
Newport rivers, N. C., 163; harbor at Beaufort, N. C., 164; New River, N. C., 165;
     Cape Fear River, above Wilmington, N. C., 166; Cape Fear River, below Wilming-
     ton, N. C., 168; Great Pe Dee River, S. C., 169; Waccemaw River, S. C., 170; harbor
     at Georgetown, S. C., 172; Santee River, S. C., 173; Wateree River, S. C., 174; re-
     moving sunken vessels obstructing or endangering navigation, 175.

IN    CHARGE OF COL. Q. A.           GILLMORE,    CORPS OF ENGINEERS,     BVT. MA.T.   GEN.,   U.
S. A.-
Charleston Harbor, S. C., 176; Wappoo Cut, S. C., 178; Asjiley River, S. C., Edisto
River, S. C., 179; Salkiehatchie River, S. C., 180; Savanah Harbor and River,
Ga., 181; Savannah River, Ga., 183; Savannah River above Augusta, Ga., 184;
Saint Augustine Creek (Thunderbolt River), Ga., Rornerly Marsh, Ga., 1h5; Alta-
maha River, Ga., 186; Brunswick Harbor, Ga., 187; entrance to Cumberland Sound,
Ga. and Fla., 189; inside passage between Fernandina and Saint John's River, Fla.,
190.

IN    CHARGE OF FIRST LIEUT. WM. M. BLACK, CORPS OF ENGINEERS-
Saint John's River, Fla., 190; Upper Saint John's River, Fla., 191; Volusia Bar, Fla.,
Tampa Bay, Fla., 192; Apalachicola Bay, Fla., 193; Suwanee River, Fla., Key
West Harbor, Fla., 194; Pease Creek, Fla., harbor at Cedar Keys, Fla., Manatee
River, Fla., 195; Caloosahatchie River, Fla., Apalachicola River, Fla., 196; With-
lacoochee River, Fla., removing sunken vessels or craft obstructing or endangering
navigation, 197.
IV                                         CONTENTS.

IN   CHARGE OF CAPT. R.      L.   HOXIE, CORPS OF ENGINEERS-
Ocmulgee River, Ga., Oconee River, Ga., 198; Flint River, Ga., Oostenaula and Coosa-
wattee rivers, Ga., 199; Coosa River, Ga. and Ala., Chattahoochee IRiver, Ga. and
Ala., 200; Alabama River, Ala., Taltapoosa River, Ala., 201; Cahaba River, Ala.,
202; Conecuh--Escambia River, Fla. and Ala., Choctawhathee River, Fla. and
Ala., 203; Bayou La Grange, Fla., harbor at Pensacola, Fla, ~O4.
IN   CHARGE OF MAJ. A. N.         DAMRELL, CORPS OF ENGINEERS-

Mobile Harbor, Ala., 205; Warrior River, Ala., Tombigbee River, from Fulton to
Vienna, 206; Tombigbee River, below Vienna, 207; Black Warrior River, from
Tuscaloosa to Daniel's Creek, Ala., Old Town Creek, Miss., Noxubee River, Miss.,
208; Pascagoula River, Miss., harbor at Biloxi Bay, Miss., 209; Horn Island Pass,
Miss., Pearl River, Miss., below Jackson, Pearl River, Miss., from Jackson to Car-
thage, 210; Pearl River, Miss., between Edinburg and Carthage, 211; examina-
tions and surveys, 211.
IN CHARGE OF MAJ. W.         H.   HEUER, CORPS OF ENGINEERS-

Inspection of the improvement at the South Pass of the Mississippi River, 212; Amite
  River, La., Tangipahoa River, La., 213; Tchefuncte River, La., 214; Tickfaw
  River, La., Bayou Teche, La., 215; connecting Bayou Teche with Grand Lake at
  Charenton, La., 216; Bayou Black, La., 217; Bayou Courtableau, La., 218; Bayou
  Terrebonne, La., Bayou La Fourche, La., 219; Calcasieu River, La., Calcasieu Pass,
  La., 220; Sabine Pass, Tex., 221; Sabine River, La. and Tex., Neches River, Tex.,
  222; removing sunken vessel or craft obstructing or endangering navigation, 223.
IN   CHARGE OF MAJ. S.      M. MANSFIELD,      CORPS OF ENGINEERS,     BVT. LIEUT.               COL.,
U. S. A.-
Entrance to Galveston Harbor, Tex., 223; ship-channel in Galveston Bay, Tex.,
Trinity River, Tex., 224; Buffalo Bayou, Tex., channel over the bar at the mouth
of Brazos River, Tex., Pass Cavado Inlet, to Matagorda Bay, Tex., 225; Aransas
Pass and Bay, up'to Rockport and Corpus Christi, Tex., harbor at Brazos Santiago,
Tex., 226; protection of river-bank at Fort Brown, Tex., 227.

                                    WESTERN RIVERS.

IN   CHARGE OF CAPT.     ERIC BERGLAND,       CORPS OF ENGINEERS-
Red River, La. and Ark., 227; survey of Bayou Pierre, La., Cypress Bayou, Tex. and
  La., 229; Cane River, La., Loggy Bayou, Lake Bisteneau, and the Dorcheat, La.,
  Ouachit. and Black rivers, Ark. and La., 230; Bayou Bartholomew, La. and Ark.,
  Bayou Boeuf, La., 231; Tensas River and Bayou Macon, La., Bayou D'Arbonne, La.,
  232; Yazoo River, Miss., 233; Big Sunflower River, Miss., Tchula Lake, Miss., Tal-
  lahatchee River, Miss., 234; Yallabusha River, Miss., Steele's Bayou, Miss., 235;
  Big Black River, Miss., Big Hatchee River, Tenn., 236; South Forked Deer River,
  Tenn., water-gauges on the Mississippi River and it principal tributaries, 237.
IN   CHARGE OF CAPT. H.      S.   TABER, CORPS OF ENGINEERS-

Removing obstructions in Arkansas River. Ark., Arkansas River at Pine Bluff, Ark.,
  238; Black River, Ark. and Mo., White River, Ark., 240; White River, above Buf-
  falo Shoals, Ark., 241; Saint Francis River, 242; Saline River, Ark., L'Anguille
  River, Ark., 243; surveys, 244.
IN   CHARGE OF MAJ. A.      M. MILLER, CORPS OF ENGINEERS-
Removing snags and wrecks from the MississiDpi and Missouri rivers, 244; Osage
  River, Kans. and Mo., 246; Gasconade River, Mo., 247.
MISSISSIPPI RIVER COMMISSION-....-..........-..........                          -............    247

MISSOURI RIVER COMMISSION.......... ..................      ....   .       .
                                                                        ......                     248

IN   CHARGE OF CAPT. C. B.        SEARS,   CORPS OF ENGINEERS-

Improvement of the Missouri River from Sioux City, Iowa, to Fort Benton, Mont., 248.
IN   CHARGE OF CAPT. JAMES B. QUINN, CORPS OF ENGINEERS--
Improvement of Yellowstone River, Mont. and Dak., 249.
                                      CONTENTS.                                    V

IN    CHARGE OF MAJ. O.   H.    ERNST, CORPS OF ENGINEERS-
Improvement of the Mississippi River from the mouth of the Illinois to the mouth of
  the Ohio, 249.
IN CHARGE OF CAPT. E.      H.    RUFFNER,   CORPS OF ENGINEERS-
Improvement of the Mississippi River from Des Moines Rapids to the mouth of Illi-
  nois River, 249.
IN CHARGE OF MAT. ALEXANDER          MACKENZIE,   CORPS OF ENGINEERS-
Upper Mississippi River, operations of snag-boats and dredge-boats, Mississippi River
from Saint Paul to Des Moines Rapids, 250; Mississippi River from Des Moines
Rapids to mouth of the Illinois River, harbor of refuge in Lake Pepin, at Stock-
holm, Wis., harbor of refuge in Lake Pepin, at Lake City, Minn., 251; removal of
bar in Mississippi River opposite Dubuque, Iowa, ice-harbor at Dubuque, Iowa,
Rock Island Rapids, Mississippi River, 252; Des Moines Rapids, Mississippi River,
253; operating and care of Des Moines Rapids Canal, dry-dock at Des Moines Rap-
ids Canal, 254.
IN CHARGE OE MAJ. CHARLES J.         ALLEN,    CORPS OF ENGINEERS-
Preservation of Falls of Saint Anthony, Minn., 255; Mississippi River above the Falls
  of Saint Anthony, Minn., 256; construction of lock and dam on Mississippi River
  at Meeker's Island, Minn., 257; Chippewa River, Wis., 258; Chippewa River at
  Yellow Banks, Wis., Saint Croix River below Taylor's Falls, Minn. and Wis., 259;
  Minnesota River, Minn., 260; Red River of the North, Minn. and Dak., 261; lock
  and dam at Goose Rapids on Red River of the North, Minn. and Dak., 262; reser-
  voirs upon the headwaters of the Mississippi River, 263; surveys for reservoirs at
  the sources of the Mississippi, Saint Croix, Chippewa, and Wisconsin rivers, 264.
IN CHARGE OF LIEUT. COL. J.        W. BARLOW, CORPS OF ENGINEERS-
Tennessee River, 264; Cumberland River, 266; Hiawassee River, 267; French Broad
River, Tenn., Clinch River, Tenn., 268;'Duck River, Tenn., Caney Fork River,
Tenn., 269; Little Tennessee River, Tenn., South Fork Cumberland River, Ky.,
270.

IN    CHARGE OF LIEUT.    COL.    WILLIAM E.    MERRILL, CORPS OF ENGINEERS,    BVT.
     COL., U. S. A.-
Ohio River, 271; operating and care of Davis Island Dam, Ohio River, 272; Monon-
gahela River, W. Va., and Pa., operating and care of Lock and Dam No. 9,
Monougahela River, Allegheny River, Pa., dam at Herr's Island, Allegheny River,
273; ice-harbor at mouth of Muskingum River, Ohio, Muskingum River, Ohio, 274;
operating and care of locks and dams on the Muskingum River, Ohio, harbor of
refuge near Cincinnati, Ohio, harbor of refuge at mouth of Great Kanawha River,
W. Va., 275; examination and survey, 276.
IN    CHARGE OF MAJOR AMOS       STICKNEY, CORPS OF ENGINEERS-
Falls of the Ohio River at Louisville, Ky., Indiana Chute, Falls of the Ohio River,
276; Louisville and Portland Canal, Wabash River, Ind. and Ill., 277; White River,
  Ind., 279.
IN    CHARGE OF LIEUT. COL. W.     P. CRAIGHILL, CORPS OF ENGINEERS-
Great Kanawha River, W. Va., 279; Elk River, W. Va.; New River, from the mouth
  of Wilson, in Grayson County, Va., to the mouth of Greenbrier River, W. Va., 281.
IN    CHARGE OF CAPT. JAMES C. POST, CORPS OF ENGINEERS-
Kentucky River, Ky., 282; operating and keeping in repair locks and dams on the
Kentucky River, Ky., 283; Tradewater River, Ky., Big Sandy River, W. Va. and
Ky., 284; Guyandotte River, W. Va., Little Kanawha River, W. Va., 285; Buck-
hannon River, W. Va., 286.

                          LAKE HARBORS AND RIVERS.

IN    CHARGE OF MAJ.   CHARLES J.    ALLEN, CORPS OF ENGINEERS-
Harbor at Duluth, Minn., 287; dredging Superior Bay, Wis., 288; harbor at Grand
Marais, Minn., 289.
VI                                     CONTENTS.

IN   CHARGE OF CAPT. CHARLES E.        L.   B.   DAVIS,   CORPS OF ENGINEERS-
Ontonagon Harbor, Mich., 290; Eagle Harbor, Mich., Marquette harbor, Mich., 291;
harbor of refuge at Grand Marais, Mich., 292; Manistique Harbor, Mich., harbor
at mouth of Cedar River, Mich, 293; Menomonee Harbor, Mich. and Wis., Oconto
Harbor, Wis., 294; Pensaukee Harbor, Wis., 295; Green Bay Harbor, Wis., harbor
of refuge at entrance of Sturgeon Bay Canal, Wis., 296; Ahnepee Harbor, Wis.,
Kewaunee Harbor, Wis., 297; Two Rivers Harbor, Wis., 298; Manitowoc Harbor,
Wis., Sheboygan Harbor, Wis., 299; Port Washington Harbor, Wis., 300; survey,
301.
IN   CHARGE OF CAPT. W.    L. MARSHALL,          CORPS OF ENGINEERS-
Harbor of refuge, Milwaukee Bay, Wis., 301; Milwaukee Harbor, Wis., Racine Har-
bor, Wis., 302; Kenosha Harbor, Wis., Waukegan Harbor, Ill., 303; Fox and Wis-
consin rivers, Wis., 304.
IN   CHARGE OF MAJ. W.    H.    H.   BENYAURD,      CORPS OF ENGINEERS-

Chicago Harbor, 1ll., 306; Calumet Harbor, Ill., 307; Illinois River, Calumet River,
308; survey, :309.
IN   CHARGE OF CAPT. D.    W.    LOCKWOOD, CORPS OF ENGINEERS-
Charlevoix Harbor, Mich, 309; Frankfort Harbor, Mich., harbor of refuge at Portage
  Lake, Mich., 310; Manistee Harbor, Mich., 311; Ludington Harbor, Mich., Pent-
  water Harbor, Mich., 312; White River Harbor, Mich., Muskegon Harbor, Mich.,
. 313; Grand Haven Harbor, Mich., Grand River, Mich., Black Lake Harbor, Mich.,
  314; Saugatuck Harbor, Mich., South Haven Harbor, Mich., 315; Saint Joseph
  Harbor, Mich., Michigan City Harbor, Ind., 316.
IN CHARGE OF LIEUT. COL. O. M.          POE, CORPS OF EFGINEERS,       BVT. BRIG.   GEN.,
U. S. A.-
Hay Lake Channel, Saint Mary's River, Mich., 318; Saint Mary's Fa'Ws Canal and
River, Mich., operating and care of Saint Mary's Falls Canal, Mich., 319; dry-dock
at Saint Mary's Falls Canal, Mich., harbor at Cheboygan, Mich., 32"; harbor at
Thunder Bay, Mich., harbor at Au Sable, Mich., 321; Saginaw River Mich., har-
bor of refuge, Sand Beach, Lake Huron, Mich., 322; steam launch or tug for har-
bor of refuge, Lake Huron, Mich., 323; ice-harbor of refuge at Belle River, Mich.,
general repairs and renewals at Saint Clair Flats Ship ('anal, Mich., 324; operating
and care of Saint Clair Flats Canal, Mich., Clinton River, Mich., 325; Detroit
River, Mich., 326.
IN   CHARGE OF MAJ. L.    COOPER OVERMAN, CORPS OF ENGINEERS-

Monroe Harbor, Mich.,.326; Toledo Harbor, Ohio, 327; Port Clinton Harbor, Ohio,
329; Sandusky City Harbor, Ohio, 330; Sandusky River, Ohio, 331; Huron Harbor.
Ohio, Vermillion Harbor, Ohio, 332; mouth of Black River, Ohio, 333; Rocky River,
Ohio, Cleveland Harbor, Ohio, 334; Fairport Harbor, Ohio, 336; Ashtabula Harbor,
Ohio, 337; Coneaut Harbor, Ohio, Dunkirk Harbor, N. Y., 338; removing sunken
vessels or craft obstructing or endangering navigation, 339.
IN   CHARGE OF CAPT. EDWARD MAGUIRE. CORPS OF ENGINEERS-

Erie Harbor, Pa., 339; Buffalo Harbor, N. Y., 340; Niagara River, N. Y., wilson
  Harbor, N. Y., Olcott Harbor, N. Y., 341; Oak Orchard Harbor, N. Y., Charlotte
  Harbor, N. Y., 342; Pultneyville Harbor, N. Y., 343; Great Sodus Harbor, N. Y.,
  Little Sodus Harbor, N. Y., 344; Oswego Harbor, N. Y., 345; Sackett's Harbor,
  N. Y., 346.
IN   CHARGE OF MAJ. MILTON B. ADAMS, CORPS OF ENGINEERS--
Ogdensburg Harbor, N. Y., 346; Grass River at Massena, N. Y., 347; breakwater at
Rouse's Point, Lake Champlain, N. Y., Swanton Ilarlor, Vt., Plattsburg Harbor,
N. Y., 348; Burlington Harbor, Vt., 349; Otter Creek, Vt., Ticonderoga River, N.
Y., 350.
                                     PACIFIC COAST.

IN CHARGE OF LIEUT. COL. GEORGE H. MENDELL, CORPS OF ENGINEERS--
Oakland Harbor, Cal., 350; Wilmington Harbor, Cal., 351; Redwood Harbor, Cal.,
removal of sunken vessels or craft obstructing or endangering navigation, 352.
                                            CONTENTS.                                            VII

IN CHARGE OF COL. C. SEAFORTH STEWART,                        CORPS OF ENGINEERS--

Harbor at San Diego, Cal., 353.
IN   CHARGE OF CAPT. A.        H.     PAYSON, CORPS OF ENGINEERS-
Humboldt Harbor and Bay, Cal., 353; San Joaquin River, Stockton and Mormon
sloughs, Cal., 354; Mokelumne River, Cal., Sacramento and Feather rivers, Cal.,
355; Colorado River, Nevada, Cal., and Ariz., 356.
IN   CHARGE OF MAJ. W. A. JONES, CORPS OF ENGINEERS-
Columbia and Willamette rivers below Portland, Oreg., 357; Upper Willamette
River, Oreg.; Columbia River at Cascades, Oreg., 358; Upper Columbia and Snake
rivers Oreg. and Wash., Cowlitz River, Wash., 359; Lower Clearwater River, Idaho,
360; examinations and surveys, 360.

IN   CHARGE OF CAPT. CHARLES F.             POWELL, CORPS OF ENGINEERS-

Mouth of the Columbia River, Oreg., and Wash., 360; entrance to Coos Bay, Oreg.,
361; entrance to Yaquina Bay, Oreg., mouth of Coquille River, Oreg., 362; Ump-
qua River, Oreg., 363; Skagit, Steilaquamish, Nootsack, Snohomish, and Snoqual-
mie rivers, Wash., Chehalis River, Wash., 364; gauging waters of the Columbia
River and principal tributaries, 365.

EXAMINATIONS, SURVEYS, AND CONTINGENCIES OF RIVERS AND HAR-
                            BORS.

Estimate for 1887-'88 ......----...        .....-----....-..................     ......   ....   365

                             WASHINGTON AQUEDUCT, ETC.

IN   CHARGE OF MAJ. G.        J.    LYDECKER, CORPS OF ENGINEERS-
Washington Aqueduct, 365; increasing the water supply of the city of Washington,
366; erection of fish-ways at the Great Falls of the Potomac River, 368.

      PUBLIC BUILuINGS, GROUNDS, ETC., DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA.

IN   CHARGE    OF LIEUT. COL. JOHN M. WILSON, CORPS OF ENGINEERS, COLONEL,
                              UNITED STATES ARMY .......................... 368


          BRIDGING NAVIGABLE WATERS OF THE UNITED STATES.

Bridge across the Mississippi River at Keithsburg, Ill., stone-arch bridge across the
  West Channel of the Mississippi River at Minneapolis, Minn., proposed bridge
  across the Ohio River at or near Cairo, Ill., 369; bridge of the Selma Bridge Company
  across the Alabama River at Selma, Ala., changes in the original plan of the
  bridge across the Ohio River at Henderson, Ky, 370.

PRINTING AND DISTRIBUTION OF CHARTS OF THE NORTHERN AND
                    NORTHWESTERN LAKES ....................... 371

                         MILITARY AND GEOGRAPHICAL MAPS................                          371


                       RECONNAISSANCES AND EXPLORATIONS.

Officers on duty at headquarters of the Army, of divisions, and departments, 372;
  reports made, 372, 373; estimate for surveys and reconnaissances and publications
  of maps, 373.
                      OFFICE OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS.

Officers of the Corps of Engineers in charge of divisions                            .      ..   374
                                                                                                 3...........
VIII                                        CONTENTS.

STATEMENT OF RANK AND DUTIES OF OFFICERS OF THE CORPS OF
            ENGINEERS DURING THE FISCAL YEAR............... 375
LAWS AFFECTING THE CORPS OF ENGINEERS, 49TH CONGRESS,                                               1ST
                     SESSION, 1885-'86 ............................                                  395

                         FORTIFICATIONS,                              ETC.
                                    APPENDIX No. 1.
REPORT OF LIEUT. COL. C. B. COMSTOCK, CORPS OF ENGINEERS, BVT.
                      BRIG. GEN., U. S. A.
Post of Willets Point and Engineer School of Application ......................                      471

                                    APPENDIX No. 2.

             REPORT OF MAJ. W. R. KING, CORPS OF ENGINEERS.
Battalion of Engineers and depot at Willets Point             ............................           489

                                     APPENDIX No. 3.

REPORT OF THE BOARD ON FORTIFICATIONS OR OTHER DEFENSES APPOINTED BY
THE PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES UNDER THE PROVISIONS OF THE ACT OF
CONGRESS APPROVED MARCH 3, 1885.               WILLIAM C. ENDICOTT, SECRETARY OF
  WAR, PRESIDENT -----...--.....------------...........................-----......-------....         499
                                                                                              ---....----


                  RIVERS             AND          HARBORS,                   ETC.

                                       APPENDIX A.

         REPORT OF MAJ. JARED A. SMITH, CORPS OF ENGINEERS.
IMPROVEMENTS.-Lubec            Channel, Me., 527; Bangor Harbor and Penobscot River,
  Me., 530; Moose-a-bec Bar, Me., 533; Belfast Harbor, Me., 535; Rockland Harbor,
  Me., 536; Portland Harbor, Me., 538; Kennebunk River, Me., 543; breakwater at
  mouth of Saco River, Me., 544; Saco River, Me., 546 ; Portsmouth Harbor, N. H.,
  546; Cocheco River, N. H., 548; examination and survey Saco River, Me., 552.

                                       APPENDIX B.

REPORT OF MAJ. GEORGE L. GILLESPIE, CORPS OF ENGINEERS, BVT.
                    LIEUT. COL., U. S. A.
IMPROVEMENTS.-Newburyport Harbor, Mass., 557;                      Merrimac      River, Mass., 560;
  Scituate Harbor, Mass., 562; Boston Harbor, Mass., 564; Plymouth Harbor, Mass.,
  571; Provincetown Harbor, Mass., 574; Lynn Harbor, Mass., 577; Malden River,
  Mass., 579; harbor of refuge at Sandy Bay, Cape Ann, Mass., 580.

                                       APPENDIX C.

  REPORT OF LIEUT. COL. GEORGE H. ELLIOT, CORPS OF ENGINEERS.
IMPROVEMENTS.-Harbor of refuge                at Hyannis, Mass., 585;          harbor of refuge at
  Nantucket, Mass., 587; Wood's Hell Harbor, Mass., 591; Westport Harbor, Mass.,
  592; Wareham Harbor, Mass., 593; Taunton River, Mass., 595; Pawtucket River,
  R. I., 598; Providence River and Narragansett Bay, R. I., 602; Green Jacke,
  Shoal, Providence River, R. I., 605; Warren River, R. I., 605; Newport Harbor, R.
  I., 606; harbor of refuge at Block Island, R. I., 609; Little Narragansett Bay, R.
  I. and Conn., 613; harbor of refuge at Stonington, Conn., 614: Pawcatuck River,
  R. I. and Conn., 616; removing sunken vessels or craft obstructing or eniangering
  navigation, 618.
                                    CONTENTS.                                    IX

                                APPENDIX D.

    REPORT OF LIEUT. COL. D. C. HOUSTON, CORPS OF ENGINEERS.

IMPROVEMENTS.-Connecticut      River, Mass. and Conn., 623; Thames River, Conn.,
629; New London Harbor, Conn., 632; Clinton Harbor, Conn., 634; New Haven
Harbor, Conn., 636; Breakwater at New Haven, Conn., 639; Milford Harbor, Conn.,
640; Housatonic River, Conn., 642; Bridgeport Harbor, Conn., 644; Black Rock
Harbor, Conn., 646; Southport Harbor, Conn., 648; Norwalk Harbor, Conn., 649;
Port Chester Harbor, N. Y., 651; New Rochelle Harbor, N. Y., 654; Echo Harbor,
New Rochelle, N. Y., 655; Mamaroneck harbor, N. Y., 657; Greenport Harbor, N.
Y., 658; Port Jefferson Harbor, N. Y., 660; Flushing Bay, N. Y., 661; East Chester
Creek, N. Y., 663.

                                APPENDIX E.

REPORT OF LIEUT. COL. WALTER McFARLAND, CORPS OF ENGINEERS.
IMPROVEMENT.-Hudson River, N. Y., 665; harbor at Saugerties, N. Y., 669;
  harbor at Rondout, N. Y., 670; Harlem River, N. Y., 672; removing obstructions
  in East River and Hell Gate, N. Y., 675; Newtown Creek, N. Y., 717; Buttermilk
  Channel, N. Y., 720; Gowanus Bay, N. Y., 7b22; Gedney's Channel, N. Y., 724;
  Sheepshead Bay, N. Y., 743; Canarsie Bay, N. Y., 746; Sumpawanus Inlet, N. Y.,
  748; Manasquan River, N. J., 751.; Shrewsbury River, N. J., 756; harbor at Key-
  port, N. J., 760; Mattawan Creek, N. J., 761; Cheesequakes Creek, N. J., 763;
  Raritan Bay, N. J., 765; Raritan River, N. J., 769; South River, N. J., 777; Wood-
  bridge Creek, N. J., 781; Rahway River, N. J., 733; Elizabeth River, N. J., 785;
  channel between Staten Island and New Jersey, 788; Passaic River, N. J., 792.

                                APPENDIX F.

  REPORT OF LIEUT. COL. HENRY M. ROBERT, CORPS OF ENGINEERS.
IMPROVEMENTS.-Delaware River from Trenton, N. J., to its mouth, 801; Delaware
  River at Schooner Ledge, 828; Delaware River near Cherry Island Flats, 829;
  Frankford Creek, Pa., 829; Schuylkill River, Pa., 830; ice-harbor at Marcus Hook,
  Pa., 832; ice-harbor at the head of Delaware Bay, Del., 834; construction of iron
  pier in Delaware Bay near Lewes, Del., 836; Delaware Breakwater Harbor, Del.,
  839; Rancocas River, N. J., 841; Woodbury Creek, N. J., 843; Mantua Creek, N.
  J., 844; Raccoon River, N. J.,844; Salem River, N. J.,846; Cohansey Creek, N.
  J., 847; removal of wrecks from Delaware Bay and River, 847; removing sunken
  vessels or craft obstructing or endangering navigation, 848; United States com-
  mission advisory to the board of harbor commissioners of Philadelphia, Pa., 849.

                                APPEN1DIX G.

      REPORT OF MR. WILLIAM F. SMITH, UNITED STATES AGENT.

IMPROVEMENTS.-Maurice River, N. J., 855; Wilmington Harbor, Del., 857; ice-
  harbor at New Castle, Del., 858; Duck Creek, Del., 859; Saint Jones River, Del.,
  860; Mispillion Creek, Del., 861; Broadkiln River, Del., 862; Broad Creek, Del.,
  from its mouth to Laurel, 863; Indian River, Del., 864; Susquehanna River above
  and below Havre de Grace, Md., 864; Chester River at Kent.Island Narrows, Md.,
  866; Chester River from Spray's Landing to Crumpton, Md., 866; Corsica Creek,
  Md., 867; Choptank River, Md., 868; Wicomico River, Md., 869; Upper Thorough-
  fare, between Deil's Island and the mainland, Md., 870.

                                APPENDIX H.

REPORT OF LIEUT. COL. WILLIAM P. CRAIGHILL, CORPS OF ENGINEERS.

IMPROVEMIENTS.--Patapsco River and channel to Baltimore, Md., 874; Annapolis
  Harbor, Md., 877; removing sunken vessels or craft obstructing or endangering
  navigation, 878.
X                                  CONTENTS.


                                APPENDIX I.

REPORT OF MAJ. PETER C. HAINS, CORPS OF ENGINEERS, BVT. LIEUT.
                         COL., U. S. A.

IMPROVEMENTS.-Harbors at Washington and Georgetown, D. C., 879; Potomac
  River at Washington, D. 0., 881; James River, Va., 887; Shenandoah River, W.
  Va., 891.

                                APPENDIX J.

          REPORT OF MR. S. T. ABERT, UNITED STATES AGENT.

IMPROVEMENTs.-Channel at Mount Vernon, Va., 899; Neabsco Creek, Va., 901; Bre-
  ton Bay, Leonardtown, Md., 901; Nomini Creek, Va., 903; harbor at entrance of
  Saint Jerome's Creek, Md., 904; Rappahannock River, Va., 906; Totusky River,
  Va., 913; Urbana Creek, Va., 914; Mattaponi River, Va., 915; Pamunky River,
  Va., 917; York River, Va., 918; Chickahominy River, Va., 920; Staunton River,
  Va., 922 and 924; Dan River, between Madison, N. C., and Danville, Va., 925;
  Roanoke River, N. C. 927; French Broad River, N. C., 929.
EXAMINATION.-Aqueduct Bridge over the Potomac at Georgetown, D. C., 931.


                                APPENDIX K.

         REPORT OF CAPT. F. A. HINMAN, CORPS OF ENGINEERS.

IMPROVEMENTS.-Harbor at Norfolk, Va., 951; Approach to Norfolk Harbor and the
  United States (Norfolk) navy-yard, between Lambert's Point and Fort Norfolk,
  Va., 956; Appomattox River, Va., 958; Nottoway River, Va., 961; Blackwater
  River, Va., 961; Archer's Hope River, Va., 962; North Landing River, Va. and N.
  C., 962; Edenton Bay, N. C., 963; Currituck Sound, Coanjok Bay, and North River
  Bar, N. C., 965; Meherrin River, N. C., 965; Pamlico and Tar rivers, N. C., 966;
  Yadkin River, N. C., 967; Scuppernong River, N. C., 969; removing sunken vessels
  or craft obstructing or endangering navigation, 970.


                                APPENDIX L.

     REPORT OF CAPT. WILLIAM H. BIXBY, CORPS OF ENGINEERS.

IMPROVEMENTS.-Contentnea Creek, N. C., 973; Trent River, N. C., 976; Neuse River,
  N. C., 979; inland navigation from New Berne to Beaufort Harbor, via Clubfoot,
  Harlowe, and Newport rivers, N. C., 983; harbor at Beaufort, N. C., 986; New
  River, N. C., 991; Cape Fear River, above Wilmington, N. C., 995; Cape Fear River,
  below Wilmington, N. C., 1000; Great Pe Dee River, S. C., 1017; Waccemaw River,
  S. C., 1022; harbor at Georgetown, S. C., 1027; Santee River, S. C., 1030; Wateree
  River, S. C., 1053; removing sunken vessels obstructing or endangering naviga-
  tion, 1060.

                                APPENDIX M.

REPORT OF COL. Q. A. GILLMORE, CORPS OF ENGINEERS, BVT. MAJ.
                         GEN., U. S. A.
IMPROVEMENTS.-Charleston Harbor, S. C., 1063; Wappoo Cut, S.C., 1077; Ashley
  River, S. C., 1080; Edisto River, S. C., 1082; Salkiehatchie River, S. C., 1084; Sa-
  vannah Harbor and River, Ga., 1086; Savannah River, Ga., 1098; Savannah River
  above Augusta, Ga., 1100; Saint Augustine Creek (Thunderbolt River), Ga., 1102;
  Romerly Marsh, Ga., 1102; Altamaha River, Ga., 1105; Brunswick Harbor, Ga.,
  1112; entrance to Cumberland Sound, Ga. and Fla., 1118; inside passage between
  Fernandina and Saint John's River, Fla., 1124.
                                     CONTENTS.                                      iI

                                  APPENDIX N.

     REPORT OF LIEUT. WILLIAM M. BLACK, CORPS OF ENGINEERS.
IMPROVEMENTS.-Saint John's River, Fla., 1125; Upper Saint John's River, Fla., 1133;
  Volusia Bar, Fla., 1135; Tampa Bay, Fla., 1137; Apalachicola Bay, 1140; Suwanee
  River. Fla., 1143; Key West Harbor, Fla., 1144; Pease Creek, Fla., 1146; harbor
  at Cedar Keys, Fla., 1148; Manatee River, Fla., 1150; Caloosahatchie River, Fla.,
  1152; Apalachicola River, Fla., 1153; Withlacoochee River, Fla., 1155; removing
  sunken vessels or craft obstructing or endangering navigation, 1157.

                                 APPENDIX O.

          REPORT OF CAPT. R. L. HOXIE, CORPS OF ENGINEERS.
IMPROVEMENT.-Ocmulgee River, Ga., 1159; Oconee River, Ga., 1161; Flint River,
  Ga., 1162; Oostenaula and Coosawattee rivers, Ga., 1165; Coosa River, Ga. and
  Ala., 1165; Chattahoochee River, Ga. and Ala., 1168; Alabama River, Ala., 1171;
  Tallapoosa River, Ala., 1172; Cahaba River, Ala., 1173; Conecuh-Escambia River,
  Fla. and Ala., 1175; Choctawhatchee River, Fla. and Ala., 1176; Bayou La Grange,
  Fla., 1178; harbor at Pensacola, Fla., 1179.

                                 APPENDIX P.

         REPORT OF MAJ. A. N. DAMRELL, CORPS OF ENGINEERS.
IMPROVEMENTS.-Mobile. Harbor, Ala., 1183; Warrior and Tombigbee rivers, Ala.
  and Miss., 1193; Tombigbee River, 1196; Black Warrior River, from Tuscaloosa to
  Daniel's Creek, Ala., 1199; Old Town Creek, Miss., 1200; Noxubee. River, Miss.,
  1201; Pascagoula River, Miss., 1203; harbor at Biloxi Bay, Miss., 1205; Horn Island
  Pass, Miss., 1206; Pearl River, Miss., below Jackson, 1207; Pearl River, Miss., from
  Jackson to Carthage, 1212; Pearl River, Miss., between Edinburg and Carthage,
  1214.
EXAMINATIONS AND SURVEYS.-Pascagoula River, Miss., from the mills at Moss Point
  down to the anchorage in the bay, with a view to securing a uniform depth of 12
  feet of water, 1215; Wacissa River, Fla., 1220.

                                 APPENDIX Q.

         REPORT OF MAJ. W. H. HEUER, CORPS OF ENGINEERS.
INSPECTION.-Improvement at the South Pass of the Mississippi River, 1225.

                                 APPENDIX R.

         REPORT OF MAJ. W. H. HEUER, CORPS OF ENGINEERS.
IMPOVEMENTS.-Amite River, La., 1239; Tangipahoa River, La., 1241; Tchefuncte
  River, La., 1242; Tickfaw River, La., 1244; Bayou Teche, La., 1245; connecting
  Bayou Teche with Grand Lake at Charenton, La., 1259; Bayou Black, La., 1261;
   Bayou Courtableau, La., 1263; Bayou Terrebonne, La., 1264; Bayou La Fourche,
  La., 1266; Calcasieu River, La., 1276; Calcasieu Pass., La., 1277; Sabine Pass,
  'rex., 1278; Sabine River, La. and Tex., 1287; Neches River, Tex., 1288; removing
  sunken vessels or craft obstructing or endangering navigation, 1290.

                                 APPENDIX S.

REPORT OF MAJ. S. M. MANSFIELD, CORPS OF ENGINEERS, BVT. LIEUT.
                         COL., U. S. A.

IMPROVEMENTS.-Entrance to Galveston Harbor, Tex., 1291; ship-channel in Galves-
  ton Bay, Tex., 1322; Trinity River, Tex., 1323; Buffalo Bayou, Tex., 1325; chan-
  nel over the bar at the mouth of Brazos River, Tex., 1327; Pass Cavado Inlet to
  Matagorda Bay, Tex., 1328; Aransas Pass and Bay up to' Rockport and Corpus
  Christi, Tex., 1330; harbor at Brazos Santiago, Tex., 1334; protection of river-
  bank at Fort Brown, Tex., 1336.
XII                                  CONTENTS.

                                  APPENDIX T.

        REPORT OF CAPT. ERIC BERGLAND, CORPS OF ENGINERS.
IMPROVEMENTS.-Red River, La. and Ark., 1337 ; survey of Bayou Pierre, La., 1343;
  Cypress Bayou, Tex. and La., 1347; Cane River, La., 1349; Loggy Bayou, Lake
  Bistenean and the Dorcheat, La., 1350; Ouachita and Black rivers, Ark. and La.,
  1351; Bayou Bartholomew, La. and Ark., 1353; Bayou Boeuf, La., 1354; Tensas River
  and Bayou Macon, La., 1355; Bayou D'Arbonne, La., 1356; Yazoo River, Miss.,
  1357; Big Sunflower River, Miss.. 1359; Tchula Lake, Miss., 1360; Tallahatchee
  River, Miss., 1361; Yallabusha River, Miss., 1362; Steele's Bayou, Miss., 1363; Big
  Black River, Miss., 1365; Big Hatchee Ri ver, Tenn., 1366; South Forked Deer River,
  Tenn., 1367; water-gauges on the Mississippi River and its principal tributaries,
  1368.

                                 APPENDIX U.

          REPORT OF CAPT. H. S. TABER, CORPS OF ENGINEERS.
IMPROVEMENTS.-Removing obstructions in Arkansas River, Ark., 1371; Arkansas
  River at Pine Bluff, Ark., 1375; Black River, Ark. and Mo., 1377; White River,
  Ark., 1378; White River above Buffalo Shoals, Ark., 1381; Saint Francis River,
  1382; Saline River, Ark., 1387; L'Anguille River, Ark., 1388.
SURVEYS.-Survey of Arkansas River, Ark., from Little Rock to its mouth, 1389;
  continuation of the survey of Arkansas River from Wichita, Kans., to Fort Gibson,
  Ind. T., 1391:

                                 APPENDIX V.

          REPORT OF MAJ. A. M. MILLER, CORPS OF ENGINEERS.
IMPROVEMENTS.-Removing snags and wrecks from the Mississippi and Missouri
  rivers, 1393; Osage River, Kans. and Mo., 1395; Gasconade River, Mo., 1396.

                                 APPENDIX W.

       REPORT OF CAPT. JAMES B. QUINN, CORPS OF ENGINEERS.
IMPROVEMENT.--Yellowstone River, Mont. and Drk., 1399.

                                 APPENDIX X.

   REPORT OF MAJ. ALEXANDER MACKENZIE, CORPS OF ENGINEERS.
IMPROVEMENTS.-Upper Mississippi River, operations of snag-boats and dredge-boats,
  1403; Mississippi River from Saint Paul to Des Moiues Rapids, 1412; Mississippi
  River from Des Moines Rapids to mouth of the Illinois River, 1422; l~rbor of ref-
  uge in Lake Pepin, at Stockholm, Wis., 1422; harbor of refuge in Lake Pepin, at
  Lake City, Minn., 1424; removal of bar in Mississippi River opposite Dubuque,
  Iowa, 1424; ice-harbor at Dubuque, Iowa, 1426; Rock Island Rapids, Mississippi
  River, 1427; Des Moines Rapids, Mississippi River, 1465; operating and care of
  Des Moines Rapids Canal, 1468; dry-dock at Des Moines Rapids Canal, 1477.

  .                              APPENDIX Y.

      REPORT OF MAJ. CHARLES J. ALLEN, CORPS OF ENGINEERS.
I[MPROVEMENT.-Preservation of Falls of Saint Anthony, Minn., 1479; Mississippi
  River above the Falls of Saint Anthony, Minn., 1483; construction of lock and dam
  on Mississippi River at Meeker's Island, Minn., 1485; Chippewa River, Wis., 1486;
  Chippewa River at Yellow Banks, Wis., 1488; Saint Croix River below Taylor's
  Falls, Minn. and Wis., 1490; Minnesota River, Minn., 1494; Red River of the North,
  Minn. and Dak., 1496; lock and dam at Goose Rapids on Red River of the North,
  Minn. and Dak., 150,0; reservoirs upon the headwaters of the Mississippi River,
  1501; surveys for reservoirs at the sources of the Mississippi, Saint Croix, Chippewa,
and Wisconsin rivers, 1507.
                                   CONTENTS.                                  XIII


                                APPENDIX Z.

    REPORT OF LIEUT. COL. J. W. BARLOW, CORPS OF ENGINEERS.

IMPROVEMENTS.-Tennessee River, 1509; Cumberland River, 1515; Hiawassee River,
  1519; French Broad River, Tenn., 1520; Clinch River, Tenn., 1521; Duck River,
  Tenn., 1523; Caney Fork River, Tenn., 1523; Little Tennessee River, Tenn., 1524;
  South Fork Cumberland River, Ky., 1525.


                              APPENDIX A A.

REPORT OF LIEUT. COL. WILLIAM E. MERRILL, CORPS OF ENGINEERS,
                      BVT. COL., U. S. A.

IMPROVEMENT.-Ohio River, 1528; Operating and care of Davis Island Dam, Ohio
  River, 1540; Monongahela River, W. Va. and Penn., 1542; Operating and care of
  Lock and Dam No. 9, Monongahela River, 1543; Allegheny River, Pa., 1544; Dam
  at Herr's Island, Allegheny River, 1545; ice-harbor at mouth of Muskingum River,
  Ohio, 1546; Muskingum River, Ohio, 1547; operating and care of locks and dams
  on the Muskingum River, Ohio, 1548; harbor of refuge near Cincinnati, Ohio,
  1549; harbor of refuge at mouth of Great Kanawha River, W. Va., 1550.
EXAMINATION AND SURVEY.-Muskingum River, Ohio, 1551.


                              APPENDIX B B.

        REPORT OF MAJ. AMOS STICKNEY, CORPS OF ENGINEERS.

IMPROVEMENTS.-Falls of the Ohio River at Louisville, Ky., 1569; Indiana Chute,
  Falls of the Ohio River, 1572; Louisville and Portland Canal, 1574; Wabash River,
  Ind. and Ill., 1582; White River, Ind., 1586.


                              APPENDIX          C C.

REPORT OF LIEUT. COL. WILLIAM P. CRAIGHILL, CORPS OF ENGINEERS.

IMPROVEMENTs.- Great Kanawha River, W. Va., 1589; Elk River, W. Va., 1598;
  New River, from the mouth of Wilson, in Grayson County, Va., to the mouth of
  Greenbrier River, W. Va., 1599.


                               APPENDIX D D.

        REPORT OF CAPT. JAMES C. POST, CORPS OF ENGINEERS.

IMPROVEMENTS.-Kentucky River, Ky., 1603; operating and keeping in repair locks
  and dams on the Kentucky River, Ky., 1610; Tradewater River, Ky., 1617; Big
  Sandy River, W. Va. and Ky., 1618; Guyandotte River, W. Va., 1622; Little Ka-
  nawha River, W. Va., 1623; Buckhannon River, W. Va., 1624.


                               APPENDIX E E.

       REPORT OF MAJ. CHARLES J. ALLEN, CORPS OF ENGINEERS.

IMPROVEMENTS.-Harbor at Duluth, Minn., 1627; dredging Superior Bay, Wis., 1632;
  harbor at Grand Marais, Minn., 1637.
XIV                                CONTENTS.


                              APPENDIX F F.

   REPORT OF CAPT. CHARLES E. L. B. DAVIS, CORPS OF ENGINEERS.

IMPROVEMENTs.- Ontonagon Harbor, Mich., 1641; Eagle Harbor, Mich., 1643; Mar-
  quette, Harbor, Mich., 1645; harbor of refuge at Grand Marais, Mich.. 1646; Man-
  istique Harbor, Mich., 1649; harbor at mouth of Cedar River, Mich., 1650; Meno-
  monee Harbor, Mich. and Wis., 1652; Oconto Harbor, Wis., 1653; Pensaukee Har-
  bor, Wis., 1656; Green Bay Harbor, Wis., 1658; harbor of refuge at entrance of
  Sturgeon Bay Canal, Wis., 1660; Ahnepee Harbor, Wis., 1662; Kewaunee Harbor,
  Wis., 1663; Two Rivers Harbor, Wis., 1665; Manitowoc Harbor, Wis., 1667; She-
  boygan Harbor, Wis., 1670; Port Washington Harbor, Wis., 1672.
SURVEY.-Ashland Harbor, in Ashland Bay, Lake Superior, 1674.


                              APPENDIX          G G.

      REPORT OF CAPT. W. L. MARSHALL, CORPS OF ENGINEERS.

IMPROVEMENTS.-Harbor of refuge, Milwaukee Bay, Wis., 1679; Milwaukee Harbor,
  Wis., 1680; Racine Harbor, Wis., 1682; Kenosha Harbor, Wis., 1684; Waukegan
  Harbor, Ill., 1685; Fox and Wisconsin rivers, Wis., 1686.


                              APPENDIX H H.

      REPORT OF MAJ. W. H. H. BENYAURD, CORPS OF ENGINEERS.

IMPROVEMENTS.-Chicago Harbor, Ill., 1701; Calumet Harbor, Ill., 1704; Illinois
  River, 1705; Calumet River, 1707.
SURVEYS.-For Hennepin Canal, 1708.


                               APPENDIX          I I.

      REPORT OF CAPT. D. W. LOCKWOOD, CORPS OF ENGINEERS.

IMPROVEMENTS.-Charlevoix Harbor, Mich., 1755; Frankfort Harbor, Mich., 1757;
  harbor of refuge at Portage Lake, Mich., 1758; Manistee Harbor, Mich., 1759;
  Ludington Harbor, Mich., 1761; Pentwater Harbor, Mich., 1762; White River
  Harbor, Mich., 1762; Muskegon Harbor, Mich , 1764; Grand Haven Harbor, Mich.,
  1766; Grand River, Mich,, 1767; Black Lake Harbor, Mich., 1768; Saugatuck Har-
  bor, Mich., 1769; South Haven Harbor, Mich., 1770; Saint Joseph Harbor, Mich.,
  1771; Michigan City Harbor, Ind., 1774.


                               APPENDIX          J J.

REPORT OF LIEUT. COL. O. M. POE, CORPS OF ENGINEERS, BVT. BRIG.
                          GEN., U. S. A.

IMPROVEMENTS.-Hay Lake Channel, Saint Mary's River, Mich., 1777; Saint Mary's
  Falls Canal and River, Mich., 1783; operating and care of Saint Mary's Falls Canal,
  Mich., 1809; dry-dock at Saint Mary's Falls Canal, Mich., 1823; harbor at Cheboy-
  gan, Mich., 1824; harbor at Thunder Bay, Mich., 1825; harbor at Au Sable, Mich.,
  1825; Saginaw River, Mich., 1826; harbor of refuge, Sand Beach, Lake Huron,
  Mich., 1829; steam launch or tug for harbor of refuge, Lake Huron, Mich., 1836;
  ice-harbor of refuge at Belle River, \Iich., 1837; general repairs and renewals at
  Saint Clair Flats Ship Canal, Mich., 1837; operating and care of Saint Clair Flats
  Canal, Mich., 1838; Clinton Riyer, Mich , 1842; Detroit River, Mich., 1842.
                                   CONTENTS.                                     XV

                               APPENDIX K K.

     REPORT OF MAJ. L. COOPER OVERMAN, CORPS OF ENGINEERS.
IMPROVEMENTS.-Monroe Harbor, Mich., 1847; Toledo Harbor, Ohio, 1849; Port
  Clinton Harbor, Ohio, 1854; Sandusky City Harbor, Ohio, 1855; Sandusky River,
  Ohio, 1857; Huron Harbor, Ohio, 1858; Vermillion Harbor, Ohio, 1859; mouth of
  Black River, Ohio, 1861 ; Rocky River, Ohio, 1862; ('leveland Harbor, Ohio, 1863;
  Fairport Harbor, Ohio, 1868; Ashtabula Harbor, Ohio, 1871; Conneaut Harbor,
  Ohio, 1873; Dunkirk Harbor, N. Y., 1874; removing sunken vessels or craft ob-
  structing or endangering navigation, 1876.

                               APPENDIX L L.

     REPORT OF CAPT. EDWARD MAGUIRE, CORPS OF ENGINEERS.
IMPROVEMENTS.-Erie Harbor, Pa., 1879; Buffalo Harbor, N. Y., 1881; Niagara River,
  N. Y., 1884; Wilson Harbor, N. Y., 1885; Olcott Harbor, N. Y., 1885; Oak Orchard
  Harbor, N. Y., 1886; Charlotte Harbor, N. Y., 1887; Pultneyville Harbor, N. Y.,
  1889; Great Sodus Harbor, N. Y., 1890; Little Sodus Harbor, N. Y., 1891; Oswego
  Harbor, N. Y., 1892; Sackett's Harbor, N. Y., 1894.

                               APPENDIX M M.

          REPORT OF MAJ. M. B. ADAMS, CORPS OF ENGINEERS.
IMPROVEMENTS.-Ogdensburg Harbor, N. Y., 1895; Grass River at Massena, N. Y.,
  1898; Breakwater at Rouse's Point, Lake Champlain, N. Y., 1899; Swanton Har-
  bor, Vt., 1901; Plattsburg Harbor, N. Y., 1902; Burlington Harbor, Vt., 1903; Otter
  Creek, Vt., 1905; Ticonderoga River, N. Y., 1905.

                               APPENDIX NN.

REPORT OF LIEUT. COL. G. H. MENDELL, CORPS OF ENGINEERS, BVT.
                          COL., U. S. A.
IMPROVEMENTS.-Oakland Harbor, Cal., 1907; Wilmington Harbor, Cal., 1911; Red-
  wood Harbor, Cal., 1914; removal of sunken vessels or craft obstructing or endan-
  gering navigation, 1915.
                                        0.
                               APPENDIX O

    REPORT OF COL. C. SEAFORTH STEWART, CORPS OF ENGINEERS.
IMPROVEMENT. -Harbor     at San Diego, Cal., 1917.

                               APPENDIX P P.

         REPORT OF CAPT. A. H. PAYSON, CORPS OF ENGINEERS.

IMPROVEMENTS.-Humboldt Harbor and Bay, Cal., 1919; San Joaquin River, Stock-
  ton and Mormon sloughs, Cal., 1921; Mokelumne River, Cal., 1924; Sacramento
  and Feather rivers, Cal., 1926; Colorado River, Nev., Cal., and Ariz., 1929.

                               APPENDIX Q Q.

           REPORT OF MAJ. W. A. JONES, CORPS OF ENGINEERS.

IMrROVEMENT.-Columbia and Willamette rivers below Portland, Oreg., 1938;
  Upper Willamette River, Oreg., 1940; Columbia River at Cascades, Oreg., 1942;
  Upper Columbia and Snake rivers, Oreg. and Wash., 1949; Cowlitz River, Wash.
  1952; Lower Clearwater River, Idaho, 1952.
EXAMINATIONS AND SURVEY.-Columbia River above mouth of Snake River, Wash.,
  1953; Columbia and Snake rivers, 1970.
XVI                                   CONTENTS.

                                APPENDIX R R.

   REPORT OF CAPT. CHARLES F. POWELL, CORPS OF ENGINEERS.

IMPROVEMENTS.-Mouth of the Columbia River, Oreg. and Wash., 1972; entrance to
  Coos Bay, Oreg., 1989; entrance to Yaquina Bay, Oreg., 1998; mouth of Coquille
  River, Oreg., 2003; Umpqua River, Oreg., 2005; Skagit, Steilaquamish, Nootsack,
  Snohomish, and Snoqualmie rivers, Wash., 2007; Chehalis River, Wash., 2009;
  gauging waters of the Columbia River and principal tributaries, 2010.

                                APPENDIX S S.

        REPORT OF MAJ. G. J. LYDECKER, CORPS OF ENGINEERS.

IMPROVEMENTS.-Washington Aqueduct, 2013; increasing the water supply of the
  city of Washington, 2043; erection of fish-ways at the Great Falls of the Potomac
  River, 2061.
                                APPENDIX T T.

                 REPORT OF COL. JOHN M. WILSON, U. S. A.

IMPROVEMENT and care of public buildings and grounds in the District of Colum-
  bia, 2075.
                                APPENDIX U U.

        BRIDGING NAVIGABLE WATERS OF THE UNITED STATES.

Bridge across the Mississippi River at Keithsburg, in the State of Illinois, 2111; stone-
  arch bridge across the West Channel of the Mississippi River at Minneapolis, Minn.,
  2111; proposed bridge across the Ohio River at or near Cairo, Ill., 2116; bridge or
  the Selma Bridge Company across the Alabama River at Selma, Ala., 2136; changes
  in the original plan of the bridge across the Ohio River at Henderson Ky., 2137.

                                APPENDIX V V.

SUPPLEMENTAL REPORT IOF THE MISSISSIPPI RIVER COMMISSION, 2143.

Q. A. GILLMORE, Col. of Engineers, Bvt. Maj. Gen., U. S. A., President.
C. B. COMSTOCK, Lieut. Col. of Engineers, Bvt. Brig. Gen., U. S. A.,
CHARLES R. SUTER, Major of Engineers, U. S. A.,
Mr. HENRY MITCHELL, Coast and Geodetic Survey,
Mr. B. M. HARROD, Civil Engineer,
Mr. S. WM. FERGUSON, Civil Engineer,
Mr. ROBERT S. TAYLOR,
                     Commissioners.

                               APPENDIX W W.

SUPPLEMENTARY REPORT OF THE MISSOURI RIVER COMMISSION, 2167.

CHARLES R. SUTER, Major of Engineers, U. S. A., President.
ALEX. MACKENZIE, Major of Engineers,
O. H. ERNST, Major of Engineers,
Mr. G. C. BROADHEAD,
Mr. WILLIAM J. BROATCH,
                   Commissioners.
[EXTRACT FROM THE ANNUAL REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF WAR.]

                                             WAR DEPARTMENT,
                                                    November 30, 1886.



                          ENGINEER BUREAU.

   During the past year work in connection with fortifications has been
restricted to that necessary for their preservation and repair. This
whole subject has been elaborately and carefully treated in the report
of the Board on Fortifications or other Defenses, submitted at the last
session, to which I again invite the special attention of Congress. The
utterly defenseless condition of our sea-coast and lake frontier is now
well understood by every civilized nation in the world, and immediate
action should be taken to prevent the disastrous and humiliating results
that might follow a declaration of war with the most insignificant of
foreign powers possessing guns,and ships of modern construction.
   What is needed for the defense of our sea-coast may be briefly stated.
The principal cities named in-the report of the Board on Fortifications
should be fortified, and work on those most important should be begun
at once, viz: New York, San Francisco, Boston, and Washington. The
defenses required must be erected and prepared to resist attack from
the water. For the great ports of Europe such defenses must also be
arranged to resist the attack of armies by land. But no considerable
army will, in all human probability, cross the sea and attempt the
invasion of our territory at these populous points. War vessels
would be sufficient for such attacks; and, besides, armies can be
rapidly raised and armed by us for defense against troops. We have,
therefore, a single problem to solve in defending our cities: How best
to resist and silence the armored ships and the steel guns and
mortars of modern construction. It can only be accomplished by
guns of equal force to those which any enemy can bring against us,
and by torpedoes or submarine mines laid in the navigable channels,
both so guarded and protected that they can do efficient,service when
required. We have no gun now which can stop the progress of or do
any material injury to a well-armored ship. The manufacture of a gun
is a work of time, and of a long time, and cannot be extemporized when
wanted. Torpedoes may be more quickly created, but still time and
money are needed for their construction. It has been said by a well-
inforjned writer on the subject that it is a matter of doubt if we have
                                                                XVII
      E--II
XVIII   EXTRACT FROM ANNUAL REPORT OF SECRETARY OF WAR.

on hand enough cables and cases to control with torpedoes the chan-
nels past Sandy Hook alone.
   The work has been thoroughly considered and laid out, and the En-
gilneer and Ordnance Corps of the Army are ready to begin, and only
wait for the appropriations from Congress.
   While there have been some differences of opinion in regard to the best
methods of preparing armor-plate for fortifications, requiring still further
study and experiment, there is no reason why this should delay the be-
ginning of the important work of fortifying our great harbors. The
preparation of sites and masonry foundations for batteries, casemates,
and turrets, and also the construction of submarine mines, and of
earthen batteries for rifled mortars, are works equally necessary as the
work of procuring the best armor, and can be constructed before the
armor-plate is required.
   Owing to the failure of appropriations for the present fiscal year,
either for fortifications or torpedoes, experiments on torpedoes have
been suspended, which had gradually developed a system of fixed mines,
which, if appropriations are renewed, promises to produce the best re-
sults. In the present condition of the sea-coast defenses, a detailed de-
scription of which is contained in the report of the Chief of Engineers,
our main reliance in case of war would be on fixed mines. The num-
ber on hand is insignificant, and the preparations for operating them
have yet to be made.
   I would also invite attention to the necessity for keeping in the service
at all times a sufficient force of engineer soldiers, well instructed in
their duties as a torpedo corps and able to place torpedoes in position
before an enemy's fleet could arrive in front of one of our important
harbors. The practical instruction of our engineer troops in the details
of this special service has to a great exltent, through want of appropri-
ations, been suspended and their efficiency thereby much impaired.
    I also desire to call attention to the needs of the Engineer School of
Application at Willets Point. This establishment, where the torpedo
experiments are carried on, is doing excellent work in preparing lieu-
tenants of engineers and of artillery as experts in torpedo warfare. It
is of the first importance that appropriations should be made as re-
quested for the school, for water sewage, additional quarters for officers,
and the other items mentioned in the estimates already submitted to
Congress.
    The funds with which the works of river and harbor improvement
were prosecuted during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1886,were, ow-
ing to the failure of appropriations during the second session of the
Forty-eighth Congress, derived mainly from such balances as remained
on hand from the appropriations of the act of July 5, 1884, and in many
instances, these being only sufficient for the care of the public property
appertaining to the works, operations were necessarily suspended. The
report of the Chief of Engineers sets forth the condition of each im-
     EXTRACT FROM ANNUAL REPORT OF SECRETARY OF WAR.                  XIX

provement, the extent of the work performed during the' last fiscal year,
the amount of money expended, and, in compliance with the provisions
of the river and harbor act of March 2, 1867, estimates of the amount
that can be profitably expended during the fiscal year ending June 30,
1888, with the probable cost of completion.
   The examination and surveys at places required and provided for in
the river and harbor act of August 5, 188f, have been assigned to the
officers in charge of the several river and harbor districts. Reports
thereon will be transmitted to Congress from time to time during the
ensuing session.
   A statement is given in the report of the Chief of Engineers of the
action taken during the year upon such pllans and locations as were
submitted, by parties interested, of bridges proposed to be built over
navigable waters under authority of Congress, subject to the approval
of the Secretary of War. Examinations were also made, whenever re-
quested by committees of Congress, of proposed bills authorizing'the
construction of bridges, upon which the views of the War Department
were desired; of bills so examined during the last session of Congress
fifteen originated in the Senate and forty-three in the House of Repre-
sentatives. A statement is also given of the work accomplished in the
removal of wrecks obstructing or endangering navigation, general pro-
vision for which is made in the river and harbor act of June 14, 1880,
enlarged by provisions of the river and harbor act of August 2, 1882.
   In consequence of the provisions of section 2 of the river and harbor
act of July 5, 1884, which require the Secretary of War to report to Con-
gress whether any bridges, causeways, or structures erected or being
erected interfere with free and safe navigation, and, if so, to report the
best mode of altering or constructing them, the Chief of Engineers was
instructed to submit reports covering all facts necessary to enable a com-
pliance with the terms of the act, and a communication enumerating all
instances reported to date, of interference with free and safe navigation
was transmitted to the Senate December 18, 1885.
   The small appropriation asked for the next fiscal year for surveys re-
quired for military purposes and for the publication of maps for the use
of the War Department is earnestly recommended.

         IMPROVEMENT OF SOUTH PASS, MISSISSIPPI RIVER.

   In the last annual report of the Department the record of this work
was brought down to September 9, 1885. The channel has been main-
tained as required by law for a full year within the period from Sep-
tember 10, 1885, to September 26, 1886, both dates inclusive, for which
Mr. Eads has been paid $100,000, and also $50,000 for one year's in-
terest on the $1,000,000 retained, making the total expenditures to
September 26, 1886, inclusive, $5,300,000. During seventeen days of
this time there was not a legal maintenance of the channel, for which
period no payment has been made.
XX   EXTRACT FROM ANNUAL              REPORT OF SECRETARY              OF WAR.

  The funds appropriated by the act of July 5, 1884, for testing the
depth of water and width of channel were exhausted at the end of
November, 1885, and the employes voluntarily continued work for seven
months without pay, relieving the Government from any obligation
unless Congress should appropriate funds for the purpose. As the law
requires the examinations and surveys, in order that payments may be
made to Mr. Eads for the legal maintenance of the channel, it is recom-
mended that the appropriation for the expenses thereof be made as an
independent measure.
                 WATER SUPPLY OF WASHINGTON, D. C.

   The work for increasing the water supply of Washington, D. C., has
been continued. The dam across the Potomac River at Great Falls is
nearly completed, and the whole work will be finished during the pres-
ent season. The tunnel has been excavated for a distance of 5,040 feet,
making the whole length of excavation 18,538 feet, and leaving unfin-
ished 2,150 feet at the close of the fiscal year. The sum provided in the
general deficiency appropriation for continuing this work is $395,000.
The ultimate cost of completion, however, will probably exceed this
amount, in consequence of the suspension of the work, which continued
for a period of six months, the available funds having been exhausted
February 1, 1886. Work on the reservoir was continued during the
year, and it is believed that the amount appropriated in the general
deficiency act, viz, $160,000, will be sufficient to complete it in all its
essential features.
                 RECLAMATION        OF THE POTOMAC FLATS.

   The project for the improvement of the Potomac River in the vicinity
of Washington was adopted by act of Congress of August 2, 1882, and
has for its object the improvement of navigation, the establishment of
harbor lines, and the elevation of the fiats in front of the city. The ex-
penditures for the improvement have thus far amounted to $739,574.
   The work has been retarded by the great number of freshets occur-
ring during the year, and by the failure to make an appropriation in
1885. It is of the utmost importance that large appropriations should
be made in the early stages of a work of this character and magnitude.
It is now in such a state of progress that it is liable to great damage
from freshets, and it should be pushed rapidly to a point nearer com-
pletion. The sum of $700,000 could be profitably expended during the
fiscal year ending June 30, 1888, in continuing the work in accordance
with the project.
                   BRIDGES OVER NAVIGABLE              WATERS.

   In view of the urgent necessity for legislation to prevent the obstruc-
tion of the navigable waters of the United States, I quote the remarks
upon the subject in my last annual report:
  Under the act of Congress of July 5, 1884, the city of Saint Paul was authorized to
construct bridges across the Mississippi River at that city, upon plans subject to the
      EXTRACT FROM ANNUAL REPORT OF SECRETARY OF WAR.                               XXI

approval of the Secretary of War. The plans of a bridge designed to be erected by
the city were submitted to me for approval in March last, according to the provisions
of the act. After consultation with the Chief of Engineers I was unable to approve
them; but at the request of the authorities of Saint Paul I submitted the question to
the Attorney-General, and in his opinion the plans were not in conformity to the pro-
visions of the act. During this.investigation it appeared that directly below the
main span of the proposed city bridge, which, in accordance with the act, was 300
feet in width, there had been erected in the middle of the navigable portion of the
stream, by the Minnesota and Northwestern Railroad Company, a large pier 40 feet
in width, which was to form a part of a bridge across the river about to be built by
that company. This fact was accordingly reported to the Attorney-General, who re-
plied that "in the existing state of the law the facts of the present case afford no
ground for a judicial proceeding on behalf of the United States against the railroad
company, and that until Congress makes some adequate provision upon the subject
the officers of the United States can in this case take no action to enforce the rights
of the Government and give effect to the duty resting upon it to protect the naviga-
tion of the Mississippi River." This railroad bridge above referred to has not been
officially reported upon by the Engineer Department, because, not having been au-
thorized by act of Congress, it is not under the jurisdiction of this Department; but
it is believed to be an obstruction to navigation; The railroad company claims au-
thority to erect it under the act of the Territorial legislature of Minnesota of 1854,
and asserts that the authority to build bridges across the Mississippi River and its
tributaries within the State of Minnesota under the authority of the laws of that
State has been exercised in several cases.
    The Attorney-General, in the decision above referred to, remarks: "As the Missis-
sippi River above, at, and for some distance below the city of Saint Paul is wholly
within the State of Minnesota, the principle enunciated by the Supreme Court of the
United States in Wilson v. The Blackbird Creek Marsh Company (2 Pet., 250) ; Gilman
v. Philadelphia, (3 Wall., 713); Pound v. Turck (95 U. S., 459); and Escanaba Com-
pany v. Chicago (107 U. S.,678) applies to this case, namely, that until Congress acts
and by appropriate legislation assumes control of the subject, the power of a State
over bridges across navigable streams within its limits is plenary."
    The only general power which the Secretary of War has to act in the matter of
bridges which obstruct navigation is found in section 8 of the river and harbor act of
July 5, 1884. This law does not prevent the erection of bridges which obstruct navi-
gation, but prescribes that the Secretary of War shall require such aids to the passage
of the draw-openings or raft-spans of such bridges as lie may deem necessary.
   This recital discloses the fact that a private corporation, acting under the authority
of a Territorial act, is obstructing the main navigable channel of the Mississippi
within a few hundred feet of the spot where Congress, in authorizing the city of Saint
Paul to build a bridge, provided there should be a span over the channel leaving a
clear water-way of not less than 300 feet in width. It has been thought proper to
call the attention of Congress to this question.
  This pier is an obstruction to navigation, and would seem to fall
within that class of cases which it is the duty of the Secretary of War
to report to Congress under the last paragraph of section 4 of the
river and harbor act of August 5, 1886.
        *          *           *           *           *           *          *
     ANNUAL      REPORT
             OF THE




CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,
    UNITED   STATES ARMY.




         1886.

                            OMMe.
                                       REPORT
                                                OF


   THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,
                            UNITED           STATES ARMY.




                             OFFICE OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,
                                           UNITED STATES ARMY,
                                  Washington, D. C., October 28, 1886.
  SIR: I have the honor to present for your information the following
report upon the duties and operations of the Engineer Department for
the fiscal year ending June 30, 1886:

            OFFICERS OF THE CORPS OF ENGINEERS.

   The number of officers holding commissions in the Corps of En-
gineers, United States Army, at the end of the fiscal year was 108 on
the active list, two of whom were graduates of the Military Academy
and commissioned second lieutenants, Corps of Engineers, to date June
14, 1885, and eight on the retired list; the latter, however, under sec-
tion 1259 Revised Statutes, not being available for duty.
   Since the last annual report the Corps has lost by death one of its
officers, Capt. Thomas N. Bailey, who died at Willets Point, N. Y.,
April 20, 1886.
   On the 30th of June, 1886, the officers were distributed as follows:
Office Chief of Engineers, including the Chief ..................................                  3
Office Chief of Engineers and Public Buildings and Grounds....................                     1
Fortifications and river and harbor works .....................................                   14
Fortifications, river and harbor works, Board of Engineers, and Board of Visit-
  ors at Engineer School of Application ........................................                   1
Fortifications and Battalion of Engineers ..................                     ................ 1
Fortifications, river and harbor works, and light-house duty ...................                   2
Fortifications, river and harbor works, Board of Visitors at Engineer School of
  Application, and Mississippi River Commission.-.........................                         1
Fortifications, river and harbor works, and supervising engineer ...............                   2
River and harbor works......................................................                      30
River and harbor works and light-house duty .............. ...................                     3
River and harbor works and Missouri River Commission........................                       2
Mississippi River Commission, Missouri River Commission, and light-house duty.                      1
Board of Engineers, Board of Visitors at Engineer School of Application, Missis-
  sippi River Commission, supervising engineer, Post. of Willets Point, and En-
  gineer School of Application .................................................                    1
Board of Engineers, Board of Visitors at Engineer School of Application, and
  light-house duty ............................................................                     1
Board of Engineers and Board of Visitors at Engineer School of Application.....                     1
Supervising engineer................----..................................                          1
Publications of geological surveys west of the one hundredth meridian......-....                    1
                                                                                              3
4           REPORT OF THE                    CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

Washington Aqueduct ........................                          ..........     ............----...               .     1
Battalion of Engineers----......-----..--....--.........--..... ..........--------- ....-----......----.....----. 15
Leave of absence.....--........................................................--                                  3
Detached, on duty with generals commanding divisions and departments, Light-
  House Establishment, Military Academy, Board of Commissioners of the Dis-
  trict of Columbia, the Mississippi River and Missouri River Commissions, and
  construction of building for State, War, and Navy Departments, &c..........                                     23
                                                                                                                           108

    The officers detached were on duty as follows:
Col. Thomas L. Casey, in charge of the construction of the building for the State,
  War, and Navy Departments; of the Washington National Moinument; of the
  improvements over the grave of Thomas Jefferson, at Monticello, Va.; of the
  erection of a pedestal and statue of the late President Garfield ; of a monument
  at Washington's Headquarters at Newburgh, N. Y.; of the erection of a monu-
  ment to mark the birthplace of George Washington, and of the erection of
   building fior the Army Medical Museum and Library; member of Advisory
  Board to Committee on Ventilation and Acoustics of the House of Representa-
  tives; member of the Light-House Board-.....                                  -..........................--.. 1
Maj. David P. Heap, engineer secretary to the Light-House Board..------------............                                1
Maj. William Ludlow, Engineer Commissioner of the District of Columbia......                                             1
Maj. William S. Stanton, engineer first and second light-house districts-.---- .                                         1
Maj. Thomas H. Handbury, on staff of Commanding General, Division of the Mis-
  souri .....------------------------------..................................................................            1
Capt. James F. Gregory, engineer fifth and sixth light-house districts ..........                                        1
Capt. John C. Mallery, engineer fourth light-house district-........--                                  ..........       1
Capt. Thomas Turtle, secretary and disbursing officer of the Mississippi River
  Commission...- .....................                      ........       ...... ............-----.....---------.....   1
Capts. Frederick A. Mahan and Thomas W. Symons, and Lieut. Eugene Griffin,
  assistants to Engineer Commissioner of District of Columbia.... ..............                                         3
Capt. Philip M. Price and Lieut. James G. Warren, on duty with Company E,
  Battalion of Engineers, and at Military Academy ............................                                           2
Capt. Dan C. Kingman, on staff of Commanding General, Department of the Platte.                                          1
Lieuts. Walter L. Fisk, Gustav J. Fiebeger, and George W. Goethals, on duty at
  Military Academy ......-----......-----............-----........-------..--...       --...------------....-
                                                                              ------......                  ---- ---.    3
Lieut. Thomas L. Casey, on staff of Commanding General, Division of the Pacific
  and Department of California..........-----......---------------.... ......--......... ---- ..--........                1
Lieut. Theodore A. Bingham, secretary and disbursing officer of The Missouri
  River Commission                                                           .....            ..--         .....----      11......---"------
Lieut. John Millis, on duty under the immediate orders of Colonel Duane as his
  assistant in connection with experiments upon electric lighting -.............                                         1
Lieut. John Biddle, on staff of Commanding General, Department of Dakota ....                                              1
Lieut. Edward Burr, on staff of Commanding General, Department of the Co-
  lumbia..----..-...---...... ..---------......--......-----......------......---- --....------....----..--......
                                                                                                           -........---....1
Lieut. Eugene J. Spencer, on staff of Commanding General, Department of Arizona.                                           1
                                                                                                                            23

          SEA-COAST                  AND        LAKE-FRONTIER                              DEFENSES.

  During the year operations have been restricted to those necessary
for the preservation and repair of existing works.
   The subject of the defensive system of the country, so far as regards
the ports at which fortifications or other defenses are most urgently re-
quired, has received the careful consideration of a Board of distinguished
officers and civilians, of which the Secretary of War was President, and
that Board has submitted an elaborate and complete report to Congress,
showing the utterly defenseless condition of our sea-coast and lake
frontier.
   It is believed that the failure of Congress to make appropriations for
this all-important work has mainly arisen from the difficulty in deter-
mining the best method of procuring armor-plate.
   The preparation of the sites, the construction of masonry foundations,
the building of mortar batteries, work equally as necessary as that of
                       DEFENSES             OF THE NORTHERN FRONTIER.                                                    5
procuring armor, will demand much time; and it is earnestly recom-
mended that funds be at once appropriated for the emplacements of
turrets and casements, for earthen batteries, for 12-inch rifled mortars,
and for submarine mines, all of which can be accomplished before ar-
mor-plate is required.
   The estimates now submitted are based upon the present defensive
system of our coasts, the amount estimated for preservation and repair
of fortifications being required to prevent such modern batteries as we
now have from going to ruin, and to maintain old works, many of which
can now only be considered as relics of an historic past.
   For fuller and more detailed estimates for the important work of con-
structing a complete system of defensive works for the more important
harbors on our coast, I respectfully invite attention to report of the
Board on Fortifications or other Defenses, to which I have already re-
ferred. (See Appendix No. 3.)
   Attention is invited to the estimates for torpedoes. For the present
our principal reliance for harbor defense in case of war must rest upon
fixed mines, and it is very necessary that there should be a full supply
of these on hand at the principal sea-ports of the nation.
   Owing to the failure of Congress to make appropriations either for
fortifications or torpedoes for the present fiscal year, it has become
necessary not only to suspend torpedo experiments, but also to a great
extent the practical instruction of the engineer troops in the details of
this service. These experiments have been in progress for some years,
and a system of fixed mines has been developed and gradually improved
until it bids fair before long, if funds are available, to reach the highest
point of excellence.

          ESTIMATES            OF APPROPRIATIONS                      REQUIRED             FOR 1887-'88.

For acquisition of sites of two martello towers at Key West, Fla., by pur-
  chase or condemnation.............. ..............................--------------------------------------------..   $9, 000
For purchase of additional land at Fort Hamilton, N. Y .................... 180,000
For protecting site of Fort Niagara, N. Y ..........                ................                ....            20,000
For sea-wall at Governor's Island, New York Harbor.................                                             .50,000
For sea-wall at David's Island, New York Harbor ........................                                             35,000
For earth embankment at David's Island, New York Harbor..............                                      .        12, 000
       Fort Marion, Florida :
For restoration of the old fort to the condition, substantially, in which it
  was left by the Spaniards ............    .......   .............                      ...............            10, 000
For protection, preservation, and repair of fortifications for which there
  may be no special appropriation available ............. ...... .........                                         175, 000
For purchase of submarine mines and necessary appliances to operate them
  for closing the channels leading to our principal sea-ports...... ........ 300, 000
For needful casemates, cable galleries, &c., to render it possible to operate
   submarine mines ......................................................                                        200,000
For continuing torpedo experiments, and for practical instruction of Engi-
   neer troops in the details of service ..............................                                            30, 000
For torpedo-shed at San Francisco Harbor ..................
                                                        ......
                                                             ....                                                 22, 000
         Total---...... ----....---------..------..--------------....................
                                                                     1,043, 000

                        DEFENSES            OF THE NORTHERN FRONTIER.

  Fort Wayne, Michigan, in charge of Lieut. Col. 0. M. Poe, Corps of
Engineers.--This work is situated on the west bank of Detroit River,
adjacent to the city of Detroit, and is intended to command the chan-
nel of the river.
         REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

         DEFENSES      OF THE NORTHERN          FRONTIER-continued.

  It is a nearly square bastioned work, with brick and concrete scarp,
semi-detached on curtains and faces, and unfinished water batteries on
the up-stream and down-stream sides.
  The construction of the fort in its present form was begun in 1862
and completed in 1871.
  Since the last annual report work has been confined to repairing 13
gun-platforms and the demilune magazine. The work was done by
hired labor.
  No estimate of funds required to complete the work is submitted.
No appropriation was made for the fiscal year ending June 30, 1887.
No appropriation asked for next fiscal year.
   Fort Porter, Black Rock, near Buffalo, New York, in charge of Capt.
Edward Maguire, Corps of Engineers.-This work, commenced in 1842,
is situated on the Niagara River, within the limits of the city of Buffalo,
and consists of a square stone tower or keep, in ruins, surrounded by a
square barbette battery.
   The keep was nearly destroyed by fire many years ago, and the entire
work is, in its present condition, useless for offense or defense.
   By joint resolution of Congress, approved July 11, 18707 published in
General Orders 93, July 22, 1870, permission was granted to the city of
Buffalo, through its park commissioners, "to improve and beautify the
grounds known as Fort Porter, situated in said city, and belonging to
the United States, in connection with a public park to be laid out on
land adjoining the said grounds, the plans for the same to be approved
by the Secretary of War: Provided, That this resolution shall not be
construed to pass any title in the said grounds, but that the ownership
and control of said grounds shall remain entirely in the United States,
and shall be subject to such changes and uses for military purposes as
the Secretary of War may direct."
   Under date of April 12, 1884, the Secretary of War granted permis-
sion to the park commissioners to construct a roadway through the reser-
vation, cutting the rampart of the fort.
   Under the above-mentioned authorities the larger part of the United
States grounds has been handsomely laid out and improved by the city
of Buffalo. The roadway was constructed, necessitating the tearing
down of the west angle, including the hot-shot furnace and the river
face. Along this face a wooden fence was erected.
No appropriation was made for the fiscal year ending June 30, 1887.
No appropriation asked for next fiscal year.
  Fort Niagara,mouth of Niagara River, New York, in charge of Capt.
Edward Maguire, Corps of Engineers.-This work, commenced in 1839,
is situated at the mouth of the Niagara River, on the south shore of
Lake Ontario, about 40 miles from, and east of, its western extremity.
   It is an irregular work, having one strong land (front running nearly
north and south, extending from Lake Ontario at its northern extremity
nearly to the Niagara River at its southern extremity. This front is
half bastioned, with detached parapet, demilune, and four casemates
for howitzers in each flank. The rest of the trace'is irregular, following
the general course of the river and of the lake shore.
  The work contains two masonry block-houses, built by the Frenc.h
about 1757, and other buildings begun by the French and finished by
the English after its capture by them during the French and Indian
war.
                              SEA-COAST       DEFENSES.

          DEFENSES OF THE NORTHERN FRONTIER-continued.

   No money has been expended on this work since 1871, except for
slight repairs.
No appropriation was made for the fiscal year ending June 30, 1887.
Appropriation asked for next fiscal year for protection of site of work .......   $20, 000
   Fort Ontario, mouth of Oswego River, New York, in charge of Capt.
Edward Maguire, Corps of Engineers.--This work is situated at the
mouth of the Oswego River, on its east bank, and on the south shore of
Lake Ontario, and lies within the limits of the city of Oswego.
   The work was commenced in 1839 and continued at intervals until
1872, at which time constructive operations ceased; since which expend-
itures have been limited to minor repairs. Its condition is essentially
the same as stated in the Annual Report for 1885. The fort was regar-
risoned in the spring of 1884.
   During the fiscal year the ditch-drains on Fronts Nos. I and II were
cleaned and repaired; a new roof was built on the Engineerstore-house,
and the revetment in rear of the officers' quarters and around the mag-
azine area was repaired.
   In other respects no changes have taken place in the work since last
reported upon.
   During the year no change has been made in the armament of this
work, or in its condition to receive armament.
No appropriation was made for the fiscal year ending June 30, 1887.
No appropriation asked for next fiscal year.
   Fort lJlontgomery, outlet to Lake Champlain, New York, in charge of
Maj. M. B. Adams, Corps of Engineers.-Thiscasemated work is situated
on the west shore of the outlet to Lake Champlain, about one-third of a
mile from the Canadian boundary, and occupies a strategic point of
great importance, and commands the entrance to Lake Champlain from
the Richelieu or Saint John River.
   This work was commenced in 1841, and its rebuilding in its present
form was accomplished in 1876, and completes the work, except the in-
terior fittings of a part of the casements intended for quarters, and also
parts of Bastions A and E, where temporary woooden floors have been
built for the second tier of casements.
   During the fiscal year ending June 30, 1886, operationA at this work
have been confined to the repairs of five center pintle and six front pin-
tle platforms, and the renewal of the wood-work of the bridge over the
moat.
No appropriation was made for the fiscal year ending June 30, 1887.
No appropriation asked for next fiscal year.

                           SEA-COAST DEFENSES.

                        DEFENSES       OF THE PENOBSCOT.

  Fort Knox, Bucksport, Penobscot River, Maine, in charge of Col. C. E.
Blunt, Corps of Engineers, until February 28, 1886; since that date in
charge of Maj. Jared A. Smith, Corps of Engineers.-This work, situated
at the narrows of the Penobscot River, furnishes a defense for the city
of Bangor, 18 miles above, and other towns bordering the river, and
renders it available as a secure harbor of refuge for the shipping of the
extensive eastern coast.
8        REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

               DEFENSES OF THE PENOBSCOT--continued.

  This work was commenced in 1844, and in 1869 was completed accord-
ing to the design save a few minor matters like the interior finish of
casement quarters.
  During the past year the grading of the parade inside the main work
was completed. No other work of construction has been carried on, and
the only other expenditures have been such as were incidental to the
care and preservation of buildings and public property.
No appropriation was made for the fiscal year ending June 30, 1887.
No appropriation asked for next fiscal year.

                       DEFENSES OF THE KENNEBEC.

   Fort Popham, Kennebec River, Maine, in charge of Col. C. E. Blunt,
Corps of Engineers, until February 28, 1886; since that date in charge of
Maj. Jared A. Smith, Corps of Engineers.-This is a granite work situated
upon EHunnewell's Point, on the west side of the mouth of the Kennebec
River. It is intended to prevent the entrance of hostile vessels into the
Kennebec River, and thus forms a refuge for our own vessels in the
waters above. The defense of the river contributes to the protection of
the State capital and the arsenal at Augusta, and to towns below on
the river having s'ome commercial and ship-building importance. It also
aids in tile defense of various points of strategic value.
   A small fortification of old design formerly occupied the extreme end
of the point. The present work was commenced.in 1862, and continued
until the close of the season of 1867, when active operations were sus-
pended. No work of construction was carried on during the last fiscal
year, except such as were required for the necessary care and for the
preservation, of public property.
   Some additions and changes to the work have been devised and ap-
proved, but extensive modifications are still required. No further opera-
tions are proposed until these modifications are complete.
No appropriation was made for the fiscal year ending June 30, 1887.
No appropriation asked for next fiscal year.

                          DEFENSES OF PORTLAND.

   Fort Gorges, Portland Harbor, Maine, in charge of Col. C. E. Blunt,
Corps of Engineers, until February 28, 1886; since that date in charge of
Maj. Jared A. Smith, Corps of Engineers.-This casemated work, com-
menced in 1857, is one of the series of forts designed to defend the har-
bor and channels leading into the harbor of the important strategic
position occupied by the city of Portland. Its construction was sus-
pended for want of funds in 1876, and the work is in an incomplete con-
dition.
No appropriation having been made, no work was done at this fortification
  during the last fiscal year beyond its protection, preservation, and re-
  pair, as far as was possible with the general appropriation made for this
  purpose, and no other work is contemplated during the current fiscal
  year for the same reason.
No appropriation asked for next fiscal year.
  Fort Preble, Portland Harbor, Maine, in charge of Col. C. E. Blunt,
Corps of Engineers, until February,28, 1886 ; since that date in charge of
Maj. Jared A. Smith, Corps of Engineers.--Thiswork occupies a position
on Spring Point, in such position that nearly all its guns bear upon the
                             SEA-COAST      DEFENSES.

                    DEFENSES OF PORTLAND-continued.

two principal channels leading to the anchorage and harbor. The latest
additions to the work were commenced in 1863, and work thereon was
suspended in 1867. The original work on this site was built in 1808.
  In the last year two magazines have received the interior finish in
the north battery; two service magazines have been similarly finished
in the redoubt and eight magazines also completed in the south battery.
All the magazines in the work are now in serviceable condition.
  With the exception of the finished magazines, the work is in the same
condition as indicated in the last annual report.
No appropriation having been made, no work was done at this fortifica-
  tion during the last fiscal year beyond its protection, preservation, and
  repair, as far as was possible with the general appropriation made for
  this purpose, and no other work is contemplated during the current fiscal
  year for the same reason.
No appropriation asked for next fiscal year.
  Fort Scammel, Portland Harbor,Maine, in charge of Col. C. E. Blunt,
Corps of Engineers, until February 28, 1886; since that date in charge of
Maj. Jared A. Smith, Corps of Engineers.-This work occupies a very
important position in the harbor, and commands four of the channels
leading into it.
   The original work on this site (House Island), built about 1808, con-
sisted of a semi-circular battery, with brick scarp and block-house in
rear, and a detached lunette northeast of it. About 1845 the works
were connected so as to form one inclosed work, with brick scarp and
earthen paraplet.
   In 1862 the execution of the new plans was commenced, and (with
some subsequent modifications in 1870) the work was carried on till the
close of theseason of 1875, when it was suspended for want of funds.
   It is an inclosed work, with detached masonry bastions and heavy
earthen batteries.
   Plans for its modification and for additional earthen batteries have
been prepared by the Board of Engineers for Fortifications and ap-
proved by the Secretary of War. They are only partially executed, and
the work is in an incomplete condition. The plans require revision.
   During the last fiscal year six magazines were put in serviceable order.
No other work has been done, and no other expenditures have been
made save such as were necessary for the care and preservation of the
buildings and public property.
No appropriation having been made, no work was done at this fortifica-
  tion during the last fiscal year beyond its protection, preservation, and
  repair, as far as was possible with the general appropriation made for
  this purpose, and no other work is contemplated during the current
  fiscal year for the same reason.
No appropriation asked for next fiscal year.
   Battery on PortlandHead, Portland Harbor, Maine, in charge of Col.
C. E. Blunt, Corps of Engineers, until February 28, 1886; since that date
in charge of Maj. Jared A. Smith, Corps of Engineers.-This earthwork,
commenced in 1873, will, when completed, cover by its guns all the ap-
proaches to the main channel leading into the harbor, and will prevent
by its fire an enemy's fleet from taking up, unopposed, a position be-
hind Cushing's Island from which to shell the shipping in the harbor.
   This work remains in the incomplete condition reported at the close
of the last fiscal year.
10      REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

                   DEFENSES OF PORTLAND-continued.

  For the construction of the operating-room and gallery for torpedo
cables an appropriation is asked under the general appropriation for
cables, galleries, &c.
No appropriation having been made, no work was done at this fortifica-
  tion during the last fiscal year beyond its protection preservation, and
  repair, as far as was possible with the general appropriation made for
  this purpose, and no other work is contemplated during the current
  fiscal year for the same reason.
No appropriation asked for next fiscal year.
   Batteries on Cowo Island, approachesto the harborof Portland,Maine.-
The object of these earthworks is, with batteries designed to be placed
on Great Hog Island, to prevent an enemy's occupation of Casco Bay
and to guard the passage from it to Portland Harbor.
   Plans for the construction of batteries for the heaviest guns on this
island have been prepared by the Board of Engineers for Fortifications,
and it is proposed to commence work upon them as soon as funds are
available. The plans require revision.
No appropriation for their construction has yet been made.
No appropriation asked for next fiscal year.
   Batteries on Great Hog Island, approaches to the harborof Portland,
Maine.-The object of these earthworks is, with batteries designed to
be placed on Cow Island, to prevent an enemy's occupation of Casco
Bay and to guard the passages from it to Portland Harbor.
   Plans for the construction of batteries for the heaviest guns on this
island have been prepared by the Board of Engineers for Fortifications,
and it is proposed to commence work upon them as soon as funds are
available. The plans require revision.
No appropriation for their construction has yet been made.
No appropriation asked for next fiscal year.
   Fort McClary, Portsmouth Harbor, New Hampshire, in charge of Col.
C. E. Blunt, Corps of Engineers, until February28, 1886; since that date
in charge of Maj. Jared A. Smith, Corps of Engineers.--This work, to-
gether with Fort Constitution, opposite, forms the inner line of defense
to the mouth of the Piscataqua River and to the navy-yard at Kittery,
Me.
   The defenses of the mouth of the Piscataqua perform an important
part in protecting the interior from invasion, as navigation above
crosses two through lines of railroad and reaches the city of Dover,
N. H., and numerous small places.
   The original fort was commenced early in the present century. An
inclosed barbette work was commenced in 1863, but has not been com-
pleted.
   The work remains the same as at the date of last report, no opera-
tions having been carried on except for the necessary care and preser-
vation of the property.
No appropriation was made for the fiscal year ending June 30, 1887.
No appropriation asked for next fiscal year.
  Fort Constitution, Portsmouth Harbor, New Hampshire, in charge of
Col. C. E. Blunt, Corps of Engineers, until February28, 1886; since that
date in charge of Maj. Jared A. Smith, Corps of Engineers.-This work,
together with Fort McClary, opposite, forms the inner line of defense
                             SEA-COAST DEFENSES.                              11
                    DEFENSES OF PORTLAND-continued.

to the mouth of the Piscataqua River and to the navy-yard at Kittery,
1Me.
   Extensive modifications are required for the casemated work at this
place before proceeding with its construction. Plans for an exterior
earthen battery for heavy rifled guns have been approved by the Sec-
retary of War, but it has not yet been commenced. The plans require
revision.
   The condition of this work has remained unchanged since the date
of the last annual report, no operations having been carried on except
for the necessary care and preservation of the property.
No appropriation was made for the fiscal year ending June 30, 1887.
No appropriation asked for next fiscal year.
   Battery on Gerrish's Island, Portsmouth Harbor, New Hampshire, in
charge of Col. C. E. Blunt, Corps of Engineers, until February 28, 1886;
since that date in charge of Maj. JaredA. Smith, Corps of Engineers.--This
earthwork, with the one opposite, on Jerry's Point, forms the outer line
of defense to Portsmouth Harbor and to the navy-yard at Kittery, Me.
It was commenced in 1873.
   The work remains in the same incomplete condition reported at the
close of the last fiscal year.
   Plans for the completion of this work have been prepared by the Board
of Engineers for Fortifications and approved by the Secretary of War,
but are only partially executed. The plans require revision.
   An appropriation for constructing the operating-room and gallery for
torpedo cables is asked under the general appropriation for cable gal-
leries, &c.
No appropriation having been made, no work was done at this fortitication
during the last fiscal year beyond its protection, preservation, and re-
pair, as far as was possible with the general appropriation made for this
purpose, and no other work is contemplated during the current fiscal
year for the same reason.
No appropriation asked for next fiscal year.
   Battery on Jerry's Point, Portsmouth iBarbor, New Hampshire,in charge
of Col. C. E. Blunt, Corps of Engineers, until February 28, 186 ; since
that date in charge of Maj. Jared A. Smith, Corps of Engineers.-This
earthwork is on the western side of the entrance to the harbor of Ports-
mouth, N. H., and with the battery at Gerrish's Island, on the opposite
side of the entrance, forms the outer line of defense to that harbor and
to the navy-yard at Kittery, Me. It was commenced in 1873.
   During the 'last year the five magazines at the battery were finished
inside and placed in serviceable order. The earthwork of the battery
is still incomplete.
   The platforms are ready to receive the 15-inch guns for which they
were designed.
   Plans for the completion of this work have been prepared by the
Board of Engineers for Fortifications and approved by the Secretary of
War, but are only partially executed. The plans require revision.
No appropriation having been made, no work was done at this fortifica-
  tion during the last fiscal year beyond its protection, preservation, and
  repair, as far as was possible with the general appropriation made for
  this purpose, and no other work is contemplated during the current fis-
  cal year for the same reason.
No appropriation asked for next fiscal year.
12      REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

  DEFENSES OF BOSTON AND THE NAVY-YARD AT CHARLESTOWN.

   Fort Warren, Boston Harbor,Massachusetts, in charge of iliacj. Charles
I. Raymond, Corps of Engineers, until February 4, 1886; since that date
in charge of Maj. George L. Gillespie, Corps of Engineers.-Thisfort, sit-
uated on George's Island, commands the main ship-channel and the
anchorage of Nantasket Roads. It consists of a granite, casematedr
full-bastioned enceinte, with an earthen cover-face and ravelin.
   It was commenced in 1833, and its plans have been modified by the
Board of Engineers for Fortifications to adapt it for modern ordnance.
These modified plans were partly executed when operations were sus-
pended in 1875-'76 for want of appropriations.
   During the fiscal year operations have been confined to the following :
   The cisterns, eleven in number, under the casemates of Front III
were repaired. The old plastering was removed and new substituted.
   Fourteen doors were built and hung at the entrances of the service
magazines.
   Extra traverse irons were placed on all of the 10-inch-gun front pin-
tle barbette platforms (181 in number), to adapt them to the new ord-
nance carriage for 8-inch converted rifles.
   A new wooden latrine, 8 by 20 feet in plan, was built on the sea-wall
near bastion A, for the use of the garrison and Engineer laborers.
   The hull and machinery of the steamer Tourist were repaired.
   The estimated amount required to complete the work is $185,000.
The plans require revision.
No appropriation asked for next fiscal year.
   Battery at Long Island Head, Boston Harbor, Massachusetts, in charge
of Maj. Charles W. Raymond, Corps of Engineers, until February 4, 1886 ;
since that date in charge of Maj. George L. Gillespie, Corps of Engineers.--
This earthwork occupies an important position in the outer line of de-
fense for Boston Harbor, and its guns bear on all the channels of en-
trance.
   It was commenced in 1871, and was designed for the reception of the
heaviest modern ordnance. Nothing has been done in construction
since the fiscal year 1875-'76 for want of appropriations, and the work,
the plans of which have been prepared by the Board of Engineers for
Fortifications and approved by the Secretary of War, is in an unfinished
condition.
   During the fiscal year ending June 30, 1886, operations have been
limited to the following:
   Nine doors were built and hung at the entrances of the parados arch.
   The iron-work of the new 15-inch gun platforms was scraped and
painted.
   The earth slopes of the traverse magazines and parados were partly
repaired.
   Some minor repairs were made to the store-house.
   To complete the work in accordance with existing plans it is estimated
that $90,000 will be required. The plans require revision.
  No appropriation asked for next fiscal year.
   Fort Winthrop, Boston Harbor,Massachusetts, in charge of Maj. Charles
W. Raymond, Corps of Engineers, until February 4, 1886; since that date
in charge of Maj. George L. Gillespie, Corps of Engineers.--This fort is sit-
uated on Governor's Island; it forms part of the inner line of defense for
Boston Harbor and the Charlestown navy-yard.
                             SEA-COAST DEFENSES.                              13
fDEFENSES     OF BOSTON       AND    THE    NAVY-YARD       AT   CHARLESTOWN--
                                     continued.

   It was commenced in 1844, and consists of a central casemated tower,
with outlying earthen barbette batteries.
   The batteries were modified by the Board of Engineers for Fortifica-
tions for the reception of modern ordnance, and their plans have been
partly executed, although no active operations have been in progress
since 1875-'76, for want of funds.
   During the fiscal year ending June 30, 1886, operations have been
limited to the following:
   Twenty doors were built and hung at the entrances of the service
magazines of the south, the east, and the mortar batteries.
   The iron work of the new 15-inch gun platforms was scraped and
painted.
   The 10-inch gun platforms (twenty-six in number) were provided with
extra traverse irons, to adapt them to the new ordnance carriage for
8-inch converted rifles.
   The entrance door of the tower was built and hung.
   The main drain of the tower was cleaned out and extended to the
northwest salient by a line of 6-inch drain-pipe from the northeast sa-
lient running through the center of the ditch.
   The work is essentially in as good order as at the date of the last an-
nual report.
   The estimated amount to complete the work in accordance with exist-
ing plans is $180,000.
   The plans of the batteries require revision.
No appropriation having been made, no work was done at this fortifica-
  tion during the last fiscal year beyond its protection, preservation, and
  repair, as far as was possible with the general appropriation made for
  this purpose, and no other work is contemplated during the current fiscal
  year for the same reason.
No appropriation asked for next fiscal year.
   Fort Independence, Boston Harbor, llMassachusetts, in charge of Maj.
Charles W. Raymond, Corps of Engineers, until February 4, 1886; since
that date in charge of Maj. George L. Gillespie, Corps of Engineers.-This
work is situated on Castle Island, and forms part of they inner line of
defense for Boston Harbor and the navy-yard at Charlestown. It was
commenced in 1833, and consists of a granite casemated enceinte, with
two exterior earthen barbette batteries.
   The plans of this work were modified by the Board of Engineers for
Fortifications for the reception of modern ordnance, and these plans
have been well advanced towards completion, although active operations
have been suspended since 1875-'76 from want of appropriations.
   During the fiscal year ending June 30, 1886, operations have been
limited to the following:
   Eleven doors were built and hung at the entrances of the service mag-
azines of the enceinte and east exterior battery.
   The iron-work of the new 15-inch gun platforms was scraped and
painted.
   The seven front pintle 10-inch gun platforms of the enceinte had each
an extra traverse iron placed on them to adapt them to the new ord-
nance carriage for 8-inch converted rifles.
   The work is in as good order as at date of last report.
14       REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

DEFENSES      OF BOSTON       AND    THE    NAVY-YARD       AT     CHARLESTOWN-
                                    continued.
The estimated amount necessary to complete the work in accordance
with the present plans is $50,000.
The plans require revision.
No appropriation having been made, no work was done at this fortifica-
  tion during the last fiscal year beyond its protection, preservation, and
  repair, as far as was possible with the general appropriation made for
  this purpose, and no other work is contemplated during the current
  fiscal year for the same reason.
No appropriation asked for next fiscal year.

                        DEFENSES OF NEW BEDFORD.

  Fort at Clark's Point, New Bedford Harbor, Massachusetts, in charge of
Lieut. Col. George H. Elliot, Corps of Engineers.-This casemated work,
commenced in 1857, commands the entrance to the harbor of New Bed-
ford.
   Plans for new earthen batteries for modern heavy guns have been
completed by the Board of Engineers for Fortifications, but nothing has
been done towards their construction. The plans require revision.
   The operations of the past fiscal year, which were confined to works
of repair and preservation, were as follows: The large dwelling house
acquired with the fort lands, and since used for office and other pur-
poses, was shored up and shingled to save it from further damage. One
of the casemates was fitted up for a store-room for Engineer property at
the fort, a portion of the floor of the iron balcony in the main work,
destroyed in a gale in the winter of 1885-'86, was relaid. Repairs were
made to the fort-keeper's house, which was also repainted; to one of the
magazine doors, and to the bridge at the sallyport, and the approach to
the latter was graded.
No appropriation having been made, no work was done at this fortifica-
tion during the last fiscal year beyond its protection, preservation, and
repair, as far as was possible with the general appropriation made for
this purpose, and no other work is contemplated during the current
fiscal year for the same reason.
No appropriation asked for next fiscal year.

                     DEFENSES OF NARRAGANSETT               BAY.

  Fort Adams, Newport Harbor, Rhode Island, in charge of Lieut. Col.
George H. Elliot, Corps of Engineers.-This large and important work,
commenced in 1824, defends the harbor and city of Newport, and com-
mands the principal passage to Narragansett Bay, one of the best road-
steads on the coast.
  The preparatory work for the construction of the new exterior earthen
battery for modern ordnance (such as opening roads, draining the
grounds, &c.) having been all completed, rapid progress can be made
in construction when the necessary funds are appropriated. This im-
portant battery at the end of the fiscal year 1875-'76 had but recently
been commenced in accordance with plans approved by the Secretary
of War, and no work has been done since that year for want of appro-
priations. The plan of this battery requires revision.
   The operations of the last fiscal year were as follows: The iron-work
of four front pintle platforms for 15-inch or heavy rifled guns was com-
pleted, and two magazines for the service of these guns were floored
and fitted with heavy oak and with ventilating doors. The cement
                             SEA-COAST DEFENSES.                              15
             DEFENSES      OF   NARRAGANSETT BAY-continued.

house was reshingled. A strong stone jetty containing one of the main
sewers of the fort was carried out into the sea on the west front far
enough to drop the sewage into the tide-way. A masonry sewer-trap-
basin was built in the demilune of the east front. The interiors of the
newly-fitted magazines were whitewashed; the iron-work of the new
gun platforms was painted, and the traverse rails in casemates were
scraped and painted. The new sea-wall for the protection of the east
shore was extended 304 feet, and repairs were made to some of the old
sea-walls. The south retaining-wall at cut for road through the north
demilune was rebuilt. The upper part of the old breast-high wall on
the land front of the main work, which had become unserviceable as a
revetment, was rebuilt for the entire length of this wall, 812 feet, ex-
cept a distance of about 90 feet, where the mortar is so much decayed
that the main wall will have to be rebuilt. The work of concreting the
surface of the terreplein of the main work, 74,586 square feet in all, was
completed by the covering of 5,743 square feet during the fiscal year.
No appropriation having been made, no work was done at this fortification
  during the last fiscal year beyond its protection, preservation, and re-
pair, as far as was possible with the general appropriation made for this
purpose, and no other work is contemplated during the current fiscal
year for the same reason.
No appropriation asked for next fiscal year.
   Defenses of Dutch Island, NarragansettBay, Rhode Island, in charge of
Lieut. Col. George I. Elliot, Corps of Engineers.-The earthen batteries
on this island, commenced in 1863, command the western entrance to
Narragansett Bay. Nothing has been done in the construction of the
defenses since the fiscal year 1875-'76. They are incomplete, and the
plans' require revision.
   The operations of the past fiscal year were as follows: Laying the
iron-work of one center pintle and four front pintle 15-inch or heavy
rifled guns, and fitting up of two magazines for their service by laying
floors and providing the necessary oak and ventilating doors; storing
the large quantity of portable railroad track belonging to the work;
small repairs to wharves and public buildings, and painting the iron-
work of gun platforms.
No appropriation having been made, no work was done at this fortifica-
  tion during the last fiscal year beyond its protection, preservation, and
  repair, as far as was possible with the general appropriation made for
  this purpose, and no other work is contemplated during the current
  fiscal year for the same reason.
No appropriation asked for next fiscal year.

         DEFENSES OF NEW LONDON HARBOR AND NAVY-YARD.

   Fort Trumbull, New London Harbor, Connecticut, in charge of Lieut.
Col. Walter McFarland, Corps of Engineers, until February 17, 186;
since that date in charge of Lieut. Col. D. C. Houston, Corps of Engi-
neers.-FortTrumbull is situated on a promontory on the west shore of
New London Harbor, about 2 miles from Long Island Sound; the reser-
vation contains about 13.9 acres, and has over 2,000 feet water-front,
with a small wharf near the northern extremity.
   The fortifications consist of-
   1. A pentagonal, masonry, bastioned, casemated work of one tier, with
a barbette battery on top, having three water-fronts and four bastions,
the bastion at the junction of the two land-fronts being omitted. This
16       REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

DEFENSES OF NEW LONDON HARBOR AND NAVY-YARD-continued.

work was built in 1838-1848. The casemates furnish positions for four-
teen heavy guns and eight flank howitzers, and the barbette for twenty-
four heavy guns.
   The northern land front, through which the sallyport passes, is pro-
tected by a cover-face arranged with a place of arms and positions for
six barbette guns.
   2. A south exterior water battery which mounts six 8-inch Rodman
guns and two 100-pound Parrotts.
   3. A north exterior earthen battery, built in 1874-'76, arranged for
mounting five 15-inch guns in single position to command the channel.
The platforms for these guns are completed, with the exception of the
traverse irons, which are on hand and ready to be laid.
   A plan of the Board of Engineers for rebuilding the south exterior
battery and fitting it for five 15-inch Rodmans in single position was ap-
proved in 1874, but no money has yet been applied to carrying out the
project.
   During the past year no work, either of construction or repair, has
been done at this fort. It is now in good condition, with the exception
of some of the brick facing of the casemates, which has been damaged
by,leakage through the covering of the arches or between the arches and
the scarp-wall.
   The alteration of the south water battery, as planned by the Board
of Engineers, to fit it for the use of 15-inch Rodmans, is necessary to
the proper defense of the position.
   Fort Trumbull is garrisoned by two companies of the First Artillery.
No appropriation having been made, no work was done at this fortifica-
  tion during the last fiscal year beyond its protection, preservation, and
repair, as far as was possible with the general appropriation made for
  this purpose, and no other work is contemplated during the current fiscal
  year for the same reason.
No appropriation asked for next fiscal year.
   Fort Griswold, New London Harbor, Connecticut, in charge of Lieut.
Col. Walter McFarland, Corps of Engineers, until February17, 1886; since
that date in charge of Lieut. Col. D. C. Houston, Corps of Engineers.--This
is an open barbette earthwork, on the east side of New London Harbor,
opposite the city of New London. It was begun in 1840, as an auxil-
iary to Fort Trumbull, and from its commanding position on Groton
heights, 80 feet above the sea, it overlooks every part of the harbor. It
has positions for sixteen guns, eleven 10-inch Rodmans and five 8-inch
Rodmans; but under an approved plan of the Board of Engineers this
battery is to be fitted for eight 15-inch Rodmans, the estimated cost of
which is $48,000.
   The reservation contains about 12.8 acres; its site is mainly on the
high east bank of the Thames River, back of the village of Groton;
it includes a roadway extending to the river, with about 66 feet of
water front.
   No money has ever been appropriated for the modification of this bat-
tery, and no work upon it has been done.
   No work has been done upon it during the past year, and it is now
in very good condition.
   There is no garrison at Fort Griswold, an ordnance sergeant being
left in charge of it.
No appropriation was made for the fiscal year ending June 30, 1887.
No appropriation asked for next fiscal year.
                             SEA-COAST DEFENSES.                              17
                          DEFENSES      OF NEW HAVEN.

   Fort Hale, New Haven, Connecticut, in charge of Lieut. Col. Walter Mc-
Farland, Corps of Engineers, until February 17, 1886 ; since that date in
charge of Lieut. Col. D. C. Houston, Corps of Engineers.--This is an earth-
work built near the close of the rebellion, situated on a low point on
the east shore of the harbor, about 2 miles below the city. It is a tem-
porary work, and is rapidly falling down. Its site is valuable in a mil-
itary sense only for a small work, to be used against small vessels that
might enter the harbor. The area of the reservation is about 30 acres;
it has 2,300 feet of water front.
   No project for rebuilding it has ever been made.
   No work has been done upon it in the last year, and no appropriation
is asked for the next fiscal year.
   DEFENSES OF NEW YORK AND                 THE NAVY-YARD         AT BROOKLYN.

  Fort Schuyler, East River, New York, in charge of Lieut. Col. H. L.
Abbot, Corps of Engineers, until May 24, 1886; since that date in charge
of Lieut. Col. C. B. Comstock, Corps of Engineers.-This work and the
opposite fort at Willets Point are our only dependence for closing the
harbor of New York City against attack from the direction of Long
Island Sound.
  The existing works at Fort Schuyler consist of an old masonry fort,
planned halfa century ago, and of three incomplete and unarmed earthen
batteries.
  During the past fiscal year the sea-wall has been repaired, and also
the slope in front of the glacis battery.
  The preparation of all but the iron-work of one turret to receive two
110-ton guns should be no longer delayed.
No appropriation having been made, no work was done at this fortifica-
tion during- the last fiscal year beyond its protection, preservation, and
repair, as far as was possible with the general appropriation made for
this purpose, and no other work is contemplated during the current
fiscal year for the same reason.
   Fort at Willets Point, eastern entrance to New York Harbor, in charge
of Lieut. Col. H. L. Abbot, Corps of Engineers, until March 11, 1886;
since that date in charge of Lieut. Col. C. B. Comstock, Corps of Engineers.-
This work, together with Fort Schuyler, forms the only defensive line
for preventing an enemy coming from the direction of Long Island
Sound from entering the harbor of New York City. It is, therefore, of
first importance.
   The defensive works at Willets Point consist of an old stone fort,
begun at the outbreak of the civil war and left unfinished since 1865;
of four unfinished earthen batteries for guns, and of a battery for six-
teen mortars.
   During the past fiscal year the roads and temporary buildings have
been repaired, and property has been cared for.
   The extensive slopes have had the grass cut upon them.
   The sea has been cutting away the shore line on the east front, sduth
of the main work, and blocks of granite, long on hand, have been placed
here to form a bank protection. This protection needs extension fur-
ther to the south.
No appropriation having been made, no work was done at this fortifica-
  tion during the last fiscal year beyond its protection, preservation, and
  repair, as far as was possible with the general appropriation made for
  this purpose, and no other work is contemplated during the current
  fiscal year for the same reason.
         2E
18      REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

DEFENSES OF NEW YORK AND THE NAVY-YARD AT BROOKLYN---Ol-
                                      tinued.

   Defenses of Governor's Island, New York Harbor, in charge of Maj.
George L. Gillespie, Corps of Engineers, until February 3, 1886; in charge
of Lieut. Col. Walter McFarland, Corps of Engineers, until February 17,
1886; since that date in charge of Lieut. Col. D. C. Houston, Corps of
Engineers.--These works comprise Fort Columbus, Castle Williams,
South Battery, and New Barbette Battery. They, with Fort Wood, on
the opposite side of the channel, defend the entrances to the East River
and the Hudson River. The fortifications on Governor's Island were
commenced in 1831. The exterior heavy earthen batteries are as yet
unfinished.
   For years past no special appropriation has been made for any of the
works on this island, and the operations during the year have been lim-
ited to repairs.
   The United States owns the whole island, an area of 70 acres.
   During the year eight interior magazine doors were built and hung
in the magazines of the New Barbette Battery, and 8 entrance stones
to cover drains were laid in the entrances of the magazines. Slight re-
pairs were made to the bridge over the ditch at Fort Columbus.
   An exterior modern earthen battery, designed by the Board of En-
gineers for Fortifications, and approved by the Secretary of War, is
partially built. The plan of this battery requires revision.
No appropriation having been made, no work was done at this fortifica-
tion during the last fiscal year beyond its protection, preservation, and
repair, as far as was possible with the general appropriation made for
this purpose, and no other work is contemplated during the current
fiscal year for the same reason.
No appropriation asked for next fiscal year.
    Sea-wall on Governor's Island, New York Harbor, in charge of Maj.
George L. Gillespie, Corps of Engineers, until February3, 1886; in charge
of Lieut. Col. Walter McFarland, Corps of Engineers, until February 17,
1886 ; since that date in charge of Lieut. Col. D. C. Houston, Corps of En-
gineers.-The project for this improvement, adopted in 1865, provides
for inclosing the entire island by a sea-wall.
   Under an allotment made in 1865, 700 linear feet of masonry wall were
built on the southwest side of the island in 1866, which, with about 399
linear feet built under other small allotments, made a total of 1,099 feet.
This was subsequently extended as a temporary dry wall nearly along
high-water mark to Castle Williams, covering the entire southwest side
of the island. By act approved August 7, 1882, $39,000 were appropri-
ated " for completing a sea-wall already commenced on the southwest
side of Governor's Island, New York Harbor, and constructing a sea-
wall on its southeastern portion." Under this appropriation and one of
$15,000, included in the sundry civil bill approved March 3, 1883, the
wall was extended 206 feet along the south side of the island, and 1,502k
feet along the east side to the coal wharves. From this point the island
is inclosed by wharf fronts and by the " ordnance wall," extending around
the northeast side and along the northwest side to within about 1,100
feet from the Engineer Wharf and the Castle Williams Wall. In 1884
an allotment of $500 was made for completing the filling and grading
behind the east wall, left unfinished on account of exhaustion of funds.
   In order to complete the project for inclosing the entire islandl, there
is yet to be built about 1,100 feet of wall on the northwest side, and the
temporary dry wall is to be replaced by a masonry wall about 1,500 feet
                             SEA- COAST DEFENSES.                             19

DEFENSES OF NEW YORK AND THE NAVY-YARD AT BROOKLYN--Cnl-
                                       tinued.

long, the latter to be built near low-water line, using the material in the
present dry wall as far as it will go; also filling in and grading behind
the waMs when built.
   No work was done during the past fiscal year, no funds being avail-
able.
   From the western extremity of the "ordnance wall" to Castle Will-
iams, a distance of 1,100 feet, the beach is wholly unprotected against
deposits of offal, dead animals, and other objectionable matter. For
carrying the sea-wall in front of this beach and for banking up the low
spaces behind it, an estimate of $50,000 is submitted; to replace the
dry wall with a permanent masonry wall will cost about $50,000 addi-
tional. Both walls could be built to advantage in a single year.
   An appropriation of $50,000 is recommended.
   Fort Wood, Bedloe's Island, New York Harbor,in charge of Maj. George
L. Gillespie, Corps of Engineers,'untilFebruary 3,1886; in charge of Lieut.
Col. Walter McFarland,Corps of Engineers, until February 17,1886; since
that date in charge of Lieut. Col. D. C. ilouston, Corps of Engineers.-.
This work, commenced in 1841, forms one of the inner line of defenses
for New York Harbor, and with those on Governor's Island is designed
to close the entrances to the East River and the Hudson River, and to
protect New York, part of Brooklyn, and Jersey City from bombard-
ment.
   The entire island belongs to the United States; its area is about 13
acres.
   The exterior modern earthen battery, designed by the Board of En-
gineers and approved by the Secretary of War, is only partially built
and should be completed. The plan requires revision.
   The pedestal for the Statue of Liberty Enlightening the World is
completed; the interior frame-work is erected up to the neck and the
iron skeleton of the right arm is partly in place; preparations are being
made for placing the copper plates of the statue.
   The only work done upon the fortifications during the past fiscal year
was fitting and hanging three interior magazine doors in the new ex-
terior battery.
   The slopes and platforms are in good condition.
No appropriation having been made, no work was done at this fortifica-
tion during the past fiscal year, beyond what was necessary for its repair
  and preservation ; for the same reason no work is contemplated during
  the ensuing year.
No appropriation asked for next fiscal year.
   Fort Hamilton and additional batteries, New York Harbor, in charge
of Maj. George L. Gillespie, Corps of Engineers, until February 3, 1886;
since that date in charge of Lieut. Col. Walter McFarland, Corps of En-
gineers.-These works, commenced in 1824, are situated at the Narrows
of New York Harbor, upon the Long Island side.
   No specific appropriation was made for the fiscal year, and the opera-
tions were confined to repairs absolutely necessary for thepreservation
of the works.
   These include, in Battery No. I, the placing of 1,190 cubic yards of rip-
rap stone against the sea-wall supporting the battery,making and hang-
ing four interior and seven exterior magazine doors, and setting pintles
in platforms 1, 2, 5, and 6; in 15-inch Gun Battery, making and hang
ing one interior door to Magazine B.
20       REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

DEFENSES OF NEW YORK AND THE NAVY-YARD                       AT BROOKLYN-COl-
                                      tinued.

  The slopes, revetments, and platforms of all the several works are in
good repair and the magazines are dry and serviceable.
  To construct a working-chamber on the east side of the channel for
the torpedo defensive system planned by the Board of Engineers, an
appropriation is requested under the general appropriation for cable
galleries, &c.
No appropriation was made for the fiscal year ending June 30, 1887.
No appropriation asked for next fiscal year.
   Mortar Battery at Fort Hamilton, New York Harbor, in charge of Maj.
George L. Gillespie, Corps of Engineers, until February 3, 1886 ; since that
dlate in charge of Lieut. Col. Walter McFarland, Corps of Engineers.-
This battery was commenced in 1871. No operations were carried on
during the year except furnishing and hanging three exterior magazine
doors.
   But little requires to be done to fit this battery to receive its full
armament as projected by the Board'of Engineers for Fortifications.
  Fort Lafayette, New York Harbor, in charge of Maj. George L. Gillespie,
Corps of Engineers, until February3, 1886 ; in charge of Lieut. Col. Wal-
ter McFarland, Corps of Engineers, until February 17, 1886; since that
date in charge of Lieut. Col. D. C. Houston, Corps of Engineers.-This old
work, commenced in 1812, occupies the best of all the positions for the
defense of New York Harbor; it is situated on a shoal at the Narrows
entrance, and is wholly surrounded by water of 8 feet depth or more.
The area inclosed by the sea-wall is about 270 feet square. The fort was
injured by fire in 1868 to such a degree as to make it practically worthless
unless rdpaired at a very considerable expense. As it was adapted to
guns of small caliber only, it was not thought advisable to restore it,
but to replace it with an iron construction which should meet the de-
mands of modern armament. Plans for this have been proposed.
   The defense of New York requires a new work which will mount the
heaviest modern ordnance, and, as many years will be consumed in the
construction, an adequate appropriation should be made without further
delay. ,
No appropriation having been made, no work was done at this fortifica-
  tion during the last fiscal year beyond its protection, preservation, and
  repair, as far as was possible with the general appropriation made for
  this purpose, and no other work is contemplated during the current
  fiscal year for the same reason.
No appropriation asked for next fiscal year.
     Fort Wadsworth, Staten Island, New York Harbor, in charge of Col.
Q. A. Gillmore, Corps of Engineers.-This fort, commenced in 1847, is
situated on the west side of the Narrows, and constitutes a part of the
second line of defense of the southern water approach to New York.
   It is an inclosed work, built of granite, containing three tiers of guns
in casemates and one en barbette, the lower tier being only a few feet
above the water-level.
   The work, in connection with those adjacent to it on either side-Fort
Tompkins and the two glacis batteries on the hill in rear-is designed
to throw a heavy concentrated fire on vessels approaching or attempt-
ing to pass through the Narrows, crossing its fire with that from Fort
Hamilton and batteries on the opposite side of the channel.
  During the past fiscal year the permanent gun platforms and the
breast-height walls were pointed. A rough, low retaining wall was
                              SEA-COAST DEFENSES.                                21
DEFENSES OF NEW YORK AND THE NAVY-YARD AT BROOKLYN--con-
                                         tinued.
built about half-way down the long slope, to prevent the earth from
washing down from above.
No appropriation having been made, no work was done at this fortification
  during the last fiscal year beyond its protection, preservation, and repair,
  as far as was possible with the general appropriation made for this pur-
  pose, and no other work is contemplated during the current fiscal year for
  the same reason.
No appropriation asked for next fiscal year.
   Fort on site of Fort Tompkins, Neu' York Harbor, in charge of Col. Q.
A. Gillmore, Corps of Engineers.-This work, commenced in 1858, with
the earthen Glacis Gun Battery on its left and the Glacis Mortar Bat,
tery on its right, crowns the hill in rear of Fort Wadsworth and the
earthen batteries known as North Cliff Battery, South Cliff Battery,
Battery Hudson, and the South Mortar Battery.
   It is an inclosed pentagonal work, having on its four land faces two
tiers of casemate quarters, a deep, dry ditch, and a heavy barbette bat-
tery to resist a land attack, and on its channel front seventeen large
casemates for storage and other purposes. It mounts its channel-bear-
ing guns en barbette. It is intended to supply quarters for the garrison,
and act as a keep for all the defensive works occupying this position.
Properly armed, this work will be able to throw a heavy fire from a
commanding position upon vessels attempting to pass through the
Narrows.
   The four land faces were, for all defensive purposes, finished in 1865.
In December, 1869, a plan giving such increased depths to the case-
mates that heavy rifled guns could be mounted over them en barbette
was adopted and carried into execution.
   Since 1876 the work has been in readiness to receive, on temporary
platforms, all the heavy guns intended for channel defense.
   The following work was done during the past fiscal year:
   The pointing of the masonry of the scarp and counter-scarp walls was
continued. The torpedoes stored at the fort, and the balcony of the
parade walls, and other exposed iron and wood work were painted.
Extensive damages caused to the exterior slope of the channel-front by
a heavy rain-storm in April, 1886, were thoroughly repaired. The work
of macadamizing the road leading from the south sallyport of the fort
to the light-house was commenced.
   The western boundary fence at the foot of the glacis, along New York
avenue, was renewed and painted.
   Grass and weeds were cut on the parade, parapet, and slopes of the
fort.
   The estimates for the completion of Fort Tompkins comprise ten
permanent gun platforms in place of the present wooden ones, four
bonnets on the traverses for the better protection of guns and gunners,
and finishing off twenty-six casemates for quarters and eleven large
casemates on the channel-front for storage purposes.
No appropriation having been made, no work was done at this fortifica-
  tion during the last fiscal year beyond its protection, preservation, and
  repair, as far as was possible with the general appropriation made for
  this purpose, and no other work is comtemplated during the current
  fiscal year for the same reason.
No appropriation asked for next fiscal year.
  Glacis Gun Battery (north of fort on site of Fort Tompkins), Staten Isl-
and, New York Harbor, in charge of Col. Q. A. Gillmore, Corps of En.
22      REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

DEFENSES OF NEW YORK AND THE NAVY-YARD AT BROOKLYN-COn-
                                      tinued.
gineers.-This earthen barbette battery, built in 1872, is designed to sup-
plement the barbette fire of Fort Tompkins. It has been in readiness
to receive its armament on temporary platforms for the last twelve years,
and may be reported as finished. It is provided with timber gun plat-
forms and ample magazine room.
  But little work was done at this battery during the past fiscal year.
The slopes, which had been damaged by a heavy rain-storm in April,
1886, were repaired, the doors of the two magazines were painted, and
grass and weeds cut on the slopes and in rear of the work.
   The cost of substituting stone for the timber gun platforms and rais-
ing the breast-height wall will be $15,000.
No appropriation having been made, no work was done at this fortifica-
tion during the last fiscal year beyond its protection, preservation, and
repair, as far as was possible with the general appropriation made for
this purpose, and no other work is contemplated during the current fis-
  cal year for the same reason.
No appropriation asked for next fiscal year.
   Glacis Mortar Battery (south of fort on site of Fort Tompkins), Staten
Island, New York Harbor, in charge of Col. Q. A. Gillmore, Corps of En-
gineers.-This battery, built in 1872 and 1873, is intended to throw a
powerful vertical fire upon vessels approaching or attempting to pass
through the Narrows. It is provided with ample storage and service
magazine room, bat the ten wooden platforms for 13-inch sea-coast mor-
tars have become unserviceable from decay.
  During the past fiscal year the doors of the service magazines were
painted, and the slopes, which had been damaged by a heavy rain-storm
in April, 1886, were repaired. Grass and weeds were cut from the
slopes of parapets and magazine covers.
No appropriation having been made, no work was done at this fortifica-
tion during the last fiscal year beyond its protection, preservation, and
repair, as far as ivas possible with the general appropriation made for
this purpose, and no other work is contemplated during the current
fiscal year for the same reason.
No appropriation asked for next fiscal year.
  Battery Hudson, Staten Island, New York Harbor, in charge of Col. Q.
A. Gillmore, Corps of Engineers.--This work, built in 1841 to 1843, and
the North Cliff and South Cliff batteries occupy the slope of the hill
between the fort on site of Fort Tompkins and the water, and are able
to bring a powerful direct fire upon the channel leading up to and through
the Narrows.
  For want of funds no work except that of preservation and repair
has been done since the close of the fiscal year ending June 30, 1876.
One of the new platforms was constructed for King's depressing carriage
and a 15-inch smooth-bore gun mounted thereon.
  The work necessary for the completion of this battery comprises twelve
new permanent gun platforms in place of old ones, the construction of
a new breast-height wall in front of some of the platforms, and raising
the wall to a higher level in frontof others, the construction of bonnets
on the traverses, and the placing of a wooden lining in one of the prin-
cipal magazines, at an aggregate cost of $45,000.
  The following work was done during the past fiscal year:
  Two wooden front-pintle platforms for 8-inch converted rifles were
constracted in the western wing of the south front, upon the concrete
foundatious previously occupied by two decayed wooden platforms for
                              SEA-COAST     DEFENSES.                         23

DEFENSES OF NEW YORK AND THE NAVY-YARD AT BROOKLYN--COl-
                                       tinued.
15-inch smooth-bore guns. Two 8-inch converted rifles, formerly in the
first tier of casemates of Fort Wadsworth, were mounted upon the new
platforms.
   The lower part of the long earth slope in rear of the permanent front-
ointle platform on the south front, next to the angle with the east front,
was cut off to the height of about 5 feet, and replaced by a wooden re-
vetment. This was done to give room for the long chassis of an 11-inch
rifle received and mounted here during the year.
   Miscellaneous repairs were made to slopes, and grass and weeds cut
on them. A new shingle roof was put on the hostler's building, and
repairs were miade to the cement-shed and blacksmith's building; both
received new underpinning where they had settled.
No appropriation having been made, no work was done at this fortifica-
  tion during the last fiscal year beyond its protection, preservation, and
repair, as far as was possible with the general appropriation made for
  this purpose, and no other work is contemplated during the current
  fiscal year for the same reason.
No appropriation asked for next fiscal year.
   South Mortar Battery (in rear of Battery Hudson Extension), Staten
Island, New York Harbor, in charge of Col. Q. A. Gillmore, Corps of En-
gineers.-This battery, commenced in 1872, is situated south of Fort
Tompkins and directly in rear of Battery Hudson Extension. It is de-
signed to throw a heavy vertical fire upon vessels approaching the Nar-
rows from the lower bay. Since 1873 no appropriation has been made
for it. The work necessary for its completion consists in constructing
and laying eight timber mortar platforms, and in fitting up the inner
magazines with doors and lamp-closets. Estimated cost of completing
the work, $10,000.
   The work done at this battery during the past fiscal year was con-
fined to cutting grass and weeds on the slopes.
No appropriation having been made, no work was done at this fortifica-
  tion during the last fiscal year beyond its protection, preservation, and
  repair, as far as was possible with the general appropriation made for
  this purpose, and no other work is contemplated during the current fiscal
  year for the same reason.
No appropriation asked for next fiscal year.
  North Cliff Battery, Staten Island, New York Harbor,in charge of Col.
Q. A. Gillmore, Corps of Engineers.-This earthen gun battery, which
was commenced in 1862, is located north of Fort Wadsworth, on the
slope of the hill between Fort Tompkins and the water. It is designed
to throw a direct fire upon vessels attempting to pass through the Nar-
rows. It was intended for an armament of 15-inch smooth-bore guns or
corresponding rifles, and was provided with two storage magazines, one
large bomb-proof shelter, and five traverses between guns, two of them
containing service magazines. Under a modification approved Decem-
ber 8, 1859, the bomb-proof shelter was suppressed and some traverses
and service magazines between the guns were added, the number of
guns being necessarily reduced thereby.
   During the last fiscal year operations were confined to repair of dam-
ages to the slopes in rear of the work, caused by a heavy rain-storm in
April, 1886, and in cutting grass and weeds from these slopes and from
the parapet and magazine covers.
24       REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

DEFENSES OF NEW YORK AND THE NAVY-YARD AT BROOKLYN--COn-
                         tinued.

   The cost of finishing this battery, by substituting six stone gun plat-
forms for those of timber, constructing six breast-height walls, two bon-
nets on the traverses, lining the two principal magazines with wood,
thickening the parapet, and constructing a rough sea-wall at the foot
of the exterior slope, will be $60,000.
No appropriation having been made, no work was done at this fortifica-
  tion during the last fiscal year beyond its protection, preservation, and
  repair, as far as was possible with the general appropriation made for
  this purpose, and no other work is contemplated during the current
  fiscal year for the same reason.
No appropriation asked for next fiscal year.
     South Cliff Battery, Staten Island, New York Harbor, in charge of Col.
Q. A. Gillmore, Corps of Engineers.--This earthen gun battery, occupy-
ing the slope of the hill between Fort Tompkins and the water directly
south of Fort Wadsworth, was built in 1858 to 1861, for 15-inch guns or
corresponding rifles, and was provided with two storage and two service
magazines. In December, 1869, modifications were ordered, adding
four new traverses, including two traverse magazines, by which the num-
ber of guns was necessarily reduced.
    No work was done at this battery during the past fiscal year beyond
cutting the grass and weeds from the slopes.
    The cost of finishing the battery, comprising the completion of four
traverses, the construction of one new traverse magazine, adding to the
thickness of a parapet, building a rough sea-wall at the foot of the ex-
terior slope, and lining the two principal magazines, will be $60,000.
No appropriation having been made, no work was done at this fortifica-
  tion during the last fiscal year beyond its protection, preservation, and
  repair, as far as was possible with the general appropriation made for
  this purpose, and no other work is contemplated during the current
  fiscal year for the same reason.
No appropriation asked for next fiscal year.
   Two-gun Battery (nearsoutheast angle of channelfront offort on site of
Fort Tompkins), Staten Island, New York Harbor,in charge of Col. Q.A.
Gillmore, Corps of Engineers.--This work is located on the crest of the
long slope in rear of Fort Wadsworth, and to the southeast and some-
what in advance of the channel front of the fort on site of Fort Tomp-
kins. It was built towards the close of the late civil war, and is de-
signed to throw additional fire from a commanding position upon ves-
sels attempting to pass the Narrows.
   The only work done here during the past fiscal year consisted in cut-
ting grass and weeds on the parapet and adjoining slopes.
  The battery contains two permanent center-pintle platforms for 10-
inch or 8-inch Rodman guns or corresponding rifles. Platforms, breast-
height, and parapet are in serviceable order, but there is no service
magazine.
No appropriation is asked for this work.
   Fort at Sandy Hook, New Jersey, in charge of Maj. George L. Gillespie,
Corps of Engineers, until February 3, 1886; since that date in charge of
Lieut. Col. Walter McFarland, Corps of Engineers.-Thiscasemated work,
commenced in 1857, commands the southern approaches by sea to the
harbor and city of New York, and is also designed to prevent the occu-
pation of the Lower New York Bay, as an anchorage by an enemy's
fleet.
                             SEA-COAST DEFENSES.                              25
DEFENSES OF NEW YORK AND THE NAVY-YARD AT BROOKLYN-Con.
                         tinued.

   No regular appropriations have been made for years past for the com-
pletion or modification of this work, and it remains in essentially the
same condition as at the date of the last annual report.
   No work has been done upon the jetties for protecting the site against
the advances of the ocean, and they have suffered no serious damage.
   This water-front is now in a good condition, affording protection to
all buildings in rear.
   The defensive work upon the Hook is the most advanced of all the
defenses of the southern approaches by sea to the harbor and city of
New York. The channel of entrance opposite the Hook is more than a
mile wide, and of depth sufficient for the largest and most powerful
armored vessels yet built or designed. The occupation by an enemy's
fleet of the capacious bay just within the Hook would prevent all egress
from the harbor southward to the sea, and effectually seal up the main
outlet from the city. The modification and completion of this important
work for the reception of the heaviest modern rifled guns protected by
impenetrable iron armor, and the protection of the site against encroach-
ments by the sea, are of very great importance.
No appropriation having been made, no work was done at this fortifica-
tion during the last fiscal year beyond its protection, preservation, and
repair, as far as was possible with the general appropriation made for
this purpose, and no other work is contemplated during the current
fiscal year for the same reason.
No appropriation asked for next fiscal year.

  DEFENSES OF PHILADELPHIA AND LEAGUE ISLAND                         NAVY-YARD.

   Fort  Mfifflin,
                 Delaware River, Pennsylvania, in charge of Lieut. Col.
Henry M. Robert, Corps of Engineers.--This barbette work, originally
established in 1779, is situated on the west bank of the Delaware River,
within the territorial boundaries of the city of Philadelphia, and con-
stitutes a part of the inner line of works for the defense of the city and
the League Island naval station.
   No specific appropriation has been made for this fort since 1875, when
the operations which were in progress in the construction of exterior
earthworks for the mounting of heavy guns, under the approved plans
of the Board of Engineers for Fortifications, terminated. These plans
require revision.
  During the past fiscal year the public buildings were cleaned and
whitewashed, the grass on the grounds of the main work and demilune
cut, and a wagon bridge built across the ditch in front of the main en-
trance to the fort.
No appropriation having been made, no work was done at this fortifica-
  tion during the last fiscal year beyond its protection, preservation, and
  repair, as far as was possible with the general appropriation made for
  this purpose, and no other work is contemplated during the current
  fiscal year for the same reason.
No appropriation asked for next fiscal year.
  Mortar Battery at Fort Miflin, Pennsylvania,in charge of Lieut. Col.
Henry M. Robert, Corps of Engineers.-The site of this battery is on the
reclaimed land west of the main work and north of the unfinished gun
battery. Operations for its construction began in 1871, and continued
until near the close of the fiscal year 1874, since which time work has
remained suspended for want of funds.                            *
26       REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

DEFENSES OF PHILADELPHIA AND LEAGUE                        ISLAND NAVY-YARD-
                       continued.

  This battery, the plans of which were prepared by the Board of En-
gineers for Fortifications, remains in' an unfinished condition, and is
suffering from exposure.
No appropriation having been made, no work was done at this fortifica-
  tion during the last fiscal year beyond its protection, preservation, and
  repair, as far as was possible with the general appropriation made for
  this purpose, and no other work is contemplated during the current
  fiscal year for the same reason.
No appropriation asked for next fiscal year.
   Site for defenses at Red Bank, New Jersey, in charge of Lieut. Col. Henry
M. Robert, Corps of Engineers.-This site is situated on the east shore
of the Delaware River, and embraces an area of 100 acres. It was
purchased in 1872, with the view of erecting thereon an earthen bar-
bette work for heavy guns, which, with the works at Fort Mifflin, would
constitute the inner line of defenses of the Delaware River.
   During the past fiscal year operations were confined to placing 114
cubic yards of rip rap stone at the foot of the bluff directly in front of
the property-keeper's house, where the bank was being rapidly washed
away by the river currents.
   No appropriation has been made for this work. The site is an impor-
tant one, the occupation of the bluff by a suitable armament, which
would command the channel at short range, being indispensable to any
attempt to defend the port of Philadelphia and the League Island navy-
yard.
No appropriation was made for the fiscal year ending June 30, 1887.
No appropriation asked for next fiscal year.
   Fort Delaware, Delaware River, Delaware, in charge of Lieut. Col.
Henry il. Robert, Corps of Engineers.-Fort Delaware is a casemated
work, with granite scarp, situated on Pea Patch Island, about 42 miles
below Philadelphia, and 12 miles below Wilmington, Del.
   The position is a very important one, commanding both channels, the
eastern or main ship-channel passing within 1,000 yards of the fort.
   The mrasonry of this fort was begun in 1852. No appropriations have
been made for it since 1876, and the modifications then in progress, to
adapt it to the greater size and power of modern ordnance, remain sus-
pended.
   This work and the batteries opposite on the Delaware and New Jersey
shores form the lower line of defense for the Delaware River, but the fort
is in no condition to contest the passage of modern ships of war, and the
thickness of neither the scarp nor the magazine walls is sufficient to
resist shot from guns now in use.
   During the past fiscal year available funds have been applied to the
following work:
   Two barbette gun platforms, Nos. 103 and 104, were so modified as to
adapt them to the modern iron carriages. This work, with the plat-
forms similarly modified in previous years, completes the modifications
of all the center-pintle stone platforms for the barbette Rdman guns.
Seven stone platforms, which were from to 11 inches out of level, were
releveled by cutting down the stone-work and relaying the traverse cir-
cles. The grounds have been partially cleaned from weeds and minor
repairs made to ditches.
                              SEA-CO A'ST DEFENSES.                            27
DEFENSES       OF PHILADELPHIA AND LEAGUE                  ISLAND     NAVY-YARD-
                              continued.

  An appropriation for constructing a torpedo casemate is asked for,
under the general appropriation for cable galleries.
No appropriation having been made no work was done at this fortifica-
  tion during the last fiscal year beyond its protection, preservation, and
  repair, as far as was possible with the general appropriation made for
  this purpose, and no other work is contemplated during the current
  fiscal year for the same reason.
   Battery at Finn's Point, Delaware River, New Jersey, in charge of Lieut.
Col. Henry M. Robert, Corps of Engineers.-The construction of this
earthen barbette battery, which forms the left of the lower line of de-
fense for the Delaware River, was commenced in 1872, under the ap-
proved plans of the Board of Engineers for Fortifications. In 1876
work was suspended for want of appropriations, and since then only
slight repairs have been made from time to time.
   During the past fiscal year slight repairs were made to the dikes and
sluices. The sea-wall along the front of the work has been but par-
tially completed, leaving a gap of about 650 feet. Along the length of
this gap the shore-line. and a part of the exterior slope of the battery
have been seriously eroded by the action of the river, and stone has
been disposed along the foot of the eroded bank, so as to give tempo-
rary protection until available funds would permit of the stone being
laid into a wall closing the gap.
No appropriation having been made, no work was done at this fortifica-
  tion during the last fiscal year beyond its protection, preservation, and
  repair, as far as was possible with the general appropriation made for
  this purpose, and no other work is contemplated during the current
  fiscal year for the same reason.
No appropriation asked for next fiscal year.
  Mortar Battery at Finn's Point, Delaware River, Netw Jersey, in charge
of Lieut. Col. Henry . Robert, Corps of Engineers.-This work was com-
menced in 1872, under the approved plans of the Board of Engineers
for Fortifications, and forms a part of the earthen battery at Finn's
Point. No appropriations having been made for it since 1874, it re-
mains in its then incomplete condition. Since then the embankments
have been washed away to a great extent by severe storms, which badly
damaged the sea-wall at their foot.
No appropriation having been made, no work was done at this fortifica-
  tion during the last fiscal year beyond its protection, preservation, and
  repair, as far as was possible with the general appropriation made for
  this purpose, and no other work is contemplated during the current
  fiscal year for the same reason.
No appropriation asked for next fiscal year.
  Fort opposite Fort Delaware, Delaware shore, in charge of Lieut. Col.
Henry M. Robert, Corps of Engineers.--This earthen barbette battery is
on the Delaware shore, opposite Fort Delaware, and commands both
channels of the river below Pea Patch Island.
  Its construction was commenced in 1873, and continued until 1876.
Since that time no appropriations have been made, and the battery re-
mains in an unfinished condition. The completed portions, including
the sodded slopes, are in fair condition. The dike on the Delaware
River front needs extensive repairs. The plan of the battery requires
revision. An appropriation for completing the torpedo cable gallery is
requested under the general appropriation for cable galleries.
28       REPORT OF THE CHIEF              OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

DEFENSES      OF   PHILADELPHIA AND LEAGUE                 ISLAND    NAVY-YARD-
                               continued.

  During the past fiscal year slight repairs were made to the buildings,
fences, and two service magazines.
No appropriation having been made, no work was done at this fortifica-
  tion during the last fiscal year, and no work is contemplated during the -
  current fiscal year for the same reason.
   Mortar Battery, opposite Fort Delaware, near Delaware City, Delaware,
in charge of Lieut. Col. Henry M. Robert, Corps o Engineers.-Thi work
was commenced in 1872, under the approved plans of the Board of En-
gineers for Fortifications. No appropriation having been made for it
since 1874, it remains in its then incomplete condition. Since then the
embankments have been washed away to a great extent by severe
storms, which badly damaged the sea-wall at their foot.
No appropriation having been made, no work was done at this fortifica-
  tion during the last fiscal year beyond its protection, preservation, and
  repair as far as was possible with the general appropriation made for
  this purpose, and no other work is contemplated during the current fiscal
  year for the same reason.
No appropriation asked for next fiscal year.

                          DEFENSES OF BALTIMORE.

  Fort McHenry, Baltimore Harbor, Maryland, in charge of Lieut. CoL.
William P. Craighill, Corps of Engineers.-This fort forms part of the
inner line of defense for Baltimore and its dependent interests, and
commands with its fire the interior waters of the harbor and the channel
of approach thereto, in which latter a depth of 27 feet exists at mean
low water.
  The fortifications at this place were commenced in'1775, and in 1794
the present work was built.
  Although the original fort has become almost useless as a defensive
work, the site is still an important one, and the water-front should be
occupied by a battery of modern guns, mounted behind an earthen para-
pet of the most approved dimensions, and provided with bomb-proof
cover for ammunition and gunners. Such a battery, the plans of which
were prepared by the Board of Engineers for Fortifications, was com-
menced in 1872, and is partly constructed, although all work upon it
has been suspended for want of funds since July, 1876. The plan of
this battery requires revision.
  A bulkhead of ballast having been made by the United States, with.
out expense, along a line in front of the site, and at a distance from the
authorized pier line of 375 feet, and a line having also been established
in the rear of the site at the same distance from the pier line, it is pro-
posed to fill in the whole area thus defined with ballast from ships com-
ing to the port. The available limits of the site will thus be largely in-
creased without expense to the United States. Little progress has been
made in this filling during the past year, as but few vessels have applied
to deposit ballast upon the area.
   A sea-wall should be built along the line of the temporary bulkheads
referred to above, and the present wharf should be removed and a new
one built near the new dry-dock.
   The repairs for the year have consisted of the following items: Mow-
ing slopes of main work and the exterior batteries; cleaning out and
readjusting some of the drains; replacing broken slates on the large
                             SEA-COAST DEFENSES.                              29
                    DEFENSES OF BALTIMORE-continued.

storage magazine near the hospital; setting three of the coping-stones
of the sea-wall; readjusting and sodding some of the slopes of the demi-
lune battery; filling, readjusting, and sodding two slips in the old outer
battery.
No appropriation having been made, no work was done at this fortifica-
tion during the last fiscal year beyond its protection, preservation, and
repair, as far as was possible wim the general appropriation made for
this purpose, and no other work is contemplated during the current
fiscal year for the same reason.
No appropriation asked for next fiscal year.
  Fort Carroll,BaltimoreHarbor, Maryland, in chargeof Lieut. Col. Will-
iam P. Craigkill, Corps of Engineers.-This fortification, commenced in
1847, is situated upon an exterior line of defense for the harbor of Bal-
timore.
   It has been proposed to modify this fort so as to enable it to be prop-
erly available for its intended purpose; the modifications to be in ac-
cordance with the requirements of warfare of the present day. Its
completion is indispensable to the safety of the rich city of Baltimore
in time of foreign war, and the work to be done cannot safely be left
until the approach of hostilities. It will require several years and lib-
eral appropriations to accomplish it, and it should be commenced with-
out delay.
   Operations during the past year have been confined to the general
care and preservation of the work and the public property stored
thereat.
No appropriation having been made, no work was done at this fortifica-
  tion during the last fiscal year beyond its protection, preservation, and
  repair, as far as was possible with the general appropriation made for
  this purpose, and no other work is contemplated during the current
  fiscal year for the same reason.
No appropriation asked for next fiscal year.

                         DEFENSES OF WASHINGTON.

  Fort Foote, Potomac River, Maryland, in charge of Maj. Peter C. Hains,
Corps of Engineers.-This earthwork is situated on the left bank of the
Potomac River, and only 2 miles below Alexandria. It commands the
water approaches to that city and to Washington.
   The work was commenced in 1862. In 1872 the Board of Engineers
for Fortifications approved a project for the modification of the old fort
and for the construction of an additional battery. Work was in progress
on the former when a suspension became necessary by reason of the
failure of appropriations. No work has ever been done on the proposed
new battery and none on the old fort since 1874.
   At the present time the condition of the work may be described as
one of utter dilapidation. The magazines, which at the time of the
suspension of operations were in an unfinished condition, are rapidly
going to ruin. The parapet on the water front was hardly begun when
work ceased. There are five gun platforms laid, four front, and one
center pintle. They are built of concrete and granite, and are service-
able. The plans of the work require revision.
   The buildings are all built of perishable material, and rapidly going
to decay. As the post is not occupied by troops, it is not deemed ex-
pedient to repair all of them. Slight repairs to two sets of officers'
quarters and the hospital are recommended.
30       REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

                  DEFENSES OF WASHINGTON--continued.

  During the past year traverse rails and pintle plates were laid for
two 15-inch guns, one set of officers' quarters was painted, the roads
repaired, and slopes mowed.
No appropriation having been made, no work was done at this fortifica-
  tion during the last fiscal year beyond its protection, preservation, and
  repair, as far as was possible with the general appropriation made for
  this purpose, and no other work is montemplated during the current
  fiscal year for the same reason.
No appropriation asked for next fiscal year.
  Fort Washington, Potomac River, Maryland, in charge of Maj. Peter
C. Bains, Corps of Engineers.-The construction of this fort was begun
in 1816. It is a casemated work, occupying a commanding position on
the left bank of the Potomac River, 11 miles below the city of Wash-
ington, and constitutes an important part of the outer line of defense
of Washington and the Washington navy-yard.
   The masonry of the old work is still in good condition, but as the
fort was designed more than half a century ago, it is not adapted to
receive guns of modern size, or to defensive purposes against such guns.
   In 1870 the Board of Engineers for Fortifications approved plans for
a modification of the demilune, converting it into a battery of modern
construction, with guns of large caliber. The platforms for four of
these guns were built, and the magazines partially so, when work was
suspended for lack of funds. Three other batteries were planned, and
received the approval of the Board of Engineers for Fortifications, but
no work has yet been done on them.
   The plans of these batteries should be modified to conform to the
latest improvements in defensive works before their construction is be-
gun.
   The fort itself will also need modification for the same reason, but the
unfinished magazines in the demilune battery ought to be completed,
to prevent deterioration and decay.
   Traverse rails and pintle plates for four 15-inch gun platforms were
laid early in the present fiscal .year. The slopes have been mowed, and
slight repairs made to some of the buildings. Two of the magazines
were cleaned out and ventilators put in. The magazines require addi-
tional work to put them in good condition. A part of the boundary
fence of the reservation, which had rotted and disappeared, has been
rebuilt.
   There has been no special appropriation for this work since 1873-'74.
The unfinished parts of the demilune battery are therefore suffering
constant deterioration.
No appropriation having been made, no work was done at this fortifica-
  tion during the last fiscal year beyond its protection, preservation, and
  repair, as far as was possible with the general appropriation made for
  this purpose, and no other work is contemplated during the current
  fiscal year for the same reason.
No appropriation asked for next fiscal year.
   Obstructions of the Potomac, in charge of Maj. Peter C. Hains, Corps of
Engineers.--The material pertaining to these obstructions was continued
in store at Fort Foote, Maryland. The timber portion has become en-
tirely worthless from decay. The irons are in good condition.
      DEFENSES OF HAMPTON ROADS AND GOSPORT NAVY-YARD.

  Fort Monroe, Old Point Comfort, Virginia, in chargeof Col. Q. A. Gill-
more, Corps of Engineers.-This extensive work, commenced in 1817,
                         SEA-COAST DEFENSES.                          31
DEFENSES OF HAMPTON ROADS AND GOSPORT NAVY-YARD--continued.

occupies an important position, covering, in co-operation With Fort
Wool, on the opposite side of the channel, the only approach from the
sea to Hampton Roads, the cities of Norfolk and Portsmouth, the Gos-
port navy-yard, and the James River.
   These works, also, in offering a safe rendezvous for our own vessels
of war, afford indirect protection to Baltimore, Annapolis, and Wash-
ington, and all the harbors and towns on the Chesapeake Bay and
Potomac River. The work covers an area of 86 acres, and the distance
around it is 14 miles.
   The modifications that have been planned and approved for adapting
Fort Monroe to the requirements of efficient defense against war vessels
of recent type contemplate arming the channel front of the advanced
redoubt with heavy barbette guns, provided with suitable traverses and
traverse magazines; mounting a similar armament in the re-entering
place of arms, located on the right of the redoubt in advance of Front
No. 5; constructing a new open battery for barbette guns to the right
of the old casemated water battery; and placing a few heavy guns in
the salients of the main work and covered way. There is plenty of
room for mortar batteries both within and without the work.
   The work of making the requisite modifications has been suspended
for several years past for want of appropriations.
   It is expected that the changes finally adopted will be of a much more
radical character than those to which reference has been made.
   In the advanced earthen redoubt the two traverse magazines are
finished, except the earth covering to one of them, and six gun plat-
forms are nearly completed. Most of the earthwork of the redoubt is
also finished. In the place of arms the concrete masonry of the service
magazine is finished, but not covered with earth, and the concrete foun-
dations for the gun platforms have been laid. The new ten-gun earthen
battery has not been commenced.
   The following operations have been carried on during the past fiscal
year :
   Traverse irons were laid on two platforms for 15-inch guns at the bat-
tery east of the casemated water battery, and the parapet and exterior
slope were repaired and sodded.
   Platform No. 96, for-8-inch or 10-inch Rodman guns, on left flank of
bastion 3-4, main work, was put in serviceable order.
   Repairs were made to a section of the parade wall near the flagstaff
bastion, Front I. A new road-bed was laid on the winding ramp of bas-
tion 3-4, formed. of rubble, gravel, and some clay. Repairs were made to
the parapet of Front IV, where 600 square feet of new sods were laid.
The interior slope of bastion 5-6 was thoroughly repaired; 115 linear
feet of revetment, 3 feet high, extending along the foot of the slope,
was entirely rebuilt, and 156 linear feet of blue-stone coping reset. A
long crevice, 21 inches wide, in the scarp wall of Front V, was filled
with concrete and pointed. Some repairs were made to the concrete
road-bed in rear of the covered way, water battery, and the.brick walk
through the southern postern taken up and relaid.
   Repairs were made to magazine No. 2, Front II; new floor timbers
and planks were laid, walls and ceilings put in order, and two oak-wood
gratings fitted to cover dust-holes.
  The seven iron leaders that take water from the top of the large mag-
azine near Carroll Hall have been cleaned out and lacquered; at the
32       REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

DEFENSES OF HAMPTON ROADS AND GOSPORT NAVY-YARD-Conltinued

mouth of each pipe an excavation was made and a drain formed, loosely
tilled with broken brick and stone.
    The bridge leading across the ditch to the main sallyport, Front VII,
was thoroughly repaired and painted, and the brick piers pointed. The
gates and iron gearing of sallyports were painted.
   The sluice-gates next to Mill Creek, Fronts VI-VIII, were altered by
shifting them to the Mill Creek side of the frame-work. By this ar-
rangement the water in the ditch is admitted through the sluice-way
in advance of Front V, and passes out through the sluice of Fronts VI-
VII. Heavy iron latches are fitted to the gate, to be used whenever it
is considered necessary to hold the water-level in the ditch at the proper
height to obtain the requisite head for flushing the main sewer. Gal-
vanized-iron wire screens were fitted in the sluice-ways to prevent float-
ing objects from entering the ditch.
    Miscellaneous repairs were made to the Engineer office, Engineer quar-
ters, stable, and fences; cisterns were cleaned out and pumps put in
working order where necessary. Privies at all the buildings under the
control of the Engineer Department were altered and fitted with gal.
vanized-iron receptacles, to replace the wooden boxes heretofore used.
No appropriation having been made, no work was done at this fortifica-
tion during the last fiscal year beyond its protection, preservation, and
repair, as far as was possible with the general appropriation made for
this purpose, and no other work is contemplated during the current
fiscal year for the same reason.
No appropriation asked for next fiscal year.
  Artesian well at Fort Monroe, Virginia, in charge of Col. Q. A. Gill-
more, Corps of Engineers.-No work was done during the last fiscal
year, and none is contemplated during the present fiscal year, for want
of funds. The present depth of the well is about 900 feet, and in view
of the importance of an independent supply of water in case of the in-
terruption of other sources, it is recommended that this be increased to
1,200 or 1,500 feet before abandoning the project.
No appropriation was made for the fiscal year ending June 30, 1887.
No appropriation asked for next fiscal year.
   Fort Wool, Hampton Roads, Virginia, in charge of Col. Q. A. Gillmore,
Corps of Engineers.-This work unites with Fort Monroe in closing the
sea approach to Hampton Roads, being located on the opposite side of
the channel from that work, and therefore crossing its fire with it.
   Fort Wool is an inclosed casemated fort. It was begun in 1818 by
forming an artificial foundation with stone of random sizes, unloaded
upon a 10 foot shoal, selected as the site of the work. When the scarp-
wall and piers had reached a height to include the lintels of the lower
tier of embrasures settlement began, and work was stopped after piling
a quantity of stone upon the walls sufficient to bring upon the founda-
tion a pressure somewhat exceeding that of the finished work.
   The work of construction was resumed in 1858, and when it was sus-
pended fifty-two casemates of the lower tier, with iron-throated embra-
sures, were finished and ready for the guns. On the second tier the
scarp-wall and piers of those portions of the work bearing on the chan-
nel had reached nearly to the height of the embrasure lintels, the em-
brasure irons had been set, and the floors of most of the casemates
paved. On the gorge faces very little work had been done.
  The work done during the past fiscal year consisted in making slight
repairs to the fort-keeper's quarters; cleaning the cistern and repairing
                             SEA-COAST DEFENSES.                              33
DEFENSES OF HAMPTON ROADS AND GOSPORT NAVY-YARD-continued.

its side walls; constructing a landing for small boats from material
taken from the old wharf, which is now a useless wreck; and repairing
and painting the Engineer yawl-boat.
   It is designed to modify this important work so that it may receive
the heaviest modern rifled guns, protected by impenetrable iron armor.
The work to be done, which will require several years for its execution,
cannot be left until the near approach of war.
No appropriation having been made, no work was done at this fortifica-
  tion during the last fiscal year beyond its protection, preservation, and
  repair, as far as was possible with the general appropriation made for
  this purpose, and no other work is contemplated during the current
  fiscal year for the same reason.
No appropriation asked for next fiscal year.

          DEFENSES      OF BEAUFORT        HARBOR, NORTH CAROLINA.

    Fort Macon, Beaufort Hatbor, North Carolina,in charge of Capt. W.
H. Bixby, Corps of Engineers.-This fort forms the sole military defense
of Beaufort Harbor and its attendant interests. It commands with its
fire all the inner waters of the harbor and the channels of approach
thereto.
    Although the old fort in itself has become almost useless as a defen-
sive work, the site is still an important one, and its water-front should
be occupied by a battery of modern heavy guns, mounted upon a sand
parapet of the most approved model and provided with bomb-proof
cover to ammunition and gunners.
    The masonry of the fort is in places badly cracked, apparently due
to unequal settlement of the foundations; but these cracks have not
materially changed for several years past; and the foundations, which
have apparently entirely stopped settling, are probably in good condi-
tion. All the wood-work and iron-work of the fort is rotting and rust-
ing everywhere, and the plastering is falling from the walls and ceil-
ings of the casemates. There are three small powder magazines inside
.the fort, all of which are in good order. The wooden buildings on the
post, used for quarters and for storage, are of a temporary character,
and they are in about as serviceable a condition as is necessary for their
present uses.
    There being no special appropriation for the fiscal year ending June
30, 1886, operations have been confined to the general care and preser-
vation of the work. These operations have consisted mainly in ex-
  tending backward the main jetty, in repairing the fence encircling the
  fort slopes, and in keeping the fort and slopes in general good order.
    The site of the fort has needed further protection against the ocean.
  As no funds were available for this, and as Fort Macon Point forms,
  also, one side of the entrance to Beaufort Harbor, its site has to a cer-
  tain extent during the last year been protected at the expense of the
  Beaufort Harbor appropriations. The most important work of this
  nature is the partial rear extension of the main jetty, the partial con-
  struction of a jetty opposite the old railroad wharf, and the construction
  of a small landing wharf.
     Further protection against the neighboring river and ocean is needed.
  The other jetties (constructed in 1844-'45 and 1883-'85) have all given
  excellent results; but the railroad jetty should be completed at a fur-
  ther expense of $3,000.
          3E
34      REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

  DEFENSES OF BEAUFORT           HARBOR, NORTH CAROLINA-continued.

  A project for adapting this work to the requirements of modern
defense is under consideration.
No appropriation was made for the fiscal year ending June 30, 1887.
No appropriation asked for next fiscal year.
                        DEFENSES OF WILMINGTON.

   Fort Caswell, mouth of Cape Fear River, North Carolina,in chargeof
Col. Q. A. Gillmore, Corps of Engineers.-This barbette work, commenced
in 1826, covers the entrance into Cape Fear ]R9iver, and hence the water
approach to the city of Wilmington, and constitutes the only defense of
that locality.
   Upon its evacuation by the Confederate forces in January, 1865, an
attempt was made to blow it up. All the scarp-wall of the southeast
face was overturned by a mine exploded in the scarp gallery of that
face; a portion of the scarp-wall of the north and west fronts was so
badly shattered by the explosion of a magazine on the covered way near
northwest salient that it will have to be rebuilt, and the citadel on the
parade of the work was burned. There is now neither armament nor
quarters for a garrison at the place.
   The subject of its modification is now under consideration.
No appropriation was made for the fiscal year ending June 30, 1887.
No appropriation asked for next fiscal year.
                         DEFENSES OF CHARLESTON.

  Fort Moultrie, Charleston Harbor, South Carolina, in charge of Col. Q.
A. Gillnore, Corps of Engineers.-This work is located on Sullivan's
Island, and co-operates with Fort Sumter in defending the water ap-
proach from the sea to the city and harbor of Charleston. It is an
earthen barbette work, and was commenced in 1841.
   The completion of the work comprises the construction of eleven per-
manent gun platforms and breast-height walls, bonnets on the traverses,
a portion of the masonry and all the earth covering of the bomb-proof
shelter, the postern gallery, a part of the earth covering of the maga-
zines, and an earthen cover-face on the channel front.
   During the past fiscal year the part of the parade fence which had
been destroyed by a storm on August 25, 1885, was rebuilt; the slopes
were mowed, and some general clearing up of the inside of the fort done.
The flag-staff, which had been blown down, was reset.
No appropriation having been made, no work was done at this fortifica-
  tion during the last fiscal year beyond its protection, preservation and
  repair, as far as was possible with the general appropriation made for
  this purpose, and no other work is contemplated during the current
  fiscal year for the same reason.
No appropriation asked for next fiscal year.
   Fort Sumter, Charleston Harbor, South Carolina,in charge of Col. Q. A.
Gillmore, Corps of Engineers.-This casemated work is located on a
shoal on the south side of the entrance into the harbor, and its guns,
crossing their fire with those of Fort Moultrie, on Sullivan's Island,
command the only channel of approach thereto practicable for vessels
of war.
   Its construction was begun in 1829, and was nearly finished, although
still wanting most of its armament, when, in April, 1861, it was captured
by the Confederate forces.
   The reconstruction of the work, with the view of adapting it to the con-
                             SEA-COAST      DEFENSES.                         35
                 DEFENSES OF CHARLESTON--Continued.

ditions of modern defense, was begun in 1870, and is now well advanced.
Of the barbette gun platforms required eight have been laid. Three
.of these eight are permanent and five are of timber. Eight casemates
on the northwest face are ready for the guns, except the traverse rails,
and the nine casemates on the northeast face, one in the pan coupd be-
tween the northeast and north faces, and one adjacent thereto on the
north face (eleven in all) are armed.
    The completion of this work comprises the construction of seven per-
manent gun platforms and their lreast-height walls, placing bonnets on
the traverses, most of the earthwork on the gorge face and the parados
and magazines adjacent thereto, the arrangement of a room for torpedo
defense, and the repair and extension of the wharf and other matters
of detail.
    The work done during the past fiscal year consisted principally in re-
pairing damages caused by the storm of August 25, 1885. That storm
washed away a great part of the exterior slope and coping of the south-
east face, broke up the deck-planks of the wharf, tore away the sally-
port gate, and set afloat everything movable in the fort, the water stand-
ing 5 feet deep in the center of the parade.
    The wharf planks were spiked down again, and other necessary repairs
made to the wharf. A large amount of sand, deposited in the casemates
by the storm, was removed, and the parade cleared of debris. The ord-
nance sergeant's quarters, which had also suffered from the storm, were
repaired, and a davit for his row-boat supplied on the wharf. The sally-
port gate was rehung.
    The earthwork of the southeast face was repaired. It is now sodded
on the exterior slope for the whole length of this face, and the top is
finished off parallel to its proposed superior slope, but 3 feet below it,
the funds allotted not being sufficient to carry it to the full height.
    The rotten wooden revetment in front of gun platforms Nos. 9 and 10,
on the same face, was replaced by a substantial marsh sod wall, with
sufficient batter to make it secure. The sea breaks against the scarp-
wall of this front so heavily at times that the slopes are likely to re-
quire further repairs.
No appropriation having been made, no work was done at this fortifica-
  tion during the last fiscal year beyond its protection, preservation, and
  repair, as far as was possible with the general appropriation made for
  this purpose, and no other work is contemplated during the present
  fiscal year for the same reason.
No appropriation asked for next fiscal year.
  Fort Johnson, Charleston Harbor, South Carolina, in charge of Col.
Q. A. Gillmore, Corps of Engineers.-This old work, situated on James
Island, a little more than 14 miles west of Fort Sumter, should consti-
tute one of the inner works in the system of defense for this locality.
   It is a fort only in name, having neither armament nor magazines,
but only some irregular mounds of earth, representing what remains of
the battery found there at the close of the civil war.
   The project for reconstructing this old work contemplates making it
a battery for heavy guns and sea-coast mortars. Timber platforms for
the mortars have been procured.
No appropriation having been made, no work was done at this fortifica-
  tion during the last fiscal year beyond its protection, preservation, and
  repair, as far as was possible with the general appropriation made for
  this purpose, and no other work is contemplated during the current
  fiscal year for the same reason.
No appropriation asked for next fiscal year.
36        REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

                  DEFENSES OF CHARLESTON--continued.

     Castle Pinckney, Charleston Harbor, South Carolina, in charge of Col.
Q. A. Gillmore, Corps of Engineers.-This work, situated on Shute's
Folly Island, about 1 mile east of the city of Charleston, is one of the
interior works in the system of defense of the harbor. The work was
commenced in 1829. In its present condition it is useless for defensive
purposes, and is now in charge of the Light-House Board for light-
house purposes.
  An expenditure of about $20,000 will be required to adapt this work
to the reception of an armament.
No appropriation was made for the fiscal year ending June 30,1887.
No appropriation asked for next fiscal year.
                            DEFENSES OF SAVANNAH.

  Fort Oglethorpe, Savannah River, Georgia, in charge of Col. Q. A. Gill-
more, Corps of E ngineers.--This work, commenced in 1842, is situated
about 4 miles from the city of Savannah, and forms the inner line of
defense for that city.
  Modifications of this work, approved January 11, 1870, so as to fit it
for the reception of heavy guns, were commenced in the fiscal year
ending June 30, 1873, but they were suspended some years since for
want of appropriations. The plans of the work require revision.
  During the past year repairs were made to the fort-keeper's house,
the casemates were cleaned out, and the slopes mowed.
No appropriation having been made, no work was done at this fortifica-
  tion during the last fiscal year beyond its protection, preservation, and
  repair, as far as was possible with the general appropriation made for
  this purpose, and no other work is contemplated during the current
  fiscal year for the same reason.
No appropriation asked for next fiscal year.
   Fort Pulaski, mouth of Savannah River, Georgia, in charge of Col. Q.
A. Gillmore, Corps of Engineers.-This casemated work, commenced in
1829, is located on Cockspur Island, covers the ship-channel leading from
Tybee Roads into the Savannah River, and constitutes the principal
defense of the city of Savannah against naval attack.
   From 1872 to 1875 the work of remodeling the deniilune was carried
on at intervals and nearly completed. Its gun platforms were built of
timber, and two 15-inch guns were mounted on the north face.
   The chief work during the past fiscal year consisted in repairing a
number of permanent barbette platforms for 8-inch or 10-inch Rodman
guns on the four channel-fronts of the main work, viz: Three front
pintle plhtforms on the north front; two front pintle and three center
pintle platforms on the northeast front; three front pintle and three
center pintle platforms on the southeast front, and six front pintle plat-
forms on the south front; total, twenty platforms.
   Lamp-closet fixtures were put in the magazines of the demilune. On
October 11, 1885, during a heavy storm, the tide rose over the magazine
floors to a height of 14 inches. The bridges across the moat were lifted
out of position, but have since been replaced. The mud, shells, &c.,
clogging the flood-gate at the entrance to the moat were removed. The
slopes and the parade were kept clear of grass and weeds.
No appropriation having been made, no work was done at this fortifica-
  tion during tihe last fiscal year beyond its protection, preservation, and
  repair, as far as was possible with the general appropriation made for
  this purpose, and no other work is contemplated during the current,
  fiscal year for the same reason.
No appropriation asked for next fiscal year.
                             SEA-COAST 1EFENSES.                                 37
                     1EFENSES OF SAVANNAH-continued.

  7New fort on Tybee Island, mouth of Savannah River, Georgia, in charge
of Col. Q. A. Gillmore, Corps of Engineers.-Plans have been prepared
for defensive earthen works to be constructed on the north point of
Ty bee Island, for the double purpose of preventing the occupation of
Tybee Roads by hostile vessels and defending the channel' of approach
to the Savannah River. The land necessary for the work was acquired
by the United States in 1875.
  The northeast shore of this reservation is protected from the inroads
of the sea by three spur-jetties composed of log mattresses overlaid with
brush and loaded with stone. One of these spurs, No. 2, has its shore
end near the old Spanish tower; No. 1 is 1,000 feet northwest and No.
3 about 1,400 feet southeast of No. 2. These works were built in 1882.
  During the past fiscal year spur-jetty No. 2 was extended about 290
feet, the work involving the use of 798.86 square yards of log mattress
and 455.65 cubic yards of stone.
  All the work done for protecting the sea shore of the reservation is in
good condition and is accomplishing its purpose. The jetties have
sanded over and the rocks where exposed are cemented together by a
growth of oyster-shells and barnacles.
No appropriation for their construction has yet been made.
No appropriation asked for next fiscal year.

                     DEFENSES OF CUMBERLAND                SOUND.

   Fort Clinch, Amelia Island, Florida,in charge of Col. Q. A. Gillmore,
Corps of Engineers.-This casemated work, commenced in 1850, defends
the entrance into Cumberland Sound and is in an unfinished condition.
A plan for modifying the work has been prepared by the Board of En-
gineers for Fortifications, which contemplates an armament of rifled
guns and the construction of an exterior earthen battery for 12-inch
rifed guns.
   The following work was done during the past fiscal year: The cyclone
of August, 1885; having somewhat damaged the shore protection imme-
diately in front of the sea-wall of the fort, between spur-jetties B and
C, built some years ago, the necessary repairs were made and two new
spur-jetties constructed between the two just named. These new spurs
are 54 and 44 feet long, respectively; they have given excellent results,
the sand having filled in rapidly, at some points to a depth of over 3
feet.
   A new ventilating flue was put in the barracks building inside the
fort and a trap-door cut in the roof of the same building.
   The weeds and grass have been cut from the fort and from the yard
of the Engineer officer's quarters, and both places have been thoroughly
policed and put in order during the year.
   A new roof was put on the Engineer officer's quarters, a new fence
built around the yard, the breakwater in front repaired, and various
minor repairs made to cisterns, water-tanks, &c.
No appropriation having been made, no work was done at this fortification
  during the last fiscal year beyond its protection, preservation, and repair,
  as far as was possible with the general appropriation made for this pur-
  pose, and no other work is contemplated during the current fiscal year
  for the same reason.
No appropriation asked for next fiscal year.
38        REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S ARMY.

                          DEFENSES-OF           SAINT AUGUSTINE.

   Fort Marion, Saint Augustine, Florida,in charge of Capt. William T.
Rossell, Corps of Engineers, until April 26, 1886; since that date in charge
of First Lieut. Williani M. Black, Corps of Engineers.--This work is
intended to .defend the harbor and city of Saint Augustine. It was
essentially completed in 1756, almost one hundred years after its com-
mencement, and under the name of ' San Marco " formed the citadel of
the elaborate system designed by the Spaniards for the defense of the
city. It is built of coquina, a natural shell concrete found on Saint
Anastasia Island, opposite Saint Augustine. The fort has never been
remodeled. A water battery was constructed along its sea-front in
1842-1843, and this is the only portion of the work which can be readily
adapted for use with modern ordnance. For this purpose the platforms
should be prepared for modern guns, the parapet raised and strength-
ened, and traverses arranged for service magazines, and bomb-proofs
constructed.
    Five thousand dollars were appropriated for the preservation of the
fort and inclosure of its grounds in the act approved July 5, 1884. In
accordance therewith a picket fence has been built along a portion of
the reservation boundary line, the sea-wall and covered-way breast-height
walls repaired, the bastion towers renewed, the interior walls refaced
where necessary, the ramp rebuilt, and a portion of the terre-plein cov-
ered with a water-proof pavement for the protection of the casemates.
In al of the repairs the original designs were followed as closely as
possible.
    Under an allotment from the general appropriation for the preserva-
tion and repair of fortifications, 1886, the materials for the repair of six
gun platforms of the water battery were purchased.
    If it is intended to fully restore the fort to its condition when left by
the Spaniards, and to inclose and beautify its ground, extending the
sea-wall to the north end of the reservation, an additional appropria-
tion of $15,000 will be required.
    In January, February, and March, 1886, 7,731 persons visited this
fort.
Appropriation asked for next fiscal year ..........................--   ---.....   $10,000 00

                                DEFENSES OF KEY WEST.

   Fort Taylor and batteries, Key West, Florida, in charge of CcGs. Will-
iam T. Rossell, Corps of Engineers, until November 17, 1885; since that
date in charge of Maj. W. H. Heuer, Corps of Engineers.-These works,
comprising a main casemated work of brick upon a submarine founda-
tion, and earthen battery northeast of the main work and one to south-
east of it, with two martello towers of brick on the south shore of the
island, are for the defense of the important harbor of Key West.
   The main work was commenced in 1844; the citadel is complete, but
the cover-face on the land-faces of this is in a very incomplete condition,
and only the former portion is at present of any defensive value. The
barracks and quarters within the fort are in very bad order and be-
coming worse through decay and neglect. The walls are much in need
of repointing, or some similar repairs. All the casemate platforms are
generally in good condition, and the barbette platforms on the sea-faces,
except those for the 15-inch guns, which, being of wood, are decayed, so
as to be of no use whatever.
                              SEA-COAST IfEFENSES.                                     39
                    DEFENSES OF KEY WEST-continued.
   During the past fiscal year all the scaffolding used in connection with
stuccoing the walls was taken down and stored.
   Five brick ventilators to magazines were built. The cistern to tem-
porary buildings was repaired; 11,800 old brick on hand were cleaned
and used for this purpose. The fences around temporary buildings were
also repaired. Two quarters, two store-houses, stables, carpenter-shop,
smith-shop, engine-houses, car-sheds, &c., were whitewashed and re-
paired.
   The drains through the reservation have been thoroughly cleaned out,
so that the tide now ebbs and flows through them and the ponds con-
nected with them.
   Three new bridges were built over the road crossings. The main
bridge was repaired, 96 embrasures on fort, 1 locomotive and engine,
17 railroad cars, 1 hoisting engine, and 140 tons embrasure irons were
scraped, cleaned of rust, and coal-tarred.
   The exterior earthen batteries are suffering the inevitable deteriora-
tion due to their incomplete condition; the platforms, a combination
of concrete and wood, are. because of the decay of wood, utterly useless
in their present condition. The estimated cost of these batteries is
$240,338, which, on account of deterioration, should be increased to
$250,000.
   The martello towers, in fair condition, were constructed in the early
part of the war of secession, on private land, the title to which has
never been acquired by the United States.
No appropriation having been made, no work has been done at these forti-
  fications during the fiscal year beyond the guarding of the property and
  the protection of the works from depredation, and none is contemplated
for the ensuing fiscal year, because of lack of funds, other than such
work of protection, preservation, and repair as the general appropria-
tion will permit.
Appropriation asked for the next fiscal year : For acquisition of sites of the
  two martello towers, by purchase or condemnation....................           $9, 000 00

             DEFENSES OF THE HARBOR OF DRY TORTUGAS.

  Fort Jefferson, Garden Key, Tortugas, Florida, in charge of Capt.
William T. Rossell, Corps of Engineers, until November 17, 1885; since
that date in charge of Maj. W H. Heuer, Corps of Engineers.--Thiscase-
mated work, commenced in 1846, perfectly commands the admirable
harbor lying in the heart of this group of keys.
  The wharf is utterly decayed, and is so far gone that it would be un-
safe to roll a barrel of powder over it. To rebuild this wharf, which is
absolutely necessary, will cost about $3,500.
  During the past fiscal year the following work was done at this fort:
Laid 16 walks around the barbette magazines; repaired and painted
10 walks around the magazines in barbette tier; painted 6 magazines;
repaired 3 store-rooms in casemates; repaired magazine doors; scraped
and tarred the rails in barbette tiers; tore down old machine shop and
stored the lumber; repaired and painted house occupied by ordnance-
sergeant; whitewashed storehouse, and painted 18 doors of powder-
magazines and all windows and shutters ; scraped and painted the water
doors of lower casemates; cleaned and coal-tarred 290 pieces of embras-
ure iron.
  The quarters are suffering from neglect, and the unfinished barracks
should be completed. Pending the adoption of modifications which the
40       REPORT     OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

     DEFENSES OF THE HARBOR OF DRY TORTUGAS-continued.

most modern conditions demand, no appropriation is at this time recom-
mended. The lower tier of casemates, in which guns in casemate are
alone mounted, are generally in good condition, and the barbette plat.
forms, for the guns of the lesser calibers, are also in good condition gen-
erally, though some of them are incomplete.
   The wooden platforms for 15-inch guns are thoroughly decayed and
are of no use.
   The scarp of the work is, in places, incomplete; the parapet is not
wholly em banked, and the traverses, most of which are incomplete, are
suffering from deterioration through loss of material; being formed of
sand and mostly unprotected, or incompletely so, the winds blow it
away.
No appropriation having been made, no work was done at this fortifica-
  tion during the last fiscal year except caring for the property and pro-
  tecting the work and buildings from depredations, and none is contem-
  plated for the ensuing year.
No appropriation is asked for next fiscal year.

          DEFENSES OF PENSACOLA HARBOR AND NAVY-YARD.


   FortPickens, PensacolaHarbor, Florida,in charge of Capt. R. L. Hoxie,
Corps of Engineers.-This casemated work, commenced in 1828, with
Fort Barrancas and the proposed new batteries near the site of Fort
McRee. constitutes the defenses of the town and harbor of Pensacola
and the navy-yard at Warrington. It is situated near the west end of
Santa Rosa Island, and is at present the only work of defense of the en-
trance and main channel to Pensacola Harbor.
   Plans for the modification of this work and the construction of exte-
rior sand batteries for heavy guns were prepared by the Board of En-
gineers for Fortifications when Bastions C and D were modified, but
since 1876 no appropriations have been made for this work, and opera-
tions have therefore been confined to the preservation and repair of the
buildings and works, and to the care of the public property appertain-
ing to the same. The plans of the work and exterior batteries require
revision.
No appropriation having been made, no work was done at this fortifica-
  tion during the last fiscal year, and no work is contemplated during the
  current fiscal year for the same reason.
No appropriation asked for next fiscal year.
   FortBarrancas and redoubt, Pensacola Harbor, Florida,in charge of
Capt. R. L. Hoxie, Corps of Engineers.-These works, commenced in 1839,
are situated on the north bank of the entrance to Pensacola Harbor,
opposite Fort Pickens, and are intended for defense of this entrance
and protection from land attacks.
   For many years operations at this work were confined to necessary
repairs to masonry, slopes, and wood-work, until 1874, when the con-
struction of four front pintle platforms for mounting new ordnance was
commenced; but work was suspended before much progress was made,
none of the platforms having been completed.     Since that time opera-
tions have again been confined to ordinary repairs.
   Plans and estimates for the construction of an exterior battery on the
bluff west of the fort have been prepared by the Board of Engineers for
                             SEA-COAST DEFENSES.                              41
  DEFENSES      OF PENSACOLA HARBOR AND NAVY-YARD-continued.

Fortifications, but so far no appropriations have been made and no work
has been done. The plans require revision.
No appropriation having been made, no work was done at this fortifica-
  tion during the last fiscal year, and no work is contemplated during the
  current fiscal year for the same reason.
No appropriation asked for next fiscal year.
  Fort McRee, PensacolaHarbor, Florida,in charge of Capt. R. L. Hoxie,
Corps ofEngineers.-This fort, situated on the west side of the main ship-
channel to Pensacola Harbor, commenced in 1836, has been a ruin since
the late war, and the greater portion has been washed away by the en-
croachment of the sea upon its site.
  Plans for the construction of batteries for the heaviest modern guns
and mortars near the site of the old fort, to co-operate with Fort Pick-
ens and the works at Barrancas in the defense of this important harbor,
have been prepared by the Board of Engineers for Fortifications, but as
no appropriation has been made for them no work was done upon them.
The plans require revision.
No appropriation having been made, no work was done at this fortifica-
  tion during the last fiscal year, and no work is contemplated during the
  current fiscal year for the same reason.
No appropriation asked for next fiscal year.

                              DEFENSES OF MOBILE.

   Fort Morgan, eastern entrance to Mobile Bay, Alabama, in charge of
Maj. A. N. Damrell, Corps of Engineers.-This casemated fort, com-
menced in 1819 and completed in 1833, is situated at Mobile Point, on
the east side of the main ship-channel to Mobile 4vy, and as it com-
mands this channel from the outer bar to the lower anchorage, and
forms, with Fort Gaines on the west side of the channel, the outer line
of defenses to the harbor and port of Mobile, its site is of great impor-
tance, but will not be of much value as a defensive work until the con-
templated water batteries for heavy ordnance along the western and
southern shores are completed. As stated in former reports, the con-
struction of these batteries was commenced in September, 1875, but
work had to be suspended in April, 1876, the amount appropriated being
exhausted; and as no appropriations have been made since, this work
has not been resumed. The plans of the batteries require revision.
   During the year fifteen iron shutters were fitted to embrasures of
casemates. All ditches, drains, gutters, and casemates in the fort were
thoroughly cleaned and grass and weeds cut twice. The outer gate of
sallyport was repaired and a portion of joints on terreplein were re-
pointed.
   All the outbuildings, except carpenter shop, and the fences, were re-
paired, and slight repairs made to wharf.
No appropriation having been made, no work was done at this fortifica-
  tion during the last fiscal year beyond its protection, preservation, and
  repair, as far as was possible with the general appropriation made for
  this purpose, and no other work is contemplated during the current
  fiscal year for the same reason.
No appropriation asked for next fiscal year.
  Fort Gaines, Dauphin Island, Alabama, in charge of Miaj. A. N. Dam-
rell, Corps of Engineers.-This work, commenced in 1848, is, with Fort
Morgan, on the opposite side of the main entrance to Mobile Harbor,
designed to command that entrance and the lower fleet anchorage.              It
42       REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

                     DEFENSES OF MOBILE-continued.

needs complete modification to adapt it to the use of modern heavy
guns, and plans therefor have been prepared by the Board of Engineers
for Fortifications; but no appropriations having been made for this
work, the fort remains in the condition as reported in former reports.
The plans require revision.
  During the year all the drains, ditches, and casemates were cleaned
out and grass cut three times. Buildings were repaired -and white-
washed.
No appropriation having been made, no work was done at the fortifica-
  tion during the last fiscal year beyond its protection, preservation, and
  repair, as far as was possible with the general appropriation made for
  this purpose, and no other work is contemplated during the current
  fiscal year for the same reason.
No appropriation asked for next fiscal year.

                      DEFENSES OF MISSISSIPPI           SOUND.

  Fort on Ship Island, in charge of Maj. A. N. Damrell, Corps of Engi-
neers.-This casemated fort, commenced in 1862, is located at the west
end of Ship Island, on the east side of Ship Island Channel, and is de-
signed for a fortified maritime depot of coal, provisions, &c., and for the
defense of the navigation of Mississippi Sound and the approaches to
New Orleans from the eastward.
   During the year fourteen shot-beds were built and painted, floors of
three service magazines cemented over and temporary wooden covers
placed over entrances to them. All embrasure shutters put in working
order and two new wooden shutters made to replace two broken iron
shutters. Sallyport gate refastened, casemates, gun platforms and
terreplein cleaned out; store house repaired, and forty-three panes of
glass put in. Grass cut and drift sand removed twice during the year.
No appropriation was made for the fiscal year ending June 30, 1887.
No appropriation asked for next fiscal year.

                         DEFENSES OF NEW ORLEANS.

  Fort Pike, Rigolets Pass, Louisiana, in charge of Maj. W. H. Heuer,
Corps of Engineers.-This casemated work, commenced in 1819, is located
on the south side of the Rigolets, a pass connecting Lake Pontchartrain
with Mississippi Sound and the Gulf of Mexico. It was designed to
guard the extreme eastern approach to New Orleans available for ves-
sels drawing 7 feet or less.
   During the late civil war, while in the possession of the Confederates,
with the aid of obstructions in channel, it served to prevent predatory in-
cursions of light-draught steam gunboats of the United States Navy into
Lake Pontchartrain, which, no doubt, but for it, would have cut off di-
rect communication by the lake and by rail between New Orleans and
the country east of the Mississippi River.
   A project for the modification of this work, to adapt it for the recep-
tion of modern ordnance, was prepared by the Board of Engineers for
Fortifications in 1870, but no appropriation has been made therefor.
The plans require revision.
No appropriation having been made, no work was done at this fortifica-
tion during the last fiscal year beyond its protection, preservation, and
repair, as far as was possible with the general appropriation made for
this purpose, and no other work is contemplated during the current
fiscal year for the same reason.
No appropriation asked for next fiscal year.
                             SEA-COAST DEFENSES.                              43
                 DEFENSES      OF NEW ORLEANS-continued.

   Fort Macomb, Chef Menteur Pass, Louisiana, in charge ofllMaj. W.
Heuer, Corps of Engineers.-Thiswork, commenced in 1822, is located on
                                                                              H.
the south side of the " Chef Menteur," a pass connecting Lake Pont-
chartrain with Lake Borgne and the Gulf of Mexico. It covers the ap-
proach to New Orleans of vessels drawing 4 feet or less via the pass and
Lake Pontchartrain, and also the practicable approach of a land force
from the pass via the " Gentilly Ridge" and the line of the Louisville
and Nashville Railroad, which crosses the pass but a few hundred yards
firom the fort.
   A project for the modification, of this work, to adapt it for the recep-
tion of modern ordnance, was prepared by the Board of Engineers for
Fortifications in 1870, but no appropriation has been made therefor.
The project requires revision.
No appropriation having been made, no work was done at this fortifica-
  tion during the last fiscal year beyond its protection, preservation, and
  repair, as far as was possible with the general appropriation made for
  this purpose, and no other work is contemplated during the current
  fiscal year for the same reason.
No appropriation asked for next fiscal year.
   Tower Dupr, Lake Borgne, Louisiana, in charge of Maj. W. H. Heuer,
Corps of Engineers.--This tower, commenced in 1830, is located at the
mouth of Bayou Dupre, a bayou connected with Lake Borgne, and
heading near the Mississippi River about 12 miles below the city of
New Orleans. It is one of the system of works designed to command
the approaches to New Orleans from Mississippi Sound.
  It was mainly through this bayou that the British forces approached
New Orleans in 1814.
  About 1873 and 1874 the bayou was converted into a canal by widening
and straightening it in places and by excavation extending to within a
few hundred feet of the Mississippi River. A pier was also extended
into the lake. Vessels drawing 4 feet or less can now easily pass from
the Gulf of Mexico via this canal to its end near the river.
   Since the late civil war but little has been done to this work, and for
the past few years nothing has been done. The tower is at present in
a fair state of preservation. The parapet of the battery has nearly all
been removed, and-there is no armament.
No appropriation was made for the fiscal year ending June 30, 1887.
No appropriation asked for next fiscal year.
  Battery Bienvenue, Lake Borgne, Louisiana, in charge of Maj. W. H.
Heuer, Corps of Engineers.-Thisbattery, commenced in 1826, is situated
in the sea marsh at thejunction of the two main branches of Bayou Bien-
venue, and about 3 miles from the mouth of the bayou. It was designed
to guard against boat expeditions from Lake Borgne, via this bayou,
to attack New Orleans in the rear of the lower portion of the city.
No appropriation was made for the fiscal year ending June 30, 1887.
No appropriation asked for next fiscal year.
   Tower at Proctorsville,Lake Borgne, Louisiana, in charge of Maj. W.
H. Heuer, Corps of Engineers.-This work, commenced in 1856, is one of
the system of works designed to command the approaches to New Or-
leans from Mississippi Sound. No work was done during the past fiscal
year.
No appropriation was made for the fiscal year ending June 30, 1887.
No appropriation asked for next fiscal year.
44       REPORT OP THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

                 DEFENSES OF NEW ORLEANS-continued.

  Fort Jackson, Mississippi River, Louisiana, in charge of Maj. W. H.
Heuer, Corps of Ehgineers.-This work, commenced in 1822, is situated
on the right (west) bank of the Mississippi River, at what is known as
the Plaquemine Bend, about 70 miles below the city of New Orleans.
   Together with Fort Saint Philip, situated on the opposite bank of the
river, it was intended to serve in the defense of the very important
port of New Orleans and its surrounding country against attack of a
hostile fleet attempting their capture by way of the river.
  It is an inclosed casemated work, with masonry scarps and new ex-
terior earthen batteries, which are in an incomplete condition.
  During the past fiscal year the grass has been mowed once; eight con.
crete and wooden platforms for 15-inch guns were replaced by concrete
platforms for the same guns. The Quartermaster's Department has
erected a new dwelling for the ordnance sergeant.        There was also
built a levee to protect the reservation from overflow. The plans of the
work require revision.
No appropriation having been made, no work was done at this fortifica-
  tion during the last fiscal year beyond its protection, preservation, and
  repair, as far as was possible with the general appropriation made for
  this purpose, and no other work is contemplated during the current
  fiscal year for the same reason.
No appropriation asked for next fiscal year.
   Fort Saint Philip, Mississippi River, Louisiana, in charge of Maj. W.
H. Heuer, Corps of Engineers.-The location and purpose of this work,
which was commenced in 1841, are sufficiently described in the preced-
ing report on Fort Jackson.
   It is fully as important to be maintained and properly armed as Fort
Jackson. Although the latter is the larger work, the position of the
former is more advantageous.
   It is an inclosed barbette work, with masonry scarp and new exterior
earthen batteries, which are in an incomplete condition.
   During the past fiscal year work on this fortification has been con-
fined to replacing eight concrete and wooden platforms for 15-inch guns
by concrete platforms for the same guns, and to cutting the grass. The
Quartermaster's Department has erected a new dwelling for the ord-
nance sergeant. The plans of the work require revision.
No appropriation having been made, no work was done at this fortifica-
  tion during the last fiscal year beyond its protection, preservation, and
  repair, as far as was possible with the general appropriation made for
this purpose, and no other work is contemplated during the current
  fiscal year for the same reason.
No appropriation asked for next fiscal year.
   Fort Livingston, Barataria Bay, Louisiana, in charge of Maj. W. H.
Heuer, Corps of Engineers.-This work, commenced in 1842, is located
on the west end of Grande Terre Island, at the entrance to Barataria
Bay, and guards the western line of approach to New Orleans offered by
the bay and the bayous and canals connecting the bay with the Mis-
sissippi River opposite New Orleans. It also secures the anchorage in
the bay as a harbor of refuge for coasting or other light-draught ves-
sels in time of war.
   During the past fiscal year the only work done at this fortification
consisted in making a survey and preparing plans and estimates for
jetties to protect the shore line of the site from further erosion by the
sea.
   No work is contemplated during the current fiscal year beyond its
                             SEA-COAST DEFENSES.                                   45
                  DEFENSES OF NEW ORLEANS-continued.

protection, preservation, and repair as far as possible with the general
appropriation made for this purpose.
No appropriation having been made, no work was done at this fortifica-
  tion during the last fiscal year except its protection, preservation, and
  repair, as far as was possible with the general appropriation made for
  this purpose.
No appropriation asked for next fiscal year.

                          DEFENSES OF GALVESTON.

  Batteries at the entrance to the harbor of Galveston, Texas.-The object
of the earthen batteries of heavy guns, recently designed by the Board
of Engineers for Fortifications, to be placed on Pelican Spit, Galveston
Island, and Bolivar Point, is for the defense of the entrance to the har-
bor of Galveston, a harbor rapidly increasing in commercial importance.
No appropriation for the construction of these works has yet been made.
No appropriation asked for next fiscal year.

                     DEFENSES OF SAN DIEGO HARBOR.

  Fort at San Diego, California, in charge of Col. C. S. Stewart, Corps of
Engineers.- This earthwork, situated in rear of Ballast Point, commands
the channel at the entrance to the bay and harbor of San Diego.
  The first and only appropriation for i t was an appropriation of $50,000
for the fiscal year 1873-'74; under it work was commenced in 1873, and
considerable progress was made, but in its present unfinished state this
battery is utterly worthless for defensive purposes. Its position wholly
controls the entrance to the important harbor and bay of San Diego,
every vessel going in necessarily passing close to the work.
  The embankment of the faces of the battery was raised to the level
of the parade, and the concrete masonry of the walls of one service
magazine built to the spring of the arch. The watchman in charge of
the public property has made the repairs to embankments which have
been required.
  To complete this work so that it may receive its armament of heavy
guns requires the construction of everything above the level of the pa-
rade; that is, of parapets, magazines, terre-pleins, breast-height walls,
platforms, and communication. It is estimated about $135,000 will be
required for these. The plans of the work require revision.
No appropriation having been made, no work was done at this fortifica-
  tion during the last fiscal year beyond its protection, preservation, and
  repair, as far as was possible with the general appropriation made for
  this purpose, and no other work is contemplated during the current
  fiscal year for the same reason.
No appropriation asked for next fiscal year.

DEFENSES OF        SAN FRANCISCO, THE NAVY-YARD AT MARE                       ISLAND,
                      AND THE ARSENAL AT BENICIA.

   Fort Winfield Scott, entrance to San Francisco Harbor, California, in
charge of Col. C. S. Stewart, Corps of Engineers.-This casemated work,
commenced in 1853, and its exterior earthen barbette batteries, begun
in 1870, form the defenses of the south side of the Golden Gate, the en-
trance to San Francisco Harbor.
 - The main work is garrisoned.
   The Engineer wvatchmain has lpailnted the iron-work of the embrasures.
   The disintegration of the mortar in the joints of the scarp and in the
soffits of the arches continues, particularly on the faces of the work er-
46       REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

DEFENSES      OF SAN     FRANCISCO,       THE NAVY-YARD AT            MIARE ISLAND,
               AND THE ARSENAL AT BENICIA-continued.

posed to the prevailing summer winds. In general, the casemates are
in good condition.
   The sea-wall is in good order; the damages to the filling and paying
in its rear caused by the extraordinary storm in January last have been
repaired, and 234 running feet of bulkhead rebuilt. The apron at the
foot of the wall has changed but little during the year.
   The magazines are in good condition. The state of the work is much
as it has been for several years past.
   Earthenbarbettebatteries exterior to the fort.-Two gun platforms have
been taken up for repairs; the roof and ceiling of overseer's quarters
have been renewed; repairs made to carpenter's and blacksmith's shops,
to the stable and other buildings; also to water-pipes, ramps, drains,
and fences. The slopes of part of the parapets and traverses have been
mowed, and the exterior of seven of the buildings whitewashed.
   Two platforms, in addition to those which are mounted, are ready to
receive their guns. Four others have been constructed, but, owing to
the settlement of the terre-pleins in deep filling, two of these are not
in condition to have the guns mounted. The pintle-blocks for eight
platforms are in position, and the concrete foundations for six more
have been built. Three positions for heavy guns are ready for plat-
forms, and fourteen more have been begun. Twelve traverse maga-
zines are ready, and sixteen in addition can be used. Twelve timber
platforms for heavy mortars are in position. The timber of these is
decayed.
   To complete the batteries for their armament of heavy guns will re-
quire, it is estimated, about $130,000. The plans require revision.
No appropriation having been made, no work was done at this fortification
  during the last fiscal year beyond its protection, pLreservation, and repair,
  as far as was possible with the general appropriation made for this pur-
  pose, and no otherwork is contemplated during the current fiscal year for
  the same reason.
No appropriation asked for next fiscal year.
  Fort at Lime Point, San Francisco Harbor, California, in charge of
Lieut. Col. G. H. Mendell, Corps of Engineers.-The name Lime Point is
given to the northern shore of the entrance to San Francisco. It covers
the ground extending from Point Cavallo to Point Bonita, about 4 miles
to the westward. It must contain all the fixed defenses on the northern
shore of the Golden Gate.
   The existing defenses are incomplete, and no work except in the way
of repair has been done during the past ten years. Two keepers are
employed to care for the batteries, roads, buildings, and fences.
   Considerable damage was done to buildings, roads, and fences by a
severe storm in January last. These damages have for the most part
been repaired, and the remainder will be taken care of during the com-
ing year.
   The water supply needs immediate attention, the tank that forms the
reservoir having become unserviceable during the year. It is proposed
to rebuild it during the coming year. The plans of the batteries require
revision.
No appropriation having been made, no work was done at this fortifica-
  tion during the last fiscal year beyond its protection, preservation, and
  repair, as far as was possible with the general appropriation made for
  this purpose, and no other work is contemplated during the current
  fiscal year for the same reason.
No appropriation asked for next fiscal year.
                             SEA-COAST DEFENSES.                                  47
DEFENSES      OF SAN FRANCISCO, THE NAVY-YARD AT MARE                         ISLAND,
               AND THE ARSENAL AT BENICIA-continued.

   Fort on A lcatraz Island, San FranciscoHarbor, California,in charge of
Lieut. Col G.H.
            .      Mendell, Corps of Engineers.-The position of Alcatraz
Island commands the channels leading to San Francisco, and of much
of the anchorage ground that might be occupied by an enemy's fleet.
   No construction took place during the year. The keeper, with the
assistance of prisoners confined on the island, kept the roads, buildings,
drains, and batteries in repair, painted and in other ways cared for the
torpedoes, and kept up the necessary miscellaneous details of caring for
the defenses, 2,100 days' labor having been applied to these purposes.
   The condition of the batteries and their armament remain unchanged.
Four magazines showed dampness during the wet season, although all
are considered serviceable.
   No construction has been done in the past ten years, and the de-
fenses are practically in the same condition now as then.
   The torpedoes remain unsuitably stored as they were last year.
They require and receive special care and attention.
   The plan of the work requires revision.
No appropriation having been made, no work was done at this fortifica-
  tion during the last fiscal year beyond its protection, preservation, and
  repair, as far as was possible with the general appropriation made for
  this purpose, and no other work is contemplated during the current
  fiscal year for the same reason.
No appropriation asked for next fiscal year.
    Fort Mason, San Francisco Harbor, California, in charge of Col. C. S.
Stewart, Corps of Engineers.-Duringthe late civil war two temporary
earthen batteries were built on this point.
    In the east battery the timber platforms are decayed as well as the
 ..     w ork of the magazine, which has caved in. This battery is un-
serviceable.
    Projects for new earthen batteries of heavy guns and mortars for the
occupation of this important point in the second line of defense for the
bay and harbor of San Francisco have been prepared by the Board of
Engineers for the Pacific Coast.
No appropriation was made for the fiscal year ending June 30, 1887.
No appropriation asked for next fiscal year.
   Batteries on Angel Island, San FranciscoHarbor, California,in charge
of Col. C. S. Stewart, Corps of Engineers.-The three earthen batteries
on this island were built during the late civil war for temporary use.
The timber platforms and the timber magazines are decayed, and nearly
all the gun-carriages have been condemned.
   The batteries are unserviceable.
   Barbette earthen batteries for the heaviest guns have been planned
by the Board of Engineers for the Pacific Coast, to occupy the most
valuable positions on the island which bear on the channels leading to
the upper part of the bay, to the navy-yard at Mare Island, and to the
arsenal at Benicia.
No appropriation was made for the fiscal year ending June 30, 1887.
No appropriation asked for next fiscal year.
                         DEFENSES OF THE COLUMBIA.

  Defenses at the mouth of the Columbia River, Oregon, and Washington
Territory, in charge of Capt. C. F. Powell, Corps of Engineers.-The de-
fenses co nsist of Fort Stevens, an inclosed earthwork at Point Adams,
48       REPORT    OF THE      CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

               DEFENSES OF THE COLUMBIA--Continued.

Oregon, on the south side, and the earthen batteries at Fort Canby,
Cape Disappointment, Washington Territory, on the north side.
  The works command the channels at the entrance, the ship-channels
leading to Astoria, and the anchorage in Baker's Bay under the lee of
the cape on the north.
  The channels to the river have natural depths of 19 to 24 feet at low
water, and a mean rise of tide above this plane of 74 feet.
  These defenses are field works in character; they were built hastily
during the late civil war in anticipation of complications with foreign
powers. On account of increased penetration of present ordnance, and
the decay of the greater part of the wooden platforms and magazine
timbers, the works are of little value in their present condition.
   Fort Stevens.-Seven gun platforms were rebuilt and minor repairs
made about the fort. A new ordnance store-house was erected and
work done on other buildings and grounds.
  Fort Canby.-Five gun platforms were built at the right battery and
shot-beds at the three batteries.
No appropriation was made for the fiscal year ending June 30, 1887.
No appropriation asked for next fiscal year.
                   THE BOARD           OF ENGINEERS.

   The Board of Engineers stationed in New York City consisted of
Col. James C. Duane, Lieut. Col. Henry L. Abbot, Lieut. Col. Cyrus B.
Comstock, Lieut. Col. David C. Houston (since January 20, 1886), Lieut.
Col. Walter McFarland (since January 20, 1886), and, when so ordered,
the officer in charge of the work under consideration.
   During the fiscal year the Board has considered the questions referred
to it by the Chief of Engineers and submitted reports thereon, of which
the following is a brief summary:
   1885, July 11. Relative to the kind of metal for armor plates, in for-
tifications.
   July 17. Upon the future prosecution of the project for the improve-
ment of Nantucket Harbor, and upon location and plan of an eastern
jetty.
   December 11. Submitting general projects for the defense of New
London, Savannah, Charleston, Key West (as a naval station), Mobile,
and the entrance to Cape Fear River.
   December 11. Upon the question of defense of our lake coasts and
cities.
   1886, January 9. Upon the question of acquiring North Head, Wash-
ington Territory, as a military reservation and the necessity of a battery
thereon.
   January 21. Upon the subject of the improvement of Galveston Har-
bor, and submitting plan and estimate therefor.
   February 16. Upon plan of Henry A. Peeler for harbor improvement
and jetty work.
   February 16. Upon plan of Israel P. Williams for the defense of
Boston Harbor.
   March 1. Upon letter of Captain Bixby relative to a form of founda-
tion for heavy guns, &c.
   March 8. Upon designs of Captain Marshall for lock-gates.
   March 10. Upon proposition to furnish Howell torpedoes and launch-
ing apparatus for experimental practice.                       -
                      THE BOARD     OF ENGINEERS.                      49
    March 10. Upon necessity of the purchase, by the United States, of
land adjacent to Fort Hamilton, New York Harbor.
    March 16. Upon design of John Ambrose for an " Occult Fort and
Moat Battery."
    March 23. Upon design of Beverly Kennon for a Counterpoise Bat-
tery.
   April 19. Upon Senate bill 662, to authorize contracts for steel guns
and armor.
   April 19. Upon plan of H. F. Knapp for improving Galveston Har-
bor.
    April 20. Upon value of land adjacent to Fort Hamilton, New York
Harbor.
    April 27. Upon design of Major von Zubovits for a land torpedo.
   April 27. Upon proposition of Sims-Edison Electric Torpedo Com-
pany to furnish five 2-mile torpedoes.
   May 11. Upon suggestions of Captain Marshall relative to mainte-
nance of locks on Fox River.
   May 25. Submitting estimate of cost of inaugurating the statue of
Liberty Enlightening the World, including electric-light plant.
   June 2. Upon question of line of proposed Harlem River improve-
ment, opposite the Ogden estate.
   June 22. Upon letter of F. I. Palmer on the subject of improvement
of New York Harbor.
   In addition to their duties with the Board of Engineers, the individ-
ual members have been otherwise engaged as follows:
   General Duane has continued in charge of his light-house duties, as
engineer of the third district, has served as member of the Board of Vis-
itors to the Engineer Shool of Application at Willets Point; and on spe-
cial Board for the examination of officers of Engineers for promotion.
   General Abbot remained in command of the Engineer Battalion and
Post of Willets Point and Engineer School of Application; also in
charge of torpedo experiments and construction of the works of dcn,,K e
at the eastern entrance to New York Harbor until March, 1886; has
continued since in charge of certain torpedo experiments; has served
throughout the year as member of Board of Visitors for the Engineer
School of Application at Willets Point; of Board of Officers and Civilians
to examine and report at what ports fortifications or other defenses are
most urgently required, &c.; and has served on special Boards for the
examination of officers of Engineers for promotion; on bridge over the
Ohio River at or near Cairo, Ill.; for trial of pneumatic dynamite tor-
pedo gun.
   General Comstock has served throughout the year as member of the
Mississippi River Commission; of Board of Visitors for Engineer School
of Application at Willets Point; of Board on improvement of the Poto-
mac River near Washington; on further improvement of Cape Fear
River, and on special Board for the examination of officers of Engineers
for promotion. Since March 15, 1886, has commanded Engineer School
of Application, the Engineer Depot and Post of Willets Point, the En-
gineer Battalion (March 15-April 26, 1886), and in charge of torpedo
experiments, of fort at Willets Point, the construction and repair of
Fort Schuyler, and as supervising engineer of all expenditures for tor-
pedoes, Engineer Depot, Fort Schuyler, and library of Engineer School
of Application, June 8, 1886.
   Colonel Houston served as supervising engineer July 1, 1885, to Jan-
uary 20, 1886; as member of the Board of Engineers and of the Board
50        REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

of Visitors for the Engineer School of Application at Willets Point swiie
January 20, 1886; in charge of works of river and harbor improve-
ment, and fortifications, under letters of Chief of Engineers of January
30 and February 5, 1886; in temporary charge of works under charge
of Lieutenant-Colonel McFarland; representing the General Govern-
ment in the erection of the pedestal being built to receive the colossal
bronze statue of Liberty Enlightening the World upon Bedloe's Island,
New York Harbor, June 7, 1886; and on special Boards, viz: on bridg-
ing the Alabama River at Selma, Ala.; for the examination of officers of
Engineers for promotion.
   Colonel McFarland has continued the various works of river and
harbor improvement and of fortifications under his charge; and since
January 20, 1886, has served as a member of the Board of Engineers
and of the Board of Visitors for the Engineer School of Application at
Willets Point; also on special Board on subject of permanent improve-
ment of Delaware River and Bay.
   Coast defense.-This subject having been fully discussed in former
reports of the Board, further reference to the condition and requirements
of our sea-coast fortifications is considered unnecessary.
   Torpedo defense.-The act of Congress providing for fortifications, &c.,
for the fiscal year 1885-'86, provided as follows :
For the purchase of movable submarine torpedoes propelled and controlled
  by power operated and transmitted from shore stations, as may be recom-
  mended by the Board of Engineers of the Army of the United States,
  and approved by the Secretary of War.......... ......................          $50, 000
For improvements, competitive test, and purchase of motors for movable
  torpedoes .............. .......... .. .............................. ....     25,000
For purchase of appliances for submarine mines for harbor defense-.......        10, 000
For continuation of torpedo experiments and for practical instruction of
Engineer troops in the details of the service  ...-.. ......-.. - - .. ......   20, 000
   About three-quarters of the whole annual appropriation for torpedo
defense was thus again restricted to the purchase and improvement of
the Sims torpedo, to which alone the wording of the law is applicable.
This torpedo was in an experimental stage, and the year has expired
before the results obtained have been such as to warrant the purchasing
of large numbers of them for store. Much of this appropriation and
still more of that for the preceding year have thus reverted to the Treas-
ury. This money could have been expended to great advantage in
providing for the defense of the coast by submarine mines had the lan-
guage of the law warranted this application. The contract for five
Sims's torpedoes under the appropriation for 1884-'85, mentioned in our
last annual report, was transferred to that for 1885-'86. Two of the
boats have been accepted, and the time for the delivery of the remaining
three has been extended until September30 upon Mr. Sims's application.
    In the present condition of the sea-coast defenses our chief reliance
in case of war would be upon fixed mines. The number on hand is in-
significant, and the essential preparations for operating even those we
have are yet to be made. The reasons for a moderate annual expendi-
turefor these objects have been so strongly urged in many former reports
of this Board, and have been so fully set forth in the report of the Board
ordered last year by Congress to report " at what ports fortifications or
other defenses are most urgently required, and the character and kind
of defenses best adapted for each, with reference to armament, utiliza-
tion of torpedoes, mines, or other defensive appliances," that it seems
unnecessary to recapitulate them here. The Board therefore presents
                                 THE BOARD               OF ENGINEERS.                                      51

the following consolidated estimate for the service of tolpedoes during
the fiscal year 1887-'88.
For the purchase of submarine mining materials to close the channels to
  our principal sea-ports against the entrance of hostile fleets............. $300, 000
For the needful casemates, cable galleries, &c., to render it possible to oper-
  ate submarine mines in the defense of the principal ports on the Atlantic
  and Gulf coasts---- ------.....................--------------......-.... -----...................---.. 200,000
For continuing torpedo experiments and for the practical instruction of
  Engineer troops in the details of the service .............-- ....-...-..                               30, 000
        Making a total of ..         .......   ..   ....... ...........    .............     ......    530, 000
  The following extracts from General Abbots report exhibit the progress
made in these matters at Willets Point during the first nine months of
the past year :
   Investigations with new explosives were restricted to determining, by my ring
method, described in Professional Papers No. 23 of the Corps of Engineers, certain
facts respecting the rack-a-rock to be used at the great Flood Rock explosion. Over
one hundred 3-pound charges were fired. They indicated (1) that from 21 to 23 per
cent. of nitro-benzol gives rack-a-rock its highest intensity of action; (2) that it is
important to have the potassium chlorate dry-2 per cent. of water, replacing an
equal weight of the salt, reduced the intensity 5 per cent.; 4 per cent. of water, 10
per cent., and 6 per cent. of water, 19 per cent.; (3) that whether loosely or solidly
compacted in a tin can submerged 35 feet under water, and whether detonated by 48
grains of mercuric fulminate (two fuses) or by 24 grains (one fuse) reinforced by a
3-ounce tonite primer, the measured intensity of action remains unchanged, and in-
dicates an explosion of the first order; (4) that the rack-a-rock used at Flood Rock
was of marked uniformity-to test this one shot was fired for every 5,000 pounds de-
livered; and (5) that the mean of over 70 shots, according well with each other, indi-
cates an intensity of action of 108 to 109 per cent. of that of dynamite No. 1 taken as
a standard.
   In the matter of Sims's movable fish torpedo, work was restricted to testing the
new motor made upon my specifications (electrical) at the Edison works, and to cer-
tain dock trials and runs to determine what speed it would give the 2-mile boat car-
rying a charge of 350 pounds. The motor proved to be superior to that made by Mr.
Weston in the ratio of 43 to 29. It developed about the same absolute power as that
made by Siemens Bros., London, but generated at a much lower armature velocity
(700 instead of 990 turns per minute) when working to the best advantage. This is
an important merit, because it dispenses with gearing. With a propeller suited to
hold the armature at 700 revolutions, about 9 or 10 horse-power can be transmitted
through 2 miles of cable without overtaxing its endurance. This probably fixes
about 11 miles per hour as the extreme maximum speed which this torpedo can main-
tain while carrying a 400-pound charge in a full 2-mile run.
   Further improvements in the steering relay and magnets have resulted from the
trials of the past year; and, by a happy suggestion of Captain Knight, the trouble-
some double revolving reel for coiling the cable has been rendered unnecessary. The
torpedo may now be regarded as perfected in its essential details; and its practical
value as a war weapon can probably be estimated with some precision after the trial
runs of the five new boats are completed and the detailed reports thereon are sub-
mitted to the Board.
   On May 14, 1885, a contract was made with Mr. Thomas F. Rowland, Continental
Iron Works, Brooklyn, to supply a steam vessel specially designed for planting sub-
marine mines, handling heavy insulated cable, &c. It was accepted on January 4,
1886, after satisfactory trials in which she exhibited over the measured mile a speed
of 9.8 miles per hour advancing, and 8.7 miles backing, with the power of causing
her sternpost to describe a circumference whose center was at her bow either to star-
board or port as desired. She has capacity for carrying all the material of a grand
group of twenty-one mines, with the men needed for planting them. Her total cost
was $28,000. She was named after Capt. David Bushnell, Corps of Sappers and
Miners, Army of the Revolution, who originated modern torpedo warfare.
   The following are her principal dimensions: Length on the water line, 75 feet, and
on deck 84 feet ; beam (over planking), 20 feet 2 inches; depth of hold, 8 feet 9 inches;
with bunkers filled with coal (9 tons) and tanks filled with water (8 tons) and in
working condition as to boilers and grates, average draft 5 feet 4 inches, correspond-
ing to a displacement of 122 tons; fully loaded, in addition with material for a grand
group of twenty-one mines, with twenty men on board, giving a displacement of 145
tons, average draft, 6 feet 2 inches. Her motive power is supplied by a pair of in-
clined condensing engines of 120 horse-power, with cylinders 14 inches in diameter
52       REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

and 15 inches stroke, geared to a Mallory patent steering apparatus, propeller 5 feet:;
6 inches in diameter and 10 feet in pitch. The boiler is of the Scotch type, with two
furnaces, 36 square feet of grate and 850 square feet of heating surface. The shaft is.
of forged steel. The hull is of composite type, having iron frames, floors, reverse
bars, stringers, &c', and wooden keel, stem, sternpost, deadwood, and planking.
   Steering may be by hand, or, if desired, by a pair of oscillating engines with 5-inch
cylinders and 5-inch stroke, controlled by a lever in the pilot-house. Another lever
enables the wheelman to start, stop, and slow the main engine (it is never reversed); :
and steam gauges exhibit to him both the pressure and vacuum. Work in the en-
gine-room is therefore reduced to tending the fires and supervising the machinery, the
boat being entirely controlled in the pilot-house.
  The David Bushnell is fitted with a revolving derrick, supplied with a lifting and
falling boom of ample power to handle 6,000 pounds, with a Burton purchase. The
mast is of wrought iron and hollow to pass the falls to the barrel of the hoisting en-
gine below. This engine has two cylinders 7 inches in diameter and 6 inches stroke;
and is so geared to the rope barrel and to two winches on deck that all may be oper-
ated from the deck in unison or either one separately.
  The vessel appears to be well suited to the work for which she was designed, and is
built in a substantial and thorough manner, very creditable to the constructor, Mr.
Rowland, at whose yard, it will be remembered, the original Monitor was built in 1862.
  Since being relieved from command at Willets Point, I am conducting a series of
experiments here to improve certain details in the firing arrangements of self-acting
mines (not under control) and of movable fish torpedoes. Good progress has been
made.
  The following is from General Comstock's report on torpedo matter
for the last three months of the year:
   Since taking charge of torpedo experiments and up to June 30, 1886, two of Sims's
fish torpedoes have passed the test required under his contract, and have been ao-
cepted. His con tract has been extended by the honorable the Secretary of War to
September 30, 1886, prior to which time he is to deliver three more.
   The tests on fish No. 7 occupied from May 20, 1886, to June 17, 1886, in which time
ten runs or attempts to run were made, the fish only attaining the required speed of
10 miles per hour for 1l miles on the last day. One of the preceding runs was for
diving under a spar and for steering, which was satisfactory, except that the cable,
burned out and stopped the run. Of the other eight runs, two were failures from.
loose belt on dynamo, the necessary energy to drive the fish thus not being furnished.
Three were failures from bad insulation in the interior of the fish, arising from de-
fective work, or, in one case, from water leaking in; two were failures from burns in,
cable, and one, without accident, failed to give speed.
   Fish No. 6 made five runs, or attempts at runs, between June 24 and 29, 1886. At the,
first trial the steering relay was burned in the fish, the accident arising from a wrong:
coupling of the wires at the steering-board. At the second run, the dynamo belt,
slipped, and sufficient energy was not furnished to the fish. At the third run defect-
ive insulation caused a burn near the shunt in the steering relay. At the fourth run
the required speed of 10 miles an hour for 1 miles was obtained. At the fifth run,
which was to test steering, the results were satisfactory.

POST     OF WILLETS POINT AND ENGINEER                                SCHOOL         OF
                 APPLICATION, U. S. A.

  The strength of the command on June 30, 1886, was 21 officers and
351 enlisted men, commanded by Lieut. Col. C. B. Comstock, Corps of
Engineers.
  The troops stationed at this post are the only ones familiar with fixed
torpedo defense, and on them almost entire reliance must be placed in
any emergency.     The command should therefore be kept at its full
strength, and be thoroughly instructed, this being the more necessary
from the absence of other effective defenses for our seaports.
   Beside being a school for the instruction of officers and men in the
complicated details of torpedo defense, advantage is taken of the op-
portunity to give officers practical instruction in military engineering.
electricity, astronomy, surveying, photography, and theoretical instruc.
tion in civil engineering,
                                        BATTALION                 OP ENGINEERS.

   Tfhere is great ieed of a sufficient water supply, of sewerage, of addi-
tional quarters, and of books for the school.
                                                  STATEMENT OF FUNDS.

    Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year 1887-'88:
For water supply ...----...-- -----...........      ...........--------------.......---..   ....------------......--..      $17,000
For sewerage and plumbing ........................---......---...... ---........                                             12, 000
For lieutenant's quarters........              --............ .........               ...... ...........                     12, 000
For a new barracks for 150 men ---........------...-..----..-........------..-----....------------......                     35,000
For books, instruments, stationery, clerical services of civilians or enlisted
men, and miscellaneous for School of Application ..........       ...........                                                1,000
    (See Appendix No. 1.)

BATTALION                      OF ENGINEERS AND DEPOT                                                         AT WILLETS
                                POINT, NEW YORK HARBOR.

   On the 30th of June, 1886, the battalion of engineers consisted of 17
commissioned officers, detailed from the Corps of Engineers, and 396
enlisted men, the maximum legal strength being 752 men. The field
and staff and band, and Companies A, B, and C, were stationed at Wil-
lets Point, New York Harbor; Company D exists only in name, and
Company E was stationed at West Point to assist in the instruction of
cadets in practical engineering, pontoniering, &c.
   The troops at Willets Point receive, store, and issue the public prop-
erty of the depot and carry out experiments with explosives, electricity
as applied to transmission of power, ignition of mines, &c., fixed and
movable torpedoes, and other matters connected with practical engi-
neering and torpedo service.
   The battalion is equipped and drilled as infantry, in addition to the
special duties for which it is organized.
   All tools and supplies for sapping, mining, pontoniering, and field for-
tification, as well as surveying and astronomical instruments for use of
officers of the Corps on surveys and works of construction, were stored
and issued at the Engineer depot at Willets Point.
   The commanding officer of the battalion and depot submits the fol-
lowing estimate of funds needed for the service during the next fiscal
year, viz :
For incidental expenses at depot --.--------------------------------.........................................---. ---         7, 000
For purchase of materials for instruction of Engineer troops ................                                                 1,500
For purchase and repairs of instruments..........--...                                      ....................              2,500
For an additional building for Engineer models ---........                                            ....... ...........     8, 000
         Total.-----.---- ----------.                       --------------                      ...............              19, 000
  For further information as to the battalion and depot, see report of
the officer in command.
  (See Appendix No, 2.)

                 RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.

   These improvements, for which appropriations are made by Congress,
constitute a great system, which, although its various parts possess very
:unequal values, taken as a whole, by extending along our ocean, lake,
and gulf coasts and reaching far into the interior, creates safe and easy
avenues of trade, leading into each other, that add vast wealth to the
,country by the facilities they afford to the movement of commerce and
the safety they insure to it.
54      REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

   The funds with which these works were prosecuted during the fiscal
year ending June 30, 1886, were, owing to the failure of appropriations
during the second session of the Forty-eighth Congress, derived mainly
from such balances as remained on hand from the appropriations of the
act of July 5, 1884, and in many instances these being only sufficient
to provide for the care of the public property appertaining to the works,
operations were necessarily suspended, to the detriment of the works.
   A brief statement taken from the reports of the officers in charge of
the several works is given below, setting forth the condition of each
improvement ; the extent of work performed during the last fiscal
year; the amount of money expended; and, in compliance with the
provisions of the river and harbor act of March 2, 1867, estimates of
the amount that can be profitably expended during the fiscal year end-
ing June 30, 1888, with the probable cost of completion.
   Although, as a general rule, regard is necessarily had in the prepa-
ration of these estimates to the more intimate acquaintance of the engi-
neer officers in charge with the requirements of each locality, they have
been revised and amended in this office, when deemed advisable, hav-
ing regard to the most economical administration of the works and
keeping in view the average of the grants by Congress for each work
during the past few years.
   The reports of the officers in charge of the various improvements will
be found in the Appendix. To these reports special reference should be
made whenever detailed information is desired concerning the progress
and condition of each work.
   The examinations and surveys at localities required and provided for
in the river and harbor act of August 5, 1886, have been distributed and
assigned to the officers in charge of the several river and harbor dis-
tricts. They are in progress, and the reports thereon will be submitted
from time to time during the ensuing session of Congress as far as re-
ceived.
   Examinations were made during the fiscal year, of such plans and
locations as were submitted by parties interested, of bridges proposed
to be built over navigable waters under authority of Congress, subject
to the approval of the Secretary of War. A brief statement is given
below of the action had in such cases. Examinations were also made
whenever requested by committees of Congress, of proposed bills au-
thorizing the construction of bridges upon which the views of the War
Department were desired. Of bills so examined during the last session
of Congress fifteen originated in the Senate and forty-three in the House
of Representatives.
   A statement is also given of the work accomplished in the removal
of wrecks obstructing or endangering navigation, general provision for
which is made in the river and harbor act of June 14, 1880, enlarged by
provisions of the river and harbor act of August 2, 1882.

        ATLANTIC       COAST     AND    GULF     OF MEXICO.

IMPROVEMENT    OF RIVERS AND HARBORS IN THE           STATES OF MAINE
                      AND NEW HAMPSHIRE.

  Officers in charge, Col. Charles E. Blunt, Corps of Engineers, to Feb-
ruary 28, 1886; since which date, Maj. Jared A. Smith, Corps of Engi-
neers. Supervising Engineer, Col. Charles E. Blunt.
  1. Lubec Channel,Mlaine.-The present project for improvement of this
channel was adopted in December, 1878, and modified in 1883 and 1885
                        RIVER        AND HARB3OR IMPROVEMENTS.                                            55
the c bject being to give a channel of not less than 275 feet in width and
300 wide at the bends, and a depth of 12 feet at mean low water, or about
8 feet at extreme low tides.
   The channel was originally obstructed by bars and shoals, having but
5 feet at mean low water.
   In the last fiscal year 5,792 cubic yards of material were removed from
the channel by dredging.
   The amount expended on this improvement to June 30, 1886, has been
$139,000. The resulting channel is 200 feet wide throughout the entire
length, and has a width of 278 feet at the lower bend. The entire length
is about 21 miles.
   The channel forms part of an important thoroughfare, the only one
belonging to the United States by which many places on our eastern
frontier can be reached.
   The appropriation asked for fiscal year ending June 30, 1888, is for
the purpose of completing the channel at its present depth to a width
of 275 feet, and 300 feet at the bends.
July 1, 1885, amount available ......                                                       $3, 039 29
                                                            ___.................................
July 1, 1866, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
outstanding July 1, 1885 ...... .... .................   .... . ..... ....                          3,039 29
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886...................
                                                        ----------------                            10, 000 00
  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project                         .....-.    22,500 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1888                        12, 500 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
     harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
  (See Appendix A 1.)
  2. Bangor Harbor and Penobscot River, Maine.-The present project
for improvement of this harbor and river was adopted in 1884, being
based upon a survey made:in 1883. The object of the improvement is
to give more room in the harbor of Bangor, by making the channel 100
feet wider, and to straighten and widen the.channel at Crosby's Nar-
rows, 31 miles below.
  In the last year the channel was widened 100 feet on the east side for
a distance of 2,728 feet, and 11 feet deep at extreme low water.
  The total amount expended upon the improvement to June 30, 1886,
has been $19,950.68. The resulting channel is 300 feet in width and 11
feet deep for about half a mile in the harbor of Bangor.
  The appropriation asked is to complete the widening of the channel
in the harbor to 300 feet and to complete the excavation in channel at
Crosby's Narrows:
July 1, 1885, amount available...... ......             ..............................             $19,966 34
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 185------....---......----....---------..--..---..........--........ .....    19, 917 22
July 1, 1886, amount available, .-._.--..--..-.- ---...................                                 49 12
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886 .---..............                               15,000 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887--......-...........                           15, 049 12
 ( Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project.......                            40, 000 00
   Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1888                       15, 000 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix A 2.)
  3. Moose a-bec Bar, Maine.-The present project for improving the
channel over Moose-a-bec Bar was based upon a survey made in 1879,
and was adopted in 1881.                   The object of the improvement was to give
56          REPORT           OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

a direct and clear channel having a width of 200 feet over the bar id
a depth of 14 feet at mean low water; the length to be dredged was
about 1,900 feet. The old channel was indirect, crooked, and obstructed
by dangerous ledges.
   The entire amount expended upon the improvement to June 30, 1886,
has been $29,946.34.
   In the last year there were removed from the channel by dredging
under contract 23,345 cubic yards of material. The resulting channel
covers all that the project contemplated save the removal of a few small
ledges, at an estimated cost of $10,000.
   The thoroughfare is one of universal use for steamers and sailing ves
sels of all kinds traversing the coast, and its benefits are general to a
large and widely distributed commerce.
July 1, 1885, amount available...._.                               ..
                                                               ......            ....................          $10, 027 04
July 1, 1S~6, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885..............................    ...... ........                                      9,973 38
July 1, 1886, amount available........ ....-........-.................... .                                          53 66
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886....................                                          10, 000 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887 ....................                                      10,053 66
   (See Appendix A 3.)
    4. Belfast Harbor, Maine.-The project for improving this harbor was
  adopted in 1876, the object being to enable vessels to arrive and to leave
the wharves at all stages of the tide.
    No work was done during the last fiscal year.
    The total amount expended to June 30, 1886, was $22,193.20.
    The resulting channel gives 10 feet in depth to the wharves in the
upper part, and 11 to 12 feet in depth to the wharves in the lower part
of the harbor.
    A small balance of $2,806.80 remains unexpended. With this balance
'it is proposed to deepen. the water as far as possible in the channel op-
posite Belfast whenever circumstances will favor its being done with
advantage and economy.
    In the spring of 1886, the wreck of schooner Waldemar was removed
from the harbor, under the general act for removing sunken vessels,
approved June 14, 1880.
July 1, 1885, amount available ......                .............      ............                  ......   $2, 843 05
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885 .............................                               ............                 36 25

July 1, 1886, amount available ............................                                   ..... ... ....     2, 806 80
   (See Appendix A 4.)
   5. Rockland Harbor, Maine.--The present project for improving this
harbor was adopted in 1881, the object being to protect the harbor so
as to form a refuge and secure anchorage for vessels, and to enable
them to land at the wharves in all kinds of weather.
   The entrance to the natural harbor is broad and exposed to easterly
winds, so that with heavy winds from northeast to southeast the anchor-
age and wharves had but little protection.
   In the last year 39,959 tons of stone have been added to the break-
water from Jameson's Point, making the total length, raised to 5 feet
above low water, 1,472 feet.
  There has been expended on the wbrk to June 30, 1886, $97,921.99.
  The resulting protection to the harbor is already felt, though it is com-
paratively small to that which will be effected by completing the break-
waters.
                          RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                                           57

   The appropriation asked is to be applied to continuing the construc-
tion of the breakwaters.
July 1, 1885, amount available......
                              -   -....-----------..............................--..                                        $17, 312 79
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
     outstanding July 1, 1885 .              .....-.......................------.....-..                                .    14.390 80

July 1, 1886, amount available                  ........--................             ..---.....       ....--------.         2, 921 99
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886 .......--..-----..----------.                                             22, 500 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887.                                     ..........       --....           25, 421 99
T Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project-------...... 427,500 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1888 50, 000 00
} Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1856 and 1867.
  .(See Appendix A 5.)
   6. PortlandHarbor, Maine-The various projects for improving this
harbor under successive appropriations have all been completed, save
the deepening by dredging of a, part of the harbor outside the '" Commis-
sioner's line" from Brown's Wharf to Galt's Wharf. The entire work
will be completed in two weeks.
   In the last fiscal year there has been removed by dredging 19,890 cu-
bic yards, thus giving 17 feet depth of water where formerly only 12 to
16 feet could be obtained.
   There has been expended from 1836 to June 30, 1886, a total of $434,-
     .The
582.05.
        object of these improvements has been to give a sufficient depth
of water in the main harbor and to afford protection from the sea; also,
to a small extent to give a channel of navigable depth in the cove back
of the city.
   The results thus far are a depth of 21 feet over the lower part of the
harbor, and 16 to 17 feet as far up the harbor as to Brown's Wharf; also,
a breakwater with light-house at its extemity, and a small channel in
the back cove giving 8 feet at mean low water.
 - The Board of Trade, a meeting of citizens, and the City Council have
urged the necessity for further improvements; plans and estimates have
been made for a channel of 29 feet depth and 500 feet width to the
point of arrival and departure of the largest steamers; also for a chan-
nel 300 feet wide and 12 feet deep in the Back Cove.
   The necessity for extending the deep water in the harbor below to
connect with the deep channel above, and also for extending the break-
water, with estimates of the expense, are submitted by the officer in
charge for consideration.
July 1, 1885, amount available ............-.........................--.                                                    $8, 326 29
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1885, ........................                                     $1,941 37
July 1, 1886, outstanding liabilities----......                              --.........   ..--.        4,519 92
                                                                                                                              6, 461 29

July 1, 1886, amount available........ .............................                                                         1, 865 00
Amount appropriated for harbor by act approved August 5, 1886-........                                                      30, 000 00
                                                       - -- -
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887 ............                                           ....           31, 865 00
  (See Appendix A 6.)
  7. Kennebunk River, Maine.-All the projects heretofore adopted for
this improvement have been completed. No further improvements are
at present contemplated. A small balance remains to the credit of the
58         REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

work which may be used for any trifling repairs or examinations re-
quired. No work has been done in the last fiscal year.
  No appropriation is asked.
July 1, 1885, amount available................ .........................                      $336 34
July 1, 1886, amount available...............................                 ...........      336 34
   (See Appendix A 7.)
   8. Breakwater at mouth of Saco River, Maine.--This breakwater, built
between 1869 and 1873, was found by a survey made in 1883 to require
repairs and raising to enable it to better effect its object of preventing
the encroachment of sand on the channel of the Saco River at the mouth.
The estimate for this purpose was $70,000, and $15,000 was appropri-
ated in the act of July 5, 1884.
   In the last fiscal year there was placed on the breakwater 7,280 tons
of stone and 216 cubic feet of ashlar.
   The entire expenditure upon this work previousto June 30, 1886, has
been $14,973.64. This has enlarged and completed the breakwater a
distance of 510 feet with some stone deposited of an additional distance
of 175 feet.
   The breakwater alone is not sufficient, in the opinion of the officer in
charge, to produce any considerable effect in deepening the channel,
and in order to obtain any benefits the jetty opposite the breakwater
should be commenced.
   The amount required to complete the breakwater is found to be larger
than the original estimate owing to the settlement and displacement of
stone, and also because the prices by contract have been higher than
were anticipated.
   The appropriation asked is to be applied to completing the repairs
to the old breakwater.
July 1,1885, amount available .............                  -..-............... ........ $10, 293 60
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885- -.....          ..... .......... ......................        10, 267 24
July 1,1886, amount available ...... ..............                  ..........              26 36
                                                    ......-----------------------....--------....
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886 ....--..--            ..-......      12,500 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887......           .............         12,526 36

  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1888                12,500 00
  Submitted in complance with requirements of section 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
  (See Appendix A 8.)
  9. Saco River, Maine.-To comply with the requirements of the river
and harbor act of July 5, 1884, a preliminary examination and survey
were made of Saco River with the view of extending the improvements
in progress at the mouth 5 miles up the river as far as the head of
navigation. A report of the results of the survey was transmitted to
Congress January 15, 1886, and printed as House Ex. Doc. No. 37,
Forty-ninth Congress, first session, which contains an estimate of $50,000
as the amount required to create a continuous channel of 6 feet at low
water.
  The river and harbor act of August 5, 1886, appropriates $12,500 for
this work, and a further sum of $12,500 could be profitably expended
thereon during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888.
  (See Appendixes A 9 and A 12.)
  10. Portsmouth Harbor. New Hampshire.-The present project for im-
proving this harbor was adopted in 1879, the object being to change the
                          RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                       59
currents sc that vessels could more easily navigate the channel and be
less in danger of striking upon protruding points and the tops of sub-
merged ledges.
   In the last fiscal year there were removed by blasting and submarine
work 608 cubic yards of rock from the ledge known as Gangway Rock.
   The total expenditure previous to June 30, 1886, was $91,991.28.
   As a result the larger portion of Gangway Rock has been removed to
a depth of 20 feet at mean low water; there remains of this ledge 632
cubic yards to complete the removal to the same depth. A part of the
projecting ledge on the point of Badger's Island has also been removed.
The officer in charge reqommends that the removal of rock on Badger's
Island Point be to a depth of 20 feet.
July 1, 1885, amount available............ ........--..-.......-...---......     ----     $15,211 00
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885.......--..----..--..----........------------.-----........---. 15,202 28
July 1, 1886, amount available................ ......................---------.                               8 72
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886....................                                   15,000 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887....................                                15,008 72
  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project--------25, 000 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1888 25, 000 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section '2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix A 10.)
   11. Cocheco River, New Hampshire.-The present project for im-
proving the channel of the Cocheco River was adopted in 1884; its
object is to give a channel having 5 feet depth of water at mean low
stages as far as to the Packet Landing.
   During the last year 829 cubic yards of rock were removed from the
channel. This completes the channel to a depth of 5 feet mean low
water and a width of 50 to 60 feet, as far as the Steam-mill wharf.
   The entire amount expended in improving the Cocheco River from
1836 to June 30, 1886, has been $150,973.64.
   At present numerous large vessels go up the river to Dover, though
as the improvements are incomplete the vessels have to be lightered a
short distance.
   The amount asked is to complete the deepening of the channel to
5 feet, in accordance with the plan adopted.
July 1, 1885, amount available ..-................                             ........-............     $9, 804 41
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885...............................-----------------------     ...      ........    9,792 29
July 1, 1886, amount available........................................                                       12 12
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886...................                                    10,000 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887 ..................                                 10, 012 12
  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project....-...                                  9,000 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1888                              9,000 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
  (See Appendix A 11.)
  12. Harbor of refuge at Little Harbor,New Bampshire.--The river and
harbor act of July 5, 1884, made provision for an examination and sur-
vey of this harbor with a view to its improvement as a harbor of refuge,
and a report thereon was transmitted to Congress and printed as House
Ex. Doo. No. 91, Forty-eighth Congress, second session.
60        REPORT   OF THE CHIEF OF' ENGINtRS,          . S. AiZMY.

   The necessity for a harbor of.refuge of moderate size at this locality,
for the numerous smatler vessels engaged in the commerce and fisheries
of this part of the coast, having been made apparent from numerous
representations of those interested, this harbor is deemed worthy of
improvement to a moderate extent at a cost of, say, $33,000. The river
and harbor act of August 5, 1886, appropriates $10,000 for this work.
EXAMINATION AND SURVEY FOR IMPROVEMENT TO COMPLY WITH
  REQUIREMENTS OF THE RIVER AND HARBOR ACT OF JULY 5,
  1884.
  It appearing, after preliminary examination, that the locality was
worthy of improvement by the General Government, Colonel Blunt was
charged with and completed the survey of Saco River, Maine, the report
on the result of which was transmitted to Congress and printed as
House Ex. Dec. No. 37, Forty-ninth Congress, first session.
  (See also Appendix A 12.)
     IMPROVEMENT    OF RIVERS AND     HARBORS IN    MASSACHUSETTS.

   Officers in charge, Maj. Charles W. Raymond, Corps of Engineers, to
February 4, 1886, since which date Maj. George L. Gillespie, Corps of
Engineers.
   1. Newburyport Harbor, Massachusetts.--The original depth of water
on the bar at the entrance of this harbor was from 5 to 7 feet at mean
low water; the mean rise and fall 'of the tide was 7.7 feet.
   The object of the improvement is to create a channel through the bar
1,000 feet wide, with a least depth at mean low water of 17 feet.
   The project adopted in 1880 was to build two converging rubble-
stone jetties, so located as to give a proper direction to the currents,.
and thereby produce and maintain the desired result. A rubble-stone
apron was also proposed to protect the shore of Plum Island, near the,
south jetty. The estimated cost of the original project was $365,000.
In 1881 a dike to close Plum Island basin was proposed, to cost $10,000.
This dike was built in 1883. The project was modified in 1883 by
changing the direction of the south jetty, and by building a sand-catch.
in rear and in prolongation of it, instead of an apron on the beach. The'
cost of the modified project, including the dike, was estimated to be!
$375,000.
   The total amount expended to June 30, 1885, is $160,131.86; by the
expenditure of which the dike across Plum Island basin had been built as
far as was then prudent; the north jetty had been built of full section
1,540 feet, and of a partial submerged section 1,100 feet further; the
south jetty had been built of full section 1,077 feet, and of a partial!
submerged section 223 feet further.,
   During the fiscal year the submerged sections of the north and southt
jetties were leveled up, and that of the north jetty was extended 35
feet. Thesand-catch in rear of the south jetty was repaired. Fifty-two
yards of sunken ledge were also removed from the harbor, just inside
of Plum Island. A comparative survey made in June, 1886, shows
that the main channel had shifted to the southward about 500 feet, and
had deepened from 9 feet in 1885 to 12 feet in 1886. This increase in
depth and the straightening of the channel are very favorable for the
ultimate success of the improvement.
  About 700 vessels enter and depart from this port annually. The
revenue collected is about $2,000. It is impossible to estimate the
prospective value of the improvement.
                    RIVER     AND     HARBOR      IMPROVEMENTS.                          61
   The officer in charge estimates the amount that can be profitably ex-
,pended during the next fiscal year at $167,500, which will complete the
,proposed improvement. By the expenditure of this sum the channel
through the bar will probably be deepened to not less than 17 feet at
mean low water, enabling the large iron steamers that frequent the port
to cross the bar without regard to the tide.

July 1, 1885, amount available.......................--     --.......-- ---        $9,868 14
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885 --........................... ..............-----. --    6,625 68
July 1, 1886, amount available ................
                                  -- --         --............ ......          .    3,242 46
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886- ..---     --.-..- ....         37, 500 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887.........-..........          40, 742 46
  SAmount (estimated) required for completion of existing project- ..       167,500 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1888 50, 000 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix B 1.)
    2. Merrimac River, 3Massachusetts.-The original condition of the river
channel was very narrow and crooked in several places, and much ob-
structed by sunken ledges, bowlders, and shoals, especially at the falls,
which were more or less bare ; while in the lower part of the river below
-Newburyport there were numerous sunken ledges, crib-works, piers, and
wrecks.
     The object of the improvement is to clear out, deepen, and straighten
the channel of the river from its mouth to the Upper Falls, a distance
of 21- miles.
    The project, originally adopted in 1870, was to remove obstructions
from the Upper and Lower Falls, remove Gangway Rock, remove
wreck of schooner Globe, and remove the "' boilers." The cost was esti-
mated to be $69,025. This project was revised and extended in 1874,
to include the removal of rocks at Deer Island and at Rock's bridges,
and at Little Currier Shoal, so that the channel should have the follow-
ing depths at high water of ordinary stages of the river: From the
:mouth to Deer Island Bridge, 16. feet; from Deer Island Bridge up to
   iHaverhill Bridge, 12 feet ; thence to the foot of Mitchell's Falls, 10 feet ;
thence to the head of the Upper Falls, not less than 41 feet, with the
mill water at Lawrence running. This revised project was estimated
to cost $147,000. The tide at the mouth of the river has a mean rise
and fall of 7.7 feet, and its influence is felt up to the foot of the Upper
Falls.
    The amount expended to June 30, 1885, was $169,910.81, and resulted
in improving the river channel from its mouth to the Lead of the Upper
Falls, in accordance with the adopted project. On June 30, 1885, the
work done was in good order, and showed no deterioration. No opera-
tions were in progress during the fiscal year.
    To complete the improvement so that the same depth of water which
has been obtained through Mitchell's Falls can be carried to Lawrence,
additional work will be required at the falls above Haverhill, which is
estimated to cost $11,000; and additional improvements are needed in
the lower part of the river, which are estimated to cost $11,500, or a
total of $22,500.
    In completing this work this amount could be expended to advantage
duriug the fiscal year ending June 30, 1883.
    About seven hundred vessels enter the river annually, and the cus-
toms collected yearly are about $2,000,
62        REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

  It is expected that the completion of the improvement will increase
the tonnage of the river, and encourage the erection of new manufac-
tories.
July 1, 1885, amount availabl........... ...... ..........................           $589 19
July 1,1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885.................... ...........................            290 15

                                    ---           --
July 1, 1886, amount available--....................... ...... ..............         299 04

iAmount  (estimated) required for completion of existing project--.....------ 22 500 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1888 11 500 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
  (See Appendix B 2.)
  3. Scituate Harbor, Massachusetts.--Previousto the commencement of
the improvement this harbor had a low-water area of about 57 acres,
over 6 acres of which there was a depth of at least 3 feet at mean low
water. It was open to the action of easterly winds.
  The object of the improvement is to create a harbor of refuge for ves
sels approaching Boston from the eastward.
   The project, adopted in 1880, is to build two breakwaters (one from
" Cedar Point" on the north side of the entrance, and the other from the
point of the "first cliff" on the south side), and to deepen by dredging
the area inclosed and in front of the entrance.
   The estimated cost of the improvement is $290,000.
   The mean rise or fall of the tide is 8.9 feet.
   The amount expended to June 30, 1885, is $37,108.54, by which the
north breakwater had been completed of its full section for a length of
720 feet; a portion of the beach near the junction of Cedar Point and
the mainland had been protected by a brush and stone bulkhead; a
channel had been dredged 1,600 feet long, 100 feet wide, and 5 feet deep
at mean low water and the " deep hole " had been enlarged to a-basin
200 by 160 feet, and 7 feet deep at mean low water.
  No work was done during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1886. The
work remains in good order, and essentially unchanged.
  The officer in charge reports that the amount that can be profitably
expended during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888, is $100,000, with
which it is proposed by him to continue the approved project, as fol-
lows:
  Build the south breakwater; remove Harbor Rocks; and enlarge the
basin to 8 acres and the channel to 150 feet wide, both 10 feet deep at
mean low water.
  About one hundred and twenty-five vessels seek this port annually,
and the money value of the resultant commerce is estimated to be
about $50,000.
  The benefit to be expected from this improvement cannot be estimated
until after its completion. No local improvement of commerce is ex-
pected, and the value of such a harbor of refuge is entirely dependent
on the accidents of the weather.
July 1, 1885, amount available. ----............   .......   ..      ...........     $391 46
July 1, 188b, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
                                                             ---------
  outstanding July 1, 1885 ..--.........................................              225 86
July 1, 1886, amount available......-------------------
                                                    .         .-..                    165 60
                                                         ---
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886 ..............-.                10, 000 00

Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887....................          10, 165 60
{Amount           RIVER AND        HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                           63
         (estimated) required for completion of existing project........ 242,500 00
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1888 50, 000 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix B 3.)
   4. Boston Harbor,Massachusetts.-Theoriginal condition of this harbor
was that its bluffs and headlands were exposed to the action of the sea,
and its main channel was in places but 100 feet wide and 18 feet deep
at mean low water.
   The object of the improvement is:
  First. To preserve the harbor by protecting the islands and head-
lands; and
   Second. To improve it by widening, deepening, and straightening
the channels.
   The projects adopted for this purpose since 1866 have been mainly in
accordance with the recommendations of the United States Commis-
sioners, whose labors terminated during that year.
   The works of preservation consist of sea-walls, aprons, jetties, &c.,
which protect the shores, prevent wash into the channels, control tidal
scour, and preserve the full height of anchorage shelter.
   Such have been built or repaired at Point Allerton and the islands of
Great Brewster, Lovell's, Gallop's, Long, Deer, Rainsford, George's, and
Castle.
   The works of improvement have been by dredging and blasting, by
which means the main ship-channel is now at least 600 feet wide and 23
feet deep at mean tow water; and the following tributary channels have
widths and depths as stated:
   1. Charles River; its channel originally crooked and but 50 feet wide
and 3 feet deep, is now 80 feet wide and 6 feet deep at mean low water,
from its mouth to Arsenal Street Bridge, a distance of 74 miles; while
up to Western Avenue Bridge, more than half of this distance, 7 feet
draught can be carried at mean low water in a channel 200 feet wide.
   2. Hingham Harbor; its channel originally 30 feet wide and 4 feet
deep, has been enlarged to 100 feet wide and 8 feet deep at mean low
water.
   3. Nantasket Beach Channel; originally 50 feet wide and 6. feet deep,
is now 100 feet wide and 9. feet deep at mean low water.
   4. The channel between Nix's Mate Shoal and Long Island has been
deepened from 4i feet to 12 feet at mean low water, and widened from
about 50 feet to 200 feet.
   The mean rise or fall of the tide is 9.8 feet.
   The amount expended to June 30, 1885, was $1,598,971.01, and at that
date all the completed works of preservation or improvement were in
good order with the exception of some minor repairs which the sea-walls
required.
   During the fiscal year some immediately necessary repairs were made
to the Deer Island sea-walls at a cost of about $150, and a hydrographic
survey of a portion of the lower harbor was made, and the notes partly
plotted.
   The river and harbor act of August 5, 1886, appropriates $56,250 for
Boston Harbor, and the otfficer in charg~ reports that during the fiscal
year ending June 30, 1888, $264,000 additional could be spent to ad-
vantage in repairing and extending the sea-walls at Point Allerton,
Great Brewster, George's, Lovell's, Deer, Long, and Castle islands; in
building new sea-walls at Deer and Governor's islands; in widening
thle main ship-channel at the upper and lower middles to 800 feet, and
in Imaking surveys on which to base additional improvements,
64            REPORT OF THE CHIEF                                 OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

  About 2,500 vessels annually enter from, and the same number clear
for, foreign ports. The duties collected during the fiscal year ending
June 30, 1886, were $21,079,311.36.
   The special benefits to be derived from the proposed expenditure are
additional safety and convenience to the commerce of this important
port, from which is derived so large a part of the national revenue.
July 1, 1885, amount available ...............................                                                      .........   $8, 528 99
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1885 ........................                                              $4, 537     58
July 1, 1886, outstanding liabilities .........................                                                       15 00
                                                                                                                         -        4,552 58

July 1, 1886, amount available .... .......... .............. ...... .. ...                                                       3, 976 41
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5,1886....................                                                            56,250 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887--
                                                     ...................                                                         60, 226 41
    SAmount (estimated) required for completion of existing project........
    Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1888
                                                                                                                                263, 750 00
                                                                                                                                264, 000 00
    Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
I   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix B 4.)
   5., PlymouthHarbor,Massachusetts.-Theoriginal condition of this har-
bor was that ILong Beach was rapidly being worn away by storms, and the
main ship-channel to the town wharves had but 6 inches of water at
mean low tide.
   The object of the improvement is to protect and preserve Long Beach
and to deepen and widen the channels of approach to the town wharves.
   The preservation of Long Beach has been carefully attended to for
many years, as the existence of the harbor depends on it. From the
nature of the work it can at no time be considered completed.
   The project for the improvement of the channel was originally adopted
in 1875. It proposed to straighten, deepen, and widen the channel, so
that it would be 2,286 feet long, 100 feet wide, and 6 feet deep at mean
low water. This was estimated to cost $28,000. This project was modi-
fied in 1877 so as to include the dredging of a basin 866 feet long, 150
feet -wide, and 8 feet deep at mean low water in front of the town
wharves. This modified project was estimated to cost $41,500. The
project was again modified in 1884, when it was proposed to dredge the
channel to 9 feet, widen it to 150 feet, and round off its junctions with
the main channel and basin. In 1885 it was proposed to deepen the
basin to 9 feet. The project of 1884 was estimated to cost $27,000, and
that of 1885 $22,500.
   The. tides rise and fall a mean distance of 9.3 feet.
The amount expended to June 30, 1885, was, for beach protection ....... $70, 329 75
For dredging ............................----
                            ----           --                        ..............                    .   .....     ......      35,152 75

          Total......----        ..............................                       ..............               ......       105, 482 50
   By the expenditure of which the beach was in good order; the chan-
nel was 90 feet wide and 9 feet deep, with rounded junctions with the
basin and main channel, and the basin was 7 feet deep. During the
fiscal year Long Beach was repaired at its southern end. Brush and
stone bulkheads were built, which filled breaches made in the beach
during the winter of 1885-'86. They aggregated 476 feet long, with 22
jetties each 15 feet long. The beach is now in good order, as is the
dredged channel and basin.
   Twenty-three hundred vessels sought this port during the fiscal year,
carrying about 43,000 tons; and some 45,000 passengers were landed
from steamers, packets, &c.
                      RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                               65
   The benefit to be expected from the completion of this improvement
is a more convenient navigation of the improved channel and greater
facilities in docking vessels.
July 1, 1885, amount available ..........    ..........  ........ ............      $3, 317 50
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1885 .-...........      ........     $1, 900 63
July 1, 1886, outstanding liabilities... -      -..-----           -         357 18
                                                                                             2, 257 81

July 1, 1886, amount available .............................---------.......----.            1,059 69
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886 .....--                . ..--.--          6, 000 00
                                                                                       -
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30,1887--....---...............------------.    7,059 69
  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project-...---..----... 15,500 00
  Amount that can be profitaby expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1888 10, 000 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix B 5.)
   6. Provincetown Harbor, Massachusetts.-This important harbor of
refuge depends for its existence on the preservation of the low sandy
beaches inclosing it. The harbor itself is capacious and deep,with con-
venient approaches and good holding ground, aud the expenditures
made for it are entirely for its preservation, which from the nature of
the work can at no time be considered completed.
   The projects adopted for the repair and preservation of the beaches
consist of detached bulkheads of wood and stone, jetties of wood and
brush, dikes, sand-catches, and the extensive planting of beach grass,
all for the sole purpose of preventing or arresting the movement of the
sand. They have been remarkably successful.
   The tides have an average rise and fall of 9.2 feet.
   The amount expended to June 30, 1885, was $135,924.59, and the
works of preservation were in good order.
   No operations were in progress during the fiscal year.
   During the year ending June 30, 1888, certain additional works of
preservation and extensions of the old ones are needed, which it is esti-
mated will cost $90,000, all of which could be advantageously expended
during that year. The most important of these new works are a dike
across House Point Island fiats, estimated to cost $78,000, and the
strengthening of the Long Point breakwater at a cost of $5,600.
  About seven thousand vessels frequent this harbor annually, carry-
ing cargoes of an estimated value of $18,500,000.
   The special benefit to be derived from the proposed expenditure is
the preservation of an important harbor of refuge.
July 1, 1885, amount available..-... .--          ..
                                                  _...-.--.--         _..---.
                                                                      -..                    $553 85
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885................................. -.............---                  549 31
July 1, 1886, amount available.... .... .... .... ......... ........... ....                      4 54
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886............ .......                       3, 000 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887 ....
SAmount  (estimated) required for completion of existing project......
                                                                          ..........


  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1888
                                                                                             3, 004 54
                                                                                            90,000 00
                                                                                            45,000 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
  (See Appendix B 6.)
  7. Lynn Harbor, MIassachusetts.-The entrance channels of this har-
bor were originally narrow and crooked, with but 6 feet depth at mean
low water, the greater part of the harbor was bare at low water.
      5E
66        REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

   The object of the improvement is to obtain an increased depth of
water, and a more direct and wider channel of approach to the city
wharves.
   The project was adopted in 1884. It proposes the excavation of a
lower channel, 200 feet wide and 10 feet deep at mean low water,
from a point near and east of the White Rocks to deep water opposite
Little Nahant, a distance of 3,610 feet; and also an upper channel
6,450 feet long, with the same width and depth, extending from deep
water opposite Sand Point to the Lynn Harbor line. It is supposed
that the upper channel will require occasional dredging. To aid in
keeping the lower channel open a training-wall is proposed from high-
water line at Little Nahant, if experience shows it to be necessary.
   The cost of this improvement was originally estimated to be $145,000.
This estimate was revised in 1885, and then made $157,000.
   The mean rise or fall of the tides is 9.3 feet. The amount expended
to June 30, 1885, was $50,209.06, by which the lower channel had been
dredged as proposed, and the upper channel had been dredged for its
full length and depth, but only 100 feet wide. No work had been done
on the training-wall.
   No operations were in progress during the fiscal year ending June
30, 1886, and the work remains essentially unaltered; some slight de-
crease in width of channel is noticed, owing to the falling in of the side
slopes, or to injuries caused by vessels getting aground.
   During the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888, $25,000 could be ex-
pended to advantage in repairing the upper channel and in extending
its width to the full proposed limit.
   About four hundred and fifty vessels annually frequent this port, and
the annual commerce amounts to about $775,000. The benefit to be ex-
pected from the completion of this improvement is a more convenient
and safe navigation of the improved channels.
July 1, 1885, amount available-- -------------------       --------------- $9, 790 94
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885.----.----------...        ....-  ..-  ..---..-.  2,755 85
July 1, 1886, amount available.. .............................              ......    7, 035 09
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886 ...................                6, 000 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887 ...................            13,035 09
iAmount (estimated)   required for completion of existing project .......            91,000 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1888          25, 000 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
  (See Appendix B 7.)
  8. Malden River, Massachusetts.-Previous to improvement the chan-
nel of this river was narrow and crooked, and had barely 7 feet of water
at mean high tide.
  The object of the improvement is to increase the width and depth of
the channel from its mouth to the second draw-bridge in Malden.
  The project, originally adopted in 1880, was to dredge a channel, 100
feet wide and 12 feet deep at mean high water, up to the second draw-
bridge, with two cut-offs, one near the mouth of the river and one half
a mile above it. The cost of this project was estimated to be $35,000.
This project was modified in 1882, when it was proposed to dredge the
natural channel of the river 100 feet wide up to the draw-bridge in
Malden, and 75 feet wide thence to the second draw-bridge near the
rubber works; the cost of the modified project was originally estimited
at $40,000, which sum was increased in 1885 to $47,000.
  The mean rise and fall of the tides at the mouth of the river is 9.8 feet.
                   RIVER AND HARBOR             IMPROVEMENTS.                         67
  The total amount expended to June 30, 1885, was $10,000, by which
14 miles of the natural channel of the river, from its mouth up, had
been improved so that it had a least width of 50 feet (70 feet at turns)
and a depth of 12 feet at mean high water.
  No work was done during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1886.
  Thirty-seven thousand dollars could be expended to advantage during
the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888, in completing the amended project.
  About one hundred vessels enter this river annually, and their cargoes
are valued at about $75,000.
  It is expected that the completion of the improvement will increase the
tonnage of the river, and encourage the building of new manufactories.
  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project-- .-----      $37, 000 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1888    10, 000 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix B 8.)
   9. Harbor of refuge at Sandy Bay, Cape Ann, Massachusetts.-This
bay, at the northeastern extremity of Cape Ann, Massachusetts, is
open to northerly and easterly winds, but is perfectly covered on the
west and south. It is spacious, easy of access, very deep, and per-
fectly free from obstructions.
   The projected improvement contemplates the construction of a " na-
tional harbor of refuge, of the first class."
   No definite project for this improvement has been adopted. Prelim.
inary estimates for it vary from $4,000,000 to $5,000,000, and a large
additional sum will be needed for the lighting, buoying, and defense of
the harbor when completed.
   The rise or fall of the tide is 9 feet.
   The amount expended on this improvement to June 30, 1885, was
$4,340.03, by which surveys, examinations, and preliminary projects
were made.
   During the fiscal year ending June 30,1886, $37,842.54 were expended
in depositing 49,762 tons of rubble-stone on the line of the proposed
breakwater, and in preparing to mark the initial point of the break-
water with a submerged pier, surmounted by an iron spindle.
   The rubble-stone deposited will form a mound (the base of the proposed
breakwater) 40 feet wide on top, at a level 22 feet below mean low water,
and the funds available will build about 1,200 feet of this mound.
   The officer in charge estimates that during the year ending June 30,
1888, $500,000 could be expended to advantage in extending the sub-
merged mound for the breakwater foundation.
   The special benefit to be derived from the proposed improvement is
the creation of a first-class harbor of refuge on this exposed, much-fre-
quented coast.
July 1, 1885, amount available .....                                      . $95, 659 97
                                                       .....................
                                           ...... -.....
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1885 ............---
                                                     .......... $25, 284 80
July 1, 1886, outstanding liabilities ................... ...... 12,557 74
                                                                --             37, 842 54

July 1, 1886, amount available .......................................-- . 57,817 43
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886 ................... 100, 000 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887 ---................... 157, 817 43
  Amount thatcan be profitably expended in fiscal yearendingJune 30, 1888 100, 000 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
   harbor ac Ls of 1866 and 1867.
  (See Appendix B 9.)
68         REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEIRS, U. S. ARMY.

IMPROVEMENT OF HARBORS AND RIVERS ON THE SOUTHERN COAST OF
    MASSACHUSETTS AND IN RHODE ISLAND AND CONNECTICUT.

   Officer in charge, Lieut. Col. George H. Elliot, Corps of Engineers.
   1. Harborof refuge at Hyannis, Massachusetts.--This harbor lies on
the south shore of Cape Cod, about 15 miles to the westward of the
heel of the cape, and is an important harbor of refuge.
   Before improvement it was an open roadstead exposed to southerly
storms.
   In the years 1827-'38 a breakwater of riprap granite, 1,170 feet long,
was constructed, covering an anchorage of about 175 acres, the en-
trance to which has a depth of about 15J feet. It was not as strongly
built as we would build a breakwater in a locality of like exposure,
and in the years 1852-'82 extensive repairs were made in increasing the
width of its base and the size of the stone forming its sides and top.
   The depth of water inside the breakwater is insufficient for many ves-
sels that seek the harbor for refuge, and the river and harbor act of July
5, 1884, provided for a preliminary examination and survey of the har-
bor, with a view of deepening it. The reports in the case, with a plat
and an estimate of the cost ($45,743.20), were printed in House Ex.
Doc. No. 96, Forty-eighth Congress, second session.
   The commencement of this work has been approved by Congress,
making an appropriation of $10,000 therefor in the act of August 5,
1886.
   No work has been in progress during the last fiscal year. The amount
expended on this work has been $123,276.77, and the breakwater has
been completed according to the original project and the subsequent
plans for strengthening it.
   The execution of the project before referred to, of deepening the an-
chorage area inside the breakwater, will be commenced at the eastern
end of the anchorage, and the full width of the area proposed to be
deepened will be carried to the westward as far as the appropriation of
August 5, 1886, will allow.
July 1, 1885, amount available           ...........................            .-
                                                                                ....   ....     $105 48
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885 .......... ..........................--------- --........              24 67
                                                                             ---.....----.
July 1, 1886, amount available..--- -...............----......----..--..-....----                  80 81
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886- ....---...---...--------.......           10, 000 00

Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887 ...................                     10, 080 81

  SAmount  (estimated) required for completion of existing project .------......
   Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1888
                                                                                              35, 662 00
                                                                                              20, 000 00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
  (See Appendix C 1.)
  2. Harbor of refuge at Nantucket, 1Massachusetts.-This harbor is the
only one between the harbors of Martha's Vineyard (Vineyard Haven
and Edgartown) and Provincetown, a distance of about 100 miles, ex-
cept the small harbor of Hyannis, on the other (the north) side of Nan-
tucket Sound, the navigation of which is intricate and dangerous by
reason of numerous shoals. Nantucket Harbor has deep water inside,
and the object of the improvement is to make it a harbor of refuge for
vessels plying between ports north and south of Cape Cod, estimated
to be fifty thousand annually. In the memorial to Congress on,which
the first appropriation for this harbor was based it was stated that more
than five hundred vessels had been wrecked in the vicinity of the island.
                   RIVER AND IIARBOR           IMPROVEMENTS.                      69
   Before the commencement of the present works there was a shoal
about 1 miles in width outside the entrance, through which shoal the
channel or line of best water was only about 6 feet deep and very crooked
and subject to changes in location.
   The present approved project is to construct jetties of riprap stone pro-
jecting from either side of the present entrance to the harbor for the
purpose of concentrating the strength of the tidal currents, and exca-
vating a channel of 15 feet depth by scour, and at the places where the
full depth required will not be reached by this means to complete the
work by dredging.
   The amount expended on this project up to the close of the fiscal year
ending June 30,1885, including liabilities outstanding at that date, was
$100,211.25, and the result was the construction of the west jetty to a
point 3,955 feet from the shore.
   The amount expended during the last fiscal year, including liabilities
outstanding June 30, 1886, was $5,620.87. The east jetty was com-
menced and fully completed to a distance of 120 feet from the initial
point on the shore, and the foundation was laid and the jetty partially
completed for an additional distance of 100 feet.
   Although but little if any effect had been expected before the two
jetties should be extended until they should become parallel and con-
tract the channel to the width contemplated, 1,000 feet, it was found in
a recent survey that on a line from Brant Point to the present end of
the west jetty the least depth of water was considerably greater than at
the time of the previous survey, and vessels have less difficulty in en-
tering and leaving the harbor than formerly.
   The work required to be done to complete the existing project is the
completion of the east and west jetties and the excavation by dredging
of so much of the channel as will not be excavated by tidal scour.
   It is proposed to devote the small remainder on hand July 1, 1886,
and the appropriation made by the act of August 5, 1886, to the exten-
sion as far as possible of the east jetty.
July 1, 1885, amount available ................ ............    .... .. ... $9, 788 75
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1885......................... $3, 048 81
July 1, 1886, outstanding liabilities .......................... 2, 572 06
                                                                             5, 620 87

July 1, 1886, amount available...... - -...
                                         ............................. .. 4,167 88
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886................... 15, 000 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887 .....-.........
                                                                   .        19,167 88
  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project-------250,000 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year endingJune 30,1888 50, 000 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
  (See Appendix C 2.)
  3. Wood's Hell Harbor, Massachusetts.--This harbor is on the north
side of Vineyard Sound, and is divided into Great Harbor and Little
Harbor. The name " Wood's Holl " is also applied to the adjoining
strait which connects Vineyard Sound with Buzzard's Bay. The site
of the works now under contraction isGreat Harbor, Wood's Holl.
   Before improvement the site of the present works was a submerged
pointV of land extending from the shore of the harbor.
70         REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

   The adopted project for the improvement of Great Harbor, Wood's
Holl, was for the construction of retaining-walls on the shore, a hollow
pier and wharves for the use of the United States Fish Commission and
to serve also as a coaling station for vessels of the Revenue Marine and
other branches of the public service, and as a harbor of refuge.
   The amount expended on these works to June 30, 1885, including
liabilities outstanding at that date, was $77,842.66. The retaining and
pier walls, and the dredging of the interior of the hollow pier, and the
berths for public vessels, had been completed, and the coal, the west,
and the cross wharves had been essentially completed.
   For want of funds no work has been in progress during the last fiscal
year.
   The work required for the completion of the project for the improve-
ment of Great Harbor, Wood's Holl, is the construction of the south
and east wharves.
   In addition to the above there is to be removed a large rock (estimated
at 22 tons) from the strait of Wood's Holl.
   It is proposed to devote the small remainder on hand July 1, 1886,
and the appropriation made by the act of August 5, 1886, to the con-
struction of the south and east wharves, and the removal of the danger-
ous rock in the strait of Wood's Holl, just referred to.
July 1, 1885, amount available..................-------------------.....-- -------------------
                                                                             ..............         $64 00
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885............ ...............................                             . 17 05
(July 1, 1886, amount available.............----...........................                          46 95
  Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886..................                           14,500 00
  Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887...... ............                       14,546 95
  (See Appendix C 3.)
  4. Westport Harbor, Massachusetts.-This harbor is an estuary of a
bay lying between Narragansett Bay, Rhode Island, and Buzzard's
Bay, Massachusetts. This is a new work, and no appropriation had
been made for it until, by act approved August 5, 1886, Congress ap-
propriated $1,000 " for sand fence."
  A report of December 12, 1878, on a survey made in accordance with
section 2 of the act of June 18, 1878, stated that "the wearing of Horse
Neck Point " (on the north side of the entrance) " could be prevented
by small sand-catch jetties, and these could be gradually prolonged so
as to narrow the space opposite, and increase the average depth" (of
the channel), and named $1,000 as the amount that could reasonably
be expended in this way. It is supposed that the sum appropriated
by the act of August 5, 1886, is intended for the construction of the
sand-catch jetties recommended, and the funds will be expended accord-
ingly.
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886....................                           $1, 000 00
   (See Appendix C 4.
   5. Wareham Harbor, Massachusetts.-This harbor is an estuary at
the head of Buzzard's Bay, The object of the improvement is to deepen'
and widen the channel leading from Buzzard's Bay to Wareham, the
industries of which and of several towns in the vicinity with which it
is connected by rail, are chiefly the manufactures of iron, and depend
largely on transportation by water of the material used therein. The
commerce of Warehani is carried on in sailing vessels, and the channel
                      RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                          71
is to be made a beating channel for such vessels. Another object of the
improvement is the raising of Long Beach, over which the sands from
the bay were washed into the harbor.
   Before improvement the ruling depth in the harbor was about 7 feet
at mean low water in a narrow and very crooked channel. Long
Beach, a narrow sand-spit at the mouth of the harbor, was washed and
abraded by the waves and currents at high water, and the material
was carried into and shoaled the channel inside.
   The original approved project of 1871 for the improvement, and its
subsequent modifications, provides for a channel 250 feet wide and 10
feet deep at mean low water from Barney's Point down to the entrance
to the harbor. Above Barney's Point the width of the channel is to be
350 feet with the same depth-10 feet--as below that point. The plan
includes also the raising and strengthening of Long Beach, of which a
large portion was submerged at low water, to carry it above the storm
waves and currents and to hold it there, in order to prevent the filling
of the improved channel above by material abraded from the beach.
   The total amount expended on the improvement up to the close of the
fiscal year ending June 30, 1885, including liabilities outstanding at
that date, was $56,467.43, and the result was a channel through and
above the upper bar to the wharves with a width of not less than 100
feet and a depth of 10 feet at mean low water. A large part of the
work on the lower reaches of the channel had been done, and the river
opposite the wharves had been deepened to 9 feet below mean low
water. Long Beach was raised above high-water storm tides, except in
a few places, so that the major part of the wash of sand into the im-
proved channel inside the beach had been stopped.
   The amount expended during the last fiscal year was $8,485.21. The
channel in the upper part of the harbor in front of the wharves was car-
ried to its full width and completed, and about one-half of the first reach
below the wharves was excavated to its full depth of 10 feet below mean
low water. This reach includes the heaviest cutting in the entire im-
provement. The ruling depth of the approaches to Wareham has now
been increased from 7 to 9 feet, and the channel has been greatly wid-
ened in all the reaches, especially in the main reach below the wharves.
Vessels of larger draught can be carried to Wareham than formerly,
and the increase in width of channel is already a great help to all ves-
sels in beating in and out of the harbor.
   The work required to complete the existing project is the excavation
of the channel to its full width and depth from the point to which it was
carried by the last contract down to the deep water above Long Beach.
There will also be required the expenditure of a few hundred dollars
more in the further building up of Long Beach.
   It is proposed to devote the small remainder on hand July 1, 1886,
and the appropriation made by the act of August 5, 1886, to carrying
on the work according to the approved project as far as the funds will
admit.
July 1, 1885, amount available ........ ................................                $8, 532 67
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
                              ......
  outstanding July 1, 1885--------              ---------........----................    8, 485 21
July 1, 1886, amount available--..----............------........----..---..........       ' 47 46
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886--....................                15, 000 00

Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887 ......-............               15, 047 46
72     REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

(Amount  (estimated) required for completion of existing project........ $4,050 00
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1888 4,050 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
  harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix C 5.)
   6. Taunton River, Massachusetts.-This river rises in Norfolk County,
Massachusetts, and empties into Mount Hope Bay, a name given to
that part of Narragansett Bay lying mainly in Massachusetts. It is
about 44 miles in length, measured along its course.
   The object of the improvement is to deepen and widen the channel
leading to the city of Taunton, at the head of navigation, which requires
large quantities of coal, iron, clay, moldings, sand, and other heavy ar-
ticles for its manufactures, depending largely on water transportation,
so that vessels of 11 feet draught can reach the city at high water.
   In its original condition the channel was narrow and obstructed by
bowlders, and from Berkley Bridge to Taunton the depth was not, in
places, more than 5 feet at mean high water. A vessel of 30 tons bur-
den was as large as could go up to Taunton.
   The approved' project of 1871, and its subsequent modification, pro-
vides for a channel 60 feet wide and 11 feet deep from Weir Bridge to
the Ship Yard; a channel 80 feet wide (100 feet at the bends) and 11
feet deep from the Ship Yard down to and through the Needles and
Briggs' Shoal; thence to Berkley Bridge a channel of the same width
and 12 feet deep, and from Berkley Bridge to the deep water at Dighton
the channel was to be 100 feet wide and 12 feet deep. The depths are
estimated from high water. The ledge which crosses the bottom of the
river at Peter's Point, and the numerous bowlders which lay on the
bottom and sides of the channel from Taunton to Dighton were to be
removed.
   The amount expended on the improvement of the river up to the close
of the fiscal year ending June 30, 1885, including liabilities outstand-
ing at that date, was $134,470.44.
   With the exception that but 40 feet of the 60 feet of width could be
dredged between the bridge at Weir and the Ship Yard, on account of
interfering with private property, and that on account of the hardness
and depth of the material at the sides the 80-foot channel was not in
all cases dredged to its full width, the channel down to Berkley Bridge
had been completed. The major part of the dredging below the bridge
had been done, but this part of the channel still lacked in width at
some places. The channel had been cleared of bowlders from Taunton
down to Berkley Bridge. The work of uncovering the ledge at Peter's
Point preparatory to its removal had been commenced.
   The amount expended during the last fiscal year, including liabilities
outstanding June 30,1886, was $2,917.95 All of the bowlders and gravel
overlying the ledge at Peter's Point within the lines of the proposed
channel have been removed; the work of blasting the ledge has been
completed; the major part of the broken rock has been removed, and
the half-tide dam between Reuben's Island and the west shore of the
river, constructed with the view of accelerating the current in the
dredged channel below, and preventing deposits, has been essentially
completed. The ruling depth of water in the river has now been in-
creased from 5 to 11 feet at mean high water, and vessels of 11 feet
draught can now reach Taunton, at the head of navigation.
   There remains to be done to complete the existing project the com-
pletion of the removal of the ledge at Peter's Point; the completioF'df
the dredging of the channel between Berkley Bridge and Dighton, and
                         RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                                 73
widening and deepening at a few points above the bridge; all of which
it is proposed to finish in the next fiscal year if the funds now available
be sufficient, as hoped for.
                                              -----------------
July 1, 1885, amount available..........................................       $22,529 56
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1885 ----............--.......... $2, 130 46
July 1, 1886, outstanding liabilities................... .....-...      787 49
                                                                                                                  2,917 95

July 1, 1886, amount available ..                .... .     .................--         ...... ........---- .    19, 611 61
   (See Appendix C 6.)
   7. Pawtucket River, Rhode Island.-The navigable part of the Paw-
tucket (or Seekonk) River, an arm of Providence River, extends from
Providence to Pawtucket, a city which has a population of about 23,000
and extensive manufactures depending largely on water transportation.
The object of the improvement is to widen and deepen the channel lead-
ing to Pawtucket, so that vessels of 12 feet draught can reach that city
at mean low water.
   Before improvement the channel in the river had a ruling depth of
about 5 feet at mean low water.
   The original project, as modified in 1883, provides for the excavation
by dredging of a channel 100 feet wide and 12 feet deep at mean low
water from the deep water above Red Bridge to the ledge opposite
Grant & Company's Wharf at Pawtucket; thence, the deepening by
blasting of the channel through the ledge to Pawtucket Bridge to the
same depth and 40 feet wide.
   The amount expended to June 30, 1885, was $52,718.44. The channel
had been excavated under the original project to a width of 75 feet and
a ruling depth of 7 feet at mean low water. A contract had been made
for deepening and widening this channel according to the modified plan
of 1883, but the work had not been commenced.
   The amount expended during the last fiscal year, including liabilities
outstanding June 30, 1886, was $49,241.02. The new channel, 12 feet
deep and 100 feet wide, with enlargements at the bends, has been carried
from its mouth at the deep water just above Red Bridge, a distance of
about 8,740 feet, or to a point about 1,000 feet above a line drawn from
Bucklin Island to Swan Point Wharf. A ruling depth of about 6 feet
can be carried from the upper end of the present work to Pawtucket.
   The work yet to be done is to excavate, by dredging, the channel 12
feet deep and 100 feet wide from the point to which the last contract
carried it to a point opposite Grant & Company's Wharf; and from thence
to Pawtucket Bridge to deepen the channel through the ledge to the
same depth with a width of 40 feet.
   It is proposed to devote the small remainder on hand July 1, 1886,
and the appropriation made by the act of August 5, 1886, to the exca-
vation, by dredging, of the upper reaches of the new channel, and, if
the funds will admit, to the commencement of the work on the ledge
which lies in the channel off Pawtucket.
July 1, 1885, amount available--..-.........---....--------..--......-------...---..---.........---              $49, 287 52
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
   liabilities outstanding July 1, 1885... -..--..--..--......                     ......         $49, 217 27
July 1, 1886, outstanding liabilities..---------...--..----..............                               23 75
                                                                                                                  49,241 02
July 1, 1886, amount available......                      --....................            ...    .........          46 50
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886 ...............----...---.                                     30,000 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887 ..................                                          30, 046 50
{Amount
74         REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

         (estimated) required for completion of existing project-........$302, 478 00
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1888 50,000 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix C 7.)
   8. Providence River and NarragansettBay, Rhode Island.-Providence
River is an estuary of Narragansett Bay. The object of its improve-
ment is to furnish a wide and deep channel for European and coastwise
cornmmnerce from the ocean to Providence, a city of about 125,000 inhab-
itaints, largely engaged in manufactures, and a port of entry for an
extensive region of country with which it is connected by railroads.
   Before the improvement of the river was commenced, in 1853, many
shoals obstructed navigation, and at one point in the channel, a place
called " The Crook," the available low-water depth was but 41 feet.
   There was expended between 1852 and the 30th of June, 1882,
$290,459.34 in deepening the channel, first to 9 feet, then to 12 feet,
then to 14 feet, and again to 23 feet, as the increasing sizes of vessels
and the growing commerce of Providence demanded. Bulkhead Rock
was also removed during this period to a depth of 20 feet below mean
low water.
   The approved project of 1878, modified in 1882, under which the work
is now in progress, provides for a channel 25 feet deep and 300 feet
wide, suitable for large ocean vessels, extending from Fox Point, in
the city of Providence, to the deep water of Narragansett Bay, and for
an anchorage-basin between Fox and Field's points of the following
dimensions in cross-section, viz: 300 feet wide at a depth of 25 feet, 600
feet wide at a depth of 20 feet, 725 feet wide at a depth of 18 feet, 940
feet wide at a depth of 12 feet, and 1,060 feet wide at a depth of 6 feet.
   The amount expended on the present project up to the close of the
fiscal year ending June 30, 1885, including liabilities outstanding at
that date, was $210,180.96.
   At that date about one-half of the excavation required for the an-
chorage basin above Field's Point had been done. Bulkhead Rock had
been removed, and the condition of the six straight reaches into which
the 25-foot channel 300 feet wide is divided, was as follows: The Fox
Point, the Sassafras Point, the Field's Point, the Pomham, and the
Pawtuxet reaches had been completed, and the lowest, the Gaspee
Reach, had been excavated to a width of 200 feet.
   For want of funds no work has been in progress during the last fiscal
year.
   To complete the 25-foot channel 300 feet wide to the deep.water of
Narragansett Bay there remains the increasing to 300 feet the 200 feet
of width already excavated in the lowest (the Gaspee) reach. There
also remains for the completion of the existing project the remainder of
the excavation of the anchorage basin between Fox and Field's points.
   It is proposed to devote the small remainder on hand July 1, 1886, and
the appropriation made by the act of August 5, 1886, to the completion
of the dredging required in the Gaspee reach, and to continuing the ex-
cavation of the anchorage basin above Field's Point.
July 1, 1885, amount available .............                    .....     .... ....................          $3, 419 67
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885-----
                          ...... ........................................                                       749 93

July 1, 1886, amount available .................                        ......    -..................         2, 669 74
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886 .................                                         30,000 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887 ....                                ...           ..   32, 669 74
                    RIVER AND        HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                          75
(Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project -....
                                                                ....       $205, 000 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1888 100, 000 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
  (See Appendix C 8.)
  9. Removal of Green Jacket Shoal, Providence River, Rhode Island.-
This shoal is in that part of the river which constitutes the harbor of
Providence. It lies off the wharves on the south front of the city and
occupies a part of the harbor that is required for anchorage purposes.
   This is a new work, and no appropriation had been made for it until,
by act of August 5, 1886, Congress authorized its commencement by
making an appropriation of $26,250 therefor.
   The report of January 10, 1885, of the survey of this shoal, with plat
and estimate of cost of the work ($112,346.25) on which the appro-
priation was founded, were published in the Annual Report of the Chief
of Engineers for 1885, Part I, pages 598-602.
   It is proposed with the appropriation of August 5, 1886, to commence
the work by removing that part of the shoal where additional anchorage
is most required.
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886 ...................      $26, 250 00
  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project-........ 86, 096 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1888 28, 000 00
  Submitted in coimpliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix C 9.)
   10. Warren River, Rhode Island.-This river is an arm of Narragan-
sett Bay, north of the harbor of Bristol, and, being a new work, no
funds had been provided for it until, by act approved August 5, 1886,
Congress appropriated $5,000 for its improvement.
   The officer in charge, in his report of January 12, 1885, upon the survey,
made in accordance with the act of July 5, 1884, stated that the ob-
structions to navigation were a rocky reef below Little Island, and a
submerged bowlder near mid-channel opposite the lower wharf of the
town of Warren, and recommended that these obstructions be removed
as far as could be done with an expenditure of $5,000 for both purposes.
This is doubtless the improvement appropriated for by the act of August
5, 1886, and the funds will be expended accordingly.
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886 ...................       $5, 000 00
  (See Appendix C 10.)
  11. Newport Harbor, Rhode Island.--This harbor is at the mouth of
the main entrance to Narragansett Bay. These waters during summer
and winter constitute an important harbor of refuge for our European
and coastwise commerce. The objects of the improvement are to widen
and deepen the southern (the main) entrance to the harbor, and to en-
large its capacity for vessels seeking refuge in storms by increasing the
area and depth of the anchorage within it. Before improvement the
capacity of the inner harbor was limited by shoals, and it was not ad-
equate to the number and size of vessels seeking it for refuge. The
southern (the main) entrance was obstructed by a bar which stretched
out from Goat Island, and the general business wharves of the city could
not be reached at low tide by vessels drawing more than 8 feet.
   The original project and its modifications, under which work is now
carried on, are substantially as follows: Widening and deepening to 15
feet below mean low water the southern (the main) entrance to the
76        REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY,

harbor, increasing the area and depth of the anchorage inside according
to the system which is fully described in the accompanying report of
the engineer officer in charge, and the construction of jetties on the
outer shore of Goat Island to arrest the drift of littoral sand and gravel
into the harbor entrance.
   The amount expended up to the close of the fiscal year ending June
30, 1885, including liabilities outstanding at that date, was $86,966.66,
with the following results: Of the area to be dredged to 13 feet within
the harbor, about two-thirds had been completed, except at a few places
in the northern part of the harbor, where the material was found too
hard for the dredge in use at the time, and except that a bulkhead was
left in the extreme northeast part of the harbor to protect an anchorage
for small vessels; the channel along and outside the harbor line south
to a point opposite gas company's wharf, and the 15-foot channel 750
feet wide around, and to the eastward of the dolphin on Goat Island
Spit had been completed. Of the 460 feet (about) of increase of width
to be made between the 15-foot curves at the southern entrance by
dredging the spit south of Goat Island, 224 feet had been gained.
   The amount expended during the last fiscal year was $5,853.38, and
the result was the further widening of the 15-foot depth at the southern
entrance by 180 feet, or to within 56 feet of the proposed northern limit
of this channel, and the effectual stopping, for the present, of the sup-
ply of littoral sand and gravel from the outside of Goat Island into the
southern entrance, by the extension and raising of the jetty on the
southwest shore of the island.
   The southern entrance is completed with the exception of the small
amount of work above mentioned, and it is now wide and safe for vessels
of 15 feet draught. Of the total area to be deepened by dredging within
the harbor (about 90 acres) about one-half has been completed.
   The work required to be done to complete the existing project is the
small remainder of the cutting away of the spit south of Goat Island to
15 feet depth; the remainder of the excavation within the harbor of the
anchorage area of 13 feet depth, and the excavation, also within the
harbor, of the anchorage area of 10 feet depth; also the building of ad-
ditional jetties outside of Goat Island whenever they may be required.
    It is proposed to devote the small remainder on hand July 1, 1886,
and the appropriation made by the act of August 5, 1886, to the com-
pletion of the deepening to 15 feet below mean low water of the spit
south of Goat Island to the northern limit before stated; to the exten-
sion of the anchorage area within the harbor of 13 feet depth, and, if
the funds will allow, to commencement of the extension, also within the
harbor, of the anchorage area of 10 feet depth. It is also proposed to
do a small amount of dredging at the end of the wharf at Fort Adams,
at which supplies for the fort are landed.
Jehly 1, 1885, amount available --.......                                 ...           6,235 37
                                                                                       $---.
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885.........................   ...... ......-......              5,853 38
July 1, 1886, amount available ...................     .........-......         ..--      381 99
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886 ...................                 15, 000 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887......---............             15,381 99
  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project....------             52,000 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1888           25, 000 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
     (See Appendix C 11.)
                 RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                          77
   12. Harbor of refuge at Block Island, Rhode Island.-This island is a
part of the State of Rhode Island. It is 14 miles east of Montauk
Point, the eastern end of Long Island, and its nearest point is about 10
miles from the mainland. Besides the wants of the mackerel-fishing
fleet and the general coast navigation, the island is an important point
on our shores for ocean navigation. It has a signal station connected
by submarine telegraph with the mainland. Vessels are passing the
island at all times and on all sides of it, and its position renders it of
national importance. The object of the improvement is to furnish a
harbor of refuge for vessels engaged in foreign and coastwise commerce.
                                                   -vessels.
Before the construction of the present harbor of refuge Block Island had
no harbor which afforded protection for decked                 The only ones
used were open boats, which on the approach of storms were hauled up
on the beach by oxen. The largest of these boats were of about 10 tons
burden.
   The original project and its subsequent modifications provided for a
harbor of refuge on the eastern side of the island, consisting of an inner
harbor or basin for small vessels and an exterior harbor for large ones.
The basin was to be about 250 by 300 feet in area, and inclosed, with the
exception of an opening of 80 feet in width. The exterior harbor was
to be formed by a riprap breakwater, which has been built. About 300
feet from the sea end of this breakwater, which is 1,900 feet long, a gap
200 feet long was left for the convenience of vessels. The present pro-
ject contemplates the filling of this gap, which was found to let in too
much sea in stormy weather.
   On the 8th December, 1884, the Senate of the United States directed
that report be made of the necessity and cost of enlarging the inner
harbor of refuge. The report, with plans and an estimate of the cost
 ($46,189), was printed in Senate Ex. Doc. No. 27, Forty-eighth Congress,
second session. The commencement of this work has been approved
by Congress, making an appropriation of $12,000 therefor in the act of
August 5, 1886.
   The total expenditures up to June 30, 1885, including liabilities out-
standing at that date, was $318,925.09.
   The inner harbor and the main breakwater built in prolongation of
the eastern side of the inner harbor, and extending 1,900 feet from the
shore, were constructed in the years 1870 to 1879, inclusive. The utility
of the work at once became apparent. In stormy weather the inner
harbor especially was filled with fishermen and coasters, and it soon
became necessary to increase its depth from 7 feet, to which it had been
dredged in the first instance, to 9 feet at mean low water. In 1883 a
strong jetty was built out from the cliff to the eastward of the inner
harbor, and a masonry wall was constructed on the inside of the crib-
work, forming the eastern side of the inner harbor. The major part of
the sea which formely came into the outer harbor through the gap in
the main breakwater in easterly storms had, at the beginning of the
last fiscal year, been stopped by the partial filling of the gap.
   The filling in the gap in the main breakwater was carried to the
height of about 1 feet above mean high water, and at the close of work
under the last contract about one-half of the total amount of stone re-
quired for the completion of this work had been delivered and placed in
the gap. The good effects of this filling, although incomplete, have
already been noticed, and vessels, both in the outer and inner harbor,
lie more quietly at their moorings in easterly storms than before.
   The work required to be done to complete the existing project is the
completion of the filling of the gap to its full height of 6 feet above mean
78        REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

high water, and its full width at top of 25 feet, and the enlargement of
the inner harbor of refuge.
  It is proposed to devote the small remainder on hand July 1, 1886,
and the appropriation made by the act of August 5, 1886, to continuing
the filling of the gap in the main breakwater and commencing the work
of enlarging the inner harbor.
  Attention is invited to the statement concerning the condition of the
Government wharf at Block Island and the recommendation for its dis-
posal contained in the report of the engineer officer in charge.
July 1, 1885, amount available........ - ------................----      ...............------.        $6, 074 91
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885....................... . ..................---- --                          5, 438 79
July 1, 1886, amount available .............. .................. ........                                 636 12
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886....................                                 20,000 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887....................                              20, 636 12
  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project.--------                              50,189 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1888                            25, 000 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix C 12.)
   13. Little NarragansettBay, Rhode Island and Connecticut.-This bay
lies on the north side of the eastern entrance from the ocean into Long
Island Sound; Pawcatuck River, upon which is situated the flourishing
commercial and manufacturing town of Westerly, R. I., empties into the
eastern side of the bay, and has been improved by the United States.
The object of the improvement of Little Narragansett Bay was to
deepen the approach from Long Island Sound to Westerly.
   The navigable draught of water through the bay before improvement
was about 41 feet at mean low water.
   The project of 1878 for the improvement of the bay provided for a
channel 200 feet wide and 7J feet deep at mean low water, extending
from the entrance to the bay to the mouth of the Paw.catuck, and the
removal of the bowlders which obstructed navigation. Subsequently
it was determined to clear away some large bowlders which interfered
with steamboat navigation between this channel and Watch Hill Land-
ing. The estimated cost of the improvement was $51,000.
   The project was completed in the fiscal year 1883-'84. Vessels draw-
ing 10 feet of water can now reach the mouth of the Pawcatuck River
at high water, but the full benefit of the improvement cannot be utilized
until further deepening of that river to enable vessels of the same draught
to reach Westerly.
   The remainder of the last appropriation for this work is reserved for
comparative surveys of Sandy Point, at the entrance to the bay, which
seems to be affected by the construction of the breakwater in Stoning-
ton Harbor, and for range-marks on Pawcatuck Point to guide through
the new channel. The total cost of the completed improvement was
$35,856.96.
July 1, 1885, amount available     ....................                 .......      ......-----....     $143 04
July 1, 1886, amount available ......................                               .... ..--
                                                                      .......... ------....               143 04
  (See Appendix 0 13.)
  14. Harbor of refuge at Stonington, Connecticut.--This harbor lies on
the north side of the eastern entrance from the ocean into Long Island
Sound, and the main object of the improvement is to furnish a harbor
of refuge for vessels entering and leaving this entrance to the sound.
                            RIVER- AND               HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                   79
   Originally it was an open bay, unprotected from southerly storms,
and obstructed by a shoal, having a low water depth of but 6 feet at
the shoalest part. This shoal nearly filled the inner harbor, and left
but a narrow channel on either side, of a depth insufficient to permit
vessels of 12-feet draught to reach the upper wharves at low water.
   A short breakwater was constructed in the years 1828-1831, at a cost
of $34,766.65, for the protection of the commerce of the town of Ston-
ington. The enlarged project of 1871 for the improvement of this har-
bor, and its subsequent modification, under which work is now carried
on, embraced dredging in the upper harbor, and the construction of two
breakwaters in the outer harbor. One of these, the western, was to be
built out from Wamphassuck Point, the southwestern limit of the har-
bor, and to extend about 2,000 feet, and the other, the eastern, was to
extend from the vicinity of Bartlett's Reef to the Middle Ground. The
western breakwater was completed in 1880, at a cost of $103,190. The
amount expended in dredging in the upper harbor was about $45,000.
   The position of the western end of the eastern breakwater has not
been determined, but it will probably be found necessary, in order to
afford all the protection desired, to extend the breakwater at least until
it intersects a range from Stonington Light to the middle of Wicopessit
Island. It may then be found desirable to carry it still further, possi-
bly to the range from Stonington Light to the eastern end of Fisher's
Island.
   The amount expended upon the eastern breakwater up to the close
of the fiscal year ending June 30, 1885, including liabilities outstanding
at that date was $89,575.98, and its length at that date was 1,850 feet.
   For want of funds no work has been in progress during the last fiscal
year.
   The work required to be done is to finish the construction of the east-
ern breakwater. In case it be found that sufficient protection to the
harbor of refuge has been afforded when the' range from Stonington
Light to the middle of Wicopessit Island is reached, which will prob-
ably be the case, the length of breakwater yet to be built is about 720
feet.
   By reason of the great danger to the large passenger steamers of
the Stonington Line (New York and Boston), which the western end of
the breakwater now is, especially in foggy and thick weather, and will
be until it is completed and a light-house and fog-signal -are erected
upon it, it is very desirable that the whole amount necessary to finish
the breakwater be granted in one appropriation.
   The completion of this work will afford a thoroughly protected anchor-
age for vessels drawing 18 feet of water, and a harbor of refuge for the
immense commerce which daily passes between Long Island Sound and
the eastward.
   It is proposed to devote the small remainder on hand July 1, 1886,
and the appropriation made by the act of August 5, 1886, to the exten-
sion of the east breakwater as far as the funds will allow.
July 1, 1885, amount available---....................----....---------.............     $424 02
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885................----- ----.........................            123 70
July 1, 1886, amount available.........................................----.             300 32
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886 ...................                20,000 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887......................           20, 300 32
80      REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY

(Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project ......- - -.. $33, 000 00
' Amount that can be protitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1888 33, 000 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
  (See Appendix C 14.)
  15. Pawcatuck River, Rhode Island and Connecticut.-The navigable
part of this river extends from the important manufacturing town of
Westerly to Little Narragansett Bay, into which it empties. The ap-
proach to the river is through Stonington outer harbor and Little Nar-
ragansett Bay, and the object of the improvement is to deepen the river
channel to the depth to which the channel through the bay has been
dredged by the United States, and also to widen it.
  Betore improvement the channel was crooked and obstructed by
numerous shoals, on some of which there was but li feet at mean low
water.
  By means of appropriations made in the years 1871-1875 the river was
improved by the United States by the excavation of a channel 5J feet
deep at mean low water, and 75 feet wide below the wharves, and from
35 to 40 feet wide between the lower and the upper wharves. The re-
port of a resurvey of the river, made in compliance with the river and
harbor act of July 5, 1884, which contained an estimate of the cost
($38,637.50), recommended the further widening of the channel to 100
feet below htbe wharves, and by an additional width of two cuts of an
ordinary dredging machine, or about 40 feet, between the lower and
upper wharves; also the deepening of the entire channel to 8 feet at
mean low water.
  The commencement of this work has been sanctioned by Congress
making an appropriation of $12,000 therefor in the river and harbor act
of August 5, 1886.
  The amount expended on the original project was $50,000, and it was
completed.
  It is proposed to commence the work of widening and deepening the
channel according to the enlarged project at the deep water near Lot-
tery, and to carry it as far towards Westerly as the funds will admit,
and also to afford such relief as the commerce of the river may require
at the shoalest places in advance of the main work.
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886................... $12, 000 00
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project........--------26, 637 00
Amount that canbeprofitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1888      12, 000 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
  harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
  (See Appendix C 15.)
   16. Removing sunken vessels or craft obstructing or endangering naviga-
tion.-Wreck of the iron steamship Perkiomen, sunk by collision in the
Atlantic Ocean off Cape Cod, July 16, 1885. A contract was made for
removing all portions of the vessel above the depth of 35 feet below
mean low water, and, as far as possible, saving all parts that were val-
uable. The weather in the vicinity of the cape during the winter of
1885-'86 was exceptionally stormy, making the work of submarine blast-
ing difficult and dangetous, but the wreck was finally removed to the
depth required January 13, 1886.
    Wreck of the schooner Almon Bacon, sunk in the Atlantic Ocean off
Point Judith, Rhode Island, November 5, 1885. Report was made on
this wreck by the officer in chlarge of the district, and the notice to all
persons interested required by law was published, but no further action
became necessary. The masts of the vessel were taken out at the in-
stance of the owners, and all danger to navigation was thereby removed.
                     RIVER AND        HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                       81
   Wrecks of the schooners Mott Haven and Willie De Wolf, sunk by
collision in the Atlantic Ocean off the entrance to Narragansett Bay,
December 25, 1885. Report was made on these wrecks by the officer
in charge of the district, but no action by the War Department became
necessary. The Willie De Wolf drifted to the shore of Block Island,
where it did not endanger navigation, and the masts were taken out of
the Mott Haven at the instance of her owners, thus romoving all dan-
ger to passing vessels.
   Attention is invited to the remarks of the officer in charge respect-
ing a defect in the present laws governing the removal of wrecks en-
dangering navigation, and the additional legislation proposed by him
for its remedy.
   (See Appendix C, 16.)
IMPROVEMENT OF CONNECTICUT RIVER, MASSACHUSETTS AND CON-
  NECTICUT, AND OF RIVERS AND HARBORS ON LONG ISLAND SOUND,
  CONNECTICUT, AND NEW YORK.

   Officer in charge, Lieut. Col. D. C. Houston, Corps of Engineers.
   1. Connecticut River, Massachusetts and Connecticut.-Above Hart-
ford.- From Holyoke, Mass., 34 miles above Hartford, down to Enfield
Falls or Rapids, a distance of 18 miles, there is a fair channel 4 to 5 feet
deep. Enfield Rapids extend about 5 miles over a rocky and uneven bed,
with a total fall of 32 feet. From the foot of Enfield Rapids to Hartford,
a distance of 11 miles, the river-bed is broad and sandy, with a channel
3 to 4 feet deep. Several years ago the Connecticut River Company
constructed a small canal around Enfield Rapids, through which boats
of 3-feet draught and 80-feet length can pass.
   The first project for improvement of this parf of the river, approved
in 1871, provided for giving an increased depth to the channel by the
construction of wing-dams and dredging. In 1878 plans and estimates
were submitted for construction of a canal around Enfield Rapids;
these estimates were revised in 1880. The estimated cost cf this canal
was $1,322,805, but it was not considered advisable to commence con-
struction with a less sum than $450,000, which has not yet been ap-
propriated.
   Up to the close of the present fiscal year $100,000 have been appro-
priated for this part of the river, of which $75,886.28 have been ex-
pended.
   All the work done has been dredging and the construction of 7 wing-
dams under the project of 1871. The channel at summer level is navi-
gable for boats of 3-feet draught nearly to the foot of Enfield Rapids.
The wing-dams require slight repairs.
   No work of construction or repair has been done during the past fis-
cal year.
   The funds on hand from previous appropriations are sufficient for
such repairs and temporary improvement as will be needed during the
ensuing year.
   The benefit to be secured by a permanent improvement would be the
reduction of cost of transportation of bulky materials to a large manu-
facturing region, now wholly dependent on railroads.
July 1, 1885, amount available..---- .................. ---        ....------.... $24, 372 72
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885. -..-...... ....... .........    ....... ...........       259 00

July 1, 1886, amount available.... .,,    . ....   ... , ..... ,,, .. , ..... ,, .   ,,   24, 111 70
  (See Appendix D 1,)
      6
82         REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGEEERSS, U. S. ARMY.

   Below Hartford.-Between Hartford and Long Island Sound, a dis-
tance of 50 miles by course of channel, the depth on the bars was formerly
5 feet, the worst place being between Hartford and Middletown, a dis-
tance of 19 miles, and at Saybrook Bar, at the mouth of the river.
Dredging was carried on and small wing-dams constructed by private
parties up to 1870, with no permanent benefit. From 1870 to 1880 tem-
porary dredging was done annually by the Government, and jetties on
the Saybrook Bar were begun.
   In 1880 a project for permanent improvement was adopted, providing
for a channel 200 feet wide and 9 feet deep from Hartford to Long
Island Sound, to be obtained by rectification and protection of the banks
between Hartford and Middletown, by construction of permanent works
to confine the current, and by such additions to the Saybrook jetties and
such annual dredging as might become necessary, the cost of which
could not then be determined; the estimated cost of all but the last two
items was $330,000.
   The total amount appropriated and expended since the adoption of
this project is $135,000.
   Two of the permanent works have been built, a training-wall at Hart-
ford Bar and another at Glastonbury Bar, the cost being $37,500; the
east and west jetties at Saybrook have been completed, and a channel
120 feet wide and 12 feet deep has been dredged between them; from
$5,000 to $10,000 have been annually expended in dredging to main-
tain 9 feet depth on the bars between Hartford and Middletown.
   During the past fiscal year $5,813.51 have been expended in complet-
ing the Saybrook jetties and in the necessary annual dredging.
   The most important part of the improvement of this river is the dredg-
ing of channels through the bars immediately after the spring freshets.
For this purpose $13,000 could be profitably expended during the fiscal
year ending June 30,1888, and for repair of the existing wing-walls and
of the east jetty at Saybrook, $12,000.
July 1, 1885, amount available .......------------..........
                                                       ---......-----........----...--..---.....   $5, 813 51
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885---       ----      --....---.. ............ ............--.              5, 813 51
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886 ...................                             26, 250 00
(Amount   (estimated) required for completion of existing project....... 169,000 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1888 25, 000 00
  Submitted in compliance with require ments of section 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix D 1.)
   2. Thames River, Connecticut.--This river is a tidal stream extending
from the city of Norwich 15 miles south to Long Island Sound. For 11
miles above its mouth the depth varies from 16 to 80 feet; improvements
have been virtually confined to a stretch of 31 miles below Norwich, in
which the most troublesome bars lie. In 1829 the channel depth over
these bars was 5 feet at mean low water.
   In 1836 a project was approved for making the channel 100 feet wide
and 14 feet deep at high water (11 feet at low water) by dredging and by
building piers. In 1878 a channel 14 feet deep at low water was pro-
jected, and in 1882 a modification was adopted, providing for a channel
200 feet wide and 14 feet deep, to be obtained by dredging and by build-
ing 5 dikes or training-walls along the outer curves of the river. The
estimated cost was $208,080.
   The total amount appropriated for this river is $281,800, of which
 $75,247.65 have been expended since the adoption of the present pro-
ject,
                         RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                   83
   Three of the proposed dikes have been completed, and 1,026 linear
feet of the fourth one have been built, being about one-quarter of its
total length, Dredging was done between the dikes in 1882, 1883, and
1884. Two of the dikes need slight repairs; the channel has about 10
feet available depth.
   During the past fiscal year $12,499.95 have been expended in com-
l)leting the third dike and in building 1,026 linear feet of the fourth.
   One hundred thousand dollars could be advantageously expended dur-
ing a single year in completing the remaining dikes and in dredging.
July 1, 1885, amount available.......................................-------------------..         $17,252 30
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1885 ....              ........--       .. ...----.$12, 499 95
July 1, 1886, outstanding liabilities----.........--....--        . ....-- ....            64 04
                                                                                                    12, 563 99

July 1, 1886, amount available-----------..................--------- -------.......-------
                                                                           ............--.           4,688 31
Amount approprial:ed by act approved August 5, 1886.... ................                            22, 500 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887--- ............----....                       27,188 31
  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project........ 105,580 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1888 35,000 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix D 2.)
   3. New London Harbor, Connecticut.-This harbor includes the lower
three miles of Thames River, from the New London wharves to Long
Island Sound.
   The project for its improvement, adopted in 1880, and slightly modi-
fied in 1882, provides for removing to a depth of 16 feet, at mean low
water, the southerly part of a shoal of sand and bowlders lying east of
the New London Northern Railroad Wharf. The original depth on this-
shoal was from 6 to 15 feet.
   Seventeen thousand eight hundred dollars have been appropriated
for and expended on this work.
   The project is about seven-eighths completed, the required depth
having been made over nearly the whole area contemplated in the
plans.
July 1, 1885, amount available......$160                                                                   64
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
                                                   --...---............--......---....
  outstanding July 1, 1885----....---....-----........                         ----                    160 64
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886 ...................                               2, 000 00
  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project .......--------.                    4,200 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year endingJune30,1888                            4,200 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix D 3.)
  4. Clinton Harbor, Connecticut.- This harbor lies 10 miles west of the
mouth of the Connecticut River. Its channel runs for nearly a mile
inside of a beach through which a breach was made about 45 years ago,
after which the channel shoaled in two places from 8 to 4 feet.
  The project for improvement, adopted in 1882, provided for closing
the breach, and if that did not restore the channel, for dredging 100 feet
wide, and 6 feet deep, at low water, through the shoals; the entire cost
was estimated at $10,000.
  Three thousand dollars have been appropriated for this harbor, and
$2,747.37 have been expended.
84        REPORT       OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

  A riprap dike was built across the breach in 1883; it requires some
repairs. The channel depth has not changed since 1882.
July 1, 1885, amount available.--...........--..--.................     .. ....      $306 73
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885.............................................                54 00
July 1, 1886, amount available...........................----..---..........--..      252 73
SAmount (estimated) required for completion of existing project-..-......          7,000 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1_67.
   (See Appendix D 4.)
   5. New Haven Harbor, Connecticut.-The original available low-water
depth up to the wharves in this harbor was about 9 feet.
   The first project for deepening the channel provided for making it 13
feet deep, which was done in 1871; it was widened at different times
until 1878, when a project was adopted for dredging a channel 16 feet
deep and not less than 400 feet wide. The required depth over the
Fort Hale Bar is to be rendered permanent by means of a dike running
out from Sandy Point, on the west shore of the harbor, with an arm
parallel to the channel; its cost was estimated at $100,000.
   Up to the close of the fiscal year $241,000'had been appropriated for
this harbor, and nearly all expended.
   A 16-foot channel has been obtained from 400 to 600 feet wide, ex-
cept over the Fort Hale Bar. The shore arm and 254 feet of the chan-
nel-arm of the Sandy Point Dike have been built.
   During the past fiscal year $9,850.58 have been expended in dredging
in the upper part of the harbor to enlarge the water-way under Tom-
linson's Bridge, and to widen the channel; the increased width was
from 40 to 120 feet, the depth made being 12 feet; its object was to
provide a place for vessels waiting to discharge, without obstructing
passage through the channel.
   The sum of $80,000 is estimated as required to complete the project.
This sum could be profitably expended during a single year in com-
pleting the Sandy Point Dike, and in dredging.
July 1, 1885, amount available- ------------------------------------ $10, 276 82
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1885....---........---------............ $9, 850 58
July 1, 1886, outstanding liabilities ..........................               290 00
                                                                               --   10,140 58

July 1, 1886, amount available........................................                 136 24
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886..................                20,000 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887 ....................          20, 136 24
  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project........            80, 000 00
  Amount that can be profitablyexpended in fiscal year ending June 30,1888          40,000 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
  (See Appendix D 5.)
  6. Breakwater at New Haven, Connecticut.-In 1880 a project was
adopted for making a large and convenient harbor of refuge at the
entrance of New Haven Harbor by the construction of two riprap
breakwaters, at an estimated cost of $1,311,134. No modification of
this project has been made, except slight changes of cross-section in
1880.
  The total armonat appropriated for this belty;gwgr is
                                                      (4    00001 f
which $318,444,14 have ben expelded,
                         RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                        85
  The east breakwater has been built 2,147 linear feet, being nearly
two-thirds its contemplated length. The west breakwater is not begun.
  No work was done on the breakwater during the past fiscal year.
Expenditures were made for current office expenses, and for an exam-
ination into the condition of the work.
  The east breakwater is now far enough advanced to warrant begin-
ning the westerly one, and carrying on both at the same time; $500,000
could be profitably expended on the two breakwaters during the ensu-
ing year.
July 1, 1885, amount available .........     ...............--...........---.       $3, 032 49
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1885 ........ .......---..             $1, 476 63
July 1, 1886, outstanding liabilities                               ....
                                         ......-----............--- ---      140 00
                                                                                               -          1, 616 63

July 1, 1886, amount available................... ......-..-............                                  1,415 86
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886 ...................                                   75,000 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887 -                          -................. 76, 415 86
     Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project .......-1,016,134 00
     Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1888. 1 0,000 00
     Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
 (     harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
     (See Appendix D 6.)
   7. Milford Harbor, Connecticut.--This harbor consists of a broad,
open bay, from the head of which a small tidal stream extends three-
quarters of a mile to the village wharves. Originally the depth on the
bar at the mouth of the river was 2 feet at mean low water. Above
that the channel was nearly bare in places.
  Under the first project of improvement, adopted in 1872, a channel
4 feet deep and 100 feet wide was excavated through the bar, and
thence 60 feet wide to the village wharves; small jetties were built to
protect the east bank from erosion, and two jetties were built to pre-
serve the channel on the bar, at a total cost of $34,600. In 1881 a
project was adopted for making a channel over the bar 8 feet deep and
100 feet wide, at an estimated cost of $11,000.
  The total sum appropriated for this harbor is $39,600. Of this
$4,758.98 have been expended (on the last project, and the channel of
8 feet depth has been made 65 feet wide.
  No work was done during the past fiscal year.
  The officer in charge reports that the project could be satisfactorily
completed in one year, at the estimated cost of $6,000.
July 1, 1885, amount available- ..-......-......-....-............                          .......       $269 29
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885 -......----- ---..........------...--.-- ..--.....---------......---....
                                                                                                 ----.       28 27
July 1, 1886, amount available ...................                    .----    ..........                   241 02
     Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project.... ....                             6,000 00
     Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
       harbor acts of 1b66 and 1867.
     (See Appendix D 7.)
  8. Housatonic River, Connecticut.--The navigable part of this river
extends from Derby, Conn., to Long Island Sound, a distance of 13
miles, and was originally obstructed by several bars upon which the
low-water depth was from 3 to 5 feet.
  In 1871 a project was adopted for making and maintaining a chan-
nel 100 feet wide and 7 feet deep at mean low water throughout this
86         REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

distance; besides the necessary dredging, it contemplated building a
breakwater east of the channel over the bar at the river's mouth.
  The amount appropriated for this river is $71,200, of which $67,859.18
have been expended.
  A channel of the required depth has been dredged several times
through the worst bars; the present available depth over them is about
5 feet.
   During the past fiscal year a channel 35 feet wide and 7 feet deep was
excavated over the bar at the mouth under contract with oyster plant-
ers, who wished to use the material, and did the work free of cost to
the Government. A similar contract is now in progress for making a
channel 9 feet deep and 70 feet wide through the bar. The permanency
of this channel, without protection from a jetty, is by no means assured.
   During the ensuing year $10,000 could be expended advantageously
in building a jetty at the mouth of the river, in removing Drew's Rock,
and in maintaining a navigable channel 7 feet deep.
July 1, 1885, amount available.................... ...... .....----- ..........                              $4, 495 85
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
                                    ................................
  outstanding July 1, 1885.........----------                                                                 1 155 03
July 1, 1886, amount available..... .....................................                                     3,340 82
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886 ....                                  ---...........---    5,000 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887 ..........                           ....       ...     8, 340 82
  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project - - ------ 25, 000 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1888 10, 000 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix D 8.)
   9. Bridgeport Harbor, Connecticut.--The available depth in this har-
bor was originally 5 feet at mean low water.
   The first project for improvement provided for a jetty on the east
shore to check the influx of sand, and for dredging to make a channel
200 feet wide and 12 feet deep at mean low water. In 1882, after the
jetty had been built and the desired channel secured, a project was
adopted for widening to 600 feet the channel from the inner beacon to
the Naugatuck Railroad Wharf, to provide room for vessels driven in by
bad weather without blocking the main channel. The estimated cost of
the latter project was $60,000.
   Two hundred and ten thousand dollars have been appropriated for
this harbor, of which $15,000 have been appropriated for, and nearly
all expended on, the present project.
   The channel has been made 440 feet wide and 12 feet deep between
the inner beacon and the railroad wharf. Shoals have been formed in
parts of the channel which will require excavating.
    No work was done during the past fiscal year.
July 1, 1885, amount available ............................-----------------------... ....
                                                                                        .....--                $792 78
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885...............................------------------------------------...........        619 30
July 1, 1886, amount available  ...... ...........---------- .........                           ......          173 48
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886 ....                           ....    ..... ....         20, 000 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887......... ....... ....
                                                                        -                                    20,173 48

   Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1888                                25, 000 00
   Submit.ed in compliance with requirements of section 2 river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
     (See Appendix D 9.)
                      RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                           87

   10. Black Rock Harbor, Connecticut.-This harbor consists of a bay
partly sheltered by Fairweather Island, and of two small tidal streams
extending inland from the head of the bay.
   The depth in Cedar Creek, the most important of these streams, was
from 2 to 4 feet at low water, and the channel was narrow and very
crooked.
   The project for improvement, submitted in 1883, includes dredging a
channel, 3,300 feet long, 80 feet wide, and 6 feet deep to extend up Cedar
Creek, and a breakwater 2,700 feet long from Fairweather Island to the
mainland; the estimated cost was $80,000.
   Twenty thousand dollars have been appropriated and nearly all ex-
pended upon this project.
   The breakwater has been built the full length, though not to the width
and height projected, and the channel has been dredged 35 feet wide,
6 feet deep, and 2,700 feet long.
  During the past fiscal year 5,540 tons of stone were delivered in the
breakwater, giving it the full length required.
  Under the next appropriation dredging will be done as provided by the
project; $20,000 could be profitably expended for this work during the
next fiscal year.
July 1, 1885, amount available...... ....................................                $9, 972 76
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885........--------...........................---- -......         9,168 56
July 1, 1886, amount available.-------.......--..----
                                                 ..........................                 804 20
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886...................                     5,000 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887.... ........ ......                 5, 804 20
  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project-.......                 55,000 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1888             20, 000 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix D 10.)
   11. Southport Harbor, Connecticut.-The original depth in this harbor
from Long Island Sound to the village wharves was but 2 feet at low
water. Between 1829 and 1838 a breakwater and dike were built east
of the channel to protect it from drifting sand.
  The project for improvement, adopted in 1876 and modified in 1880,
included repairing the breakwater and dikes, and dredging a channel
100 feet wide and 4 feet deep to the village wharves.
  Thirty-one thousand eighty-seven dollars and twenty-three cents
have been appropriated for this harbor, of which $18,000 have been ap-
plied to the last project.
   The breakwater and dike have been repaired and the channel has
been made 4 feet deep with a width of 95 feet outside the end of the
breakwater, and 50 to 80 feet wide above that point.
   Nothing was done during the past fiscal year.
   Although the proposed width of channel has not been fully secured,
this improvement may be considered completed as far as is now needed.
   No appropriation is required for the ensuing fiscal year.
July 1, 1885, amount available...... ..................           ..... ..
                                                           ........                ..      $159 07
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885...--....--.---- ---- -------- --- ----....-........----...
                                                                               ....          79 47
July 1, 188, amount available ----..................       ..   ...........   ....   .       79 60
   (See Appendix D 11.)
88          REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

   12. Norwalk Harbor, Connecticut.-This harbor consists of the tidal
part of Norwalk River, extending from Norwalk to Long Island Sound,
a distance of 3 miles. South Norwalk is about 1 miles below Norwalk.
Originally the depth up to South Norwalk was about 5 feet at low
water; between there and Norwalk the bed ran nearly bare.
   The first project for improvement contemplated a channel 100 feet
wide and 6 feet deep from Long Island Sound to Norwalk. In 1881
this project was modified to provide for 8 feet depth below South Nor-
walk. The last estimate for this work places the cost from commence-
ment at $84,000.
   Seventy-four thousand two hundred and forty-six dollars and sixty-
six cents have been appropriated, and nearly all expended upon this
project; some parts of the river have required dredging several times.
  A channel has been made 100 feet wide and 8 feet deep to South
Norwalk, and thence to Norwalk from 60 to 100 feet wide and 6 feet
deep. This channel is in a navigable condition, though it has shoaled in
places from 1 to 2 feet.
  The contract in operation at the beginning of the last fiscal year was
completed, resulting in widening the 8-foot channel below South Nor-
walk to 100 feet.
   The amount estimated as required for the completion of the project
could be advantageously expended in a single year.
July 1, 1885, amodnt available-- ------..........................................            ----          $3,713 34
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885------..........................................------------------------..---.    2,960 12
July 1, 1886, amount available ......--.....
                                       ------....---...--------.......---........---.                          753 22
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886 -..                  .... ..........                     3, 000 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887--...----....--...----...-------......                 3,753 22
  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project--.......
                                                                     ------                                 7, 000 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1888                                7, 000 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix D 12.)
  13. Port Chester Harbor, New York.-This harbor consists of a bay
opening into Long Island Sound at the mouth of the Byram River and
of the lower part of the river itself, which is navigable for about a mile
above its mouth. The original available depth in the river was not
above a foot at low water, and Salt Rock in the river and Sunken Rock
in the bay were considered dangerous obstructions.
   The scheme for improvement, adopted in 1871, provided for the re-
moval of these rocks to 9 and 11 feet depth respectively, and for the
construction of a breakwater on the bar at the mouth of the harbor, at
an estimated cost of $96,632. In 1884 the project was amended to pro-
vide for dredging a channel 3 feet deep and from 60 to 100 feet wide
from the bay to the vicinity of the wharves.
   The total amount appropriated for this harbor is $27,000, of which
$24,490.38 had been expended up to July 1, 1886.
   Salt Rock has been removed to the required depth of 9 feet at mean
low water, and a channel 21 feet deep and not less than 40 feet wide has
been nearly completed to the wharves.
   During the past fiscal year dredging has been carried on and is still
in progress, with a view to straightening the channel and giving it a
uniform depth. This will be completed under a contract now in force.
   Future appropriations will be applied to the removal of Sunken Rock,
as irovided in the project for improvement.
                          RIVER AND HARBOR                           IMPROVEMENTS.                                     89
July 1, 1885,     amount available                                                                          $4,913 18
                                                                                                            $...............--...................
July 1, 1886,     amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
   liabilities    outstanding July 1, 1885.--..        -----.----.                             $2, 403 56
July 1, 1886,     outstanding liabilities...................--..---...                             942 54
                                                                                                              3,346 10
July 1, 1886, amount available ...-...................                                ..................      1,567 08

SAmount (estimated) required for completion of existing project........ 69,632 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix D 13.)
   14. New Rochelle Harbor, New York.-This harbor consists mainly of
a narrow and crooked channel lying between rocky islands.
   The project for improvement, adopted in 1871, provided for removal
of two rocks and for dredging and removing a reef to secure a channel
6 feet deep and 100 feet wide between Hunter's and Flat islands; the
estimated cost was $40,825.
   Thirty-five thousand dollars have been appropriated for this work;
of this sum $17,493.63 have been expended.
   The channel has been dredged and the reef removed to sufficient ex-
tent, though not quite as far as projected; one of the rocks, Corning
Rock, has been removed to the required depth of 12 feet; upon the
other, Rock Z C," no work has been done.
   Nothing was done during the past fiscal year.
   The balance available is probably sufficient for removing Rock " C,"
should it be found, on examination, that the necessity for its removal
still exists.
July 1, 1885, amount available...... ....................................  $18,210 61
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885 .............................................       704 24
July 1, 1886, amount available ......                .............     .....................                17,506 37

SAmount (estimated) required for completion of existing project------........ -5,                               825 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
  (See Appendix D 14.)
  15. Echo iarbor,  New Rochelle, New York.-The channel of this harbor
was obstructed by two reefs, Start Rock and Sheepshead Rock, the for-
mer bare at low water, the latter covered to a foot depth or more.
  The project for improvement, adopted in 1876, provided for the re-
moval of these reefs to 6 feet and 9 feet depths, respectively. Subse-
quently the project was modified to provide for a depth of 7 feet over
Start Rock. The estimated cost was $38,955.38.
  Twenty-two thousand dollars have been appropriated for this har-
bor, of which $19,743.13 have been expended.
  Start Rock has been wholly removed to 7 feet depth and part of
Sheepshead Rock to 9 feet depth.
  The available funds were not sufficient for continuing operations on
Sheepshead Rock, and nothing was done during the past fiscal year.
  According to the estimate the amount required for completion of the
project is $17,000.
July 1, 1885, amount available .........................................                                    $3, 361 87
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885 .-......- ...............................   ...                                        105 00
July 1, 1886, amount available..................                       ........................               3, 256 87
92         REPORT OF THE               CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

  The project for improvement, adopted in 1872 and modified in 1873,
provided for a channel 9 feet deep at high water, extending to a point
3,000 feet above Lockwood's, and for 5,800 feet of diking to maintain
the channel. The estimated cost was $136,500.
  Of this sum $54,000 have been appropriated and nearly all expended.
   The channel has been made 9 feet deep and 125 feet wide to the head
of Goose Island, one-half mile from the mouth of the creek ; thence to
Town Dock from 40 to 90 feet wide, and from Town Dock to Lockwood's
100 feet wide, and 1,235 linear feet of diking have been built.
  No work was done during the past fiscal year.
                                     ............................
July 1, 1895, amount available--....-----                                ........ ..              $81 50
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885----............--..---- ----.---.....-------- ------...............-
                                                                           .... ....               32 60
July 1, 1886, amount available......................-----------
                                                             ........               ....-...       48 90
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886.....--...-.... -                   ...      10, 000 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887........-----------..-------........      10, 048 90
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project - -- - -                       72,500 00
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1888                    10, 000 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1857.
   (See Appendix D 20.)

IMPROVEMENT OF HUDSON RIVER AND OF HARBORS OF RONDOUT AND
  SAUGERTIES, NEW YORK-REMOVING OBSTRUCTIONS IN EAST RIVER
  AND HELL GATE--IMPROVEMENT OF RIVERS AND HARBORS IN THE
  VICINITY OF NEW YORK AND IN NORTHERN NEW JERSEY-IMPROVE-
  MENT OF ENTRANCE TO NEW YORK HARBOR.

   Officer in charge, Lieut. Col. Walter McFarland, Corps of Engineers,
with Lieut. George McC. Derby, Corps of Engineers, under his im-
mediate orders.
   1. Hudson River, New York.-The improvement of the channel of this
river has been chiefly confined to a stretch of about 21 miles, extending
from Troy, at the head of navigation 6 miles above Albany, down to New
Baltimore, about 14 miles below Albany.
   Before the present scheme of improvement was adopted in 1867, a
depth of 7.5 feet could be carried at low water from New Baltimore to
Albary, and 7.2 feet from Albany to Troy. According to the survey
made in September, October, and November, 1884, 10 feet could then be
carried from New Baltimore to Albany, except at one point, Beacon
Island, where there was a depth of but 8.8 feet at mean low water, and
8 feet could be carried from Albany to Troy, except at Covill's Folly and
Patroon's Island, where the depths were 7.8 and 7.5 feet, respectively, at
low water.
   The channels over several of these shoals have since been deepened
by the dredges employed by the State.
   The project for the improvement of the river adopted in 1867, pro-
vided for securing, by means of longitudinal dikes and by dredging,
channels of 11 feet deep at mean low water, between New Baltimore and
Albany, and 9 feet deep between Albany and Troy.
   The original estimate of cost was increased by the addition of new
work in 1868, and again in 1882, when the total cost of executing the
project was estimated at $1,062,304; of this amount the sum of $1,053,538,
has been appropriated, including $26,250 appropriated by the act of
                             RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                                   91
   The project for improvement, adopted in 1871 and modified in 1875
and 1877, provided for making an entrance channel 100 feet wide and
8 feet deep at mean low water, by dredging through the bar and pro-
tecting the cut by two jetties. The estimated cost of this work was
$79,000, which has all been appropriated.
   The channel has been dredged to the width and depth provided; the
east jetty has been made 1,390 feet long, and the west jetty 940 feet;
at the time of completion they extended, respectively, to 10 and 61
feet depth.
   No operations were carried on during the past fiscal year.
  This improvement is completed for the present; it may become neces-
sary to extend the project in order to maintain the channel perma-
nently.
  No appropriation is needed for the ensuing year.
July 1, 1885, amount available ................................                                             .......       $475 06
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
   outstanding July 1, 1885 .............................................                                                   90 70

July 1, 1886, amount available--- ..................                            ..........           .........             384 36
    (See Appendix D 18.)
  19. Flushing Bay, New York.-Before improvement the available
depth in this broad shallow bay and in the channel leading to Flush-
ing was less than 4 feet at mean low water.
  The project for improvement, adopted in 1879, contemplated building
16,700 feet of diking, to form a tidal basin, which, by filling and dis-
charging through the main channel, would maintain a channel depth of
6 feet or more at mean low water, after once dredging; the material of
the bottom is soft mud. The estimated cost of this work was $173,500.
  Nearly all of the appropriations for this harbor, amounting to
$60,000, have been expended.
  The dike on the west side of the channel has been built 3,057 feet
long, and the channels through the bay and up the -east and west
branches of Flushing Creek have been dredged 6 feet deep; the former
twice.
   No operations were carried on during the past fiscal year, except
placing beacons to mark the dike at high tide.
   Thirty-five thousand dollars could be profitably expended during the
ensuing fiscal year in extending the dike and in maintaining the chan-
nel depth.
July 1, 1885, amount available ............--................--..............                                             $699 02
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
   outstanding July 1, 1885.................--------..--...........----                      ............                  326 55

July 1, 1886, amount available ............................------------------------------------.........--.    372 47
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886............---..--                      - --          . 10, 000 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887....................                                               10, 372 47
   Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project                                            ------.   103,500 00
   Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1888 35, 000 00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
    (See Appendix D 19.)
   20. East Chester Creek, New York.-This is a small tidal stream empty-
ing into Pelham Bay; it was navigable at high tide to vessels draw-
ing 7 feet, up to Lockwood's, a distance of 24 miles. The rise of tide is
7.1 feet.
90        REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

 (Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project. ....                       ...   17, 000 00
 ! Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1888                       3, 000 00
1  Submitted in compliance with requirements c( section 2 of river and
     harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix D 1.5.)
   16. Mamaroneck Harbor, New York.-This harbor consists of a narrow
inlet opening into a broad bay. Several dangerous rocks lay in or near
the channel. The low-water depth to the Old Steamboat Wharf, about
half way up the inlet, was 5 feet; from there to the upper wharves it
was about 1 foot.
   A project for improvement was adopted in 1882, providing for the
removal of one rock to 4 feet depth, of five rocks to 7 feet depth, and
for making a channel 100 feet wide and 7 feet deep up to the Old Steam-
boat Wharf, thence to the village wharves 80 feet wide and 4 feet deep;
the estimated cost was $43,000.
   Fifteen thousand dollars have been appropriated for this harbor and
nearly all expended.
   Three of the rocks have been removed to the required depth; no
dredging has been done.
July 1,1885, amount available           ...............................             ......           $301 23
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885..............................................                             .    77 00
July, 1, 1886, amount available ...................................................                      224 23
SAmount (estimated) required for completion of existing project........                           '28, 000 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
    harbor act of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix D 16.)
   17. Greenport Harbor, New York.-This harbor, at the eastern end of
Long Island, is exposed to easterly storms ; its anchorage ground, which
was sheltered by Joshua's Point, has materially shoaled by erosion of
the point and by the influx of drifting sand.
   The project of improvement, adopted in 1882, provided for construc-
tion of a riprap breakwater, extending from Joshua's Point 1,700 feet in a
southeasterly course, to arrest drifting sand, to check the erosion of the
point, and to increase the sheltered area; its cost was estimated at
$16,000.
   Twenty thousand dollars have been appropriated for this harbor, and
nearly all expended.
   The breakwater has been built out to the 10-foot curve, a distance of
1,233 feet.
July 1, 1885, amount available ................................................                       $300 78
July 1, 1886, amount available .............. ....... ................ ....                            300 78
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886 ............        ....                         5, 000 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887 ..                  .................         5, 300 78
  Amount (estimated) revuired for completion of existing project........ 21,000 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1888 10, 000 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
    (See Appendix D 17.)
    18. Port Jefferson Harbor, New York.-This harbor is a large, deep
bay, with a narrow entrance at the outer side, of which the channel
depth was but 3 feet at mean low water.
                                             RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                                           93
Congress, approved August 5, 1886, which would leave $8,766 still to
be appropriated. But of this amount over $35,000 have been already
expended on the repair of the existing works, and the last two appro-
priations of July 5, 1884, and August 5, 1886, amounting to $56,250
must be applied in the same way to repairs and not to construction.
   Of the works included in the original estimate, six yet remain to be
constructed or completed.
These were estimated to cost in 1832....---.---.......................---------------------..----...                                             $78,000
To which must be added the removal of a rock near Van Wie's Point in the
  Overslaugh Channel, not included in the original estimate, estimated
  at    ............----....---..........--------                  ----...........-------.......................                                  16,000

          Total .................................                                 ................                           ..........           94, 000
  Since 1882 little or nothing has been done towards their completion,
the funds having been chiefly spent in repairs, so that this amount,
$94,000, is still required for the completion of the scheme of improve-
ment.
  The act of August 5, 1886, reads:
Improving Hudson River, New York: Continuing improvement, $26,250; of which
which $15,000 may be used for the removal of the rock in channel at Van Wie's Point.
  Considering the satisfactory results hitherto obtained, the material
assistance afforded by the State of New York every year, and the large
commerce of the river, the present funds made available for this im-
provement, by act of Congress approved August 5, 1886, will be applied
to the repair of existing works, and a further sum of $94,000 should be
appropriated for the completion of the original project.
July 1, 1885, amount available .........................................                                                                       $31,570 74
Received from sales of fuel .   -..-......         ....-- ...........................                                                               39 36

                                                                                                                                               31,610 10
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885------ -----..--..           .-
                                                     .--.-    . ..----.                                                                          3, 091 70
July 1, 1886, amount available ........................................                                                                         28, 518 40
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886 .--                                                                     -
                                                                                                                   --.............. -..-   .    26, 250 00

Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887...-................                                                                       54,768 40
   Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project.- -.... -                                                                     94, 000 00
   Amount that can beprofitably expendedinfiscal year ending June 30, 188                                                                        8,750 00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
     harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
       (See Appendix E 1.)
   2. Harbor at Saugerties, New York.-To comply with the river and
harbor act of August 2, 1882, two projects for the improvement of the
mouth of this harbor, so as to give an 8-foot channel, by means of par-
allel dikes and dredging, were submitted November 28, 1883. For one
plan the estimated cost was $46,419.80. For a second plan the esti-
mated cost was $43,113.50.
    In view of the fact that the State of New York had undertaken to
make some improvement here it was decided not to begin work, but to
wait until further examination could be made.
    No work has been done by the United States Government during the
year, but the State of New York has dredged a channel 8 feet deep
and about 200 feet wide from the 8-foot curve in the Iudsor iRiver to
the 8-foot                 eurve                   inside the mouth of the sopus greek,
94          REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

  With the balance of the old appropriation and the $15,000 appropri-
ated by act of Congress approved August 5, 1886, it is proposed to be-
gin the diking.
July 1, 1885, amount available . .....-----......----.---.............---------------........---------.   $4, 955 95
July 1, 1886, amount available .........................................                                   4,955 95
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886 ...................                                    15,000 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887 .-................                                  19, 955 95
   Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project .......                                 26,419 80
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of.section 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
    (See Appendix E 2.)
  3. Harborat Rondout, New York.-The original condition of the navi-
gable channel of this harbor showed a depth of about 7 feet at mean
low water.
   A project adopted in 1872 provided for the construction of two parallel
dikes running from the mouth of the creek into the Hudson River, and
a longitudinal dike on the river side, connecting with the north dike in
the creek, to direct the current of the Hudson River, and to protect
the dikes from running ice, and finally for such dredging in the channel
as would secure a depth of 13 feet at mean low water.
   The original estimate for this work was $172,000, subsequently modi-
fied to $104,000, of which $94,000 have been appropriated.
   The project has virtually been completed; there being a 13-foot chan-
nel between the dikes.
   No work has been done during the fiscal year. The $2,500 appropri-
ated by act approved August 5, 1886, will be applied to widening the
outlet between the dikes and making the necessary repairs to them.
   The estimated cost of completing the project and giving the outlet
the full width originally proposed is $10,000, of which $2,500 has been
appropriated.
July 1, 1885, amount available ..                     ........................      ..........               $60 36

July 1, 1886, amount available .----..--...---....------..
                                                        ---......---....----.......--.. ------....----.        60 36
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886 .-...........-......
                                                                   -                                       2, 500 00

Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887 ...... ............                                  2,560 36
  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project-----.......                               7, 500 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1888                               7,500 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
 ( harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
     (See Appendix E 3.)
   4. Harlem River, New York.--The survey of this work was directed
by an act of Congress approved June 23, 1874, and was made in the
fall of that year under the direction of General Newton. The prelimi-
nary report upon it was made February 18,1875, and a final report was
given in General Newton's annual report for 1884. It provides for se-
curing a channel from the Hudson River through Spuyten Duyvel
Creek and the Harlem River to the East River 15 feet deep at low water
and 400 feet wide, except in the cut which is to be made through Dyck-
man's Meadow, where the width, for the sake of economy, is to be re-
duced to 350 feet.
     The estimated cost of this work is $2,700,000, of which $400,000 have
                         RIVER AND HARBOR                      IMPROVEMENTS.                  95
been already appropriated, but with the condition attached that no part
of it is to be expended until the right of way for the improvement is
secured without cost to the United States.
  Under an act of the legislature of the State of New York all expenses
incurred iin securing the right of way and in paying for land damages
are to be assessed upon the property bordering on the line of the pro-
posed improvement.
   The report of the commissioners appointed by the supreme court of
the State of New York to secure the right of way free of cost to the
United States is still awaiting the action of the court, as stated in the
last annual report.
July 1, 1885, amount available ....................................            ....   $400,000 00
July 1, 1886, amount available ........................................                400, 000 00

  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project ...... 2, 300, 000 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix E 4.)
   5. Removing obstructions in East River and Hell Gate, New York.-
General John Newton, Chief of Engineers, retained the charge of these
works, with Lieut. Col. Walter McFarland, Corps of Engineers, on duty
in connection with them, and Lieut. George McC. Derby, Corps of En-
gineers, in superintendence of the operations at Flood Rock, and of the
steam-drilling scow until December 31, 1885, when the works were put
in charge of Lieut. Col. Walter McFarland, Corps of Engineers.
    In its original condition the channel of East River and Hell Gate was
obstructed by many large and dangerous reefs, some of which projected
above high water, others having least depths on them varying from
nothing to 17: feet at mean low tide. Owing to the violence of the cur-
rents, the sudden change at right angles in the direction of the river,
and the crowded condition of this thoroughfare, vessels were continu-
ally being wrecked on these reefs.
   The first project for the improvement of Hell Gate was adopted in
1867, and was subsequently modified in 1868, 1874, 1880, and 1884, by
extending it to embrace the removal of other reefs in Hell Gate and in
the East River. It now includes the removal to a depth of 26 feet at
mean low water of all the dangerous reefs in Hell Gate, Diamond Reef,
and North Brother Island Reef in the East River; the removal of Coen-
ties Reef, East River, to 251 feet, the removal of a number of small rocks
in the shoaler portions of the channels ; and the construction of sea-walls
on Great and Little Mill rocks, and on Hog's Back and Holmes Rock.
   The original estimate for this project was $5,139,120. The amount ex-
pended to the end of the fiscal year is $3,467,331.80, with which about
four-fifths of the project have been completed, greatly to the relief of
navigation.
   During the fiscal year the great mine at Flood Rock has been fired,
and the whole of the Middle Reef broken with entire success. About
$100,000, saved from the estimated cost of the blast, has been expended
in dredging, resulting in the production of a through channel 320 feet
wide and 18 feet deep at mean low water across the most dangerous por-
tion of the reef.
   The appropriation of $500,000 asked for is to be applied to continu-
ing the removal of the d6bris of Flood Rock by contract and to operat-
ing the Jnited States steam-drill scow on Heel Tap and Frying Pan.
96        REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

July 1, 1885, amount available .............       ..............           ..........        $267, 949 74
Received from sales of fuel......      ......    ........................                ..         29 25

                                                                                               267,978 99
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1885...................... $197,502 30
July 1, 1886, outstanding liabilities............. .....       29, 828 35
                                                                                               227, 330 65
July 1, 1886, amount available .....-...... ...... ..... ....                                   40, 648 34
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886--...............                            112,500 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887 ..................                       153, 148 34
  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project-....   1,488,843 67
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
    1888 .....................------- .----     ...--------- -------      500, 000 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix E 5.)
   6. Newtown Greek, New York.-This is a tidal stream about 4 miles long,
running through the eastern part of Brooklyn, and emptying into the
East River opposite Thirty-fourth street, New York City.
   It had originally a depth of but 124 feet at low water from its mouth
up to Vernon Avenue Bridge, a distance of 1,100 feet, its width for
this distance being about 240 feet; thence it gradually decreased in
depth and width until, at the head of navigation, where Metropolitan
avenue crosses it, there was a low-water depth of about 4 feet and a
width of about 100 feet.
   In 1880 it was decided to dredge a channel about 200 feet wide and
from 18 to 21 feet deep at low water from the mouth of the creek up
to Vernon Avenue Bridge, the estimated cost of which was $44,050.
   In 1884 a survey was made and a project adopted for carrying the
improvement from the Vernon Avenue Bridge to the head of naviga-
tion, a distance of about 4 miles, with a depth of 18 feet and a width of
175 feet from Vernon Avenue Bridge to the Central Oil Works; thence
to Queens County Oil Works 15 feet deep and from 120 to 150 feet in
width; thence to the Nichols Chemical Works 12 feet deep and from
125 to 150 feet wide; and thence to the head of navigation in both
branches, namely, the points where they are crossed by the Metropolitan
Avenue Bridge, 10 feet deep and from 100 to 125 feet wide.
   The estimated cost of this improvement was $211,519, making the
total estimated cost of the projected improvement of Newtown Creek
$255,569, of which $45,000 have been appropriated up to June 30, 1886.
   The only parts of the creek at which work has been done so far are
at the mouth, where a channel 18 feet deep and from 75 to 150 feet wide
has been excavated, extending from the East River up to Vernon
Avenue Bridge, a distance of a little over 1,000 feet; and also near the
head of the creek, where channels 10 feet deep and from 50 to 200 feet
wide have been dredged from Covert's Dock up to the head of naviga-
tion at Grand street, on the west branch, a distance of about 3,000 feet,
and from Covert's Dock up the east branch to the Grand Street Bridge.
   No work has been done during the past fiscal year.
   The act of Congress approved August 5, 1886, appropriating $37,500
for continuing the improvement directs " $9,375 to be expended on west
branch between Maspeth avenue and Dual Bridge, at Grand street and
Metropolitan avenue; $9,375 to be expended on main branch between
Easterly Grand Street Bridge to Metropolitan avenue; and balan on
lower end, from Saspeth avenue to the mouth of the creek,"
                              RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                                   97
   This appropriation will be applied to dredging channels at the points
indicated, which are at the upper end of the creek, and in the lower
portion of the creek; to widening the channel at Penny Bridge, and be-
low the Vernon Avenue Bridge.
   As the creek has no fall and as it is the receptacle for all the refuse from
the factories, refineries, and slaughter-houses of the east of Brooklyn,
constant deposits are forming in it, which will necessitate annual dredg-
ing, even after the project has been completed, and as the banks are of
marsh mud they will continue to wash into the channel until they are
protected by bulkheads the whole way up from the mouth.
   The commerce of the creek is so large that the improvement should
be pushed at least 3 miles up as rapidly as possible, and, in the opinion
of the officer in charge, $100,000 can be well applied there in the next
fiscal year.
July 1, 1885, amount available ----...--------------------.................---                                           $7,419 96
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885---............-----......---.-----.--....----.-----.......----......---------..............    1,110 43
July 1, 1886, amount available ......-...... .... ... ......... ... ......                                                6, 309 53
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886 .--..................                                                 37,500 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887 ............                                        -..-       .   43,809 53


   Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,18x8                                             40, 000 00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
    (See Appendix E 6.)
   7. Buttermilk Channel, New York.- This channel lies between the city
of Brooklyn, N. Y., and Governor's Island, New York Harbor, and is ob-
structed at its upper end, where it joins the'East River, by a shoal over
which there is a minimum depth of 91 feet at mean low water. The
crest of this shoal lies about 800 feet outside the line of the Brooklyn
wharves.
   The original project of improvement, adopted in 1881, provides for
the removal to a depth of 26 feet at mean low water of such parts of
the shoal as came within 850 feet of the Brooklyn wharves, which would
take off the crest of the shoal and give nowhere less than 15 feet water
on it.
   The estimated cost of this improvement was $210,000, of which
$190,000 has been appropriated up to June 30, 1886.
   With this the channel has been widened to the full width proposed,
and deepened to not less than 24 and probably 26 feet at mean low
water. But as no survey has been made since the last work done, it
cannot be definitely stated whether the full depth of 26 feet was ob-
tained by the last dredging.
   The importance of this part of the East River to the commerce of the
harbor is so great that it is proposed to remove the whole shoal to a
depth of 26 feet.
   The crest of the shoal has unquestionably a less depth of water upon it
than it had a few years ago, on account, principally, it is supposed, of the
ashes spilled from an ash scow which was anchored there to receive the
ashes from tug-boats and small steamers.
   The estimated cost of removing the remainder of the shoal to a depth
of 26 feet mean low water is $170,000 according to the latest data.
   In view of the importance of the improvement and the very large
             7E
98          REPORT OF THE CHIEF OTC ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

commerce in this part of New York Harbor, it is recommended that
$50,000 be granted to carry on the improvement.
  The appropriation of $56,250, by act approved August 5, 1886, will
be applied to widening the channel already dredged.
July 1, 1885, amount available---..--------...............-------..-----------................--.                      $324 97
July 1, 1886, amount available......------ -----------...................                                               324 97
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886 ...................                                               56,250 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887 ........--                                    .......          56, 574 97
  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project........ 113,750 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1888 50, 000 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
    harbor acts 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix E 7.)
   8. Gowanus Bay, New York. -The depth of water in the channels of
Gowanus Creek and Bay was originally only from 7 to 12 feet at mean
low water, which was wholly insufficient for the passage of vessels em-
ployed in the commerce of the district.
   The plan of improvement, adopted in 1881, provided for giving a
depth of 18 feet to the channels in the bay leading up tto the mouth of
the creek on both the north and south sides, and for carrying the im-
provement with the same depth up the creek to Hamilton Avenue Bridge,
a distance of about 1 mile. The channel widths were to be 200 feet except
for the last few hundred feet up to the bridge, where the width would
gradually decrease.
   The estimated cost of this improvement was $199,564.90, of which
$65,000 had been appropriated up to June 30, 1886. With this money
the northern channel leading up the creek has been completed and the
dredging has been carried on up the creek to within 2,100 feet of Ham-
ilton Avenue Bridge; and the southern channel has been dredged to
within 2,000 feet of the mouth of the creek.
   The act approved August 5, 1886, appropriated $7,500, which will be
expended in continuing the improvement.
   The commerce using the channels in Gowanus Bay and Creek is very
large, and $50,000 is recommended by the officer in charge for continu-
ing the improvement.
July 1, 1885, amount available-......... .....................--....-                                         ....     $167 74
July 1, 1886, amount available...... .............. . .. ......... ......                                                167 74
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886----...................
                                                                     --                                               7, 50 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887 ...................
                                                            -------------                                             7,667 74
   Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project-------120,064 90
   Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1888 20, 000 00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix E 8.)
   9. Gedney's Channel, New York.-The act of Congress approved July
5, 1884, appropriated $200,000 for deepening Gedney's Channel through
" Sandy Hook Bar, New York."
   No previous survey with a view to the improvement of this channel,
or of the interior channels of the lower bay of New York, had been or-
dered by Congress, or had been made under direction of the War De-
partment. Consequently, on the 5th of August, 1884, upon recommen-
dation of the Chief of Engineers, and Board of Engineers for Fortifica-
                   RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                  99
tions and for River and Harbor Improvements, the Secretary of War
ordered a survey to be made of the entrance to New York Harbor,
between Long Island and Sandy Hook, extending eastward to the 12-
fathom curve outside the bar, and westward to the west side of the
main ship-channel leading down from the Narrows to the point of
Sandy Hook.
   This survey was made under direction of Maj. G. L. Gillespie, Corps
of Engineers, in the autumn of 1884, and his report with maps was
submitted December 6, 1884.
   That report stated that the low-water depth on the bar was between
23 and 24 feet; that the large steamers making use of the harbor drew,
loaded, from 26 to 28 feet; and that the low-water depth on the bar
should be greater than this, in order to permit the passage of these
vessels at all stages of the tide. That such an increased depth could
only be maintained, probably, by the construction of permanent works
in the nature of dikes; but that as the act of Congress making the
appropriation distinctly designated that it should be applied to deep-
ening Gedney's Channel, the engineer in charge recommended that it
should be applied to dredging Gedney's Channel between the 30-foot
curves inside and outside of it, although there was a part of the channel,
near Flynn's Knoll, that was just as much in need of deepening; and
that in any event the experiment of keeping this channel open by
dredging ought to be tried before considering the question of construct-
ing permanent works for the same purpose.
   That report was referred to the Board of Engineers for Fortifications
and for River and Harbor Improvements, whose opinions in the matter
were summed up as follows:
  The Board recommends, as a general plan for improving the entrance to New York
Harbor so as to give 30 feet from New York to the ocean, the construction of a low-
water or half-tide stone dike, running about south southeast from Coney Island to
such distance as shall be found necessary, and probably not less than 4 miles, the pro-
tection of the head of Sandy Hook, and the dredging of a 30-foot channel from deep
water near Sandy Hook to deep water below the Narrows; also the immediate dredg-
ing of a channel 1,000 feet wide and 28 feet deep through the shoal west of Flynn's
Knoll, as soon as Congress shall furnish the funds; also that the existing appropria-
tion be applied to dredging Gedney's Channel to a depth of 28 feet.
  In regard to the expenditure of the $200,000 appropriated July 5,
1884, while the Board did not expect large results from dredging, they
recommended that the experiment should be made; but that if it was
found that the channels rapidly filled up during the dredging the work
should be suspended.
  Proposals were therefore asked for deepening the channel by one of
the different methods of dredging, and these were opened January 15,
1885, when a contract for dredging by means of a hydraulic plow or
water-jet was let to Roy Stone, with a provision that if, after fair trial,
his method should be found impracticable, the work could be stopped
without his receiving any pay from the Government. His method
proved to be a failure, and he was released from the contract at his own
request. No payment was made to him by the Government, as no re-
sults had been obtained.
  Proposals were therefore again invited, and opened June 23, 1885,
and a contract was awarded to Elijah Brainard July 21, 1885, at 54
cents per cubi cyard.
   The contractor proposed to put on a hydraulic pumping plant capable
of excavating 3,000 cubic yards of solid material per day. The plant was
built, and work was begun September 26, 1885, but the capacity of the
plant did not come up to the expectations of the builder or the require-
ments of the contract; and during the spring of 1886 the contractor
100        REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

built a second and larger plant; and also in May, 1886, hired a third
plant.
  Up to the close of the fiscal year, 86,708 cubic yards of material had
been excavated.
  Owing to difficulties in conducting the work, the contract was ex-
tended from June 30, 1886, to November 1, 1886.
  The average daily capacity of the three plants, on working days, ir-
respective of breakdowns, may be put at 3,400 cubic yards for a work-
ing day of 15 hours.
  On June 30, the channel had an increased depth of 1.5 feet for a
width ofB00 feet on the north side, giving nearly 25 feet of water, where
in places a little over 23 had existed before.
  This seemed to prove, up to June 30, at least, that it was possible to
deepen the channel by the method in use. But whether the channel so
dredged may be regarded as permanent, or even partly so, cannot be
determined until after the effects of the coming winter storms are ob-
served.
  If no material shoaling takes place on this bar during the winter, it
seems probable that the required depth may be preserved by annual
dredging, and it may be unnecessary to undertake the construction of
permanent works, but it is impossible to say yet whether it will be a
success or not.
  The river and harbor act approved August 5, 1886, appropriated
$750,000 for "improving New York Harbor, New York : To secure a
thirty-foot channel at mean low water at Sandy Hook entrance of the
harbor, upon such a plan as the Secretary of War may approve."
  It is probable that the larger part of this amount will be applied to
the dredging in both the outer and inner channels, as recommended by
the Board of Engineers in the extract from their report before given.
July 1, 1885, amount available ......----........ ----......         ......---- ....      ........-----.. $186, 469 35
July 1, t 86, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1,      P85
                                        ,......       -...       ......       .     ...   $27, 281 86
July 1, 1886, oustanding liabilities........--..             ..------......       ....     27, 115 37
                                                                                                           54,397 23

July 1, 1886, amount available ......................     ------------
                                                      ..................                                  132,072 12
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886...... ..              ......                           750, 000 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887 -.............
                                                                -                               ..   .    882,072 12
SAmount (estimated) required for completion of existing project-...... 6,000,000 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix E 9.)
  10. Sheepshead Bay, New York.-The project for this improvement,
adopted in 1879, provided for the maintenance of the natural outlet of
the bay into Rockaway Inlet, by means of diking and dredging, and
for the contraction of the channel in the bay above by means of dikes,
so as to afford a channel 6 feet deep up to the head of navigation about
2 miles above the mouth.
   The depth of water at the mouth was about 2 feet, but the channel
was uncertain and shifting. The rise and fall of tide was stated to be
4.5 feet.
   The estimated cost of the improvement was $100,000.
  A resurvey was made in 1882, when the old outlet was found to be
nearly closed up, and it was proposed to cut a new outlet 6 feet deep
and 100 feet wide north of the old one, into Dead Horse Inlet, and to
dredge the interior channels of the bay to a depth of 6 feet at mean low
water.
                       RIVER AND           IIARBOR        IMPROVEMENTS.                             101
  The estimated cost of this was $34,200, of which $16,000 had been
appropriated up to June 30, 1886.
  After some correspondence and delay the new outlet was excavated,
protected on the north side by a bulkhead built partly by the property-
owners and partly by the contractor who was doing the dredging for
the Government.
  The navigation of the bay is restricted almost entirely to pleasure
boats used by the Coney Island and Gravesend Bay hotels, and there
seems to be no present necessity for further appropriation for this im-
provement.
  The appropriation of $5,000, approved August 5, 1886, will be ap.
plied to dredging shoals in the cut and in closing up the old inlet which
has reopened during the last winter.
July 1, 1885, amount available ...... .................. ....... .......... $4, 967 83
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885--...---------   ------------------ -----------. 4,684 10
July 1, 1886, amount available----
                               ....-------.... --....---.................... .......... ----       283 73
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886 ....          -- ...... --....---.... .      5, 000 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887...................                        5,283 73
  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project------ - 13, 200 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending J une 30, 1888 10, 000 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix E 10.)
   11. Canarsie Bay, New York.-The project for this improvement,
adopted in 1879, was to obtain a channel, by means of diking and dredg-
ing, from the 6-foot curve in Jamaica Bay up to the Canarsie Dock, a
distance of about 3,500 feet. The proposed channel was to be 6 feet
deep at mean low water, the mean range of tides being 4.7 feet.
   The estimated cost of this improvement was $88,000, of which $23,000
had been appropriated up to the fiscal year ending June 30, 1886. With
this amount a pile dike 1,050 feet long was built on the north side of the
outer end of the channel, and a channel 6 feet deep and from 50 to 75
feet wide was dredged from the 6-foot curve in Jamaica Bay up to the
dock of Canarsie Landing. Narrow cuts were also made along two faces
of the dock.
   No work has been done during the fiscal year, but serious shoaling
has occurred at the upper and lower ends of the dike, and as the set of
the ebb current is directly across the line of the dike and dredged chan-
nel, it is evident that no permanent benefit will occur until the south
channel dike is built.
   Canarsie Landing, apart from having a large trade in oysters, clams,
and fish, is the terminus of the Brooklyn, Rockaway land Jamaica Bay
Railroad, from which point people transship to Rlockaway Beach. Two
steamers make six trips a day in summer from Canarsie to Rockaway,
besides one steamer running throughout the year to Barren Island.
  It is believed the construction of the south dike and a little more
dredging would give the necessary facilities to commerce.
July 1, 1885, amount available ......
                               -        ...... ..............      ...... ...                    $486 74
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885...... .... -- ....----
                                              -- ----....-
                                                        ....  .... .... .... ...... ..            287 63
July 1, 1886, amount available .----.....--.........- ----......--...                 .---.        199 11
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886.- ................                          10, 000 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887...................                       10,199 11
102       REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

(Amount   (estimated) required for completion of existing project.......------.        55,000 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1888            20,000 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river a.nd
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix E 11.)
   12. Sumpawanus Inlet, New York.-The original project, adopted in
1880, provides for dredging a channel about 4,500 feet long, 100 to 150
feet wide, and 5 feet deep at the mean low water from the 5-foot curve
in Great South Bay, up to the town of Babylon, Long Island.
   The navigable depth at the time of the survey, made with a view to
this improvement, varied from 5 feet at mean low water in the bay to
2 feet at the wharf, and thence from 1 to 2 feet at mean low water up
the creek a distance of a little over half a mile.
   The range of tides was approximately 1.3 feet.
   Owing to the peculiarities of the locality there was no scour in the
channel, nor could it be obtained by contracting the channel width,
and every indication was that, of late years, not only the channel, so
called, but that part of the Great South Bay near it has been filling in
gradually but steadily.
   The scheme proposed, therefore, was to give a 5-foot channel 100 feet
wide by dredging from the deeper waters of the bay up to the mouth
of the creek, a distance of 1,500 feet, and thence up the creek for a dis-
tance of 3,500 feet, the estimated cost being $23,115.
   Seven thousand dollars were appropriated for the improvement in
1881 and 1882, and with that a channel was dredged up to the mouth
of the creek not less than 75 feet wide from a point 750 feet southeast
of the dock at the mouth of the creek, and cuts 25 feet wide were made
round the sides of the dock.
   No work has been done since May 17, 1883.
   Owing to the high price of dredging and small appropriations, the
original estimate of cost was increased to $40,000.
   The commerce has changed materially since the original survey, and
most of the trade is now done by rail, except the summer trade, which
is carried in three steamboats of light draught over to Fire Island, and
in pleasure-boats of very light draught taking boating and fishing par-
ties out into Great South Bay.
   Any further appropriations for this work should be applied to giving
a good channel 5 feet deep from the deeper waters of Great South Bay
up to the mouth of the creek ; but apart from the steamboat interest the
commerce is too small to warrant a continuation of the improvement.
July 1, 1885, amount available ...... ---................................         --     $106 93
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885......... ....       ...................... ...........          25 05
July 1, 1886, amount available...........................         ..................       81 88
(Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project--------                33,000 00
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1888              5, 000 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix E 12.)
  13. Manasquan River, New Jersey.-The present project was adopted
in 1879, and provided for opening a direct outlet 6 feet deep and 250
feet wide into the Atlantic Ocean through the beach and the sand-bars
lying outside of it, by means of parallel jetties at the mouth of the
river.
  The depth of water on the bar at the mouth, which fcnmerly lay 400
                 RIVER AND          HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                             103
feet north of the proposed mouth, was from 1 to 1l feet, and varied and
shifted continually. The project also contemplated the dredging of an
inner basin 2,000 feet by 200 feet and 5 feet deep at low water. The
estimated cost of executing this scheme was $72,000.
    The alleged object of the improvement was to furnish to small coasters
a harbor of refuge midway between Sandy Hook and Barnegat Inlet;
but it was stated by the Board of Engineers, to whom the project was
submitted, that the desired harbor could not be obtained and main-
tained except at a cost so large as to be unwarranted by any possible
prospective commerce.
    There was practically no existing commerce.        However, appropria-
tions were made, amounting, up to August 2, 1882, to $72,000, and by
the 30th of June, 1883, two parallel jetties had been built across the
beach at right angles to the shore-line. The north jetty 1,513 feet in
length; the south jetty 475 feet, and a channel had been dredged be-
tween them.
    No appropriations have been made to protect the existing work since
August 2, 1882, and no work has been done since June 30, 1883.
    At first, this change in the mouth served its purpose so well that a
depth of from 3 to 4 feet was secured across the outside bar and
through the new channel between the jetties and was maintained for
several years; but the beach kept making round the outer end of the
jetties, and it was soon evident that the channel would be shortly
closed, unless the jetties were extended out to the 1 or 2 fathom curve
outside. A large shoal at the inner end of the north jetty also began
to make over towards the inner end of the south jetty, and drove the
current across to that side of the river so as to threaten making a breach
through the beach back of it.
   The present condition of the improvement is most unsatisfactory.
   The shoal above mentioned, has increased until the low-water mark
is about 20 feet outside of the inner end of the south jetty, and the
inner 150 feet of the jetty is now directly in midchannel.
   The filling of this 150 feet of the jetty has been completely washed
out, the beach has made up to the outer end of the north jetty, and
past the outer end of the south jetty, and outside, and about 200 feet
distant from the ends of the jetties a shoal has formed, awash at low
water, with channels north and south of it, with from 1 to 1 feet of
water in them at mean low water.
   The outlet now is in worse condition than before the improvement
was begun. There is not now, nor has there ever been, any commerce
in Manasquan. The little there is is done by railroad.
   The Manasquan River is only used by pleasure-boats, drawing from
6 inches to 2 inches, hardly any of which go outside.
   There appears to be no good reason for continuing this improvement,
and no money isg#therefore, asked for it.
Amount (estimated) r      ired for completion of existing project -.......   $33, 000 00
Submitted in compli
   harbor acts -18°6..
                         gyvith
                            1867.
                                  requirements of section 2 of river and

  (See Ap
  14. Shros                New Jersey.-The Shrewsbury River, empty-
ing into    n       j     y, New Jersey, is formed by the union of two
branches° w          *     Rocky Point, just below Seabright, 3 n~yes
above the     er's ,i     . One branch, called the North Shrewsbly
River, is ni igable to Red Bank, about 4 miles above the junction; for
the upper 3 miles of its course it widens out into a large, shallow, land-
locked bay.   The other branch, called the South Shrewsbury River, is
104         REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

navigable to Branchport, about 5 miles above the junction; and for the
upper 3 miles of its course broadens out into a similar shallow bay,
known as Pleasure Bay.
    Both these bays have channels through them 6 feet deep at mean low
water; but the lower mile of the North Branch and the lower 2 miles
of the South Branch, as well as the main river below their junction.
have always been obstructed by bars which proved serious obstacles to
their navigation.
    In 1870 a project for improving their navigation by dredging was
formed, the estimated cost of the work being $14,000. This amount was
appropriated, and subsequently a further sum of $5,000, all of which
was applied to the work between 1871 and 1874. But the improvement
did not prove permanent, and in 1878 a second survey was ordered, on
which the present project of improvement is based. This provided for
obtaining a channel 6 feet deep at mean low water, by diking and dredg-
ing from the mouth of the main river up into both branches.
    This project was referred for consideration to a Board of Engineers,
who, after making certain modifications in the plans, estimated the cost
of the improvement at $142,086.
   From June 18, 1878, to August 2, 1882, inclusive, $174,000 was appro-
priated for the improvement, but nothing since that time up to June 30,
1886.
   With these appropriations a dike, 4,021 feet long, was built at the
mouth of the river, and channels were dredged up to the junction of
the two branches 6 feet deep and from 25 to 100 feet wide, as needed.
From the junction at Rocky Point a dike was built on the right bank
of the North Branch, extending up-stream towards Barley Point, 1,885
feet long, and from Barley Point a dike 598 feet long was built, extend-
ing down-stream towards the other dike, leaving a space between their
extremities of 1,940 feet.
   On the South Branch a dike 1,856 feet long was built on the left bank
of the river, connecting with the lower end of the dike built on the
North Branch; and at the entrance to Pleasure Bay a dike 1,513 feet
long was built on the left bank from Gunning Island down-stream, and
a dike 503 feet long was built opposite to it on the right bank. Chan-
nels 6 feet deep were also dredged where needed, from 75 to 100 feet
in width on the North Branch, and from 60 to 150 feet in width on the
South Branch, including some rock excavation in the channel above
Seabright Bridge on the South Branch.
   These channels have since shoaled in some places and have deepened
in others, so that now a scant 5 feet can be carried through the North
Shrewsbury, a scant 4 feet through the South Shrewsbury, and 5 feet
over the bar at the mouth.
   The cost has already exceeded the estimate, partly on account of the
increased cost of dredging and diking, and partly on account of having
to re-dredge in'places. But the commerce of the river appears to war-
rant the maintenance of a 6-foot channel at low water, and $40,000 is
recommended, by the officer in charge, for continuing the improvement,
exclusive of the $10,000 appropriated by act approved Agust 5, 1886.
July 1, 1885, amount available              ----                 ------...................................               ...         $577 20
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of l                                                    lities
  outstanding July 1,1885-                                                             ------
                                              -----....................--..--.......----.......                                       355 50

Ju   1, 1886, amount available.........................                                 .......--            -------..                221   0
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886........
                                                       ----....---...                                                    - -....   10, 000 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887 .----..................                                                      10,221 70
                            RIVER AND                HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                              105

  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June30,188                                          20, 000 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
    (See Appendix E 14.)
   15. Harborat Keyport, New Jersey,--The project for this improvement,
approved in 1872, was to dredge a channel 8 feet in depth, at mean low
water, and 200 feet wide from the steamboat wharf at Keyport to the
8-foot curve in Raritan Bay, a distance of about 5,000 feet, at a cost of
$30,475.
   No money for this purpose was furnished until August 2, 1882, when
the whole amount was appropriated, and in 1882-'83 a channel was
dredged from the steamboat wharf at Keyport to the 8-foot curve in the
bay, 8 feet deep and 200 feet wide, except for a short stretch between
the steamboat wharf and the wharf of the New York and Freehold
Railroad, where it was only 160 feet wide.
   No appropriations have been made since.
   In 1884 an appropriation of $10,000 was recommended to complete
the improvement.
   The commerce of Keyport is stated to have increased from $3,000,000
in 1872 to $5,650,000 in 1884, and it is recommended that the improve-
ment be completed.
July 1, 1885, amount available................--.....                          ......-.......                  .     $982 19
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885----------....----............-------......--------......----......--......---......         30 20

July 1, 1886, amount available.---. -------....--......--.....----.............-----......                            951 99

   Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project........                                          10,000 00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
    (See Appendix E 15.)
   16. Mattawan Creek, New Jersey.--Mattawan Creek empties into
Raritan Bay at Keyport, New Jersey. The project for its improvement,
adopted in 1881, provided for a channel 4 feet deep at mean low water
and 100 feet wide from the mouth for about 1 miles up and thence 75
feet wide to the head of navigation at the Long Branch Railroad cross-
ing, 2 miles above the mouth, at a cost of $33,120.
   The original depth was 2 feet at mean low water and the range of tides
4.7 feet.
   The appropriations up to and including that of August 2, 1882,
amounted to $21,000. With this a channel 100 feet wide and 4 feet deep
had been dredged up to Winkson's Dock, - feet above the mouth; thence
to a point 600 feet above the brick-yards, 4 feet deep and 50 feet wide;
thence to the railroad bridge, a distance of 2,000 feet, 30 feet wide, and
4 feet deep ; and a basin was dredged opposite the steamboat dock at the
head of navigation, so as to enable the steamboat to turn.
   No appropriation has been made since that of August 2, 1882, and no
work done since 1883.
   Under the original estimate $12,120 is required to complete the im-
provement; but by a subsequent estimate made in 1884 it was esti-
mated that the project could be completed for $9,000.
   The amount of commerce of the creek is stated to be valued at $150,000,
consisting of $70,000 worth of bricks and $80,0(00 worth of sundries.
106       REPORT OF THE                  CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

   The existing commerce does not seem to warrant further appropria-
tions at present.
rAmount (estimated) required for completion of existing project-------.... $12, 120
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal yearending June 30,1888 10, 000
                                                                                                           00
                                                                                                           00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix E 16.)
   17. Cheesequakes Creek, New Jersey.-The original project, adopted in
1879, provided for a new outlet 5 feet deep from the creek into Raritan
Bay, at right angles to the shore line, through a beach which put across
the mouth of the creek from the right bank, and which had forced the
outlet nearly half a mile to the westward. This was to be obtained by
dredging and constructing parallel jetties each side of the dredged chan-
nel; the old outlet was to be closed by a pile dike, and a channel 4
feet deep and from 50 to 100 feet wide was to be dredged from the mouth
to the head of navigation, 3. miles up the creek. In this distance two
dikes were to be built, and a new channel to be made through the marsh,
was to cut off a bend in the creek.
   The available navigable depth in the creek was originally 1 feet at
mean low water over the shoals.
   The rise and fall of tide was 5.1 feet.
   The estimated cost of the improvement was $75,279.
   The total appropriations up to June 30, 1886, have been $40,000, and
with this amount the old outlet has been closed, and the proposed new
channel through the beach dredged out into Raritan Bay 5 feet deep,
with dikes built on each side.
   The channel has shoaled about half a foot since the dredging was done.
   No work has been done above the mouth of the creek, but it is be-
lieved that the improvement made so far is all that is warranted by the
present commerce, and no further appropriation is asked for.
July 1, 1885, amount available-.... ....................................                               $1 52
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885 ..........--------..................---------------.---...---..-------        1 52
SAmount (estimated) required for completion of existing project....-----....--                     50,000 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix E 17.)
   18. Raritan Bay, New Jersey.-The present project, adopted in 1880,
provides for opening a channel, by dredging, 8,000 feet long, 300 feet
wide, and 21 feet deep, at mean low water, through a shoal on the north
side of Raritan Bay, east of Seguines Point, so as to permit the passage
of deep-draught vessels to or out from the Amboys and Raritan River.
The original depth upon the shoal was 14- feet. The estimated cost of
the improvement was $126,500, of which, up to June 30, 1886, $120,000
had been appropriated, and the channel was completed for the proposed
length, depth, and width in 1884.    A survey made in 1885 showed that
the side slopes of the cut had run in, so as to give a channel-width of
only 250 feet, with a depth of 21 feet.
   In 1884 it was recommended that an interior channel, leading from
Great Beds Light up to Perth Amboy, by Ward's Point, on the Staten
Island shore, should be dredged 300 feet wide and 21 feet deep, and
in 1885 it was recommended that a 15-foot channel, 300 feet wide, should
be dredged from outside of Great Beds Light up to South Amboy.
  The estimated cost of the excavation of these two channels and for
widening the channel east of Seguines Point to 300 feet was $114,000.
                          RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                       107
   The channel east of Seguines Point appears to be sufficient for the ex-
isting commerce at present, and the $37,500 appropriated August 5,
1886, will be applied to the interior channels after a survey has been
made.
   The shipments of coal, iron ore, and other heavy freights from the
Amboys, which pass through this channel, is very large, and is car-
ried in sea-going vessels and steamers drawing 20 feet and under,
and the existing project, as modified in 1884 and 1885, should be car-
ried out.
July 1, 1885, amount available...........---------          ............     ..................             $724 70
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1,1885......--------......--....--....----...... .... --......                             31 95
July 1, 1886, amount available..........---..---...--.......---------...--------------------.......          692 75
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886--------.........--..---..--                        -   37,500 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887-----------------................                    38,192 75
i Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing prqject ..... -                                 76,500 00
  Amount that canbe profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1888                                50, 000 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section                               2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix E 18.)
    19. Raritan River, New Jersey.-The project for the improvement of
this river, adopted in 1874, provided for a channel 10 feet deep and 200
feet wide from the mouth up to New Brunswick, a distance of 12? miles,
by means of diking and dredging, at a cost of $2,093,662.05.
    New Brunswick is at the head of navigation, although the river is
navigable by boats of light draught 5 miles further up. The Delaware
and Raritan Canal opens into the river at New Brunswick and has a
depth of 8 feet.
    When the improvement was begun in 1874 the river was obst'ructed by
two long shoals, beginning about 5 miles above the mouth, known as the
Stakes and the Middle Ground, with from 6 to 7 feet water on them; the
river at this point is half a mile wide, and it was proposed to contract this
width to about 800 feet by means of dikes, and to dredge a channel along
them.
   For 4 miles below New Brunswick the river was very much narrower,
and was crossed by rock, gravel, and bowlder bars, with from 7 to 8 feet
of water upon them.
   A slight addition to the original project was made in 1881, providing
for a channel 100 feet wide and 5J feet deep at low water inside the dikes
on the southern side of the river at the Stakes and Middle Ground; the
estimated cost of which was about $50,000, the object being to accom-
modate the factories on the right bank of the river which were cut off
from the main channel by the dikes.
   Up to June 30,1886, $445,000 had been appropriated for the improve-
ment, and the following work had been done:
   The dikes at the Stakes and Middle Ground have been completed, and
there is a channel over those shoals I11 feet deep at mean low water,
and varying from 130 to 200 feet in width; 4,000 linear feet of the pro-
jected 13,000 feet of the South Channel has been completed.
   On this part of the river, therefore, the following work remains to be
done under the project: to widen the channel at the Stakes from 130 to
200 feet, and to excavate the remainder of the South Channel for a
distance of 9,000 feet. No work has been done on this part of the river
during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1886.
108       REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

   On the upper 4 miles of the river the only important work that has
been done is the excavation of a rock-reef known as " Rocky Reach,"
4 miles below New Brunswick; this work has been nearly completed,
as a channel 200 feet wide and 12 feet deep has been excavated through
the shoal, except for a distance of 150 feet at the lower end, where the
width is only 180 feet. The only work done on this part of the river
during the fiscal year ending June 30,1886, was the excavation of 6,39'
cubic yards of material from Rocky Reach with the small balance of
the appropriation of July 5, 1884, which was available at the beginning
of the fiscal year.
   The work remaining to be done, therefore, on this part of the river is
the excavation of a 10-foot channel from above Rocky Reach to New
Brunswick, a distance of about 3 miles, and the finishing of the little
remaining work in Rocky Reach.
   Under the appropriation of $26,250 approved August 5, 1886, it is
proposed to extend the improvement up-stream from Rocky Reach by
dredging and blasting towards New Brunswick.
   The commerce of the Raritan River is very large and thoroughly
warrants the early completion of the project.
   One hundred thousand dollars is recommended to be appropriated
for the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888, for continuing the improvement.
July 1, 1885, amount available..............
                                      -      ...........----------.. . - . $10, 727 41
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885........................---......-- ....---..........          10, 109 43
July 1, 1886, amount available ......    ...----....   -----.....................            4i7 98
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5. 1886......... ........                     26, 250 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887.................                   26,867 98

(Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project...... 1, 622, 412 05
I Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1888--...----------------------------------------------------100, 000 00
    Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
(    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
    (See Appendix E 19.)
  20. South River, New Jersey.-This river is a tributary of the Raritan
River, entering it from the southward about 8k miles above its mouth.
  In order to cut off a great bend, a canal was dug by the New Jersey
Transportation Company about fifty years ago from a point on South
River to the Raritan, 14 miles below the natural mouth, thereby saving
a distance of over 3 miles.
  The first Government survey with a view to its improvement was
made in 1870, and $20,000 was appropriated and expended in 1872-'73
in deepening the canal.
  No work was then done until 1879, when the present project was
adopted, which was to form a channel 150 feet wide and 8 feet deep by
means of diking and dredging from the lower end of the canal up to
the village of Little Washington, a distance of about   miles, and thence
by the same means up to Old Bridge, 4J miles further, by channels 100
                                                                                    1i
and 60 feet wide and 6 and 4 feet deep, respectively. The project also
provided    for
              closing up the old channel about 2k miles above its mouth.
  The estimated cost of the project was $194,695, of which $56,000 had
been appropriated up to June 30,1886. With this, dikes have been built
on each side of the canal for about half its length up from its mouth,
and a long training-dike has been built on the south (right) bank be-
tween the head of the canal and Little Washington. With the excep-
                          RIVER AND HARBOR                       IMPROVEMENTS.                                109
tion of cutting a short channel through a shoal just above Little Wash-
ington, no work has been done above the village.
   The dikes appear to have done good service so far, but it will be
necessary to protect the banks of the canal through its entire length,
as they are undermining and falling in, so that shoals are forming rap-
idly.
   No work has been done during the fiscal year.
   Under the appropriation of August 5, 1886, it is proposed to extend
the dikes in the canal up-stream.
   For so small a stream the commerce is large, and indicates that the
river is worthy of improvement under the present project.
July 1, 1885, amount available......---      ----......-------............----......--
                                                                      ------            ........--...      $382 63
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885.....--...----.....----.....----....----....----....---- ......--
                                                                                        -..........----      21 36
                                                                          ----
July 1, 1886, amount available...-------.......................................                              361 27
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886 ...................                                    5,000 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887 ......----........---                           .   5,361 27

  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project .......     133,695 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June30, 1888- 10, 000 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix E 20.)
   21. Woodbridge Creek, New Jersey.-The project for this improvement
adopted in 1878, provided for dredging a channel 80 feet wide and 12
feet deep at mean high water from the mouth of the creek up to the town
dock, a distance of about 2 miles, over which a depth of from 7) to 12
feet at mean high water had originally existed.
   The estimated cost of this improvement was $13,809.14; $19,000 had
been appropriated to June 30, 1886, for this improvement, which has
been virtually completed, and the channel appears to be ample for the
existing commerce. No appropriation is therefore asked for.
   The exceedingly high prices of dredging increased the cost of the work
50 per cent. more than the original estimate.
   The commerce of the creek consists in shipments of brick, tiles, and
fire-clay from seven factories, situated on the creek from the mouth to
the town dock, and from the numerous beds of fine clays and fire-clay
which are situated near its banks. The commerce of the creek is esti-
mated at about 120,000 tons yearly, carried in vessels of from 6 to 10
feet draught.
  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project ....... $10, 000 00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
     harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
    (See Appendix E 21.)
  22. Rahway River, New Jersey.--The project for improvement of this
river, adopted in 1878, provided for dredging a channel from Brick-
town, nearly 4 miles above the mouth, up to the Main Street Bridge, in
the town of Rahway, a distance of 6,900 feet. The channel proposed
was to be 125 feet wide and 8 feet deep at mean high water from Brick-
town to the Milton Avenue Bridge in Rahway, a distance of 5,500 feet,
and thence only 100 feet wide and 8 feet deep at mean high water up to
the head of navigation at the Main Street Bridge, a distance of 1,400
feet.
   The range of tides is 5.3 feet.
110        REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

   The estimated cost of this work, including the removal of a large
bowlder at Bricktown, was $36,653. Up to and including the act of
August 2, 1882, $37,000 had been appropriated for this improvement,
with which an improved channel not less than 7 feet in depth at mean
high water has been obtained to within 550 feet of the head of naviga-
tion at the Main Street Bridge.
   No appropriation has been made since that of August 2, 1882.
   Owing to the great difference between the originally estimated and
the actual price of dredging, it was estimated in 1882 that to carry out
the project would increase the estimated cost $37,500, but it is also
stated in the report for 1883, as well as in subsequent reports, that the
existing channel is sufficient for the present needs of commerce, which
has fallen from an estimated amount of 120,500 tons in 1879 to 48,500
tons in 1884 and 1885.
   The channel may be regarded as sufficient for the present require-
ments of the commerce, and no further appropriation is now asked for.
July 1, 1885, amount available ............             ..........     ...... -----............    $200 70
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1. 1885 ....----......------...... --....----.. ..........            .....       21 10
                                         --.................---
July 1, 1886, amount available ......------                                ............             179 60
SAmount (estimated) required for completion of existing project ....... 29, 250 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix E 24.)
  23. Elizabeth.River, New Jersey.-The project for this improvement,
adopted in 1879, provided for dredging a channel 7 feet deep at mean
high water, and 60 feet wide, from the mouth of the river up to the Stone
Bridge at Broad street, in the city of Elizabeth, a distance of 24 miles.
  Before this improvement was begun, there was a depth at mean high
water of 8. feet at the mouth, and 3 feet at the Stone Bridge, while the
depth for nearly a mile below the bridge was only from 3 feet to 34 feet.
  The mean rise and fall of the tides is stated to be 4.7 feet at the mouth
and 3.4 feet at the Stone Bridge.
   The estimated cost of this improvement was $25,530; but, on account
of the excessively high prices bid for the dredging in carrying out the
work, this estimate was increased in 1881 to $43,160.
   Twenty-seven thousand dollars have been appropriated for the im-
provement up to June 30, 1886, with which a channel 7 feet deep at mean
high water, and from 50 to 60 feet wide, has been dredged from the
mouth nearly up to the Stone Bridge.
   It has been stated in previous reports that this is all that is required
for the existing commerce, and no furthor appropriation is asked for at
present.
July 1, 1885, amount available..--------....----..........................----......                $601 64
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885 .----...........--............------
                                                   ----......-------..--- ----  - ---
                                                                               ....----....           20 80
July 1, 1886, amount available....------------.----..........            -....---...-....--.         580 84
  SAmount  (estimated) required for completion of existing project .......--------.
   Submitted in compliance with the requirements of section 2 of river and
                                                                                                  16,160 00
     harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
    (See Appendix E 23.)
  24. Channel between Staten Island and Newo Jersey.-The improvement
of this channel has, so far, been restricted to that part of Staten Island
                          RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                         111
Sound, about 1 miles long, which lies between Elizabethport, N. J., and
Newark Bay.
   The project for its improvement, first proposed in 1873 and since mod-
ified, provides for dredging a channel east from Elizabethport to the
deep waters of the Kill von Kull 400 feet wide and 13 feet deep at mean
low water. At first it was meant to make only the middle part of this
channel 13 feet deep, the outside part being but 12 feet deep.
   Previous to the beginning of this work 9 feet had existed over this
shoal at mean low water.
   The estimated cost of dredging this channel to the full depth of 13
feet was $150,000. In addition to this, it was decided, should it be
found necessary, to build four dikes along the line of the channel, two
on the north side and two on the south, the estimated cost of which was
$60,000, making the total cost ofthe proposed improvement $210,000.
   Up to June 30, 1886, $154,000 have been appropriated for this work.
With this amount the channel has been given the full width and depth
proposed, and in 874-'75 2,237 linear feet of dike were built on the south
side of the channel, under the first project.
   It is not thought advisable at present to begin either of the four dikes
proposed in the modified project of 1880, and it is proposed to main-
tain the channel by dredging and to widen certain parts so as to enable
vessels to pass each other more easily.
   The $15.000 appropriated by act of Congress approved August 5,
1886, will be applied to dredging, and a further sum of $30,000 is asked
for continuing the improvement.
July 1, 1885, amount available ..........-......-- ......--- ...   -........--                                 397 47
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
outstanding July 1, 1885...----........--........--------......-- -....----.---... .....-------------......---.. 397 47
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886- ...................       - -             -
                                                                                          - - --             15, 000 00

 ( Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project.                          --------      91,000 00
   Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1888                              30, 000 00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
     harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix E 24.)
  25. PassaicRiver, New Jersey.-The Passaic is a large river in New
Jersey, emptying into Newark Bay. It is navigable to Passaic, about
13 miles above its mouth. Four miles above the mouth is situated the
city of Newark, N. J.
  The appropriation for this river has been divided into two parts
  1. The Passaic River above Newark, from the Pennsylvania Railroad
Bridge, in the city of Newark, to the head of navigation at Passaic.
  2. The Passaic River below Newark, from the Pennsylvania Railroad
Bridge down to the mouth.
   1. The Passaic River, above Newark: The original navigable depth
of this part of the river was about 2 feet at mean low water, the rise and
fall of tides being nearly 5 feet at Newark and 3 feet at Passaic.
  The channel was obstructed by rocky and gravelly bars, notably
those called Middle Bar, Lime Kiln, Belleville, Rutherford Park, and
Holsman's.
   The project for its improvement, adopted in 1872, provided for ob-
taining, by means of diking and dredging, a channel 6 feet deep andfrom
60 to 70 feet wide from Newark up to Passaic, the estimated cost of
which was $123,924.
   Up to June 30, 1886, $124,000 had been appropriated; and a channel
not less than 6 feet in depth and from 60 to 125 feet wide had been
112         REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

obtained from the Pennsylvania Railroad Bridge in Newark to Passaic,
the head of navigation.
   The dredged channels have slightly deteriorated at different times,
but the project may be called completed.
   The $2,250 allotted by act of August 5, 1886, for this part of the river
will be applied to removing any obstructions which may form in the
river from ice or freshets next spring.
   The commerce of this part of the river is quite large.
July 1, 1885, amount available....----.....----..-----.......-----..------..-...      .........                  $2, 272 26
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885............----              ........ ....................           ......            2, 034 30
July 1, 1886, amount available.... .......... ---- -......---........... ..........----                             237 96
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886.... ...... .... .....----.                                    2, 250 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887 ...................                                         2, 487 96
SAmount (estimated)   required for completion of existing project .......                                        7, 512 00
  Submittet in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
  2. The Passaic River below Newark: The project for this part of the
river, adopted in 1880, provided for obtaining a 10-foot channel at mean
low water, 200 feet wide, from the Pennsylvania Railroad Bridge in
Newark to Newark Bay, by means of diking and dredging, the esti-
mated cost being $232,875.
   In 1884 this project was modified so as to include the deepening of
the channel through certain shoals in Newark Bay by dredging and by
extending the dike at the mouth of the river about 8,000 feet into the
bay, as it was found that these shoals had less water over them than
the improved channel in the river.
   The estimated cost of this modification was $121,000, making a total
estimate for the whole project of $353,875. Of this, $148,000 had been
appropriated up to June 30, 1886, and a channel through the bay and
up the river to the Newark and New York Railroad Bridge has been
excavated 12 feet deep and 200 feet wide. From the Newark and New
York Railroad Bridge up to the Pennsylvania Railroad Bridge a channel
varying in width from 100 to 200 feet, and 12 feet deep, has been
dredged, and 4,705 linear feet of diking has been built at the mouth of
the river.
   To complete the improvement 7,300 linear feet of diking will have to
be built in Newark Bay and the channel dredged to full width above
the Newark and New York Railroad Bridge.
   With the appropriation of $24,000 made by act of Congress of Au-
gust 5, 1886, for this part of the river, it is proposed to extend the dik-
ing into the bay a distance of 1,000 linear feet.
   The commerce of the river up to Newark is estimated at 1,200,000
tons yearly, besides which the commerce of the HTackensack uses the
channel in Newark Bay.
   The commerce warrants the completion of the project as soon as possi-
ble; $125,000 is asked by the officer in charge for the fiscal year ending
June 30, 1886, to continue the improvement.
July 1, 1885, amount available...........................----------                 ---...----                   6,711 12
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885 ......--......--.--..--...             -----.................               .....      6, 138 30

July 1, 1886, amount available ...----......----......                                                      --
                                                                             ---......--......--......-....-..      572 82
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886 ...................                                           24,000 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887..                          ...............                 24,572 82
                  RIVER AND        HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                            113
(Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project......-       $181, 875 00
A mount that can be profitably expended in fiscal'year ending June30,1868     60, 000 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
  (See Appendix E 25.)
IMPROVEMENT OF DELAWARE AND SCHUYLKILL RIVERS AND OF
  RIVERS IN NEW JERSEY-HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS IN DELAWARE
  RIVER AND BAY--CONSTRUCTION OF PIER AT LEWES-DELAWARE
  BREAKWATER.

   Officer in charge, Lieut. Col. Henry M. Robert, Corps of Engineers.
   1. DelawareRiver from Trenton, New Jersey, to its mouth.-Trenton is
the head of natural navigation on the Delaware River. Between Trenton
and the upper part of Philadelphia, a distance of about 30 miles, the
river in its orginal condition was obstructed by shoals which reduced
the depth at low water to 3 or 4 feet in the upper part, and to 6 or 7
feet in the lower part of this distance of 30 miles.
   Below Philadelphia the river in its original condition presented ob-
structions at Mifflin Bar which reduced the depth at mean low water to
17 feet, at Schooner Ledge and Cherry Island Flats to 18 feet, at Bulk-
head Shoals and Dan Baker Shoals to about 20 feet.
   The project for the comprehensive improvement of the Delaware
River between Trenton and the upper part of Philadelphia has not yet
been considered. Efforts in the past have been directed toward reliev-
ing commerce from the obstructions which exist in the upper 8 or 10
miles of the river, or that part between Kinkora Bar and Trenton. This
part of the river was originally obstructed with shoals which reduced
the available depth at low water to from 3 to 4 feet. By dredging, a
depth of from 6 to 7 feet has been obtained in this upper 10 miles of
river, except at Periwig Shoal, which is about 21 miles below Tren-
ton, where there is at present a depth of only 3 feet at low water. A
detailed survey of the river between Bridesburg and Trenton is in prog-
ress for the purpose of obtaining the necessary data for determining
upon a compre.hensive plan forhe permanent improvement of the river
between Trenton and the upper part of Philadelphia to meet the re-
quirements of commerce, and also the plan adopted for the improve-
ment of the river at and below Philadelphia.
   The efforts of the past to improve the river between Philadelphia and
the bay have been confined to dredging, except at Schooner Ledge, where
solid rock has been removed, under appropriations for special localities
and also under general appropriations for the Delaware River below
Bridesburg.
   A Board of Engineers, convened by direction of the Secretary of War
for the purpose of considering the subject of the permanent improve-
ment of Delaware River and Bay, recommended, under date of January
23, 1885, the formation of a ship-channel from a point opposite Phila-
delphia and about midway between the American Shipbuilding Com-
pany's yard and the Gas Trust Wharf to deep water in Delaware Bay,
having a least width of 600 feet, and a depth of 26 feet at mean low
water. The formation of such a channel is to be obtained, except at
Schooner Ledge, where rock would require to be removed, by regula-
ting the tidal flow by means of dikes, with recourse to dredging where
necessary as an aid to such contracting and regulating works. The
estimated cost of obtaining a channel of the above dimensions is about
$2,425,000, which covers the estimated cost of the permanent improve-
ment of the Delaware River between the upper part of Philadelphia
and deep water in the bay,         The entire cost of the permanent improve-
      8E
114         REPORT OF THE                    CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

ment of the river between Trenton, N. J., and its mouth cannot be
stated until after the completion of the survey between Bridesburg and
Trenton and the formation of a project based thereon.
   The entire amount expended on the improvements of the Delaware
River from 1836 to June 30, 1885, under appropriations both for the gen-
eral river and for special localities, was $1,364,746.87, of which $45,000
was expended on that part of the river between Trenton and the upper
part of Philadelphia.     At the latter date, there had been formed a
channel of navigable width and 7 feet deep at mean low water through
the bars between Bridesburg and Bordentown; 200 feet wide and 9 feet
deep at mean low water over the bar between Bridesburg and the head
of Petty's Island Bar; 225 feet wide and 24 feet deep through Petty's
Island Bar; 300 feet wide and 10 feet deep at mean low water through
Smith's Island Bar; 300 feet wide and 26 feet deep at mean low water
through Mifflin Bar; 330 feet wide and 24 feet deep at mean low water
through Schooner Ledge; 470 feet wide and 24feet deep through Cherry
Island Flats; and 385 feet wide and 24 feet deep at low water through
Bulkhead Shoals.
   During the fiscal year ending June 30, 1886, the sum of $134,971.05
was expended in surveys, examinations, and tidal observations; in
dredging through Five Mile Bar just above Petty's Island, in the main
ship-channel west of Petty's Island, and at Mifflin Bar; and in dike
construction near Periwig Shoals above Bordentown, between Fisher's
Point and the upper end of Petty's Island, and between Hog and Maiden
islands near Mifflin Bar.
   The dredging through Five Mile Bar is still in progress, and has re-
sulted, so far, in opening a channel between the deep water above and
below the bar about 100 feet wide and 10 feet deep at mean low water.
The dredging west of Petty's Island has widened the main channel to a
width of about 400 feet, with a depth of from 21 to 26 feet at mean low
water. The dredging at Mifflin Bar was applied to the deepening. of
the previously dredged channel to a depth of 26 feet at mean low water.
The dikes are as yet unfinished and the extent of their action towards
deepening adjacent channels undeterminfed.
   An appropriation of $500,000 is recommended for the fiscal year end-
ing June 30, 1888, which would be applied in accordance with the ap-
proved project.
July 1, 1885, amount available                 ......   ......        ....- ...............               $185, 555 96
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive
  of liabilities outstanding July 1, 1885..----..........-------------.......133, 273 88
July 1, 1886, outstanding liabilities-----------------...---...--....          34,374 09
                                                                                                            167, 647 97

July 1, 1886, amount available........................................                                       17,907 99
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886.... ........ ....                                        210, 000 00

Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887-- ...........                               ....      227, 907 99
  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project-*.. -                                         2,215,000 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June
   30, 1888---..--------------................ --......----------.........---...--..-.....-----.---.......---.   500, 000 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix F 1.)
  *This amount of $2,215,000 covers the estimated cost of the permanent improvement
of the Delaware River between the upper part of Philadelphia and deep water in the
bay. The entire cost of the permanent improvement of the river between Trenton,
N. J., and its mouth cannot be stated until after the completion of the survey now
in progress between Bridesburg and Trenton and the formation of a project baseq
thereon.
                   RIVER AND HARBOR             IMPROVEMENTS.                       115
   2. Delaware River at Schooner Ledge.-This locality is about 19 miles
below Philadelphia. In its original condition the obstruction to naviga-
tion consisted of a ledge of rock, with superposed gravel and bowlders,
lying in the main ship-channel quite close to the Delaware shore. The
depth of water over this ledge was about 18 feet and the obstructioh was
dangerous to navigation.
   The original project for its improvement was to obtain a channel 24
feet deep at mean low water by the removal of rock and other material,
at an estimated cost of $227,000. Under the general project of the
Board of Engineers of 1884 the improvement of this part of the river
was included in the comprehensive plan for the permanent improvement
of Delaware River and bay so as to obtain a depth of 26 feet at mean
low water, with a least channel-width of 600 feet at all points where a
less depth and width now exist below Philadelphia.
   Work under the original project was commenced in 1879, and con-
tinued to 1884, when the available funds became practically exhausted.
The amount expended to June 30, 1885, was $169,837.07, and had re-
sulted in the formation of a channel through the ledge 330 feet wide and
24 feet deep at mean low water.
   Specific appropriations are not recommended for this work. The im-
provement of this locality is considered in the report of the Board of En-
gineers of 1884, and forms a part of the comprehensive plan for the perma-
nent improvement of the Delaware River as recommended by the Board.
July 1, 1885, amount available.................................... ..----------------...
                                                                                 $162 93
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885..........--------....................................   162 93
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project..........         (*)
  (See Appendix F 2.)
  3. Delaware River near Cherry Island Plats.-Thislocality is about 28
miles below Philadelphia. In its original condition the obstruction to
navigation consisted of a shoal about 2 miles in length between the
24-foot curves, carrying a least depth of about 18 feet at mean low
water.
   The original project for its improvement was to obtain by dredging
a channel of navigable width and 24 feet deep at mean low water, at an
estimated cost of $522,720. Under the general project of the Board of
Engineers of 1884 the improvement of this part of the river was in-
cluded in the comprehensive plan for the permanent improvement of
Delaware River and bay, so as to obtain a depth of 26 feet at mean low
water, with a least channel-width of 600 feet, at all points where a less
depth and width now exist below Philadelphia.
   Work under the original project was commenced in 1879 and con-
tinued through 1883, when the available funds became practically ex-
hausted.
   The amount expended to June 30, 1885, was $398,543.26, and had re-
sulted in the formation of a dredged channel through the shoal about
470 feet wide and 24 feet deep at mean low water.
   Specific appropriations are not recommended for this work. The im-
provement of this locality is considered in the report of the Board of
Engineers of 1884, and forms a part of the comprehensive plan for the
permanent improvement of the Delaware River, as recommended by the
Board.
  *Included in amount required for completion of existing project, "Delaware River
from Trenton, N. J., to its mouth."
116          REPORT           OF THE CHIEF                    OF ENGINEERS, U. S, ARMY.

July 1, 1885, amount available..........................................                              $1, 456 74
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885 ......--.......... -- --.............. --...........                        1,456 74

Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project ..........                               (*)
   (See Appendix F 3.)
   4. 1rankford Creek, Pennsylvania.-This creek flows eastward to the
Delaware River, through the northern portion of the city of Philadel-
phia. The grounds of the Frankford Arsenal border upon the left bank
of the creek. In its original condition it had a low-water width of
about 100 feet, and a low-water depth of about 5 feet at its mouth,
above which it rapidly shoaled for a distance of about 3 miles, to the
head of tidal flow.
   The original project proposed the formation of a dredged channel 50
feet wide from its mouth to Frankford avenue, a distance of about 3
miles, the channel to have a depth of 3 feet at mean low water at its
upper end, and increasing to 7 feet at its mouth. The estimated cost
was $40,000.
   The act of August 2, 1882, appropriated $10,000, which was applied
to the formation of a dredged channel 7 feet deep from its mouth to
Horseshoe Bend.
   This creek, being entirely within the corporate limits of Philadelphia,
is being regulated by the city, and no further appropriation for its im-
provement by the United States is recommended.
   No work has been done since 1883. The amount expended to June
30, 1885, was $9,442.83.
July 1, 1885, amount available ..........----------.............................                        $557 17
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885.......... .... .........  ..............     .... ....                        292 67

July 1, 1886, amount available...... ....                     ......   ............   .....   .   -      264 50
                                                                 .......
  SAmount (estimated) required for completion of existing project----                                 30,000 00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix F 4.)
   5. Schuylkill River, Pennsylvania.-When the work of improvement
was commenced in 1870 there was a channel of entrance into the mouth
of the river carrying a depth of only 15 feet at mean low water.
   The original project under which work was commenced in 1870 pro-
posed the formation of a channel 100 feet wide with a depth of 20 feet
from the mouth of the river to Gibson's Point, and a depth of 18 feet
from thence to Chestnut Street Bridge in Philadelphia.
   In 1875 and 1883 this project was amended so as to increase the mean
low-water channel between the mouth and Girard Point to 400 feet wide
and 24 feet deep, and from Girard Point to Gibson's Point to 250 feet
wide and 20 feet deep.
   The amount expended upon these projects to June 30, 1885, was
$331,701.23, and has resulted in the formation of a channel as follows:
From the mouth to Girard Point piers, a distance of about 1 mile, the
channel was 300 feet wide and 24 feet deep at mean low water; from
Girard Point to Gibson's Point, a distance of about 3 miles, the channel
was 150 to 200 feet wide and 20 feet deep; from Gibson's Point to Chest-
nut Street Bridge, a distance of about 3 miles, the channel was 150 feet
                                                                      '
   * Included in amount required for completion of existing project, " Delaware River
from Trenton, N, J., to its mouth,"
                           RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                           117
wide and 18 feet deep at mean low water. This latter reach of river has
required no other improvement than the removal of about 1,000 cubic
yards of rock near Locust and South streets.
  During the fiscal year ending June 30, 1886, the sum of $17,914.15
was expended in widening and deepening the channel at points between
Gibson's and Girard points by the removal of about 36,000 cubic yards
of material.
  The sum of $75,000 can be profitably expended during the fiscal year
ending June 30, 1888, in continuing the dredging of the channel. The
commerce of the river is rapidly increasing, and the improvement of
the river to the completion of the existing project would be of great ad-
vantage.
July 1, 1885, amount available .----.......---......---.. ....---....----......----...---.. ...----- $11, 578 97
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885.... ......   ...... ....                      - ... ......--- .. . 11, 194 35
                                                          .. - ---.....---
July 1, 1886, amount available----..------......................-------------...---............-- ---- ------      384 62
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886--....----.----------                             ..          18,750 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887-- -...................
                                                                      ------                                    19,134 62
   Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project- - -...-- - - 116,250 00
   Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June30, 1888                                    58, 000 00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
     harbor acts of 1866 and 1867
   (See Appendix F 5.)
   6. Ice-harboratMarcus Hook, Pennsylvania.-This work in its present
plan was commenced in 1867, the object being to provide a harbor to
protect vessels against moving ice.
   The original project with the amendments thereto proposed the con-
struction of stone piers behind which vessels could anchor, and the con-
struction of a bulkhead about 1,800 feet in length, parallel to the shore
line, and about 150 feet outside of high-water line, together with the
deepening by dredging of the area behind the piers and in front of the
bulkhead.
   The amount expended from 1866 to June 30, 1885, was $171,561.84,
and resulted in the construction of three landing-piers and seven detached
ice-piers, and the deepening by dredging to a depth of 18 feet of a part
of the area between the first and second pair of piers. Extensive re-
pairs were also made to the piers from time to time.
   The work done rendered the harbor available for a limited number of
vessels of comparatively light draught seeking protection against run-
ning ice.
   During the fiscal year ending June 30, 1886, $7,438.16 was expended
in deepening, by dredging to a depth of 22 feet at mean low water, the
area between the first and second pairs of ice-piers, and to a depth of 24
feet the area between the second and third pairs of ice-piers. A group
of mooring piles was also placed midway between the inner lines of the
first and second and the second and third pairs of ice-piers. This work
renders about two-thirds of the harbor available at mean low water for
vessels drawing from 22 to 26 feet, and gives also increased mooring facil-
ities.
   The amount required for the completion of the existing project could
be profitably expended during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888, in
giving increased harbor facilities, by the construction of the bulkhead,
and dredging.
118          REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

July 1, 1885, amount available ........................................                                         $7, 438 16
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
 'outstanding July 1, 1885.............................................------------------------------------.     7,438 16


{Amount
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886 ...................
                (estimated) required for completion of existing project........
   Amountthat can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1888
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
                                                                                                                15, 000 00
                                                                                                               35,000 00
                                                                                                               35, 000 00
     harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
    (See Appendix F 6.)
   7. Ice-harborat head of Delaware Bay, Delaware.-The act of August 2,
1882, appropriated $25,000 for the commencement of work on the ice-
harbor at the head of Delaware Bay, to include the removal of some
sunken piers, the remains of an old ice-harbor, in the channel east of
Reedy Island, Delaware.
   The necessity for an ice-harbor at the head of Delaware Bay has long
been recognized, and considerable study has been devoted to the ques-
tions of location and general plan of construction. As to location, the
prevailing judgment would place the ice-harbor at or very near Liston's
Point. The plan of construction which has been hitherto proposed in
general terms provided for a nearly inclosed area, by means of a barrier,
to protect vessels against moving ice. This barrier was to consist of
iron piles placed at intervals and connected with an iron superstructure
so arranged as to either hold or ward the ice from the area within the
barrier. The cost of such an ice-harbor has been variously estimated
at from $300,000 to $400,000.
   In the opinion of the officer in charge the plan of detached ice-break-
ers, as heretofore used in all the ice-harbors on the Delaware River, is
preferable to that of an inclosed area, which latter would prevent the
broken ice from escaping from the harbor; but as to whether these ice-
breakers should consist of stone piers, or pile piers, or floating pontons
requires more time for decision.
   The problem of successfully designing and constructing an ice-harbor
at the head of Delaware Bay is difficult, and of a character where prece-
dent furnishes but small guidance; therefore, before the work is com-
menced the most careful examination and study should be given to the
question.
   The amount expended to June 30, 1885, was $7,500, of which $3,700
was applied to the removal of the sunken piers back of Reedy Island,
as provided in the act of August 2, 1882, making the appropriation of
$25,000.    The balance of $3,800 was expended iu surveys, examina-
tions, and preliminary studies.
   During the fiscal year ending June 30, 1886, nothing was expended.
   No appropriation is recommended at present by the officer in charge.
July 1, 1885. amount available. ... ......... . ......      .............. .....                               $17, 500 00
July 1,1886, amount available-........       ...... ..........     ......... ....                               17,500 00
   Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project ........ 381, 090 00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
      harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
    (See Appendix F 7.)
  8. Construction of ironpier in Delaware Bay, near Lewes, Delaware.-
The original project for this work proposed the construction of a landing-
pier about 1,700 feet in length, extending from the shore south of the
breakwater into Delaware Bay to a depth of 22 feet at mean low-water,
the pier to consist of a substructure of wrought-iron screw-piles sur-
                        RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                               119
motinted with a timber superstructure. The work was commenced in
1871 and completed, except as to superstructure, in 1880.
   The amount expended to June 30, 1885, was $367,612.72, and resulted
in the construction of 1,155 linear feet of pier 21 feet in width, and 546
linear feet 42 feet in width, or a total length of 1,701 feet. The depth
of water at the outer end of the pier-head was about 21 feet at mean
low water.
   From the decayed condition of the timber superstructure it was not
availale for use by the railroad, to which the right was given to use the
pier under the provisions of the act of July 15, 1870.
   During the fiscal year ending June 30, 18867 $700.14 was expended in
the care of the work and its property.
   If the pier is to be rendered available for the general purposes of the
Government, and also for railroad traffic, as contemplated in the act
above referred to, the officer in charge recommends the replacing of the
present decayed wooden superstructure by permanent iron-work at an
estimated cost of $93,000. If this is approved by Congress the entire
amount could be profitably expended during the fiscal year ending June
30, 1888, as when the change in superstructure commences the pier is
useless until the change is completed.
July 1, 1885, amount available..............        .................                   ......     $887 28
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885 ...............   ..........          ...... .... ............           700 14
July 1, 1886, amount available.           .....................................                     187 14
SAmount (estimated) required for completion of existing project........                         15,000 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix F 8.)
   9. Delaware Breakwater Harbor, Delaware.--Underact of Congress,
May 7, 1822, $22,700 was appropriated for a survey of Delaware Bay,
near Cape Henlopen, for the purpose of determining upon the site for a
harbor of shelter. In 1828 an appropriation of $250,000 was made for
commencing the work, under a plan submitted by a Board of Commis-
sioners appointed by Congress.
   The project of the Board contemplated the construction in the concavity of the
bay, just inside Cape Henlopen, of two massive works on the pierresperdues or riprap
system, separated by an interval or gap of 1,390 feet-the greater, called the break-
water, to afford safe anchorage during gales from the north and east; the other,
called the ice-breaker, to protect shipping against northwesterly gales and the heavy
.drifting ice of the bay.
   This project was completed in 1869, under aggregate appropria-
tions, including the first for survey, of $2,192,103.70. The stone used
in the work amounted to 892,528 gross tons, and varied from one-quar-
ter of a ton to 7 tons in weight, the smaller constituting the bulk of the
mass, the larger used to cover the exterior slopes.
   As completed in 1869 the breakwater is 2,558 feet long, and the ice-
breaker 1,359 feet long on top. The average width on top is 22 feet,
and at base 160 feet. The top is from 12 to 14 feet above mean low
water.
   In 1882 a project was adopted for closing the gap between the break-
water and the ice-breaker by means of a random stone foundation with
a concrete superstructure.      The random stone foundation is to be
brought to a height of 12 feet below low water, with a width on top of
48 feet.
120          REPORT OF THE CHLEF                            OF ENGINEERS, U. S. A1tMY.

   The concrete superstructure is to have a width on bottom of 24 feet,
rising to a height of 12 feet above mean low water, with a width on
top of 12 feet. The estimated cost of this project was $675,000.
   In 1883 and 1884 the project was modified by providing a foundation
of brush mattresses for the random stone substructure, and omitting
the construction of a pile bridge across the gap, which formed part of
the project of 1882 for closing the gap.
   From the beginning of the work, in 1822, to June 30, 1885, the total
amount expended was $2,322,195.27, of which $132,066.22 was expended
on the project of 1882 for closing the gap.
   During the fiscal year ending June 30, 1886, $68,329.10 was applied
to the delivery of 30,339 tons of stone in the substructure of the work.
   It is proposed as funds, become available, to continue the work in
progress.
July 1, 1885, amount available.......... ......-................   ......       $67, 937 78
July 1, 1887, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885 .. ... ............. ..................       ...... 66,358 45
July 1, 1886, amount available .... ........... ..........  .... ...........                                       1,579 33
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886 ..................                                             56, 250 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887 .... ...............                                        57, 829 33
   Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project........ 418,750 00
   Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1888 200, 000 00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1567.
   (See Appendix F 9.)
   10. Rancocas River, New Jersey.-The Rancocas is a comparatively
large and important stream 200 yards wide at its mouth, and narrows
to about 400 feet at a distance of 8 miles above. As is usual with riv-
ers entering into the Delaware Bay and River, a bar exists at its mouth,
difficult to treat effectively and cheaply on account of the liability of
the cuts to close up unless protected by deflecting dikes. There is,
however, a low-water navigable depth of nearly 8 feet over this bar at
present.
   Ths original project provided for a low water-channel from 150 to 200
feet wide and 6 feet deep at low water to Centreton, 74 miles above the
mouth, and eventually a 5-foot low-water channel to Mount Holly, 54
miles above Centreton. The estimated cost of the whole was $82,000.
The amount expended up to June 30, 1885, was $19,833.24. On that
date a dike had been built from the head of Hamill's Island to the north
bank of the river, and a 6k-foot low-water chainel 150 feet wide cut
through Coate's Bar.
  The appropriation asked would be expended in carrying the improve-
ment up-stream by dredging the shoals in the order in which they ap-
pear.
July 1, 1885, amount available ......--....----.......... ......................                                    $166 76
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885. ......................                          ..     .................                  66 67
July 1, 1886, amount available........................................----------------------------------------.      100 09
 (Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project---..--.... 62, 000 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal yearendingJune 30,1888 10, 000 00
     harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix F 10.)
                     RIVER AND         14ARIBOR         IMPROVEMENTS.                               121




   11. Woodbury Creek, New Jersey.-The lower part of Woodbury Creek,
from its mouth to the Crown Point Road Bridge, is considered to have
sufficient depth of water at high stages of the tide for the needs of nav-
igation. The portion which should be improved is the reach extending
from this bridge to the Broad Street Bridge in the town of Woodbury,
the head of navigation. At low tide this portion of the creek is almost
entirely devoid of water, but the range of tide being between 5 and 6
feet, small vessels can ascend at high stages.
   The project of 1883 proposed to dredge a channel affording a high-
water depth of 8 feet and a width of 40 feet from Crown Point Road
Bridge to Broad Street Bridge in the town of Woodbury, at an esti-
mated cost of $15,000. This channel when once made is to be main-
tained by the parties interested.
   The sum of $450.31 was expended up to June 30, 1884, for a survey
of the creek.
   The partial dredging of a channel being of no commercial value, ex-
penditures have been withheld to await further appropriation sufficient
to complete the dredging as far as Woodbury.
July 1, 1885, amount available........................---.......-----......                   $4, 549 69
July 1, 1886, amount available .......................................--- --.                  4,549 69
( Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project.
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1888
                                                                                     ---...----...
                                                                                            10, 500 00
                                                                                             5, 000 00
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix F 11.)
   12. Mantua Creek, New Jersey.--The original project for this improve-
ment contemplates the construction of a low-water channel 10 feet deep
and 80 feet wide at the mouth of the creek, which is to diminish to 4 feet
in depth and 40 feet in width at the town of Mantua, situated some 11
miles from the mouth, at an estimated cost of $35,000.
   The stream in its natural condition possesses good depth of water for
a distance of 3 or 4 miles from the Delaware River, having a low-water
depth of 9 feet throughout this distance. Above this, however, the
channel depth slowly diminishes until at Mantua there is a low-water
depth of only 2 feet.
   No money has yet been expended on the work, and since whatever
dredging done here would not be permanent, no further appropriation
is recommended.
July 1, 1885, amount available       ..............        ........-----................      $3, 000 00
July 1, 1886, amount available .. _..........         ............................                3,000 00

  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project-----
                                                                .......                    -32,    000 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix F 12.)
   13. Raccoon River, New Jersey.-This river has a high-water width at
its mouth of about 450 feet, gradually diminishing to 100 feet at Swedes-
borough, about 91 miles up-stream. There is a good 4-foot low-water
channel and a high-water channel of from 9 to 10 feet from the mouth
of the river to more than half the distance to Swedesborough. The se-
rious and extensive obstructions are found within 2 miles of that town.
There are four bridges across the stream. Two of these are located at
Bridgeport, about 2 miles above the mouth of the river, and the other
two at Swedesborough. The lower one of the two latter is the Swedes-
122       REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

borough Railroad Bridge, and barges can pass under it; the upper one
is the Main Street Bridge, and is the head of navigation.
   The project submitted with the report on the survey, dated February
26, 1883, contemplates making the navigation up to Main Street Bridge
in-Swedesborough more safe and less difficult for the class of vessels
now navigating the stream by dredging, at an estimated cost of $18,000,
   The sum of $757.23 was expended up to June 30, 1883, for surveys,
and nothing since, the bal ance on hand being held to await further ap-
propriation.
July 1, 1885, amount available..................       .-.... ...... .... ......   $2,242 77
July 1, 1886, amount available...... .... ...... ...... ........         ........- 2, 242 77
  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project...... ..                                      16, 000 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix F 13.)
   14. Salem River, New Jersey.-The original navigable capacity of this
stream was 6 feet at low water over the bar in Salem Cove, and 3 to 4
feet at low water on the shoals at Biddle's Landing.
   The originally adopted project consisted in dredging an 8-foot low-
water channel, as wide as the vessels needed, through the bar in Salem
Cove. Subsequently the work was changed to the shoals in the canal
and river above the latter.
   The amount expended to June 30, 1885, was $13,009.34. On that
date a low-water channel 8 feet deep and 110 feet wide had been dredged
through the bar in Salem Cove, and a channel 60 feet wide and from 6
to 7 feet deep at low water had been dredged from the head of the
canal to a point about 200 feet above Biddle's Landing.
   Nothing was expended during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1886.
   The estimated amount required to complete the work according to
the existing project, that is, to Hoxie's Landing, is $4,000. If the im-
p rovement is carried up to Sharptown, the amount would be $37,000.
July 1, 1885, amount available..........                       ...............            ...........          $1, 490 66
July 1, 1886, amount available             ......--------------------..................-------..............    1,490 66
    (See Appendix F 14.)
    15. Cohansey Creek, New Jersey.-Cohansey Creek, in its original con-
dition, was navigable to Bridgeton, 20 miles above its mouth, through a
tortuous channel of ample depth. The obstructions to its free navigation
were found at Bridgeton and at its mouth, where the creek discharged
across a soft mud-bar without any well-defined channel. The gas and
water mains of the city of Bridgeton cross the creek at Broad Street at
a level of only 4 feet below low Water, and prevent the use of any fur -
ther deepening of the channel above them. In the event of the city
authorities lowering the pipes to a proper depth, the amount required
to complete the project by carrying a 6-foot low-water channel to the
 "' Nail Works" Bridge would be about $5,500.
    The original project contemplated the construction of a channel at
Bridgeton 130 feet wide and 4 feet deep, at a total cost of $30,000.
This was modified to reduce the width to 80 feet and to increase the
depth at mean low water to 7 feet from the lower steamboat landing to
the bridge, and above that point to 5 feet. This project was again
amended in June, 1880. It contemplates bringing the 7-foot low-water
channel from deep water below the lower steamboat landing upward as
far as the Commerce Street Bridge, and thence to the " Nail Works"
Bridge, a low-water channel of 6 feet, the channel to be 100 feet wide
at its lower end and to decrease to 50 feet at the upper bridge.
                      RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                123
   The total amount expended to June 30, 1885, was $35,489.27. At
that date the 7-foot low-water channel had been widened and straight-
ened, and it is now 90 feet wide between the upper and lower steam-
boat wharves, and 70 feet above that to the bridge.
   No more money can be advantageously expended until the gas and
water pipes are lowered or removed. If this is done, the amount that
can be profitably expended during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888,
is $5,500, which would complete the improvement according to the ex-
isting project.
  A~mount (estimated) required for completion of existing project........                       $5, 500 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix F 15.)
  16. Removal of wrecks from Delaware Bay and River.-There have
been no operations during the past fiscal year under this appropriation,
the removal of all wrecks having been made under the general provis-
ions for " Removing sunken vessels or craft obstructing or endangering
navigation."
July 1,1885, amount available .......       ......     ....... ...........--      .... ......   $2, 420 97
July 1, 1886, amount available .....................               .......................       2, 420 97
   (See Appendix F 16.)
   17. Removing sunken vessels or craft obstructing or endangering naviga-
tion.-Duringthe past fiscal year the following wrecks were removed
from the Delaware River under the provisions of section 4, act of June
14, 1880: The sloop Ann, from near the Deep Water Point range, off
the lower part of New Castle, Delaware, and the steam canal-boat
Thomas Carroll from near the intersection of the Schooner Ledge and
Cherry Island fiats ranges.
   (See Appendix F 17.)
   18. United States Commission Advisory to the Board of Harbor Com-
missioners of Philadelphia,Pennsylvania.--The United States Commis-
sion Advisory to the Harbor Commission of Philadelphia have had under
consideration the establishment of the Port-Wardens' lines.
   Plans were submitted for a Port-Wardens' line from the mouth of the
Schuylkill to Bridesburg, which were approved by the Harbor Com-
mission and formally adopted by the councils of the city of Philadelphia.
   This action, in connection with previous State legislation, has estab-
lished the legality of the Port-Wardens' lines for this part of the Dela-
ware River front. The commission have under consideration the plan
for the definite Port-Wardens' lines between Bridesburg and the upper
city limits, and pending the establishment of such lines, have, at the
request of the Harbor Commission, prepared a chart showing a line be-
yond which no wharf should for the present be allowed to extend. The
city councils have passed a resolution requesting the Board of Port
Wardens not to grant permission to extend wharves beyond the line
recommended.
   A physical survey of the river is now in progress between Brides-
burg and the upper limits of the city, for the purpose of obtaining the
necessary data required for the definite establishment of the Port-War-
(lens' lines for this part of the river.
   Besides the establishment of this line, the following work of the com-
mission yet remains to be accomplished: The reference of the Port-
Wardens' lines to fixed monuments; the establishment of Port-Wardens'
124       REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

lines around Smith and Windmill islands, and for the Delaware River
between the mouth of the Schuylkill and the lower city limits.
   (See AppendixF 18.)
IMPROVEMENT OF HARBORS AND RIVERS IN THE STATES OF DELA-
  WARE AND MARYLAND, AND OF MAURICE RIVER, NEW JERSEY.

   Engineer in charge, Mr. W. F. Smith, United States agent.
   1. Maurice River, New Jersey.-This river is in the southern part of
New Jersey, flowing through extensive swamps into Delaware Bay.
From a point 4 miles below the town to the mouth the depths vary from
10 to 20 feet or more; the chief obstructions are in the 4 miles just below
the town of Millville and in the bar at the entrance.
   The low-water depth over the bar is about 5 feet, with a range in the
tide of 6.1 feet. The average depth over the 4 miles just below the town
of Millville is 24 feet. The original project for this improvement con-
templates the construction of a 6-foot low-water navigation from the
mouth of the river to the town of Millville and a 4-foot navigation along
the front of the town by the removal of obstructions extending over the
4 miles below the town.
   The estimated cost was $112,000.
   The amount expended to the close of the fiscal year ending June 30,
1885, is $1,004.80, without any material change in the navigation of the
river.
   During-the fiscal year ending June 30, 1886, $18,994.14 was expended,
and has resulted in giving a channel 100 feet wide and from 5 to 6 feet
deep at low water through French's Bar, and from a point 2.14 miles
below Miliville to the town, and along its front a low-water navigable
channel of 5 feet in depth and varying from 100 to 50 feet in width, in-
cluding a cut-off through the point of land at Silver Run. This cut-off
will save in distance 1,300 feet, as welt as avoiding four abrupt bends.
   The amount that can be profitably expended during the fiscal year
ending June 30, 1888, is $20,000, which would be applied to continuing
the improvement of the river by the construction of a 6 foot navigation
from Millville to its mouth.
   The amount required for the entire completion of the work of im-
provement in accordance with approved and adopted project is $87,000,
and it is believed the improvement when made will be permanent.
July 1, 1885, amount available ..---..----...............------.............. $18,995 20
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885 ......--..--.................................-------------.. 18,994 14
                                              --................. .......
July 1, 1886, amount available ....---......--...                                                1 06
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886 ...................                       5, 000 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887-..----....-------------.............   5,001 06
    Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project .....-.   87, 000 00
    Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June30,1888 20, 000 00
    Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
      harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix G 1.)
  2. Wilmington Harbor, Delaware.-In its original condition this har-
bor had only a narrow channel entrance from the Delaware River with
a depth of 9 feet at mean low water; from thence to the city of Wilming-
ton a 12-foot navigation was available.
  The originally adopted project for the improvement provided for a low-
water navigation of 12 feet in depth with a chafinel width varying from
' feet to 150 feet, from Market Street Bridge to the entrance of the har-
our into the Delaware River.
                     RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                        125
   A later project was submitted and approved providing for a 15-foot
low-water navigation from the entrance of the harbor to the Pulp Works
above the city of Wilmington, and from thence to the Delaware Railroad
Bridge, a 12-foot low-water navigation; the width of the channel to be
150 feet from the entrance to Market Street Bridge, and from thence
to the Pulp Works 75 feet, and from that point to Delaware Railroad
Bridge 50 feet.
   This 15-foot and 12-foot navigation was to be obtained by dredging,
constructing a jetty at the entrance of the harbor, and the removal of a
small quantity of rock near Third Street Bridge.
   This project was amended in 1884, which provided for an additional
height to the jetty then already completed, and to extend it 322 feet in
length into the Delaware River. It is thought that these additions to
the jetty will check the unexpected eddying and counter-currents which
cause shoaling at some points more rapidly than before it was con-
structed; also dredging out the bar at the entrance uniting the 15-foot
curves inside the harbor with the 15-foot curve of the Delaware River.
   The amount expended to the close of the fiscal year ending June 30,
1885, was $190,956.77, and at that date the harbor had a 15-foot naviga-
tion from its entrance to Market Street Bridge and from there to the
Pulp Works a 12-foot navigation, excepting in the draw of Market Street
Bridge where in some places only 8 feet of water existed.
  The amount expended during the year ending June 30,1886, is $3,927.22,
and the result was the removal of a sunken crib off Lobdell's Canal and
the two old light-house wharves at the entrance of the harbor, each of
which were obstructions and increased the difficulties of navigation by
choking and jamming the floating ice during spring months; also the
deepening of the channel through the draw at Market Street Bridge to
a depth of 15 feet at mean low water, and a width of 80 feet.
   The amount that can be profitably expended during the year ending
June 30, 1888, is $75,000, and if appropriated it is proposed to extend
the jetty 322 feet aid to continue the work on the project for a 15-foot
navigation to the pulp works.
   The amount estimated for the completion of the improvement is
$147,634. It might be supposed that the amendment of 1884 to the
project for a 15-foot navigation would increase this estimate, but in the
Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1883, Part I, page 620, the esti-
mate of cost of this work is there increased, and it is thought the amount
now estimated for the completion of the work is sufficient to do all that
is required, including the amendment and the work of removal of the
old crib and wharves.
July 1,1885, amount available ..................---------.. .............        ...  $17, 043 23
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885    ..........                          ...... ---.... ....
                                               -.................--                     3, 927 32
July 1,1886, amount available   ............. .....................- .......          13,115 91
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5,1886 ....................------          1, 750 00

Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30,1887----...... --....--..--....       31,865 91
  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project - ---     147,634 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1888 75, 000 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 4 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix G 2.)
  3. Ice-harbor at New Castle, Delawarc.-- This important harbor of
refuge was finished August 8, 1882. It is now complete according to
126        REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

the existing project, but is greatly in need of repairs in various direc-
tions. Those most to be recommended are the continuing of the dredg-
ing inside the harbor, so as to give throughout the entire area 18 feet at
mean low water, to repair one crib, and to rebuild another, which is in
constant danger of being destroyed, and to place about 100 cubic yards
of riprap around the pier.
   The amount that can profitably be expended during the fiscal year
ending June 30, 1888, is $15,600. If this sum should be appropriated
it is proposed to expend it in dredging the harbor to a depth of 18 feet
at mean low water, to rebuild one pier, repair another, and place rip-
rapping around those piers exposed to strong currents.
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886 ....................          $5, 000 00

( Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project.......          15,600 00
    Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1888   15,000 00
    Submitted in complance with requirements of section 2 of river and
      harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
    (See Appendix G 3.)
  4. Duck Creek Delaware.-The original condition of Duck Creek was
a bar at the mouth, having 3 feet at ordinary low water,with nine shoals
with a minimum depth of 2.5 feet in the channel between the bar and
Smyrna, the head of navigation.          The approved project was to con-
struct a channel through the bar to 8 feet depth at mean low water and
having in width not less than 100 feet, and the removal of the existing
shoals as far as Smyrna to the same depth.
   The amount expended to the close of the fiscal year ending June 30,
1885,was $10,000, in making a channel through the bar at the mouth of
the creek, but the improvement was not permanent, and the channel
soon filled up for want of a protecting work.
  No work was ever done to remove the shoals between the mouth of
the river and Smyrna. The navig ation would be greatly improved if
these shoals could be removed, by enabling vessels to pass between
Smyrna and the mouth on any tide, and reach the deep water of Dela-
ware Bay with high water, whereas it now takes several high tides to
reach that point. The commerce on this stream is large and would seem
to justify the rem oval of the sho als, but it is not believed to be suffi-
cient for the expenditure necessary for the permanent improvement of
the mouth. This plan has been adopted for the improvement of both
the Saint Jones and Broadkiln rivers, and navigation has been greatly
benefited thereby, and the tendency has been, as reported by captains
of vessels sailing these rivers, since the removal of the shoals from the
bed of these rivers, to increase the depth of water over the bar at the
mouth. Nothing was done during the year ending June 30, 1886, for
want of money.
  The amount that can be profitably extended during the fiscal year
endingJune 30, 1888, is $6,000, and if appropriated will be applied to


{
the removal of the shoals between Smyrna and the mouth of the river,
to give a low -water navigation of 8 feet in depth.
  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project-------$12, 000 00
    Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1888     6, 000 00
    Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
     harber acts of 1866 and 1867.
    (See Appendix G 4.)
  5. Saint Jones River, Delawuare.-The obstructions to navigation in
this river consist of a bar at its mouth with only 2 feet in depth at mean
low water on it i from its mouth to Lebanon numerous shoals over which
                         RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                     12T
there is only 4 feet at mean low water, and from Lebanon to Dover, the.
head of navigation, 2.5 feet at low water. Many bends in the river also
interfere with navigation. The original project for the improvement of
this river was to give a 6-foot navigation by cutting a channel through
the bar at the mouth 100 feet in width, to be protected by a jetty; to
remove the shoals and make several cut-offs. The amount expended
to the close of the fiscal year ending June 30, 1885, was $719.99.
  The amount expended during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1886, is
$11,546.08, and has resulted in giving a 6-foot navigation from the mouth
of the river to Lebanon and a portion of the distance between Lebanon
and Dover. Vessels are enabled now to go from Lebanon to the mouth
of the river on any tide, and pass over the bar on high water, whereas
before the improvement they were frequently detained by low water at
each shoal.
  The amount that can be profitably expended during the fiscal year
ending June 30, 1888, is $10,000, and if appropriated will be applied to
continuing the improvement by removing the shoals, cutting off points
and bends which obstruct navigation.
  The benefits to be derived from this improvement are to shorten the
distance between Dover and the mouth of the river, and to lessen the
time required by enabling vessels to navigate the river at any tide.
July 1, 1885, amount available----..---..   -......-......-----......     ..................           $14, 162 11
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1885 ..........---------.---....--........---..        $11, 546 08
July 1, 1886, outstanding liabilities ....       ....................                        1, 122 44
                                                                                                        12, 668 52
July 1, 1886, amount available...........................................                             1,493 59
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886 .. ..................                             10,000 00


{
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887 ....................
    Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project-------- 10,000 00
    Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1888 10, 000 00
    Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
                                                                                                      11,493 59



     harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix G 5.)
   6. Mispillion -Creek, Delaware.-Inits original condition this river had
a width of about 90 feet at Milford, the head of navigation, increasing
to 240 feet at its mouth. The entrance to Delaware Bay had a depth
of li feet at mean low water, and between the mouth and Milford are
several shoals having a depth of from 4 to 5 feet on them. The origin-
ally adopted project was to make a 6-foot low-water navigation with a,
channel width of 40 feet through the bar at the mouth, and to remove
the shoals from the bed of the stream to the same depth. The amount
expended to the close of the fiscal year ending June 30, 1885, was
$13,000, in removing the shoals from the bed of the river, which has
been of benefit to the ship-building and commercial interests of this
locality.
   Nothing has been done during the year ending June 30, 1886, for
want of appropriations.
   The amount that can be profitably expended during the year ending
June 30, 1888, is $3,500, and if appropriated it is proposed to continue
the removal of the shoals between Milford and the mouth of the river
to a depth of 6 feet at mean low water, which will be a further benefit
to' navigation by allowing vessels to go up and down the stream at any
stage of the tide and lessening the time now required.
128        REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

   The estimated amount required for the entire and permanent comple-
tion of the work of improvement in accordance with the adopted pro-
ject is $58,500, and if the bar at the mouth is to be improved the whole
amount should be appropriated at once.
 (Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project........ $58, 500 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1888 3,500 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section '2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix G 6.)
   7. Broadkiln River, Delaware.-The Broadkiln River had a bar at its
mouth having only 24 feet of water over it at mean low water, and was
also obstructed by numerous shoals between its mouth and Milton, the
head of navigation.
   The original project was for a 6-foot navigation from the mouth of the
river to Milton, by improving its entrance into the Delaware Bay and
removal of the shoals from the bed of the river and cutting off certain
points.
   Owing to the appropriations being small no attempt has been made
to improve the mouth, and operations have been confined to removing
the shoals and cutting off points. The amount expended to the close of
fiscal year ending June 30, 1885, was $11,745.92 which was applied to
dredging the main shoals and to examinations of the river; $13,254.08
was expended during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1886, and resulted
in giving a 6-foot navigation at low water from Milton to the mouth of
the river. The mean rise of tide at Milton before the improvement was
commenced was 1.8 feet; after the work was finished, it was 3 feet.
Vessels are now able to pass between Milton and the mouth of the river
at any stage of the tide, saving from two to three days in time.
July 1, 1885, amount available                     .........
                                         ---...... --          ......   ......   ..-.......   ....   $13, 254 08
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885 ..............------------------.........----..-----................       13,254 08
  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project .......--------.                     31, 500 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
  (See Appendix G 7.)
  8. Broad Creek, Delaware, from its mouth to Laurel.-The originally
adopted project was to make a channel 7 feet in depth and 60 feet in
width to the town of Laurel, the estimated cost of which was $46,500;
and if training-walls, to regulate the water-way, are constructed the
estimate should be increased to $60,000.
  The project was amended by the officer in charge in 1883, who recom-
mended a channel of 6 feet in depth at mean low water, and 50 feet in
width, which is as great a width as the stream will bear, and the build-
ing of dikes for the protection of the channel. The estimated cost is
$32,625.
  The amount expended to the close of the fiscal year ending June 30,
1885, was $20,000, and a channel was excavated, 32 feet wide and 6 feet
deep at mean low water, from the railroad bridge at Laurel to a point
about 6,900 feet down the stream, and the natural channel below this
point straightened and widened by cutting off some sharp points for a
further distance of 4,300 feet.
  Nothing was done during the year ending June 30, 1886, for want of
money, no appropriations having been made for this improvement since
1882,
                  RIVER    AND     HARBOR     IMPROVEMENTS.                     129
  It is proposed to make a channel 7 feet in depth and 50 feet in width,
and to construct dikes for its protection.
SAmount (estimated)  required for completion of existing project ........ $32, 000 00
Amount that can beprofitably expended in fiscal year endingJune30, 1888 10,000 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
  (See Appendix G 8.)
   9. IndianRiver, Delaware.-The main obstructions in the Indian River
in its original condition consisted, in "The Bulkhead," over which there
was only a depth of about 2 feet at low water; the bar at its mouth with
a depth on it of only about 2 feet at mean low water, and a few ob-
structions in Indian River proper.
   The original project for the improvement was to dredge a channel 80
feet wide and 4 feet deep through " The Bulkhead"; thence a channel
straight to the inlet, protecting it by means of a dike on its northern
side, through to the sea-beach, and to construct a > -shaped dike to
bring the currents on each side at Burton's Island into more regular
confluence.
   The estimated cost of this project was $50,000. The amount expended
to the close of the fiscal year ending June 30, 1885, was $10,000, and
the cut through the Bulkhead Shoal was completed, but not to the full
width contemplated. The cut was made 4 feet in depth the entire
length of the shoal, and 80 feet wide for two-thirds of the length and 60
fect wide through the other one-third.
   Nothing was done on the improvement during the year ending June
30, 1886.
   The dredging here will amount to more than the original estimate,
and will certainly cost $60,000. Its entire completion, therefore, will
require the sum of $50,000 additional.
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project........ $50, 000 00
Submitted in compliance with requirement s of section 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix G 9.)
   10. Susquehanna River above and below Havre de Grace, Maryland.-
The first appropriation by the United States for this river was made in
1852, and at that time the navigation was obstructed by two shoals
between the light-house at Havre de Grace and Spesutia Island, upon
which there were depths of only 5 and 6 feet at mean low water. The
originally adopted project for the improvement was to increase the depth
by dredging to 12 feet at mean low water. This has been done several
times, but the improvement has not been permanent.
   A later project was submitted and approved for the improvement of
the channel to the depths of 12 and 15 feet at mean low water, respect-
ively; to dredge off the shoal above the railroad bridge and along the
west bank of the river near Watson's Island to a depth of 8 feet, with a
view to relieving the ice-gorge which usually occurs there and does
much damage; for the construction of a channel, basins, and break-
waters, under the designs of the United States Fish Commission, at
Fishing Battery light-house for use of the commission. The amount
expended to the close of the fiscal year ending June 30, 1885, was
$130,746.13, in maintaining the 12-foot low-water navigation below the
bridge; the shoal near Watson's Island was dredged back a width of
200 feet, to a depth of 8 feet at mean low water, and at Fishing Battery
light, the channel, basins, and breakwaters were constructed for use of
the United States Fish Commission.
        9E
130          REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

   The amount expended during the year ending June 30, 1886, is
$11,224.80, and the shoal near Watson's Island was dredged back a
further distance of 200 feet, to a depth of 8 feet at mean low water.
The effect of this work has been of great benefit and the tendency of the
ice to gorge lessened.
   The two important interests of the Susquehanna River below Havre
de Grace, the navigation and fishery, are somewhat in antagonism, as
the means deemed necessary for securing a permanent deeper channel
in that section of the river, viz, jetties and other regulating works, are
greatly opposed by those engaged in the fisheries.
   The alternative was submitted to Congress, in the Annual Report of
the Chief of Engineers for 1883, of appropriating at once $100,000 for
these regulating works to be put in, to the detriment of the fishery in-
terests, or to appropriate $20,000 annually for dredging.
   Assuming the alternative adopted by Congress by appropriating
$20,000 for this improvement in 1884, the amount that can be profitably
expended during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888, is $20,000. If
appropriated, it is proposed to continue the work, under the adopted
project for a 15-foot navigation below Havre de Grace, by redredging
the two shoals to that depth, and to cut off as much more of.the shoal
near Watson's Island as the balance of the funds will permit.
July 1, 1885, amount available........--- .----.. .----......--......-.. --.. $11, 643 s8
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885........................-----------------------------------------11,224                80

July 1, 1886, amount available--..------------...--...----...----....--------.....------....                 419 07
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886---......--....-....-                                   6, 000 00
                                                      - -- -           - - -- - - - -.
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887 ..................                                  6,419 07

                                                             .............
   Amount (estimated) required for annual dredging-- ...-----------------                                20, 000 00
   Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1888                            20, 000 00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
     harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix G 10.)
   11. Chester River, at Rent Island Narrows, ]liarytland.-The approved
project was to reopen a channel, formerly existing between Chester
River and Eastern Bay, which had been shut up by a solid causeway
under the authority of the State of Maryland. This project was com-
pleted and an unexpended balance of $2,500, has remained since 1878.
   No further work is deemed necessary. The channel opened seems to
be of little use, and, as no steamers pass through, it has been gradually
filling up.
July 1, 1885, amount available----......----------................--......----..---............          $2, 500 00
July 1, 1886, amount available.................--------   ---....--------------......-----....--------    2,500 00
    (See Appendix G 11.)
  12. Chester River,frontm Spry's Landing to Crumpqton,Maryland.--In its
original condition only                   64
                            feet of water could be carried betweeu these
two places.
   The originally adopted project was for dredging an artificial channel
120 feet wide and 8 feet deep at mean low water. This project was com-
pleted in July, 1883. No work has been done on this locality since that
time.
   The amount expended to June 30, 1885, was $13,000, which was the
original estimate for the improvement.
    (See Appendix G 12.)
                     RIVER AND         HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                      131
   13. Corsica Creek, Maryland.-The condition of this stream originally
was such that navigation between Hooper's Wharf and the town of
Centreville was kept up by the use of lighters.
   The originally adopted project for the improvement was to construct
a channel 100 feet wide and 8 feet deep at mean low water, from Hooper's
Landing to the town of Centreville, with a turning basin at the head.
The estimated cost was $30,000. To the close of the fiscal year ending
June 30, 1885, $10,000 had been appropriated for this improvement, and
a channel 8 feet deep at low water and 50 feet in width has been made
from Hooper's Landing to within 344 feet of the County Bridge, the
head of n avigation. The channel was also straightened by cutting off
a point of land near the town of Centreville, the right to which was
given the United States free of cost.    Steamers are able now to reach
Centreville Landing, and lighterage is no longer necessary. Nothing
was done during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1886, for want of funds.
   The amount that can be profitably expended during the fiscal year
ending June 30, 1888, is $10,000, and if appropriated it is proposed to
apply the same to the continuance and completion of the improvement
in accordance with adopted project.
   The commerce of the creek is very large, and navigation has been
greatly benefited by the improvement, as well as a saving in expense
of lighterage.
July 1, 1885, amount available .........................................      $308 86
July 1, 1886, amount available .............- ..... .............. .....       308 86
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886 ...................      10,000 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887 ..................    10,308 86
SAmount (estimated)   required for completion of existing project........ 10,000 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1888 10, 000 00
] Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
 ( harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix G 13.)
   14. Choptank River, Maryland.-This river originally had a depth of
about 9 or 10 feet of water, except at one point, as high up as Denton,
where, the mean rise of tide is about 2 feet. Between Denton and
Greensborough, the portion 6n which the improvement has been made,
the width varies from 100 to 650 feet, with a depth varying from 2 feet
to 8 feet at mean low water.
   The originally adopted project for the improvement of the river was
for an 8-foot low-water channel, with a width of 75 feet, at a cost of
$79,000. It was stated, however, that the cost would be much reduced
if the depth was kept at 7 feet.
   The total amount appropriated for this improvement to the close of
the fiscal year ending June 30, 1885, was $20,000, and a 6-foot low-water
navigation has been attained from Denton to Case's Wharf, and from
thence to the town of Greensborough 5-foot low-water navigation has
been made. The width of the artificial channel varies from 47 feet to
75 feet.
   There were no operations during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1886.
   The estimated amount required to complete the work of improvement
in accordance with the adopted project is $47,000. The benefits ex-
pected by the completion of this improvement are, that a larger class
of steamers and vessels will navigate this portion of the river, and
freights reduced thereby. Denton and Greensborough are both thriv-
ing towns on the eastern shore of Maryland, and large quantities of
132        REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

grain, lumber, fruit, and other products are shipped from there to Bal-
timore by water.
   A small steamer has already been put on this river between Denton
and Greensborough, since the improvement has begun, and a larger
steamer comes within 8 miles of the town of Greensborough.
July 1, 1885, amount available              ..            ---------------------------------------
                                                                                        $.109 25
July 1, 1886, amount available.......... .....................           ...........            109 28
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886 .....................                     10,000 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887 .-....                ..............   10,109 28
  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project-.--.--. 47,000 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1888 10, 000 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix G 14.)
   15. Wicomico River, .Maryland.--In the original condition, this river
was only navigable to a point several miles below the town of Salisbury.
   The originally adopted project for the improvement of this river was
to give 7-foot low-water navigation in a channel about 70 feet in width
for a distance of about 2 miles below Salisbury.
   The project also included some dikes for the contraction of the water-
way, and as a place behind which to deposit material removed from the
channel.
   The project approved for the expenditure of the appropriation of July
5, 1884, recommended an amendment to the original project by straight-
ening and widening the channel from 85 to 100 feet.
   The amount expended to the close of the fiscal year ending June 30,
1885, was $45,524.17, and a 7-foot low-water channel had been made to
the town of Salisbury, with a width of 70 feet the entire distance, and
from 85 to 100 feet in width, to within 2,217 feet of the town. Also a
good turning-basin has been excavated near the town.
   The amount expended during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1886,
is $3,105.36, and the remaining portion of the channel, 2,217 feet, was
widened to 85 and 100 feet to correspond to the balance of the artificial
channel, which work completed the project.
   No further improvement seems necessary to this river at present.
The improvement made has been of great benefit to navigation, and
placed Salisbury, Md., in direct communication with Baltimore by
water.
July 1, 1885, amount available .......................... ................                   $4, 478 16
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885...-----..........................-----------......---........      3, 105 36

July 1, 1886, amount available.---.....-.-...                    .   ....           ....      1,372 80
   (See Appendix G 15.)
  16. Upper Thoroughfare,between Deil's Island and the mainland.--This
water-passage separates Deil's Island from the mainland of Somerset
County, Maryland. At its eastward end this passage is an arm of Tan-
gier Sound, of considerable width, narrowing and shoaling rapidly, and
exposed to southwest storms.
  The original project of this improvement was to provide a harbor of
refuge for small vessels, and a place at which steamers could stop and
hring the people and their abundant crops from the land and water
into quick communication with the markets of Baltimore and Philadel-
phia by dredging an anchorage basin with an approach to deep water,
                             RIVER AND                 HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                133
and construct a breakwater for its protection from filling. The esti-
mate of the cost of this improvement is $20,000. No work has been
done as yet, as the funds available are inadequate to be applied advan-
tageously.
  The Maryland Steamboat Company, running from Baltimore, have a
pier at DeiPs Island.
July 1, 1885, amount available ......-----------......--------......----......-...--...------......--.....        . $4.669 91
July 1, 1886, amount available                    ......................................-.                           4,669 91

SAmount (estimated) required for completion of existing project........-------- 15,000 00
   Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1888                                         5, 000 00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
     harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
    (See Appendix G 16.)
IMPROVEMENT OF PATAPSCO RIVER AND CHANNEL TO BALTIMORE,
   MARYLAND, AND OF THE HARBOR OF ANNAPOLIS, MARYLAND.

  Officer in charge, Lieut. Col. W. P. Craighill, Corps of Engineers.
  1. Channel to Baltimore, Maryland.-The depth of this channel has
been by successive steps increased from 17 feet at mean low water to
27 feet, with an average rise of tide of about 18 inches.
  The project of improvement at first adopted and commenced in October,
1853, had for its object to give a channel 22 feet at mean low water with
a width of 150 feet.
   Little was done before the late war, but afterwards these dimensions
were increased, a depth of 24 feet at mean low water being determined
upon, with a width of channel ranging from 250 to 400 feet. This chan-
nel was completed in 1874, important changes of position having been
given to a portion of it, by which the distance was materially lessened
and the expense of maintenance decreased.
  The object of the improvement was to permit the approach to Balti-
more at mean low water of vessels drawing from 22) to 23 feet, and at
ordinary high water of vessels drawing 24 and 24) feet.
  The last appropriation previous to 1884 was in August, 1882, $450,000,
there being none in 1883. This was expended in giving a depth of 27
feet in the Fort McHenry, Brewerton, and Craighill branches of the
channel, and in the " cut-off" between the Brewerton and Craighill
branches, by which last a saving of nearly a mile in distance was made,
besides an improvement in direction and diminution in cost of main-
tenance. The width attained was, however, too little.
  For want of funds the work of improvement was entirely suspended
during the whole of the year ending June 30, 1886.
  Advantage was taken of the absence of the dredges with their numer-
ous attendant tugs and scows to make a thorough resurvey of the whole
channel, the map of which has also been prepared.
  The following are the widths of the respective branches of the chan-
nel June 30, 1886, with a depth of 27 feet at mean low water:
                                                                                                                           Feet.
Craighill Channel..----....----..--....................--..------------------......      ------....------....-- ..-----......      350
Cut-off Channel      ---------------------- -----....................................--
                                                                                    ---------------- ---........----............
                                                                                                                              ---- 300
Brewerton Channel..--......--      ......-----------......--......-----......--------..---------......---............              250
Fort McHenry Channel......----.....       ------      ------        ----.....................        ...............--             250
  Though the depth of 27 feet at low water has been reached, and seems
to suffice for the present needs, the width is too little for easy or safe
navigation by very large vessels, whose length is considerably greater
than the width of the channel.
134         REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

   Up to June 30, 1886, the United States h'ad expended $2,032,833.72,

     2Maryland,
with the results indicated above. The city of Baltimore and the State
of            chiefly the former, had contributed to the same object
$584,000. The estimate below is for making the channel of a uniform
width of 400 feet, which is still too little.
July 1, 1885, amount available.....---.------..............-.             ....----..........------.      30,8416 41
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, l85 .-..--- --                     ..--..----             -
                                                                    .............-----    ...--.. .       6, 052 97
July 1, 1886, amount available .--...--...-                 ---..--....--...-...----....--..........    24, 793 44
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886----......-..----..-..--......                        150, 000 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887-                         --...................--
                                                                                                174,793 44
 {Amount      (estimated) required for completion of existing project.-- - -.. .
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1888 80, 000 00
                                                                                                        80, 000 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix H 1.)
   2. Harbor of Annapolis, Maryland.-An appropriation of $5,000 was
made for this harbor June 14, 1880, and another of the same amount
March 3, 1881. Until recently it had not been considered necessary or
expedient to spend the money for reasons which have been fully stated
in several preceding annual reports.
   Information was received towards the close of 1885 that certain areas
within the harbor had shoaled considerably, and the free movement of
vessels was consequently much impeded. As soon as possible an ex-
amination was made of these shoal portions, much delay having been
caused by the presence of ice, by high winds, &c.
   The survey was finished late in April, and the map completed in
May. It has been deemed necessary to dredge a part of the harbor to
a depth of 20 feet, and a part to a depth of 14 feet, at mean low water.
   The work was duly advertised and put under contract, and is to be
finished in 1886.
   There yet remain two bars with not more than 18 feet on them at
mean low water, which prevent large ships from passing from the bay
into the deeper water (24 feet and more) of the Severn River, just
abreast the Naval Academy.
   The commerce of Annapolis is small. Its importance arises mainly
from its being the seat of the Naval Academy, and from its strategic
relations to the capital of the nation. -
   A project, suggested several years ago, for the removal of these bars
by dredging a channel through through them 24 feet deep at mean low water,
with minimum width of 150 feet, is estimated to cost $66,000, which, if
due regard be had for econony, should be provided in one sum and
spent in a single season.
   The rise of tide is about 1 foot.
July 1, 1885, amount available-..------...... ------......---.............------... ---------..--. 9, 205 98
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885 .............................................                                    436 99
July 1, 1886, amount available ...................                    ..........        ....   ......     8, 768 99
  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project--........
                                                                        -                               66, 000 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1888                            66, 000 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
     harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix H 2.)
                         RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                  135
   3. Removing sunken vessels or craft obstructing or endangering naviga-
tion.-Notice was received   in June, 1886, that there was a dangerous
wreck near Cove Point, Chesapeake Bay. Upon investigation this ves-
sel was found to be the schooner Oliphant, loaded with guano, bound
from Baltimore. The necessary steps have been taken for her removal,
in conformity to the law of June 14, 1880.
   (See Appendix II 3.)

IMPROVEMENT OF THE HARBORS AT WASHINGTON AND GEORGETOWN,
  DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA-IMPROVEMENT OF THE POTOMAC RIVER
  AT WASHINGTON, DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA--IMPROVEMENT OF JAMES
  RIVER, VIRGINIA, AND OF SHENANDOAH RIVER, WEST VIRGINIA.

  Officer in charge, Maj. Peter C. Hains, Corps of Engineers.
  1. Harbors at Washington and Georgetown, .Districtof Columbia.-The
improvement of the harbors at Washington and Georgetown was first
undertaken by the Government in 1870. Prior to that time the chan-
nel over the bar below Georgetown had only 8 feet of.water at mean
low tide. It was crooked, narrow, and difficult to navigate, so much so
that up to 1870 the corporation of Georgetown had itself spent consider-
able money in dredging it. The channel over the bar below Long
Bridge was less troublesome and somewhat deeper, but did not satisfy
the wants of commerce.
   The Washington Channel, or Harbor, along the city front from the
northern limit of the arsenal to Long Bridge, had a ruling depth of only
10 feet at mean low tide. There were, besides, in the harbor of George-
town, many projecting rocks with a depth of water over them that ren-
dered navigation difficult and dangerous.
  The original project looked to securing a depth of 16 feet at low tide
to Georgetown, and along the wharves of the Washington Harbor from
Arsenal Point to Long Bridge, and the removal of the most dangerous
rocks that obstructed navigation in the harbor of Georgetown. When
by act of August 2, 1882, Congress made an appropriation for improv-
ing the Potomac River in the vicinity of Washington, D. C., having
reference to the improvement of navigation, the establishment of the
harbor lines, and the raising of the flats, the project was modified to
the removal of rocks in Georgetown Harbor to the depth of 20 feet at
mean low tide, that being the depth to be given to the channel below.
   The total amount expended on the improvement of Washington and
Georgetown harbors up to the close of the fiscal year ending June 30,
1886, is $290,000. Of this amount, $260,821.45 has been expended in
dredging. The remainder was expended in the removal of rocks in
Georgetown Harbor. At the present time there is 20 feet of water at
mean low tide in both harbors.
  During the past year operations were confined to completing the re-
moval of rocks in Georgetown Harbor, and in dredging the Georgetown
Channel above Long Bridge. The removal of rocks was completed
in November, 1885. The completion of this work left a balance of
$11,316.17, which was applied to dredging the Georgetown Channel
above Long Bridge, which was done under contract, the material being
deposited on the Potomac Flats.
July 1, 1885, amount available..--                .....-----        ------ ----------..
                                                               ..--------                          $18, 425 67
July 1, 1856, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1885..........---------------------............... $16, 909 79
July 1, 1886, outstanding li~abilities..----....................                     1,515 88
                                                                                                    18,425 67
   (See Appendix I 1.)
136    REPORT OF THE CHIEF         OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

   2. Potomac River at Washington, District of Columbia.-The project
for the improvement of the Potomac River in the vicinity of Washing-
ington, D. C., was adopted by act of Congress, passed August 2, 1882,
and has for its object the improvement of the navigation of the river
by widening and deepening its channels so as to accommodate ves-
sels of the largest class that can reach Giesboio' Point, the establish-
ment of harbor lines beyond which no obstructions, such as wharves,
&c., should be built, and at the same time to fill and raise the marshes
or flats in front of the city above overflow by the highest freshets, the
material taken from the river in deepening and widening the channel
to be used in filling the flats.
    Before the improvement was commenced the flats or marshes in front
of the city had become so offensive that parts of the city in their neigh.
borhood were not habitable.
    The channel to Georgetown was narrow and crooked, and had not
sufficient depths to accommodate vessels sailing to and from that port;
the Washington Channel, between Long Bridge and the Arsenal, was
also inadequate to the wants of commerce. Vessels drawing 16 feet fre-
quently grounded in the Georgetown Channel, and that depth was only
maintained by frequent dredging.
    The expenditures for the improvement have thus far amounted to
 $739,574.19, and have given a channel from Giesboro' Point to George-
town over 300 feet wide and 20 feet deep (except where the depth has
been somewhat reduced by the'deposits of freshets), and a channel along
the wharves from Washington Barracks 20 feet deep and from 200 to
350 feet wide. About 4,230,000 cubic yards of material have been de-
posited on the fiats, raising an area of about 375 acres of marshes to
a height of from 4 to 10 feet above mean low tide. The dredging dur-
ing the past fiscal year was done by contract. The method used is that
known as the ' hydraulic." The material forming the bed of the river
is stirred up by a system of plows at the base of the suction-pipe and,
passing up through a centrifugal pump, is forced ashore through dis-
charge-pipes, resting on pontoons.
    The contract for dredging 1,000,000 cubic yards from the Washing-
ton channel is about completed. The material was all deposited on
Section III, below Long Bridge. The contract for dredging the Virginia
channel above Long Bridge (1,000,000 cubic yards) has been greatly re-
tarded by freshets, ice, and stormy weather, but particularly by the
amount of sand found in the material dredged. Good progress was
being made when, on the night of the 19th of June, 1886, the best of the
three dredges on the work was destroyed by fire.
    The contract for dredging the Virginia Channel below Long Bridge,
and a portion of the Tidal Reservoir (700,000 cubic yards) has progressed
satisfactorily, and is now near completion.
    The past year has been noted for the great number of freshets. These
have retarded work, and have filled up to some extent the dredged
channels. The failure to make an appropriation in 1885 has also been
of great detriment to the work. It is of the utmost importance that
large appropriations should be made in the early stages of a work of
this character and magnitude. It is now in such a stage of progress
that it is liable to, and during the past winter received, great damage
from freshets. It should be pushed rapidly to a point nearer comple-
tion.
  Provision should be made at an early day for retaining-walls to the
sewer canal. An estimate was submitted in a former report. The esti-
mated cost of such walls, built of concrete, would be about $20,144.
There is little current in this canal; the level rises and falls with the
                        RIVER AND             HARBOR         IMPROVEMENTS.                          137
tide. It receives, however, a large portion of the sewage of the city,
which is pushed out in the river only by the continuous additions it re-
ceives. The plan of improvement contemplates the construction of a
small tidal reservoir of about eight acres near the head of the sewer canal.
Such a reservoir can be made to discharge about 1,000,000 cubic feet
of water into it at each ebb tide; and this amount of: fresh water dis-
charged into the canal at proper intervals, daily, will ameliorate its
present offensive condition, but as the city grows larger, and the quan-
tity of sewage greater, it will only be a partial remedy. It is under-
stood that the District authorities propose to establish a pumping sta-
tion at the foot of Seventeenth street, and pump the sewage far out into
and down the river-the canal to receive only the discharge from the
sewer during a heavy rainfall. Such an arrangement is entirely practi-
cable, and, it is believed, would solve this sewage problem in a satis-
factory manner.
   .The officer in charge of this improvement reports that the time has
now come when something should be done in regard to Long Bridge.
The Board of Engineers that recommended the present plan of im-
provement stated in its report that "the Long Bridge should be rebuilt
at an early period during the progress of the improvements." No plan
can be made satisfactory while this bridge remains a serious obstruc-
tion to the flow of water beneath it.      The riprap stone placed around
the piers for their protection, together with the piers themselves, form
a partial dam across the river, obstructing its flow, and will eventually
cause a gradual deposit of sediment in the river above it. When the
upper end of Washington Channel is closed, as it is intended to be, pro-
vision must be made in the Virginia Channel for discharging the freshet
water that now passes through both. This cannot be done under the
present bridge.     It should, therefore, be rebuilt on piers with greater
spans.
    The sum of $700,000 can be profitably expended during the fiscal
year ending June 30, 1888. If this sum be appropriated it will be ex-
pended in continuation of the work, in accordance with the approved
project, in dredging the Virginia and Washington channels and filling
Sections I,II, and III, in dredging the Tidal Reservoir, and building the
inlet and outlet gates.
July 1, 1885, amount available ......-...... ..........                                   $358, 027 93
                                                                            . ............--
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive
  of liabilities outstanding July 1, 1885.- -...                             $197,
                                                                   -............     602 12
July 1, 1886, outstanding liabilities....................----------------------   38, 188 75
                                                                                               235, 790 87

July 1, 1886, amount available........................................                         122, 237 06
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886---..-................                       375, 003 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887 .................                        497, 237 06
  Amonnt (estimated) required for completion of existing project...... 1,441,365 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June
     30, 1858...........................................- ...........700, 000 00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix I 2.)
  3. James River, Virginia.-When the improvement of the James
River was regularly undertaken by the Government, the navigation
was obstructed by sunken vessels, by remains of military bridges, and
by other obstructions purposely put in the river during the late war to
prevent the national fleet from approaching too close to Richmond.
138         REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

There were, besides, other material obstructions. Rocketts' Reef and
Richmond Bar had only 7 feet of water at mean low tide; from War-
wick Bar to Richmond the channel was crooked and obstructed by
dangerous rocks and ledges; the Dutch Gap Cut-off was not then open
and the river was in a poor condition as regards its availability for com-
mercial purposes.
    The original project for improvement was to secure a depth of 18 feet
                                                  tide) to Richmond, with a
at full tide (corresponding to 14.5 feet at low tide)
channel width of 180 feet. This project had reached an advanced stage
of progress when Congress, by act approved July 5, 1884, adopted the
project looking to 22 feet at mean low tide from the sea to Richmond,
the width to be 400 feet from the sea to City Point, 300 feet from thence
to Drury's Bluff, and 200 feet from thence to Richmond.
    Operations during the past year have been restricted chiefly to an
endeavor to maintain the condition of affairs that existed at the be-
ginning of the fiscal year. The failure of the river and harbor bill of
1885 rendered the undertaking of new work impracticable.
    The year has been remarkable for the frequency of high freshets.
These have caused deposits of sand and silt, which had to be immediately
removed. The total expenditures of the Government up to the close of
the fiscal year 1886, on the improvement of this river, wire $812,440.73.
In addition to that the city of Richmond has expended $444,696.45.
    The results of these expenditures may be stated as follows: Swan
Point Shoal, where the depth had only been 16.5 feet at mean low tide,
was deepened to 20 feet. This increase of depth adds a foot to the
available depth of the river from its mouth to Kingsland Reach, a dis-
tance of 98 miles. The Dutch Gap Cut-off, which was of no use to navi-
gation, has been widened to 300 feet, with a depth of about 18 feet, shorten-
ing the distance to Richmond 5.- miles. From Drury's Bluff to the
ship-locks at Richmond the de th has been increased from 7 feet at low
tide to the present depth of a on 13.5 feet at low tide.
    It is proper to add that a river subjected to such freshets as the James
will require an annual expenditure to maintain the depth that is to be
made. Experience can alone determine what that amount will he, but
it is thought that not less .than $15,000 will be required annually, de-
pending on the number and height of the freshets.
     The light sediment held in suspension will be carried far down the
  river, and the greater part deposited in places .where it will do no harm ;
  but the sand and gravel rolled along the bottom, the amount of which
  is large, will drop in the upper section of the river, and must be re-
  moved or it will cause an obstruction to navigation.
     The amount that can be profitably expended during the fiscal year
ending June 30, 1888, is put at $400,000. This is less than one tenth
  the estimated cost of the entire project.
July 1,1885, amount available------------------------
                                   ..............----------.........................         $19,256 22
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885 ...........................................                        16,696 95
July 1, 1886, amount available---..---------
                                    ......--------......----...... ....----...............
                                                                                    -----      2, 559 27
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886........... ....                           112, 500 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30,. 1887 .............                        115, 059 27
rAmount (estimated)required for completion of existing project ...... 4,263,570 45
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June
      30, 1888......----.         .
                                ......   ......
                                       .....                                    . ....
                                                      ..... ..... ...............               400, 000
 ( Submitted in compliance         with requirements of section 2 of river and
      harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix I 3.)
                          RIVER AND HARBOR                       IMPROVEMENTS.                                  139
  4. Shenandoah River,                    VWest
                                 Virginia.--Congress, by act of June 14,
1880, made an appropriation of $15,000 for improving the Shenandoah
River, West Virginia. By act of March 3, 1881, an additional appro-
priation of $2,500 was made for the same object. A proviso was added
to the latter act, to the effect that neither ot these appropriations shall
be expended " until any corporate rights or franchises that may exist
over said river shall have been relinquished to the United States, to
the satisfaction of the Secretary of War." This condition has been
complied with.
   The project for the improvement has for its object the rebuilding of
the locks, dams, and chutes of the navigation company, so as to secure
a down-stream navigation of about 18 inches. At the present time
there is practically no commerce to be benefited by this improvement,
and whether any would be built up by it is a question. Congress, by
act of July 4, 1884, sold the sites of the lower locks that would be
needed in this improvement, and with them all the water privileges at
Harper's Ferry. The right to use a portion of the water to operate
these locks, and the sites of the locks themselves, would, therefore, have
to be purchased again by the United States. The question has now
been raised, Can the United States undertake this improvement in view
of the late act authorizing the sale of the Harper's Ferry property ?
   Under the circumstances, and in view of the fact that there does not
appear to be any commerce to be benefited by the improvement, fur-
ther legislation is asked.
July 1, 1885, amount available-------....-----......-------......---......---....-               .---....-- $16, 083 40
                                                                                      -....--...--
July 1, 1886, amount available.......------------....................------------....--------......--....    16, 083 40
    (See Appendix I 4.)

IMPROVEMENT OF THE H-ARBORS AT BRETON BAY AND SAINT JEROME'S
  CREEK, MARYLAND-OF THE CHANNEL A'f MIOUNT VERNON--OF RAP-
  PAHANNOCK RIVER, AND YORK RIVER, VIRGINIA-OF TRIBUTARIES
  OF THE LOWER POTOMAC, AND OF CERTAIN RIVERS IN VIRGINIA AND
  :NORTH CAROLINA.

   Engineer in charge, Mr. S. T. Abert, United States Agent; Supervis-
ing Engineer, Lieut. Col. W. P. Craighill, Corps of Engineers.
   1. Channel at Mount Vernon, Virginia.-Previous to the commence-
ment of this improvement there was a depth of but 4 feet at low water
over the wide flat between the wharf at Mount Vernon and the main
channel of the Potomac River, a distance of 1,900 feet.
   The present project for improvement was adopted in 1879, the object
being to excavate a channel from deep water of the Potomac River to
the wharf at Mount Vernon, which should have a width of 150 feet, and
a navigable depth of from 6 to 7 feet at low water, with turning-basin
at the wharf. The amount, expended to the close of the fiscal year end-
ing June 30, 1882, was $8,442.86, which resulted in securing a,channel
145 feet wide, with a depth varying from 7 to 9 feet from the Potomac
Channel to the wharf, and a circular turning-basin at the wharf of the
same depth, with a radius of 150 feet.
   No recent examination has been made, but the Superintendent at
Mount Vernon reports that the steamer, drawing 4 feet, finds great
difficulty in making the turn at the pier, and the engineer in charge be-
lieves that $5,500 will be necessary for widening the channel, enlarging
the turning-basin, and removing the silt which has been deposited in
140      REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

the cat, and that this sum will complete the proposed plan of improve-
ment.
July 1, 1885, amount available .... ........ ...... ..... . ....
                                                              ..--..
                                                                   ......       $57 14
                                                            . . ...... ..
July 1, 1886, amount available..--.. .....-............. .....                   57 14
IAmount (estimated) required for completion of existing project.... .... 5,500 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year endingJune 30, 1888   5, 500 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
  (See Appendix J 1.)
   2. -Neabsco Creek, Virginia.-The obstruction to navigation in this
stream consisted of a wide flat at the mouth, about 1 miles in length,
over which but 24 feet could be carried at low water, and several short
bars in the upper part of the creek where the channel is narrow and
tortuous.
   The present project was adopted in 1881, and contemplated the exca-
vation of a channel through the bars, 100 feet wide and 7 feet deep at
low water, from the Potomac River to Atkinson's Upper Landing (in-
cluding a channel to Atkinson's Lower Landing and Willis's Wharf), a
distance of about 14,800 feet.
   The amount expended to the close of the fiscal year ending June 30,
1884, was $4,942.73, which resulted in securing a channel 50 feet wide,
and from 4 to 5 feet deep at low water, from the Potomac River to a
point 1,800 feet above Willis's Wharf, where the creek is narrow and
has a sufficient depth, although other bars still exist above this point.
Twenty thousand doliars will complete the improvement as far as seems
to be needed at the present time.
July 1, 1885, amount available .........................................        $57 27
July 1, 1886, amount available .........................................         57 '27
  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project..------- 20, 000 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1888 5,000 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section '2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
  (See Appendix J 2.)
  3. Breton Bay, Leonardtown, Maryland.--The harbor of Leonardtown,
at the upper end of Breton Bay, prior to the commencement of the pres-
ent improvement, had a least depth of 5 feet at low water, which was
insufficient for the passage of steamers to and from the Leonardtown
Wharf. The bar which extended to the 9-foot curve in the bay was
about 1 mile in length.
  The present project for the improvement was adopted in 1878, the ob-
ject being to excavate a channel 150 feet wide and 9 feet deep between
the 9-foot curve-in the bay and Leonardtown Wharf.
  The engineer in charge recommends increasing the width of the chan-
nel to 200 feet, and enlarging the basin to a length of 800 feet, and a
width of 400 feet. The depth should not be less than 10 feet at low
water.
  Up to June 30, 1885, $22,950.49 was expended in removing 131,358
cubic yards of material. The channel was at that time 115 feet wide
and from 9 to 10 feet deep.
  The appropriation recommended is for the object of dredging a per-
manent channel to the Leonardtown Wharf.
  Leonardtown is one of the landings of the Baltimore and Potomac
River boats.
                     RIVER AND          HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                       141
July 1, 1885, amount available ......     .   ..... ......   ............   ............          $49 51

July 1, 1886, amount available .................. .... ......-............                 -       49 51
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886 ...................                          6,500 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30,1887............ .......                        6, 549 51

SAmount
( Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project........     19,500 00
          that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1888 10, 000 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix J 3.)
   4. Noomini Creek, Virginia.-This stream is an'important tributary of
the Potomac, 82 miles below Washington, draining a large area of pro-
ductive country.
   Navigation was obstructed by a bar of sand and oyster shells at its
mouth, over which but 3 feet could be carried at low water, and the
danger in passing the bar was further increased by the cross-tide and
an exceedingly rapid current. The length of the bar to the 9-foot curve
in Nomini Bay is 5,700 feet. After passing the bar 81 feet can be car-
ried to Nomini Ferry, 3 miles above the mouth.
   The engineer in charge recommends the enlargement of the width
from 150 to 200 feet; also to dredge a training-channel and to sink a
mattress for the purpose of diverting a cross-current detrimental to the
integrity of the main channel and obstructive to steamers which enter
it. The amount recommended in 1885 for this purpose was $30,000.
   The landings in Nomini Creek are the most important of the Balti-
more and Potomac River boats.
   The amount expended to June 30, 1886, was $32,500, which resulted
in securing a channel 100 feet wide and 9 feet deep from the 9-foot
curve in the bay to White Oak Point, a distance of 4,400 feet.
  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project-. ------ $30, 000 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1888                   10,000 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix J 4.)
  5. Harbor at entrance of Saint Jerome's Creek, Maryland.-SaintJe-
rome's Creek enters the Chesapeake Bay 91 miles south of Baltimore
and 6 miles north of Point Lookout. The outer bar in the bay has
a length of 2,193 feet from the ninth-foot curve in the bay to Corsey's
Point in the creek. The least depth of water on it before improvement
was 2.8 feet. The average depth in the channel to the ponds used by
the Fish Commission for hatching oysters was one-half foot. The length
of the inner channel to the wharf of the Fish Commission is 3,742 feet.
   The project for the improvement of this harbor was adopted in 1881,
and contemplated dredging a channel 100 feet wide and 9 feet deep at
low-water through the outer bar at the mouth of the creek, and a chan-
nel 40 feet wide and 6 feet deep through the south prong of the creek,
the material therefrom to be thrown up in a dike, if practicable, so as
to form a pond of a portion of. this south prong for the purposes of the
United States Fish Commission.
   This harbor is situated at a desirable point for a refuge for oyster-
boats.
   Up to June 30, 1885, $20,289.37 was expended, and during the fiscal
year ending June 30, 1886, $3,779.10 have been expended, making a
total, to June 30, 1886, of $24,068.47.
142         REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S ARMY.

July 1, 1885, amount available----............--...... ...........-                      ........       $6, 210
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive
  of liabilities outstanding July 1, 1885 ......-             ....--....--........    $3, 739 10
July 1, 1886, outstanding liabilities...... ....................                             40 00
                                                                                                         3,779 10

July 1, 1886, amount available ....----
                                     ...........---........----------..               ...........--.-    2, 431 53

 (Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project--------........                        26, 000 00
  Amount that can be proli tably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1888                            18, 000 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
l harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix J 5.)
   6. Rappahannock River, Virginia.-The distance from Fredericksburg
to the mouth of the river is 106k miles.
   The present project for the improvement of this river was adopted in
1.871 and modified in 1879, the object being to provide a channel 150
feet wide and 10 feet deep through the bar at Fredericksburg, channels
100 feet wide and 10 feet deep through the bars between Fredericks-
burg and Port Royal, and channels 200 feet wide and 15 feet deep
through two bars between Port Royal and Tappahannock, wgere a
larger class of vessels should be provided for.
   Between March 3, 1871, and June 30, 1879, $90,500 was expended on
the first project.
   The amount expended on the present project from June 14, 1880, to
June 30, 1886, is $75,898.70. This expenditure has resulted in securing,
by means of dredging at various times and the construction of longitu-
dinal and spur dikes, navigable channels at Fredericksburg, Pollock's,
Bernard's, Pratt's, Spottswood, Castle's Ferry, and Farley Vale bars,
extending over a distance of 12.6 miles.
July 1, 1885, amount available .--..--. ..------
                                            .........----....................                $11, 554 69
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1885----..-- -...---....----.... --........... $10, 154 83
July 1, 1886, outstanding liabilities-...---..-----------.................            298 56
                                                                                              10, 453 39
July 1, 1886, mount available.........---------------------......--..........---......-----......---....  1,101 30
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886 ...........                                    ....-- 20, 000 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887..................                                 21, 101 30

 ( Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project-....... 194, 000 00
   Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1888 30,000 00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
     harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix J 6.)
  7. Totusky River, Virginia.-The obstructions to the navigation of this
river consisted of two bars, one at its mouth, which forms a part of the
wide flat between the outlet of the river and the navigable channel of
the Rappahannock, having a least depth of 41 feet, and the other about
2- miles above the mouth, known as Booker's Bar, having a ruling
depth of 3 feet. The improvement of Booker's Bar is needed for pur-
poses ot navigation.
  Ten thousand dollars have been appropriated for this work up to
August 2, 1882. This sum has been expended in building a longitudi-
nal dike 2,117 feet in length, the effect of which has been to scour out
the channel to a depth of 34 feet at low water, but this action is slow
                      RIVER AND          HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS                                        143
in its results. The channel should be dredged if prompt improvement
of the navigation is desirable. For this object $12,000 will be required.
July 1, 1885, amount available..........................................                          $400 82
July 1, 1886, amount available ......-..........................               .......     ..      400 82

IAmount (estimated) required for completion of existing project........                         12,000 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1888                      5,000 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix J 7.)
   8. Urbana Creek, Virginia.-This creek is a tidal tributary of the
Rappahannock, which it enters 91 miles below Fredericksburg, Va.
   Prior to the commencement of this improvement the navigation was
obstructed by a bar at the mouth, over which but 6 feet of water could
be carried.
  The present project was adopted in 1879, the object being to excavate
a channel through this bar 150 feet wide and 10 feet deep at low water.
The amount expended up to June 30, 1884, was $15,431.41. No appro-
priation has since been made. The expenditure resulted in securing a
channel through the outer bars of 10 feet in depth at low water and a
width of 120 feet at the narrowest part, with the ends of the channel
widened for facility in entering.
  A turning basin 200 feet wide, 300 feet long, and 10 feet deep has also
been made at Urbana Wharf; and a channel of approach within the
creek 1,090 feet long, 80 feet wide, and 10 feet deep at low water. This is
one of the landings of the Baltimore and Norfolk boats.
  The engineer in charge asks, for the completion of this work, an ap-
propriation of $6,000 for the year ending June 30, 1888.
July 1, 1885, amount available.----..--.....................-------...---...... ......            $68 59
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885...............................             ..............               40 00
July 1, 1886, amount available...... ............           .....    .......    ........           28 59

 ( Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project..-----......                  6, 000 00
   Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1888                    6, 000 00

     harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix J 8.)
  9. Matt.aponi River, Virginia.-This stream empties into York River,
at West Point, Va. It is navigable for 56 miles.
  Previous to the commencement of this improvement, the Mattaponi
River was obstructed by numerous bars and by snags, wrecks, and over-
hanging trees. The object of the first project for improvement, adopted
in 1880, was to provide a channel 40 feet wide and 51 feet deep at low
water, by the removal of snags, drift-logs, wrecks, and overhanging
trees, and by dredging through the bars.
  The amount expended to June 30, 1885, was $6,023.80, and during the
year ending June 30, 1886, $174 have been expended, making a total
to June 30, 1886, of $6,197.80. This sum was expended in snagging
operations and in the removal of wrecks, logs, and overhanging trees
for a length of river of about 24 miles.
  The engineer in charge recommends making a channel through Robin-
son and Latane's bars, with a width of 40 feet at bottom and a depth of
6 feet at low water.          The cost of this improvement would be $31,000 in
144         REPORT OF THE CHIEF                         OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

addition to the amount available for the fiscal year ending June 30,
1887.
July 1, 1885, amount available.---------------.....--......--.......--       ----- ----------
                                                                       ......--..                       2,276 20
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
   outstanding July 1, 1885 .---...........--......--      .......-        .....-------.........          174 00


July 1, 1886, amount available ..........................................                               2, 102 20
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886 ...................                                  5, 000 00

Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887                   ...................             7,102 20

                                                                        --
r Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project-........                             31,000 00
I Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1888                            7,000 00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix J 9.)
  10. Pamunky River, Virginia.-This stream empties into York River
at West Point, Va. Its navigable length is 80 miles.
   The present project for improvement was adopted in 1880, the object
being to provide a channel 40 feet wide and from 3 to 5 feet deep from
Hanovertown to Newcastle ferry, a distance of 9 miles, and 100 feet
wide and 7 feet deep at low water on the lower bars.
  The work can be prosecuted economically if the entire sum required
for completion is appropriated for the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888.
   The total expenditure to June 30, 1886, is $5,743.61.
July 1, 1885, amount available .....................                        ........   ---.....----.   $1, 876 39
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885 ..................... .......... .............                                 120 00

July 1, 1886, amount available..... ..      ......
                                       ......      _................ ....                               1,756 39
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886............ ......-                                  5, 000 00

Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887                 ...................               6,756 39

  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project.......      15,800 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1881  8, 000 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and"
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix J 10.)
  11. York River, Virginia.-This is a large tidal tributary of the Chesa-
peake Bay, into which it empties about 16 miles in a line north of For-
tress Monroe.            It is formed by the Mattaponi and Pamunky rivers, and
has a deep, navigable ship-channel for a distance of 41 miles.
  The navigation of the river prior to the commencement of the present
improvement was obstructed by a bar at the mouth of Potopotank
Creek, having a least depth of 19 feet at low water, and a bar about 8.
miles above, at West Point, Va., having a least depth of 14 feet.
   The present project was adopted in 1880, the object being to provide
a channel, by dredging, 22 feet deep and 200 feet wide (to be increased
afterwards to 400 feet wide) through the bars, and also a basin of the
same depth at the wharves at West Point.
  The first appropriation ($10,000), made June 14, 1880, was applied to
the improvement of the Potopotank Bar, through which a channel 105
feet wide and 22 feet deep was secured by dredging.
  The appropriations since 1880 have been applied to dredging the bar
at West Point.
                       RIVER AND HARBOR                 IMPROVEMENTS.                           145
  The amount expended up to June 30, 1885, was $67,833.31, and during
the fiscal year ending June 30, 1886, $10,847.30 have been expended;
making a total to June 30, 1886, of $78,680.61.
July 1, 1885, amount available ............    .................
                                                           ----            ....--- ....   $12, 166'69
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
    liabilities outstanding July 1, 1885 ............     ............   $10, 764 69
July 1, 1886, outstanding liabilities..........-----...........                 82 61
                                                                                           10, 847 30

July 1, 1886, amount available_......... ................. ... --...........- 1,319 39
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886...----------- --- . 18,750 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887..........             ..........     20,069 39

Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project.......  -157,250   00
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1888 50, 000 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river a ad
1 harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
     (See Appendix J 11.)
   12. Chickahominy River, Virginia.-This river is navigable for 37
miles. The present project was adopted in 1878, the object being to
dredge channels 100 to 150 feet wide through Binn's, Old Fort and
Windsor Shades bars to a depth of not less than 8 feet at low water,
and to remove snags, logs, &c., from points above Windsor Shades.
The least depths on these bars, prior to the commencement of the im-
provement, were from 4 to 5 feet at low water.
   The appropriations, amounting to $15,000, have been expended, and
resulted in securing a channel through Binn's Bar, 150 feet wide
and 8 feet deep; through Windsor Shades and Old Fort bars, 100 feet
wide and 8 feet deep, and through the bar at the mouth of the river, 90
feet wide and 14 feet deep at low water.
   For the completion of the project for the improvement of the upper
part of the river $1,000 are still required, and for completing the pIroject
for improving the bar at the mouth an'appropriation of $13,000 was rec-
ommended in the report for the year ending June 30, 1885.
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886 ...................
                                                      - -----                              $4,000 00


T   SAmount (estimated) required for completion of existing project--------........
     Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1888
     Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
                                                                                           10, 000 00
                                                                                            5, 000 00
      harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
     (See Appendix J 12.)
   13. Staunton River, Virginia, between Randolph Station and Brook
Neal.-The length of the Staunton is 200 miles. It unites with the Dan
at Clarksville, and, thence to Albemarle Sound; the stream thus formed
is called Roanoke River.
   The present project for the improvement of this river between Ran-
dolph Station, on the Richmond and Danville Railroad, and Brook
Neal, 31 miles above, was adopted in 1879, the object being to secure a
navigable channel, not less than 35 feet wide and 2 feet deep at low
water, through the various ledges and sand-bars which obstruct naviga-
tion, with a slope of water-surface at rapids not greater than 10 feet to
the mile.
   The amount expended to June 30, 1885, was $25,069, and during the
fiscal year ending June 30,1886, $1,725.38 have been expended, making
a total to June 30, 1886, of $26,794.38.
        10 E
146         REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

July 1, 1885, amount available .....     .................       ......     .. .  $2, 431 00
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1885..................-.....          $1,695 38
July 1, 1886, outstanding liabilities ..........................            30 00
                                                                           --      1,725 38

July 1, 1886, amount available ...................... .... .......... ......          705 62
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886 ...................             5, 000 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887 ................-----...     5, 705 62
  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project........          36,200 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1888      10,000 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
  (See Appendix J 13.)
  14. Staunton River, Virginia, between Brook Neal and Pig River.--The
distance between Brook Neal and Pig River is 52 miles, and the aver-
age fall per mile is 4.3 feet.
  The present general project for the improvement of this part of the
river was adopted in 1882, the object being to secure a navigable chan-
nel for bateaux not less than 14 feet wide and from 1 to 2 feet deep
at low water, with a slope of water-surface at rapids not greater than
10 feet to the mile.
  The amount expended to June 30, 1884, was $1,894.79, which resulted
in the improvement of navigation through the worst shoals in a distance
of 15 miles.
July 1, 1885, amount available.......................................               $105 21
July 1, 1886, amount available ............... ...... ..................              105 21
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886...................              5, 000 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887............... ....          5,105 21
  SAmount (estimated) required for completion of existing project........   27,000 00
  Amount that can be profitably expendedin fiscal year ending June 30, 1888 10, 000 00
SSubmitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix J 14.)
   15. Dan River, between Madison, North Carolina, and Danville, Vir.
ginia.-The distance by the river from Madison to Danville is 49.81
miles and the descent 2.82 feet per mile.
   The object of the first project for this improvement, adopted in 1880,
was to provide a channel for navigation not less than 35 feet wide, but
it was afterward modified to a channel of not less than 16 feet wide and
2 feet deep in the rapids at low water.
   The amount expended to June 30, 1885, was $28,111.99, and during
the fiscal year ending June 30, 1886, $1,739.86 were expended, making
a total to June 30, 1886, of $29,851.85. This expenditure has resulted
in the improvement of 5 miles of the river above Danville, and about
13 miles of the river have been freed from serious obstruction by this
work.
   The officer in charge reports that $5,000 will be required to complete
the work, and that this sum could be profitably expended during the
fiscal year ending June 30, 1888.
   The work was to have been completed in three years, but has extended
through seven, rendering it necessary to meet the contingent expenses
for four years more than was intended.
                          RIVER AND HARBOR                      IMPROVEMENTS.                147
July 1, 1885, amount available.......................................... $2, 388 01
July 1, 1886, amount expended duringfiscal year, exclusive of
  liabiliities outstanding July 1, 1885----------------------........................ $1, 699 86
July 1, 1886, outstanding liabilities. ...-..... --..... .-..                              40 00
                                                                                _----    1, 739 86

                                                                     -648
July 1, 1886, amount available .......................................        15
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886.. ........... ..-...20,000 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887.......... ..........              20,648 15
  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project-- -- --.  -             5,000 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1888             1,500 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
  (See Appendix J 15.)
  16. Roanoke River, North Carolina.--Thefirst project for the improve-
ment of this river was submitted in 1871, the object being to improve
navigation by the removal of rocks near Weldon and Halifax, and all
wrecks, snags, and overhanging trees at various other points, and
dredging channels through the numerous bars and shoals. A part only
of this project was adopted.
  The amount expended under the first project to June 30, 1884, was
$45,000.
  The first approptiation under the present project of $5,000, malte
August 2, 1882, was expended in repairing two dikes at Indian High-
land Bar. A survey was also made to ascertain the changes which had
taken place since 1871, and a report was submitted.
  The appropriation of July 5, 1884 ($3,000), was not expended because
insufficient to prosecute the work economically.
  The engineer in charge recommends that the operations should be
limited, for the present, to the building of snag-boats, the removal of
snags, and to the careful examination of certain bars. This work will,
when accomplished, effect a much needed improvement.
July 1, 1885, amount available.......................................                   $3,300 24
July 1, 1886, amount available................  .......................                  3, 300 24
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886 ....................                 20, 000 00
Amount availnble for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887....................               23,300 24
   (See Appendix J 16.)
  17. French Broad River, North Carolina.--Thefirst project for the im-
provement of this river was adopted in 1878, the object being to secure
a channel 35 feet wide and not less than 21 feet deep at low water be-
tween Brevard and Big Buck Shoals, a distance of 31.61 miles.
   The amount expended to June 30, 1882, was $37,780.22, with which
expenditure the following results were attained: A survey of the river
between Brevard and Big Buck Shoals; the improvement of the various
shoals and rapids by means of rock and gravel excavation; and the
construction of wing-dams for a distance of 26 miles below Brevard.
   The act of August 2, 1882, appropriated $5,000 for improving the
river " from Smith's Bridge up." A survey from Smith's Bridge (near
Asheville) to the foot of Long Shoal, a distance of 12.09 miles, was made
in 1882, and a project adopted for securing a channel 30 feet wide and
not less than 24 feet deep at low water for this distance. The estimates
amounted to $76,000. In the fiscal year ended June 30, 1884, this part
of the river was improved for a distance of 4J miles above the bridge,
under a special act of appropriation.
148      REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

  If Congress direct the improvement between Brevard and Big Buck
Shoals, $8,000 is required ; and for continuing the improvement between
Long Shoal and Smith's Bridge, $25,000.
  The amount expended to June 30, 1885, was $42,788.23, and during
the fiscal year ending June 30, 1886, $52 have been expended, making a
total to June 30, 1886, of $42,840.23.
                                                          $211           .--        77
July 1, 1b85,'amount vailable ...--......--------- .......---..---------.............-----.
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885 .--.....----                                          52 00
                                                                  --............------.
                                           .-...----....----...--..--...--..---...
                                            -..-....  -- ....-
July 1, 1886, amount available...--------- ......--....--....  - -----.......
                                                             ....-              159 77

SAmount (estimated) required for completion of existing project .......    79,000 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix J 17.)
   18. Aqueduct Bridge over the Potomac at Georgetown, District of Co-
lumbia.-To enable a compliance with a resolution of the Senate of Feb-
ruary 25, 1866, Mr. Abert was charged with an examination of the con-
dition of this bridge, especially as to its safety for ordinary travel when
the aqueduct is filled with water. His report thereon was transmitted
to the Senate May 12, and printed as Senate Ex. Doe. No. 138, Forty-
ninth Congress, first session.
   (See also Appendix J 18.)
IMPROVEMENT OF THE HARBOR AT NORFOLK, VIRGINIA-APPROACH
  TO NORFOLK HARBOR, VIRGINIA--CURRITUCK    SOUND-COANJOK
  AND EDENTON BAYS, AND NORTH RIVER BAR, NORTH CAROLINA-
  IMPROVEMENT OF CERTAIN RIVERS IN VIRGINIA AND NORTH CAR-
  OLINA.

   Officer in charge, Capt. F. A. Hinman, Corps of Engineers. Super-
vising Engineer, Lieut. Col. W. P. Craighill, Corps of Engineers.
   1. HarboratNorfolk, Virginia.-Theproject for improvement, adopted
in 1877, was to deepen and widen the channel at the mouth of the South-
ern Branch and along the Berkley and Portsmouth flats, in the harbor
proper, and, for the approaches, to dredge a channel 500 feet wide and
25 feet deep at ordinary low water through the bars at the Western
Branch and Sewall's Point.
   The revised project of 1885 is as follows: 1. To secure a channel not
less than 25 feet deep and 500 feet wide at ordinary low water, by dredg-
ing, from the deep water of Hampton Roads to Norfolk and the United
States navy-yard on the Southern Branch, and also to secure a chan-
nel in the Eastern Branch, at the same stage, not less than 22 feet deep,
with a width at least 300 feet at the Norfolk and Western Railroad
Bridge, and gradually increasing to about 700 feet at its mouth, by
dredging between said points; and, 2. To ultimately dredge the entire
area bounded by lines parallel to and 75 feet from the Port-Warden
lines to a depth not less than 25 feet, at ordinary low water, from Fort
Norfolk to the United States navy-yard, and not less than 22 feet deep
from the mouth of the Eastern Branch to Campostella Bridge, and to
construct a bulkhead at Berkley Flats.
   With slight modifications all operations have been conducted in ac-
cordance therewith. The amount expended to June 30, 1885, was
$383,032.814 which resulted in a channel at least 25 feet deep and not less
than 200 feet wide at ordinary low water from the deep water of Hamp.-
                      RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                          149
ton Roads to the United States navy-yard, and also a channel at least
22 feet deep and not less than 200 feet wide at same stage in the East-
ern Branch up to the Norfolk and Western Railroad Bridge.
   The former channel at Sewall's Point has contracted somewhat, an'
has shoaled in places to 24 feet; at the mouth of Southern Branch it
has shoaled to 24 feet for a distance of 700 feet. The latter channel
has deteriorated slightly. The easterly side of the cut through Sewall's
Point Bar should be buoyed every 1,200 feet to mark it properly.
   There was expended in the fiscal year ending June 30, 1886, $113.53,
which was applied to contingencies.
   Since the original estimates were made for this harbor the conditions
upon which they were based have changed very materially, owing to
increased commerce necessitating more wharves and anchorage-ground.
The aggregate appropriations exceed the original estimates slightly, but
expenditures have been made in localities not originally contemplated.
  There will be but a small balance on hand at the close of the fiscal
year ending June 30, 1887.
  To entirely and permanently complete this work, so far as can be
foreseen, will require the expenditure of $507,744.56, and this amount
can be profitably expended in the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888, in
the general improvement of the harbor and its approaches by dredging,
and the construction of a bulkhead. The portion of the approach to
the harbor between Lambert's Point and Fort Norfolk is not included
herein as it is the subject of the following report.
July 1, 1885, amount available ....-----....-------...............................        2, 000 94
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885 ..................          ..........   .................-      113 53
July 1, 1886, amount available...... ..................................                   1, 887 41
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886 ....................                  50, 000 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887 ...................                51, 887 41
(Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project ........ 457,744 56
) Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal yearendingJune 30,1888 100, 000 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix K 1.)
   2. Approach to Norfolk Harbor and the United States (Norfolk) Navy-
yard, between Lambert's Point and Fort Norfolk.-The original condi-
tion of the channel was good, with the exception of a bar opposite the
mouth of the Western Branch, on some parts of which the ruling depth
was only about 15 feet at mean low water.
   The project for the improvement adopted in 1878 was to dredge this
bar for a distance of 4,800 feet to a width of 500 feet and a depth of 25
feet at mean low water.
   The amount expended on this work to July 5, 1884, cannot be stated,
as it cannot be separated from the sum total of the general expendi-
tures for the work of improving the harbor at Norfolk, Va., and its ap-
proaches, of which this was a part up to that date.
   The result obtained from the expenditures at this point to November,
1880, was a channel 4,400 feet long, 265 feet wide, and 25 feet deep at
mean low water, which greatly facilitated navigation and commerce.
This channel has since shoaled to 24 feet in places, and contracted con-
siderably.
   No work was done in this locality thereafter until subsequent to the
passage of the act of July 5, 1884, which appropriated $50,000 specific-
ally for widening the channel.
150       REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

  There was expended in the fiscal year ending June 30, 1885, $381.36,
which was applied to surveying the locality in question and preparing
map of same.
   A Board of Engineer officers was convened August, 1884, to prepare a
project for the application of this appropriation. The Board reported a
plan involving, in conjunction with dredging, the construction of a dike
at or near Pinner Point, expressing at the same time doubts whether,
under the phraseology of the law, any part of the money could be ap-
plied to a work of construction.
   However, the requirements of navigation demanding the widening
of the channel as contemplated in the project already commenced and
partly executed, by dredging, it was recommended that the existing
appropriation be applied to widening the channel between Lambert's
Point and Fort Norfolk by dredging along the eastern side thereof.
This having been approved, the work was done accordingly.
   There was expended in the fiscal year ending June 30,1886, $46,806.89,
which was applied to the removal of 469,944 cubic yards of material,
measured in scows, resulting in a straight channel not less than 25 feet
deep and at least 400 feet wide, at mean low water, the entire length
of this approach. Formerly the channel had an angle in it. This
work has materially benefited navigation and commerce. The easterly
side of the channel should be buoyed every 1,200feet to mark it properly.
   The amount that can be profitably expended in the fiscal year ending
June 30, 1888, is $118,100, which it is proposed to expend in the con-
struction of a dike and in widening the channel along the eastern side
by dredging. This will complete the project.
   The advantages and benefits to be derived therefrom will be a better
approach to the harbor and the navy-yard and more room for anchorage.
July 1, 1885, amount available. .......... ........................                                $49, 618 64
Amount received from sale of fuel to an officer ........................                                 38 25

                                                                                                    49, 656 89
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885 .__             . ..... _....   _..   ........   _...   .   ....
                                                                                       ..     ..    46, 806 89

July 1, 1886, amount available ..........-.... ..........- ...... ........- 2, 850 00
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886.................... 137,500 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887.............. ...... 140,350 00
( Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project.... .... 118, 100 00
  Amount that can be profitably expendedin fiscal year ending June 30,1888 118,100 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix K 2.)
   3. Appomattox River, Virginia.-At the close of the late war the navi-
gation of this river was in such a condition that the depth of water on
more than one of the shoals did not exceed 6J feet at high tide, and this
depth was diminished by 3 feet at low tide. The plan of improvement
adopted in 1870 was to attain a depth of 12 feet at high tide, with as
much width of channel as the river would bear. This plan has been
steadily adhered to, constant progress being made towards its comple-
tion from year to year by the use of the money granted by Congress.
The means depended on have been jetties, wing-dams, and training-
walls, with resort to the dredge only when the needs of commerce re-
quired immediate work in the channel to give more width or depth than
had been attained under the slower operation of the structures men-
tioned, of which the system has not yet been fully carried out for want
                       RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                          151
of sufficient funds. The amount expended by the United States up to
June 30,1885, on the project adopted in 1870, is $371,703.95, and resulted
in securing a turning basin at Petersburg about 155 by 110 feet and a
navigable channel of 12 feet and upwards at high water, with some short
shoals, from Petersburg down to Point of Rocks, all of which vastly ben-
efited navigation and largely increased the extensive commerce carried
over this river.
   There was expended in the fiscal year ending June 30, 1886, the sum of
$9,579.79, which was applied to enlarging Puddledock Cut, about 2 miles
long. This was materially widened and deepened.along the entire west-
erly side, and also along 1,250 feet of the easterly side, by the removal
of 121,424 cubic yards of material, measured in place, including 51,300
cubic yards removed last year. To prevent the dredged material cast
on the bank from sliding back into the channel, 940 linear feet of cheap
pile and brush revetment was built. This work benefited navigation
and commerce. The dikes and training-walls required no repairs to
speak of.
   There will be but a small balance on hand at the close of the fiscal
year ending June 30, 1887. There can be profitably expended in the
fiscal year ending June 30, 1888, $27,250, which it is proposed to ex-
pend for the completion of the existing project, after which an annual
expenditure of $5,000 will be, required to maintain the work, as is the
case with all works of this class.
   The principal portion of the work projected has been done, and, in
the main, performs the service required of it.
   The condition of permanence of the deepened and improved channel
seems to be nearly reached under the influence of its regulation. The
truth of this statement is confirmed by the diminished use of the dredge
year by year. The best results cannot be said to be reached until its
services can be dispensed with under ordinary circumstances.
July 1, 1885, amount available--....................----.....--.....-----.-----...... $10, 437 09
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1885....---...........--        ...... $9, 519 79
July 1, 1886, outstanding liabilities................--..--......               60 00
                                                                                        9,579 79
July 1, 1886, amount available ..................................         ..--       ..       857 30
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886---...--.........-----------..--..       18,750 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887...............-----     --       .   19,607 30
                                                                    --
  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project-........                  27, 250 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1888                27, 250 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix K 3.)
   4. 1\ottoway River, Virginia.-Priorto improvement the condition of
this river at low water was as follows: At the mouth the navigable
depth was only 2 feet, due to sunken logs; thence to the Seaboard and
Roanoke Railroad Bridge, 19 miles, the channel was from 9 to 25 feet
deep and much obstructed by a war blockade of sunken vessels, and
also by snags, overhanging growth, &c. The next reach, to Peter's
Bridge, 31 miles, was so filled with snags, logs, &c., that it was with
difficulty that a flat-boat of 1 foot draught could pass over it.
   The original project, adopted in 1881, was to obtain a channel not
less than 60 feet wide and at least 9 feet deep from the mouth to the
railroad bridge, and 2 feet deep thence to Peter's Eridge, by removing
the said obstructions.
152         REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

  The amount expended to June 30, 1882, is $6,420.30, which completed
the project for the lower 29 miles. There have been no operations since.
  This improvement has not led to the development of much trade on
the river. There is no regular line of boats there. The river is crossed
by the railroad, and for some distance is paralleled, about 5 miles off, by
the Blackwater River, on which are lines of steamers.
  The small amount, $333.54, expended since June 30, 1882, has been
applied to contingencies.
  The last examination, made in June, 1885, showed that the portion
below the railroad bridge was in fair condition, while that above had
again become obstructed by logs, &c., owing to the careless manner in
which they had been handled and rafted. For this reason the river is
not susceptible of entire and permanent completion.
  No further appropriation is asked for this river.
July 1, 1885, amount available ........................................                                   $453 29
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885..---........------...........----.-----------............-----............      207 13
July 1, 1886, amount available .........................................                                   246 16
   (See Appendix K 4.)
  5. Blackwater River, Virginia.-This river originally had a channel,
with a minimum depth of 8 feet scant, much obstructed by logs, lean-
ing trees, shoals, projecting points, and a war blockade of sunken ves-
sels, all of which rendered navigation exceedingly difficult.
  The original project, adopted in 1878, was to make a channel 9 feet
deep and not less than 60 feet wide at ordinary low water, by dredging
the bars and points, and removing all the obstructions from its mouth
to Franklin, the head of navigation, 13 miles.
   There was expended up to June 30, 1884, $14,000. This completed the
project except dredging at projecting points, which was only partially
done. The work done has materially benefited navigation and com-
merce.
   There were no operaions during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1886,
there being no funds available. The last examination, made in June,
1885, showed that the work was generally in good condition, with the
exception that two bars previously dredged had shoaled slightly, and
several projecting points require more work.
   The sum of $2,500 can be profitably expended on this work during
the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888. It is proposed to expend this
amount in redredging two bars, completing the dredging at three pro-
jecting points, and removing a few scattering logs, snags, &c.
   This work is not susceptible of entire and permanent completion, and
small appropriations will be required from time to time to maintain the
channel, which slowly deteriorates.
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1888                            $2, 500 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix K 5.)
   6. Archer's Hope River, Virginia.-Priorto the commencement of this
work there existed a natural channel about 4 feet deep in the river,
which could not be reached on account of the bar near its mouth, where
it enters the James River.
   The original project, adopted in 1881, is to dredge a channel 6 feet
deep and not less than 50 feet wide from the mouth to Williamsburg,
5 miles above, where it is crossed by the Chesapeake and Ohio Railroad.
  The amount expended to June 30, 1884, is $9,874.79, which resulted
in a channel 2,300 feet long, 6 feet deep, and 50 feet wide at mean low
                            RIVEE AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                            153
water from the mouth up. This did not carry the channel over the bar,.
which is 700 feet longer. No material benefit to navigation and com-
merce has yet been realized. There have been no operations since.
  The small amount, $104.58, expended since June 30, 1884, has been
applied to contingencies. The last examination, made in June, 1885,
showed that the outer end of the dredged channel had shoaled about 1
foot, and that the inner part was in good condition.
July 1, 1885, amount available..........................................                                             $45 96
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
   outstanding July 1, 1885 .......................................                                                   25 33

July 1, 1886, amount available.........................................                                               20 63

, Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project .------......                                    9, 400 0(
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
      harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix K 6.)
   7. North Landing River, Virginia and North Carolina.-Originallythis
river was much obstructed by logs, snags, overhanging growth, &c., and
also by shoals and abrupt bends, the least depth being 6- feet in places.
   The original project, adopted in 1879, is to make a channel at low
water not less than 9 feet deep and 80 feet wide its entire length-17
miles-by dredging the shoals and bends, and by removing the obstruc-
tions.
   The amount expended to June 30, 1884, is $49,777.34, and resulted in
completing the project, thereby allowing much larger vessels to pass
over the river, and increasing the commerce thereon.
   The amount expended in the fiscal year ending June 30, 1885, is $4,-
021.38, $2,082.94 of which was applied to the removal of logs, snags,
&c., that had lately entered the river, and the balance to the construc-
tion of a combined steam-hoister and pile-driver, pertaining to this and
another work.
   The amount expended in the fiscal year ending June 30, 1886-
$201.28-was applied to the construction of the above machine and to
contingencies.
   The lower 44 miles of the river, from Beacon 1 to Beacon 4, was sur-
veyed in April and May, 1885, and the 9-foot channel therein found to
be from 20 to 60 feet in width. No examination has since been made.
To restore it to the required width and depth requires the removal of
28,882 cubic yards of material, measured in place, at an estimated cost
of $7,220.50.
   There will be but a small balance on hand at the close of the fiscal
year ending June 30, 1887. There can be profitably expended in the
fiscal year ending June 30, 1888, $10,000, which will be applied to re-
dredging some of the shoals and removing logs, snags, &c., that may be-
encountered.
   As this work is not susceptible of entire and permanent completion, no
estimate can be made for that purpose. Small expenditures will be re-
quired from time to time to maintain it. It has been repeatedly cleared
of logs, &c., and this must be expected to continue, unless there be
some radical change for the better in the handling of logs that are rafted
through it.
July 1, 1885, amount available.--...--..--       ......-----...---..---....------......---...-------....---....   $1,701 28-
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 185....----------.......----....------........-----....--...--- -------..-.---                 201 28
July 1, 1886, amount available............ ....                         ....   ...............----.               1,500 00.
    (See Appendix K 7,)
154        REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

   8. Edenton Bay, North Carolina.-The navigable channel through
this bay was originally obstructed by an extensive hard sand-shoal,
with a depth thereon of 61 feet.
   The project, adopted in 1878 and modified in 1879 and 1885, contem-
plates making a channel 9 feet deep, 150 feet wide at the outer end and
200 feet wide at the inner end, with a triangular turning-basin midway
of about 12 acres, by dredging through the bay to Edenton.
   The amount expended thereon up to the close of the fiscal year end-
ing June 30, 1880, is $5,000, and resulted in a channel 100 feet wide and
9 feet in depth, and also the partial construction of the turning-basin,
thus materially aiding navigation.
   Under the act of August 2, 1882, a survey was made of this locality.
   The foregoing comprises all the operations up to July 5, 1884.
   The amount expended in the fiscal year ending June 30, 1885, is
$11,306.37, and resulted in a channel 9 feet deep at ordinary low water
from the 9-foot curve in the bay to Edenton, which channel is 1,100 feet
long and 150 feet wide at the outer end, and 1,150 feet long and at least
100 feet wide at the inner end, in front of the Norfolk Southern Rail-
road Wharf, with the turning-basin midway between nearly completed,
all of which has very materially aiiled navigation and commerce.
   The amount expended during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1886,
$3,295.22, was applied to enlarging the foregoing channel by the re-
moval of 46,043 cubic yards of material, measured in situ, including
29,000 cubic yards (estimated) removed last year. This makes the
channel 150 feet wide at the outer end and 165 feet wide at the inne
end, with a triangular turning-basin midway of 94 acres. The total
area dredged here is 174 acres and the area 9 feet deep and upwards,
at ordinary low water, 18 acres. There is a navigable channel of vary-
ing width at least 10 feet deep, at same stage, the entire length of the
harbor.
   The balance of the estimate required for the completion of the adopted
project is $6,000, but no appropriation is asked for at present, as Eden-
ton now has a harbor amply sufficient for all the present wants of nav-
igation and commerce, which, so far as can be forecasted, will suffice for
some time to come. It is probable that dredging will be required at
long intervals, as the bay has a tendency to silt slowly.
July 1, 1885, amount available ...............--........---.-----.........-----.. ---.....--. $3, 742 63
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885..............................................                        3, 295 22
July 1, 1886, amount available. .....................--- ...... ....             ........        447 41
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886----................--.                     2, 000 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887 ...................                     2,447 41
SAmount (estimated) required for completion of existing project ....-....                    6,000 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
  (See Appendix K 8.)
  9. Currituck Sound, Coanjok Bay, and North River Bar, North Caro-
lina.-Previousto the commencement of this improvement there was
an indifferent natural channel, with a depth of from 5 to 7 feet at low
water, which had been partially dredged, in the sound and bay, by the
Albemarle and Chesapeake Canal Company.
  The original project, adopted in 1878, is to obtain a channel 80 feet
wide at bottom and 9 feet deep at ordinary winter water, by dredging
the entire length of the sound, 104 miles, to which was added, in 1880,
                           RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                           155
the project to prolong this channel by dredging through the bay about
2 miles, and to construct a shell dike 9,600 feet along the westerly side
of the channel through the latter, to maintain it.
   The amount expended to June 30,1885, is $123,500 and resulted in the
construction of the dike, and a channel from 40 to 80 feet wide the en-
tire length and depth projected, all of which greatly improved naviga-
tion and increased the commerce over this important inland water-route.
There have been no expenditures since.
   The entire channel was surveyed last in April and May, 1885, to as-
certain its condition, which was found to be quite good, although
shoaled in places. This is probably due very largely to steamers ground-
ing out of the channel and creating shoals in their efforts to get off.
More buoys maintained constantly between the gas-beacons would tend
to diminish this. To restore and complete the work will require the re-
moval of 215,075 cubic yards ofinaterial measured in place.
   A survey was also made of North River Bar in May, 1885, which can
be best and most economically improved by dredging a straight channel
through it 7,150 feet long, 150 feet wide, and 9.4 feet deep at ordinary
low water. This will require the removal of 37,847 cubic yards of ma-
terial, measured in place, and the construction of two range-lights (gas
beacons) to mark the channel.
   The total estimated amount required to do the foregoing dredging is
 $55,122.85.
   Other works have been added to that originally estimated for, mak-
ing it necessary to increase the estimates accordingly to accomplish all
the work contemplated. There will be but a small balance on hand at
the close of the fiscal year ending June 30, 1887.
July 1, 1885, amount available ......------......----......----------....---......--------......--......        $1,500 00
July 1, 1886, amount available --------............... ...... ..............                                .    1,500 00
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886 ...... .............                                         10, 000 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887.....                                 ...........--.       11,500 00

TAmount (estimated) required for completion of existing project ........
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1888
                                                                                                                55, 122 85
                                                                                                                30, 000 00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of section '2 of river and
     harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix K 9.)
   10. Meherrin River, North Carolina.-Previousto the commencement
of operations on this improvement the channel was so much obstructed
by logs, snags, leaning trees, &c., as to make navigation difficult and
and dangerous. There were also some shoals, having a ruling depth of
less than 8 feet.
   The original project, adopted in 1883, for the improvement of this
river from its mouth to Murfreesboro', the head of navigation, 11 miles,
confined operations to the removal of logs, &c., the appropriation not
being sufficient to undertake dredging in addition.
   The amount expended to June 30, 1884, was $4,133.90, which resulted
in doing all the work projected except dredging, and giving a channel
having a depth of 9 feet save at a few places.
   In the fiscal year ending June 30, 1885, there was expended $418.50,
which resulted in again clearing the river of all obstructions like the
aforesaid. The last examination, made in June, 1885, showed that the
river was in fair navigable condition.
   The amount expended in the fiscal year ending June 30, 1886, $32.13,
was applied to contingencies.
156          REPORT          OF THE CHIEF                   OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

  The amount that can be profitably expended in the fiscal year end-
ing June 30, 1888, is $7,500, with which it is expected to still further
aid navigation and commerce by dredging shoals and removing obstruc-
tions as they form. This is expected to complete the improvement as
estimated, securing a channel 9 feet deep and 60 feet wide at low water.
Small appropriations will be required from time to time in order to-
maintain the work, as it is not susceptible of entire and permanent com-
pletion, being a log-bearing stream,
July 1, 1885, amount available--..........------....-------------------........--..----............--------          $447 60
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885--.......--------.....---..               -.....................------------------...---... 32 1
July 1, 1886, amount available.----                    ---.....---......--.....   .....------....----.........     415 47

( Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project-........                                        7,500 00
) Amountthat can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1888                                       4, 000 00
, Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
( harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix K 10.)
   11. Pamplico and Tar rivers, North Carolina.-The Pamplico River
was originally obstructed by a war blockade of piling near HilPs Point,
and also by stumps and shoals just below Washington. The Tar River
was likewise obstructed by a war blockade of piling near Washingtonu,
and also by shoals, snags, &c., further up, which made navigation diffi-
cult and uncertain.
   The original projects for the improvement of these rivers contemplated
removing these obstructions, and also widening, deepening, and straight-
ening the channel of the Pamplico River below Washington, by
dredging.
   Previous to the act of June 14, 1880, the appropriations for them were
distinct and separate. Since then they have been consolidated in one-
appropriation.
   The amount expended to June 30, 1885, is $50,537.10, and resulted in
a channel 9 feet deep at low water, and from 108 to 175 feet wide, from
the deep water of Pamplico River to Washington, 1, miles. Nothing
further is desired except to widen the channel, which it is not proposed
to do at present.
    On the Tar the work resulted in a navigable channel 3 feet deep at
low water, from Washington to Greenville, 23 miles, the year round,
and thence to Tarboro', 26 miles, only during high water.
   The amount expended in the fiscal year ending June 30, 1886, is
$2,414.23, which was all expended on the Tar River and applied to the
construction of a combined steam-hoister and pile-driver for this and
another work, and the removal and destruction of 683 obstructions be-
tween Washington and Greenville, thereby effecting an improvement
greatly desired.
    There will be but a small balance on hand at the close of the fiscal
year ending June 30, 1887. The amount that can be profitably ex-
pended during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888, is $5,000. It is
proposed to apply this to continuing the improvement by removing.
snags, shoals, overhanging growth, &c., and the repair and construc-
tion of jetties, for the furtherance of navigation and commerce.
   The work of improvement contemplated in the original estimates
upon the Tar River is complete, but more work is needed. It is not
susceptible of entire and permanent completion, as the jetties require
repairs, and logs, snags, &c., are constantly appearing. A continuance
of its best possible condition requires an annual expenditure of $5,000
to maintain it.
                            RIVER ATD HARBOR                       IMPROVEMENTS.                                 157
July 1, 1885, amount available. ............................                    ..........----   .           $2,462 90
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
                                            .--------.....------......
  outstanding July 1, 1885 ---....---------......                      ....---.....------.......             2, 414 23
July 1, 1886, amount available ....--------........-------.....-----......--------------------......             48 67
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886....----------..------                             ....-   5, 000 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887..................---.                                  5,048 67
   Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1888                                 5,000 00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
      harbor acts of 1866 and 1867....................................
   (See Appendix K 11.)
   12. Yadklin River, North Carolina.-Previousto the commencement
of this improvement, in the fall of 1880, there was no navigable channel
whatever, as the river was obstructed by numerous shoals, rock ledges,
and mill-dams. The original project of 1879, adopted in 1880, was to
improve the portion of the river from the North Carolina Railroad Bridge
near Salisbury up to the foot of Bean Shoals, 644 miles, over which it
was proposed to obtain a low-water channel the entire year from 24 to
3 feet in depth and of ample width for the trade seeking it. To accom-
plish this the project was to blast and remove the rock, construct jetties,
and take out the mill-dams. No locks were contemplated.
    The act of July 5, 1884, provides: "That the sum of $6,000 author-
ized by the act approved June 14, 1880, to be expended for the removal
of dams in Yadkin River, North Carolina, may be used by the Secretary
of War for acquiring the right of way by removal or otherwise of such
dams as may be necessary for the contemplated improvement, the said
right of way or removal to be obtained by agreement with the parties
interested, or in event of failure, to make a reasonable agreement by
condemnation, as provided for by the laws of the State of North Caro-
lina."
    It is questionable whether any of this will be necessary, as recent in-
vestigations of the local engineer show that the dams can all be best
and most economically passed by wing-dams and training-walls, or by
locks, as the case may be. Accordingly, this amount will be held for
the present, and the balance of the funds available will be devoted to
  securing a navigable channel at least 24 feet deep and 60 feet wide at
winter stage only from the North Carolina Railroad Bridge to Hartley's
Mill-dam, 28 miles, by the construction of wing dams and training-walls,
and the removal of rock ledges.
    It would be very expensive to make low-water navigation on this river
in any manner; the commerce to be developed would not justify it.
Locks must be resorted to from Douthet's Mill-dam up, in order to pass
most of the mill-dams. Below this point none are required.
    Up to June 30, 1885, there was expended $62,276.05, which resulted
in securing an indifferent channel from 40 to 70 feet wide, and from 2
to 24 feet deep for eight months of the year, the season of " winter
water," from the North Carolina, Railroad Bridge to Swicegood's Mill-
dam, 21J miles; at the lowest stage there is no continuous navigable
channel, it being but 9 inches deep at one point, Boone's Ford.
    In the fiscal year ending June 30, 1886, there was expended $6,339.85,
which completed the channel at winter stage around Swicegood's Mill-
dam by the construction of 361 linear feet of wing-dams, two sill-dams
60 linear feet each, and 125 linear feet of training-wall, the raising of
498 linear feet of wing-dams, and 150 linear feet of training-wall above
low water, and the removal of rock ledges.
    It is proposed to expend the available funds in lehgthening and fur-
158       REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

ther improving the channel at winter stage. The advantages and ben-
efits to be expected therefrom will be to create a navigable channel for
which there are no commercial boats on this river, and but little pros-
pect of any.
   The estimated amount required for the entire and permanent comple-
tion of the work of improvement in accordance with the approved and
adopted project is largely in excess of the estimate, $81,674.85, origi-
nally submitted (see page 627, Report of the Chief of Engineers, 1879),
the sum of $77,000 having already been appropriated and $68,615.90
spent to June 30, 1886, and only 21- miles (one-third the distance) par-
tially improved, and this for only navigation at winter stage. The
most difficult and expensive portion yet remains to be improved, even
for navigation at winter stage. Of course, for navigation at low water,
as projected, the expense would be much greater.
July 1, 1885, amount available.....--                    ----.        .---....--- ----.   $14, 723 95
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
                                        ------
  outstanding July 1, 1885....-- --..........................................               6,339 85
July 1, 1886, amount available---- .-...... ..... ...... ._......    ........ ....          8,384 10
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886..............------------------..       10, 000 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 187.....---.......--             ....     18,384 10
   (See Appendix K 12.)
   13. Scupperncng River, North Carolina.-Beforework was commenced
on this river there was a bar at the mouth with about 5 feet of water
thereon. The upper portion of the river was obstructed by logs, snags,
stumps, overhanging growth, and projecting points at abrupt bends, per-
mitting navigation for small vessels only, and with difficulty.
   The original project, adopted in 1876, was to dredge the bar and make
cut-offs at the projecting points, and also to remove the said obstruc-
tions to obtain a channel at low water 9 feet deep and 60 feet wide from
its mouth to Spruill's Bridge, the head of navigation, 22 miles.
   The amount expended to June 30, 1883, wa& $6,000, and resulted in
completing the greater portion of what was projected, to the great ben-
efit of navigation and commerce. There have been no funds available
since, until the passage of the act of July 5, 1884, which appropriated
$2,000 for this work. The amount expended in the fiscal year ending
June 30, 1885, was $120.67, which was applied to an examination of the
river and the purchase of dynamite, &c., preliminary to the resumption
of operations.
   In the fiscal year ending June 30, 1886, there was expended the bal-
ance of the appropriation, $1,879.33, which resulted in making one cut-off,
widening another and the thoroughfare, cutting off eight projecting points
at abrupt ends, enlarging the turning-basin at the head of navigation
(Spruills's Bridge), and removing a shoal 650 feet long at the mouth of
Collins's Canal. This work has practically completed the improvement,
which has shortened the distance about half a mile, saved almost end-
less trouble and lessened danger in the management of steamers, per-
mitted larger loads to be carried, &c.
   It is believed that the channel is amply sufficient for the trade seek-
ing it, and that it will be quite permanent, as this river is not subject
to freshets of any magnitude. However, a shoal may re-form slowly at
Collins's Canal.
   No further funds are asked for.
July 1, 1885, amount available         .
                                 -......--  . - .--.---.........      ----- $1,879 33
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
   outstanding July 1, 1885... .......         ....           ... ....       1, 879 33
    (See Appendix K 13.)
                RIVER AND      HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                    159
   14. Removing sunken vessels or craft obstructing or endangeringnaviga-
tion.-1. The schooner Lawrence.-This wreck, referred to in last annual
report, was sunk in the Scuppernong River, North Carolina, and was
removed by the Government, after due advertisement, as the owner did
not do so, at a cost of $100.
   2. The barge Albemarle.-This wreck was reported an obstruction to
navigation on the coast, off Hog Island light-house, Virginia. An ex-
amination was made of the same, without cost to the Government,
which showed that it had ceased to be such an obstruction.
   3. The schooner Maria and Elizabeth.--This wreck, which is sunk off
Cape Charles light-house, Virginia, was reported an obstruction to navi-
gation. An examination was made of the same, without expense to the
United States, which showed that it had ceased to be such an obstruc-
tion.
   4. The schooner Tarry Not.-This wreck was reported an obstruction
to navigation on Craney Island Flats, near the mouth of the Nanse-
mond River, Virginia. An examination verified the report. After due
advertisement, the wreck and cargo, being worthless, were destroyed
by explosives, at a cost of $428.43.
   5. The schooner Anthea Godfrey.-This wreck,sunk in Lynn Haven
Roads,Virginia, was reported an obstruction to navigation. An examina-
tion showed such to be the case, and, after due notice, the wreck and cargo,
being valueless, were removed by explosives, at a cost of $387,37.
   6. The steamer Concord.--This steamer was burnt and sunk in the
Pamplico River, near Washington, N. C., on February 20, last. An ex-
amination thereof was made, which showed that she endangered navi-
gation. After due notice, she was libeled in the United States District
Court, and advertised to be sold on July 2, 1886. There will, therefore,
be no further operations in this matter until the Court has finally dis-
posed of her, and the purchaser, if any, has had reasonable time to act.
Her machinery has some value, but the hull and cargo (principally cot-
ton) have but little, if any.
   All the foregoing work was done by hired labor, the purchase of ma-
terial in open market, and the use of the Government plant, that being
the most economical and advantageous mode of doing it. It is pro-
posed to remove the wreck of the Concord in a similar manner, if it has
to be done by the Government; the estimated cost being $500.
    (See Appendix K 14.)
IMPROVEMENT      OF CERTAIN RIVERS AND HARBORS           OF NORTH CARO-
                     LINA AND SOUTH CAROLINA.

  Officer in charge, Capt. W. H. Bixby, Corps of Engineers ; Supervising
Engineer, Lieut. Col. W. P. Craighill, Corps of Engineers.
1. Contentnea Creek, North Carolina.-Thisstream, a tributary of the
Neuse River, has a total length of about 144 miles and a drainage area
of 1,184 square miles. Prior to Governmental improvement in 1881, it
had a depth of about 3 feet during 9 months of the year, from its mouth
in the Neuse River upward about 63 miles to Stantonsburg, its practical
limit of navigation; but its channel was completely blocked at all
stages of water by sunken logs and stumps, and by floating obstruc-
tions. Its steamboat commerce was nothing.
   The original project of 1881, as continued to date, proposed to secure
a safe and unobstructed 3-foot navigation over this entire distance
during the high-water season of about nine months.
   During the last fiscal year ending June 30, 1886, $1,419.08 was spent
in diking the river bank near its mouth to prevent the water running
160        REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

Off into the adjacent swamps, and in removing dangerous obstructions
in the river channel below Snow Hill. Further work was stopped by
want of funds.
    Up to June 30, 1886, therefore, a total of $24,687.69 has been spent in
all upon this improvement in securing a roughly cleared 3-foot naviga-
tion over the 31 miles from its mouth up to Snow Hill, during the high-
water season. In consequence of this, a steamboat line has been per-
manently established upon the whole length thus improved, and two
steamboats have made biweekly trips during nearly nine months each
year, to the great benefit of the neighboring country, otherwise without
transportation facilities for its products. The present commerce (includ-
ing rafted goods) is rapidly increasing, and is at present about $450,000
per year; showing that each dollar spent on this improvement has been
accompanied by the development of $18 in annual commerce.
    There are three county bridges, without draws, above Snow Hill;
their obstruction is not serious at present.
    The officer in charge recommends that this improvement be com-
pleted in accordance with the present proposed and approved project,
so as to secure a thoroughly cleared 3-foo navigation over the entire
river from its mouth 03 miles upward to Stantonsburg during the nine
commercial busy months of the year; at a total expense of $35,000 in
addition to the amount available for the fiscal year ending June 30,
1887, this amount to be appropriate: in one sum. Smaller appropria-
tions will increase the cost.
    Further improvement, so as to extend this navigation above Stantons-
  burg, or so as to make the lower river navigable during the low-water
season, is not recommended at present.
    After the improvement is finished, its proper maintenance may cost
 .from $1,000 to $3,000 per year.
    It is estimated that $30,000 can be profitably spent in a single year;
20,000 of this to secure a fairly cleared natural channel for steam navi-
  gation nine months of the year from Snow Hill 32 miles upward to
  Stantonsburg, by removing from the river channel the most dangerous
,obstructions, such as sunken logs and snags, and by cutting down and
pulling back from the banks the most troublesome leaning trees, and
also those which would otherwise soon fall into the river channel; and
 .$10,000 to dike and dredge the natural channel near the river's mouth
  so as to keep the water from running off into the adjacent swamps.
  The extension of the navigation to Stantonsburg will open up the rich-
est part of the Contentnea Basin and will greatly increase the river
commerce.
July 1, 1885, amount available ..................            ................
                                                                           ... ..       $1,731 39
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1885 ....................                 $1,398 67
July 1, 1886, outstanding liabilities ....................          .....      20 41
                                                                                         1, 419 08

July 1, 1886, amount available .--..------......------......
                                                 --....--......--.-----     312 31
                                                                    -..............
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886-...................   15,000 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887 ...............                   15, 312 31

 (Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project.... ....35, 000 00
   Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal yearending June 30, 1888            20,000 00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
  (See Appendix L 1.)
  2. Trent River, North Carolina.-Thisriver, a tributary of the Neuse
River, has a total length of about 73 miles, and a drainage area of 657
                           RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                      161
square miles. In 1879, at the time when placed under Governmental im-
provement, it possessed a 6-foot to 8-foot roughly cleared navigation
from its mouth at New Berne up 21 miles to Pollocksville, and a lighter
draught navigation 9 miles further to Qhaker Bridge. Above Pollocks-
ville the bars, snags, and trees prevented all navigation, except occa-
sionally by small: fat-boats during high freshets. Its commerce is esti-
mated to have been about $400,000 of goods per year.
   The original projects of 1879 and 1880, as continued to date, assumed
that 6 to 8 feet of water could be carried at all stages of water from its
mouth 21 miles to Pollocksville, and proposed to secure a thoroughly
cleared 3-foot navigation, with at least 50 feet channel width, at all
stages of water, from Pollocksville 22 miles up to Trenton, the practi-
cable limit of steamboat navigation, using the balance of the funds to
improve the channel from its mouth 30 miles upward to Pollocksville
and Quaker Bridge.
   During the last fiscal year, ending June 30, 1886, while awaiting fur-
ther appropriations, $159.50 was spent in caring for the property and
records, and in preparing reports and future projects.
   Up to June 30, 1886, therefore, a total of $41,489.06 has been spent in
all upon this improvement, in securing a moderately well cleared 6-foot
to 8-foot navigation at all stages (8 to 9 feet at ordinary stages) from
New Berne 30 miles up to Quaker Bridge, and thence a thoroughly
cleared 3-foot navigation, at least 50 feet wide at all stages, 13 miles
further to Trenton, and an excellent turning-basin at Trenton. In con-
sequence of this improvement a steamboat navigation has been perma-
nently established over the entire river to Trenton, with weekly trips
in summer and tri-weekly trips in the busy season of winter. The com-
merce is still increasing, and is now about $600,000 (including rafted
goods) of transported goods per year, showing that each dollar spent
on this improvement has been accompanied by the development of about
$5 of annual commerce.
  The river navigation is not obstructed by bridges without draws.
   The officer in charge recommends that the present approved and
adopted project be completed by thoroughly clearing the present chan-
net of its remaining obstructions, at a total cost of $11,000, in addition
to the amount available for the year ending June 30, 1887, this amount
to be appropriated in one sum within the next year. Smaller appro-
priations will increase the cost.
   After this is done no further improvement is recommended at pres-
ent; but the proper maintenance of the improved channel may cost from
$1,000 to $2,000 per year.
   It is estimated that the entire $11,000 can be profitably spent in one
year-$8,000 to cut off projecting points at sharp turns of the river, and
the remaining $3,000 to clear the entire river thoroughly of all remain-
ing obstructions to its free navigation.
July 1, 1885, amount available ......-----.....----.....
                                                      .............--.                                     $670 44
April '23, 1886, amount received from sales to Contentnea Creek---..........                                 25 00
                                                                                                             695 44
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1885 ......................---
                                                              .. $158 78
July 1, 1886: outstanding liabilities..........................       72
                                                                                                      --     159 50

July 1, 1886, amount available--.........-----....---..----....--.------------............--------......      535 94
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886......---........----------------..                      3, 500 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887 .................                                    4, 035 94

           11 E
{Amount
162     REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

          (estimated) required for completion of existing project-------$11,000 00
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1888
Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
                                                                              11,000 00
  harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix L 2.)
   3. Neuse River, North Carolina.-Thisriver, emptying into Pamplico
Sound, has a total length of about 360 miles, and a drainage area of
5,781 square miles (2,506 of which are situated above the mouth of its
upper main tributary, the Contentnea). This river, when placed under
Governmental improvement in 1878, possessed during nine months of
the year a 9-foot depth of channel from its mouth 40 miles up to New
Berne; thence a 4-foot depth 50 miles further to Kinston; thence a 3-
foot depth 46 miles further to Goldsboro'; and thence a 2-foot depth 62
miles further to Smithfield, this depth being reduced during the low.
water season to 8 feet at New Berne, 2 feet at Kinston, and 1 foot at
Smithfield. Over the whole 198 miles the river was so blocked by arti-
ficial and natural obstructions that navigation was impracticable. Its
steamboat navigation was therefore nothing.
   The projects of 1878, 1880, and 1883, as continued to date, proposed
to clear out the obstructions placed in the river during the war of
1861-'65, to remove all sunken logs, snags, and floating obstructions,
and to contract she channel-way, so as to assure during the entire year
an unobstructed 8-foot navigation 40 miles up to New Berne, and a sim-
ilar 4-foot navigation 50 miles further to Kinston, and during nine
months of the year a 3-foot navigation 108 miles farther to Smithfield.
   During the last fiscal year ending June 30, 1886, $9,557.42 was spent
in contracting by jetties about 2 miles length of river channel between
New Berne and Kinston, in removing the most troublesome obstructions
in this same length of river, in caring for property and records, and in
preparing reports and future projects.
   Up to June 30, 1886, therefore, a total of $205,825.72 has been spent
in all upon this improvement, giving a moderately well-cleared channel
over the entire length of the river, allowing an 8-foot navigation 40
miles to New Berne, and a 2-foot navigation 50 miles further to Kinston
all the year; also a 3-foot navigation 46 miles further to Goldsboro'
during nine months per year, and 60 miles still further to Smithfield six
months per year. In consequence of this two steamboat lines have been
permanently established between New Berne and Kinston, and the river
commerce has increased from almost nothing up to over $1,000,000 per
year, showing that each dollar spent upon this improvement has been
accompanied by a development of about $5 of annual commerce.
   The Atlantic and North Carolina Railroad Drawbridge at Kinston has
a draw, but not over the main channel-way; its obstruction is not seri-
ous at present. The Wilmington and Weldon Railroad Bridge at Golds-
boro' is without a draw, but 17 feet above low water; its obstruction is
not serious at present. Higher there are six county bridges without
draws; their obstruction is not serious at present.
   The officer in charge recommends that this improvement be com-
pleted in accordance with the present approved and adopted projects,
so as to secure a thoroughly cleared 9-foot navigation 40 miles up to
New Berne and a similar 4-foot navigation 50 miles further to Kinston
during the entire year; and thence a similar 3-foot navigation 108 miles
further to Smithfield during nine months of the year; at a total ex-
pense of $137,500, in addition to the amount available for the fiscal year
ending June 30, 1887, this amount to be appropriated in three yearly
installments of $46,000 each; smaller appropriations will increase the
                           RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                163
cost. Further improvement, so as to extend the navigation above
Smithfield, or so as to increase the depth of water or length of time
of such navigation below Smithfield, is not recommended at present.
After the improvement is finished its proper maintenance may cost
from $2,000 to $6,000 per year.
   It is estimated that the first installment can be profitably spent in a
single year, $30,000 of which is to secure an unobstructed channel of 3 feet
depth at low water from New Berne 50 miles upward to Kinston, by com-
pleting the present work of contraction of the river channel, and $16,000
towards securing a thoroughly-cleared, natural channel from Kinston,
108 miles upward to Smithfield, by removing from the river channel
sunken logs and snags, and by cutting down and pulling back from the
banks such trees as overhang the channel, or as might fall into the chan-
nel by the caving of banks. The works have given satisfactory re-
sults so far as their construction has been carried, but they cannot pro-
duce their effect upon the river commerce until they are finished over the
entire distance thus to be improved.
July 1, 1885, amount available -...------...-.....--..------..---...--......---....----   -------.... $13,731 70
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1885 ..........................                       $9, 166 05
July 1, 1886, outstanding liabilities ........................                           391 37
                                                                                                     9, 557 42

July 1, 1886, amount available.....................--------...............                           4,174 28
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886 ...................                             22,500 00


tAmount
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887--.......... .........
               (estimated) required for completion of existing project ........ 137,500 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1888
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
                                                                                                   26, 674 28

                                                                                                   46, 000 00

    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix L 3.)
   4. Inland line of navigation,from New Berne to Beaufort, North Car-
olina.-The inland line of navigation from New Berne to Beaufort Har-
bor, via Clubfoot, Harlowe and Newport rivers, established in about
1826, follows the course of the line now in reconstruction by the New
Berne and Beaufort Canal Company. This inland line of navigation,
by the way of Clubfoot, Harlowe, and Newport rivers, was recommended
in 1883 as conditionally worthy of improvement; and was estimated in
1883 to cost $883,580. This line of navigation possessed then no steam-
ers, but one has since been placed upon the route, and is now making
regular trips. This line of navigation is of much value as a connecting
link between Pamplico Sound and Beaufort Harbor, and completes ex-
isting inland navigation from the Chesapeake to Beaufort, N. C.
   Ten thousand dollars was appropriated in 1882 ($5,000 to be taken
from the appropriation for Neuse River, $5,000 from that for Beaufort
Harbor) for an inland line of navigation from New Berne to Beaufort
Harbor; and it was decided in 1884 that this money was to spent upon
the route via Clubfoot, Harlowe, and Newport rivers. The adopted pro-
ject of 1884 for the expenditure of this $10,000, as continued to date,
proposed to widen and deepen Harlowe Creek so as to secure a through
canal, of 5 feet depth at mean low water and of 30 feet bottom width,
from the mouth of Harlowe Creek upward 3.25 miles to its head; and
to use the remaining funds in similar work upon Clubfoot River.
   During the last fiscal year ending June 30, 1886, while awaiting the
further action of Congress, $131.45 was spent in inspecting the canal
164       REPORT OF TI]HE CIEF OF ENGINEERS, tt. S. ARMY.

and creeks, in caring for property and records, and in preparing reports
and future projects.
   Up to June 30, 1886, therefore, a total of $2,205.76 has been spent in
all on necessary surveys and in commencing the proposed canal cutting.
It was required that the work should be done at once, and by contract.
Work was commenced, but on account of unexpected obstacles and the
small amount of available funds, the contractor could not afford to build
or hire the expensive plant that he would need in order to fulfill his con-
tract. Beneficial results have therefore not been as yet obtained. Work
was directed to be stopped March, 1885, to await further action of Con-
gress.
   The officer in charge recommends that this improvement be extended
in general accord with the projects of 1883 and 1884, over the whole dis-
tance through the New Berne and Beaufort Canal, as well as through
Clubfoot River and Harlowe Creek, so far as to secure a through chan-
nel of 5 feet depth at mean low water, and 30 feet bottom width, from
the mouth of Harlowe Creek to the mouth of Clubfoot River, thus com-
pleting a 5-foot navigation from New Berne to Beaufort, at a total ex-
pense of $75,000, in addition to the $17,794.24 available for the fiscal
year ending June 30, 1887, this amount to be appropriated in two yearly
installments. Smaller appropriations will increase the cost. The dan-
gers of ocean travel around Cape Hatteras and Cape Lookout are so
great that some such 5-foot navigation for small vessels appears neces-
sary between Pamplico Sound and Beaufort Harbor, and no similar
navigation can be secured by any other route, except at greatly increased
expense. Further improvement over this route, so as to secure a chan-
nel of more than 5 feet depth at low water, is not recommended for the
present.
    After this improvement is completed its proper maintenance may cost
from $1,000 to $3,000 per year.
July 1, 1885, amount available .      ............    .. ...... ...   ... ....   ....     ...   $7, 925 69
July 1, 1866, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1885 ----........................
                                                                 -----               $1 97
July 1, 1886, outstanding liabilities ..........................                    129 48
                                                                                                   131 45

July 1, 1886, amount available .---....---....-------............................                7, 794 24
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886...................                           10,000 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887..................-------          ---     17, 794 24

  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1888                    38,000 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix L 4.)
   5. Harbor at Beaufort, North Carolina.-This harbor, at the eastern
terminus of the Atlantic and North Carolina Railroad, is the only one
of any importance between Chesapeake Bay and Wilmington, N. C., a
distance of over 300 miles. It is especially valuable as the natural out-
let to the inland commerce of Northern and Middle North Carolina, and
as the natural harbor of refuge to vessels overtaken on this most ex-
posed portion of the Atlantic coast. If its channel were marked by
range lights, it would be the easiest harbor to enter between the Ches-
apeake and Savannah. Beaufort Harbor, before improvement in 1880,
possessed a bar entrance of 15.3 feet least depth at mean low water,
with an average rise and fall of tide of 3 feet. From the bar it pos-
sessed a channel of 25 feet depth upward, 3.7 miles to the Atlantic and
                          RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                    165
North Carolina Railroad Wharf at Morehead City, and a branch channel
of 9 feet deep for six-tenths of a mile up to Bulkhead Channel, and of
2 feet minimum depth six-tenths ot a mile to the wharves of Beaufort
City, where coasting vessels had a good wharfage of 7 feet depth and
1,800 feet long.
   The projects of 1881, 1882, and 1884, as continued to date, proposed
to secure this harbor, by stopping further erosion of the sand-banks at
Shackleford Point and Fort Macon Point, which limit the width of the
harbor entrance, and which had been worn away 500 feet between the
years 1864 and 1880, and 900 more between the years 1880 and 1881,
and by stopping further deterioration of the bar entrance, which was
rapidly shoaling ; and they also proposed afterward to extend the 9-foot
depth of water from Bulkhead Channel to Beaufort City, by a cutting
200 feet wide, and thence to dredge a 6-foot channel 100 feet wide to
North River and Core Sound for the accommodation of the small craft
of the neighboring sound.
   During the last fiscal year ending June 30, 1886, $2,218.56 was spent
in strengthening existing jetties at Shackleford Point, in commencing
a new jetty at Fort Macon Point, in rebuilding a small landing wharf,
and in completing a survey of the harbor. Further much needed work
was stopped for want of funds.
   Up to June 30, 1886, therefore, a total of $75,000 has been spent in all
upon this improvement in successfully stopping the erosion of Shackle-
ford Point and Fort Macon Point, in probably arresting the shoaling
upon this bar, and in making a careful survey of the present condition
of the harbor entrance preparatory to the definite location of further
works. No improvement of commerce nor depth of water was thereby
expected nor obtained, but the retrograde movement has been in gen-
eral arrested, and the old shore line has commenced to reform.
   The officer in charge recommends that the present approved projects
be completed so far as to thoroughly protect Shackleford and Fort Ma-
con from further erosion, and to dredge a reduced channel of 100 feet
width and 5 feet depth at low water from Bulkhead Channel entirely
through to Beaufort City, at an expense of $69,000 in addition to the
funds available for the fiscal year ending June 30, 1887; this amount
to be appropriated in one sum during the next year. Smaller appro-
priations will increase the cost. Further improvement in accord with
the original project, so as to secure to Beaufort City a channel of over
5 feet depth at low water from Bulkhead Channel, or of any depth by
any other route to North River and Core Sound, is not recommended at
present. This improvement once thoroughly completed should be per-
manent.
July 1, 1885, amount.available .....        .....    ................ ...................              $2,218 56
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885- ----.------.....--     ----
                                          ......--------....---....--...........--------.....---....    2, 218 56
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886- - -......             - -......---      ...        15, 000 00
 ( Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project.- - -... -..                         69, 000 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1888 69, 000 00
  Submitted in compliance with .requirements of section 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
  (See Appendix L 5.)
  6. New River, North Carolina.- This river, emptying directly into the
Atlantic Ocean between Beaufort Harbor and Wilmington, N. C., has
a total length of about "52 miles and a drainage area of 492 square
miles. Its lower 14 miles, from its mouth to Jacksonsville, forms a fine
basin of brackish water of from 500 to 10,000 feet width and of at least
166         REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

5 feet channel depth, with 40,000 acres of oyster farms and with rich
agricultural surroundings. When placed under Governmental improve.
ment in 1882 it had very poor facilities for transporting its goods to
market. Its communication with the ocean was blocked by an oyster-
rock barricade, through which there existed only a long and very
crooked channel of 50 feet width and 3 feet depth at low water. Its
commerce, limited to wagons and small boats, was estimated to be about
$400,000 of goods per year.
  The original project, as continued to date, proposed to secure a 150-
foot channel, 5 feet deep at low water, from the upper river to the ocean
by dredging.
  No money had been spent upon this work prior to June, 1885, because
the available funds were too small for profitable use under the existing
project.
  During the last year ending June 30, 1886, $9,810.24 was spent in
making a new survey and project; in newly locating the line of pro-
posed channel and in excavating 34,991 cubic yards of material, thereby
replacing the long and crooked channel by a shorter and straight chan-
nel of 40 feet bottom width and 3.5 feet least depth at low water.
Further work was stopped for want of funds.
  The officer in charge recommends that the present adopted project be
completed so as to secure a channel of from 100 to 150 feet width and 5
feet depth at low water, from the ocean up to the upper river, at a total
expense of $20,000, in addition to the amount available for the fiscal
year ending June 30, 1887, to be appropriated in a single amount within
the next year. Smaller appropriations will increase the cost. Further
improvement, so as to give a channel of greater depth or width, is not
recommended at present. This improvement, once thoroughly completed,
should be permanent.
  He also estimates that $30,000 can be profitably spent in a single
year in completing and extending the above channel of 40 feet width,
and in increasing its dimensions to 100 feet width and 5 feet depth at
low water.
July 1,1885, amount available..........................................                  $10, 000 00
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1885..---...-----....----...--------........ $9,152 04
July 1, 1886, outstanding liabilities ...........................                 658 20
                                                                                          9, 810 24

July 1,1886, amount available ............ :............................                     189 76
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5,1886----------      ...................     10, 000 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30,1887 ...............                     10,189 76
  ( Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project........               20,000 00
J Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1888            10, 000 00
 ' Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
     harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix L 6.)
  7. Cape Fear River, above Wilmington, North Carolina.-The Cape
Fear River, above Wilmington, has a total length of about 400 miles,
and a drainage area of 7,167 square miles, of which 5,620 square miles lie
above the mouth of its main tributary, the Black River. Before im-
provement in 1881, it was navigable during the nine flush-water months
of the year from Wilmington 112 miles upward to Fayettville, but the
channel for the upper 75 miles was badly obstructed by sunken logs,
snags, overhanging trees, and shoals; and for the upper 66 miles was
fill of shoals, on which there was not more than 12 to 14 inches of water
during the low-water season., At that time the navigation was owned
                     RILER AND        HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                167
by private parties. Its commerce was estimated to have been about
$800,000 of transported goods per year.
   The original project of 1881-'82, as continued to date, proposed to buy
out the private owners of the river for $10,000, then to clear out its
natural obstructions, and to further provide a continuous channel over
its upper 66 miles by dredging and by artificially contracting its water-
way through 32 shoals at least.
   During the last fiscal year, ending June 30, 1886, $5,516.98 was spent
in contracting the river channel by jetties at 4 shoals between Fayette-
ville and Elizabethtown, in removing the most troublesome obstruc-
tions in this same length of river, in completing maps, in gauging the
river at several points, and establishing its longitudinal slope at dead
low water, in repairs of plant and care of property. Further work was
stopped by want of funds.
   Up to June 30, 1886, a total of $64,530.81 has been spent in all upon
this improvement, giving a moderately well cleared channel over the
whole length of river; a moderately good continuous 4-foot channel dur-
ing the entire year from Wilmington 44 miles to Kelley's Cove; thence a
similar 2-foot channel 26 miles further to Elizabethtown (a place of con-
siderable commerce); and thence a similar 1-foot channel 42 miles fur-
ther to Fayettville, increased to 5 feet draught from Wilmington to
Fayettville during seven months per year. In consequence, three per-
manently established steamboat lines have been running over the entire
distance with full draught for seven months each year, and with lessened
draught the rest of the time. The commerce during those years has in-
creased about $200,000 per year, showing that each dollar spent upon
this improvement has been accompanied by the development of about
$28 of annual commerce.
   It is recommended that improvement be completed in accordance with
the present approved and adopted project, so as to secure a thoroughly
cleared 4-foot channel from Wilmington 70 miles to Elizabethtown;
thence a similar 3-foot channel 42 miles further to Fayettville during 11
or 12 months of the year; at a total expense of about $200,000, to be ap-
propriated in yearly installments of about $30,000, as smaller appropria-
tions will increase the cost.
   The first installment can be profitably spent in a single year; to in-
crease the depth of water at the worst shoals by contracting the river
channel byjetties; and in removing from the river channel the most
troublesome sunken logs and snags and to cut down and pull back from
the river banks the most troublesome' leaning trees, as also such as
might soon fall into the river channel.
   After the improvement is completed it may cost from $1,000 to $3,000
for its proper maintenance per year.
July 1, 1885, amount available --------------.----.----.----.--------....            $5,986 17
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1885 ........................           $5, 480 74
July 1, 1886, outstanding liabilities--- .....................                 36 74
                                                                                       5, 516 98

July 1, 1886, amount available .......... ........ ..--..................          .   469 19
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886...................               11,250 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887 ...................           11,719 19
  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project. -       200,000 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal yearending June 30,1888 30, 000 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
  (See Appendix L 7.)
168     REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

   8. Cape Fear River below Wilmington, North Carolina.--This river,
emptying into the Atlantic Ocean at Cape Fear, has from its mouth up
to its headwaters in the mountains a total length of about 426 miles,
and a drainage area of 9,115 square miles. The two main branches of
the river meet at Wilmington, bringing with them an average fresh-
water discharge of 14,000 cubic feet per second. Below Wilmington
the river is a tidal basin with about 26 miles length, 350 square miles
drainage area, 37 square miles water surface, 3.5 feet rise of tide (2.5
at Wilmington, 4.5 at the ocean), and an average discharge during ebb
of 160,000 cubic feet per second, the ocean bar being 2 miles seaward
of the river mouth. The Cape Fear River, below Wilmington, before
improvement in 1829, had three bar entrances with least depths as fol-
lows: About 9 feet at the Baldhead Channel, 9 feet at the Rip Channel,
and 110 feet at New Inlet Channel, these bars being, respectively, 9, 6, and
2 miles below the point which was then the head of the river's delta.
Prom the head of this delta 20 miles up to Wilmington there were sev-
eral shoals with a least depth of 7.5 feet at low water.
   The original project of 1827 to 1847 proposed to improve the upper
20 miles by dredging and by jetty contraction of the channel.
   During this time, $203,204.59 were spent in increasing the depth upon
the shoals to 9.5 feet at low water, equal to that at the bar entrance.
   At or about this time, the shore at Fort Caswell, opposite Baldhead
Point, was protected by stone jetties.
   The projects of 1852 to 1857 proposed to deepen the water at the
main entrance by jetties at Baldhead Point, and by jetty and dike ob-
structions between Zeke's Island and Smith's Island, near New Inlet,
and suggested the possible future necessity of closing New Inlet. Dur-
ing this time $156,296.26 were spent upon these works, which, never
fully completed for want of funds, were moreover nearly destroyed later
by the heavy storms of 1857 and 1871. The project of 1870 proposed a
crib closure of the space (4,403 feet long) between Smith's and Zeke's
islands (finished in 1873), to prevent further widening of New Inlet.
The projects of 1870 to 1872 for the proposed complete closure of New
Inlet (begun in 1875 and finished in 1881), in order to deepen the water
at the main (Baldhead) bar entrance. The projects of 1872 to 1883, as
continued to date, proposed the extension of the New Inlet dam 2 miles
further down the stream to prevent the further erosion of Smith's Island
at the swashes. The project of 1875, as continued to date, proposed the
occasional use of dredging upon the outer bar to assist the tidal cur.
rents in gradually localizing, straightening, deepening, and fixing the
bar entrances. The projects of 1874 to 1881 for the 20 miles above New
Inlet, as continued to date, proposed dredging wherever necessary
across shoals, so as to secure first a 12-foot channel, 200 feet wide, and
then a 16 foot channel, 270 feet wide, at low water over this whole
length.
   During the last fiscal year ending June 30, 1886, $66,052.81 was spent
in opening a continuous channel of at least 111 feet width and 16 feet
depth at low water from Wilmington to the ocean bar, in making these
channels by guide-piles and range-targets, in completing the extension
of the New Inlet dam from Zeke's Island southward to Smith's Island,
and in raising this extension to mean tide-level, in necessary surveys
and in the care of property. Further work was stopped for want of
funds.
   Up to June 30, 1886, therefore, a total of $1,698,411.74 has been spent
in all upon the propoked improvement of 1870 to 1882 with great suc-
cess, obtaining a 13.5 to 14-foot least depth of water at the main bar
                     RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                   169
entrance, and completing to partial width the desired 16-foot channel
28 miles further to WAmington. This depth, combined with the aver-
age rise of tide (4.5 at the bar and 2.5 at Wilmington), is such that at
present vessels loaded to 16 feet draught can readily go from Wilming-
ton to the ocean in a single tide any day of the year. The total com-
merce, exports and imports, foreign and coastwise, has increased from
about $13,000,000 of transported goods in 1870 up to about $17,000,000 in
1886 (all this increase being foreign commerce), showing that each dollar
spent upon this improvement has already been accompanied by the de-
velopment of about $2.40 of annual (foreign) commerce, although the
last increase of 2 feet in draught in the river channel is too recent to
have produced its effect on such development.
   The officer in charge recommends that the above improvements be
carried as originally projected by completing the unfinished dike south
of Zeke's Island, so as to thoroughly secure Smith's Island from further
erosion by the ocean ; and by widening and deepening the existing river
channels to their full dimensions of 270 feet width and 16 feet least
depth at low water, and by further protecting them against further sub-
sequent deterioration by submerged stone dikes where necessary, and by
straightening, deepening, and fixing the bar entrance, at a total ex-
pense of $245,000 in addition to the amount available for the fiscal year
ending June 30, 1887, to be appropriated in one sum during the next
fiscal year. Smaller appropriations will increase the cost. So far as can
be seen at present, this amount will complete all existing projects for
this improvement.
   After this improvement is finished, its proper maintenance may cost
from $5,000 to $15,000 per year for a few years, but the improvement
should be fairly permanent.
   It is estimated that the entire sum can be profitably spent in a single
year, in repairs of plant, in the completion of dikes, and in the com-
pletion of dredging, so as to secure a channel of 270 feet width and 16
feet depth at low water, from Wilmington 29 miles to the ocean bar, and
14 feet depth at low water over the bar.
July 1, 1885, amount available ...........----   ........        ............
                                                            ......              $70, 141 07
July 15, 1885, amount received from sales to Beaufort Harbor............             720 00

                                                                                 70,861 07
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1885 ........................ $65, 124 33
July 1, 1886, outstanding liabilities .........................      928 48
                                                                                 66, 052 81
July 1, 1886, amount available . -...-...... .......... ....... ..... .....     .  4, 808 26
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886.....--......         ........ 157,500 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887..--. .....----.......     162, 308 26
( Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project ...... 245, 000 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in.fiscal year ending June 30,1888 245,000 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix L 8.)
   9. GreatPee Dee River, South Carolina.--Thisriver, emptying into Win-
yaw Bay at Georgetown, S. C., has (including its upper portion, called
the Yadkin) a total length of about 500 miles, and a drainage area of
16,329 square miles, of which 9,642 square miles lie above the mouth
of the Black, Lynche's, and Little Pee Dee rivers, its main tributaries. At
Cheraw, at five-tenths of a foot above low water, the discharge is about
7,000 cubic feet per second. This river, prior to improvement in 1880,
was dangerously obstructed with snags and logs everywhere, but was
170         REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,-U. S. ARMY.

otherwise available for 9-foot boats at ordinary stages of water to Smith's
Mills, 67 miles above its mouth; and thence for 3.5-foot draught boats
at low water 88 miles further, to Little Bluff, or at high water 183 miles
further, from Smith's aills to Cheraw, the present head of steam navi-
gation, 250 miles above Georgetown. The commerce of this river is
estimated to have then been about $400,000 of transported goods per
year. The original project of 1880, as continued to date, proposed to
secure a thoroughly cleared 9-foot navigation to Smith's Mills, and a
3.5-foot navigation to Cheraw at all stages of water.
   During the last fiscal year ending June 30,1886, while awaiting further
appropriations, $829.02 was spent in mapping the river, in caring for
the property and records, and in preparing reports and future projects.
   Up to June 30, therefore, a total of $26,919.43 has been spent in all
upon this improvement, giving at all ordinary stages of water a well-
cleared 9-foot navigation 67 miles upward to Smith's Mills, and a fairly-
cleared 3.5-foot navigation at low water, 83 miles further to the railroad
station at Pee Dee, or at high water 183 miles further from Smith's Mills
to Cheraw. The commerce of the river has thereby increased so as to
be at present about $2,000,000 of transported goods per year, showing
that each dollar spent upon this improvement has been accompanied by
the development of about $59 annual commerce.
   The Wilmington, Columbia and Augusta Railroad Drawbridge, 5 miles
below Little Bluff, is improperly fendered; its obstruction is somewhat
dangerous, and should be corrected. The Society Hill Drawbridge
near Cheraw is improperly fendered; its obstruction is somewhat dan-
gerous, and should be corrected.
   The officer in charge recommends that this improvement be completed
in accordance with the present approved and adopted proect, so as to
secure a thoroughly cleared 9-foot navigation 67 miles upward to
Smith's Mills, and thence a 3.5-foot navigation 183 miles further to
Cheraw at all stages of water, at a total expense of $70,000 in addi-
tion to the amount available for the fiscal year ending June 30, 1887,
appropriated in two yearly installments of $40,000 andt 30,000 respect-
ively. Smaller appropriations will increase the cost.
   It is estimated that the first installment can be profitably spent re-
moving from the river channel the most troublesome sunken logs and
snags, and in cutting down and pulling back from the river banks the
most troublesome leaning trees, and also such as appear liable to fall into
the river channel during the next year.
   After the appropriation is finished, its proper maintenance may cost
from $2,000 to $5,000 per year.
July 1, 1885, amount available ..........................................                                   $909 59
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1885 ............             --............                  $489 30
July 1, 1886, outstanding liabilities.....................-------.             ---               339 72
                                                                                                             829 02

July 1, 1886, amount available ..-...               .............    ......--...........----.                 80 57
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886....................                                    20,000 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887 ....................                                20,080 57

  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1888 40,000 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
 (See Appendix L 9.)
10. Waccemaw River, South Carolina.--Thisriver, emptying into the
Winyaw Bay at Georgetown, has a total length of 244 miles, and a
                       RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                            171
drainage area of 1,572 square miles of rich agricultural lands. This
river, prior to Governmental improvement in 1880, was navigable for
12-foot-draught boats at all stages of water from Georgetown, Winyaw
Bay, 26 miles to Bull Creek, and at high water 4 miles further,, to Buck's
Lower Mills; thence for 7-foot draught boats at high water 36 miles
further to Conway borough; thence it possessed an obstructed channel for
3-foot-draught boats at ordinary water 124 miles to Reeves Ferry, the
present head of steam navigation; thence an obstructed channel with
3-foot depth at high water for 54 miles to Lake Waccemaw, which is
244 miles distant from Georgetown. The commerce of this river is es-
timated to have then been about $400,000 of transported goods per year.
The original project of 1880, as continued to date, proposed to secure a
channel 12 feet deep at all stages of water, with 80-foot bottom width
from the mouth of the river 66 miles upward to Conwayborough, and
afterwards a cleared channel 178 miles farther to Lake Waccemaw.
   Up to June 30, 1886, a total of $35,367.17 has been spent in all upon
this improvement, giving a thoroughly cleared channel, with 100 feet
least width and 6.8 feet least depth at high water as far as Conwaybo-
rough.     The commerce upon this river has been thereby increased to
about $1,300,000 per year, showing that each dollar spent on this im-
provement has been accompanied by the development of about $25 of
annual commerce.
   The officer in charge recommends that this improvement be com-
pleted in accordance with the present approved and adopted project;
so far as at present to secure a channel 12 feet deep at mean low water,
with 80 feet bottom width, from the mouth of the river 41 miles, up to
Bucksville; and thence a channel 10 feet deep at mean low water, with
80 feet bottom width, 25 miles further, to Conwayborough; thence a
thoroughly-cleared 3-foot navigation 24 miles further, to Reeves Ferry,
throughout the entire year; and thence a thoroughly-cleared natural
channel 54 miles further, to Lake Waccemaw, at a total expense of
$88,000, in addition to the amount available for the fiscal year ending
June 30, 1887; this amount to be appropriated in two yearly install-
ments.     Smaller appropriations will increase the cost of the work.
Further improvement in accord with the original project, so as to secure
a 12-foot navigation at all stages of water from Bucksville 25 miles,
to Conwayborough, is not recommended at present.
   After the improvement is finished its proper maintenance may cost
from $1,000 to $4,000 per year.
   It is estimated that the first installment can be profitably spent to
secure a 12-foot navigation at high water from the mouth of the river
41 miles, to Bucksville, and a similar 10-foot navigation thence 25 miles
upward, to donwayborough; and towards securing a clear 3-foot steam
navigation from Conwayborough 24 miles further, to Reeves Ferry.
July 1, 1885, amount available...... ......-..-
                                           -    ...... ......... ... ......                    $36 19
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885......---..        ....--......----........................   .3          35

July 1, 1886, amount available............................ .............                         32 84
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886..-- -..............                       15,000 00

Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887 ....................                   15,032 84

 (Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project ........  88, 000 00
 ) Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal yearending June30,1888 48,000 00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
     harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix L 10.)
172        REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

   11. Harborat Georgetown, South Carolina.-Georgetownis situated at
the head of Winyaw Bay, and at the corfluence of the Sampit, Great Pee
Dee, and Waccemaw rivers (the latter having conjointly a drainage area
of 18,040 square miles), and is the natural harbor and sea-port for all com-
merce passing to and from these rivers and their tributaries. It is also a
railroad terminus. This harbor prior to improvement in 1880 had an
excellent, well-protected anchorage of at least one mile length, 150 feet
width, and 15 feet depth. A bar of about 2,850 feet length and with only
9 feet depth of water was the only obstacle to an otherwise good 13-foot
navigation from Georgetown 12 miles, to the ocean. The commerce of
this harbor is estimated to have then been $2,000,000 of transported
goods per year.
    The original project of 1881, as continued to date, proposed to secure
a dredged channel of 200 feet bottom width and 12 feet low-water depth
entirely through this bar. No money was spent upon this improvement
prior to June 30, 1884, because the available funds were too small to
allow of being profitably spent.
   During the last fiscal year, ending June 30, 1886, $3,552.91 was spent
in widening the existing dredged channel, in caring for property and
records, and in preparing reports and future projects. Further work
was stopped for want of funds.
    Up to June 30, 1886, therefore, $11,986.04 has been spent in all upon
this improvement, giving a through cut entirely across the bar, with 12
feet low-water depth, and with a width varying from 40 to 80 feet.
The commerce of the river is now about $3,500,000 of transported goods
per year, an increase of $1,500,000 since 1880.
   The officer in charge recommends that the above improvement be
completed in accordance with the present and adopted project, so as to
secure a channel of 12 feet depth at mean low water and of about 200
feet bottom width entirely through the bar, at a total expense of $22,000,
in addition to the amount available for the fiscal year ending June 30,
1887; this amount to be appropriated in two yearly installments of
$15,000 and $7,000, respectively. Smaller appropriations will increase
the cost of the work. Further improvement is desirable in order to
continue this channel by a similar easy ', well-marked, and well-defined
channel entirely through the upper portion of Winyaw Bay. With this
object in view, a survey of the entrance to Georgetown Harbor through
Winyaw Bay, S. C., is desirable, and is recommended as an extension
of the Georgetown Harbor improvement.
   The channel once thoroughly opened will probably be permanent.
By this improvement ocean vessels of 12 feet draught, after once cross-
ing Winyaw Bay Bar, can proceed without delay 15 miles further, to
their anchorage at Georgetown.
   It is estimated that the first installment of $15,000 can be profitably
spent in a single year in widening the existing narrow channel.
July 1, 1885, amount available ......---
                                   -......        .......... ........- --------......   $3, 566 15
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1885 ..........            ..........    $3, 550 19
July 1, 1886, outstanding liabilities ..........................                 2 00
                                                                                         3,552 19

July 1, 1886, amount available.........................................                     13 96
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886 ..................                   5, 000 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887 ...................                5,013 96
                  RIVER AND IIARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                 173

Amount that
Amount               required expended
              can be profitably
         (estimated)                     in fiscal
                                for completion  ofyear ending
                                                   existing                  15,000
                                                              June 30, 1888 $22,
                                                            project........      000 00
                                                                                     00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix L 11.)
   12. Santee River, South Carolina.-This river, formed by the Congaree
and Wateree rivers, and emptying into the Atlantic Ocean just south
of Winyaw Bay, has, from the sea to its headwaters in the mountains,
a total length of about 500 miles and a drainage area of 15,414 square
miles. It was formerly navigated by 4-foot draught boats from the sea
up to Columbia on the Congaree and Camden on the Wateree. In 1880,
the date of commencement of the improvement, this navigation was con-
siderably obstructed and blocked at all stages of water by sunken logs,
snags, and floating timber. Its bar entrance was narrow, crooked, and
shifting, with only about 4 feet depth of water at low tide, and so sit-
uated as to be very difficult and expensive to improve. Four steamers
and a few small vessels were then running upon portions of this river.
Its commerce is estimated to have then been about $600,000, and to now
be about $1,400,000 of transported goods per year.
   The original project of 1880 proposed to provide the river with a good
outlet through Mlosquito Creek to Winyaw Bay, by deepening and
straightening this creek to 50 feet width and 7 feet depth, and to secure
a safe and unobstructed 7-foot navigation in the river itself from its
mouth, 154 miles upward, to Wright's Bluff; and thence a similar 5-foot
navigation 30 miles further to its head in the Congaree and Wateree
rivers.
   The appropriation of 1881, and since, provided only for work upon the
outlet of the river through Mosquito Creek to Winyaw Bay ; and the
approved project for 1881 for this expenditure, as continued to date,
proposed to secure to the river a straightened canalized outlet through
Mosquito Creek 7 miles long, 30 feet wide, and 6 feet deep at mean low
water, and to construct one draw-bridge over the creek.
   During the last fiscal year ending June 30, 1886, $14,993.62 was spent
in extending the Mosquito Creek Canal, in building the draw-bridge,
and in making necessary surveys, examinations, and reports. The work
of dredging was stopped in November for want of funds.
   Up to June 30, 1886, therefore, $55,346.37 has been spent in all upon
this improvement, in cutting 15,610 linear feet of canal 30 feet wide and
5 feet deep, from Santee River along Mosquito Creek toward Winyaw
Bay, and in building the proposed draw-bridge. No improvement of
commerce has yet been produced, nor was any to be expected there-
from until the canal should be finally completed.
   The Northeastern Railroad Drawbridge, between the mouth of the
river and Wright's Bluff, is improperly fendered; the obstruction is
somewhat dangerous and should be corrected.
   The officer in charge recommends that this improvement be completed
in accordance with the present approved and adopted project of 1881,
so as to secure to the Santee River a straightened canalized outlet
through Mosquito Creek 7 miles long, 30 feet wide, and 6 feet deep, at
mean low water, at a total expense of $71,000 in addition to the $1,653.63
available June 30, 1886, this amount to be appropriated in two yearly
installments of $48,000 and $23,000, respectively; also that this improve-
ment be extended in accordance with the proposed original project of
1880, so as to secure a safe and unobstructed 7-foot navigation from
the mouth of the Santee River 154 miles upward to Wright's Bluff,
and thence a similar 5-foot navigation 30 miles further to its head in
174         REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, t.                                             S. ARMY.

the Congaree and Wateree rivers, at a total expense of $75,000, to be
appropriated in two yearly installments of about $40,000 each. Smaller
appropriations will increase the cost of the work. It is estimated that
this last recommended improvement would at once (as already shown by
past experience on the neighboring Pee Dee River) increase the Santee
River commerce from $1,000,000 to $2,000,000 per year. Further im-
provement, so as to increase the above widths and depths of either canal
or river, is not recommended until commerce shall have shown a further
immediate necessity therefor.
   After this improvement is finished its proper maintenance may cost
from $3,000 to $5,000 per year.
   It is estimated that $48,000 can be profitably spent in a single year
in opening the canal to vessels of about 20 feet width and 4 feet draught,
and in removing in part from the river channel its sunken logs and
snags, and cutting down and pulling back from its banks such trees as
overhang the channel or might soon fall into the channel from caving
banks.
July 1, 1885, amount available ........                  ............    .................          $16, 647 05
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1885 .---.....--......-----......---...... $14,557 33
July 1, 1886, outstanding liabilities----....... --..........            ....    436 09
                                                                                                        14,993 42

July 1, 1886, amount available.----------...........--..-------...---...------------...----...           1, 653 63
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886.                       ..---.- .-           .        18, 750 00

Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887 ....................                              20, 403 63

     Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project ......                              71, 000 00
     Amount that canbe profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1888                           48, 000 00
     Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
l     harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
     (See Appendix L 12.)
   13. Wateree River, South Carolina.--Thisriver, which unites with the
Congaree to form the Santee, has (including its upper portion, called the
Catawba) a total length of about 310 miles, and a drainage area of 5,642
square miles. This river, prior to Governmental improvement in 1882,
had a low-water depth of from 3 to 4 feet from its mouth in the Santee
upward 64 miles to Camden, its practical limit of steam navigation. From
its mouth upward 12 miles the river was completely blocked at all stages
of water by sunken logs and stumps and by floating obstructions; thence
42 miles to Camden navigation was possible, but dangerous, except during
high water. Its commerce was then almost nothing.
   The original project of 1881-'82, as continued to date, proposed to secure
a safe and unobstructed 4-foot navigation over this entire distance at all
stages of water.
   During the last fiscal year ending June 30, 1886, while awaiting further
appropriations, $238.46 was spent in mapping the river, in caring for
the property and records, and in preparing reports and future projects.
   Up to June 30, 1886, therefore, a total of $27,965.63 has been spent
in all upon giving a thoroughly cleared 4-foot navigation upon this im-
provement at all stages of water from the mouth of the river 7 miles up-
ward; and thence a roughly cleared 4-foot navigation over the rest of the
57 miles to Camden. In consequence of this improvement a steamboat
line would have been permanently established upon the whole length of
                        RIVER AND HARBOR                     IMPROVEMENTS.                          175
the river had it not been prevented by the obstructions offered by two
low railroad bridges.
   This long desired and now possible navigation is obstructed at pres-
ent only by the South Carolina Railroad and the Wilmington, Colum-
bia and Augusta Railroad, who should either raise or put draw-spans
in their two low through-bridges across the river near its mouth. If
the railroad obstructions can be removed, it is estimated that the river
commerce will increase at once by about $1,000,000 of transported goods
per year.
   It is recommended that this improvement be completed in accordance
with the present approved and adopted project, so as to secure a thor-
oughly-cleared 4-foot navigation over the entire river at all stages of
water, at a total expense of $22,500 in addition to the amount available
for the fiscal year ending June 30, 1887; this amount to be appropri-
ated in one sum during the next year. Smaller yearly appropriations
will increase the cost. Further improvement so as to extend the navi-
gation above Camden or to deepen that below Camden is not recom-
mended.
   After the improvement is finished its proper maintenance may cost
from $1,000 to $3,000 per year.
   It is estimated that the appropriation asked can be profitably spent
in a single year in removing from the river channel its sunken logs and
snags, and in cutting down and pulling back from its banks such trees
as overhang the channel or as might soon fall into the river channel
from caving banks.
July 1, 1885, amount available .......... ...... ...................... $272 83
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1885....................-------------------------    $3 71
July 1, 1886, outstanding liabilities ...... ....................                     234 75
                                                                                      _-           238 46

July 1, 1886, amount available............---....-----..... ......---..........                     34 37
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886 ...................                           7,500 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887...................                         7,534 37

TAmount (estimated) required for completion of existing project-
   Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1888
                                                                                      .-...--   22, 500 00
                                                                                                22, 500 00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix L 13.)
  14. Removing sunken vessels obstructing or endangering navigation.-
The wrecks of the brig Clio and steamer North Heath, in the Cape
Fear River, below Wilmington, were examined and reported as ob-
structing and endangering navigation.
  After the usual preliminaries, a contract was approved June 23,
1886, for the removal of both these wrecks within the following four
months. There were no expenditures upon this work prior to June 30,
1886.
   The circumstances connected with the removal of these wrecks sug-
gest to the officer in charge some modification of the act of June 14,
1880, so as to allow the Secretary of War some discretion as to whether
the wreck after removal may not in certain cases become the property
of the contractor. Such a modification in the act might result in econ-
omy to the Government.
   (See Appendix L 14.)
176    REPORT     OF THE    CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

IMPROVEMENT OF RIVERS AND HARBORS ON THE COAST OF SOUTH
  CAROLINA AND GEORGIA, AND PART OF THE ATLANTIC COAST OF
  FLORIDA.

   Officer in charge, Col. Q. A. Gillmnore, Corps of Engineers, having under
his immediate orders First Lieuts. F. V. Abbot and O. M. Carter, Corps
of Engineers.
   1. Charleston Harbor, South Carolina.-The works of improvement
now in progress of construction comprise two jetties, composed of rip-
rap stone resting on a broad foundation mattress of logs and brush,
with a mattress hearting wherever deemed expedient and advantageous.
   The two jetties spring, respectively, from Sullivan's and Morris isl-
ands, and converge towards each other on curves in such manner as
to cross the bar on parallel lines at a distance of about 2,900 feet from
each other. The object of the work is to establish and permanently
maintain a practicable channel across the bar of not less than 21 feet
navigable depth at mean low water, where heretofore the available low-
water depth has usually not exceeded 11J feet.
   A greater navigable depth than 21 feet at mean low water can be
obtained by increasing the length of the jetties and building them higher.
   Previous to the adoption of this project in 1878 there had been ex-
pended in improving this harbor since the close of the civil war, from
1871 to 1878, the sum of $93,700 in taking up the wrecks of fourteen
iron-clads and wooden vessels, and for other purposes.
   The estimated cost of the project is $3,000,000.
   The following work on jetties is reported to have been done during
the past fiscal year:
   North Jetty.-A second course of log-and-brush mattresses, 55 feet
wide and covered with about 12 inches of rip-rap stone, was laid over
the bottom course of the jetty, extending 2,030 feet seaward from a point
11,090 feet from the shore end on Sullivan's Island, measured along the
axis of the work. A pile of riprap stone, nominally 5 feet high at the
ridge line, with natural side slopes, was deposited upon work previously
laid, beginning at a point 9,193 feet from shore and carried seaward for
a continuous length of 4,485 feet. The outer end of this pile of rock
work reaches a point about 560 feet from the present seaward end of the
bottom course of the north jetty.
   South Jetty.-The foundation course of this jetty was extended seaward
43 feet by laying a log-and-brush mattress of that length and of 108 feet
width. A third course of mattresses, 44 feet wide, was placed upon that
section of second-course work which had been laid about two and a half
years ago where the jetty crosses the deep pocket east of the existing
main ship-channel. This third course commences at a point 7,986 feet
from the shore end of the work on Morris Island and extends 1,206 feet
seaward. A ridge of riprap work, triangular in cross-section, and av-
eraging 4.6 feet in height, was deposited upon the existing work, begin-
ing at the inner end of the third course just mentioned and extending
6,038 feet seaward. During the past fiscal year 18,289 square yards of
log-and-brush mattresses and 15,341 cubic yards of riprap stone were
put in the work on the two jetties, and the sum of $97,212.92 was ex-
pended. Previous to July 1, 1885, the total expenditures amounted to
$1,197,732.08.
   On June 30, 1886, the seaward end of the north jetty reached a point
14,327 feet from the shore of Sullivan's Island, measured along the axis
of the work, and 1,200 feet within the outer 18-foot curve of the bar,
                 RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                        177
taken on the prolongation of the axis of the jetty. By a similar way
of measurement, the outer end of the south jetty was 16,440 feet from
the shore of Morris Island, and 2,500 feet from the outer 18-foot curve
of the bar.
   Dredging between the jetties was carried on during the first six
months of the past fiscal year; 76,620 cubic yards of material were re-
moved during that time. It appears from the report of the engineer
officer in charge that the average height now attained by the north jetty
is 4.95 feet, while the height required under the project is 10.66 feet.
The contraction of the water-way is at present 464 per cent. of what
it should be. The mean height of the south jetty on June 30, 1886, was
5.95 feet; ultimate height required, 11.23 feet; the contraction of the
water-way at the same time was 53 per cent. of what is required by
the project. These results show that a considerable amount of addi-
tional work is needed to develop scouring currents of sufficient strength
between the jetties to produce and maintain the new channel.
    Both jetties were generally in good order at the end of the fiscal year,
with some unimportant exceptions. For a short length the apron of
the north jetty at Drunken Dick Shoal has settled somewhat, but other-
wise sand had freely accumulated over the work in that section. Near
the outer end of the north jetty the apron seems to be a good deal
broken up, probably by the action of the waves. Considerable scour-
ing has taken place on the south side of the south jetty where it crosses
the deepest of the Morris Island ship-channel, but the work does not
seem to have settled in consequence. Some settling has occurred at
and near the outer end of this jetty. The ridges of riprap stone placed
over portions of both jetties have been lowered by the action of the
waves and the stone spread out over the mattress work below. No
material changes of the bar between the jetties are reported. Jim Ev-
an's Shoal is about in the same condition as last year, but has moved
slightly seaward. The area of Swash Reef, between the 9-foot curves,
has diminished one-half during the year. Some deepening has been
produced by dredging, but the form of the cut dredged has been oblit-
erated by the shifting sand. Pumpkin Hill Channel, for many years
the channel of entrance across the bar, has fallen into disuse towards
the end of the fiscal year, and a more southerly channel located practi-
cally in the prolongation of the axis of the main ship-channel has taken
its place.
    The sea-beach of Sullivan's Island east of Bowman's Jetty has changed
but little, but to the west of that work washing has continued. The
same is reported of the northern end of Morris Island, and some lower-
ing of the beach has taken place in the vicinity of the south jetty.
    The two spur-jetties built in 1884 for the protection of a part of the
shore of Mount Pleasant, are stated to be in good condition and col-
lecting sand at their inner ends, but caving of the bluff continues at
other points of the shore-line.
    The progressive widening of Hog Island Channel at its upper end,
about which the engineer officer in charge made some remarks in his
last annual report, is again referred to in his present report, and he re-
peats his opinion that works should be built to prevent further enlarge-
ment.
    With the first money that becomes available the north and south jet-
ties will be raised to higher levels, and dredging will be resumed if the
funds at disposal shall be sufficient for that purpose.
    The appropriations made by Congress for this improvement to the
       12 a
178        REPORT       OF    THE     CHIEF OF           ENGINEERS,                    U. S. ARMY.

end of the past fiscal year aggregate $1,295,000.                                        The total expendi-
tures were $1,294,945.
July   1, 1885, amount available ------------------------........--....--..                             $97, 267 92
July   1,1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive
  of   liabilities outstanding July 1, 1885 ...................   $97,156 73
July   1, 1886, outstanding liabilities ........................        56 19
                                                                                                         97,212 92
July 1, 1886, amount available.................... .......... ..------------------....  5 00
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886 ..................             187 500 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887----..............--------------                   187,555 00

 (Amount (estimated.) required for completion of existing project-...... 1, 525, 000 00
S
IAmount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June
      30, 1888-----------------           --       -------------------------.........................   750,000 00
I Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
 . harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
     (See Appendix M 1.)
  2. Wappoo Cut, South Carolina.-Three appropriations, aggregating
$23,000, have thus far been made by Congress for improving Wappoo
Cut. The last of these appropriations, amounting to $3,000, was made
by act approved July 5, 1884.
   Wappoo Cut is a narrow, tortuous, tidal stream, separating James
Island from the mainland and connecting Stono and Ashley rivers.
   The project of improvement submitted by the Engineer officer in
charge contemplates the establishment of a straighter channel, 6 feet by
90 feet, low-water dimensions, at an estimated cost of $34,000. In its
unimproved condition, only 2 to 4 feet could be carried over the prin-
cipal shoals at mean low water.
   The plan of improvement comprised dredging at the entrance from
Ashley and Stono rivers and through a portion of the cut; a cut-off
through the marsh, about 24 miles from Ashley River, closing three small
tidal branches, and the construction of a short jetty at both the Stono
and Ashley rivers.
   The first two appropriations, aggregating $20,000, were expended in
improving the westerly section of Wappoo Cut, known as Elliott's Cut;
in making a solid cut through the marsh of the neck of the bend known
as Devil's Elbow, and in deepening the crooked channel between these
places. Some dredging was done on the bar at the entrance from
Ashley River. A dam was built across the tidal branch named Pompey's
Cut, and a number of snags and overhanging trees were removed. The
expenditures for these works to June 30, 1885, were $19,972.16.
   During the last fiscal year some dredging was done in the bends be-
tween Elliott's Cut and the cut at the bend of Devil's Elbow, where the
channel had sloughed to from 44 to 54 feet; 15,050 cubic yards of material
was removed.
   At the end of the fiscal year the improved reaches of the cut are re-
ported to be in a satisfactory condition, and to have a practicable mean
low-water depth of 54 to 6 feet, with the exception of a small bar at the
Stono River entrance. The engineer officer in charge expresses the
opinion that the small amounts of the appropriations and the long in-
tervals of time between them will cause an increase of the total cost of
the improvement.
   When additional funds shall be provided, the bar at the mouth of
Elliott's Cut will be removed, and such other work done as a re-exam-
ination of the several reaches of Wappoo Cut may show to be most im-
portant,
                         RIVER AND             HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                          179

   The total amount expended to June 30, 1886, is $22,968.40.
July 1, 18r5, amount available .......................... ....-..--.....-
                                                                   -----.  $3, 027 84
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 185--- .....................    .. ...... --......    2, 996 24
July 1, 1886, amount available..................---------------.......--....---------............           31 60
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886 .---.................-----.                           5,000 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887 .--.................
                                                                ----.                                    5,031 60
  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project-...---.....                        -   10,000 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1888                            10, 000 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix M 2.)
   3. Ashley River, South Carolina.-Thisriver is about 40 miles in length,
and runs in a generally southeasterly direction. At its mouth the city
of Charleston occupies the left bank.
   Three appropriations have been made by Congress for improving this
river in the years of 1880, 1881, and 1884, respectively, and aggregating
$4,500.
   The plan of improvement comprised-
  1. The removal of a shoal at a place known as Accabee, about 8 miles
above the city of Charleston, where, according to a survey made in
1873, there was then only 9 feet of water at low tide; and
  2. The removal of a shoal just below the Wando Phosphate Works,
where only 6 feet of water was found at low tide. It was proposed to
increase the draught of water over these shoals by dredging to a depth
of from 10 to 11 feet at mean low tide. The cost of the project was es-
timated at $5,000.
  The first two appropriations, amounting to $2,500, were expended in
dredging a channel through the shallow crossing near the Wando Works,
of over 1,000 feet length, 100 feet depth, and an improved low-water
depth of 11 feet.
  During the past fiscal year dredging was done at a shoal near the
Stono Phosphate Works, about 9 miles from Charleston. The channel
averaged here about 9 feet at mean low tide; a clear cut was made,
securing 11 feet depth upon a width of 210 feet, removing 8,567 cubic
yards of material. It is stated that in June, 1886, both the old cut and
the new one were in good condition. The Engineer officer in charge
expresses doubts, however, that the depths established in Ashley River
can be maintained sojely by the scouring power of the currents, and
expects that dredging will be needed from time to time, unless works
of contraction are constructed.
  The total amount expended to June 30, 1886, was $4,457.26.
July 1, 1885, amount available ............       ......---...---..----...........                      $2, 054 57
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885 ......--.......... ...        __...........-....-----....---....              2, 011 83
July 1, 1886, amount available............-- ...........----. ...-----..-......-----                        42 74
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886 ...................                                   1,000 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887 ...................                                1, 042 74
SAmount (estimated) required for completion of existing project ....
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
                                                                                             ....        1, 000 00
     harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
  (See Appendix M 3.)
  4. Edisto River, South Carolina.-Two appropriations have been made
by Congress for improving Edisto River, aggregating $13,000. The
180)         REPORT          OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

last appropriation, amounting to $5,000, was made by the act approved
July 5, 1884.
   The Edisto is one of the principal rivers in South Carolina. It is
formed by the junction of the North and South forks, which unite in the
southern part of Orangeburg County. The South Fork, commonly
known as the South Edisto, is the main river.
   The obstructions to navigation consist of numerous bends, logs,
snags, overhanging trees, and piles; also of shoals, generally of sand,
but in some places of hard clay.
   The plan of improvement contemplates the establishment of a safe
navigation channel at all seasons of the year for light-draught steam-
boats from the sea to the junction of the North and South forks, a dis-
tance of 183 miles, and from that point to Guinguard's Landing, 77 miles
higher up, for rafts and flat-boats. The plan embraces enlarging all the
new channels now in progress of formation, cutting off bends, shutting
off lateral arms of the river, removing shoals, snags, logs, piles, and
other obstructions, and building a deflecting jetty. The cost of the
project is estimated at $33,385.
   No operations were carried on during the past fiscal year owing to
lack of funds.
   Prior to July 1, 1885, a large number of snags, logs, overhanging
trees, and piles were removed from the reaches extending from the
mouth of the Edisto to Kennedy's Bridge, a distance of 130 miles by
                                                                1
river. A narrow cut-off known as the Suck," 50 miles above Jackson-
boro', through the neck of a long bend, was widened and deepened and
made the regular channel of the river. Many outlets, feeding adjoining
swamps, and incipient cut-offs were closed, and the river banks trimmed
at numerous places. The cost of these works to June 30, 1885, was
$12,629.86.
   It seems that the raft navigation of the Edisto, on the reaches where
operations were carried on, has been substantially benefited. Lumber-
men state that their products can now more economically be brought
from mill to market, as trips can be made in much shorter time and with
less risk; which saving is to a large extent attributed to the improve-
ments made by Government.
   The Engineer officer in charge recommends that the necessary appro-
priations be made to complete the improvement according to the ap-
proved project.
  The total expenditures to June 30, 1886, were $12,719.33.
July 1, 1885, amount available ......-----................------------....-----....----... ---------....     $370 14
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885............................................                                         89 47
July 1, 1886, amount available ..................................----.....                                    20 67
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886....------------..............                           3, 000 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887...--...---...--------------                          3,280 67

f Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project -.....-.
   Amount that canbe profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1888
                                                                                                           17, 385 00
                                                                                                           10,000 00
   Submitted in complianube with requirements of section 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix M 4.)
   5. Salkiehatchie River, South Carolina.-Theappropriations heretofore
made and expended on this improvement aggregate $8,000.
   The Salkiehatchie, known as the Big Salkiehatchie, to distinguish it
from its principal tributary, the Little Salkiebatchie, rises in Aiken
                        RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                  181
County, S. C., and flows into the Atlantic Ocean. The two rivers unite
about 80 miles from the sea-coast. The lower part of the river is known
as the Combahee. Above a point named Hickory Hill, about 44 miles
from the sea-coast, the river is obstructed in many places by piles, logs,
and sand-shoals.
   The prqject of improvement contemplates the establishment of a con-
tinuous channel, suitable for fkst-boats and rafts, from a point 5 miles
above Toby's Bluff down to Hickory Hill, a distance of about 77 miles
by river.
   The work comprises the removal of logs, shoals, and piles, and cut-
ting a navigable channel through two places known as Murdoc Sand
Drags and Weekly Sand Drags, where the river at present is divided
into numerous small streamlets unfit for any kind of navigation. The
cost of the project was estimated at $18,000.
   No work was done on the river during the last fiscal year, as no funds
were available.
   Previously the United States snag-boat Toccoa cleared the 12-mile
reach, from the Charleston and Savannah Railroad Bridge down to Hick-
ory Hill, from piles and other obstructions. Between 11,000 and 12,000
snags, logs, and trees were removed from several reaches of the river
above the bridge as far as Braxton's Ford, a total length of 80 miles;
over one hundred outlets were closed; many projecting points were cut
off, and the channel straightened.
   The Engineer officer in charge reports that raft navigation on the
Salkiehatchie has been materially benefited by the work done by the
Government, and that thereby the cost of rafting timber has been re-
duced from 33 to 50 per cent. from former rates. He further states that
the reaches where improvements have been effected have remained in
the same condition substantially in which they were when work was
suspended in May, 1885.
   It seems desirable that the necessary funds be provided by Congress
to finish the upper section of the river in conformity with the project.
The sum of $10,000 is required for the purpose. The total expendi-
tures to June 30, 1886, were $7,924.17.
July 1, 1885, amount available...........- . .. ..----... ...                     ..............    $141 10
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885........------..---- ..............-....----- ........--..--....----     65     27
July 1, 1886, amount available ........--- ......... ..... ................                            75 83
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886 ...................                             2, 000 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30,1887 .............---                       ...    2, 075 83

  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project--------                           8, 000 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal yearending June 30, 1.888                       8, 000 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
     harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
    (See Appendix M 5.)
    6. Savannah Harbor and River, Georgia.-Duringa part of the past
fiscal year operations were carried on in conformity to the enlarged pro-
ject of January 16, 1882.
    This plan contemplates the establishment of a channel from Tybee
Roads to the city of Savannah, navigable for vessels of 22 feet draught,
and the widening of the river opposite the city to 600 feet of uniform
depth with the balance of the channel. This is to be accomplished by
improving the north channel in preference to the south channel, from
the head of Elba Island to the head of Long Island, closing with dams
182    REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

all the lateral channels connecting the north and south channels from
Elba Island to Tybee Roads; constructing a low dam across the south
channel above Saint Augustine Creek, in order to increase the volume of
ebb-flow down the north channel, raising the dam at Cross-Tides 4
miles above the city of Savannah to a higher level, possibly to the level
of high water ; narrowing the river between Savannah and Tybee Roads
by wing-dams where the widths are excessive and navigation poor;
constructing a low jetty or training-wall from some point on either
Jones or Turtle Island, in a southerly direction to the Red Light Bea-
con, and protecting Saint Michael's Channel below that beacon by a
similar wall or by some other device. Works of shore protection will be
built and dredging done wherever deemed necessary. The estimated
cost of the improvement according to the plan submitted January 16,
1882, is $730,000.
   The following is a summary of the work done previous to July 1, 1885:
   The Cross-Tides Dam had been built up to the level of mean high
water, and at places where it had settled its base was protected by an
apron of log mattress and stone. A portion of the old King's Island
jetty had been removed; three wing-dams for reducing the width of the
water-way were constructed opposite the lower part of the city, and a
fourth lower down, near the lower end of Fig Island; a training-wall
was built extending 6,000 feet down-stream from the lower end of Fig
Island, with its crest from 3 to 5 feet above mean low water, and eleven
short spurs added to the wall on its channel side; a sumerged dam was
built across the South Channel, near the head of Elba Island; two side
channels northwest and southeast of Barnwell Island, above Elba Island,
and three side channels below that island were closed by dams; a wing-
dam was constructed to improve the channel at "The Obstructions"
between Barnwell Island No. 3 and the head of Elba Island; three
pairs of wing-dams were built to regulate and improve the channel at
the " Upper Fats"; one pair of wing-dams was completed and a single
one about two thirds finished at the "Lower Flats" or "Cabbage Tree
Crossing"; a fifth pair was built lower down to improve the shallow
passage at "Long Island Crossing", and a dam was commenced at the
mouth of the river, designed to improve the ship-channel northwest of
Fort Pulaski, near the Oyster Bed Beacon. The channel was dredged
at numerous points of the river from the Cross-Tides Dam to Tybee
Roads, an aggregate of 1,667,233 cubic yards df material having been
removed.
   The following work was done during the past fiscal year:
   Cross-Tides Dam, the central portion of which had been washed down
to the level of low water, was again raised to the required height, and
other subsequent damages were repaired as far as practible. The closing-
dams at Philbrick's Cut and Big Gap, below Elba Island, which had
practically settled, were again raised to the level of high water.
   The crest of the Fig Island Jetty was brought up to a uniform height of
about 5 feet above mean low water. Three wing-dams at the Upper
Flats, and the two at Long Island Crossing, all of which had settled at
a number of places, were repaired; 38,474 cubic yards of material were
removed from the channels at Garden Bank, " The Wrecks," "The
Obstructions," and Upper and Lower Flats, by dredging.
   The Engineer officer in charge states that other breaks have occurred
in Cross Tides Dam, by which for a length of about 300 feet the crest
has been more or less lowered, and that these damages, to a considerable
extent, are caused by fishermen and others who are interested in keep-
                        RIVER AND HARBOR                     IMPROVEMENTS.                                183
ing a passage open across the dam for their boats. The cyclone which
visited the South Atlantic coast in August, 1885, caused more or less
damage to the Fig Island Jetty, to the wing-dams at the Lower Flats and
Long Island Crossing, and to the unfinished dam at Oyster Bed Shoal.
Otherwise the works are in good condition. The river is reported to
be in excellent condition; the draught of vessels that can enter and leave
the port is increasing; in one instance last year a vessel drawing 204 feet
was brought in, which had never before been accomplished. As a matter
of fact a permanent increase of draught of from 3 to 3.1 feet has been
produced in the navigable channel within the past five or six years, as
a result of the operations carried on during that period for the improve-
ment of the river.
   In view of this fact, the Engineer officer in charge recommends that a
liberal appropriation be made by Congress for completing the work of
improvement.
   The total estimated cost of the work is $1,212,000.
   The total appropriations made since 1874 up to June 30, 1885, were
$882,000; the expenditures to June 30, 1886, were $879,056.10.
July 1, 1885, amount available--..-------..---.....--.............--------------------.............. $50,385 60
July 1, 1886, amount expeniled during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1,1885......                       ............        $47, 168 21
July 1, 1886, outstanding liabilities ..........................                              273 49
                                                                                                      47,441 70
July 1, 1886, amount available.----.............-------------........---------.............------------ 2, 943 90
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886-----------------     ...................            150,000 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887 ..................                           152, 943 90

  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project.--.--180, 000 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1888 180, 000 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867
   (See Appendix M 6.)
   7. Savannah River, Georgia.-Three appropriations, aggregating $55,-
000, have been made by Congress for improving Savannah River be-
tween the cities of Augusta and Savannah since the present plan of
improvement was adopted. On this section of the river navigation
was seriously obstructed at several places during the dry season by ex-
tensive shoals or sand-bars, with only 2 or 3 feet of water over them,
and at numerous other points by snags, floating and overhanging trees,
and piles.
   The plan of improvement contemplates the creation of a low-river chan-
nel of 5 feet depth over all shoals of less depth, and clearing the river
of other obstructions to navigation. For these purposes wing-dams
were to be built for narrowing the river where the widths are excessive;
deposits of silt to be promoted along the banks by light hurdle-works;
caving banks revetted where necessary; projecting points to be cut
away; snags and other obstructions to be removed, and dredging to
be done where necessary to assist the formation of a low-river channel.
The cost of the project is estimated at $91,000.
   No work was done during the past fiscal year, owing to want of funds.
   The following operations have thus far been carried on: A suitable
snag-boat was constructed and put to work in removing obstructions
from near Augusta down to Saxon's Landing, 142 miles from that city.
Large numbers of snags, piles, stumps, and leaning trees were taken
184          REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

out, and the wrecks of several flat-boats removed.      The channel at
Gardner's Bar and Course's Bar, just below the city, was improved by
wing-dams constructed from the bank opposite the city, and the caving
banks on the city side were strengthened. Wing-dams were also built at
Sand-Bar-Ferry Bar, 4 miles above the city, and at Blue House Bar, 2
miles lower down.
  The Engineer officer in charge was unable to report upon the present
condition of the works, as during the latter part of the fiscal year the
high stage of the river prevented an examination. It is stated, however,
that no complaints have been received relative to the navigation at the
improved reaches during low-river stages.
  Several bars remain to be improved, and numerous other obstructions
have yet to be removed.
  It is recommended by the Engineer officer in charge that any funds
that may be made available be applied to the construction of wing-dams
at points lower down the river where required, and to resume the work
of removing snags and other obstructions from the channel-way.
  The total expenditures from the beginning of operations to June 30,
1886, were $57,264.85.
July 1, 1885, amount available.------..---------------.....................------------------............     $514 17
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
   outstanding July 1, 1885 ...---..-----------.........................---...........                         279 02

July 1, 1886, amount available ................     ...... .....
                                                . .....                  .........                              235 15
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886 .....................                                    15, 000 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887 .....................                                 15, 235 15

 (Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project........     21,000 00
  Amount that can besprofitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1888 21,000 00
      harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix M 7.)
   8. Savannah River above Augusta, Georgia.-No operations were car-
ried on during the past fiscal year, as no appropriation for continuing
the work had been made, and nothing has been done since August, 1883.
   Three appropriations, aggregating $39,000, have been made by Con-
gress for improving this portion of the Savannah River, which amount
has been expended, with the exception of a small balance still on hand,
for work done in conformity to the first of two projects submitted by the
Engineer officer in charge under date of February 8, 1879, which con-
templates the improvement of the river for pole-boats only from the city
of Augusta up to Trotter's Shoals, a distance of 64 miles. The cost of
the project was estimated at $45,000. The obstruction to pole-boat nav-
igation consisted chiefly in rock ledges running across the channel,
bowlders of various sizes, and shoals of gravel. On many shoals there
is but 1 to 2 feet of water during low-river stages.
   The project is designed to create a clear channel of 30 feet width and
3 feet depth at low water.
   At numerous points the channel-way was improved, especially in the
lower reaches. From the canal lock, 7 miles above the city of Augusta,
to Barkdale Ferry, a distance of 50 miles, a channel was established
through the obstructions 20 feet wide and 24 feet deep at summer low
water. For this purpose a large quantity of ledge-rock, with some
bowlders and gravel, had to be removed and a on.siderable number of
wing-dams built,
                   RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                                   185
  The total expenditures to June 30, 1886, were $38,177.29.
July 1, 1885, amount available..    ....            .........................                          ......     $877 06
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885 .-..........-...... ...-......         -....
                                                              ........-  .                                          54 35
July 1, 1886, amount available     ................-------------------------..--........---.---------......        822 71
  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project.----......                                      6,000 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
  (See Appendix M 8.)
  9. Saint Augustine Creek (Thunderbolt River), Georgia.-No work has
been done here since September, 1880, and no appropriation is asked
for.
July 1, 1885, amount available..       ...........           ............            ......         ......      $3, 417 66
July 1, 1886, amount available.....................                             .................                3, 417 66
    (See Appendix M 9.)
    10. Romerly Marsh, Georgia.-Two appropriations aggregating $20,000
have been made by Congress for improving Romerly Marsh. The act
by which the first of these appropriations was provided directed that
the improvement be carried on " by the route designated in the survey
of the engineers as route numbered four."
    The water-route through Romerly Mars. forms part of the inland
passage between the Savannah River, Georg.- and Fernandina, Fla.
The marsh is situated between Wassaw Sound U. 'he north and Ossa-
baw Sound on the south. The route lately used was )bjectionable from
its excessive crookedness and deficiency in depth. Vessels drawing 5
feet of water could not pass through on less than half-tide.
    In his report of an examination of Romerly Marsh, the Engineer offi-
cer in charge described four ditfferent routes that might be" adopted i"
preference to the existing passage. Either one of the lines suggest(
was designed and recommended to receive a low-water depth of not I ,
than 7 feet and a bottom width of 48 feet.
    Route number 4, named in the act, is the most easterly one of ti je
examined, and nearest to the ocean. By this route Dead Man's F m-
mock Creek, which flows through the marsh and empties into Wa aw
Sound, is to be connected by a solid cut of about 1,160 yards 1 ,gth
with Wassaw Creek, which flows into Odingsell River near the point
where the latter discharges into Ossabaw Sound. The cost of estab-
lishing route number 4 was estimated at $38,720.
    This estimate has been exceeded, owing chiefly to repeated stoppage
of operations from lack of funds, which made it necessary to do part of
the work over again.
     Prior to July 1, 1885, the cut had been opened for a length of 1,720
feet, beginning at Dead Man's Hammock Creek or at the northerly end.
This cut was 40 to 50 feet wide at the bottom, and had 7 feet depth at
mean low water. The material removed amounted to 101,100 cubic
yards. The total expenditures to June 30, 1885, including the sum of
 $5,000 contributed by the Georgia and Florida Steamboat Company,
were $21,156.63.
     During the past fiscal year the cut was completed and a channel of
50 feet bottom width and 7 feet depth at low water was obtained through
the marsh and through the shallow water south of it until sufficiently
deep water in Wassaw Creek was reached. The total length of solid
marsh cut was 3,547 feet; 110,163 cubic yards of material were removed
during the year.
186         REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

  The total cost of the completed work is $46,712.57.
   As the appropriations made by Government amounted to only
$20,000, this improvement could not have been finished if funds had
not been supplied by the Inland Steamboat Company and other parties
who were interested in its speedy completion. The money thus pro-
vided was expended under the supervision of the Engineer officer in
charge, under conditions approved by the Secretary of War.
   It appears from a recent examination of the work that for all prac-
tical purposes the new route is in a condition which is in accordance
with the project.
   For reasons stated in his report the Engineer officer in charge recom-
mends that the private parties who during the past fiscal year supplied
the funds necessary for completing the work be reimbursed by Govern-
ment.
July 1, 1885, amount available . ..... ....... ................           ....... .. .   $3, 843 37
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1885 ...............--------.........-- $3, 346 70
July 1, 1886, outstanding liabilities ...---------.....---.............        100 47
                                                                                          3, 447 17

July 1, 1886, amount available ..........................................                   396 20
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886...... ...... ........                 17,475 00

Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887.--.......----...--........-        17,871 20
  Amount (estimated) required to pay for completion of existing project.                  5, 625 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
    (See Appendix M 10.)
  11. Altamaha River, Georgia.-Three appropriations, aggregating
$35,000, have thus far been made by Congress for the improvement of
Altamaha River.
  The Altamaha is the most important river lying entirely within the
State of Georgia. It is formed by the confluence of the Oconee and
Ocmulgee. Its length is 155 miles. It has a southeasterly course, and
empties into the Atlantic Ocean through Altamaha Sound below the
town of Darien. It has been badly obstructed by rock ledges, sand-
bars, and snags; and the plan of improvement provides for their re-
moval, so as to secure a navigable low-river channel 80 feet wide and
3 feet deep, at a cost roughly estimated at $60,000. The engineer offi-
cer in charge states that this estimate will be exceeded by $15,000 in
order to provide for wing-dams and training-walls, not included in the
original estimate, at some points where sand-bars exist.
   The first expenditure, prior to July 1, 1885, was incurred in paying part
of the expenses of building and equipping a suitable snag-boat; the
entire first appropriation-$5,000-was applied to that purpose Since
then this boat has removed nearly one thousand snags, logs, overhang-
ing trees, and piles. An improved channel of 100 feet width and 4 feet
depth at summer low water was opened through the rock-bars at Town
Bluff and Piney Bluff, 18 and 19J miles, respectively, below thejunction
of the Oconee and the Ocmulgee. The shallow crossing at Beard's Bluff
Bar, 63 miles below the junction, was improved by a training-wall 1,750
feet in length, with two short spurs on the channel side, built to re-
duce the excessive width of the river at this point. The caving bluffy
bank was protected by a fascine revetment. The expenditures to June
30, 1885, aggregated $32,085.34.
                           RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                 187
  All that could be done during the last fiscal year, with the small
amount of funds on hand at its beginning, consisted in completing the
work at Beard's Bluff Bar. Four spur-jetties were added to the train-
ing-wall, and the revetment on the opposite bank was finished.
  The total expenditures to June 30, 1886, were $34,458.13.
  At the close of the last fiscal year the channel was in good condition
at the reaches where improvements had been made, except that some
bowlders have been found that interfere with navigation at Town Bluff
and Piney Bluff. These will have to be removed, and other reaches
require improvement, as provided for in the existing project, before a
clear channel can be secured through the entire length of the Altamaha.
  The Engineer officer in charge names in his report a number of points
on the river where work should be done as soon as an additional appro-
priation is made, and recommends that Congress should provide funds
to complete the improvement of Altamaha River, and to commence
that of Darien Harbor and Bar.
                                                                      ......----.... $2, 914 66
July 1, 1885, amount available.--..........................------------------
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1885--------..........---...----.......---------.      $2, 332 79
July 1, 1886, outstanding liabilities ....................                        ....        40 00
                                                                                                       2, 372 79
July 1, 1886, amount available .......--------------..................-------......--......--....         541 87
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886---...-------........--.....-------                 20, 000 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887....................----20,541                          87
 (Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project........- 20, 000 00
   Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1888                          20, 000 00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix M 11.)
   12. Brunswick Harbor, Georgia.-Operationsfor improving Brunswick
Harbor, in general accordance with a project submitted by the Engineer
officer in charge on April 29, 1876, modified in his annual report, dated
July 22, 1880, have intermittently been carried on from May, 1880, to
May, 1885, by means of five successive appropriations aggregating
$70,000.
   That project comprises the construction of a jetty starting from the
northeasterly end of Buzzard Island, and located approximately parallel
to and 1,000 feet distant from the established pier-head line on the oppo-
site shore, for the purpose of contracting the water-way and concen-
trating the current upon a shoal about 1 mile below the town of Bruns-
wick. The bottom being hard and tough, expensive dredging has been
necessary.
   The object of these works was to establish and permanently main-
tain a channel not less than 15 feet deep at mean low tide over the
shoal on which heretofore the navigable low-water depth was only 9
feet. The cost of the project was estimated at $73,187. This estimate
did not include works that might eventually be needed at the upper
end of East River, a loop of the main stream on which Brunswick is
situated.
   An appropriation of $10,000 was made for this locality in 1836, and
expended in dredging on the shoal referred to.
   The Engineer officer in charge states in his annual report that the
existing project must be modified, or rather enlarged, in order perma-
nently to secure the lowering of the refractory shoal in Brunswick River
(East River) to a minimum low-water depth of 15 feet. His report
188         REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                                              U. S. ARMY.

gives the outlines of the enlarged plan, which embraces the existing
project, and provides in addition for a low dam across Turtle River, at
the upper end of Buzzard Island, and dredging in that vicinity; short
spur-jetties in the lower part of Brunswick River; raising the existing
jetty to a higher level, and additional dredging on the shoal in that
river. The cost of the enlarged plan is estimated at from $190,000 to
$200,000, inclusive of the appropriations heretofore made for Brunswick
Harbor.
   No work was done during the last fiscal year, there being no funds
available.
   The following is a summary of the work thus far accomplished. The
main line of the jetty was laid to a length of 4,199 feet, reaching the
outer 18-foot low-water curve of the main stream, or Turtle River. At
the upper end the jetty is connected with the shore of Buzzard Island by
a spur or return face 310 feet in length. This spur and the adjoining 780
feet length of jetty are formed of palmetto cribs attached to platforms
of round logs, and filled with brush and material obtained by dredging,
and topped off with riprap stone. The outward portion of the jetty, a
length of 3,419 feet, is composed of log mattresses, double-raft style,
covered with brush and riprap stone. The top of the return face has
been raised by means of log mattresses and stone, resting upon the
crib-work below, to the height of from 2 to 3 feet above low water, and
an apron of mattresses and stone protects the base of the return face
and the adjacent portion of the jetty from scour. On the main line the
ridge of stone-covering upon the crib-work is a few feet below the level of
low water; that of the mattresses further down reaches up to that level,
except at the outer end, where it is lower.
   The material removed by dredging aggregated 80,502 cubic yards;
the dredging operations were carried on upon lines about parallel to the
jetty and 720 feet from it. Three cuts were made through the shoal to a
low-water depth of 15 feet, each cut being from 4,400 to 4,800 feet in
length and from 20 to 25 feet in width. A fourth cut is about 1,500
feet long and 12 feet deep at low water.
   The channel thus obtained by dredging has shoaled more or less
during the last three years, showing that additional works are needed
to control and strengthen the ebb-currents. The jetty work is in good
order.
   The total expenditures to June 30, 1886, were $69,871.81.
   With any funds that may become available it is proposed to raise the
existing jetty to a higher level and begin the work of improvement at
the upper end of Buzzard Islad, in conformity to the enlarged project
submitted by the Engineer officer in charge.
July 1, 1885, amount available..................                     ......   ..................               $387 43
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1885 . ............                         ..........           $125 47
July 1, 1886, outstanding liabilities.............................                                  133 77
                                                                                                                259 24
                                                                                                                S

July 1, 1886, amount available.............--------------............................-                           128 19
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886...................                                        22,500 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887 ......---..........                                    22,628 19

r Amount  (estimated) required for completion of existing project........                                    97, 500 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1888                                 75, 000 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 166 and 1867.
   (See Appendix M 12.)
                 RIVER AND HARBOR. IMPROVEMENTS.                      189
   13. Entrance to Cumberland Sound, Georgia and Florida.-Four ap-
propriations, aggregating $255,000, have thus far been made by Con-
gress for the improvement of the entrance to Cumberland Sound, in
conformity to the plan described in general terms in a report of the
Engineer officer in charge, dated June 30, 1879, contained in Appendix
I 8, Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1879.
   The project consists essentially of two low jetties, composed of riprap
stone, resting on a broad foundation-mattress of logs, or logs and brush,
starting respectively from the opposite shores of the entrance and ex-
tending seaward across the bar upon lines so directed that the outer ends
will be approximately parallel to each other, and from 3,000 to 3,500 feet
apart, or such distance as may hereafter be adopted. The estimated
cost of the improvement with two long jetties is $2,071,023. They are
calculated to maintain a low-water depth across the bar of not less than
20 to 21 feet, or a high-water depth of 26 to 27 feet. Heretofore the
depth on the bar has varied from 11 to 12. feet at mean low tide, with
exceptional depths 1 foot greater.
   No work has been done on the jetties during the last fiscal year from
want of funds.
   The following is a summary of the work done to the present time:
The foundation-course of the north jetty, consisting of a log-and-brush
mattress overlaid with riprap stone, has reached a point 7,372 feet from
the shore of Cumberland Island. Its width varies from 25 to 52 feet,
and its thickness through log and brush from 19 to 22 inches. A sec-
ond course of mattresses, of similar thickness, from 20 to 25 feet width,
covered with riprap stone, and of an aggregate length of 1,490 feet,
was laid upon the foundation-course along the deeper portions of Cum-
berland Channel. Foundation-mattresses for two spurs were also laid
here on the south side of the jetty. The bottom course of the south
jetty has reached a point 7,667 feet from its shore end on Amelia Island.
From that point for a length of 4,160 feet the widths of mattresses vary
from 40 to 87 feet; further out to the seaward end the mattresses have
a uniform width of 100 feet.
   An aggregate sum of $251,301.69 had been expended upon the work
here described to June 30, 1885.
   Two surveys of the bar were made during the past fiscal year, the first
in July and August, 1885, and the second in June, 1886. It appears
that the jetty work is in good condition, except that exposed logs are
worm-eaten. The shore lines near either jetty are advancing seaward.
The local deepening where the north jetty crosses Cumberland Channel
is still increasing and seemsto call for preventive measures. The inner
18-foot low-water curve has during the last three years advanced about
1,650 feet toward the crest of the bar, extending about one-fourth of a
mile in advance of the present outer end of the south jetty. Depths
have generally increased on the bar. The Engineer officer in charge
calls attention to the fact that the northern marginal 12-foot curve of
Amelia Basin has pushed out at a certain point from 1,200 to 1,500 feet
northward, indicating that a new northward channel may break out
here that might ultimately take the place of Cumberland Channel un-
less prevented by an early extension of the north jetty. The sailing
line over the bar has of late years approached the south jetty, from
which it is now about 600 feet distant. The least available low-water
depth in the bar channel is reported to be at present 14 feet.
   The sum of $2,933.67 was expended during the last fiscal year for
making surveys and examinations, care and preservation of plant, &c.
190       REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

  The Engineer officer in charge concludes that the extension of both
jetties should be proceeded with vigorously to promote the development
of the favorable changes that have occurred on the bar. Any funds
that may be provided he recommends to expend for such extension of
the jetties, for raising them to a higher level, and for taking the neces-
sary precautionary measures where local deepening has occurred in
Cumberland Channel. The total expenditures to June 30, 1886, were
$254,235.36.
July 1, 1885, amount available........ ...............................                                         $3, 698 31
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive
  of liabilities outstanding July 1, 1885 ......----..............     $2, 566 69
July 1, 1886, outstanding liabilities...---. ...... ........--.            366 98
                                                                                                                2,933 67
July 1, 1886, amount available....... ............                ....................                            764 64
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886.................                                           112,500 00
Amonut available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887....                                ..........           113, 264 64

(Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project...... 1,693, 523 00
J Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June
  . 30, 1888..........--.......... .........--..... ...... ..................----- 500,000 00
SSubmitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix M 13.)
   14. Insidepassagebetween Fernandinaand Saint John's River, Florida.--
Nothing has been done for improving this route since the last suspen-
sion of operations, on December 1, 1880. The work has not been resumed
for the reason given by the Engineer officer in charge that there seemed
to be not only no urgent need for its continuance, but no prospect of
securing any permanent improvement from the expenditure of small ap-
propriations.
July 1, 1885, amount available .---..                 --.... ... ...---..........---..........
                                                   ....--                                                      $4, 434 45
July 1, 1886, amount available .-..        ----.       .--.--..                      .--..----.       .   .     4, 434 45
   (See Appendix M 14.)

IMPROVEM ENT OF RIVERS AND HARBORS IN THE STATE OF FLORIDA.

  Officers in charge, Capt. William T. Rossell, Corps of Engineers, to
April 26, 1886, since which date Lieut. William M. Black, Corps of En-
gineers.
  1. Saint John's River, Florida.-Operationsfor the improvement of the
channel over the bar at the mouth of this river were carried on from
July 1 to September 23, 1885, in conformity with the plan submitted by
the Engineer officer in charge June 30, 1879.
  The plan consists essentially in the construction of two low jetties
starting, respectively, from the opposite shores of the entrance and so
directed that the outer ends on the bar will be approximately parallel
and 1,600 or 1,800 feet apart. By means of these works it is expected
to maintain a practicable low-river depth of 15 feet upon the bar, where
previously the navigable low-water depth had not usually exceeded 6 to
7 feet.
   Prior to July 1, 1885, the .south jetty had a total length of 6,715.4
feet. It consisted for the greater part of this length of but one course
of mattresses, covered with from 12 to 15 inches of stone. Along one
portion of the jetty seven additional courses of mattresses had to be
added. To deflect the rapid current formed along the jetty eight low
                            RIVER         AND HARBOR                  IMPROVEMENTS.                               191
spur jetties of two courses of mattresses covered with sone were con-
structed, four on each side of the main jetty and opposite to each other.
The jetty as first constructed proved too narrow and had to be widened.
Accordingly, in all of the later foundation mattresses placed the width
was increased to from 110 to 120 feet.
   The north jetty had a total length of 2,617.5 feet, and was composed
of a single course of mattresses, covered with from 9 inches to 12 inches
of stone.
   On July 1, 1885, a 6-foot channel 400 feet wide had formed across the
bar between the ends of the jetties.
   During the past fiscal year work was continued until September 23;
28.93 cubic yards of stone were placed on the south jetty.
   The north jetty was extended.
   At the close of the fiscal year 1885-'86, the total length of the south
jetty was 6,715.4 feet. The north jetty had a total length of 4,330.7 feet.
   The total appropriations to date amount to $525,000; the total expend-
itures to $523,065.72.
   A channel 400 feet wide, 8 feet deep, with a mid-channel depth of 8.8
feet at mean low water, has opened across the bar between the jetties.
This has been the ship entrance since March, 1886.
   With the balance available and the appropriation asked for it is pro-
posed to continue operations under the approved project.
July 1, 1885, amount available                           ......--- ....---......
                                                    ......--                            .....--.......... $30, 925 95
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1885..---..---------- ---.       $28, 339 33
July 1, 1886, outstanding liabilities........     .............. '      652 34
                                                                                                             28, 991 67

July 1, 1886, amount available---- ------..........................................-----------------------     1,934 28
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886... ...............                                        150,000 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887....................                                    151,934 28

   Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project-------...   631,409 00
   Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1888 300,000 00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
     harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix N 1.
   2. Upper Saint John's River, Florida.-By the river and harbor act of
July 5, 1884, the sum of $5,000 was appropriated for improving the Upper
Saint John's River, Florida, this being the first appropriation made for
this work.
   The part of the Saint John's River referred to in the act extends from
Lake Monroe to the head of Lake George, a distance of 45 miles. The
stream has sufficient depth for the class of vessels adapted to navigate
the Upper Saint John's, but is very crooked.
  The Engineer officer then in charge-October 5, 1883-recommended
to confine the work of improvement to the most prominent bends, es-
tablishing a straighter channel by suitable cut-offs, to be made 6 feet
deep at low-river stage, and 100 feet wide at the bottom. Two estimates
were submitted, one for straight cut-offs, at a cost of $43,000, and one
for curved cut-offs, at a cost of $38,800.
  The work consists chiefly in dredging, but some light closure dams
and some grubbing will also be required.
  The work was advertised, but no bids were received, on account of
the small sum appropriated, and operations have been deferred until
further appropriations are made.
192         REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

  The balance available and the appropriation asked for are to be used
in accordance with the approved project.
July 1, 1885, amount available ......------.....-- -----..................     ......           $4, 979 21
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885--............. .-..................         ....... ......                4 05
                              .....------......----. --........---....----....--.....--.
July 1, 1886, amount available------                                                             4,975 16

IAmount  (estimated) required for completion of existing project.---..-----. 3:3, 800 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1888 10, 000 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
  (See Appendix N 2.)
  3. Volusia Bar, Florida.-Operationshave been carried on here at in-
tervals since December, 1880, in conformity to the project submitted
July 16, 1879, and revised in 1882 and 1883.
  The plan of improvement comprises the construction of two converg-
ing brush-and-stone jetties, with a view to establishing and maintain-
ing a channel 6 feet deep over this bar, where the minimum low-water
depth had been from 31 to 4 feet. The estimated cost of the revised
project was $25,000.
  The west jetty now is 2,206 feet long. It is generally formed of a
single course of brush mattresses from 6 to 12 feet wide covered with
broken stone. At its outer end there is a second course 6 feet wide and
159 feet long.
  The east jetty ib 3,459 feet long. Its construction is similar to that
of the west jetty. The second course of mattress at its outer end is 247
feet long. At their shore ends the jetties are 2,400 feet apart. On the
bar the jetties are 240 feet apart, and parallel. Clusters of piles se-
curely fastened with chains were driven in two rows, 100 feet apart,
parallel to the west jetty.
  The appropriations for this improvement have aggregated $17,500.
The total expenditures to June 30, 1885, were $17,337.51, and have re-
sulted in forming and maintaining a channel between the jetties having
a least depth of 54 feet and a width of about 70 feet.
  No operations were carried on here during the past fiscal year, owing
to a lack of funds. An examination made in June, 1886, showed the
channel as above; 121 out of the 158 piles driven are still standing.
  The balance available is to be used in accordance with the project.
                                       ......---.... -
July 1, 1885, amount available.....--- --                    -.... -
                                                        ..----.           ...--..--....---        $162 49
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1885...............             ....                $2 75
July 1, 1886, outstanding liabilities.... .............         .... ....             12 00
                                                                                                    14 75

July 1, 1886, amount available........ ........ .... ............ .... ....                        147 74
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886...................                            7,500 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887...                        .............    7, 647   74
  (See Appendix N 3.)
  4. Tampa Bay, Florida.--Theharbor of Tampa, at the head of this bay,
was separated from deep water by a flat 2 miles wide. Through this
was a narrow channel with an available depth of about 5 feet, formed
by the waters of the HIillsborough River.
  The present project was adopted in 1880, and has for its object the
formation of a 9-foot channel from the 9-foot curve in the bay to the
wharves of Tampa, in Hillsborough River, 150 feet wide through the
bay and 200 feet wide in the river, atan estimated cost of $97,000.
                           RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                                    193
   Up to June 30, 1885, $47,801.50 had been expended, resulting in a
somewhat narrow 9-foot channel from the mouth of the river to deep
water in the bay. This was obstructed by several shoals, having only
71 feet of water.
   Work was continued from the beginning of the fiscal year to August
15, under a contract for dredging and rock excavation, and was then
stopped by the near exhaustion of the appropriation.         When work
ceased there was a 9-foot channel 4,793 feet long and from 45 to 150
feet wide from deep water in the river toward the bay. An examina-
tion made in May, 1886, showed its center line but little changed.
   To complete the present project, the original estimate must be in-
creased on account of extra labor due to the deterioration of the dredged
cut in the intervals between appropriations. Without auxiliary works
there is but little hope of permanency in the dredged channel.
July 1, 1885, amount available ....                ....----..........--........--                                 ----- $12, 198 50
                                                                                                        ......----.....
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
                                                 -         ---------
  outstanding July 1, 1885.....-------------.........................................                                    11,368 04

July 1, 1886, amount available ......-- ........................- ....--...                                                  830 46
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886...............-....                                                   10, 000 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887 ...................                                                10, 830 46

( Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project ........                                                63, 000 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1888                                             25,000 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
. harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix N 4.)
   5. Apalachicola Bay, Florida.-Thepresent project for this improve-
ment was adopted in 1880, the object being to afford a channel of en-
trance from Apalachicola Bay into Apalachicola River up to the
wharves of the city of Apalachicola, 100 feet wide and 11 feet deep at
mean low water. Before the improvement was begun the channel had
an available depth of 3- feet.
   The amount expended to June 30, 1885, is $54,284.37, and has re-
sulted in giving a channel of 60 feet in width and 6.5 feet depth through
the bar.
   The results have not been satisfactory. In previous reports doubts
have been expressed as to the permanency of the dredged channel un-
less it could be fully cut through at one time. The limited appropria-
tions hereto fore made have not permitted this to be done. It is believed
that the desired channel cannot be maintained without the aid of aux-
iliary works.
   On account of the continued shoaling of the dredged channel the es-
timate for the original project must be increased by $23,000.
   No appropriation having been made, and the balance available hav-
ing been small, no work was done during the past fiscal year.
   The balance available and appropriation asked for are to be expended
in accordance with the approved project.
July 1, 1885, amount available ...-.................                                       .......----......               $715 63
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
   outstanding July 1, 1885...--.                . .         .        .             .. .       ..     .. ......               18 90
July 1, 1886, amount available.....................----                         -           .................               696 73
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886 ...................                                                   12, 000 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887--...                                                  ..........   12, 696 73
           13 v
194       REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

(Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project....-------.... $56, 696 73
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1888 25, 000 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
  harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
  (See Appendix N 5.)
  6. Suwanee River, Florida.-Thepresent project for the improvement
of this river was adopted in 1880. Its object is to make a channel 150
feet wide and 5 feet deep at mean low water from the Gulf through the
east and west passes into the river and as far up as Roland's Bluff.
From there to Ellaville the channel is to be 60 feet wide and 4 feet
deep.. Before the improvement there was a depth of 3 feet on the bar
and of 1 feet in the river above Roland's Bluff. Above its mouth the
river is much obstructed with snags and overhanging trees.
   The amount expended up to June 30, 1885, is $15,683.76, and has
given a dredged channel 4,429 feet long, 60 feet wide, and 5 feet deep
from the river partly across the bar at the east pass.
   During the past fiscal year operations were continued there. Four
thousand five hundred and eighty-two cubic yards of material were
dredged, increasing the length of channel to 5,835 feet. To complete
this channel an additional distance of 9,765 feet must be dredged, where
there is an average depth of 3) feet.
  The balance available and the appropriation asked for will be ap-
plied to continuing work under the present project.
                                                                          $2, 316 24
July 1, 1885, amount available------...... ......-....--............-----------..-------.
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885.......... ..................---                   2,256 24
                                                               ................----
July 1, 1886, amount available ..................-............ ...... ......       60 00
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886...................           5,000 DO
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30. 1887 ....      ...........     5,060 00
SAmount  (estimated) required for completion of existing project ........     32,158 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1888   10, 000 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
  Sharbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
  (See Appendix N 6.)
   7. Key West Harbor, Florida.-The present project for the improve-
ment of this harbor was adopted in 1882, the object being to afford a
channel of entrance from the Gulf of Mexico into the northwest chan-
nel to Key West, so as to give a depth of 17 feet at mean low water.
   The principal object to be gained by this improvement is in the great
saving in distance for all vessels plying between Key West and the
Gulf ports.
   The amount expended to June 30, 1885, is $25,000, and has resulted
in cutting a channel entirely through the bar 60 feet in width at the
bottom and 65 feet at the top, with a depth of 15 feet at mean low
water.
   From the soundings taken on the mail steamer using this channel it
is believed that this cut has filled and that there now exists a channel-
way with only an available depth of 11 feet at mean low water.
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886 ...................         $2,500 00

  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix N 7.)
                   RIVER AND       HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                          195
   8. Pease Creek, Florida.-The project for the improvement of this
stream, adopted in 1881, is to improve it for high-water navigation by
the removal of snags, overhanging trees, and loose rocks from the
channel from its mouth up to Fort Meade.
   The amount expended to June 30, 1885, is $10,453.18, and has resulted
in the improvement of about 64 .miles of the river from its mouth up-
stream.
   During the past fiscal year nothing has been done except caring for
the public property, the small balance available rendering any work im-
possible.
   Before the improvement the stream was of generally sufficient width
and depth, but was much obstructed.
   The balance available is to be applied to the care and preservation
of the public property, and to the continuation of the work under the
approved project.
July 1, 1885, amount available ....----..........                   .....--.$546 82
                                                       --.........-..--
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1885_. ..-............      ..   $32 75
July 1, 1886, outstanding liabilities............    ....... .....  30 00
                                                                    ---       62 75
July 1, 1886, amount available.............-----------------.
                                                      .--...--..........----.   484 07
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886.....................       5,000 00
                                                                      5, 484 07
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887....----..-----.----............
  (See Appendix N 8.)
  9. Harbor at Cedar Keys, Florida.-The present project for the im-
provement of this harbor was adopted in 1884. It consists in cutting
a channel, by dredging and rock excavation, 200 feet wide and 104 feet
deep at mean low water, through the Middle Ground. By act approved
July 5, 1884, an appropriation of $5,000 was made to carry on this work,
the only appropriation under this project.
  Under a former project a cut 114 feet deep was made through the
Middle Ground. This is gradually shoaling.
  No work was done on the present project prior to June 30, 1885.
Since then dredging and rock excavation were carried on in the shoal
near Buoy No. 12; 370 cubic yards of sand and 615 cubic yards of rock
were removed, making a channel 11 feet deep and from 30 to 60 feet
wide almost through the shoal when the appropriation was exhausted.
This cut has retained its depth.
  The appropriation asked for is to be used in accordance with the
present project.
July 1, 1885, amount available ........---------------------...........-----------
                                                                 $4, 802 55
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
outstanding July 1, 1885-------....-......-......
                                    ---.......... ....................       4, 802 55
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886 ..................        7, 000 00


  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
  (See Appendix N 9.)
  10. Manatee River, Florida.--Thepresent project for the improvement
of this river was adopted in 1882, the object being to afford a channel
of entrance from Tampa Bay into Manatee River, so as to give a depth
of 13 feet at mean low water from Tampa Bay up the river to Shaw's
196        REPORT OF TIE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

and McNiel's points. The least depth on the bar at the river before
the improvement was 8 feet at mean low water, not sufficient for the
class of vessels engaged in the commerce between the river and outside
 )ports.
   The amount expended to June 30, 1885, is $12,000, and has re-
sulted in securing a channel 2,150 feet in length, 1,750 feet of which has
a depth of 12 feet and a width of 60 feet, and 400 feet has a depth of
11) feet and width of 35 feet through the bar at the entrance of the
river from Tampa Bay.
   There being no funds available, no work has been done during the
past fiscal year.
   The appropriation asked for is to be applied to continuing the im-
provement in accordance with the project, extending, widening, and
deepening the cut by dredging.
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886...................                     $8, 000 00
  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project........                  50, 000 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1888                8,000 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1886 and 1867.
   (See Appendix N 10.)
   11. Caloosahatchie River, Florida.-The present project for the im-
provement of this river was adopted in 1882, the object being to so
improve the river from the bar at the mouth up to Fort Meyers as to
accommodate vessels of 6 feet draught.
   The amount expended up to June 30, 1885,is $5,544.71, and has re-
sulted in improving the bar at the mouth of the river, giving a channel
depth of 9 feet at mean low water, where there was only 5J feet before.
   During the past fiscal year dredging was continued in the vicinity of
Jew Fish Bayou. At the close of operations there was a clear channel
of the required width and depth from the mouth to Fort Meyers.
  No further appropriation is needed. The balance available will be
used in maintaining and caring for the work.
July 1, 1885, amount available ....---....-----...--        ..----- ....--..........
                                                                     --......             $4, 455 29
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885--..........--------..----..........---....................      3,911 88

July 1, 1886, amount available .............. ....---
                                                  ---- ---- --....--....   ....... ---.      543 41
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886 - .....                  ...........   4,000 CO

Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887 ...................                  4,543 41
   (See Appendix N 11.)
  12. Appalachicola River, Florida.--The project for the improvement
of this river was adopted in 1874, the object being to afford a channel
of 6 feet depth and 100 feet navigable width its whole length, avoiding
the worst portions by utilizing Styx River and Moccasin Slough. The
channel at that time had sufficient depth and generally sufficient width,
but was obstructed by snags and overhanging trees, but the portion
through Moccasin Slough was narrow, crooked, and difficult.
  The amount expended to June 30, 1886, is $39,383.22, and has re-
sulted in the complete execution of the project, and, in addition, the
opening of Chipola Cut-off to White's Bluff, a distance of 9 miles, the
widening of the canal at Moccasin Slough, and the removal from the
river of the yearly accumulation of snags, logs, and sunken timber.
  During the past fiscal year operations were limited to clearing about
one mile of the channel above Moccasin Slough.
                      RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                          197
  The amount available and the appropriation asked for are to be ap-
plied to maintaining the improvement as completed.
July 1, 1885, amount available.....-----...... ...... ..........----....----......---....
                                                                                      --- $2, 255 49
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1885. - .......-------..------.....--...---. $2, 072 81
July 1, 1886, outstanding liabilities..- ---............ .......                    65 90
                                                                                          2,138 71

July 1, 1886, amount available...------ ................  ..-----............               116 78
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886--..........-----..-----.........       1,000 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887....................                 1,116   78
  SAmount   (estimated) required for preservation of improvement annually.
  Amount that can be profitably expended i n fiscal year endingJune 30,1888
                                                                                          2,000 00
                                                                                          2,000 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
     harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix N 12.)
  13. Withlacoochee River, Florida.-Theproject for this improvement,
adopted in 1881, is to improve the river by the removal of snags, loose
rocks, and overhanging trees, and by deepening a bar at the mouth of
the river and some of the worst shoals, so as to enable boats drawing
two feet of water to navigate the river during about half the year.
  The amount expended to June 30,1885, is $10,071.20, and has resulted
in improving the river from its mouth to Lake Panasofkee. In many
places, however, along the route the width and depth are insufficient (be-
ing 20 feet and 2 feet respectively) and must be increased.
  No work was done during the past fiscal year beyond caring for the
public property.
  The balance available and the appropriation asked for are to be ex-
pended in accordance with the project.
July 1, 1885, amount available-----....   ---.................. .................          $428 80
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885---                                  ........---............
                            ....-------......---.. -....--......--                          272 00
July 1, 1886, amount available........................................._ -----.              156 80
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886.....................                   3, COO 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887....................-                3, 156 80

  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project-.....       10,400 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1888 10,400 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix N 13.)
   14. Removing sunken vessels or craft obstructing or endangering naviga-
tion.- Wreck of the steamer Dictator.--A contract, approved December
8, 1885, was made for the removal of this wreck from the harbor at
Tampa, Fla. After some work had been done the contractors disagreed
and the contract had to be annulled. Proposals for its removal were
again asked for, and a contract is now being made with the lowest
bidders.
   Removal of sunken scow from harborat Tampa, Florida.-Publicnotice,
according to law, was given to persons interested in this boat. No an-
swer having been received, a contract for its removal was duly entered
into. The work was reported finished on May 17, 1886.
   (See Appendix N 14.)
198       REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

IMPROVEMENT OF CERTAIN RIVERS IN THE STATES OF GEORGIA,
  FLORIDA, AND ALABAMIA---IPROVEMENT OF THE HARBOR OF PEN-
  SACOLA.

   Officer in charge, Capt. R. L. Hoxie, Corps of Engineers.
   1. Ocnulgee iver, Georgia.-The present plan of improvementis based
upon an examination made in 1875, when the obstructions were found
to be snags, sand and gravel bars, rock reefs, overhanging trees, and
submerged rafts, in a shifting and tortuous channel, with a varying
depth of from 22 inches to 4 feet at low water. The project for the
improvement of the river contemplates the removal of these obstruc-
tions.
   The expenditure up to June 30, 1886, of $57,000 has resulted in se-
curing a good navigable channel at low water between Hawkinsville
and the junction of the Oconee, while many of the most serious obstruc-
tions have been removed.
   During the past fiscal year very little work could be done with the
small amount of money available. A number of obstructions were re-
moved from the channel, and at the close of the season it was found
that the working plant was worn out. It was condemned and sold at
public action.
   The appropriation available and that herein asked for can be profita-
bly expended in continuing the removal of obstructions from the river
channel.
July 1, 1885, amount available ....---.................................... $2,376 61
July. 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885--------......---......-------......--- ......---......--------
                                                                   -----                        2, 376 61
                                                                                 ......---......-------....
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886...................                           7,500 00

IAmount     (estimated) required for completion of existing project.......
  Amount that canbe profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1888
                                                                                         48, 000 00
                                                                                         15, 000 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix O 1.)
   2. Oconee River, Georgia.-Thisriver rises in Northeast Georgia, flows
past Milledgeville and Dublin, and joins the Ocmulgee in the southern
part of the State, forming the Altamaha.' The State of Georgia has ex-
pended about $35,000 for its improvement. The first examination made
by authority of the United States was in 1874, and a plan of improve-
ment was subsequently adopted which contemplated the removal of ob-
structions from the channel, and cutting through rock-reefs where
necessary, in order to secure a depth of about 3 feet at low water from
the mouth of the river to Milledgeville, Ga. The result of the work
done up to June 30, 1886, has been to enable steamboats navigating this
river to run on a stage of water 4 feet lower than that at which naviga-
tion was possible before improvement. The amount expended up to
June 30, 1886, is $23,499.22.
   During the past fiscal year no work was done owing to the exhaustion
of the appropriation for this improvement. At the close of the season it
was found that the working plant was completely worn out; it was
therefore condemned and sold at public auction.
   The appropriation available, and that herein asked for can be profit-
ably expended in continuing the removal of obstructions from the river
channel.
                           RIVER AND HARBOR                              IMPROVEMENTS.                                                 199
July 1, 1885, amount available ....                            ..--.........--......---.............. --                            $352 22
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885----------... ------.................. ----..---..--------...... -----...-.. ----                          351 44

                                                                ------..----..--.... ---...-----....
July 1, 1886, amount available ....----....----....------....--.....                                                                     78
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886 ................                                                                9,000 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887 ......-----------......---........                                  -----     , 000 78


  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1888                                                       17, 500 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix O 2.)
   3. Flint River, Georgia.-The present project for the improvement of
this river was adopted in 1873, and modified in 1880, the object of the
original project being to afford a channel 100 feet wide and 3 feet deep
at ordinary low water from its mouth up to Albany, Ga., and the modi-
fication, to improve for high-water navigation that portion of the river
between Albany and Montezuma, about 100 miles above. The channel
before the improvement was commenced was only navigable at low
water from its mouth up to Bainbridge, and even that portion was nar-
row, crooked, and dangerous. The expenditure up to June 30, 1886, of
$94,919.87, has resulted in obtaining a completed high-water channel
from its mouth up to Albany; a completed low-water channel of the
projected depth from its mouth up to Tea Cup Shoal, about 19 miles
below Albany, also a partially completed high-water channel over that
portion of the river between Albany and Montezuma.
   During the past fiscal year, a small hand-power snag-boat was kept
at work between Montezuma and Warwick removing logs and cutting
overhanging trees; and a number of drilling-scows on the reefs below
Albany were engaged in effecting the removal of 5,477 cubic yards of
rock and 440 snags and overhanging trees.
   The amount available and the appropriation asked for are to be ap-
plied to continuing the removal of obstructions from the channel of the
river.
July 1, 1885, amount available----.... .....----
                                            ---                        . ___ .........--   -.... $14, 449 27
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1885......................... $12, 339 38
July 1, 1886, outstanding liabilities ......----------........------------..----....     163 00
                                                                                                  12, 502 38
July 1, 1886, amount available             --------.........---..----------------------......................-----...              1,946 89
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886                                   ---------.......----..-----.......           20,000 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887........---------..--...--..-------                                          21,946 89
TAmount (estimated) required for completion of existing project --------                                                         83, 000 00
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1888                                                        40, 000 00
SSubmitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix O 3.)
   4. Oostenaula and Coosawatlee rivers, Georgia.-Thesestreams are trib-
utaries of the Coosa in Northwestern Georgia. Examinations were made
in 1872 and 1874, and the improvements then projected have been prac-
tically finished. No work has been done since August, 18S1. The ex-
penditure up to June 30, 1886, of $24,858.14 has resulted in removing
th) most dangerous channel obstructions and in reducing the gravel
200         REPORT OF THE CIIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. AlMkV.

bars. Good channels were obtained for about nine months in the year,
that on the Oostenaula having a depth of 3 feet, and on the Coosawattee
a depth of 2 feet of water. No commercial necessity exists for any fur-
ther appropriations for these rivers at present.
July 1, 1885, amount available.................. ............                         ............       $, 163 71
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
    liabilities outstanding July 1. 1885..............                  .          ..            $20 00
July 1, 1886, outstanding liabilities ........................--------------------------..         21 85
                                                                                                          41 85

July 1, 1886, amount available ..........................................                             1,121 66
   (See Appendix O 4.)
  5. Coosa River, Georgia and Alabama.---A plan was adopted in 1875
to provide a channel, not less than 80 feet wide and 3 feet deep at low
water, between Rome and Greensport, and the improvement of the
shoals and reefs below Greensport by channel excavation and locks and
dams.
  The expenditure up to June 30, 1886, of $417,896.06 has resulted in
securing a fair navigable channel from Rome to Greensport.
  During the past fiscal year, with the limited appropriation available,
the work of quarrying and dressing stone for the locks and dams at
Ten Island Shoals was continued.
  The funds available and the appropriation asked for can be profitably
expended in continuing the construction of locks and dams below Greens-
port and the removal of obstructions from the river channel.
July 1, 1885, amount available ...................                            -
                                                                 -.................. $21,862 12
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1885 ........................       $21, 058 18
July 1, 1886, outstanding liabilities ..........................         1,254 41
                                                                                                     22, 312 59

Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886 ...................                               45,000 00

  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project... .        96, 968 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1888- 97,000 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix O 5.)
  6. Chattahoochee River, Georgia and Alabama.-The present plan of
improvement (adopted in 1873) contemplates a low-water channel, 4
feet in depth and 100 feet in width, from Columbus, Ga., to Chatta-
hoochee, Fla., a distance of 223 miles, by the removal of snags and
other obstructions from the channel, overhanging trees from the banks;
by cutting a channel through the rock shoals, and deepening sand-bars
by scour.
   The expenditure up to the present time of $188,857.40 has resulted
in securing a fair, navigable channel between Chattahoochee and Eu-
faula at all seasons of the year, and between Eufaula and Columbus at
all times except during the prevalence of extreme low water.
   During the past fiscal year the principal work done has been the ex-
cavation of a channel through a portion of Uchee Shoals, removing
4,473 cubic yards of rock. A new steam snag-boat has been completed
and equipped for work on this river.
   The amount available and the appropriation asked for are to be ap-
plied to continuing the removal of obstructions from the river channel.
                        RIVER AND           HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                     201
July 1, 188i5, amount available .........................................                        $30,755 65
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1885 ---------------------........................ $16, 594 08
July 1, 1886, outstanding liabilities ...              ..... ..............            5, 095 87
                                                                                                  21,689 95
July 1, 1886, amount available............ ........................ ....                        9, 065 70
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886...................                          20,000 00
Amount avilable for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887....................                       29, 065 70

 (Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project ....... 162,228 69
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal yearending June 30, 1888 40, 000 00
5 Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
   Sharboracts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix O 6.)
   7. Alabama River, Alabama.-The plan of improvement for the Ala-
bama River, adopted in 1876, contemplates a channel, 200 feet in width
and 4 feet in depth at low water, from its mouth, 50 miles above Mobile,
Ala., to Wetumpka, Ala., a distance of 323 miles. Before the improve-
ment was commenced the channel had a least depth of about 2 feet on
some of the shoals, and was badly obstructed by snags and overhang-,
ing trees.
   The expenditure up to June 30, 1886, of $129,714.12 has resulted in
rendering that part of the river below Montgomery easy of navigation
during ordinary low water.
   During the past fiscal year the snag-boat belonging to this improve-
ment was kept at work, while the appropriation held out, in removing
snags and other obstructions from the channel, and at one point on the
.river works of contraction were put in for deepening the channel. The
amount available and the appropriation asked for are to be applied to
continuing the work of improvement in accordance with the adopted
plan, and maintaining the work already done.
July 1, 1885, amount available .......---_---         ____ .     ........ ....------ $6, 003 76
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1885......................... $5, 717 88
July 1, 1886, outstanding liabilities ..........................            65 75
                                                                                      5,783 63
July 1, 1886, amount available .---.......----..----...........................                   220 13
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886............ ........                       15, 000 00

Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887.......-- --..........-----.              15,220 13
(Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project........     84,741 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1888 40,000 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix O 7.)
  8. Tallapoosa River, Alabama.-The plan of improvement adopted
pursuant to an examination and partial survey of this river, made by
an act of Congress approved June 14, 1880, contemplates obtaining a
navigable channel from the mouth of the river to the foot of Tallas-
see Reefs, 2 miles below the town of Tallassee, a distance of 48 miles,
with a least depth of 3 feet and width of 60 feet at low water. This is
to be accomplished by the removal of snags, logs, &c., from the chan-
nel ; cutting overhanging trees from the banks; cutting the prescribed
channel through the rock-reefs, and the removal of bars by works of
contraction.
202       REPORT        OF THE CHIEF              OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

   The expenditure up to June 30, 1886, of $23,441.46 has resulted in
the partial improvement of the channel in the lower portion of this
river, but the work has not progressed sufficiently to affect navigation.
   During the past fiscal year about 12 miles of this river was cleared
of snags, logs, and overhanging trees.
   The amount available and the appropriation asked for are to be ap-
plied to continuing the work of improvement of the river in accordance
with the approved plan ; removing obstructions from the channel, blast-
ing through rock-reefs, and deepening the channel over movable bars
by works of contraction.
July 1, 1885, amount available ........................................                           $7, 098 80
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive
  of liabilities outstanding July 1, 1885.......................                     $5, 522 26
July 1, 1886, outstanding liabilities.................-------------........               45 00
                                                                                                   5, 567 26

July 1, 1886, amount available-..........................................                          1,531 54
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886...................                              7, 500 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887........ ............                         9, 031 54
SAmount (estimated) required for continuing existing project .. ..........
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1888
                                                                                                  15, 000 00
                                                                                                  15, 000 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix O 8).
   9. CahabaRiver, Alabama.-The plan of improvement adopted in 1883
contemplates a channel 60 feet in width and 3 feet in depth at low water
from its mouth to the town of Centreville, a distance of 88 miles, by
the removal of all obstructions from the channel, cutting through rock
reefs, scouring bars, and cutting overhanging trees.
   The expenditure up to June 30,1886, of $28,989.79, has resulted in the
partial improvement of the river from its mouth to Centreville, adapting
it to high-water navigation.   This is within a distance of 21 miles of
Cane Creek, which is near the Cahaba coal fields. For this section of
the river, lock and dam navigation is proposed.
  During the past fiscal year about 19± miles of the river was cleared
of snags, logs, and overhanging trees.
   The funds available and the appropriation asked for are to be applied
to continuing the work of improvement, in accordance with the ap-
proved plan; removing obstructions from the channel, blasting through
rock-reefs, and deepening the channel over movable bars by works of
contraction.
July 1, 1885, amount available ....................._$5,   ...................                       197 97
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1885 ...-...........   ....          .... $4, 187 76
July 1, 1886, outstanding liabilities...... ....................                 49 50
                                                                                                   4,237 26

July 1, 1886, amount available.-_- ....         ..................................                   960 71
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886 ...................                             7, 500 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887 .--.....-- ..-......                         8,460 71
  Amount (estimated) required for conmpletion of existing project------- 157,500 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1888 30, 000 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix O 9.)
                          RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                 203
   10. Conecuh-Escarbia River, Florida and Alabama.-The plan of
improvement for this river, adopted pursuant to partial examinations
and surveys made in 1878-'79, contemplates the removal of snags and
sunken logs and other obstructions from the channel, closing cut-offs,
and cutting through rock-shoals from the mouth of the river, in Pensa-
cola Bay, to Indian Creek, a distance of 273 miles, for the purpose of
facilitating the movement of logs and rafts down the river, affording at
the same time facilities for steamboat navigation.
   The expenditure up to June 30, 1886, of $38,953.64, has resulted in
dredging a channel through the bar at the mouth of the river, and in
the removal of obstructions to navigation, so that at the present time
the river is navigable at ordinary stages for steamboats drawing 5J
feet of water from Ferry Pass to Skinner's Landing, a distance of 17
miles, and for boats drawing 3 feet to the Alabama State line.
  During the past fiscal year about 11,000 logs, snags, and overhang-
ing trees were removed from this river, together with a small amount
of rock from the channel.
  The amount available and the appropriation asked for are to be ap-
plied to the continuation of the work of river improvement in accord-
ance with the approved plan; removing obstructions from the channel,
blasting through rock-reefs, and deepening the channel over movable
bars by works of contraction.
July 1, 1885, amount available ...... ...... ...... ..........                --....      .......   $9, 296 00
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1885..----. --......---......--------..              $8,195 87
July 1, 1886, outstanding liabilities----.---..----..........--------------........        34 50
                                                                                                     8,230 37

July 1, 1886, amount available---....-----...---..--......----............. ....--....               1,065 85
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886..--..-...........                                12, 000 00

Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887 ...................                           13, 065 85

SAmount (estimated)                                                          -
                               required for completion of existing project ........                 35, 376 00
    Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal yearending June 30, 1888 20, 000 00
    Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
L    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
    (See Appendix O 10.)
   11. Choctawhatchee River, Florida and Alabama.-The present plan of
improvement was adopted in 1872 and modified in 1880, pursuant to
an examination made under the act of March 3, 1879, and contemplates
the improvement of the river from its mouth to Newton, a distance of
252 miles, so as to obtain a low-water navigable channel.
   The expenditure up to June 30, 1886, of $71,645.95 has resulted in
giving 41 feet of water in the channel, except during low water, as far
as Jones' old ferry, 27 miles above Geneva, and 2 feet of water in the
channel as far as Pates Creek at a medium stage of water. During high
water, 5 feet can be carried to this point.
   During the past fiscal year, 8,787 snags, logs, and overhanging trees
were removed from the river.
   The funds remaining on hand and the appropriation asked for are to
be applied to the further improvement of the river in accordance with
the approved plan; removing obstructions from the channel, blasting
through rock-reefs, and deepening the channel over movable bars by
works of contraction.
204        REPORT        OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

July 1, 1885, amount available .........................................                      $10, 094 45
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1885-- -.-- ..............             ..    $9, 740 40
July 1, 1886, outstanding liabilities--..........................                   45 00
                                                                                                9,785 40

July 1, 1886, amount available .............. .. .........-.............                           309 05
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886..-.......... ...--.                         15, 000 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887...................                       15, 309 05

  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project--.......35,832 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1888                   20, 000 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix O 11.)
  12. Lagrange Bayou, Florida.-Theplan of improvement adopted was
made pursuant to an examination of this bayou in 1881, under an act
of Congress approved March 3, 1881, and contemplates the deepening
of the channel through the bayou so as to admit the passage of vessels
drawing 4- feet at mean low water, the work to be done by dredging.
  Up to June 30, 1886, there has been expended on this work the sum
of $2,000, allotted from the appropriation of $20,000 made by an act
approved August 2, 1882, for the improvement of the Choctawhatchee
River, Florida, the two improvements being closely related. The result
has been to secure a channel 5 feet in depth at mean low water.
  The appropriation asked for is to be applied to the widening of the
channel and removing the remaining obstructions.
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886..                   ..................      $2, 000 00

SAmount    (estimated) required for completion of existing project........
                                                                     -
  Amountthat can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,                 1888
                                                                                                3,000 00
                                                                                                3,000 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and"
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix O 12.)
  13. Harbor at Pensacola, Florida.-Theplan of improvement adopted
in 1881 contemplates dredging a channel 300 feet wide and 24 feet deep
at mean low water across the inner bar, for the temporary relief of the
navigation of this harbor, and the preservation of the site of old Fort
McRee by the construction of suitable works of shore protection, with
a view to retaining this position for defensive purposes, and preventing
further changes in the tidal currents through the continued abrasion of
the shore at this point.
  The expenditure up to June 30, 1886, of $192,223.99 resulted in ob-
taining a channel 120 feet in width and 24 feet in depth at mean low
water across the shoal inside the bar, and in stopping the abrasion of
the shore line at Fort McRee; but this channel was not maintained by
the tidal currents, and on June 30, 1886, was 23 feet in depth at mean
low water, a gain of 3.6 feet over the depth existing when the work was
commenced.
  An annual outlay will be necessary to maintain this dredged channel
until the permanent improvement of this harbor shall have been au-
thorized by Congress. The works of shore protection at the site of Fort
McRee have been successful in stopping abrasion of the beach, advanc-
ing it 250 feet on the south side of the south jetty at this point, and ad-
vancing the 12, 18, and 24 foot curves of the western channel slopes
fronting the shore-line at the same place.
                           RIVER AND HARBOR                        IMPROVEMENTS.                                   205
  During the past fiscal year works of shore protection at the site of
Fort McRee were maintained by frequent repairs, and about 55,000
cubic yards of sand was dredged from the inner bar.
  The amount available and the appropriation asked for will be ex-
pended in the completion of the works of shore protection, and of the
dredging of the inner bar.
July 1, 1885, amount available...--.----...---------.........--            ..--..--....--........---..----..--- $31, 800 29
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
   liabilities outstanding July 1, 1885......................... $29,024 28
July 1, 1886, outstanding liabilities------......-----.----...........-----........            330 00
                                                                                                            29,354 28

July 1, 1886, amount available.......----..............-----..........-----...........                        2,446 01
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886........--                                 .........      20,000 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887 ...................                                   22, 446 01
  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project--------........                            20,000 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1888                                20, 000 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
     harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix              0 13.)
IMPROVEMENT OF THE HARBOR OF MOBILE: OF WARRIOR, TOMBIGBEE,
  AND BLACK WARRIER RIVERS, ALABAMA, AND OF CERTAIN RIVERS
  IN MISSISSIPPI-IMPROVEMENT OF CHANNEL TO BILOXI BAY.

  Officer in charge, Maj. A. N.Damrell, Corps of Engineers.
  1. Miobile Harbor, Alabama.-The present project for the improvement
of this harbor was adopted in March, 1880, the object being to afford a
channel of entrance from the Gulf of Mexico to the city of Mobile of
200 feet width and not less than 17 feet depth at mean low water.
  The channel before was 200 feet wide through Choctaw Pass Bar,
with not more than 13 feet at the shoalest part, and was obtained by
dredging under previous appropriations, from 1870 to 1878, inclusive,
amounting to $401,000.
  The amount expended to June 30, 1885, is $584,159.39, and resulted
in obtaining a channel with a minimum width of 125 feet and a maxi-
mum width of 200 feet, a minimum depth of 161 feet, and a maximum
depth of 23 feet, from the 17-foot curve in Mobile River to the curve of
same depth in the lower bay, a length of 26.33 miles.
  The amount expended during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1886, is
$74,927.83, and has resulted in increasing the minimum width of the
above channel from 125 to 140 feet, its maximum width from 200 to 300
feet, and minimum depth from 161 to 174 feet.
   The amount available and the appropriation asked for are to be ap-
plied to widening and deepening the channel, and it is expected the
combined amounts will complete the project.
July 1, 1885, amount available .............        ..................$75, 840 61
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885...........        ............................. 74,927 83
July 1, 1886, amount available ..--.....................................                                         912 78
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886                          ..................              90, 000 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887                      ......       ...........         90, 912 78

   Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1888                               80,000 00
   Submitted in comp)liance with requirements of section 2 of river and
     harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix P 1.)
206         REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

   2. Warrior and Tombigbee rivers, Alabama and Mississippi.-(a) War-
rior River, Alabama.--The present project for the improvement of this
river was adopted in 1875, the object being to obtain a channel 4 feet
deep and 80 feet wide at ordinary low water from its junction with the
Tombigbee up to Tuscaloosa.
   The channel at that time was not navigable at low water and was
much obstructed at a medium stage.
   The amount expended to June 30, 1885, was about                 (exact $90,806.57
figures cannot be given for the years 1875 to 1882, inclusive; the ap-
propriation was made for the Warrior and Tombigbee jointly, without
any specified allotment for each, and therefore no separate account was
kept), and resulted in obtaining a channel safely and easily navigable
at a stage of water fully 3 feet lower than was formerly practicable, en-
abling boats of 3 feet draught to run when the water was 1 foot above
ordinary low water.
   The amount expended during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1886, is
$6,316.84, arid resulted in removing snags from 38 miles of the river
and the partial improvement of one of the bars.
   The amount available and the appropriation asked for are to be ex-
pended in continuing the improvement according to project adopted,
and will probably complete it.
July 1, 1885, amount available................... ................         ....        $6, 831 81
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885...... ...... ........   ......    ...... .... ......         6, 316 84
July 1, 1886, amount available................--.......       ...................          514 97
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886 ..................                  18, 750 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887.......... ..........             19,264 97

 (Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project........               34,714 62
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1888            35, 000 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
      harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
  (See Appendix P 2.)
   (b) Tombigbee River, from Fulton to Vienna.-The project for the im-
provement of the river between Columbus and Fulton was adopted in
1873, the object being to give good high-water navigation throughout
by the removal of snags and overhanging trees.
   The channel before improvement was not navigable at all from Ful-
ton down to Cotton Gin Port. From Cotton Gin Port down to Aber-
deen, about 35 miles, it was navigable for small barges carrying about
125 bales of cotton. From Aberdeen to Columbus, about 65 miles, nav-
igation was difficult when the river was 12 feet above ordinary low
water.
   The project for the improvement of the portion of the river between
Columbus and Vienna was adopted in 1879, the object being to afford a
channel of navigable width 3 feet deep during ordinary low water.
   Before the improvement was commenced the channel was much ob-
structed by snags and overhanging trees, and there was only 1 foot of
water on some of the bars during ordinary low water.
   The amount expended to June 30, 1885, was $68,138.04, about (exact
figures cannot be given for the reason mentioned in statement for War-
rior River), and resulted in completion of the improvement projected
for that section of the river from Fulton down to Columbus, and in
giving such a channel from Columbus down to Vienna that navigation
was possible on a 2-foot rise for boats drawing 3 feet, and the accom-
plishment of over one-half of the work projected.
                               RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                               207
  The amount expended during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1886, is
$3,788.98, and resulted in preservation of the improvement already ob-
tained above Columbus and in the removal of snags and overhanging
trees from Vienna up to within 5 miles of Pikerville, a distance of 38
miles, principally preservation of improvement already obtained.
   The amount available and appropriation asked for are to be expended
in continuing the improvement as projected, and it is expected will com-
plete it.
July 1, 1885, amount available.-----..... ......--...--..--.... .....-- ......--           ....----- $3, 912 01
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 185.---....--......------..-------......-------.......--..... ------..........  3,788 98
July 1, 1886, amount available......----------.. ....---..---------....--.--.....----............--------                  123 03
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886........-....                          -         ....                 7, 500 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887..--...------------..............                                  7, 623 03
   Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project ........                                              6, 000 00
   Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1888                                            6, 000 00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
     (See Appendix P 2.)
   (c) Tombigbee River below Vienna.--The project for the improvement
of this portion of the river was adopted in 1879, the object being to
afford a channel of navigable width and 4 feet deep at ordinary low
water from the mouth up to Demopolis and 3 feet deep from Demopo-
lis up to Vienna.
   Before the improvement was commenced the river was navigable
from the mouth up to Bladen Springs, 143 miles above Mobile, during
the entire year, but was obstructed by snags. From Bladen Springs
up to Demopolis, 243 miles above Mobile, navigation was suspended
about two months yearly during low water.
   From Demopolis up to Vienna the channel was much obstructed by
snags and overhanging trees, and the water was so shoal on the bars
that navigation was only attempted on a considerable rise. A railroad
bridge at Jones's Bluff also gave considerable trouble.
   The amount expended to June 30, 1885, was about $92,253.40 (exact
figures cannot be given for reason given in report for Warrior River),
and resulted in obtaining an unobstructed channel with 3 feet depth
of water from the mouth up to Tompkins's Bluff, 197 miles above Mo-
bile, with 2 feet depth up to Kirkpatricks, 260 miles above Mobile, and
1 foot depth (all at ordinary low water) up to Vienna.
   The amount expended during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1886, is
$2,341.47, and resulted in removing the logs and other obstructions that
had accumulated during the last two years from Vienna 250 miles down
stream, in preservation of improvement already obtained.
   The amount available and the appropriation asked for are to be ex-
pended in continuing the improvement according to the project adopted,
and will probably complete the improvement.
July 1, 1885, amount available ............-----                                -.--         -----........ --.         $3, 058 17
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885----....----....-----...............---- -------- ....----....------......------....--....
                                                                                 ----                                   2,341 47
July 1, 1886, amount available .--.......-----....---......---------------..................--------------. 716 70
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886-- .................                                     11, 250 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887 ...................                                              11,966 70
208        REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project-........ $12, 888 38
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1888 12,900 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
  (See Appendix P 2.)
  3. Black Warrior River, from Tuscaloosa to Daniels Creek, Alabama.-
The present project for the improvement of this section of the river was
adopted in 1886, the object being to afford a water-way for the transpor-
tation of coal in barges from the Warrior coal-fields to the Gulf of Mexico.
  The present natural channel is only navigable during very high water,
and is even then extremely dangerous.
   The amount expended to June 30, 1885, was $2,978, and resulted in
the completion of a survey for preparation of a project with plans and
estimates.
  The amount expended during fiscal year ending June 30, 1886, is
$919.96, and has resulted in the adoption of a project and preparation
of plans and estimates.
   The amount available and appropriation asked for is to be applied to
construction of locks and dams in accordance with the adopted project.
                                                 ....---....
July 1, 1885, amount available.----....-- ...---..  ----     -....-......---....-....---......    $47, 022 00
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885................------                                       ..----
                                                                 ---- -- -- -- -.........................
                                                                                            --            919 96

July 1, 1886, amount available......---------............----....................                   46, 102 04
Amount appropriated by act approved Angust 5, 1886---....------......--------........               56, 250 00

Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887..................---------------..          102, 352 04
  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project.. ..-     463, 854 00
  Amount that can be probtably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1888 200, 000 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
  (See Appendix P 3.)
  4. Old Town Creek,
                G       Mississippi.-The project for this improvement,
adopted in 1883, is to improve this stream for high-water navigation by
the removal of logs, snags, and overhanging trees from its mouth to
City Point, a distance of 30 miles.
  The amount expended to June 30, 1886, is $3,000, and has resulted in
obtaining, by the removal of overhan ging timber from the banks, logs
and stumps from the bed of the river, a fair high-water channel from its
mouth up to Camargo, 16 miles.
  No work was done and no expenditure made during the fiscal year
ending June 30, 1886.
  The appropriation asked for is to be applied to continuing the im-
provement according to the approved plan by removing obstructions to
high water navigation, working up stream toward City Point.
  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project-..--                               $7, 000 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1888                         7,000 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
  (See Appendix P 4.)
  5. Noxubee River, Mississippi.-The present project for the improve-
ment of this river was adopted in 1880, the object being to afford a
channel for small river steamers from its mouth up to Macon, Miss., of
navigable width and depth during about nine months of the year, or
when the water is above the ordinary low-water stage.
   The amount expended to June 30, 1885, was $34,114.60, and resulted
in obtaining a channel partially improved, which has been used by steam-
                             RIVER AND HARBOR                            IMPROVEMENTS.                                  209
boats the entire distance from the mouth of the river up to Macon, and a
wholly improved channel (according to project) from Macon to a point
28 miles below, and from the mouth to a point 12 miles above, giving a
river 40 miles wholly and 514 miles partially improved.
   The amount expended during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1886, is
$3,222.89, and has resulted in wholly improving 15 miles of the river,
so that there is now 55. miles of the river wholly improved and 36 miles
partially improved.
   The amount available and the appropriation asked for is to be applied
to continuing the improvement in accordance with the project adopted,
and it is thought this amount will complete the improvement.
July 1, 1885, amount available......---- ---......--....-.....................                                    $3, 385 40
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885 ---------------...                  ------------------..............................    3,222 89
July 1, 1886, amount available .....-- ...--...... -......      --....
                                                                  .........                                          162 51
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886 ---...--................                                        7,500 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887 ....................                                         7,662   51


   Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1888                                     10,000 00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
    (See Appendix P 5.)
    6. PascagoulaRiver, Mississippi.-The present project for the improve-
  ment of this river was adopted in 1880, the object being to afford a
  channel 200 feet wide and 7 feet deep at mean low water from Missis-
sippi Sound into East Pascagoula River, and to improve the river above
by the removal of snags, overhanging trees, &c.
    The channel before the commencement of the improvement had a
depth of not more than 3 feet at mean low water at its shoalest place.
    The amount expended to June 30, 1885, was $58,430.84, and resulted
in securing a channel 180 to 190 feet wide and 74 feet deep at mean low
water from Mississippi Sound into Pascagoula River, and the thorough
improvement of the river above for 501 miles, and partially for 49 miles
'further up.
    The amount expended during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1886; is
 $455.79, for watching and care of property, &c.
July 1, 1885, amount available;--..........---............................                                          $569 16
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885 ....... .................   ...................                                           455 79
July 1, 1886, amount available ----........... --......--....--...........--------......--                           113 37
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886------................                                          20,000 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887 ...................                                         20,113 37
   (See Appendix P 6.)
  -7. Harbor at Biloxi Bay, Mississippi.-The amount appropriated by
the river and harbor act of August 5, 1886, together with the money
on hand heretofore appropriated, is directed by the act to be applied to
deepening the channel from Mississippi Sound to the wharves at Biloxi.
July 1, 1885, amount available ...................------.----..........                                           $4, 988 55

July 1, 1886, amount available ...........                       ................              ....   ......       4, 988 56
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886 ...................                                            12, 500 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887 ....................                                        17,488 55
          14 E
210       REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

SAmount (estimated) required for completion of proposed project ...     $37, 500 00
Amount that canbe profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1888 37,500 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
  harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
  (See Appendix P 7.)
  8. Horn Island Pass, Mississippi.-No project has been adopted foi
the improvement of this locality, the amount appropriated being deemed
insufficient for an economical prosecution of the work. It is possible
that the increase in depth through this pass from natural causes will do
away with the necessity for any expenditure to obtain the improvement
desired.
   The river and harbor act of August 5, 1886, directs that the balance
on hand for this improvement be applied to the improvement of Pasca-
goula River.
July 1, 1885, amount available..........-................................                   $5, 000 00
July 1, 1886, amount available---...---....----------..............---........--.......      5, 000 00
   (See Appendix P 8.)
   9. Pearl River, Mississippi, below Jackson.--The present project for
the improvement of this portion of the river was adopted in 1880, the
object being to obtain a channel 5 feet deep at ordinary low water, and
of navigable width from the mouth of the river up to Jackson.
   Before the improvement the river was not navigable at all at low
water, and was difficult at high water.
   The amount expended on the work to June 30, 1885, was $71,619.99,
and resulted in considerable but incomplete improvement of the river
for high-water navigation from Jackson to Poitevant's Bluff, a distance
of 295 miles.
   The amount expended during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1886, is
 $8,378.56, and resulted in considerable but incomplete improvement of
that part of East Pearl River situated between the head of West Pearl
River and the lower end of Home's Bayou, a distance of 20 miles.
   Nothing has been done towards the improvement of the river below
Home's Bayou to the mouth, about 20 miles.
   The amount available and the appropriation asked for is to be ex-
pended in continuing the improvement, and will probably so improve
the worst portions of this section, and the bar at the mouth of the river,
as to meet the present demands of the commerce of the river.
July 1, 1885, amount available ........                                             $8, 380 01
                                                     .....................................
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885 .........................          ..............  .      8, 378 56
July 1, 1886, amount available...............................  ............           ...        1 45
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886 ...........              ...      ....   13,125 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887 ......................                13,126 45
  SAmount  (estimated) required for completion of proposed modification of
    existing project_.............. .... ......................   .......... . 70,000 "00
   Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1888. 30, 000 00
 | Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
  (See Appendix P 9.)
  10. PearlRiver, Mississippi, from Jackson to Carthage.-The present
project for the improvement of this portion of the river was adopted in
1880, the object being to obtain a channel 5 feet deep and of navigable
width throughout.
  Before the improvement was commenced navigation was difficult even
during high water on account of snags and overhanging trees.
                              RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                             211
   The amount expended to June 30, 1885, was $18,447.60, and resulted
in a material improvement of this section of the river.
   The amount expended during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1886, is
$52.40, and was expended in the care and preservation of the plant and
property.
   Boats of 3 feet draught of water can navigate the river from Carthage
down, 12 miles, on a stage of 4 feet above low water, and the remaining
distance to Jackson, 93 miles, on a rise of 6 feet.
   The amount available, and the appropriation asked for, is to be ap-
plied to a continuation of the improvement according to the project, and
will probably.obtain a channel that can be navigated on a stage con-
siderably lower than at present.
July 1, 1885, amount available--.................. ......--                   ........---...--......----                $52 40
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885---- -------------------------------------..............................................      52 40
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886----...................                ----------                  2,250 00
                                                                  ....
  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project-------- 29, 000 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal yearending June 30,1888                                           5,000 00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix P 10.)
   11. Pearl River, Mississippi, between Edinburg and Carthage.--Tlhe
project for the improvement of this portion of the river was adopted in
1884, the object being to obtain a good high-water channel throughout
for the use of steamers during six or eight months of the year.
   Before the improvement was commenced navigation was only possi-
ble during very high water, and was even then troublesome.
   The amount expended to June 30, 1885, was $2,110.39, and resulted
in such an improvement of over two-thirds of the distance as to permit
of the passage off steamboats of 3 feet draught, with comparative ease
and safety, on a rise of 6 feet above ordinary low water.
   The amount expended during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1886, is
$389.61, and resulted in the improvement of the remaining one-third of
the whole distance, so that boats of 3; feet draught can navigate the
river between Edinburg and Carthage, with comparative safety, on a
rise of 6 feet above ordinary low water.
   The amount available and the appropriation asked for is to be ap.
plied to continuing the improvement as projected, and it is thought that
the amount will complete the work.
July 1, 1885, amount available..........................................                                              $389 61
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885.....------
                               ....-----------..---...-..--..-..
                                                           ........----.......-.....---.                               389 06
July 1, 1886, amount available, -...                     ......          ......      ...............
                                                                                  ----......                               55
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886 ...................                                               2,250 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887...................                                             2,250 55

  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1888                                          5, 000 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix P 11.)
EXAMINATIONS AND SURVEYS FOR IMPROVEMENT, TO COMPLY WITH
  REQUIREMENTS OF THE RIVER AND HARBOR ACT OF JULY 5, 1884.
  Major Damrell was charged with and completed the following, it ap-
pearing, after preliminary examinations, that the localities were worthy
of improvement by the General Government:
  1. PascagoulaRiver, Mississippi, from the mills at Moss Point down
212        REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                                       U. S. ARMY.

to the anchorage in the bay, with a view to securing a uniform depth
of 12 feet water.
   Report transmitted to Congress and printed as House Ex. Doc. No.
83, Forty-ninth Congress, first session. (See also Appendix P 12.)
   2. Wacissa River, Florida.--Report transmitted to Congress and
printed as House Ex. Doc. No. 82, Forty-ninth Congress, first session.
(See also Appendix P 13.)
INSPECTION OF              THE      IMPROVEMENT AT THE SOUTH                                PASS        OF THE
                                      MISSISSIPPI RIVER.

   Inspecting officer, Maj. W. H. Heuer, Corps of Engineers.
   The inspecting officer in his annual report states that the full depths
and widths of channels required by law have been maintained through-
out the fiscal year ending June 30, 1886, except for seventeen days dur.
ing January and February, when there was a deficiency in depth or
width in the channel between the jetties. No dredging has been done
on any part of the work since February, 1883.
   The channel from the main river into the Gulf is in better condition,
as regards width, depth, and navigability, than at the end of the pre-
vious fiscal year.
   A complete survey of South Pass shows a channel having in the pass
a least depth of 29.8 feet and the 26-foot channel was 300 feet wide.
   In the jetties the average increase in depth of water during the year,
as compared with the year previous, was about 5 feet.
   Beyond the jetties the channel is 31.2 feet deep.
   The 26-foot channel is 260 feet wide; the 30-foot channel is 190 feet
wide. In the fan-shaped area beyond the jetties the scour and fill nearly
balanced each other. The diagrams accompanying report show nearly
all the scour to the eastward, and all of the deposit or fill to the west-
ward of the ends of the jetties.
   Attention is especially invited to that part of the report wherein Con-
gress requires an inspecting officer "' to report the depth .of water and
width of channel secured and maintained from time to time in said
channel, together with such other information as the Secretary of War
may direct."
   The funds for this examination were exhausted at the end of Novem-
ber, 1885, the employes were seven months without pay, and continued
work, voluntarily relieving the Government from any obligation unless
Congress should appropriate funds for this purpose. The inspecting
officer recommends that as the law requires these examinations and
surveys, provision for making them in the way of an appropriation
should be made an independent measure and not part of the river and
harbor bill as heretofore.
July 1, 1885, amount available............-------------------------............----.---------......     $3,849 44
Amount appropriated by act applroved May 26, 1886, to supply deficiency
  in amount required for expenditure to June 30, 1886-....-------------......-....                       6,492 00
                                                                                                        10,341 44
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1885..---------......................                $9,119 92
July 1, 1886, outstanding liabilities....        -...... -------....
                                      ----..--..--....                                     49 02
                                                                                                         9,168 94
July 1, 1886, amount available .....................                                      .......        1, 172 50
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886...................                                   10,000 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887 ...........                               ,,...   11, 172 50
                              RIVE R AND                 HAR13OR IMPROVEMENTS.                 213
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1888 $16, 870 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix Q.)

IMPROVEMENT OF VARIOUS WATER-COURSES IN THE STATE OF LOU-
  ISIANA-IMPROVEMENT OF SABINE PASS AND OF SABINE AND
  NECHES RIVERS, TEXAS.

   Officer in charge, Maj. W. H. Heuer, Corps of Engineers, with Lieut.
O. T. Crosby, Corps of Engineers, under his immediate orders.
   1. Amite River, Louisiana.-Beforeimprovement the river was much
obstructed by snags, sunken logs, and trees standing in the river. It
was used, however, by a small steamer and some sailing vessels. In
1880 a project was made to improve the river by removing all obstruc-
tions and dredging above the Bayou Manchac as far as the appropria-
tion would permit and get 5 feet depth of water. With the appropria-
tion of $8,000, made in 1880, 40 miles of river improvement was done
by contract; this proved very unsatisfactory, and was of but little bene-
fit to navigation. In 1881 $5,000 was appropriated to continue the
work. That under the first contract having been accepted in 1883, the
project of improvement was modified so as to improve the river below
Bayou Manchac by means of hired labor and Government plant. With
this money about 8 miles of river was properly improved, the other 8
miles below this not yet having been touched. The original estimated
cost of 'the work was $23,760, of which $13,000 has been appropriated
and $12,878.01 spent.
   To clear out the balance of the lower part of the river, as well as re-
move all other obstructions as far up as the mouth of the Cornite, be-
yond which it is thought inadvisable to improve the river, will cost
$8,205.
   The improvement has been beneficial to navigation, but it is not known
that freight rates have been reduced, nor that commerce has been bene-
fited to any extent by the money thus far spent. No money has been
spent during the past year except to care for the plant.
   The estimated amount required for completion of approved project,
if appropriated, can be all expended in the fiscal year, and will be used
in clearing out the stream, as indicated.
   The improvement will not be permanent, as obstructions will re-form.
                              ...................-
July 1, 1885, amount available--                         .--------------.                   $121 99
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885 .--.............................................                  120 00

July 1, 1886, amount available................. ........................                        1 99
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886...................                       , 000 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887 ..............             .. ....   2, 001 99

  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1888                6, 000 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section '2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
  (See Appendix R 1.)
  2. Tangipahoa River, Louisiana.-Beforeimprovement the river was
obstructed by snags, logs, rafts, standing and overhanging trees. The
project adopted in 1880 was to remove these obstructions as far up as
Connor's Bridge, 53 miles above its mouth, and get all depth possible
without dredging. The river was neavigable for 34 miles of this distance
for vessels of very light draught.
214      REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

   Congress has appropriated for the improvement of this river $11,000,
and with this amount 41 miles of river were improved by contract work,
which has been far from satisfactory.
   The upper 7 miles of river worked over is now nearly as much ob-
structed as it was before work was commenced.
   Total expended to June 30, 1884, $6,186.02.
   During the fiscal year ending June 30, 1885, the Government plant,
with hired labor, was sent to continue this work, and did effective work
between Lanier's Bridge and the mouth. The upper 12 miles of the
river has not been touched, and it seems useless to undertake to carry
the improvement any further up-stream, as there does not seem to be
any increase of commerce, and the obstructions form nearly as fast as
they are removed. The original estimated cost of the improvement was
$10,700, of which $9,000 have been appropriated and $9,000 spent.
   Lumber and saw-logs are the principal products carried on the river.
Should any further appropriations be made the money can be used in
removing obstructions in the lower part of the river as they may form,
but no recommendation for appropriation is made.
   No work has been done during the past fiscal year, no appropriation
having been made since that of July 5, 1884.
   The river is not susceptible of permanent improvement.
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project ......... $1, 700 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
  harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
  (See Appendix R 2.)
   3. Tclefuncte River, Louisiana.-The river is navigable for steamers
drawing 5 feet to Old Landing, about 10 or 12 miles above its mouth,
and then for lighter draught schooners to Covington, about 2 miles fur-
ther up on the Bogue Falia. The bar at the mouth of the river had a
depth of 4J feet on it at the lowest stage of the water. The project for
the improvement of the river was made in 1880, and contemplated the
removal of overhanging trees, logs, &c., in channel and the dredging
of the bar at its mouth.
   The obstructions, such as overhanging trees, logs in bed, &c., were
removed, but the bar at the mouth was not dredged, as it would be
likely to re-form. To prevent this, or retard its re-formation, the officer
in charge in 1884 recommended the building of a breakwater extending
into the lake for 2,500 feet and then dredging a channel through the
bar.
   With the two appropriations of $1,500 each, made in 1881 and 1882,
the obstructions below Covington were removed ; part of the unexpended
balance was used for the construction of the breakwater extending 820
feet into the lake.
   The original estimated cost of improving the river was $5,460, but
this did not include the building of any breakwater across the bar. The
project as modified in 1884 is estimated to cost $20,400. This has not
yet received the sanction of Congress.
   At the close of the fiscal year ending June 30, 1885, $3,000 had been
expended on this improvement, at which time the navigation had been
improved for schooners to Covington in consequence of removal of
snags and overhanging trees, and it is thought that the breakwater has
retarded the drift of sand on the bar at the river's mouth. For the
year ending June 30, 188, $19,000 can be expended in comleting the
work of improvement, and, if appropriated, it is proposed to extend the
                            RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                            215
breakwater, dredge the bar, and remove any other obstructions that
may have re-formed in the river since it was cleaned out.
  The benefit to commerce is local. It is not known that there has
been any increase to commerce in consequence of improvements thus
far made. Should the improvements be made as contemplated, the
mouth of the river would then become an excellent harbor of refuge for
small vessels navigating the lake.
  The report of 1884 gives commercial statistics of this river at $106,500,
consisting of brick, sand, charcoal, wool, cotton, lumber, hides, beef,
sugar, and molasses.
   Amount (estimated) rAquired for completion of existing project ....... $19, 000 00
   Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1888 5, 000 00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
    (See Appendix R 3.)
   4. Tickfaw River, Louisiana.--The natural channel was much ob-
structed by snags and overhanging trees. The original project was
adopted in 1881, the object being to obtain a channel of navigable width
and depth for a distance of 26 miles up-stream. The amount expended
to the close of the fiscal year ending June 30, 1883, is $2,004.64. The
river was then navigable for 18 miles for vessels drawing 4 feet.
   The amount expended during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1884, is
$1,955.14, for part payment of plant for Amite, Tickfaw, and Tchefuncte
rivers, and for work resulting in the removal of all obstructions for a
distance of 20 miles from the mouth, 18 miles of which have been pre-.
viously worked over by contract.
   The amount that can be profitably expended during the fiscal year
ending June 30, 1888, is $4,230, to be expended in carrying on the ex-
isting project, which will result in increasing the navigable length of
the river.
   No work was done during the past fiscal year.
July 1, 1885, amount available---------------------------------------..........................................     $33 72
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885...--.---...----------------..---..---....................-----------------.               30 00
July 1, 1886, amoupt available--------------.........-----..........----..........--------............                 3 72
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886................                              --...             2, 000 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887 ...................                                         2, 003 72
   Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project--------4,230 00
   Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1888 4, 000 00
   Submitted in corqpliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
    (See Appendix R 4.)
   5. Bayou Teche, Louisiana.-The upper portion of this bayou from
New Iberia to its head (80 miles), and especially from Saint Martinsville
to its head (50 miles), was much obstructed by logs, trees, and snags.
Below New Iberia considerable trouble was given by logs and snags.
The project for its improvement contemplated the removal of these ob-
structions and the making of slackwater navigation by locks and dams.
The original estimated cost was $135,625. Investigations as to cost of
lock-construction, made in the light of recent work in other sections
of the country, and made in much more detail than those first attempted,
show that this estimate is much too small. (For full report of this mat-
ter, see Appendix R 5.) The lowest safe estimate is $175,000 for a lock
and movable dam, to be placed about 60 miles below the head, and to
216         REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

carry slackwater navigation to within about 20 miles. To this must be
added the amount necessary for clearing the bayou of obstructions,
which has now been appropriated, or at least very nearly this amount.
The appropriations aggregate $32,500. With this, obstructions have
been thoroughly removed from Franklin, near the mouth, to Leonville,
13 miles below the head, a total distance of about 100 miles, except for
a few miles, from which only the most dangerous could be taken on ac-
count of approaching high water, and surveys have been made sufficient
for presenting a plan of improvement. The funds on hand will proba-
bly suffice to carry the work to the head of the bayou, should that prove
desirable, and to rectify any omission that work at comparatively high
stages may have caused. Of the sum expended, nearly $6,000 covers a
contract completed in June, 1881, under which work was done and ac-
cepted by an assistant engineer at such high stage as to be valueless.
The effective work has been done during the last two fiscal years, and
much benefit to navigation has resulted, but there has been little, if
any, extension of commerce. The, officer in charge, therefore, recom-
mends that no large appropriation be made until it be seen whether the
interests of commerce demand more than has been secured. As soon
as the stage of water permits, further work thay be prosecuted in the
way of removal of obstructions until all has been done in this line that
seems necessary. The winter and spring months of 1886-'87 will dem-
onstrate whether any considerable use will be made of the improve-
men t.
   This matter will be watched and reported upon, probably in time for
Congressional action upon appropriations for 1887-'88.
   The railroad touching at numerous points on the bayou, in connection
with its steamboats as feeders from the plantations to the railway sta-
tions, offers the short route to market for the products of the bayou
and controls and carries nearly all the business of this section of the
country.
July 1, 1885, amount available         -
                               - -.......... ....... ...... .... .... .... $18, 005 90
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885 ..........---.......------ ....----............-   ........    10, 687 97
July 1, 1886, amount available .........................................                   7, 317 93
   (See Appendix R 5.)
   6. Connecting Bayou Teche with GrandLake at Charenton,Louisiana.-
The original project was adopted in 1880, the object being to connect
Bayou Teche with Grand Lake at Charenton by the construction of a
canal a little over a mile long, 50 feet wide, and 5 feet deep, with a lock
at one end, estimated to cost $75,000.
   This was modified by further study and examination, and it was found
to cost no more to dig a canal 100 feet wide of same depth, on which no
lock would be necessary. The latter is the more desirable project. The
amount expended to date is $2,899.95, which was for examinations, sur-
veys, and engineering and office expenses.
   The officer in charge states that the work, if constructed, will be of
local benefit only, will save 75 or 80 miles of transportation in logs and
rafts, and that no advantage can be derived even by these until the
completion of the canal. He therefore suggests that the work be not
commenced until the amount necessary for its completion, viz, $75,000,
is available.
   No appropriation has been made by Congress since March 3, 1881.
July 1, 1885, amount available .......................................                    $22, 100 05
July 1, 1886, amount available........... ..........                             ,. ...
                                                                                    ..     22,100 05
                 RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                              217
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project.------. $53,000 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix R 6.)
   7. Bayou Black, Louisiana.-An examination of this bayou was pro-
vided for by act of Congress 1880, a report of which, with plan and esti-
mate, was published in the Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1881.
In his report of 1881 Major Howell recommended the dredging of a
channel 50 feet wide by 6 feet in depth from Tigerville to Houma, a dis-
tance of 24 miles and 4,000 feet, the estimated cost being $47,520. No
level-line having been run, the depth of cut necessary to go 6 feet be-
low tide-level was not known. An appropriation of $10,000 was made
March 3, 1881. Authority was received for the transfer of dredge ma-
chinery from the charge of Major Mansfield to Major Howell. This ma-
chinery was put into a hull, the cost being borne by the appropria-
tions for Bayous Black and Terrebonne and that part charged to Bayou
Black was $4,708. A second appropriation of $10,000 was made Au-
gust 2, 1882.
   A line of levels run in 1883-'84 showed the bottom of the bayou at
Houma to be 51 feet above tide-level, this rise of 5J feet occurring in
the last 12 miles counted toward Houma. In his report of an examina-
tion of this bayou, made in April, 1885, by the officer in charge, he says
" that there is no channel nor scarcely any water for the 14 or 15 miles
of cut yet unopened; the bed of the bayou is filled with mud and ob-
structions, and that, owing to the softness of the mud, it may be neces-
sary to build a timber revetment for a considerable portion of the route,
to prevent the mud from running back into the cut."
   The dredge-boat began work May 7, 1883, at Tigerville, and worked
almost continuously until April 25, 1885, when it was stopped by the
officer in charge on account of the smallness of the unexpended appro-
priation.
   The original estimate for completing this improvement was $47,520.
Of this amount nearly $25,000 has been expended, of which about
$4,500 was used in part payment for the building of a dredge-boat. This
would leave $20,000 expended in actual dredging of about 10 miles of
bayou and between 14 and 15 miles yet to be dredged. The average
quantity of material to be removed in each mile of cutting is estimated
to be nearly double what it was in the preceding 10 miles already
opened, and therefore is estimated to cost nearly twice as much, or
$4,000 per mile. As there are yet 14 miles of cut to be made, the esti-
mate for completing this cut should be fourteen times $4,000, equal to
$56,000. This together with the $25,000 expended would be $81,000, an
excess of $33,480 over the original estimate. It is barely possible that
this estimate may be too great. But when the sunken imbedded logs,
stumps, and roots thrown up by the dredge all along the embankment
are seen, no prudent engineer would submit a smaller one. Nor is it
likely that any contractor would make a contract to do the work re-
quired even on this estimate. Moreover, in pushing the work to advan-
tage, the engineer in charge of this improvement has never estimated
less than $10,000 to be necessary for any one year's work. On July 5,
1884, Congress appropriated $5,000. Such an amount enables a dredge
and crew to work five or six months, then the funds become exhausted,
and the balance of the year the dredge is laid up, and is deteriorating
for want of use in charge of a watchman, at considerable expense.
  The products of adjacent plantations seem to vary in value, and ag-
gregate from $300,000 to $500,000 per year, and consist ordinarily of
218       REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

about 7,000 hogsheads of sugar, 14,000 barrels of molasses, together
with corn, rice, and other products. The freight on these at present is
expensive, but the improvement of the bayou by inducing competition
will possibly cause a reduction of freight charges and also an increase
of the products. The improvement at best is simply a local one, and
only benefits the people living on or near the bayou, and can in no wise
be considered a public necessity. But as it has been begun by author-
ity of Congress, and $25,000 has been expended on it, if the work were
now stopped the greater portion of this money would be wasted. It is
therefore assumed that the work will be continued to completion, and,
in this event, that no less than $10,000 should be appropriated for the
fiscal year ending June 30, 1888.
   The dredge-boat belonging to this and the Bayou Terrebonne im-
provement was during the last fiscal year hired to a contractor for
Government work on Red River. The sum of $2,330, received for
hire, was applied to the Bayou Black appropriation, and almost en-
tirely expended in repairing the dredge, which is now in fair condition.
July 1, 1885, amount available ...... ...... ............                   .............    $427 68
December 5 to 12, 1885, amount received for rent of dredge-boat .........                   2, 330 00

                                                                                            2,757 68
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885 ............ .. _........................                        2, 325 87
July 1, 1886, amount available ...... ...... ............................                     431 81

  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project-.......                    56,000 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix R 7.)
   8. Bayou Courtableau, Louisiana.-Examinationwas made in 1879.
Estimated cost of improvement for bayou between Port Barre and At-
chafalaya was $40,000.
   The act of June 14, 1880, appropriated $7,500 to commence improve-
ment, the project for which was to close some run-out bayous, with a
view to confine the water in the Courtableau, and cause its current to
wash out Little Devil Bar at its mouth. After this was accomplished,
then to make slackwater navigation by means of locks and movable
dams to Port Barre and above.
   In 1883 this estimate was increased by $38,500, and provided for a
masonry lock instead of a timber lock. This estimate, in so far as it
applies to lock construction, is now known to be far too small. Careful
estimates since made for Bayou Teche, when the conditions are similar
to those existing on Bayou Courtableau, place the cost of one 10-foot
lift-lock with movable dam at $175,000.
   In 1882 some of the run-out bayous were closed by slashing trees,
and one dam was built on the Big Fordoche; also one in the Little
Fordoche. These cut the bar down 3 feet in two days. Sickness
and high water materially interfered with properly pushing the work.
In 1884 it was reported that the Little Fordoche dam had been cut by
swampers and Little Devil Bar had shoaled 4 feet in vertical height.
   During the past fiscal year the dams across the two Fordoche bayous
were rebuilt. The work proved difficult and costly on account of an
unexpected rise of the water and sickness of the workmen. The bar
has now moved quite above Little Fordoche, which, when the dams
were built, was at its head, and that part of Little Fordoche which is
                       RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                            219

above the dam is iow probably filled with sand. The high stage of the
water at present prevents an examination.
  Work was stopped during November, 1885; a considerable bill of
lumber bought for the construction of another dam was stored and the
quarter-boat laid up, funds having run too low to begin another-a
third dam. In consequence of great floods in the Atchafalaya country,
the other bayous running from the Courtableau have increased in size
and will cost more to close than the original estimate.
  The bayous must all be closed before any good results can be ex-
pected on Little Devil Bar and before any work should be attempted
on the locks and dams.
  The estimate for closing these bayous is $16,000.
July 1, 1885, amount available--.......... ---........              ................-        $3, 892 10
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885.........................................                   ....    3,553 25
July 1, 1886, amount available ---..--------------...................--.................         338 85
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886 ...................                        5, 000 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887......-......-.......                    5, 338 85

  SAmount
 (Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project ........
             that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1888 11, 000 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
                                                                                             11,000 00

   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix R 8.)
   9. Bayou Terrebonne, Louisiana.-The natural low-water channel was
much obstructed by shoals and sunken logs. The original project was
adopted in 1880, the object being to obtain a depth of 4 feet with navi-
gable width from Houma down to Gulf. The bayou is navigable for
vessels of 5 feet draught as far as the improvement has been carried.
Above that it is navigable to Houma, a distance of about 10, miles, for
vessels of very light draught. No work has been done during past
fiscal year. Freight rates have been reported considerably cheapened
by the improvement.
   The amount available and the appropriation asked for the next fiscal
year will be applied to the continuation of the work towards Houma,
and it is estimated will complete it to that point.
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886----.---....----------.............. $10, 000 00
  Amount (estimated) required for completion ofexisting project.----.-                        3, 000 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1888                  3, 000 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix R 9.)
   10. Bayou La ourche, Louisiana.--The natural channel was much ob-
structed by snags, overhanging trees, shoals, and wrecks. The original
project, adopted in 1879, had for its object the removal of these obstruc-
tions. The amount expended on this work up to end of fiscal year
ending June 30, 1884, was $24,998.24. The amount expended during
fiscal year ending June 30, 1885, was $3,756.21, for care of property,
gauge-reading, and continuing improvement. Much relief has been
given to commerce by removal of snags, &c. No permanent relief for
the difficulties of low water over numerous shoals can be had save by
some rather costly improvement, such as that by movable dams and
locks. During the past fiscal year surveys were completed and plans
and estimates submitted. The plan preferred by the engineer in charge
is that for the canalizing the bayou, connecting it with the Mississippi
220         REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

by a lock at its head. This improvement is estimated as costing $450,-
000, with $31,000 annual expense of maintenance; this including $22,-
500 interest on original cost, $450,000, at 5 per cent. The saving in
freight obtainable by having steamboat navigation all the year round
is estimated at $19,000. No indirect and indefinite benefits are here
considered. Congress has not yet considered the advisability of under-
taking this improvement.
July 1, 1885, amount available ................            .......................        $1, 244 55
July 1, 1866, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885 .......       ......... .. ..............     ......-   -.. ..     989 94
July 1, 1886, amount available .........................................                    254 61
   (See Appendix R 10.)
   11. Calcasieu River, Louisiana.--The project made for the improve-
ment in 1880 was to improve the river above the town of Lake Charles
to Philip's Bluff by removing logs, snags, &c., at an estimated cost of
$10,080, and then to dredge the bar at foot of Calcasieu Lake, at an es-
timated cost of $15,000 additional, making a total of $25,080.
   In March, 1881, Congress appropriated $3,000 for improving this
river from Philip's Bluff to its mouth; in August, 1882, appropriated
$7,000 for improving Calcasieu River (no locality mentioned); and in
July, 1884, appropriated $6,500 more without mentioning any locality.
   Subsequent information was obtained showing that it was of far
more importance to Government and all concerned to have the river
improved below Lake Charles than above it, because the obstructions
below interfered seriously with navigation, while those above did not.
These obstructions below were a bar where the river enters Calcasien
Lake, and another much more serious one where the lake and Calcasieu
Pass join, and finally the outer bar at the junction of the pass with the
Gulf of Mexico. This second bar, that at the junction of the pass and
lake, has been twice dredged through, under appropriations for improv-
ing Calcasieu Pass, but has again refilled. The estimated cost to cut
a channel through this bar is $15,000, but it has not yet been decided
that any money appropriated for Calcasieu River can be applied to re-
moving this bar at the foot of Calcasieu Lake.
   Until $15,000 becomes available for dredging a channel through this
bar, it is useless to commence the work, and pending a decision from
Congress as to whether this money can be used on this bar or other
money becomes available, no work can be done. No part of this money
has been spent as yet, except a small amount for the examination and
surveys made.
   NOTE.--The river and harbor act of August 5, 1886, directs that the
money on hand heretofore appropriated for the improvement of Calca-
sieu River can be expended on Calcasieu Pass.
July 1, 1885,, amount available ...........  ........ .... ...........      ..........   $16,255 46
July 1, 1886, amount available ................ ....-      ....- ...          ....--
                                                                                ..        16,255 46
   (See Appendix.R 11.)
  12. Caleasieu Pass, Louisiana.-In 1874 a cut was dredged through the
bar at the junction of the pass and Calcasieu Lake. This cut was 6,300
feet long, 60 feet wide, and 6 feet deep. The channel refilled in 1881-'82,
was redredged by contract work to a depth of 8 feet by 7,500 feet long
by 70 feet wide, and at a cost of $10,444. Information obtained in the
fiscal year ending June 30, 1885, shows this cut to have again refilled to
its original condition, about 3~ feet of depth.
                           RIVER AND              HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                             221
   In making these two dredged channels in 1874 and 1882 a demand was
urgent to get immediate relief, and dredging was undoubtedly the quick-
est way to produce such results. As the appropriations were small, the
cuts were made on the shortest line across the bar, which would require
the least amount of excavation. The currents and seas passing from
the lake into the pass, which were due generally to the prevailing winds
in that particular section, did not, as a rule, follow the line of the cut,
but moved diagonally across it, and to this, in a great measure, added
to the small number of steamers plying through the cut, must be attrib-
uted the rapid refilling. It is possible that by changing the direction
of any new cut to be made across the bar, so that the axis of the cut
shall be in prolongation of the axis of the upper end of the pass, it may
refill less rapidly than those formerly made; but a cut on this line will
necessitate the removal of about 95,000 cubic yards of material, as com-
pared with 75,000 on the old line. At all events, with the funds avail-
able ($2,925) nothing toward making a channel over the bar can be
done. unless the appropriation for the Calcasieu River, viz, $16,255.46,
can be applied to this locality, and pending a decision on this point the
work is practically tied up. If the Calcasieu River fund can be used
for this purpose, then it is probable that a channel can be recut through
the bar, and after this question has been decided it will be proper to
make a determination of the best line to select for improvement.
   It is thought that no improvement on this bar will be permanent. It
is useless to make improvements elsewhere on this river until a channel
is obtained over this bar. To dredge an effective channel 100 feet wide,
8 feet deep, over the bar will cost $16,500.
   The commerce of the pass is about the same as that of the river, and
estimated at $528,000 per year.
   (See preceding note.)
July 1, 1885, amount available......-......-............-
                                           -......                                                   $2,95 25
                                                                                        .....------.--..---....
July 1, 1886, amount available--..---.....-----..........----.-----..------------------.................        2, 95 25
   (See Appendix R 12.)
   13.    Sabine
              Pass, Texas.-Surveys made in 1853, 1872, 1873, 1881, and
1882 showed about 61 feet of water over the bar at mean low tide. In
1876 and 1881 channels were dredged over the bar, but refilled. In 1882
a project was made for getting deeper water over this bar by means of
two jetties, each about 4 miles long, extending from shore to beyond
the outer crest of the bar. The improvement was estimated to cost
$3,177,606.
   In August, 1882, Congress appropriated $150,000 for this work. This
and an unexpended balance from former appropriations made $300,000
with which to start the work. Contracts were made, and in 1883 a
little over 3 miles of foundation of west jetty was laid and      miles of                                 1-
this jetty near shore were completed.
   In July, 1884, Congress appropriated $200,000 for continuing the
work. Work was continued by contract, and by June 30, 1885, 10,200
feet of the foundation of east jetty was laid, and 8,825 feet of this
was built up to the level of mean high water.
   During the past fiscal year work was continued until August 26,
1885, as far as the funds would permit. At this date the condition of
the work was as follows:
   East jetty foundation was 11,190 feet long. Ten thousand eight hun-
dred and forty feet of this was built up nearly to the level of mean high
tide.
222       REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

   The west jetty foundation was laid for a length of 16,074 feet, and
9,710 feet of this was raised above the level of mean high water.
   Surveys made early in1886 and one in June, 1886, show that the depth
of water on the bar has increased to 8 feet at mean low water. A cyclone
struck this work in June and destroyed about 6,000 feet of the top work
of the jetties. The estimated damage to the work is about $23,000.
   The officer in charge now reports the work as producing results in
increasing the depth of water on the bar. If the portion of the jetties
near the crest of the bar could be raised to or above the level of mean
high water, and this is prevented in consequence of the want of funds,
it is probable that very much better results would speedily be obtained.
The injury to both jetties in the late cyclone may possibly also retard or
prevent a further increase in depth on the bar, unless the injury can be
repaired by further appropriation from Congress.
   If this work is to be continued to completion, then, in an engineering
point of view, the best results can be obtained by the expenditure of
$1,000,000 per year.
   The commerce of Sabine Pass is very little, and depends entirely on
the completion of the work.
July 1, 1885, amount available .... .... .... .... ............-.........         . $107, 902 46
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabili-
  ties outstanding July 1,1885.... ....-----.. ....-....-                 .. ....    105, 256 10
July 1, 1886, amount available ........................................               2, 646 36
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886 .................                198,750 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887.................             201,396 36

 (Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project ...... 2, 298, 604 00
I Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June
    30,1888----......---- ----------------------- .    -----................ 500, 000 00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
  (See Appendix R 13.)
  14. Sabine River, Louisiana and Texas.-At the commencement of the
improvement of the river there was a depth of 3) feet on the bar at its
mouth, and also above the town of Orange. Logs, snags, &c., above here
interfered with navigation.
  In 1880 a channel 6 feet deep, 70 to 100 feet wide, was dredged through
the bar. In 1881 several small cuts to avoid bends obstructed with
logs were made above Orange. No work has been done since that date
to June 30, 1885. Sixteen thousand five hundred dollars have been
spent on the improvement of the river.
  The dredged channel over the bar is somewhat obstructed by logs,
but the depth is sufficient for present demands of navigation and com-
merce.
  No material increase of commerce or navigation has resulted from
the improvement made.
  No work was done during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1886, and
no appropriation is asked for the next fiscal year.
  This river is not susceptible of permanent improvement.
July 1, 1885, amount available............................................ $4,546 56
July 1, 1886, amount available .........------------------..............----------
                                                                            4,546 56
   (See Appendix R 14.)
  15. Neches River, Texas.-Before improvement of this river the bar
at its mouth had 3 feet depth of water, and between Yellow Bluff and
Bevilport navigation was interfered with by snags and fallen trees.
                    RIVER AND HARBOR      IMPROVEMENTS.                      223
   In 1879 a channel was dredged at the mouth of the river 5 feet deep
and from 30 to 60 feet in width. In 1881 obstructions between Yellow
Bluff and Bevilport were removed; $20,892.43 was expended in this im-
provement to June 30, 1881. During the past fiscal year the bar at
mouth of river has been again surveyed, and shows a least depth of
3J feet. To again deepen this channel to 5 feet would require the re-
moval of 56,590 cubic yards of material, at an estimated cost of $16,977.
   Conditionof the improvement.--The depth of water on the bar at present
seems to be ample to accommodate the limited commerce passing over it.
Only one steamer uses it, and that only in doing Government work at
Sabine Pass.
   Sail-vessels cannot use the river below Beaumont without tow-boats,
and there are no tow-boats in this stretch of river. This river is not
susceptible to permanent improvement, and until commerce increases
it is not deemed advisable at present to expend more money upon it.
   No appropriation is asked for the next fiscal year.
July 1, 1285, amount available-.- .....   ..      .....
                                               .------                 $11,667 84
July 1, 1886, amount available ..                         .....-....    11, 667 84
  (See Appendix R 15.)
  16. Removal of sunken vessels or craft obstructing or endangering navi-
gation.-Removal of wreck in harbor of New Orleans, Louisiana.-After
due advertisement a contract was made in 1884 for the removal of the
wrecks of the steamships Gresham, Ailsa, and General Grant. The
work was satisfactorily completed in December, 1885.
  Amount expended during fiscal year ending June 30, 1886, $28,117.
  (See Appendix R 16.)

IMPROVEMENT OF RIVERS AND HARBORS IN                 THE STATE OF TEXAS.

   Officer in charge, Major S. M. Mansfield, Corps of Engineers.
   1. Entrance to Galveston Harbor, Texas.-The report of the Board of
Engineers for Fortifications and for River and Harbor Improvements,
mentioned in the last annual report, is appended to the report of the
officer in charge, and will be found in Appendix S 1, herewith.
   The Board estimates the amount required to carry completed jetties
to the crest of the bar, with a view to obtaining a depth of 16 to 20 feet
for navigation, at $3,000,000; to extend the jetties to the 30-foot curve,
to obtain a 25 or 30 foot channel, $4,000,000 additional; total estimated
to complete improvement, $7,000,000, providing the money is freely
supplied.
   The plan is in continuance of the project of 1880, and is designed to
concentrate the outfiowing currents upon a certain extent of bar to effect
its removal and increase the depth of bar channel.
   The amount expended prior to June 30, 1885, was $1,576,337.12 (in-
cluding $100,000 of Galveston City funds), and was applied to works of
improvement under the projects of 1874 and 1880.
   The amount expended during fiscal year 1885-'86, $1,565.90, was ap-
plied to the examination, &c., of south jetty, required by the Board of
Engineers.
   The estimated amount required for the entire and permanent comple-
tion of the work of improvement, in accordance with the project of 1886,
is $6,700,000.
  One million dollars can be profitably expended in the fiscal year end-
ing June 30, 1888, in jetty construction.
224         REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

July 1, 1885, amount available. -----............ -             ---......................                               $1, 662 88
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
                                                                      ..... $1, 565 90
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1885 .............---------------------....
July 1, 1886, outstanding liabilities .........................                        84 78
                                                                                                                         -, 650 68

July 1, 1886, amount available---........ -----......
                                                 ....................                                            .           12 20
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886 .................                                                   300, 000 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887 .................                                                300,012 20
  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project...... 6, 700, 000 00
  Amoun; that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June
   30, 1888-----.....-------..........----....------....----...----.........------.......-----....--.....--------- 1,000, 000 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix S 1.)
   2. Ship-channel in Galveston Bay, Texas.-The project of 1871 (modi-
fied in 1877) proposed the deepening and widening of the channel from
the head of Bolivar Channel to the cut through Morgan's Point, to afford
a channel of 12 feet depth at mean low tide, with a width at bottom of
100 feet. The natural channel had a depth of not more than 7 feet in
the shoalest places.
  The amount expended to June 30, 1886, $286,629.50, secured a navi-
gable channel from the Gulf entrance to Morgan's Cut of 8.9 feet at
mean low tide.
  No work has been done since 1883, owing to the reserving of funds for
Congressional action at first, and then afterwards and to the present
time because of the provision in act of July 5, 1884, that the money in
hand should not be expended until the Secretary of War be satisfied
that the Buffalo Bayou Ship-Channel Company has relinquished or
abandoned to the United States forever all its franchises and any and
all right to collect or impose tolls or charges from any part of said ship-
channel or Buffalo Bayou.
July 1, 1885, amount available ................                             .......... ...........                   *$159, 870 50
July 1, 1886, amount available.......... ......                        ..........     : --...........                  159, 870 50
   (See Appendix S 2.)
   3. Trinity River, Texas.-The project of 1871 (modified in 1873) had
for its object the opening of the river to navigation so as to admit the
entrance of vessels drawing 5 feet.     At the mouth of the river the
natural channel was shoal (41 feet) and extremely narrow across the bar.
  The amount expended to and including June 30, 1886, $34,188.35,
gained a channel of entrance to the river by Middle Pass of 6 feet depth,
and opened the river to Liberty for vessels of 5-feet draught. The im-
provement is, however, only temporary.                                     The balance of the estimate,
$14,541, is required to continue work, dredging, &c., as found necessary.
   The work is not susceptible of permanent completion.
July 1, 1885, amount available ..........----------.............. ....--   --..............                               $506 50
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885......................                ...............---  ........                               194 85
July 1, 1886, amount available ...............................                                          ......             311 65

  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project ........                                               14,541 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix S 3.)
  *The river and harbor act of August 5, 1886, directs that the balance on hand from
the money heretofore appropriated shall be expended in the Bompletion of this chan-
ael in accordance with the plans heretofore adopted,
                         RIVER AND HARBOR                    IMPROVEMENTS.                              225
   4. Buffalo Bayou, Texas.-The project of 1880 proposed the opening
up of the channel between Simm's and White Oak bayous for commer-
cial purposes. The original channel-way below Houston in 1880 was
navigable for vessels drawing 6 feet of water.
   The approved project carried an estimate of $385,299.75 for a chan-
nel 12 feet deep and 100 feet wide, clear of all obstructions to naviga-
tion between the points above named.
   The amount expended to June 30, 1886, $99,566.25, resulted in de-
veloping an improved channel in the bayou to an extent much appre-
ciated by the commerce thereon. The work done was that of deepening
and widening the shoalest and narrowest places and clearing the stream
of stumps, sunken logs, &c. One hundred thousand dollars can be
profitably expended in the fiscal year ending June 30,1888, in enlarging
the present channel, to the advantage of commercial interests.
July 1, 1885, amount available......----.......... ..........................                       $4, 477 87
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885....       ...... ......    .
                                                    .....  ........ .............                    4,044 12
July 1, 1886, amount available .................... .....................                               433 75
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886 .................                                18, 750 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887 ..................                            19,183 75

  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1888 50, 000 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix S 4.)
   5. Channel over bar at mouth of Brazos River, Texas.-The project of
1880 has for its object the maintenance of a good navigable channel
across the bar; the natural channel afforded a depth of not over 8 feet,
being subject to changes due to winds, tide, and stages of water in the
river.
   The amount expended to June 30, 1886, $139,783.47, has been applied
to constructing jetties. The resulting effect of the work has been the
holding of a channel across the bar sufficient in every way for the re-
quirements of the port's navigation and commerce. The work in place
is not sufficient in extent to realize permanent results so far. One hun.
dred thousand dollars can be profitably expended in the fiscal year end-
ing June 30, 1888, in continuing jetty construction.
July 1, 1885, amount available..-..----....-...             .....--- ...................              $345 53
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
                           ............------------...........---------------..........----------
  outstanding July 1, 1885------                                                                       129 00
July 1, 1886, amount available-...... . --.............................                                 216 53
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886 ...................                              18, 750 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887 ...............                               18, 966 53
  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project........ 364,000 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1888
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
                                                                             000 00                 90,
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix S 5.)
  6. Pass Cavallo Inlet to MlatagordaBay, Texas.-The project of 1879
proposes the obtaining of a channel of 12 feet depth across the bar, and
the protection of the head of Matagorda Island.
  The amount expended to June 30, 1886, $287,965.12, has been applied
to constructing a jetty on the south side of the pass entrance, and has
      15 E
226         REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

resulted in making a marked improvement in depth,of channel across
the bar, and giving the channel permanency of position in a direction
more suitable for navigation.
  One hundred thousand dollars can be profitably expended in the fiscal
year ending June 30, 1888, in continuing jetty construction, extending
and raising the south jetty in accordance with approved plan.
July 1, 1885, amount available .---....---............------------------...........----...--.....-----.... $22, 183 05
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885.............. ................................                                   20,148 17
July 1, 1886, amount available ...... -..---.----..... ...--..-..-...---..------........                    2, 034 88
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886 ...............-------                       ...        37, 500 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887 .................-                              .    39,534 88
  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project.----.--                                  711,780 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1888 100, 000 00
  Submitted in comnpliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
    (See Appendix S 6.)
   7. Aransas Pass and Bay up to Rockport and Corpus Christi, Texas.-
The project of 1879 has for its object the maintenance of a 12-foot chan-
nel, at mean low water, over the bar, and the protection of the head of
Mustang Island up to and beyond Turtle Cove.
   The amount expended to June 30, 1886, $386,939.03 (including
$9,938.93 of the fund subscribed by private parties), has been applied
to protecting by groins the head of Mustang Island up to and above
Turtle Cove, in conjunction with a brush and stone revetment along the
channel-face of the island, and the partial construction of a jetty on the
south side of the channel. The effect of this work has resulted in a per-
manent channel across the bar, wherein is afforded a depth of 11 feet
for navigation and commerce. During 1880, in an ever-shifting channel,
there was a depth available across this bar of but 5 to 51 feet. This
just prior to beginning of work here by the Government.
   The officer in charge renews his recommendation for sufficient funds
to continue the improvements so as to accommodate shipping up to the
wharves at Rockport and Corpus Christi at an early date.
   He estimates that $600,000 can be very profitably expended in the
fiscal year ending June 30, 1888, in constructing jetty at the pass and
improving interior channels.
                                        --
July 1, 1885, amount available.............       ......---...--------     .
                                                                        ----.     ....---- $6, 913 11
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885...... ......    .... ......           ......   ..  ....          3, 913 21
July 1, 1886, amount available .......................................                                      2, 999 90
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5,1886....................                                     101,250 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887 ....................                                104,249 90
  SAmount (estimated) required for completion of existing project-----
                                                                 ......--. 719,472 00
   Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1888 100, 000 00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
  (See Appendix S 7.)
  8. lHarbor at Brazos Santiago, Texas.-The project of 1881 (only partly
adopted) proposed the deepening of the channel across the bar and the
maintenance of a suitable harbor inside the pass.
  The depth of water over the bar, maintained by natural causes alone,
was 7) feet.
  The amount expended to June 30, 1886, $184,148.72, has been applied
to constructing a jetty on the south side of the entrance channel, and
                          RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                     227
has resulted in maintaining a better channel than that afforded by nat-
ural causes alone.
  One hundred thousand dollars can be profitably expended in the fiscal
year ending June 30, 1888, in constructing the works originally esti-
mated for.
July 1, 1885, amount available...... ....................................                                  $851 28
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885.---....--...-----------................................                          515 00

July 1, 1886, amount available-.... ............ .......- ....... ....... .                                 336 28
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886................---.                                   37,500 00

Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887..                              ...........----..   37,836 28

 (Amount   (estimated) required for completion of existing project-....     455, 500 00
   Amount that can be profitably expendedin fiscal year ending June 30,1888 100, 000 00
   Submitted in comprliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
      harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix S 8.)
   9. Protection of river bank at Fort Brown, Texas.-This work was de-
signed to arrest the progress of encroachment which threatens not only
to destroy the most valuable buildings at the post, but to break through
into the lagoon, which would entirely change the channel of the river,
and leave the greater portion of the post on the opposite side of the
channel.
   The amount expended to June 30, 1886, is $16,996.46. The results
attained have not been commensurate with the expenditure, and it has
been considered best not to attempt to control the Rio Grande at this
point by artificial works, and that it would be more expedient to move,
from time to time, such of the buildings as may be in actual danger.
   No further appropriation for this work is recommended.
July 1, 1885, amount available ......................                     ................               $1, 003 54
July 1, 1886, amount available.......           ................................                          1,003 54
    (See Appendix S 9.)
IMPROVEMENT OF RED RIVER AND OF CERTAIN RIVERS IN THE
  STATES OF LOUISIANA, MISSISSIPPI, AND TENNESSEE, TRIBUTARY
  TO THE MISSISSIPPI--WATER-GAUGES    ON THE MISSISSIPPI AND
  PRINCIPAL TRIBUTARIES.

  Officer in charge, Capt. Eric Bergland, Corps of Engineers.
  1. Red River, Louisiana and Arkansas.-The present improvement of
the river was begun in 18?2. At that time navigation above Shreve-
port, La., was almost impossible, on account of the great raft. Low-
water navigation between Shreveport and Grand Ecore, La., was seri-
ously affected by the gradual enlargement of the Tone's Bayou outlet,
which depleted the main channel of the river below without giving
another navigable route. The entire river from Fulton, Ark., to its
mouth, was greatly obstructed by snags, logs, wrecks, leaning trees,
and similar obstructions; and the navigable channel at Alexandria
was insufficient for the demands of commerce.
   The project has contemplated removal of the great raft, the closure of
Tone's Bayou, the removal of snags and other obstructions, the opening
of a channel through the falls at Alexandria, and deepening the water
over shoal places.
  The work from 1872 to the end of the fiscal year 1884-'85 had greatly
benefited navigation and commerce. The great raft had been removed
228       REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

and about 150 miles of river above Shreveport opened to navigation.
By means of snag-boats and shore-parties numerous obstructions were
removed, the raft kept from re-forming, and the river kept open from
Fulton, Ark., to its mouth, being navigable between those points almost
the entire year. Several ineffectual attempts bad been made to close
Tone's Bayou, but nothing has been done since early in 1882, when the
dam then in process of construction was destroyed. The work of exca-
vation at the falls of Alexandria was let by contract October 14, 1882,
but had progressed slowly up to this time. The work of protecting the
harbor at Alexandria, by means of a wing-dam and training-wall, was
well under way when stopped by high water in December, 1884.
   During the fiscal year, the channel excavation through the upper
falls at Alexandria was resumed by the contractor August 20, and con-
tinued until November 25, when, the cut being practically completed,
the contract was closed, a total of 7,630; cubic yards of rock having
been removed by the contractor. Many boats have passed through the
cutat low stages of water, since work was discontinued, without experi-
encing any difficulty or meeting any obstructions. The rock and debris
excavated at the upper falls were deposited in the dam at the lower
falls, which sufficed to close the c.hannel along the west shore and has
changed the direction of the current from the west to the east shore;
resulting in an almost total cessation of erosion of the west bank and
the removal of the extensive sand-bar along the east bank. The work
for the protection of Alexandria Harbor was completed according to
the project, as far as the funds available would permit-the training-
wall being somewhat shorter than projected, because the site had scoured
out to a greater depth than when the estimates were submitted. This
work, in connection with the dam at the lower falls, has been of some
benefit to the river bank at Alexandria; but little caving having taken
place during the fiscal year, which little was due to a stratum of quick-
sand causing a sloughing of the bank when the water falls. No work
has been done for the general improvement of the river, as the balance
available was not sufficient.
   The amount expended to June 30, 1886, is $725,049.10.
   The amount estimated for can be profitably expended in continuing
the removal of obstructions by snag-boats and shore-parties, completing
the improvement at the falls at Alexandria, and extending the work for
the protection of the harbor at Alexandria.
   It is of great importance that the survey of Red River, from Fulton,
Ark., to the mouth, be made, the estimate cost of which is $45,000. This
survey, which was included in the examinations and surveys provided
for in river and harbor act of August 2, 1882, but not undertaken for
want of funds, would be of the utmost importance in determining fu-
ture methods of improving the river.
   No estimate for the permanent improvement of the river can be pre-
sented, as new obstructions are continually added by caving banks, &c.,
and each flood brings down large quantities of drift from the upper river,
the removal of which requires that the work be carried on from year to
year in order to keep the river open to navigation.
July 1, 1885, amount available.....         .        ... ........ ."......       $12, 972 33
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885 ...............................            ..........  11, 021 43
July 1, 1886, amount available ....................      ....................      1,950 90
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886.. -.............              75,000 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887.................           76,950 90
                   RIVER AND HARBOR            IMPROVEMENTS.                     229
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1888$100,000 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
  harbor actsof 1866 and 1867.
  (See Appendix T 1.)
   2. Survey of Bayou Pierre, Louisiana.-Thiswas directed by river and
harbor act of July 5, 1884, the object being to ascertain the advisabil-
ity and cost of opening a navigable channel from Red River through
Tone's Bayou and Bayou Pierre, to the point where the waters of the
latter again join Red River.
   The survey was begun in October, 1884, but owing to several unfore-
seen circumstances, which combined to make the cost exceed the orig.
inal estimates, the amount appropriated was not sufficient for its com-
pletion. It is about two-thirds completed, and the remaining field work
can probably be accomplished in about six weeks. No estimate of the
cost of opening the Bayou Pierre route to navigation can be submitted
until the completion of this survey.
   It is of great importance that the survey be completed as contem-
plated, in order that the question of advisability and cost of opening
this route to navigation may be definitely settled. The cost of com-
pleting the survey is estimated at $5,000.
July 1, 1885, amount available ...... ........................    ...........
                                                                          .     663 85
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1685 ................................... .. ... ..        525 80
July 1, 1886, amount available .   ......... .......   .. ............
                                                                  .........     138 05
   NOTE.--The river and harbor act of August 5, 1886, appropriates for
the completion of this survey.
   (See Appendix T 2.)
   3. Cypress Bayou, Texas and Louisiana.--This improvement included
the whole navigable channel from Shreveport, La., to Jefferson, Tex.,
via Sodo and Fairy lakes and Cypress Bayou.
   The first project consisted in cutting and dredging a good high-water
channel from Jefferson, Tex., to Red River, and was completed in 1880.
   The second project contemplated constructing a dam across the lake
at Albany Point, and making a cut through to Red River, at an esti-
mated cost of $372,580, recommending that the funds be made availa-
ble in one appropriation to successfully execute the work. No funds
have been appropriated for this project.
   The river and harbor act of July 5, 1884, directed a resurvey, to as.
certain if the improvement could not be made upon some other plan than
the above. With the small balance available only an examination could
be made, and the report thereon recommended that the improvement
be confined to strengthening and marking the present channel, cutting
stumps therefrom, and reopening the cuts by dredging, which it is be-
lieved will secure safe navigation to Jefferson during seven or eight
months of the year. The cost of this improvement is estimated at
$18,000.
  In order to complete the work according to the above project it is im-
portant that the whole amount be made available in one appropriation.
  The amount expended to June 30, 1886, is $94,000.
July 1, 1885, amount available. ........................--------------------.......
                                                                              $31 15
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885 ...---........................--....- .........     31 15
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886....................     18,000 00
  (See Appendix T 3.)
230         REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

   4. Cane River, Louisiana.-The only appropriation for this work was
made by river and harbor act of July 5, 1884 ($2,500). The amount
expended to June 30, 1886, was $2,425.31, and has resulted in freeing
the channel of obstructions to a great extent, increased the depth of
water during the navigable season, and enabled steamboats to make
quicker trips. No work was done during the year.
   This stream being an arm or high-water channel of Red River, ex-
tending from a point 2 miles below Grand Ecore, where it leaves the
main stream, to Colfax, La., where it re-enters, it is recommended that
appropriations for future improvement be included in those for Red
River, in which case necessary work can be done when and where the
interests of navigation may require it.
July 1, 1885, amount available .........................................                     $149 69
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885 .......................                       ...................   75 00
July 1, 1886, amount available........ .................................                              74 69
   (See Appendix T 4.)
   5. Loggy Bayou, Lake Bistenau, and the Dorcheat, Louisiana.-The
only appropriation for this improvement ($5,000) was made by river and
harbor act approved July 5, 1884. The amount expended to June 30,
1886, was $4,908.21, which was applied to the removal of snags, logs,
stumps, leaning trees, and brush obstructing navigation; and sign-
boards, indicating the cleared channel were set up in Lake Bistenau.
This work gave increased facilities for navigation, and the navigable
depth in many places was increased fully 3 feet. No work was done
during the year.
   The commerce of these streams has been greatly diminished by rail-
road connection with the principal shipping point, and it is doubtful
whether the great expenditure necessary to lengthen the navigable
season would be justified, hence no appropriation is asked for the next
fiscal year.
July 1, 1885, amount available. ............. ................ ........ ....                        $431 79
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885....--                 -   -   -..........................          ...    340 00

July 1, 1886, amount available.....              -----------.                   ..     ...   ...      91 79
  (See Appendix T 5.)
  6. Ouachita and Black rivers, Arkansas and Louisiana.-The improve-
ment of Ouachita River was begun in 187i.      Black River, being the con-
necting link between Ouachita and Red rivers, was added under the
same head of appropriation by the river and harbor act of 1884. The
original project contemplated the construction of a series of locks in
the Ouachita River for slackwater navigation, but, on account of the
great cost and doubtful utility of the work, was abandoned in 1874, and
the present project adopted. This contemplates the removal of wrecks,
logs, snags, leaning trees, &c., obstructing navigation, and the improve-
ment of shoal places between Camden, Ark., and the mouth of Black
River.
  The amount expended under present project to June 30, 1886, includ-
ing cost of iron-hull snag-boat and outfit, was $176,320.07, which has
greatly benefited navigation by the removal of obstructions, and an in-
creased depth of from 12 inches to over 3 feet has been gained at some
of the shoal places. Previous to improvement boats plied between New
Orleans and Camden about half the year. These boats now run to
                          RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                   231
Camden from seven to eight months in the year, and the smaller ones
ascend the river as high as Monroe, La., during the entire year.
   No work was done during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1886.
   The amount asked for the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888, can be
profitably expended in continuing the removal of obstructions from the
channel and banks of the streams, and building and repairing wing.
dams where necessary.
  No estimate for permanent improvement can be submitted, as the ob-
structions are continually forming and require removal from time to
time.
July 1, 1885, amount available.......................................                      $1, 190 81
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885............................                .......--. .....----- 1, 098 75
July 1, 1886, amount available--..---------------.................--...................----            92      06
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886 -.................                                  17, 500 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887 ...................                              17, 592 06
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1888 20, 000 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
     harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix T 6.)
   7. Bayou Bartholomew, Louisiana and Arkansas.--This stream is navi-
gable only during high stages of water in Ouachita River, of which it
is a tributary. The improvement was begun in 1881. the project con-
templating the removal of wrecks, snags, overhanging timber, &c., ob-
structing navigation between Baxter, Ark., and the mouth, a distance
estimated at 213 miles, at a cost of $26,862.
   The amount expended to June 30, 1886, was $17,978.82, and has greatly
benefited navigation and lessened the dangers thereof, enabling boats
to run regularly to Baxter during high water. No work was done dur-
ing the year.
   The appropriation asked for the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888, can
be profitably expended in continuing the removal of obstructions from
the channel and banks as heretofore.
   No permanent improvement can be effected, as new obstructions are
continually forming, which require removal from time to time in the
interests of safe navigation.
July 1, 1885, amount available-------
                                  ......--...     ......--------..-----....---.....------.....--....     $248 68
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885............      ..... .................................                       227 50
July 1, 1886, amount available.......................                        ...............               21 18
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886 ......................                               5,000 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887                           ................... 5,021 18
   Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1888                            5,000 00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix T 7.)
   8. Bayou Bceuf, Louisiana.--Thisbayou is navigable only during high
water. The project for its improvement was adopted in 1880, and con-
templated the removal of snags, logs, leaning timber, &c., obstructing
navigation between Wallace's Landing, La., and its mouth, a distance
of 280 miles, at an estimated cost of $20,000. An examination of three
outlets of this bayou, near Point Jefferson, La., was made in 1884, and
their closure recommended at an additional cost of $8,500.
232       REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

  The amount expended to June 30, 1886, was $14,995.68, which has
given increased facilities to navigation by the removal of obstructions,
and enabled boats to run during high water to Point Jefferson, 19 miles
below Wallace's Landing. No work was done during the year.
  The amount asked for the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888, can be
profitably expended in continuing the removal of obstructions to high-
water navigation ($5,000), and in closing the outlets near Point Jeffer-
son ($8,500).
  No permanent improvement can be secured, as new obstructions are
added from time to time, which will require removal in the interests of
safe navigation.
July 1, 1885, amount available .........        ..... ..... ...... ...... ......                       $124 32
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885 .............. ...... ...... ................        .                        120 00
July 1, 1886, amount available.... ............. ....... ..... ...........                                4 32
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886...................                                 5,000 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887 -..                      ......---   ----........ 5, 004 32
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1888                           8,500 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix T 8.)
   9. Tensas River and Bayou llacon, Louisiana.-The project for the
improvement of Tensas River was adopted in 1881, and contemplated
the removal of snags, logs, leaning timber, &c., obstructing navigation,
from Dallas, La., to its mouth, about 180 miles, at an estimated cost of
$23,000.    Bayou Macon, a tributary of the Tensas, was added under
the same head of appropriation by the river and harbor act of 1884, and
the project contemplates the removal of obstructions, of the same class
as in the Tensas, at an estimated cost of $17,000.    No work has been
done in the latter stream, as the amount appropriated was insufficient
for the improvement of both.
   The amount expended to June 30, 1886, was $7,000, which was ap-
plied to the improvement of Tensas River, and has benefited naviga-
tion by the removal of obstructions as far as practicable with that
amount. No work was done during the year.
   With the appropriation asked for the fiscal year ending June 30,1888,
it is proposed to continue the removal of obstructions from the channel
and banks as heretofore.
   If the entire amount estimated for be granted, work can be prose-
cuted in both streams.
   The work is not permanent, as new obstructions are added from time
to time, which will require removal in the interests of safe navigation.
July 1, 1885, amount available ....      --.................................                             $15 34
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885.............. ...... ........ ...................                             15 34
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886 ......         - ...........                       4,000 00
SAmount   that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1888
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
                                                                                                     10, 000 00
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
  (See Appendix T 9.)
  10. Bayou D'Arbonne, Louisiana.-Like the other tributaries of Oua-
chita River, this bayou is only navigable during high stages of water
in the main stream. The project for its improvement was adopted in
1884, and contemplates the removal of snags, logs, wrecks, leaning trees,
                            RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                            233
&c., obstructing navigation from Stein's Bluff to its mouth, 421 miles
at an estimated cost of $15,000.
   The amount expended to June 30, 1886, was $4,974.07, which has re-
sulted in the removal of obstructions from about one-half of that part of
the stream in which improvement is contemplated by the present proj-
ect, and consequently has improved high-water navigation and lessened
the danger thereof. No work was done during the year.
   With the amount asked for the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888, it is
proposed to continue the removal of obstructions to high-water naviga-
tion according to the project.
   The work is not permanent, as new obstructions are added from time
to time, which will require removal in the interests of safe navigation.
July 1, 1885, amount available....--..---..............--------------............-------------......---....----     $130 59
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885-----..----.....           ---................. ....             ...........               104 66

July 1, 1886, amount available...---------------..............................                                         25 93
Amount appropriated by act approved August 1886..--................   b,                                           2, 000 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887....................                                          2,025 93
   Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project........                                         10, 000 00
   Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1888                                      5, 000 00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix T 10.)
  11. Yazoo River, Mississippi.-Work in this river was begun in 1873
by removing the wrecks of eleven steamboats sunk during the late war.
The project for its improvement contemplates the removal of wrecks,
logs, snags, overhanging trees, &c., which obstruct the channel through-
out the entire length of the stream. No permanent improvement can
be effected, as each flood brings new obstructions into the river, and
others are continually added by caving banks, &c. These require re-
moval from time to time to render navigation safe.
  The amount expended to June 30, 1886, was $142,998.53, and has re-
sulted in a marked benefit to commerce and improvement of the navi-
gable channel. The large number of wrecks and natural obstructions
which had limited the navigation of the stream had been removed to
such an extent that the river was navigable from its head to its mouth
during the entire year, and steamboats made regular trips without much
difficulty.
  No work was done during the year.
  The amount asked for the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888, can be
profitably expended in continuing the removal of obstructions from the
channel and banks of the river by means of the snag-boat and shore
parties.
July 1, 1885, amount available ......................................                          $1,246 47
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885------....----......----........----....---......-----....--........  1,245 00
July 1, 1886, amount available..-----..----..................................                                           1 47
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886...-----------------..........                                  15, 000 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887---------.......---------........                            15,001 47
   Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1888                                      20, 000 00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
     harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix T 11.)
234         REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

   12. Big Sunflower River, Mississippi.-The project for improving this
stream was adopted in 1879, and contemplated building wing-dams to
scour a channel of from 3 feet to 40 inches over the bars, and the removal
of snags, sunken logs, and leaning timber obstructing navigation, at an
estimated cost of $66,000.
   The amount expended to June 30, 1886, was $42,000, and has resulted
in a marked benefit to commerce and navigation by the removal of ob-
structions and the increased depth of water of from 18 inches to 3. feet
gained over the bars where dams have been built.
   Steamboatmen state that in 1879 it took from ten to fifteen days to
make a trip, which now can be accomplished without difficulty in six
days at the lowest stages of water.
   No work was done during the year.
   With the amount asked for the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888, it is
proposed to continue the removal of obstructions from the channel and
banks, and the construction and repair of wing-dams where necessary.
July 1, 1885, amount available ................... .... .... ........... $45 38
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885 .............. ..............  ................                                  45 38
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886...................                                    5,000 00
 (Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project........ 19,000 00
J Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1888 10,000 00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
 ( harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix T 12.)
   13. Tchula Lake, Mississippi.-The project for this improvement was
adopted in 1881, and contemplated the removal of snags, logs, over-
hanging trees, &c., obstructing navigation, to enable light-draught
steamboats to enter the lake earlier in the season. The estimated cost
of this improvement was $10,000.
   The amount expended to June 30, 1886, was $6,846.76, which has re-
sulted in improving the channel and lengthening the navigable season.
Much work, however, remains to be done, and new obstructions are
continually forming which require removal from time to time. Con-
sequently the improvement cannot be permanent.
   No work was done during the fiscal year.
   With the amount asked for the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888, it is
proposed to continue the removal of obstructions from the channel and
banks as heretofore. As this stream is really the easterly branch of
Yazoo River, extending from the head to foot of Honey Island, about
67 miles in length, it is recommended that future appropriations for its
improvement be included in the general appropriation for Yazoo River.
July 1, 1885, amount available ..................................--------------------------..--------.    $425 84
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885..------------------------------------------                                     272 60
July 1, 1886, amount available......-----...... ---......---.......            .........---....            153 24
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886...... ....                            ..........      2, 000 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887...... .............                                2, 153 24
SAmount that can be profitably expended in fiscalyear ending June 30,1888                               5,000 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
  (See Appendix T 13.)
  14. Tallahatchee River, Mississippi.-This improvement was begun in
1879. The project contemplated the removal of snags, sunken logs,
                   RIVER      AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                              235
and overhanging timber obstructing low-water navigation below the
mouth of Coldwater River, a distance of 165 miles, and also removal of
the wreck of the steamer Star of the West, lying in the channel 8 miles
above the mouth. The estimated cost of such improvement was $40,000.
The river and harbor acts of 1880, 1881, and 1882, however, required
the expenditure of funds above mouth of Coldwater to Batesville, Miss.,
and $10,000 has been expended in removing obstructions from that part
of the stream.
   The amount expended to June 30, 1886, was $24,000 (of which amount
$14,000 had been expended in the lower river), and has resulted in the
removal of a large number of obstructions, greatly increasing the ca-
pacity of the river for navigation. Previous to improvement the river
from the mouth of the Coldwater to the Yazoo was navigable about
six months of the year. Boats from Yazoo now run to Sharkey's Land-
ing, 100 miles above the mouth, the entire year, but seldom go above
that point at any stage of water, as the amount of commerce higher
up the river is not sufficient to justify the expense of a longer trip.
   No work was done during the year.
   If the entire amount asked for is appropriated for the fiscal year end-
ing June 30, 1888, the work can be.carried on in both sections of the
river. Should a smaller amount be appropriated, the interests of navi-
gation would be best promoted by continuing the removal of obstruc-
tions from the lower river according to the project.
   New obstructions, caused by sliding and caving banks, are continually
forming, and no permanent improvement can be effected on this account.
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886...................          $3, 500 00

  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project-........      22,500 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1888   10, 000 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix T 14.)
   15. Yallabusha River, Mississippi.-This improvement was begun in
1881. The project contemplated the removal of snags, sunken logs, lean-
ing timber, &c., obstructing navigation from Grenada, Miss., to its mouth,
a distance of about 63 miles. New obstructions, caused by caving
banks, &c., are continually forming, and require removal from time to
time in the interests of safe navigation. Consequently no estimate for
permanent improvement can be submitted.
   The amount expended to June 30, 1886, was $9,000; the removal of
obstructions hay resulted in a greatly improved channel, and the river
is now navigable from five to six months of the year, or during high
and medium stages of water.
   No work was done during the year.
   The amount asked for the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888, can be
profitably expended in removing obstructions from the channel and
banks, as heretofore, for the purpose of extending the period of naviga-
tion.
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886 ...---............          $2, 000 00

  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1888    5, 000 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix T 15.)
  16. Steele's Bayou, Mississippi.-The only appropriation for this im-
provement was made by river and harbor act of 1884. The project con-
236        REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

templates the removal of snags, logs, stumps, overhanging trees, &e.,
obstructing high-water navigation.
  The amount expended to June 30, 1886, was $2,494.74, and the ob-
structions removed have benefited high-water navigation to a great
extent, and lessened the danger thereof. However, much remains to be
done before navigation at medium stages can become practicable and
profitable. No work was done during the year.
  With the amount asked for the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888, it is
proposed to continue the removal of obstructions from the channel and
banks.
July 1, 1885, amount available ............... ........          ...
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
                                                                                -..............     $125 26
  outstanding July 1, 1885 ................          ......................... -                      120 00
July 1, 1886, amount available ..            ...... .................................                   5 26
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886.....................                             2, 500 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887....................                           2,505 26
SAmount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1888                        5, 000 00,
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix T 16,)
  17. Big Black River, Mississippi.-The only appropriation for improv-
ing this stream was made by river and harbor act of 1884. The project.
contemplates removal of snags, logs, wrecks, and overhanging trees
obstructing navigation between the mouth and Cox's Ferry, 130 miles
above, at an estimated cost of $32,000. This improvement would not
be permanent, as new obstructions are added from time to time.
   The amount expended to June 30, 1886, was $4,741.62, resulting in
the removal of the principal obstructions from the channel and banks
for a distance of 751 miles up stream from the mouth.
   No work was done during the year.
  Two railroad and two highway bridges form obstructions to free and
safe navigation at all stages of water. Until these are remedied it is
recommended that no additional appropriations be made.
July 1, 1885, amount available....................---...---...-- --
                                                                 -...-.......----------              $879 73
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885_      ...........................     .................                    621 35,
July 1, 1886, amount available ..-------..........................----
                                                               -----------------..........             258 38
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886--.--....---------------............              5, 000 00,
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887....................                           5,258 38
  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project -    22,250 00            ......
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
  (See Appendix T 17.)
  18. Big Hatchee River, Tennessee.-This improvement was begun iin
1880. The project contemplated removal of logs, snags, leaning tim-
ber, &c., obstructing navigation, from Bolivar, Tenn., to the mouth of
the river, about 240 miles, to render that portion of the stream navi-
gable for light-draught boats throughout the year. The estimated cost
of such improvement was $30,000. The improvement will not be per-
manent, as new obstructions form from time to time.
  The amount expended to June 30, 1886, was $18,766.56, and has re-
sulted in the removal of a large number of obstructions, and benefited
commerce by allowing shipment of products by river where previously
                          RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                      237
railroads had a monopoly of the carrying trade. Navigation was almost
impossible before this work was commenced.     No work was done dur-
ing the year.
   The amount asked for the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888, can be
profitably expended in continuing the removal of channel and bank ob-
structions, as heretofore.
July 1, 1885, amount available .........................................                   $788 99
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885.....................--------...............------.               555 55
July 1, 1886, amount available .................................----......                  233 44
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886...,..............                      3, 000 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887 .......-..                   ...   3, 233 44
  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project........                 8, 000 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1888             5, 000 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
     harbor acts of 1866 and 1867
   (See Appendix T 18.)
   19. South Forked Deer River, Tennessee.-This improvement was oe-
gun in 1883. The project contemplated removal of snags, logs, leaning
timber, and similar obstructions to navigation, from the mouth of the
stream to Sharon, about 114 miles above, atan estimated cost of $19,250.
Operations have, however, been extended to Jackson, the head of navi-
gation, 81 miles above Sharon. The work will not be permanent, as
some sbstructions are added from time to time.
   The amount expended to June 30, 1886, was $5,000, which resulted in
the removal of a large number of obstructions, principally overhanging
timber, and greatly increased facilities for navigation. No work was
done during the year.
   Two railway and five highway bridges, all without draws, a log-boom,
and a brush-dam form serious obstructions to the navigation of this
stream. While these remain the whole river cannot be made navigable
for steamboats, but that portion below the lower obstruction, about 100
miles above the mouth, and the reach from Bell's Depot to Jackson, about
60 miles, can be improved in the interests of steamboat navigation.
   With the amount asked for the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888, it is
proposed to continue the removal of natural obstructions from the chan-
nel and banks, below and above the artificial obstructions.
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886....................                   $5, 000 00

  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project             ........    14,250 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1888              5, 000 00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
    (See Appendix T 19.)
  20. Water-gauges on the Mississippt River and its principaltributaries.-
Observations were continued at all the guages, and repairs made as far
as practicable with the funds available.
  By joint resolution of Congress approved February 21,1871, the sum
of $5,000 was to be appropriated annually for these gauges. As no ap-
propriation was made for the past fiscal year, and the funds available
were insufficient to maintain all the gauges, the Mississippi River Com-
mission has paid the observers and made the necessary repairs at the
gauge-stations on the Mississippi River to prevent the suspension of
those important observations.
238          REPORT OF THE CHIEF                             OF ENGINEERS, U S. ARMY.

July 1, 1885, amount available ................ ....--...       ..        .--                                     $2, 117 53
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885.-...............    ..      ...... ...........     .                                    1,866 39
July 1, 1886, amount available.-------------.....------....----.... ......-----.....---..---...--.....--.            251 14

   Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1888                                       5, 000 00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix T 20.)

IMPROVEMENT OF ARKANSAS RIVER j OF RIVERS IN THIE STATE OF
  ARKANSAS, AND OF BLACK RIVER IN ARKANSAS AND MISSOURI.


   Officer in charge, Capt. I. S. Taber, Corps of Engineers.
   1. Removing obstructions in Arkansas River, Arkansas.-Priorto the
first improvements in 1833, shifting sand bars, numerous drift-piles, and
dangerous snags constituted the obstacles to navigation in the lower
reaches, and gravel and rock shoals, with a few snags and many over-
hanging trees, constituted those of the upper. Except for a few special
reaches, like the Fort Smith and Pine Bluff, the general plan of im-
provement has consisted in snagging operations, including the cutting
of overhanging trees, in building wing-dams to improve the shoals, and
in surveys looking to plans for its permanent improvement. The ap-
propriations to June 30, 1886, amount to $420,376.87. Of this there
had been expended to June 30, 1885, $340,214.35, resulting in great re-
lief to navigation. During the fiscal year ending June 30,1886, $6,321.11
were expended in the running expenses of two snag-boats, and in the
care of the same. Much of the excellent service rendered by these
boats in the fiscal year ending June 30, 1885, has been practically lost
by there being no appropriation for the year ending June 30, 1886.
Only about 30 days' work with one boat was done in the entire year, for
lack of funds, and on account of the rotten condition of the hull of the
light draught boat. This work being done at extreme low water gave
great relief to navigation, though entirely inadequate to meet the wants
of commerce.
July 1, 1885, amount available -.... .... ..........-....--..............         $7, 631 21
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885              ..........
                                              -...... ............-....--.- -....  6, 321 11
July 1, 1886, outstanding liabilities ..... ...................                                   $297       00
July 1, 1886, amount available                --....
                                            .............. .    ... -.....                            ....         1,310 10
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886.. .............                                                18, 750 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887 ....................                                        20, 060 10

   Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1888                                      50, 000 00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
     harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix U 1.)
   2. Arkansas River at Pine Bluff, Arkansas.-The reach of river which
lies in the vicinity of Pine Bluff, Ark., was in a very bad condition
prior to any attempts at improvement. At one point a cut-off was
threatened which would change the slope of the river from three-fourths
of a foot per mile to 4 feet per mile. At another point a bad bar inter-
fered with navigation at low water, and in the sharp bend in front of
                RIVER AND HARBOR        IMPROVEMENTS.                239
the town of Pine Bluff the river was eroding the banks with a rapidity
that threatened the town.
   The original project proposed: 1. To protect the river bank in front
of the town from further erosion; 2. To rectify the course of the river
in the bend above town, in order to remove a bar now existing there,
and also, by diminishing the curvature of the bend, to lessen the ten-
dency to excessive scour in front of Pine Bluff; and 3. To prevent the
formation of a cut-off then threatened across the peninsula opposite
Pine Bluff. The whole improvement to extend over 13 miles of river.
   Up to June 30, 1884, $67,287.14 had been expended with the above
objects in view; 3,900 feet of the town front, beginning at Brump's
Bayou, was revetted during 1881; 3,700 feet of Yell'sBend was revetted
the same year to prevent the cut-off, and a wire-curtain dike 1,110 feet
long was put in to affect the bar. In 1882, 3,000 feet more of Yell's Bend
was revetted, and in 1883 the old works were repaired; 3,000 feet of
bank in Yell's Bend was regraded, and 1,000 feet of high-water protec-
tion put in place. During the fiscal year ending June 30, 1884, little
was done except to care for plant. July 1, 1884, there remained of all
this work only the wire-curtain dike. This result was predicted by the
various engineers in charge, inasmuch as the works had to be left in
an unfinished state, owing to failure of funds. The works in Yell's
Bend had existed, however, long enough to delay the advance of the
river until changes above rendered the danger less imminent. The
wire-curtain dike did good service, and the bar was much improved.
The town, however, was left at the mercy of the river. During the high
water of the spring of 1884, the front was eroded in places 120 feet and
upward, and it was apparent that if something could not be done the
entire business portion of the town would have to move back or be
swept away.
   By act of July 5, 1884, $55,500 was appropriated for this work, and
of this $48,813.98 had been expended up to July 1, 1885, in such a man-
ner as to protect the entire front, except the last two blocks.
   These results were secured by plans differing radically from the orig-
Inal project. A dike was erected on a bar which was forming down-
stream. This dike was well provided with foot-mats and so deflected
the river that it eroded over 275 feet of the opposite bank, and cut out
a deep channel. A second dike was thrown in nearer the town, and this
checking the velocity, caused the river to lose its load, which being
dropped upon the layer of quicksand, kept it from being eroded, and
hence no caving occurred. Dikes were made very strong and built for
the peculiar action of alluvial streams. By using boxes filled with sand
instead of stone the dike was built at a reduced cost of $49,000, and
the balance remaining was held for contingencies.
   During the fiscal year ending June 30, 1886, two additional hurdle-
dikes were built to increase the deposit along the town front. Both old
and new works are in excellent condition and have produced greater
results than was expected. It appears now that nothing except care
in watching and checking any slight change in the river's regimen is
required to give security to the town.
   The engineer should have annually $8,000 as a contingent for this
entire reach until the permanent improvement of the river above has
been made. Two or three blocks at the lower end of the town are as
yet unprotected. This will be attended to with the amount appropri-
ated by act approved August 5, 1886.
240       REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

July 1, 1885, amount available..-        ----..          . ----..             ..             7, 073 13
Received by sale of fuel to officer...... ............              ................. ....      12 00

                                                                                             7, 085 13
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885_..................                     .   .
                                                                 ......    ......
                                                                      ......   ... .         4, 619 80
July 1, 1886, outstanding liabilities ..........................               $465 00

July 1, 1886, amount available.. -..                                               2,465 33
                                                  ......................----..........---.
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886 ...................                       8,000 00

Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887 ....................                   10,465 33
IAmount that can be profitably expendedin fiscal year ending June 30,1888
  Sumbitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
                                                                                             8, 000 00
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix U 2.)
  3. Black River, Arkansas and Missouri.-Before any improvements
were made upon this river its channel was choked with logs and snags
and obstructed by overhanging trees, and in many places shoals inter-
fered with its navigation at low water by any but very light-draught
boats. Its banks caved but little, and, except at the shoals, it was char-
acterized by greater depth of water than is found in streams generally
in its vicinity, due to its being narrow and its banks firm. The original
plan for its improvement contemplated the removal of the obstructions
and the improvement of the shoals, the latter by wing-dams. A few
sloughs were to be closed up so as to confine the water to the main chan-
nel.
   Up to June 30, 1885, $49,610.80 had been expended for these pur-
poses. This expenditure gave great relief to navigation at certain
places, but has proven inadequate to thoroughly open up the river.
There is a constantly increasing demand for navigation facilities.
   During the year ending June 30, 1886, nothing could be done but
care for the plant, the small balance on hand being inadequate even for
this. During the year $1,121.32 was expended for this purpose.
   An annual appropriation of from $8,000 to $10,000 will be required
to keep this river available for navigation.
July 1, 1885, amount available ...----.......--------..---....--------......------......--
                                                                       $1,624 10
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1,1885............ .. .. .................. ........-- -- -. $1,121 32
July 1, 1886, outstanding liabilities- ......---........
                                                      ........ $145 00
July 1, 1886, amount available ......----
                                        ......-----......----......         502 78
                                                     ------......---............
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886 ...................    5,000 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887..--                    .............    5, 502 78
  Amount that canbe profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1888                   10,000 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix U 3.)
   4. White River, Arkansas.--Prior to improvement this river was much
choked with drift-piles, logs, and snags in its lower portion, and from
Batesville up, gravel bars, rocky shoals, channel bowlders, and over-
hanging trees impeded navigation. The original adopted project con-
sisted in snagging operations and blasting of ledges and bowlders and
dam building to remove gravel bars or -to close chutes, from time to
time as appropriation warranted and commerce required.
   The first separate appropriation for this stream was made by act ap-
proved July 5,1884. At the time it was passed the river was in excellent
navigable condition for boats drawing not to exceed 3 feet of water, from
its mouth to Newport, Ark. From Newport to Batesville there were
                           RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                                  241
many troublesome snags, and from Batesville to Buffalo Shoals there
were numerous bad shoals, rendering navigation very uncertain. From
Buffalo Shoals to Forsythe, Mo., there were many fine reaches of river,
but the depth of water on Buffalo Shoals and others less dangerous pre.
vented any navigation at ordinary stages of water. The present project
provides that the appropriation of July 5, 1884, be applied to removing
snags and bowlders and other obstructions to navigation, building
wing-dams to improve shoals, repairs and care of plant, and survey of
the river, as provided for in the act, with a view to its improvement
from Forsythe, Mo., as far down as funds will admit. The survey was
begun early in May, 1885, and was in progress at close of last fiscal year.
Except when the interests of navigation required immediate improve-
ments, it was deemed best to do as little work as possible until the sur-
vey gave a better idea of where appropriations could be applied to best
advantage. The field work of the survey was completed in 1885. It
was pushed to Newport before funds were exhausted, 248 miles of river
survey having been made at a cost of $11,340 in round numbers, or
about $45 per mile. Estimate placed it at $80. Nearly double the dis-
tance was covered that the appropriation contemplated.
  During the fiscal year ending June 30, 1886, $18,670.79 was expended,
completing the survey as above and in removing obstructions at extreme
low water (the survey having shown just where work was most needed)
as high as Calico Rock, with some work on Buffalo Shoals in connection
with another appropriation, the balance to be used in carrying the works
from Calico Rock to Buffalo Shoals. This will give temporary relief
until money is available for the permanent improvement.
  There will be needed annually $10,000 to maintain this improved
channel until the survey is completed, for which $13,634 is required.
The recommendation that it be appropriated is renewed.
July 1, 1885, amount available.....-----.... .......----..-----                           ............------......   $26, 592 63
Received by sale of fuel to officer                       .................................                                15 00
                                                                                                                      26, 607 63
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
     outstanding July 1, 1885..--...--.........-------..-- ---......--....---.....----.                               18, 670 79

July 1, 1886, outstanding liabilities................                        ............ $276 43
July 1, 1886, amount available ....-----. ...-------............-----------..----...----......-----......              7,936 84
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886. ---......---.......                                               18, 000 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887................                                                25, 936.84
 [ Amount (estimated) annually required to maintain present channel....
1 Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1888
                                                                                                                     10,000 00
                                                                                                                     10, 000 00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
  (See Appendix U 4.)
  5. White River above Buffalo Shoals, Arkansas.-Before any work was
done on this particular reach the channel at low water was much choked
by logs. In many places large bowlders rendered navigation danger-
ous or impossible, and in others gravel and rock shoals existed which
held the water in pools. It was a reach to which lock and dam, or
movable dams, could only be applied with any permanent success for
low- water navigation.
  The first appropriation was $50,000 by act of June 23, 1874, and this
applied not only to this reach, but all the way from Jacksonport. This
was expended in removing logs and the most dangerous bowlders and
improving the shoals by wing-dams, but appears to have been more
largely expended below this reach.
           16 E
242        REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

  By act of August 14, 1876, $10,000 was appropriated for Buffalo
Shoals. The first separate appropriation for the river above this point
was by act of June 14, 1880, $20,000. It was then estimated that the
total cost of the improvement would be about $101,000, which was to
be largely used in improving shoal places. The next was by act of
August 2, 1882, $4,000. To July 1, 1885, $23,181.63 had been expended
from direct appropriations.
   This expenditure has relieved navigation very much, but was too
small in amount to cover only a few miles immediately above Buffalo
Shoals.
   During the year ending June 30, 1886, $818.37, the entire balance,
was expended at Buffalo Shoals in repairing the dams, in connection
with the general appropriation for the entire river.
July 1, 1885, amount available...................................                            ..   $818 37
Received by sale of fuel to officer.... ......................                 ........              6 00
                                                                                                    824 37
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885..............  .............................                             824 37
  (See Appendix U 5.)
  6. Saint Francis River, Arkansas.-The first separate appropriation
made for the entire river was made under the act approved July 5,
1884. The first appropriation of any kind was made in connection with
other rivers March 2, 1833, prior to which this river was choked with
drift-piles, logs, and snags, and its waters spread out through a great
variety of sloughs, while overhanging trees added to the difficulties of
navigation. The originally adopted project was principally for snag-
ging operations, and attempts have been made to close up some of the
many sloughs. Appropriations for this river having been united with
the White River and also with the Black River, exactly how much had
been expended upon the Saint Francis River to June 30, 1884, cannot
well be stated.
   July 1, 1885, the river was in an excellent navigable condition (at me-
dium stages) fromi its mouth as high as Wittsburg, Ark. During high
water boats have beei as high as Lester's Landing. From Lester's
Landing to Saint Francis the river was very badly choked with drift
and divided into many channels, thus cutting off a rapidly developing
section from all facilities of transportation.
   During the fiscal year ending June 30, 1886, the new outfit built the
year bef'ore, after surmounting obstacles almost defying its capacity,
worked through to Saint Francis, exhausting the funds, leaving a pas-
sable channel, and at once affording great relief to navigation, though
doing less than one-half the work urgently required.
   The recommendation that $8,000 be appropriated annually for this
river is renewed.
  Attention is invited to the extensive commerce awaiting the opening
of the river to navigation.
July 1, 1885, amount available ......      ............             _.....................        4, 537 42
Received by sale of fuel to officer ...........................             ...........                6 00
                                                                                                  4, 543 42
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885.........................     ..........................                4,479 05
July 1, 1886, amount available ..................... ........         ........... 64 37
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886. .................            8, 000 00
amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887.....................                        8,064 37
                     RIVER AND         1HARBOR               IMPROVEMENTS.                                         243
Amount that can be profitably expended infiscal year ending June 30,1888                                      $8,000 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
    harbor act of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix U 6.)
   7. Saline River, Arkansas.-Before improvement this river was ob-
structed by snags, logs, drift-piles, and overhanging trees, and by shoals.
The original plan for improvement contemplated the rendering of its
channel navigable as high as practicable or as commerce demanded by
the removal of these obstructions, and then further improvement of the
shoals if the commerce warranted.
  There was expended upon this river up to June 30, 1885, $20,951.70.
This has given much relief- to navigation, and has practically cleared
the river, so far as present navigation demands.
   During the fiscal year ending June 30, 1886, $404.56 has been ex-
pended in caring for the property.
   Until the requirements of commerce are greater than they are now it
is not recommended that any further appropriation be made. From
$5,000 to $6,000 per year would keep this river in a fair navigable con-
dition during medium stages of water for 250 miles from its mouth-
that is, up to Big Island--should it be required.
July 1, 1885, amount available ....          ....        .................................                 .     $568 30
Received by sale of fuel to officer             ................         ......---------....--------........        4 50
                                                                                                                  572 80
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885..............................................                                          404 56
July 1, 1886, outstanding liabilities ...-...................          $10 00
July 1, 1886, amount availalable...          ..-......         ... ...-.-.........                ....            168 24
   (See Appendix U 7.)
   8. L'Anguille River, Arkansas.--This river, like all the streams in
eastern and southeastern portions of Arkansas, before being improved
was obstructed by logs, snags, and overhanging trees, and the shoals
incident to the accumulation of snags and logs. The original plan of
improvement, begun in 1879, contemplated the removal of these ob-
stacles, and up to June 30,1885, $13,850.53 had been expended in such
a manner as to remove all obstructions to navigation at medium stages
of water, leaving a balance of $3,149.47.
   No plant in this district was adapted to the balance of the work re-
quired except the new hand snag-boat A. B. Johnson, built in 1885 for
the Saint Francis River work. It was deemed advisable to attempt no
work on this river until this boat was available. During the year end-
ing June 30, 1886, this boat became available from the exhaustion of
her own appropriations, and a beginning was made upon the final work
of improvement, $2,407.80 being expended. Continued high water pre-
vented the prosecution of the work to completion during that year. A
suitable stage of water is expected early in the present fiscal year, when
it is believed such thorough work may be done with the balance re-
maining that no further appropriation will be needed in many years.
July 1, 1885, amount available           .               .             ...                                     $3, 149 47
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885 ...-.-.        ....-.-.-.         . ............  ....                               2, 407 80
July 1, 1886, outstanding liabilities ......................          ...   $5 15
July 1, 1886, amount available ...............           ............................                      .      741 67
   (See Appendix U 8.)
244      REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

  9. Survey of Arkansas River, Arkansas,from Little Rock to its mouth.-
The original plan for this survey contemplated covering the river
with a series of triangles, determining the shore-line, both at high
and low water, the position of the bars and islands, the general topog-
raphy of the valley to the bluffs, when these are not too far from the
river, the depth of the water, the gauging of the river at various points
and principal tributaries, the nature of the soil and character of the
river-bed, cross-sections to be made at frequent intervals, the slope to
be accurately determined, and all other attainable data to be collected
that will bear upon the problem of the permanent improvement of the
navigation of the river.
  There had been expended upon this project'to June 30,1885, $17,361.79,
which had completed the field work practically and placed the maps in
an advanced stage of completion.
  During the fiscal year ending June 30, 1886, $1,627.01 has been ex-
pended in completing the maps.
July 1, 1885, amount available ..............................- ........ ... $1,930 71
Received by sale of fuel to officer.................... .............. .....     4 50
                                                                                1,935 21
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885.................................... ..........       1,627 01
July 1, 1886, amount available ................          . .....
                                                     ----...... .. .......        308 20
   (See Appendix U 9.)
   10. Continuationof survey of Arkansas River from Wichita, Kansas,
to Fort Gibson, Indian Territory (provided for in the river and harbor
act of August 2, 1882).-There was expended to June 30, 1885, upon
this, $9,120.87, which completed the field-work in an indifferent way,
and plotted the notes after a very rough fashion.
   During the fiscal year ending June 30, 1886, the balance of the allot-
ment, $179.13,was expended in putting the maps in a little better shape,
and in prepairing a rough tracing to forward with the plans and esti-
mates for this reach of river. This still leaves the maps in a very un-
satisfactory condition.
   A report was prepared and submitted January 23, 1886, which was
printed as House Ex. Doc. No. 90, Forty-ninth Congress, first session,
with full plans and estimates for the improvement of the river from
Arkansas City, Kans., to Fort Gibson, Indian Territory.
July 1, 1885, amount available ................... ._....... ............. .      17,9 13
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1,1885....._. ..   ....       .... .-. ... .      ..---  -     179 13
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886...................           1,125 00
  (See Appendix U 10.)

REMOVING SNAGS AND WRECKS FROM THE MISSISSIPPI AND THE
  MISSOURI RIVERS-IMPROVEMENT OF OSAGE RIVER, MISSOURI AND
  KANSAS-GASCONADE RIVER, MISSOURI.

   Officer in charge, Maj. A. M. Miller, Corps of Engineers.
  1. Removing snags and wrecks from the Mississippi and Missouri
rivers.-Misissippi River.-The channel of this river was greatly ob-
structed by the presence of snags and other obstructions in the bed of
the stream, and overhanging timber on the banks, thus materially in-
terfering with navigation on the river. For the removal of these ob-
structions appropriations were made as early as 1824, and the project
                    RIVER AND         HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                           245
consisted in the building of boats suitable for pulling the snags, &c., and
these boats were almost continually employed during favorable boating
stages in pulling the snags, &c., and cutting the leaning timber.
    The total amount expended for this purpose cannot be definitely given,
as previous to the appropriation made by act of March 3, 1879, no stated
amount was set aside for this improvement, but a general amount was
appropriated to be applied to several streams, as their needs required.
From the time, March 3, 1879, when the first specific amount was ap-
propriated up to June 30, 1885, $484,495.04 was expended for this pur-
pose. The navigation of the river has been very materially improved
by this method, and the danger of accidents to boats has been lessened.
   During the fiscal year ending June 30, 1886, $20,047.71 was expended
on this improvement. One snag-boat was employed between the mouth
of the Missouri River and Vicksburg, Miss., removing obstructions.
The boat worked two months, removing 693 snags, cutting down 567
trees, and traveling a distance of 2,256 miles. In addition the boat as-
sisted in saving the Government plant carried down the river with the
ice when the gorge below Saint Louis broke and carried the fleet with
it. All the worst obstructions to navigation were removed, and com-
nmerce was greatly benefited thereby.
   With the appropriation asked for fiscal year ending June 30, 1888, it
is proposed to continue the snagging operations and rebuild one of the
wooden snag-boats for wrecking purposes. Should this be done the
navigation will be greatly facilitated during the low-water season.
   No definite amount can be stated as required to complete this proj-
ect. During every high-water season new snags and other obstruc-
tions are brought down and lodged in the channel; the banks are also
continually caving in the river, and it is necessary to cut the timber
where this is threatened to prevent the trees being caved into the river
and forming new obstructions. For this reason an annual appropria-
tion is required to properly carry on this improvement.
July 1, 1885, amount available. ........
                                     .     ..
                                         .$28,     . , ..      .. .... ...--       455 59
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885.........    ..     ..
                                            .............   ...
                                                             ..   ..   ...--.   20, 047 71

July 1, 1886, amount available ......................................            8, 407 88
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886....................          56, 250 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887....................       64, 657 88
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1888 129, 000 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
  (See Appendix V 1.)
   Missouri River.-The necessity for the improvement of this stream
was first recognized in 1832, as its navigation was rendered difficult and
dangerous by numerous snags, &c., in the channel and leaning timber
on the banks of the river.
   The plan adopted for its improvement was the removal of these ob-
structions by snag-boats, and they have been used to great advantage
in securing the result aimed at.
   The first appropriations were made so as to cover the needs of sev-
eral streams, a sufficient amount being allotted for each river to do the
work required.     For this reason the total amount expended on this
river for the removal of obstructions cannot be given. Since June 18,
1878, however, when the first specific appropriation was made, up to
June 30, 1885, $326,651.29 was expended in that manner. The expend-
246      REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

iture of this money resulted in greatly improved navigation during
the low-water season when the snags are very dangerous obstructions.
   During the fiscal year ending June 30, 1886, $70,224.82 was expended
in removing obstructions and benefiting navigation and in building the
hull of a new snag-boat for this river. One snag-boat was employed in
removing obstructions, working eight weeks in the river.       Five hun-
dred and forty-six snags were removed, the boat having traveled 904
miles. The hull of the new snag-boat was completed and accepted, and
contracts for upper works, cabin, &c., and the machinery for the new
snag-boat, were entered into.
   During the coming season it is proposed to outfit the new snag-boat,
and, as far as the funds available will permit, continue the snagging op-
erations.
   With the appropriation asked for fiscal year ending June 30, 1888, it
is proposed to complete the outfit of new boat and continue the snag-
ging operations, and it is expected that the worst obstructions can be
removed, and navigation rendered comparatively safe.
   As new obstructions are continually brought down the river, work is
required every year, so no amount can be given as required to com-
plete this work. An annual appropriation, however, is very necessary.
July 1, 1885, amount available......................................... $113, 348 71
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1885-------------- --- --- $70, 224 82
July 1, 1886, outstanding liabilities.....-....-- ....-.....   42, 634 17
                                                                            112, 858 99

July 1, 1886, amount available ........................................         489 72
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886 .---..--..............   22, 500 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887..................     22,989 72

rAmount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  1888----..----..----....     -...................----   --..----          44,000 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix V I.)
  2. Osage River, Kansas and Missouri.-The navigation of this stream
was greatly interfered with by obstructions in the channel and shoal
crossings.
  The original project, adopted in 1871, was to obtain a low-water navi-
gation of 2 feet by means of dam and training-walls, but this was
abandoned and no other definite project was adopted. The improve-
ments have consisted in the removal of overhanging trees from the
banks and of snags from the bed of the stream and the construction of
wing-dams and training-walls.
  The amount expended to June 30, 1885, was $190,000, at which time
the navigation was in a fair condition, the worst obstructions having
been removed.
  No work having been done on this stream since June 11, 1883, new
obstructions have accumulated, thus hindering navigation.
   With the amount asked for fiscal year ending June 30, 1888, it is pro-
posed to continue the removal of obstructions, and increased boating
facilities are expected.
  An annual appropriation is required to keep this stream in navigable
condition by the removal of new obstructions that are brought down
during the floods. No stated amount can be given as required to com-
plete the improvement.
                      RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                         247
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886..........----           ....---------. $10,000 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1888 10, 000 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix V 2.)
  3. GasconadeRiver, Missouri.--This river was greatly obstructed by
snags, logs, and leaning timber, thereby greatly interfering with nav-
igatipn.
  Work was commenced on this stream in 1880, and the project adopted
for its improvement consisted in the removal of the snags and logs and
the cutting of the leaning timber.
  The amount expended on this improvement to June 30, 1885, was
$28,875.28, and at that time the navigation was improved so much that
boats could navigate the stream with but little danger and for longer
periods during the year. During the fiscal year ending June 30, 1886,
$195.67 was expended in caring for plant, no field work having been
done.
   No work will be done during the coming season, the funds on hand
not being sufficient for that purpose, unless a further appropriation is
made.
   With the amount asked for fiscal year ending June 30, 1888, it is pro-
posed to continue the removal of obstructions, and it is expected that
commerce will be greatly benefited thereby.
  The original estimate for the improvement of this stream was $50,000,
of which $30,000 has already been appropriated, leaving an estimated
amount of $20,000 to complete the project. This amount will probably
be exceeded, however, as new obstructions are continually brought down
the river, and it will require a small amount each year to keep the chan-
nel open after the principal work has been done.
July 1, 1885, amount available............--....---....----......----................   $1, 124 72
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885 ......----------................ ............... ........        195 67
July 1, 1886, amount available ...........  ......----...... ..---.... -.                   929 05
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886...................                    7, 500 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887..................                 8,429 05
SAmountthat can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1888 10, 000 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix V 3.)

                MISSISSIPPI               RIVER         COMMISSION.

   This Commission, organized under the provisions of the act of June
28, 1879, reports to and receives instructions from the Secretary of
War, through this office.
   The Secretary of War transmitted to the House of Representatives
January 15, 1886, a report from the Commission, of December 8, 1885,
exhibiting the financial condition of their work on December 1, 1885,
and the operations prior to that date and subsequent to June 30, 1885,
and also describing, from a recent inspection of the river, the condition
of the work of improvement executed by the Commission. This report
was printed as House Ex. Doec. No. 38, Forty-ninth Congress, first ses-
sion. (See also Appendix V V.)
248            REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

  The estimates for the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888, submitted by
the Commission, are as follows:
For improving the Mississippi River below Cairo, Ill....................                                                          $5, 000,000
Continuing surveys of the river between Head of the Passes and its head-
  waters ........---------.............----------... ......--....---------....-----......--- -----------......--......--             100, 000
Salaries and traveling expenses of Mississippi River Commission, and for
  salaries and traveling expenses of assistant engineers under them, and
   for office expenses and contingencies......                                        .......................                        100, 000
Improving harbors on the river below Cairo, 111., namely :
   At Columbus, Ky .........................................                                                          $61,750
   At Hickman, Ky............................................
                    - -------------                                                                                   251,750
   At Memphis, Tenn-- ..........................................                                                       25, 000
      At Greenville, Mo......                   ...................................                                   148,500
      At New Orleans, La                  ....--.....--..               ..... .... ..........                   ..--.. 608, 600
                                                                                                                            -      1,095, 600

                                                        .--..---..---......---- ..................
                Total----....--------...............----------.                                                                    6,295,600

                          MISSOURI                      RIVER COMMISSION.

   This Commission, organized under provisions of the river and harbor
act of July 5, 1884, reports to and receives instructions from the Secre.
tary of War, through this office.
   The first report of the Commission was transmitted to the Senate by
the Secretary of War January 7, 1885, and printed as Senate Ex. Doc.
No. 24, Forty-eighth Congress, second session.
   The second report of the Commission, containing in detail the project
of surveys and of works of construction carried out from December 1,
1884, to October 13, 1885, was printed in the last Annual Report of this
office.
   The third report, describing operations under their charge from the
close of the fiscal year ending June 30, 1885, to December 1, 1885,
being supplemental to that above mentioned, was transmitted to the
House of Representatives by the Secretary of War, January 15, 1886,
and printed as House Ex. Doc. No. 41, Forty-ninth Congress, first ses-
sion. (See also Appendix W W.)
   The estimates submitted by the Commission for the fiscal year ending
June 30, 1888, are as follows:
For improving Missouri River from mouth to Sioux City, Iowa ..........                                                            $1,000,000
For surveys and examinations...... .................................--------------...                                                120, 000
For office and traveling expenses and salaries of Commissioners ..... ....                                                            30,000
         Total..---..-
                    .........----.----.---................-----..........-----..-----------...........                             1,150, 000

IMPROVEMENT                    OF THE MISSOURI RITVER FROM SIOUX CITY, IOWA,
                                   TO FORT BENTON, MONTANA.

  Officer in charge, Capt. C. B. Sears, Corps of Engineers.
  The supervision of the work in progress on this portion of the river
having passed to the Missouri River Commission by provisions of the
river and harbor act of July 5, 1884, report of operations here during
the fiscal year ending June 30, 1886, is made by that Commission.
   The river and harbor act of August 5,1886, in making appropriations
for continuing this improvement, returns its supervision to the Chief
of Engineers, as heretofore.
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886-- ..----............                                                           $60, 000 00
   A mount that can beprofitablyexpended in fiscal year ending June30, 1888 135,000 00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
     harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
                           RIVER AND              HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                              249
   IMPROVEMENT OF YELLOWSTONE RIVER, MONTANA AND DAKOTA.

  Officer in charge, Capt. James B. Quinn, Corps of Engineers.
  During the past season the work has progressed in accordance with
present project and has consisted in the construction of brush-dams,
for the closing of chutes and cut-offs in the portion of the river below
Glendive. These dams aggregate a total of 1,282 linear feet and were
built at an average cost of $5.79 + per linear foot, the lowest average
rate as yet reached in the construction of such works on the Yellow-
stone River.
                               ESTIMATES.

For necessary plant to continue operations--                         ........               ......-..               $14,000
For expenses of working parties for one season's operations............ ..-- 25, 700
For repairs to dams---...-.....----...........................-------------------------.......-----......---------.   5,000
For new barges and dredge-boat--------...............................----------........                              30,000
         Total that may be profitably expended during the next year ...... ...                                    74, 700
   Exclusive of repairs to dams the cost of the improvement of the river
from Glendive to the mouth will not probably exceed $106,000.
July 1, 1885, amount available- ................--   ......................           $10,112 32
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1885 .........        --.... ....-.       $8,402 56
July 1, 1886, outstanding liabilities--.............. ......-..-             1,016 25
                                                                                                       --      9,418 81

July 1, 1586, amount available ..................... .... ................                                        693 51
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886..-..............                                           18, 750 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887 ...................                                     19,443 51

   Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1888                                 50, 000 00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
     harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix W.)

IMPROVEMENT OF THE MISSISSIPPI RIVER FROM THE MOUTH OF
         THE ILLINOIS TO THE MOUTH OF THE OHIO.

  Officer in charge, Maj. O. H. Ernst, Corps of Engineers.
  The supervision of the work in progress on this portion of the river
having passed to the Mississippi River Commission, by provisions of
the river and harbor act of July 5, 1884, report of operations here dur-
ing the fiscal year ending June 30, 1886, is made by that Commission.
  The river and harbor act of August 5, 1886, in making appropriation
for continuing this improvement, returns its supervision to the Chief of
Engineers as heretofore.
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886 .................                                        $375, 000 00
   Amount that canbe profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1888 600, 000 00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.

IMPROVEMENT OF THE MISSISSIPPI RIVER FROM DES MOINES RAPIDS
             TO THE MOUTH OF ILLINOIS RIVER.

    Officer in charge, Capt. E. H. Ruffner, Corps of Engineers.
  The supervision of the work in progress on this portion of the river
having passed to the Mississippi River Commission by provisions of the
250      REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

river and harbor act of July 5, 1884, report of operations here during
the fiscal year ending June 30, 1886, is made by that Commission.
   The river and harbor act of August 5, 1886, in making appropriation
for continuing this improvement, returns its supervision to the Chief of
Engineers as heretofore.
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886................... $150,000 00
SAmount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1888 264,000 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.

IMPROVEMENT OF THE NAVIGATION OF THE MISSISSIPPI BETWEEN
  SAINT PAUL AND DES MOINES RAPIDS, INCLUDING IMPROVEMENTS
  AT SPECIAL LOCALITIES BETWEEN THOSE POINTS-OPERATION AND
  CARE OF THE DES MOINES CANAL.

   Officer in charge, Maj. A. Mackenzie, Corps of Engineers.
   1. Upper Mississippi River; operations of snag-boats and dredge-boats,
&c.-There being no funds available from this appropriation small
allotments were made from the general appropriations for improvement
of the river between Saint Paul and the mouth of the Illinois River, by
means of which the snag-boat General Barna rd was enabled to make
one hurried trip over the district named. Only the worst obstructions
were removed. The snag-boat J. G. Parke was not in commission dur-
ing the year. From lack of care during the past year the river is now
more obstructed by snags and overhanging trees than for several years.
The total amount expended for snag-boat service on Upper Mississippi
River between Saint Paul and the mouth of the Missouri to July 1, 1886,
is $502,140.
   The officer in charge submits an estimate of $30,000 for operating the
snag-boats during fiscal year ending June 30, 1888, and recommends
that the appropriation be made a permanent one, such as those made
for the Government canals, in order to do away with the trouble ex-
perienced through the failure of river and harbor bills.
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886 ...................        $22, 500 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1888    30,000 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
  (See Appendix X 1.)
   2. Mississippi River from Saint Paul to Des Moines Rapids.-With
the small amount of funds available but little work could be done.
During the year the work of improvement was carried on in the con-
struction of brush, rock, and pile dams and shore protections at Saint
Paul, between Saint Paul and Hastings, in vicinity of Fountain City,
and in Coon and Cassville sloughs. A small island below Alma, very
troublesome to raft navigation, was removed by dredge. Considerable
dredging was done at West Saint Paul to form a basin or harbor there,
and a system of buoys was maintained on Rock Island Rapids.
   Though the river reached a low stage in September, 1885, the large
boats were able to reach Saint Paul throughout the season, owing to
improvements made in former years.
   The work is no longer experimental, but certain of good results, and
the Government is now well provided with equipments in the way of
steamboats, barges, &c., and can expend to advantage the amount
                           RIVER AND HARROR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                              251
($1,500,000) recommended by the officer in charge. The total amount ex-
pended to July 1, 1886, under this title of appropriation is $1,170,915.10.
July 1, 1885, amount available .-.......................                             .............               $75, 992 45
Received from sale of fuel.......            --.........................--.                          $105 03
Received from sale of rock .... .. ...... ....................                                       1, 078 05
                                                                                                                   1,183 08

                                                                                                                  77, 175 53
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1885..................... ..... 68, 090 63
July 1, 1886, outstanding liabilities.....----... ..- .....-.    ..  215 65
                                                                                                                  68,306 28

July 1, 1886, amount available.............................. ..........                                           8, 869 25
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886 .--............                                         ..-. 382, 500 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887 -...                                  ..---     .. ..--- . 391,369 25
   Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1888 500,000 00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of section
      harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
                                                                of river and            2
   (See Appendix X 2.)
   3. Mississippi River from Des Moines Rapids to mouth of the Illinois
River.-In April, 1885, an allotment of $5,000 was assigned to Major
McKenzie from this appropriation for snag-boat operations. Of the
amount available July 1, 1885, a portion was expended during the year
in removing snags between Keokuk and the Illinois River, and in care
and repair of snag-boats General Barnard and J. G. Parke.
July 1, 1885, amount available-...--...............                     ..................                         $4, 324 50
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885---------....------....------.....---..---...           ---.........----......---------.  2, 598 54
July 1, 1886, amount available..................... ..................                                             1, 725 96
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 186-....--....-...
                                                               -       ...- -.                                   150, 000 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887....................                                        151,725 96
   (See Appendix X 3.)
  4. Harbors of Refuge in Lake Pepin: Harborat Stockholm, Wisconsin.-
The projectfor this work proposed the building of a breakwater to protect
and facilitate the landing of steamboats and afford safety to rafts caught
in the lake by storms. A crib-work pier 579 feet in length was com-
pleted during the fall of 1885. It has passed through one winter without
being injured by ice, and has already proved of considerable advantage
to boats and rafts. The amount expended to June 30, 1886, is $18,748.41.
No further appropriation is asked for for the fiscal year ending June
30, 1888.
July 1, 1885, amount available............................... ........                       $20,831 30
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885......-----...--..---------..---..----..----...----.....---..-----
                                                                                    .....     14,579 71
July 1, 1886, amount available.... ........................                                  ..........            6, 251 59
  (See Appendix X 4.)
  5. Harbors of refuge in Lake P1epin: Harborat Lake City, Minnesota.-
The project for this work proposed the building of a breakwater to pro-
tect and facilitate the landing of steamboats and afford safety to rafts
caught in the lake by storms. No work has as yet been done, and no
money expended, but preparations are being made for constructing a
pier on a plan so modified as to afford reasonably good results with the
small amount of money available.
252          REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

July 1, 1885, amount available                   - .........         .....   .......................                  -      $25, 000 00

July 1, 1886, amount available..........................................                                                      25,000 00
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886                                        .            ---......... ......    10, 000 00

Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887................                                                         35, 000 00
   (See Appendix X 5.)
   6. Removal of bar in Mississippi River opposite Dubuque, Iowa.--The
original project for this work embraced the removal of the bar extend-
ing along the river front so as to give 4 feet at extreme low water. The
bar had been very troublesome at low water, nearly blockading the
city and causing boats to make a wide detour to effect a landing.
   The work heretofore accomplished has consisted in dredging away
the bar along the landings and in mid-river, affording ample depth at
all stages and furnishing a wide and deep entrance to the ice-harbor.
   During the past year the bars opposite to and above the"entrance
to the ice-harbor and along the shore for about 1,000 feet above were
removed by dredge to the depth of 4- feet at low water, as also consid-
erable deposits at the lower landings and at the foot of the mid-river
bar; 37,968 cubic yards of material were disposed of by dumping on
the bar below Dunlieth.
   This work affords about 1,200 feet of additional landings for steam-
boats and rafts.
   The amount expended to June 30, 1886, is $39,140.69.
   No further appropriation is asked for.
July 1, 1885, amount available.... ......................................           $7, 141 82
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885 ........          ....... .....................- . .....  5,282 51
July 1, 1886, amount available .........................................                                                       1,859 31
  (See Appendix X 6.)
  7. Ice-harbor at Dubuque, Iowa.-The project for this work, submitted
December 31, 1880, proposed to deepen and enlarge Waple's Cut, a
basin used by boats for years as a winter harbor, so as to afford 6 feet
depth at extreme low water over an area of about 500,000 square feet.
The original estimate was $40,000, and that amount was appropriated
in two installments.
  Some minor modifications in the plan have afforded an increase of
dredged area to 520,000 square feet, and that portion of the work is com-
pleted. The amount now available will be sufficient to protect the first
street side of the harbor whenever the city sees fit to establish the
proper width and slope at that street. The amount expended to June
30, 1886, is $35,496.01.
  No further appropriation is asked for.
July 1, 1885, amount available....-.... ..........................     ...... $11, 254 20
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885..------.... --......... ................... ......   6, 750 21
July 1 1886, amount available......... ...............--...--..                               ----..........                   4,503 99
   (See Appendix X 7.) .
   8. Rock IslandRapids, Mississippi River.-Duringthe past year a sys-
tem of buoys for guidance of navigators was maintained, the expense
of which was borne by the general appropriation for the river from Saint
Paul to Des Moines Rapids, there being no money specially appropriated
for the purpose.
  The officer in charge recommends an annual appropriation of $5,000
to provide for the care of the Rock Island Rapids by maintaining the
                     RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                         253
system of buoys and removing sand, loose rock, bowlders, &c., from the
channel, and further urges that the Rock Island Rapids be put on the
same basis as the canal at the Des Moines Rapids and be provided for
by a permanent annual appropriation.         *
   The amount expended to June 30, 1886, is $1,166,608.50.
   The river and harbor act of August 5, 1886, appropriates the sum of
$6,000 to be applied to the removal of the rock at Duck Creek Chain.
   (See Appendix X 8.)
   9. Des Moines Rapids, Mississippi River.-This work was commenced
in 1866. The adopted plan consisted in building a closed canal 8 miles
long and in cutting an open channel in the rocky bottom of the river
over the remaining 4 miles of the rapids. The canal was opened Au-
gust, 1877, although not fully completed, and has been in operation
since that time.
   The work of the past year has consisted in the continuation of rip-
rapping canal embankment, cutting of stone preparatory to raising side-
walls of:lower lock, building two additional cribs above the guard-lock
to facilitate entrance to the canal, and repairing portions of the plant.
The work remaining to be done to complete this work in accordance
with the modified project is as follows:
   Completing blasting and dredging in open channel, raising lock-walls
of middle and lower locks 4 feet, refilling and completing paving of
embankment, building two sluices for removing sediment, building an
office at lower lock, and completing the lock grounds. There is also
to be built, in accordance with requirements of the act of Congress of
July 5, 1884, a pier connecting the outer wall of the canal with the pier
of Keokuk Bridge, for which purpose $10,000 was allowed by Congress.
   The amount of money allotted by Congress for pier construction is
not sufficient for the purpose, and it has not been deemed prudent or in
the interest of navigation to commence the work until funds are availa-
ble for its completion. It is now thought that a floating boom, which
can probably be built for the $10,000 available, will be preferable (con-
sidering relative cost) to the permanent pier.
   There has been appropriated and allotted for this work $4,491,700, and
the net cost to the United States to date has been $4,480,680.88. There
is now required to complete work in accordance with modified project
$101,745, making estimated total cost of work $4,582,425.88. Certain
errors in previous reports of appropriations and cost are now corrected
and the figures here given are absolutely correct.
   The good of this work requires that the amount needed for comple-
tion be granted at as early a date as is practicable. The work has now
dragged through many years and its total cost has been increased
thereby. When the improvement of the Des Moines Rapids is com-
pleted the expense of operating the Des Moines Rapids Canal will be
somewhat reduced.
July 1, 1885, amount available .....................              ...........  ...... $30, 387 15
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885.......................    .........................    ..... 20, 387 15
July 1, 1886, amount available-...... ......-     .    ...     . ... ......     ....   10, 000 00
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886 ...................                 26,250 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887 ...................              36,250 00
254         REPORT         OF       itHtC1IEF             OF ENGINEERS, if. S. ATRMY.

 (Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing projects ....... $30, 495 00
  Amount added for completion of modified projects ....................    45, 000 00
                                                                                                     75, 495 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1888 75, 000 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix X 9.)
   10. Operating and care Des Moines Rapids Canal.-During the past
fiscal year the Des Moines Rapids Canal was open for navigation 238
days, during which time there passed through it 784 steamboats and
218 barges, carrying 22,221 passengers, 56,001 tons merchandise, 465,681
bushels grain, 22,769,823 feet of lumber, 3,195,360 feet of logs, 8,253,000
shingles, and 4,302,800 lath.
   A favorable stage of water during the spring of 1886 permitted boats
and rafts to pass over the rapids around the canal, and the traffic of
the year was thereby reduced. Repairing canal embankments and re-
moving deposits washed in from adjoining bluffs were, as heretofore, a
continued source of trouble and will so continue until the improvement
of the Des Moines Rapids according to modified project is completed.
Sixty-five thousand nine hundred and seventy cubic yards of material
were removed from the canal by dredges during the year.
   Electric lights were put up at Guard Lock during the year, and the
similar lighting of Middle Lock during coming year will complete the
system. The approved project for past fiscal year authorized the ex-
penditure of $45,500. The expenses of year, including outstanding
liabilities of previous year and extensive repairs, have been $43,009.53.
   There has been appropriated and allotted to date for this work
$360,500, and the net expense to the United States for same time has
been $360,497.41. These figures are absolutely correct, and eliminate
certain errors which have found their way into previous reports.
   The standing estimate for operating and care of canal, including
ordinary repairs, &c., is $40,000, and when improvement of the Des
Moines Rapids and Canal and the river improvement in the vicinity of
Montrose are completed, expenses can be brought considerably inside
of this amount, but at present the large expenses for dredging and re-
pairs to embankment may necessitate a slight increase of expense over
that originally contemplated. By the approved project for the fiscal
year ending June :0, 1887, a possible expenditure of $40,000 is author-
ized.
Amount available on approved project for fiscal year ending June 30, 1886 $45, 500 00
July 1, 1885, balance on hand ........................                          .......    $12 12
June 30, 1886, amount drawn from Treasury under indefinite ap-
  propriation -----........-----......-------....--......---......--...........         43, 000 00
                                                                                                     43,012 12
June 30, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, including $60.82 out-
  standing June 30, 1885 .             ................                                              43,009 53

June 30, 1886, balance on hand ...............................                       .........            2 59.
July 1, 1886, amount available under indefinite appropriation on approved
  project for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887 ............................                          45,000 00
   (See Appendix X 10.)
   11. Dry-dock at Des Moines Rapids Canal.-The project for this work
provides for the building on the river side of Des Moines Rapids Canal,
above Middle Lock, of a dry-dock 400 feet long and 100 feet wide, with
gates giving an opening of 80 feet into the canal. The estimated cost
is $125,000.
                     RIVER AND           HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                          255
   For work of past year there has been available but $8,555.72, and
comparatively little work has been accomplished. The present condi-
tion of dock is as follows : The earthen embankment has been finished,
the paving on outer slope and on a large portion of inner slope of dock
embankment has been completed; the sluice-ways have been completed,
excepting arched covering and coping.
   The principal work remaining to complete dock is the construction of
abutments, wing-walls, and gates at entrance to dock, paving prisms,
completing sluice-ways, and paving of inner slope of embankment, re-
moving portion of canal embankment, and placing pumping machinery.
   There has been appropriated for this work to date $60,000, and there
is required to complete this work according to approved project $65,000.
The allowance of this amount in one sum and at an early date will be
in the interest of economy.
July 1, 1885, amount available ...           ......................................               $8, 555 72
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885 ......    ..- .    ......           .... ...................   .   .    8,555 72
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886...................                             48,750 00
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project........ 16,250 00
Amount that can be profitably expendedin fiscal year ending June 30, 1888 16, 250 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
  (See Appendix X 11.)

PRESERVATION OF TIHE FALLS OF SAINT ANTHONY AND IMPROVE-
  MENT OF THE MISSISSIPPI ABOVE THE FALLS--IMPROVEMENT OF
  CHIPPEWA AND SAINT CROIX RIVERS, WISCONSIN, AND OF MINNE-
  SOTA RIVER AND RED RIVER OF THE NORTH, MINNESOTA AND
  DAKOTA-RESERVOIRS AT THE SOURCES OF THE MISSISSIPPI.

   Officer in charge, Maj. Charles J. Allen, Corps of Engineers.
   1. Preservationof the Falls of Saint Anthony.-In 1868 an attempt by
private parties to tunnel under the limestone ledge forming the Falls
was followed by undermining and subsidence of a large portion of the
ledge. This, with the rapid recession of the crest, threatened the ex-
istence of the Falls, and the aid of Congress was invoked, the plea be-
ing that destruction of the Falls would result in converting the river
above them into a series of rapids to the destruction of its navigation.
The first appropriation made by Congress to preserve the Falls of Saint
Anthony was $50,000, by act approved July 11,1870. This was followed
by three appropriations of $50,000 each, in 1871, 1872, and 1873, the
whole aggregating $200,000, which was applied in efforts to avert the
threatened danger by surrounding the chasms by coffer-dams and a
stone wall; also, in closing the openings or tunnels leading from the
chasms with gravel, clay, &c.
   The present project for the preservation of the Falls, adopted in 1874,
provided for the construction of a concrete dike underneath the lime-
stone ledge to prevent percolation through, and consequent destruction
of, the soft underlying sand-rock; the construction of flooding, or roll-
ing, dams to keep the upper surface of the ledge flooded during the
winter in order to prevent injurious action upon it of frost ; and a tim-
ber apron and wings to prevent recession of the crest and consequent
destruction of the dike. The dike was completed in 1876 and the other
works by 1878. Since 1878 work has been confined to the preservation
and repair of the timber structures. No work of repairs was done dur-
ing the past fiscal year for want of funds.
  The concrete dike is in good condition, but the wing and apron are
256        REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

,very much undermined by the action of ice and water, and of loose
saw-logs, which find their way to the apron from the log-booms above
the Falls.
    The rock filling of the apron crib-work has been removed in large
part by the undermining action of the water, and the deck planking is
in parts torn off by running ice and logs. Should the timber apron be
destroyed the ledge would recede until the concrete dike would be en-
dangered. The dike was constructed simply to serve as a diaphragm
impervious to running water, and is not calculated to withstand-un-
aided by the sand-rock on its down-stream side-pressure due to a great
head of water.
    The occupation of about two-thirds the width of the stream above
the crest of the Falls by the dams and other works of the water-power
companies chartered in 1857, forcing the greater part of the flood vol-
umes of the river through a width of 450 feet, narrowing down to 360
feet, and through a fall of 45 feet to act upon the river bed at the foot
of the Falls accelerated the rate of recession of the crest prior to the
completion of the apron, and renders the work of protection at the
present time difficult and expensive.
    The officer in charge, after stating his opinion that the best plan to se-
cure the preservation of the Falls would consist in the removal of most,
if not all, the mill-dams from the bed of the stream, extending the roll-
ing-dams from bank to bank, and largely extending the apron-work,
estimates that should the Government adhere to the present project of
exterior protection the cost of repairs and extensions immediately nec-
essary would be $210,000, of which amount $150,000 could be expended
in the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888, toward extending the main
apron along the front of Farnham and Lovejoy's mill-pond, protecting
this front so far as necessary, removal of a portion of the point of rocks
from the river, near the lower end of the pond, in order to reduce the
eddy, repairing the main apron and east apron, continuing the line of
submerged cribs across the bed of the river at the toe of the apron, and
for general repairs.
    The total amount expended under the present project (including in
this the appropriation of $10,000 for a log sluice by act of Congress ap-
proved March 30, 1879) to June 30, 1886, including outstanding liabil-
ities, is $414,985.29.
July 1, 1885, amount available..--..-.-..--..---            ------....-..--..----..-----....
                                                 -.........--...--.....-                                          $459 29
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1885......-...................                   $357 75
July 1, 1886, outstanding liabilities.--.........................
                                                            -86                                         83
                                                                                                                   444 58
July 1, 1886, amount available..----......................----..                              -----............     14 71
  SAmount    (estimated) required for project........................---------------------------.......
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
                                                                                                             210,000 00
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
  (See Appendix Y 1.)
  2. Mississippi River above Falls of Saint Anthony, Minnesota.-The
present project, adopted in 1880, consists in improvement of the river
mainly between Aitken and Grand Rapids, a distance of 165 miles, by
removal of snags, bowlders, bars, and leaning trees from the channels,
and construction of wing-dams where necessary to afford 3 feet depth
during low-waer stage. The cost is based upon the results of a survey
in 1874, the estimate for improving the extent of river from Conradi's
Shoals to Grand Rapids, 252 miles, including the stretch from Aitken
to Grand Rapids, being placed at $54,127.50. The last appropriation
                     RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                            257
for this improvement was that of $10,000 by the river and harbor act
passed August 2, 1882.
   No work was done upon the channels during the past fiscal year for
want of funds.
   Total expended under the present project to June 30, 1886, including
outstanding liabilities, $34,998.10.
   Before improvement commenced in 1880, the stream between Aitken
and Grand Rapids was so obstructed that at low, and even high, stages
of water, navigation was difficult and at times almost impossible for
steamers of lightest draught. There is now a general depth in the im-
proved channels of 3 feet at low water, and the three completed reser-
voirs at the headwaters of the Mississippi River above Grand Rapids
may be relied upon henceforth to provide sufficient depth for the steam-
ers which carry passengers, supplies, and freight to the settlements and
lumbermen's camps above Aitken; but there are many snags, leaning
trees, bowlders, and gravel-bars yet remaining to be removed, as they
contract the channels and thus interfere with the movement of steamers
at any stage of water.
   Prior to the adoption of the present project the sum of $45,000, ap-
propriated by acts of Congress June 23, 1874, and August 14, 1876, had
been expended between the Falls and Saint Cloud, 76 miles above the
Falls, in the removal of sand, gravel, and bowlder-bars, and construc-
tion of wing-dams. But steamboat navigation having discontinued
upon that stretch of river, the present project was adopted, as already
stated, in 1880.
   The sum of $15,000 asked for the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888, is
to be expended in continuing removal of obstructions to navigation
between Aitken and Grand Rapids.
July 1, 1885, amount available .........................................                     $251 90
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1885.........................                   $246  33
July 1, 1886, outstanding liabilities ..........................                      3 67
                                                                                              250 00

July 1, 1886, amount available      .............-.............            ........             1 90

  Amount (estimated) required for completion of project, viz, improve-
    ment between Grand Rapids and Conradi's Shoals-- ...................- 19,127 50
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1888 5, 000 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix Y 2.)
   3. Construction of lock and dam on Mississippi River at Meeker's Island,
Minnesota.--The project for this work is given in the report of the Chief
of Engineers for the fiscal year ending June 30, 1874, and the cost esti-
mated- at $922,121.46, the object being to connect with the improvement
of the Mississippi River below Saint Paul, so as to secure steamboat
navigation up to the Falls of Saint Anthony.
   No improvement of the river between Saint Paul and the site of the
proposed lock and dam has been authorized by Congress.
   The act approved July 23, 1868, made a grant of 200,000 acres of pub-
lic lands to the State of Minnesota to aid in constructing a lock and
dam at this point in accordance with plan and estimate previously sub-
mitted.
   The act of March 3, 1873, appropriated--
  For construction of the lock and dam on the Mississippi River at Meeker's Island,
Minnesota, according to the surveys and plans of the War Department, twenty-five
thousand dollars : Provided, That all rights and claims in and to said land grant made
        17 a
258       REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

to the State of Minnesota for the above work by act approved July twenty-third,
eighteen hundi~d and sixty-eight, shall be fully relinquished to the United States
before any of .this appropriation is expended.
  None of this appropriation has been used, the required relinquish-
ment not having been made, and the appropriation has been lying un-
used for thirteen years.
  No appropriation is asked for the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888.
July 1, 1885, amount available, subject to conditions in act .............. $25, 000 00
July 1, 1886, amount available, subject to conditions in act      --.............---. 25,000 00
SAmount (estimated) required for completion of existing project-.....-.. 897,121 46
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix Y 3.)
  4. Chippewa River, Wisconsin.--This work consists in the construction
of dams and jetties to confine the low-water volume to a practicable
channel, and in revetment of caving bends, between Eau Claire and the
mouth of the river, a distance of 57 miles. The project was adopted in
1876, and its cost, based upon the results of an examination in 1875,
was placed at $75,790; revised estimates in 1883, however, brought the
cost up to $132,476.35.
   Work on the improvement, during the past fiscal year, was limited to
some needed repairs to the west jetty at the mouth of the river, the
balance of funds available from the appropriation of 1884 only sufficing
for small repairs.
   Expended to June 30, 1886, including outstanding liabilities, $97-
380.13.
   Wherever dams and jetties have been constructed the low-water chan-
nel has been benefited, a depth of 3 feet being generally maintained
where, before improvement, the depth seldom exceeded 18 inches. The
improvement has been principally confined to the 16k miles of river be-
tween the mouth and Durand.
   The jetties at the mouth of the river have been of great benefit to
raft and steamboat navigation in securing a stable channel of sufficient
depth where, before improvement commenced, there was a broad bar
intersected by shallow, shifting channels passable with difficulty at
times of low water by rafts and steamers.
   A number of shoals between Durand and the mouth yet need im-
provement. Improvement of the channel at Shaw's Rapids, Eau Claire,
is much needed, the flood of September, 1884, having almost obliterated
.the old channel at that point.
   The sum of $30,000 asked for the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888, to
be expended in furtherance of the plan of improvement from the mouth
to Eau Claire, including Shaw's Rapids.
July 1, 1885, amount available . ...............                   . ..        $1, 710 63
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1885 .................... ....    $1, 074 76
July 1, 1886, outstanding liabilities ....       ............. . .       16 00
                                                                                1,090 76
July 1, 1886, amount available................. ......................                  619 87
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886 ...................               18,750 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887 ..................             19, 369 87
 (Amount   (estimated) required for completion of existing project ........          15, 726 35
   Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1888         15,750 00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
     harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
    (See Appendix Y 4.)
                      RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                    259
  5. Chippewa River, at Yellow Banks, Wisconsin.-The object of this
work is to prevent erosion of the high sand-banks or bluffs on the Chip-
pewa River below Eau Claire and thereby relieve the channels of this
river and of the Mississippi below the junction of the two streams from
the masses of sand contributed by those banks.
  The project for improvement was adopted in 1883 following an appro-
priation of $30,000 for the work by act of Congress passed August 2,
1882. The estimated cost of the work, based upon the results of a sur-
vey reported upon January 30,1875, was originally placed at $64,102.50.
The estimate, however, as revised June 30, 1883, was increased, it hav-
ing been found from experience as the work progressed that the cost
per linear foot of protection was about $4, thus making the cost of pro-
tecting the 24,000 linear feet of banks $96,000.
  The protection work consists of revetment of piles, brush, and sand
at foot of slopes.
                                                                                                   Linear feet.
Banks protected since commencement of work .......--.... ................   4,969
Banks partially protected since commencement of work..................... 3,145
Banks upon which no work has been done ...... .....         -- .... ...... 15, 886
                                                       .. ......
   Total expended on the project to June 30, 1886, including outstanding
liabilities, $29,745.16.
   No work of protection was done during the past fiscal year for want
of funds.
   The sum of $30,000 asked for the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888, to
be expended in completing the work at Waubeek, Rumsey's, and Mary
Dean banks.
July 1, 1885, amount available..         ........   .........     ..................                 $296 59
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1885 .....---- ...............                       $37 75
July 1, 1886, outstanding liabilities ...... ...................                         4 00
                                                                                                        41 75
July 1, 1886, amount available................................................         ....   ..       254 84
( Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project........
                                                                      -  66,000 00
  Amount thatcan be profitably expendedin fiscal yearending June30,1888 15, 000 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
l harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix Y 5.)
  6. Saint Croix River, below Taylor's Falls, Minnesota and Wisconsin.-
The original project, adopted in 1878, was based upon the results of a sur-
vey made in 1874, when the Saint Croix was at a high stage of water
and comparatively few obstructions visible. Estimated cost, $21,758.
The project, which was followed until 1880, resulting in lessening the
difficulties of navigation, contemplated removal of obstructions from
the channels between Taylor's Falls, Minnesota, and Prescott, Wis.
Expended under this project, $18,000.
  The present project, adopted in 1880 and modified as to cost in 1882,
consists in the removal of snags, bowlders, wrecks, leaning trees, and
sand-bars from the channel between Taylor's Falls and Prescott, and
the contraction of the low-water channel into one of nearly uniform
width, especially at the bars and crossings, by means of jetties of brush
and stone and dams of same material to close island chutes and sec-
ondary channels. Estimated cost, $83,450.
  During the fiscal year the training-wall across the bar at Hudson was
extended 165 feet, and 758 feet of the wall were protected against scour
with brush, stone, and gravel, and 3,000 cubic yards of material were re-
260        REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

moved from the improved channel at Catfish Bar. These bars are below
Stillwater.
   The work, since the adoption of the present project, has resulted in a
least depth of 3 feet on the improved bars above Stillwater, and 5 feet
on the bars below that place. It may be said of the work done that at
many places navigation has been made permanent where formerly it
was uncertain, and that in other places it has been made practicable,
where before improvement commenced it was impossible. Expended
under the present project to June 30, 1886, including outstanding lia-
bilities, $56,588.42.
    Some bars above Stillwater yet require improvement. Below Still-
water the wall at Hudson Bar should be extended, and the lower part
of the improved channel dredged; and a brush dam should be built out
from the right bank at Catfishs Bar, to maintain the improved channel
at that point. These channels are depended upon for the heavy steam-
boat and lumber-rafting business of Stillwater.
    The sum asked for the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888, to be expended
iAi furtherance of the existing project, and principally at Hudson and
(latfish bars, and in repairs to and extension of the revetment at Kelly's
Tsland, where a diversion of the channel has been threatened for sev-
eral years past.
July 1, 1885, amount available ......................................            $2, 882 68
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1885 ........................       $2, 450 28
July 1, 1886, outstanding liabilities ........................             20 82
                                                                                   2, 471 10
July 1, 1886, amount available ........................................                        411 58
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886 ....                   ................   7,500 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887 ...................                    7, 911 58

 ( Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project ........ 19, 000 00
   Amount thatcanbeprofitably expendedii in fiscalyear ending June 30,1888 19,000 00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
     harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix Y 6.)
   7. Minnesota River, Minnesota.-Forwant of funds no work for im-
provement was done during the past fiscal year. The last appropriation
for this stream was $10,000, made by the river and harbor act of Coh-
gress approved June 18, 1878.
   The original plan for the improvement of the Minnesota River was
based upon the results of an examination made in 1866. Two plans
were considered. viz, one to provide for 4 feet of water from the mouth
to the Yellow Medicine River by means of locks and dams, at cost of
$775,500; the olher to secure 2 to 3 feet of water throughout the same
distance by removal of snags and bowlders in addition to the construc-
tion of a lock and dam at Little Falls'and the operation of a scraper and
dredge-boat, at a cost of $117,000. Following this report and also a re-
port made in accordance with requirement of section 2, of act approved
June 10, 1872, Congress appropriated in all $77,500, which was applied
to removal of snags, bowlders, and overhanging trees between Minne-
sota Falls and Mankto.
   By act of Congress approved June 23, 1874, an appropriation of
$10,000 was made "for the survey or improvement of the Minnesota
River." This sum was applied to a survey from the mouth of the river
to South Bend, 116.4 miles, to determine the practicability of improve-
ment by means of canals, lock, and dams. The survey proved the pos.
                      RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                     261
sibility of lock and dam navigation for the distance passed over, the es-
timated cost being-
For five locks and dams.    _..............     ........................... $699,283 53
And for removal of snags, &c......................            ................     34,585 10
       Total ..---....-......
                          ....-------....--....
                                             ----...........................       733, 868 63

   Following the report of this survey, upon which is based the present
plan of improvement, so far as removal of obstructions is concerned,
Congress appropriated $30,000 for the stream by acts of 1875,1876, and
"1878, which sum was applied to clearing the river of obstructions below
South Bend.
   The result of the work was to clear of obstructions long stretches of
the river. Little or no use, however, was made of the improved chan-
Aels, there being no steamboat navigation of importance on the river.
   No appropriation is asked for the year ending June 30, 1888.
   There has been expended upon the present project of improvement to
June 30, 1886, including outstanding liabilities, $29,967.
July 1, 1885, amount available.....................        ..........
                                                             ......                    $42 00
July 1, 1886, outstanding liabilities .....................................              9 00
July 1, 1886, amount available ...... .......... ......-          ..............        33 00
   (See Appendix Y 7.)
   8. Red River of the North, Minnesota and 1)akota.-The present,
which is also the original, project for the improvement of this river
from Breckenridge to the northern boundary line, adopted in 1877
and amended as to cost in 1883, consists in removal of snags, leaning
trees, and bowlders, and in dredging channels through the bars. Esti-
mated cost, $179,310.18.   During the past fiscal year dredging was con-
tinued to a point 47 miles by river below Grand Forks, 3,950 linear feet
of channels having been excavated through the bars, the work cover-
ing 15 miles in extent of river.
  The first work of improvement was done in 1877. The total of work
to date may be briefly summarized as follows:
Number of miles over which work has been done, including dredging,
  removal of snags, bowlders, &c... ..........          ....... ............              275
Number of miles passed over by dredges............ ..................                                   127
Number of channels cut by dredges...... .... ..............                                             101
Tumber of cubic yards of material excavated.                                                      334,179
  otal linear feet excavated.............................................                           36, 725
Total linear feet of dams constructed of excavated material........ ......                          63, 500
Number of leaning trees removed.................................                          ......     8, 878
Number of snags removed ............              ............          .....   ...... .........        604
Number of cubic yards of bowlders removed............ ...............                                   321
Number of piles removed-------............--....--------...... ..-------.......-------------------       16
Sunken barge removed..........---
                             ---......--------....--......---........--------------                       1
  Before work of improvement commenced the ruling depth on the bars
between Moorhead and the head of Goose Rapids at low water was 1I
feet; and below Grand Forks 2 feet, and the channel between Moor-
head and Breckenridge was much obstructed by snags and leaning trees.
Since commencing the work of improvement a least depth of 3 feet at
low water has been secured for 80 miles below Moorhead, and of 4 feet
for 47 miles below Grand Forks, and no difficulty is now experienced
over those improved portions of the river by boats loaded for those
depths. In addition, snags and other obstructions have been removed
from the channels for /76miles above Moorhead to the improvement of
navigation at high and medium stages of water
262           REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

    The improvement has resulted in largely increasing facilities for mov-
ing grain and merchandise.
  Total amount expended on the project to June 30, 1886, including out-
standing liabilities, $122,149.97.
July 1, 1885, amount available......----....---------..........................-                    $5, 571 85
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885..........------------------------..--..----------................ ------  4,721 82
July 1, 1886, amount available--...... ......
                                        --....-...... ....-
                                                        - ....  -----
                                                             ....---
                                                                ....--.... 850 03
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886 ................... *46,947 65
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887 ....                                               47,797 68
                                                                                               --...........
  SAmount (estimated) required for completion of existing project-------.......                                    56, 310 18
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
    (See Appendix Y 8.)
    9. Constructing lock and dam at Goose Rapids, Red River of the North,
Minnesota and Dakota.--The original estimate for this proposed work,
1877, was $219,287.99. Object to overcome the fall at the worst ob-
structions near the head of the rapids, so as to connect with the pro-
posed dredging improvements of the river above and below the rapids.
  The acts March 3, 1881, and August 2, 1882, appropriated a total of
$50,000 for the work. This sum being small in proportion to the proba-
ble cost of the work, and more detailed information in regard to the en-
tire extent of rapids than was at hand being needed, a survey was made
during the season of 1883, in order that a close estimate of the cost of
improvement might be available for consideration.                                                 The report of the
survey, which was transmitted to the House of Representatives March
12, 1884, presented three plans, with estimates of cost, as follows:
1. Lock and dams at Buffalo Neck and Isabella Island, and necessary
    dredging----.--......----...........-----...---............................-----------------------------....    $481,128
2. Lock and dam at Buffalo Neck, and necessary dredging ...............                                              274, 128
3. Dredging the bars on the rapids and utilizing the dredged material
     for dams, training-walls, &c----.......................................--                                        30,000
  The report suggested the advisability of substituting an improve-
ment by dredging for that by locks and dams, and the consideration of
the advisability of rendering the appropriations already made available
for the work of dredging. Should, however, the improvement by a lock
and dam with dredged approaches (cost $274,128) be decided upon, the
sum of $100,000, in addition to the sums already appropriated, can be
profitably expended during the fiscal year ending June 30, 18887 in pre-
liminaries, excavation, foundations, &c.
  Amount expended (in examinations) to June 30, 1886, is $3,052.35,
which also is the total amount expended.
   There are no operations to report for the year ending June 30, 1886.
July 1, 1885, amount available.......... .............. .................. $46, 947 65
                                                               t46, 947 65
July 1, 1886, amount available.........--......--------........----....---.......
  Amount (estimated) required for completion of projected lock and dam, &c. 224,128 49
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix Y                 9.)
  * The river and harbor act of August 5, 1886, directs that the money heretofore ap-
propriated for locks and dams on this river be made available for the continuation of
the above improvement.
  t The. river and harbor act of August 5, 1886, directs that the above "amount
available" be applied to clearing the river of obstructions.
                       RIVER       AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                       263
   10. Reservoirs at headwaters of Mississippi River.-The object of the
reservoirs is to collect surplus water, principally from the precipitation
of winter, spring, and early summer, to be systematically released, so
as to benefit navigation during the season of drought upon the reaches
of the several streams below the dams, and also upon that of the Mis-
sissippi below Saint Paul. This project may be said to have been
adopted in 1880, following an appropriation by Congress for the work
by act of June 14, 1880. The system, as originally reported upon, pro-
vided for 41 reservoir dams in Minnesota and Wisconsin, at an esti-
mated first cost (omitting that of land, &c., damages) of $1,809,083.
   No benefit of consequence can accrue to the navigation of the Mis-
sissippi River below Lake Pepin unless the entire system of dams be
built.
   During the fiscal year construction of the dam on Pine River at the
outlet of Cross Lake progressed. The dam will probably be completed
by the latter part of August. The reservoir created by this dam has
a capacity of 7,000,000,000 of cubic feet.
   In addition to the Pine River reservoir dam are three dams completed
in 1884, viz: At Lake Winnibigoshish, Leech Lake, and Pokegama Falls.
During the low-water season of 1885 the volume of water discharged
from the reservoirs created by these dams undoubtedly added from 1
foot to 18 inches to the depth of the Mississippi River at Saint Paul
for seventy days. Expended to June 30, 1886, including outstanding
liabilities, $568,521.31, which amount includes that awarded to Indians
for damages.
   The officer in charge calls attention to the numerous private dams
at the headwaters of the Mississippi River and its tributaries erected
by lumbermen in order to impound water for log-driving, many of the
dams being closed from July to the April following, thus depriving the
Mississippi of water when it is most needed, the impounded water being
liberated in the spring for driving purposes, when the river does not
generally need an increase in volume of water. He recommends that
the system of reservoirs on the Mississippi River above Minneapolis be
completed before extending it in other directions, in order that a full
test of the project may be made, and recommends increasing the lift of
Pokegama Reservoir by 2 feet, and a survey of Sandy Lake and River
with a view to converting the lake into a reservoir.
   The sum of $29,500 asked for the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888, to
be expended in care and maintenance of dams built, increasing the lift
of the Pokegama Reservoir, in survey of Sandy Lake and River, and
in securing the title, for reservoir purposes, to about 400 acres of low
lands below the Pokegama Reservoir.
July 1, 1885, amount available......- ........................              ..........       $65, 256 87
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1885......---...... ........... 46, 584 92
July 1, 1886, outstanding liabilities........................      2,193 26
                                                                                             .48, 778 18

July 1, 1886, amount available....--------........----------------------------............    16, 478 69
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886.................. -----------------        37, 500 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887.--------........------........          53,978 69
 ( Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project...... 1,186, 583 50
   Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
     1888......---------                                       ----------------------- ---
                   ....---......--- ........................--------....--.                29,500 00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of section ? of river an4
k harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
    (See Appendix Y 10.)
264        REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

  11. Surveys for reservoirs at the sources of the Mississippi, Saint Croix,
Chippewa, and Wisconsin rivers.--The officer in charge reports that if
the reservoir work now begun in Minnesota at the headwaters of the
Mississippi River is to extend to the Saint Croix, Chippewa, and Wis-
consin rivers, it will be necessary, in order to meet questions constantly
arising as well as to be enabled to make close estimates of cost of dams,
&c., to continue hydrological observations, borings, and contouring of
proposed dam-sites. The funds available for these surveys in 1878 and
1879 were not sufficient for a thorough examination of all the region
with reference to flowage, so that in estimating areas of land liable to
overflow from creation of reservoirs, large margins were necessarily
taken, on the side of safety. He estimates the cost of examinations for
one year at $50,000. There having been no appropriation for such work
during the past fiscal year, nothing was done under this head.
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project...,.-- $50, 000 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix Y 11.)
IMPROVEMENT OF TENNESSEE AND CUMBERLAND RIVERS, AND OF
    CERTAIN RIVERS IN EASTERN TENNESSEE AND KENTUCKY.

  Officers in charge, Maj. W. R. King, Corps of Engineers, to March
20, 1886; since which date Lieut. Col. J. W. Barlow, Corps of Engi-
neers.
  1. Tennessee River.-(a) Abave Chattanooga.-Thissection, from Chat-
tanooga to Knoxville, a distance of 189 miles, is navigable the greater
part of the year. The obstructions are principally rock-reefs, gravel
and sand bars, &c.
  The present plan of improvement consists of blasting a channel
through the reefs, reducing the bars, and building wing-dams to con-
tract the water-way, so as to secure a depth of 3 feet at low water.
   No work was done during the fiscal year. Active operations were
suspended in October, 1884.
   The total amount expended to June 30, 1886, was $218,442.86, which
has resulted in the permanent improvement of many of the principal
obstructions, and in giving safer navigation and an increased depth of
water over the shoals near Knoxville.
   The appropriation of August 5, 1886, now made available, and the
amount herein asked for can be profitably expended in continuing the
work under the existing project, and in repairing and extending the
dams already built.
July 1, 1885, amount available          .        .       ...                                       $149 64
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1885 .----..... ---.... --...... ..--.....----.       $67 39
July 1, 1886, outstanding liabilities --. ...... ......                                  25 11
                                                                                    "                92 50
July 1, 1886, amount available .................. .... .... ... ............                         57 14
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886...................                            7, 500 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887 -...........
                                                           ----......                    ---      7,557 14

r Amount                                              project........
           (estimated) required for completion of existino
   Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal
                                                                                                 74,000 00
                                              yearending June 30, 1888                           10, 000 00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix Z 1.)
                     RIVER AND HARBOR               IMPROVEMENTS.                         265
   (b) Below Chattanooga.-This section of the river is about 456 miles
in length. In its original condition from Chattanooga to Brown's Ferry,
162 miles, it was obstructed by reefs, bars, &c., and had about 3 feet of
water in channel for nine- months in the year; thence to Florence, 39
miles, including the Muscle Shoals obstructions, not navigable. From
Florence to mouth of river, 255 miles, there were the usual surface ob-
structions, with numerous shoals, having navigable pools between them.
   The present project consists in building a canal, 14J miles long, 70
feet to 120 feet wide, and 6 feet deep, around the Big Muscle Shoals,
having nine locks, each 300 feet long between gates, and 60 feet wide,
and an aqueduct, 900 feet long and 60 feet wide, over Shoal Creek; in
constructing a canal, 1 miles long, with two locks, around Elk River
Shoals, and in blasting a channel through the bed-rock and building
wing-dams at Little Muscle Shoals; in improving the most dangerous
obstructions above Decatur and below Florence.
   The total amount expended to June 30, 1886, was $2,689,839.74, which
has resulted in the improvement of the river as follows: The Little
Muscle Shoals work, as modified, is practically completed; a channel
24 miles long has been cut through the rock-bed and necessary wing-
dams built.
   At the Big Muscle Shoals the nine locks are completed, and all the
lock-gates except the drop-gates of Locks No. 5 to No. 9 are built. The
lower gates of Locks No. 1 to No. 8 are erected, and those of Lock No. 9
are framed and drilled. The upper gates of Locks No. 1 to No. 4 are
in position. The masonry of the Shoal Creek Aqueduct is completed,
and all the supporting beams are in position, and the drilling and
riveting of the:steel bottom-plates well advanced. Several permanent
bridges and dry rubble protection-dams have been built. The canal-
trunk is approaching completion.
  At the Elk River Shoals the channel excavation is completed; the
masonry of both locks is nearly finished; all the gates are built, and
on one lock are placed in position; the excavation of the canal-trunk is
well under way.
   Several of the most serious obstructions, above Decatur and below
Florence, have been greatly improved by the work done at various times
since 1868.
   The appropriation now available, and the amount herein asked for,
can be profitably expended in completing the work of opening the
Muscle Shoals Canal to navigation, and in improving the channel below
Chattanooga, at the Bridgeport Bar, Tuscumbia Shoals, Colbert Shoals,
and other points, also in removing surface obstructions below Florence,
Ala.
July 1, 1885, amount available ........................................              $120,506 28
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive
  of liabilities outstanding July 1, 1885 ...................           $105, 664 30
July 1, 1886, outstanding liabilities .......................              9,181 72
                                                                                      114,846 02
July 1, 1886, amount available ................................ .....                 5, 660 26
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886..................                262,500 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887.................              268,160 26
I Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project...... 1,175,000 00
   Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June
( 30, 1888-......... ......... ..................   .....--............   500, 000 00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
     harbor acts of 1866 and 1867,
   (See Appendix Z 1.)
266        REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

   2. Cumberland River, Tennessee and Kentucky.-Some work was done
by the States of Tennessee and Kentucky about fifty years ago, but
without permanent beneficial results.
   (a) Below Nashville, 192 miles.-The project for improving this sec-
tion consists in deepening and widening the channel through rock-reefs
and gravel-bars, removing snags, bowlders, &c., and building riprap
dams, so as to secure a lengthened season of navigation.
   A small working force was employed for a few weeks in clearing the
channel between Elk Creek and Line Island, but operations were sus-
pended September, 1885, the available funds being exhausted.
   The entire amount expended to June 30, 1886, was $242,359.26, and
has resulted in lengthening the season of safe navigation and an im-
proved channel for steamboats drawing 31 or 4 feet of water, and per-
mitting light-draught boats to run during the low-water season.
   The amount herein estimated for can be profitably expended in con-
tinuing the work of improving the lower Cumberland, including the bat
at its mouth, in accordance with the present project.
July 1, 1885, amount available..........--....--....---....--...-----..--......-----.... $1, 588 77
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1885------......................... $1, 303 34
July 1, 1886, outstanding liabilities.....----.... ......-- ...-- ....            144 69
                                                                                          1,448 03
July 1, 1886, amount available ....................                 ......           ..........             140 74
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886----------...........--..-..---------.                 12,500 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887 .---                   -..................------
                                                                                                - ---    12, 640 74
SAmount (estimated) required for completion of existing project ........
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1888
                                                                                                         93,000 00
                                                                                                         20, 000 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix Z 2.)
   (b) Above Nashville, 335 miles.-This section now extends from Nash-
ville to the head of Smith's Shoals.
   Prior to 1884, the river above Nashville was provided for in the river
and harbor acts, under four distinct heads, making an aggregate appro-
priation of $281,000, all of which has been expended, and has resulted
in securing a greatly improved channel, with a lengthened season of
navigation, and an increased depth of from 6 to 8 inches of water on the
principal obstructions.
   The present project consists of building locks at the worst obstruc-
tions and dikes upon the sections least obstructed, thus seeking to se-
cure the benefits of both systems, with an expenditure much less than
would be obligatory for a complete system of locks.
   The amount expended under this plan has amounted to $39,601.75,
which has been applied to the improving of the shoals at Upper Nash-
ville Island, by excavation and spur-dams, and in quarrying stone for
dams at Priestly's Shoals, an obstruction about 7 miles above Nashville.
   The funds that are now available and the amount herein asked for
can be profitably expended under the existing plan in channel work and
in building locks, beginning with the lowest lock near Nashville.
   The engineer officer in charge suggests the advisability of such a sub-
division of future appropriations for the river above Nashville as will
enable operations to be carried on simultaneously at either end of the
proposed system of locks and dams, with a view to giving to each sec-
tion, as the work progresses, the benefits of an improved navigation.
                          RIVER AND             HARBOR          IMPROVEMENTS                             267
July 1, 1885, amount available..                                                                 $29, 060 35
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive
   ofr liabilities outstanding July 1, 1885.................... $17,491 44
July 1, 1886, outstanding liabilities ........................   1,170 66
                                                                                                    18,662 10
July 1, 1886, amount available.................. ......................                            10, 398 25
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886.................                                75,000 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887 ..................                           85, 398 25
   Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project .....                   3,952,922 00
   Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
     1888 ............................ ......-----------------------------------.....----------...........-----.......
                                                                                            400,000 00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
    (See Appendix Z 2.)
   (c) Above the mouth of Jellico, Kentucky, 110 miles.-No work has been
done on this section since 1882, for the reason given in former reports.
   The total amount expended on this section is $10,000, which has re-
sulted in clearing the channel below Pineville of snags, bowlders, and
overhanging trees, and reducing gravel-bars, &c.
   The principal obstructions remaining are 11 mill-dams, and until these
are removed or modified no further work can be done to advantage.                                            A
list of these dams is given in Annual Report of Chief of Engineers, 1883.
July 1, 1885, amount available.........................................                            $5, 361 56
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885.... ..........................................                              361 56
July 1, 1886, amount available ..........................................                           5,000 00
  SAmount  (estimated) required for completion of existing project....
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
                                                                                                   40, 000 00
     harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix Z 2.)
   3. Hiawassee River, Tennessee.-This river is a tributary of the Ten-
nessee.
   The natural channel is chiefly obstructed by bowlders and rock-bars.
The overhanging trees falling in during the flood season form snags,
and require work from year to year to keep the channel free from these
surface obstructions.
   The present plan is to secure a clear channel 40 feet wide and 2 feet
deep at low water, from the mouth of the river to Savannah Ford, the
head of navigation, about 33 miles.
   Work was begun in the channel in August, and continued until Oc-
tober, when high water stopped operations.
   The total amount expended to June 30, 1886, is $30,367.72, and has
resulted in obtaining an improved channel throughout the 33 miles, as
projected, but many of the shoals require much additional work in the
interest of safe navigation.
   The funds available, and the amount herein asked for, can be profit-
ably expended in continuing the work of clearing the channel, building
necessary wing-dams, &c.
July, 1885, amount available...........................................                             2, 631 53
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1885...... ...                  ..............
                                                                  $1, 461 51
July 1, 1886, outstanding liabilities ....................                               37 74
                                                                                                     1,499 25
July 1, 1886, amount available. ---------------------------.         -----------                    1,132 28
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886 ....................                             2,500 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887.. .................                            3,632 28
268        REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project--------........             $2,500 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year endingJune 30,1888                    2,500 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix Z 3.)
   4. FrenchBroadRiver, Tennessee.-This river rises in North Carolina,
and after a course of 121 miles in Tennessee joins the Holston, about 44
miles above Knoxville, thus forming the Tennessee River.
  The present plan consists in removing surface obstructions and in
building wing-dams, so as to secure a safe channel having 2J feet dur-
ing the low-water season as high as Leadvale (90 miles); above that
point the river is not susceptible of improvement, except by slack-
water navigation.
   The total amount expended to June 30, 1886, is $21,870.20, which has
resulted in securing a greatly improved channel and .the removal of
what had been very dangerous obstructions. The work done has given
much satisfaction to river-men generally.
  The amount herein asked for could be profitably expended in con-
tinuing the work of improvement as projected.
July 1, 1885, amount available.- -.                   .   ....-           --                    440 00
                                                                                               $--
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1885.........................                   $261 29
July 1, 1886, outstanding liabilities..........-...               .   .             48 91
                                                                                                310 20
July 1, 1886, amount available ...................-
                                                 ---. ... ..----.                               129 80
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886...................                         6,000 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887..........                ..........    6,129 80
  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project....        122,000 00....
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1888 20, 000 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix Z 4.)
   5. Clinch River, Tennessee.--This river, about 400 miles long, rising
in Virginia, is a tributary of the Tennessee River, and has a course in
Tennessee of about 230 miles.
   The plan of improvement consists in excavating a clear, wide chan-
nel through the ledges and gravel-bars, securing at ordinary low water
a depth of 2 feet to Clinton, 70 miles, and at 11 feet from Clinton to
Walker's Ferry, 75 miles; above this point some excavation was done
a few years ago in clearing and deepening the channel.
   The total amount expended to June 30, 1886, is $20,963.43, and has
resulted in securing a greatly improved channel at some of the most
dangerous obstructions, and navigation made safe at a stage of water
from 2 to 3 feet lower than before the work was begun.
   The improvement is practically permanent, and river-men express
satisfaction therewith.
   The amount herein asked for can be profitably expended in continu-
ing the work as projected.
July 1, 1885, amount available.------------. ---- --------------. ---------                   $110 15
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1885..--...................       $27 66
July 1, 1886, outstanding liabilities.... ..........          .--    45 92
                                                                                                73 58

July 1, 1886, amount available.. -... ..............--
                                                 -     - -       ..-- ...                       36 57
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5,1886..- .....-.---.          .                  5,000 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887...................--                   5, 036 57
                       RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS,                                          269
SAmount (estimated) required for completion of existing project....... $24,000 00
) Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1888 10,000 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix Z 5.)
   6. Duck River, Tennessee.-This river is a tributary to the Tennessee
River, which it enters about 14J miles above Johnsonville.
  An examination made in 1879 to Centerville, Tenn., about 68 miles,
shows that the channel was partly filled, and in some places blocked, by
surface obstructions.
  The present plan is to remove the snags and overhanging trees, re-
duce the rock and gravel bars, and build wing-dams where necessary
to obtain 3 feet of water, from four to six months of each year.
  No work has been done since 1883.
  The total amount expended to June 30, 1886, is $13,000, and has re-
sulted in placing the river in fair navigable condition from Cartersville
to its mouth.
  The amount herein asked for can be profitably expended in carrying
on the work under the present project, if Congress deems it advisable
to complete the improvement.
  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project........ $22,118 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix Z 6.)
   7. Caney.ForkRiver, Tennessee.-This stream flows wholly in the State
of Tennessee, and is an important tributary of the Cumberland River,
which it enters about 120 miles above Nashville.
  It was examined in 1879 to the head of navigation at Sligo Ford,
about 80 miles from its mouth. The obstructions were found to be
gravel-bars, snags, and overhanging trees, with a crooked channel, hav-
ing only a few inches of water at many of the shoals, when the river was
at a 3-foot stage above low water.
  The present plan is to clear, deepen, and straighten the channel, by re-
moving surface obstructions, building wing-dams, &c., so as to obtain
safe navigation for about five months in each year, when this river and
the Cumberland are at a good boating stage.
  No work was done during the fiscal year, the available funds being
nearly exhausted.
  The total amount expended to June 30, 1886, is $16,569.28, which has
resulted in obtaining a greatly improved channel, from its mouth to the
head of navigation, when the river is at a stage of about 3 feet above
low water.
  The amount herein asked for can be profitably expended in continu-
ing the work of improving channel as projected under the existing plan,
and in clearing away the snags, logs, &c., that are brought down more
or less every year by the heavy floods.
July 1, 1885, amount available ...... .........................             ......          $430 72
July 1, 1886, amount available... .... ..             ..........                     ..      430 72
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886..................                       3,000 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887 ...................                  3, 430 72
[ Amount
  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project........
         that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1888
                                                                                          10,228 00
                                                                                           5, 000 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (Bee Appendix Z 7.)
270 -      REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF                           ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

  8. Little Tennessee River, Tennessee.-This stream rises in the Blue
Ridge in Georgia, and enters the Tennessee River about 47 miles below
Knoxville. An examination was made in 1882 of the lower 13 miles
to the mouth of the Tellico River. The obstructions were found to be
those common to mountain streams, snags, rock-reefs, bowlders, &c.
The present plan is to remove the surface obstructions, and build the
wing-dams necessary to obtain at low water a channel 2 feet deep and
40 feet wide, as high as the mouth of Tellico River.
   No work was done during the fiscal year, no funds being available.
   The total amount expended to June 30, 1886, is $5,000, and has re-
sulted in securing a greatly improved channel, and improving some of
the most dangerous shoals. The proposed plan is, however, very far
from completion, and the amount asked for can be profitably expended
in the manner covered by the existing project.
  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project....... $18, 724 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1888 5, 000 00
  Submittedin compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix Z 8.)
   9. South Fork of the CGumberland River, Kentucky.-This stream is a
tributary of the Cumberland River, which it enters near Burnside, Ky.
   The obstructions are chiefly reefs, large bowlders, gravel-bars, &c.
The present plan is to improve the channel as far up as the Devil's
Jumps, about 44 miles, by removing surface obstructions, excavating
rock, and building wing-dams, so as to obtain safe navigation when the
river is at a 3-foot stage above low water.
   No work has been done during the year, the available funds having
been nearly exhausted in February, 1885.
   The total amount expended to June 30, 1886, is $6,867.30, which has
been applied in the improvement of the lower river, principally at Sloan
Shoals, and in fitting up the necessary boats, &c.
   If Congress deems it desirable to continue the work of improvement
the amount herein asked for can be profitably expended in channel
work between the Devil's Jumps and the mouth of the river.
July 1, 1885, amount available .............................           .............    $132 70
July 1, 1886, amount available..........................................                   132 70
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886 ...................                  5, 000 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887....................               5,132 70

  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1888            10,000 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix Z 9.)
IMPROVEMENT OF THE OHIO, MONONGAHELA, ALLEGHENY, AND MUS-
  KINGUM RIVERS.-OPERATING AND CARE OF DAVIS ISLAND LOCK
  AND DAM, OHIO RIVER, AND LOCK AND DAM NO. 9, MONONGAHELA
  RIVER.--CONSTRUCTION OF ICE-HARBOR AT MOUTH OF MUSKINGUM
  RIVER, OHIO7 AND HARBORS OF REFUGE NEAR CINCINNATI AND AT
  THE MOUTH OF THE GREAT KANAWHA RIVER.

  Officer in charge, Lieut. Col. William E. Merrill, Corps of Engineers,
having under his immediate orders First Lieut. George W. Goethals,
Corps of Engineers, to August 25, 1885, and First Lieut. Lansing H.
Beach, Corps of Engineers, from December 1, 1885, to end of fiscal year.
                RIVER AND ItARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                    271
   1. Ohio River.-The general method followed in improving the navi-
gation of the Ohio River is to secure additional depths at islands and
sand-bars by the construction of low dams closing unused passages or
shore dikes confining the water to narrower channels. A snag-boat
and two dredges are owned by the United States, and have constant
employment during the low-water season in taking out snags and
wrecks and dredging away gravel bars that cannot otherwise be re-
moved.
   The first appropriation for the improvement of the Ohio River was
made in 1827. The total amount thus far appropriated, including the
appropriation of August 5, 1886, is $3,770,479.25. In addition to this,
there has been allotted to this river a portion of twenty-three different
combined appropriations for the Ohio, Mississippi, Missouri, and Ar-
kansas rivers, which aggregated $1,947,000; but the amount thus allot-
ted is unknown.
   An outline of the work carried on during the past year is as follows:
   Davis Island movable dam.--This dam is 5 miles below Pittsburgh,
and forms a pool giving a constant depth of 6 feet above low water in
Pittsburgh Harbor. The dam can be lowered to give an open river in
high stages of water, and is an experimental structure towards the per-
manent improvement of the river by a system of movable dams.
   The lock was formally opened October 7, 1885, and parts not then
completed were finished during the year.
   The total cost of the work has been $910,000.
   Dike at Merriman.-Work now under contract; dike to be 2,200 feet
long. Has been built to a length of 780 feet.
   Darm at Black's Island.--A timber apron 500 feet long is to be built
below the exposed portion of dam. Work just begun.
   Dam at Wheeling Island.-Dam 500 feet long, closing channel behind
Wheeling Island. Finished, except a few weeks' work at surfacing.
   Dam at Captina Island.--Nearly completed for a length of 1,700 feet,
with 300 feet more yet to be built.
   Dam at Fish Creek--Partly completed for 1,250 feet. Yet to be built
550 feet.
   Dam at Three Brothers Islands.-To be 2,500 feet long. Crib-work
completed, but 2,000 cubic yards of riprap yet to go in.
   Dike at Sand Creek.-Extended to its full length of 1,485 feet, but the
outer 200 feet not ballasted. A spur-dike 150 feet long has been built
out from the shore, 200 feet below main dike, to arrest scour.
   Dike at Eight Mile.-Finished for a length of 800 feet from the bank,
and partly finished for the remaining 1,600 feet.
   Dike at Rising Sun.-The full length of 2,700 feet of substructure is
completed, and also 120 feet of superstructure.
   Improving Grand Chain.-Underthe project of reducing the width of.
the river at the Grand Chain by a series of dikes, two of the three dikes
projected have already been built, and the third is now under contract.
The substructure of No. 3 is completed for 800 feet and the superstruct-
ure partly built for a length of 550 feet. The finished dike will have a
length of 3,000 feet.
   The effect of the scour caused by these dikes is to wash away the
sand from the adopted channel and lay bare the patches of rock that
have made this part of the river so dangerous to navigation. In con-
tinuing the work, efforts will be directed to blasting out and removing'
the rock from the channel.
   The cost of the three dikes to the end of the fiscal year has been
 $126,438.97.
  Dredging.-Two iron hull dredge-boats built especially for work on
272        REPORT OF THE CitEP OF ENGCINEERS, tT. S. ARM.

the Ohio River, are owned by the United States, but for want of funds
both boats remained idle in port at Paducah during the year.
   Snagging.--After being lengthened 45 feet, the snag-boat E. A Wood-
ruffcame off the docks at South Saint Louis, August 28, and began her
season's work August 30, 1885. She worked over the whole length of
the river from this time until December 13, when she went into winter
quarters at the mouth of the Kentucky River. During the season 513
snags and 3 rocks were removed and 47 wrecks were wholly or partly
taken out or destroyed.
   Levee at Jefersonville, Indiana.-The building of this levee has been
carried on under a provision in the river and harbor act approved July 5,
1884, allotting "fifty thousand dollars, or as much thereof as may be nec-
essary, for the improvement of navigation of the river at Jeffersonville
and the protection of the Government property." The approved pro-
ject was the construction of a levee 5,818 feet long on the river front of
the town of Jeffersonville. This levee is practically completed. A
small amount of grading and paving is yet required where the levee is
crossed by Meigs avenue, Fulton street, and Mechanic street.
   The cost of the work to the end of the fiscal year has been $45,255.74.
   Removing obstructions at mouth of Licking River.-This obstruction
consists of a limestone ledge, across which there is only about one foot
depth of water in low stages of the river. As there is deep water for
2 miles up the Licking, it is proposed to cut a channel through the
ledge, giving Ohio River boats access to the many manufacturing estab-
lishments along the banks of the Licking not now accessible by boats
in low water. The cut will be about 1,500 feet long, 200 feet wide, and
4 feet deep at low water. The estimated cost of the work is $75,000.
Amount required to complete project, $56,250.
July 1, 1885, amount available............................... .....-- ...        $395, 760 19
July 1, 1885, allotment for improving falls of the Ohio....... $6, 219 47
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive
                                                - - -...-
  of liabilities outstanding July 1, 1885-- ......    -.......
                                                        - - - -- - - 303, 400 85
July 1,1886, outstanding liabilities....................-...... 32, 317 82
                                                                                  341,938 14
July 1, 1886, amount available... .............................                                     ....    53, 822 05
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 186.........                             ..........          375, 000 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887 ..................                                   428, 822 05
T Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
    1888 ....................-----...----. ......----......-----........------....--..-----------....       - 600,000 00
                                                                                                      ----....
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
  (See Appendix A A 1.)
  2. Operation and care of Davis Island Dam, Ohio River.-The lock
and dam were opened October 7, 1885, and have since been in regular
use. Some delay has been experienced in working lock gates on ac-
count of the breakage of the wheels supporting them. It has been
found desirable to have more power for moving the gates, and to make
use of steam-power for maneuvering wickets of dam.
  The number of steamboats, barges, and miscellaneous craft that
passed through the navigable pass from time of opening, October 7,
1885, to the end of the fiscal year was 14,015. Through the lock, 314.
Number of lockages, 83.
  The total expenses incurred during the year were $8,062.02. Esti-
mated expenses for 1886-'87, $12,015.
  (See Appendix A A 2.)
                      RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                  273
   3. Monongahela River, West Virginia and Pennsylvania.-No work
was done on this improvement during the past year, owing to lack of
funds.
   The work undertaken on the Monongahela is the extension of the
existing slackwater navigation from the mouth of Dunkard Creek to
Morgantown, W. Va., a distance of 14 miles. Two locks and dams are
required for this extension; No. 9, the upper, is already built, and No.
8, next below, is now in course of construction, with about two-thirds
of the lock masonry completed. Sufficient cut stone is already on
hand to finish the lock.
   The total amount appropriated for this improvement, including the
appropriation of August 5, 1886, is $397,900; of this sum $303,275.66
had been expended up to June 30, 1886. The money required for com-
pletion is to complete Lock and Dam No. 8, all of which could be ex-
pended to advantage during the next fiscal year.
July 1, 1885, amount available-.-............................              .........    $3, 724 34
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885.......---... ..... ............  ..... .........          ..     287 38
July 1, 1886, amount available.-.....-........... ......................                           3, 436 96
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886 ...................                            90,900 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887-..................                          94, 336 96
T Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project.....
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1888
                                                                                                  30, 376 00
                                                                                                  30, 376 00
  submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
l harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix A A 3.)
   4. Operating and care of Lock and Dam No. 9, MonongahelaRiver.-New
shafts and gear were put in to operate valves for the filling culverts of
the lock, and the stony valve was overhauled and adjusted. Face of
lock-wall also pointed. The total expenses incurred for the year were
$1,064.41". The estimated expenses for 1886-'87 is $1,200.
   (See Appendix AA 4.)
  5. Allegheny River, Pennsylvania.-No funds were available, and no
work was done during the past year. Money heretofore appropriated
for this river has been expended in removing rocks from the channel
and closing low-water chutes behind islands. It is recommended that
this work be continued. The estimate given is for this purpose.
  Work of improvement on this river was begun in 1879. Total amount
appropriated, including appropriation of August 5, 1886, is $135,000;
ex-pended to June 30, 1886, $104,365.71.
July 1, 1885, amount available.......            .......   ....   .....................             $634 29
July 1, 1886, amount available .................................                          .....       634 29
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886                    .................           30, 000 00

Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887..................                           30,634 29
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June30,1888                        40,000 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
  (See Appendix A A 5.)
  6. Dam at Herr's Island, Allegheny River.--The appropriation of
$37,500 under act of August 5, 1886, is the first that has been made for
this work. The undertaking is designed to form a navigable pool in
       18 E
274        REPORT OF THE CHIEF                     OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

the Allegheny River, opposite the cities of Pittsburgh and Allegheny,
by the construction of a lock and dam at the head of the backwater now
formed by the D)avis Island Dam. This will give increased harbor fa-
cilities for the two cities, and be a material benefit to the whole shipping
interests of the Upper Ohio River.
   Legislation is needed from the State of Pennsylvania, giving the
United States the necessary jurisdiction over land required for the
structure before any work can be done. It is hoped that this matter
will be settled during the coming winter and that the work can be taken
up in the spring. The officer in charge calls for the balance of the orig-
inal estimated cost of the work, since the whole structure can be advain-
tageously put under contract during the next fiscal year.
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886...................                          $37, 500 00

                                                                                  -....
( Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project -- ...-. 115,500 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1888 115,500 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix A A 6.)
   7. Ice-harbor at mouth of Muskingum Rtivcr, Ohio.-No money was
available for construction, and nothing was done during the year beyond
taking care of the property and protecting the work.
   The work in hand is the construction of a lock to give Ohio River
boats access to Pool No. 1 of the Muskingum River slack water when ice
is troublesome in the Ohio. The lock is somewhat more than half
finished, with sufficient uncut stone on hand to complete it. As the old
lock, now used to pass boats to and from the Ohio River, is in bad con-
dition, there is an additional demand for the use of the ice-harbor lock
by the regular Muskingum River boats.
   Including the sum contained in the river and harbor act approved
August 5, 1886, the total appropriation for this work amounts to $237,500.
and the total expenditure to J une30,1886, was $199,988.33. The amount
that can be profitably expended during the next fiscal year is the esti-
mated amount required to finish the lock.
July 1, 1885, amount available .............            ......-..----         ..............      $836 63
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885..............--------- ...........................                      824 96
July 1, 1886, amount available ................ .........................                            11 67
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886....-.                  ..........--     .    37, 500 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887 ...................                       37,511 67

  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project-------- 57,633 37
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1888 57, 633 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix A A 7.)
  8. JiMuskingum River, Ohio.-By a clause in the river and harbor act
approved August 5, 1886, provision was made for receiving the Musk-
ingum River Slackwater Improvement from the State of Ohio, but at.
the time when the annual report of Lieutenant-Colonel Merrill was sub-
mitted the work had not been turned over to the United States.
  This slackwater system is now in operation from the mouth of the
Muskingum to Zanesville, Ohio, a distance of 81 miles. In this distance
there are eleven locks and ten dams, the dam at Zanesville having a
                       RIVER AND            HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                   275
flight of two locks. The lock and dam at Symmes Creek, 4 miles above
Zanesville, is out of repair and is not now in use.
   The locks and dams below Zanesville are nearly all in need of imme-
diate repair, and it is estimated that the sum of $200,000 will be re-
quired to put them in good condition. This sum could be expended to
advantage in the next fiscal year. The sum of $20,000, appropriated by
the act of August 5, 1886, together with the balance of the State appro-
priation, will be used for operation and care of work whenever its trans-
fer to the United States shall have been made.
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886...................                         $20 000 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June30,1888 200,000 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix A A 8.)
  9. Operating and care of Locks and Dams on the iiMuskingum iver,
Ohio.-Ii case the Muskingum River Slackwater is received by the
United States, as provided for in the river and harbor act approved
August 5, 1886, the expenditures for the fiscal year ending June 30,
1888, are estimated at $37,000.
  (See Appendix      A 9.)A
  10. Harbor of Refuge near Cincinnati.-A contract for a third dike at
Four-Mile Bar, Ohio River, 10 miles above Cincinnati, is still in force.
The dike is finished for a length of 500 feet, but has yet to be raised 4
feet over the remaining distance of 2,000 feet.
  The object of this work is to protect the commerce of Cincinnati dur-
ing winter by catching and holding back ice floes, and secondarily to
deepen the water on Four-Mile Bar. Two dikes have been completed
and the third is now under construction. The amount expended on the
work to the end of the last fiscal year, June 30,1885, is $79,843.13.  No
additional appropriation is asked for this harbor.
July 1, 1885, amount available ................              .......................           $19, 466 61
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1885..........                   .. .... ...... $16, 309 74
July 1, 1886, outstanding liabilities ........................                       3, 156 87
                                                                                                19, 466 61
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886.....................                        11,250 00
   (See Appendix A A 10.)
   11. Harborof Refuge atmouth of GreatKanawhaRiver, West Virginia.-
The work consisted of the construction of three ice-piers in the Great
Kanawha River, a little more than a mile above the Ohio River. Two
of the piers are on the right bank, at distances of 4,200 and 6,300 feet
from the mouth of the river, and the third is on the left bank, at a dis-
tance of 6,600 feet. The piers are rectangular in shape and are built
to a height of 29 feet above low water.
   The three piers are completed and have already proved of great serv-
ice to the coal-shippers of the Great Kanawha. No additional funds
are required. Total amount expended, $14,831.56.
July 1, 1885, amount available.......................................... $10, 081 42
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885.......................................... ....  9,912 98
July 1, 1886, amount available ................................                    ........       168 44
    (See Appendix A A 11.)
276'      REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

EXAMINATION AND SURVEY FOR IMPROVEMENTS TO COMPLY WITH
REQUIREMENTS OF THE RIVER AND HARBOR ACT OF JULY 5, 1884.

   It appearing after preliminary examination that the locality was
worthy of improvement by the General Government, Lieutenant-Colonel
Merrill was charged with and completed the survey of Muskingum
River, Ohio, the report on the results of which were transmitted to
Congress and printed as House Ex. Doc. No. 48, Forty-ninth Congress,
first session.
   (See Appendix A A 12.)

IMPROVEMENT OF THE FALLS OF THE OHIO AND OPERATING AND CARE
  OF THE LOUISVILLE AND PORTLAND CANAL-IMPROVEMENT OF WA-
  BASH AND WHITE RIVERS, INDIANA.

  Officer in charge, Maj. Amos Stickney, Corps of Engineers.
  1. Falls of Ohio River, Louisville, Kentucky (Lieut. Col. William E.
Merrill, Corps of Engineers, in charge to March 15, 1886).-The present
project was adopted in 1883, the object being the enlargement of the
upper portion of the Louisville and Portland Canal and widening of the
approach thereto, which practically effects a very considerable enlarge-
ment of the harbor of Louisville, Ky.
  The amount expended to June, 30, 1886, was $70,533. The material
moved to June 30, 1886, was 158,102.5 cubic yards. The work was done
under three contracts. Operations were begun July 9, 1885, and carried
on during favorable stages of the river until the end of the fiscal year.
Work was suspended for nearly four months by reason of high water
and bad weather. The earth, loose rock, and river wall are nearly re-
moved from the lower section, and the rock excavation is about half
completed to grade. The contractor for the middle section has removed
about half the material necessary to clear the rock surface for blasting.
Under the three contracts about 245,130.5 cubic yards of material remain
to be removed.
  The appropriation asked for could be applied to building of north
wall and continuation of excavation.
July 1, 1885, amount available..................................... . ..... $284, 181 41
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1885 ......................   $54, 714 41
July 1, 1886, outstanding liabilities .........................  12, 017 18
                                                                              66,731 59
July 1, 1886, amount available .........................................     217, 449 82
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886 ...................       150,000 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887...................     367, 449 82

tAmount (estimated) required for completion of existing project........ 885, 363 00
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1888 300, 000 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
  (See Appendix B B 1.)
  2. Indiana Chute, Falls of the Ohio River.-The object of this work
was to improve the navigation of the Falls of the Ohio by straighten-
ing and deepening the channels of the middle and Indiana chutes, by
building guiding-dikes and removing rock obstructions.
  The amount expended to June 30, 1886, was $100,737.85, with consid-
erable benefit to commerce. The work so far is considered a great im-
                            RIVER         AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                      277
provement to the chute, but much remains to be done to give the ease
and safety to navigation that is required. But little work was done
during the year, owing to a high stage of water.
   The appropriation of $30,000 asked for could be applied to continua-
tion of work of rock excavation, repairs of dam, and perhaps a contin-
uation of the crib-work, forming a guiding-dike on the north side of the
chute.
July 1, 1885, amount available. ........            .................            ....     .--. $6, 219 47
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885---... ----..........------.................--..............--.       1,957 32
July 1, 1886, amount available..........                       ....-..                    ............
                                                                                    -....-......                   4,262 15
   Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project....... 150, 000 00
   Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1888 30, 000 00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
     harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
    (See Appendix B B 2.)
   3. Louisville and Portland Canal (Lieut. Col. William E. Merrill, Corps
of Engineers, in charge to March 15, 1886).-During the fiscal year the
canal was in operation 321 days; it was closed 41 days on account of
high water, and 3 days on account of ice.
   During the fiscal year 5,057 vessels, representing an under-tonnage of
1,254,342 tons, passed through the canal. The total nnmber of vessels
that passed Louisville by canal and river combined was 6,726, repre.
senting an under-tonnage of 1,765,497 tons. The work is in fair condi-
tion, needing only some minor repairs. The two bridges over the canal
were repaired. Small repairs were made to lock-gates and parts of the
moving machinery. The dry-dock was put in good order and necessary
repairs made to the old dredges and dredge-tender. Three new mud-
scows have been built. The new iron dredge hull was received from
the contractors, a boiler put in, and the machinery, &c., is being fitted
up. Proposals were invited for buil'ding a new tow-boat, and contract
awarded and executed May 13, 1886. The work is well under way.
   The plant for lighting the locks by electricity will probably be pro-
cured and placed during the coming year.
   The total receipts from all sources will amount to $988.31.
   The estimated amount required for operating and maintaining the
canal during 1886-'87 is $82,320.
July 1, 1885, amount available on approved project for fiscal year ending
  June 30, 1886---- ------...........-----..--...--..--------..........--......-----...--------------................ $91,840 00
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1885---- ------.......--..-....---...... $64, 262 75
July 1, 1886, outstanding liabilities.                     ..............              ....-..         5, 339 39
                   B B 3.)                                       69,602 14
   (See Appendix
   4. Wabash River, Indiana and Illinois (in charge of Maj. A. M. Mil-
ler, Corps of Engineers, to April 10, 1886).-Commerce on this river was
greatly interfered with by shoals, snags, logs, and leaning timber block-
ing the navigable channel. Appropriations for its improvement were
first ~made in 1872, and the project adopted was first the construction
of a lock and dam at Grand Rapids, near Mount Carmel, at which place
the river is completely cut in two at ordinary stages of water, and the
removal of certain rock ledges, sand-bars, snags, leaning timber, and
the closing of chutes, the idea being to obtain a navigable channel of
3J feet in depth from its mouth up to Vincennes.
278       REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

   This river has been separated into two portions in reference to its im-
provement, the dividing point being Vincennes, Ind., and appropria-
tions were made for each portion.
   (a) Below Vincennes.-In this portion the principal work was the con-
struction of a lock and dam at Grand Rapids, supplemented by the re-
moval of obstructions in the channel and the deepening of the water over
bars so as to give 3- feet in depth at low water.
   Previous to July 1, 1880, the appropriations were made to cover the
whole river, and up to that time $304,996.19 was expended on the im-
provement. Since then and up to June 30, 1884, $88,247.74 was ex-
pended on the removal of obstructions, and $7,000 for purchase of land,
&c., at site of lock and dam at Grand Rapids.
   During the fiscal year ending June 30, 1885, $1,756.07 was spent on
repairs to New Harmony Dam and removal of obstructions, and $2,824.54
on the lock and dam. During the past year no work except delivery
of stone has been done on the river owing to the want of funds. Plant
has been laid up under care of watchman.
   The amount of expenses for fiscal year ending June 30, 1886, was
$12,097.29. The appropriation asked for would be applied to the repair
of present works and the construction of the lock at Grand Rapids, and
protection of bank to prevent cut off at Grayville.
July 1, 1885, amount available .........................................                $27, 175 46
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1885.... .--.....--..............        $12, 097 29
July 1, 1886, outstanding liabilities............           ..............    1, 153 57
                                                                                         13,250 86
July 1, 1886, amount available .........................................               13, 924 60
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886...................                  69,000 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887 ....................              82, 924 60

(Amount (estimated) required for completion of works indicated....... 241, 600 00
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1888 100, 000 00
<Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
   I
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix B B 4.)
   (b) Above Vincennes.-The project for the improvement of this por-
tion of the river was the removal of obstructions and the construction
of wing-dams where necessary.
   In addition to the amount, $304,996.19, expended on the whole river
to July 1, 1880, $53,021.14 was spent on improving this portion of the
river to June 30,1884. This resulted in giving a fair navigable channel,
the principal obstructions having been removed.
   During the fiscal year ending June 30,1885, $8,701.77 was expended,
and the work done consisted in the removal of snags and the comple-
tion of the dam at Horseshoe Bend. During the past year no work
has been done. Plant has been laid up under care of watchmen. Of
two dams built, one has attained the object for which it was built and
is now in fair condition, needing but few repairs. The other dam, across
Horseshoe Cut-off, has proved a failure, the river cutting a new channel
around the root of the dam. The channel is 80 feet wide and enlarging.
The dam will have to be removed, with the snags and trees in the cut-off,
to afford passage for steamboats, navigation being cut in two at low
water.
   The amount expended during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1886,
was $1,901.98. The appropriation of $22,500 asked for would be applied
to snagging, repairs of Eight Mile Dam, and to removal of the dam in
                       RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                       279
cut-off at Horseshoe Bend, afterward to dredging, contraction works,
and protection of banks.
July 1, 1885, amount available ....- ...................................                               $3, 009 59
September 19, 1885, sale of steamboat Kerasind to another work---........                               1, 000 00
                                                                                                        4,009 59
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1885......................... $1,901 98
July 1, 1886, outstanding liabilities..---..     .............       3 90
                                                                                                        1,905 88
July 1, 1886, amount available.-..---- .--..--......--.   ----....--...-..--------......--    ---........ 2,103 71

rAmount (estimated) required for completion of existing project.-......                              22,500 00
I Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1888                          10, 000 00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix B B 4.)
   5. White River, Indiana (in charge of Maj. A. M. Miller, to April 10,
1886).-The project of improvement for this river contemplated the ob-
taining of a depth of water of 3) feet at low water. This has been par-
tially obtained from the mouth to Hazleton by means of dikes, a cut in
the rock at Kelly's Ripple, and the removal of snags in the channel.
The rock cut at Kelly's Ripple, which is the most important of the
works, has not yet been completed, but will, after completion, remove
the worst obstruction between the mouth of the river and Hazleton
Railroad Bridge, where the bad location of the draw prevents any navi-
gation at low water.
   The first appropriation was made in 1879, since which date improve-
ments have been carried on. The amount expended to June 30, 1885,
was $93,948.58.
   During the fiscal year ending June 30, 1886, no work was done be-
yond watching and taking care of plant.
   With the amount asked ($25,000) for the fiscal year ending June 30,
1888, it is proposed to remove snags, dredge some hard gravel bars,
and complete the cut at Kelly's Ripple. It is not considered advisable
to spend any money on improvements above Hazleton as long as the
present railroad bridge remains an obstruction.
July 1, 1885, amount available ...... ................          ...... ............      $1, 051 42
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1885 ........................                 $637 53
July 1, 1886, outstanding liabilities ..........................                    9 08
                                                                                         --               646 61

July 1, 1886, amount available .........................................                                  404 81
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886 ...........        ....                             7, 500 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887 ...................                              7,904 81
  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project .......                              17,500 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1888                          17,500 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix B B 5.)
IMPROVEMENT OF GREAT KANAWHA AND ELK RIVERS, WEST VIRGINIA,
       AND OF NEW RIVER IN VIRGINIA AND WEST VIRGINIA.

  Officer in charge, Lieut. Col. W. P. Craighill, Corps of Engineers.
  1. Great Kanawha River, West Virginia.--This river flows through afer-
tile and picturesque region, filled with mineral wealth, especially coal and
280          REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

salt. It was by nature divided into a number of pools, some of consid-
erable length and depth, separated by shoals of gravel and coarse sand,
which were the principal obstructions to navigation in low water, there
being often on them at such seasons but a few inches of water. In
some of the pools were found shallow places also obstructing naviga-
tion. There were also snags and loose rock in the channel. The navi-
gation above Charleston was more obstructed than below. Above, it
was almost suspended in summer. The coal and salt were generally
sent out on rises, which enabled the boats to pass safely over the ob-
structions that otherwise would stop their movements entirely. The
use of the river for the movement of these valuable products was there-
fore unsatisfactory and intermittent. By the agency and superintend-
ence of a Board acting under the State, first of Virginia and then of
West Virginia, considerable improvement in the river was from time to
time effected, tolls being charged on the commerce for payment of ex-
penses.
   The object of the improvement, begun several years ago by tho
United States, was to give a constant navigable depth of at least 6 feet
throughout the whole length of the Kanawha to its mouth at the Ohio
River, to be accomplished by large locks and dams. Those already
built have been about 350 by 50 feet in the clear. The peculiarity of
most of the dams is that they can be lowered, when the stage of water
in the river will suffice, over the shoals. This gives them the name of
"movable dams," and enables an open river to be had when the water
is high enough.
   Dams 3 and 2, both above Paint Creek, are fixed, as the declivity of
the river in that section is too great to permit the advantageous use of
the movable system. Dam 1 will also be fixed.
   Up to June 30,1885, the amount expended was $1,583,481.54. At that
date Lock and Dam 3, 21 miles above C(harleston Ferry, had been dom-
pleted, as also Locks and Dams 4 and 5, respectively 15 and 9 miles
above the same point. Lock 6, 4 miles below Charleston, was also com-
pleted except the gates, and good progress had been made at Lock 2,
26J, miles above Charleston.
   The amount expended in the year ending June 30, 1886, was $145,-
971.54, which has been applied to Lock 2 and Dam 6. The completion
of both is expected b.efore the end of 1886. Lock 2, however, cannot be
used until the dam is built, for which at least one more working season
will be required.
   Had funds been available, all the locks and dams needed for this im-
portant improvement could have been begun at the same time and fin-
ished in three years, with much economy to the United States, and with
manifest advantage in the use of the improved water-way.
   The development of commerce on this river has been very great since
its improvement by the United States, although the project has been
only partially executed, for want of money.
July 1, 1885, amount available------
                                 ......................................-----------------------.        $189 345 01
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1885 ..........-....                      ... - .. $134, 298 09
July 1, 1886, outstanding liabilities ...............                         ........       11,673 45
                                                                                                        145 971 54
July 1, 1886, amount available .............                  ...... ...... ...-       .   .        43,373 47
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886 .................                              187, 500 00

Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887........... -.....                            230,873 47
                      RIVER      AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                          281
(Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project ..... $1,670, 000 00
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June
                                      .--       ---....---.....-----
                                         ...........-...-------
   30, 1888..............------....--..........---                       500, 000 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix C C 1.)
   2. Elk River, West Virginia.-TheElk is one of the chief tributaries of
the Great Kanawha. Its course is tortuous, as is shown by the fact
that the distance from its mouth to Braxton Court-House is 54 miles in
a straight line, but 100 miles by the windings of the stream. The
average low-water width is about 200 feet, with narrows at the rapids
of about 150 feet in width, and occasional portions of about 300 feet in
width. The pools vary in depth from 3 to 10 feet, and are separated by
rapid shoals of cobble-stones and gravel, on which there has been, at
low seasons, a depth of but a few inches of water. The average fall per
mile in the river, from Braxton Court-House down, is about 24 feet, but
is not uniformly distributed, being greatest (about 4 feet per mile) in
the central section, and less (about 2 feet) in the upper and lower sec-
tions. Freshets of small height are of frequent occurrence, but rapidly
pass off. The annual rise in the spring is about 10 or 12 feet. An ex-
traordinary rise is sometimes had of 25 or 30 feet, but the duration is
not great.
   The approved project of improvement has been the removal of rocks,
snags, overhanging trees, &c., and the cutting of narrow sluices through
the rapids and shoals. The principal interests to be served are those
of lumbering and rafting, but much country produce is also carried
down stream in small boats, which return with merchandise, &c. The
cost of the improvement was originally estimated as $100,000, to make
it complete of its kind.
   The amount expended from the beginning to June 30, 1885, was
$17,000. Nothing has been done in the year ending June 30, 1886, for
want of funds. The country through which this stream flows is rich
in minerals and well fitted for agriculture and grazing. The improve-
ment already done has been of great benefit to that as yet compara-
tively undeveloped section.
   There are several obstructions to the navigation of this river, due to
the action of private parties or corporations, which should be removed
if the improvement is to be continued by the United States.
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886....................                                      $1, 500 00

  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1888.                                 3, 000 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix C C 2.)
   3. New River, from the mouth of Wilson, in Grayson County, Virginia,
to the mouth of GreenbrierRiver, West Virginia.-As has been stated in
previous reports, but is here repeated to save trouble in referring to
other volumes, the appropriations have been made in such manner as
to divide this portion of the river into three sections, as follows:
                                                                                                                   Miles.
Upper, or Lead Mines ....-----...-----........ ...                                                                  62
                                                                    -..-..----......................---------.........
Middle, or New River Bridge ....            ................---...........                     --........            43
Lower, or Greenbrier........ ..- .    ---   ---...--.............                 ...................          .     86J
   Throughout this distance the navigable channel consisted of natural
chutes through the ledges and shoals of varying widths, rarely over 1
foot in depth, in some places so tortuous as to render navigation ex-
tremely difficult and dangerous.
282        REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

   The original project adopted for the improvement of these natural
channels was to widen them to 30 or 50 feet, as might be required,
deepen them to 2 feet, and straighten such as needed it. This was for
bateau navigation; the improvement, however, to be made in such a
manner as to aid the work should a greater depth and width be required
in the future.
   A small steamboat, draught 12 inches when light, having been built
at Hinton in the fall of 1878, rendered it necessary to make the channel
in that section 50 feet wide at all points, and in many from 75 feet to
100 feet, the depth of 2 feet being retained. This steamboat was not
adapted in dimensions and power to the navigation of the river, and
has been withdrawn.
   The original plan of improvement has been adhered to, except that
the width of channels on the middle and upper divisions has been re-
duced to 20 feet, and on the former to 10 feet for several miles, to allow
iron to be shipped from the furnaces above.
   There was no appropriation for this river in 1883, 1884, or 1885. July
1, 1886, there was a balance remaining unexpended of $3,000 from the
appropriation of August 2, 1882. This pertained by special designation
of the law to the portion of the river above Foster's Falls, which are
not passable. The balance remained unexpended because of the im-
passibility of these falls. As the disconnection with routes of trans-
portation caused by these falls would practically disappear on the com-
pletion of the railroad up Cripple Creek, and as boats could then ship
to the railroad their freight at Porter's Ferry, above the lead mines and
the falls, it was concluded to improve the condition of Williamson's
Ledges and Shoals. This work was continued as late as the season
allowed, a small balance of funds being left unexpended, but not large
enough to justify the resumption of operations in the summer of 1886.
   The navigation of the river not being continuous as yet, it is practi-
cally a feeder to the railroads which cross it and run along portions of
it. It has also been of much use in carrying materials and supplies to
the railroads while in process of construction near it. It is probable
that when the river is fully improved boats will transport one-third of
the products of the fine agricultural country through which it flows,
and seven-eighths of those of the mines, exclusive of coal.
July 1, 1885, amount available ..............--------....--------------......----....--... ------ $3, 000 00
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885...... .......................................                           2,533 43
July 1, 1886, amount available ..........................................                              466 57
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886.......................                          10, 000 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887....-                 -        --..........   10,466 57
 ( Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project........ 159,000 00
   Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1888 20, 000 00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
   Sharbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix C C 3.)
IMPROVEMENT OF KENTUCKY AND TRADEWATER RIVERS, KENTUCKY;
  OF BIG SANDY RIVER, WEST VIRGINIA AND KENTUCKY ; AND OF
  GUYANDOTTE, LITTLE KANAWHA, AND BUCKHANNON RIVERS, WEST
  VIRGINIA.

Officer in charge, Capt. J. C. Post, Corps of Engineers.
1. Kentucky River, Kentucky.-The present project for the improve-
ment of this river was adopted in 1879, the object being to repair the
                       RIVER      AND     HARBOR        IMPROVEMENTS.                           283
five locks and dams built by the State of Kentucky, and extend slack.
water navigation for a draught of 6 feet by the construction of additional
locks and dams to Beattyville, a distance of 261 miles from the mouth
of the river.
   Four of the locks have been repaired, three of the Aams rebuilt, and
the fourth partially repaired during the previous years.
   The operations during the past fiscal year have been the reconstruc-
tion of Dam No.5, and the completion of the repairs to the lock, which has
extended the slackwater navigation to Oregon, Ky., 99 miles from the
mouth of the river. A new keeper's dwelling has been constructed at
Lock No. 1, the land has been procured for the dam at Beattyville and
its construction commenced, negotiations are about completed for the
land for Lock and Dam No. 6, and the repairs upon the snag-boat were
partially made. The upper river between the Kentucky Central Rail-
road Bridge and Beattyville was improved by the removal of obstruc-
tions and the construction of wing-walls, &c.
   During the present fiscal year the land for Lock and Dam No. 6 will
be purchased and the construction of these works commenced. The
dam at Beattyville will be completed, as also the repairs to the snag-
boat.
July 1, 1885, amount available .........................................                  $264, 721 80
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1885....................... $155, 641 81
July 1, 1886, outstanding liabilities ................                 ....... 24, 186 60
                                                                                           179, 828 41
July 1, 1886, amount available . ........... ..........................                   84, 893 39
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 186.................-     -                187,500 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887 ...................                272, 393 39
( Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project...... 2,034, 139 26
I Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
S188--...---...--......-------....------.----....---       ..------..----....
                                      .....--.---.....----.....--..---....    400, 000 00
I Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix D D 1.)
   2. Operating and keeping in repair locks and dams on the Kentucky
River, Kentucky.-During the fiscal year the slackwater navigation of
the Kentucky River was extended a distance of 17 miles by the com-
pletion of Dam No. 5, and the repair of the lock. The up-stream half
of Dam No. 4 was also reconstructed, and there is at present slackwater
navigation upon the Kentucky River for a draught of 6 feet a distance of
99 miles. Navigation has been continuous except when interrupted by
ice and the repairs to Dams Nos. 4 and 5. Two thousand one hundred
and ninety-five steamboats, 1,282 barges and flats, 1,936 rafts, and 780
miscellaneous craft passed through the locks, requiring 4,952 lockages.
This is a material gain over the amount of navigation reported last
year.
   The total expenditures to June 30, for the fiscal year, were $26,608.27.
The estimated amount required for operating and maintaining naviga-
tion for the year 1886-'87 is $33,965, with which it is proposed by the
officer in charge to remove by dredging several bars that have been in-
terfering with navigation, and to make the necessary repairs to the
locks and dams.
   The restoration of the slackwater system in this river has resulted
in a very material reduction in freight charges to the various points
284        REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

that can be reached by it. A year ago this reduction was estimated to
amount to about $70,000 for the preceding year. Since that time there
has been a still further reduction, as the system has been extended, and
the cost of transportation is now only about 50 per cent. of what it was
formerly. It is estimated that upon the item of coal alone there has
been a saving in freight of over $40,000 during the past year.
  (See Appendix D D 2.)
   3. Tradewater River, Kentucky.-This river is a tributary of the Ohio
and empties into it 79 miles below Evansville, Ind.
   The present project for improving this river was adopted in 1881.
It contemplates removing obstructions, and, by forming a channel with
a minimum width of 40 feet and a least depth of 2J feet during six
months of the year, rendering navigable for 41 miles a stream that
was practically closed.
   No work was done upon this river during the past fiscal year, no
funds being available.
   With the $2,000 appropriated by act of August 5, 1886, the improve-
ment of the river will be continued. It is proposed to complete the
improvement with the amount asked for.
July 1, 1885, amount available                     .............               ..... ......... .     $31 29
                                                                                                     $.........
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885 .......................               .............................        31 29
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886                     . .-...........             2, 000 00


  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1888                       6, 000 0
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix D D 3.)
  4. Big Sandy River, West Virginia and Kentucky.-The Big Sandy
River empties into the Ohio River and is the dividing line between
West Virginia and Kentucky. The project for improving the natural
channels of this river and its forks, by the removal of snags, bowlders,
and overhanging trees, and the concentration of the water at low stages
in the narrow channels, was adopted in 1878, the object being to form a
channel with a minimum width of 50 feet, containing at least 1 foot of
water during six months of the year. In 1880 this project was modified
and the construction of a lock and dam at Louisa added.
   During the past year the masonry work of the lock was completed
and data has been obtained to determine the character of the dam re-
quired. No work was done upon the forks or lower river, no funds be-
ing available for that purpose.
   When the improvement of this river was commenced navigation was
exceedingly hazardous, owing to the large number of snags, trees, and
rocks in the channel. These have been in a great degree removed, and
the river is at present navigable with at least 1 foot less water than
formerly. There have been 251 days of good boating-water in the river
during the past year.
   With the amount now available, the lock and the abutment will be
completed, and the excavation of the approaches to the lock continued.
The improvement upon the upper river will also be continued. It is
proposed to complete the dam and the excavation of the approaches
and continue the improvements of the forks with the amount asked for.
                      RIVER ANID HARBOR               IMPROVEMENTS.                            285
July 1, 1885, amount available .........................................                 $21, 064 53
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1885............ ............            $19, 930 51
July 1, 1886, outstanding liabilities ..         ...........   ........        202 00
                                                                                          20, 132 51

July 1, 1886, amount available ........................................                      932 02
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886 ......--...--.........                 30,000 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887 ...................                 30,932 02

  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project .......                  62,645 31
SAmount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June30,1888                62,645 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix D D 4.)
   5. Guyandotte River, West Virginia.-The Guyandotte River is a trib-
utary of the Ohio, and joins it at the town of Guyandotte, about 12
miles above the mouth of the Big Sandy River.
   The project for the improvement of this river was adopted in 1878.
This contemplated the formation of a clear channel 122 miles long, with
a minimum width of 30 feet and a least depth of 18 inches during five
months of the year, by the removal of snags, rocks, and other obstruc-
tions.
   When work was undertaken the channel was obstructed by the d6bris
of the old wooden locks and dams, together with the ordinary obstruc-
tions of snags, rocks, &c., and navigation was exceedingly difficult.
Since the work was commenced the commerce of the river has greatly
improved, and amounted to $1,450,000 during the past year.
   No work was done upon this river during the past year.
   The $2,000 appropriated by act of July 5, 1884, was retained pending
the action of Congress, as stated in the last annual report.
   This amount having been made available by act of August 5, 1886,
the improvement of the river will be continued in accordance with the
approved project.
July 1, 1885, amount available ......................... .. ...... ...... ......          $2, 000 00
July 1, 1886, amount available....................................................         2, 000 00
Amount reappropriated by act approved August 5, 1886 ................                      2, 000 00
  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project ........                  8, 000 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscalyear ending June 30,1888                 4, 000 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix D D 5.)
   6. Little Kanawha River, West Virginia.-Little Kanawha River is a
tributary of the Ohio, and empties into it at Parkersburg, W. Va.
   The present project for the improvement of this river, adopted in
1876 (and modified in 1880), contemplates the construction of a lock
and dam to extend slackwater navigation for a draught of 4 feet a dis-
tance of 12 miles, and the improvement of the natural channel of the
upper river by the removal of obstructions for a distance of 80 miles,
the object of the latter being to obtain a channel of a minimum width
of 40 feet, containing at least 2 feet of water during four months of the
year.
   This river flows through a rich wooded and mineral section. The
improvement of the upper river has resulted in not only a material in-
crease in the amount of commerce, but has made navigation much less
hazardous. The work upon the lower river has not progressed suf-
ficiently to affect the amount of commerce.
286        REPORT OF TILE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

  During the past year work upon the construction of the lock was
continued until October, when it was suspended by the exhaustion of
the funds then available. The foundation of the river and miter walls
was excavated, and the construction of the walls commenced. About
one-seventh of the masonry work of the lock was completed.
   Ten per cent. has been added to estimated cost of constructing this
work. This has been made necessary by the deterioration of the un-
finished work and the natural increase in the expense of conducting a
work where operations can only be continued a brief period each year.
   During the present season, with the amount now available, the con-
struction of the lock will be advanced as far as practicable, and the im-
provement of the upper river will be continued.
July 1, 1885, amount available......---------------...... .........------.....-----------................ $15,451 03
July 1,1886, outstanding liabilities-- .................                        ...                ...- - 14,479 99
                                                                                           -----......
July 1, 1886, amount available..... .... .... ...... .... .....    ....                         -
                                                                                           .... ....-       971 04
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886 ....................                                 16, 875 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887 ...................                               17,846 04

r Amount    (estimated) required for completion of existing project -....-.                            51,800 00
I   Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1888                         26, 800 00
     Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
     Sharbor  acts of 1866 and 1867.
     (See Appendix D D 6.)
  7. Buckhannon River, West Virginia.-TheBuckhannon River empties
into the Tygart Valley River, a tributary of the Monongahela River.
  The improvement of this river (approved in 1884) contemplates the
formation of a channel 241 miles long, with a minimum width of 30 feet,
and a depth of at least 2 feet during an average of four months each
year.
  When work was commenced this river was practically closed and it
was only possible to float out timber during the highest water. The
annual amount brought out at that time was about 115,000 linear feet.
The result of the improvement already made has increased the amount
of timber brought out to over 2,000,000 linear feet, and coal is now being
brought to market by river from mines that have been lately opened.
The latter, in consequence, has already been reduced materially in price
to consumers.
  No work was done upon this river during the past year.
  With the amount now available the improvement will be continued.
It is also proposed to continue it with the amount asked for.
July 1, 1885, amount available ........      .... .... .... .....              .....     ...........        $46 63
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1885 .... ..........           .... .... - ...             $8 50
July 1, 1886, outstanding liabilities ..........................                                75
                                                                                                               9 25
July 1, 1886, amount available ..........................................                                   37 38
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1866....................                                   1,500 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887 ...................                                1,537 38

     Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1888                          5, 000 00
     Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
       harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
      (See Appendix D D 7.)
                        RIVER       AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                287
IMPROVEMENT OF THE HARBOR AT DULUTH, MINNESOTA, AND OF
  THE ENTRANCE TO SUPERIOR BAY-IMPROVEMENT OF THE HAR-
  BOR AT GRAND MARAIS, MINNESOTA.

    Officer in charge, Maj. Charles J. Allen, Corps of Engineers.
    1. HarboratDuluth, Minnesota.-The original project for improvement
at Duluth, adopted in 1871, consisted of a breakwater in Lake Superior,
outside of Minnesota Point, it being a continuation of a breakwater
commenced by the Northern Pacific Railroad Company.
    The city of Duluth in 1870 commenced a canal through Minnesota
Point to connect the Bay of Superior with the lake. This proceeding
was resisted by Superior City on the ground that the canal would di-
vert the waters of the Saint Louis River from the natural entrance and
thus deprive it of the current necessary to its maintenance. In 1871
an injunction was issued at the instance of the War Department re-
straining further operations at the canal, but it was subsequently dis-
solved upon the execution by the city of Duluth of a bond for $100,000
to secure the construction of a dike to extend from Minnesota Point to
Rice's Point, thus isolating the harbor of Duluth from the rest of the
Bay of Superior. The dike was completed in 1872, but at present only
traces of it are visible.
   The act of Congress approved March 3, 1873, appropriated $100,000
for the purpose of dredging out the Bay of Superior from the natural
entrance to the docks of Superior and Duluth and preserving both
entrances from the lake thereto. This was regarded as legalizing the
canal. The outer breakwater was abandoned; the canal and inner har-
bor rendered it unnecessary. Expended upon original project,$110,000.
   Under an allotment of $36,049.20 from the appropriation of 1873, work
of improvement commenced upon the inner harbor and canal, the pro-
ject providing for dredging the harbor, extending and completing the
piers bordering the canal, and in making an opening through the dike
to provide for the passage of boats from Duluth to Superior, the Gov-
ernment assuming charge of the canal and its piers-work originally un-
dertaken by the city of Duluth. Work under this project continued un-
til 1881, the piers having been kept in repair, the south pier extended,
the main harbor area in front of the docks having been enlarged and
deepened in part to 16 feet, and a narrow channel dredged along the
east side of Rice's Point leading to intersection with the channel of the
Saint Louis River. Expended under this project, about $160,651.81
   The present project, adopted in 1881, provides for maintaining'depths
over existing dredged areas, and enlargement of the harbor by dredging
to a line joining Rice's and Minnesota points and about 600 feet easterly
from the canal, and on lines parallel to Minnesota and Rice's points, the
dredging to provide for vessels drawing 16 feet. Estimated cost, as re-
vised in 1884, $305,424.
   Work of improvement during the past fiscal year consisted in deepen-
ing and enlarging the main harbor in front of the docks, the following-
named quantities of material having been dredged:
                                                                                      Cubic yards.
From the old basin of main harbor ....... ...............             ....   ........... 41,476. 2
In enlarging the basin of main harbor .............................               .......21,709. 9
  Fifty-one and two-tenths cords of stone riprap were\ placed in the
canal at the inner face of south pier to guard against further settling
of the substructure of that part of the pier. This part of the pier-work
288          REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

was built by the city prior to the Government assuming charge of the
canal.
   Expended on the present project to June 30, 1886, including out-
standing liabilities, $143,648.67.
   The piers are in good condition, a slight settling of the portion of
south pier excepted. The ruling depths in the portions of the harbor
dredged by the United States are:
                                                                                                                  Feet.
               --------......-- ------ -----------......
In canal .................-------             ......                                          ......--............ 17
                                                                                       --------......-----
                                                                                ......----------
In main harbor or basin..................................           --.....................                           16
In Rice's Point Channel to a point opposite ElevatorE..........................                16
From point opposite Elevator E, through dredged channel along Rice's Point, to
                        ....                    ......-------......-......-----............... 12
  the Saint Louis River ------......-------........--.
  The portion of main harbor dredged by the United States has an area
of 741 acres. All, the areas and channels above mentioned, canal ex-
cepted, require widening.
  Before dredging commenced, in 1873, the depth in front of the docks
in what is now the main harbor averaged 9 feet; and before adoption
of the present project the harbor area was restricted, and there was no
channel of consequence along Rice's Point.
  The sum asked for the fiscal< year ending June 30, 1888, is to be ex-
pended in dredging and especially in enlarging the harbor, and in main-
tenance of the piers.
July 1, 1885, amount available .-....----......------....--....----..............--..--....-----.----........ $12, 836 80
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1885........... ....-........ $11, 064 70
July 1, 1886, outstanding liabilities .....................-------------------------.                  3 38
                                                                                                               11,088 08
July 1, 1886, amount available......................................--------------------------------------.    1,748 72
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886 ...................                                        56,250 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887 ----...................                                 57,998 72
   Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project ........ 119, 174 00
   Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1888 60, 000 00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix E E 1.)
   2. Dredging Superior Bay, Wisconsin.-The original project for im-
provement, adopted in 1867, consisted in construction of two nearly par-
allel piers at the entry to connect the deep water of the bay and lake,
the piers crossing and bordering a narrow tortuous channel of 8 to 9 feet
depth. Work under this project, including scraping between the piers,
which increased the depth between them to 10 feet, continued until
1873, at which time the total length of piers was 5,218 feet. Expended
under this project, $258,000. In 1873 the project adopted consisted in
extension of pier-work and in dredging between the piers and to the
wharves of Superior City, the dredging to afford 13 feet of water. The
piers were completed in 1874, total length 5,512 feet, the lake ends
resting in 16 feet of water and depth of water between the piers not
less than 12 feet. From this time until 1881 the work for improvement
was almost entirely confined to maintenance of the piers and of portions
of Minnesota Point through which waves threatened, irruption. A
small amount of dredging was done in 1879 near Connor's Point to fa-
cilitate passage of light.draught boats between that point and Duluth.
   Expended under the second project, $77,513.26, the piers having been
extended and kept in repair and Minnesota Point protected. By 1881
the ruling depth from the lake to the wharves was 11 feet.
                            RIVER AND HARBOR                              IMPROVEMENTS.                                                   289
   The present project, adopted in 1881 and modified in 1884, provides
for maintenance of piers and beach protection, and for dredging to af-
ford depths of 16 feet, as follows:
   Between the piers at the entry.
   From the entry along and parallel to the front of Superior City.
   Up the Nemadji River for about one-half a mile.
   The preservation of the Quebec Wharf Channel was added in 1881,
and dredging the channel of the Saint Louis River within the Bay of
Superior was added in 1884 by the act of July 5 of that year. This
last addition increased the estimate of cost of the project $33,000, thus
making it $345,080.
   During the past fiscal year dredging was done between the piers in
the Saint Louis River Channel and in the Quebec Wharf and Northern
Pacific Railroad Dock channels, and necessary repairs made to the north
pier at the entry.
   Expended under the present project to June 30, 1886, including out-
standing liabilities, $99,716.20.
   The piers and beach protection are in generally good condition, some
slight repairs and extension of beach protection being needed.
   The improved channels have the following-named ruling depths:
                                                                                                                                          Feet.
From Connor's Point to the entry ...........................................----------------------------------------.                       15
From the Northern Pacific Railroad Dock to the entry                                      --..------------------.......................     15
In front of Quebec Wharf ..........................---------                                     ---.....---......--.....
                                                                          ..--------------------....---......                               12
In the entry between lake ends of piers, the storm of November 6, 1885, having
  caused some shoaling .......--- .........--..---....--..------- ---........------....--- ---------------                                  16
In remainder of entry ....--..- - - - -----------..........- -...-----......----
                                                                            ....------...---------......         ..----....                 16
  Channel at mouth of Nemadji River, narrow with 8 feet depth of water.
   All of these channels require widening, and such as do not admit
vessels drawing 16 feet of water should be deepened accordingly. The
sum of $40,000 asked for the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888, to be ex-
pended in maintaining piers and beach protection, in extending the lat-
ter, and in widening and deepening the channels between the piers
from the entry to Connor's Point, and from the Saint Louis River Chan-
nel, within the Bay of Superior, to the Northern Pacific Railroad and
Quebec docks.
July 1, 1885, amount available                   ----..       --...............   .....................                         $13,010 07
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1885 .--...-.....-- . ......--- ... $9, 660 96
July 1, 1886, outstanding liabilities ..........................          194 77
                                                                                                                                    9,855 73
July 1, 1886, amount available---....---....---.................. ................                                                 3,154 34
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886----         ........--------...........                                        22,500 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887                                      --...-.....-- ......                   25, 654 34
 (Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project.....                                                           227, 580 00
   Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1888                                                      40, 000 00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
     harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
  (See Appendix E E 2.)
  NOTE.-The river and harbor act of August 5, 1886, directs that the
sum of $9,000 of the above appropriation of $22,500 be applied to dredg-
ing in Saint Louis Bay.
  3. Harbor at Grand Marais,Minnesota.-The project for improvement
of this harbor, adopted in 1879 and continued since that time, provided
for a breakwater to narrow the entrance and thus to increase the area
       119 ii
290        REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

of shelter for vessels occupying the harbor, and for dredging to enlarg(
the anchorage area and to afford depth of 16 feet of water. Estimated
cost, $139,669.40. The breakwater was completed in 1883, and dredg-
ing was done as appropriations were made for the work.
   Grand Marais is on the north shore of Lake Superior, about 110 miles
from Duluth, and is the only harbor of refuge for vessels on that rocky
coast. It lies within a few miles of the course of American steamers
from Duluth to Port Arthur, Ontario, and of the Canadian steamers from
Duluth to points beyond Saint Mary's Falls. American tugs are also
engaged in the fishing business along the north shore.
   Before the work of improvement was begun there was but a narrow
space under the lee of Mayhew's Point accessible to vessels drawing 10
feet of water, and the approach to this sheltered space was narrow.
Consequently navigators of small vessels had not always confidence in
their ability to make the harbor during storms. There is now a shel-
tered area behind the point, due to dredging operations and to the break-
water, of 8 acres, with least depth of 16 feet. During the past two
seasons many vessels have sought shelter in the improved harbor. But
in order to bring this harbor up to its maximum usefulness its anchor-
alge area should be enlarged and deepened.
   Some slight repairs were made to the breakwater during the past
fiscal year.
   Total expended on the project to June 30,1886, $68,045.42.
   The sum asked for the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888, is to be ex-
pended in dredging and maintenance of breakwater.
July 1, 1885, amount available ..........................---              . ............ .. $2, 493 87
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fical year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885......................             .....................              539 29
July 1, 1886, amount available. ..........------...........................                  1,954 58
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886... .........                .. .. ....   10, 000 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887...... ...... ........                 11,954 58
  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project ......-- .. 59,669 40
  Amount that can profitably be expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1888 30, 000 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix E E 3.)
HARBORS ON LAKE SUPERIOR (EAST OF SUPERIOR CITY), ON GREEN
BAY, AND ON THE WESTERN SHORE OF LAKE MICHIGAN NORTH OF
MILWAUKEE, WISCONSIN.

  Officers in charge, Lieut. Col. J. W. Barlow, Corps of Engineers, to
March 10, 1886; Capt. W. L. Marshall, Corps of Engineers, from March
10 to May 24, 1886; and Capt. Charles E. L. B. Davis, Corps of Engi-
neers, since that date.
  1. Ontonagon Harbor, Michigan.-Previousto the improvement of this
harbor the channel of the river's mouth was but 7 feet deep at the
shoalest place, and the shifting nature of the lake-bottom caused fre-
quent changes in its position.
  The project of constructing piers extending from each bank of the
river's mouth lakeward to the 18-foot curve, and dredging a channel not
less than 12 feet deep between them, was adopted in 1867.
   The total expenditure, amounting to $270,374.70, of which $70.40 was
expended during the past fiscal year, has resulted in the construction
                        RIVER AND           HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                      291
of an east pier 2,265 feet in length, and a west pier 2,375 feet in length,
and the removal by dredging of 10,546 cubic yards of sand from the
outer bar, forming a channel 100 feet wide at its narrowest point, with
a depth of about 12 feet at low water.
  This is an important harbor, especially for refuge, affording the only
shelter obtainable between the Apostle Islands and the Portage Lake
Canal entrance, and the latter is difficult of access in bad weather.
  The appropriation asked for the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888, is
for further pier extension and possibly repairs.
July 1,1885, amount available .... -..............         ......   ......              ....
                                                                                   -......     $     295 70
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885 .. ........ ......................... .........                            70 40
July 1, 1886, amount available .........................................                        2, 225 30
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886...................                          13, 000 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887...................                       15,225 30

  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1888 25,000 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix F F 1.)
   2. Eagle Harbor, Michigan.-Previous to the improvement of this
harbor the entrance was obstructed by a rocky reef, having about 9 feet
of water over the shoalest point.
   The project of improvement was adopted in 1866, and modified in
1868, 1874, and 1877, and consisted in blasting and dredging a channel
130 feet wide and 14 feet deep through the reef. The work was com-
pleted in 1879. The channel is now marked by a guiding-crib on each
side, and meets the present demands of commerce. As stated in the
last annual report, the channel was obstructed by a number of bowlders,
which reduced its available depth in places to 12 and 13 feet, and their
removal was in progress at the beginning of the fiscal year. The work
was completed July 11, 1885.
   The total expenditure to June 30, 1886, is $94,113.67.
   No appropriation is asked for this harbor, as the funds on hand will
probably be sufficient to cover the expenses of keeping the channel and
piers in good condition for several years.
July 1, 1885, amount available ........................................                        $3,   213 84
July 1, 1386, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885..............................................                             327 51
July 1, 1886, amount available .........................                     _...... ......        2,886 33
  (See Appendix F F 2.)
  3. Marquette Harbor,Michigan.-In its original condition, no protection
was afforded to vessels at this harbor during the prevalence of easterly
and northerly gales.
  In 1866 a project of improvement was adopted, which consisted in- the
construction of a crib-breakwater 2,000 feet in length and 25 and 40 feet
in width, built to a height of 6 feet above water, at an estimated cost of
$385,129.58. Under a modification of this project the width was reduced
to 20, 25, and 30 feet, and the structure was completed in accordance
therewith in 1875, the total length being 2,010 feet, and the total cost
$290,646.55.
  The total expenditures to June 30, 1886, were $308,166.48.
  No work was done during the year, but arrangements were made for
292          REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

delivering and placing 150 cords, more or less, of stone required as rip-
rap near the outer end of the breakwater, which will probably be done
in July. It is probable that some repairs will also be required this
season to the superstructure.
  The breakwater now affords an excellent protection for a limited num-
ber of vessels during bad weather; but further protection should be
afforded to provide the necessary anchorage room for the largely in-
creased business now being carried on at this port.
  An extension of the breakwater 400 feet has been recommended, at an
estimated cost of $68,000, but this is now deemed insufficient for the
prospective needs of this harbor, a much greater extension than this, or
an additional detached work, being required.
   It is proposed to retain the funds now on hand, except such as may
be needed for repairs, until a sufficient amount shall have been appro-
priated with which to build either an extension to the present break-
water or a new structure, as may then be considered most expedient.
July 1, 1885, amount available .....................----................                                            $11, 616 02
July 1, 188ti, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885 ......................................... ......                                             552 50

July 1, 1886, amount available .                 ......   ......        ......      ............          ..    .    11,063 52
   (See Appendix F F 3.)
  4. Harbor of Refuge, Grand Marais,Michigan.-The object of this im-
provement is to provide a harbor of refuge for vessels navigating Lake
Superior. The project was adopted in 1881, on the recommendation of
a Board of Engineer Officers, and consists in the formation of an artifi-
cial entrance to the harbor by the construction of two parallel crib-piers
500 feet apart, and dredging a cut through the sand-spit north of the
harbor and between the piers to make a channel 300 feet wide and 18 to
20 feet deep, connecting the deep water of the lake with the deep water
of the natural harbor. Originally the channel was variable, with a depth
of not more than 6 feet.
   Under contract dated September 17, 1884, during the past fiscal year
the west pier was extended 250 feet, the east pier 150 feet, and the con-
tract completed. By hired labor and purchase of materials in open
market, the east and west piers were each extended 100 feet shoreward
to prevent the waves from cutting sand away from the inner ends of the
piers.
  The total expenditures since the beginning of the improvement amount
to $100,856.38, of which sum $27,621.71 have been expended during the
fiscal year ending June 30, 1886.
   The west pier now consists of 1,000 feet of crib-work and 100 feet of
pile-dike, and the east pier of 750 feet of cribs and 100 feet of pile-work.
Thirty-two thousand one hundred and four cubic yards of material have
been removed by dredging.
   The importance of completing this work at an early day can hardly
be overestimated ; and the interests of the lake marine, representing as it
does millions of dollars, would seem to justify large appropriations an-
nually until the harbor is completed.
July 1, 1885, amount available ...............................           ... $31, 765 33
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1385..............................................      27, 621 71
July 1, 1886, amount available.........                            .........................                          4, 143 62
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886...                                              .----- . -- ..    26, 250 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887 ...--..--.....                                                 30, 393 62
                        RIVER       AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                          293
i Amount that
         (estimated) required for completion of existing project ......
                                                                      100, 000 00
              can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 18r8
                                                                                                 318, 750 00
  Amount
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
     harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix F F 4.)
   5. Manistique Harbor, Michigan.-This harbor is at the mouth of Man-
istique River. The natural channel of entrance to the mouth of the
river was 7 feet deep. By private enterprise 3,000 linear feet of slab-pier
was built at the mouth of the river, and the channel was dredged to a
depth of 10 feet previous to any appropriation having been made by the
Government.
   By the acts of 1880 and 1881 the sum of $6,000 was appropriated for
this harbor, in order to dredge a channel 150 feet wide and 12 feet deep
between the piers built by a local lumbering company. Dredging was
done to the amount of 11,780 cubic yards, and the work was then sus-
pended in consequence of the refusal of the company controlling the
harbor to rectify their pier-lines when rebuilding the same.
   No work has been done during thd year.
   No appropriation is asked for this harbor.
July 1, 1885, amount available ..........----............----............ $3,501 79
July 1, 1886, amount available .............................                   ............---     3, 501 79
   (See Appendix F F 5.)
 - 6. Harborat inouth of CedarRiver, Michigan.-The project of improve.
ment consists in the construction of two parallel piers 200 feet apart,
extending from the mouth of Cedar River to the 16-foot curve in Green
Bay, with dredging outside the shore lines between the piers sufficient
to make a channel 14 feet deep at low water, extending to the deep
water in Green Bay.
   Fifteen thousand dollars was appropriated by act of Congress passed
August 2, 1882, toward carrying out this project, and a second appro-
priation of $15,000 was made July 5, 1884.
   At the begining of the fiscal year ending June 30, 1886, work had just
begun under contract dated November 4, 1884. Under this contract the
east pier was extended 200 feet, and the west pier begun and bfilt to a
length of 300 feet, and contract closed November, 9, 1885.
   The expenditures during the year have amounted to $10,517.06, and
the total expenditures since the beginning of the improvement amount
to $27,329.98.
   The east pier is now 753 feet in length and terminates in 9 feet depth
of water; the west pier 300 feet long with a depth of 5 feet of water at
its outer end. Soundings made in October, 1885, showed a channel
about 50 feet in width 13 feet deep, and 100 feet in width 11 feet deep.
   The interests at this harbor are of a local character, the business,
which consists in the manufacture and shipment of lumber, being con-
fined at present to a single saw-mill. It is not important that the im-
provemnent of this harbor be continued at present, and no appropriation
is asked for the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888.
July 1, 1885, amount available .................-- ........       . ....    .. .. .$13, 187 08
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885..........................        ..................... . 10,517 06
July 1, 1886, amount available.----..----..          ..     ............   ............            2, 670 02
  SAinount (estimated) required for completion of existing project........ 108, 000 00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
     harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix F F 6.)
294        REPORT          OF TIIE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

   7. Menomonee Harbor, Michigan and Wisconsin.-Previous to the im-
provement of this harbor the natural channel was obstructed by a bar
opposite the mouth of the Menomonee River, over which there was a
depth of only 6 feet of water.
   The project of improvement was adopted in 1871 and modified in
1874, its object being to afford a navigable width of channel not less
than 14 feet deep, by pier-extension and dredging.
  "During the fiscal year ending June 30, 1886, no work was done. The
expenditures during the year, $524.05, have been applied, mainly, to
fitting out and repairing the dredges and tug. The total expenditure
since the beginning of the improvement is $196,869.83.
   The north pier is completed in accordance with the existing project,
having a length of 1,854 feet, and terminating in 16 feet depth of water,
and the south pier is 2,710 feet in length and extends 100 feet beyond
the outer terminus of the north pier, but must be continued 350 feet
further to attain the same depth of water.
   There have been 205,828 cubic yards of material removed from the
channel by dredging. There is a 12-foot channel between the piers not
less than 150 feet wide. A shoal spit of about 11 feet depth has been
forming in advance of the south pier and now extends 280 feet beyond it.
   It is proposed to improve the channel by dredging to the extent of
available funds, with the United States dredges, during the present
working season.
   The appropriation asked for the year ending June 30, 1888, is for fur-
ther pier extension.
   The piers are extensively used by a lumber company for storing and
handling lumber and for mooring vessels. Such use is injurious and
should be discontinued.
July 1, 1885, amount available................................                ..   $3, 654 22
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1,1885   ..... ... .........................   .....               524 05

July 1, 1886, amount available ................ ...... ....................         3, 130 17
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886 ....................             3, 000 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887.......................        6,130 17
  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project .......            9,000 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
  (See Appendix F F 7.)
  8. Oconto Harbor, Wisconsin.-In its natural condition the channel at
the entrance to Oconto River was obstructed by a bar with less than 2
feet of water over it. Previous to 1881, when the first appropriation
was made for its improvement, the citizens had, by the construction of
a small amount of slab-pier, and by dredging, increased the depth to 3)
feet.
   The project of improvement proposes to secure an 8-foot channel from
deep water in Green Bay to the city of Oconto by dredging and the
ccnstruction of 'piers, at an estimated cost of $150,000.
   During the year ending June 30, 1886, a pile protection 1,000 feet
long for the south pier was finished by the placing of 120 feet of wales;
the south pier was extended 301 feet, and the north pier 503 feet, under
contract dated September 12, 1884.
   By hired labor and the use of a United States dredge 30,529 cubic
yards of material were removed, and minor repairs were made to the
bouth pier.
                        RIVER AND HARBOR                   IMPROVEMENTS.                             295
   The north pier is now 1,603 feet in length. The south pier is 2,151 feet
long, the full length contemplated by the approved project, and 141,980
cubic yards of material have been removed by dredging.
   The total amount expended to June 30, 1886, is $39,897.49, of which
amount $11,065.92 was expended during the last fiscal year.
   The navigation interests at Oconto are at present dependent upon
the business of three lumber companies located there, and the benefits
to be derived are essentially local.
   The officer in charge recommends a modification in the project, so as
to restrict the work to be done under Government appropriations ,to
the part outside the shore-line, as is customary at other lake harbors;
and as the outside improvement will be of little value without the
other, he suggests that the further application of funds to this work be
contingent upon a proper improvement of the channel inside the shore.
line by local authority.
Jrly 1, 1885, amount available        ......        ..... ... ....... .......    --..........    $11,168 43
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885 ...........................                        --     --.................
                                                                                                   11,065 92
July 1, 1886, amount available            .....     ...................................             102 51
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886...................                            8,000 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887 .................                          8, 102 51

rAmount (estimated) required for completion of existing project....... 102,000 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1888 20, 000 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix F F 8.)
  9. Pensaukee Harbor, Wisconsin.-The first appropriation for this
harbor was made in 1882. At that time the facilities of the natural
channel had been increased by private enterprise from a depth of 2 teet
of water to a depth varying from 7 to 9 feet, for a width of 30 feet, by
the construction of 1,600 linear feet of continuous slab-pier and by
dredging.
  The project of improvement is for the extension of this 1,600 feet of
pier a distance of 2,500 feet further, and the formation of a channel 100
feet wide and 10 feet deep from the bay to the harbor, at an esqimated
cost of $50,000.
  The total amount expended to June 30, 1886, is $10,552.08, of which
$1,328.83 was expended during the last fiscal year.
  There have been built 1,300 feet of the proposed extension of the pier,
and 5,698 cubic yards of material have been dredged, making a channel
25 feet wide and 10 feet deep at low-water. The entire length of the
pier was 2,900 feet, the inner 1,600 feet having been built by private
parties, and the remaining 1,300 linear feet having been built by the
United States.
  A severe storm, September 8 and 9, 1885, carried away some 1,200
feet of the pier built by private parties, filled up or obstructed a large
portion of the channel, and caused some injury to the Government pier,
which latter was repaired.
   The officer in charge having reported that there are at present no
commercial or navigation interests to be benefited by improving this
harbor, and that it is not necessary as a harbor of refuge, and having
recommended that further expenditure upon its improvement be de-
ferred until more satisfactory evidence of the necessity of the work is
received, with the concurrence of the Chief of Engineers in this opinion,
296         REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

the recommendation was submitted to the Secretary of War, and ap-
proved by him.
July 1, 1885, amount available .. . .... .................. $5, 775 75
July 1,1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885.. ..-.....-.... ..---.    ....---------...                                       1, 328 83
July 1, 1886, amount available ........................................                                    4, 446 92
SAmount (estimated) required for completion of existing project-....... 35,000 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
    (See Appendix F F 9.)
  10. Green Bay Harbor, Wisconsin.--Before the improvement of this
harbor was begun the channel between the mouth of Fox River and the
deep water in Green Bay was circuitous and narrow, with but 6 feet of
water at its shoalest point.
  The project of improvement was adopted in 1866 and modified in 1872
and 1881, its object being to secure a channel 200 feet wide, 14 feet deep,
and 2 miles long, in place of the natural channel, including a revetted cut
across Grassy Island.
  During the past fiscal year 11,500 cubic yards of material were re-
moved from the channel by dredging under contract; and by hired labor
and purchase of material in open market the superstructure of the east
revetment at Grassy Island (705 linear feet) was entirely rebuilt,$8,812.84
being expended.
  The total expenditures since the beginning of theimprovement amount
to $270,507.90, resulting in a dredged channel 10,600 feet long, 200 feet
wide, and 14 feet deep, except where occasional shoals reduce the depth
to 13 feet, and the construction of 1,325 linear feet of pile and timber re-
vetment on the sides of the cut through Grassy Island.
  The appropriation asked for the fiscal year ending June 30,1888, will
be applied to dredging and repairs.
July 1, 1885, amount available .              - --..    --.......        ---.............     ..........   $8, 854 94
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
   outsanding July 1, 1885 -..---                      --- .....-----.                      ...             8, 812 84

July 1, 1886, amount available.----                  ......--.....---..-..........
                              .-------......--------....                                                        42 10
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886.---..                 --................                 7, 000 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887 ...................                                   7,042 10

   Amount that can be profitably expendedin fiscal year ending June 30,1888                                15,000 00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix F F 10.)
   11. Harbor of Refuge at entrance of Sturgeon Bay Canal, Wisconsin.-
Before the construction of this harbor was undertaken the location
afforded no shelter at all from storms ranging from northeast to south-
west.
   The project of constructingaharbor of refuge at this point was adopted
in 1873 and modified in 1879 and 1880. The modified project provides
for the construction of two piers, each 1,200 feet long, 850 feet apart
at the shore-line, protecting the lake entrance to the canal, and con-
verging so as to make the harbor entrance 235 feet wide, and to inclose
an area of about 10 acres.
  During the fiscal year ending June 30,1886, the United States dredges
removed 30,940 cubic yards of material from the harbor, $2,580.82 being
expended.
                         RIVER AND             HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                         297
  The total expenditure at this harbor since the begi~ning of the im-
provement has been $157,794.42, resulting in the entire completion of
the piers as projected and in the dredging out of 121,0(99 cubic yards of
material, affording a channel 16 feet deep and over 1CO0 feet wide from
the lake to the entrance of the canal, and making 14 feet depth over
the greater part of the remainder of the sheltered area.
  The amount asked for the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888, will be
expended in dredging and repairs.
July 1, 1885, amount available.....               ..........--.....................                                     4, 786 40
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885 ----------------....        ....                   ......                     ......         2, 580 82
July 1, 1886, amount available........-----....                             ..................--........                 2, 205 58
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886-........                                                              5, 000 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887 ....................                                              7,205 58
  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project-                                            .....      15,000 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1888                                            15,000 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
     harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
  (See Appendix F F 11.)
  12. Ahnapee Harbor, Wisconsin.-Previous to the improvement of this
harbor the depth of water at the river mouth was only about 2 feet.
The project of improvement adopted in 1875 and modified in 1884 pro'-
vides for the formation of a small artificial harbor and a channel with
not less than 12 feet of water, by the construction of piers and dredging.
  During the past fiscal year there have been no operations except the
removal, by one of the United States dredges, of about 20 cubic yards
of loose rock from two shoal places in the channel. The amount ex-
pended was $818.69.
  The total expenditures on this improvement to June 30, 1886, have
been $139,498.61, resulting in the construction of 900 linear feet of north
pier and 1,125 feet of south pier, 250 feet of superstructure being yet
unbuilt, and in the removal of about 22,220 cu bic yards of rock and
82,343 cubic yards of sand and mud, making a channel of 50 feet width
and over, with a depth of not less than 10 feet at low water.
   The appropriation desired for the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888,
will be applied to pier extension and removal of rocks and sand.
July 1, 1885, amount available..........................                                 .................              $1, 320 08
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885....................--...........................                                                818 69
July 1, 1886, amount available..                   ..      .........   ....                                                 501 39
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886 .....................                                                15, 000 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887.                                 ......... ....           .....   15,501 39
  SAmount  (estimated) required for completion of existing project. -      -          00
   Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1888 20, 000 00
                                                                                                                        20,000
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix F F 12.)
  13. Kewaunee Harbor, Wisconsin.-The natural entrance to this har-
bor was via Kewaunee River. The river mouth was not more than 20
feet wide, with a depth of about 2 feet at its shoalest point,.and ob-
structed by submerged bowlders.
  The project of improvement was adopted in 1881. Its design was
to cut a channel through a neck of land between the river and the lake
298        REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

at a point about 2,000 feet south of the river mouth, and to continue
this channel to deep water in the lake by the construction of two par-
allel piers 200 feet apart, extending from each side of the cut ]akeward
to the 18-foot curve.
   During the fiscal year ending June 30, 1886, under contract dated
September 12, 1884, the south pier was extended 500 feet. By hired
labor the United States dredges removed 116,976 cubic yards of mate-
rial. The amount expended was $17,290.58.
   The total amount expended to June 30, 1886, is $34,936.67, in addition
to which the Harbor Commissioners have expended $8,042.72. These
expenditures have resulted in the construction of 700 linear feet of a
north pile-pier and 775 linear feet of a south pile-pier, and in the dredg-
ing of a new channel 125 feet wide and 12 feet deep, in accordance with
the approved project.
   The appropriation asked for the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888, will
be applied mainly to pier extension.
July 1, 1885, amount available ..........................................--          $17, 353 91
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885 .-...                        .... .--.....       . .----.  17, 290 58
July 1, 1886, amount available---
                              ...   ..--. --.---------..........
                                                          ----..---......                 63 33
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886....................               10, 000 00
Amount    available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887.........-..........         10,063 33
i   Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project........ 146.957           28
    Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1888 30, 000 00
    Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
      harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix F F 13.)
   14. Two Rivers Harbor, Wisconsin.-Previous to the improvement of
this harbor the natural channel was obstructed by a bar covered by but
2 or 3 feet of water.
   The project of improvement adopted in 1870 provided for the forma-
tion of a channel of navigable width and not less than 12 feet deep.
This was to be accomplished by the construction of two piers extending
from the river mouth lakeward to the 18-foot curve, and by dredging.
   During the year ending June 30, 1886, 26,663 cubic yards of material
were dredged from the channel, 345 linear feet of sand-fence built, and
minor repairs made to the north and south piers, the amount expended
being $3,069.74.
   The total expenditures to June 30, 1886, were $197,864.67, resulting
in the construction of two parallel piers, as follows:
   A north pier 1,810 feet long, the inner 1,060 linear feet of which con-
sists of pile-pier, and the outer 750 feet of crib-pier; a south pier 1,710
feet long, 960 linear feet of which is pile-pier, and the outer 750 feet
crib-pier. The crib sections of the two piers begin at points opposite,
and are 230 feet apart. The pile sections are 270 feet apart; 240,600
cubic yards of material have been removed by dredging. The channel
is 12 feet deep for a width of about 180 feet.
   The appropriation asked for the year ending June 30, 1888, is for the
maintenance of the channel and piers.
July 1, 1885, amount available ..................  .... ...... .............        $3, 205 07
July 1, 1886; amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885..............................................              3,069 74
July 1, 1886, amount available.............................................             135 33
 {Amount                RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.

          (estimated) required for completion of existing project...--.
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
                                                                            67, 588 80
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June30, 1888 5, 000 00
                                                                                              299


   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix F F 14.)
   15. Manitowoc Harbor, Wisconsin.-Previous to the improvement of
this harbor but 3 feet of water existed at the shoalest point over the bar
at the mouth of the river.
   The project of forming a channel of not less than 14 feet depth by
the construction of parallel piers extending from the river mouth lake-
ward, and by dredging between them, was adopted in 1866, and modi-
fied in 1872 and 1881.
   During the fiscal year ending June 30, 1886, the plank walk of the
north pier was repaired. The amount expended during the year was
$717.82.
   The total expenditures to June 30, 1886, amounting to $276,098.57,
have resulted in the construction of a north and south crib-pier 1,970
and 1,650 feet long, respectively, 228 feet apart at the shore-line and
250 feet apart at the outer ends, and in the dredging of a channel, which
is now 150 feet wide and 14 feet deep.
   The appropriation asked for the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888, is
to be applied to pier extension, rebuilding superstructure, and dredging,
if needed.
July 1, 1885, amount available...... ............         ....................            $1, 439 25
Amount received from sale of fuel to officers ............................                     80 50
                                                                                           1,519 75
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885.......  . -...............................    .                   717 82
July 1, 1886, amount available..................                   ....................      801 93
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886...................                     15,000 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887...................                  15,801 93
  SAmount (estimated) required for completion of existing project..-......
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1888
                                                                                          16,362 54
                                                                                          16, 000 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix F F 15.)
  16. Sheboygan Harbor, Wisconsin.-Previous to the improvement of
this harbor the natural channel had a depth not exceeding 4 feet on the
bar at the entrance to the river.
   The project adopted had for its object the formation of a 12-foot
channel by the construction of piers and dredging. This was modified
in 1873 so as to secure a deeper channel by further pier extension and
dredging. Both projects were completed within their estimated cost,
and a channel was formed 100 feet wide with a depth of 15 to 16 feet
between the piers. The existing project was adopted in 1881, its ob-
ject being to deepen the channel still further by extending the piers to
the 20-foot curve and dredging to a depth of 18 feet between their outer
ends, the depth decreasing to 14 feet at the shore line.
  During the fiscal year ending June 30, 1886, under contract dated
March 20, 1885, the south pier was extended 350 linear feet by sinking
seven cribs on pile foundations and completing the superstructure over
the same. The superstructure upon 95 feet of the pier adjoining the
new work which had settled was also built up to the proper height.
The amount expended during the year was $21,271.71.
300       REPORT OP THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, i. S. ARMY.

   The total expenditures to June 30, 1886, have amounted to $273,446.69,
and have resulted in the construction of a north and south pier, 1,844
and 2,260 feet long, respectively, built of cribs (except less than 300
feet at the shore end), of widths from 14 to 20 feet, and in dredging
172,558 cubic yards of material from the channel.
   In June of this year there was a narrow but available channel of 13J
feet depth to the inner harbor.
   The only means of securing a permanent channel is by the rapid ex-
tension of the piers to deep water; hence a liberal appropriation is
urged as a matter of economy and of necessity to the commerce of this
important harbor.
   The appropriation asked for the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888, will
be applied to pier extension and repairs to the south pier, and dredging
if needed.
July 1, 1885, amount available ............                   ......................... $21, 273 93
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885 .........................................                     21,271 71
July 1, 1886, amount available                                           .................
                                                     -......................                                 2 22
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886 .                               ......---.........   15,000 00

Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887..................--.                              15, 002 22

  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project ....-....
                                                                       --                               97, 000 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1888                             30, 000 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix F F 16.)
   17. Port Washington Harbor, Wisconsin.-The natural channel at the
mouth of the Sank River was narrow, and at the shoalest point had a
depth of but 1 foot.
   The project for the improvement of the harbor, adopted in 1869 and
modified in 1870 and 1876, was for the formation by dredging of two in-
terior basins, having a combined area of about 5g acres, with a depth
of 12 feet, and a channel of the same depth connecting them with the
lake, the channel entrance to the basins to be north of the mouth of the
Sauk River, inclosed between two piers, so constructed that the flow of
the river should be separated from the channel, and that the ddbris
brought down by freshets, instead of shoaling the channel, should re-
inforce the south pier.
   During the fiscal year ending June 30, 1886, $2,370.78 have been ex-
pended in removing from the channel 10,681 cubic yards of material by
the United States dredges, making a depth of not less than 12 feet,
with a width varying from 35 to 110 feet, and in riprapping the north
and south piers.
   Up to June 30, 1886, $164,489.39 had been expended in this improve-
ment in constructing a north and south pier, respectively, 870 and 1,226
feet in length, including about 400 linear feet of revetment along the
north bank of the river, extending to the inner end of the south pier;
also in the formation by dredging of two interior basins, with an area
of 24 and 3 acres, respectively, with an available depth of from 8 to 12
feet, and in making a channel 60 feet wide and 12 feet deep, extending
between the piers from the basins to the lake.
   The appropriation asked for the year ending June 30, 1888, is for the
purpose of completing the project and making necessary repairs to the
old work.
                      RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                          301
July 1, 1885, amount available. .........          .......... ........         .......... $2, 381 39
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885......------- ..........           ............-- ..........     2, 370 78

July 1, 1886, amount available...--- ..........--- ...---............... .                    10 61
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886...... .... .........                   5, 000 00

Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887 ...................                 5, 010 61
   Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project.....                   12,000 00
   Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1888              5, 000 00
   submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
     harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix F F 17.)

EXAMINATION AND SURVEY FOR IMPROVEMENT TO COMPLY WITH RE-
   QUIREMENTS OF THE RIVER AND HARBOR ACT OF JULY 5, 1884.

  Ashland Harbor, in Ashland Bay, Lake Superior.-The preliminary re-
port upon this harbor, and a report upon a survey with the view to its
improvement, were transmitted to Congress and printed in House Ex.
Doc. No. 89, Forty-eighth Congress, second session, and also in the Re-
port of the Chief of Engineers for 1885, page 2010.
  For a subsequent report from Lieut. Col. J. W. Barlow, Corps of En-
gineers, of the results of a survey made in June, 1885, to ascertain the
proper location for a breakwater, and to prepare estimates of its cost,
see Appendix F F 18.

CONSTRUCTION OF HARBOR OF REFUGE, MILWAUKEE BAY-IMPROVE-
  MENT OF THE HARBORS OF MILWAUKEE, RACINE, KENOSHA, AND
  WAUKEGAN-IMPROVEMENT OF FOX AND WISCONSIN RIVERS.

   Officer in charge, Capt. W. L. Marshall, Corps of Engineers, with
Lieut. G. D. Fitch, Corps of Engineers, under his immediate orders.
   1. Harbor of Refuge, Milwaukee Bay, Wisconsin.-The project for this
work was approved in 1881, and contemplated the formation of an arti-
ficial harbor by inclosing a portion of Lake Michigan within an outer
breakwater of crib-work upon a stone foundation. This harbor will
furnish 417 acres of safe mooring ground beyond the 18-foot curve and
about twice this area beyond the 12-foot curve.
   Work was begun in 1881, and up to June 30, 1886, there has been
expended $277,199.86, resulting in the completion of 3,100 feet of the
substructure and 2,450 linear feet of the superstructure of the break-
water.
    During the fiscal year ending June 30,1886, the east arm of the break-
water was extended 50 feet, and the superstructure completed over 1,600
linear feet of breakwater.
    The breakwater when completed will be 7,250 feet in length; there
remains then to be constructed 4,150 linear feet of substructure and
4,800 linear feet of superstructure to complete the work.
    The small balance of appropriation now available is sufficient only to
maintain the required light at the end of the breakwater during the
p)resent season of navigation.
    The funds asked for the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888, are to be
applied to the extension southward of the east arm of the breakwater.
    The harbor has now begun to be used as a harbor of refuge to a lim-
ited extent for vessels during northeast storms, Its value will rapidly
increase as the east arm is extended,
302        REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

July 1, 1885, amount available..............                         -...............---......               $29, 160 43
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885-...          ................................
                                                                   ....-..                                    27,421 81

July 1, 1886, amount available.... ....           ...--                           .          .....             1, 738 62
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886.... .....                                         .....    60, 000 00

Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887 ....................                                    61,738 62
  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project-..--  -.     455, 000 00
  Amount that can be profitably expendedin fiscal year endingJune 30,1888 150, 000 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of      section 2 of river    and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix G G 1.)
   2. lilwaukee Harbor, Wisconsin.-The present project was adopted
in 1852, and was directed to securing 12 feet of water at the entrance
to the river and to protecting this channel by parallel piers. Since that
date a channel, 18 feet in depth and of sufficient width, has been formed
by extending the piers and dredging. The project has been completed,
and consequently the only expenditures now demanded are for the
maintenance of the piers by timely repairs and the depth of the channel
by dredging.
   The original depth of water at the mouth of the river was not more
than 3J feet.
   The United States has expended on this harbor up to June 30, 1886,
$276,110.27; in addition to $321,355.66 by the city of Milwaukee.
   During the fiscal year ending June 30, 1.886, no work has been done
upon this harbor.
   The superstructure of the piers is in urgent need of rebuilding, but
the funds now available are insufficient even to begin the work with ad-
vantage.
   The present available funds and the money asked for the fiscal year
ending June 30, 1888, are to be applied to the maintenance of the pres-
ent piers and channel, and to the rebuilding the superstructure over
the north and south piers, built in 1871-'72.
July 1, 1885, amount available .------------------------.             ...       .-----
                                                                          -------..                          $9, 690 89
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885...........................................                                          .952 99
July 1,1886, amount available........            ..............................                               8,737 90
(Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project........                                      22,000 00
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1888                                  10,000 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix G G 2.)
   3. Racine Harbor, Wisconsin.-The entrance to this harbor originally
varied in depth from absolute closure after storms to about 6 feet.
   The present project was adopted in 1843, and contemplated originally
a channel 12 feet in depth. The piers have since been further extended
and the channel deepened to 16 feet by dredging.
   There has been expended upon this harbor up to June 30, 1886, $221,189.
   During the fiscal year ending June 30, 1886, a contract was made for
dredging the channel, which had deteriorated to 13 feet, to restore its
depth to 16 feeti which work is now in progress, two dredge-cuts the en-
tire length of the piers having been made up to the close of the fiscal
year.
   The funds now available will be required and used under this contract.
                      RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                                      303
   The funds asked for the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888, are to be
applied to the extension of the south pier, as explained in the Annual
Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1883, and to rebuilding parts of
the superstructure of the piers. The pier extension is not urgent, but
the repairs to the piers are now necessary, which will require an appro-
priation of $10,000.
July 1, 1885, amount available ..................    ......................                                           $3, 582 18
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1885----------- -------------- $731 96
July 1, 1886, outstanding liabilities ...-..      .....                .    1,732 72
                                                                                                                      2, 464 68
July 1, 1886, amount available ...--........           ......................                           ......         1,117 50
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886                              ........-----                         10,000 00

Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887 ...................                                             11,117 50


   Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
     harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
  (See Appendix G G 3.)
  4. Kenosha Harbor, Wisconsin.-The present plan of improvement by
parallel piers and dredging was first directed to securing a channel 12
feet in depth. The depth of water in the channel at the present stage
of water in Lake Michigan is 12 feet; at ordinary low water it is only
10 feet. The original depth was 4 feet or less ; sometimes it was entirely
closed.
  It is now intended to increase the depth of the channel to 15 feet or
more by extending the piers and dredging.
  There has been expended upon this harbor up to June 30, 1886,
$215,591.37.
  During the fiscal year ending June 30, 1886, no work was done upon
this harbor.
  The funds now available, and the money asked for the fiscal year end-
ing June 30, 1888, are to be applied to the replacing of the superstruct-
ure over 415 linear feet of the south pier, to pier extension, and to
dredging.
  The pier extension is not urgent, but to maintain the present piers
and depth of channel an annual appropriation of $8,000 is necessary.
July 1, 1885, amount available ..............................-- ... ...... $1, 836 07
SJuly 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
   outstanding July 1, 1885......           ..................                       .          .....                    473 87

July 1, 1886, amount available .............. ........................                                           ..    1, 362 20
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886 ................                                          ....      5, 000 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887 ...................                                             6,362 20
   Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project...                                                  41,000 00
   Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1888                                          10,000 00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
     harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix G G 4.)
   5. Waukegan Harbor, Illinois.-The present project was adopted in
1880, and, as since modified, consists in excavating a small basin in the
low ground between the lake and bluffs to form the harbor, and in
dredging an entrance between parallel piers from the lake to this basin.
   The harbor here is to be created upon a shallow exposed coast and
304         REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

will not begin to be available for commercial purposes until the piers
are sufficiently extended into the lake to allow the entrance to be dredged
with hope of permanency and the basin excavated.
   There has been expended upon this harbor up to June 30, 1886,
$68,857.81.
   During the year ending June 30, 1886, the north pier has been ex-
tended into the lake 32 feet.
   The balance now available and the money asked for the fiscal year
ending June 30, 1888, is needed to complete the pier-work at the en-
trance to the basin, and for dredging in the basin and entrance. The
work is very much exposed, and it is advisable for the sake of economy
to proceed rapidly with it. The advance of the fore-shore and the fill-
ing in with drifting sand is rapid. The cost will be materially increased
by delay, and the work already done, being of wood, will deteriorate
without benefit therefrom if not made available by sufficient progress.
   The estimated cost of the work still to be done, excluding present
balance, is $71,000.
July 1, 1885, amount available....          ...............................                        $5,754 16
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1585--- ......-......                   ......      .... ........-........    4,611 97
July 1, 1886, amount available .....................................                      ....      1,142 19
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886 ...................                             20, 000 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887..                       ........             21,142 19

  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project........                           71,000 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1888                       35, 000 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix G G 5.)
  G.. Fox and Wisconsin rivers, Wisconsin.-The works for the improve-
ment of the Fox and Wisconsin rivers were purchased by the United
States from the Green Bay and Mississippi Canal Company in 1872.
These works were all, except one stone lock, temporary structures,
many of them in bad condition. There was no low-water navigation on
the Upper Fox, and on the Lower Fox navigation was uncertain.
   For the Fox River.-The adopted project contemplated the replacing
of the temporary structures with permanent works, the construction of
five additional stone locks on the Upper Fox, and widening and deep-
ening the channels throughout the river and canals to 6 feet depth
and 100 feet width.
   For the Wisconsin River.-The method adopted has been to contract
the channel-way by wing-dams of brush and stone, to give increased
depth by concentrating the water and by scour due to the increased
currents. The estimate, including the Wisconsin River, made in 1874
and 1876, was $3,745,663, since which time there has been appropriated
$1,780,000, leaving for completion of the adopted project $1,965,663.
   The general subject of the improvement of the Fox and Wisconsin
rivers has been referred to the Board of Engineers, who have not yet
announced any final conclusions. The necessary additional observa-
tions are now being taken for the Board.
   Pending the final determination of the question of the practicability
of improving the Wisconsin River, the original project is now held in
abeyance, and the work confined to the Fox River under the modified
project of the Board of Engineers, submitted September 17, 1884, ap-
                RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                      305
proved by the Secretary of War December 10, 1884, as further modi-
fied by authority of the Chief of Engineers May 14, 1886.
   This modified project applies only to the Fox River and its needs,
and contemplates the renovation of 11 old locks, rebuilding the Cedars
Lock of stone now on hand, and the deepening and widening the chan-
nel of the Fox River from Montello to Green Bay to 6 feet depth and
100 feet width ; the estimate for which is $602,000.
   The amount expended on the improvement of the Fox and Wisconsin
rivers from 1867 to date is $2,587,642.07, and for operating and care of
canals and other works of navigation applied to Fox and Wisconsin
rivers up to fiscal year ending June 30, 1886, $89,309.40.
   The result of this expenditure has been:
   (1) On the Fox River.-The construction of 13 new locks of stone, 12
dams, 4 of which are temporary, 12 cut-offs, 10 miles of canals dredged
and deepened, stone cut for 1 additional lock, and for sluice-ways and
abutments of 1 dam. Over 2,000,000 cubic yards of material have been
dredged from the Upper Fox, and all temporary structures repaired
and maintained in working order. The navigation has thus been con-
tinuous throughout the season from Portage to Green Bay, there being
3 feet navigation on the Upper Fox and 51 feet on the Lower Fox, except
at the entrance to Lake Winnebago, where there is only 44 feet.
   There remains to be built under the original project 12 locks, 8 dams,
5 guard-locks, weirs or sluices in all dams not provided with them,
deepening navigation to 6 feet throughout and widening the channels
to 100 feet, erecting lock-tenders' dwellings, and strengthening and
paving canal banks.
   Under the modified project there remains to be done 2,800,000 cubic
yards of dredging and rock excavation, the deepening of the De Pere
Lock to 6 feet, the rebuilding Cedars Lock of stone, and the building
of a new dam at Appleton. The old works to be maintained under the
continuous appropriation.
    (2) On the Wisconsin River.-To date 108,312 linear feet of wing-dams
have been constructed over a distance of 50 miles, of which a section
9.2 miles in length below Portage has been completed. The result
has been an increased depth of navigation wherever the works have
been applied. There is not now, nor has there been, any regular navi-
gation on the Wisconsin River, due to the prevalence and shifting nature
of the sand-bars, and the consequent lack of any defined channel for
considerable distances.
    The practicability of improving the open river navigation of the Wis-
consin by wing-dams to the extent required for an effective through
route of navigation is to be determined by the results of the observa-
tions now in progress on the improved section of the river. As yet the
river has not attained a low-water stage since observations have been
carried on.
    During the past year the following work has been done:
    (1) Wisconsin River.--The work was restricted to the repair and main-
tenance of the wing-dams on the improved section below Portage, and
to observations for discharge and depth at low water.
    (2) Fox River.-On the Upper Fox the Governor Bend and Montello
locks were renovated, and navigation maintained by timely repairs and
by dredging bars.
    On the Lower Fox the various mechanical works were maintained by
timely repairs in serviceable condition, and the navigable depth of the
channels and canals preserved by dredging. A site was purchased for
Menasha Dam, for carrying out the provisos attached to the river and
        20 E
306        REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

harbor acts of August 2, 1882, and July 5, 1884-items, Fox and Wis-
consin rivers, and the construction of the dam begun, the dam partly
completed and made available as a weir. Deepening the Menasha
channel by rock excavation, and widening the Neenah outlet to Lake
Winnebago, as recommended in the report of the Board of Engineers,
September 17, 1884, approved by the Secretary of War, December 10,
1884, were begun and are under way at the close of the fiscal year.
   The new work of improvement on the Fox and Wisconsin rivers dnr-
ing the last fiscal year was under the acts of August 2, 1882, and July
5, 1884. The works of maintenance were paid for under section 4 of
the river and harbor act of July 5, 1884, which provides for the operat-
ing and care of canals and other works of navigation.
   For the fiscal year ending June 30, 1887, it is proposed to apply the
funds now available to continuing the work at Menasha and Neenah,
to carry out the provisos attached to the river and harbor acts of Au-
gust 2, 1882, and July 5, 1884-i. e., to the completion of thelengthen-
ing of the Menasha Dam and widening the Neenah outlet; to deepen-
ing the Menasha outlet to Lake Winnebago to 6 feet by rock excavation,
and to deepening and widening the Menasha Canal.
   The funds asked for the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888, are for the
furtherance of the modified project relating to the improvement of the
Fox River below Montello, to be applied to deepening the De Pere Lock,
to rebuilding the Cedars Lock of stone, to rock excavation on the Lower
Fox, and to dredging in the Upper Fox.
July 1, 1885, amount available...... .... ...... ..... ...................  $175, 675 38
Fuel sold to officers, deposited to credit of appropriation................       105 00
                                                                                   175, 780 38
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885..........-------. ----...................... ......---- 107, 079 22
July 1, 1886, amount available ........ ..............    ........ ....                    68,701 16
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886..................                       56, 250 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887 ..................                  124,951 16
  SAmount (estimated) required for completion of existing project..-__..1,965,663 00
  Amount (estimated) required for modified project, Fox River......... 546, 000 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1888....................      ----.................... ...................---- 200, 000 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   Under the continuous appropriation for operating and care of canals
and other works of navigation, it is proposed to maintain existingnavi-
gation by timely repairs to old locks until replaced by new, and to con-
tinue the repairs of works that have already been completed and used,
injured by the extraordinary flood of 1881:
Amount appropriated by act approved July 5, 1884...                     --..---- - ..-.- .. Indefinite.
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1,1885..............................................                     $42, 622 00
Amount (estimated) for expenditures in fiscal year ending June 30, 1887.. 43, 668 00
   (See Appendix G G 6.)

IMPROVEMENT OF THE HARBORS OF CHICAGO AND CALUMET, ILLT.
  NOIS-IMPROVEMENT OF ILLINOIS AND CALUMET RIVERS-SUR-
  VEYS FOR HENNEPIN CANAL.

  Officer in charge, Maj. W. H. H. Benyaurd, Corps of Engineers.
  1. Chicago Harbor, Illinois.-The project of illmplrovemlent now in
course of execution at this lharbor was adopted in 1870 and modified in
                            RlIVER       AND       HARBOR            IMPROVEMENTS.                                  307
1878. The objects sought are, first, the formation of an outer harbor
adjoining the entrance to the Chicago River, and de signed also to fur
nish increase( commercial facilities by relieving the river from its over-
crowded condition ; second, the creation of a harbor of refuge, affording
a good anchorage in deep water, and safe access to the harbor and
river.
   The amouint expended upon the work for harbor at Chicago since
1870 is $1,337,005.37, and has resulted in the completion of the outer
harbor (excepting the dredging necessary to afford the contemplated
depth of 16 feet); the completion of 3,836 feet of the exterior break-
water, with the exception of the superstructure on the easterly end
thereof; and the building of four additional cribs yet to be sunk in po-
sition. No work was done during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1886,
except that necessary for the care and preservation of public property,
and the receiving of material contracted for, as the funds available
would not admit of active operations.
   On the 4th of December last a severe storm damaged 400 feet of the
southerly breakwater of the outer harbor, necessitating repairing at the
earliest possible moment, in order that the remainder of the structure
shall be secured against further damage. As the cost of the necessary
repairs will be in addition to the amount required to complete the im-
provement under existing project, the officer in charge has submitted
an increased estimate amounting to $31,000 for that work and for other
requirements in order to secure the stability of the structures.
   With the funds available for the present fiscal year it is p)roposed to
continue the extension of the exterior breakwater and to repair the
break in the southerly breakwater caused by the storm of December 4.
   To continue the work of improvement under the existing project
the sum of $240,000 will be required.
July 1, 1885, amount available ............                        ......    ..........         ...........     $4, 423 38
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding Jly  1, 15 -------------------------------------...........................................--..    3,88 41

July 1, 1886, amount available ...- .................................-....                                         574 97
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886 ...................                                          75, 000 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887...                                  ................      75,574 97
J Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project .......    240, 000 00
   Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1888 240,000 00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
      harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
  (See Appendix H H 1.)
  2. Calumet Harbor, Illinois.-The present project for the improve-
ment of this harbor has for its object the creation and maintenance of
a channel 300 feet wide and 16 feet deep from Lake Michigan to Calu-
met River.
  The amount expended in the execution of this project to June 30,
1886, is $381,619.53; 5,360 feet of pier-work have been completed, and
384,376 cubic yards of material have been dredged from the channel.
  No work was done during the past season, as the funds available
were barely sufficient for the care and preservation of the public prop-
erty.
  The funds now available will be applied to the extension of the south
pier.
  The appropriation of $11,400 asked for is to be applied to the samo
work, and to the repair and preservation of the existing works.
308         REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

July 1,1885, amount available-----....----..----------..........------------------.....................    $1,225 59
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885........      .....................................                                 845 12

July 1, 1886, amount available........................ ...............                                         380 47
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886. ................                                       10, 000 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887...... .......... ....                                10, 380 47
  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project.... _..11,400     00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1888 11,400 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix H H 2.)
   3. Illinois River, Illinois.-Previous to the adoption of the present
project the improvement of the Illinois River, as carried on by the Gen
eral Government, consisted chiefly in constructing wing-dams and dikes
and in dredging through the worst bars.
   The amount expended in that way up to June 30, 1880, was $550,450.55.
   The State of Illinois has constructed two locks, each 75 feet wide by
350 long between gates, situated at Henry, and Copperas creek.
   The present project contemplates the extension of this slackwater
system 100 miles below by the construction of two more locks and dams,
situated, respectively, at La Grange and Kampsville. It is also pro-
posed to dredge the channel of the river where needed from the State
lock at Copperas Creek to the mouth of the river.
   At Kampsville the foundation of the lock was completed two years
ago, but the appropriations not being sufficiently large to carry on oper-
ations at both lock-sites, the coffer-dam and works were flooded, and
have so remained.
   At La Grange the lock-walls have been completed. The funds now
available will be expended in constructing the lock-gates and purchas-
ing material for the damage at La Grange, and in.contracting for stone
for the Kampsville lock. In addition, the amount allotted for dredg-
ing at Peoria will be expended for that purpose.
   The amount required for the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888, will be
expended in completing the work at La Grange and in carrying on
operations at Kampsville.
July 1, 1885, amount available .         .....   ..........        ...... ..    $18, 592 74
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885......................            ...... ...... .....  14, 232 31
July 1, 1886, amount available....         .     ....................                                       4,360 43
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886 ..............                                         112, 500 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887 ..................                                  116,860 43
  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project--....                                    587,500 00
   Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1888 350, 000 00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1866.
    (See Appendix H H 3.)
   4. Calumet River, Illinois.-The project for the improvement of the
lower section of this river, extending from the harbor to the forks, a dis-
tance of 64 miles, was recommended by a Board of Engineer Officers in
accordance with the requirements of the river and harbor act of August
2, 1882. It was proposed to dredge a channel 200 feet wide and 16 feet
deep, " no work, however, to be undertaken until the right of way shall
have been conveyed to the United States free from expense, and the
                       DIVER ANTD IIARBOR               IMPROVEMENTS.                                             309

United States released from all liability for damages to adjacent prop-
erty-owners."
   By the provisions of the river and harbor act of August 5, 1886, the
improvement of the upper section of the river as far as Hammond is
also contemplated and appropriation made therefor. It is intended to
extend the project for the improvement of the lower river to cover this
stretch also.
   The work of improvement will be commenced so soon as the necessary
releases have been obtained and approved by the Secretary of War.
Parties interested in the improvement are actively engaged in securing
the right of way required, and as the act last above referred to contains
provisions for condemnation proceedings in the name of the United
States in cases where it was impossible to obtain the land otherwise, it
is believed that the entire right of way will be obtained during the
present season.
   As the improvement of the lower and upper sections of the river is
now embraced under one head, the estimates therefor have been com-
bined.
   For continuing operations the sum of $100,000 is asked.
July 1, 1885, amount available ..................              ........................                     $50, 000 00
July 1, 1886, amount available .................. ......................                                .    50, 000 00
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886.......... .........                                       30, 000 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887................                                        80, 000 00
  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project........ 345, 000 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1888 50, 000 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
    harbor acts of lt66 and 1867.
   (See Appendix H H 4.)
   5. Surveys for the Hennepin Canal.-Additional surveys for a route
from the summit level to the Misississippi River were made in the fall of
1885, and reported upon by Maj. Thomas H. Handbury, Corps of Engi-
neers, and printed in House Ex. Doc. No. 117, Forty-ninth Congress,
first session.
July 1, 1885, amount available....................................------                            -   .    $8, 271 51
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885 ........-....    -....-
                                          ..........    .... ..... ........                                   7, 637 85

July 1, 1886, amount available ...            ......   .....         ......      ................               633 66
  (See Appendix H H 5.)

IMPROVEMENT OF HARBORS ON THE EASTERN SHORE OF LAKE MICHI-
       GAN AND OF GRAND RIVER BELOW GRAND RAPIDS.

  Officer in charge, Capt. D. W. Lockwood, Corps of Engineers, with
Capt. C. F. Palfrey, Corps of Engineers, under his immediate orders.
  1. Charlevoix Harbor, Michigan.-The average width of the original
channel of entrance was 75 feet; the depth varied from 2 to 6 feet. The
present project for its improvement, adopted in 1868 and revised in 1875
and 1876, is to dredge a channel 100 to 150 feet wide to a depth of 12
feet, and to protect both sides with close piling. This was modified in
1876 by substituting crib-work for pile-piers.
  The amount expended to June 30, 1885, was $66,207.10, and resulted
in obt;inin g a clhannel of navigable width and 12) feet mid-depth between
the iiers, and a 12.foot channel 50 feet wide connecting Round and Pine
310        REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, 1.                                S. ARMY.

lakes, revetted on the north side for 339 feet and on the south side 366
feet. The amount expended during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1886,
was $3,774.79, and resulted in repairing and refilling 330 feet of old
north pier from shore-line out.
   The available depth for navigation is about 12 feet.
  The amount that can be profitably expended during the fiscal year
ending June 30, 1888, is to be applied to extending the south pier into
Lake Michigan in accordance with approved project, completing the
revetment of channel between Round and Pine lakes, and in general
repairs to piers and plank beam revetments.
July 1, 1785, amount available..........................................    $4, 802 90
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885 .........  ........................    ....-.... 3,774 79
July 1, 1886, amount available .............. ...............                    .......... 1,028 11
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886 .                    ................. 10, 000 00
Amount available for the fiscal year ending June 30, 1887................                    11,028 11

rAmount  (estimated) required for completion of existing project ........ 105, 000 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1888 30, 000 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix I I 1.)
  2. Frankford Harbor, Michigan.-The natural channel of entrance to
this harbor was not more than from 3 to 4 feet deep. The present proj-
ect for its improvement, adopted in 1866, was to dredge an outlet through
a strip of land separating Lake Aux Becs Scies from Lake Michigan,
and to build two parallel piers 200 feet apart, extending from 12 feet
soundings in the inner lake to the same depth in Lake Michigan. The
amount expended to June 30, 1885, was $238,283.98, and resulted in se-
curing a channel of entrance 195 feet wide, with an available depth of
12 feet.
  The amount expended during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1886, was
$588.74, in paying office and other expenses, the balance being too small
for any work but that of minor repairs.
  The amount that can be profitably expended during the fiscal year
ending June 30, 1888, is for pier-extension, in accordance with approved
project, and for general repairs.
July 1, 1885, amount available... .                       .
                                                 -...........       ................... ..   $4,654 37
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885.... ..........................................                       588 74
July 1, 1886, amount available...... ........... .........................                    4, 065 63
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886 ....................                       7, 500 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887 ....................                   11,565 63
  SAmount    (estimated) required for completion of existing project--......----..
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1888
                                                                                             68,500 00
                                                                                             25, 000 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
     harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix I I 2.)
  3. Harbor of Refuge at Portage Lake, Michigan.-No natural channel
existed prior to the beginning of the improvement. The project for
improvement, adopted in 1879, was to make this a harbor of refuge,
with a navigable channel 300 feet wide and not less than 18 feet deep.
The piers as constructed, however, are 370 feet apart.
                        RIVER AND IIAR3BOR                         IMPROVEMENTS.                                             311
   The amount expended to June 30, 1885, was $58,491.08, and resulted
in revetting the north side of the channel and the extension of the
revetment by pier-work into Lake Michigan a distance of 525 feet be-
yond the shore-line; also, in building 573 feet of revetment and pier
on the south side, and opening a cut 50 feet wide and 12 feet deep be-
tween the lakes.
   The amount expended during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1886,
was $8,326.70, and resulted in building 805 feet of revetment on south
side of channel and in removing 19,110 cubic yards of material from
between the piers to keep a channel open. The present depth of water
is about 11 to 12 feet.
   The amount that can be profitably expended during the fiscal year
ending June 30, 1888, is to be applied to pier extension and dredging,
in accordance with the approved project.
July 1, 1885, amount available ..... ............................--....                                                  $9, 008 92
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1885 .......................                                              $7, 508 70
July 1, 1886, outstanding liabilities ..........................                                                818 00
                                                                                                                         8, 326 70
July 1, 1886, amount available          ....     .........................--....--....                                      682 22
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886. .................                                                    15, 000 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887 ....................                                               15,682 22
  SAmount(estimated) required for completion of existing project......- . 182,500 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1888 60, 000 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
     harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix I I 3.)
   4. Manistee Harbor, Mlichigan.-A narrow channel, not more than 8
feet, was obtained at this harbor by the slab-pier built by local enter-
prise. The present project for its improvement, adopted in 1866 and
modified in 1870 and 1874, was to afford a channel of entrance of navi-
gable width not less than 12 feet deep. The amount expended to June
30, 1885, was $216,259.87, and resulted in securing a depth of 15 feet be-
tween the piers and 13 feet on the bar outside. The amount expended
during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1886, was $6,522.81, and resulted
in placing one crib 50 feet long by 30 feet wide on pile foundation in
extension of north pier. The depth of water available for vessels up to
Manistee Lake is about 12 feet, although between the piers the depth
is somewhat greater. The amount that can be profitably expended dur-
ing the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888, it is proposed to apply to pier-
extension, in accordance with approved project, and to general repairs
of piers and revetments.
Tuly 1, 1885, amount available ............................        ......  $11, 740 13
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885 ............................-..-..---------....                                               6, 522 81
July 1, 1886, amount available ......................                                    ................                5, 217 32
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886..                                             ---...........-....     10, 000 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887 ...................                                                15,217 32
  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project.--------                                                 2, 700 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1888                                             30, 000 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
     harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix I I 4.)
312       REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

  5. Ludington Harbor, Michigan.-The channel made by local enterprise
at this harbor was narrow and not more than 7 feet deep. The project
for its improvement, adopted in 1867, was to afford a channel of entrance
to Pere Marquette Lake, of navigable width, and not less than 12 feet
deep.
   The present project, approved January, 1885, is to widen the entrance
to 400 feet by building a new south pier 400 feet south of the present
north pier, remove the present south pier, and dredge the channel to a
depth of 18 feet.
   The amount expended to June 30, 1885, was $229,298.38, and resulted
in securing a channel about 200 feet wide and 14 feet deep. The amount
expended during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1886, was $5,190.99,
and resulted in placing superstructure on crib sunk in previous year,
and in removing 9,990 cubic yards of material from channel. The
depth of water available is about 14 feet. The amount that can be profit-
ably expended during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888, is to be ap-
plied to building new south pier and dredging in accordance with the
approved project.
July 1, 1885, amount available ..........................................                              $6, 888 62
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 185 ..............                 ............................                   5, 190 99
July 1, 1886, amount available ..........            .....   .......                                    1, 695 63
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886.........-.........                                  56,250 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887 ....................                             57,945 63
  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project-------362, 9:35 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1888 120, 000 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
     harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
  (See Appendix I I 5.)
  6. Pentwater Harbor,Michigan.-The original channel of entrance was
narrow, and not more than 4 feet in its shoalest part. The present
project for its improvement, adopted in 1866, was to afford a channel of
navigable width and not less than 12 feet deep.
  The amount expended to June 30, 1885, was $203,474.32, and resulted
in securing a channel of navigable width and about 12 feet deep. The
amount expended during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1886, was
$1,405.52, and resulted in placing superstructure on crib sunk in pre-
vious year, rebuilding superstructure on a part of north pier, leveling
up, repairing, and refilling pier-head of south pier, and in refilling piers
where necessary to stop leaks. The depth of water is about 12 feet be-
tween the piers.
  The amount that can be profitably expended during the fiscal year
ending June 30, 1888, is to be applied to extending the south pier in
accordance with approved project, and to general repairs.
July 1, 1885, amount available .......- -..............................                                $4,345 68
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885. ..........                _.......... ................              ....    1, 405 52
July 1, 1886, amount available .................. ..... ........... ......                              2,940 16
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886...................                                  10, 000 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887.---....-                       .   ......--.     12, 940 16
   Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project-- ---........ 45, 000 00
   Amount that can be profitablyvexpended in fiscal year endiung.June.l0,1888 15,000 00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
    (See Appendix I I 6.)
                        RIVER        AND       tAlI3Ol         IMPIOVEMENTS.
   7. White River Harbor, Michigan.-The old channel was narrow,
crooked, and too shoal to accommodate any but very small vessels.
The present project for its improvement, adopted in 1866, was to afford
a channel of navigable width not less than 12 feet deep. The amount
expended to June 30, 1885, was $231,176.58 and resulted in obtaining a
channel of navigable width and 11 feet deep.
  The amount expended during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1886,
was $4,503.44, and resulted in rebuilding and refilling pile-pier, head
of north pier, and in cutting down old pile-work preparatory to putting
on new superstructure. The depth of water is between 9 and 10 feet.
  The amount that can be profitably expended during the fiscal year
ending June 30, 1888, is to be applied to pier extension in accordance
with approved project, and to rebuilding superstructure on pile-piers
and revetments.
July 1, 1885, amount available ............              ..........                    ... .....      $..6, 373 42
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1885 ........................                         $4, 016 39
July 1, 1886, outstanding liabilities.......................                                487 05
                                                                                              --       4,503 44

July 1, 1886, amount available .......................................--.                              1,869 98
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886 ...............                                    10,000 00

Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30,1887-..............                                   11,869 98
SAmount (estimated) required for completion of existing project--------........
  Amount that can beprofitablyexpended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1888
                                                                                                      84, 225
                                                                                                      25,   000
                                                                                                                  00
                                                                                                                  00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
     harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix II 7.)
  8. .?Muskegon Harbor, Michigan.-The original channel was irregularly
defined by slab-piers which gave fair access, but a bar just at the end
of the piers, on which there was only 7 feet of water, obstructed navi-
gation. The present project for improvement, adopted in 1866, was to
obtain a channel of entrance of navigable width, and to extend the
piers over the bar to 117 feet soundings. Modified in 1880 so as to se-
cure 300 feet width of entrance. The amount expended to June 30,
1885, was $203,940.86, and resulted in obtaining a width of entrance of
300 feet, the main channel inside being 186 feet. The depth of water
at close of fiscal year was about 15 feet.
  The amount expended during fiscal year ending June 30, 1886, was
$11,262.47, and resulted in extending the north pier 100 feet by two cribs
on pile foundation, and in general repairs to piers. The depth of water
remains about the same as last year.
  The amount that can be profitably expended during the fiscal year
ending June 30, 1888, is to be applied to pier extension under approved
project and to general repairs.
July 1, 1885, amount available ...........                        .....   ........   .............   $17, 559 14
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885-----, ......-.....---- .....................                               11,262 47
July 1, 1886, amount available......................   ...................                             6, 296 67
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886 ..................                                 12, 500 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887 .....................                           18,796 67
  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project-------
                                                                   .    101,125 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1888                          30, 000 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
  (See Appendix I I 8.)
314        REPORT OP TIHE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

  9. Grand Haven Harbor, Michigan.-The natural outlet was wide but
shoal, the water being only 9 feet deep in the best course. The present
project for its improvement, adopted in 1866, was to obtain a chan-
nel of navigable width with a minimum depth of 18 feet. The amount
expended to June 30, 1885, was $452,605.83, and resulted in obtaining a
channel of entrance 400 feet wide and 18 feet deep.
  The amount expended during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1886,
was $28,038.59, and resulted in extending the south pier 200 feet by
four cribs 30 feet wide on pile foundation, and in repairing piers and
revetments where necessary. The depth of water remains the same as
last year.
  The amount that can be profitably expended during the fiscal year
ending June 30, 1888, is to be applied to pier extension under the ap-
proved project and to making general repairs.
July 1, 1885, amount available..........................................                       $41, 760 32
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1885.........................                $27, 670 80
July 1, 1886, outstanding liabilities.................... ......                      367 79
                                                                                                28,038 59

July 1, 1886, amount available .... _.....................................                      13,721 73
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886 ...................                          30, 000 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887 ...................                       43,721 73
  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project........ 180,000 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1888                     60, 000 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix I 1 9.)
  10. Grand River, Michigan.-The portions of channel below Grand
Rapids to be improved have less than 4 feet depth of water at low stage.
The original project adopted in 1881 is to give relief to light navigation
by securing 4 feet depth of water at low-water stage. The project now
in force is to secure a 4-foot navigable depth by dredging to 4.5 feet.
  The amount expended to June 30, 1885, was $30,795.78, and resulted
in dredging a portion of the channel above Lake Shore Railway Bridge,
making a detailed survey of the river from the head of navigation to a
point 114 miles down-stream, and in dredging under new project 14,112
cubic yards of material from the channel, the depth of cut being 4.5.
  The amount expended during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1886,
was $17,494.33, and resulted in removing 61,883.51 cubic yards from the
channel and carrying the improvement down-stream a distance of 7.6
miles.
  No appropriation is asked for.
July 1, 1885, amount available........            ......... ....... ................   $19, 204 22
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1885 .......................            $13, 057 52
July 1, 1886, outstanding liabilities .......................                4, 436 81
                                                                                                17,494 33

July 1, 1886, amount available ............             ...................... ....     ....     1,709 89
  (See Appendix I I 10.)
   11. Black Lake Harbor,Michigan.-The channel made by the Harbor
Board of the city of Holland was narrow, irregular, and only 5: feet
deep. The project for its improvement, adopted in 1866 and modified
in 1873, was to obtain a channel of entrance of navigable width and
not less than 12 feet deep. The amlount expended to June 30, 1885, was
$250,614.24, and resulted in obtaining a channel of about 200 feet width
                          RIVER        AND HARBOR                 IMPROVEMENTS.                                   315
at the entrance, somewhat narrower inside, with a depth of about 11
feet.
  The amount expended during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1886,
was $1,766.07, and resulted in placing 33 cords of stone in north pier,
in leveling and rebuilding outer end of south pier, and refilling it with
stone, and in cutting down and rebuilding a part of south revetment.
The depth of water remains about the same as last year.
  The amount that can be profitably expended during the fiscal year
ending June 30, 1888, is to be applied towards completing the harbor
under the approved project.
July 1, 1885, amount available ..............                  ..................                  ......--   $4, 001 07
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1685......-.... .......-......... ................                                       1,766 07
July 1, 1886, amount available ........-.......... ........................                                    2, 235 00
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886....................                                         5, 000 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887.............. ......                                     7,235 00
  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project                                        .--. 15, 000  00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1888                                    5, 000 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
  (See Appendix I I 11.)
  12. Saugatuck Harbor,Michigan.-The channel originally made by local
enterprise was narrow and not more than 7 feet deep in the best water.
The project for its improvement, adopted in 1869, was to obtain a chan-
nel of entrance of navigable width, with a minimum depth of 10 feet.
  The amount expended to June 30, 1885, was $123,683.94, and resulted
in obtaining a narrow channel about 8 feet deep inside, and 11 feet on
the bar.
  The amount expended during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1886, was
$399.84, for office expenses and contingencies.      The depth remains
about the same as last year.
  The amount that can be expended during the fiscal year ending June
30, 1888, is to be applied to securing the south pier and "maintaining
the existing condition of the improvement."
July 1, 1885, amount available .....................                            ...... .....   .........      $3, 755 06
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885.............................................                                          399 84
July 1, 1886, amount available ..........................................                                      3, 355 22
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886...................                                          8,000 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887 ....................                                    11,355 22
   (See Appendix I I 12.)
  13. South Haven Harbor, Michigan.-The channel was originally made
by private enterprise, was narrow, and not more than 7 feet deep in the
deepest place. The present project for its improvement, adopted in
1866, and modified in 1879, was to obtain a channel of entrance of navi-
gable width, not less than 14 feet deep.
  The amount expended to Jane 30, 1885, was $168,285.86, and resulted
in obtaining a channel of navigable width, and 9.5 feet deep between
the piers, 10.5 feet up to the railway bridge, and 14 feet on the bar.
The amount expended during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1886, was
$3,165.53, and resulted in removing 29,865 cubic yards of material from
between the piers. The depth of water is now 12 feet between the
piers. The depth on the bar and in the river to the railway dock re-
nmain the same as last year.
  The amount that can be profitably expended during the fiscal year
816         REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, I. S. ARMY.

ending June 30, 1888, is to be applied to pier extension and dredging
in accordance with approved project, and to making general repairs.
July 1, 1885, amount available... ....                   ..................................                                       $8,714 14
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885 .-..   ........... --..-..            .       .                                                          3,165 53
July 1, 1886, amount available........                             .         .       .... ....                                      5, 548 61
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886............                                       ........                      5, 000 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30,                                 1887................-- ....                      10,548 61
    Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project --                                                   ....      77, 500 00
    Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1888                                                    20, 000 00
    Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
      harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
  (See Appendix I I 13.)
  14. Saint Joseph Harbor, Michigan.-The natural channel was about
250 feet wide and 12 feet deep at the entrance, shoaling to 9 feet in the
river above. The present project for its improvement, adopted in 1866
and 1874, was to obtain a channel of entrance of navigable width and
not less than 16 feet deep. The amount expended to June 30, 1885, was
$311,745.80, and resulted in securing a channel of entrance of about 14
feet depth, and a canal leading from Saint Joseph Harbor to Benton
Harbor 100 feet wide and 11 feet deep, partially revetted.
  The amount expended during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1886,
was $5,728.34, and was expended in closing two breaks in north pier
near the shore-line, caused by severe storms, and in building a scow 70
feet by 30 feet by 61 feet.
  The amount that can be profitably expended during fiscal year end-
ing June 30, 1888, is to be applied to rebuilding the north pier, resuper-
structuring the south pier, and constructing close-piling wing-dam from
end of north pier to railway bridge, in accordance with approved pro-
ject.
July 1, 1885, amount available.              ..-............                     .            ..          .....             ...   $20, 367 20
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, including
  transfer to Michigan City for timber purchased, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1885    .         -------.
                                               . ..---                                                            $5, 680 57
July 1, 1886, outstanding liabilities.....................                                         .   ....            47 77
                                                                                                                                    5, 728 34

July 1, 1886, amount available.....                                              ...........-                                      14,638 86
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886.- ---.-----                                                      -.-.-          10,000 00


{
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887-.....
    Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project- - --- -
    Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1888
    Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
                                                                                                              .......---....       24, 638 86
                                                                                                                                   41,015 00
                                                                                                                                   15, 000 00
     harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix I I 14.)
   15. Michigan City Harbor, Indiana-Outer Harbor.-Work at this
harbor was commenced by the Government in 1836. The first project
was that of 1857, for the construction of a breakwater. Various modi-
fications up to 1870 provided for pier extensions and dredging of chan-
nel. In 1870 a project for an exterior harbor was approved. In 1882
a project for an exterior breakwater west of the harbor entrance and
the construction of a pier at west end of exterior breakwater of outer
harbor was adopted. The amount expended to July 30, 1885, was
$800,699.84, and resulted in completing the breakwater for outer harbor
and extending the breakwater pier 300 feet. The depth of water was
sufficient to admit the largest class of vessels on the lakes. The amount
                        RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                    317
expended during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1886, was $8,581.04,
and resulted in placing one crib on pile foundation, in extension of
breakwater pier, and putting superstructure on 150 feet of same; the
superstructure on 408 feet of west pier near shore-line was rebuilt, and
the substructure of 500 feet more leveled up to receive superstructure.
Other repairs were made where necessary, and the plant put in work-
ing condition. The depth of water remains the same as last year.
   The amount that can be profitably expended during the fiscal year end-
ing June 30, 1888, is to be applied to the construction of the west ex-
terior breakwater, the completion of the breakwater pier at entrance,
and renewal of superstructure and filling of old west pier.
July 1, 1885, amount available.....--..........................--........                            $13, 718 75
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1885 ..........-.......  ...-- $8, 111 04
July 1, 1886, outstanding liabilities......................         ----                    470 00
                                                                                                       8, 581 04

July 1, 1886, amount available ...                ...............          ..............     ....     5, 137 71
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886....................                               54, 375 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887....-----......----..........                    59,512 71

  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project......       395,625 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1888 150, 000 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix 1I 15.)
   Inner Harbor.-The site of the present inner harbor was originally a
small creek, crooked and with a depth insufficient for commercial pur-
p)oses. The first project was that of 1870 for dredging up to the rail-
road bridge. In 1878 a project, submitted by the officer in charge, for
extending the inner harbor up Trail Creek by dredging, was adopted,
the cut to be 120 feet wide and 15 feet deep, and the city to revet the
cut.
   The amount expended to June 30, 1885, was $88,965.31, and resulted
in securing a depth of 17 feet up to the railroad bridge, and about 15
feet beyond that point. The amount expended during the fiscal year
ending June 30, 1886, was $4,224.36, and resulted in removing 22,365
cubic yards of material in Trail Creek, giving a depth of 17 feet up to
a point 600 feet south of Sixth Street Bridge; the depth above to within
500 feet of upper basin is 13 feet; also in removal of 4,804 cubic yards
of material in channel near shore-line.
   The amount that can be profitably expended during the fiscal year
ending June 30, 1888, is to be applied to continuation of dredging ac-
cording to approved project.
July 1, 1885, amount available ...........................................            $6, 034 69
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1885 .........................           $4, 029 36
July 1, 1886, outstanding liabilities ..........................               195 00
                                                                                       4,224 36
July 1, 1886, amount available ...............................     ....... 1, 810 33
Transferred from Saint Joseph appropriation (timber for scow)..........       488 84
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886......................   1, 875 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887 ....................                             4, 174 17
SAmount   (estimated) required for completion of existing project--------3,125 00
   Amount that can be proti       tably
                                expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1888 3, 125 00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
     harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix I I 15.)
518         REPORT OF              THE      CHIEF         OF     ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.


IMPROVEMENT OF SAINT MARY'S RIVER--ENLARGEMENT OF AND OP-
  ERATING SAINT IMARY'S FALLS CANAL-CONSTRUCTION OF HARBOR
  OF REFUGE ON LAKE HURON, AND IMPROVEMENT OF CERTAIN HAR-
  hBORS ON LAKE HURON AND OF SAGINAW RIVER-PRESERVATION OF
  AND OPERATING SAINT CLAIR FLATS CANAL-IMPROVEMENT OF DE-
  TROIT RIVER.

  Officer in charge, Lieut. Col. O. M. Poe, Corps of Engineers, with
Lieut. H. F. Hodges, Corps of Engineers, under his immediate orders.
  1. IHay Lake Channel, Saint Mary's River, Michigan.-The original
estimates for this improvement were based upon a project for a channel
300 feet wide and 7 feet deep, leaving the present navigable channel of
Saint Mary's River at Sugar Island Rapids (about 24 miles below the
canal); through these into Hay Lake, and then, by way of the Middle
Neebislh, rejoining the present navigable channel at the foot of Sugar
Island, thus saving a distance of 11 miles and obtaining a route which
it is practicable to mark with lights so as to be navigable at night, a
condition impracticable with the present channel.
   The estimated cost of this project was $2,127.292. It was subse-
quently modified to increase the depth to 19 feet, and it is now evident
that a further modification is required with a view to obtaining a depth
of 20 feet.
   These modifications will necessarily increase the cost, but not to so
great an extent as would at first be supposed, because the prices at which
the most difficult part of the work can be done prove to be lower than
those of the original estimates.
   Based upon the best data available, the- estimated cost of the im-
provement, if modified as proposed, is $2,659,115.
   The amount thus far appropriated for the work is $325,000, and the
expenditures to June 30, 1886, including all determined outstanding lia-
bilities, amount to $291,218.50, which has been principally applied to
excavation under a contract at Middle Neebish, to surveys, to engineer-
ing, and office expenses, &c. The available balance is to be applied,
as far as may be, to excavation at Middle Neebish.
   The amount of material removed from the proposed channel to June
30, 1886, was 352,128 cubic yards, of which 344,124 cubic yards were
removed from Middle Neebish.
   Owing to the distance over which the plant can be distributed, a
large amount of work can be carried on at the same time, and the sum
that can be profitably expended during the fiscal year ending June 30,
1888, is therefore correspondingly large, and an appropriation of $400,000
is recommended for continuing the excavation at Middle Neebish, and
beginning operations at Sugar Island Rapids, and on the fiats at the
lower end of Hay Lake.
July 1, 1885, amount available ......................                         ........    ......---   .   124,207 57
Received from sale.of fuel.............................................                                          16 13
                                                                                                          124, 223 70
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive
   of liabilities outstanding July 1, 185......-                    -......- --........   $76, 328 11
July 1, 1886, outstanding liabilities........................                              14, 017 32
                                                                                                           90, 345 43

July 1, 1886, amount available ................ . .. ..................---- ---- ---                       33, 878 27
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 186.................                                        150, 000 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887 .................                                   183,   878 27
                          RIVER AND HARBOR                        IMPROVEMENTS.                                 319
  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project .....                                  $2,184,115 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June
    30, 188---..--...............-----......
                                         -------....--...-------..........--...--.....-------....----     400,000 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix J J 1.)
  2. Saint Mary's Falls Canal and River, Michigan.-This improvement,
originally projected to obtain a 16-foot navigation between Lakes Su-
perior and Huron, has been completed accordingly, at a cost, to June
30, 1886, of $2,405,432.83.
   Statistics show that the commerce using this route is increasing so
rapidly that if it continues at the same rate for four years the present
lockage system at the canal will not suffice to pass all the vessels.
  The greatest depth advisable to obtain in the canal and river is 20
feet in the clear, because that can be effected at reasonable cost, and
any additional depth is not likely to be required for along time to come,
because a channel of greater depth can be obtained across Lake Saint
Clair only at such enormous cost as to render its expediency very doubt-
ful.
   A necessary part of the plan of enlargement is the increase in the
capacity of Saint Mary's Falls Canal, including its lockage system.
   It is now proposed to give the canal a depth of 20 feet, and to replace
the present "Old Locks" (of 1855), as useless under the changed condi-
tion, by a lock 800 feet between gates, 100 feet wide, having 21 feet of
water on its miter-sills, and a lift of 18 feet.
   The estimated cost of these improvements is $2,055,576, and an ap-
propriation of $400,000 is earnestly recommended for the next fiscal year
to continue the work.
July 1, 1885, amount available...----...........---....-...........---- ----..-..--..                        $182 31
July 1, 1886, outstanding liabilities-......... ...............-182........                                        31
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886       .................                                250, 000 00

  SAmount
 (Amount (estimated) required for completion of project
              that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June
    30, 1888--- --..-------------- ---------------. ---------------...
                                                                                  .............
                                                                       --.. 400, 000 00
                                                                                                        1, 805, 576 00


  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 166 and 1867.
   (See Appendix J J 2.)
   3. Operating and care of Saint Mary's Falls Canal, Michigan.-During
the fiscal year the canal was open to navigation two hundred and twenty-
two days. It closed December-2,1885, and was opened April 25,1886. Six
thousand two hundred and three vessels and rafts, having a registered
tonnage of 3,529,184 tons and carrying 3,701,014 tons of freight, 34,356
passengers, passed through in 3,232 lockages.
   The staple articles transported were 922,158 tons of coal; 32,615 tons of
copper; 1,696,263 barrels of flour; 17,346,212 bushels of grain; 1,529,021
tons of iron ore; 73,691 tons of pig and manufactured iron; 136,664,000
feet of timber, board measure; 159,840 barrels of salt; 3,434 tons of
silver ore; 9,366 tons of building stone; and 199,052 tons of unclassified
freight.
The estimated expense of operating and care f-or the fiscal year was......                                $32, 000 00
The actual expenses were ......................--                             --------------....           25, 400 95
The receipts for rents and dry-dockage were ............................                                       498 00
   The estimated amount required on account of operating and care of
the canal for the fiscal year ending June 30, 1887, is $36,540, all of which
is already provided for by indefinite appropriation,
320       REPORT OF THE CHIEF (IF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

July 1, 1885, amount available .-...          ......... ......-.......      ........... $32, 000 00
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1885 ....................-----..         $23, 349 00
July 1, 1886, outstanding liabilities..---.........---.    ....-----......   2, 051 95
                                                                                         25,400 95

Amount available by allotment for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887 ......                                 36,540 00
   (See Appendix J J 3.)
  4. Dry-dock at Saint Mary's Falls Canal.-In the printed Annual Re-
port of the Chief of Engineers for the fiscal years ending June 30, 1884
and 1885 (see pages 2030 et seq. of 1884 and 2124 et seq. and 2188 et seq.
of 1885), are to be found full reports upon this subject.
  Under the provisions of the act of the legislature of the State of Mich-
igan, in accordance with which the Saint Mary's Falls Canal was trans-
ferred to and received by the General Government, it seems to be
obligatory upon the United States to construct a dry-dock at Sault Ste.
Marie.
   For reasons fully set forth in the reports referred to, the officer in
local charge strongly objects to the construction of a dry-dock in im-
mediate proximity to the locks, and suggests that it be located at the
eastern end of the area transferred from the Fort Brady military res-
ervation to the canal reservation.
   The estimated cost of a dry-dock so located is $323,872, and the amount
which can be profitably expended during the fiscal year ending June 30,
1888, is $215,000, of which $150,000 should be appropriated by the
United States and $65,000 (more or less) transferred by the State of
Michigan.
   (See Appendix J J 4.)
   5. Harborat Cheboygan, Michigan.--The project for the improvement
of this harbor was adopted in 1871, the object being to afford a channel
of entrance from the Straits of Mackinac 200 feet wide and not less
than 14 feet in depth into Cheboygan River.
   This project was modified in August, 1882, to provide for the deep-
ening of the basin opposite the steamboat landing and the entire channel
to the 15-foot curve in the Straits of Mackinac.
   Nothing was done towards the improvement during the fiscal year,
and upon the 30th of June, 1886, its condition was substantially as re-
ported at the close of the preceding year.
   The same opinion is still entertained in regard to the amount required
to complete the improvement, and therefore the estimate of 1885 is re-
peated, and the sum of $100,000 is named as that which will probably
be required for that purpose, the ultimate cost thus amounting to but
little more than half the original estimate.
The original estimate for this work was...                       ........---..................          $395, 000 00
Amount thus far appropriated----.        .... .... ....
                                         ------...          --....         $118, 000 00
                                                                       ......
Received from sale of fuel.. --......... ..........       ............             3 00
Revised estimate of cost of completion-           ...-.. --............. 100,000 00
       Total......             -
                       ... ....-......   .....   ....      -...... ................                ...... 218. 003 00
       Difference.................... ......            ......          ........................          176,997 00
   The foregoing estimate, indicating that the object may probably be
attained at so much less cost than the amount of the original estimate,
is based upon the possibility that the long pier provided for and in-
tended to protect the channel may be omitted. Should this not prove
to be the case, the original estimate willbe found not to have been too
great.
                       RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                           321
   Thereasoinsfor undertaking this improvement have been so frequently
stated in preceding annual reports that it is deemed unnecessary to re.
peat them, and an appropriation of $20,000 is recommended with which
to continue the work during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888.
                                                                           $5, 000 00
July 1, 1885, amount available..........................................--------
Received from sale of fuel .............-............... _..........._....      13 13
                                                                                            5,013 13
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities,
  outstanding July 1, 1885--   .     .     .      .      .   .       .                         22 47
July 1, 1886, amount available .............................. ...........                   4,990 66
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886......                      ..........   15,000 00



{
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887 ....................

    Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project........85,000
    Amountthat can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1888 20, 000 00
    Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
                                                                                           19,990 66

                                                                                                  00


     harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
    (See Appendix J J 5.)
   6. Harborat ThunderBay, Michigan.-The project for the improvement
of this harbor was adopted in 1876, the object being to obtain an en-
trance channel from the bay into the river of navigable width and of
not less than 13 feet in depth. The project was subsequently modified
with a view to obtaining a depth of 14 feet. This had been practically
accomplished at the date of the Annual Report for 1884.
   It was then stated that the improvement is of such a character that
it will require attention from time to time, and as the nature of this
could not be foretold, it was recommended that a sufficient appropria-
tion be made to render available the sum of $10,000.
   During the last fiscal year no complaints concerning this harbor have
been received, owing, probably, to the high stage of water in Lake Hu-
ron, and only $23.02 was expended on account of the harbor. Conse-
quently it is not necessary to do more than repeat the recommendation
of the last two years, which would require an appropriation of $5,474.93.
   The commerce directly benefited by this work is that to and from
Thunder Bay River, at the mouth of which is situated the important
and rapidly growing city of Alpena.
July, 1885, amount available........ ................................                       4, 534 96
Received from sale of fuel............................                  ................        13 13

                                                                                           4, 548 09
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885 ..........................................                          23 02
                                              ....  ...................
July 1, 1886, amount available.... ..................                                      4, 525 07

    Amount (estimated) required for maintenance of existing project-......                 10,000 00
    Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
      harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
    (See Appendix J J 6.)
  7. Harbor at Au Sable, Michigan.-The present project for the im-
provement of the harbor was adopted in 1866, and modified in 1879, the
object being to obtain a channel of not less than 10 feet in depth for a
width of 100 feet from the lake to the State road bridge at Au Sable.
  The attempts to improve this harbor have not been so successful as
had been hoped, The reaonS for this are fully set forth in the Annunl
322       REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

Report of 1885 (see pages 2130, et seq., Annual Report of the Chief of
Engineers for 1885).
  Since submitting that report, the officer in charge of the work has
seen no reason for modifying the opinion therein expressed, that it is
not possible to make any permanent improvement of the harbor at a
cost at all commensurate with the advantages to be gained.
  The officer in charge of the work does not recommend the abandon-
ment of the improvement, but refrains from recommending at this time
any appropriation for the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888.
  About 130,000,000 feet, board measure, lumber, 45,000,000 lath, and a
quantity of salt, are annually shipped from this port.
July 1, 1885, amount vrailable..-...--..--...........----.---...--..--------.........--..--..$4,900 55
Received from sale of fuel .-- ........          .......... ........... ...           .           13 13
                                                                                             4,913 68
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885............................................                          52 15
July 1, 1886, amount available .-.....--..................................                   4, 861 53
  (See Appendix J J 7.)
  8. Saginaw River, Michigan.-The present project aims to secure a
channel of 200 feet in width, 14 feet in depth from Saginaw Bay to Bay
City, and 12 feet in depth thence to the head of navigation in Saginaw
River.
  After the close of the fiscal year 1884-'85, operations were continued
on the bar at the mouth of the river, under contract dated October 2,
1884.
   This contract expired by its own limitation August 31, 1885, the funds
available for the purpose being practically exhausted at the same time.
  The result accomplished during the fiscal year 1885-'86 was the re-
moval of 16,200 cubic yards of material.
  It is estimated that the original project can be completed for the sum
of $337,250, which sum is obtained by deducting from the estimate of
1883-'84 the amount since appropriated.
  The interests involved are so large as to justify the most extensive
operations, and the length of the channel (nearly 23 miles) is such that
they can be readily carried on without interfering with each other.
  Itis therefore recommended that the sum stated below be appro.
priated for the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888.
July 1, 1885, amount available .. ---..            .......................
                                                                 ..........$8,509 12
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885.---...--.    . .....---...---...      .-. .----. 8, 461 39
July 1, 1886, amount available..----- -----------------------------------                      47 73
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886 ...................                     33,750 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887 ...................                  33,797 73
  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project--.....    337,250 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June30,1888 100, 000 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
  (See Appendix J J 8.)
  9. Harborof Refuge, Sand Beach, Lake Huron, Michigan.--The present
project for this improvement was adopted in 1873. It consists of a
breakwater constructed of timber cribs filled with stone, inclosing an
area which is to be deepened, where necessary, by dredging.
  its object is to afford a harbor of refuge to the vessels engaged in
                            RIVER AND HARBOR .IMPROVEMENTS.                                                           323
the navigation of the northern and northwestern lakes, when caught by
heavy weather near the dangerous Pointe aux Barques. Previous to
1876 vessels so caught were compelled to run a distance of 60 miles,
and find refuge in Saint Clair River. After the subsidence of the gale,
those upward bound had to work their way back again.
   The estimate of the probable cost of the improvement was $1,442,500,
and the aggregate amount of appropriations (previous to that of August
5, 1886) has been $975,000. The total amount expended toJune 30,
1886, was $970,930.16.
   The total amount of available funds has thus been $975,213.76, or
$467,286.24 less than the amount of the original estimate, whilst the
estimated cost of the work remaining to be done to complete the proj-
ect is only $100,000 (less $30,000 appropriated by act of August 5,
1886)-that is to say, the total cost of the project will be but three-
fourths of the estimate.
   On the 4th and 5th December, 1885, a northeast storm of unprece-
dented severity wrought serious damage to the work, the extent being
given in detail in the report.
   The estimated cost of repairing the damage is $60,000.
   The timber superstructure is now at that stage of. its life when ex-
tensive renewals in some more durable materials should be undertaken.
It is proposed to use concrete for this purpose, and an estimate of
$50,000 is submitted for beginning this work.
  The river and harbor act of August 5, 1886, appropriates $45,000 for
repairs, and the total amount of funds required for the purpose indi-
cated is $165,000 additional, which the officer in charge earnestly recom-
mends be appropriated.
July 1, 1885, amount available ...........                       .............................                $24, 521 55
Received from sale of fuel .......................---------------------------------------.......                     13 13
                                                                                                               24,534 68
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1885 ............... ..........  $18, 613 41
July 1, 1886, outstanding liabilities ................  ..........   1, 637 67
                                                                                                               20,251 08
July 1, 1886, amount available ..........................................                                       4,283 60
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886 ...................                                         75,000 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887 ....................                                     79, 283 60

 (Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project........ 70,000 00
I Amount that can be profitably expended for repairs, &c., in fiscal year
     ending June 30, 1888 .--------....---...................................-------------...-...----------------. 135,000 00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
     harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
    (See Appendix J J 9.)
  10. Steam launch or tug for Harbor of Refuge, Lake Huron, Michigan.--
Under the provisions of the act approved June 19, 1882, a contract has
been made for the purchase of a steam launch for use at the harbor of
refuge, Lake Huron, building by David Bell, of Buffalo, N. Y., under
specifications. The boat is expected to be first class in every respect,
and to be specially adapted to the requirements of the service required
of her.
  The expenditures on this account to the close of the fiscal year amount-
ed to $338.94.
  No additional appropriation is required.
324         REPORT OF THE CHIEF                          OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

July 1, 1885, amount available ..........................................                        $10, 000 00
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885--...........              ......... ...--        -....--- -- -- -- --
                                                                          ..........                  338 94

July 1, 1886, amount available ..............                             ........................-- .   9,661 06
   (See Appendix J J 10.)
   11. Ice-harbor of Refuge at Belle River, Michigan.-The project for this
improvement was adopted in 1880, the object being to obtain a channel
50 feet wide, 13 feet deep to the first bridge, 12 feet deep thence to the
second bridge, and affording a safe harbor against running ice.
   The work has been completed according to the project and gives sat-
isfaction.
   Nothing further is required at this time, and in consequence no esti-
mate is submitted.
July 1, 1885, amount available ............................                              ...........     .$4Y 10
July 1, 1886, amount available.........................................                                     47 10
   (See Appendix J J 11.)
   12. General repairsand renewals at Saint ClairEFlatsShip- Canal.-The
canal was projected in 1866 with a view to obtaining a straight channel
13 feet deep and 300 feet wide, across Saint Clair Flats, the channel
being bounded on each side by a dike 7,221 feet long, or an aggregate
of 14,442 feet.
   These dikes consist of timber cribs, resting upon piles driven into
the original bottom of the shoal, the crib pockets being filled with ma-
terial dredged from the channel.
   To maintain a channel bank a single row of sheet-piling was driven
along the channel face of the cribs previous to dredging.
   The lake sides of the dikes were protected from wave action by
shorter sheet-piling.
   In 1873 the demands of commerce required a deeper channel, and
this was obtained by dredging to 16 feet, for a width of 100 feet on each
side of the axis of the canal, or a width of 200 feet in all.
   The single row of sheet-piling is insufficient to prevent the leakage
of material through it into the channel, and it should be re-enforced
with a double row of at least 8 feet greater penetration, with a view
not only to the protection of the present channel, but to further dredg-
ing at an early day,to obtain a greater depth.
   As the dikes now stand, intended for a 13-foot channel, and made to
do duty for one of 16 feet, it is manifest that no greater depth can be
maintained without such re-enforcement.
   The entire timber structure is much decayed and should be removed
as soon as possible.
   In the Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1885 (see pages
2159 et seq.) a project was submitted for such works as will accomplish
the desired result and at the same time provide for subsequently deep-
ening the channel to 20 feet.
   The estimated cost of the project was $153,289, and it is again re-
spectfully submitted, with the remark that the estimate relates only to
the dikes, and does not include any portion of such excavation as must
subsequently be made.
   The bad condition of the entire superstructure and sheet-piling of the
dikes, dwelt upon in prior reports, has become worse through the natural
processes of decay, and proceed more rapidly as the timber grows less
able to resist them,
   The great jmportance of this improvement is so well known, its use
is so advantageous to a commerce hailing from every lake port, both
is ]e LTnittd B ak¢          1.4w! loand wh i] is neay, if F'q j quite, tqaud
                             RIVER AND HARB3OR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                                                           325
to our entire foreign commerce by sea, that no additional representa-
tion seems to be necessary to secure early and favorable consideration.
   The necessity for the work proposed is immediate and urgent.


{Amount
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886 ..----.... .......... $18, 750 00
                (estimated) required for completion of existing project -......- . 135, 000 00
   Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1888
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
                                                                                                                                                  67, tO 000
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
    (See Appendix J J 12.)
   13. Operating and care of Saint Clair Flats Canal, Michigan.-The
minor repairs involved in operating and care of the canal during the
fiscal year amounted to only $232.57. This was due, as in the preced-
ing year, to the fact that the stage of water was such that but few ves-
sels grounded in the canal, and slight damage was done to the dikes.
   Cavities in the dikes were filled with cedar bark; the willows grow-
ing on the dikes were trimmed, and the cuttings tied in bundles, also
deposited in cavities; plank were placed on the lake side of the dikes,
where they are most threatened with injury from the wash of waves.
   At the beginning of the fiscal year a contract for dredging was in
force. The work was completed on the 19th of September, 1885. The
entire amount of dredging done under contract was 64,580 cubic yards,
of which 60,298 cubic yards were dredged during the fiscal year and
4,282 cubic yards during June, 1885. The price paid was 11I cents per
cubic yard, a remarkably low rate.
   Of the total amount dredged and removed, 7,516 cubic yards were
from the head of the canal, and 57,034 from the foot.
   The estimated cost of operating and care of the canal (including the
dredging) for the fiscal year was $17,700.
   The actual cost was $10,171.54, of which an itemized statement is
hereto appended (Appendix J J 13) as required by law.
   The estimated cost of operating and care of the canal for the fiscal
year ending June 30, 1887, is as follows:
Salary of custodian--  .--...-...--...- -....---...----... ....----
Current repairs ......----
                                                            -.. - .            -.....---......
                       -------........-..---- ----.........-----.----..-- ----......--....
                                                                                                ---..
                                                                                          -....--.
                                                                                   ----.---..--.--......
                                                                                                                                                     $1, 500
                                                                                                                                                      3, 500
                           ....----....------....--.......
         Total----....----....---------                                     -------......             ---......--.--....--..............     .-       5,000
July 1, 1885, amount available ....-- ....--..--- ....                         ......       .. ....        ..--......            ..--.....        17, 700 00
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885 ......--                ...................---      --------....--                .....--- -..... ......-               9,588 35
Amount available by allotment for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887 .......                                                                         5,000 00
   (See Appendix J J 13.)
   14. Clinton River, Michigan.-In 1870 the channel over the bar at the
entrance to the river afforded a depth of only 3,1 feet, whilst the depth
in the river some distance above the bar was 10 feet.
   The present project for improvement was adopted in 1870 and modi-
fied in 1880. It aims to obtain an entrance channel of 8 feet.
   In a report dated January 23, 1885, the officer in local charge pro-
posed a further modification of the project, and submitted estimates of
the probable cost, amounting to $32,926.
   The conditions have not changed meanwhile.
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886 ...................                                                                            $6, 000 00
( Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project-.......                                                                          26,926 00
/ Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
      harbor acts of 1866 and 187.
   (See Appendix J J 14.
326         REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

   15. Detroit River, Michigan.-Before improvement to the channel at
Lime Kiln Crossing, Detroit River, was undertaken, not more than 13
feet of water could be depended upon, the ordinary depth being much
affected by the direction and force of the winds.
   As originally projected in 1874, the improvement was to consist of                                         ,
carved channel 300 feet wide, with a uniform depth of 20 feet, and the
estimate was based upon this project.
   In 1883 the project was modified to secure a straight channel, the least
width of which should be 300 feet, with a somewhat greater width at each
end, utilizing the work already done, and this constitutes the project now
under execution, which, if the present rate of progress is maintained, will
be completed before the close of the current season.
   The obstruction is a ledge of solid rock, which is first broken up by
drilling and blasting, and the ddbris then removed by dredging.
   The unavoidable result of this is to leave channel banks with rugged
edges, which would prove destructive to any vessels striking them, and
in order to diminish the danger of such results it is now earnestly recom-
mended by the officer in charge that the width of the channel be increased
to 400 feet by removing 100 feet additional from the western (American)
side.
   To do this will require the excavation of 25,765 cubic yards of rock, at
an estimated cost of $168,000.
   This recommendation is made with the greater confidence because the
ultimate cost of the improvement will even then be but little more than
half the original estimate. That is to say, the estimated cost of the im-
provement, as modified in 1883, was $1,206,500, whilst the actual cost
of the same will not exceed $535,000, and, with the estimated cost of
the additional width ($168,000), the amount will be $703,000.
July 1, 1885, amount available ...................           ....................               $149, 385 46
Received from sale of fuel............ .....................                      ...........   -      48 39

                                                                                                    149,433 85
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1885.... ..................    $68, 060 59
July 1, 1886, outstanding liabilities ............    ..........  22, 027 96
                                                                                                     90, 088 55

July 1, 1886, amount available ............................. ...............                        59, 345 30
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886-- ---- ---...................                    37, 500 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887 ....................                           96,845 30
  Amountthat can be profitably expendedin fiscal year ending June30, 1888 130,500 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix J J 15.)

IMPROVEMENT OF HARBORS ON LAKE ERIE WEST OF BUFFALO, WITH
  THE EXCEPTION OF THE HARBOR AT ERIE--IMPROVEMENT     OF
  SANDUSKY RIVER.

  Officer in charge, Maj. L. Cooper Overman, Corps of Engineers.
  1. Monroe Harbor, Michigan.-The original project for the improve-
ment of this harbor was adopted in 1835, when Monroe was a town of
considerable importance, and when the navigable waters of the River
Raisin were separated from the waters of Lake Erie by extensive shoals.
  It provided for cutting a canal between the river and the lake, 4,000
feet long and 100 feet wide, through the peninsula called " River Raisin
Point," and protecting the entrance into the lake by parallel piers run-
                    RIVER AND         HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                            327
ning out to a depth of 10 feet, the object being to afford a channel of
entrance of navigable width with a depth of 10 feet. Work was com-
menced in 1835 and has been continued from time to time since that
date.
   At the close of the last fiscal year there was a good channel, with a
least depth of 10 feet, up to a point below Monroe, which is deemed
sufficient for the present commerce of the port.
   During the fiscal year ending June 30, 1886, no work of any kind was
done for want of funds.
   The total amount appropriated for this harbor has been $213,515.27,
which. has resulted in securing a navigable channel with a least depth
of 10 feet up to a point just below the docks at Monroe, where rock bot-
tom occurs.
   If this harbor is to be kept up, there is need of extensive repairs to
piers and canal revetment, in order to prevent their unlimited destruc-
tion or more expensive renewals in later years. These repairs are esti-
mated to cost $20,000.
  The present commerce of Monroe is not sufficient, in the opinion of
the officer in charge, to justify such a large expenditure. Hence, he
considered a small annual appropriation for repairs sufficient until an
increase of commerce demands the extensive renewals. But as there
has been no appropriation for Monroe Harbor since 1882, and then only
$1,000, the proposed annual repairs have not been made, and extensive
repairs are badly needed.
  The river and harbor act of August 5, 1886, appropriates $2,000. It
will be expended in repairs.
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886 ...................           $2, 000 00
  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project-------.......   18, 000 00
  Amountthat canbe profitably expended in fiscal year ending June30,1888          2,000 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix K K 1.)
   2. Toledo Harbor, Ohio.--Vhen operations were commenced at this
harbor, in 1866, the channel through the bay was narrow and intricate,
presenting a depth of only 11 feet. The original project provided for
cutting a channel 200 feet wide and 12 feet deep through Maumee Bay,
and this was amended from time to time, until the present project
provides for a channel 20.0 feet wide at bottom and 16 feet deep at low
water between the city of Toledo and deep water in Lake Erie. In
1868, there was a channel 100 feet wide and 12 feet deep; in 1875, the
depth had been increased to 14 feet, and at the beginning of the fiscal
year ending June 30, 1886, there was a good channel 200 feet wide at
bottom on the ranges and from 260 to 350 feet wide at the angles, with a
depth of from 15 to 17 feet at low water between Toledo and deep water
in the lake.
   The total amount appropriated for this harbor since 1866 to close of
fiscal year ending June 30, 1886, has been $704,700, all of which sum
has been expended. This expenditure has resulted in obtaining a good
16-foot channel where before there was a narrow, intricate channel with
but 11 feet for vessels.
   During the fiscal year the sum of $253.81 has been expended in main-
taining the channel.
   The estimated cost of the present project was $570,000, of which
amount there has been appropriated $510,000. The balance of $60,000
yet required will not complete the project as originally estimated, owing
to the time consumed in doing the work for want of adequate appro-
328     REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

priation, the contingent expenses, and the annual removal of the de-
posits of each winter and spring, repeated for twelve years, having ab-
sorbed at least $100,000 of the original estimate. It will therefore re-
quire at least $160,000 to complete the improvement of the natural
channel, the whole of which can be expended during the year ending
June 30, 1888, in deepening and widening the channel between Toledo
and 16 feet of water in Lake Erie, after which an annual expenditure of
about $20,000 will be needed to maintain the dredged channel through
the open bay.
   The act of July 5, 1884, appropriated $25,000 to commence the work
of making a straight channel for the Maumee River from its mouth to
Lake Erie, in accordance with the second plan recommended by Major
Wilson in report dated November 19, 1881. This plan is estimated to
cost $2,363,923, which amount includes item for contingent expenses
amounting to $214,902.
   The officer in charge believes that the sum of $500,000 is as small a
sum as should be on iand to begin this work in a proper manner in ac-
cordance with the specified plan.
   In accordance with the above views it was recommended by him that
the appropriation of $25,000 be retained until further appropriations
made the amount large enough to properly commence the work. This
was approved and no operations were undertaken during the fiscal year
ending June 30, 1885, in connection with the " Straight Channel" im-
provement, or for over a year after the passage of the act.
   During the summer of 1885, there being no work in progress for the
improvement of Toledo Harbor, and but little Government work being
done at any of the Lake Erie harbors for want of appropriations, a
vigorous effort was made by citizens of Toledo to have work on the
"'Straight Channel" improvement begun by the expenditure of the
$25,000. This effort was successful and the expenditure ordered. The
engineer in charge was instructed under date of August 15, 1885, to
take the necessary steps to begin the work by dredging along a "sec-
tion of channel between the point where the present channel trends
towards the east and the land at North Cape Point," the said section
not to connect with the existing channel nor extend so far north as to
come under the influence of Ottawa River, which crosses the line of
proposed channel.
   Proposals for the dredging were invited and contract entered into
dated September 21, 1885, for the removal of 130,000 cubic yards, more
or less, of material from along a section of channel as indicated, at the
rate of 10 cents per cubic yard, place measurement.
   The contract was completed and closed November 30, 1885, and un-
der it 127,260 cubic yards of material were dredged and removed at a
cost of $12,726. It resulted in making a cut in the open bay of about
7,500 feet in length, about 100 feet in width, with 11 feet depth of water.
No practical benefit accrued from making the cut.
   No further work was done for the " Straight Channel" improvement
during the remainder of the fiscal year.
   The total expenditures during the fiscal year were $15,367.39 and a
partial refilling has occurred in the cut during the winter of 1885-86
and spring of 1886.
   The act approved August 5, 1886, making appropriations for rivers
and harbors reads, as relates to Toledo Harbor, Ohio, as follows:
   Improving harbor at Toledo, Ohio: Continuing improvement of the Maume River,
by a straight channel along such line as may be approved by the Secretary of War,
$112,500; and the balance of $25,000 heretofore appropriated are hereby made avail-
able for clearing the old channel.
                          RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                        329

  The proviso as to the line of " the Straight Channel" will necessitate
additional examination of the locality in order to determine which is
the best line for it. The necessary examination can be made this fall,
contracts perfected, and work begun vigorously in the spring of 1887.
                                                Natural channel.

July 1, 1885, amount available.......-----        -............--...-----..----....-----............---.      $253 81
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885 ----....----....--..---..--.----.....................---....----..                  253 81
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886..... ...... ........                                     9, 632 61
 (Amount  (estimated) required for completion of existing project -...-------. 50,000 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscalyear ending June 30, 1888 25,000 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.

                                 Making a straight channel to Lake Erie.

July 1, 1885, amount available... .......-- ...-.....................                                      $25, 000 00
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885..--.. -----......-----......---....----....--..........----.                     15,367 39
July 1, 1886, amount available (this balance made applicable to old
  channel by act of August 5, 1886) .-----.......- ..........-- ..........                                   9, 632 61
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886 .................                                       112,500 00
  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project...... 2, 226, 423 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June
   30, 1888-.....----.....------..............----........---......----..--.--..-------.....----.......---. 250, 000 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and            1867.
  (See Appendix K K 2.)
  3. Port Clinton Harbor, Ohio.-The first survey of the harbor was
made in 1867, but no action was taken upon it. In 1870 a new survey
was made, which showed the channel at the entrance to be narrow and
intricate, with a depth of only 5 feet. The original project provided
for cutting a channel 8 feet deep through the outer bar and construct-
ing piers from the shore out to the necessary depth.
  Efforts were made, without success, during the years 1872, 1873, and
1874 to obtain a channel by dredging only, but the required depth could
not be maintained.
  The present project, adopted in 1875, provides for a pile revetment
running from the north shore of the Portage River, opposite the town,
967 feet out into the lake, in a direction north 570 east; then inclin-
ing towards the north, a pile-pier about 1,500 feet long extends to the
depth of 10 feet in the lake; parallel to this and 200 feet from it an east
pier 2,600 feet long, to run out from the south shore of the river. It is
expected that a full depth of 9 feet can be maintained by confining the
waters of the Portage River between these piers.
   The total amount appropriated for this harbor to the close of the fiscal
year ending June 30, 1886, has been $46,000, all of which has been
expended. The expenditure has resulted in obtaining a depth of 9 feet
from the lake to the town where there was originally but 5 feet.
   During the fiscal year no work of any kind has been done, for want
of funds, making two years without any work.
   The original estimate for the ' work was $122,000, a revised estimate
$90,000, of which $46,000 has been appropriated, but the engineer in
charge questions the advisability at present of expending the remain-
ing $44,000, as the commerce, present or prospective, is not such as to
justify such an expenditure.
330     REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

  If it is deemed best to continue the improvement as projected, the
sum of $20,000 can be expended diring the fiscal year ending June 30,
1888, extending the piers and repairing same. The river and harbor
act of August 5, 1886, appropriated $2,000 for this harbor, to be used
in "repairs of existing works." It will be expended during the fiscal
year.
July 1, 18 5, amount available .............. ...---
                                                  --.... ............    .. $17 70
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885 ........     -- --................-----      ...
                                                         .............---    17 70
                                                                 -2,000
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886...................           00
SAmount (estimated) required for completion of existing project......   41,000 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix K K 3.)
   4. Sandusky City Harbor, Ohio.-The original survey of this harbor
was in 1826, but no appropriation was made until 1844. In the latter
year the depth in the channel through the outer bar was 10 feet and
the greatest depth in the bay was about 12 feet. There was an exten-
sive breach in the peninsula which protects the harbor on the west and
northwest. The original project provided for closing this breach by
crib-work and deepening the channel through the outer bar to 12 feet.
   The appropriations of 1844 and 1852 were applied to closing the breach
in the peninsula, but the failure of further appropriations left the work
unfinished, and in 1864, when operations were resumed, the old work
was found to have been destroyed.
   In 1864 a project was proposed for opening a channel 400 feet wide
and 12 feet deep through the outer bar. This has been amended from
time to time, and at present the project calls for a channel through the
outer bar and the bay up to within 50 feet of the line of docks and
then parallel to the docks, the portion through the bar and bay to be
200 feet wide and that parallel to the docks 100 feet wide, the whole
to be 15 feet deep. In 1869 the channel through the outer bar was 240
feet wide and 12 feet deep. In 1872 the depth was increased to 13 feet
and work was commenced upon the channel within the bay. In 1875
there was a channel 100 feet wide through the outer bar and one 150
feet wide and from 13 to 15 feet deep within the bay, up to a point
about 1I miles from the docks at Sandusky City.
   At the close of the fiscal year ending June 30, 1885, the sum of
$254,450.07 had been expended on this harbor, and there was a channel
through the outer bar about 150 feet wide, with a depth of about 15 feet,
and a depth of 152 feet for a width of 50 feet, and through the bay up
to a point 50 feet from line of docks, with a width of 200 feet and a
depth of about 15 feet.
   During the fiscal year ending Junie 30, 1886, the sum of $398.22 has
been expended; 741 cubic yards of mud, clay, sand, &c., have been re-
moved from the channel through outer bar, and it was thereby restored
to a similar condition as at the close of 1885. An annual removal of at
least 10,000 cubic yards is necessary to maintain the unfinished channel,
after which the additional dredging can be applied toward the comple-
tion of the channel to 200 feet in width and 15 feet in depth.
   The sum of $10,000 is required to complete the existing project, the
whole of which can be profitably expended during the period ending
June 30, 1888, in widening and deepening the channel from deep water
in the lake to the docks at Sandusky City.
   An increased depth of 16 feet at low water has been recommended
                     RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                          331
for this harbor on account of the increased size of vessels navigating
the lakes.
   The estimated cost of this extra depth is $61,000 additional, and if
this project is favorably considered the sum of $30,000 additional (mak-
ing $40,000 in all) can be profitably expended during the fiscal year
ending June 30,1888.
   The act of July 5, 1884, contained the following proviso in connec-
tion with the appropriation of $20,000 for this harbor: "One-half of
said sum to be expended in deepening the channel, and the other half
in the repair of existing works."
   Since 1855 there has been no work carried on by the United States
for the improvement of Sandusky Harbor other than-dredge work.
Previous to and during 1855 a number of rough cribs had been located
along the then existing sand-bar or peninsula which protected Sandusky
Bay on the north and west from the winds and lake waves, but during
the winter of 1859 the crib-work was nearly all destroyed, and no ex-
penditure has since been made towards replacing it. At present there
is not a vestige of cribs to be seen.
   There are therefore no "existing works" in the improvements of the
harbor of Sandusky City, and only one-half of the whole appropriation
was therefore deemed applicable to continuing the work on the existing
channel, and no work was possible with the $10,000 held as " unavail-
able."
   The river and harbor act of August 5, 1886, made this sum of $10,000
available, and made an additional appropriation of $5,000 (making a
total of $15,000 to be expended during the fiscal year ending June 30,
1887, in dredging in accordance with the existing project).
July 1, 1885, amount available ....... .... ....---
                                               ---  .. ..........       --......
                                                                       ..--                $629 93
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885........................... .....
                                                          ----    ....---......             398 22

July 1, 1886, amount available.............. ........         ..........    ......   .       231 71
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886...................                    15, 000 00

Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887 ...................                15,231 71
   (See Appendix K K 4.)
   5. Sandusky River, Ohio. - ) uring the years 1867 and 1872 the sum
of $30,000 was expended in opening a navigable channel with a depth
of 8 feet from Sandusky Bay to Fremont, a distance of 17 miles; since
1872 the cuts then made through the various bars have filled up.
   The present project, which was based on a survey made August, 1880,
provides for opening a channel 100 feet wide and 9 feet deep between
the town of Fremont and the depth of 9 feet in Sandusky Bay, at an
estimated cost of $44,000.
   At the close of the fiscal year ending June 30, 1883, the sum of $21,500
had been appropriated for the project of 1880, of which amount
$20,871.53 has been expended, and by the expenditure there was at the
close of the season of 1883 a good channel, with least'depth of 9 feet,
from Fremont, the head of navigation, to the lake. The last appropria-
tion for this river was that of August 2, 1882.
   The balance on hand, viz, $628.47, was too small to attempt any fur-
ther work last season, but will be held for an emergency or until further
appropriations are made.
   Up to the present date $51,500 has been appropriated for this river,
of which $50,871.53 has been expended. The sum of $22,500 will be
required to complete the existing project, the advisability of which is
deemed doubtful by the officer in charge.
332          REPORT OF THE CHIEF                           OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

July 1, 1885, amount avilable .......................................                                         $628 47
July 1, 1886, amount available ..........                    ....     ......   .... ...........     -. .   -. 628 47

   Amount (estimated)required for completion of existing project--------........                           22,500 00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
  (See Appendix K K 5.)
  6. Huron Harbor, Ohio.-The present plan for the improvement of
this harbor consists of parallel piers, 140 feet apart, running out into
the lake. It was adopted in 1826, and modified in 1871, the object be-
ing to afford a channel of entrance of navigable width, and of not less
than 14 feet in depth.
   When work was commenced, in 1827, there was a bar at the minutli of
the river, dry at low water. In 1839 the channel was 130 feet wide, and
not less than 9J feet deep; in 1844 this depth was found to have been
maintained, but in 1852, as very little work had been done for fourteen
years, for want of appropriation, the piers were in a dilapidated con-
dition, and the channel had shoaled. In 1866 there was a depth of 11
feet at the entrance. At the close of the fiscal year ending June 30,
1885, there was a good channel through the outer bar, with a depth of
15 feet, and between the piers, with a depth of from 16 to 17 feet. The
superstructure of both piers, except where repaired in 1883 and 1884,
was in a decayed condition and needed immediate renewal.
   The heavy gales of the springs of 1884, 1885, and 1886 did consider-
able damage to the piers and to the beaches, so that a breach was made
between inner end of east pier and shore. Extensive and immediate
repairs are much needed.
   Up to the end of the fiscal year the sum of $114,273.71 has been ap-
propriated for this harbor, of which amount $114,064.78 has been ex-
pended, including the last appropriation, that of July 5, 1884.
   A good wide channel with least depth of 14 feet has been obtained
where originally there was a sand-bar, dry at low water.
   The estimated cost of renewing the superstructure of the piers is
$22,000; $13,500 has been appropriated, but owing to the extra repairs
made necessary by the storms of 1884, 1885, and 1886, the estimate to
complete the renewals is made greater.
   The river and harbor act of August 5, 1886, appropriated $3,000 for
this harbor. It will be expended this season in repairing piers, etc.
July 1, 1885, amount available ............... .............................                                 $213 07
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885..... ...............                ........... .........                             4 08
July 1, 1886, amount available....    ..      .     ..            .                               ......       208 99
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886 ................                                         3, 000 00

Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887. ..-......                                            3,208 99

   Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1888                                3,000 00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix K K 6.)
   7. Vermillion Harbor, Ohio.-The original project for this improvement
in 1826, when the mouth of Vermillion River was closed by a sand-bar,
upon which there was a depth of less than 2 feet, consisted of parallel
piers running out to a depth of 12 feet in the lake, from each side
of the mouth of the river, in order to secure a depth of 10 feet. This
                     RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                         333
project has been amended from time to time, and now provides for a
depth of 14 feet.
   In 1838 there was a channel 50 feet wide and 6 feet deep. No appro-
priations were made between 1838 and 1866, and in the latter year the
piers were found to be dilapidated and the depth at the entrance to be
7 feet.
   In 1878 the channel was about 70 feet wide, with a depth of about 12
feet.
   At the close of the fiscal year ending June 30, 1885, the piers were in
fair condition; the depth in channel was about the same as at the close
of the previous fiscal year. The amount appropriated to close of fiscal
year ending June 30,1886, has been $114,942.32, of which sum $114,183.64
has been expended.
   The act of July 5, 1884, made no appropriation of funds for this har-
bor; hence but a limited amount of repairs could be done with the small
balance of funds on hand.
   No work was done during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1886.
   The amount estimated for the completion of the proposed project can
be expended during the period ending June 30, 1888,in removing rock,
shoal, sand, &c., from the channel and repairing the piers, but the Eu-
gineer in charge is doubtful as to the advisability of such an expendi-
ture.
  The river and harbor act of August 5, 1886, appropriated $3,000 for
this harbor, which will be expended this season in repairs, &c.
JL.1y 1, 1885; amount available ...... ......-- ...... ...........-      ..... .....     $908 68
.T ly 1, 1836, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
   outstanding July 1, 1885.........................       ..--.. ...............         150 00
iuly1, 1886, amount available .............. ....... ..................
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886 ...----....--............
                                                                                          758 68
                                                                                        3,000 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887 .............         .....       3, 758 68
  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project.......                11, 000 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix K K 7.)
   8. Mouth of Black River, Ohio.-The present project for the improve-
ment of this harbor consists of parallel piers, 200 feet apart, running out
to a depth of 16 feet in the lake. It was adopted in 1828, modified so
as to give an increased depth in 1873, and again in 1880, the object
being to afford a channel of entrance of navigable width and not less
than 16 feet in depth.
   When work was commenced in 1828 there was a depth of only 3 feet
at the entrance; in 1839 there was a least depth of 91 feet. But one
appropriation of $5,000 was made between 1839 and 1865, and in the
latter year the piers were found to be in a dilapidated condition; but
a narrow channel, with a least depth of 7 feet, remained near the west
pier. In 1871 there was a depth of 12 feet; in 1874, of 14 feet; and at
the close of the last fiscal year there was a good wide channel, with a
least depth of 16J feet from the lake up into the river.
   Up to the close of the fiscal year ending June 30,1885, there had been
appropriated the sum of $200,138.73, of which $200,138.73 had been ex-
pended, with which a channel with least depth of 161 feet has been ob-
tained where originally there was but 3 feet at the entrance.
  At the close of the fiscal year ending June 30, 1885, both piers were
in fair repair, but nothin wms complishned towards extensioa of piers,
334        REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

which is the most important work when funds sufficient shall be avail-
able. In April, 1886, it was reported that a shoal had formed in chan-
nel beyond piers; but being without funds no action could be had to-
wards its removal.
  The unexpected and extra repairs made and to be made at this harbor,
will increase the estimate for repairs and renewal and prolonging piers
at least $12,000, so that the sum of $20,000 is still needed to complete
the existing project.
  The river and harbor act of August 5, 1886, appropriated $10,000 for
this harbor, all of which will be expended during the fiscal year end-
ing June 30, 1887, in accordance with existing project and in repairs.
July 1, 1885, amount available.....                    ..--........................-----......                                  $0 36
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885.......        ..........-                                 - - ....       ...   . ---                     36
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886...... ..... ...-                                                    ..   10, 000 00

  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project-........                                                   20, 000 00
  Amount that can be profitablyexpended in fiscal year ending June 30,1888                                                  10,000 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix K K 8.)
   9. Rocky River, Ohio.-The project for the improvement of this river
was adopted in 1871, the object being to afford a channel of entrance
100 feet wide and from 6 to 12 feet deep. It required the construc-
tion of a pier 500 feet long, and a large amount of excavation.
   The pier as projected was constructed, but only a small amount of
excavation was done, and no further appropriations were made for con-
tinuing the work after March 3, 1875.
   By the act of June 14, 1880, an appropriation of $4,000 was made for
repairs, and during the years 1880 and 1881 portions of this amount
were expended in placing the pier in good condition. The storms of
1883 did considerable damage to this pier, and it was repaired during
the fiscal year ending June 30, 1884, at a cost of $1,248.61. At the
close of that season the pier was in fair condition, but the storms of the
springs of 1884, 1885, and 1886 have again damaged the pier, and con-
siderable repairs are now needed. As the act of July 5, 1884, made no
appropriation for this harbor, and the balance on hand is too small to
attempt any repairs, there will be no work practicable until further ap-
propriation, and the damaged pier will be still further improved. The
sum of $3,000 is required for immediate repairs, if deemed advisable.
July 1, 1885, amount available ....-----..--....-----......                        ..............         ..........          $131 87
July 1, 1886, amount available ......-.....--                            -.. ..        ...... ..................                131 87
   (See Appendix K K 9.)
   10. Cleveland Harbor, Ohio.-The present project for the improvement
of the mouth of the Cuyahoga River was adopted in 1825, and has been
amended from time to time to gain increased depth. It consists of par-
allel piers about 200 feet apart, running out to a depth of 16 feet in the
lake.
   When operations were commenced in 1825 there was a long, low
sand-bar, where the river now empties into Lake Erie, and the entrance
was through a narrow, intricate channel with a depth of about 3 feet.
   At the close of the fiscal year ending June 30, 1886, there had been
expended about $368,000, and there was as the result a good wide chan-
nel at the entrance of the harbor with a depth of from 17 to 20 feet
between the lale and the railroad bridge at the inner end of the piers,
                RIVER AND HARBOR        IMPROVEMENTS.                 335
with a pile protection work 620 feet long at the inner end of the west
pier, constructed in 1882.
   The storms of the winter and spring of this year did some damage
to piers, and their use by vessels to " lay up " to, and also destroyed
many timbers, all of which had to be repaired during the fiscal year
ending June 30, 1886, at a cost of about $1,000.
    The new breakwater.-The original project for a harbor of refuge pro-
vides for an outer breakwater, starting from the lake shore about 700
feet west of the upper end of the old river-bed.
    This breakwater runs out in a direction about due north, a distance
of 3,130 feet, to a depth of 28 feet. The angle is then turned, and it
runs for 4,030 feet nearly parallel to the shore with a spur 100 feet long
on the north side of the lake-arm, and 200 feet from its eastern end, in
a depth of from 28 to 30 feet. The entrance to the harbor on the east side
it was proposed to protect by extending the east pier at the mouth of
the river 1,400 feet.
    To the close of the present fiscal year the sum of $809,206.26 has been
expended, and 7,160 linear feet of breakwater had been finished, which
completed. lake-arm of the breakwater, leaving but the eastern protec-
tion to be built to complete the harbor of refuge.
    The engineer in charge in May, 1884, suggested that the plan for the
closing of the eastern side of the harbor of refuge be changed; that
instead of prolonging the east pier another lake-arm of breakwater be
built to the eastward, leaving an opening opposite the piers of 350 feet
for an entrance. This plan would give about 80 per cent. additional har-
bor room, and would give as much protection to the original harbor as
the present plan. The increased cost would be proportionately small,
and the entire cost of the harbor of refuge thus enlarged would be about
the amount of the revised estimate for completion upon the present
plan, and nearly $500,000 less than the original estimate.
    This project was referred to a Board of Engineers, which in Septem-
ber, 1884, approved of the project in an amended form. The recommen-
dation of the Board having been finally approved, with slight modifi-
cation, the matter was made the subject of a special communication to
the House of Representatives in January, 1885. But owing to the fail-
ure of the river and harbor bill of 1885 no sanction was given by Con-
gress for the application of the remainder of the $100,000 appropriated
by act of July 5, 1884, towards the construction of the proposed east-
ern arm of the breakwater, and no work was practicable during the past
fiscal year.
    The remaining balance on hand July 1, 1885, when all outstanding
contracts were completed, was $1,135.29, too small a sum, to invite pro-
posals for continuing the breakwater; hence there has been no work
done during the fiscal year ending June 30,1886, for the extension of
the breakwater, the appropriation of July 5, 1884, being unavailable
for the proposed eastern extension of the breakwater, and no work will
be practicable until further legislation, thereby occasioning over two
and three-fourths years' delay in progress of the work.
    The amount expended for repairs to piers and breakwater, incidental
expenses, superintendence, &c., during the fiscal year was $14,133.43.
    Total appropriated for the harbor of refuge to July 1, 1886, is $900,-
000, of which sum $809,206.28 has been expended (to same date), less
about $34,000 expended in repairs to piers, dredging, &c., for Cleveland
harbor proper,
336        REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S ARMY.

  The river and harbor act of August 5, 1886, reads as follows as re-
lates to harbor at Cleveland, Ohio:
  Improving harbor at Cleveland, Ohio, on the last plan projected, $93,750, of which
$30,000 are to be used in building a parapet on the existing breakwater, and the
$100,000 now on hand to be available for work on the last plan.
  The above funds will be expended during the fiscal year ending June
30, 1887, in building parapet on the west breakwater and in constructing
about 1,200 linear feet of east breakwater on the approved plan.
July 1, 1885, amount available...... ...................................      $1, 135 29
July 1, 1885, amount partly unavailable ................................     100,000 00
                                                                             101, 125 29
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885................  ............................      14, 133 43

July 1, 1886, amount partly available...................................      87,001 86
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886....................        93, 750 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887....................    180,751 86
  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project ........  319,250 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year endingJune 30,1888 100, 000 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix K K 10.)
   11. FairportHarbor, mouth of Grand River, Ohio.--The present pro-
ject for the improvement of this harbor consists of parallel piers, 200
f'eet apart, running out into the lake. It was adopted in 1825, and has
been modified by prolonging the piers from time to time so as to give
increased depth, the object being to afford a channel of entrance of
navigable width and not less than 16 feet in depth. When the work of
improvement was commenced, in 1826, the mouth of the river was closed
by a sand-bar 1,200 feet wide, at times so hard and dry that teams could
be driven across.
   In 1829 the depth in the channel was about 8 feet, and in 1839, when
work was suspended, there was a depth of 11 feet, and any vessel then
navigating the lakes could enter at any time without danger.
   In 1865 the piers were found to be seriously dilapidated. In 1870
there was a depth of 12 feet in the channel. In 1879 this depth was
increased to 14 feet, in 1881 to 15 feet, and at the close of the fiscal
year ending June 30, 1886, there was a good channel between the piers
with least depth of 16 feet at low water, and in the lake beyond piers
with least depth of 15J feet at ordinary level of the lake.
   During the fiscal year the work in progress at beginning was com-
pleted by which the east pier was extended 80 feet, the superstructure
of the west pier repaired, and minor repairs made to both piers. The
dredging in spring of 1885 restored a good 16-foot channel between the
piers and a good 15k-foot channel through the bars in lake beyond end of
piers. The above work was under the appropriation of July 5, 1884.
   The sum of $6,087.32 was expended during the fiscal year.
   Extensive improvements as to docks and yards for receiving cargoes
of iron ore and shipping coal have been commenced at Fairport Harbor
by Pittsburgh capitalists. The gauge of the Painesville and Youngs-
town Railroad is being changed to standard gauge, and connections
made in the interest of the Baltimore and Ohio Railroad Company.
These changes will be completed during the summer of 1886, and it is
expected they will largely increase the busines of lhis harbor, The
                      RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                           337
extension of piers and repairs should be made at as early a day as pos-
sible.
  As the river and harbor act of August 5, 1886, appropriated $18,750
for this harbor, the work of improvement, in accordance with existing
project, will be continued during the fiscal year ending June 30,1887.
July 1, 1885, amount available ............----...   -..........----.         -------     $6, 087 32
July 1, 1886., amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885.-- ......
                               .         ..........-  ..---     .............       ..     6, 087 32
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1986---................                     18, 750 00

  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1888               20, 000 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix K K 11.)
   12. Ashtabula Harbor, Ohio.-The original project for the improve-
ment of this harbor was adopted in 1826. The rock bottom was then
found at 9 feet below the surface, and there was a depth of only 2 feet
of water on the bar at the entrance when operations were commenced.
   The project provided piers running out on either side of the mouth
of the river from shore to 12 feet water in the lake.
   The present project contemplates the extension of the piers out to 16
feet water, the removal of the decayed portions of both piers and re-
building with new material, at the same time straightening the line of
the west pier so as to afford a uniform width of 160 feet in the channel.
   Operations were commenced in 1826, and have been prosecuted with
more or less interruption and suspensions (no work was doner between
1839 and 1865), and have resulted in a much-improved harbor. At the
close of the year 1885 there was a good wide channel 151 to 16 feet
ldeep from the lake into the harbor.
   There has been appropriated a total of $372,401.21 up to the close of
the fiscal year ending June 30, 1886, all of which has been expended.
   During the fiscal year the balance of the old west pier was removed
for 400 linear feet shoreward to widen and straighten the channel; about
380 linear feet of this shore thus exposed was partially revetted with
timber revetment, all in accordance with existing project. There was a
good channel between the piers with 16 feet depth of water, except
where rock bottom occurs at less depth. The bar in lake at end of piers
gave considerable trouble to vessels this spring. The piers should be
extended at as early a day as possible, and dredging is needed imme-
diately. The exhaustion of the appropriations left this harbor in bad
condition, and the delay consequent thereon is both unfortunate and
expensive, and unless some work is possible this season much work
already begun will be swept away.
   Revised estimates give the sum of $50,250 as required to complete
the existing project, all of which amount can be profitably expended
during fiscal year ending June 30, 1888, in renewing piers, extending
piers, dredging, and rock excavation.
   The river and harbor act of August 5, 1886, appropriated $30,000 for
continuing the improvement of this harbor. It will be expended in rock
excavation, dredging, and repairs to piers.
July 1, 1885, amount available.............................................. $13, 962 40
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885 ...--...............
                                         -----....................-......     13,962 40
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886 ..................         30,000 00
                            22                                                                  ij
                                                                                         i _r-P~?'Xco
338         REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

 (Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project ........ $50, 000 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1888                           50,250 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix K K 12.)
   13. Conneaut Harbor, Ohio.-The original project for the improve-
ment of this harbor was adopted in 1829. Operations were carried on
during the years 1830 to 1832, and from 1836 to 1838, inclusive, which
consisted in the construction of piers 125 feet apart, running from shore
out to a depth of 12 feet of water in the lake, and in dredging. The
design was to afford a depth of 12 feet of water through the bar at the
mouth of Conneaut Creek, which bar was dry at low water, when work
was commenced.
   The improvements have been prosecuted at this harbor with more or
less interruptions and suspensions. No work was done from 1839 to
1844, from 1845 to 1852, from 1853 to 1866, and none for, the past four
years. The best channel ever obtained was 11 feet, and the more usual
depth has been 8 or 9 feet. The present depth of water on the bar is
less than 7 feet. Up to the close of the present fiscal year the sum of
$112,629.39 has been appropriated for this harbor, of which sum $112,-
629.39 has been expended. The present project for this improvement
contemplates rebuilding the east pier and renewing the superstructure
of the west pier, at an estimated cost of $35,090. The last appropria-
tion for this harbor was that of June 14, 1880, amounting to only $6,000.
   The commerce of the port has always been small.
July 1, 1885, amount available......----............-------......---......------......--.....----.        $6 11
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
                                                                     ....-.--...---........--......
  outstanding July 1, 1885---......---..........------.....----...------                                   6 11

SAmount (estimated) required for completion of existing project....  -35,090 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix K K 13.)
  14. Dunkirk Harbor, New York.-The existing project for theimprove-
ment of this harbor was adopted in 1870, the object being to form an
artificial harbor by constructing a breakwater 2,860 feet long and nearly
parallel with the shore, and by excavating a channel so as to afford a
depth of 13 feet into this harbor, the estimated cost of which was
$350,000.
   The breakwater construction has been carried out in part, 1,341 feet
having been completed at a cost of $98,000, and the channel has been
excavated to 13 feet in depth, but is quite narrow, besides presenting
the ragged edges of the unblasted rock, jutting out on either side, and
being exposed to wind and waves from any direction between north-
west around to northeast. It is therefore somewhat dangerous at times
for a vessel to make the entrance. In case any further extension of the
breakwater is deemed advisable the officer in charge recommends its
extension to the westward 560 feet, as contemplated in the original de-
sign, which would diminish in some degree the dangers of the entrance,
and at the same time create additional shelter within the harbor. A to-
tal of $459,079.38 has been appropriated, of which amount $459,044.11
has been expended to the close of the fiscal year ending June 30, 1886.
   The breakwater, if extended 560 feet to the westward, might also, with
benefit to the harbor, be extended 300 feet eastwardly, a total of 860
feet. It would then be 659 feet shorter than its original estimated
                          RIVER         AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                339
length. The cost of such extensions, with present prices of materials,
would be some $70 per linear foot, and would amount to $60,200.
  During the fiscal year work was in progress for about nine weeks in
dredging and repairs to east breakwater.
  The condition of the harbor is about the same as at the close of the
last fiscal year, as the destruction by storms and detonation counter-
balanced the small improvements made.
  The river and harbor act of August 5, 1886, appropriated $20,000
for this harbor, which amount will be expended during the fiscal year
ending June 30, 1886, in accordance with the existing project.
July 1, 1885, amount available....                                    .     . .'....                    .   $8, 467 40
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885 ..................................  ..........                                    8,432 13
July 1, 1886, amount available ...- --......------......----.......-------- ...--..----....----......           35 27
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886 ...................                                      20,000 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887 ..................                                    20,035 27

   Amount that can be profitably expendedinfiscalyearending June30,1888                                     20,000 00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
     harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
    (See Appendix K K 14.)
   15. Removing sunken vessels obstructing or endangering navigation.-
The wreck of a schooner loaded with stone that had sunk in the channel
between the piers at Fairport, Ohio, was, after due notice given to the
owners to remove it, removed by contract at a cost of $989, and the wreck
and cargo sold at auction. The proceeds of the sale, $55, were covered
into the Treasury.
   (See Appendix K K 15.)

IMPROVEMENT OF THE HARBORS OF ERIE, PENNSYLVANIA, AND BUF-
  FALO, NEW YORK, AND OF NIAGARA RIVER.-IMPROVEMENT     OF
  HARBORS ON LAKE ONTARIO.

   Officer in charge, Capt. Edward Maguire, Corps of Engineers.
   1. Erie Harbor,Pennsylvania.-The original survey of this harbor was
malde in 1819, at which time the channel was narrow and tortuous, with
a depth of only 6 feet. In 1823 a plan for the improvement was adopted,
and constitutes the present work at the entrance to the harbor, except-
ing some changes which have been required either on account of the age
of the structures originally built or other causes.
   The piers have been extended from time to time, and are now in good
condition. "
   The present project contemplated the extension of the pier to the 16-
foot curve in the lake, and the maintenance of a channel of navigable
width and 16 feet in depth from the harbor inside to the lake outside.
   The officer in charge is of the opinion that, on account of the rapid
current which flows in and out through the channel, the north pier should
not be extended, but that, owing to the increasing shoaling which has
already taken place, the south pier should be extended 400 feet. He
recommends that the neck of the peninsula be protected by a break-
water, and that the movement of sand around the eastern end of the
peninsula, and which threatens to close the harbor entrance, be arrested
by the construction of jetties perpendicular to the shore of the penin-
sula. The estimated cost of the work is $173,044.50.
340        REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

   If the present project of pier extension alone be carried out, the
amount required will be $84,120.
   Operations have been prosecuted with more or less interruptions and
suspensions (no work was done from 1838 to 1842, from 1.846 to 1853.
and from 1855 to 1864), and have resulted in much benefit to the harbor
and its channel entrance. The work during the fiscal year consisted of
minor repairs to the piers.
   To carry out the recommendation of the Board of Engineers of June
14, 1882, $10,000 of the amount available for the harbor are set aside to
provide for the prompt construction of a dike at the neck of the penin-
sula in case of necessity.
   The total amount appropriated for this harbor up to June 30, 1886,
is $731,367.23, of which $673,202.75 have been expended.
July 1, 1885, amount available.             -.    ....           ...........                                  $59, 130 86
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1885 ........................                                     $966 38
July 1, 1886, outstanding liabilities...... ....................                                     135 25
                                                                                                          -     1,101 63

July 1, 1886, amount available...................... .. ...... .... .... ....                                  58, 029 23
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5,'1886....................                                         37, 500 00

Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887...................                                       95,529 23
   Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project-------- 46,620 00
   Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1888 46, 620 00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix L L 1.)
   2. Buffalo Harbor, New York.-The original project for the improve-
ment of this harbor was adopted in 1826, the date of the first appropria-
tion, and, as modified at various times, provided for the construction of
a north and south pier at the mouth of Buffalo Creek, a masonry sea-
wall running south from the inner end of the south pier, and a break-
water less than half a mile in front of the Buffalo light-house, its long
arm extending nearly parallel with the shore. The present project was
adopted in 1874, and provides for the construction of a breakwater of
crib-work 7,600 feet long, running parallel to the shore, and a shore-arm
of pile and crib-work 4,100 feet long, running out towards the southern
end of the main or detached breakwater, leaving an opening of about
150 feet between them.
   The total amount appropriated for this harbor up to June 30, 1886, was
$1,761,880.41, of which $1,684,424.67 have been expended, resulting in
the construction of the north and south piers, the sea-wall, 870 linear
feet of pile-pier, and 6,349.8 linear feet of main breakwater.
   The northern portion of the main breakwater is very much in need of
repairs.
   The appropriation asked for is to be applied to extension and repair
of the breakwater.
July 1, 1885, amount available ............--..........................------. $59,453 94
July 1, 18 6, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive
  of liabilities outstanding July 1, 1885.........- ...                         ..-      -   $50, 123 74
July 1, 1886, outstanding liabilities. .......           ............             ....            122 53
                                                                                                      -        50, 246 27

July 1, 1886, amount available .......................                         ................                 9, 207 67
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886...--...............                                        112,500 00

Amowat availble for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887 ..- ,..                                 ....... ....     121,707 67
                          RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                          341
  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project-.... $1,117,500 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June
    30, 1888..---.....---..--...------.....--............------..----....--.......-----..-......----..       250,000 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
    harbor acts of. 1866 and 1867.
  (See Appendix L L 2.)
  3. NiagaraRiver, New York.-The project for this improvement was
adopted in 1881, the object being the removal, by dredging, of the bars
and removal of the submerged rocks in the channel in the neighborhood
of Tonawanda Island.
  The total amount appropriated for this work was $6,500, of which
$5,912.48 have been expended, resulting in the formation of a channel
of navigable width and a depth of 13 feet at low water. The natural
channel was from 13 to 16 feet in depth, but narrowed by bars and
rocks. All the work contemplated in this part of the river has been
done.
July 1,1885, amount available............................                ...........                            $587 52
July 1, 1886, amount available ......................................................                            587 52
  (See Appendix L L 3.)
  4. Wilson Harbor, New York.-The project for the improvement of
this harbor was adopted in 1873 and modified in 1877, the object being
to afford a channel of navigable width and 12 feet in depth by the ex-
tension of the parallel piers, from the mouth of Twelve-Mile Creek to
the 12-foot curve in the lake, with the formation of a protected channel
between the piers. The mouth of the creek was originally obstructed
by a bar, upon which there was a depth of about 1 foot.
  Before the commencement of operations by the United States, the
pier had been carried about 400 feet into the lake byf)rivate enterprise.
  The existing channel between the piers has a depth of about 8 feet
for a narrow width, while the depth of the inner harbor is even less.
  The funds available for this harbor were practically exhausted dur-
ing the fiscal year ending June 30, 1884, and no appropriation having
been made by the act of July 5, 1884, no work has been done during
the present fiscal year.
  The amount expended to June 30, 1886, is $49,967.71, and has re-
sulted in the extension of the piers to the 8-foot curve in the lake.
  Any further appropriations will be applied to pier extension and
maintenance, and such dredging as may be necessary.
July 1, 1885, amount available ........................................... $40 40
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885.. ...  ................. .....    ... ... ......                                        8 11
July 1, 1886, amount available -------------................................... ...                                32 29
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886...................                                         10, 000 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887....................                                     10, 032 29
  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project--------........
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
                                                                                                   30,1888    40,000 00
                                                                                                              10,000 00
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
  (See Appendix L L 4.)
  5. Olcott Harbor,New York.-The project for the improvement of this
harbor was adopted in 1866, the date of the first appropriation, and pro-
posed to connect the deep water in the lake with the deep water in
Eighteen-Mile Creek by the extension of two parallel piers from the
mouth of the creek to the 11-foot curve in the lake with the formation
342        REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

of a dredged channel between the piers. The project was modified in
1874 and 1881 to provide for the removal of ruck found to exist in the
channel between the piers, and for additional pier extension. The nat-
ural channel between the mouth of the creek and the lake was obstructed
by a bar upon which there was a depth of about 1 feet.
  The last appropriation for this harbor was made March 4, 1881, and
was expended in the construction of a shore-arm to the west pier. No
work has been done during the present fiscal year.
  The amount expended to June 30, 1885, is $118,000 and has resulted
in the extension of the piers to about the 9-foot curve in the lake and
the formation between the piers of a channel of navigable width, with
a depth of about 74 feet at low water.
  Any further appropriation will be applied to pier extension and main-
tenance, and such dredging as may be necessary.
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886-------          10,000 00
                                                       ..................----.

    Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project---....----....         20,000 00
    SAmount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year endingJune 30, 1888            10,000 00
    Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
      harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix L L 5.)
  6. Oak OrchardHarbor, New York.-The earliest project for the im-
provement of this harbor was adopted in 1836, the date of the first ap-
propriation, and proposed the construction of an east and west break-
water, approaching to within 200 feet of each other, and connecting at
this opening with parallel piers extending into the lake.
   Subsequent modifications were extensions of the original project to
provide for rock rynoval, and to adjust it to the increased demands of
commerce. The present project was adopted in 1881, the object being
to extend the piers to the 12-foot curve in the lake, with the formation
of a channel of navigable width and 12 feet depth between the piers at
low water. The natural channel of entrance into Oak Orchard Creek
was narrow, with a depth of from 2 to 4 feet.
  The total amount expended from 1836 to June 30, 1885, is $181,405.19,
and has resulted in extending the piers to the 9-foot curve in the lake,
securing a protected channel of navigable width and a depth of 9 feet
at low water.
  The amount expended since the adoption of the present project in
1881 is $7,905.19. No work was done during the year.
   The appropriation asked for is to be applied to pier extension and
maintenance, and such dredging as may be necessary.
July 1, 1885, amount available ........................................                    $222 47
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885 ............................                 ...............      127 66
July 1, 1886, amount available .........................................   94 81
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886 ................... 12,500 00
Amount avilable for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887 ............            ........     12,594 81
(Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project--------........           79, 500 00
    Amount that canbeprofitablyexpendedin fiscal year ending June 30, 1888                12, 000 00
    Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
l     harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix L L 6.)
   7. Charlotte Harbor, New York.-The earliest project for the improve
ment of this harbor was adopted in 1828, the date of the first appropria-
tion, and proposed to connect the deep water in the Genesee River with
                     RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                           343
the deep water in the lake 1y parallel piers about 360 feet apart. The
subsequent modifications were extensions of the original project, so as
to adjust it to the demands of commerce.
  The present project was adopted in 1881, the object being to extend
the piers to the 15-foot curve in the lake, with the formation by dredg-
ing of a channel, between the piers, of a navigable width and 15 feet in
depth at low water.
  The natural channel over the bar was tortuous, and in calm weather
would admit, at ordinary stage of the lake, vessels drawing 8 feet.
  The total amount expended from 1828 to June 30, 1886, is $370,200.92.
The amount expended from the adoption of the present project in 1881
to June 30, 1886, is $52,122.52.
  The total expenditure has resulted in extending the piers to the 13-
foot curve in the lake, securing a channel between the piers of navigable
width, and of not less than 12 feet in depth at low water.
  The appropriation asked for is to be applied to pier extension and
maintenance, and such dredging as may be necessary.
                                               -
                                   ----....---..-
July 1, 1885, amount available ......-            --......-..-- ....--.. $19, 554 55
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1885..--..---....--          ...       . $16, 677 07
July 1, 1886, outstanding liabilities.       --...........--..       -          272 00
                                                                                         16,949 07
July 1, 1886, amount available........--. -----......... .... --..............-- .        2, 605 48
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886...................         .          24, 250 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887 ...................                28, 855 48
SAmount    (estimated) required for completion of existing project...
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1i88
                                                                             -    . - $72, 750 00
                                                                                         25, 000 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix L L 7.)
   8. Pultneyville Harbor, New York.-The project for the improvement
of this harbor was adopted in 1870, the date of the first appropriation,
and proposed the construction of a breakwater running easterly from
the west shore, and thence northerly into the lake, with an east pier
parallel to, and about 200 feet from, the northerly arm of the west break-
water.
   The project was modified in 1875 to provide for increased dredging.
The object of the improvement was to provide a channel of navigable
width and not less than 10 feet depth. The natural channel was not
more than 2 feet in depth.
   The total amount expended to June 30, 1886, is $73,997.10, and has
resulted in the extension of the piers to the 10-foot curve in the lake.
The shoaling between the piers has reduced the available depth of chan-
nel to about 7 feet, while the channel along the shore-arm of the west
pier has shoaled so as to leave an available depth of from 4 to 7 feet.
If it be desired to continue the improvement of this harbor so as to give
an available depth of 10 feet at low water, it will be necessary to ex-
clude the sand by means of a construction cutting off the shallow area
at the south end of the harbor and then redredging the channel between
the piers and along the shore-arm of the west pier, at an estimated cost
of $30,000.
   Should it be found to be necessary to extend the piers to the 12-foot
curve in the lake in order to maintain a 10-foot channel, the cost of such
extension would be about $50,000.
   The appropriation of $4,000, August 2, 1882, completed the estimated
amount required for the completion of the existing project.
344          REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

July 1, 1885, amount available ..........................................                    $177 90
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885..............................................                       175 00
July 1, 1886, amount available ...............................----..........--.                  2 90
   (See Appendix L L 8.)
   9. Great Sodus Harbor, New York.-The earliest project for the im-
provement of this harbor was adopted in 1828; the first appropriation
was made in 1829. The original project proposed the construction of
two breakwaters, from the east and west shores, approaching to within
500 feet of each other, and connecting at this opening with parallel piers
extending into the lake.
   Subsequent modifications were extensions of the original project to
adjust it to the increased demands of commerce. The present project
was adopted in 1881, the object being to extend the piers to the 15-foot
curve in the lake, and dredging a channel between the piers 15 feet deep
at low water.
   The natural channel would admit vessels drawing 8 feet at ordinary
lake stage.
   The total amount expended from 1829 to June 30, 1886, is $395,129.36.
The amount expended from the adoption of the present project in 1881
to June 30, 1886, is $33,357.56.
   The total expenditure has resulted in the extension of the west pier
to the 14-foot curve in the lake, the extension of the east pier to the
9-foot curve in the lake, with a channel of navigable width, and 10 feet
depth at low water between them.
    The appropriation asked for is to be applied to pier extension and
maintenance, and such dredging as may be necessary.
July 1, 1885, amount available .........................................---.                $6, 770 14
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885..............................           ..........                5, 130 70
July 1, 1886, amount available ............ . -..... ............                    ....    1,639 44
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886..------........                ......
                                                                                  --   -    16, 875 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887... ...... ...... ....                 18, 514 44
                                                                   ....
   Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project----                       48,000 00
   Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1888                24, 000 00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
  (See Appendix L L 9.)
  10. Little Sodus Harbor, New York.-The earliest project for the im-
provement of this harbor was adopted in 1829 and has since been vari-
ously modified.
  The first appropriation was made in 1852.
  The early project proposed the partial closing of the opening between
the bay and the lake by lateral dikes connected with two parallel piers
extending into the lake. The present project, which is an expansion of
the earlier ones, was adopted in 1881, and is designed to afford a channel
of navigable width of not less than 15 feet depth at low water.
  The total amount expended from the date of the first appropriation
in 1852 to June 30, 1886, is $267,023.49. The amount expended from
the adoption of the present project in 1881 to June 30, 1886, is $32,581.72.
   The total expenditure has resulted in the extension of the piers to
the 12-foot curve in the lake, securing a channel between the piers of
navigable width and 14 feet in depth, with a channel through the outer
bar 12 to 14 feet deep at low water.
                     RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                          345
The appropriation asked for is to be applied to the extension and
maintenance of the piers and such dredging as may be necessary to
maintain a channel through the outer bar.
July 1, 1885, amount available ..........-... ........      ........ ....    ........   $8, 963 88
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885.--.... ......     ..... .... ...........----..... ..--        6,545 60
July 1, 1886, amount available.-...... .......... .... ...... ....... ....--- .          2,418 28
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886-.... ......-         ......          12, 500 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887- .................                14,918 28

rAmount (estimated) required for completion of existing project .......                32,500 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1888             16, 000 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix L L 10.)
   11. Oswego Harbor, New York.-The earliest project for the improve-
ment of this harbor was adopted in 1827, and proposed to inclose an
area at the mouth of the river by extending jetties from the shore into
the lake, joining the outer ends by a breakwater, but leaving an open-
ing through which to enter the harbor.
   The project was completed in 1869 and forms the present inner harbor.
The present project was adopted in 1870, and consists of a breakwater,
5,800 feet in length, parallel to the old west breakwater, and 1,100 feet
in advance of it. The estimated cost was $1,161,682. It was modified
in 1879, 1880, 1882, and 1883, by the proposed construction of an east
breakwater 2,700 feet in length, the reduction of 350 feet of the open-
ing between the east end of the west breakwater and the north end of
the light-house pier, the use of creosoted timber in repairs to the old
breakwater, the construction of spurs along the face of the outer west
breakwater to reduce the effect of accumulated seas, and for deepening
by dredging the inner harbor at the mouth of the Oswego River.
   The object of these improvements was to give protection to the city
docks and wharves, and to the commerce of the harbor and lake a
depth suitable for the heaviest draught vessel on the lakes. The natural
entrance to the mouth of the river was shallow and difficult of access.
   The total amount expended from the date of the first appropriation
in 1826 to June 30, 1886, is $1,564,158.20.   The amount expended from
the adoption of the present project in 1870 to June 30, 1886, is $1,090,-
795.33,
   The total expenditure has resulted in the completion of the originally
projected harbor, the completion of the west breakwater with the re-
duction of 350 feet of the opening between the east end of the west
breakwater and the north end of the light-house pier, the construction
of 213 linear feet of the east breakwater, the completion of one spur-
crib, and the deepening of the river mouth to a depth of 15 feet at low
water, securing full protection to the docks and wharves west of the
river mouth and channels of entrance, 16 feet deep and 350 feet wide
each, to the inner and outer harbors and 15 feet deep at low water.
Early in December, 1884, a severe northwest storm caused a breach in
the west breakwater 145 feet in width, and necessitating repairs for a
length of 100 feet each side of the breach. This portion of the break-
water has been repeatedly breached, and in the opinion of the officer
in charge the remaining old work should be entirely removed and re-
built in a stronger manner, at an estimated cost of $80,000. The appro-
priation asked for includes the cost of repair of the breach and $70,G682,
346         REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

the balance of the original estimate, and is to be applied to repairs and
the extension of the breakwater.
   The officer in charge reports that the old west breakwater of the inner
harbor is in a very dilapidated condition and should be repaired, in order
to prevent it from becoming all obstruction to the harbor. It has been
transferred to the Light-House Department under authority of the Sec-
retary of War.
July 1, 1885, amount available..........-...............- ------                .   ---.... $1,772 76
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1885-------....---.----......--------....--..... $1,568 09
July 1, 1886, outstanding liabilities ......        ................                   90 00
                                                                                             1,658 09
                                                   ----...---..
July 1, 1886, amount available ......................--               -..............     114 67
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5,1886 ...................                 71, 250 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887 ....................                71,364 67

 (Amount      (estimated) required for completion of existing project, and
I  repairs ...........--.........             ----.............. ............
                                   -----..........--                           79,612 00
( Amount that can be profitably expended infiscalyear ending June 30, 1888 80, 000 00
I Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
 ( harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix L L 11.)
   12. Sackett's Harbor, New York.-The project for the improvement of
this harbor was adopted in 1881, and proposed the deepening of the har-
bor over an area of about 15 acres to a depth of 12 feet at low water.
The depth previously existing was less than S feet over a large part of
its area.
   In 1826 and 1828 the sum of $6,000 was expended in clearing and
deepening the harbor.
   The total amount expended from 1826 to June 30, 1886, is $12,740.18.
The amount expended from the adoption of the present project to June
30, 1886, is $6,740.18, and has resulted in the removal of 24,010 cubic
yards of sand, mud, and gravel. With the completion of that work the
harbor had a depth of 12 feet at low water over about 6 acres of its area,
except a small part thereof where the presence of rock in place limited
the depth to a little less than 12 feet.
   No work was done during the year.
   To protect the harbor from the shore-drift around Ship-House Point
the officer in charge recommends the construction of low jetties, and to
this work it is proposed to apply the appropriation asked for.
July 1, 1885, amount available .....................--..                                 $72 11
                                                                      --..........----....
July 1, 1886, amount available ................--.                 ---....--....-- .
                                                      ----....--......--                   72 11


     Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1888            2, 000 00
     Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
      harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
     (See Appendix L L 12.)
IMPROVEMENT OF OGDENSBURG HARBOR ON THE RIVER SAINT LAW-
  RENCE; OF HARBORS ON LAKE CHAMPLAIN, AND OF GRASS AND
  TICONDEROGA RIVERS, NEW YORK, AND OF OTTER CREEK, VERMONT.

  Officer in charge, Maj. Milton B. Adams, Corps of Engineers.
  1. Ogdensburg Harbor, New York.-The present project for the im-
provement of this harbor, which was adopted in 1882, contemplates the
                        RIVER AND HARBOR                    IMPROVEMENTS.                                    347
leepening of the channels along the city front and in prolongation of
,he lower reach of the Oswegatchie to deep water in the Saint Lawrence
River, so as to afford a depth of 15 feet in the channels and 16 feet on
;he outer bar at extreme low water.
  When operations were first commenced at this harbor the channels
Ifforded depths of 5 to 12 feet only, and now there are two good chan-
iels  from deep water in the Saint Lawrence to the nearest docks or
wharves, in which water from 15 to 16 feet deep is afforded, and a chan-
iel 12 feet deep and 150 feet wide has been effected along the entire
3ity front as the result of the work done by the Government.
  The total amount expended from the date of the first appropriation
n 1852 to June 30, 1886, has been $136,406.97, and from the adoption of
bhe present project $26,406.97 have been expended.
  The officer now in charge calls attention to a probable necessary in-
3rease in the estimate for the improvement under the existing project,
)wing to the material encountered in gaining increased depths being
harder than was expected, which makes the cost double that of the es-
imate in some portions of the channels. Be recommends that the esti-
mated cost be placed at $108,000, on this account, and suggests a modi-
tcation of the present project at a total estimated cost of $48,400.
  The sum asked for this improvement is to be applied to dredging
)perations. Should it be thought best to discontinue the dredging
within the harbor, after carrying the improved channels from deep water
n the Saint Lawrence Riiver to the vicinity of the docks and wharves
which are nearest to the upper and lower entrances, then $23,400 will
be sufficient to complete the work.
July 1, 1885, amount available......................................                                     $4,375 47
Tuly 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
outstanding July 1, 1885 .......               ......................................                   4,101 57
July 1, 1886, amount available...........                   ... _......   ..........-........               273 90
kmount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886 ...................                                   10,000 00
kmount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887--..........--                        ...... ....   10, 273 90
  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project .......
                                                                    - - .                                73, 000 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1888                              15,000 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix M M 1.)
   2. Grass River (at Massena), New York.-The project for the improve-
ment of this river was adopted in 1881, and has for its object the forma-
;ion of a channel with a least depth of 4 feet and a least width of 40 feet
rom the Saint Lawrence River to the village of Massena, a distance of
Ibout 7J miles by water. The natural depth of the shoal places is some
3feet.
   Proposals were invited by advertisement in 1883, and in response but
)ne bid was received, which indicated that the funds available were only
sufficient to remove one-fourth the amount of obstructing material at
)ne  of the shoal places, and that the original estimate should have been
X17,600, on the basis of $12,000 for the first item, and 10 per cent. added
;o the whole for contingencies.
   Additional appropriation, if made, will be applied, together with the
kunds available, in deepening the channel by dredging.
Fuly 1, 1885, amount available_        .......... ...........              .....................         $2, 948 60
iuly 1, 1886, amount available.... .......................................                                2, 948 60
348        REPORT OF-THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

SAmount (estimated) required for completion of existing project........ $17,600 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
    (See Appendix M M 2.)
    3. Breakwater at Rouse's Point, Lake Champlain, New York.-The pro-
ject for this improvement was adopted in 1885, and contemplates the
construction of a breakwater composed of rubble and large stone on a
straight line extending from Stony Point in the general direction of
the southern point of the 6-foot curve south of Windmill Point, until
the 18-foot curve is reached, a total distance of about 2,000 feet.
    The estimated cost of the breakwater is placed at $110,000.
    Under a contract dated August 22, 1885, work was commenced on the
breakwater September 1, since which time operations have progressed
satisfactorily. This contract should be completed, according to its
terms, by November 30, 1886, and comprises the construction of 800
linear feet, the shore section of the breakwater.
July 1, 1885, amount available.......                   ....
                                                ..........                ......    ......    $33, 978 17
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1885...............           .........        $7, 590   71
July 1, 1886, outstanding liabilities.... .....................                   2, 176 19
                                                                                                9, 766 90
July 1, 1886, amount available..............--
                                       -.....-..--...                             ......
                                                                               _.....        24,211 27
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5,1886                                   20,000 00
                                                                    ............--.......---.
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887.......                  ......   ...   44, 211 27
  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project........ 90, 000 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1888 30, 000 00
  Submitted in compliance'with requirements of section 2 of river and
     harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix M M 3.)
  4. Swanton Harbor, Vermont.-The project for the improvement of
this harbor was adopted in 1873, and had for its object the protection
of anticipated docks and wharves by the construction of a breakwater
in front of the place it was thought would be selected as their location.
   The amount expended to June 30,1886, is $70,188.07, and has resulted
in the construction of the existing breakwater. Its site was necessarily
selected before the docks there now were located, and the existing slight
shipping facilities have unfortunately been located so that very little if
any protection is received from it.
   In the event of the general plan for the improvement of this harbor,
as recommended after the examination and survey of 1884, being car-
ried out, the officer now in charge recommends that such new work be
placed about 200 feet further from shore than was favored by his pre-
decessor two years ago ; and, instead of curving in and joining the shore,
he recommends the construction of two sections of breakwater, the one
prolonging the present structure nearer to shore, the other starting at a
point 200 feet north of the outer end of the present structure, to be ex-
tended on a line about parallel with the shore until directly west of the
most northerly portion of the shipping in the harbor.
July 1, 1885, amount available ...................................................              $326 93
July 1, 1886, amount available...........      ..................        ..........              326 93
  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project........ 169,500 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
  (See Appendix M M 4.)
  5. PlattsburgHarbor,New York.-The first project for the improvement
of this harbor was adopted probably in 1836, the date of the first ap-
                       RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                   349
propriation for it. That project and the modification of it, adopted and
completed, have resulted in the construction of 1,250 feet of breakwater,
the protection of a portion of the beach, and the dredging of shoal areas
within the harbor.
   The last modification, made in 1870, proposed the extension of the
structure to the southeast, the protection of the adjacent beach by re-
vetment and.dredging. If, however, the plan of improving the mouth of
Saranac River, Plattsburg, N. Y., as explained in the Annual Report for
1885, page 2319, should be carried out, it would constitute a further
modification, by the enlargement of the area of dredging operations at
this harbor.
   Operations have been confined to dredging and repairs since 1875.
   During the season of 1884 there were 3,022 cubic yards of material
removed from shoal places near the docks, in order to afford sufficient
depths for the steamboats frequenting the harbor, which consumed the
available funds.
   Some repairs to the breakwater and additional dredging are required.
   The total amount expended to June 30, 1886, has been $138,411.94 of
which amount $52,911.94 were expended since the adoption of the modi-
fied project in 1870.
   The appropriation asked for is to be applied in dredging operations
and repairs to the existing structure.
July 1, 1885, amount available .........................      . ........     ....      $88 06
July 1, 1886, amount available  ....
                                  ....-......--.....
                                                   -..... -....-..-...
                                                                     .    88 06
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886-- --.....
                                                           ..........  5,000 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887 ....................           5, 088 o6
  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project .......             7,000 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal yearending June 30, 1888          7, 000 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix M M 5.)
   6. Burlington Harbor, Vermont.-The improvement of this harbor
dates from 1836. Modifications of the original plan have occurred from
time to time, so as to afford adequate protection to the increase of the
commercial and shipping interests at the harbor.
   The officer now in charge has submitted a plan for the further ex-
tension of the breakwater, both to the north and to the south, which
awaits consideration before action can be taken on it.
   Operations (luring the past year have been confined to repairs to the
existing structure by the renewal of old and decayed portions of the
superstructure, which were liable to become breached, and by raising
it for 300 feet at the northern end, so as to be above high-water level.
   The total amount expended to date is $479,969.89.
   As additional funds become available they will be applied in further
extensions of the breakwater, so as to keep pace with the growth of
the commerce and the extension of the line of docks and wharves, and
in repairing such old portions of the existing structure as may from
time to time require it.
July 1, 1885, amount available ......--..........--......................  $11,302 00
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885 .----.....---............................-- ... 8, 099 69
July 1, 1886, amount available...............................................        3,202 31
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886 ...........             ....     18, 750 00

Amount    available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887 ,,,.,. .,.......... .21,952       31
{Amount
350       REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

            (estimated) required for completion of existing project ....... $185, 250 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1888
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
                                                                                             50, 000 00
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
  (See Appendix M M 6.)
  7. Otter Creek, Vermont.--The project for this improvement was adopted
in 1872, and, as modified in 1882 and 1884, proposes the formation of a
channel of navigable width and a least depth of 8 feet from Vergennes,
Vt., to Lake Champlain.
  No operations have been carried on since the improvement of Bull
Brook Bend and vicinity, in 1884, whereby this obstruction, which had
been most serious as it previously existed, was entirely removed, so as
to afford a good channel 75 feet wide and 8 feet deep at low water.
  There have been expended to June 30, 1886, $33,351.66.
  Steamboat Landing, Sharkie's and Crittenden's Bends, and the mouth,
should all be improved by widening and deepening the channels in
order to carry out the scheme of improvement.
July 1, 1885, amount available ..............    ..........          ............     ....     $648 34
July 1, 1886, amount available .............      ..........................                    648 34
(Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project---....----.... 39, 748 00
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1888     5, 000 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
   barbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
  (See Appendix M M 7.)
   8. ficonderoga River, New York.--The project for this improvement
was adopted in 1881, its object being to afford a channel of navigable
width and a least depth of 8 feet at low water from Ticonderoga Village
to Lake Champlain, a distance of about 2 miles.
   The original estimated cost of this improvement was $42,516, of which
amount $10,000 have been appropriated and expended, and have resulted
in an improved channel which is now 60 feet wide, except the upper
2,000 feet, only 30 feet wide, and affords a least depth of 6 feet.
   To complete the scheme of improvement, this channel should be
widened in its upper reach to 60 feet, and should be generally deepened.
   The principal industry subserved by this improvement is the manu-
facture of pulp and paper from wood fiber, which requires the annual
transportation of about 2,000 tons of coal and 10,000 cords of wood.
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886 .............                    ......   $2,000 00
SAmount    (estimated) required for completion of existing project .......
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1888
                                                                                             30,516 00
                                                                                              5, 000 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
  (See Appendix M M 8.)

                                 PACIFIC        COAST.

IMPROVEMENT OF THE HARBORS OF OAKLAND, WILMINGTON, AND RED-
                     WOOD, CALIFORNIA.

Officer in charge, Lieut. Col. G. H. Mendell, Corps of Engineers.
1. Oakland Harbor,California.-Theproject for this improvement was
made in 1874, when there was about 2 feet at low water on the bar. It
is intended to secure a ship-channel 18 to 20 feet deep at low water by
jetties, dredging, and the introduction of tidal water of San Leandro
                     RIVER AND          HARBOR       IMPROVEMENTS.                         351
Ba,y. The developments of commerce following partial improvement
have required some modifications of the original project, particularly in
dredging the existing ship-channel. The jetties have also been brought
above high-water mark, in order to keep out sand and to do away with
cross-currents. The present maximum depth of ship-channel is 18 feet
at high water, while the width varies from 100 to 300 feet.
  The amount appropriated since 1874 is $934,600, and the amount ex-
pended $870,464.53.
  The contract of October 4, 1884, in force at the beginning of the year,
for dredging the tidal basin and depositing the spoil ashore behind em-
bankments, was completed May 19. The amount for the year was
698,312 cubic yards, and for the contract 728,359 cubic yards. The
year's operations increased the channel flow per second more than 400
cubic feet, which ismore than 6 per cent. of the original flow.
  The condition of the channels and jetties remains practically the same
as at the beginning of the year. The narrow ship-channel in front of
Oakland is buoyed, making navigation convenient.
  The appropriation asked is to be applied to further increase of tidal
prism as originally projected either by dredging the tidal basin or by
beginning the excavation of the San Leandro Canal, or both, in case
the amount granted is adequate.
  The completion of mansonry remaining unfinished on the south jetty
and some filling on the north slope of the north jetty are also to be un,
dertaken under the next appropriation.
July 1, 1885, amount available .. .....
                                     .           ..........
                                                         ......       .......     .$99,
                                                                                  ..      311 33
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive
  of liabilities outstanding July 1, 1885 ..--...--....-------------............
                                                                 $95,175 86
July 1, 1886, outstanding liabilities............ ..............       5 76
                                                                                      95,181 62

July 1, 1886, amount available........................ .......           ...........    4,129 71
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886-..--..............--------------... 60, 000 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887 ..............------------------.
                                                                      64,129 71

 (Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project-........ 879,929 20
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1888 250, 000 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix N N 1.)
   2. Wilmington Harbor, California.--The present project is intended to
secure 14 to 16 feet depth at low water. The present low-water depth
is 10 feet. Before the improvement was begun there was practically no
navigation, the low water being only 1 foot. Vessels drawing 15 feet
can now enter the harbor at high water. The greater part of the coast-
ing trade of the port is now done in the harbor. Increase of depth is
to be attained by dredging and by enlarging and extending the jetties,
which operations need to be carried on together.
   The operations of the past year consisted in completing the dike 600
feet in length, built for the purpose of protecting the southern end of
Rattlesnake Island, and in completing the stone-work of the east jetty.
The contract for stone in force at the beginning of the year was com
pleted October 31, including a total delivery of 17,295 tons, of which
12,011 were delivered during the present year. The dike required 5,610
tons of stone. Its action has been favorable in collecting large depos-
its of sand at the southern end of the island. The main east jetty is
now all above the level of high-water. The depth and dimension,- of
352       REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

the interior channels have been slightly increased during the year, while
the depth at the entrance has remained practically unchanged.
   The application of future appropriations will be in dredging and in
extending and raising the west jetty and contingencies.
   The total amount appropriated for this harbor is $780,000, and the
amount expended $703,519.40. The amount appropriated for the en-
larged project is $150,000 and the amount expended $148,519.40.
July 1, 1885, amount available...........................   ......   ...... $40,166 85
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1885......................... $38, 686 25
July 1, 1886, outstanding liabilities...                   .........                   85 00
                                                                                               38,771 25

July 1, 1886, amount available............ .............................                        1,395 60
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886.....----------.....-..-------. 75, 000 00
Amount available for fiscal year-ending June 30, 1887 ...................                      76,395 60
SAmount (estimated)profitably
                     required for completion of existing project........ 175,000 00
                               expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1888 100, 000 00
  Amount that can be
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix N N 2.)
   3. Redwood Harbor,California.-The improvement of this harbor has
.not been begun, the appropriation of $3,000 in the act of July 5, 1884,
being regarded as insufficient for purpose of making a contract.
   The character of the contemplated improvement is to dredge a narrow
channel about 1 mile long in the bed of Redwood Slough to a depth of
3 feet, so as to give 7 feet at high water. This depth will fairly accom-
modate the small vessels which carry on commerce with San Francisco
and other towns on the bay. It is intended to apply the money already
appropriated and that asked for to contracts for dredging.
   The trade to be accommodated is local, taking in a fertile belt of
country adjoining Redwood City, the amount of which trade in 1882
was in excess of $1,000,000.
July 1, 1885, amount available .........................                   ........... ....    $3, 000 00
July 1, 1886, amount available ................. .......................                        3,000 00
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886 .....................                        5,000 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887 ......                  .............     8, 009 00
  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project ...... ..                      7, 4(0 00
  Amountthat can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1888                      7, 400 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix N N 3.)
  4. Removal of sunken vessels or craft obstructing or endangeringnavi-
gation.--An examination of the wreck Escambia, made in April and
May, 1886, discovered the fact that there is but 4J fathoms of water
over pqrtions, and that the wreck has been much broken by the sea and
the fragments displaced. The last examination gave 5 fathoms, which
is the general depth in the channel. With this depth over it the wreck
was not considered to be a danger. The present condition is, however,
a danger to vessels.
   A contract was made, after advertisement, on June 29 for the re-
moval of the boilers and of such other portions of the wreck as promise
to be dangerous. It is expected that the removal will be effected dur-
ing the present summer,
                       RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                          353
   The Escambia is an iron ship which foundered on San Francisco Bar
in the fairway channel on June 19, 1882.
   (See Appendix N N 4.)

      IMPROVEMENT OF THE HARBOR                             OF SAN     DIEGO, CALIFORNIA.

    Officer in charge, Col. C. S. Stewart, Corps of Engineers.
    The object of the improvement is to prevent this harbor from being
the place of deposit of the materials brought down by the San Diego
River during floods.
    In 1875 a project was formed to turn the river back into one of its
former outlets in the False Bay. This was carried into effect in 1876.
From a point in the river-bed near Presidio Hill a new water-way was
cut across the plain to a slough from False Bay. The old channel was
closed. A levee faced with stone and extending from high land to high
land was built along the artificial cut and between it and the harbor of
San Diego, to restrain the river overflow in floods.
    The improvement has thus far been a success.
   The injuries to the levee from all causes has been so slight during the
year that no repairs to it have been made. It is in fair order.
   The sum of 95 cents has been expended in the fiscal year.
   The total expenditure from the beginning of the improvement, to in-
clude June 30, 1886, amounts to $80,451.45.
   The money still available from the appropriation for repairs made in
*1879 will probably suffice for several years.
July 1, 1885, amount available......----- --..----............ ............--......         $549 50
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885 --.......----.....-------........---..--...................          95
July 1, 1886, amount available~...           ...   ......     ......    .................    548 55
   (See Appendix O 0.)

IMPROVEMENT OF ENTRANCE TO HUMBOLDT BAY; OF SAN JOAQUIN,
   MOKELUMNE, SACRAMENTO, AND FEATHER RIVERS, CALIFORNIA;
   AND OF COLORADO RIVER, NEVADA, CALIFORNIA, AND ARIZONA.

   Officer in charge, Capt. A. H. Payson, Corps of Engineers. Super-
vising Engineer, Lieut. Col. G. H. Mendell, Corps of Engineers.
   1. Humboldt Harbor and Bay, California.-The project for the im-
provement of the Bay was adopted in 1881, and had for its object to se-
cure by dredging a channel 13 feet deep at low water and 200 feet wide
to the upper end of Eureka wharves with channels 100 feet wide and
10 feet deep at low water to Arcata and Hookton. This project was
supplemented in 1882, after investigation by a Board of Engineers, to
seek a fixed position and increased depth for the channel across the bar
by a training-wall to level of low water extending from the south spit in
a northwesterly direction. The bay channels in their unimproved con-
dition had minimum depths of 7 feet to Eureka and 6 feet to Arcata
and Hookton.
   The channel across the bar varied widely in position and in depth
from 8 to 16 feet at low water. The amount expended to June 30, 1885,
was $80,027.32, all in dredging and in examinations bearing on proposed
improvement of bar channel.
  In June, 1884, the dredging had resulted in securing the desired
depths in the bay channels, but in tLe lack of recent surveys it is im-
       23 E
354       REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

possible to give their present condition precisely. The channel to Ar-
cata is reported as maintained, but along the front of Eureka wharves
and across the shoal below a shoaling of some 3 feet is thought to have
taken place. No work has been done during the year ending June 30,
1886, as the sum available did not justify the beginning of so costly and
exposed a work as the proposed jetty.
  The amount estimated for completion of existing project could, in the
opinion of the officer in charge, be most advantageously expended if all
appropriated in two successive years. The land on the south spit which
will be needed has been held at an exorbitant price by the owners, and
will probably have to be condemned.
July 1, 1885, amount available............ .... ..............       ....      . $62,472 68
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885...........      .........................      ....       109 04

July 1, 1886, amount available.......... .... ........         ..... . 62, 363 64
                                                       ..............
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886..................   75,000 00

Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887 ....................      137, 363 64

  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project ........   462,500 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1888 200, 000 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
 ( harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix P P 1.)
   2. San JoaquinRiver, Stockton and Mormon sloughs, California.-The
project was originally adopted in 1877, the object being to obtain by
dredging a channel 100 feet wide, and 6 feet deep at low water in the
tidal parts of the river below Stockton, and to cut off the points at cer-
tain sharp bends.
   This project was modified in 1881 to seek the maintenance of a chan-
nel 9 feet deep at low water, and 100 feet wide through Stockton Slough
and the tidal river below; a channel 4 feet deep at low water, and 80
feet wide in Mormon Slough to Miller's Warehouse, the straightening
of the river below mouth of Stockton Slough by cut-offs at certain sharp
bends, and the temporary improvement of the low-water channel of the
Uipper San Joaquin by removal of snags, scraping of bars, and construc-
tion of wing-dams.
   The tidal parts of the river below Stockton in their natural condition
afforded a channel of practical width and 6 feet deep at low water.
The upper river to Hill's Ferry was bnly navigable for boats drawing
2 feet during six to seven months in each year.
   The amount expended to June 30, 1885, was $105,633.93 in dredging,
and $33,812.45 in snagging and temporary measures on the upper river.
   The balance of funds permitted no work during the fiscal year ending
June 30, 1886, other than an examination of the crevasse at Paradise
Cut.
   The desired tidal channels below Stockton can only be maintained by
annual dredging, and, as this has been remitted for two seasons, they
have now reverted to their natural condition, except in Stockton and
Mormon sloughs, where the original natural depths have been seriously
impaired by the influx of sediment with land drainage. With the com-
ing low water it is probable that not more than 4 feet can be taken to
Stockton.
    The cut-offs have maintained themselves and been of substantial
benefit to the navigation. The sums available and asked for are to be
applied, in the order named, to fitting dredge now under contract with
centrifugal pump discharge, dredging below Stockton, removal of snags
                                RIVER AND                  HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                   355
in the upper river, partial closure of Paradise Cut, and cut-offs at
Twenty-one Mile Slough and Head Reach.
  The estimated cost ofcompletion of project is exclusive of the dredg-
ing and snagging, which will be a yearly necessity.
July 1, 1.85, amount available ........................................                        $553 60
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885--..---....----......--.. ............................                  35 32
                                 ..----.....--.......... ....................
July 1, 1886, amount available ----                                                            518 28
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886 ..................                       18,750 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887...................                     19,268 28

 (Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project, exclu-
I     sive of dredging ...................................................                139,000 00
     Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1888               40, 000 00
1Submitted in compliance       with requirements of section 2 of river and
 ( harbor acts of 1866 and      1867.
   (See Appendix PP 2.)
   3. Mokelumne River, California.-The present project for improve-
ment was adopted in the autumn of 1884, and has for its object to clear
the river of snags and overhanging trees from the mouth to Benson's
Ferry.
   The natural channel in this part of the river had depths of from 5 feet
to 10 feet. The amount expended to June 30, 1885, in work by the United
States snag-boat was $4,958.09, and resulted in a practicable channel
by the north fork for the steamers in use as far up as Benson's Ferry.
   During the fiscal year ending June 30, 1886, there has been expended
also in work by the snag-boat over the same part of the river the sum
of $3,499.39, resulting in the removal of 324 snags and 394 trees, and in-
creased convenience for the navigation. With the sum of $5,000 asked
for it is proposed to continue the work of snagging and clearing of banks
to Benson's Ferry and possibly a little above, and to clear about 2 miles
at the head of the south fork, which is the only part of it not now navi-
gable.
   As the project contemplates annual work as necessary, hence no
estimate can be given of the sum required for completion.
July 1, 1885, amount available..--.... ......---......---....--- --.. ....----....--......
                                                                                    -----.... $3, 541 91
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885 ......---------....-----
                                             ......--......----------......---....--..--.....  3, 499 39
July 1, 1886, amount available--..-----.... .---...............................                  42 52
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886.. ................                        2, 500 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887 ...............                        2, 542 52
     Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1888               5, 000 00
     Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
       harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
     (See Appendix P P 3.)
   4. Sacramento and Featherrivers, California.---Theproject was adopted
in 1874 with the object of temporary improvement of the low-water chan-
nel by wing-dams and scraping and removing of snags, annually carried
on by contract.
   This was modified in 1879 to provide for the construction of a snag-
boat and barge, and the further prosecution of the work by hired labor.
   Up to June 30, 1885, there had been expended $221,750.53, of which
$43,554 was for the building of a boat and barge, and $178,196.53 in
actual work upon the river. During the year ending June 30, 1886, there
356          REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

was expended $25,316.99 in the removal of 650 snags and 139 trees, with
37 days spent in scraping crests of bars and 27 days in dam building.
   The channel of the Sacramento before improvement offered a depth
of 3) feet as far as Jacinto, and 21 above that to Chico Landing; but
these depths were not available on account of snags.
   The result of work has ,been to secure safe channels with these.depths
above the mouth of the Feather, and marked decrease in accidents to
the navigation.
   The river, below the mouth of Feather, which has deteriorated since
improvement was undertaken from the inflow of detritus from the mines,
last season offered greater difficulty to navigation than ever before.
   The snag-boat is now in her sixth season and will need hereafter ex-
tensive annual repairs.
   With the sums available, and asked for, it is proposed to continue
work as before with the snag-boat.
   The work being an annual necessity, no estimate can be given for a
final completion.
   Of the annual expenditures this fiscal year $2,000 was paid to the
contractors for the new dredge.
July 1, 1885, amount available...                   ......----.. ..............   ---   ...........   $220, 511 35
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1885---- .---.....-----..........----......--- $24, 608 87
July 1, 1886, outstanding liabilities   ----.........................              6, 509 72
                                                                                                        31,118 59

July 1, 1886, amount available ..........................................                              189, 392 76
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal yearending June 30, 1888                             40, 000 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix P P 4.)
   NOTE.-The river and harbor act of August 5, 1886, directs that the
balance of unexpended moneys for this improvement shall not be used
until the Secretary of War be satisfied that hydraulic mining, hurtful
to navigation, has ceased on these rivers and their tributaries.
   5. Colorado River, Nevada, California, and Arizona.-A project for
improvement was adopted October, 1884, the object being to afford a
channel of practicable width and 3 feet in depth from Camp Mojave to
El Dorado Caion during six months in each year, by hired labor.
  The river in its unimproved condition was navigable with some diffi-
culty for 21 feet draught throughout the year from its mouth to Camp
Mojave, but from thence to El Dorado were numerous rapids and some
sunken rocks with less than 1 foot of water. The worst obstructions
were at Hatteras Bar, Six Mile Rapid, and Mojave Crossing.
  The amount expended to June 30, 1885, was $15,741.59, and resulted
in a permanent improvement to the desired limits, and Six Mile Rapid
by the removal of sunken bowlders, and a partial improvement at 3Mo-
jave Crossing by the closure of a side channel.
  During the year ending June 30, 1886, there has been expended
$9,077.95 and the result has been an increase in the low-water depths
at Mojave Crossing from 1 foot to 3 feet, and at Hatteras Bar from 1 foot
to 2 feet.
  Explorer's Rock, above El Dorado Caion, was removed from 1 foot
above low water to 1 foot below, and is no longer an obstacle at stages
when navigation in this part of the river is possible. Contracted chan-
nels were widened at Bull's Head Caion and Bowlder Rapid, and a side
channel closed at Pest House Rapid.
                        RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                               357
   The effect of work thus far, in the opinion of steamboatmen, has been
to make navigation to ElDorado Canon practicable for about five months
in each year.
   The appropriation is exhausted and no work is proposed for the com-
ing fiscal year.
   In the lack of detailed surveys of the river no precise estimate of cost
of completing original project can be made.
July 1,1885, amount available ........................----                             ..      ........---....   $9, 258 41
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885 .........................-- . ...................                                      9, 077 95
July 1, 1886, amount available         ................................-..........                                  180 46
   (See Appendix P P 5.)

IMPROVEMENT OF UPPER AND LOWER COLUMBIA AND WILLAMETTE
  RIVERS; OF THE SNAKE, COWLITZ, AND YAMHILL RIVERS, OREGON
  AND WASHINGTON; AND OF LOWER CLEARWATER RIVER, IDAHO-
  CONSTRUCTION OF CASCADES CANAL, COLUMBIA RIVER.

   Officer in charge, Maj. W. A. Jones, Corps of Engineers, with Lieut.
Willard Young, Corps of Engineers, under his immediate orders. Su-
pervising Engineer, Lieut. Col. G. H. Mendell, Corps of Engineers.
   1. Columbia and Willamette rivers below Portland, Oregon (in charge
of Capt. C. F. Powell, Corps of Engineers, to March 31, 1886).-The
project for this improvement was adopted in 1877, and modified subse-
quently; the object being to afford a ship-channel of 20 feet depth at
low water, by contraction and shore-protection works at four bars from
Portland to Columbia City, by temporary improvement at the bars dur-
ing construction of the works, and at three shoal places below Columbia
City, and by snagging operations.
   The natural depth of channel at the shoalest place was about 9 feet,
and on six other bars 101 to 15 feet at low water. The amount expended
on the project to June 30, 1886, is $373,755.06, and has resulted gener-
ally in maintaining a channel depth of successively 17, 18, and 19 feet,
low water, from Astoria, near the mouth of the Columbia River, to Port-
land, 100 miles distant inland.
   Operations during the year consisted of sounding and surveying bars,
ballasting dike at Saint Helen's; willow plantations above shore-pro-
tection works; repairs to tug Lincoln, and care and protection of prop-
erty and plant.
   The amount asked for the next fiscal year is for completion of the
project of contraction and shore-protection works, temporary improve-
ment during the year, extension of the plan of permanent works below
Columbia City, and for removal of a rock obstruction. Amount ex-
pended to June 30, 1886, is $373,755.06.
July 1, 1885, amount available..--..                           ..--...........       ...    ................       $506 28
Received during fiscal year ending June 30, 1886, from transfer of property
  to other appropriations-- .---..--............------------ ...--................                                2, 530 35
                                                                                                                  3,036 63
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885....................------------......................                                  3,036 12
July 1, 1886, amount available----...---.....-------------.............----------
                                                                   ................                                      51
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886 ..................                                            75, 000 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887..........................                                  75, 000 51
358      REPOIT     O     TE
                           1    Cli1P      OF" ENGINEERS, U. S. A1tt1Y.

(Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project..-----...... 332,000 00
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June30, 1888 150, 000 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
  harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
  (See Appendix Q Q 1.)
  2. Upper Willamnette River, Oregon.-The project for this improvement
was adopted in 1870, modified in 1878, and extended in later years.
The object is to afford and maintain an easy light-draught navigation
from Portland to Eugene City, and on 12 miles of tributaries, making
in all a distance of 184 miles.
   The work consists of snagging operations, bar scraping, and for the
reach between Willamette Falls and Corvallis, in the contraction of
water-way by low cut-off or wing-dams and rock removal. The natural
channelfrom Portland to Willamette Falls, 12 miles, was generally deep
and wide. Above it is narrow, tortuous, and much obstructed. The
mouth of the Yamhill, 28 miles from the falls, was the head of an in-
convenient low-water navigation in a draught of 21 feet. Only 1 foot
could be carried above. The present project was adopted in 1878. Total
appropriation to August 5, 1886, $84,000. Amount expended, $73,984.52,
of which about $22,000 has been applied to construction, and the re-
mainder to maintenance.
   Operations for the year have been work with the snag-boat and con-
struction of wing-dams.
   The amount asked for is to be applied to rock removal, river-con-
struction works, and annual maintenance.
July 1, 1885, amount available...........
                                     --   ................... ....--......      $3, 394 72
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885 ..              -................
                                   -...........                            ..
                                                                -...........     3,379 24
July 1, 1886, amount available .................... .....................            15 48
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886...................           10, 000 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887...... .... .........      10, 015 48

SAmount  (estimated) required for completion of existing project.......-     29,000 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1888 29, 000 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river         and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix Q Q 2.)
  3. Columbia River at Cascades, Oregon.--The plan for this improve-
ment, adopted in 1877 and modified in 1880, is to give lockage around
the main rapid and open river navigation through the minor rapid be-
low, from low water up to a stage of about 20 feet, at the foot of the
canal. The plan contemplates the construction of a guard-lock for use
at the higher stages. The canal will be about 3,000 feet long. The
low-water lock will have a lift of about 24 feet. The lock capacity will
be 90 feet by 462 feet, with a least draught of 8 feet. Amount expended
to June 30, 1886, is $951,450.25. During the year work has been car-
ried on in the excavation for canal and lock-pits, grading grounds, quar-
rying stone from bowlders, completion of cement-shed, repairs of plant
and quarters, repairing road for wagon-portage, construction of scow,
water-guage observations, and care and protection of plant and property.
   The appropriation asked for is to be applied to construction of wing-
walls, lock-walls, guard-gate, purchase of timber for gates, lock and
canal-pit excavation, and grading.
                          IRIVER       ANID     ItARBOR          IMPROVEMENTS.                                   359
July 1, 1885, amount available---....................---...................                              $21, 823 67
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive
  of liabilities outstanding July 1, 1885 ..---.......... --.... $18, 273 92
July 1, 1886, outstanding liabilities ........................        776 82
                                                                                                          19,050 74

July 1, 1886, amount available .......................................                                     2,772 93
                                                                         -----
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886.------------...............                           187,500 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887 ...... ....-----...                                190, 272 93

  SAmount (estimated) required for completion of existing project...... 1,100,000 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June
    30, 1888......----..---. --........------......--...---..-----........----...--.......--....--......---- 400, 000 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix Q Q 3.)
  4. Upper Columbia and                      Snake
                               rivers, Oregon and Washington                                                  Terri-
tory.-The plan of this improvement, adopted in 1877, consists in rock
removal at a number of very swift rapids to give channel depths at low
water of 5, feet in the. Columbia and 4- feet in Snake River, a river
length of 266 miles between Celilo on the Columbia and Lewiston on the
Snake.         The natural channel was narrow, tortuous, and dangerous,
with many very difficult rapids.
   Amount expended to June 30, 1886, is $113,550.90, and has resulted
in improvement at fifteen localities. All work has been done by con-
tract, but has been very much impeded by bad weather and accidents.
The rapids are very strong and work is difficult and dangerous.
   Rock removed during year, 58.45 cubic yards. Gravel and cobble-
stone removed during the year, 587.04 cubic yards.
  It is proposed to apply the appropriation asked for to the removal of
rocks and cobble-stone bars to complete the project.
July 1, 1885, amount available......-
                                   -....................................                                  $8, 398 79
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1885..........................                          $5,949 69
July 1, 1886, outstanding liabilities ..........................                              77 50
                                                                                                            6, 027 19

July 1, 1887, amount available ..........................................                                   2,371 60
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886...................                                      10, 000 00



 {Amount
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887...................

          (estimated) required for completion of existing project ........
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscalyear ending June 30,1888
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
                                                                                                           12,371 60

                                                                                                           26,000 00
                                                                                                           20,000 00
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
    (See Appendix Q Q 4.)
  5. Cowlitz River, Washington Territory.-The project for this improve-
ment, adopted in 1880, consists in wing-dam construction, bar-scraping,
and snagging operations, to secure light-draught navigation up to To-
ledo, a little more than 30 miles above the mouth.
   The original estimate for this work was $3,000 for construction in
the first year, and an annual expenditure thereafter of $2,000 for main-
tenance by snagging operations. Total appropriation to August 5,
1886, is $8,000. Amount expended to June 30, 1886, is $6,000.
  During the year no work was performed, the appropriation having
been practically exhausted in previous year.
  60         REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

July 1, 1885, amount available ..............--                   ..-- ...... ........ ..------....               $11 87
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885-------...............................-----------------------------------..........      11 87
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886 ...................                                          2,000 00


   Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
     1888, to include maintenance ......................................------------------------------------.   5, 000 00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix Q Q 5.)
  6. Lower Clearicater River, Idaho.-The present project, adopted in
1878, is to make a channel through rock-reefs and cobble-stone bars from
Lewiston, at the mouth of the river, to North Fork, a distance of 40
miles, to secure a low-water channel depth of 4 feet.
  The amount expended to June 30, 1884, is $15,000, and has resulted
in improvement, more or less complete, over the lower reach of 30 miles.
SAmount (estimated) required for completion of existing project-------........ $19, 424 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix Q Q 6.)
  7. Survey of Columbia River above the mouth of Snake River, Washing-
ton Territory.-An allotment of $6,000 was made from the appropriation
of July 5, 1884, for this work, and a project was duly approved for the
applying this sum to a survey of Priest Rapids. The survey of the
reach embraced by the Priest Rapids, a distance of 10.22 miles, and a
rapid survey also made of Cabinet Rapids, 45 miles above, was made
and completed within that sum.
  A project is submitted by the officer in charge for opening the river
to navigation by means of open-river improvement and the removal of
submerged rock by blasting, with an estimate of the cost of the same,
$153,240.
  (See Appendix Q Q 7.)

IMPROVEMENT OF THE MOUTH OF THE COLUMBIA RIVER, OREGON
  AND WASHINGTON TERRITORY; OF THE ENTRANCES TO COOS AND
  YAQUINA BAYS; OF MOUTH OF COQUILLE RIVER AND OF UMPQUA
  RIVER, OREGON; AND OF CERTAIN RIVERS EMPTYING INTO PUGET
  SOUND AND GRAY'S HARBOR, WASHINGTON TERRITORY-WATER-
  GAUGES ON COLUMBIA RIVER.


  Officer in charge, Capt. Charles F. Powell, Corps of Engineers, with
Lieut. Edward Burr, Corps of Engineers, under his immediate orders
until October 20, 1885. Supervising Engineer, Lieut. Col. G. H. Men
dell, Corps of Engineers.
  1. Mouth of the Columbia River, Oregon and Washington Territory.-
The project of this improvement, adopted in 1884, is to afford a channel
30 feet deep at mean low tide by a low-tide jetty, about 41 miles long
and of a partly tentative character, from near Fort Stevens, on the
south cape, to a point about 3 miles south of Cape Disappointment.
  The natural channel is generally divided; the bar channels are change-
able in location and depth. Of late years the main channel has car-
ried about 19 feet at low water, and for an insufficient width; 26 feet
are required on the bar in a wide, direct, and stable channel, and 30
                       flIV11      AN)      HABAR13   R    ,PRO         i   Mt      PS.
                                                                                 N'lt                   361
feet are desirable for the deep vessels needed by the Columbia River
trade, on account of the heavy seas of the locality.
   The amount expended on the project to June 30, 1885, is $59,376.70,
and was for necessary preliminary work, building certain accessory
structures and obtaining plant.
   The amount expended during the fiscal year 1886 is $38,615.39.
   The jetty, of a brush-mattress and stone ballast, was built for 1,020
feet from ordinary highest tide-line, and minor constructions added.
A hydrographic survey was made.
   The general effect of the jetty has been to cause the sands to fill
against the south side and to move seaward, as expected, the shore-
lines on that side. The work has not been far enough advanced to have
any influence on the channel.
   The improvement is important and of magnitude.
   The appropriation asked for is to build part of 3 miles of jetty for
closing a swash channel across Clatsop Spit, on which sand the jetty is
to be built; this section of jetty is expected to considerably improve the
ship-channel.
July 1, 1885, amount available .......................................                             $34, 362 98
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive
  of liabilities outstanding July 1, 1885 ..........---------........            $32, 355 07
July 1, 1886, outstanding liabilities ........................                            574 30
                                                                                                    32, 929 37

July 1, 1886, amount available ... .....-- ........................... ---                           1,433 61
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886.................                                187, 500 00

Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887.-....-.........                              188,933 61

  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project ..... 3, 422, 500 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June
   30, 1888 ...........---------------------------------.....        --------.
                                                              ---....--        700, 000 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix IR 1 i.)
   2. Entrance to Coos Bay, Oregon.--The project of this improvement,
adopted in 1879, and subsequently extended, is to build a half-tide jetty,
or deflecting dike, about 2,400 feet long, from near Fossil Point, inside,
of the entrance, towards Coos Head, exterior to the entrance, for afford-
ing a direct channel of 14 feet depth at mean lower low water, and one
less exposed to heavy seas and of easier access under storm winds than
the ordinary natural channel. The mean rise of tide above the plane of
reference is 5.6 feet. The natural channel sometimes carried not more
than 7 to 8 feet low-water depth.
   The amount expended on the project to June 30, 1885, is $124,953.48;
it has resulted in the construction of 1,825 feet of incomplete jetty,partly
in deep water, affording during the preceding four years a straighter
and more stable channel by partly eroding the north spit, as desired,
and deflecting the ebb about one half from its former direction towards
that intended.
   The amount expended during the year, June 30, 1886, is $3,305.77.
A hydrographic survey was made and minor quarry operations con-
ducted. The channel has considerably further improved during the year.
   The appropriation asked for is to extend the jetty and to raise the
present submerged part to low tide.
     62     RiPoRT OF THE crIEFP OF                   ENtGINERS, ti. S. ARMY*.

July 1, 1885, amount available ......-.................................. $3,758 78
Amount received by transfer of property to other improvements .........      10 78

                                                                                             3, 769 56
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1885 ........................   $2,999 64
July 1, 1886, outstanding liabilities-.........           .  ......
                                                                .    231 67
                                                                                             3,231 31

July 1, 1886, amount available ..----..........--.....................      538 25
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886                       33,750 00
                                                       ...................

Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887 ...................                   34,288 25

rAmount     (estimated) required for completion of existing project........ 436,250 00
I   Amount that can be profitably expendedin fiscal year ending June 30,1888 100, 000 00
     Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
      harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
     (See Appendix      RR    2.)
     3. Entrance to Yaquina Bay, Oregon.-The project of this improve-
ment is to build a brush-mattress and stone jetty about 4,000 feet long
on the south side of the entrance, with shore protection, to close a rock-
obstructed channel, for providing a central free channel of 12 feet depth
at mean lower low water. A shorter jetty on the north side was pro-
posed for future consideration. The mean rise of tide above the plane
of reference is 7.1 feet.
  Of three natural channels of a best depth of 7 to 10 feet reduced, two
of them are obstructed by dangerous rocks.
   The amount expended on the project to June 30, 1885, is $152,247.41,
and has resulted in the construction of 2,517 feet of jetty and 450 feet
of shore protection. For the greater part of the time since the first con-
siderable work the channel has been deeper and removed from the south
rocks. The channel is now in about the desired position and has o low-
water depth of 11 feet.
  The amount expended during the year June 30, 1886, is $2,852.49.
  A survey of June, 1886, was mapped, and an investigation made of
the advisability of extending the project to give a greater depth of water
than now contemplated, for a discussion of which see reports of the
engineer in charge and supervising engineer in Appendix.
July 1, 1885, amount available------.-              -- --.            --..   ---.           $4, 180 72
Amount received by transfer of property to other improvements--.....                            98 37
                                                                                             4, 279 09
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1885.......................... $2,587 49
July 1, 1886, outstanding liabilities ............................                  53 87
                                                                                             2, 641 36

July 1, 1886, amount available..........................................                     1,637 73
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886 ...................                      75,000 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887-------....-..-----.........-----.     76,637 73
     Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project- .--         96,970 00
     Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1888 200,000 00
     Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
       harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
      (See Appendix R R 3.)
     4. Mouth of Coquille River, Oregon.--The plan of this improvement,
adopted in 1880, is to afford a direct free channel 10 feet deep at mean
lower low water, by a half-tide jetty or deflecting dike about 3,400 feet
                           lIVER AND 1ATBO1t IMPROVEMENITS.                                                       363
long, built from the left bank and passing 800 feet south of the Rackliff
Rock. The mean rise of tide above the reference plane is 4 feet.
   The natural channel was long, tortuous, shoal, and rendered ex-
tremely dangerous by numerous rocks.
   The amount expended on the project to June 30, 1885, is $27,455.28,
and has resulted in the construction of a jetty 1,523 feet long, but not
of full strength. The channel projected by the improvement was
opened four year ago, and has since been maintained with but little va-
riation in position and depth; it is short, direct, free from dangerous
rocks, and about double the depth of the former channel.
   The amount expended during the year June 30, 1886, is $414.13.
Periodical examinations of the jetty and channel were made, and a con-
struction building repaired to render secure property stored therein.
   The amount asked for is to extend the jetty and make it permanent
by heavy ballast and riprap.
July 1, 1885, amount available .................................-----------------------------...---..---..    $329 81
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1885 ------------------------........................        $104 94
July 1, 1886, outstanding liabilities .................-........                                  27 00
                                                                                                                131
                                                                                                                S     94

July 1, 1806, amount available ............................. ........ ...........                                197 87
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886 ...................                                       20,000 00
Amount available for fiscal year-ending June 30, 1887 ...................                                    20,197 87
   Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project           114,000 00          -..------.
   Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1888 50,000 00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river gnd
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (fSee Appendix R R 4.)
  5. Umpqua River, Oregon.--The project of this work is to apply the
balance of the appropriation of the act of March 3, 1871, in rock re-
moval at five reefs near and below Scottsburg for a low-water channel 3
feet deep by 50 feet wide, for aiding small screw-vessel navigation from
Scottsburg down-stream.
   Previous to the year June 30, 1886, no work had been done on the
river below Scottsburg. During that year $3,891.89 were expended on
the project. The Scottsburg reefs, including a rock shoal below the
lower reef were drilled and, except the upper reef, blasted.
   It is proposed with the balance on hand to remove the broken rock,
which will afford a channel about 2 feet low-water depth. One thou-
sand dollars are asked for completing the 3-foot channel through the
Scottsburg Reefs. The engineer in charge estimates the cost of a needed
4-foot channel from Scottsburg to Gardiner, near the mouth of the river,
at $30,000.
July 1, 1885, amount available .....................................                                         $4, 685 89
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1885 .........................                               $3, 891 89
July 1, 1886, outstanding liabilities.................. .... ....                                   73 47
                                                                                                              3, 965 36

July 1, 1886, amount available ..........                    ...............................                    720 53
   Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project......- -                                    1,000 00
   Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1888                                  1,000 00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
    (See Appendix R R 5.)
864       REIPORT     OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

  6. Skagit, Steilaquamish, Nootsak, Snohomish, and Snoqualmie rivers,
Washington Territory.-The project of the improvement for these rivers,
adopted in 1882, consists in annual snagging and moderate bar scrap-
ing by a regularly equipped snag-boat for light-draught navigation to
the natural heads thereof, being an aggregate length of river of about
250 miles.
  The natural channels are deep in the tidal sections, shoal and gener-
ally rapid in the upper portions, and much obstructed by drift through-
out.
   The amount expended on the project to June 30, 1885, is $29,984.39,
and has permitted partial work on four of the five rivers covered by the
project. There were no expenditures during the year ending June 30,
1886.
   The amount asked for is to complete the construction and appliances
of the snag-boat, operate her on each of the rivers named, reserving
$4,000 for a fund for rebuilding the boat at the end of ten years.
July 1, 1885, amount available, inclusive of outstanding liabilities .......              $15 61
July 1, 1886, outstanding liabilities ....................  ...........-----.             135 00
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886 ...................                 10,000 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887 .----....--...... ........   -    9,880 61
  Amount (estimated) required for continuing existing project.-.--.--.                 29,000 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year endingJune 30,1888             15, 000 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Apjendix R R 6.)
   7. Chehalis River, IWashington Territory.-The project of this improve-
ment, adopted in 1882, consists in annual snagging operations below
Claquato, 82 miles from the river's mouth, at an estimated cost of $5,000.
   The lower river, 12 miles from Montesano, the head of coasting nav-
igation, to Gray's Harbor is free of bad snags. From Montesano to
Elma, the head of tide, 16 miles, the river is considerably obstructed by
snags, and from Elma to Centralia, on the Northern Pacific Railroad,
it was practically blocked by 3 drift-jams and numerous snags. Above
that to Claquato the river is tolerably free.
   The expenditures on the project to June 30, 1885, are $5,004.93. A
passage was cut through the jams and some snags removed as far as
Elma, but yet not making navigation practicable. No operations were
conducted during the year.
   Since previous work was partial, drift has accumulated from a long
suspension of operations.
July 1, 1885, amount available..........................................                $495 07
Amount received by transfer of property to other improvements and by
  deposit ............................................................                     23 04
                                                                                          518 11
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilitiesoutstanding July 1, 1885 ........ - --... ......--......      $147 42
July 1, 1886, outstanding liabilities ..........................            360 00
                                                                                          507 42
July 1, 1886, amount available .................. .......................                  10 69
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886...................                  2, 500 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887....................               2,510 69
                     RIVER      AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                   365

  Amount (estimated)
  Amount that         required for
              can be profitably    continuing
                                expendedin     existing
                                            fiscal      project...........
                                                   yearending Juno 30, 1888            8,000
                                                                                       5,     00
                                                                                          000 00
SSubmitted  in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
  (See Appendix R R 7.)
  8. Gauging waters of the Columbia River and principal tributaries.-
The object here is to operate an automatic gauge at Astoria and main-
tain staff-gauges above, for pilots' information and for record of tides
and stages of river, one service of the Astoria gauge being to show the
condition of the bar at the mouth of the Columbia River with regard to
roughness. It is also intended to measure the tidal and river volumes.
The amount expended therefor to June 30, 1886, is $1,495.27; it has
permitted p)artial service of water-gauges, but none in measuring the
water-volumes.
  During the last year the Astoria gauge was operated for part of a
month. Four staff-gauges, for pilots' use on the Lower Columbia,were
renewed and similar gauges established at eight places near bars on that
river or on the Lower Willamette. Float-gauges were fixed at Columbia
City and Coffin Rock, Lower Columbia; day-time highest and lowest
waters were observed at these places, and at Saint Helen's for part of
the year and at North Portland for all the year. The service was much
cu'tailed for lack of funds.
July 1,1885, amount available............................                 ..........
                                                                        ....            $210 24
July 1, 1I86, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885.......... ........ .........................                  205 51
July 1, 1886, amount available .. ......
                                       ..................
                                                        ..............                     4 73
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5,1886.....................                 1,000 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887...................               1, 004 73
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1888            4,000 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix R IR 8.)

EXAMINATIONS,           SURVEYS,        AND CONTINGENCIES                OF    RIVERS      AND
                                         HARBORS.

  For examinations and surveys, for improvements and for contingencies,
and for incidental repairs of harbors for which there is no special appro-
priation, an appropriation of $150,000 should be made, of which sum
$50,000 for surveys and $100,000 for contingencies, including incidental
repairs of harbors.

PUBLIC        WORKS, APPROPRIATIONS FOR WHICH ARE                                         NOT
              INCLUDED IN RIVER AND HARBOR ACTS.

MAINTENANCE AND REPAIRS OF WASHINGTON AQUEDUCT--INCREAS-
ING WATER-SUPPLY OF THE CITY OF WASHINGTON -ERECTION OF
FISHIWAYS AT THE GREAT FALLS OF THE POTOMAC.

   Officer in charge, Maj. G. J. Lydecker, Corps of Engineers, with
Capt. Thomas W. Symons, Corps of Engineers, under his immediate
orders to April 16, 1886.
   1. Washington Aqueduct.-The appropriation of $20,000 has been ap-
plied as usual, mainly to the routine work involved in the care of the
366      REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

aqueduct and distribution of the water-supply. A large break in the
36-inch supply main caused a serious reduction in the amount of water
flowing into the city during a period of thirty-six hours, the time re-
quired for making the repairs.
   Near the inlet to the aqueduct at the Great Falls a new masonry dis-
charging-weir was built through the bank of the Chesapeake and Ohio
Canal, and the old discharging-weir and two waste-weirs were closed
up, the object being to secure the water flowing into the aqueduct from
danger of pollution by the waters in the adjoining canal level.
   The amount required for the expenses of the aqueduct and its ap-
purtenances for the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888, is $20,000. In ad-
dition, the officer in charge of the work renews his recommendation of
last year in relation to certain improvements at the Receiving Reservoir
and at the Great Falls, which are designed to secure the water-supply
against all danger of contamination from surface drainage. The esti-
mated cost of the work is, in round numbers, $125,000, and the appro.
priation of this sum is commended to the favorable consideration of
Congress, in view of the importance of doing everything possible to
insure a delivery of the Potomac water in its purest natural condition.
July 1, 1885, amount available--.......
                                     -     --.......----..
                                                      .      .......--...   ..........     $20, 000 00
July 1,1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1885......     ............ .... $18, 969 13
                                      ------------
July 1, 1886, outstanding liabilities--...----.........---......---.. 1. 030 87
                                                                                            20, 000 00
Amount appropriated by act approved June 30, 1886 ...........-..                   .-...    20, 000 00

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1888 20, 000 00
  (See Appendix S S 1.)
   2. Increasing the water-supply of Washington, D. .- The approved
project for this work comprises, first, the extension of the dam at the
Great Falls of the Potomac across Conn's Island and the Virginia Chan-
nel to the Virginia shore, and the completion of the whole to an eleva-
tion of 148 feet above mean high tide at the navy-yard, this elevation
being about 15 inches above the crest of the old dam across the Mary-
land Channel of the river; second, the extension of the aqueduct by
a tunnel about 20,700 feet long, from the terminus of the conduit at
Drovers' Rest (Distributing Reservoir) to the site of a new reservoir
near Howard University; third, construction of a new reservoir at that
place capable of holding about 300,000,000 gallons; fourth, making the
necessary main connections for taking the water from the new reservoir
into the system of supply-mains for the city.
   Contracts for the dam, tunnel, and reservoir were made in the fall of
1883, and operations have been in progress under these contracts since
that time.
   It was .expected that work on the dam would be completed in the fall
of 1885, but the contractors, having experienced considerable trouble
on account of high water, did not succeed in so doing, and the work
was carried over into the past spring. At the close of the fiscal year it
had been completed with the exception of about 192 linear feet of cop-
ing. The whole work will be finished during the present season.
   On the tunnel the work of excavation in the several headings aggre-
gated 13,500 linear feet, of which 745 linear feet were lined with masonry,
at the commencement of the last fiscal year. Operations were con-
tinued until February 1, 1886, when it became necessary to suspend
                RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.             *         367
work because the appropriation was about exhausted, the balance then
available being only $1,571.93, and this was held to protect the tunnel
from damage by flooding during the suspension of work, pending action
in Congress in relation to the additional appropriation that had been
asked for in the last annual report and again urgently recommended
in a special communication that was forwarded to Congress by the
Secretary of War, under date of January 15, 1886 (published as House
Ex. Doc. No. 39, Forty-ninth Congress, first session). Action was de-
layed, however, until this balance was exhausted, whereupon Congress
made a special supplementary appropriation of $5,000 to continue
pumping operations. At the close of the fiscal year this appropriation
was reduced to $231.03. Since then the general deficiency bill has passed
both houses of Congress, and contains the necessary appropriation for
resuming work (but'the bill has not, at this writing, become a law).
   The length of excavation accomplished during the fiscal year was
5,040.2 linear feet, and 745 linear feet of tunnel was lined with masonry,
making the total length of excavation 18,538.2 feet, or about 3j miles,
of which 1,490 feet was lined with masonry. The excavation is now con-
tinuous for a distance of 16,327 feet, or a little over 3 miles, from the
west end of the tunnel. There remains a distance of about 2,150 feet to
be excavated, when the tunnel will be "holed " through from end to end.
The sum named in the general deficiency bill for continuing this work is
$395,000, and operations will be resumed as soon as it becomes available.
The above amount was that estimated as necessary to complete the
tunnel before the suspension of operations; but the officer in charge of
the work is of opinion that the ultimate cost of completion will be in-
creased as the direct result of the suspension, which has now lasted for
a period of six months; but he is unable to submit any estimate of the
probable amount of increase until after a thorough examination, and
that cannot be made until work on the tunnel is resumed.
   Work on the reservoirwas continued during the year, but the progress
has been slow; the principal feature of the work is the excavation of
about 850,000 cubic yards of earth and its embankment to form a mass-
ive dam, and the laying of about 76,000 square yards of dry stone pav-
ing on the slopes of the reservoir and dam. On the 30th of June, 1886,
the total amount of excavation was 727,329 cubic yards, and of paving
39,414 square yards, of which 232,033 cubic yards of excavation and
19,722 square yards of paving was done during the past fiscal year;
during the same time about 3,700 linear feet of masonry conduits or
sewers, for intercepting the flow of storm-waters, sewage, &c., were con-
structed. The general deficiency bill contains an item of $160,000 for
continuing the work, and this, it is believed from all that can now be
foreseen, will be sufficient to complete the work in all its essential
features.
   Nothing of moment was done on the main connections during the past
fiscal year, this part of the work having been completed during the pre-
ceding year, so far as anything can be done until the effluent gate house
is constructed at the reservoir, when the outlet-main, 75 inches in di-
ameter, will be connected with that structure. The balance available
for this purpose is $2,847.48, and will probably be sufficient.
   There has been expended .to June 30, 1886, for land damages, water
rights, and damages to Chesapeake and Ohio Canal,the sum of $248,152.19,
of which $15,189.51 applies to the past fiscal year.
368          REPOR'T OF              IHE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

July 1, 18-5, amount unexpended ...............                       ....           ..........         ......--- $615, 310 81
Amount appropriated by act approved March 26, 1886......                                      ...........           5, 000 00

                                                                                                                  620, 310 81
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1885 ........................            $380, 162 66
July 1, 1886, outstanding liabilities, including retained per-
  centages...... ....    .....    ..
                                ....  ...................       ----...... 116,119 24
                                                                                              ------              496,281 90

July 1, 1886, amount available ----------...............--- ---......-----...............----                     124.028 91
  Amount appropriated by act approved August 4, 1886 .................                                            555,000 00
   Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887......                                    .........       679,028 91
   (See Appendix S S 2.)
   3. Erection offish-ways at Great Falls.-The project for this work pro-
vides for building, in the Maryland Channel or Falls Branch of the Po-
tomac iiver, a fish-way in six sections, in accordance with detailed
plans and specifications that were prescribed by the United States
Commissioner of Fish and Fisheries, in pursuance of the act of Con-
gress approved July 15, 1882.
   Active operations were commenced in June, 1885, under contract
executed towards the end of the preceding month, and continued until
the close of October; at that time a flood in the river carried away the
protecting dams, destroyed one section of the fish-way, and caused dam-
age to the others that were in process of construction, the precise ex-
tent of which is as yet unknown, for the reason that they have remained
submerged since that date. Operations were then suspended and the
contract terminated, in pursuance of the recommendation of the officer
in charge of the work, who is of the opinion that they were not planned
with sufficient strength to resist the effect of floods in that locality.
   No estimate is- submitted at this time for completing the work, for
the reason that no intelligent computation of the cost can be made un-
til the flow of water which now submerges the damaged portions has
been diverted and the extent of damages determined. Steps to ac-
complish this have been taken, and the matter will be made the sub-
ject of special report and estimate at a later date.
July 1, 1855, amount unexpended-.....--......--------....              --....-----.........-..------------.... -$47, 640 12
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885 .....................................----..                                          .. 38,263 81
July 1, 1886, amount available                 .............           ..-...... ..........              ......     9, 376 31
   (See Appendix S S 3.)
IMPROVEMENT                AND CARE OF PUBLIC BUILDINGS AND GROUNDS IN
                              THE DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA.

  Officer in charge, Lieut. Col. John M. Wilson, Corps of Engineers,
colonel, U. S. A.
  At the Executive Mansion, the entire old copper roof, which leaked
badly, was removed and replaced with first-quality dipped Martin-
Siemens steel roofing-plates; the area thus covered was about 18,000
square feet; the fifty-nine telegraph wires which were stretched across the
roof were removed during the year; the c'onservatory and greenhouses
were painted, and minor repairs made to the mansion, greenhouses, and
stables.
  A new plant-house and two new brick cold-frames were erected, and
numerous minor repairs and improvements made to the greenhouses
and grounds at the nurseries.
                       RIVER       AND IIARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                       369
   In addition to the work performed for maintaining in good condition
the improved public reservations, extensive improvements were made
at Washington Circle, Garfield Park, Smithsonian and Seaton parks,
and at the South Carolina Avenue reservation.
   Water-pipes were laid and water introduced into sixteen reservations.
Five unimproved reservations were improved during the year, as fol-
lows:
   One at corner of Massachusetts avenue and Twenty-first street,
northwest.
   One at corner of Massachusetts avenue and Fifth street, northwest.
   One at corner of New Jersey avenue and Second street, northwest.
   One at corner of Pennsylvania avenue and Ninth street, southeast.
   One at corner of Pennsylvania avenue and Tenth street, southeast.
   The officer in charge has endeavored to distribute the new improve-
ments made through various sections of tle city.
   Attention is invited to the detailed report of the officer in charge,
and to his estimates and recommendations for the fiscal year ending
June 30, 1888. His estimates are as follows:
For improvment and care of public grounds ................................ $170, 500
For compensation of persons employed upon public buildings and grounds-..    51, 100
For replacing the overhead system of telegraph wires with duplicate six-
  conductor underground cable, and for care and repair of lines............                       10, 000
                                                                ---
For copying the original map of Washington City ...................-     -        --...-- -.          400
For contingent and incidental expenses of the Office of Public Buildings
  and Grounds---......-......---......--- --................... ...............---......--   ..      500
For rent of Office Public Buildings and Grounds ...........................                          900
   (See Appendix T T.)
BRIDGING NAVIGABLE WATERS OF THE UNITED STATES

   1. Bridge across the Mississippi River at Keithsburg, in the State of
Illinois.-The plan and location of this bridge, authorized by act of
April 26, 1882, were approved by the Secretary of War, July 6, 1885,
on condition that certain modifications be made thereto, and having
been modified accordingly, were finally approved October 13, 1885.
   (See Appendix U U 1.)
  2. Stone arch bridge across the west channel of the Mississippi River at
Minneapolis, Minnesota.--In consequence of representations made to the
War Department, that the construction of this bridge, proposed to be
built by the city of Minneapolis, under authority of the legislature of
Minnesota, might imperil not only the expensive works constructed
by the United States for the preservation of the Falls of Saint An-
thony, but ultimately destroy the falls themselves, at the request of
parties interested, and in view of the contrariety of opinion existing in
relation thereto, a Board of Engineer Officers was constituted to ex-
amine the subject and report its conclusions.
  The report of the Board was duly submitted to the War Department
and returned to this office, with opinion that there not appearing to be
any injury probable to the works constructed by the General Govern-
muent at the falls by the erection of the proposed bridge, in view of the
opinion of the Attorney-General of May 1, 1885, in the matter of the
railroad bridge at Saint Paul, the Secretary of War has no authority
upon other grounds to interfere with or to regulate the construction.
  (See Appendix U U 2.)
  3. Proposed bridge on the Ohio River, at or near Cairo, Illinois.-The
Committee of Commerce of the House of Representatives having trans-
              ii;
370    REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

mitted, with request for suggestions of the War Department, bill H. R.
6047, Forty-ninth Congress, first session, " to authorize the Chicago,
Saint Louis and New Orleans Railroad Company and the Illinois Cen-
tral Railroad Company, or either of them, to construct a bridge at or
near Cairo, Illinois," in view of the great importance of the interests
involved and the difficulty and expense attending the construction of
a bridge at the locality proposed, it was deemed expedient, with the
sanction of the Secretary of War, to refer the bill in question to a Board
of Engineer Officers for examination and report.
  The Board, after giving the subject full investigation and study,
reached the unanimous conclusion " that no modification of the act ap-
proved February 14, 1883," [supplementary to the act of December 17,
1872, prescribing the dimensions of bridges across the Ohio River], " cart
be recommended which would tend to lessen its requirements, and es-
pecially that prescribed in the final proviso of section 2, which fixes a
clear height of 53 feet above local highest water, measured to the lowest
part of the channel-span, as the minimum for a continuous bridge with-
out a draw."
   The Board also " unanimously decided to report adversely to.the
construction of a draw-bridge at Cairo." * * * "A low draw-bridge
with clear headway of only 15 feet at high water, with openings on
each side of 160 feet in the clear, as proposed in the bill, is regarded by
the Board as entirely inadmissible. Such a bridge would be an intol-
erable obstruction to navigation at all boating stages, and, in the opin-
ion of the Board, should not be seriously considered."
   The conclusions of the Board were concurred in by the Chief of Engi-
neers and by the War Department and printed as House Mis. Doc.
No. 339, Forty-ninth Congress, first session.
   (See Appendix U U 3.)
   4. Bridge of the Selma Bridge Company acrossthe AlabamaRiver at Selma,
Alabama.-Representations having been made that this bridge, which
was being built, would be likely to create an obstruction to the naviga-
tion of the Alabama River, the subject was referred, with the approval
of the Secretary of War, to a Board of Engineer Officers for considera-
tion, with instructions to report its recommendations, having in view
the requirements of section 8 of the river and harbor act of July 5,
1884.
   The Board in its report, March 25, 1886, regarded the bridge in ques-
tion a serious obstruction to navigation, and recommended that the
Selma Bridge Company be required to prepare a channel for the pas-
sage of boats, between the pivot-pier and the north bank of the river,
for all stages of water exceeding a 24-foot stage ; with the understand-
ing that, if at any time in the future, it should be necessary to provide
further facilities for navigation, the bridge company shall then be re-
quired to alter and change the bridge, at its own expense, in such man-
ner as may be proper to secure free and complete navigation without
impediment.
   The recommendation of the Board was concurred in by this office and
by the War Department.
   (See Appendix U U 4.)
  5. Changes in the originalplan of the bridge across the Ohio River at
Henderson, Kentucky.-This bridge, as constructed, differs in plan from
that recommended September 24, 1881, by a Board of Engineer Officers,
                                   LAKE SURVEYS-MAPS.                                              371
and approved by the Secretary of War October 11, 1881, as appears in
annual report of this office for 1882, page 1989.
  There being nothing in print to show when and in what manner the
changes were authorized, the correspondence relating thereto is inserted
in the appendix of this report for convenience of reference, and to com-
plete the printed record.
  (See Appendix U U 5.)
    6. In consequence of provisions of section 2 of the river and harbor act
of July 5, 1884, which require the Secretary of War to report to Con-
.gress whether any bridges, causeways, or structures, erected or being
erected, interfere with free and safe navigation, and if so, to report the
best mode of altering or constructing them, with the view of supplying
the'information desired, officers under direction of this office were in-
structed to submit reports covering all facts necessary to enable the
Secretary of War to comply with the terms of the act. A communica-
tion containing reports received in compliance with these instructions,
and comprising all instances reported to this office up to date of inter-
ference with free and safe navigation by bridges and other structures,
was transmitted to the Senate December 18, 1885, and printed as Sen-
ate Ex. Doc. No. 12, Forty-ninth Congress, first session.

PRINTING AND DISTRIBUTION OF CHARTS OF TIHE
    NORTHERN AND NORTHWESTERN LAKES.

  Under the supervision of this office the following engraved copper-
plates of charts of the Northern and Northwestern lakes have been
electrotyped:
   Lake Michigan Coast Chart No. 4, Niagara Falls.
  The following charts have been photolithographed and an edition
printed :
   Buffalo Harbor, scale
   Erie Harbor, scale wo-.
                              -To0
   Saint Lawrence River Detail Sheets Nos. 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, and 6, scale -ry.
  During the year 4,537 charts were issued under the supervision of
Lieut. Col. O. M. Poe, Corps of Engineers, 1,212 of which were sold at
30 cents each, and the amount, $363.60, turned into the Treasury.
Amount appropriated by act approved March 3, 1885..................... $3,000 00
June 30, 186, amount expended during the fiscal year....................                       2,544 04
Amount available for the fiscal year 1886-'87 --.........................--------------------. 2, 000 00
Amount required for survey of Northern and Northwestern lakes for fiscal
  year ending June 30, 1888, namely, for printing and issuing charts for
  the use of navigators, and electrotyping copper-plates for chart-printing. 2, 000 00

                 MILITARY AND GEOGRAPHICAL                                  MAPS.

  The following maps have been photolithographed and an edition
printed :
  Map of the Department of Dakota, scale -          , by Lieut. John Biddle, Corps of
Engineers, 1886.
  Preliminary sketches of sheets 3, 4, 7, 8, and 12 of survey of Western Texas, scale
1 inch to 4 miles, by Maj. W. R. Livermore, Corps of Engineers, 1884.
  Map of a portion of Southeastern Arizona, scale 8 miles to 1 inch, by Lieut. E. J.
Spencer, Corps of Engineers, 1886.
  Map of part of Turkey in Europe, in seven sheets.
  Map of the Arkansas River from Little Rock to its mouth, in 22 sheets, scale 1 inch
to 27400 feet, made under t1e direction of Capt. H. S. Taber, Corps of Engineers, 1886,
372        REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

  Map of the United States and Texas boundary line, determined and surveyed in
1857-'58-'59-'60, by J. H. Clark, United States Commissioner; scale,
  The compilation of a map of Central America on a scale of ~avo has been com-
                                                                                       mm-g.
menced and considerable progress made.
  The compilation of a map of the United States on a scale of r2o                       has been com-
menced.
Amount appropriated by act approved March 5, 1885...... ..............                      $5, 000 00
June 30, 1886, amount expended during the fiscal year .................------------------.      910 55

              RECONNAISSANCES AND EXPLORATIONS.

   The following officers of the Corps of Engineers have been on duty
at the headquarters of the Army and at the divisions and departments,
engaged in preparing such maps and making such surveys as were re-
quired by their respective commanding officers:
    Capt. James F. Gregory, lieutenant-colonel and aid-de-camp to the
Lieutenant-General at headquarters of the Army, to October 10, 1885.
   Maj. Thomas H. Handbury, at headquarters Division of the Missouri.
   Maj. W. . Livermore, at headquarters Department of Texas, to
March 15, 1886.
   Capt. D. C. Kingman, at headquarters Department of the Platte.
   Lieut. Eugene Griffin, at headquarters Division of the Atlantic and
Department of the East, from September 7, 1885, to May 29, 1886.
   Lieut. Thomas L. Casey, at headquarters Division of the Pacific and
Department of California.
   Lieut. Theodore A. Bingham, at headquarters Department of Arizona,
to August 13, 1885; Lieut. E. J. Spencer, from February 1, 1886, to
(late.
   Lieut. John Biddle, at headquarters Department of Dakota.
   Lieut. Edward Burr, at headquarters Department of the Columbia,
from October 22, 1885.
   Maj. T. H. Handbury, engineer officer headquarters Military Division
of the Missouri, reports that his work has consisted in collecting geo-
graphical information for the improvement of existing maps, and in
making copies of maps of military posts, scouts, reconnaissances, and
of military and Indian reservations for use at division headquarters.
   Capt. D. C. Kingman, engineer officer, headquarters Department of
the Platte, reports that he has surveyed and plotted a tract of 80 acres
of land lying north and northwest of Fort Omaha, with a view to its
purchase by the Government for a rifle range, surveyed and re-estab-
lished the southern boundary of the military reservation at Fort D. A.
Russell; also surveyed and set out a rifle range at Bellevue, Nebr. A
map of the department is being compiled under his direction.
   Captain Kingman has also been engaged in the construction of roads
and bridges in the Yellowstone National Park, in accordance with the
provisions of an act of Congress approved March 3, 1883.
    Lieut. T. L. Casey, engineer officer, Division of the Pacific and De-
partment of California, reports that operations have been carried on as
follows:
    Triangulation of proposed rifle ranges for skirmish firing on the
Presidio Reservation, photographing military implements, copying, en-
larging, and reducing maps and drawings by photography, and the
preparation of a new map of the Department of California. In addi-
tion to his duties as engineer officer of the division and department he
has performed the duties of inspector of rifle practice for the Depart-
ment of California, and by order of the President, dated War Depart-
ment, Adjutant-General's Office, Washington, September 24, 1885, was
               ttCONNAISSANCtA      AND) :XP'L t     "O1INS.


detailed as one of the commission to run and mark the boundary line
between a portion of the Indian Territory and the State of Texas, in
connection with a similar commission to be appointed by the State of
Texas.
   Lieut. John Biddle, engineer officer of Department of Dakota, re-
ports the survey of the boundary line of Fort Buford Military Reserva-
tion by Lieut. J. E. Wilson, Fifth Infantry, also an examination and
report by the same officer of the irrigating ditches at the Indian Agencies
at Poplar Creek and Wolf Point, Montana Territory, also a reconnais-
sance made by himself from Fort Shaw, Montana, to the Jocko Indian
Agency and return, to ascertain the practicability of the mountain
passes in that vicinity. A new map of the Department of Dakota has
been completed, photolithographed, and distributed throughout the
department. New information is being collected of the country sur-
rounding the various military posts in the department.
   Lieut. Edward Burr, engineer officer Department of the Columbia,
entered upon his duties October 22, 1885, relieving acting engineer
officer Capt. J. W. MacMurray, First Artillery, and reports that opera-
tions have been carried on as follows:
   A boat reconnaissance of Pend d'Oreille River from Sand Point,
Idaho Territory, to the mouth of Sullivan's Gulch, Washington Terri-
tory, was made during the month of August, 1885, byLieut. W. R. Aber-
crombie, Second ifantry. Lines of levels were run upon the Vancouver
Military Reservation in connection with the sewerage system, contour
map, and for road and building purposes. A survey of the old roads
in the timber reserve was made, and new roads located in the post re-
serve. The work of revision of .the progress sheets of the department
has been continued. Plans were prepared for new and proposed build-
ings for the Quartermaster's Department. New plans of occupied posts
in the department, on a small scale, are being prepared for publication.
A large number of drawings, tracings, and blue prints have been made
for the use of the Quartermaster's Department, Chief Ordnance Officer,
and other staff officers, during the year.
   Lieut. T. A. Bingham, engineer officer department of Arizona, from
July 1, 1885, to August 13, 1885. Capt. C. W. Williams, assistant quar-
termaster, acting engineer officer from August 13, 1885, to November
6, 1885. Capt. J. F. Weston, commissary of subsistence, acting engi-
neer officer from November 6, 1885, to February 1, 1886. Lieut. E. J.
Spencer,'engineer officer, February 1, 1886. During portions of the
months of February and April, and the month of March, Lieutenant
Spencer was engaged in a compass and odometer survey of Cochise and
the eastern portion of Pima counties in Arizona. This work was plotted
and a map prepared on a scale of 4 miles to 1 inch.

ESTIMATE FOR AMOUNT REQUIRED FOR SURVEYS AND
RECONNAISSANCES IN MILITARY DIVISIONS AND DE-
PARTMENTS.

  For military surveys and reconnaissances and surveys of military res-
ervations by the engineer officers attached to the several headquarters
of military divisions and departments, being an average of $5,000 for
each of eight military divisions and departments west of the Mississippi
River, $40,000; for publication of maps for use of the War Department,
$10,000; total, $50,000.
84      REPORT OF    THE   CHIEF OP ENGINEERS, t . S. ARMY.

           OFFICE OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS.

   In the labors of the office the Chief of Engineers was assisted on the
30th of June by the following officers in charge of the several divisions:
   Lieut. Col. John M. Wilson, colonel, U. S. A.
   FIRST DIVISION.-Fortifications and Surveys relating thereto--Arma-
ment of Fortifications-Sitesfor Engineer Defenses-Boards of Engineers
for Defenses.
   SECOND" DIVISION.-Battalion of Engineers-Engineer School of Ap-
plication and Engineer Depot and Post-ProfessionalPapers and Inform-
ation-Personnel- Orders--MilitaryReservations-Land Files.
   Col. John C. Parke, brevet major-general, U. S. A.
   THIRD DivIsIoN.-Improvement of Rivers and Harbors and Surveys
relating thereto-BridgingNavigable Waters of the United States-Public
Buildings and Grounds and Washington Aqueduct.
   Capt. Henry M. Adams.
   FOURTH DIVISION.-Accounts for Disbursements--Contracts--Returne
of Engineer Property and Instruments-Applications for Remittances-
Appropriations and Estimates-Blank Forms.
   FIFTH DIVISION.--Survey of the Lakes--Explorations and Surveys--
Reconnaissances-Maps--Instruments- Claims.
        Very respectfully, your obedient servant,
                                                      J. C. DUANE,
                                          Brig. Gen., Chief of Engineers.
  Hon. WILLIAM C.     ENDICOTT,
                      Secretary of War.
STAT.EMENT SHOWING THE RANK AND THE DUTIES OF OFFICERS OF
THE CORPS OF ENGINEERS DURING THE FISCAL YEAR ENDING JUNE
30 1886.


  RANK AND NAME.                                    DUTIES.



BRIGADIER-GENERAL
    AND CHIEF OF
     ENGINEERS.

John Newton ..........    In command of the Corps of Engineers and in charge of the
  Bvt. Major-General.       Engineer Department. Charged with the supervision of
                            such matters connected with construction of jetties and
                            other works at South Pass, Mississippi River, as require
                            the action of the Secretary of War. In charge of the re-
                            moval of obstructions in the East River and Hell Gate, N.
                            Y. Member of Joint Commission to supervise the con-
                            struction of the Washington National Monument. Di-
                            rected by the President to co-operate with the authorities
                            of the State of New York in examining and deciding upon
                            exterior pier and bulkhead lines on Hudson River from
                            State dam at Troy to the city of Hudson. Member of the
                            Lighthouse Board. Member of Board of Officers and
                            Civilians to examine and report at what ports fortifica-
                            tions or other defenses are most urgently required, &c.

      COLON1FS.

Charles S. Stewart.....   In charge of the construction of Fort Winfield Scott, and
                            batteries at Fort Mason, and fortifications at Angel Island
                            in San Francisco Bay, and at San Diego, Cal. In charge
                            of the improvement of the harbor at San Diego, Cal.
                            Senior member of Board of Engineers for the Pacific Coast.
Charles E. Blunt.......   In charge of Forts Knox, Popham, Gorges, Scammel, Mc-
                            Clary, and batteries at Portland Head and Gerrish's
                            Island, Me., and Fort Constitution and battery at Jerry's
                            Point, N. H., and of construction of Fort Preble, Me. In
                            charge of the improvement of the harbors at Bangor, Bel-
                            fast, Rockland, and Portland, Me., and Portsmouth, N.
                            H. In charge of the improvement of the rivers Penobscot
                            and Kennebunk, Me., and Cocheco, N. H., Saco River
                            Breakwater, Lubec Channel, and Moose-a-bee Bar, Me.
                            In charge of preliminary examination and of survey of
                            Saco River. To take steps towards the removal of wreck
                            of schooner Waldemar in Belfast Harbor, Me. Supervis-
                            ing Engineer over districts embracing works in charge of
                            Majors Smith, Overman, and M. B. Adams, and Captain
                            Maguire.

James C. Duane.......     Member and President of the Board of Engineers. Senior
  Bvt. Brig. General.      member of Board of Visitors for Engineer School of Appli-
                           cation at Willets Point, N. Y. Engineer 3d Lighthouse
                           District. Member of Board of Engineer Officers for the
                           examination of certain officers of the Corps with view to
                           their promotion.
                                                                           375
876      REPORT OF THI          CIHIEF O       ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

Statement showing rank and duties of oficers of Corps of Engineers-Cont'd.

  RANK AND NAME.                                   DUTIES.



      COLONELS.
      (continued.)
Qpincy A. Gillmore....    In charge of Forts Wool,Va.; Caswell, N.C.; Moultrie, Sum-
  Bvt. Major-General.       ter, and Johnson, S, C.; Oglethorpe and Pulaski, Ga., and
                            Clinch, Fla., and of the construction of Forts Wadsworth,
                            Tompkins and its batteries, N. Y.; Monroe, Va., and Castle
                            Pinckney, S. C. In charge of the improvement of the har-
                            bors at Charleston, S. C., and Savannah and Brunswick,
                            Ga. In charge of the improvements of Ashley River and
                            Wappoo Cut, S. C.; Cumberland Sound, Ga. and Fla.;
                            Savannah and Altamaha rivers, and Romerly Marsh, Ga.,
                            and Edisto and Salkahatchie rivers, S. C. In charge of
                            preliminary examination of North Fork of the Edisto River,
                            S. C. Member of Board of Visitors for Engineer School of
                            Application at Willets Point, N. Y. Member of Boards of
                            Engineer Officers on further improvement of Cape Fear
                            River, N. C., and on improvement of the Potomac River
                            near Washington, D. C. Member of Board of Officers to
                            examine into and report upon question of source and
                            method of water-supply, sewerage, &c., at Willets Point,
                            N. Y. Member and president of the Mississippi River
                            Commission created by act of Congress approved June 28,
                            1879. In charge of the removal of sunken lighter in the
                            channel at Elliot's Cut, Charleston Harbor, and to take
                            steps for removal of wreck of barge in Town Creek, near
                             Charleston, S. C.

Thos. Lincoln Casey.. -   Detached; in charge of the construction of the building for
                           the State, War, and Navy departments; of the Washing-
                           ton National Monument; of the improvements over the
                           grave of Thomas Jefferson, at MontiGllo, Va.; of the
                           erection of a pedestal and statue of toe late President
                           James A. Garfield; of a monument at Washington's head-
                           quarters at Newburgh, N. Y.; of the erection of a monu-
                           ment to mark the birthplace of George Washington; and
                           of the erection of building for the Army Medical Museum
                           and Library. Member of Board of Army Officers to de-
                           termine whether the moneys raised and appropriated are
                           sufficient to complete the proposed Bennington Battle
                           Monument in accordance with approved design. Member
                           of Board of Officers on plan of reservoir for additional
                           water-supply for the cities of Washington and Georgetown.
                           Member of Advisory Board to Committee on Ventilation
                           and Acoustics of the House of Representatives.       Mem-
                           ber of the Lighthouse Board.
John G. Parke...     ..   In charge of 3d Division, Office of the Chief oCTEngineers.
  Bvt. Major-General.
LIEUTENANT-COLONELS.
George H. Mendell.....    In charge of the construction of Fort Winfield Scott, fort on
        Bvt. Colonel.       Alcatraz Island, batteries at Fort Mason, fortifications at
                            Angel Island, and defenses at Lime Point, San Francisco
                            Bavy.   Supervising Engineer over districts embracing
                            works in charge of Major Jones and Captains Powell and
                            Payson. In charge of the improvement of the harbors at
                            Oakland and Redwood, and of the construction of the
                            breakwater at Wilmington Harbor, Cal. In charge of the
                            improvement of Petulma Creek, Cal. To investigate the
                            causes tending to decrease the depth of water and dimin-
                            ish the commercial value of San Francisco Harbor. Mem-
                            ber of Board of Engineers for the Pacific Coast. In charge
                            of the removal of the wreck of the steamer Escambia from
                            entrance to San Francisco Harbor.
                     I ANK AND       DUTIES OF OFFICERS.

Statcment showing rank and duties of officers of Corps ofEngineers--Cont'd.

  RANK AND NAME.                                    DUTIES.


LIEUTENANT-COLONELS.
     (continued.)
Henry L. Abbot.......     Member of the Board of Engineers. In charge of fort at
  Bvt. Brig. General.      Willets Point, and of the construction of Fort Schuyler,
                           N. Y. In charge of experiments with torpedoes. Com-
                           manding Engineer Depot and Post of Willets Point, and
                           Battalion of Engineers, and Engineer School of Applica-
                           tion at Willets Point. Member of Board of Visitors for
                           Engineer School of Application at Willets Point, N. Y.
                           Member of Board of Officers and Civilians to examine
                           and report at what ports fortifications or other defenses
                           are urgently required, &c. Member of the Board of Of-
                           ficers to convene in New York City for the purpose of
                           arranging for and witnessing the trial of pneumatic-dyna-
                           mite torpedo guns and to report thereon.       Member of
                           Boards of Engineer Officers on bridge over the Ohio River
                           at or near Cairo, Ill., and for examination of certain offi-
                           cers of the Corps with view to their promotion.

William P. Craighill...   In charge of Fort Carroll, and the construction of Fort Mc-
                            Henry, Md. Supervising Engineer over districts embrac-
                            ing works in charge of Captains Hinman and Bixby,
                            Messrs. S. T. Abort and W. F. Smith. In charge of the
                            improvement of the harbors at Baltimore and Annapolis,
                            Md. In charge of the improvement of New River, Va.,
                            and W. Va., and Great Kanawha and Elk rivers, W. Va.
                            In charge of the survey across the peninsula of Maryland
                            and Delaware to connect by canal the waters of the Dela-
                            ware and Chesapeake bays. Member of Boards of Engi-
                            neer Offices on further improvement of Cape Fear River,
                            N. C.; on improvement of the Potomac River near Wash-
                            ington, D. C.; on subject of permanent improvement of
                            Delaware River and Bay; on plan of reservoir for addi-
                            tional water-supply for the cities of Washington and
                            Georgetown, and on project for improvement of Black
                            Warrior River, Ala. Member of Board of Officers to de-
                            termine whether the moneys raised and appropriated are
                            sufficient to complete the proposed Bennington Battle
                            Monument in accordance with the approved design. To
                            investigate and report upon certain obstructions to navi-
                            gation of Cherrystone Inlet, &c.

Cyrus B. Conmstock ....   Member of the Board of Engineers. In charge of Fort at
   Bvt. Brig. General.     Willets Point, and of the construction of Fort Schuyler,
                           N. Y. In charge of experiments with torpedoes. Com-
                           manding Engineer Depot and Post of Willets Point, and
                           Battalion of Engineers, and Engineer School of Applica-
                           tion at Willets Point. Member of Board of Visitors for
                           Engineer School of Application at Willets Point, N. Y.
                           Supervising Engineer of all expenditures for torpedoes for
                           harbor defense, the Engineer Depot at Willets Point, N.
                           Y., the construction and repair of Fort Schuyler, N. Y.,
                           and the Library of the Engineer School of Application.
                           Member of Boards of Engineer Officers on further improve-
                           ment of Cape Fear River, N. C.; on improvement of the
                           Potomac River near Washington, D. C., and for examina-
                           tion of certain officers of the Corps with view to their
                           promotion. Member of the Mississippi River Commission
                           created by act of Congress approved June 28, 1879.
378      REPORT      OF THE          CH11E      OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ATRMY.

Statement showing rank and duties of oficers of Corps of Engineers-Cont'd.

  RANK AND NAME.                                        DUTIES.
                         i----



LIEUTENANT- COLONELS.
      (continued.)
                  -
Orlando M. Poe.......- In charge of the construction of Fort Wayne, Mich. In
  Bvt. Brig. General.    charge of the improvement of the harbors at Cheboygan
                         and Au Sable on Lake Huron and Alpena at Thunder Bay,
                         and of the construction of harbor of refuge on Lake Hu-
                         ron; of the improvement of the Saint Mary's Falls Canal
                         and River, and of the rivers Detroit, Saginaw, and Clinton,
                         Mich., and Hay Lake Channel of the Saint Mary's River ; of
                         removing bar at ice-harbor of refuge at Belle River, Mich. ;
                         and construction of dry-dock, Saint Mary's Falls Canal.
                         In charge of Saint Clair Flats Canal and Saint Mary's
                         Falls Canal, Mich. In charge of issuing charts of North-
                         ern and Northwestern Lakes, and of water-level observa-
                         tions on Lake Huron. In charge of preliminary examina-
                         tion and of survey of Saint Clair River. To cause plans, es-
                         timates, and specifications for dry-dock, at the Saint Mary's
                         Falls Ship Canal, above the locks, and also to report
                         whether the old locks can be used for a dry-dock, and the
                         cost of fitting the same for that purpose. Member of Boards
                         of Engineer Officers on plan for lock and dam at Grand
                         Rapids, Wabash River; on proposed bridge across the
                         Mississippi River at Minneapolis, &c., and on bridge over
                         the Ohio River at or near Cairo, Ill.
David C. Houston ....        Supervising Engineer of the districts embracing works in
         Bvt. Colonel.         charge of Majors Damrell and Heuer, and Captains Hoxie
                               and Rossell. Member of Board of Engineer Officers to con-
                               sider question of construction of a bridge over the Ala-
                               bama River at Selma, Ala. Member of the Board of En-
                               gineers. In charge of Forts Griswold and Hale, Conn., and
                               Lafayette, N. Y., and of the construction of Forts Trum-
                               bull, Conn., and Columbus and Wood, N. Y.; Castle Will-,
                               iams, South Battery, new Barbette Battery and Sea-wall
                               at Governor's Island, N. Y., and of permanent platform for
                               modern canon of large caliber. In charge of the improve-
                               ment of the harbors of New London, Clinton, New Haven,
                               Milford, Bridgeport, Black Rock, Southport, and Norwalk,
                               Conn., and Port Jefferson, Greenport, Mamaroneck, Port
                               Chester, New Rochelle, and of Echo Harbor, N. Y., and of
                               the construction of breakwater at New Haven, Conn. In
                               charge of the improvement of the rivers Housatonic and
                               Thames, Conn., Connecticut, Mass. and Conn., Flushing
                               Bay, and East Chester Creek, N. Y. In charge of the man-
                               ufacture and supply of Mastic. Member of Board of
                               Visitors for Engineer School of Application at Willets
                                 Point, N, Y,   Reprenting the General Government in the
                                 erection of a pedestal for the statue of Liberty Enlight-
                                 ening the World upon Bedloe's Island, N. Y. H. In tem-
                                 porary charge of Fort at Sandy Hook, N. J., and of the
                                 construction of Fort Hamilton and additional batteries,
                                 and Mortar Battery at Fort Hamilton, N. Y. In tempo-
                                 rary charge of the improvement of the harbors of Rondout
                                 and Saugerties, N. Y., and Keyport, N. J. In temporary
                                 charge of the improvement of theHudson and Harlem riv-
                                 ers, N. Y.; Shrewsbury, Rahway, Elizabeth, Manasquan,
                                 South, Raritan, and Passaic rivers, N. J.; Sheepshead and
                                 Canarsie bays, N. Y., Raritan Bay, N. J.; channelin Gow-
                                 anus Bay and Buttermilk Channel, N. Y.; channel between
                                 Staten Island and New Jersey, and deepening Gedney's
                                 Channel, N. Y.; Woodbridge, Cheesequakes, and Matta-
                                 wan creeks, N. J., Newtown Creek and Sumpawanus Inlet,
                                 N. Y. In temporary charge of the removal of obstructions
                      RANK AND DUTIES OF OFFPICES.

Statement showing rank and duties ofofficers of Corps of Engineers-Cont'd.

   RANK AND NAME.                                       DUTIES.
                          I                  -                     -   -----        --
                                                                               -------
LIEUTENANT-COLONELS.
     (continued.)
                                in East River and Hell Gate, N. Y. Member of Board of
                                Engineer Officers for the examination of certain named offi-
                                cers of the Corps with view to their promotion.
George H. Elliot.......       In charge of the Forts at Clark's Point, Mass., and Dutch
                                Island, R. I., and of the construction of Fort Adams, R. I.
                                In charge of the construction of Harbor of Refuge at Wood's
                                Holl, Mass. In charge of the improvement of the harbors
                                of Nantucket, Wood's Holl, Wareham, and Hyannis, Mass.,
                                Newport and Block Island, R. I., and Stonington, Conn.
                                In charge of the improvement of the rivers Taunton, Mass.,
                                Pawtucket and Providence and Narragansett Bay, R. I.,
                                and Little Narragansett Bay, R. I. and Conn. Member of
                                Advisory Council to the Rhode Island State Board of Harbor
                                Commissioners. To take steps for removal of wrecks of
                                steamer Perkiomen, Nantucket Sound, Mass., and of sunken
                                schooner lying off Point Judith, R. I.
Henry M. Robert ......        In charge of Forts Delaware, Del., and Mifflin, Pa., Fort and
                                Mortar Battery opposite Fort Delaware, Del., and battery
                                and mortar battery at Finn's Point, N. J. In charge of the
                                improvement of the harbor at Delaware Breakwater; Ice-
                                harbors at Marcus Hook, Pa., and the head of Delaware
                                Bay; of the Salem, Rancocas, and Raccoon rivers, and Co-
                                hansey, Mantua, and Woodbury creeks, N. J.; Frankford
                                Creek, Schuylkill River, and north branch of the Susque-
                                hanna River, Pa. ; Delaware River below Bridesburg, Pa.;
                                between Bridesburg and Trenton; near Cherry Island
                                flats; at Schooner ledge; and from Trenton, N. J., to
                                its mouth; and of the construction of pier-near Lewes,
                                Del. Member of Commission Advisory to Board of Harbor
                                Commissioners of Philadelphia. In charge of preliminary
                                examination and of sur-ey of Maquam Bay, Swanton, Vt.
                                In charge of preliminary examination of the mouth of Sal-
                                mon River, and inner natural harbor thereat, on Lake On-
                                tario, N. Y. In charge of the removal from Delaware River
                                of wrecks of steam canal-boat Thomas Carroll, schooners
                                Estella Bright and Annie, and of wreck of ship Adolphus
                                lying off Cape Henlopen, Del.
William E. Merrill.....       In charge of the improvement of the Ohio River; the Falls
        Brt. Colonel.           of the Ohio; the Louisville and Portland Canal, and Har-
                                bor of Refuge near Cincinnati, Ohio. In charge of the im-
                                provement of the Monongahela River, W. Va. and Pa. ; of
                                the Allegheny River, Pa., and of the construction of Ice-
                                harbors at mouth of Muskingum River, Ohio, and mouth of
                                Great Kanawha River, W. Va. In charge of preliminary
                                examination of Muskingum River, Ohio. Engineer 14th
                                Lighthouse District. Member of Boards of Engineer Offi-
                                cers on plan for a lock and dam at Grand Rapids, Wabash
                                River, and on project for improvement of Black Warrior
                                River, Ala.

Walter McFarland .....        In charge of Forts Griswold and Hale, and of the construc-
                                tion of Fort Trumbull, Conn. In charge of the improve-
                                ment of the harbors of New London, Clinton, New Haven,
                                Milford, Bridgeport, Black Rock, Southport, and Norwalk,
                                Conn., and Port Jefferson, Greenport, Mamaroneck, Ron-
                                dout, Port Chester, New Rochelle, Saugerties, and of Echo
                                Harbor, N. Y., and of the construction of breakwater at
                                New Haven, Conn. In charge of the improvement of the
 8()      REPORf      OF       ThE   CHIEF    OF ENGINEERS,       Tr.   S. AItMY

Statement showing rank and duties ofoficers of Corps of Engineers-Cont'd.

   RANK AND NAME.                                      DUTIES.
                           i




LIEUTENANT-COLONELS.
       (continued.)
                                rivers Housaton'e and Thames, Conn., Connecticut, Mass.
                                and Conn., Hudson and Harlem, and Buttermilk Channel,
                                Channel in Gowanus Bay, Flushing Bay, and Newtown
                                Creek, N. Y. In charge of the removal of obstructions
                                in East River and Hell Gate. In charge of removal of
                                wreck of schooner Jane at mouth of New Haven Harbor,
                                Conn. Member of Board of Visitors for Engineer School
                                of Application at Willets Point, N. Y. Member of Board
                                of Engineer Officers on subject of permanent improvement
                                of Delaware River and Bay. In charge of Fort Lafayette,
                                N. Y., and Fort at Sandy Hook, N. J., and of the construc-
                                tion of Forts Columbus, Wood, and Hamilton and addi-
                                tional batteries Castle Williams, South Battery, new Bar-
                                bette Battery, and Sea-wall at Governor's Island, and
                                Mortar Battery at Fort Hamilton, N. Y. In charge of the
                                improvement of Keyport Harbor, N. J. In charge of the
                                improvement of the Shrewsbury, Rahway, Elizabeth,
                                Manasquan, South, Raritan, and Passaic rivers, Raritan
                                Bay, and Woodbridge, Cheesequakes, and Mattawan
                                creeks, N. J.; Sheepshead and Canarsie bays, Sumpawa-
                                nus Inlet, and East Chester Creek, N. Y., and channel be-
                                tween Staten Island and New Jersey, and deepening Ged-
                                ney's Channel, N. Y. In charge of the manufacture and
                                supply of Mastic.

John M, Wilson .....-          In charge of the 1st and 2d Divisions. Office of the Chief
         Bvt. Colonel.           of Engineers. In charge of Public Buildings and Grounds
                                 in the District of Columbia, with the rank of colonel.

John W. Barlow ......- In charge of the improvement of the harbors at Ontonagon,
                         Eagle Harbor, Marquette, Manistique, and Cedar River,
                         Mich., Menomonee, Green Bay, Ahnapee, Two Rivers, Maun-
                         itowoc, Sheboygan, Port Washington, Kewaunee, Pensau-
                         kee, and Oconto, Wis. ; and harbors of refuge at entrance
                         to Sturgeon Bay Canal, Lake Michigan, and Grand Marais,
                         Mich. In charge of water-level observations on Lake Supe-
                         rior. Advisory Engineer for improvement of Kewanne
                         Harbor, Wis. In charge of the improvement of the rivers
                         Tennessee, Tenn., Ala., and Ky., Cumberland above and
                         below Nashville, Ky., and Tenn., Hiawassee, Caney Fork,
                         Duck, French Broad, Clinch, and Little Tennessee, Tenn.,
                         and South Fork of the Cumberland, Ky.
        MAJORS.

Peter C. Hains...... -- -. In charge of Forts Foote and Washington, Md.         In charge
   Bvt. Lieut. Colonel.         of the improvement of the harbors at Washington and
                                Georgetown, D. C. In charge of the improvement of the
                                Potomac River in the vicinity of Washington, D. C., the
                                establishment of the harbor lines, and the raising of the
                                river flats. In charge of the improvement of James River,
                                Va., and Shenandoah River, W. Va. Member of Board of
                                Engineer Officers on improvement of Potomac River in
                                vicinity of Washington, D. C.
George L. Gillespic --..       In charge of Fort Lafayette, N. Y., and Fort at Sandy Hook,
   Bvt. Lieut. Colonel.          N. J., and of the construction of Forts Columbus, Wood,
                                 and Hamilton and additional batteries, Castle Williams,
                                 South, Battery, new Barbette Battery, and Sea-wall at
                                 Governor's Island, and Mortar Battery at Fort Hamilton,
                                 N. Y. In charge of the improvement of Keyport Harbor,
                                 N. J. In charge of the improvement of the Shrewsbury,
                      RANK AND DUTIES OF OFFICERS.                               381
Statementshowing rank and duties of officers of Corps of Engineers--Cont'd.

  RANK AND NAME.                                    DUTIES.


       MAJORS.
     (continued.)
                            Rahway, Elizabeth, Manasquan, South, Raritan, and Pas-
                            saic rivers, Raritan Bay, and Woodbridge, Cheesequakes,
                            and Mattawan creeks, N. J.; Sheepshead,and Canarsie bays,
                            Sumpawanus Inlet, and East Chester Creek, N. Y., and
                            channel between Staten Island and New Jersey, and deepen-
                            ing Gedney's Channel, N. Y. In charge of the manufacture
                            and supply of Mastic. In charge of the removal of the
                            wreck of steamer Nankin at entrance to New York Harbor.
                            To represent the General Government in the arrangement
                            for, and the erection of, a pedestal to be built to receive
                            the colossal bronze statue of Liberty Enlightening the
                            World, to be erected upon Bedloe's Island, N. Y. H. In
                            charge of preliminary examination and of survey of Hud-
                            son River, New Jersey side, from Weehawken to Bergen
                             Point. Member of Board of Engineer Officers on subject
                             of permanent improvment of Delaware River and Bay.
                             Member of Board of Officers to determine whether the
                            moneys raised and appropriated are sufficient to complete
                            the proposed Bennington Battle Monument in accordance
                             with the approved design. In charge of Forts Winthrop,
                            Standish, Andrew, Independence, and work on Long Island
                             Head, and of the construction of Fort Warren, Mass. In
                             charge of the improvement of the harbors at Newbury-
                            port, Lynn, Boston (including sea-walls on Point Allerton,
                             Great Brewster Island, Lovell's Island, Gallops Island,
                             Long Island Head, Rainsford Island, and Deer Island;
                             Mystic and Charles rivers; and channel leading to Nan-
                             tasket Beach), Provincetown, Plymouth, and Scituate,
                             Mass. In charge of construction of a national harbor of
                             refuge (of the first class) at Sandy Bay, Cape Ann, Mass.
                             In charge of the improvement of the rivers Merrimac and
                             Malden, Mass.

Charles R. Suter_.......   In charge of the improvement of the Missouri River from its
                             mouth to Sioux City, Iowa. Member of the Mississippi
                             River Commission created by act of Congress approved
                             June 28, 1879. Member and president of the Missouri
                             River Commission, created by act of Congress approved
                             July 5, 1884. Engineer 15th Lighthouse District.
Jared A. Smith ........    Engineer 5th and 6th Lighthouse Districts.      In charge
                            of Forts Knox, Popham, Gorges, Scamrmel, McClary,
                            and batteries at Portland Head and Gerrish's Island, Me.,
                            and Fort Constitution and Battery at Jerry's Point, N. H.,
                            and of construction of Fort Preble, Me. In charge of the
                            improvement of the harbors at Bangor, Belfast, Rockland,
                            and Portland, Me., and Portsmouth, N. H. In charge of
                            the improvement of the rivers Penobscot and Kennebunk,
                            Me., and Cocheco, N. H., Saco River Breakwater, Lubec
                            Channel, and Moose-a-bee Bar, Me. To take steps towards
                             the removal of the wreck of the schooner Waldemar in
                            Belfast Harbor, Me.

Samuel M. Mansfield,       In charge of the improvement of the harbors at Galveston
Bvt. Lieut. Colonel.        and Brazos Santiago, Tex. In charge of the improve-
                             ment of ship channel in Galveston Bay, Pass Cavallo,
                             Aransas Pass and Bay up to Rockport and Corpus Christi,
                             Brazos River, Buffalo Bayou, deepening channel at mouth
                             of Trinity River and removal of obstructions to Liberty,
                             and the protection of river bank at Fort Brown, Tex.
                             Engineer 10th and 11th Lighthouse Districts. Member of
                             commission to run and mark the boundary lines between
                             a portion of the Indian Territory and the State of Texas,
382         REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. P. ARMY.

Statement showing rank and duties of officers of Corps of Engineers--Cont'd.

  RANK AND NAME.                                       DUTIES.

        -                --       --      -   ---                                        --



       MAJORS.
      (continued.)
William R. King.......        In charge of the improvement of the rivers Tennessee, Tenn.,
                                Ala., and Ky., Cumberland above and below Nashville,
                                Ky. and Tenn., Hiawassee, Caney Fork, Duck, French
                                Broad, Clinch, and Little Tennessee, Tenn., and South
                                Fork of the Cumberland, Ky. In charge of preliminary
                                examinations of Cumberland River above the mouth of
                                Jellico and Holston River, Tenn., and extension of survey
                                of Caney Fork River to Frank's Ferry, Tenn. Member of
                                Boards of Engineer Officers on plan for a lock and dam at
                                Grand Rapids, Wabash River, and on project for improve-
                                ment of Black Warior River, Ala. Commanding Bat-
                                talion of Engineers. In charge of Torpedoes for harbor
                                defense and the Engineer Depot at Willets Point, N. Y.
Wm.   H H. Benyaurd..         In charge of improvement of the harbors at Chicago and Calu-
                                met, Ill. In charge of the improvement of the Illinois
                                and Calumet rivers. In charge of survey of the Henne-
                                pin Canal, and for enlargement of Illinois and Michigan
                                Canal. In charge of preliminary examination and of sur-
                                vey of Caluimet River, east of Hammond to the forks of
                                the river.

Garret J. Lydeeker ...        In charge of the Washington Aqueduct; increasing water
                                supply of the city of Washington, and the erection of fish-
                                ways at Great Falls of the Potomac River. Engilneer
                                Commissioner of the District of Columbia. Member of
                                board of officers on plan of reservoir for additional water
                                supply for the cities of Washington and Georgetown.
Amos Stickney.........        In charge of 4th District of the Mississippi River, from
                                Warrenton to Head of the Passes, for the purpose of im-
                                provement and the construction and repair of levees, to
                                include levees and special work on the river, the improve-
                                ment of the harbor at New Orleans, the Mississippi River
                                at Natchez and Vidalia, the mouth of Red River, and the
                                rectification of the Red and Atchafalaya rivers at mouth
                                of Red River. Member of Board of Engineer Officers on
                                building and repair of levees on the Mississippi River. In
                                charge of the Louisville and Portland Canal. In charge
                                of the improvement of the Falls of the Ohio River, Wa-
                                bash River, Ind. and Ill., and White River, Ind.
Alexander Mackenzie..         In charge of the improvement of the harbor at Rock Island,
                                Ill. In charge of the improvement of the Mississippi River
                                from Saint Paul to Des Moines Rapids; the Upper Missis-
                                sippi River, and Rock Island Rapids and Des Moines Rapids
                                of the Mississippi River; and of removing bar in Mississippi
                                River opposite Dubuque, Iowa. In charge of the con-
                                struction of a dry-dock at the Des Moines Rapids Canal;
                                of ice-harbor at Dubuque, Iowa, and of harbors of refuge
                                on Lake Pepin at Stockholm, Wis., and Lake City, Minn.
                                In charge of operating the Des Moines Rapids Canal.
                                Member of the Missouri River Commission, created by act
                                of Congress approved July 5, 1884. Member of Boards of
                                Engineer Officers on plan for lock and dam at Grand Rap-
                                ids, Wabash River; on proposed bridge across the Mis-
                                sissippi River at Minneapolis, &c., and on bridge over the
                                Ohio River at or near Cairo, Ill,
                          RANK AND DUTIES OF OFFICERS.                                   383
Statementshowing rankand duties of of cers of Corpsof Engineers--Cont'd.

   RANK AND NAME.                                          DUTIES.
                           i---~-.    -   --..-   .-                       -   -     -
                     -




         MAJORS.
      (continued.)
Oswald H. Ernst .......       In charge of the improvement of Mississippi Riverbetween
                                the months of the Illinois and Ohio rivers, opposite Saint
                                Louis, Mo., and at Cape Girardeau, Mo., and Minton's
                                Point, and the harbor at Alton, Ill. Member of the Mis-
                                souri River Commission, created by act of Congress ap-
                                 proved July 5, 1884.

David P. Heap .........        Detached; Engineer Secretary to the Lighthouse Board.
William Ludlow ......         .On leave of absence for one year from April 1, 1885, under
  JBvt. Lieut. Colonel.              provisions of joint resolution of Congress approved Feb-
                                     ruary 13, 1885. Detached; Engineer Commissioner of the
                                     District of Columbia.
William A. Jones......         In charge of the improvement of the Columbia River at
                                 Cascades, Oreg., Upper and Lower Columbia and Snake
                                 rivers, Oreg. and Wash., Willamette River above Port-
                                 land, and Lower Willamette River below Portland, Oreg.,
                                 Cowlitz River, Wash., Yamhill River, Oreg., and Lower
                                 Clearwater River, Idaho. In charge of survey of Columbia
                                 River above mouth of Snake River, Wash.
Andrew N. Damrell....          In charge of Forts Morgan and Gaines, Ala., and fort on Ship
                                 Island, Miss.   In charge of the improvement of the har-
                                 bor at Mobile, Ala. In charge of the improvement of the
                                 rivers Black Warrior, Ala., Pascagoula, Pearl, and Noxu-
                                 bee, Miss., Tombigbee, Ala. and Miss., the roadstead lead-
                                 ing into Back Bay of Biloxi in Mississippi Sound, chan-
                                 nel of Biloxi Bay, and Old Town Creek and Horn Island
                                 Pass, Miss. In charge of preliminary examinations and of
                                 surveys of Wacissa River, and Pascagoula River from the
                                 mills at Moss Point to the anchorage in the bay. Member
                                 of Boards of Engineer Officers to consider question of a
                                 bridge over the Alabama River at Selma, Ala., and on proj-
                                 ect for improvementof Black Warrior River, Ala.

Charles J. Allen .......       In charge of the improvement of the harbors of Duluth,
                                 Grand Marais, and Superior Bay, on Lake Superior. In
                                 charge of the improvement of the Chippewa River, and
                                 protection of sand-banks on the same; of the Minnesota
                                 and Saint Croix rivers, and the Red River of the North;
                                 of the Mississippi River above the Falls of Saint Anthony;
                                 of the Falls of Saint Anthony; construction of Meeker's
                                 Island lock and dam, and lock and dam at Goose Rapids
                                 on Red River of the North. In charge of the construction
                                 of reservoirs at headwaters of the Mississippi River and
                                 its tributaries. In charge of the examination and surveys
                                 of the sources of the Mississippi, Saint Croix, Chippewa,
                                 and Wisconsin rivers, with a view to ascertaining the
                                 practicability and cost of creating and maintaining res-
                                 ervoirs, &c. Member of Boards of Engineer Officers on
                                 proposed bridge across the Mississippi River at Minneapo-
                                 lis, &c., and on bridge over the Ohio River at or near
                                 Cairo, Ill.
Charles W. Raymond ..           In charge of Forts Winthrop, Standish, Andrew, Independ-
                                  ence, and work on Long Island Head, and of the con-
                                  struction of Fort Warren, Mass. In charge of the im-
                                  provement of the harbors at Newburyport, Lynn, Boston
                                  (including sea-walls on Point Allerton, Great Brewste
384      REPORT OF THE CHIEF                OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

Statementshowingrank and duties of officers of Corpsof Engineers-Cont'd.


  RANK AND NAME.                                      DUTIES.
                         i



       MAJORS.
      (continued.)
                              Island, Lovell's Island, Long Island Head, Rainsford Island,
                              and Deer Island; Mystic and Charles rivers ; and channel
                              leading to Nantasket Beach), Provincetown, Plymouth,
                              and Scituate, Mass. In charge of construction of a na-
                              tional harbor of refuge (of the first class) at Sandy Bay,
                              Cape Ann, Mass. In charge of the improvement of the
                              rivers Merrimac and Malden, Mass. Engineer, tempo-
                              rarily, of 1st and 2d Lighthouse Districts. In charge of
                              Fourth District of the Mississippi River, from Warrenton
                              to Head of the Passes, for the purpose pf improvement
                               and the construction and repair of levees, to include levees
                              and special work on the river, the. improvement of the
                              harbor at New Orleans, the Mississippi River at Natchez
                              and Vidalia, the mouth of Red River, and the rectification
                              of the Red and Atchafalaya rivers at mouth of Red River.
                              Member of Board of Engineer Officers on building and
                              repair of levees on the Mississippi River.
L. Cooper Overman----        In charge of the improvement of harbors at Port Clinton,
                               Monroe, Toledo, Sandusky, Huron, Vermillion, Black
                               River, Rocky River, Cleveland, Fairport, Conneaut, and
                               Ashtabula, Ohio, and Dunkirk, N. Y. In charge of im-
                               provement of Sandusky River, Ohio. In charge of water-
                               level observations on Lake Erie. In charge of the re-
                               moval of wreck of schooner J. J. Hill, in Fairport Harbor,
                               Ohio.
Alexander M. Miller --... In charge of the improvement of the rivers Mississippi and
                               Missouri, removal of snags, &c.; Osage River, Mo. and
                               Kans.; Gasconade River, Mo.; Wabash River, Ind. and
                               Ill., and White River, Ind. Member of Board of Engineer
                               Officers on lock and dam at Grand Rapids, Wabash River.
Milton B. Adams ...... In charge of the construction of Fort Montgomery, N. Y. In
                         charge of the improvement of the harbors at Ogdensburg,
                         on the river Saint Lawrence, and Plattsburg, Burlington,
                         and Swanton, and construction of breakwater at Rouse's
                         Point, on Lake Champlain. In charge of the improve-
                         ment of Ticouderoga and Grass rivers, N. Y., and Otter
                         Creek, Vt.
Win. R. Livermore       - - Detached; Engineer Officer, Department of Texas. Member
                             of Commission to run and mark the boundary lines be-
                             tween a portion of the Indian Territory and the State of
                             Texas. Member of general court-martial to meet at Fort
                             Clark, Tex., August 12, 1885. In charge of the improve-
                             ment of the Missouri River from its mouth to Sioux City,
                             Iowa.
William H. Heuer ....        In charge of Forts Taylor and Jefferson, Fla., Jackson, St.
                               Philip, Livingston, Pike, and Macomb, Tower Dupr6,
                               Battery Bienvenue, and Tower at Proctorsville, La. In
                               charge of the improvement of the Amite, Tangipahoa,
                               Tickfaw, Tchefuncte, Bogue Falia, and Calcasieu rivers,
                               bayous Terrebonne, Teche, Black, and Courtableau, and
                               Calcasieu Pass, La., Sabine Pass, Blue Buck Bar, and
                               Neches River, Tex., and Sabine River, La. and Tex., and
                               of removal of obstructions in Bayou La Fourche, La. In
                               charge of connecting Bayou Teche with Grand Lake at
                               Charenton, La. To report upon the depth and width of a
                               channel secured and maintained by jetties constructed b)
                          RANK AND DUTIES OF OFFICER$.                                  385

Statement showing rank aud duties of officers of Corps of Engineers--Cont'd.


   RANK AND NAME.                                          DUTIES.

                           I

         MAJORS.
      (continued.)
                                 James B. Eads at the mouth of the Mississippi River. In
                                 charge of removal of wrecks in Mississippi River in front
                                 of the wharves at New Orleans, La., and of wreck of
                                 steamer John M. Chambers in Bayou Teche. In charge of
                                 preliminary examinations of Atchafalaya River above Ber-
                                 wick Bay, and Bayou Pierre, Miss. Engineer 7th and 8th
                                 Lighthouse Districts. Member of Board of Engineer Offi-
                                 cers on subject of permanent improvement of Delaware
                                 River and Bay.
William S. Stanton .-...       Detached; on duty at the Military Academy as instructor of
                                practical military engineering, and in command of Com-
                                pany E, Battalion of Engineers. Member of general court-
                                 martial to meet at West Point, N. Y., August 17, 1885.
                                Engineer of 1st and 2d Lighthouse Districts.
Thomas H. Handbury..           Engineer Officer Division of the Missouri. In temporary
                                charge of improvement of the harbors at Chicago and Cal-
                                umet, Ill. In temporary charge of the improvement of
                                the Illinois and Calumet rivers. In temporary charge of
                                 survey of the Hennepin Canal.
        CAPTAINS.

James C. Post .........        In charge of the improvement of the Little Kanawha, Guy-
                                 andotte, and Buckhannon rivers, W. Va.; the Big Sandy
                                 River, W. Va. and Ky., and the Kentucky and Tradewater
                                 rivers, Ky. In charge of preliminary examination and of
                                 survey of Rough River, Ky. Member of Board of Engineer
                                 Officers on project for improvement of Black Warrior River,
                                 Ala.
James F. Gregory .....         Detached ; aid-de-camp on the personal staff of the Lieuten-
                                ant-General of the Army, with the rank of lieutenant-
                                colonel. Engineer Officer, Headquarters of the Army. On-
                                temporary duty in Office of the Chief of Engineers. De-
                                tached; Engineer 5th and 6th Lighthouse Districts.
Henry M. Adams ......          In charge of the 4th and 5th Divisions, Office of the Chief of
                                 Engineers.
Charles E. L. B. Davis. Engineer 10th and 11th Lighthouse Districts. In charge
                         of the improvement of the harbors at Ontonagon,
                         Eagle Harbor, Marquette, Manistique, and Cedar River,
                          Mich.; Menomonee, Green Bay, Ahnepee, Two Rivers,
                         Manitowoc, Sheboygan, Port Washington, Kewaunee,
                         Pensaukee, and Oconto, Wis. In charge of harbors of
                         refuge at entrance to Sturgeon Bay Canal, Lake Michigan,
                          and Grand Marais, Mich. In charge of water-level obser-
                         vations on Lake Superior. Advisory Engineer for improve-
                          ment of Kewaunee Harbor, Wis.

George M. Wheeler.....         On temporary duty to supervise certain publications pertain-
                                ing to Geographical Surveys West of the 100th Meridian.
James B. Quinn.......          In charge of the improvement of the Yellowstone River; and
                                 the Missouri River from Sioux City, Iowa, to Fort Benton,
                                 Mont.
Daniel W. Lockwood ..          In charge of the improvement of the harbors at Charlevoix,
                                 Frankfort, Manistee, Ludington, Pentwater, White River,
                                 Muskegon, Grand Haven, Black Lake, Saugatuck, South
         25 E
386      REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

Statement showing rank and duties of officers of Corpsof Engineers-Contd.

   RANK AND NAME.                                   DUTIES.



       CAPTAINS.
      (continued.)
                            Haven, New Buffalo, and Saint Joseph, and harbor of
                            refuge at Portage Lake, Mich., and harbor at Michigan
                            City, Ind. In charge of the improvement of Grand River
                            from its mouth to city of Grand Rapids, Mich.
Ernest H. Ruffner .....   In charge of the improvement of the Mississippi River be-
                            tween Des Moines Rapids and the mouth of the Illinois
                            River. To take steps for removal of wreck of steamer A.
                            M. Jarrett, and of flat-boat in Mississippi River at Quincy
                            Bay.

John C. Mallery.......    Detached; Engineer 4th Lighthouse District.
Clinton B. Sears.......   In charge of 3d District of the Mississippi River, from mouth
                            of White River to Warrenton, for the purpose of improve-
                            ment and the construction and repair of levees, to include
                            the improvement of the harbor at Vicksburg, Miss. Mem-
                            ber of Board of Engineer Officers on building and repair
                            of levees on the Mississippi River. In charge, temporarily,
                            of 1st and 2d Districts of the Mississippi River.

Thomas Turtle ........    Detached ; secretary and disbursing officer of the Mississippi
                           River Commission created by act of Congress approved
                           June 28, 1879. Member of board of survey to examine
                           into and fix the responsibilty for the loss of certain ves-
                           sels, &c., used upon the improvement of the Mississippi
                           River. Temporarily secretary and assissant to the con-
                           struction committee of the Mississippi River Commission,
                           and disbursing officer for works carried on by the Com-
                           mission.

Edward Maguire ......     In charge of the construction of Forts Porter, Niagara, and
                            Ontario, N. Y. In charge of the improvement of the har-
                            bors at Erie, Pa., and Buffalo, Wilson, Olcott, Oak Orchard,
                            Charlotte, Pultneyville, Great Sodus, Little Sodus, Os-
                            wego, and Sackett's Harbor, N. Y. In charge of the im-
                            provement of Niagara River, N. Y. In charge of water-
                            level observations on Lake Ontario. Secretary of board
                            of officers and civilians to examine and report at what
                            ports fortifications or other defenses are most urgently re-
                            quired, &c. To locate and map a rock in the Saint Law-
                            rence River six or eight miles below Dark Island.
Frederick A. Mahan...     Detached; assistant to the Engineer Commissioner of the
                           District of Columbia,.
Charles F. Powell......   In charge of Fort Stevens, Oreg., and of the construction of
                            Fort Canby, Wash. In charge of the improvement of the
                            mouth of the Columbia River, Oreg. and Wash., entrance
                            to Coos Bay and entrance to Yaquina Bay, and mouth of
                            Coquille River, Oreg. In charge of the improvement of
                            the Columbia and Lower Willamette rivers below Port-
                            land, and Umpqua River, Oreg., and of the rivers Cheha-
                            lis., Skagit. Stielaq namish, Nootsack. Snohomish, and Sno-
                            qualmie, Wash. In charge of water-gauges on the Co-
                            lumbia River from Astoria to the bar. Engineer 13th
                            Lighthouse District. In temporary charge of the im-
                            provement of the Columbia River at Cascades, Oreg.,
                            Upper Columbia and Snake rivers, Oreg. and Wash., Wil-
                            lamette River above Portland, Oreg , Cowlitz River, Wash.,
                            Yamhill River, Oreg., and Lower ClearwaterRiver, Idaho.
                            In temporary charge of survey of Columbia River above
                            mouth of Snake River, Wash. In charge of preliminary
                            examination and of survey of Olympia Harbor, Wash.
                     .SANK AND DUTTI1S             Or O PIC1tfS.                      387
Statement showing rank and duties of officers of Corps of Engineers-Cont'd.

   RANK AND NAME.                                      DUTIES.

                         I




       CAPTAINS.
      (continued.)
Frederick A. Hinman..        In charge of the improvement of the harbor at Norfolk and
                               the approach to Norfolk Harbor and the United States
                               navy-yard, Va. In charge of the improvement of the
                               Blackwater, Nottoway, Archer's Hope, and Appomattox
                               rivers, Va., Scuppernong, Pamplico, Tar, Yadkin, and
                               Meherrin rivers, Currituck Sound, Coanjok and Edenton
                               Bays, and North River Bar, N. C., and North Landing
                               River, Va. and N. C. Member of board advisory to State
                               harbor commissioners of Norfolk and Portsmouth, Va. To
                               take preliminary steps for removal of wreck of schooner
                               Lawrence from Scuppernong River, N. C. In charge of
                               the removal of wrecks of schooners Tarry Not and Anthea
                               Godfrey, and steamer Concord, on Craney Island Flats,
                               Va., in Lynn Haven Roads, Va., and in Pamplico River,
                               N. C., respectively.
Albert H. Payson.            In charge of the improvement of Humboldt Harbor and Bay,
                               Cal. In charge of the improvement of the Sacramento,
                               Feather, San Joaquin, and Mokelumne rivers, Cal., and
                               Colorado River, Nev., Cal., and Ariz. Engineer 12th
                               Lighthouse District.
John G. D. Knight.           Commanding Company A, Battalion of Engineers. In
                              charge of the construction of Fort Schuyler, N. Y. H. Mem-
                              ber of General Courts-Martial, to meet at Willets Point,
                              N. Y., July 29 and November 2, 1S85, and .May 3, 1886.
Richard L. Hoxie......       In charge of Forts Pickens and McRee and the construction
                               of Fort Barrancas and redoubt, Fla. In charge of the im-
                               provement of Pensacola Harbor, Fla. In charge of the im-
                               provement of the rivers Coosa and Chattahoochee, Ga.
                               and Ala., Ocmulgee, Oconee, Oostenaula, Coosawattee,
                               and Flint, Ga., Choctawhatchee and Conecuh-Escambia,
                               Fla. and Ala., Escambia, Fla., Alabama, Caha wba, and
                               Tallapoosa, Ala., and La Grange Bayou, Fla. In charge
                               of examination or survey of Clear Water Harbor and Up-
                               per Oconee River, from Skull Shoals to the Georgia Rail-
                               road Bridge. Member of Board of Engineer Officers to
                               consider question of construction of a bridge over the Ala-
                               bama River at Selma, Ala.
William L. Marshall...       In charge of the improvement of the harbors at Milwaukee,
                               Racine, and Kenosha, Wis., and Waukegan, Ill., and har-
                               bor of refuge at Milwaukee Bay, Wis. In charge of the
                               improvement of the rivers Fox and Wisconsin. In charge
                               .of water-level observations on Lake Michigan. In tempo-
                               rary, charge of the improvement of the harbors at Ontona-
                               gon, Eagle Harbor, Marquette,Manistique,and Cedar River,
                               Mich., Menomonee, Green Bay, Ahnapee, Two Rivers,
                               Manitowoc, Sheboygan, Port Washington, Kewaunee,
                               Pensanukee, Oconto, and harbors of refuge at entrance to
                               Sturgeon Bay Canal, Lake Michigan, and Grand Marais,
                               Mich. In temporary charge of water-level observations
                               on Lake Superior. Advisory engineer for improvement of
                               Kewaunee Harbor, Wis.
Joseph H. Willard.....       Secretary and assistant to the construction committee of
                              the Mississippi River Commission created by act of Con-
                               gress approved June 28, 1879, and disbursing officer
                              for works carried on by the Commission. Member of Board
                               of Survey to examine into and fix the responsibility for the
388       REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

Statementshowingrank and duties of officers of Corps of Engineers-Cont'd

   RANK AND NAME.                                    DUTIES.



       CAPTAINS.
      (continued.)
                             loss of certain vessels, &c., used upon the improvement
                             of the Mississippi River. In charge of the improvement
                             of Tensas River and Bayou Macon, and Cane River, La.,
                             Ouachita and Black River and Bayou Bartholomew in La.
                             and Ark., Bayous Bajuf and D'Arbonne, Loggy Bayou,
                             Lake Bisteneau, and the Dorcheat, La., and Cypress Bayou,
                             La. and Tex.; Red River, La., and South Forked Deer
                             River, Tenn.; of the rivers Big Sun Flower, Yazoo, Yalla-
                             busha, Big Black, and Tallahatchie, and Tchula Lake
                             and Steel's Bayou, Miss., and the Big Hatchie River, Tenn.
                             In charge of survey of Bayou Pierre, La. In charge of
                             the water-gauges on the Lower Mississippi River and its
                             principal tributaries.

Philip M. Price........    Commanding Company C, Battalion of Engineers. Mem-
                            ber of General Court Martial to meet at Willets Point, N.
                            Y., October 12. Detached; on duty at the Military Acad-
                            emy as instructor of Practical Military Engineering, and
                            in command of Company E, Battalion of Engineers. In
                            charge of water-works and supply line, and Acting Signal
                             Officer at West Point, N. Y.

Francis V. Greene .....    Detached; on duty at the Military Academy as instructor
                             of Practical Military Engineering, and in command of
                             Company E, Battalion of Engineers. Acting Signal Offi-
                             cer at West Point, N. Y. On leave of absence until De-
                             cember 31, 1886.
Carl F. Palfrey ........   On duty under the immediate orders of Captain Lockwood.

William H. Bixby .....     In charge of Fort Macon, N. C. In charge of the improve-
                             ment of Beaufort Harbor, N. C., and Georgetown Harbor,
                             S. C. In charge of the improvement of Cape Fear River
                             above and below Wilmington, Neuse, Trent, and New
                             Rivers, N. C., and Santee, Wateree, Great Pee Dee, and
                             Waccamaw rivers, S. C., and Contentnia or Moccasin
                             River, N. C. In charge of examinations or surveys of
                             Black River, and entrance to Winyaw Bay, near George-
                             town, and of survey of Northeast Branch of Cape Fear
                             River. To take necessary steps towards removal of wrecks
                             from Cape Fear River below Wilmington, N. C.

Henry S. Taber........      In charge of protection of harbor at Fort Smith, Ark. In
                              charge of the improvement of the Arkansas River, removal
                              of snags, &c.; Arkansas River between Fort Smith, Ark.,
                              and Wichita, Kans, ; and at Pine Bluff, and of rivers Saint
                              Francis, White, L'Anguille, and Saline, Ark., and Black,
                              Mo. and Ark. In charge of survey of Arkansas River
                              from Fort Gibson to Wichita, Kans., and from Little Rock
                              to its mouth.
Eric Bergland .........    ,In charge of the improvement of Tensas and Bayou Macon
                              and Cane Rivers, La.; Ouachita and Black River and Ba-
                              you Bartholomew, in La. and Ark.; Bayous Bmuf and
                              D'Arbonne, Loggy Bayou, Lake Bisteneau, and the Dor-
                              cheat, La., and Cypress Bayou, La. and Tex.; Red River,
                              La., and South Forked Deer River, Tenn.; of the rivers
                              Big Sun Flower, Coldwater, Yazoo, Yallabusha, Big Black,
                              and Tallahatchie, and Tchula Lake, and Steel's Bayou,
                              Miss., and the Big Hatchie River, Tenn. In charge of sur-
                              vey of Bayou Pierre, La. In charge of the water-gauges
                              on the Lower Mississippi River and its principal tribu-
                              taries. In charge of examination or survey of Red River
                              from its mouth to Fulton.
                       RANK        AND DUTIES OF OFFICERS.                              389
Statement showingrank and dutiesof Oficers of Corps of Engineers-Cont'd.

   RANK AND NAME.                                        DUTIES.
                           I                                  -



       CAPTAINS.
      (continued.)
William T. Rossell. ....       In charge of Forts Marion, Taylor, and Jefferson, Fla. In
                                 charge of the improvement of the harbors at Key West,
                                 Tampa Bay, and Cedar Keys, Fla. In charge of the im-
                                 provement of the Saint John's River (at channel over bar
                                 at mouth, and upper Saint John's River), Volusia Bar,
                                 Caloosahatchee, Manatee, Withlacoochee, Suwannee, and
                                 Apalachicola rivers, Apalachicola Bay, and Pease Creek,
                                 Fla. In charge of the examination and surveys of Mos-
                                 quito Inlet, and for canal and inland communication from
                                 Saint John's River through Mosquito Lagoon and Indian
                                 River to Jupiter Inlet and Lake Worth, Fla. To take
                                 preliminary steps toward removal of wreck of steamer Dic-
                                 tator from harbor of Tampa, Fla., and of wreck of scow in
                                 Tampa Bay. In charge of 3d District of the Missis-
                                 sippi River, from mouth of White River to Warrenton, for
                                 the purpose of improvement and the construction and re-
                                 pair of levees, to include the improvement of the harbor
                                 at Vicksburg, Miss. Member of board of Engineer Offi-
                                 cers on building and repair of levees on the Mississippi
                                 River.

                                 .
Thom as N. Bailey ...... Commanding Company B, Battalion of Engineers. Member
                          of General Courts-Martial, to meet at Willets Point, N.
                          Y., July 29, October 12, and November 2, 1885, and Febru-
                          ary 23, 1886.
Thomas W. Symons....           On duty under the immediate orders of Major Lydeoker as
                                his assistant in connection with the Washington Aqueduct
                                and the extension thereof. Recorder of Board of Officers
                                on plan of reservoir for additional water-supply for the
                                cities of Washington and Georgetown. Detached ; assist-
                                ant to the Engineer Commissioner of the District of Co-
                                lumbia.
Smith S. Leach........         In charge of 1st District of the Mississippi River, from Cairo
                                 to foot of Island No. 40, and 2d District, from foot of
                                 Island No. 40 to mouth of White River, for the purpose
                                 of improvement and the construction and repair of levees.
                                 Member of Board of Engineer Officers on building and re-
                                 pair of levees on the Mississippi River.
Dan C. Kingman......           Detached; Engineer Officer Department of the Platte. Des-
                                ignated to carry out provisions of act of Congress for im-
                                provement of Yellowstone National Park.
FIRST LIEUTENANTS.

Eugene Griffin.........        Detached; on duty at the Military Academy as Assistant
                                Professor of Civil and Military Engineering. Aid-de-camp
                                on the staff of the Major-General commanding Division
                                of the Atlantic. Engineer Officer Division of the Atlantic
                                and Department of the East. Assistant to the Engineer
                                Commissioner of the District of Columbia.
Willard Young.........         On duty under the immediate orders of Major Jones, and
                                temporarily under Captain Powell.
William M. Black ...... Detached ; on duty at the Military Academy as Assistant In-
                         structor of Practical Military Engineering, and with Com-
                         pany E, Battalion of Engineers. Recruiting Officer of
                         Company E, Battalion of Engineers. Officer in charge of
390      REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

Statementshowingrank and duties of ofiers of Corpsof Enginers--Cont'd.

  RANK AND NAME.                                        DUTIEs.
                          I               -            -
  FIRST LIEUTENANTS.
      (continued.)
                               Post Schools. Member of Railroad Board at West Point,
                               N. Y. Member of General Court Martial to meet at West
                               Point, July 1, 1885. On duty under the immediate orders
                               of Captain Rossell. In charge of Fort Marion, Fla. In
                               charge of the improvement of the harbors at Key West,
                               Tampa Bay, and Cedar Keys, Fla. In charge of the im-
                               provement of the Saint John's River (at channel over bar
                               at mouth, and Upper Saint John's River), Volusia Bar,
                               Caloosahatchee, Manatee, Withlacoochee, Suwannee, and
                               Apalachicola rivers, Apalachicola Bay, and Pease Creek,
                               Fla. To take preliminary steps toward removal of wrecks
                               of steamer Dictator from harbor of Tampa, and scow in
                               Tampa Bay, Fla.
Walter L. Fisk ........ Detached; secretary and disbursing officer of the Missouri
                         River Commission. On duty at the Military Academy as
                         Assistant Professor of Civil and Military Engineering.
Solomon W. Roessler...    Adjutant and Treasurer of the Battalion of Engineers and
                           Post of Willets Point, and Signal Officer and Recruiting
                           Officer, Post of Willets Point. Commanding Company D,
                           Battalion of Engineers. Inspector of Rifle Practice, Bat-
                           talion of Engineers. In charge of the library of the En-
                           gineer School of Application. To inspect certain unserv-
                           iceable public property at Fort Schuyler, N. Y. Member
                           of General Court Martial to meet at Willets Point, N. Y.,
                           May 3, 1886.
George McC. Derby....     On duty in connection with the removal of obstructions in
                           East River and Hell Gate, N. Y. On duty under the im-
                           mediate orders of Lieutenant-Colonel McFarland.

James L. Lusk ........    Quartermaster Battalion of Engineers. Acting Assistant
                           Quartermasterand Acting Commissary of Subsistence, Post
                           of Willets Point.

Frederic V. Abbot.....        On duty under the immediate orders of Colonel Gillmore.
Thomas L. Casey ...... Detached; Engineer Officer Division of the Pacific and De-
                        partment of California. Inspector of Rifle practice of the
                        Department of California. Member of Commission to run
                        and mark the boundary lines between a portion of the
                        Indian Territory and the State of Texas.
Theodore A. Bingham..         Detached; Engineer Officer, Department of Arizona. Sec-
                               retary and disbursing officer of the Missouri River Com-
                               mission, created by act of Congress approved July 5, 1884.
                               Member of Board of Survey to examine into and fix the
                               responsibility for the loss of certain vessels, &c., used upon
                               the improvement of the Mississippi River.
Curtis McD. Townsend. Detached; Assistant to the Engineer Commissioner of the
                       District of Columbia. On duty with the Battalion of En-
                       gineers.

Gustav J. Fiebeger ....       Detached; on duty at the Military Academy in Department
                               of Civil and Military Engineering. Member of General
                               Court Martial to meet at West Point, N. Y., March 15, 1886.
Oberlin M. Carter......       On duty under the immediate orders of Colonel Gillmore.
                       RANK AND DUTIES OF OFFICERS.                                      391
Statement showing rank and duties of officers of Corpsof.Engineers--Cont'd.

   RANK AND NAME.                                     DUTIES.
                 -        I           --                               ; -
                                                                       ..          ---




FIRST LIEUTENANTS.
      (continued.)
George W. Goethals ....       On duty under the immediate orders of Lieutenant-Colonel
                               Merrill. Detached; on duty at the Military Academy in
                               Department of Civil and Military Engineering.
John Millis.........          Detached; on duty under the immediate orders of Colonel
                               Duane as his assistant in connection with experiments
                               upon electric lighting.
John Biddle...........        Detached; Engineer Officer, Department of Dakota.
Harry F. Hodges ......        On duty under the immediate orders of Lieutenant-Colonel
                               Poe.
James G. Warren .....         On duty under the immediate orders of Major King. De-
                               tached; on duty as Assistant Instructor of Pratical Mili-
                               tary Engineering at the Military Academy, and with Com-
                               pany E, Battalion of Engineers. Officer in charge of Post
                               Schools, and Recruiting Officer for Company E, Battalion
                               of Engineers. Instructor in Department of Civil and Mili-
                               tary Engineering. Member of General Court Martial to
                               meet at West Point, N. Y., March 15, 1886.

Edward Burr..........         On duty under the immediate orders of Captain Powell. De-
                               tached ; Engineer Officer Department of the Columbia.

Oscar T. Crosby .......       On duty under the immediate orders of Major Heuer.
Lansing H. Beach .....        On temporary duty with Company E, Battalion of Engi-
                               neers. On duty under the immediate orders of Lieutenant-
                                Colonel Merrill. Member and Disbursiljg Officer of Com-
                               mission to run and mark the boundary lies between a por-
                               tion of the Indian Territory and the State of Texas.

Graham D. Fitch ......        On duty with Company B, Battalion of Engineers. On duty
                               under the immediate orders of Major King, Lieutenant-
                               Colonel Barlow, and Captain Marshall.
Eugene J. Spencer-...         On duty with Company A, Battalion of Engineers. Mem-
                               ber of General Court Martial to meet at Willets Point, N.
                               Y., November 2, 1885. Detached; Engineer Officer, De-
                               partment of Arizona.

George A. Zinn ........       On duty with Company B, and temporarily with Company
                               E, Battalion of Engineers. Judge-Advocate of General
                               Court Martial to meet at Willets Point, N. Y., July 29 and
                               October 12, 1885.

William C. Langfitt ...       On duty with Company C, Battalion of Engineers. Member
                               of General Courts Martial to meet at Willets Point, N. Y.,
                               July 29, October 12, 1885, and February 23, 1886.
Henry E. Waterman ...         On duty with CompanyA, Battalion of Engineers. Member
                               of General Court Martial to meet at Willets Point, N. Y.,
                               July 29, and Judge-Advocate of General Courts Martial to
                               meet at Willets Point October 12, 1885, February 23 and
                               May 3, 1886.
392        REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

Statement showing rank and duties of officers of Corps of Engineers--Cont'd.

   RANK AND NAME.                                       DUTIES.

                            I                       -



SECOND LIEUTENANTS.

Irving Hale ..........          On duty with Company C, Battalion of Engineers. Acting
                                 Ordnance Officer, Post of Willets Point. Member of Gen-
                                 eral Courts Martial to meet at Willets Point October 12
                                  and November 2, 1885, and February 23 and May 3, 1886.
James C. Sanford ......         On duty with Company A, Battalion of Engineers. Member
                                 of General Courts Martial to meet at Willets Point, N.
                                 Y., October 12, and November 2, 1885. On duty under the
                                  immediate orders of Lieutenant-Colonel Houston.
Hiram M. Chittenden ..          On duty with Company B, Battalion of Engineers. Member
                                  of General Courts Martial to meet at Willets Point, N. Y.,
                                  July 29, October 12, and November 2, 1885, and February
                                  23, 1886, and Judge Advocate of General Court Martial to
                                  meet May 3, 1886.
Cassius E. Gillette .....       On duty with Company C, Battalion of Engineers. Member
                                 of General Courts Martial to meet at Willets Point, N. Y.,
                                 July 29, October 12, and November 2, 1885, and February
                                 23 and May 3, 1886.
David DuB. Gaillard...          On duty with Company A, Battalion of Engineers. Member
                                  of General Courts Martial to meet at Willets Point, N. Y.,
                                  July 29, October 12, November 2, 1885, and February 23
                                  and May 3, 1886.

rry H Taylor..........          On duty with Company B, Battalion of Engineers. Member
                                 of General Courts Martial to meet at Willets Point, N. Y.,
                                 July 29, October 12, November 2, 1885, and February 23,
                                 1886.
William L. Sibert .....         On duty with Company C, Battalion of Engineers. Member
                                 of General Courts Martial to meet at Willets Point, N. Y.,
                                 July 29, October 12, November 2, 1885, and May 3, 1886.
Joseph E. Kuhn .......          On duty with Company B, Battalion of Engineers. Member
                                 of General Courts Martial to meet at Willets Point, N. Y.,
                                 October 12, November 2, 1885, and February 23 and May
                                 3, 1886.

William E. Craighill ..         On duty with Company A, Battalion of Engineers. Member
                                 of General Court Martial to meet at Willets Point, N. Y.,
                                 February 23, 1886.
UNITED STATES AGENTS.

S. T. Abert............. In charge of the improvement of the harbor at Breton Bay,
                           Leonardtown, and at entrance of Saint Jerome Creek, Md.
                           In charge of the improvement of the rivers Rappahannock,
                           Chickahominy, Mattaponi, Totusky, York, Pamunky, and
                           Staunton, Va., Roanoke and French Broad, N. C., and
                           Dan, Va. and N. C. ; of channel in Potomac River through
                           flats in front of landing at Mount Vernon, and of Neabsco,
                           Nomini, and Urbana creeks, Va. In charge of prelimi-
                           nary examination and of survey of Colonial Beach, Va.
William F. Smith......          In charge of the improvement of the harbors at Wilmington,
                                  Del., Annapolis and Cambridge, Md., and ice-harbor at
                                  New Castle, Del. In charge of the improvement of the
                                  Maurice River, N. J., Broadkiln, Indian, and Saint Jones
                                  rivers, Duck, Mispillion, and Broad creeks, Del., Susque-
                       RANK AND DUTIES OF OFFICERS.                              393
Statementshowing rank and duties of officers of Corps of Engineers--Cont'd.

   RANK AND NAME.                                  DUTIES.


UNITED STATES AGENTS.
       (continued.)
                           hanna River, above and below Havre de Grace, and work at
                           the Fishing Battery light-station near Spesutia Island ; of
                           the Chester, Wicomico, Choptank, and Elkrivers, Corsica
                           creek, and upper thoroughfare at DeiP's Island, Md. In
                           charge of preliminary examinations and of surveys of
                           Tuckahoe Creek and Sassafras River above Georgetown.
  UNITED STATES CIVIL
      ENGINEER.

M. Meigs ...........     On duty under immediate orders of Major Mackenzie.
 _UI~I_                I__


              LAW             S
                  AFFECTING




THE CORPS OF ENGINEERS,
          UNITED STATES ARMY,

    FORTY-NINTH CONGRESS, FIRST SESSION.



               188.5-'86.

                                           395
                                        LA         W S
                                            AFFECTING



THE CORPS OF ENGINEERS, UNITED STATES ARMY.

                     FORTY-NINTH CONGRESS,         FIRST SESSION,     1885-'86.




                                              ACTS.

CHAP. 27.-An act to provide for certain of the most urgent deficiencies in the ap-       March 26, 1886.
propriations for the serviceof the Government for the fiscal year ending June thir-
tieth, eighteen hundred and eighty-six, and for other purposes.

  Be it enacted by the Senate and House of epresentatives of the United
States of America in Congress assembled, That the following sums, or so .Urgent deft-
much thereof as may be necessary, be, and the same are hereby, appro- acncy appropri-
priated, out of any money in the Treasury not otherwise appropriated,
for the objects hereinafter expressed, for the service of the fiscal year
ending June thirtieth, eighteen hundred and eighty-six, and prior years,
namely :

                 WATER SUPPLY DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA.                                     District of Co.
                                                                                       lumbia.
   The sum of five thousand dollars, or so much thereof as maybe neces- Water supply
sary, to enable the Secretary of War to preserve from flooding or other to protect tunnel
injury during the suspension of operations thereon the tunnel now being for increased.
constructed under authority of an act to increase the water supply of
Washington City and for other purposes, approved July fifteenth, eight-
een hundred and eighty-two, the said sum to be subject to all the pro- Vol. 22, p. 168.
visions and restrictions of said act and of the act approved July fifth,
eighteen hundred and eighty-four, making appropriations for the ex- Vol 23, p. 132.
penses of the Government of the District of Columbia, as to its appor-
tionment and settlement between the United States and the District of
Columbia and the refunding thereof.
   Approved, March 26, 1886.



CHAP. 48.-An act authorizing the construction of a bridge over the Mississippi          April15, 1886.
            River at or near Alton, Illinois, and for other purposes.
   Be it enacted by the Senate and House of Representatives of the United Bridge ov er
States of Americd in Congress assembled, That it shall be lawful for the Mississippi Riv-
Central Missouri Railway Company, a corporation duly and legally in-        entr al onMis-
corporated under and by virtue of the laws of the State of Missouri, s o u ri Railway
its assigns or successors, to construct and maintain a bridge, and ap- Company may
proaches thereto, over the Mississippi River at or near Alton, in theonstruct.ge of
State of Illinois.    Said bridge shall be constructed to provide for the trains, tolls, &c.
passage of railway trains, and, at the option of the persons by whom
it may be built, may be used for the passage of wagons and vehicles of
all kinds, for the transit of animals, and for foot-passengers, for such
reasonable rates of toll as may be approved from time to time by the
Secretary of War.
                                                                                             397
398      REPORT       OF   THE c1IEF OF           ENGINERS         ti. S. ARMY.

  Declaredalaw- SEC. 2. That any bridgebuilt under this act and subject to its limit-
ful structure and ations shall be a lawful structure, and shall be recognized and known
post-route.         as a post-route, upon which also no higher charge shall be made for the
                    transmission over the same of the mails, the troops, and the munitions
                    of war of the United States, or passengers or freight passing over said
                     bridge, than the rate per mile paid for the transportation over the rail-
                    road or public highways leading to the said bridge; and it shall enjoy
                    the rights and privileges of other post-roads in the United States.
                       SEc. ;3. That if said bridge shall be made with unbroken and continu-
  Spans.            ous spans, the spans thereof shall not be less than three hundred feet
                    in length in the clear, and the main span shall be over the main chan-
                    nel of the river. The lowest part of the superstructure of said bridge
                    shall be at least fifty feet above high-water mark, as understood at the
                    point of location, and the bridge shall be at right angles to and its
  Proviso.          piers parallel with the current of the river : Provided, That if the same
                    shall be constructed as a draw-bridge, the draw or pivot pier shall be
  Draws.            at or near that shore nearest the channel of the river where, in the
                    opinion of the Secretary of War, the passage through the draw at that
                    point can be consistently maintained ; if not so constructed, then the
                    draw-pier to be in the main channel, and the opening or passage-way
                    to be so protected that water-craft can be worked through it by lines
                    when not safe to pass otherwise; and the spans shall not be less than
                    two hundred feet in length in the clear, with two side spans of three
                    hundred feet each, and the piers of said bridge shall be parallel with
                    and the bridge itself at right angles to the current of the river, and the
                    spans shall not be less than ten feet above high-water mark, as under-
  Proviao.          stood at the point of location, to the lowest part of the superstructure
                    of said bridge: Provided also, That said draw shall be opened promptly
  Lights, etc.       upon reasonable signal for the passing of boats; and said company or
                    corporation shall maintain, at its own expense, from sunset till sun-
                    rise, such lights or other signals on said bridge as the Light-House
  Free naviga- Board shall prescribe. No bridge shall be erected or maintained uuder
tion to be main-
tineto be mathe authority of this act which shall at any time substantially or mate-
                    rially obstruct the free navigation of said river; and if any bridge
                    erected under such authority shall, in the opinion of the Secretary of
                    War, obstruct such navigation, he is hereby authorized to cause such
                    change or alteration of said bridge to be made as will effectually obvi-
                    ate such obstruction; and all such alterations shall be made and all
                    such obstructions be removed at the expense of the owner or owners
  Litigation.       of said bridge ; and in case of any litigation arising from any obstruc-
                    tion or alleged obstruction to the free navigation of said river caused
                    or alleged to be caused by said bridge, the case may be brought in the
                    district court of the United States of the State of Missouri in which
                    any portion of said obstruction or bridge may be located: Provided
                    further, That nothing in this act shall be so constructed as to repeal or
                    modify any of the provisions of law now existing in reference to the
                    protection of the navigation of rivers, or to exempt this bridge from the
                     operation of the same.
  All railroad Sue. 4. That all railroad companies desiring the use of said bridge
  ompaniees eto shall have and be entitled to equal rights and privileges relative to the
hav
bridge; compen- passage of railway trains over the same, and over the approaches
sation; Secretary thereto, upon payment of a reasonable compensation for such use; and
of War to decide in case the owner or owners of said bridge and the several railroad
disagreements. companies, or any one of them, desiring such use, shall fail to agree
                     upon the sum or sums to be paid, and upon rules and conditions to
                     which each shall conform in using said bridge, all matters at issue be-
                     tween them shall be decided by the Secretary of War, upon a hearing
                     of the allegations and proofs of the parties.
   Plans, etc., for SEC. 5. That any bridge authorized to be constructed under this act
security of navi- shall be built and located under and subject to such regulations for the
gation, etc., to be
submittedto Sec. security of navigation of said river as the Secretary of War shall pre-
retary of War. scribe; and to secure that object the said company or corporation shall
                     submit to the Secretary of War, for his examination and approval, a
                     design and drawings of the bridge, and a map of the location, giving,
                     for the space of one mile above and one mile below the proposed loca-
                     tion, a topography of the banks of the river, the shore-lines at high and
                     low water, the direction and strength of the currents at all stages, and
                     the soundings, accurately showing the bed of the stream, the loca-
                     tion of any other bridge or bridges, and shall furnish such other infor-
                     mation as may be required for a full and satisfactory understanding of
                   LAWS AFrECtINGG CORPS OF ENGINEERS.                                             399
the subject; and until the said plan and location of the bridge are ap-
proved by the Secretary of War the bridge shall not be built; and should
any change be made in the plan of said bridge during the progress of
construction, such change shall be subject to the approval of the Sec-
retary of War.
   SEC. 6. That all the rights, privileges, and immunities granted Assignment of
and included in an act entitled "An act authorizing the construction rights of Hanni-
of a bridge over the Missouri River at or near Arrow Rock, Missouri,"     and Soath.
                                                                               Sal
approved April first, eighteen hundred and eighty-two, having been Company rati-
transferred and assigned by the Hannibal and Southwestern Railway
Company to its successor, the Central Missouri Railway Company said Vol. 22, p. 38
                                                                                       fled.
transfer and assignment is hereby ratified and confirmed to said Cen-
tral Missouri Railway Company.
  SEC. 7. That the right to alter, amend, or repeal this act is hereby Right       to
expressly reserved.                                                                    amend, etc.,    re-
  Approved, April 15, 1886.                                                            served.



CHAP. 49.-An act to authorize the Mississippi Water-Power and Boom Company,              April 15, 1886.
    of Brainard, Minnesota, to construct a dam across the Mississippi River.

   Be it enacted by the Senate and House of Representatives of the United
States of America in Congress assembled, That the consent of the Gov- Dam across
ernment is hereby given to the Mississippi Water-Power and Boom Mississippi Riv-
Company of Brainard, Minnesota, to construct across the Mississippi er may be built
River, at some point not more than two miles from the limits of said b y       ississippi
city of Brainard, to be approved by the Secretary of War, a dam, canal and Boom Com-
and the appurtenances thereof;, for water-power and other purposes, pany, of Brain-
and in connection therewith a wagon and foot bridge for public travel : ard, Minn.
Provided, That the Government of United States may at any time con- bridge.
struct in connection therewith a suitable lock for navigation purposes: Provisos.
Provided also, That the Government of the United States may at any Lock.
time take possession of said dam and control the same for purposes of Government
navigation, by paying said company the actual cost of the same, but maytake posses-
shall not do so to the destruction of the water-power created by said lion.
dam: Provided further, That the Secretary of War may at any time
and
require and enforce, at the expense of the owners, such modification
     changes in the construction of said dam as he may deem advisable
in the interests of navigation; and that said dam shall, if necessary, be Navigation.
so built that boats and rafts may pass through the same, without the
imposition of any toll or charge: And provided further, That all suits Litigat
relative to any obstruction of navigation arising from said dam may
be tried in the United States circuit and district courts for Minnesota.
   SEC. 2. That'the right to alter, amend, or repeal this act is hereby Rightto amend
expressly reserved without any claim of any kind arising in favor of etc., reserved.
any party in consequence of such amendment or repeal.
  Approved, April 15, 1886.



CHAP. 59.-An act to amend the act of Congress approved June twelfth, eighteen            Apr. 22, 1886.
hundred and eighty-four, entitled "An act to authorize the construction of bridges
across the Wisconsin, Chippewa, and Saint Croix Rivers, in the State of Wisconsin".

  Be it enacted by the Senate and House of Representatives of the United Bridges over
States of America in Congress assembled, That an act of Congress ap- Wisconsin, Chip-
proved June twelfth, eighteen hundred and eighty-four, entitled "An pewa, and Saint
act to authorize the construction of bridges across the Wisconsin, Chip- Wis x Rivers,
Ipewa, and Saint Croix Rivers, in the State of Wisconsin", be, and the Chicago, Bur-
same is hereby, amended by striking out the words "Winona, Alma 1in g to n a nd
and Northern Railway Company", wherever the same"occur        in the said Northern Rail-
                                                         c                road   Company
law, and by inserting in lieu thereof the words "the Chicago, Burling- substituted for
ton and Northern Railroad Company, its successors and assigns.            Winona, Alma
                                                                          RailwayNorthern
                                                                          and      Cothern
  Approved, April 22, 1886.
                                                                          pany.
                                                                                         Vol. 23, ch. 81,
                                                                                       p. 41, amended.
400          REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

  May 1, 1886.        CHAP. 70.-An act authorizing the partition of certain land in Louisville Ken-
                       tucky, belonging jointly to John Echols and the Government of the United States.

  Partition of Whereas a tract of ground situated in Louisville, Kentucky, adjoin-
land ownne d by ing the Louisville and Portland Canal, and known as " Rowan's Basin,"
the Echols
John           and.
        U hol ne      o e by
                   • owned
                 d is           t IIIUnited
                              b the       e States of America and by John Echols in the
States, in Louis- following proportion and under the following conveyances, to wit: The
ville, Ky.         United States, as the proprietor of the Louisville and Portland Canal
  Preamble.        and the owner of all the stock of the Louisville and Portland Canal
                   Company, owns an undivided three-eighths of said real estate, by virtue
                   of the following deeds: One from R. H. Campbell and others to the
                   Louisville and Portland Canal Company, recorded in deed-book num-
                   bered one hundred and thirty-five, page four hundred and twenty-
                   three, and one from George H. Douglas to said canal company, recorded
                   in deed-book numbered one hundred and thirty-seven, page four hun-
                   dred and two, both in the Jefferson County, Kentucky, clerk's office;
                   and said John Echols owns an undivided five-eighths of said real estate,
                   under and by virtue of the following deeds to him, to wit : One from
                   Eliza H. Boone and others, recorded in deed-book numbered two hun-
                   dred and fifty-five, page one hundred and thirty-four; one from Rebecca
                   B. Rowan, trustee, and others, recorded in deed-book numbered two
                   hundred and fifty-four, page three hundred and eighty-two; one from
                   Rowan Buchanan and others, recorded in deed-book numbered two
                   hundred and fifty-four, page three hundred and sixty-two; and one
                   from Samuel J. Broadwell and others, recorded in deed-book numbered
                   two hundred and fifty-four, page six hundred and two, all in the Jeffer-
                   son County, Kentucky, clerk's office; and it is to the interest of both
                   parties that partition shall be made of said real estate: Therefore,
                      Be it enacted by the Senate and Bouse of Representatives of the United
  Secretary of States of America in Congress assembled, That the Secretary of War of
War to agree the United States is hereby authorized and empowered to agree with
partition,         said Echols, his heirs or his assigns, upon such partition of said real
                   estate as may seem to the Secretary of War to be just and proper, and
                   may, in the name of and on behalf of the United States of America,
                   make, execute, and deliver to said Echols, his heirs or his assigns, and
                   receive from him or them, such deed of conveyance as may effectuate
                   the partition herein provided for.
                      SEC. 2. That this act shall take effect from its passage.
                      Approved, May 1, 1886.



May 15, 1886.        CHAP. 329.--An act to authorize the Chicago, Freeport and Saint Paul Railroad
                       Company to construct a bridge across the Saint Croix River (or lake) at any acces-
                        sible point between Prescott, Wisconsin, and Stillwater, Minnesota.
                   Be it enacted by the Senate and House of Representatives of the United
  Chicago, Free- States of America in Congress assembled, That the Chicago, Freeport and
port andSt. Paul Saint Paul Railroad Company, a corporation duly organized under the
izedto bridethe laws of the States of Illinois, Wisconsin, and Minnesota, be, and is
St. Croix River hereby, authorized to construct and maintain a bridge, and approaches
between Pr e s -thereto, over the Saint Croix River (a part of which is commonly called
cott. Wis., and Lake Saint Croix"), between the States of Minnesota and Wisconsin,
Sillwater,       n.        ny accessible    pointn       aid river between       Prescott, Wisconsin,

  Wagon and and Stillwater, Minnesota. Said bridge shall be constructed to provide
foot bridge. for the passage of railway trains, and, at the option of the corporation
             by which it may be built, may be used for the passage of wagons and
             vehicles of all kinds, for the transit of animals, and for foot-passengers,
  Tolls.     for such reasonable rates of toll as may be approved from time to time
             by the Secretary of War.
Navigation not         SEC. 2. That any bridge built under this act shall be constructed and
to be materially built without material interference with the security and convenience
interfered with. of navigation of said river beyond what is necessary to carry into effect
                 the rights and privileges hereby granted; and in order to secure compli-
                 ance with these conditions, the corporation, previous to commencing
  Planstobesub- the construction of the bridge, or of the accessory works designed to se-
mitted to Secre- cure the best practicable channel-way for navigation and confine the
tary of War.     flow of the water to a permanent channel at said point, shall submit to
                 the Secretary of War a plan of the bridge and other accessory works
                 provided for in this act, together with a detailed map of the river at
                 LAWS AFFECTING            CORPS OF ENGINEERS.                             401

the proposed site of the bridge and for a distance of a mile above and
below the site, together with all other information touching said bridge
and river and accessory works as may be deemed requisite by the Sec-
retary of War to determine whether the said bridge, when built, will
conform to the prescribed co'nditions of this act. That as to any bridge        Spans.
built under this act, if the said bridge shall be made with unbroken and
continuous spans, it shall not be of less elevation in any case than fifty
feet above extreme high-water mark, as understood at the point of loca-
tion, to the bottom chord of the bridge, nor shall the spans of said
bridge over the main channel be less than two hundred feet in length,
and the piers of said bridge shall be parallel with the current of said
river, and the main span shall be over the main channel of the river and
not less than two hundred feet in length. That if any bridge built un-
der this act shall be constructed as a drawbridge, the same shall be            Draw.
constructed as a pivot draw-bridge, with a draw over the main channel
of the river at an accessible and the best navigable point, and with
draw-openings of not less than one hundred and sixty feet in length in
the clear on each side of the central or pivot pier of the draw, which
said draw shall be opened promptly upon reasonable signal for the pass-
ing of boats, vessels, and other water-craft; and the spans adjoining
said draw shall not be less than two hundred feet wide in the clear, and
the elevation of the bottom chord of said bridge shall not be less than
ten feet above the extreme high-water mark: Provided, however, That             Proviso.
no bridge shall be built under the provisions of this act except there
also be built, at the time of the erection of the piers, proper sheer-booms     Protection to
or other proper protections to safely guide boats, vessels, rafts, and        n avi g a t io n;
other water-craft through said draw-spans, and at the expense of the           lights, etc.
company or corporation erecting the bridge; and said company or cor-
poration shall maintain, at its own expense, from sunset to sunrise, such
lights or other signals on said bridge as the Secretary of War shall pre-
scribe.
   SEC. 3. That the Secretary of War is hereby authorized and directed,         Approval of
upon receiving any such plan and map and other information, and upon            ear eta ry of
being satisfied that a bridge built on such plan and with such accessory
works and at such locality will conform to the prescribed conditions of
this act, to notify the company that lie approves the same; and upon
receiving such notification the said company may proceed to an erection
of said bridge, conforming strictly to the approved plan and location;
but until the Secretary of War approve the plan and location of said
bridge and other accessory works provided for in this act, and notify
the company of the sathe, the bridge shall not be built; and should
any change be made in the plan of the bridge or other accessory works
provided for in this act, during the progress of the work thereon, such
change shall be subject likewise to the approval of the Secretary of
War, not, however, to be in any wise inconsistent with the provisions
or conditions of this act.
   SEc. 4. That any bridge and accessory works, when built and con-              Bridge    de-
structed under this act and according to its provisions and conditions,       clared a lawful
shall be a lawful structure; and said bridge shall be recognized and           structure and
known as a post-route, upon which also no higher charge shall be made
for the transmission over the same of the mails, the troops, and the
munitions of war of the United States than the rate per mile paid for
the transportation over the railroads or public highways leading to said
bridge; and said bridge shall enjoy the rights and privileges of other         Charges.
post-routes in the United States; and Congress reserves the right at
any time to regulate, by appropriate legislation, the charges for freight
and passengers over said bridge; and the United States shall have the           Postal tele-
right of way for postal-telegraph and telegraph lines, free of charge,        graph.
across said bridge,
    SEc. 5. That it shall be the duty of the Secretary of War, on satis-         Aids to navi-
factory proof that a necessity exists therefor, to require the company        gation, if neces-
or persons owning said bridge to cause such aids to the passage of said       sary, to be pro-
bridge authorized by the provisions of this act to be constructed, placed,    vided.
and maintained, at their own cost and expense, in the form of booms,
dikes, piers, or other suitable and proper structures for confining the
flow of water to a permanent channel, and for the guiding of rafts,
steamboats, and other water-craft safely through the draw and raft
spans, as shall be specified in his order in that behalf; and on the
failure of the company or persons aforesaid to nmake and establish such
additional structures within a reasonable time, the said Secretary shall
         26 E
402       REPORT OF THE CHIEF                  OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

                    proceed to cause the same to be built or made at the expense of the
   Attorney-Gen- United States, and shall refer the matter, without delay, to the A ttorney-
eral to bring suit General of the United States, whose duty it shall be to institute, in the
in case of failure, name of the United Stutes, proceedings in any circuit court of the
                    United States in which such bridge, or any part thereof, is located, for
                    the recovery of the cost thereof; and all moneys accruing from such
                    proceedings shall be covered into the Treasury of the United States.
  Ri g h t      t o    SEC. 6. That the right to alter, amend, or repeal this act is hereby ex-
amend, etc., re- pressly reserved; and the right to require any changes in said structure,
served.             at the expense of the owners thereof, whenever Congress shall decide
                    that the public interests require it, is also expressly reserved.
                       SEC. 7. That this act shall take effect and be in force from and after
                    its passage.
                       Approved, May 15, 1886.




May 15, 1886.   CHAP. 330. An act authorizing the construction of a bridge across the Mississippi
                   River at or near Keithsburg, in the State of Illinois, and for other purposes.

                        Be it enacted by the Senate and House of Representatives of the United
                     States of America in Congress assembled, That the assent of Congress is
   New York and hereby given to the New York and Council Bluffs Railway Company, a
Railway Com- corporation duly created and organized under the laws of the States of
pany authorized Ohio, Indiana, Illinois, and Iowa, or its successors or assigns, to build
to bridge the a bridge across the Mississippi River at such point on said river at or
Mississippi Riv- near Keithsburg, in the State of Illinois, as may accommodate lines of
burg, 1       eiths- railroad which said corporation may build to said point on the said
                      Mississippi River, or to a point on the west bank of said river in the
                      State of Iowa, opposite to said point at or near Keithsburg, in the State
                     of Illinois, and to lay on or over said bridge a railroad track or tracks,
                     for the more perfect connection of any railroad or railroads that are
                     or shall be constructed to said river, on either or both sides thereof,
                      at or opposite said point, under the limitations and conditions herein-
   Free naviga- after provided; that said bridge shall not interfere with the free navi-
tion not to be in- gation of said river beyond what is necessary in order to carry into
terfered with.       effect the rights and privileges hereby granted; and in case of any
   Litigation.       litigation arising from any obstruction or alleged obstruction to the
                     free navigation of said river, the cause may be tried before the circuit
                     court of the United States in and for any district in which any portion
                     of said bridge or obstruction touches.
   May be either SEC. 2. That any bridge built under the provisions of this act may,
draw-bridge or at the option of the company building the same, be built as a draw-
   Provisoes.        bridge or with unbroken and continuous spans: Provided, That if the
                     said bridge shall be made with unbroken and continuous spans, it shall
   Height and not be of less elevation in any case than fifty-feet above extreme high-
spans if not a water mark, as understood at the point of location, to the bottom chord
draw-bridge.         of the bridge, nor shall the spans of said bridge give a clear width of
                     water-way of less than two hundred and fifty feet, and the piers of said
                     bridge shall be parallel with the current of said river, and the main
                     span shall be over the main channel of the river and give a clear width
                     of water-way of not less than three hundred feet: And providedfurther,
   Draw.             That if any bridge built under the provisions of this act shall be con-
                     structed as a draw-bridge, the same shall be constructed as a pivot
                     draw-bridge, with a draw over the main channel of the river at an ac-
                     cessible and navigable point, and with spans giving a clear width of
                     water-way of not less than one hundred and sixty feet on each side of
                     the central or pivot pier of the draw; and the next adjoining span or
                     spans to the draw shall give a clear width of water-way of not less than
                     two hundred and fifty feet, and said spans shall not be less than thirty
                     feet above low-water mark, measuring to the bottom chord of the
                     bridge, and the piers of said bridge shall be parallel with the current
                     of the river where said bridge shall be erected: And provided also, That
                     said draw shall be opened promptly upon reasonable signal for the pas-
                     sage of boats.
   To be a lawful       SEC. 3. That any bridge constructed under this act and according to
structure and its limitations shall be a lawful structure, and shall be known as a post-
post-route    route, and the same is hereby declared to be a post-route, upon which
              also no higher charge shall be made for the transmission over the same
                    LAWS AFFECTING              CORPS OF ENGINEERS.                                 403
of the mails, the troops, and the munitions of war of the Uni ted States,
or for passengers or freight passing over said bridge, than the rate per
mile paid for their transportation over the railroads and public high-
ways leading to said bridge; and the United States shall have the right P o s t a 1 tele-
of way for postal-telegraph purposes across said bridge,                  graph.
   SEC. 4. That all railway companies desiring to use said bridge shall Other railway
have and be entitled to equal rights and privileges in the passage of the compause
                                                                               the bridge,
same, and in the use of the machinery and fixtures thereof, and of all upon terms to be
the approaches thereto, under and upon such terms and conditions as                    prescribed     by
shall be prescribed by the Secretary of War, upon hearing the allega- Waecretary of
tions and proofs of the parties, in case they shall not agree.               Plans, etc., to'
   SEC. 5. That the structure herein authorized shall be built and located be subject to ap-
under and subject to such regulations for the security of the navigation proval of Secre-
of said river as the Secretary of War shall prescribe; and to secure tary of War.
that object the said company or corporation shall submit to the Secre-
tary of War, for his examination and approval, a design and drawings
of the bridge, and a map of the location, giving, for the space of one
mile above and one mile below the proposed location, the topography
of the banks of the river, the shore-lines at high and low water, and
the direction and strength of the current'at all stages, and the sound-
ings, accurately showing the bed of the stream, the location of any
other bridge or bridges, and shall furnish such other information as
shall be required for a full and satisfactory understanding of the sub-
ject; and until the said plan and location of the bridge are approved
by the Secretary of War the bridge shall not be built; and should any
change be made in the plan of said bridge, during the progress of con-
struction, such change shall be subject to the approval of the Secretary
of War; and the said structure shall be at all times so kept and man-
aged as to offer reasonable and proper means for the passage of vessels
through or under said structure; and for the safety of vessels passing
at night there shall be displayed on said bridge, fromthe hours of sun- Lights.
set to sunrise, such lights as may be prescribed by the Secretary of
War. And the said structure shall be changed or removed, at the cost
and expense of the owners thereof, from time to time, as Congress may
direct, so as to preserve the free and convenient navigation of said
river; and the authority to erect and continue said bridge shall be sub-
ject to revocation and modification by law when the public good shall,
in the judgment of Congress, so require, without any expense or charge
to the Ujited States.
   SEC. 6. That the right to alter, amend, or repeal of this act is hereby Rightto amend
expressly reserved.                                                        etc., reserved.
   SEC. 7. That this act shall take effect and be in force from and after
its passage.
   Approved, May 15, 1886.


CHAP. 331.-An act authorizing the construction of bridges across the Illinois River,     May 15, 1886.
in the State of Illinois, and the Des Moines River, in the State of Iowa, and for
  other purposes.

  Be it enacted by the Senate and House of Representatives of the United
States of America in Congress assembled., That the assent of Congress is                 New York and
                                                                                       Council      Bluffs
hereby given to the New York and Council Bluffs Railway Company, Railway Compa-
an organization incorporated under the laws of the States of Ohio, In- ny authorized to
diana, Illinois, and Iowa, its successors or assigns, to construct bridges bridge the Illi-
over the Illinois River at or near the town of Lacon, in the State of Illi- nois River at La-
nois and over the Des Moines River, in the State of Iowa, and in such Moines River,
county of said State of Iowa as said railway company may desire or find Iowa.
most practicable in the final location of its road.
   SEC. 2. That said bridges shall be so constructed, either by draw, span, May be draw,
or otherwise. that a free and unobstructed passage may be secured to span,  wise, ornotother-
                                                                                          ob-
all vessels and other water-craft navigating said rivers.                   structingnaviga-
                                                                                       tion.
   SEC. 3. That any bridge built under this act and subject to its limita- To be lawful
tions shall be a lawful structure, and shall be recognized and known as structures and
a post-route, upon which also no higher charge shall be made for the post-routes.
transmission over the same of the mails, the troops, and the munitions
of war of the United States, or passengers or freight passing over said
bridges, than the rate per mile paid for the transportation over the rail-
roads or public highways leading to said bridges; and they shall enjoy
the rights and privileges of other post-roads of the United States.
404        REPORT        OF   THE CHIEF        OF    ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

   Draws, lights, SEC. 4. That if either of said bridges authorized to be constructed by
etc.               this act shall be constructed as a draw-bridge, the draw shall be opened
                   promptly upon reasonable signals for the passage of boats; and said
                   company or corporation shall maintain, at its own expense, from sunset
                   until sunrise, such lights or other signals on said bridge or bridges as
                   the Secretary of War shall prescribe.     No bridge shall be erected or
                   maintained under the authority of this act which shall at any time
                   substantially or materially obstruct the free navigation of said rivers;
                   and if any bridge erected under such authority shall, in the opinion of
                   the Secretary of War, obstruct such navigation, he is hereby author-
                   ized to cause such change or alteration of said bridge to be made as
                    will effectually obviate such obstruction; and all such obstructions
                   shall be removed and alterations made at the expense of the owner or
   Proviso.         owners of said bridge: Provided, That nothing in this act shall be so
   No repeal or construed as to repeal or modify any of the provisions of law now exist-
  aws protectinof ing in reference to the protection of the navigation of rivers, or to ex-
navigation.         empt any bridge erected under this act from the operations of the same.
   Other compa-       SEC. 5. That all railroad companies desiring the use of either of said
nies entitled to bridges that may be erected under the provisions of this act shall have
useup onterms to and be entitled to equal rights and privileges relative to the passage of
SecretaryofWar. railway trains or cars over the same, and over the approaches thereto,
                    upon the payment of a reasonable compensation therefor; and in case
                    the owner or owners of said bridge or bridges, and the several railroad
                    companies, or any one of them, desiring such use, shall fail to agree upon
                    the sum or sums to be paid, and upon rules and conditions to which
                    each shall conform in using said bridge or bridges, all matters of issue
                   between them shall be decided by the Secretary of War, upon the hear-
                   ing of the allegations and proofs of the parties.
   Plans,etc.,tobe    SEC. 6. That any bridge authorized to be constructed under this act
subject to ap- shall be built and located under and subject to such regulations for the
proval of Secre-
tary of War.      security of navigation of said rivers as the Secretary of War shall pre-
                  scribe; and to secure that object said company or corporation shall
                  submit to the Secretary of War, a design and drawings of said bridge
                  or bridges to be erected, for his examination and approval, and a map
                  of its location, and shall furnish such other information as may be re-
                  quired for a full and satisfactory understanding of the subject, and in
                  all things shall be subject to such rules and regulations as may be pre-
                  scribed by the Secretary of War; and until said plan and location of
                  said bridge or bridges are approved by the Secretary of War said bridge
                  or bridges shall not be built; and should any change be made in the
                  plan of any such bridge or bridges authorized to be constructed under
                  this act, during the progress of the work of construction, such change
                  shall be subject to the approval of the Secretary of War.
  Right to amend,    SEC. 7. That the right to alter, amend, or repeal this act is hereby
etc., reserved.   expressly reserved ; and the right to require any changes in said struct-
                  ures, or their removal, at the expense of the owners thereof, whenever
                  Congress shall decide that the public interest requires it, is also ex-
                  pressly reserved.
                     SEc. 8. That this act shall take effect and be in force from and after
                  its passage.
                     Approved, May 15, 1886.




  May 15, 1886.    CHAP. 332.-An act to authorize the Red River Bridge Company of Texas to main-
                                         tain a bridge across Red River.
   R e d Riv er    Be it enacted by the Senate and House of Representatives of the United
Bridge Company States of America in Congress assembled, That the Red River Bridge Com-
ized to build a pany of Texas, composed of Frank Colbert, W.B. Munson, J. B. McDou-
r a i w a y and gal, J. R. Carr, Samuel Star, J. T. Munson, Edward Perry, and L. L.
wagon br idge Maughs, be and is hereby, authorized to construct and maintain a rail-
acros nthe Ded way and wagon bridge across Red River betwccn the State of Texas and
ison, Tex.       the Chickasaw Nation of the Indian Territory, at any accessible point on
                 said river near Denison, Texas, that may be selected by said company ;
                 and said company shall be permitted to charge and take such rates of
  Tolls.           toll for crossing said bridge as may be reasonable, subject to the ap-
                   proval of the Secretary of War; the said bridge to be of such height
  Height.          as not to interfere with the navigation of said river: Provided, That
  Provisos.        any bridge constructed under this act and according to its limitations
                 LAWS      AFFlCTING        CORPS     OF ENGINEERS.                     405
shall be a lawful structure, and shall be known and recognized as a
post-route, and the same is hereby declared to be a post-route, upon structure laan
which also no higher charge shall be made for the transmission over post-route.
the same of the mails, the troops, and the munitions of war of the
United States, or for through passengers or freight passing over said
bridge, than the rate per mile paid for their transportation over the
railroads leading to the said bridge; and the United States shall have
the right of way for a postal telegraph across said bridge: And pro- Postal tel e -
vided further, That before this act shall take effect said company shall graph.
submit to the Secretary of War the plans of said bridge, showing the Plans subject
existing structure and any additions or changes that may be contem- to approval o f
plated; and that it shall be decided by the said Secretary that the Secretaryof War
bridge does not and will'not obstruct, impair, or injuriously modify
the navigation of the said river, due regard being had to the character
of the proposed navigation of said stream.
  SEC. 2. That Congress reserves the right to alter, amend, or repeal Free naviga-
this act at any time; and that if at any time navigation of the said tion to be pre
                                                                 bridge,
river shall in any manner be obstructed or impaired by the said
the Secretary of War shall have authority, and it shall be his duty, to
require the said company to alter and change the said bridge, at its
own expense, in such manner as may be proper to secure free and com-
plete navigation without impediment ; and if upon reasonable notice
to said company to make such change or improvements the said com-
pany fails to do so, the Secretary of War shall have authority to make
the same at the expense of said company, and all the rights conferred
by this act shall be forfeited ; and Congress shall have power to do any
and all things necessary to secure the free navigation of the river.
  Approved, May 15, 1885.




CHAP. 334.-An act to authorize the construction of a railroad and wagon bridge May 15, 1886.
across the Mississippi River from Winona, Minnesota, to the opposite shore in Wis --
consin.

   Be it enacted by the Suiate and House of Representatives of the United Winona Pon-
States of America in Congress assembled, That the Winona Pontoon toon Bridge Com-
Bridge Company, a corporation existing under the laws of the State of pan,      authorized
                                                                           to bridge the
Minnesota, is hereby authorized to construct and maintain a pile and M issis          ip   p
pontoon railway and wagon bridge across the Mississippi River from RiveratWinona,
the city of Winona, State of Minnesota, so as to connect with the oppo- Minn.
site shore of said river, in the State of Wisconsin, said bridge to be
bhilt subject, except as herein modified to all the terms, requirements S ubj ect to
and limitations contained in the act entitled "An act to legalize and es- terms of vol. 18,
tablish a pontoon railway bridge across the Mississippi River at Prairie ch. 224, p. 62.
du Chien, and to authorize the construction of a similar bridge at or
near Clinton, Iowa," approved June sixth, eighteen hundred and
seventy-four, so far as they may be applicable thereto.
   SEc. 2. That said bridge shall be so constructed with a suitable pon- Draw.
toon draw of not less than four hundred feet in width, located over the
main channel of the river: Provided, That said bridge shall not be built Proviso.
or commenced until the plan and specifications for its construction have
been submitted to the Secretary of War for his approval, nor until he Subject to ap
shall approve the plan and location of said bridge; and if any change tary of War as to
be made in the plan of construction of said bridge at any time, such plans, etc.
change shall be subject to the approval of the Secretary of War; and
any change in the construction or. any alteration of said bridge that
may be directed at any time by Congress or the Secretary of War shall
be made at the cost and expense of the owners thereof.
   SEC. 3. That if said bridge is constructed as a wagon bridge, the said Tolls.
company may charge such reasonable rates of toll for the passage of
wagons and vehicles of all kinds and for the transit of animals and foot-
passengers thereon as may fom time to time be approved by the Sec-
retary of War.
   SEC. 4. That Congress may at any time alter, amend, or repeal this act.
   Approved, May 15, 1886.
406       REPORT       OF   THE CHIEF         OF ENGINEERS,           U. S. ARMY.

May 15, 1886.   CHAP. 335.-An act to authorize the construction of a bridge across the Yellow-
                                          stone River, in Montana.

                        Be it enacted by the Senate and House of Representatives of the United
  Miles C ity States of America in Congress assembled, That the Miles City Bridge
Bridge Company Company, a corporation existing under the laws of the Territory of
authorized to Montana, and having authority to construct and maintain a bridge
bridge the Yel- across the Yellowstone River at or near Miles City, in the county of
at Miles City, Custer, in said Territory, be, and is hereby, authorized to construct and
Montana.             maintain, for the purpose of making a more perfect crossing of said
                     river at all times during the year, a bridge across the said Yellowstone
                     River at or near said Miles City, to be used by said company, its suc-
                     cessors or assigns, for all purposes of rail and other transportation over
                     said river.
                        SEC. 2. That any bridge built under this act shall be constructed and
  Not to impair built without material interference with the security and con venience
free navigation,. of navigation of said river beyond what is necessary to carry into
                     effect the rights and privileges hereby granted; and in order to secure
                     a compliance with these conditions the corporation, previous to com-
                     mencing the construction of the bridge, or of the necessary works in
                     the booms, dikes, or piers designed to secure the best practicable
                     channel-way for navigation and confine the flow of water to a permanent
                     channel, and for the guiding of steamboats and rafts safely through the
                     draw-spans at said point, shall submit to the Secretary of War a plan
   Plans, etc., of the bridge and of such accessory works, together with a detailed
subject     to   ap-
provaluectof oSecre- map of the river at the proposed sice of the bridge and for a distance
tary of War.         of a mile below and above the site, together with all other in formation
                     touching said bridge and river and accessory works as may be deemed
                     requisite by the Secretary of War to determine whether the said bridge,
                     when built, wi 1 conform to the prescribed conditions of this act; that,
                     as nearly as practicable, the said bridge shall be at right angles to and
                     the piers parallel with the current of said river ; and if it be found here-
                     after that the said bridge or accessory works materially interfere with
                     the security and convenience of navigation of said river beyond what is
                     necessary to carry into effect the rights and privileges hereby granted, by
                     reason of any defect or failure in the accessory works aforesaid to accom-
                     plish the purpose for which they are designed, it shall be the duty of the
   Provisos.         Secretary of War to require the necessary changes to be made therein,
   Spans.            in the interest of navigation, at the expense of the owners: Provided,
                     That as to any bridge built under this act, if the said bridge shall be
                     built of unbroken and continuous spans, it shall not be of less elevation
                     in any case than fifty feet above extreme high-water mark, as under-
                     stood at the point of location, to the bottom chord of the bridge, nor
                      shall the spans of said bridge be less than two hundred feet in length,
                      and the main spans shall be over the main channel of the river and not
   Draw.             less than two hundred feet in length: And provided also, That if any
                      bridge built under the provisions of this act shall be constructed as a
                      draw-bridge, the same shall be constructed as a pivot draw-bridge, with
                      a draw over the main channel of the river at an accessible and navigable
                     point, and with spans not less than ten feet above extreme high-water
                     mark at the point of location, and of not less length than one hundred
                     feet on each side of the central or pivot pier of the draw; and the next
                      adjoining spans shall be not less than one hundred and twenty-five feet
                      in length, unless otherwise expressly directed by the Secretary of War,
   Lights, etc.       and if so directed shall be according to such direction: Provided also,
                                        be
                      That said draw shall      opened promptly upon reasonable signal for the
                     passing of boats; and said company or corporation shall. maintain, at
                      its own expense, from sunset till sunrise, such lights or other signals
   Other compa-on said bridge as the Light-House Board may prescribe: Provided also,
of way.              That all railway companies desiring to use said bridge shall have and
                      be entitled to equal rights and privileges in the passage of the same,
                      and in the use of the machinery and the fixtures thereof, and of all the
                      approaches thereto, under and upon such terms and conditions as shall
                      be prescribed by the Secretary of War, upon hearing the allegations
                      and proofs of the parties, in case they shall not agree.
   Secretary of SEC. 3. That the Secretary of War is hereby authorized and directed,
War to give his upon receiving any such plans and map nld other infrmation
                                                                                             and
bridge can be upon being satisfied that a bridge built upon such plan and with such
commenced.    accessory works and at such locality will conform to the prescribed con-
              ditions of this act, to notify the company that he approves the same;
                    L&WS       AFFECTING          CORPS OF ENGINEERS.                             407

and upon receiving such notification the said company may proceed to
an erecting of said bridge, conforming strictly to the approved plan
and location ; but until the Secretary of War approve the plan and loca-
tion of said bridge and accessory works, and notify the company of the
same, the bridge shall not be commenced; and should any change be
made in the plan of the bridge or accessory works, during the progress
of the work thereon, such change shall be subject likewise to the ap-
proval of the Secretary of War.
   SEC. 4. That any bridge and accessory works, when built and con- To be a lawful
structed under this act and according to the terms and limitations structure a nd
thereof, shall be a lawful structure; and said bridge shall be recognized
and known as a post-route, and said bridge shall enjoy the rights and
privileges of other post-routes in the United States; and Congress re-                    Charges may
serves the right to regulate by appropriate legislation the charges for                 be regulated by
freight and passengers over said bridge.
  SEC. 5. That the United States shall have the right of way for postal                   Postal tele-
telegraph across said bridge.                                                           graph.
  SEC. 6. That the said Miles City Bridge Company, its successors and                     Tolls.
assigns shall have the right to charge tolls for the use of said bridge,
except as hereinbefore limited and provided.
  SEC. 7. That the right to alter, amend, or repeal this act is hereby                    Ri gh t    t o
expressly reserved ; and the right to require any changes in said struct-               amend, etc., re-
ure, or its entire removal, at the expense of the owners thereof, when-                 served.
ever Congress shall decide that the public interests require it, is also
expressly reserved.
  Approved, May 15, 1886.




C HAP. 342.-An act authorizing the removal of the statue of Major-General John A.        May 17, 1886.
  Rawlins from its present location to a site to be selected by the Secretary of War.

   Be it enacted by the Senate and House of Representatives of the United
States of America in Congress assembled, That the Secretary of War be, Stat ue        of
and be is hereby, authorized and directed to have the statue of Major- Major- G en eral
General John A. Rawlius removed from the present location to another John A. Rawlins
                                                                                site.
site within the limits of the city of Washington, District of Columbia, another
to be selected by the Secretary of War; and an amount not exceeding Appropriation
five hundred dollars is hereby alppropriated for that purpose out of any
money in the Treasury not otherwise appropriated.
  Approved, May 17, 1886.




CHAP. 344.-An act to authorize the construction of a bridge across the Missouri          May 17, 1886.
River at some accessible point within ten miles below and five miles above the city
of Kansas City, Missouri.

  Be it enacted by the Senate and House of Representatives of the United
States of America in Congress assembled, That the Wabash, Saint Louis
and Pacific Railway, a corporation duly organized, be, and is hereby,      Wabash, Saint
authorized to construct and maintain a bridge, and approaches thereto, Louis andPacific
over the Missouri River, at some accessible point consistent with the ized
                                                                         Railway   author-
                                                                             to bridge the
interests of the river navigation within five miles above and ten miks Missouri River,
below the present railroad bridge across said river at the city of Kan- near Kansas
sas City, in the county of Jackson and State of Missouri. Said bridge City, Mo.
shall be constructed to provide for the passage of railway trains, and,
at the option of the corporation by which it may be built, may be used
for the passage of wagons and vehicles of all kinds, for the transit of Wagonandfoot
animals, and for foot-passengers, for such reasonable rates of toll as may bridge.
be approved from time to time by the Secretary of War.                       Tolls.
   SEC. 2. That any bridge built under this act and subject to its limit- To be a lawful
ations shall be a lawful structure, and shall be recognized and known structure an d
as a post-route, upon which also no higher charge shall be made for the post-route.
transmission over the same of the mails, the troops, and the munitions
of war of the United States, or for passengers and freight passing over
said bridge, than the rate per mile paid for the transportation over the
railroad or public highways leading to said bridge; and it shall enjoy
the rights and privileges of other post-roads in the United States.
408       REPORT      OF THE      CHIEF      OF ENGINEERS,          U. S. ARMY.

                      SEc. 3. That if said bridge shall be made with unbroken and contin-
Spans.            uous spans, the spans thereof shall not be less than three hundred feet
                   in length in the clear, and the main span shall be over the main chan-
                   nel of the river. The lowest part of the superstructure of said bridge
                   shall be at least fifty feet above extreme high-water mark, as under-
                   stood at the point of location, and at least eighty feet above low water,
                   and the bridge shall be at right angles to and its piers parallel with
  Provisos.        the current of the river : Provided, That if the same shall be constructed
  Draws.            as a draw-bridge, it shall have two or more pivot or draw-span open-
                   ings over the main channel of the river, giving one hundred and sixty
                   feet clear channel-way in each opening, and the piers of said bridge
                   shall be parallel with and the bridge itself at right angles to the cur-
                   rent of the river; also that all fixed spans located between the short-
                   lines at the medium stage of water shall be three hundred feet or more
                   in length, and that the clear head-room under such spans shall not be
                   less than ten feet at highest water: Provided also, That said draw shall
                   be opened pro:i.ptly, upon reasonable signal, for the passage of boats;
  Lights, etc-     and said corporation shall maintain, at its own expense, from sunset
                   till sunrise, such lights or other signals on said bridge as the Light-
                   House Board shall prescribe. No bridge shall be erected or maintained
                   under the authority of this act which shall at any time substantially
                   or materially obstruct the free navigation of said river; and ifany
  Free nav iga- bridge erected under such authority shall, in the opinion of the Secre-
tionnotto be ob- tary of War, obstruct such navigation, he is hereby authorized to cause
                   such change or alteration of said bridge to be made as will effectually
                   obviate such obstructions; and all such alterations shall be made and
                   all such obstructions be removed at the expense of the owner or own-
                   ers of said bridge; and in case of any litigation arising from any ob-
                   struction or alleged obstruction to the free navigation of said river
                    caused or alleged to be caused by said bridge, the case may be brought
  Litigation.       in the district court of the United States of the State of Missouri in
                    which any portion of said obstruction or bridge may be located: Pro-
                   vided furth r, That nothing in this act shall be so construed as to repeal
                    or modify any of the provisions of law now existing in reference to the
                   protection of the navigation of rivers, or to exempt this bridge from the
                   operation of the same.
  Other compan-       SEC. 4. That allrailroad companies desiring the use of said bridge shall
iesto have right have andbe entitled to equal rights and privileges relative to the passage
of way.             of railway trains or cars over the same, and over the approaches thereto,
                   upon payment of a reasonable compensation for such use; and in case
                    the owner or owners of said bridge and the several railroad companies,
  Secretary     of or any one of them, desiring such use shall fail to agree upon the sum or
War to decide sums to be paid, and upon rules arid conditions to which each shall con-
disagreement as form in using said bridge, all matters at issue between them shall be
to compensation. decided by the Secretary of War, upon a hearing of the allegations
  Proviso.          and proofs of the parties: Provided, That the provisions of section two
                    in regard to charges for passengers and freight across said bridge shall
                    not govern the Secretary of War in determining any question arising as
                    to the sum or sums to be paid to the owners of said bridge by said
                    companies for the use of said bridge.
  Plans, &c.,sub- SEC. 5. That any bridge authorized to be constructed under this act
ject to approval shall be built and located under and subject to such regulations for the
of Secretary of security of navigation of said river as the Secretary of War shall pre-
     Warscribe;              and to secure that object the said persons or corporation shall
                    submit to the Secretary of War, for his examination and approval, a
                    design and drawings of the bridge, and a map of the location, giving,
                    for the space of one mile above and one mile below the proposed loca-
                    tion, the topography of the banks of the river, the shore-lines at high
                    and low water, the direction and strength of the currents at all stages,
                    and the soundings, accurately showing the bed of the stream, the loca-
                    tion of any other bridge or bridges, and shall furnish such other in-
                    formation as may be required for a full and satisfactory understanding
                    of the subject; and until the said plan and location of the bridge are
                    approved by the Secretary of War the bridge shall not be built; and
                    should any change be made in the plan of said bridge during the prog-
                    ress of construction, such change shall be subject to the approval of the
                Secretary of War.
Rightto amend,   SEC. 6. That the right to alter, amend, or repeal this act is hereby ex-
etc.            pressly reserved; and the right to require any changes in said struct-
                   LAWS      AFFECTING         CORPS      OF ENGINEERS.                      409
ure, or its entire removal, at the expense of the owners thereof, when-
ever Congress shall decide that the public interest requires it, is also
expressly reserved.
  Approved, May 17, 1886.


CHAP. 345.-An act to givethe assent of Congress to the construction of a bridge by   May 17, 1886.
the Nashville, Jackson and Memphis Railroad Company over the Tennessee River.

   Be it enacted by the Senate and House of Representatives of the United
States of America in Congress assembled, That the assent of Congress is Nashville, Jack-
hereby given to the Nashville, Jackson and Memphis Railroad Corn- son            and Memphis
                                                                             Railroad C o m-
pa ny, a corporation organized under the laws of the State of Tennes- pany authorized
see, to construct and maintain a bridge, and approaches thereto, over to bridge the
the Tennessee River, at a point in the counties of Perry and Decatur, TennesseeRiver,
in said State of Tennessee, where it is most practicable (to be deter- in Tennessee.
mined by actual survey) for said railroad to cross said river. Said
bridge shall be constructed to provide for the passage of the locomo-
tives, passenger and freight trains, and other rolling-stock of said
Nashville, Jackson and Memphis Railroad Company over the same.
   SEc. 2. That any bridge built under the provisions of this act and sub- structure    andwfu
ject to its limitations shall be a lawful structure, and recoglnized and post-route.
known as a post-route; and it shall enjoy the rights and privileges of
other post-roads in the United States: Provided, That the United Proviso.
States may construct a postal telegraph over said bridge without charge Postal t el e-
therefor.                                                                    graph.
   SEC. 3. That-if said bridge shall be built with unbroken and contin- Spans.
uous spans, the spans thereof shall be of such width and height above
the water as may be prescribed by the Secretary of War: Provided, Provisos.
That the same shall not be less than one hundred and sixty-four feet Dimensions.
each in the clear; and the main span shall be over the main channel of
the river, and the bridge shall be at right angles to and its piers paral-
lel with the current of the river: Provided, That if the same shall be
constructed as a draw-bridge, the draw or pivot span shall be over the Draw.
main channel at an accessible point, and the span shall be of such
width and height above the water as may be prescribed by the Secre-
tary of War: Provided. that said draw or pivot spans shall not be less Dimensions.
than one hundred and sixty-four feet in the clear on each side of the
draw or pivot pier; and the piers of said bridge shall be parallel with
and the bridge itself at right angles to the current of the river : Pro-
vided also, That the said draw shall be opened promptly by said cor- Protections to
poration upon reasonable signal for the passage of boats; that sheer- navigation.
booms shall be constructed by said corporation; and that said corpora-
tion shall maintain, at its own expense, from sunset to sunrise, such Lights.
lights or other signals on said bridge as the Light House Board shall
prescribe.    No bridge shall be erected or maintained under the aun- Free naviga.
thority of this act which shall at any time substantially or materially tion not to be ob-
obstruct the free navigation of said river; and if any bridge erected structed.
under such authority shall, in the opinion of the Secretary of War,
obstruct such navigation, he is hereby authorized to cause such change
or alteration of such bridge to be made as will effectually obviate such
obstruction; and all such alterations shall be made and all such ob-
structions be removed at the expense of said corporation; and in case
of any litigation arising from any obstruction or alleged obstruction to Litigation.
the free navigation of said river, caused or alleged to be caused by said
bridge, the case may be brought in the circuit court of the United
States in whose jurisdiction any portion of said obstruction or bridge
may be located: Provided further, That nothing in this act shall be so
construed as to repeal or modify any of the provisions of law now exist-
ing in reference to the protection of the navigation of rivers, or to ex-
empt the bridge herein authorized to be constructed from the opera-
tions of the same.
   SEC. 4. That any bridge authorized to be constructed under the pro- Plans, etc.,
visions of this act shall be built and located under and subject to such subject to ap-
regulations for the security of navigation of said river as the Secretary of proval of Secre-
War shall prescribe; and to secure that object the said corporation shall tary of War.
submit to the Secretary of War, for his examination and approval, a
design and drawings, ot the bridge, and a map of the location, giving,
for a space of one mile above and one mile below the proposed location,
the topography of the banks of the river, the shore-lines at high and
410        REPORT OF THE           CHIEF      OF   ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

                 low water, the direction and strength of the currents at all stages, and
                 the soundings, accurately showing the bed of the stream, the location
                 of any other bridge or bridges, and shall furnish such other information
                 as may be required for a full and satisfactory understanding of the sub-
                 ject; and until the said plan and location of the bridge are approved
                 by the Secretary of War the bridge shall not be built; and should any
                 change be made in the plan of said bridge during the progress of con-
                 struction, such change shall be subject to the approval of the Secretary
                 of War.
                    SEC. 5. That the right to alter, amend, or repeal this act is hereby
    i
amenR   etc., re expressly reserved, and the right to require any changes in said struct-
served.          ure, or its entire removal, at the expense of the owners thereof, when-
                 ever Congress shall decide that the public interest requires it, is also
                 expressly reserved.
                    Approved May 17, 1886.



May 17, 1886.   CHAP. 347.-An act authorizing the construction of a bridge across the Missouri
                     River at or near the city of Council Bluffs, Iowa, and for other purposes.

                     Be it enacted by the Senate and House of Representatives of the United
  New York and States of America in Congress assembled, That the New York and Coun-
Council Bluffs dl Bluffs Railway Company, an incorporation organized under the laws
Railway Com-
pany authorized of the States of Ohio, Indiana, Illinois, and Iowa, its successors or as-
                 signs,
to bridge the Mis-        is hereby authorized to construct and maintain a bridge across
souri River in the Missouri River at such point as may be hereafter selected by said
Iowa.              corporation, bietween the north and south 1ines of the county of Potta-
                   wattamie, in the State of Iowa, and at least one-third of a mile from
                   any other bridge, as shall best promote the public convenience and
                   welfare and the necessities of business and commerce, and also to con-
                   struct and maintain the accessory works necessary to secure the best
                   practicable channel-way for navigation and to confine the flow of the
                   water to a permanent channel at such point, and also, if the said cor-
                   poration shall de m it for the best interests of the public so to do, to
                   lay on and over said bridge a railway track, for the more perfect con-
                   nection of any railroads that are or shall be constructed to said river
  W a g o n and at or opposite to said point; and said corporation shall construct and
foot bridge.       maintain ways for wagons, carriages, and for foot-passengers, and may
  Tolls.           charge and receive such reasonable toll therefor as may be approved
  Proviso.         from time to time by the Secretary of War : Provided, That said bridge,
  Combined rail. and all the property belonging thereto or connected therewith, may be
road and wagon
bridge,             constructed, maintained, and used as a combined railway and wagon
                    bridge, for the safe and convenient passage of wagons, carriages, stock,
                    steam, cable, and street cars, foot-passengers, and all road travel, or as
                    a wagon-bridge alone, for the safe and convenient passage of wagons,
                    carriages, stock, and foot-passengers, as the'said corporation shall elect,
                    as hereinbefore provided; but if the said corporatiou shall elect to
                    build a combined railroad and wagon bridge, then the track for wagons,
                    carriages, stock, and foot-passengers shall not be upon the same space
                    as that used for railroad track and cars.
  Free naviga-         SEC. 2. That said bridge shall be constructed and built without ma-
tion not to be terial interference with the security and convenience of navigation of
obstructed.         said river beyond what is necessary to carry into effect the rights and
  Plans. etc.. sub- privileges hereby granted; and in order to secure that object the said
ject to approval company or corporation shall submit to the Secretary of War, for his
of Secretary of examination and approval, a design and drawings of the bridge, and a
War.                map of the location, giving, for the space of one mile above and one
                    mile below the proposed location, the topography of the banks of the
                    river, the shore-lines at high and low water, the direction and strength
                    of the currents at all stages, and the soundings, accurately showing the
                    bed of the stream, the location of any other bridge or bridges, and shall
                    furnish such other information as may be required for a full and satis-
                    factory understanding of the subject ; and until the said plan and loca-
                    tion of the bridge are approved by the Secretary of War the bridge
  Provisos.         shall not Ibe built: Provided, That if the said bridge shall be made with
  Spans.         unbroken and continuous spans, it shall have three or more channel-
                 spans, and shall not be of less elevation in any case than fifty feet above
                 extreme high-water mark, as understood at the point of location, to the
                 bottom chord of the bridge, nor shall the spans of said bridge be less
                 LAWS      AFFECTING CORPS OF ENGINEERS.                              411
than three hundred feet in length, and the piers of said bridge shall be
parallel with the current of said river, and the main span shall be over
the main channel of the said river and not less than three hundred feet
in length: And provided also, That if any bridge built under this act
shall be constructed as a draw-bridge, the same shall be constructed as Draw.
a pivot draw-bridge, with a draw over the main channel of the river at
an accessible and navigable point, and with spans not less than one
hundred and sixty feet in length in the clear on each side of the central
or pivot pier of the draw, and the next adjoining span or spans to the
draw shall not be less than three hundred feet, and the head-room under
such span shall not be less than ten feet. above high-water mark: And
provided also, That said draw shall be opened promptly upon reasonable
signal for the passing of boats ; and said company or corporation shall Lights, etc.
maintain, at its own expense, from sunset until sunrise, such lights or
other signals on said bridge as the Light-House Board shall prescribe:
And provided also, That if said company or corporation shall elect, as Other compa-
is hereinbefore provided, to erect a combined railroad and wagon bridge, nies to have right
then all railway companies desiring to use said bridge shall have and be of way.
entitled to equal rights and privileges in the passage of the same, and
in the use of the machinery and fixtures thereof, and of all the ap-
proaches thereto, under and upon such terns and conditions as shall be Secretary of
prescribed by the Secretary of War, upon hearing the allegations and War to decide
proofs of the parties in case they shall not agree.                        disagreement as
    SEC. 3. That the Secretary of War is hereby authorized and directed, to terms.ar of
upon receiving such plan and map and other information, and upon            War    to notify
being satisfied that a bridge built on such plan, and with such accessory company of ap-
works, and at such locality will conform to     the prescribed conditions proval.
of this act, to notify the company that he approves the same; and upon
receiving such notification the said compn any may proceed to an erection
of said bridge, conforming strictly to the approved plan and location;
and should any change be made in the plan of the bridge or said ac-
cessory works, during the progress of the work thereon, such change
shall be subject likewise to the approval of the Secretary of War: and
in case of any litigation arising from any obstruction or alleged ob- Litigation.
struction to the free navigation of said river caused or alleged to be
caused by said bridge, the case may be brought in the circuit court of
the United States for the State of Iowa or the State of Nebraska, in
which any portion of said obstruction or bridge may be located.
    SEC. 4. That the said bridge and accessory works, when built and To be a lawful
constructed under this act and according to the terms and limintations structure a n d
thereof, shall be lawful structures:; and sai(l bridge shall be recognized post-route.
and known as a post-route, upon which also no higher charge shall be
made for the transmission over the same of the mails, the troops, and
the munitions of war of the United States than the rate per mile paid
for the transportation over the railroads or public highways leading to
said bridge; and said bridge shall enjoy the rights and privileges of
other post-routes of the United States; and Congress reserves the
right any time to regulate by appropriate legislation the charges for Charges.
freight and passengers over said bridge.
    SEC. 5. That the United States shall have the right of way for such Postal tel e -
postal-telegraph lines across said bridge as the Government of the graph.
United States may construct and control.
    SEC. 6. That Congress shall have power at any time to alter, amend, Right to amend,
or repeal this act so as to prevent or remove all material and substan- etc., reserved.
tial obstructions to the navigation of said river by the construction of
said bridge and its accessory works; and the expense of altering said
bridge or removing such obstructions shall be at the expense of the
owners of or persons controlling said bridge.
    SEC. 7. That this act shall take effect and be in force from and after
its passage.
    Approved, May 17, 186i.
412       REPORT       OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

May 17, 1886.   CHAP. 348.-An act authorizing the Inter-State Rapid Transit Railway Company
                                   to build a bridge across the Kansas River.

                    Be it enacted by the Senate and lHouse of Representatives of the United
  Inter-State States of America in Congress assembled, That the Inter-State Rapid-
Rapid-Transit Transit Railway Company, a corporation duly and legally organized
Railway Compa-
ny authorized to and existing under and by virtue of the laws of the State of Kansas,
bridge the Kans- its successors or assigns, be, and is hereby, authorized to construct and
asRiver,between maintain a brid e, and approaches thereto, over the Kansas River, in
Wyandotte and Wyandotte County, in the State of Kansas, between the city of Wyan-
Kansas, Kans.     dotte and the city of Kansas, Kansas, at the point where said company's
                  line of railway, as now projected, crosses said river, near the mouth
                  thereof    Said bridge shall be constructed to provide for the passage
                  of its railway trains, and, at the option of said company by which it
  Wagon and foot may be built, may be used for the passage of wagons and vehicles of
bridge.           all kinds, for the transit of animals, and for foot passengers, for such
   Tolls.         reasonable rates of toll as may be approved from time to time by the
                  Secretary of War.
   Post-route.       SEC. 2. That the briage that shall be built under this act shall be
                  recognized and known' as a post-route, upon which also no higher charge
                  shall be made for the transmission ox er the same of the mails, the
                  troops, and the munitions of war of the United States than the rate
                  per i:ile paid for the transportation over the railroad or public highways
                  leading to the said bridge; and it shall enjoy the rights and privileges
                  of other post-roads in the United States.
  Freenavigation     SEC. 3. That no bridge shall be erected or maintained under the au-
not tobeobstruct- thority of this act which shall at any time substantially or materially
ed.               obstruct the free navigation of said river; and'if any bridge erected
   Secretary of under such authority shall, in the opinion of the Secretary of War, ob-
War to prevent. struct such navigation, he is hereby authorized to cause such change
                  or alteration of said bridge to be made as will effectually obviate such
                  obstruction ; and all such alterations shall be made and all such obstruc-
                  tions be removed at the expense of' the owner or owners of said bridge;
   Litigation.    and iii case of ny litigation arising from any obstruction or alleged
                  obstruct ion to the free navigation of said river, caused or alleged to be
                  caused by said bridge, the case may be brought in the circuit court of
   Proviso.       the United States in and for the district of Kansas: Provided, That
                  nothing in this act shall be so construed as to repeal or modify any of
                  the provisions of law now existing in reference to the protection of the
                  navigation of rivers, or to exempt said bridge from the operation of
                  the same.
  Righttoamend,      SEC. 4. That the right to alter, amend, or repeal this act is hereby
etc., reserved.  expressly reserved.
                     Approved, May 17, 1H86.



  May 17,1886.   CHAP. 350.-An act to authorize the construction of a bridge across the Missouri
                  River at a point to be selected either in the counties of Clay and Jackson, in the
                  State of Missouri, or in the county of Clay or Platte, in said State, and the county
                  of Wyandotte, in the state of Kansas, and to make the same a post-route.

                     Be it enacted by the Senate and House of Representatives of the United
  Chicago, Mil- States of America in Congress assembled, That the Chicago, Milwaukee
w auk e e and and Saint Paul Railway Company. a cornoration orrganized under the
way    company    laws of the State of Wisconsin, and authorized by the laws of the State
authorized to of Missouri to locate and construct its railway Into and through said
bridge the Mis- State, is hereby authorized to construct and maintain a bridge across
souri River, in the Missouri River, on such line as its railway may hereafter be located,
M isso uri and either in the counties of Clay or Jackson, in the State of Missouri, or in
                  the county of Clay or Platte, in said State, and the county
                                                                                 of Wyan-
                  dotte, in the State of Kansas; and also to construct accessory works to
                  secure the best practicable channel-way for navigation and confine the
                  flow of the water to a permanent channel at such point; and also to lay
                  on and over such bridge a railway track for the more perfect connection
                  of its railway when constructed to said river.
  Free naviga-       SEC. 2. That said bridge shall Ire constructed and built without ma-
tion not to be b- taerial interference with the security and convenience of the navigation
             S    of said river beyond what is necessary to carry into effect the rights
                  and privileges hereby granted; and in order to secure that object the
                LAWS     AFFECTING        CORPS    OF    ENGINEERS.                 413
said company or corporation shall submit to the Secretary of War, for Plans, etc,, to
his examination and approval, a plan, design, and drawings of the be approved by
bridge, and a map of the location, giving, for thn 'space of one mile War.e           of
above and one mile below the proposed location, the topography of the
banks of the river, the shore lines at high and low water, the direction
and strength of the currents at all stages, and the soundings, accu-
rately showing the bed of the stream, the location of any other bridge
or bridges, and shall furnish such other information as may be required
fir a full and satisfactory understanding of the subject; and until the
said plan and location of the bridge are approved by the Secretary of
War the bridge shall not be built: Provided, That if the said bridge Provisos.
shall be made with unbroken and continuous spans, it shall have three Spans.
or more channel-spans of not less than three hundred feet each in the
clear, and shall not be of less elevation in any case than fifty feet above
extreme high-water mark as understood at the point of location, to the
bottom chord of the bridge, aind the piers of said bridge shall be par-
allel with the current of said river, and the main span shall be over the
main channel of the river, and not less than three hundred feet in
length in the clear: Proridedalso, That if any bridge built under this Draw.
act shall be constructed as a draw-bridge, the same shall be con-
structed as a pivot draw-bridge, with the draw over the main channel
of the river at an accessible and navigable point, and with spans of not
less than one hundred and sixty feet in length in the clear on each side
of the central or pivot pier of the draw, and the next adjoining span or
spans to the draw shall not be less than three hundred feet, and the
head-room under such span shall not be less than ten feet above high-
water mark : Provided also, That if any bridge built under this act shall
be constructed as a draw-bridge, the same shall be constructed as a
pivot draw-bridge, with the draw over the main channel of the river at
an accessible and navigable point, and with spans of not less than one
hundred and sixty feet in length in the clear on each side of the central
or pivot pier of the draw, and the next adjoining span or spans to the
draw shall not be less than three hundred feet, and the head-room under
such span shall not be less than ten feet above high-water mark: Pro-
vided also, That said draw shall be opened promptly upon reasonable Lights, etc.
signal for the passing of boats; and said company or corporation shall
maintain, at its own expense, from sunset till sunrise, such lights or other
signals on said bridges as the Light-House Board shall prescribe.
    SEC.8.   That the Secretary of War is authorized and directed, upon Secretary or
receiving such plan, map, and other information, and upon being satis- War t o notify
fled that the bridge built upon such plan and with such accessory works proval.y of ap-
and at such locality will conform to the prescribed conditions of this
act, to notify said company or corporation that he approves the same;
and upon receiving such notification said company or corporation may
proceed to the erection of said bridge, conforming strictly to the ap-
proved plan and location; and should any change be made in the plan
of the bridge or said accessory works during the progress of the work
thereon, such change shall be subject likewise to the approval of the
Secretary of War; and in case of any litigation arising from any ob- Litigation.
struction or alleged: obstruction to the free navigation of said river
caused or alleged to be caused by said bridge, the case may be brought
in the circuit court of the United States of the district where said bridge
or any part thereof is located.
    SEC. 4. That the said bridge and accessory works, when built and To be a lawful
constructed under this act and according to the terms and limitations structure a n d
thereof, shall be lawful structures; and said bridge shall be recognized post-route.
and known as a post-route, upon which also no higher charge shall
be made for the transmission over the same of the      mails,   the troops,
and the munitions of war of the United States, or for passengers and
freight passing over said bridge, than the rate per mile paid for the trans-
portation over the railroads or public highways leading to said bridge;
and said bridge shall enjoy the rights and privileges of other post-
routes in the United States.
    SEC. 5. That the United States shall have the right of way for such Postaltelegraph.
postal-telegraph lines across said bridge as the Government may con-
struct or control.
    SEC. 6. That all railroad companies desiring the use of said bridge Other compa-
shall have and be entitled to equal rights and privileges relative to the ipestohaveright
passage of railway trains or cars over the same, and over the aplproaches
thereto, upon payment of a reasonable compensation for such use; and
414           REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

Secretary of in case the owner or owners of said bridge and the several railroad
War to decide companies, or any one of them, desiring such use shall fail to agree
disagreements as upon the sum or sums to be paid, and upon rules and conditions to
to terms.       which each shall conform in using said bridge, all matters at issue be-
                tween them shall be decided by the Secretary of War, upon a hearing
  Proviso.      of the allegations and proofs of the parties: Provided, That the provis-
  Charges.      ions of section Four in regard to charges for passengers and freight
                across said bridge shall not govern the Secretary of War in determin-
                ing any question arising as to the sum or sums to be paid to the owners
                of said bridge by said companies for the use of said bridge.
Right to amend, SEC. 7. That Congress shall have power at any time to alter or amend
etc., reserved. this act so as to prevent or remove all material and substaptial obstruc-
                tions to the navigation of said river by the construction of said bridge
                and its accessory works ; and the expense of altering said bridge or re-
                moving such obstructions shall be borne by the owners of or persons
                controlling such bridge.
                   Approved, May 17, 1886.


  May 17, 1886.         CHAP. 351.-An act to authorize the construction of a pile and pontoon railway
                         and wagon bridge across the Mississippi River from the city of Red Wing, Minnesota
                         to the opposite shore, in the State of Wisconsin.

                 Wing Be it enacted by the Senate and House of Representatives of the United
            Red Pon-
toonBridgeCom- States of America in Congress assembled, That the Red Wing Pontoon
pany authorized Bridge Company, a corporation existing under the laws of the State of
to bridgetheMis- Minnesota, is hereby authorized to construct and maintain a pile and
issippi River, at pontoon railway and wagon bridge across the Mississippi River, from
  Subject to termsn. the city of Red Wing, State of Minnesota, so as to connect with the
of Vol. 18,   ch.224,   opposite shore of said river, in the State of Wisconsin; said bridge to
p. 62.                  built subject, except as herein provided, to all the terms, require-
                        ments, and limitations contained in the act entitled " An act to legalize
                        and establish a pontoon railway bridge across the Mississippi River at
                        Prairie du Chien, and to authorize the construction of a similar bridge
                        at or near Clinton, Iowa", approved June sixth, eighteen hundred and
                        seventy-four, so far as they may be applicable thereto.
  Draw.                   SEC. 2. That said bridge shall be so constructed with a suitable pon-
                        toon draw of not less than four hundred feet in length, located over the
  Proviso.              main channel of the river: Provided, That said bridge shall not be
  Subject to ap- built or commenced until the plan and specifications for its construc-
tary of War, as to tion have been submitted to the Secretary of War for his approval, nor
plans, etc.        until he shall approve the plan and location of said bridge; and if any
                   change be made in the plan of construction of said bridge at any time,
                   such change shall be subject to the approval of the Secretary of War;
                   and any change in the construction or any alteration of said bridge
                   that may be directed at any time by Congress or the Secretary of War
                   shall be made at the cost and expense of the owners thereof.
  Tolls.             SEC. 3. That if said bridge is constructed as a wagon bridge, the said
                   company may charge such reasonable rates of toll for the passage of
                   wagons and vehicles of all kinds and for the transit of animals and foot-
                   passengers as may from time to time be approved by the Secretary of
                        War.
                          SEC. 4. That Congress may at any time alter, amend, or repeal this
                        act.
                          Approved, May 17, 1886.


  May 17, 1886.         CHAP. 352.-An act to authorize the construction of a bridge over the Missouri
                          River at the most accessible point between the mouth of the Femme Osage Creek
                         and a point two miles above the city of Saint Charles, in the county of Saint Charles
                         in the State of Missouri.

                          Be it enacted by the Senate and House of Representatives of the United
Saint Louis States of America in Congress assembled, That the Saint Louis Kansas
Kansas City City Short-Line Railway Company, a corporation organized under the
Short-Line      Rail-
    SCom pany laws of the State of Missouri. and its assigns or successors, be, and they
authori z ed to are hereby, authorized to construct and maintain a bridge, and p-
bridge the Mis- proaches thereto, over the Missouri River at the most accessible point
sour River, near between the mouth of the Femme Osage Creek and a point two miles
aMo.tCarle above the city of Saint Charles, in the county of Saint Charles, in the
                 LAWS     AFFECTING        CORPS OF       ENGINEERS.                 415
State of Missouri. Said bridge shall be constructed to provide for the Passage of rail-
passage of railway trains, and at the option of the corporation or com- way trains, wag-
pany by which it may be built, may be used for the passage of wag- onsetc.,
ons and, veihcles of all kinds, for the transit of animals, and for foot-
passengers for such reasonable rates of toll as may be approved from Tolls.
time to time by the Secretary of War.
   SEC. 2. That any bridge built under this act and subject to its limita- To be a lawful
tions shall be a lawful structure, and shall be recognized and known as struct ure and
a post-route, upon which also no higher charge shall be made for the post-route.
transmission over the same of the mails, the troops, and the munitions
of war of the United States, or for passengers and freight passing over
said bridge, than the rate per mile paid for the transportation over the
railroad or public highways leading to the said bridge; and it shall
enjoy the rights and privileges of the other post-roads in the United
States.
   SEC. 3. That if said bridge shall be made with unbroken and con- Spans.
tinuous spans, the spans thereof shall not be less than three hundred
feet in length in the clear, and the main span shall be over the main
channel of the river. The lowest part of the superstructure of said
bridge shall be at least fifty feet above extreme high-water mark, as
understood at the point of location, and the bridge shall be at right
angles to and its piers parallel with the current of the river: Provided,
That if the same shall be constructed as a draw-bridge, the draw or pivot Provisos.
shall be over the main channel of the river at an accessible point, and Draw.
the spans shall not be less than one hundred and sixty feet in length
in the clear, and the piers of said bridge shall be parallel with and the
bridge itself at right angles to the current of the river, and the spans
shall not be less than ten feet above extreme high water-mark, as under-
stood at the point of location to the lowest part of the superstructure
of said bridge: Provided also, That said draw shall be opened promptly Lights, etc.
upon reasonable signal for the passage of boats: and said company or
corporation shall maintain, at its own expense, from sunset till sunrise,
such lights or other signals on said bridge as the Light-House Board
shall prescribe. No bridge shall be erected or maintained under the Free naviga-
authority of this act which shall at any time substantially or materially tion notto be ob-
obstruct the free navigation of said river; and if any bridge erectedtruted.
under such authority shall, in the opinion of the Secretary of War,
obstruct such navigation, he is hereby authorized to cause such change
or alteration of said bridge to be made as will effectually obviate such
obstruction; and all such alterations shall be made and all such ob-
structions be removed at the expense of the owner or owners of said
bridge; and in case of any litigation arising from any obstruction or Litigation.
alleged obstruction to the free navigation of said river caused or alleged
to be caused by said bridge, the case may be brought in the district court
of the United States of the State ofMissouri, in which any portion of said
obstruction or bridge may be located: Provided further, That nothing
in this act shall be so construed as to repeal or modify any of the pro-
visions of law now existing in reference to the protection of the navi-
gation of the river, or to exempt this bridge from the operation of the
same.
   SEC. 4. That all railroad companies desiring the use of said bridge Other compa-
shall have and be entitled to equal rights and privileges relative to of way.
the passage of railway trains or cars over the same, and over the ap-
proaches thereto, upon payment of a reasonable compensation for such
use; and in case the owner or owners of said bridge and the several Secretary o f
railroad companies, or any one of them, desiring such use, shall fail to War to decide
agree upon the sum or sums to be paid, and upon rules and conditions to terms, etc.
to which each shall conform in using said bridge, all matters at issue
between them shall be decided by the Secretary of War upon a hearing
of the allegations and proofs of the parties : Provided, That the provis- Proviso.
ions of section two in regard to charges for passengers and freight
across said bridge shall not govern the Secretary of War in determin-
ing any question arising as to the sum or sums to be paid to the owners
of said bridge by said companies for the use of said bridge.
   SEC. 5. That any bridge authorized to be constructed under this act Plans, etc., to
shall be built and located under and subject to such regulations for thee  cretarved by
security of navigation of said river as the Secretary of War shall War.
prescribe; and to secure that object the said company or corporation
shall submit to the Secrerary of War, for his examination and approval,
a design and drawings of the bridge, and a map of the location, giving,
416         REPORT     OF    THE     CHIEF       OF ENGINEERS,            U. S. ARMY.

                for the space of one mile above and one mile below the proposed loca-
                tion, the topography of the banks of the river, the shore-lines at high
                and low water, the direction and strength of the currents at all stages,
                and the soundings, accurately showing the bed of the stream, the loca-
                tion of any other bridge or bridges, and shall furnish such other informa-
                tion as may be required for a full and satisfactory understanding of the
                subject; and until the said plan and location of the bridge are an-
                proved by the Secretary of War the bridge shall not be built; and
                should any change be made in the plan of said bridge during the prog-
                ress of construction, such change shall be subject to the approval of the
                 Secretary of War.
Righttoamend,     SEC. 6. That the right to alter, amend, or repeal this act is hereby
etc.. reserved,  expressly reserved; and the right to require any changes in said struct-
                 ure, or its entire removal, at the expense of the owners thereof, when-
                 ever Congress shall decide that the public interest requires it, is also
                 expressly reserved.
                   Approved, May 17, 1886.



May 17, 1886.   CHAP. 353.-An act to authorize construction of a bridge over the Missouri River
                  at the most accessible point in Saline City, or within five miles above or five miles
                  below the same, in the county of Saline, in the State of Missouri.

                   Be it enacted by the Senate and House of Representatives of the United
  Saint Louis States of America in Congress assembled, That the Saint Louis Kansas
Kansas City City Short-Line Railway Company, a corporation organized under the
Short-Line Rail- laws of the State of Missouri, and its assigns or successors, be, and they
thri C p     d to are hereby, authorized to construct and maintain a bridge, and ap-
bridge the Mis- proaches thereto, over the Missouri River at the most accessible point
souri River at Sa- in Saline City, or within five miles above or five miles below the same,
li aage ofail- in the county of Saline, in the State of Missouri. Said bridge shall be
way trains, wag- constructed to provide for the passage of railway trains, and, at the
ons., etc.         option of the corporation or company by which it may be built, may be
                    used for the passage of wagons and vehicles of all kinds, for the transit
                   of animals, and for foot-passengers, for such reasonable rates of toll as
                   may be approved from time to time by the Secretary of War.
   To be a lawful     SEC. 2. That any bridge built under this act and subject to its limit-
struct u r e and ations shall be a lawful structure, and shall be recognized and known
post-route.         as a post-route, upon which also no higher charge shall be made for the
                   transmission over the same of the mails, the troops and the munitions
                    of war of the United States, or for passengers and freight passing over
                    said bridge, than the rate per mile paid for the transportation over the
                   railroad or public highways leading to the said bridge; and it shall
                    enjoy the rights and privileges of other post-roads in the United States.
                      SEc. 3. That if said bridge shall be made with unbroken and contin-
   Spans.           uous spans, the spans thereof shall not be less than three hunred feet
                    in length in the clear, and the main span shall be over the main channel
                    of the river. The lowest part of the superstructure of said bridge shall
                    be at least fifty feet above extreme high-water mark, as understood at
                    the point of location, and the bridge shall be at right angles to and its
   Provisos:       piers parallel with the current of the rive : Provided, That if the same
   Draw.            shall be constructed as a draw-bridge, the draw or pivot shall be over
                   the main channel of the river at an accessible point, and the spans shall
                   not be less than one hundred and sixty feet in length in the clear, and
                    the piers of said bridge shall be parallel with and the bridge itself at
                   right angles to the current of the river, and the spans shall not be less
                   than ten feet above extreme high-water mark, as understood at the
                   point of location, to the lowest part of the superstructure of said bridge :
                   Provided also, That said draw shall be opened promptly, upon reason-
                               for
                    able signal,      the passage of boats; and said company or corporation
   Lights, etc.     shall maintain, at its own expense, from sunset till sunrise, such lights
                    or other signals on said bridge as the Light-House Board shall prescribe.
                    No bridge shall be erected or maintained under the authority of this
   Free navigation act which shall at any time substantially or materially obstruct the free
not to be ob- navigation of said river; and if any bridge erected under such author-
structed.        ity shall', in the opinion of the Secretary of War, obstruct such naviga-
                 tion, he is hereby authorized to cause such change or alteration of said
                 bridge to be made as will effectually obviate such obstriuction ; and all
                  LAWS     AFFECTING         CORPS     OF    ENGINEERS.                   417
such alterations shall be made and all such obstructions he removed at
the expense of the owner or owners of said bridge; and in case of any
litigation arising from any obstruction or alleged obstruction to the free Litigation.
navigation of said river caused or alleged to be caused by said bridge,
the case may be brought in the district court of the United States of the
State of Missouri in which any portion of said obstruction or bridge
may be located: Provided further, That nothing in this act shall be so
construed as to repeal or modify any of the provisions of law now ex-
isting in reference to the protection of the navigation of rivers, or to
exempt this bridge from the operation of the same.
   SEC. 4. That all railroad companies desiring the use of said bridge Other compa-
shall have and be entitled to equal rights and privileges relative to the nies to have right
passage of railway trains or cars over the same, and over the approaches of way.
thereto, upon payment of a reasonable compensation for such use; and Secretary of
in case the owner or bwners of said bridge and the several railroad com- War to decide
panies, or any one of them, desiring such use, shall fail to agree upon to terms, etsac.s
the sum or sums to be paid, and upon rules and conditions to which
each shall conform in using said bridge, all matters at issue between
them shall be decided by the Secretary of War upon hearing of the
allegations and proofs of the parties: Provided, That the provisions of Proviso.
section two in regard to charges for passengers and freight across said
bridge shall not govern the Secretary of War in determining any ques-
tion arising as to the sum or sums to be paid to the owners of said
bridge by said companies for the use of said bridge.
   SEC. 5. That any bridge authorized to be constructed under this act Plans, etc., to
shall be built and located under and subject to such regulations for the be appproved by
security of navigation of said river as the Secretary of War shall pre- Secretary         o f
scribe; and to secure that object the said company or corporation shall
submit to the Secretary of War, for his examination and approval, a
sdesign and drawings of the bridge, and a map of the location, giving,
for the space of one mile above and one mile below the proposed loca-
tion, the topography of the banks of the river, the shore-lines at high
and low water, the direction and strength of the currents at all stages,
and the soundings, accurately showing the bed of the stream, the loca-
tion of any other bridge or bridges, and shall furnish such other infor-
mnation as may be required for a full and satisfactory understanding of
the subject; and until the said plan and location of the bridge are ap-
proved by the Secretary of War the bridge shall not be built; and
should any change be made in the plan of said bridge, during the prog-
ress of construction, such change shall be subject to the approval of the
Secretary of War.
   SEC. 6. That the right to alter, amend, or repeal this act is hereby Right              to
expressly reserved; and the right to require any changes in said struct- amser, etc., re-
nre, or its entire removal, at the expense of the owners thereof, when-
ever Congress shall decide that the public interest requires it, is also
expressly reserved.
   Approved, May 17, 1886.



CHAP. 354.-An act granting to the Gainesville and Chickasaw Bridge Company the    May 17, 1886.
consent of the United States to construct and maintain a bridge over Red River
at or near Brown's Ferry, in Cooke County, Texas.
   Be it enacted by the Senate and House of Represeunatives of the United
States of America in Congress assembled, That to the Gainesville and Gainesville and
Chickasaw Bridge Company, a corporation created under the laws of C h i c k a s a w
Texas by charter filed January twenty-fourth, eighteen hundred and Bridge Company
eighty-five, is granted the conseiit of the Government to construct and build a wagon
maintain for ninety years a bridge, and approaches thereto, over Red and foot-bridge
River, at or within three miles of Brown's Ferry, in Cooke County, over the Ren's
Texas, to be used for the passage of foot-passengers, animals, and vehi- Ferry, Tex.
cles of all kinds, for reasonable rates of toll, to be approved from time Tolls.
to time by the Secretary of War.
   SEC. 2. That the right herein granted shall be void unless said bridge  To be built
is constructed within four years from the passage of this act.            within four
   SEC. 3. That the bridge constructed under this act shall be a lawful To be a lawful
structure, and shall be known and recognized as a post-route; andthe structure and
same is hereby declared to be a post-route upon which also no higher post-route.
charge shall ble made for the transmission over the same of the mails,
         27 E
418       REPORT        OF THE       CHIEF      OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

                  the troops, arid the mnnitions of war of the United States than other
   Provisos,      persons pay for like transportation ; and the United States shall have
   Plans, etc.,to the right of way for a postal telegraph across said bridge: Provided,
approved by Sec- That before this act shall take effect said company shall submit to the
retary of War. Secretary of War the plans and specifications of said( bridge, showing
                  the proposed location and structure contemplated, and that it shall be
                  decided by the Secretary that said bridge does not and will not ob-
  Righttoamend, s rict or impair the navigation of said Re(l River : Provided further,
etc., reserved.   That Congress reserves the right to alter, amend, or repeal this act at
   Free naviga- any time ; and that if at any time navigation of the said river shall in
tion notto beob- any manner be obstructed or impaired by the said bridge, the Secre-
structed.         tary of War shall have authority, and it shall be his duty, to require
                  the said company to alter and change the said b)rildge, at its own ex-
                  pense, in such manner as may be proper to secure free and complete
                  navigation without impediment ; and if upon reasonable niotice to said
                  colmpany to make such change or improvements the said company fails
                        so, the Secretary of War shall have authority to take the same
                  to (1do
                  at the expense of said company , and all rights conferred by this act
                  shall be forfeited ; and Congress shall have power to do any and all
                  things necessary to secure the free nay gation of the river.
                    Approved, May 17, 186.



  May 17, 1886.   CHAP. 355.-An act to authorize the construction of a bridge across the Missour
                   River at some accessible point within two miles north and two miles south of the
                   city of Atchison, in the county of Atchison. in the State of Kansas.

                   Be it enacted by the Senate and House of Representatives of the United
  A t c h i so n States of America in Congress assemnbled, That the Atchison Bridge Com-
Bridue Company pany, an incorporation organized under the laws of the State of Kan-
author iz e d to sas, is hereby authorized to construct and maintain a bridge across the
build a railroad Missouri River at such a point as may be hereafter selected by said cor-
bridge across the poration within two miles north and two miles south of the city of Atch-
Missouri River ison, in the county of Atchison, in the State of Kansas, as shall best
at A t c his o n, promote the public convenience and welfare and the necessities of busi-
Kans.             ness and commerce; and also to construct accessory works to secure
                  the best practicable channel-way for navigation and confine the flow of
                  the water to a permanent channel at such point; and also to lay on and
                  over said bridge a railway track for the more perfect connection of any
                  railroads that are or shall be constructed to said river at or opposite
                  said point; and said corporation may construct and maintain ways for
                  wagons, carriages, atid for foot-passengers, charging and receiving rea-
  Tolls.          sorable toll therefor as may be approved from time to time by the Sec-
                  retary of War.
  Plans, etc., to SEC. 2. That said bridge shall be constructed and built without inter-
e approved by ference with the security and convenience uf navigation of said river
Secretary of
War.             beyond what is necessary to carry into effect the rights and privileges
                  het eby granted; and in order to secure that object the said company or
                  corporation shall submit to the Secretary of War, for his examination
                  and approval, a design and drawings of the bridge, antd a rnap of the
                  location, giving, for the space of one nile above and one mile below the
                  proposed location, the topography of the banks of the river, the shore-
                  lines at high and low water, the direction and strength of the currents
                  at all stages, and the sonnlding, accurately showing the bed of the
                  streamn, the location of any other bridge or bridges, and shall furnish
                  such other information as may be required for a full and satisfactory
                  understanding of the subject; and until the said plan and location of
                  the bridge are approved by the Secretary of War the bridge shall not
   Provisos.      be built: Provided, That if the said bridge shall be made with unbroken
                  continuous spans, it shall have three or more channel-spans and shall
   Spans.         not be of less elevation in any case than fifty feet above extreme high-
                  water mark, as understood at the point of location, to the bottom chord
                  of the bridge; nor shall the spans of said bridge be less than three hun-
                  dred feet in length, and the piers of said bridge shall be parallel with
                  the current of said river, and the main span shall be over the main
                  channel of the river, aid not less than three hundred feet in length:
                  And rovided albo, That if any bridge built under this act shall be con-
                  structed as a draw-bridge, the same shall be constructed as a pivot
                   LAWS      AFFECTING CORPS OF ENGINEERS.                                    419
draw-bridge, with a draw over the rluain channel of the river at an
accessible and navigable point, and with spans of not less than two Draw.
hundred feet in length in the clear on each side of the central or pivot
pier of the draw, and the next adjoining span or spans to the draw
shall not be less than three hundred feet, and the head-room under such
span shall not be less than ten feet above high-water mark: Provided Lights, etc.
also, That said draw shall be opened promptly upon reasonable signal
for the passing of boats ; and said company or corpcrat ion shall rmain-
tain, at its own expense, from sunset till sunrise, such lights or other
signals on said bridge as the Light-House Board shall prescribe : Pro-
vided also, That all railway companies desiring to use said bridge shall Other compas
have and be entitled to equal rights and privileges in the passage ofof way.
the samne, and in the use of the machinery and fixtures thereof, aind of
all the approaches thereto, under and upon such terms and (conditions Secretary of
as shall be prescribed by the Secretary of War, upon hearing the alle- iarto deci8d e
gatioas and proofs of the parties, in case they shall not agree.          to terms, etc.
   SEC. :3. That the Secretary of War is hereby authorized and directed, Secretary         of
upon receiving such plan and map and other information, and upon War to notify
being satisfied that a bridge built on such plan and with such     accts- company     of  ap-
sory works and at such locality will couformi to the prescribied condi-
tions of this act, to notify the company that he approves the samle; and
upon receiving such notification the said company may proceed to an
erection of said bridge, conforming strictly to the approve plan and
location; and shoild any change be mirade in the plan of thic bridge or
said accessory works, during the progress of the work thereon, such
change shall be sulbject likewise to the approval of the Secretary of
War; and in case of any litigation arising from any obstruction or al- Litigation
leged obstruction to the free navigation of said river, caused or al-
leged to be caused by said bridge, the case may be brought in the
circuit court of the United States of the State of Kansas or State of
Missouri in which any portion of said obstruction or bridge may be
located.
   SEC. 4. That the said bridge and accessory works, when built and To be a lawful
constructed under this act, and according to the terms and limitations structure         and
                                                                          post-route.
thereof, shall be lawful structures; and said bridge shall be recognized
and known as a post-route, upon which also no higher charge shall be
made for the transmission over the same of the mails, the troops, and
the munitions of war of the United States than the rate per mile paid
for the transportation over the railroads or public highways leading to
said bridge; and said bridge shall enjoy the rights and privileges of
other post-routes in the United States; and Congress reserves the right
at any time to regulate by appropriate legislation the charges for freight Charges.
and passengers over said bridge.
   SEC. 5. That the United States shall have the right of way for such Postal-tele-
postal-telegraph lines across said bridge as the Government may con- graph.
struct or control.
   SEc. 6. That Congress shall have power at any time to alter, amend      Righttoamend,
or repeal this act so as to prevent or remove all material and substai- ect., reserved.
tial obstructions to the navigation of said river by the construction of
said bridge and its accessory works; and the expense of altering said
bridge or removing such obstructions shall be at the expense of the
owners of or persons controlling such bridge.
   Approved, May 17, 1886.




CHAP. 356.-An act to authorize the construction and maintenance of a bridge by the   May 17, 1886.
Dakota Central Railway Company, across the Missouri River, at Pierre, Dakota.

  Be it enacted by the Senate and House of Representatives of the United
States of America in Congress assembled, That the Dakota Ceuntral Rail- Dakota Central
way Company, a corporation duly organized under the general incor- Railway Co -
poration laws of the Territory of Dakota, its successors and assigns, is pary authorized
hereby authorized to construct and maintain a bridge across the Mis- souri eRiver at
soiri River at or near the city of Pierre, Hughes (County, Dakota, and Pierre, Dak.
also to lay on and over said bridge a railway track or tracks for the
passage of railway trains; and said corporation may construct and
maintain ways for wagons, carriages, and foot-passengers, charging Wagon andfoot
and receiving such reasonable tolls therefor as may be approved, from bridge.
time to time by the Secretary of War.                                                Tolls.
420       REPORT OF        THE    CHIEF      OF ENGINEERS,          U. S. ARMY.

  Plans, etc., to SEC. 2. That said bridge shall be constructed and built without in-
be approved by terference with the security and convenience of navigation of said
War.               river beyond what is necessary to carry into effect the rights and
                   privileges hereby granted; and in order to secure that object the said
                   cor'poration shall submit to the Secretary of War, for his examination
                   and approval, a design and drawings of the bridge, and a map of the
                   location, giving, for the space of one mile above and one mile below
                   the proposed location, the topography of the banks of the river, the
                   shore-lines at high and low water, the direction and strength of the
                   currents at all stages, and the soundings, accurately showing the bed
                   of the stream, the location of any other bridge or bridges, and shall
                   furnish such other information as may be required for a full and satis-
                   factory understanding of the subject; and until the said plan and loca-
                   tion of the bridge are approved by the Secretary of War the bridge
   Provisos.       shall not be built: Provided, That if the said bridge shall be made
  Spans.           with unbroken and continuous spans, it shall not be of less elevation
                   in any case than fifty feet above extreme high water mark, as under-
                   stood at the point of location, to he the lov est part of the superstruct-
                   ure of the bridge, nor shall the spans of said bridge be less than three
                   hundred feet in length, and the piers of s:id. bridge shall be parallel
                   with the current of said river, and the main span shall be over the
                   main channel of the river and not less 1han three hundred feet in
                   length : And protided also, That if any bridge built under this act shall
   Draw.           be constructed as a draw-bridge, the same shall be constructed as a
                   pivot draw-bridge, with a draw over the nwain channel of the river at
                   an accessible and navigable point, and with spans of not less than one
                   hundred and sixty feet in length in the clear on each side of the cen-
                   tral or pivot pier of the draw, and the next adjoining span or spans to
                   the draw shall not be less than three hundred feet, and the head room
                   uinder such span shall not be less ten feet above local high-water mark :
   Lights, etc.
                Provided      also, That said draw shall be opened promptly upon reason-
                   able signal for the passing of boats; and said company or corporation
                   shall maintain, at its own expense, from sunset till sunrise, such lights
                   or other signals on said bridge as the Light House Board shall pri,-
   Other corn- scribe: Provided also, That all railway companies desiring to use said
panies to have bridge- shall have and be entitled to equal rights and privileges in the
right of way.      passage of the same, and in the use of the machinery and fixtures
                   thereof, and of all the approaches thereto, under and upon such terms
   Secretary    of and conditions as shall be prescribed by the Secretary of War, upon
Wa r o decide hearing the allegations and proofs of the parties, in case they
disagreements aotr                                                                       shall
to terms, etc.     not agree.
  Secretary     of SEc. 3. That the Secretary of War is hereby authorized and directed,
War to notify upon receiving such plan and map and other information, and upon
company of ap- being satisfied that the bridge built upon such plan with such acces-
                   sory works, and at such locality will conform to the prescribed condi-
                   tions of this act, to notify the company that he approves the same,
                   and upon rei eiving such notification the said company may proceed to
                   an erection of said bridge, conforming strictly to the approved plan
                   and location ; and should any change be made in the plan of the bridge
                   or accessory works, during the progress of the work thereon, such
                   change shall be subject likewise to the approval of the Secretary of
  Litigation.      War; and in case of any litigation arising from any obstruction or al-
                   leged obstruction to the free navigation of said river, caused or alleged
                   to be caused by said bridge, the case may be brought in any circuit
                   court of the United States or any district court of the Territory of Da-
                   kota, within whose jurisdiction, any portion of said bridge may be
                   located.
  To be a lawful      SEC. 4. That the said bridge and accessory works, when built and
structure and constructed under this act and according to the terms and limitations
post-route.        thereof, shall be lawful structures; and said bridge shall be recognized
                   and known as a post-route, upon which no higher charge shall be
                   made for the transmission over the same of the mails, the troops, and
                   the munitions of war of the United States than the rate per mile paid
                   for the transportation over the railroads or public highways leading to
                   such bridge, and said bridge shall enjoy the rights and privileges of
                   other post-routes in the United States ; and Congress reserves the right
  Charges.         at any time to regulate by appropriate legislation the charges for
                    freight and passengers over said bridge.
  P o s t a 1-t ele- SEC. 5. That the United States shall have the right of way for such
graph,              postal-telegraph lines acros
                                            cr   said bridge as the Government may con-
                    struct or control.
                  LAWS     AFFECTING         CORPS     OF ENGINEERS.                     421
  SEC. 6. That the right to alter, amend, or repeal this act is hereby Righttoamend,
expressly reserved; and the right to require any changes in said struct- etc., reserved.
are, or its entire removal, at the expense of the owners thereof, when-
ever Congress shall decide that the public interest requires it, is also
expressly reserved.
  Approved, May 17, 1886.



CHAP. 357.-An act to authorize the Chicago, Milwaukee and Saint Paul, Rail. May 17, 1886.
way Company to construct, operate, and maintain a Bridge across the Missouri --
River near or in the vicinity of Chamberlain in the Territory of Dakota.

   Be it enacted by the Senate and House of     iepresenlotires
                                                              of the United Chicago, Mil-
States of America in Congress assembled, That the Chicago, Milwaukee waukeeandSaint
and Saint Paul Railway Company shall have the right to construct PaulRailway
and maintain a Bridge across the Missouri River near or in the vicinity eCompanb        ather-
of the city of Chamberlain, in the Territory of Dakota and also to lay Missouri Riv er
on and over said bridge a railway track or tracks for the passage of at Chamberlain,
railway trains; and said corporation may, at its option, construct and Dak.
maintain ways for wagons, carriages, and loot-passengers, charging Wagon and foot
and receiving such reasonable tolls therefor as may be apiproved from bridge.
time to time by the Secretary of War.                                           Tolls.
   SEC. B. That said bridge shall be constructed and built without in-
                                                                    of  said
                                                                                Free n a vig a-
                                                                             lion not to be ob-
terference with the security and couvenienience of navigatiosn
                       necessary to carry into effect t e rights aLnd privi-
river beyond what is
leges hereby granted ; and in order to secure that object the said cor- Plans, etc., to
poration shall submit io the Secretary of War, for his examination and be approved by
approval, a (designi andl drawings of the bridge, and a map of the loca- the Secretary o
tion, giving, for the space of one mile above and one mile below the
proptosed location, the topography of the ban,ks of the river, the shore-
lines at high and low water, the direction and strength of the curreuts
at all stages, and the soundings, accurately showing the bed of the
stream, the location of anly other bridge or bridges, anld shall furnish
such other information as ,may be required for a full and satisfactory
understanding of the subject; and until the said plan and loc'ation of
the bridge are approved by the Secretary of War the bridge shall not
be built: Provided, That if the said bridge shall be made with un- Prorisoe.
broken and continuous sp)ans, it shall not be of less elevation in anly Spans.
case than fifty feet above extreme high-water mark, as untlerstood at
the poilt of location, to the lowest hart of the superstructure of the
bridge, nor shall the spans of said bridge be less than three hundred
feet in length, and the piers of said bridge shall be parallel with the
current of said river, and the main span .shall be over the main chan-
nel of the river and not less than three hundred feet in length : And
provided also, That if any bridge built under this act shall be con-
structed as a draw-bridge, the same shall be constructed as a pivot Draw.
draw-bridge, with a draw over the main channel of the river at an ac-
cessible and navigable point, and with spans of not less than one hun-
dred and sixty feet in length in the clear on each side of the central or
pivot pier of the draw, and the next adjoining span or spans to the
draw shall not be less than three hundred feet, and the head room
under such span shall not be less that ten feet above local sigh-water
mark : Provided also, That said draw shall ie opened promsptly upon
reasonable signal for the passing of boats ; and said company or cor- Lights, etc.
poration shall maintain, at its own expense, from sunset till sunrise,
such lights or other signals on said bridge as the Light       ouse Board
shall prescribe: Provided also, That all railway companies desiring to Other coin-
use said bridge shall have and be entitled to equal rights and privi- panies to have
leges in the passage of the same, and in the use of the machinery and right of way.
fixtures thereof, and of all the approaches thereto, under and upon
such terms and conditions as shall be prescribed by the Secretary of Secretary of
War, upon hearing the allegations and proofs of the parties, in case War to decide         a
they shall not agree,                                                       to terms, etc.
  SEC. 3. That the Secretary of War is hereby aiuthorized and directed,        Secretary of
upon receiving such plan and miap and other i::tformuation, and upon War to notify
being satisfiedl that the bridge built uponi siuchIlin,   with slc(l acces- coany of ap.
sory works, and at sut:h locality will cotiforim to tlie lrsecribce condi-
tions of this act, to notify the companry that he approves the same;
and upon receiving such notification the said compantty iay proceed to
422          REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF                       ENGINEERS,        U. S. ARMY.

                      an erection of said bridge, conforming strictly to the approved plan
                      and location ; and should any change be made in the plan of the bridge
                      or accessory works, during the progress of the work thereon, such
                      change shall be subject likewise to the approval of the Secretary of
  Litigation.         War; and in case of any litigation arising from any obstruction or al-
                      leged obstruction to the free navigation of said river, caused or alleged
                      to be caused by said bridge, the case may be brought in any court of the
                      United States of the Territory of Dakota, of competent jurisdiction, in
                      which any portion of said bridge may be located.
  To be a lawful         SEC. 4. That the said bridge and accessory works, when built and
structure and         constructed undler this act and accoriling to the terms and limitations
post-route.           thereof, shall be lawfull structures; and said bridge shall Ibe recognized
                      and known as a post-route, upon which also no higher charge shall be
                      made for the transmission over the same of the mails, the troops, and
                      the munitions of war of the United States than the rate per mile paid
                      for the transportation over the railroads or public highways leading to
                      such bridge, and said bridge shall enjoy the rights and privileges of
                      other post-routes in the United States; and Congress r, serves the right
  Charges.            at any time to regulate by appropriate legislation the charges for freight
                      and passengers over said bridge.
  Po s ta l-t e 1 -      SEC. 5. That the United States shall have the right of way for such
graph.                postal-telegraph lines across said bridge as the Government may con-
                      struct or control.
  Right to amend         SEC. 6. That the right to alter, amend, or repeal this act is hereby
etc., reserved.       expressly reserved ; and the right to require any changes in said struct-
                      ure, or its entire removal, at the expense of the owners thereof, when-
                      ever Congress shall decide that the public interest requires it, is also
                      expressly reserved.
                        Approved, May 17, 1886.


  May 20, 186.        (CHAP. 363.-An act to authorize the Covington and Cincinnati Elevated Railway
                               and Bridge Company to erect a bridge across the Ohio River.
  Covington and         Be it nacted by the Senate and House of R ,presentatives of the United
Cincinnati Ele- States of America in Congress assenmbled, That the Covington and Cinnati
vated Railway,
Transfer       and Elevated Railway, Transfer and Bridge Company, and its successors or
Bridge Co. au- assigns, are hereby authorized and empowered to erect a bridge across
thor i z e         to the Ohio River between Covington, Kentucky, and Cincinnati, Ohio,
brider the Ohio subject to the limitations annd restrictions of the general law regulat-
Covington, Ky., ing the construction of bridges over the Ohio Rivrr: Provided, however,
and Cincinnati. That said bridge shall not be of less elevation than the Covington and
Ohio.                 Cincinnati sutspension bridge, and muay be constructed without a pivot
  Vol. 17, p. 'l8.
  Vol. 22, p. 414.     raw-span.
  Proviso.              Approved, May 20, 1886.


  May 26, 1886.       CHAP. 377.-An act making appropriation to sup ply deficiency in amount required
                 .     for expenditure to June thirtieth, eighteen hundred and eighty-six, for examina-
                       tion and surveys required by acts of March third, eighteen hundred and seventy-
                       five, and June nineteenth, eighteen hundred and seventy-eight, to ascertain depth
                       of water and width of channel at South Pass of Mississippi River.

  South Pass ,     Be it enacted by the Senate and House of ARpreentatires of the United
Mississippi Rhi.St         Iofmti. i.cai Ciilres assembled, T .hat
                                                                 the following sube, and
er.             the sane is hereby, appropriated out of any money in the Treasury not
                    otherwise appropriated, to wit: To supply detficiency in amonut re-
  Defpropritcie
propriation      for uor                                                                 y-
                       ired for expenditure to June thirtieth, eighteen hundred and eighty-
examinatini and six, for examinations and surveys required by acts of March third,
surveys to ascer- eighteen lhundred and seventy-tve, and June nineteenth, eighteen hun-
tain depth ofwa- dre l and seventy-eight. to ascertain the depth of water nd width of
channel.            channel secured and maintained from time to time by James B. Eads at
   Vol. 18, p. 463. South Pass of the Mississippi River, and to enable the Secretary of War
   Vol. 20, p 168. to report to Congress during the maintenance of the work, six thou-
                    sand four hundred and ninety-two dollars.
   Appropriation      SEC. 2. That the      moneyhereby appropriated shall be immediately
i mme diately available.
available.            Approved, May 26, 1886.
                   LAWS      AFFECTING         CORPS OF ENGINEERS.                            423
CHAP. 417.-An actto authorize the construction of a bridge across the Staten Island   June 16. 1886
    Sound, known as Arthur Kill, and to establish the same as a post-road.

  Be it enacted by the Senate and House of Representatives of tihe United
States of America in Congress assembled, That it shall be lawful for the Staten Island
Staten Island Rapid Transit Railroad Corapany, a corporation existing Rapid TransitR.
under the laws of the State of New York, and the Baltimore and New tor., and New
York Railroad Company,'a corporation existing under the laws of the York R. R. Co.,
State of New Jersey, or either of said companies, to build and main- authorized             to
tain a bridge across the Staten Island Sound, or Arthur Kill, from New bridge Arthur
                                New    York, for  the  passage of  railroad and  Sound.       l-
Jersey to Richmond County,
trains, engines, and cars thereon, and to lay on and over said bridge
railway tracks for the more perfect connection of any railroads that
are or shall be constructed to the said sound at or opposite said point;
and in case of any litigation concerning any alleged obstruction to the Litigation.
free navigation of said sound on account of said bridge, the cause may
be tried before the circuit court of the United States of either of said
States in which any portion of s:id obstruction or bridge touches; and Other compa-
that all railway companies desiring to use the said bridge shall have nies tohaveright
and be entitled to equal rights and privileges in the passage over of way.
the same, and in the use of the machinery and fixtures thereof and of
all the approaches thereto, for a reasonable compensation to be paid to Secretary            of
the owners of said bridge under and upon such terms and conditionsas War to pre-
shall be )prc-scribedby the Secretary  of War   upon   hearing the  allega- scribe terms.
tions and proofs of the parties in case they shall not agree.
   SEC. 2. That said bridge shall be constructed as a pivot draw-              )raw.
bridge, with a draw over the Ilainu(hannel of the sound at an acces-
sille and navigable poinit, and with spans of not less than two hun-
dred feet in length in the clea on each side of the central or pivot pier
of the draw ; and said spans shall not be less than thirty-two feet above
mean low-water mark mreasurin g to the lowest member (,f the bridge 1'~ oiso.
superstructure:     And provided also, That said draw shall be openedOpeningdraw
promptly, upon reasonablle signal, except when trains are passing over
the said bridge, for the passage of the boats whose construction shall
not be such as to admit of their passage under the draw of said bridge
when closed : but in no case shall unnecessary delay occur in oplening
the said draw after the passage of trains;          zand
                                                     the said company or
corporation shall maintain, at its own expense, from sunset to sunrise,       Lights, etc.
such lights or other signals on said bridge as the Light-House Board
shall prescribe.
   SEC. 3. That any bridge coast ructed under this act and according to To be a lawful
its limitations shall be a lawful structure, and shall b)e recognized andr structure an d
known as a post-route, upon which also no higher charge shall be post-route.
made for the transmission over the same of the mails, the troops, and
the munitions of war of the United States than the rate per mile paid
for their transportation over the railroads or public highways leading        Postal tele-
to said  biridge ; and the United States shall have the right of way ftnr graph.
postal-telegrarh plurposes across said bridge.
   SEc. 4. That the plan and location of said bridge, with a detailed Plans, etc., to
mnap of the sound at the proposed site of the bridge and near thereto, be approved by
exhibiting the depths and currents, shall be submitted to the Secre- Secretary of
tary of War for his approval, and until he approve the plan and loca- War.
tion of said bridge it shall not be built; ibut upon the approval of said
plan by the Secretary of War the said companies, or either of them.
may proceed to the erection of said bridge in conformity with said
approved plan; and should any change be made in the plan of said
bridge during the progress of the work thereon, such change shall be
subject likewise to the approval of the Secretary of War. If the Sec-
retary of War shall at any time deem any change or alteration neces-
sary in the said bridge, so that the same shall not obstruct navigation,
or if he shall think   1he removal of the whole structure necessary, the
alteration so relquired or the removalof the whole structure, shall be
made at the expense of rihe parties owning said bridge; and if said To be finished
bridge shall not be finished within two years from the passage of this in two years.
act, the rights and privileges hereby granted shall determine and cease.
   SEC. 5. That the right to alter, amend, or repeal this act is hereby Righttoamend,
expressly reserved.                                                         etc., reserved.
  Approved, June 16, 188ti.
424      REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                          U. S. ARMY.

June 21, 1886. CHAP. 463-An act to authorize the purchase of the Aqueduct Bridge or the con-
                 struction of a bridge across the Potomac River at or near Georgetown, District
                 of Columbia.
                     Be it enacted by the Senate and House of Representatives of the United
                  States of America in Congress assembled, That the Secretary of War is
   A q u educt hereby authorized and directed to acquire by purchase a title in fee
Bridge, Potomac simple, free from all litens or claims of lessees or others, the bridge
River.            known as the Aqueduct Bridge, including the piers thereof, across the
  Purchase of. Potomac River, and the approaches thereto ani(l all the rights and fran-
                  chises connected with said bridge, for a stul not to exceed one hun-
                  dred and twenty-five thousand dollars, the title to be approved by the
                  Attorney-General of the United States; andl said bridge, when so ac-
                  quired, shall be used as a free bridge, under such regulations as the
  To be a free Secretary of War may prescribe: and the Secretary of War is further
bidge,            authorized, in case the United States shall acquire title to the said
                  bridge, to repair or reconstruct the same ; and for the purpose of acquir-
                  ing such title and repairing and reconstructing said bridge the sum of
  Appropriation. two hundred and forty thousand dollars, or so much thereof as may be
                  necessary for such purpose, is hereby appropriated, out of any money
                  in the Treasury not otherwise appropriated; and one half of the ex-
                  pense of such purchase and reconstruction or repair of said bridge shall
                  be charged to and paid by the District of Columbia, anti the balance,
  District of Co- one-half of the sum so expended, shall be paid out of the Treasury of
lumbia to pay the United States.
one-half.             SEC 2. That if the provisions of the first section of this act author-
bidge to   Thrbe izing the purchase of the Aqueduct Bridge shall not be fully executed
Sisters if Aque- within six months frotm the passage of this act, and the title therefor
duct Bridge not approved as therein required, then the Secretary of War be, and he is
purchased in six hereby, authorized and directed to cause to be constructed across the
months.           Potomac River at the Three Sisters, above Georgetown, in the District
                  of Columbia, a substantial iron and masonry bridge, with approaches;
                  and the sumi of two hundred and twenty thousand dollars be, and the
  Appropriation. same is hereby, appropriated, out of anly money in the Treasury not
                  otherwise appropriated, for the construction of said bridge and ap
  Provisos.        proaches, the same to be maintained as a free bridge for travel: Pro-
                  rided, That the said Secretary of War shall construct a bridge upon
  Cost.           such a plan as shall cost no more than the amount herein appropriated,
                  and which cost shall include the construction of a substantial iron
  Bridge over bridge over the Chesapeake and Ohio Canal and highway, andany and
Chesapeake and all approaches to the said iron bri idge, which said bridge shall not be less
Ohio Canal.       than fourteen feet in the clear above the water-line of said canal; and
                  not exceeding fifteen thousand dollars of this appropriation shall be
                  paid out of the Treasury until contracts shall have been entered into
                   with responsible parties, and with good and sufficient sureties, to be
                  approved by the Secretary of War, for the construction and completion
                  of said bridges across the Potomac River and the Chesapeake and Ohio
                  canal, including the masonry, iron-work, and approaches, at a cost not
                  to exceed in the agregate two hundred and twenty thousand dollars.
                  less such sum as may be expended for advertising and making neces-
  District of Co- sary survey : And provided also, That one-half of the expense of the
lumbia to pay construction of said bridge shall be charged to andl paid by the District
one-half.         of Columbia, and the balance (one-half) of the sum hereby appropri-
                  ated shall be paid out of the Treasury of the United States: Provided
                  further, That the Secretary of War shall, as soon as possible, cause
   nrveys, .         survey of +athe rigver to be ocmadeo at the Three Sisters, determine the
                  length, width, and height of said bridge, and thereupon advertise for
                  plans toand
Advertisement. nent            price for the construction of said bridge, such advertise-
                            be inserted  in one or more daily newsnptpers published in Wash-
                  ington, District of Columbia; New York ; Cleveland, Ohio; Detroit,
                  Michigan ; Philadelphia, Pennsylvania ; Chicago, Illinois ; Richmond,
  Part of appro- Virginia; Saint Louis, Missouri, for the space of one week : An.d provided
priation immedi- further, That the sum of fifteen thousand dollars s hall be available at
diatelyavailable. once f(or such investigation and surveys and sutch contingencies as
                                                                                          the
                  Secretary of War shall deem necessary.
   Condemnation       SEc. : . That if in the purchase of the Aqueduct Bridge under the
to secure title.   first section, at any time, is shall be deemed tecessary to obtain from
                  the Chesapeake and Ohio Canal Company. or its grantees, any release
                  or conveyance of any portion of the ground upon which the northern
                  abutiiment of the Aqueduct Bridge rests,or righlt to cross the Chesa-
                   peake and Ohio Canal from the abutment to Bridge street, or if a good
                  title cannot be procured by contract to any property required in the
                 LAWS      AFFECTING        CORPS      OF ENGINEERS.                       425

construction of a bridge under the second section, the same shall be
acquired by the Secretary of War by condemnation in the manner pro-
vided by the act approved May eighth, eighteen hundred and seventy- Vol 17             84
two,  entitled "An act making appropriations for the legislative, exec-
utive, and judicial expenses of the Government for the year ending
                                                                              . 17, p.

June thirtieth, eighteen hundred and seventy-three, and for other pur-
poses :" Provided, That the condemnation proceedings, if any such pro- Proviso.
ceedings are necessary, shall not prevent the taking possession, on
payment of the purchase money, of the Aqueduct Bridge by the Uni- prConedmnation
ted *States, and opening the same to the public as a free bridge, if the to prevent tak-
same shall be acquired under the first section: Procided further, That ing possesion.
the sum of ten thousand dollars of the sum hereby appropriated shall       Condemnation.
be available to meet the payments under condemnation proceedings, if dexpiatelyavailable.-
any shall be had.
  SEC. 4. The act approved February twenty-third, eighteen hundred Vol. 21, chap.
and eighty-one, entitled "An act to authorize the construction of a 69, p. 328, re--
bridge across the Potomac River at or near Georgetown, inlhe Districtpealed.
of Columbia, and for other purposes," is hereby repealed.
  Approved, June 21, 1886.


CHAP. 574--An act making appropriations for the support of the Army for the      June 30, 1886.
  fiscal year ending June thirtieth, eighteen hundred and eighty-seven, and for
  other purposes.
  Be it enacted by the Senate and House of Representatives of thle United
States of America in Congress assembled, That the following sums, be, Army appro.
and the same are hereby, appropriated, out of any money in the Treas- priations.
ury not otherwise appropriated, for the support of the Arily for the
year ending June thirtieth, eighteen hundred and eighty-seven"

  For additional pay to officer inll charge of public buildings, and so Charge of pub-
forth, in Washington, District of Columbia, five hundred dollars.      lie buildings,
                     '               *                 .         .     Washington.

                         ENGINEER     IDEPARTMENT.

   Engineer depot at Willets Point, New York: Incidental expenses Engineer De-
of the depot: Fuel, chemicals, stationery, extra-duty pay for soldiers partment.
employed in wheelwright's work, engine-driving, draugh+ing, printing,        Incidental ox-
photographing, and lithographing engineer documents, repairs of pub-penses.
licbuildings, and unforeseen expenses, three thousand dollars.
   For purchase of materials for the instruction of engineer troops at Materials fo r
Willits Point in their special duties of sappers, tMiners, and ponton- instruction of en-
eers, one thousand dollars.                                               gineer troops.
   For repairs of instruments for general use of the Corps of Engineers,     Repairs of in-
and for the purchase of small instruments to fill requisitions, two thou- struments.
sand dollars.
   Library of the Engineer School of Application: Purchase of profes- Library.
sional works of recent
five hundred dollars.
                         (late
                             treating of military and civil engineering,

   For construction of a new building to contain the officers' mess, the Building.
library, and draughting-rooms of the School of Application, ten thou-
sand dollars, to be immediately available, or so much thereof as may
be necessary : Provided, That the cost of the building complete for use Proviso.
and occupotion shall not exceed ten thousand dollars.                       Cost.
  Approved June 30, 1886.


CHAP. 623. -An act to authorize the improvement of the water-power of the Mis.    July 3, 1886.
                   sissippi River at Little Falls, Minnesota.

  Be it enacted by the Senate and House of Representatives of the United
States of America in Congress Sassembled, That it shall be lawful for the Little Falls.
Little Falls Water-Power Company of Minnesota to improve and de- Water-Power
velop the water-power of the Mississippi River at Little Falls, in the Company ma y
State of Minnesota, by constructing, maintaining, and operating in said build dam, etc.,
river, at said Little Falls, damls, piers, sluice ways, canals, locks, at ittle
                                                                              ssipp
ponds, break-waters, abutments, and mill sites for manufacturing pur- River, Minn.
426         REPORT OF THE               CHIEF OF         ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

  Provisos.       poses: Provided, That there shall be placed and maintained in con-
  Sluice-way, nection with said dam and other works a sluice-way, lock, or other
etc., for passage fixture sufficient and so arranged as to permit logs, timber, and lumber
of logs, etc.     to pass around, through, or over said          (lam
                                                              or other works without un-
                  reasonable delay or hindrance, and without tolls or charges: Prorided,
  Changes.        further, That the Secretary of       var may at any time require such
                  changes and alterations to be made in said works, at the expense of
                  said(l water-power company, as he may deem advisable and necessary
                  in the interest of navigation.
                     SEC. 2. That the right to alter, amend, or repeal this act is hereby
                  expressly reserved.
                     Approved, July 3, 1886.



   July 8, 1886.    CHAP. 747.-An act to ' * * provide for the sale of the old site of Fort Brady,
                     Michigan, and for a new site and the construction of suitable buildings thereon.

                      Be it enacted by the Senate and House of Representatives oJ the United
                    States of America in Congress assembled,

  Fort Brady
military             SEC. 3. That the Secretary of War is hereby authorized to sell the
miliaon  reserva-
         reserMichigan-
                  military reservation known as Fort Brady, in the village of Sault Sainte
to be sold; ex-Marie, in the State ot Michigan, except that portion lying north of
ception.         Water street extended, which shall be reserved for canal and wharf pur-
                 poses, and except the plat of gronnd now occupied as a military ceme-
                 tery, which shall also be reserved.  In disposing of said property the
  Property to be Secretary of War shall cause the grounds to be platted in blocks, streets,
,platted and sold
:in lots.        and alleys, corresponding as near as may be with the plat of the village
                 of Sault Sainte Marie, and in lots not exceeding one-quarter of an acre
                 in each, unless with due reference to the requirements of the houses
                 and buildings now located on said grounds. The Secretary of War
                 shall also cause the lots to be appraised and sold at public or private
                 sale, at not less than the appraised value, having first been offered at
  Expenses.      public sale.    The expense of advertising, appraisement, survey, and
  Proceeds.      sale shall be paid out of the proceeds of said sale, and the balance paid
                 into the Treasury of the Urited States.
  Secretary of SEC. 4. That the Secretary of War is also authorized to purchase
War to purchase grounds in or near the village of Sault Sainte Marie, suitable and snf-
grounds in ors
near Sault Ste. ficient for fortifications and for garrison purposes and construct thereon
Marie, Mich.,and the necessary buildings, with appurtenances, sufficient for a four corn-
construct mi1i- pany military post, to be known as Fort Brady, in accordance with es-
tary post called timates to be prepared by the War Department; and a sufficient sum
  Appropriation. of money, not txceeding one hundred and twenty thousand dollars, is
                 hereby appropriated, out of any money in the Treasury not otherwise
                 appropriated, to enable the Secretary of War to comply with the pro-
  Proviso.       visions of this act: Provided, That the title to lands authorized to be
  Title.         purchased under the fourth section of this act shall be approved by the
                 Attorney-General.
  Ground for       SEC. 5. That in platting these grounds the Secretary of War, in his
public park may discretion, may reserve all that part of the reservation lying south of
be reserved.     Portage street, to be set apart and kept by the municipal authorities
                  of Sault Sainte Marie, as a public park for its citizens and the people
                  of the United States.
  New site to be SEc. 6. That section three of this act shall not be of effect until the
purchased     eol-purchase of a new site, provided for in section four, shall have been
                  effected.
                    Approved, July 8, 1886.




  July 9, 1886.     CHAP. 757.-An act making appropriations to provide for the expenses of the gov-
                     ernment of the District of Columbia for the fiscalyear ending June thirtieth, eight-
                     een hundred and eighty-seven, and for other purposes.
  District of         Be it enacted by the Senate and House of Representatives of the United
Columb ia ap- States of America in Congress assembled, That the half of the following
prop                sums named, respectively, is hereby appropriated, out of any money in
                    the Treasury not otherwise appropriated, and the other half out of the
                    revenues of the District of Columbia, for the purposes following, being
                    LAWS      AFFECTING          CORPS       OF ENGINEERS.                            427
the estimated expenses of the government of the District of Columbia
for the fiscal year ending June thirtieth, eighteen hundred and eighty-
seven, namely :

                FOR SALARIES       AND CONTINGENT         EXPENSES.                       Salaries    and
                                                                                         contingent    ex
  For executive office: * * *   *
                                                                                 (dol-
                                   one engineer commissioner, nine peCommissioners
hundred and twenty-four dollars (to make salary five thousand
lars);


                            WASHINGTON       AQUEIDUCT.                                    Was h ington
                                                                                         Aqueduct.
  For engineering, maintenance, and general repairs, twenty thousand
dollars.

  Approved, July 9, 1886.



CHAP. 759.-An act to authorize the construction of a bridge across the Missouri           July 10, 1886.
River at or near the city of Saint Joseph, in the State of Missouri, and to establish
it as a past-road.
   Be it  vnacted by the Senate and House of Itr)reseentattioesof the United
States of America in Congress assembled, That the Saint Joseph and Rio Saint Joseph
Grande Railroad Company of the State of Kansas, its successors or as- Rairoad Grande    C o
signs, are hereby, authorized to build a bridge across the Missouri River pany, authorized
at or near the city of Saint Joseph, in the State of Missouri, andt to lay to bridge Mis-
on or over saidl bridge rail way tracks for the more perfect connection of suri River, at
any railroads that are or shall be constructed to the said river at or Maint Joseph,
opposite said point, under the limitations and conditions hereinafter
provided : IProrided, That said bridge shall not interfere with the free Free       isonaviga
navigation of said river beyond what is necessary to carry into effect tion not to be im-
the rights and privileges hereby granted.                                    paired.
   SEC. 2. That any bridge built under the provisions of this act may, Construction.
at the option of the company building the same, be built either as a
pivot draw-bridge or with unbroken or continuous spans: Prorided, Provisos.
That if the said bridge shall be made wvitli unbroken and continuous Sp
spans, it shall not be of less elevation in any case than fifty-feet abov      Spans.
high-water mark, as understood at the point of location, to the bottomi
chord of the bridge, nor shall the spans of said bridge be less tlan three
hundred feet in lenlgth, and the piers of said bridge shall be parallel
with the current of the river, and the main span shall be over the main
channel of the river and n<4 be less than three hundred feet in length:
And provided also, That if any bridge built under this act shall be con- Draw.
structed as a pivot draw bridge, the same shall be constructed with a
draw over the main channel of the river at an accessible and navigable
point, with spans not less than one hundred and sixty feet in length in
the clear on each side of the central or pivot pier of the draw ; and the
next adjoining spans to the draw shall be inotless than three hundred
feet, if the proper location of the draw over the channel will admit
spans of this width between it and the shore; and said spans shall not
be less than thirty feet above low-water mark, and not less than twenty
feet above extreme high-water mnark, measuring to the bottom chord of
the bridge ; and the piers of the said bridge shall be parallel with the
current of i he river: And provided also, That said draw shall be opened
promptly, upon reasonable signal, for passage of boats
   SEC. 3. That in case said hi idge be constructed as a low bridge, Construction,or
there shall be at least one protection-pier of masonry, crib-work, or a low bridge.
piling extlnding from the upper end of a pivot-pier or one of the rest
piers of a draw-span, up streamn, for a distance of not less than five
hundred feet from the centre line of the bridge, or such other distance
as may be determined by the Secretary of War, which protection-pier
shall be properly arranged with ring-bolts and fender-planking so as
to enable boats to tie up alongside of it and drop down through the
draw-openings at such times as it niay be dangerous to attempt the
passage of the draw-opening under headway. That all draw or pivot Opening draw.
spans authorized by this act shall be operated by steam or other reli-
able mniechanical power, and shall be opened promptly upon reasonable
428       REPORT OF THE                 CHIEF      OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

                   signal for the passage of boats, except when trains are passing over
                   said span or spans; but in no case shall unnecessary delay occur in
                   opening said draw after the passage of trains; and in case the open-
                   ing of a draw be delayed by reason of the passing of a train after the
                   signal has been given from a boat ready to pass through, the draw
                   shall be opened for the passage of such boat before another train is
                   allowed to pass over the bridge. That the piers of all high channel
                   spans and all pivot-spans shall be built parallel with the current of
                   the river at that stage of water which is most important for naviga-
                   tion; and riprapping, or other protection for imperfect foundations
                   which will materially lessen the water way, shall not be employed in
                   the channel-ways of the high spans or of the draw-openings, and piers
                   which will produce cross-currents or bars dangerous to navigation
                   shall not be constructed, and if, after constructionl, any piers (,r pro-
                   tection-walls are found to produce the above mentioned effects, the
                   nuisance shall be abated or corrected by or at the expense of the
  Aids to naviga- persons owning said bridge. That in case the approaches to draw-
tion.              span opening, channel-spans, or raft-passages in said bridge be found
                   dangerous or difficult of access by any important class of river traffic,
                   the Secretary of War shall order the construction of such sheer-booms,
                   guide-piers, or (ther similar device as will obviate the difficulty,
                   which sheer-booms, guide-piers, or other device shall be paid for by
                   the persons owning said bridge. That the persons owniinig, controll-
                   ing, or operating the bridge authorised by this act shall maintain, at
                   their own expense, from sunset to sunrise, throughout the year, and
   Lights, etc.    during heavy fogs, such lights or other signals as the Light-House
                   Board shall prescribe, and shall, in case a high bridge be constructed,
                   during t he season of navigation, have posted in a conspicuous place on
                   or near the bridge the clear head-room under the channel-span on that
                   dlay, the figures expressing this height to be not less than two feet
                   high, and to be readily visible from any point in the channel of the
                   river for a stretch of three thousandl(l feet above and one thousand feet
                   below the bridge.
   To be a lawful     SEC. 4. That any bridge constructed under this act and according
structure     and to its limitations shall be a lawful structure and shall be known and
post route.        recognized as a post-route, upon which also no higher charge shall be
                   made for the transmission over the same of the inails,the troops, and the
                   munitions of war of the United States than the rate per mile paid for
                   their transportation over the railroads or public highways leading to
                   the said bridge.
   Other compa-       SEc. 5. That all railway companies desiring to use the said bridge
Hies to have use shall have and be entitled to equal rights and privileges in the passage
 *f.               of the same and in the use of the machinery and fixtures thereof, under
   Secretary o f and upon such terms and conditions as shall be prescribed by the Sec-
War to prescribe retary of War upon hearing the allegation, and proofs of the parties in
terms.
                   case they shall not agree.
   Secretary o f SEC. 6. That any bridge constructed under this act shall be built and
War to approve located under and subject to such regulations for the security of navi-
plans, locations, gation of said river as the Secretary of War shall prescribe; and to
                   secure that object the said company shall submit to the Secretary of
                   War, for his examination and approval, a design of the drawings of the
                   bridge and piers and a map of the location, giving, for the space of at
                   least one mile above and one mile below the proposed location, the to-
                   pography of the banks of the river, the shore-lines at high and low water,.
                the   d.rection   and   strength   of   t    i
                                                            riirnts   t aU   all   ages,   and   th e   sound-
                ings, accurately showing the bed of the stream, the location of any
                other bridge or bridges, and shall furnish such other infirmation as may
                be required for a full and satisfactory understanding of the subject, and
                until said plan and location of the bridge are approved by the Secretory
                of War the bridge shall not be built; and if any change be made in
                the plan of construction of said bridge (luring the progress of the work
                thereon, or before the completion of said bridge, such chanfge shall be
                sabject to the approval of the Secretary of War; and the said structure
                shall be at all times so kept and managed as to offer reasonable and
                proper means forthe passage of vessels through or under said structure;
                and the said structure shall be changed at the cost and expense of the
                owners thereof froim time to time, as Congress may direct, so as to pre-
                serve the firee and conlvenient navigation of saidl river; and the authority
                to erect and continue said bridge shall be subject to the revocation or
                modification by law whenever the public good shall, in the judgment of
                   LAWS      AFFECTING          CORPS     OF ENGINEERS.                       429
Congress, so require, without any expense or charge to the United
States and in case of any litigation arising from any obstruction or Litigation.
alleged obstruction to the free navigation of said river caused or al-
leged to be caused by said bridge, suit may be brought in the circuit
courts of the United States of Missouri or Kansas in whose jurisdiction
any "portion of said bridge may be located.
   SEC. 7. That the right to alter, amend, or repeal this act is hereby Right toamend,
expressly reserved; and the right to require any changes in said etc., reserved.
structure, or its entire removal, at the expense of the owners thereof,
whenever Congress shall decide that the public interest requires it, is
also expressly reserved.
   Approved, July 10, 186.



CHAP. 775.-An act to authorize the construction of a railroad,wagon, and foot-pas- July 19, 1886.
senger bridge across the Mississippi River at or near Dubuque, in the State of------
Iowa.
    Be it enacted by the Senate and Hlouse of JIepresentatives of the United
States of America in Congress assembled, That the Chicago, Burlington Chicago, Bur
and Northern Railroad Company, its successors and assigns be, and lington and
they are hereby, authorized to construct and maintain a railroad, Northern Rail-
wagon, and foot-passenger bridge across the Mississippi River at a suit-road      Company
                                                                             authorized to
able point in the vicinity of the city of Dubuque, in the State of Iowa, bridge the Mis-
and to lay on or over said bridge a railroad track or tracks for the more sissippi River.
perfect connection of any railroad or railroads that are or shall be con- R a i r o a d,
structed to said river, on either or both sides thereof, at or opposite bridge. and             foot
said point, under the limitations and conditions hereinafter provided;
that said bridge shall not interfere with the free navigation of said Free naviga-
river beyond what is necessary in order to carry into effect the rights tionnot tobe im-
and privileges hereby granted; and in case of any litigation arising paired.
from any obstruction or alleged obstruction to the free navigation of
said river, the cause may be tried before the circuit court of the United
States in and for any district in which any portion of said bridge or ob-
struction touches.     Said bridge shall be constructed to provide for the
passage of railroad trains, and for the passage of wagons and vehicles
of all kinds, for the transit of animals, and for foot-passengers, for such
reasonable rates of toll as may be fixed from time to time by the Sec- Tolls.
retary of War: Provided, That the proviso regarding wagons, animals, Proviso.
foot-passengers, and so forth, shall not influence the location of said
bridge in its relation to the interests of navigation.
    SEC. 2. That any bridge built under the provisions of this act may, Construction.
at the option of the company building the same, be built as a draw-
bridge or with unbroken and continuous spans: Provided, That if the Provisos.
said bridge shall be made with unbroken and continuous spans, it shall Spans.
give clear head-room of not less in any case than fifty-five and one-half
feet above extreme high-water mark, as understood at the point of loca-
tion, nor shall the spans of said bridge give a clear width of water-way
of less than two hundred and fifty feet, and the piers of said bridge shall
be parallel with the current of said river, and the main span shall be
over the main channel of the river and give a clear width of water-way
of not less than three hundred feet: And provided further, That if any
bridge built under the provisions of this act shall be constructed as a
draw-bridge, the same shall be constructed as a pivot draw-bridge, with Draw.
a draw over the main channel of the river at an accessible and navi-
gable point, and with spans giving a clear width of waterway of not
less than one hundred and sixty feet on each side of the central or pivot
pier of the dr aw, and the next adjoining span or spans to the draw shall
give a clear width of water-way of not less than two hundred and fifty
feet : Provided, That if the pivot-pier of said bridge shall be constructed   Location of
within less tha u four hundred and ten feet of the east shore of said pivot-pier.
ri ver, the ,pan constructed east of said pivot-pier may be less than two
hundred and fifty feet, and said spans shall give clear head-room of not
less than thirty feet above low-water rnak, and not less than ten feet
above extreme high-water mark and the piers of said bridge shall be
parallel with the current of the river where said bridge shall be erected:
And provided also, That said draw shall be opened promptly upon rea-                  Opening draw.
sonable signal for the passage of boats, except when trains are passing
over the draw; but in no case shall unnecessary delay occur in opening
the said draw during or after the passage of trains. In the event that
430        REPORT OF THE CHIEF                OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

                    the bridge herein provided for, or any part thereof, shall be constructed
                    within seven hundred and fifty feet south of the present bridge between
                    Dubuque and East Dubuque, any expenditures that may hereafter be
                    made by the owners of the bridge now constructed for the purpose of
    Pro tecti on guarding against casualties by floods or ice, and made either north of
  against damage the present bridge or around the piers of the same,.shall be borne in
by floods or ice. equal parts by the two companies, respectively, and paid for as the
                    work progresses ; and any expenditures which have been made or that
                    may be hereafter itmade for the purpose of complying with existing laws
                                            for
                    or laws hereafter enacted      the protection of navigation, by means of
                    sheerbootms or otherwise, shall be borne equally by the two companies
                    aforesaid : Provided, That in the location of the piers of said bridge, if
                    made within seven hundred and fifty feet, due regard shall be had to
                    the existing structure, and said piers-shall be so constructed as not to
                     increase the danger of the same either from floods or ice.
    Tobe a lawful SEC. 3. That arty bridge constructed under this act and according to
struct ure and its limitations shall be a lawful structure, and shall be known as a post-
post-route.        route, and the same hereby declared to be a post-route, upon which
                    also no higher charge shall be made for the transmission over the same
                    of the mails, the troops, and the ut unitions of war of the United States,
                   for
                    or     passengers or freight passing over said bridge, than the rate per
                    miil. paid for their tratnsortation over the railroads and public high-
    Post al t ele ways leading to said bridge; and the United States shall have the right
graph.             of way for postal-telegraph purposes across said bridge.
   Other compa- SEc. 4. That all railway companies desiring to use said bridge shall
of weshaveright have and be entitled to equal rights and privileges in the passage of
                    the same, and in the use of the machinery and fixtures thereof, and
  S e c re tary of of all the approaches thereto, under and upon such terms and conditions
War       to pre- as shall be prescribed by the Secretary of War, upon hearing the
scribe terms.      allegations and proofs of the parties, in case they shall not agree.
                       SEC. 5. That the structure herein authorized shall be built and lo-
                    cated under and subject to such regulations for the security of the
                    navigation of said river as the Secretary of War snall prescribe; and
approved by Sec. to secure that object the said company or corporation shall submit to
retary of War. the Secretary of War, for his examination and approval, a design and
                    drawing of the bridge, and a map of the location, giving, for the space
                   of one mile above and one mile below the proposed location, the topog-
                   graphy of the banks of the river, the shore-lines at high and low water,
                   the direction and strength of the current at all stages, and the sound-
                   ings, accurately showing the bed of the stream, the location of any other
                   bridge or bridges, and shall furnish such other information as shall be
                   required for a full and satisfactory understanding of the subject; and
                   until the said plan and location of the bridge are decided by the Secre-
                   tary of War to be such as will not materially affect the interests of
                   navigation the bridge shall not be commenced or built ; and should any
                   change be made in the plan of said bridge during the progress of con-
                   struction, such change shall be subject to the approval of the Secretary
                   of War; and the said structure shall be at all times so kept and man-
                   aged as to offer reasonable and proper means for the passage of vessels
                   through or under said structure; and for the safety of vessels passing
                   at night there shall be displayed on said bridge, from the hours of sun-
                   set to sunrise, such lights as may be prescribed by the Secretary of
   Ligh            War; and the said structure shall be changed or removed at the cost
                   and expense of the owners thereof, from time to time as Congress may
                   direct, so as to preserve the free and convenient navigation of said
                   river: and the autlhority to erect and continue said bridge shall be sub-
                  ject to revocation and modification by law when the public good shall,
                   in the judgment of Congress, so require, without any expense or charge
                   to the United States.
Right to amend, SEC. 6. That the right to alter, amend, or repeal this act is hereby
etc., reserved, expressly reserved.
                      Approved, July 19, 1886.
                 LAWS      AFFECTING        CORPS     OF   ENGINEERS.                     431

CHAP. 778.-An act to provide for the construction of a bridge across the west   July 20, 1886.
   channel of the Detroit River to connect Belle Isle Park with the mainland.

   Be it enacted by the Senate and Bouse of Representatires of the United
States of America in Congress assembled, That the assent of Congress is City of Detroit
hereby given to the municipality known as the city of Detroit, a body authorized to.
corporate existing by and under the laws of the State of Michigan, to brivger between
erect a bridge across the Detroit River between any point on the north- the city and Belle
western bank of said river within the limits of said corporation afore- Isle Park.
said and the island inl the Detroit River heretofore known as Belle Isle,
and now known and designated as Belle Isle Park, the said bridge to
be devoted to such general use as may be prescribed by the municipal
authorities of the city of Detroit.
   SEC. 2. That the bridge authorized to be erected by this act shall be Not toobstruct
so located and conistructed that the channel of said Detroit River shall navigation.
not be unreasonably obstructed, but that a draw or pivot span of not Draw.
less than one hundred and twenty-five feet clear opening on each side
of the pivot-pier shall be located over the above-specified chanlnel in
such a manner that one or both of the opelnings of said draw or p)iv!\t
span can be conveniently and safely reached and passed by boats pur-
suing the ordinary channel of the river; that one opening at least of a
draw or pivot, span shall be over the best and most convenient channel
of the river for such classes of river traffic as shall find it convenien t to
use said channel.
   SEC. 3. That the height at which said bridge shall be constructed Height.
above the surface of the river shall be such as may be approved by the
Secretary of War.
   SEC. 4. That all draw or pivot spans authorized by this act shall be Draw to be op-
operated by steam or other reliable mechanical power, and shall be erated by steam.
opened promptly upon such signals as are now prescribed by law for
the passage of boats through draw or bridges, and such other and fur-
ther regulations as may be prescribed in the premises.
   SEC. 5. That piers upon which said bridge is built shall be parallel Piers.
with the current of the river, and so as to avoid producing cross-currents
or bars dangerous to navigation; and if, after construction, any piers
are found to produce the above-mentioned effects, the nuisance shall be
abated or corrected by or at the expense of the corporation owning or
operating said bridge, and whed advised by the Secretary of War.
   SEC. 6. That it shall be the duty of the municipal corporation an- Lights.
thorized to erect a bridge under this act to maintain, at its own expense,
from sunset to sunrise of each day throughout the season of navigation,
and during heavy fogs, such lights on the bridge as may be required
by the Light-House Board for the security of navigation.
   SEc. 7. That any bridge constructed under this act and according to To be lawful
its limitations shall be a lawful structure, and shall be recognized and structure and
known as a post-route, over which the mails, troops, and munitions of post-route.
war of the United States may be transported at no higher charge than
is made for transportation of said mails, troops, and munitions of war
over railroads and public highways leading to said bridge; and the
United States shall have the right of way for postal-telegraph lines and Post al tele-
appliances across said bridge,                                                 graph.
    SEC. 8. That before commencing work on the bridge contemplated Secretary of
in this act it shall be the duty of the municipal authorities of the city War to approve
of Detroit to submit to the Secretary of War, for his examination, a plans, etc.
design and drawing of the bridge and piers, and a map of the location,
giving, for the space of one-half mile above and one-half mile below the
proposed location, the topography of the banks of the river, the shore-
lines at high and low water, the direction of the current, and sound-
ings showing accurately the bed of the stream, and such other and
further information as the Secretary of War may require for a full and
satisfactory understanding of the subject.
    SEC. 9. That when the Secretary of War is satisfied that the pro- Construction to
visions of this act have been complied with in the matter of location begin when Sec-
and the submission of plans, the building of the piers may at once retary of War is
commence; but if it shall appear that the conditions prescribed by this plans, etc.
act canpot be complied with at the location where it is desired to con-
struct the bridge, the Secretary of War shall, after considering all re-
monstrances filed against the building of said bridge, and furnishing
copies of remonstrances to the board of engineers provided for in this Remonstrances.
act, detail a board of experienced engineers from the Engineer Corps
432       REPORT       OF THE       CHIEF OF        ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

                 of the United States Army to examine the case, and may, on their
                 recommendation, authorize and direct such modifications as appear
                 necessary.
                    SEC. 10. That the Secretary of War may, in his discretion, appoint
   Board of Army one or more Army engineers to supervise and personally examine the
engineers to su- construction of said bridge: and that the proposed bridge shall only
pervisethe work. be a lawful structure when built as approved by the Secretary
                                                                                    of War,
                 who shall have authority, by and with the advice of the engineers de-
                 tailed by him, to order such change in construction or appliances as
                 he may deem necessary for the afety of said bridge and the conven-
                 ience of navigation.
  Litigation.       SEC. 11. That in case of any litigation from any obstruction, or alleged
                 obstruction, to navigation created by the construction of any bridge
                 under this act, the cause or question arising may be heard by the Dis-
                 trict Court of the United States of any State in which any portion of
                 said obstruction or bridge touches.
  Municipal law,    SEC. 12. That the municipal laws and ordinances of the city of De-
to extend to troit may be enforced on said bridge, and the care, control, and the use
bridge.          of the same shall be governed by ordinances of the city enacted, as
                 though said bridge was a public street in said city.
Right to amends    SEC. 13. That the right to alter, amend, or repeal this act, and to
etc., reserved.  require the removal of material obstructions to navigation by the con-
                 struction of any bridge under its provisions, is hereby expressly re-
                 served, without any liability of the Government for damages on ac-
                 count of such alterations, amendment, or repeal, or on account of the
                 prevention or the requiring of the removal of any such obstruction;
                 and if any change be made in the plan of any bridge constructed under
                 this act, during the progress of the work thereon or before the com-
                 pletion of said bridge, such change shall be subject to the approval of
                 the Secretary of War ; and any change in the construction or any alter-
                 ation of any such bridge, and the removal of any such obstruction, that
                 may be directed at any time by Congress or the Secretary of War, shall
                 be made at the cost and expense of the owners of the said bridge.
                   Approved, July 20, 1886.


  July 29,1886. CHAP. 802.-An act to authorize the Bellingham Bay Railway and Navigation Com-
                        pany to build certain bridges in the Territory of Washington.

  Bellin ghaam          Be it enacted by the Senate and House of Representatives of the United
BayRailway and States of America in Congress ssembled, That the Bellingham Bay Rail-
N a v i g a t i o n way and Navigation Company, a corporation duly organized under the
ized Companyabuildthor-laws of Washington Territory, its successors or assigns, be, and is
bridges, Wash- hereby, authorized to construct, maintain, and operate bridges, and alp-
ingtonTerritory. proaches thereto, over the Nooksack River, in the county of Whatcom,
   N o o k s a c k the Skagit River, in the county of Skagit, and the Stillaquamish and
  SkaRit River. Snohomish Rivers, in the county of Snohomish, at the points where the
  Stillaquam is h said company's line of railways, as now projected, cross said rivers re-
River.              spectively ; said bridges shall be constructed to provide for the passage of
  RSnoh o m is h railway trains, and, at the option of said company by which the same or
  Wa g o n and either of the same shall be built, may be used for the passage of wagons
foot bridges.       and vehicles of all kinds, for the transit of animals, and for foot-passen-
                    gers, for reasonable rates of toll to be fixed by said company; but such
  Tolls.            rates shall be reasonable rates,and the Secretary of War shall have the
                    right from time to time to revise, prescribe, and fix the same. Said conm-
  Right to cross pany shall also have the right to cross either Lake Union or Salmon Bay
Lake Union or (sometimes called Shilshole Bay), or the waters between, or the canal
Salmon Bay.         l)uilt or to be built between said Lake Union and said bay. Said works
  Draw.             to contain a draw of such width as shall accommodate the commerce
                     passing through said waters, and to be built upon plans to be approved
                    by the Secretary of War, as provided in section two of this act, and
                    subject to be changed, enlarged, and altered from time to time as the
                    Secretary of War or Congress shall from time to time direct, and as the
                    exigencies of commerce may require.
  Plans subject         SEC. 2. That the plan and location of any bridge the construction of
to approval of which is hereby authorized shall be subject to the approval of the Sec-
Secretary of War retary of War; and each of the same shall be so located as not mate-
                rially to obstruct or impair the free navigation of such rivers respect-
                ively or said canal, and shall be built with piers parallel to the cur-
                rent, leaving the water-way unobstructed by riprap, or piling, or other
                 LAWS AFFECTING             CORPS     OF ENGINEERS.                     433
obstructions, and shall have at the crossing of each of the main chan-
nels of said rivers or said canal (unless the same shall be built above
the head of navigation) a draw of the width to be fixed by the Secre- Draw.
tary of War, which shall be located at the points best calculated to ac-
cormmodate commerce, to be determined by the Secretary of War;
which draws shall at all times be opened promptly for passing vessels,
upon reasonable signal, except when railway trains are passing over
the same; and at all times during the season of navigation proper sig-
nal-lights shall be used and maintained, at the expense of the aforesaid Lights.
company, its successors and assigns, to guide vessels approaching said
draws: Provided, That the construction of neither of said bridges shall Proviso.
                                                                             C o n s truction
be commenced until the plan location, and width of draw thereof has to await Secre-
been approved by the Secretary of War, and the said company has been taryof War's ap-
notified in writing of the same.                                           proval.
   SEC. 3. That any bridge built under this act shall be a lawful struct- To be lawful
ure, and shall be recognized and known as a post-route, upon which post-route.
also no higher charge shall be made for the transmission over the same of
the mails, the troops, and the munitions of war of the United States
than the rate per mile paid for the transportation over the railroad or
public highways leading to such bridge; and it shall enjoy the rights
and privileges of other post-routes in the United States. And the said
structure shallbe changed, at the cost and expense of the owners thereof, Changes.
or persons controlling or operating the same, from time to time,.as Con-
gress may direct, so as to preserve the free and convenient navigation
of said rivers and bays; and the authority to erect and continue any
and all said bridges shall be subject to revocation by law whenever the
public good shall, in the judgment of Congress, so require; and all
such structures shall, upon such revocation, be removed, at the expense
of the owners thereof, or the persons controlling and operating the same.
   SEC. 4. That in case of any litigation arising from any obstruction Litigation.
or alleged obstruction to the free navigation of said rivers and waters
caused or alleged to be caused by said bridges or other obstructions,
the case may be brought in the district court of the district where such
obstruction is alleged to exist, unless meanwhile the portion of said
Territory where said erection exists shall have been admitted into the
Union as a State, in which case the same may be brought in the circuit
court of the United States of such State: Provided, That nothing in Proviso.
this act shall be so construed as to repeal or modify any of the provisions Navigation not
of law now existing in reference to the protection of the navigation of to be impaired.
rivers, or to exempt said bridges from the operation of the same.
   SEC. 5. That the right to alter, amend, or repeal this act is hereby Riattt             to
expressly reserved.                                                        served: etc.
   Approved, July 29, 1886.


CHAP. 804.-An act to grant the Astoria and Winnemucca Railroad Company the     July 29, 1886.
           right to construct bridges over navigable water-courses.

   Be it enacted by the Semnate and House of Representatives of the United Astoria and
States of America in Congress assen bled, That the consent of the Govern- W in ne m u c c a
                                                                          Railroad
ment is hereby given to the Astoria and Winnemucca Railroad Company ,, pany         C o m-
                                                                                authorized
a corporation duly organized under the laws of Oregon, to build rail- to bridge t he
road bridges across the Willamette River,. south of Oregon City, at such Willamette Riv-
point as it may select, and across such other navigable streams orsloughs erandothernavi-
within the State of Oregon as it may be necessary to bridge along the gable wat r.
line of said railroad or along the line of any of its branches.
   SEC. 2. That any bridge built under the provisions of this act may, Construction.
at the option of said railway company, be built as a draw-bridge or with
unbroken and continuous spans: Provided, That if any such bridge shall. Provisos.
be made with unbroken and continuous spans, the main span shall be Spans.
over the main channel of such navigable river or slough, and shall be
of such width, and the lowest part of the superstructure shall be of
such height above extreme high-water mark, as the Secretary of War
may prescribe, and such bridge shall be at right angles to and its piers
parallel with the current or channel of the river or slough over which
it may be constructed; and if any bridge built under this act shall be
constructed as a draw-bridge, the same shall be constructed with an            Draw.
opening over the center of the channel of the rive ror slough, and shall
be of such width, character, and construction as the Secretary of War
        28 E
434        REPORT       OF THE       CHIEF      OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

                   shall prescribe, and the piers of said bridge shall be parallel with the
                   current, and the draws of said bridge shall be over the main or deep
                   channel of the river or slough, as may be fixed and determined by the
                   Secretary of War: Provided also, That said drawers shall be opened
                   promptly upon reasonable signal for the passage of boats, and in no case
                   shall unnecessary delay occur; and said company or corporation shall
   Lights, etc.    maintain, at its own expense, from sunset to sunrise, such lights or other
                   signals on said bridge as the Light House Board shall prescribe: Pro-
                   vided also, That said bridge or bridges, at the option of the corporation
   May be wagon or company by which it may be built, may be used for the passage of
and foot bridges. wagons or vehicles of all kinds, for the transit of animals, and for foot-
   Tolls.          passengers, for such reasonable rate of toll as may be approved from
                   time time by the Secretary of War.
   To be lawful       SEC. 3. That any bridge authorized to be constructed under this act
structure and shall be a lawful structure, and shall be recognized and known as a
post-routes.       post-route, and it shall enjoy the rights and privileges of other post-
                   roads in the United States, upon which also no higher charge shall be
                   made for transmission over the same of the mails, the troops, and the
                   munitions of war of the United States, or for through passengers or
                   freight passing over said bridge or bridges, than the rate per mile for
                   their transportation over the railroads leading to the said bridge or
   Postal tele- bridges; and the United States shall have the right of way for a postal
graph.             telegraph across said bridge or bridges.     Said bridge or bridges shall
                   be built and located under and subject to such regulations for the
                   security of navigation of navigable rivers or sloughs as the Secretary
                   of War shall prescribe ; and to secure that object the said company or
   Plans, etc., to corporation shall submit to the Secretary of War, for his examination
be approved by and approval, a design and drawing of any such bridge, and a map of
Secretary of the location, giving, for the space of one mile above and one mile be-
                   low the proposed location, the topography of the banks of the river or
                   slough, the shore-line at high and low water, the direction and strength
                   of the current at all stages, and the soundings, accurately showing the
                   bed and channel of the stream, the location of any other bridge or
                   bridges, and shall furnish such other information as may be required
                   for a full and satisfactory understanding of the subject; and until the
                   said plans and location of the bridge or bridges are approved by the
                   Secretary of Warthe bridges shall not be built; and should any change
                   be made in the plan of any such bridge during the progress of con-
                   struction thereof, such change shall be subject to the approval of the
                   Secretary of War.
   Other compan-      SEc. 4. That all railroad companies desiring the use of any bridge
ies to have right constructed under this act shall have and be entitled to equal rights
of way.            and privileges relative to the passage of railway trains or cars over the
                   same, and over the approaches thereto, upon payment of a reasonable
                   compensation for such use; and in case the owner or owners of said
                   bridge and the several railroad companies, or any one of them, desiring
                   such use, shall fail to agree upon the sum or sums to be paid, and upon
   Termstobede- rules and conditions to which each shall conform in using said bridge,
cided by Secre- all matters at issue between them shall be decided by the Secretary of
tary of War.       War upon a hearing of the allegations and proofs of the parties.
   Changes.           SEC. 5. That such alterations or changes as may be required by the
                   Secretary of War or Congress in bridges constructed under the provis-
                   ions of this act shall be mnade by the persons or corporations owning or
  Righttoamend, controlling said bridges, at their own expense; and it is hereby ex-
etc., reserved.    pressly provided that Congress reserves the right at any time to alter,
                   amend, or repeal this act.
                      Approved, July 29, 1886.


July 29, 1886.   CHAP. 805.-An act authorizing the city of Salem to construct a bridge across the
                                    Willamette River. in the State of Oregon.

                   Be it enacted by the Senate and House of Representatives of the United States
  Salem, Oregon, of America in Congress assembled, That the city of Salem, in the county of
build wagon and Marion and State of Oregon, be authorized and permitted to build a
footbridgeacross wagon and foot bridge across the Willamette River at such point as it
W illa m e t t e may select opposite said city and between the counties of Marion and
River.          Polk, in the State of Oregon. Such bridge may also, at the option of
                said city, be so constructed as to be available as a railroad bridge.
  Construction.   SEC. 2. That such bridge built under the provisions of this act may,
                 LAWS     AFFECTING       CORPS    OF ENGINEERS.                    435
at the option of said city of Salem, be built as a draw-bridge or with
unbroken and continuous spans : Provided, That if such bridge shall be      Provisos.
made with unbroken and continuous spans, the main span shall be over        Spans.
the main channel of such navigable river, and shall be of such width,
and the lowest part of the superstructure shall be of such height above
extreme high-water mark, as the Secretary of War may prescribe; and
such bridge shall be at right angles to and its piers parallel with the
current or channel of the said river. And if such bridge built under        Draw.
this act shall be constructed as a draw-bridge, the same shall be con-
structed with an opening over the center of the channel of the river,
and shall be of such width, character, and construction as the Secretary
of War shall prescribe; and the piers of said bridge shall be parallel
with the current, and the draws of said bridge shall be over the main
or deep channel of the river, as may be fixed and determined by the
Secretary of War: Provided also, That said draws shall be opened Opening draw.
promptly upon reasonable signal for the passage of boats, and in no
case shall unnecessary delay occur; and said city of Salem shall main-
tain, at its own expense, from sunset to sunrise, such lights or other Lights, etc.
signals on said bridge as the Light-House Board shall prescribe : Pro-
vided also, That said bridge at the option of the said city of Salem, by
which it may be built, may be used for the passage of wagons or vehicles
of all kinds, for the transit of animals, and for foot-passengers, for such Tolls
reasonable rate of toll as may be approved from time to time by the
Secretary of War, or the same shall, at the option of said city of Salem, brMay be free
be a free bridge.
    SEC. 3. That the bridge authorized to be constructed under this act To be a lawful
shall be a lawful structure, and shall be recognized and known as a structure and
post-route, and it shall enjoy the rights and privileges of other post-
roads in the United States, upon which also no higher charge shall be
made for transmission over the same of the mails, the troops, and the
munitions of war of the United States, or for through passengers or
freight passing over said bridge, than the rate per mile for their trans-
portation over any railroad leading to the said bridge; and the United
States shall have the right of way for a postal telegraph across said Postal tele-
bridge. Said bridge shall be built and located under and subject to graph.
such regulations for the security of navigation of navigable rivers as Secretary of
the Secretary of War shall prescribe; and to secure that object the said War to approve
city of Salem shall submit to the Secretary of War, for his examination plans, etc.
and approval, a design and drawing of such bridge, and a map of the
location, giving, for the space of one mile above and one mile below the
proposed location, the topography of the banks of the river, the shore-
line at high and low water, the direction and strength of the current at
all stages, and the soundings, accurately showing the bed and channel
of the stream, the location of any other bridge or bridges, and shall fur-
nish such other information as may be required for a full and satisfac-
tory understanding of the subject; and until the said plans and location
of the bridge are approved by the Secretary of War the bridge shall
not be built; and should any change be made in the plan of such bridge
during the progress of construction thereof, such change shall be sub-
ject to the approval of the Secretary of War.
   SEC. 4. That such alterations or changes as may be required by the Changes.
Secretary of War or Congress in the bridge constructed under the pro-
visions of this act shall be made by the said city of Salem at its own
expense; and at any time after the completion of such bridge the said
city of Salem may, at its option, surrender and transfer to the counties May be trans-
of Marion and Polk, in the State of Oregon, the said bridge, and the ferred to Marion
entire control and management thereof, in which event, and in case of and Polk Coun-
                                                                       shall ties.
the acceptance thereof by said counties of Marion and Polk, they
thenceforth be subject to all the obligations and conditions imposed on
the city of Salem by the provisions of this act. And it is hereby ex- Ramdight tore
pressly provided that Congress reserves the right at any time to alter, served.
amend, or repeal this act.
  Approved, July 29, 1886.                                      "       *
436         REPORT OF          THE CHIEF          OF ENGINEERS,           U. S. ARMY.

  July 29, 1886.   CHAP. 806.-An act granting to the Oregonian Railway Bridge Company of Oregon
                    the right to construct a bridge over the Willamette River in the vicinity of Ray's
                    Landing, Oregon.
                     Be it enacted by the Senate and House of Representatives of the United States
  OregonianRail- of America in Congress assembled, That the Oregonian Railway Bridge
way Bride Com- Company, a corporation duly organized under the laws of Oregon, be
tobridgetheWil- authorized and permitted to build a railroad bridge across the Willam-
lamette River, at ette River south of Oregon City, at such point as it may select in the
Ray's Landing, vicinity of Ray's Landing, within the State of Oregon.
  Construction.      SEC. 2. That the bridge built under the provisions of this act may,
                  at the option of said bridge company, be built as a draw-bridge or with
  Provisos.       unbroken and continuous spans: Provided, i hat if such bridge shall be
  Spans.          made with unbroken and continuous spans, the main span shall be over
                  the main channel of such navigable river, and shall be of such width,
                  and the lowest part of the superstructure shall be of such height above
                  extreme high-water mark, as the Secretary of War may prescribe, and
                  such bridge shall be at right angles to and its piers parallel with the
                  current or channel of the river over which it may be constructed; and
  Draw.           if the bridge built under this act shall be constructed as a draw-bridge,
                  the same shall be constructed with an opening over the center of the
                  channel of the river, and shall be of such width, character, and con-
                  struction as the Secretary of War shall prescribe, and the piers of said
                  bridge shall be parallel with the current, and the draws of said bridge
                  shall be over the main or deep channel of the river, as may be fixed
  Opening draw. and determined by the Secretary of War: Provided also, That said draw
                  shall be opened promptly upon reasonable signal for the passage of
                  boats, and in no case shall unnecessary delay occur; and said company
                  or corporation shall maintain, at its own expense, from sunset to sun-
  Lights, etc.    rise, such lights or other signals on said bridge as the Light-House
                  Board shall prescribe: Provided also, That said bridge, at the option of
                  the corporation or company by which it may be built, may be used for
  Wagon andfoot the passage of wagons or vehicles of all kinds, for the transit of ani-
bridge.           mals, and for foot-passengers, for such reasonable rate of toll as may
  Tolls.          be approved from time to time by the Secretary of War.
                     SEC. 3. That the bridge authorized to be constructed under this act
  To be a lawful shall be a lawful structure, and shall be recognized and known as a post-
structure and route, and it shall enjoy the rights and privileges of other post-roads in
post-route.       the United States, upon which also no higher charge shall be made for
                  transmission over the same of the mails, the troops, and the munitions
                  of war of the United States, or for through passengers or freight pass-
                  ing over said bridge, than the rate per mile for their transportation over
  Postal t ee-the railroads leading to the said bridge; and the United States shall
graph.l           have the.right of way for a postal telegraph across said bridge. Said
                  bridge shall be built and located under and subject to such regulations
                  for the security and navigation of navigable rivers as the Secretary of
  Se cre ta ry of War shall prescribe; and to secure that object the said company or cor-
War to approve poration shall submit to the Secretary of War, for his examination and
plans, etc.       approval, a design and drawing of such bridge, and a map of the loca-
                  tion, giving, for the space of one mile above and one mile below the
                  proposed location, the topography of the banks of the river, the shore-
                  lines at high and low water, the direction and strength of the current
                  at all stages, and the soundings, accurately showing the bed and chan-
                  nel of the stream, the location of any other bridge or bridges, and shall
                  furnish such other information as may be required for a full and satis-
                  factory understanding of the subject; and until the said plans and lo-
                  cation of the bridge are approved by the Secretary of War the bridge
                  shall not be built; and should any change be made in the plan of such
                  bridge during the progress of construction thereof, such change shall
                  be subject to the approval of the Secretary of War.
  Other compa-       SEC. 4. That all railroad companies desiring the use of the bridge
hies to haveright constructed under this act, shall have and be entitled to equal rights
of way.           and privileges relative to the passage of railway trains or cars over the
                  game, and over the approaches thereto, upon payment of a reasonable
                  compensation for such use; and in case the owner or owners of said
                  bridge and the several railroad companies, or any one of them, desiring
                  such use, shall fail to agree upon the sum or sums to be paid, and upon
                  rules and conditions to which each shall conform in using said bridge,
War to decide all matters at issue between them shall be decided by the Secretary of
erms.         War upon a hearing of the allegations and proofs of the parties.
                  LAWS      AFFECTING CORPS OF ENGINEERS.                                    437
  SEC. 5. That the right to alter or amend this act so as to prevent or Rightto amend,
remove all material obstructions to the navigation of said river is hereby etc., reserved.
expressly reserved; and all changes or alterations so required shall be Changes.
made at the expense of the parties owning or controlling said bridge.
  Approved, July 29, 1886.


CHAP. 807.-An act to authorize the construction of bridges across the Tennessee    July 29, 1886.
        and Cumberland Rivers by the Ohio Valley Railway Company.

  Be it enacted by the Senate and House of Representatives of the United Ohio Valley
States of America in Congress assembled, That the Ohio Valley Railway Railroad Com-
Company, organized under act of the general assembly of the common- pany authorized
wealth of Kentucky, be, and is hereby, authorized to construct and tobridgeTennes-
maintain bridges, and approaches thereto, over the Tennessee River land Rivers.
at any point below Aurora, in the State of Kentucky, and the Cum-
berland River at any point b)elow Canton, on said river. Said bridges Railway, wag-
shall be constructed to provide for the passage of railway trains, and, on, and foot
at the optibn of the corporation by which they may be built, may be bridges.
used for the passage of wagons and vehicles of all kinds, for the transit
of animals, and for foot-passengers.
   SEC. 2. That any bridge built under this act and subject to its limita- 'I, be lawful
tions shall be a lawful structure, and shall be recognized and known as structures and
a post-route, and it shall enjoy the rights and privileges of other post- post-routes.
roads in the United States.
  SEC. 3. That all railroad companies desiring the use of said bridges             Other compa-
shall have and be entitled to equal rights and privileges relative to nies to have right
the passage of railway trains over the same, and over the approaches of wiay.
thereto, upon the payment of a reasonable compensation for such use;
and in case the owner or owners of said bridges and the several rail-
road companies, or any of them, desiring such use, shall fail to agree
upon the sum or sums to be paid, and upon rules and conditions to
which each shall conform in using said bridges, all matters at issue be- Secretary of
tween them shall be (lecided by the Secretary of War upon a hearing War to decide
of the allegations and proofs of the parties.
   SEc. 4. That any bridlges authorized to be constructed under this act Secretary       of
shall be built and located under and subject to such regulations for the War to approve
security of navigation of said rivers as the Secretary of War      shall plans,  etc.
prescribe; and to secure that object the said company or corporation
shall submit to the Secretary of War, for his examination and approval,
a design and drawings of the bridges, and a map of the location, giving,
for the space of one mile above and one mile below the proposed loca-
tion, the topography of the banks of the rivers, the shore-lines at high
and low water, the direction and strength of the currents at all stages,
and the soundings, accurately showing the bed of the stream, the loca-
tion of any other bridge or bridges, and shall furnish such other in-
formation as may be required for a full and satisfactory understanding
of the subject ; and until the said plan and location of the bridges are
approved by the Secretary of War the bridges shall not be built, and
should any change be made in the plan of said bridges during the prog-
ress of construction, such changes shall be subject to the approval of
the Secretary of War.
   SEC. 5. That the right to alter, amend, or repeal this act is hereby Right to amend,
expressly reserved,.                                                     etc., reserved.
  SEC. 6. It is hereby provided that the bridges authorized to be con- Commencement
structed by this act shall be commenced within twelve mouth's and com- and completion..
pleted within three years from the passage of this act.
  Approved, July 29, 1886.


CHAP. 809.-An act granting to the county of Clatsop, in the State of Oregon, the   July 29, 1886.
right to construct a bridge across Young's Bay, a navigable stream in said
county and State.
  Be it enacted by the Senate and House of' Representatives of the United
States of America in Congress assembled, That the county of Clatsop, in            Clatsop   Coun-
the State of Oregon. is hereby auhorized and empowered to construct ty, Oregon,  br au-
                                                                        Young's Bay,idgun-
a bridge across Yonug's Bay, a navigable stream in said county• and thorizedto
State, at such poillt as said county may select and may be approved by der approval of
the Secretary of War, with such channel spaus, draws, safe-guards and secreta ry of
auxiliary works as shall cause the bridge not unduly to obstruct or in- War.
438        REPORT       OF    THE    CHIEF      OF ENGINEERS,           U . S. ARMY.

                   jure the navigation of the waters crossed by it; and that said channel-
                   spans and structures shall be as the Secretary of War may prescribe;
   S k i p a n o n and also to construct, establish, and maintain a bridge across Skipanon
Creek.             Creek, in the county of Clatsop, in the State of Oregon, by permanent
   Proviso.        vided                 draws as
                                     otherwise,
                         also, Theorsaid
                   embankment                      the Secretary of War may approve: Pro-
                                                 shall be opened promptly upon reasonable
  Openingdraws. signal for the passage of ships and boats, and in no case shall unneces-
                   sary delay occur; and said county shall maintain, at its own expense,
    Lights, etc. from sunset to sunrise, such lights or other signals on said bridges as
                   the Light-House Board shall prescribe.
   To be a lawful SEC. 2. That any bridge authorized to be constructed under this act
s tru c ture and shall be a lawful structure, and shall be recognized as a post-route ; and
post-route.        it shall enjoy the rights and privileges of other post-routes in the United
                   States, upon which also no higher charge shall be made for transmission
                   over the same of the mails, the troops, and the munitions of war of the
                   United States, or for through passenger or freight passing over said
                   bridge, than the rate per mile for their transportation over any railroad
                   or other routes leading to said bridge, or over said stream in the vicinity;
   Telegraph.      and the United States shall have the right of way for a telegraph across
                   said bridges; the said bridges to be built and located under and subject
                   to such regulations for the security of navigation on said bay and creek
   Secretary    of as the Secretary of War shall prescribe; and to secure that object the
War to appgove said county, by its proper court and duly authorized officers or agents,
plans, etc.        shall submit to the Secretary of War, for his examination and approval,
                   a design and drawing of such bridge across Young's Bay, and a map of
                   Young's Bay from the mouths of its navigable tributaries to the adja-
                   cent ship-channel, which map shall be on a scale of at least one to
                   twenty thousand, and whose topography of the shores and hydrography
                   shall reasonably represent the banks, the bottom, and steamboat chan-
                   nels by contours of six feet, and which shall be accompanied by other
                   maps, drawn to a scale of one inch to two hundred feet, giving, within
                   areas of one-fourth of a mile from each draw-span, an accurate repre-
                   sentation of the bottom of the bay by contour-lines two feet apart, de-
                   termined by accurate soundings, and also showing the force and direc-
                   tion of the currents at each two feet of tidal stage, by triangulated ob-
                   servations on suitable floats; also showing the Skipanon Creek to the
                   head of usual navigation. The maps shall also show the locations of
                   other bridges in the vicinity, and shall give such other information as
                   the Secretary of War may require for a full and satisfactory under-
                   standing of the subject.
  Righttoamend,       SEC. 3. That Congress shall have power, at any time, to alter or
etc., reserved.    amend this act so as to prevent or remove all material and substantial
                   obstruction to the navigation of said bay and said creek by the con-
   Changes.        struction of said bridges and accessory works ; and the expense of alter-
                   ing said bridges or removing such obstructions shall be borne by the
                   owner of said bridges.
                      Approved, July 29, 18i6.


July 29, 1886.   CHAP. 811.-An act to give the assent of Congress to the construction of a bridge
                   by the municipalities of Menominee, Michigan, and Marinette, Wisconsin, over
                   Menominee River.

                    Be it enacted by the Senate and House of Representatives of the United
  Menominee, States of America in Congress assembled, That the assent of Congress is
Mich., and Mari, hereby given to the municipalities of Menominee, in the State of Mich-
nette, Wis., an- igan, and Marinette, in the State of Wisconsin, to construct and main-
bridge the Meno. tain a bridge, and approaches thereto, over the Menominee River, be-
minee River.     tween the States of Michigan and Wisconsin, at a point to be deter-
                 mined by said municipalities, not to exceed one and one-fourth miles
                 from the mouth of said river.
  To be a lawful    SEc. '2. That any bridge built under the provisions of this act and
structure and subject to its limitations shall be a lawful structure and recognized and
post-route.      known as a post-route, and it shall enjoy the lights and privileges of
                 other post-roads in the United States : Provided, That the United States
  Po st al tele- may construct a postal telegraph over said bridge without charge there-
graph.           for.
                    SEC. 3. That if said bridge shall be built with unbroken and contin-
  Spans.          uous spans, the spans thereof shall be of such width and height above
                  the water as may be prescribed by the Secretary of War, and the main
                   LAWS      AFFECTING          CORPS      OF   ENGINEERS.                      439

span shall be over the main channel of the river, and the bridge shall
be at right angles to and its piers parallel with the current of the river :
Provided, That if the same shall be constructed as a draw-bridge, the Provisos.
draw or pivot shall be over the main channel at an accessible point, and Draw.
the spans shall be of such width arpd height above the water as may be
prescribed by the Secretary of War, and the piers of said bridge shall
be parallel with and the bridge itself at right angles to the current of
the river: Provided also, That the said draw shall be opened promptly Opening draw.
by said municipalities upon reasonable signal for the passage of boats;
that sheer-booms shall be constructed by said municipalities; and that
said municipalities shall maintain, at their own expense, from sunset to
sunrise, such lights or other signals on said bridge as the Light-House      Lights, etc.
Board shall prescribe. No bridge shall be erected or maintained under
the authority of this act which shall at any time substantially or ma-
terially obstruct the free navigation of said river; and if any bridge F r ee naviga-
erected under such authority shall, in the opinion of the Secretary oftion not to be im-
                                                                       such paired.
War, obstruct such navigation, he is hereby authorized to cause
change or alteration of such bridge to be made as will effectually ob-
viate such obstruction ; and all such alterations shall be made and all
such obstructions be removed at the expense of said corporation; and
in case of any litigation arising from any obstruction or alleged obstruc- Litigation.
tion to the free navigation of said river, caused or alleged to be caused
by said bridge, the case may be brought in the circuit court of the United
States for the western district of Michigan or the eastern district of
Wisconsin, in which any portion of said obstruction or bridge may be
located : Provided further, That nothing in this act shall be so construed Laws to pro-
as to repeal or modify any of the provisions of law now existing in notrepealedton
reference to the protection of the navigation of rivers, or to exemptn
the bridge herein authorized to be constructed from the operations of
the same.
   SEC. 4. That any bridge authorized to be constructed under the pro- Secretary of
visions of this act shall Le built and located under and subject to such War to approve
regulations for the security of navigation of said river as the Secretary plans, etc.
of War shall prescribe; and to secure that object the said municipali-
ties shall submit to the Secretary of War, for his examination and ap-
proval, a design and drawings of the bridge, and a map of the loca-
tion, giving, for a space of one mile above the proposed location, and
below said location to the shore of Green Bay, at the mouth of said river,
the topography of the banks of the river, the shore-lines at high and
low water, the direction and strength of the currents at all stages, and
the soundings, accurately showing the bed of the stream, the location
of any other bridge or bridges, and shall furnish such other information
as may be required for a full and satisfactory understanding of the sub-
ject; and until the said plan and location of the bridge are approved
by the Secretary of War the bridge shall not be built ; and should any
change be made in the plan of said bridge during the progress of con-
struction, such change shall be subject to the approval of the Secretary
of War.
   SEC. 5. That the right to alter, amend, or repeal this act is hereby Righttoamend
expressly reserved, and the right to require any changes in said struct- etc., reserved.
ure, or its entire removal, at the expense of the owners thereof, when-
ever Congress shall decide that the public interest requires it, is also
expressly reserved.
  Approved, July 29, 1886.


CHAP. 827.-An act making appropriations for thelegislative, executive, and judicial   July 31, 1886.
expenses of the Government for the fiscal year ending June thirtieth, eighteen
hundred and eighty-seven, and for other purposes.
   Be it enacted by the Senate and House of Representatives of the United
States of America in Congress assembled, That the following sums be, and Legislative, ex-
the same are hereby, appropriated, out of any money in the Treasury ecutive, andjudi-
not otherwise appropriated, in full compensation for the service of the cial expenses ap-
fiscal year ending June thirtieth, eighteen hundred and eighty-seven, propriations.
for the objects hereinafter expressed, namely:

  IN THE OFFICE OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS.--One                   chief clerk, at     Office of Chief
two thousand dollars; four clerks ofclassfour ; two clerks of class three; of Engineers.
three clerks of class two; three clerks of class one; one clerk, at one
440      REPORT OF THE               CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

                thousand dollars; one assistant messenger; and two laborers; in all,
                twenty-three thousand two hundred and forty dollars.
   Draughtsmen,    And the services of skilled draughtsmen, civil engineers, and such
etc.            other services as the Secretary of War may deem necessary may be em-
                ployed in the Office of the Chief of- Engineers to carry into effect the
                various appropriations for rivers and harbors, fortifications, and sur-
                veys for military defenses, to be paid for from such appropriations:
  Proviso.      Provided, That the expenditures on this account for the fiscal year end-
  Limitation.   ing June thirtieth, eighteen hundred and eighty-seven, shall not exceed
                sixty thousand dollars; and that the Secretary of War shall each year,
  Report.       in the annual estimates, report to Congress the number of persons so
                employed, and the amount paid to each.

Rent.           For rent of buildings for use of the War Department, as follows:

               for the Chief of Engineers' Office, one thousand two hundred dollars;


  Public build-                      PUBLIC BUILDINGS AND GROUNDS.
ingsandgrounds.
  Clerk, messen- For clerk in the Office of Public Buildings and Grounds, one thousand
ger.              six hundred dollars; and for messenger in the same office, eight hun-
                  dred and forts dollars.
  Gardener.          For the public gardener, one thousand eight hundred dollars.
  Overseers, etc.    For overseers, draughtsman, foremen, mechanics, and laborers em-
                  ployed in the public grounds, twenty-eight thousand dollars.
  Watchmen.          For watchman in Franklin Square, six hundred and sixty dollars.
                     For watchman in Lafayette Square, six hundred and sixty dollars.
                     For two day-watchmen in Smithsonian Grounds, at six hundred and
                  sixty dollars each, one thoasand three hundred and twenty dollars.
                     For two night-watchmen in Smithsonian Grounds, at seven hIludred
                  and twenty dollars each, one thousand four hundred and forty dollars.
                     For one watchman for Judiciary Square, and one for Lincoln Square
                  and adjacent reservations, at six hundred and sixty dollars each, one
                  thousand three hundred and twenty dollars.
                     For one watchman for Iowa Circle; one watchman for Thomas Cir-
                  cle and neighboring reservations; one for Rawlins Square and Wash-
                  ington Circle; one for Dupont Circle and neighboring reservations;
                  one for McPherson and Farragut Squares; one for Stanton Place and
                  neighboring reservations; two for Armory Square and reservations
                  east to Botanic Garden; one for Mount Vernon Square and adjacent
                  reservations ; one for greenhouse at the nursery ; one for grounds south
                  of Executive Mansion, eleven in all, at six hundred and sixty dollars
                  each, seven thousand two hundred and sixty dollars.
                     For one night-watchman for Armory Square and reservations east to
                  Botanic Garden, at seven hundred and twenty dollars.
                     For contingent and incidental expenses, five hundred dollars.
  Contingent ex-
penses.             For rent of office, nine hundred dollars.
Rent.                          sa          *                   **

                 Approved, July 31, 1886.



August 2, 1886. CHAP. 843.--An act to authorize the Secretary of War to permit the Carrollto
                  and Lock Number One Turnpike Road Companyto locate and construct its road on
                land belonging to the United States at Lock Number One, on the Kentucky River,
                in the State of Kentucky.
  Rightofwayto       Be it enacted by the Senate and House of Representatives of the United
Lockarrolltonand States of America in Congress assembled, That the Secretary of War be,
pike Road Com- and is hereby, authorized and empowered to permit the Carrollton- and
pany, through Lock Number One Turnpike Road Company to locate and construct its
United S t a tes road through the land belonging to the United States at Lock Number
 , atentuLocko.y
             Riv- One, on the Kentucky River, in the State of Kentucky, upon such
                                                                                     terms
er, Ky.           and conditions as he may consider proper: Provided, That said road
  Proviso.        shall not be so located or constructed as to obstruct the use of the said
  Location.       land by the United States for public purposes.
                 Approved, August 2, 1886.
                  LAWS      AFFECTING        CORPS      OF   ENGINEERS.                     441
CHAP. 902.-An act making appropriations for sundry civil expenses of the Gov-      August 4, 1886.
ernment for the fiscal year ending June thirtieth, eighteen hundred and eighty-
seven, and for other purposes.
  Be it enacted by the Senate and House of Representatives of the United
States of America in Congress assembled, That the following sums be, Sundrycivilap.
and the same are hereby, appropriated for the objects hereinafter ex- propriations.
pressed for the fiscal year ending Juie thirtieth, eighteen hundred and
eighty-seven, namely :

  PROTECTION AND IMPROVEMENT OF THE YELLOWSTONE NATIONAL Yellowstone
PARK: For the construction and improvement of suitable roads and Park, construc-
bridges within the park, under the supervision and direction of an en- tion of roads and
gineer officer detailed by the Secretary of War for that purpose, twenty bridges.
thousand dollars.

                    AND   GROUNDS     IN   AND   AROUND   WASHINGTON.              Buildings and
       BUILDINGS                                                         grounds, Wash-
                                                                         ington, D. C.
  For the improvement and care of public grounds as follows:                Improvement,
  For improvement and maintenance of grounds south of the Executive care, etc.
Mansion, six thousand dollars.
  For ordinary care of greenhouses and nursery, two thousand dollars.
  For ordinary care of Lafayette Square, one thousand dollars.
  For ordinary care of Franklin Square, one thousand dollars.
   For care and improvement of reservation numbered three (Monument
Grounds), one thousand dollars.
   For continuing improvement of reservation numbered seventeen, and
site of old canal, northwest of same, ten thousand dollars: Provided,
That no part thereof shall be expended upon other.than property be-
longing to the United States.
  For manure, and hauling same, five thousand dollars.
  For painting iron fences, vases, lamps, and lamp-posts, one thousand
dollars.
   For purchase and repair of seats, one thousand dollars.
  For purchase and repair of tools, two thousand dollars.
   For trees, tree-stakes, lime, white-washing, and stock for nursery,
three thousand dollars.
  For removing snow and ice, one thousand two hundred dollars.
  For flower-pots, twine, baskets, and lycopodium, one thousand dol-
lars.
  For care, construction, and repair of fountains in the public grounds,
one thousand five hundred dollars.
  For abating nuisances, five hundred dollars.
  "For improvement, care, and maintenance of various reservations,
twelve thousand dollars.
  For improvement maintenance, and care of Smithsonian Grounds,
ten thousand dollars.
  For improving grounds around the Pension Building, Judiciary
Square, five thousand dollars.
  That under appropriations herein contained no contract shall be Limitofcostof
made for making or repairing concrete or asphalt pavements in Wash- concrete pav e-
ington City at a higher price than two dollars per square yard for a ments.
quality equal to the best heretofore laid in the District of Columbia.
  For repairs and fuel at the Executive Mansion as follows :               Executive Man-
  For care, repair, and refurnishing the Executive Mansion, sixteen sion.
thousand dollars to be expended by contract or otherwise as the Presi- Repairs, fuel,
dent may determine.
  For fuel for the Executive Mansion and greenhouses, three thousand
dollars.
  For care and necessary repair of greenhouses, four thousand dollars.
  For repair of conservatory of Executive Mansion, six thousand dol-
lars.
  LIGHTING, THE EXECUTIVE           MANSION      AND PUBLIC    GROUNDS,     For    Lighting Exec-
gas, pay of lamp-lighters, gas-fitters and plumbers; gas-fitting and u tiv e Mansion
plumbing; purchase and erection of lamps and lamp-posts; purchase gan ds
of matches, and for repairs of all kinds: fuel and lights for office, sta-
bles, watchmen's lodges, and for the greenhouses at the nursery, four-
teen thousand dollars: Provided, That for each six-foot burner not con- Proviso.
nected with a meter in the lamps on the public grounds no more than Maximum pay-
twenty dollars shall be paid per lamp for gas, including lighting, clean- ment per lamp.
442            REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

                      ing, and keeping in repair the lamps, under a'ny expenditure provided
                      for in this act; and authority is hereby given to substitute other illu-
                      minating material for the same or less price, and to use so much of the
                      sum hereby appropriated as may be necessary for that purpose.
Water-pipes            REPAIR OF WATER-PIPES AND            FIRE-PLUGS-For    repairing and ex-
and fire plugs.       tending water-pipes, purchase of apparatus to clean them, and clean-
  Repairs, etc.       ing the springs and repairing and renewing the pipes of the same that
                      supply the Capitol, the Executive Mansion and the building for the
                      State, War, and Navy Departments, two thousand five hundred dollars.
  Government            TELEGRAPH      TO   CONNECT    THE   CAPITOL   WITH   THE DEPARTMENTS
telegraph.            AND GOVERNMENT PRINTING OFFICIE: For care and repair of existing
                      lines, one thousand two hundred and fifty dollars.
  Building      for     BUILDING    FOR     THE   STATE,   WAR,   AND NAVY    DEPARTMENTS:     For
State, War, and completing the construction of the building, roofs, heating apparatus,
Navy Depart- elevators, partitions, iron work, doors, plastering and stucco-work,
  Completion.   plumbing and gas-fitting, approaches, and for each and every purpose
                connected with the construction of the building, including the rent of
                necessary office-room, five hundred thousand dollars.
Washington  WASHINGTON MONUMENT: For completion of the Washington Mon-
Monument.   ument, namely : For earth-filling and grading around the monument,
                  filling so much of the pond just north of Monument as may be needful
                  to secure the foundation of the monument, office expenses, including
                  rent of necessary office-rooms, and for each and every purpose con-
  Completion.     nected with the completion of the monument, fifty-seven thousand dol-
  Vol. 21, p.123. lars, to be expended under the direction of the joint commission created
  Proviso.        by the act of August second, eighteen hundred and seventy-six: Pro-
  Filling pond. vided, That the work of filling the pond north of the monument shall
                  not be commenced before December first, eighteen hundred and eighty-
                  six.
  Medical Mu-           BUILDING FOR XRMY MEDICAL MUSEUM AND LIBRARY : For stacks
seum.                 of book-cases in library hall, including iron supports, stairs, and per-
                      forated gallery-floors, twenty thousand dollars.
  Cases,       shelv-   For shelving and cases for record and pension division two thousand
ing, etc.             dollars.
                        For   cases for museum, ten thousand dollars.
                        For   shelving and cases for center building, two thousand dollars.
                        For   carpets and furniture, three thousand dollars.
                        For   gas-fixtures for entire building, one thousand and fifty dollars.

  Fort      Monroe,     WHARF AT FORT MONROE, VIRGINIA: In full for the construction
Va.                   and completion of a new wharf, and improvements to the roadway
Construction of leading thereto, on the Government reservation at Fortress Monroe,
wharf.           Virginia, upon plans to be approved by the Secretary of War, one
                      hundred thousand dollars, or so much thereof as may be necessary for
                      the purpose.
  Snu r v e y of   SURVEY OF NORTHERN AND NORTHWESTERN LAKES: For printing
northern and and issuing charts for use of navigators, and electrotyping copper-
lakes.           plates for chart-printing ; two thousand dollars.
                              la5                  *         *         S        *

                        Approved, August 4, 1886.



  August 4, 1886. CHAP. 903.-An act making appropriations to supply deficiencies in the appropria
                   tions for the fiscal year ending June thirtieth, eighteen hundred and eighty-six,
                   and for prior years, and for other purposes.

                    Be it enacted by the Senate and House of Representatives of the United
  Deficiency ap- States of America in Congress assembled, That the following sums be, and
propriations.    the same are hereby, appropriated, out of any money in the Treasury
                 not otherwise appropriated, to supply deficiencies in the appropria-
                 tions for the fiscal year eighteen hundred and eighty-six, and for other
                 objects hereinafter stated, namely :

  Increase of wa-       INCREASE OF WATER SUPPLY, WASHINGTON, DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA:
ter supply.       To enable the Secretary of War to complete the work of increasing the
Vol. 22, p. 168. water supply of the city of Washington under the act entitled "An act
                  to increase the water supply of the city of Washington, and for other
                  purposes," approved July fifteenth, eighteen hundred and eighty-two,
                     LAWS    AFFECTING         CORPS      OF   ENGINEERS.                            443
namely: To complete the reservoir, one hundred and sixty thousand To complete
dollars; to complete the tunnel, three hundred and ninety-five thou- reservoir and
sand dollars; in all, five hundred and fifty-five thousand dollars, or sotunnel.
much thereof as may be necessary; but the Secretary of War is in-
structed forthwith, to submit to the Board of Engineers for Fortifica- Board of Engi-
tions and for River and Harbor Improvements whether any changes whether changes
are demanded for reasons of safety or economy in the method of lining are required.
said tunnel heretofore adopted and pursued, and whether any changes
are required in the method of lining and perfecting the reservoir: Pro- Proviso.
vided, That said board shall make full report thereon and pending such ceork to           rngo-
examination the work shall proceed upon such parts thereof as the Sec- port.
retary of War shall direct. The work above provided for to be done Apportionment
under the contract heretofore made or by a relettiug, as in the discre- between United
tion of the Secretary of War shall be most promotive of the interest of States    and Dis-
                                                                           trict.
the Government, and the two sums hereinabove appropriated to be Vol. 22, p. 170.
subject to all the provisions and restrictions of the said act of July fif- Vol. 23, p. 132.
teenth, eighteen hundred and eighty-two, and of the act approved July
fifth, eighteen hundred and eighty-four, making appropriations for the
expenses of the government of the District of Columbia, as to its ap-
portionment and settlement between the United States and the District
of Columbia and the refunding thereof.


      PUBLIC BUILDINGS       AND   GROUNDS     UNDER CHIEF ENGINEER.


  To pay outstanding liability contracted by Colonel A. F. Rockwell, Publicbuildings
while in charge of public buildings and grounds, under the Chief of and grounds.
Engineers, for putting down and taking up crash, and so forth, at re- Executive Man-
ceptions at the Executive Mansion, between January thirteenth and sion.
February twenty-first, eighteen hundred and eighty-five, being for the
service of the fiscal year eighteen hundred and eighty-five, one hundred
and thirty-five dollars and fifty cents.


CLAIMS ALLOWED BY TIHE THIRD AUDITOR AND SECOND COMPTROLLER.                                Claims allowed
                                                                                          by Third Audi-
                                                                                          tor and Second
                 *           *          *           *            *             "*         Comptroller.


                                 WAR DEPARTMENT.                                           War    Depart-
                                                                                          ment.
  For contingencies of fortifications, eighteen hundred and sixty-four     Fortifications,
and prior years, two thousand three hundred and thirty-nine dollars contingencies.
and forty-two cents.
  For surveys for military defenses, eighteen hundred and eighty-three Military defen-
and prior years, twelve dollars.                                       ses, surveys.

                                                                                           Claims allowed
                                                                                          by Third Auditor
WAR    DEPARTMENT      CLAIMS      ALLOWED    BY THE     THIRD       AUDITOR        AND    n d S e c o nd
                            SECOND COMPTROLLER.                                           Comptroller,
                                                                                          War Depart-
                                                                                          ment.
  For contingencies of fortifications, seventy-one dollars and seventeen   Fortifications.
cents.
  For improving Umpqua River, Oregon, one dollar and forty-seven UmpquaRiver,
cents.                                                                   Oregon.

  Approved, August 4, 1886.



CHAP. 929. An act making appropriations for the construction, repair, and preser- August 5, 1886.
  vation of certain public works on rivers and harbors, and for other purposes.

  Be it enacted by the Senate and House of Representatives of the United
States of America in Congress assembled, That the following sums of bor appropria
money be, and are hereby, appropriated, to be paid out of any money tions.
in the Treasury not otherwise appropriated, and to be expended under     Harbors.
the direction of the Secretary of War, for the construction, completion,
repair, and preservation of the public works herein named:
444       REPORT OF THE             CHIEF    OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

Rockland, Me.       Improving harbor at Rockland, Maine: Continuing improvement,
                   twenty-two thousand five hundred dollars.
  Saco River,        Improving breakwater at the mouth of Saco River, Maine: Continu-
breakwater, Me.    ing improvement and repairs, twelve thousand five hundred dollars.
  Portland, Me.      Improving harbor at Portland, Maine: Continuing improvement,
                   thirty thousand dollars.
  Back Cove,         Improving the channel in Back Cove, Portland, Maine : Continuing
channel, Me.       improvement, twenty-six thousand two hundred and fifty dollars.
  York, Me.          Improving harbor at York, Maine, fifteen thousand dollars.
  Portsm oun th,     Improving harbor at Portsmouth, New Hampshire: Continuing ilm-
N. H.              provement, fifteen thousand dollars.
  Little Harbor,     Improving the harbor of refuge at Little Harbor, New Hampshire :
N. H.              Continuing improvement, ten thousand dollars.
  Burlington,Vt.     Improving harbor at Burlington, Vermont: Continuinuing improve-
                   ment, eighteen thousand seven hundred and fifty dollars.
  Gordon'sLand-      For a breakwater at Gordon's Landing, on Lake Champlain, to be
ing breakwater,    built on the twelve foot curve mentioned in the papers accompanying
Lake Champlain.    the report of the Secretary of War to the Senate dated March first,
                   eighteen hundred and eighty-six (Executive Document Number Eighty-
                   one, Forty-ninth Congress, first session), eighteen thousand seven hun-
                   dred and fifty dollars.
  Boston, Mass.       Improving harbor at Boston, Massachusetts: Continuing improve-
                   ment, fifty-six thousand two hundred and fifty dollars; of which
                   eigteen thousand seven hundred and fifty dollars are to be expended at
                   Fort Port Channel, on Part A, below Congress Street Bridge.
Lynn, Mass.          Improving harbor at Lynn,Massachusetts : Continuing improvement,
                   six thousand dollars.
Nantu cket,          Improving harbor at Nantucket, Massachusetts: Continuing improve-
Mass.              mnent, fifteen thousand dollars.
Rannis Harbor        Improving Hyannis Harbor, Massachusetts, ten thousand dollars.
Mass.
  Newburyport,     Improving harbor at Newburyport, Massachusetts : Continuing im-
Mass.            provement, thirty-seven thousand five hundred dollars.
  W ar h a m,      Improving harbor at Wareham, Massachusetts: Continuing improve-
Mass.            ment, fifteen thousand dollars.
  Plym out h , Improving harbor at Plymouth, Massachusetts: Continuing improve-
Mass.            ment, six thousand dollars.
Hingham,Mass.     Improving harbor at Hingham, Massachusetts : Continuing improve-
                 ment, six thousand dollars.
  Provincetown,    Improving harbor at Provincetown, Massachusetts: Continuing im-
Mass.            provement, three thousand dollars.
Gloucester,       Improving harbor at Gloucester, Massachusetts, five thousand dol-
Mass.            lars; of which two thousand dollars, or so much as may be needed for
                 a survey, and remainder on Babson's Ledge.
Sandy Bay,har-    For the national harbor of refuge of the first class at Sandy Bay:
bor, of refuge.  Continuing improvement, one hundred thousand dollars.
  Scituate,Mass.   Improving harbor at Scituate, Massachusetts: Continuing improve-
                 ment, ten thousand dollars.
Westport, Mass. Improving harbor at Westport, Massachusetts : Continuing improve-
                 ment, one thousand dollars, for sand-fence.
  Wood's Roll,     Improving harbor at Wood's Holl, Massachusetts: Continuing im-
Mass.            provement, fourteen thousand five hundred dollars.
  Block Island,    Improving harbor at Block Island, Rhode Island: Continuing im-
R. I.            provement, twenty thousand dollars; of which eight thousand dollars
                 shall be expended on the breakwater and twelve thousand dollars on
                 the inner harbor.
  Newport, R. I.. Improving harbor at Newport, Rhode Island : Continuing improve-
                 ment, fifteen thousand dollars.
Bridgeport,       Improving harbor at Bridgeport, Connecticut: Continuing improve-
Conn.            ment, twenty thousand dollars.
  Black R oc k,    Improving harbor at Black Rock, Connecticut: Continuing improve-
Conn.            ment, five thousand dollars.
   New Haven       Improving breakwater at New Haven, Connecticut: Continuing im-
Conn.            provement, seventy-five thousand dollars.
                   Improving harbor at New Haven, Connecticut: Continuing improve-
                 ment, twenty thousand dollars.
  New London,      Improving harbor at New London, Connecticut: Continuing iri-
Conn.            provement, two thousand dollars.
Norwalk,Conn.     Improving harbor at Norwalk, Connecticut: Continuing improve-
                   ment, three thousand dollars.
                 LAWS     AFFECTING        CORPS OF ENGINEERS.                      445
   Improving harbor at Stonington, Connecticut: Continuing improve- St onin gton,
ment, twenty thousand dollars.                                           Conn.
   Improving harbor at Stamford, Connecticut: Continuing improve- Stamford,Conn.
ment, ten thousand dollars.
   Improving harbor at Buffalo, New York: Continuing improvement,          Buffalo, N. Y.
and repairs on the outer breakwater, one hundred and twelve thousand
five hundred dollars.
   Improving Buttermilk channel, New York : Continuing improvement, CButtermilk
                                                                           Rouse's Point'
fifty six thousand two hundred and fifty dollars.
   Improving breakwater at Rouse's Point, New York : Continuing im- N. .se's        Point'
provement, twenty thousand dollars,                                        Dunkir
   Improving harbor at Dunkirk, New York: Continuing improvement, D                k,N.Y.
twenty thousand dollars.
   Improving harbor at Canarsie Bay, New York: Continuing improve- N.          narsie Bay,
ment, ten thousand dollars.
   Improving harbor at Charlotte, New York: Continuing improve- CharlotteNY.
ment and repairs, twenty-six thousand two hundred and fifty dollars.
   Improving harbor at Flushing Bay, New York: Continuing improve- Flushing Bay,
ment, ten thousand dollars.                                              N. Y.
   Improving channel at Gowanus Bay, New York: Continuing im- Gowanus Bay,
provement, seven thousand five hundred dollars.                          N. .
   Improving harbor at Great Sodus Bay, New York: Continuing im- Great Sodus
provement, sixteen thousand eight hundred and seventy-five dollars.      Bay, N. Y.
   Improving harbor at Greenport, New York: Continuing Improve- Greenport, N.
ment, five thousand dollars.                                             Y.
   Improving harbor at Little Sodus Bay, New York: Continuing im-          Little Sodus
provement, twelve thousand five hundred dollars.                         Bay, N. Y.
   Improving harbor at Oak Orchard, New York: Continuing improve- Oak Orchard,
ment by repairs, twelve thousand five hundred dollars.                   N. Y.
   Improving harbor at Olcott, New York: Continuing improvement and Olcott, N. Y.
repairs, ten thousand dollars.
   Improving harbor at Wilson, New York: Continuing improvement,           Wilson, N. Y.
ten thousand dollars.
   Improving harbor at Ogdensburg, New York : Continuing improve- O g d en s burg
ment, ten thousand dollars; which, together with the amount on hand, N. Y.
is to be used in removing obstructions from the mouth of the Oswe-
gatchee and continuing the excavation at the lower harbor up stream.
   Improving harbor at Oswego, New York: Continuing improvement,           Oswego, N. Y.
seventy-one thousand two hundred and fifty dollars; of which fifty-six
thousand two hundred and fifty dollars to be used in repairs and fifteen
thousand dollars in continuing work on the harbor.
   Improving harbor at Rondout, New York: Continuing improvement,          Rondout, N. Y.
two thousand live hundred dollars.
   Improving harbor at Saugerties, New York: Continuing improve- Saugerties, N.
ments, fifteen thousand dollars.
   Improving harbor at Sheepshead Bay, New York: Continuing im- Sheepshead
                                                                           Y.
provement, live thousand dollars.                                        Bay, N. Y.
   Improving New York Harbor, New York: To secure a thirty-foot New York.
channel at mean low water at Sandy Hook entrance of the harbor, upon
such plan as the Secretary of War may approve, seven hundred and
fifty thousand dollars.
   Improving channel between Staten Island and the New Jersey shore, ChannelStaten
New York and New Jersey: Continuing improvement, fifteen thousand Jersey.
dollars.
   Improving harbor at Raritan Bay, New Jersey: Continuinuing iprove- N. .aritn Bay,
ment, thirty-seven thousand five hundred dollars.
   Improving harbor at Plattsburg, New York: Continuing improve- Plattsburg, N.
ment, five thousand dollars.
   For a more thorough and definite survey and examination of the Atlantic City,
harbor at Atlantic City,'New Jersey, with a view to making a harbor survey for har-
of refuge at that point, five thousand dollars; sid examination and bor ofrefuge.
survey to be made by a board consisting of three JUnited States engi-
neers.
   Improving harbor at Erie, Pennsylvania: Continuing improvement,          Erie, Pa.
and also for the improvement of said harbor as recommended by the
Chief of Engineers, January thirteenth, eighteen hundred and eighty-
five, thirty-seven thousand five hundred dollars: Providedl, That the Proviso.
Secretary of War be, and lie is hereby, authorized and directed to re-
ceive and accept for the United States, from the marine hospital of
446       REPORT      OF    THE    CHIEF OF        ENGINEERS,       U. S. ARMY.

    Title to Pres- Erie, Pennsylvania, the title to the peninsula of Presque Isle, at Erie,
que Isle to be ac- Pennsylvania, as tendered by the said marine hospital, agreeably to
tary of War.        the provisions of an act of the legislature of the State of Pennsylvania,
                     approved May eleventh, eighteen hundred and seventy-one: And pro-
                     vided further, That twenty-two thousand five hundred dollars of said
                     sum shall not be expended until the aforesaid title shall be accepted
                     by the Secretary of War.
    Marcus Hook,         Improving ice-harbor at Marcus Hook, Pennsylvania: Continuing
Pa., ice-harbor. improvement, fifteen thousand dollars.
  Chester,Pa.,ces-      The Secretary of war is authorized to cede to the city of Chester.
sion of piers to. Pennsylvania, the upper and lower piers located in said city and extend-
                     ing into the Delaware River, and formerly used as an ice harbor.
     D e 1 a w a r e Improving Delaware breakwater, Delaware: Continuing improve-
breakwater.         ment, fifty-six thousand two hundred and fifty dollars.
    New Castl e,        Improving ice-harbor at New Castle, Delaware: Continuing improve-
Del., ice-harbor. ment, five thousand dollars.
   Wilmington,          Improving harbor at Wilmington, Delaware: Continuing improve-
Del.                ment, eighteen thousand seven hundred and fifty dollars.
    Baltimore, Md.      Improving harbor at Baltimore, Maryland: Continuing improvement,
                     one hundred and fifty thousand dollars.
    Breton Bay,         Improving harbor at Breton Bay, Maryland: Continuing improve-
Md.                 ment, six thousand five hundred dollars
   Washington,D.        For continuing the improvement of the Potomac River in the vicinity
C., P otom a c of Washington, with reference to the improvement of navigation, the
River.             establishment of harbor-lines, and the raising of the flats, under the
                    direction of the Secretary of War and in accordance with existing plans,
    Proviso.         three hundred and seventy-five thousand dollars: Provided, That no
    Not to be ex- part of the sum hereby appropriated shall be expended upon or with
title is doubtful. reference to any place in respect of which the title of the United States
                    is in doubt, or in respect to which any claim adverse to the United
                    States has been made.
  Norfolk,Va, ap- Improving harbor at Norfolk, Virginia, and improving approach to
proach to harbor Norfolk Harbor and the United States navy-yard at Norfolk: Continu-
and navy-yard. ing improvement by widening the channel of Elizabeth River to the
                    port-warden's line on the eastern side, between Lambert's Point Light
                    and Fort Norfolk, one hundred and eighty-seven thousand five hundred
                    dollars; of which fifty thousand.dollars shall be expended in improv-
                    ing the harbor, and one hundred and thirty-seven thousand five hun-
                    dred dollars in widening the channel of Elizabeth River to the port-
                    warden's line on the eastern side, between Lambert's Point Light and
                    Fort Norfolk, beginning at Lambert's Point Light, including the con-
                    struction of the proposed dike.
   Beaufort, N. C.      Improving harbor at Beaufort, North Carolina: Continuing improve-
                    ment, fifteen thousand dollars.
   Edenton Bay,         Improving harbor at Edenton Bay, North Carolina: Continuing im-
N. C.               provement, two thousand dollars.
Water way,New          Improving the inland water way between New Berne and Beaufort.
Berne and Beau- North Carolina, ten thousand dollars.
  Charleston, S.C.     Improving harbor at Charleston, including Sullivan's Island, South
                    Carolina: Continuing improvement, one hundred and eighty-seven
                    thousand five hundred dollars.
   Winyaw Bay,         Improving Winyaw Bay, South Carolina: Continuing improvement,
S. C.               eighteen thousand seven hundred and fifty dollars.
   Georgetown, S.       Improving harbor at Georgetown, South Carolina: Continuing im-
C.                  provement, five thousand dollars.
  Brunswick, Ga. Improving harbor at Brunswick, Georgia: Continuing improvement,
                    twenty-two thousand five hundred dollars.
   Cumberland          Improving Cumberland Sound, Georgia and Florida: Continuingim-
Sound, Georgia provement, one hundred and twelve thousand five hundred dollars.
   Savannah, Ga.       Improving harbor at Savannah, Georgia: Continuing improvement,
                    one hundred and fifty thousand dollars.
   Apalachicola        Improving  harbor at Apalachicola Bay, Florida: Continuing improve-
Bay, Florida.       ment, twelve thousand dollars; of which two thousand dollars may, in
                    the discretion of the Secretary of War, be expended at the Carabello
                    or Crooked River.
   KeyWest,Fla.,       For examination and survey of the entrance to harbor at Key West,
survey of en-Florida, two thousand five hundred dollars.
trance.
   Pensacola, Fla.     Imnproving harbor at Pensacola, Florida: Continuing improvement,
               twenty thousand dollars.
                 LAWS      AFFECTING        CORPS OF ENGINEERS.                        447
   Improving harbor at Tampa Bay, Florida: Continuing improvement,            T a mp a Bay,
ten thousand dollars.                                                      Fla.
   Improving harbor at Cedar Keys, Florida, seven thousand dollars.           Cedar Keys.
   Improving harbor at Mobile, Alabama: Continuing improvement, Fla.
ninety thousand dollars.                                                      Mobile, Ala.
   Improving harbor at Biloxi Bay, Mississippi: Continuing improve- Biloxi, Miss.
ment, twelve thousand five hundred dollars; which sum, together with
the money on hand heretofore appropriated for the roadstead, is hereby
directed to be used in deepening the channel from Mississippi Sound to
the wharves at Biloxi.
   Improving Aransas Pass and Bay up to Rockport and Corpus Christi, Aransas Pass
Texas : Continuing improvement, one hundred and one thousand two and Bay, Tex.
hundred and fifty dollars.
   Improving Brazos Santiago Harbor, Texas : Continuing improvement, Brazo s S an -
thirty-seven thousand five hundred dollars.                                tiago. Tex.
   Improvement of entrance to Galveston Harbor, Texas: Continuing Gal v eston,
improvement, three hundred thousand dollars.                               Tex.
   Improving Pass Cavallo, Texas: Continuing improvement, thirty- Pass Cavallo,
seven thousand five hundred dollars.                                       Tex.
   Improving Sabine Pass and Blue Buck Bar, Texas : Continuing im-            Sabine Pass,
provement, one hundred and ninety-eight thousand seven hundred and Tex.
fifty dollars.
   Improving ship-channel in Galveston Bay, Texas, from Morgan's Cut           G a1 v e st on
to Bolivar Channel: Continuing improvement, for which purpose the Bay, ship-chan-
balance now remaining of the money heretofore appropriated for this nel, Tex.
work is hereby directed to be expended by the Secretary of War in the
completion of said channel, in accordance with the plans heretofore
adopted, and in marking out said channel by piles or stakes, so as to
enable navigators to find the same without difficulty.
   Improving harbor at Ashtabula, Ohio: Continuing improvement,               Ash tab u 1 a,
thirty thousand dollars.                                                   Ohio.
   Improving harbor at mouth of Black River, Ohio: Continuing inm- Black River,
provement, ten thousand dollars.                                           Ohio.
   Improving harbor at Cleveland, Ohio, on the last plan projected, Cleveland,
ninety-three thousand seven hundred and fifty dollars ; of which thirty Ohio.
thousand dollars are to be used in building a parapet on the existing
breakwater, and the one hundred thousand dollars now on hand to be
available for work on the last plan.
   Improving harbor at Fairport, Ohio: Continuing improvement, eight-
een thousand seven hundred and fifty dollars.                                 Fairport, Ohio.
   Improving harbor at Huron, Ohio: Continuing improvement, three Huron, Ohio.
thousand dollars.
   Improving ice-harbor at the mouth of the Muskingum River, Ohio : Muskingum
Continuing improvement, thirty-seven thousand five hundred dollars. River, Ohio.
   Improving harbor at Port Clinton, Ohio, by repairs of existing works, Port Clinton,
two thousand dollars.                                                      Ohio.
   For the purpose of acquiring the title to the land adjoining the inner Purchase of
end of the west pier built by the United States for the improvement of land at.
the harbor at Port Clinton, Ohio, the Secretary of War shall negotiate
with the owner or owners of the land for the purchase thereof at a rea-
sonable price, to be approved by Congress; and if an agreement as to
price cannot be made with the owner, then the value of the same shall
be ascertained in the mode provided by the laws of Ohio for the con-
demnation of lands for public uses in that State, the result of said pro-
ceedings of condemnation, if taken, to be reported to the next Con-
gress for its approval.
    Improving harbor at Sandusky City, Ohio, by dredging the channel S an d us k-y,
through the outer bar and within the bay; and for this purpose the Ohio.
money appropriated by act of July fifth, eighteen hundred and eighty-
four, now on hand, is hereby made available, and the further sum of
five thousand dollars is hereby appropriated.
    Improving harbor at Toledo, Ohio : Continuing improvement of the Toledo, Ohio.
Maumee River, by a straight channel along such line as may be approved
by the Secretary of War, one hundred and twelve thous'and five hundred
dollars; and the balance of the twenty-five thousand dollars heretofore
appropriated are hereby made available for clearing the old channel.
    Improving harbor at Vermillion, Ohio: Continuing improvement,             Vermillion,
three thousand dollars.                                                    Ohio.
    Improving harbor at Michigan City, Indiana: Continuing improve- Michigan City,
ment, fifty-six thousand two hundred and fifty dollars; of which sum Ind.
448      REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF                   ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

                     one thousand eight hundred and seventy-five dollars are to be used on
                     the inner harbor.
  Calumet, Ill.         Improving harbor at Calumet, Illinois: Continuing improvement, ten
                     thousand dollars.
  Chicago, Ill.         Improving harbor at Chicago, Illinois: Continuing improvement,
                     seventy-five thousand dollars.
  Waukegan,Ill.         Improving harbor at Waukegan, Illinois : Continuing improvement,
                     twenty thousand dollars.
   Char levoix, Improving harbor at Charlevoix and entrance to Pine Lake, Michi-
Mich.                gan : Continuing improvement, ten thousand dollars.
  Cheboygan,            Improving harbor at Cheboygan, Michigan: Continuing improve-
  Mich.              ment, fifteen thousand dollars.
   Fran kfort,          Improving harbor at Frankfort, Michigan, by extension of piers and
Mich.                 repairs: Continuing improvement, seven thousand dollars.
   Grand Haven,         Improving harbor at Grand Haven, Michigan: Continuing improve-
Mich.                 ment, thirty thousand dollars.
   Grand Marais,        Improving harbor of refuge at Grand Marais, Michigan: Continuing
Mich.                improvement, twenty-six thousand two hundred and fifty dollars.
  L udin gton,          Improving harbor at Ludington, Michigan : Continuing improvement,
Mich.                fifty-six thousand two hundred and fifty dollars.
       Sn i t e e, Improvin harbor at Manistee, Michigan: Continuing improvement,
      Mich.          ten thousand dollars.
  Marq uet t e'         Improving harbor at Marquette, Michigan : Continuing improvement,
  Mich.              ten thousand dollars.
  Monroe, Mich.         Improving harbor at Monroe, Michigan: By repairs, two thousand
                     dollars.
  M ask ego n, Improving harbor at Muskegon, Michigan : Continuing improvement,
Mich.                twelve thousand five hundred dollars.
  Ontonagon,            Improving harbor at Ontonagon, Michigan: Continuing improve-
Mich.                ment, thirteen thousand dollars.
   Pent w a te r, Improving harbor at Pentwater, Michigan: Continuing improvement,
       Mich.         ten thousand dollars.
  Portage Lake,         Improving harbor at Portage Lake, Michigan : Continuing improve-
       Mh            ment, fifteen thousand dollars.
   Sand Beach,          Improving and repairing harbor of refuge at Sand Beach, Michigan :
                      Continuing improvement, seventy-five thousand dollars; of which not
                     exceeding forty-five thousand dollars are to be used in repairs.
  Saint Joseph, Improving harbor at Saint Joseph, Michigan: Continuing improve-
       S     u       ment, ten thousand dollars.
  Sau g at uc k, Improving harbor at Saugatuck,Michigan: To complete improvement,
   South Haven, eight thousand dollars.
Mich.                   Improving harbor at South Haven, Michigan : Continuing improve-
   White       iver, met,    five thousand dollars.
Mich.        River,     Improving harbor at White River, Michigan: Continuing improve-
                     ment, ten thousand dollars..
Mich.      L            Improving harbor at Black Lake, Michigan: Continuing improve-
   Ahnapee, Wis. ment, five thousand dollars.
   Wharfageto be        Improving harbor at Ahnapee, Wisconsin : Continuing improvement,
free.                fifteen thousand dollars ; but no part of said sum is to be expended until
                     the wharfage over the Government piers at that port shall be made
                     free.
   Green Bay,           Improving harbor at Green Bay, Wisconsin: Continuing improve-
Wis.                 ment, seven thousand dollars.
  Kenosha, Wis          Improving hai bor at Kelosha, Wisconsin: Continuing improvement,
                     five thousand dollars.
  K e waunee, Improving harbor at Kewaunee, Wisconsin: Continuing improve-
Wis.
                              ten thousand dollars.
                        ent,wo,
                     Manito
Wis.      to            Improving harbor at Manitowoc, Wisconsin: Continuing improve-
   Menomonee, nient, fifteen thousand dollars.
Wis.                    Improving harbor at Menomonee, Wisconsin: Continuing improve-
                     ment, three thousand dollars.
      ilwaukee           mproving harbor of refuge at Milwaukee, Wisconsin: Continuing
   Oconto, Wis. improvement          on bay and harbor, sixty thousand dollars.
                        Improving- harbor at Ocouto, Wisconsin: Continuing improvement,
                             thousand dollars.
                Port Washingeight
ton, Wis. hing-         Improving harbor at Port Washington, Wisconsin: Continuing im-
   Racine, Wis. proveent, five thousand dollars.
                   Improving harbor at Racine, Wisconsin: Continuing improvement,
            and ten thousand dollars.
         Superior
Saint Louis Improvig harbor at Superior Bay and Saint Louis Bay, Wisconsin:
Bays, Wis.        Continuing improvement, twenty-two thousand five hundred dollars;
                  LAWS     AFFECTING CORPS            OF ENGINEERS.                     449
and the engineer in charge, in his next annual report, shall submit an
estimate of the cost of a dredge-boat or other facilities that may be
needed for dredging the harbors ot Duluth and Superior. Thirteen
thousand five hundred dollars of the money hereby appropriated are to
be expended in dredging in said Superior Bay and Harbor, and in re-
pairing piers at natural entry, and nine thousand dollars in dredging
Saint Louis Bay, along the dock-line on the Wisconsin shore, from
deep water at Connor's Point towards deep water at Grassy Point.
    Improving harbor at Sheboygan, Wisconsin : Continuing improve- Sheboygan,
ment, fifteen thousand dollars.
    Improving harbor at Sturgeon Bay, Wisconsin : Continuing improve- Sturgeon Bay,
ment, five thousand dollars.
    Improving harbor at Ashland, Wisconsin: Continuing improvement, Ashland, Wis.
twenty-two thousand five hundred dollars.
    The Secretary of War is authorized and directed to appoint a Board Sturgeon Bay
of three engineers from the United States Army whose duty it shall be ran Shin Canal.
to examine, in all their relations to commerce, the Sturgeon Bay and Board of engi-
Lake Michigan Ship-Canal, connecting the waters of Green Bay with neers to report as
Lake Michigan, in the State of Wisconsin, with a view to making the to its value, etc.
same a free passage way and harbor of refuge, to consider their value,
and all other matters connected with their usefulness to navigation,
and which shall give information as to the expediency of the work and
the desirability of their acquisition and improvement. The said Board
shall report to the Secretary of War, who shall lay its report before
Congress at its next session, together with the views of himself and
the Chief of Engineers of the United States Army thereon; and five
thousand dollars, or so much thereof as may be necessary, is hereby ap-
propriated for this purpose.
    Improving harbor at Duluth, Minnesota: Continuing improvement, Duluth, Minn.
andl enlarging basin between Minnesota and Rice's Points, fifty-six thou-
sand two hundred and fifty dollars ; of which a sum not exceeding five
hundred dollars may be used in placing buoys in the channels and else-
where where needed in the harbor; and the consent of the United
States is hereby given to a change of the existing dock-line on the east
side of Rice's Point by the municipal authorities of Duluth: Provided,
That such change meets the approval of the Secretary of War.
    Improving harbor at Grand Marais, Minnesota: Continuing improve- Grand Marais,
ment, ten thousand dollars.                                                 Minn.
    Improving harbor at Agate Bay, Minnesota, twenty-two thousand five A gate Bay,
hundred dollars.                                                             Minn.
    Improving h arbor at Lake City, Minnesota, Continuing improvement, Lake City,
ten thousand dollars.                                                       Minn.
    Improving harbor and bay at Humboldt, California: Continuing im- Humboldt, Cal.
provement,    seventy-five thousand dollars: Provided, That no part of said  Proviso.
sum shall be expended until the twelve acres of land necessary to said
improvement shall have been conveyed to the United States free of ex-
pense, and such conveyance has been approved by the Secretary of
War, after the Attorney-. General of the United States shall have certi-
flied to the Secretary of War that the title is perfect.
     Improving harbor at Oakland, California: Continuing improvement, Oalland, Cal.
sixty thousand dollars.
     The sum of eleven thousand dollars, or as much thereof as may be Survey of San
necessary, is hereby appropriated for a survey of San Francisco Har- Francisco PHar
bor, San Pablo Bay, Suisun Bay, Strait of Carqulnex, mouth of San Bay, SuisunBay,
Joaquin River, and mouth of Sacramento River, California.                   Strait of Carqui-
                                                                             nex, San Joaquin
                                                                             and Sacramento
                                                                             Rivers.
     Improving harbor at Red Wood, California: Continuing improve- Redwood, Cal.
ment, five thousand dollars.
     The sum of five thousand dollars, or so much thereof as may be neces. Survey, etc., of
sary, is hereby appropriated for examination, survey, and estimated cost San Diego, New-
of obtaining a channel two hundred and fifty feet wide and twenty-four portand San Luis
feet deep at mean low water across the outer bar, and from thence to a Oalspo Harbors,
point abreast of beacon number two, in San Diego Harbor, California;
also, of obtaining a navigable channel at least eight feet in depth at
mean low water at Newport Harbor, California; also, of the establish-
ment of a breakwater extending in a southeasterly direction one-fourth
of a mile, more or less, along the sunken reef commencing at or near
Whaler's Point, so called, at San Luis Obispo Harbor, California.
         29 E
450      REPORT     OF THE CHIEF         OF   ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

Wilmington,      Improving harbor at Wilmington, California: Continuing improve-
Cal.            nent, seventy-five thousand dollars.
Yaquina Bay,     Improving harbor at Yoquina Bay, Oregon: Continuing improve-
Oreg.           ment, seventy-five thousand dollars.
Coos Bay,        Improvement of the harbor at entrance of Coos Bay, Oregon, thirty-
Oreg.           three thousand seven hundred and fifty dollars.
Lubec Channel.   Improving Lubec Channel, Maine: Continuing improvement, ten
                thousand dollars.
  Moosebec Bar.   Improving Moosebec Bar, Maine: Continuing improvement, ten
                thousand dollars.
  Pen obscot       Improving Penobscot River, Maine: Continuing improvement, by
River.          widening the channel opposite Bangor and removing obstructions near
                 Crosby's Narrows, fifteen thousand dollars.
Saco River.        Improving Saco River, Maine, twelve thousand five hundred dollars.
Narragaugus
River.              Improving Narragaugus River, Maine, ten thousand dollars.
CochecoRiver.      Improving Cocheco River, New Hampshire: Continuing improve-
                 ment, ten thousand dollars.
  Ipswich River.    Improving Ipswich River, Massachusetts, two thousand five hutndred
                 dollars.
  Warren River.     Improving Warren River, Rhode Island, five thousand dollars.
  Pawtucket         Improving Pawtucket River, Rhode Island: Continuing improve-
River.           ment, thirty thousand dollars.
  Providence        Improving Providence River and Narragansett Bay, Rhode Island:
River, Narragan- Continuing improvement, thirty thousand dollars
  Providence        For removing Green Jacket Shoal, Providence River, Rhode Island,
River.           twenty-six thousand two hundred and fifty dollars.
  Pawcatuck         Improving Pawcatuck River, Rhode Island, twelve thousand dollars.
River.
  Connecticut       Improving Connecticut River below Hartford, Connecticut: Continu-
River.           ing improvement, twenty-six thousand two hundred and fifty-dollars.
  Housat onic       Improving Housatonic River, Connecticut, five thousand dollars.
River.              Inmproving Thames River, Connecticut, Continuing improvement,
                 twenty-two thousand five hundred dollars.
  East Chester      Improving East Chester Creek, New York : Continuing improvement,
Creek.           ten thousand dollars.
  Hudson River.     Improving Hudson River, New York: Continuing improvement,
                 twenty-six thousand two hundred and fifty dollars; of which fifteen
                 thousand dollars may be used for the removal of the rock in channel at
                 Van Wie's Point.
  N e w t own       Improving Newtown Creek and Bay, New York : Continuing im-
Creek and Bay. provement, thirty-seven thousand five hundred dollars; of which nine
                 thousand three hundred and seventy-five dollars to be expended on
                 west branch between Maspeth avenue and Dual Bridge, at Grand street
                 and Metropolitan avenue; nine thousand three hundred and seventy-
                 five dollars to be expended on main branch between Easterly Grand
                 Street bridge to Metropolitan avenue; and balance on lower end, from
                 Maspeth avenue to the mouth of the creek.
  Hell Gate.        Improving Hell Gate, New York : Continuing improvement one hun-
                 dred and twelve thousand five hundred dollars.
  Lake C ham-       Improving Narrows at Lake Champlain, New York, from Benson,
plain, Narrows. Vermont, to canal locks at Whitehall, New York, thirty thousand dol-
                 lars.
  Ticonderoga       Improving Ticonderoga River, New York: Continuing improvement,
River.           two thousand dollars.
  MauriceRIiver     Improving Maurice River, New Jersey: Continuing improvement,
                 five thousaud dollars.
  Passaic River.    Improving Passaic River, New Jersey: Continuing improvement,
                 twenty-six thousand two hundred and fifty dollars; of which two thou-
                 sand two hundred and fifty dollars are to be used above Newark.
  Raritan River.    Improving Raritan River, New Jersey: Continuing improvement,
                 twenty-six thousand two hundred and fifty dollars.
  Shrewsbury        Improving Shrewsbury River, New .Jersey : Continuing improvement,
River.           ten thousand dollars.
  South River.      Improving South River, New Jersey: Continuing improvement, five
                 thousand dollars.
  Saint Jones Improving Saint Jones River, Delaware: Continuing improvement,
River.           ten thousand dollars.
  N a n tico k e Improving Nanticoke River, Delaware : Continuing improvement up
River.      to and near the town of Laurel, Delaware, ten thousand dollars.
Monongahela Improving Monongahela River, Pennsylvania and West Virginia:
River.      Continuing improvement, ninety thousand nine hundred dollars; but
                LAWS     AFFECTING        CORPS OF ENGINEERS.                      451
no charges or tolls shall be collected on any other part of the river on
any commerce on said river which originates above the works herein
appropriated for.
   For beginning the construction of a dam at Herr's Island, in the Al leg h e n y
Allegheny River, near Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, thirty-seven thousand River.
five hundred dollars.
   Improving Allegheny River, Pennsylvania: Continuing improve-
ment, thirty thousand dollars.
   Improving Schuylkill River, Pennsylvania: Continuing improve- Sc huylkill
ment, eighteen thousand seven hundred and fifty dollars.                River.
    Improving Delaware River, Pennsylvania and New Jersey : Contin- D e a w a r e
ing improvement from Trenton to its mouth, two hundred and ten River.
thousand dollars; of which thirty thousand dollars shall be applied to
improving the channel between Camden, New Jersey, and Philadelphia,
Pennsylvania, and seven thousand five hundred dollars, or so much
thereof as may be needed, shall be expended on said river and its tidal
tributaries above Bridesburg.
   Improving Chboptank River, Maryland: Continuing improvement, ten C hop t a n k
thousand dollars.                                                        River. *
   Improving Corsica Creek, Maryland : Continuing improvement, ten Corsica Creek.
thousand dollars.
   For rebuilding piers at Battery Island, head of the Chesapeake Bay, Chesapeake
which were carried away by ice, strengthening and protecting the Bay.
works at that point from future destruction, seventeen thousand two
hundred and seventy-five dollars.
   Improving Susquehanna River, Maryland and Pennsylvania : Con- Susqueh anna
tinning improvement, six thousand dollars; to b3 expended above the River.
Philadelphia, Wilmington and Baltimore Railroad Bridge.
   Improving Pocomoke River, Maryland : Continuing and completing P o c o m ok e
improvement, eight thousand dollars.                                    River.
    Improving, by dredging and otherwise, the inland water-way from Water-way
Chincoteague   Bay, Virginia, to Delaware  Bay at or near Lewes,  Dela- from Ch in co-
ware, to be used from Chincoteague Bay to Indian River Bay, eighteen teague Bayito
thousand seven hundred and fifty dollars.                               Bay.
   Improving Appomattox River, Virginia: Continuing improvement, Appomattox
eighteen thousand seven hundred and fifty dollars.                      River.
   Improving Chickahominy River, Virginia: Continuing improvement,          Chickahominy
four thousand dollars.                                                   River.
   Improving James River, Virginia: Continuing improvement below James River.
Richmond, one hundred and twelve thousand five hundred dollars.
   Improving Mattaponi River,Virginia: Continuing improvement, five Mat t a po ni
thousand dollars.                                                        River.
   Improving New River, Virginia: Continuing improvement between New River.
the lead-mines,in Wythe County, and the mouth of Wilson's Creek, in
Grayson County, ten thousand dollars, together with the three thou-
sand dollars now on hand.
   Improving Pamunky River, Virginia: Continuing improvement, five Pam u n k y
thousand dollars.                                                        River.
   Improving Rappahannock River,Virginia : Continuing improvement, Rappahannock
twenty thousand dollars.                                                 River.
   Improving Staunton River, Virginia: Continuing improvement, ten S t a u n t o n
thousand dollars; one-half of which is to be expended between the River.
month of Pig River and the Midland Railroad Crossing.
   Improving York River, Virginia: Continuing improvement, eighteen York River.
thousand seven hundred and fifty dollars.
   Improving Dan River, Virginia: Continuing improvement, ten thou- Dan River.
sand dollars.
   Improving Big Sandy River, West Virginia and'Kentucky: Continu- B i g S a n d y
ing improvement, thirty thousand dollars; of which sum three thou- River.
sand seven hundred and fifty dollars are to be expended on Tug Fork,
in West Virginia, and three thousand seven hundred and fifty dollars
on Lavisa Fork, in Kentucky.
   Improving Buckhannon River, West Virginia: Continuing improve- Buckhannon
ment, one thousand five hundred dollars.                                 River.
   Improving Great Kanawha River, West Virginia: Continuing ini- Great K a-
provement, one hundred and eighty-seven thousand five hundred dol- nawha River.
lars.
  Improving Elk River, West Virginia: Continuing improvement, one          Elk River.
thousand five hundred dollars.
452      REPORT        OF THE    CHIEF     OF ENGINEERS,         U. S. ARMY.

  Guy and ot te      Improving Guyandotte River, West Virginia: Continuing improve-
iver.            ment, the amount heretofore appropriated is hereby made available for
                   this purpose.
  Little     Ka- Improving Little Kanawha River, West Virginia: Continuing im-
nawha River.      provernent, sixteen thousand eight hundred and seventy-five dollars ;
                  of which one thousand eight hundred and seventy-five dollars shall be
                   used in continuing the improvementof navigation above the west fork.
                   But no toll shall be collected by any person or corporation for this im-
                  proved navigation; and such right, if any exist, shall be relinquished,
                  in a manner satisfactory to the Secretary of War, before the expendi-
                  ture of arly of the money herein appropriated for this work.
  Cape Fear Improving Cape Fear River, North Carolina: Continuing improve-
River.             ment, one hundred and sixty-eight thousand seven hundred and fifty
                  dollars; of which sum eleven thousand two hundred and fifty dollars
                  are to be expended above Wilmington, the remainder below and oppo-
                  site the city of Wilmington, including as much of its northeast branch
                   as lies in front of Wilmington, within the city limits.
  Contentnia         Improving Contentnia Creek, North Carolina: Continuing improve-
Creek.             ment, fifteen thousand dollars.
  C u r r i tuc k     Improving Carrituck Sound, Coanjok Bay, and North River Bar,
Sound.             North Carolina: Continuing improvement, ten thousand dollars.
  Neuse River.        Improving Neuse River, North Carolina: Continuing improvement,
                   twenty-two thousand five hundred dollars.
  New River.         Improvilng New River, North Carolina: Continuing improvement,
                   ten thousan ddollars.
PamlicoandTar        Improving Pamlico and Tar Rivers, North Carolina: Completing im-
Rivers.            provement, five thousand dollars.
  Blaci River.        Improving Black River, North Carolina, three thousand dollars: Pro-
                   vided, That all claims of private parties to the navigation of the river
                   shall be ceded to the United States, free of charge, before the com-
                   mencement of said improvement.
                      Improving Roanoke River, North Carolina: Continuing improvement,
Roanoke River. twenty thousand dollars. Two thousand five hundred dollars, or so
                   much thereof as may be necessary, of the aforesaid twenty thousand
                   dollars shall be used for the purpose of removing obstructions in the
                   Thoroughfare and Coshoke Creek.
  Trent River.        Improving Trent River, North Carolina: Continuing improvement,
                   three thousand five hundred dollars.
  Dan River,          Improving Dan River, North Carolina: Continuing improvement, be-
                   tween Madison, North Carolina, and Danville, Virginia, ten thousand
                  dollars.
Yadkin River.     Improving Yadkin River, North Carolina: Continuing improvement,
                ten thousand dollars.
                   Improving the aland waterway between Beaufort Harbor and New
                  aterway,
Beaufort to New River, North Carolina, through Bogue Sound, ten thousand dollars.
River.             Improving Ashley River, South Carolina : Continuing improvement,
  Ashley River. one thousand dollars.
  Edisto River.    Improving Edisto River, South Carolina: Continuing improvement,
                three thousand dollars.
  Great Pee Dee    Improving Great Pee Dee River, South Carolina: Continuing im-
River.          provement, twenty thousand dollars.
  Salkiehatchi e Improving Salkiehatchie River, South Carolina: Continuing improve-
River.          ment, two thousand dollars.
  Santee River.    Improving Santee River, South Carolina: Continuing improvement,
                eighteen thousand seven hundred and fifty dollars; no part of which
                sum to be used for the construction of any road-bridge across the Mos-
  Proviso.      quito Creek Canal: Provided, That if salt water be found flowing into
                said Mosquito Creek, five thousand dollars of said sum, or so much
                thereof as may be necessary, shall be used for the construction of a
                flood-gate at the upper end of the canal, to prevent the same.
  Waccamaw         Improving Waccamaw River, South Carolina: Continuing improve-
River.          ment, fifteen thousand dollars.
  Wappoo Cut.      Improving Wappoo Cut, South Carolina: Continuing improvement,
                five thousand dollars.
Wateree River.    Improving Wateree River, South Carolina: Continuing improvement,
                seven thousand five hundred dollars.
CongareeRiver.     Improving Congaree River, South Carolina, seven thousand five hun-
                  dred dollars.
                 LAWS     AFFECTING       CORPS     OF ENGINEERS.                   453

   Improving Altamaha River, Georgia: Continuing improvement, Altamaha'River.
twenty thousand dollars; of which ten thousand dollars are to be used
on Doboy Bar, or so much thereof as may be necessary.
   Improving Chattahoochee River, Georgia and Alabama: Continuing Chattahoochee
improvement, twenty thousond dollars.                                   River.
   Improving Coosa River, Georgia and Alabama: Continuing improve- Coosa River.
ment, forty-five thousand dollars.
   Improving Flint River, Georgia: Continuing improvement, twenty Flint River.
thousand dollars; of which stum five thousand dollars are to be expended
between Albany and Montezuma, and fifteen thousand dollars below
Albany.
   Improving Ocmulgee River, Georgia: Continuing improvement, seven 0 c m u 1g e e
thousand five hundred dollars.                                           River.
   Improving Oconee River, Georgia : Continuing improvement, nine Oconee'River.
thousand dollars; one thousand five hundred dollars of said sum to be
expended between Skull Shoals and the Railroad Bridge.
   Improving Romely Marsh, Georgia: To complete improvement, sev- Romely Marsh.
enteen thousand four hundred and seventy-five dollars; and so much of
said sum as may be necessary may be applied by the engineer in charge,
with the approval of the Secretary of War, to pay for work done on said
improvement, under the direction of the War Department, since the last
appropriation was exhausted.
   Improving Savannah River below Augusta, Georgia: Continuing iin-         S a v a n n ah
provement, fifteen thousand dollars.                                     River.
   Improving Apalachicola River, Florida: Continuing improvement, Apalach i cola
one thousand dollars.                                                    River.
   Improving Caloosahatchee River, Florida :.Continuing improvement, Caloosahatchee
four thousand dollars.                                                   River.
   Improving Choctawhatchee River, Florida and Alabama: Continu- Choc t'a wh a t-
ing improvement, fifteen thousand dollars; of which sum five thousand cheeRiver.
dollars to be expended below Geneva, and ten thousand dollars to be
expended between Geneva and Newton, Alabama.
   Improving Conecuh-Escambia River, Florida and Alabama : Continu- ( oneecu h-Es-
ing improvement, twelve thousand dollars.                                cambia River.
   Improving La Grange Bayou, Florida: Continuing improvement, two La Grange Ba-
thousand dollars.                                                        you.
   Improving Manatee and Pease Rivers, Florida: Continuing improve.        Manatee and
ment, thirteen thousand    dollars; of which   five thousand dollars may Pease  Rivers.
be expended on Pease River.
   Improving channel over the bar at the mouth of Saint John's River, Saint Jo h n'
Florida: Continuing improvement, one hundred and fifty thousand River.
dollars.
   Improving Suwanee River, Florida: Continuing improvement, five Suwanee River.
thousand dollars.
   Improving Volusia Bar, Florida: To complete improvement, seven Volusia Bar.
thousand five hundred dollars.
   Improving Withlacoochee River, Florida: Continuing improvement,         Withlacoochee
three thousand dollars.                                                  River.
   Improving Alabama River, Alabama: Continuing improvement, fif- Alabama River
teen thousand dollars.
   Improving Black Warrior River from Tuscaloosa to Daniel's Creek, Black Warrior
Alabama, fifty-six thousand two hundred and fifty dollars, together with River.
the forty-seven thousand dollars on hand; to be expended in accordance
with the plan adopted by the board of engineers.
   Improving Caha'wba River, Alabama: Continuing improvement, CahawbaRiver
seven thousand five hundred dollars: Provided, That no part of said Proviso.
sum shall be expended until the officer in charge shall have reported
that the railroad and other bridges across said river have been provided
with good and sufficient draw-openings.
   Improving Tallapoosa River, Alabama: Continuing improvement,            T all apoos:a
seven thousand five hundred dollars.                                     River.
   Improving Warrior River, Alabama : Continuing improvement, eight- Warrior River.
een thousand seven hundred and fifty dollars; to be expended below
Tuscaloosa.
   Improving Tombigbee River, Alabama and Mississippi: Continuing Tomb ig bee
improvement, eighteen thousand seven hundred and fifty dollars ; to be River.
expended below Vienna, eleven thousand two hundred and fifty dollars;
and between Vienna and Fulton, seven thousand five hundred dollars.
  Improving Big Sunflower River, Mississippi: Continuing improve- Big Sunflowe
ment, five thousand dollars; of which two thousand dollars to be ex- River.
pended between Woodburn and Lehrton.
454      REPORT      OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                 U. S. ARMY.

NoxubeeRiver.      Improving Noxubee River, Mississippi: Continuing improvement,
                 seven thousand five hundred dollars.
  Pasc ago ala Improving Pascagoula River, Mississippi: Continuing improvement,
River.           including bar at the mouth, and from there to the mills at Moss Point,
                 twenty thousand dollars; and the balance of the money now on hand
                 heretofore appropriated for improving Horn Island Pass is to be applied
                 to the same purpose.
  Pearl River.      Improving Pearl River, Mississippi : Continuing improvement, seven-
                 teen thousand six hundred and t wenty-five dollars ; of which two thou-
                 sand two hundred and fifty dollars are to be expended between Edinburg
                 and Carthage, two thousand two hundred and fifty dollars between
                 Carthage and Jackson, and the remainder below Jackson, including bar
                 at the mouth of East Pearl River.
  Steele'sBayou.    Improving Steele's Bayou, Mississippi, including Washington Bayou:
                 Continuing improvement, two thousand five hundred dollars.
  Tallahatchee      Improving Tallahatchee River, Mississippi: Continuing improve-
River.           ment, three thousand five hundred dollars.
  Tchula Lake.      Improving Tchula Lake, Mississippi: Continuing improvement, two
                 thousand dollars.
  Yallabusha        Improving Yallabusha River, Mississippi: Continuing improvement,
River.           two thousand dollars.
  Bayou Pierre.     Improving Bayou Pierre, Mississippi : Continuing improvement, five
                 thousand dollars.
  Yazoo River.      Improving Yazoo River, Mississippi: Continuing improvement, fif-
                 teen thousand dollars; of which five thousand dollars, or so much as
                 may be necessary, to be used in repairing snag-boat.
  Big B 1 a c k Improving Big Black River, Mississippi: Continuing improvement,
River.           five thousand dollars: Provided, That no part of this appropriation
  Proviso.       shall be used until the State of Mississippi shall have first caused the
                 bridges over said stream south of the Vicksburg and Meridan Railroad
                 to be so constructed as not to obstruct the navigation of said stream.
  Amite River.      Improving Amite River, Louisiana: Continuing improvement, two
                 thousand dollars.
  BoIuf River.      Improving Buenf River, Louisiana: Continuing improvement, and
                 for closing Outlet Number One, five thousand dollars.
  Bayou Bar-        Improving Bayou Bartholomew, Louisiana and Arkansas: Contiuu-
tholomew.        ing improvement, five thousand dollars.
  Bayou Courta-     Improving Bayou Courtableau, Louisiana: Continuing improvement,
bleau.           five thousand dollars.
  Bayou D'Ar-       Improving Bayou D'Arboune, Louisiana: Continuing improvement,
bonne,           two thousand dollars.
  B ay on Terre.    Improving Bayou Terrebonne, Louisiana: Continuing improvement,
bonne,           ten thousand dollars.
  CypressBayou.     Improving Cypress Bayou and the lakes between Jefferson, Texas,
                 and Shreveport, Louisiana, Texas and Louisiana: To complete improve-
                 ment, eighteen thousand dollars.
  Tensas River Improving Tensas River and Bayou Macon, Louisiana: Continuing
a n d B a y o u improvement, four thousand dollars.
  MaReRoniver.      Improving Red River, Louisiana, and Arkansas: Continuing improve-
                 ment from Fulton, Arkansas, to the Atchafalaya River, Louisiana, in-
                 cluding completing the work at Alexandria, seventy-five thousand dol-
                 lars; of which sum twenty-five thousand dollars, or so much thereof as
                 may be necessary, shall be used in making a thorough survey of the
                 river from Fuiton, Arkanisas to thue Atchaflaa       Rivei, and in com-
                 pleting the survey of Bayou Pierre, Louisiana.
  Tehefunete        Improving Tchefuncte River and Bogue Falia, Louisiana: Contiunu-
River and Bogue ing improvement, two thousand five hundred dollars; to be expended
                 in the improvement of Bogue Falia up to Covington.
  TickfawRiver.     Improving Tickfaw River, Louisiana: Continuing improvement, two
                 thousand dollars; to be expended on its navigable tributaries.
  Ouachita and      Improving Ouachita River, Louisiana and Arkansas, and Black River,
Black Rivers.    Louisiana: Continuing improvement, seventeen thousand fiv' hundred
                 dollars; of which seven thousand five hundred dollars, or so much
                 thereof as may be necessary, for repairing snag boat Wagner.
  CalcasieuRiver    Improving Calcasieu River and Pass, Louisiana: Continuing improve-
and Pass.        ment to secure a navigable channel eight feet deep over the bars affect-
                ing the entrance to said river and pass, and for this purpose the money
                on hand heretofore appropriated for improvement of Calcasieu River is
                to be used.
  Brazos River.   Improving mouth of Brazos River, Texas: Continuing improvement,
                eighteen thousand seven hundred and fifty dollars.
                 LAWS AFFECTING CORPS OF ENGINEERS.                                  455
   Improving Buffalo Bayou, Texas: Continuing improvement, eighteen Buffalo Bayou.
thousand seven hundred and fifty dollars.
   Improving Saint Francis River, Arkansas and Missouri, to the town Saint Francis
of Saint Francis: Continuing improvement, eight thousand dollars.          River.
   Improving Arkansas River, Arkansas: Continuing improvement,                Ar k a n s as
seventy-five thousand dollars, according to the plan and recommenda- River.
tion in Appendix V thirteen, Executive Document One, Forty-ninth
Congress; of which there are to be expended eight thousand dollars at
Pine Bluff, thirteen thousand dollars at Fort Smith, and ten thousand
dollars at Dardanelles, or so much thereof under those sums, respectively,
as may be necessary at those points.
   For the removal of snags, wrecks, and other obstructions in the Ar- Removing of
kansas River, nineteen thousand eight hundred and seventy-five dollars; snags, etc.
of which suni one thousand one hundred and twenty-five dollars, or so
much thereof as may be necessary, shall be used to complete the survey
of the Arkansas River, between Little Rock, Arkansas, and Wichita,
Kansas.
   Improving Red River, Arkansas, above Fulton, Arkansas, seven Red River.
thousand dollars.
   Improving Little Red River, Arkansas, three thousand dollars.             Little R e d
   Improving Black River, Arkansas and Missouri, five thousand dol- River.
                                                                             Black River.
lars.
   Improving Petit Jean River, Arkansas, three thousand five hundred P e t i t J e a n
dollars.
   Improving White River, Arkansas: Continuing improvement, eight- White River.
een thousand dollars; thirteen thousand dollars of which, or so much
thereof as may be necessary, to complete the survey of said river; the
remainder for general improvement.
   For removing the rock shoals in Fourche River, Arkansas, situate FourcheRiver:
four miles south of Perryville, in Perry County, Arkansas, according to
the plans of the engineers for creating a fifty-foot channel, five thou-
sand dollars.
   Improving Big Hatchee River, Tennessee: Continuing improvement, Big Hatchee
three thousand dollars.                                                    River.
   Improving Caney Fork River, Tennessee: Continuing improvement, Caney               Fork
three thousand dollars.                                                    River.
   Improving Clinch River, Tennessee: Continuing improvement, five Clinch River.
thousand dollars.
   Improving Cumberland River, Tennessee and Kentucky: Continu- Cumberland
ing improvement above Nashville, with a view to secure in the channel River.
a deplh of four feet, commencing with the lock at or near the lower
island at Nashville, seventy-five thousand dollars.
   Improving Cumberland River below Nashville, Tennessee: Continu-
ing improvement, twelve thousand five hundred dollars.
   Improving French Broad River, Teainessee: Continuing improvement,         Frenca Broad
six thousand dollars.                                                      River.
   Improving Iliawassee River, Tennessee: Continuing improvement,            H ia wassee
two thousand five hundred dollars.                                         River.
   Improving South Fork of Forked Deer River, Tennessee: Continu.            South    Fork,
ing improvement, five thousand dollars.                                    Riorked Deer
   Improving Tennessee River above Chattanooga, Tennessee: Continu- TennesseeRiv-
ing improvement, seven thousand five hundred dollars.                      er.
   Improving Tennessee River at Big Mussel Shoals, Little Mussel
Shoals, and Elk River Shoals, Alabama : To complete improvements at
these localities, two hundred and sixty-two thousand 'five hundred
dollars.
   Improving South Fork of Cumberland River, Kentucky: Continuing South               Fork,
improvement, five thousand dollars.                                        CumberlandRiv-
   Improving Kentucky River, Kentucky: Continuing improvement,               kentucky Riv-
one hundred and eighty-seven thousand five hundred dollars.                er.
   Improving Tradewater River, Kentucky: Continuing improvement Trad ewater
two thousand dollars.                                                      River.
   Improving the Falls of the Ohio River at Louisville, Kentucky: Con- FallsoftheOhio
tinning improvement, according to the last plan of the engineer in River, Louisville.
charge, and to be first applied to the completion of the work now in
progress, one hundred and fifty thousand dollars: Provided, That of that Proviso.
sum fifty thousand dollars shall be expended in enlarging the canal
basin, as recommended in the last report of the engineer in charge.
   The Secretary of War is hereby authorized and directed to ascertain Board of engi-
the value and commercial importance of the works and property of the neersto reporton
456       REPORT       OF   THE   CHIEF     OF    ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

the value, etc.,of Green and Barren River Navigation Company, situated on the Green
the works of and Barren rivers, in the State of Kentucky, and of the Monongahela
RiverNavigation Navigation Company, situated on the Monongahela River, in the State
Company, and of Pennsylvania; and in order to acquire such information the Secre-
Moonngah ela tary of War shall appoint a board of three competent engineers from
Company.            the Engineers Corps of the United States Army, which board shall in
                    each case report to the Secretary of War, who shall report thereon to
                    Congress at its next succeeding session; and the cost of such examina-
                    tion shall be paid out of the sum appropriated by this act for surveys:
   Proviso.         Provided, That nothing herein shall be construed as committing Con-
                    gress to the purchase of the said works.
   Muskingum           Improvement of the Muskingum River, Ohio, between Zanesville and
River.              the mouth of the river, and for operating the same, twenty thousand
   Acceptance dollars. And the United States hereby accepts from the State of Ohio
fromoo          us- the said Muskingum River improvement, and all the locks, dams, and
             MRiver
improvements, their appurtenances, and the canals, belonging to said improvement,
caDal, etc.         and all the franchises and property of every kind, and rights, in said
                    river, and its improvements, now owned, held, and enjoyed by the State
                    of Ohio, including all water leases and rights to use water under and
                    byvirtue of any lease of water now running and in force between the
                    State of Ohio and all persons using said water, hereby intending to
                    transfer to the United States such rights in said leases and contracts as
                    are now owned, held, or reserved by the State of Ohio; but not to af-
                    fect any right to the use of the water of said river now owned and held
                    by the lessees of any water right under any lease or contract with the
                    State of Ohio. And the United States hereby assumes control of said
   To take effect river, subject to the paramount interest of navigation. The provisions
whenproperty is of this act, so far as they relate to the Muskingum River, shall not take
turned over.        effect, nor shall the money hereby appropriated be available, until the
                    State of Ohio, acting by its duly authorized agent, turns over to the
                    United States all property ceded by the act of the general assembly
                    aforesaid, and all personal property belonging to the improvement
                    aforesaid, and used in its care and improvement, and any balance of
                    money appropriated by said State for the improvement of said river,
                    and which is not expended on the fifteenth day of July, eighteen hun-
                    dred and eighty-six.
   Clinton River.      Improving Clinton River, Michigan: Continuing improvement, six
                    thousand dollars.
   Detroit River.      Improving Detroit River, Michigan : Continuing improvement, thirty-
                    seven thousand five hundred dollars.
   Saint Clair Improving Saint Clair Ship-Canal Michigan: Continuing improve-
Ship-Canal.        ment, eighteen thousand seven hundred and fifty dollars.
   Saint Mary's Improving Saint Mary's River, Michigan : Continuing improvement
River.             by a new lock and approaches, two hundred and fifty thousand dollars.
   Hay LakeChan-       Improving Hay Lake Channel, Michigan: Continuing improvement,
nel.               one hundred and fifty thousand dollars.
   Saginaw River.      Improving Saginaw River, Michigan: Continuing improvement,
                    thirty-three thousand seven hundred and fifty dollars ; of which sixteen
                    thousand eight hundred and seventy-five dollars are to be used above
                    Bay City, and five thousand dollars in improving the west channel
                    along West Bay City.
   Roard of engi-      The Secretary of War is authorized and directed to appoint a Board
neers to report of three engineers from the United States Army whose duty it shall be
on value, etc., of                n
  Potad ec.a to examine, in all their relations to commerce, the two improved water
Improvement ways known as the Portage Lake and River Iriprovement Company
Company Canal Canal and the Lake Superior Ship-Canal Railway and Iron Company
and Lake Supe- Canal, being the improved harbors of refuge and the water communi-
riorShip Canal. cation across Keweenaw Point, from Keweenaw Bay to Lake Superior,
                     by way of Portage River and Lake, in the State of Michigan, with a
                     view to making the same a free passage-way and harbors of refuge, to
                     consider their value and all other matters connected with their useful-
                     ness to navigation, and which shall give information as to the expedi-
                     ency of the work and the desirability of their acquisition and improve-
                     ment. The said board shall report to the Secretary of War, who shall
                     lay its report before Congress at its next session, together with the
                     views of himself and the Chief of Engineers of the United States Army
                     thereon; and ten thousand dollars, or so much thereof as may he nec-
                   essary, is hereby appropriated for this purpose.
   Chippewa Riv-      Improving Chippewa River, Wisconsin: Continuing improvement
er                from the Dalles Dam to its mouth, eighteen thousand seven hundred
                   and fifty dollars.
                 LAWS     AFFECTING        CORPS    OF   ENGINEERS.                 457
   Improving Fox River, Wisconsin: Continuing improvement below Fox River.
Montello, on the approved plan, fifty-six thousand two hundred and
fifty dollars. And the Secretary of War is hereby directed to have the Survey to be
examination and survey of the Wisconsin River from Portage to the completed as
mouth, now being made by a board of engineers, completed as soon as blon as practica-
practicable, and a report thereof made on or before the meeting of the
next session of Congress. And the sum of six thousand dollars of the
above appropriation, or so much thereof as may be necessary, may be
expended at or near Portage City to prevent the overflow of the Wis-
consin River into the Upper Fox River, so as to prevent injury to the
Government works on Fox River; and this expenditure niay be made
separately, or, if deemed more economical by the Secretary of War, in
adding to any protecting works which may be made by the State of
Wisconsin.
   Improving Saint Croix River, Wisconsin and Minnesota: Continuing Saint Croix
improvement, seven thousand five hundred dollars.                          River.
   Improving Wabash River, Indiana and Illinois: Continuing work on Wabash River.
lock and dam at Grand Rapids, and on the river from Grand Rapids,
to its mouth, sixty thousand dollars, and nine thousand dollars to be
expended on the river at Grayville.
   Improving White River, Indiana: Continuing improvement, below White River.
Hazleton, seven thousand five hundred dollars.
   Improving Calumet River, Illinois: Continuing improvement, thirty Calumet River.
thousand dollars ; of which eleven thousand two hundred and fifty dol-
lars are to be used between the Forks and one-tialf mile east of Ham-
mond, Indiana, five thousand six hundred and twenty-five dollars of
which are to be used in dredging the river between the Forks and the
State line of Illinois and Indiana,. and five thousand six hundred and
twenty-five dollars on the river at Hammond, Indiana: Provided, how- Provisos.
ever, That no part of said sum, nor any sum heretofore appropriated,
except the said eleven thousand two hundred and fifty dollars, for the
river above the Forks shall be expended until the entire right of way,
as set forth in Senate Executive Document Number Nine, second session Right ofwayto
Forty-seventh Congress, shall have been conveyed to the United States be first secured.
free of expense, and the United States shall be fully released from all
liability for damages to adjacent property-owners, to the satisfaction of
the Secretary of War ; and if any of the owners of real estate required
to be taken or that is damaged for the purpose of straightening or
widening that portion of the Calumet River for which the appropria-
tion herein is now made, cannot be induced to convey to the United
States such real estate so required, and release their claim 'or damages
caused by said improvement, or should the owner or ownersbe incapa-
ble of conveying and releasing, or should his or her name or residence
be unknown, or he or she be a non-resident of the State of Illinois, it Condemnation
shall then be the duty of the United States attorney for the northern proceedings.
district of Illinois to immediately file a petition in any court having
jurisdiction thereof, in the manner and as authorized by the laws of the
State of Illinois in such cases, for the purpose of ascertaining the just
compensation to be paid the respective owners of the land taken or
damaged: Provided, however, That the other owners of property and
parties interested in said improvement shall first execute a bond to the
United States, to be approved by the Secretary of War, for the payment
of the costs of such proceedings, and to pay any judgment that may be
rendered therein ; and on failure to do so the proceedings shall be dis-
missed.
   Improving Illinois River, Illinois : Continuing improvement, one hun. Illinois River.
dred and twelve thousand five hundred dollars; of which sum three
thousand seven hundred and fifty dollars may be expended in dredging
the river in front of Peoria.
   The Secretary of War is authorized and directed to appoint a Board Board of engi-
of three engineers from the United States Army whose duty it shall be neers to reporton
to examine, in all their relations to commerce, the Illinois and Michigan value,etc., ofth
Canal, and the proposed Hennepin Canal, to consider their value and
all other matters connected with their usefulness to navigation, and
shall report upon the acquisition and improvement of the Illinois and
Michigan Canal and the construction of the Hennepin Canal. The said
Board shall report to the Secretary of War,who shall lay its report before
Congress at its next session, together with the views of himself and the
Chief of Engineers of the United States Army thereon; and fifteen
thousand dollars, or so much thereof as may be necessary, is hereby
458         REPORT    OF THE CHIEF          OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.


Proviso.        appropriated for this purpose: Provided: That nothing in this para-
                 graph shall be construed as committing the Government to the said
                 improvement.
  Gasconade         Improving Gasconda River, Missouri : Continuing improvement, seven
River.           thousand five hundred dollars.
  Osage River.      Improving Osage River, Missouri : Continuing improvement by snag-
                 ging and removing obstructions, ten thousand dollars.
  Red River of      Improving Red River of the North, Minnesota: Continuing improve-
the North.'      ment from Breckenridge to the northern boundary-line of the United
                 States, including dredging, removal of snags and bowlders, and con-
                 struction of wing-dams, and so forth ; and the money heretofore appro-
                 priated for locks and dams is hereby made available for this purpose.
  Yellowston e Improving Yellowstone River between Glendive and the mouth, Mon-
River.           tana: Continuing the improvement, eighteen thousand seven hundred
                 and fifty dollars.
  M ok elumn e Improving Mokelumne River, California, by removing obstructions,
River.           two thousand five hundred dollars.
Sacramentoand      Improving Sacramento and Feather Rivers, California, forty thousand
Feather Rivers. dollars of the money heretofore appropriated for improving said rivers
                 that may remain unexpended at the enid of the present fiscal year, for
                 snagging and dredging operations and the cost of the proceedings here-
                 inafter authorized, also ten thousand dollars to complete dredges au-
                 thorized by act of July fifth, eighteen hundred and eighty-four; the bal-
                 ance of said unexpended money not to be used until the Secretary of War
  Secretary of be satisfied that hydraulic mining hurtful to navigation has ceased on
War to be satis- said rivers and their tributaries. If he be not so satisfied, he is hereby
edthatuinri     instructed to institute such legal proceedings as may be necessary to
has ceased.      prevent the washing, sluicing, dunmping,or discharging detritus, debris,
  Legal proceed- or slickens, caused by or arising from such hydraulic mining, into either
ings to prevent, of said rivers or any of its tributaries, or into the San Joaquin River or
                 any of its tributaries, or in or to such place or situation from which such
                 detritus, debris, or slickens may be liable to be washed or carried by
                 storms or floods into either of said rivers or tributaries ; and he is hereby
                 instructed to use out of said sum as much as may be necessary for said
                 purpose.
  San Joaquin       Improving San Joaquin River and Stockton and Mormon Sloughs,
River; Stockton California: Continuing improvement, eighteen thousand seven hun-
and Mormon dred and fifty dollars.
  Canal at Cas-     Improving canal at the Cascades, Oregon: Continuing improvement,
cades, Oreg.      one hundred and eighty-seven thousand five hundred dollars.
  C ol u m b i a Improving the Upper Columbia River, including Snake River, Ore-
River.            gon and Washington Territory: Continuing improvement ten thousand
                  dollars.
                    Improving the mouth of the Columbia River, Oregon, one hundred
                  and eighty-seven thousand five hundred dollars.
  W illa mette      Improving Lower Wilamette River, and Columbia River below Port-
and Columbia land, Oregon: Continuing improvement, seventy-five thousand dollars;
Rivers.           of which sum twenty-one thousand dollars for a snag-boat to be used
  Snag-boat.      on the Willamette and Columbia Rivers, and five thousand dollars to
                  be expended on the river in front of Portland.
  Willam m e t t e Improving the Upper Willamette River above Portland, Oregon:
River, abo v eContinnuing improvement, ten thousand dollars.
Portland.
                    Improving Coquille River, Oregon: Continuing improvement, twenty
  Coquille River. thousand dollars.
                   IImproving Chehalis River, Washington Territory: Continuing im-
  ChehalisRiver provement,
                             two thousand five hundred dollars.
  Cowlitz River.   Improving Cowlitz River, Washington Territory: Continuing im-
                 provement, two thousand dollars.
  Skagit, Stila- Improving Skagit, Steilaquamish, Nootsack, Snohomish, and Sno-
quamish, Noot- qualmie Rivers, Washington Territory: Continuing improvement, ten
sack, Snohomish, thousand dollars.
and Snoqualmie
Rivers.
  M i s sou r i. Improving Missouri River from its mouth to Sioux City: Continuing
River.           improvement, including necessary work at Omaha, Atchison, Saint Jo-
                 seph, Fort Leavenworth Reservation, Arrow Rock, Kansas City, Platts-
               mouth, Brownsville, and Nebraska City, three hundred and seventy-
               five thousand dollars; to be expended under the direction of the Secre-
               tary of War, in accordance with plans and estimates to be furnished by
               the Missouri River Commission.
                 LAWS     AFFECTING        CORPS     OF   ENGINEERS.                  459
   Improving Missouri River from Sioux City to Fort Benton: Continu- From Sioux
ing improvement, sixty thousand dollars, under the direction of the City to Fort Ben-
Secretary of War.
   For removing obstructions in the Missouri River, twenty-two thou- stRemoving ob-
sand five hundred dollars.
   Improving the Ohio River: Continuing improvement, three hundred Ohio River.
and seventy-five thousand dollars; out of which sum thirty-seven thou-
sand five hundred dollars are to be expended at Grand Chain in remov-
ing rocks and other obstructions to navigation at that locality; also
eighteen thousand seven hundred and fifty dollars may be expended in
constructing or aiding in the construction of such an embankmen t on the
south side of the Great Miami River, near its junction with the Ohio, as
may be necessary to confine the waters of the Great Miami in great floods
to the general course of its channel at or near the Ohio, to the end that
the formation of the bar in the Ohio River now forming and obstruct-
ing navigation may be arrested; also thirty-seven thousand five hun-
dred dollars, or so much thereof as may be necessary, of said appro-
priation shall be expended in constructing five ice-piers, pursuant to Ice-piers.
the present or prospective plans of the Chief of Engineers, at or near
the following places, to-wit: One at Pomeroy, Ohio; one at Middleport,
Ohio; one at Gallipolis, Ohio; and one at Ironton, Ohio; and one at Provisos.
or near Ashland, Kentucky, on the south side of the Ohio River: Pro-
vided, That the Secretary of War is hereby authorized and directed to
obtain, if he can do so without cost to the United States, perpetual
leases or conveyances of the riparian rights of the property-owners at R i p a r i a n
each of said localities, in the event said ice-piers, or any one of them, rights.
shall be located where there is no improved landing-place: And pro-
vided further, That at localities where there are improved landings he Reli quish.
shall first obtain a relinquishment of wharfage rights and dues in favor ment         wharf-
                                                                                    quf
of water-craft seeking protection from damage by ice; and no part of age rights.
this appropriation shall be used for such purpose until the foregoing
conditions are complied with. Also, out of said appropriation for the
Ohio River eighteen thousand seven hundred and fifty dollars for re-
moving obstruction at the mouth of Licking River; also eleven thou-
sand two hundred and fifty dollars for completing ice-harbor at Four-
Mile Bar, near Cincinnati; also twenty thousand dollars, or so much
thereof as may be necessary, for Davis Island Dam.                           Mississippi
   For continuing operations upon the reservoirs at the headwaters of reservoir.
the Mississippi Rive , thirty-seven thousand five hundred dollars:           Proviso
Provided, That in the opinion of the Chief of Engineers the expendi-
ture of this appropriation and the ultimate completion of this part of
the reservoir system will adequately improve navigation.
   For operating snag-boat on Upper Mississippi River, twenty-two sipper Missis-
thousand five hundred dollars.
   Improving Mississippi River from Saint Paul to Des Moines Rapids: Mississippi
Continuing improvement, three hundred and eighty-two thousand five Paul to Des
hundred dollars; of which sumn six thousand dollars or so much thereof Moines Rapids.
as may be necessary, shall be applied to the removal of the rock at
Duck Creek Chain, at the Rock Island Rapids; and of which sum the
further amount of fifteen thousand dollars, or so much thereof as may
be necessary, may be used by the Secretary of War, in his discretion,
for continuing the practical test of the flume invented by NI. J. Adams,     Test of flume.
the said test to be made under the supervision and direction of said
Adams; but if not so used the sum shall remain as a part of said ap-
propriation, and be used for the purposes first in this paragraph speci-
fied.
   Improving Mississippi River at Des Moines Rapids Canal, under the Mississippi
modified project, twenty-six thousand two hundred and fifty dollars; Rivere atRapiDes
of which sum fifteen thousand dollars are to be used for pier construe- Canal.
tion, in extending the outer wall of canal to the pivot-pier of the bridge.
   For dry-dock at Des Moines Rapids, forty-eight thousand seven hun- Dry dock.
dred and fifty dollars.
   Improving ice-harbor at Dubuque, Iowa, the unexpended balance, or Ice-harbor, Du-
so much thereof as shall be necessary, shall be applied to paving in- buque.
stead of riprapping said ice-harbor.
    Improving Mississippi River from Des Moines Rapids to the mouth of From Des
the Illinois River, including the river at Quincy Bay and the removal Molnois Raive
of the bars at the mouth of Whipple Creek and Hamburg Bay, includ-
ing also the strengthening of Sny Island Levee whereit crosses Snicarte
Slough and other sloughs: Continuing the improvement, one hundred
and fifty thousand dollars.
460      REPORT       OF THE      CHIEF     OF ENGINEERS,          U. S. ARMY.

  From Illinois      Improving Mississippi River from the mouth of the Illinois River to
River to uhio the mouth of the Ohio River, including the completion of the work at
River.            Alton, and, at the discretion of the Secretary of War, the protection of
                  the Illinois shore opposite the month of the Missouri River: Continuing
                 improvement, three hundred and seventy-five thousand dollars; of which
                  thirty-seven thousand five hundred dollars, or so much thereof as may
                  be necessary, to be expended in extending the work for the protection
                  of the eastwardly bank of the Mississippi River at Cairo, and the pre-
                  vention of its wash or erosion, commencing at the southerly end of the
                  present Government revetient work and continuing down stream, and
                  twenty-two thousand five hundred dollars for continuing improvement
                  at Cape Girardeau, Missouri, and Montana Point, Illinois: Provided,
                  That the Secretary of War, in his discretion may use not to exceed
                  seventy-five thousand dollars of said sum of three hundred and seventy-
                  five thousand dollars to correct the current of the river and improve the
                  channel at Saint Louis.
  From Head of Improving Mississippi River from Head of the Passes to the mouth
the Passes to of the Ohio River: Continuing improvemen t, two million dollars; which
Ohio River.       sum shall be expended under the direction of the Secretary of War, in
                  accordance with the plans, specifications, and recommendations of the
  Provisos.       Mississippi River Commission: Provided, That no portion of this appro-
                  priation shall be expended to repair or build levees for the purpose of
                  reclaiming lands or preventing injury to lands or private property by
                  overflows: Provided, however, That the Commission is authorized to
  Levees.         repair and build levees if, in their judgment, it should be  (lone  as part
                  of their plan to afford ease and safety to the navigation and commerce
                  of the river and to deepen the channel. And provided further, That
                  no works of bank protection or revetment shall be executed in said
               .reaches or elsewhere until after it shall be found that the completion
                  of the permeable contracting works and uniform width of the high-
                  water channel will not secure the desired stability of the river banks:
                  Provided, however, That nothing herein contained shall prevent the con-
                  struction of revetment works where the banks are caving at Greenville
                  Reach, Delta Point, in front of the cities of Vicksburg, Memphis, Hick-
                  man, and Columbu: And provided further, That contraction works shall
                  be built at the same time in the wide portions of the river immediately
                  above the said revetment works. Of the amount herein appropriated
                  for the Lower Mississippi, seventy-five thousand dollars are to be ex-
                  pended in continuing the work in progress at New Orleans; one hun-
                  dred and eighty-seven thousand five hundred dollars for the rectifica-
                  tion of the Red and Atchafalaya Rivers by preventing further enlarge-
                  ment of the latter stream and restricting its outlet capacity, and for
                  keeping open a navigable channel through the mouth of Red or Old
                  River into the Misissippi ; thirty-seven thousand five hundred dollars
                  in improving navigation in the Greenville Reach, by preventing the
                 bank at Greenville from further caving; seventy-five thousand dollars
                 in deepening the channel at Vicksburg by dredging through the bar
                 existing there; but this last-named sum shall not be expended unless
                 after another examination or survey the Commission shall deem it ad-
                 visable; and if they shall not, then thirty-seven thousand five hun-
                 dred dollars shall be expended in the improvement of navigation at
                 Vicksburg by constructing suitable dikes and other appropriate works,
                  and fifty-six thousand two hundred and fifty dollars in completing the
                  work on the river at Memphis; also eighteen thousand seven hundred
                  and fifty dollars for work on the river at Hickman, and eighteen thou-
                 sand seven hundred and fifty dollars for work on the river at Colum-
                 bus, Kentucky.
  South Pass.        For examinations and surveys at South Pass, of the Mississippi River,
  Examinations pursuant to the act of March third, eighteen hundred and seventy-five,
and surveys.,    ten thousand dollars.
  Survey from For survey of the Mississippi River from the Head of the Passes to its
Heade tof theheadwarters: Continuing survey thirty thousand dollars.
waters.
  Gauging.           For gauging the waters of the Lower Mississippi River and its trib-
                  utaries, as provided for in joint resolution of the twenty-first of Febru-
                  ary, eighteen hundred and seventy-one, five thousand dollars.
  Removal of For continuing the removal of snags, wrecks, and other obstructions
snags, etc.     in the Mississippi River, fifty-six thousand two hundred and fifty dol-
  Columbia Riv- lars.
er, gauging.       For gauging the waters in the Columbia River, one thousand dollars.
                 LAWS     AFFECTING       CORPS OF       ENGINEERS.                   461
   SEC. 2. That in places where harbor-lines have not been established,     Harborlinesto
and where deposits of debris of mines or stamp works can be made with- be established.
out injury to navigation, within lines to be established by the Secretary
of War, said officer may, and is hereby authorized to, cause such lines
to be established; and within such lines such deposits may be made,
under regulations to be from time to time prescribed by him.
   SEC. 3. It shall not be lawful to cast, throw, empty, or unlade, or New York har-
cause, suffer, or procure to be cast, thrown, emptied, or unladen, either boProhibitingrde
from or out of any ship, vessel, lighter, barge, boat, or other craft, or posits in.
from the shore, pier, wharf, or mills of any kind whatever, any ballast,
stpne, slate, gravel, earth, slack, rubbish, wreck, filth, slabs, edgings,
sawdust, slag, or cinders, or other refuse or mill-waste of any kind, into
New York Harbor: Provided, That nothing herein contained shall ex- Proviso.
tend, or be construed to extend, to the casting out, unlading, or throw- Not to prevent
ing out of any ship or vessel, lighter, barge, boat, or other craft, any improvements.
stones, rocks, bricks, lime, or other materials used, or to be used, in or
toward the building, repairing, or keeping in repair, any quay, pier,
wharf, weir, bridge, building, or other work lawfully erected or to be
erected on the banks or sides of said harbor, or to the casting out, un-
loading or depositing of any material excavated for the improvement
of navigable waters, into such places and in such manner as may be
deemed by the United States officer supervising the improvement of
said harbor most judicious and practicable and for the best interests of
such improvement.
    SEc. 4. The Secretary of War shall prescribe such rules and regula- Regulations,
tions as may be necessary to secure a judicious and economical expendi- etc., to be pre-
ture of the money herein appropriated, and shall cause to be made and tarbeof War to
  submitted to Congress annual reports, together with maps and plans, secure economi-
including the report of the Mississippi River Commission, on or before cal expenditure
December first, giving detailed statements of the work done, contracts of appropriation,
made, the expenditures thereunder or otherwise, and balances of money
on hand up to November first, and the effect of such work, together with
such recommendations as he may deem proper. He shall, at the same
time, report to Congress all cases in which piers, breakwaters, locks, and
dams. or other structures or works built or made by the United States
in aid of commerce or navigation are used, occupied, or injured by a
corporation or an individual, a'nd the extent and mode of such use,
occupation, or injury. He shall report, at the same time, whether any
bridges, causeways, or structures now erected or in process of erection
do or will interfere with free and safe navigation.
    SEC. 5. It shall be the duty of the Secretary of War to apply the Work to be
money herein appropriated for improvements other than surveys and done by contract
estimates, in carrying on the various works, by contract or otherwise,
as may be most economical and advantageous to the Government.
Where said works are done by contract, such contract shall be made
after sufficient public advertisement for proposals, in such manner and
form as the Secretary of War shall prescribe; and such contracts shall Contracts.
be made with the lowest responsible bidders, accompanied by such se-
curities as the Secretary of War shall require, conditioned for the faith-
ful prosecution and completion of the work according to such contract.
and for the prompt payment of all liabilities incurred in the prosecution
thereof for labor and material.
    SEc. 6. The Secretary of War is hereby directed, at his discretion, to Examinations,
cause examinations or surveys, or both, to be made, and the cost of im- and surveys.
provements to be estimated, at the following localities, to wit:
    In the States of-
                                 ARKANSAS.                                  Arkansas.

  Re-examination of Little River.
  The lakes connecting with Red River, between Shreveport, Louisian a,
and Fulton, Arkansas.
  Re-examination of Ouachita above Camden, Arkansas.
  Saline River.
  Cache River.
                             CALIFORNIA.                                     California.
  San Pedro Bay near the entrance to Wilmington Harbor, with a view
to establishing an outer harbor for the protection of deep-draught ves-
sels.
  Mouth of Smith's River.
  Crescent City Harbor, with a view to a sea-wall from Battery Point
to Flat Rock.
462          REPORT    OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

Connecticut.                                CONNECTICUT.

                  Five-Mile River Harbor.                                          .
                  Resurvey of Duck Island Harbor, on Long Island Sound, including
                plans, specifications, and estimate of cost for making the same a har-
                bor of refuge.
Dakota.                                  DAKOTA TERRITORY.
                   James River.
Delaware.                                    DELAWARE.
                   Duck Creek.
Florida.                                    FLORIDA.
                  Punta Rassa Harbor.
                  Resurvey of Tampa Bay, including Hillsborough River up to the city
                of Tampa.
                  Resurvey of outer and inner bars at Pensacola.
                  Charlotte Harbor, including San Carlos Bay.
                  Clear Water Harbor, including Anclote and Saint Joseph's Bays and
                the Narrows into Boga Ciega Bay.
                  Wakulla River from its mouth to Wakulla Springs.
                  Survey of the channel from Haul-over, on Indian River, to Gilbert's
                gar.
                   Saint Augustine, for a deep sea-channel on the outer bar.

Georgia.                                      GEORGIA.

                  Savannah River from cross-tides above Savannah to the bar, with a
                view to obtaining twenty eight feet of water in the channel.
                  Flint River from Montezuma to Old Agency.
                  From Doboy Island to Doboy Bar.
                  Jekyl Creek.
Illinois.                                     ILLINOIS.

                  Farm Creek, with a view to changing its course.
                   Kaskaskia River from New Athens to mouth.
                   Bars in Hamburg Bay.
                   Calumet River from the forks of the river near its entrance to Lake
                Calumet to Riverdale; also Calumet River from Riverdale to Blue
                Island.
                  Mississippi River at Rush Island Bend and Ivy Landing, with a view
                to confining and deepening the channel.
Indiana                                       INDIANA.

                  For a survey of the Ohio River, near the city of Evansville, Indiana,
                with a view to determine what, if anything, will be necessary to pre-
                vent a change of the channel of the river in front of that city.
Kentucky.                                    KENTUCKY.
                   Pond River.
                  The Secretary of War is directed to report to the next session of Con-
                gress whether or not the Government dry-dock at the Louisville and
                Portland Canal is adequate for the purposes of commerce, and what
                alterations, if any, are necessary, and the cost of making the same.
                   Licking River from Farmer's to West Liberty.
                   Salt River.
                   For ice harbor at Paducah, Kentucky.
                  The bar at the mouth of Limestone Creek, in the harbor of Mays-
                ville.
Louisiana.                                   LOUISIANA.
                  Little River.
                  Bayou Rouge.
                  Dugdemona River.
                  Month of Bayou Plaquemine, with a view to its connection with the
                Mississippi River by locks; also Bayou Plaquemine and other connect-
                ing streams, to form the best route to Grand Lake.
                  Bague Falia from present landing to Covington.
               LAWS     AFFECTING CORPS OF ENGINEERS.                             463
  Calcasieu Pass, the two bars obstructing the navigation thereof.
  Mouth of Calcasieu River, the bar obstructing its mouth.
  Iayou Terrebonne from Houma to Thibodeaux.
  Bayou Teche from Saint Martinsville to Fort Barre.
   Mouth of Bayou La Fourche, with a view to the construction of a
lock and damrn; Clear Lake, Black Bayou, Red Bayou, Black Lake, and
Kelley' Bayou, to reopen navigable communication between those
streams and Red River; Bayou La Fourche, to secure navigation at low
water.
  Cornay River.
   Ouchita River from Camden to mouth, with a slackwater navigation.
   Bayou Vermillion, to secure navigation from Abbeville to the rail-
road bridge of the Louisiana and Texas Railroad.
   Bayou Rondeway.
   Cypress Bayou.
   Bayou Vidal.
                                MAINE.                                   Mai e.

  Bayoduce River between the towns of Penobscot and Brooksville.
  Big Rapids of Saint John's River.
   Camden Harbor.
  Rockport Harbor.
   Kennebec River at Bath, and from Augusta to lower end of Perkin's
Island.
   Saint George's River from Warren to to Thomaston.
   Matinicus Isle, with a view to a harbor of refuge.
   Penobscot River from Bangor to Bucksport Narrows.
   Saint Croix River from Ferry Point Bridge, at Calais, to Breakwater
Ledge.
   Bar Harbor, Maine, with the view to establishing a breakwater and
deepening the waters of said harbor, and especially the channel be-
tween Rodick's Island and Mount Desert Island.
                             MARYLAND.                                   Maryland.
  Cambridge Harbor.
  Fairlee Creek.
  Patuxent River from Benedict to Hills Landing.
  For widening the channel of Baltimore Harbor to six hundred feet.

                           MASSACHUSETTS.                                Massachusetts.
  Manchester Harbor.
  Duxbury Harbor.
  Wellflett Harbor.
  Falmouth Harbor of Refuge.
  Vineyard Haven Harbor.
  Cottage City Harbor.
  Menemsha Harbor of Refuge.
  Taunton River.
  Winthrop Harbor.
  New Bedford Harbor.
                              MICHIGAN.                                  Michigan.

  Bar in Saint Clair River opposite Saint Clair City.
  Grand River.
  North River between Essex and North Bridges.
  Biddle's Point at Mackinac Harbor, with a view to a breakwater.
  Harbor at Forestville, Lake Hurn.
  Pigeon River.
  Mouth of Black River, Saint Clair County.
  Carp River at Leland, with a view to affording an entrance to Carp
Lake for harbor of refuge.
  Lake Michigan at Empire, with a view to cutting the channel across
the bar from Lake Michigan to Bar Lake.
  Grand Traverse Bay, with a view to connecting it with Torch Lake,
near Eastport.
  Pinepog River.
  Rouge River at its junction with Detroit River, and up the river to
bridge of Saint Louis and Wabash Railroad.
  Torch Lake Channel, Lake Superior.
464        REPORT OF THE' CHIEF              OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

Minnesota.                                     MINNESOTA.

                     Red River of the North from Moorehead to Fergus Falls.         *
                     Red Lake River from Grand Forks to Red Lake.
                     Mississippi River between Saint Paul and Saint Anthony's Falls.
                     Minnesota River with a view to its improvement by locks and dams.
Mississippi.                                   MISSISSIPPI.


                     Tombigbee River, to ascertain what improvement is necessary to
                   make said river continuously navigable from Vienna, Alabama, to
                   Walker's Bridge, Mississippi.
                     Cassity Bayou.
                     Noxubee River, to ascertain whether it can be made continuously
                   navigable by a system of locks and dams, or otherwise.
                     Bear Creek.
Missouri.                                       MISSOURI.
                     Resurvey of the Osage River from its mouth to Osceola, with a view
                   to movable locks and dams, or other methods of improvement.
                     Little River from Hornersville to its junction with the Saint Francis
                   River.
                     Saint Francis River from Greenville to the Arkansas State line.
New Hampshire.                              NEW HAMPSHIRE.

                     Bellamy River.
North Carolina.                            NORTH CAROLINA.

                     Alligator River.
                     Lockwood's Folly River.
                     Lumber River.
                     Yadkin River from South Carolina line to the Narrows.
                     Catawba River.
New Jersey.                                   NEW    JERSEY.

                      Thoroughfare running back of the ocean from Cape May to the
                   Great Bay north of Atlantic City.
                      Channel back of Brigantine Beach, between Absecon and Brigan-
                   tine Inlets.
New York.                                      NEW YORK.

                     Channel between Jamaica Bay and Rockaway Inlet.
                     The East River with a view to the removal of a ledge of rocks situ-
                   ated between five and six hundred feet from the foot of Tenth and
                   Eleventh streets in the city of New York.
                     Spring Creek.
                     Waddington Harbor.
                     Mouth of Patchouge River.
                     Hudson River between New Baltimore and Coxsackie.
                     Peter's Neck Bay.
                     Tonawanda Harbor and Niagara River between Black Rock and Ton-
                   awanda, with a view to a sixteen-foot channel.
                     Glen Cove Harbor.
Oregon.                                          OREGON.
                     Wood River.
                     Link River.
                     Suislaw River and Bar.
                     Coquille River between Coquille City and Myrtle Point.
                     Nehalem Bay and Bar.
                     Tillamook Bay and Bar.
                     Umpqua River.
Ohio.                                               OHIO.

                     Sandusky Harbor, with a view to a straight channel from the north
                   end of Cedar Point to the east end of the existing channel in front of
                   the city.
                     Big Hockhocking River from its mouth to Coolville.
                     Chagrin River at its month.
                  LAWS     AFFECTING         CORPS     OF ENGINEERS.                       465
                              PENNSYLVANIA.                                     Pennsylvania.
  Darby Creek.
                              RHODE ISLAND.                                     Rhode Island.

  Little Narragansett Bay, entrance to the wharves at Watch Hill.

                             SOUTH CAROLINA.                                   SouthCarolina.

  Mosquito Creek between the South Edisto and Ashepoo Rivers, with
a view to connect the South Edisto with the Ashepoo at or near Fen-
wick's Island.
  Mingo Creek.
  Clark's Creek.
  Little Pee Dee River.
  Alligator River and other waters connecting Santee River and Bull's
Bay.
                                TENNESSEE.                                     Tennessee.

  North Fork of the Forked Deer River below Dyersburg.
  Obeils River from the point where improvements have heretofore
been made to the month of the West Fork.

                                   TEXAS.                                      Texas.


  C   ar Bayou, where it empties into Galveston Bay.

                              VIRGINIA.                                        Virginia.
  Mattox Creek.
  Nansemond River.
  Louisa Fork of Sandy River.
  Roanoke River from Clarkesville, Virginia, to Eaton Falls, North
Carolina.
  Hunters Creek.
                              WEST   VIRGINIA.                                 West Virginia.
  Meadow River.
  Gauley River.
  Coal River.
                                WISCONSIN.                                     Wisconsin.

   Harbor at Hudson, Lake Saint Croix.
   Examination and report on the cause of the extraordinary overflows Examinations,
of the Chippewa River, and what means, if any,     can be adopted to pre- survey, etc., not
                                               ventspecially                            pro-
vent their recurrence,                                                   .vped        y pfor.
   SEC. 7. For examinations, surveys, and contingencies, and for inci-
dental repairs, for which there is no special appropriation, for rivers
and harbors, one hundred thousand dollars: Provided, That no survey Proviso.
shall be made of any harbors or rivers until the Chief of Engineers
shall have directed a preliminary examination of the same by the local Preliminary
engineer in charge of the district, or an engineer detailed for the pur- examinations to
pose ; and such local or detailed engineer shall report to said Chief ofbe made before
Engineers, whether, in his opinion, said harbor or river is worthy of im- surveys.
provement, and shall state in such report fully and particularly the
facts and reasons on which he bases such opinion, including the present
and prospective demands of commerce; and it shall be the duty of the
Chief of Engineers to direct the making of such survey if, in his opinion,
the harbor or river proposed to be surveyed be worthy of improvement
by the General Government; and he shall report to the Secretary of
War the facts, and what public necessity or convenience may be sub-
served thereby, together with the full reports of the local engineer.
Said reports of preliminary examinations and surveys shall be made to Reports to be
the House of Representatives, and are hereby ordered to be printed made         to House of
                  when made.                                               Representative s
when so made.                                                              and printed.
   SEC. 8. That the Secretary of War shall report to Congress, at its Names of civil.
next and each succeeding session thereof, the name and place of resi ian engineers to
dence of each civilian engineer employed in the work of improving be reported to
rivers and harbors by means and as the result of appropriations made Congress, etc.
in this and succeeding river and harbor appropriation bills, the time so
employed, the compensation paid, and the place at and work on which
employed.
  Approved, August 5, 1886.
        30 E
466       REPORT       OF    THE    CHIEF      OF   ENGINEERS,         U. S. ARMY.

August 5, 1886. CHAP. 930.-An act to provide for protecting the interests of the United States in
                                the Potomac Flats, in the District of Columbia.

                        Be it enacted by the Senate and House of Representatires of the United
   Potomac Fiver States of America in Congress assembled, That it shall be the duty of the
Flats, D. C.         Attorney-General of the United States to institute, as soon as may be,
   S nit t o b e in the supreme court of the District of Columbia, a suit against all per-
brought to estab- sons and corporations who may have or pretend to have any right, title,
lish title etc., int                                                                          le
land affected by claim, or interest in any part of the land or water in the District of
the improve-Columbia within the limits of the city of Washington, or exterior to
ment.                said limits and in front thereof toward the channel of the Potomac
                     River, and composing any part of the land or water affected by the im-
                     provements of the Potomac River or its flats in charge of the Secretary
                     of War, for the purpose of establishing and making clear the right of
                     the United States thereto.
   Who to be par- SEC. 2. That the suit mentioned in the preceding section shall be in
ties defendant; the nature of a bill in equity, and there shall be made parties defendant
service of pro- thereto all persons and corporations known to set up or assert any claim
                     or right to or in the land or water in said first section mentioned, and
                     against all other persons and corporations who may claim to have any
                     such right, title, or interest.   On the filing of said bill process shall
                     issue and be served, according to the or dinuary course of said court, upon
                     all persons and corporations within the jurisdiction of said court; and
                    public notice shall be given, by advertisement in two newspapers pub-
                    lished in the city of Washington, for three weeks successively, of the
                    pendency of said suit, and citing all persons and corporations interested
                     in the subject-matter of said suit, or in the land or water in this act
                     mentioned, to appear, at a day named in such notice, in said court, to
                      answer the said bill and set forth and maintain any right, title, interest,
                     or claim that any person or corporation may have in the premises; and
                     the court may order such further notice as it shall think fit to any party
                     in interest.
  Effect of decree.     SEC. 3. That the said cause shall then proceed with all practicable
                     expedition to a final determination by said court of all rights drawn in
                     question therein; and the said court shall have full power and jurisdic-
                     tion by its decree to determine every question of right, title, interest,
                     or claim arising in the premises, and to vacate, annul, set aside, or con-
                     firm any claim of any character arising or set forth in the premises;
                     and its decree shall be final and conclusive upon all persons and corpo-
                     rations parties to the suit, or who shall fail, after public notice as here-
                     inbefore in this act provided, to appear in said court and litigate his,
                     her, or its claim, and they shall be deemed forever debarred from setting
                     up or maintaining any right, title, interest, or claim in the premises.
   Interest s ad-        SEC. 4. That if, on the final hearing of said cause, the said supreme
verse to the Uni- court of the District of Columbia shall be of opinion that there exists
ted States to be
valued and re- any right, title, or interest in the land or water in this act mentioned
ported to Con- in any person or corporation adverse to the complete and paramount
gress.               right of the United States, the said court shall forthwith and in a sum-
                      mary way proceed to ascertain the value of any such right, title, inter-
                      est, or claim, exclusive of the value of any improvement to the property
                      covered by such right, title, or interest made by or under the authority
                      of the United States, and report thereof shall be made to Congress.
   Appeal to Su-         SEC. 5. That from the final decree of the supreme court of the Dis-
premee ounitof trict of Columbia, and every part thereof, in the premises, an appeal
States.              shall be allowed to ,the United States, and to any other party in the
                      cause complaining of such decree, to the Supreme Court of the United
                      States, which last-mentioned court shall have full power and jurisdic-
                      tion to hear, try, and determine the said matter, and every part thereof,
    Cause to be ad- and to make final decree in the premises; and the said cause shall, on
vanced.              motion of the Attorney-General of the United States, be advanced to
   Proviso.           the earliest practicable hearing: Provided, That no payment under any
    Payments.         such judgment shall be made unless hereafter authorized by Congress.
   No money to be SEC. 6. That until the final decision of the matters hereinbefore in this
spentonproperty act mentioned shall have been had, no moneys appropriated for the im-
in dispute until provement of the Potomac River within the District of Columbia, the
                      establishment of harbor-lines in the District of Columbia, and
                                                                                        the rais-
                      ing of the flats therein shall be expended otherwise than upon property
                 in respect of which there is no claim aldverse to the title of the United
                 States or for the improvement of navigation in the said river.
                   Approved, August 5, 1S886.
                       LAWS      AFFECTING          CORPS      OF ENGINEERS.                      467
                                            RESOLUTIONS.

[No. 7.] Joint resolution authorizing the Superintendent of Public Buildings and        March 29,1886.
  Grounds in the District of Columbia to supply plants and shrubs to fill certain
  vases in the Pension building.

   Resolved by the Senate and House of Representatives of the United States. Pension build.
of America in Congress assembled, That the Superintendent of Public inases in inte-
Buildings and Grounds in the District of Columbia be, and is hereby, rior court to be
authorized and. directed to supply, and to keep supplied, from the pub- filled with plants
lic green-houses and nurseries, the vases around the interior court of and shrubs.
the Pension Building with plants and shrubs suitable thereto.
  Approved, March 29, 1886.




[No. 18.]    Joint resolution to provide temporarily for the expenditures of the Gov-   July 1, 1886.
                                         ernment.


   Resolved by the Senate and House of Representatives of the United States
of America in Congress assembled, That all appropriations for the neces- Temporary pro-
sary operations of the Government under existing laws which shall vision for expen-
remain unprovided for on the thirtieth day of June, eighteen hundred ses of the Gov-
and eighty-six be, and they are hereby continued and made available teen days.
for a period of fifteen days from and after that date, unless the regular
appropriations therefor provided for in bills now pending in Congress, Post, p. 345.
shall have been previously made for the service of the fiscal year end-
ing June thirtieth, eighteen hundred and eighty-seven ; and in case the
appropriations, or any of them, hereby continued, are or is, insufficient
to carry on the said necessary operations, a sufficient amount is hereby
appropriated, out of any money in the Treasury not otherwise appro-
priated, to carry on the same: Provided, That no greater amount shall
be expended therefor than will be in the same proportion to the appro-
priations of the fiscal year eighteen hundred and eighty-six, as fifteen days
time bears to the whole of said fiscal year: Providedfurther, That author-
ity is also granted for continuing during the same period the necessary
work required for public printing ancrbinding, and for all other miscel-
laneous objects embodied in the sundry civil and naval appropriation
acts, in advance of appropriations to be hereafter made for said objects :
And providedfurther, All sums expended under this act shall be charged
to and be deducted from the appropriations for like service for the
fiscal year ending June thirtieth, eighteen hundred and eighty-seven.
   Approved, July 1, 1886.




[No. 24.] Joint resolution to continue the provisions of a joint resolution approved
  July first, eighteen hundred and eighty-six, entitled a "Joint Resolution to pro-     Jly   15,1886.
  vide temporarily for the expenditures of the Government."

  Resolved by the Senate and House of Representatives of the United States
of America in Congress assembled, That the provisions of a joint res-viemporary pro.
olution     entitled    a " Joint Resolution to provide          temporarily for the ses of the Gov-
expenditures of the Government," approved July first, eighteen hundred ernment extend-
and eighty-six, be, and the same are hereby, extended and continued in ed to July 3431,
full force and effect to and including the thirty-first day of July, eighteen 86. ante, p. 3.
hundred and eighty-six.
  Approved, July 15, 1886.




          [No. 13.]   Joint resolution for the relief of William L. Dunlop, trustee.    May 26, 1886.

  Resolved by the Senate and House of Representatives of the United States              William          L.
of Atnerica in Congress assembled, That the United States, in favor of Dunlop, trustee.
the said William L. Dunlop, of the District of Columbia, as trustee
of the estate of George Lowry, late of said District, deceased, his heirs
468      REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

  Releaseofright and assigns, hereby surrender, abandon, and forever release all right
of United States or   claim they may have, by reason of any escheat, to any part of lot
                  n u m be r e d
7, Wlot       reashi             thirteen, in square numbered seventy-five, in the city of
City, to.       - Washington, in the District of Columbia, as the same is known and
                  distinuished on the plan or plat of said city and included in the fol-
  Description. lowing lines and bounds, to wit : Beginning for the same at a point on
                  the line of the southwest side of Pennsylvania avenue seventy-nine
                  feet three inches from the stone planted at the northwest corner of the
                  square, and running thence along the line of Pennsylvania avenue
                  toward said corner-stone, twenty feet; thence at right angles to the
                  avenue back to an alley nine feet wide, heretofore laid off in a lease to
                  Thomas Y. Sprogell; thence with the line of said alley due east till it
                  intersects with said Sprogell's line; thence with said Sprogell's line to
                  the place of beginning, with the free use and privilege of the said alley
                  of nine feet in width, and with the brick dwelling-house and building
                  thereon.
                     Approved, May 26, 1886.
        I    _



            APPENDIXES

                 TO THE




REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,
        UNITED   STATES   ARMY.




                                  469
                       APPENDIXES
                                      TO THE



       REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,
                            UNITED STATES ARMY.




                                    CATIONS, ETC.



                             APPENDIX No. i.



POST OF WILLETS POINT AND ENGINEER SCHOOL OF APPLICATION.




ANNUAL REPORT OF LIE UTENANT-COLONEL C. B. COMSTOCK, CORPS OF
ENGINEERS, B VT. BRIG. GEN. U. S. A., OFFICER IN COMMAND, FOR THE
FISCAL YEAR ENDING JUNE 30, 1886.

                           WILLETS POINT, NEW YORK HARBOR,
                                                        July 16, 1886.
  GENERAL: I have the honor to submit the annual report for the
Post at Willets Point and the Engineer School of Application.
  I relieved Lieut. Col. H. L. Abbot of these duties on March 15, 1886.
  On June 30, 1886, the garrison, present and absent, at Willets Point,
consisted of the following officers and men, viz.:

                                 Post Commander.

Lieut. Col. C. B. Comstock, Corps of Engineers.

                                    General staff.

Maj. J. C. G. Happersett, surgeon, U. S. A.
Captain Charles Richard, assistant surgeon, U. S. A., and 4 enlisted men.

                                Field staff and band.

Maj. W. R. King, Corps of Engineers, commanding Battalion of Engineers.
First Lieut. S. W. Roessler, Corps of Engineers, adjutant.
First Lieut. James L. Lusk, Corps of Engineers, quartermaster, and 11 enlisted men.
                                                                           471
472      REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

                         Company A, Battalion of Engineers.

  Capt. J. G. D. Knight, Corps of Engineers, commanding company.
  First Lieut. H. E. Waterman, Corps of Engineers.
  Second Lieut. D. DuB. Gaillard, Corps of Engineers.
  Second Lieut. W. E. Craighill, Corps of Engineers, and 112 enlisted men.

                         Company B, Battalion of Engineers.

  Second Lieut. H. M. Chittenden, Corps of Engineers, commanding company.
  Second Lieut. Harry Taylor, Corps of Engineers.
  Second Lieut. Joseph E. Kuhn, Corps of Engineers, and 112 enlisted men.

                         Company C, Battalion of Engineers.

  First Lieut. W. C. Langfitt, Corps of Engineers, commanding company.
  Second Lieut. Irving Hale, Corps of Engineers.
  Second Lieut. C. E. Gillette, Corps of Engineers.
  Second Lieut. W. L. Sibert. Corps of Engineers, and 112 enlisted men.

                                     Unassigned.

  First Lieut. C. McD. Townsend, Corps of Engineers.

                                     A ttached.

  First Lieut. Allyn Capron, First Artillery.
  Second Lieut. C. G. Treat, Fifth Artillery.
  Second Lient. Isaac N. Lewis, Second Artillery.
  Total, 21 officers and 351 enlisted men.
   Aside from the ordinary duties at military posts, the officers and men
of the Engineer Battalion are required to be familiar with the details of
pontoniering, sapping and mining, siege works, and, what is still more
difficult, with the complicated details of electrical torpedo defense, the
latter requiring a large amount of theoretical and practical instruction.
Since at the outbreak of a foreign war the Engineer Battalion would be
the only body of soldiers having any knowledge of our fixed torpedo
defense, the importance of keeping the Battalion up to at least its pres-
ent strength and in the highest state of efficiency is evident. During
the year it has received practical and theoretical instruction in the sub-
jects mentioned.
   The water supply of the post is inadequate, being obtained from wells
and from cisterns. This makes any general system of sewerage im-
practicable, and the need of both sewers and an ample water supply
should at once be met. In case of fire, with the present water supply,
there would be much danger of a great conflagration. The town of
Flushing has constructed water-works and its water authorities have
made propositions in reference to laying pipes to the Willets Point
reservation, which shall supply 00 persons, for $5,000 for the first year
and an annual rental of $3,000 thereafter. The Board on the water
supply and sewerage of Willets Point constituted by Special Orders
No. 187, Adjutant-General's Office, August 17, 1885, objected to the
Flushing water supply on the score of its being derived from surface
drainage. Flushing now obtains its water from wells sunk in the sand
and the water is of good quality. This Board, composed of officers of
rank in the Quartermaster's, Medical, and Engineer departments, stated
in their report (of which a copy is inclosed, Appendix E) that the
present water supply " is entirely inadequate to the comfort of the gar-
rison fobr ordinary sanitary purposes and for protection against fire."
The Board recommended an artesian well. That has been tried and
         APPENDIX 1----REPORT      OF LIEUT.-COL. COMSTOCK.           473
has failed, and the Flushing supply seems now the only resource. The
estimate of the Board for water supply was $30,000. But, as the reser-
voir and pumping-engine their plan contemplated would be unnecessary
if water were obtained from Flushing, this estimate may be reduced to
 $17,000, as the amount needed for next year. The same Board states
that there is no system of sewerage on the post, and estimate the cost of
such a system, including the necessary plumbing, at $12,000.
    During the past winter the lack of quarters has been partially re.
lieved by several officers occupying but a single room, instead of the
two to which they are entitled. The number of officers the coming
winter will probably be two to four more than last winter, and the two
sets of quarters in the old mess-hall are so bad that they should be
abandoned. There is needed a new double house, with quarters for four
lieutenants, costing $12,000.
    Detailed estimates are not submitted, since the current Army appro-
priation bill requires them to be made by the Quartermaster's Depart-
ment.
    The Board of Visitors bhas recommended that permanent barracks be
gradually constructed for the companies here, and Lieutenant-Colonel
Abbot prepared a plan and estimate for a one-company barrack, which
are returned herewith. (See Appendix F.)
    The following modifications in the plan are proposed:
    1. That the barrack be heated by steam or furnaces instead of by
stoves.
    2. That a basement be put under a part or all of the building, so that
when the present mess-hall and kitchens become unserviceable the base-
ment can be used for that purpose.
    3. That balconies be put on the rear wing.
    4. That latrines and cisterns be provided.
    Without change in cost or in general dimensions, it may be advisable
to change the relative dimensions of the wings when the precise site
for the barrack is fixed.
    The cost of the barrack for 150 men, with these changes, is estimated
at $35,000.
    There is a large amount of stone belonging to the fort on hand and
a large amount of ponton material, which js deteriorating. So far as
is practicable, this material should be used in constructing new build-
ings, thus reducing their cost.
    The Engineer School of App;ication is at present organized under a
project approved by the Secretary of War, given as Appendix A.
    The object of the school is primarily to form a body of officers and
enlisted men who shall be theoretically and practically familiar with
the fixed electrical torpedo defense of our harbors, and who, at the out-
break of war, with numbers too small to do the work themselves, would
yet have the knowledge needed to supervise others in promptly putting
down torpedo defenses.
    Its secondary object is to give practical instruction in military engi-
neering, electricity, astronomy, surveying, and photography, and theo-
retical instruction in civil engineering. An idea of the scope of the in-
struction can be formed from the orders arranging details of work, and
given as Appendices B, C, and D of this report.
   The following-named artillery officers, First Lieut. Allyn Capron, First
Artillery; Second Lieut. Charles G. Treat, Fifth Artillery; Second Lieut.
Isaac N. Lewis, Second Artillery, were detailed for a seven-months
course in torpedo instruction at Willets Point, and were relieved on July
474          REPORT           OF THE           CHIEF         OF ENGINEERS,                  U. S. ARMY.

1, 1886. They showed much interest in the work, and would be avail-
able for planting torpedoes should an emergency arise.
   The following is a recapitulation of the funds required for the post
at Willets Point and for the Engineer School of Application for the
fiscal year 1886-'87:
                                               ESTIMATE OF FUNDS.

For water supply, provided $5,000 may be paid to the town of Flushing
           ......------......-------......------....---............................-------......-------....---....-$17,000
  therefor-----
For sewerage and plumbing ..............                       ...................             ..........     -- .    12, 000
For one double building for officers' quarters-     .....................                    ........                 12, 000
For one brick barrack for 150 men, provided that any available material at
  Willets Point may be used ............--......                     --......--...............--......                35, 000
For purchase, for the Engineer School of Application, of books, instruments,
  stationery, clerk hire, or extra-duty pay to enlisted men employed as clerks,
  and miscellaneous-...--..............................------..--.. ....---------..........                            1,000

         Total .......................-------....--...----....
                                      ------------     ------------......              ----
                                                                                       ......--------......-....     77,000

           Very respectfully, your obedient servant,
                                                C. B. COMSTOCK,
                        Lieutenant-Colonel of Engineers, Commanding.
   Brig. Gen. JOHN NEWT ON,
                 Chief of Engineers, U. S.. A.



         APPENDIX A.-ORGANIZATION OF ENGINEER SCHOOL OF APPLICATION.

                                      OFFICE OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,
                                                          UNITED STATES ARMY,
                                                Washington, D. C., February20, 1885.
   SIR: I have the honor to submit herewith a report of the Board of Engineers for For-
tifications, &c., upon the reorganization of the Engineer School of Application, at
Willets Point, made in compliance with instructions based upon your authority as
granted in indorsement upon my letter of August 18, 1884.
   In submitting this report I have to say that the first condition necessary to make
the school at Willets Point efficient as a practical school of instruction for engineer
officers is to insure its permanency.

                                                BOARD OF VISITORS.

   The Board of Engineers for Fortifications, &c., in New York, together with such
other officers of the Corps of Engineers above the rank of major as shall be stationed
in New York City, should constitute a Board of Visitors, which should visit the
school at least twice in each year and make a thorough and detailed inspection of
everything connected with it, submitting a report thereof to the Secretary of War,
through the Chief of Engineers, with such recommendations in reference to the school
as may be deemed necessary.
                                                  ACADEMIC STAFF.

  The academic staff of the school should consist of the commanding officer, at least
one other field officer, and the captains commanding the companies; the adjutant of
the battalion of Engineers should be the secretary.

                                                   TOURS OF DUTY.

  The tours of duty of the commanding officer and of the field officers detailed for
the school should be as long as possible, subject to the exigencies of the service.
  The regular tour of the captains should be not less than three years, and only one
of them should be relieved in any single year.
  As the duty of instruction in some branches of the profession will probably devolve
upon the adjutant and quartermaster, who should be first lieutenants of high rank,
the tour of each should be not less than three years, and only one of them should be
relieved in any one year.
          APPENDIX       1-REPORT         OF LIEUT.-COL. COMSTOCK.                475
                GRADUATES ASSIGNED       TO THE CORPS OF ENGINEERS.

  All graduates of the Military Academy who may be assigned to the Corps of Engi-
neers, at the expiration of their graduating leave, should, as far as circumstances will
permit, be ordered to the School of Application at Willets Point, and their tour of
service should not be less than two and a half years.

                                       LIBRARY.

  Provision should be made from the appropriation for incidental expenses of the
Engineer Depot at Willets Point for the annual purchase of a few new standard books
for the library of the school.

                           INSTRUCTION    OF ENLISTED MEN.

  The enlisted men of the Battalion of Engineers should be instructed not only in their
duties as soldiers of the line of the Army, but also iu sapping, mining, pontouiering,
the duties of a Torpedo Corps, &c.
  The non-commissioned officers of the Battalion should receive theoretical as well as
practical instruction.

           REORGANIZATION     OF THE ENGINEER      SCHOOL OF   APPLICATION.


  The following plan of reorganization of the school, mainly a repetition of the ideas
submitted in the report of the Board of Engineers, is recommended for approval.
  The establishment shall be designated "The Engineer School of Application of
the Army of the United States."
  It shall be divided into five departments, as follows:
  Submarine Mining.-Including electricity, our own and foreign systems of defensive
torpedo warfare, and modern high explosives.
  Military Engineering.-Includingthe operations of armies in the field, sea-coast de-
fense, modern siege operations, and modern ordnance.
   Military Photography.-Includingall methods of map multiplication in the field, and
the use of the camera.
  PracticalAstronomy.-Including the best methods and the. use of instruments em-
ployed upon the more important boundary surveys.
  Civil Engineering.-Includingpractical surveying, river and harbor improvements,
and barometric hypsometry.

                              OBJECT OF   ESTABLISHMENT.


   The object of the establishment should be to conduct researches in the branches of
science applicable to the duties of the Corps of Engineers, to instruct newly assigned
officers in the profession, and to train the enlisted men of the Battalion of Engineers
to the highest possible degree of efficiency.

                                       COMMAND.


  The establishment, under the Chief of Engineers, should be under the military com-
mand of the officer of Engineers, assigned to the command of the Post of Willets Point,
N, Y.

                                   ACADEMIC    STAFF.


   The academic staff should consist of the commandant of the other field officers of
the school, and of the captains commanding the Engineer companies stationed at Wil-
lets Point. Any other officer charged with a department of instruction should be a
member when his branch is under consideration. The adjutant of the Battalion of
Engineers should be the secretary of the academic staff.

                                       STUDENTS.

  The students should consist of the subaltern officers serving with companies, of
such other officers as may be authorized to study the course in whole or in part, and
of the non-commissioned officers and privates of the Battalion of Engineers stationed
at Willets Point.
476           REPORT            OF THE             CHIEF OF               ENGINEERS,                U. S. ARMY.

                                                        EXAMINATIONS.

   There should be two semi-annual examinations of the officers under instruction dur-
ing the first and second years, and one during the last half year of their service with
the Battalion. These examinations should be conducted by the academic staff in the
presence of one or more members of the Board of Visitors. Careful records should be
kept, which should be duly reported to the Chief of Engineers by the commanding
officer of the post.
   These semi-annual examinations should take place on or about the end of January,
and on or about the end of April.
   Their scope, subject to tthe approval of the Chief of Engineers, should be designated
by the commandant on the recommendation of the academic staff.
   Officers of other arms of service attached to the school should be examined by the
academic staff at such time as may be ordered by the commandant, on the approval
of the Chief of Engineers, and the results of such examinations should be reported,
through the Chief of Engineers, to the General Commanding the Army when such
officers are relieved from duty, or sooner if deemed expedient by the academic staff.
                                                          RESEARCHES.

  The researches to be conducted at Willets Point shall be such as may be approved
by the Chief of Engineers.
                                                   COURSE        OF INSTRUCTION.

   The annual course of instruction should be divided into two parts-winter and sum-
mer. The former, which will be chiefly library and laboratory work, should extend
from about the first of December to about the end of April. The latter should include
the rest of the year, and will be chiefly practical.   So far as the season permits,
theory and practice should at all times be combined.
   During the summer season each member of the academic staff should be assigned
by the commandant to the charge of one of the departments of instruction, and as far
as practicable this detail should be changed every year. In making such assign-
ments, however, no captain should be relieved of responsibilities which properly per-
tain to his military command.
   During the winter season the supervision of the course should be divided among
the academic staff.
  The following should be the general program of instruction, the details being or-
dered by the commandant, upon the approval of the Chief of Engineers, upon the
recommendation of the academic staff, which shall designate the necessary text books.

                                                 COURSE FOR OFFICERS.

  The young officers should be required to assist in the various researches in military
science conducted at Willets Point, with a view to familiarizing them with the
methods employed in such work.
  Their technical course of study should be arranged as far as practicable upon the
following basis. Details should be arranged by the academic staff:

                                                                                                   First        Second         Third
                                                                                                  winter.       winter.       winter.

                                                                                                      Weeks.   Weeks.      Weeks.
Submarine mining ..........    ......-----..-..---...--..-----.........-------......------......           14         7            6
Chemistry and military photography ................. ....                         ...........    ..          4       4 ...     ..
M ilitary engineering .............................. ...............                             .....                7..3
Civil engineering ..-----------------..............................................----..---------                                11


   During the summer much time will be occupied by the regular company duties, and
it is not deemed possible to arrange the course as definitely as for winter.
   The following schedule indicates the general disposition of time:


                                                                                                                 First         Second
                                                                                                               summer.        summer.

                                                                                                                   Weeks.     Weeks.
Submarine mining--............. . ...                        ..... --..         .....   ......------------....-------... 7              6
Practical astronomy ...-- ..... .....................-...........................                                         5             6
Military engineering        -........... -- .........................--.                                             (*j        (*)
Civil engineering -...- ...      . . . ..          ..       . ..          .       ..  .. . ..              ...            4             7

* Sapping, mining, and pontoniering drills.                 Infantry drills and target practice with their companies.
           APPENDIX      1-REPORT         OF LIEUT.-COL. COMSTOCK.                  477
                             COURSE FOR ENLISTED MEN.

   The course of instruction for the enlisted men of Engineers should be determined
by the academic staff, and should be repeated annually, more care and time being
devoted to recruits than to instructed soldiers.
   In submarine mining recruits should receive three months and instructed soldiers
one month of drilling, covering seven hours daily. These drills should include all
the duties of the loading-room, boat service, and the handling and firing of modern
high explosives. Grand groups of mines should be frequently planted and raised, and
the entire familiarity with the service which practice alone can give should be in-
sisted upon.
   In field fortification and sapping each company should have one month's regular
practice in the molding-room, and such outside work as may be found practicable.
   In pontoniering each company should have two months' regular practice, arranged
to include every part of the authorized manual. In military mining on land each
company should have one month's practice, including the construction and firing of
mines charged with gunpowder and modern high explosives. In infantry drill and
target practice each company should be exercised enough to maintain the reputation
already acquired by the battalion in this necessary part of its duty.
   In foot reconnaissance and military-map making all the non-commissioned officers
and many selected privates should be thoroughly instructed. In military photog-
raphy and the multiplication of maps in the field all the non-commissioned officers
should receive regular instruction, which for men of special aptitude should be suffi-
ciently extended to provide each company with skillful artisans to perform this work
in war.
   The practice in simple reconnoitering and surveying and in the use of the barom-
eter already carried out should be continued not only for its own utility, but also to
train the men in intelligence, and in manual dexterity in the use of instruments which
their field duties often demand.
   As the object of this organization is to obtain a complete system of instruction, it
is suggested that if the foregoing meet with approval, such approval be given, with
the understanding that changes may be made from time to time by the Chief of
Engineers, with the approval of the Secretary of War.
   I have also the honor to recommend that there be prepared at Willets Point, under
the direction of the Board of Engineers, a torpedo manual, which will present the
practical method of loading and anchoring torpedoes, making all electrical connec-
tions, and firing both single 'mines and groups. This manual should give a concise de-
scription of all boats and machinery for planting torpedoes with expedition, and the
whole subject of the torpedo system should be condensed in a course of instruction
similar in scope to the drill for pontoniers.
   The object of this manual is, without betraying anything which in the judgment
of the Chief of Engineers it is important to keep secret, that officers and even intelli-
gent non-commissioned officers who have been through the school of instruction
may be enabled to plant the torpedoes both singly and in groups, and to manipulate
them efficiently and skillfully.
   In connection with the researches at Willets Point, the commandant should from time
to time inform the Board of Engineers for Fortifications, through the Chief of Engi-
neers, of every new discovery or invention of this character, in order that the Board
may be able to use such information in preparing the system of defense for various
harbors throughout the United States.
        I am, sir, very respectfully, your obedient servant,
                                                                 JOHN NEWTON,
                                                                 Chief of Engineers,
                                                      Brig. and Bt. Maj. Gen., U. S. A.
  Hon. ROBERT T.     LINCOLN,
                  Secretary of War.




                 APPENDIX B.-COURSE OF WINTER INSTRUCTION.

                                  [Printed Orders No. 9.1

                                                            BATTALION OF ENGINEERS,
                                   illets Point, New York Harbor,    lovember
                                                                           23, 1885.
  I. Officers of the Battalion who have not already submitted the reports and papers
required by Printed Orders No. 3, current series, will forward them at once.
  II. The following course of winter instruction at the Engineer School of Applica-
tion of the United States Army, recommended by the academic staff and approved
478      REPORT      OF THE      CHIEF     OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

by the Chief of Engineers, is ordered by the commandant for the ensuing season be-
ginning on the 30th instant.
  There will be two stated examinations of Engineer officers, conducted by the aca-
demic staff--one at the end of January, and the other at the end of April. The monthly
examinations of the annual artillery detail-vill be held as required by existing orders.

                                 SUBMARINE MINING.

   The laboratory course (from December to April inclusive), under the supervision of
the commandant, is placed under the special charge of the captains of the academic
staff; one of them in weekly rotation will be in command of the buildings and of the
details of officers and enlisted men.
   Engineer officers studying the course are divided into two classes-those of the first
and those of the second winter of duty with the Battalion. The first examination
covers Part I of the Torpedo Manual. omitting Chapter IV, and includes a set of ob-
servations and measurements prescribed therein, the notes of which will be submitted
to the staff.
   The second examination covers in addition Parts II and III of the Manual, and every
piactical detail of the duty of electrician in setting up his apparatus, making the tests,
etc. Samples of all mechanical work described in the Manual must be executdd per-
sonally by each officer and submitted at this examination.
   The third examination, in addition to the above, covers both parts of the report
upon the experiments and investigations conducted at Willets Point to develop our
system of submarine mining.
   The fourth examination, in addition to the above, covers the professional papers of
the school, treating of submarine mining, together with a full discussion of foreign
systems as described in the writings of Stotherd, de darrepont, Van de Welde, Slee-
man, and others, in the library of the torpedo laboratory.
   The roster for the coining season will be arranged to give each officer 14 weeks for
his first winter of service with the Battalion, 7 weeks for his second, and 6 weeks for
his third winter.
   Officers will proceed to the laboratory at guard-mounting daily, except on Satur-
days and Sundays, and will remain there not less than six working hours.
   The instruction roster of non-commissioned officers, arranged in regular rotation,
will be kept by the adjutant. The details of privates will be made from the com-
panies in turn. These details will spend the regular fatigue hours daily, Saturdays
and Sundays excepted, at the laboratory for enlisted men. Every soldier not excused
by orders will be included on this list, but the roster will be arranged specially for the
benefit of the recruits. Their instruction will be directed by the captain in charge,
who will be assisted by the senior lieutenant on the detail.
   Instruction will comprise telegraphing with the dial instrument, including the code
for action; the duties of the loading-room, and, so far as practicable, of the boat
service as prescribed in the Torpedo Manual-comprising preparing the plugs of the
buoyant and ground torpedoes; charging the mines; charging the cut-off boxes, three
methods; jointing the cores; making turk's heads in the electrical cable; using the
junction boxes; attaching a cable stop; splicing and knotting hemp rope; inserting
thimbles in the wire mooring rope. They will also receive from the commissioned
officers daily verbal instruction respecting the fuses, explosives, torpedo material (ex-
cept that of the operating room), voltaic batteries, simple electrical testing, and the
use of the portable apparatus for the electrical ignition of mines. On the Saturday
terminating his tour, the captain in charge will submit a report giving the names and
proficiency of the detail, what verbal and other instruction they have received, and
figures showing the insulation of the core joints made by them. Printed blank forms
will be supplied.
                     CHEMISTRY    AND   MTIrITARY   PHOTOGRAPY.


   The building, apparatus, chemicals, &c., are in charge of the Battalion quarter
master.
   Officers detailed for instruction will proceed to the photographic laboratory at guard-
mounting daily, Saturday and Sunday excepted, and spend not less than six hours
there on duty. Officers not on the roster may, at their option, use the laboratory on
Saturdays, and on such other days as will occasion no confusion or overcrowding.
   The course of instruction will be arranged to cover, (1) making negatives with gela-
tine emulsion plates, including the preparation of developers, intensifiers and other
solutions; (2) silver printing, including the preparation of all necessary solutions,
finishing and mounting the prints; (3) map printing, including the preparation of
glass and paper negatives, the blue process, &c. ; (4) photolithography, including
the preparation of the negatives by the wet-plate process, the preparation of the
prints, the transfer to the stone or zinc plates, and the mechanical process of printing.
          APPENDIX       1-REPORT        OF   LIEUT.-COL.      COMSTOCK.           479
Each officer who has made a survey will submit a dozen copies of it prepared in this
manner; (5) miscellaneous work, such as the heliotype process, &c.
   At the close of each weekly tour, each officer of the detail will submit, through the
Battalion quartermaster, a personal report upon the work he has accomplished; and
at the close of the season a set of pictures made by himself. Printed blanks for the
weekly reports will be supplied.
   Five non-commissioned officers from each company in turn will be detailed for in-
struction for one week, Saturday and Sunday excepted.        Attendance will include the
usual fatigue hours.
                                MILITARY ENGINEERING.

  The examination in this course will be held at the end of April.
  Engineer officers studying this course are divided into two classes-those of the
second and those of the third winter of service with the Battalion. The roster will
be arranged to give the former 7 weeks and the latter 3 weeks of instruction.
  For the second winter the course will be such portions of the following works as
may be designated by the academic staff: lamley's Art of War; Clark's Coast De-
fense; Vol. VII, Professional Papers, Corps Royal Engineers; Very's Development of
Armor for Naval Use; Tidball's Heavy Artillery Tactics ; Gun Foundry Board Report;
Griffin's Monograph ; Professional Paper No. 25, Corps of Engineers, U. S. A.; Forti-
fications of to-day; Report of Board of Engineers, 1883; U. S. Fortifications, Report
of Chief of Engineers, 1882; Woolwich Text-Book; Abbot's Hasty Notes.
  For the third winter the course will be the remaining parts of Hamley and a re-
view of the second winter's course.

                                  CIVIL ENGINEERING.

  The examination in this course will be held at the end of April.
  The course will be 11 weeks for officers serving their third winter with the bat-
talion, and will constitute such portions of the following works as may be designated
by the academic staff: Non-tidal Rivers, Janicke, &c., Merrill; Rankine's Civil En-
gineering; Lake Survey Report, Professional Paper, Corps of Engineers, No. 24;
Hydraulic Gates and Dams; Jackson's Hydraulics; Harcourt's Rivers and Canals,
and Harbors and Docks; Johnson's Topographical Surveying; Treatise on the Steam
Engine; Schlichting's Regulation and Canalization of Navigable Non-tidal Rivers
(translation).
                                     METEOROLOGY.

  The usual meteorological observations at Willets Point will begin on January 2,
1886, and will continue for sixty consecutive days. Officers will make themselves
familiar with the contents of Professional Paper No. 15 of the Corps of Engineers,
treating of meteorology and barometric hypsometry.
  The three captains, each acting for ten days in turn, are charged with the super-
vision of these observations.
  The observers will consist of the lieutenants on company duty with the Battalion
at this post, and of the requisite number of non-commissioned officers from each of
the three companies, to be selected by the captains. Each tour will consist of one
day, during which time all reductions and plotting pertaining to their records will
be made. Observations between the hours of 12 p. m. and 6 a. m., both inclusive,
may be omitted. The roster of companies will be kept by the Battalion adjutant.
  Immediately after the termination of the observations the data will be fully and
intelligently discussed upon Colonel Williamson's system, by aid of the daily plots
and diagrams, and under the supervision of the captains, by the lieutenants of the
companies. Reduction to second level will be omitted.
  To Company B is assigned the reduction of the observations with the psychrome-
ter, including force of vapor and relative humidity; to Company C, those with the
aneroid barometer and of the air temperature, and to Company A those with the
mercurial barometer, and of the winds and clouds.

                                   INFANTRY DRILLS.

  Company commanders will see that their companies are kept well drilled in the
manual of arms, and that they are practical in the bayonet exercise, gallery target
practice, and, when the weather is suitable, in estimating distances. The hours of
practice and of recruit drills will be regulated as may be most convenient.    One
company drill will be had at 3 p. m. by Company A on Wednesday, by Company B
on Thursday, and by Company C on Friday of each week, recall being sounded at
2.30 p. m. for that purpose. The drill will be attended by all men except the fore-
going details and men excused by orders.
480        REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                                                      U. S. ARMY.

                                 RECITATIONS OF ENLISTED MEN.

  The non-commissioned officers of each company in turn will, unless excused by
orders, be detailed for one week for theoretical instruction. They will be excused
from all duties but those necessary in the company. Recitations will be conducted
daily (Saturdays and Sundays excepted) under the supervision of the company com-
manders.
   Regular classes will be formed in field fortification (including mining), pontonier-
ing, topographical drawing, infantry tactics, the theoretical and practical use of the
railroad transit, military signaling, and submarine mining according to the three pyrts
of the Manual. The instruction in electricity will include verbal explanations and
experiments in the electrical laboratory.     Each recitation will be marked on the
West Point system, and at the close of each week a list showing the marks of each
non-commissioned officer, in each branch, will be forwarded to the commandant.
  A school for soldiers will be established as prescribed in the Regulations of the
Army. Attendance will be voluntary, the object being to extend aid to such enlisted
men as desire to devote a portion of their winter's leisure to study. This school will
be under the charge of the Battalion adjutant. Sessions will be held between71 and
8J p. m. on Tuesdays, Thurdays, and Fridays of each week. Weekly reports of prog-
ress will be rendered.
   III. The following is a consolidated roster for the officers of Engineers taking the
course above ordered. The letters T, P, M, and C denote submarine mining, photog-
raphy, military engineering, and civil engineering, respectively. No exchanges on
this roster will be allowed, and no exchanges on other rosters, except upon written
applications forwarded through company commanders:

                           CONSOLIDATED ROSTER FOR OFFICERS.


                             Company A.                              Company B.                                  Company C.


                      a-    p                                                                      .        'd
Week beginning--                             _
                                                                                              4

                                     a                m               am           a          a!                   a

November   30......   T                       T       P       C       T......                 T             C      T                        P
                      C     C    .

December 6 ......           C        P                T        T                  M           T             C     P       T..
December 13 ...        C    ..       T        P       T     ......    M           T           P             T    ..... M                T
December20-..C              T        M        T   .            C      T           P           T        .          T       P             M
December 27 .....
January 3....     ....
                       T    C
                                     iT       P
                                                      T
                                                      T
                                                              C
                                                               T
                                                                      P
                                                                      M
                                                                                ....T   ...
                                                                                              T             C
                                                                                                            C     M
                                                                                                                    ..
                                                                                                                       ..
                                                                                                                          T             P
                                                                                                                                        T
January 10 .          C     C                 T       P       C       T           M           T             T      T       M            -
January 17...         C     T        P                'r.     C.                 M            T             C     P        T            M
January 24.....       C    ...                P       T       T   M              T
                                                                                 "T                         C_    M        P            T
January 31-..--.      T     C                 T   .           C.. T               P           T             C     T        M        .
February 7 ...        C     T    .            M       T       C   P                ..         T        ..         M        T                P
February 14........--       C        T        P       T       C                  T            P             T          .   M                T
February 21...        T     M        M        T       P           T
                                                                  M              P            T             C      T           .M
February 28 .-..      M     M        P        M       T       T                  M            T             C      P       T            M
March 7............ M       M        T        M               M   M              T            P             T      M       M            T
March 14............ M      T        M        T               M   T              P            T             M      T       P            M
March 21.........     T     C        M        M       T       M   P                           T             M              T                P
March 28 .........    C     C        T        M       T       T   M                T          P             M     M        M
AprilA                C     C             C   T                        T          N           T             T              M
April 11.........     C     T        P        M       T       C       M           M        T                C      P       T            M
April 18..........    C     C        T        M       T       C       P           T     .....               C     M        P                T


  The weekly detail of enlisted men for instruction in submarine mining will consist
of 5 sergeants, 9 corporals, and 60 privates, or as nearly these numbers as the exigen-
cies of the service will permit.
  The recitations of the school for soldiers will be held in the evening in the new tor-
pedo drill building. Company recitations of non-commissioned officers may be held
in the same building, or in one or both of the rooms assigned to the post school for
children, at the option of the company commanders-provided, however, that such
hours are selected as will not interfere with the regular use of these rooms.
  IV. Unless otherwise ordered by the Superintendent of the Military Academy, the
enlisted men of Company E will receive, so far as practicable, the same instruction
          APPENDIX       1-REPORT         OF LIEUT.-COL. COMSTOCK.                 481
as the rest of the Battalion ; and a consolidated report of the recitations of the non-
commissioned officers in each branch will be forwarded to the adjutant at the close of
the season.
  By order of Lieutenant-Colonel Abbot.
                                                                S. W. ROESSLER,
                                              First Lieutenant of Engineers, Adjutant.




  APPENDIX     C.-PROGRAMME     OF STUDY AND INSTRUCTION FOR SUMMER SEASON.

                                      fOrder   No. 74.1

                     ENGINEER SCHOOL OF APPLICATION, U.        S. A.


                                WILLETS POINT, New York Harbor, April 22, 1886.
  The following programme of study and instruction for the ensuing summer season,
to commence May 3 and end November 27, 1886 (thirty weeks), having been recom-
mended by the acedemic staff and approved by the Chief of Engineers, will he carried
into effect accordingly.
                               MILITARY    ENGINEERING.


   1st. Verbal instruction by the company officers in the nomenclature and dimensions
of the siege battery. 2d. Instruction in the molding room, including the making of
modern siege batteries and saps, to scale. This drill will be by company, each in turn
being entitled to the use of the room for one month. A commissioned offlicer of the com-
pany must always be present. 3d. A full course of trestle and wooden ponton drill,includ-
ing both maneuvers. 4th. The preparation and firing of a military mine by each com-
pany. 5th. Infantry tactics, including the school of the soldier and of the company.
Battalion drills will be had under the direction of the Battalion comnmader, each cap-
tain being occasionally detailed to command at a drill. 6th. Target practice under the
authorized system. A commissioned officer will supervise all firing. 7th. Military
map making. Each lieutenant on company duty who has not already done so, and
each non-commissioned officer and as many selected privates from each company as
practicable, will make a satisfactory foot reconnaissance at least five miles long in
the vicinity of the post. The instructions laid down in General Orders No. 12, series
of 1S6ti, from these headquarters, will be strictly followed, including the contouring.
Especial attention will be given to making the scales correctly; (1) no attempt being
made to chalnge the natural length of step in the field work; (2) the plot being miade
in terms of this natural unit ; (3) its absolute length being determined carefully by
pacing several times over a known distance; and (4) a correct scale being constructed
from these data, with 100 yards as the unit, the zero being between the first and sec-
ond divisions on the left, and the first division being subdivided into ten equal parts.
The plot will disdinctly show the beginning and end of the reconnaissance, without any
attempt at compromising discrepancies.
   The captains will submiit to these headquarters, on or before the termination of the
season, the several maps and drawings, each duly approved by themselves.

                                  SUBMARINE       MINING.

   A weekly detail of two lieutenants-not from the same company-will be made, who
will spend seven hours daily on this duty (Saturday and Sunday excepted). They
will be excused from all other duties except dress-parades and inspections. The ar-
tillery officers will be included in the above detail. The other company commanders
and the Battalion staff officers will occasionally be detailed to relieve the officer in
charge in the (luty of supervising these drills. Weekly details will be made of not
less than two nou-commissioned officers and of twelve privates froim the companies not
on the roster for special drills in military engineering, fir one week.
   In the absence of commissioned officers Sergeants William H. Brown, Company A,
and Henry Warner, Company B, assistaut instructors in submarine mining, will be
in general charge of this detail. During fatigue hours (except on Saturday andl Situ-
day) the men will be instructed (1) in the duties of the boat service connected with
submarine mines, and (2) in those of the loading room. The following system will
be observed as closely as circumstances permit.
  :1st. MONDAY. Judgment torpedo drill.-The mapping drill will first be practiced;
then the judgment tiring drill. A f'ew steamers or sailing vessels should be tracked
at every drill, and the diagrams will be neatly finished and preserved.
        31 E
482      REPORT      OF THE      CHIEF    OF ENGINEERS,         U. S. ARMY.

  2d. TUESDAY. Placing the junction boxes.-This drill will be simulated on land until
the principles are fully understood by every member of the detail. It will then be
executed on the river, using the base line between the fort and Engineer Wharf.
Care must be taken, by providing buoy ropes of sufficient strength, to avoid the loss
of anchors.
   3d. WEDNESDAY. Planting a group of mines.-One officer will act as electrician, and
the other will command on the steam launch; the former, on Monday or Tuesday,
will set up the apparatus completely in the mining casemate, so that everything shall
be in readiness. All the tests used in planting a grand group will be made. Before the
officer's detail is relieved, it will remove all the apparatus from the mining casemate,
unless otherwise ordered.
  4th. THURSDAY. Automaticfiring drill.-This drill must first be practiced at the
wharf, in the manner prescribed in the manual.          Subsequently it may be combined
with the judgment drill on the river.
  5th. Daily instruction in rowing.-This drill (weather permitting) will be under the
direction of Lance-Corporal Lane, Company C, assistant instructor in submarine min-
ing, and will be had between morning fatigue call and 8.30 a. m.
  6th. In unfavorable weathet, the detail will be exercised in the duties of the load-
ing-room, in the shore duties pertaining to the boat-service, and in the use of the dial
telegraph; and verbal instruction will be given respecting the fuzes, explosives, tor-
pedo material (except that of the operating room), simple glectrical testing. and the
practical use of the ordinary forms of apparatus for the electrical ignition of mines.
This may be done in the enlisted men's laboratory, by reading and elaborating por-
tions of the text of the manual.
   On each Saturday the officer in charge will submit the plots of the mapping drills,
and a report giving the names of the enlisted men; what they have been drilled in,
and their classification as to proficiency; printed blank forms will be supplied. Also
personal reports from each officer showing what he has accomplished, with notes of
his tests, and a statement of any difficulty encountered, and any suggestion he may
desire to make.
                                     CIVIL ENGINEERING.

   The following instrumental surveys will begin at once, and officers will be excused
from all other duty when detailed for this purpose. The detail will be made by the
adjutant, if officers are available, upon the application of the officer in charge from
companies on no special roster in military engineering. Each lieutenant on company
duty who has not already done so will make and plot a careful instrumental survey
of at least 1 square mile of ground. The work will include contours with a surveyor's
level. He will be assisted in the field work by details of non-commissioned officers
and privates from his company. The work will be plotted on a scale of 12 inches to
the mile, with contour planes 10 feet apart, and may be executed upon any recog-
nized system preferred by the officer. Good level bench marks should be made and
located on the map, the references being given in a column of notes. The name of
the residents should be recorded. A field azimuth of one of the lines will be deter-
mined astronomically. The finished maps will be submitted on or before the termina-
tion of the drill season.
   A careful hydrographic survey of at least one-quarter of a square mile will be made
by the lieutenants on company duty, if practicable.
   Current measurements will be taken by the electric current meter, and with double
floats, by officers serving their second year with the Battalion, and will include a full
set of observations and a discussion of the same.

                                  FIELD ASTRONOMY.

  All the lieutenants who have not already completed the course, and been excused
from further observations, will eonstitite, the ohervers, being called upon by the of-
ficer in charge as wanted. In addition, when officer of the day (except on Sundays),
the weather permitting, they will observe the sun for time. These observations will
be computed at once in the book prepared for the purpose, and the error of the mean
solar chronometer will be distinctly recorded there and on the guard report where, in
case no observations are taken, the cause should be stated.
   The following system will govern the observations at the observatory.    The course
covers two seasons, the first including sextant work, and transit and zenith telescope
work, with the instruments in the east wing and on the outer pier, and the scond in-
cluding sextant work, practice with the new combined instruments in the west wing,
and with the equatorial. Advantage will be taken of every suitable night for observ-
ing. Officers wishing to use the instruments for special observations or practice must
apply for authority to do so.
  Special note books will be provided for each officer, which, after the end of the sea-
son, and inspection by the commanding officer, will become his personal property.
           APPENDIX       1--REPORT        OF LIEUT.-COL.        COMSTOCK.           483

Suitable blanL forms will be printed, both for observations and computations, and
these original records will be pasted into the books, thus rendering them valuable for
future reference.
   The following allowance of time will be made for computations. Three days for a
set of latitude observations with the sextant, for a set of time observations with the
transit, for a longitude- by Jupiter's satellites, for the value of a level division or for
a micrometer turn with the zerith telescope. Ten days for a longitude by moon
culmination, or l)y lunar distances, or by an occultation by the moon, or for latitude
by the zenith telescope. These limits as to time must be strictly observed, or daily
reports will be submitted in writing to the instructor explaining the reason of any
delay. The following will be the ordinary routine of observations with the several
instruments.
   Sextant.-After becoming skillful in the use of this instrument upon the sun, ob-
servers will deduce at least one satisfactory latitude by observing a north and a south
star, using the time deduced from an east and west star, each based on ten altitudes
taken on the same night. These observations for latitude and time must be made
near the observatory, and the time results must be reported for the Luken's chronom-
eter. No other record will be accepted. The results will be reported to the officer in
charge, and the work done under his direction.
   Transit.-A set of time observations for rating the chronometer will be made about
once a week, observing a star above and a star below the pole for deviation, and
about five south stars for time. Occasionally an observation on a sl w circumpolar
star will be mnade for determining the collimation constant. Every moon culmination
occurring before 1 a. inm. will be observed, until each officer has secured at least one
satisfactory result. At first the observer will take his own time, afterwards the
chronograph will be used.
   Zenith telescope.-Observers will first determine the level correction by daylight,
using a distant terrestrial object, or at night using a slow circumipolar star. They
will then find the value of a turn of the micromneter by observing Polaris at elonga-
tion. Lastly, they will observe for latitude, until they have obtained a satisfactory
determination based on three nights' work upon not less than twenty pairs.
   Equatorial telescope.--Every practical occultation of a star of the sixth or higher
magnitude by the dark limb of the moon will be observed, either with this instrument
or with an astronomical telescope, until each officer serilng his second year has ob-
tained one satisfactory result. Suitable lists will be prepared in advance so that no
opportunity may be lost.
   Personalequatio machine.-Each officer will occasionally take a set of observations
(80 to 100 transits) to determine his personal equation. This work will be done on
cloudy nights (see Battalion Order No. 3, series of' 1-82, for form of record.)
   A trononmical azimuth.-Each officer serving his second year will determuine an astro-
nomical azimuth accurately-using a large theodolite for the purpose. The results will
be reported in a shape for publication.

                               MILITARY PHOTOGRAPHY.

  The officers' laboratory will be open daily from 1.30 p. m. until 4 p m. The build-
ing, apparatus, chemicals, &c., will be under the charge of the post quartermaster,
whose duty it is to furnish any desired assistance, and who will be held responsible
for the judicious use of the property. Officers are invited to avail themselves of the
advantages of the laboratory, making such arrangements with the officer in charge
as shall insure no confusion in his official duties, or in those of the men under his in-
struction. The instruction of enlisted men will be restricted to one from each com-
pany, selected from those having special aptitude. They will be detailed singly, for
one week at a time, and will receive such instruction as, in the judgment of the officer
in charge, is best suited to perfect their knowledge of the subject.
   By order of Lieutenant-Colonel Comstock.
                                                                 S. W. ROESSLER,
                                               First Lieutenant of Engineers, Adjutant.



  APPENDIX D.-ASSIGNMENTS TO CHARGE OF DEPARTMENTS OF INSTRUCTION.
                                      [Orders No. 83.1
                                ENGINEER SCHOOL OF APPLICATION, U. S. A.,
                               Post at Willets Point, New York Harbor, April 30, 1886.
  The following assignments to the charge of departments of instruction are an-
nounced. At the close of the season each officer will submit a report upon the work
done in his department, with anlly recommendations he may desire to make.
484       REPORT       OF   THE   CHIEF    OF ENGINEERS,               U.    S. ARMY.

   Military engineering, Maj. W. R. King,
   Submarine wining, Capt. J. (G. D. Knight.
   Civil engineering, Capt. J, G. D. Knight, tmnorarily.
   Practical astronomy, First Lieutenant S. W. Roessler, temporarily.
   Military photography, First Lieutenant J. L. Lusk.
   I. Daily drills in infantry will commence on the 3d proximo, and will be continued
(Saturdays and Sundays excepted) until July 1st. The Battalion commanuder will
order such additional recruit drills in infantry as may in hisjudgement be necessary.
   The regular target practice season will be the months of May, June, July, andl Sep-
tember, under the direction of the Battalion comnmand(er.
   In engineering there will be daily drills, Saturdays and Sundays excepted.
   Ponton exercises for Cornpany A in May, for Company B in June, and for Company
C in July, will be devoted to drills on land, includitng building trestle bridlges, load-
ing the wagons, and putting together the canvas boats; those for Company A in Au-
gust, for Company B in September, and for Company C in October, will be devoted
to drills on the water, including the construction of bridges and boat maneuvers.
After the plontons are put in the water, captains may order such exercises in rowing
in the morning as they think expedient.
   Instruction in field fortification and the saps, will be given in the molding room--
for Company A in June, for Company B in July, and for Company C in August.
   Practice in military mining will be given on the glacis of the old land front-for
Company A in Juse, for Company B in July, a           nd
                                                       for Company C in August.
   This programme leaves November unassigned, and also three mouths for each cornm-
pany (Colmpany A, July, September, alld October; Company B1, May. August, and
October; and Company C, May, June, and September).               During these mnatntl s all
torpedlo and fatigue details will, if practicable, be taken from the companies off duty;
and the spare time will lbe devoted to surveys, practice in military map-making, and
preliminary target practice and range tiring.
   By order of Lieutenant-Colonel Comstock.
                                                                   S. W. I OESSLEI,
                                           First Lieutentant of Engineers, Post Adjutant.




       APPENDIX    E.--WATER      SUPPLY, SEWERS,          HOSPITAL   ACCOMMODATIONS.

    Proceedings of a Board of Officers convened by virtue of the following order:
SPECIAL   ORDERS   (                                  HEADQUARTERS          OF   TilE ARMY,
      No. 187.                                             A
                                                           ADJUTANT (GENERAL'S OFFICE,
                                                               tWashington, Auagu.st 17, 1865.
                                         [Extract.]
   1. By direction of the Secretary of War, a Board of Officers, to consist of-
   Col. Quincy A. Gill note, Corps of Eiigitneers,
   Lieut. Col. Hlenry G. Hodges, )epi ty Qu|artermaster-General, U. S. Army,
   Maj. Davrid L. Hintinigton, surgeon, U. S Army,
will assemble at Willets Point, New York, upon the call of the senior nmember, at such
time as the duties of the members will perriit, to exainie into and report tupon the
question of source and mnethod of water supply, and of sewers and proper hospital ac-
comiodations at that post.
   The junior memler of the Board will act as recorder.
   The report of the B oardlwill be forwarded, through the Chief of Engineers, to the
Adjutant-General of the Army.
   Upon the final adjournment of the Board, the members will rejoin their proper
stationls.
   The travel required under this order is necessary for the public service.

  By command of Lieutenant-General Sheridan.
                                                                            R. C. DnuM,
                                                                              Adjutant-General.


                                            WILLETS POINT, N. Y., September 3, 18-5.
  In accordance with the above order, the Board met at Willets Point on the above
date at 12 o'clock m1.
  Present: All the mnemlbers.
  After a careful inspection o(f the post, with reference to the points indicated in the
above order, the Board adjourned to meet in New York City to consider their report.
          APPENDIX       1-REPORT         OF   LIEUT.-COL.      COMSTOCK.           485
                                                    NEW YORK, September 7, 1885.
  The Board met according to adjournment.
  Present: All the members.     And respectfully submits the following report, pre-
mising that tile reconnmeudations made upon water supply and sewerage must be re-
garded as preliminary and dependent upon the experiment now in progress at Willete
Point, which will be adverted to below.

                      SOURCE AND     METHOD    OF WATER    SUPPLY.


   The Board finds that the present water supply is derived from surface wells located
at different points within the reservation.
   The opinion of the Board is that the quantity of water supplied from these sources
is entirely inadequate to the comfort of the garrison for ordinary sanitary purposes
and for protection against fire.
   From the evidence submitted to the Board there is no reason to believe that the
quality of the present supply is positively impure, but it is certain that in time these
wells must be contaminated by their close proxirmity to habitations, gardens, privies,
and stables.
   It is, therefore, in the opinion of the Board, imperative that the water supply shall
be derived from sources free from all suspicion of pollution, and in quantity sufficient
to meet all the necessary requirements of the post. Moreover, the troops of the gar-
rison should be relieved from the severe duty of distributing water by the almost obso-
lete system of water wagons and barrels.

                               FLUSHING WATER SUPPLY.

  From evidence presented to the Board, it is their opinion that the system of water
supply now in use by the city of Flushing, L. I., cannot be relied upon for the use of
this post, it being understood that the present sources of supply are regarded as im
pure, and in quantity deficient.

                                INDEPENDENT SPRINGS.

  The Board examined a certain spring, or cluster of springs, discharging within the
fort, and find the water pure andt potable, but in their opinion of insufficient quantity
to satisfy the ordinary demands of the garrison. In case of emergency, it is probable
that this supply could be relied upon to furnish water for drinking and cooking pur-
poses for a limited time.
                                    ARTESIAN WELL.


   The experiment looking to a full supply of good water by the artesian system is
now in progress, the boring having reached a depth of over 300 feet, and will be con-
tinued at least 500 feet deeper, if necessary. It is hoped that the result of this experi-
ment will Ire a plentiful supply of potable water, and in quantity sufficient for all
possible demands. Should this prove to be so, the problem of water supply is happily
solvBd.
   The Board is unanimously of the opinion that this work should be continued until
a satisfactory result is reached, or until it becomes manifest that no supply can be
obtained.
   If the Artesian experiment fails, it is the opinion of the Board that a sufficient sup-
ply, may be obtained from surface wells sunk in such localities upon the reservation
that all possibility of pollution may be avoided.
   It is the opinion of the Board that not less than 60,000 gallons of water a day will
be needed to properly supply the demands of the garrison. This estimate is based
upon an allowance of 100 gallons per head per diem for a population of 600 individu-
als. Should it be found impracticable to obtain this quantity, the Board is of the
opinion that any amount which may be secured below this estimate should be re-
served exclusively for domestic purposes, and that a cistern of sufficient capacity to
store 250,000 gallons of rain water, gathered from the root of the molding building,
should be constructed near that building, to be held in reserve for all possible emergen-
cies arising from water famine, fire, and for police purposes. A cistern of this capacity
is required to avoid the necessity for using the water from what is known as the
 "ice pond," a small sheet of impure wati:r surrounded by sources of pollution.         In
view of its quality and the necessity of draining it for sanitary reasons, it is earnestly
recommended that no use whatever be made of this water.
   In this connection the Board is of the opinion that the post shouldbe provided with
   steam fire engine for such emergencies as may arise.
   With regard to the method of distribution of the water when obtained, the Board
  of the opinion that the water should be delivered from its sources into a properly
486         REPORT         OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

constructed reservoir or stand-pipe, and thence distributed by mains over the garri-
son, provision being made for connecting with quarters and barracks, and for furnish-
ing a sufficient supply for domestic purposes, bath-rooms, and water closets.
  Provision should also be ma. e to place hydrants at points convenient to the quar-
ters, barracks, hospitals, and store-houses of the post.

                                         SYSTEM OF SEWERAGE.

  There is at present no system of sewerage at the post. Earth-pit privies are pro-
vided for the quarters and all other buildings except the barracks.     Closets for the
accommodation of the enlisted men are placed over the water, below high-water
mark, but are inconvenient on account of their distance from the barracks. Refuse
from the kitchens is removed in barrels for final disposition,
  After a due consideration of the subject of a general sewerage, the Board believes
that the plan recommended by a board of officers convened at Willets Point to ex-
amine into and report upon this subject is as well adapted to the purposes required
as the nature of the ground will admit.
  With regard to the particular system which should be adopted at this post, the
Board is inclined to recommend the separate system as preferable for the purposes of
this garrison, but as the result of the present experiment, having in view the obtain-
ing of a proper water supply, must largely influence the decision for one or another
system, it is deemed better to make no further recommendation upon this subject at
present, reserving a full expression of views for a supplementary report.
  Inasmuch as the cost of distributing water and supplying sewerage will be sub-
atantially the same for either source of supply or system of sewerage disposal, esti-
mates are herewith appended.

  The Board desires to express its acknowldgments for much valuable information
upon the points under discussion derived from a report by a Board of officers convened
to meet at Willets Point, October 21, 1884, to report upon the present water-supply
at the post, &c., by order of Lieutenant-Colonel Abbot, commanding the post.
  Appended to this report will be found-
      I. An estimate for constructing storage cistern near model building.
    II. An estimate for engine-house, steam pumps, and reservoir for water supply.
  III. An estimate for iron pipes, labor, &c., for water supply.
   IV. An estimate for labor and material for sewerage system.


                                                 ESTIMATES.

For constructing storage cistern near model building, for possible contingen-.
  cies arising from water famine, fire, and for police purposes ..........                            ....- $3, 875
For steam pumps and boiler, engine-house, pipes, and distributing reservoir. 20, 000
For 9,000 feet of iron mains, at 67 cents .....-       ----.....     .....................                     , 000
For 20 hydrants, at $50.....  ..............    ....................                    ...--- ........ -    1, 000
For labor on mains and hydrants...--..-.... -..- ....--......-- - ---------   ..... ......---......          3, 000
For labor and material for system of sewerage and house plumbing ..........                                 12, 000

  There being no further business before the Board, it adjourned subject to the call
of the senior member.
                                                     Q. A. GILLMORE,
               Coloel of Engineers, Brevet Major-General, U. S. A., Senior Member.
                                                                        HENRY       C. HODGES,
                             Lieutenant-Colonel and Deputjq Quartermaster-General, U. S. A.
                                                                        DAVID      L.   HUNTINGTON,
                                                                       Surgeon, U. S. Arm
                                                                                       1y,           Recorder
  The ADJUTANT-GENERAL                OF THE ARMY.
     (Through the Chief of Engineers.)




                  APPENDIX F.-PLAN AND ESTIMATE FOR BRICK BARRACK.

                                                    ENGINEER SCHOOL OF APPLICATION,
                                                        WILLETS POINT, N. Y., March 10, 1886.
  GENERAL: In compliance with your instructions of July 6, 1885, I have the honor
to transmit herewith a drawing of a brick barrack for a full company of engineer sol-
diers (10 sergeants, 10 corporals, 2 musicians, 64 first-class privates, 64 second-class
privates), 150 enlisted men.
                    APPENDIX                     1----REPORT                    OF LIEUT.-COL.                                   COMSTOCK.                    487
   Beds for 152 corporals and privates are indicated on the drawing-the sergeants are
quartered in the small rooms (10). This gives a surplus of 12 beds. Allowing for men
living outside of barracks-married soldiers, quartermaster room near stable, watch-
men in separate building, &c.-provision is thus made for having one large barrack
room without beds, for use as an amusement room and company formations in inclem-
ent weather.
   Ventilation has received special attention. Each man is allowed 600 cubic feet,
and, as shown on the drawing, fresh air is admitted under the stoves, and a ventilat-
ing shaft is provided. The kitchens are in the separate building now occupied as
such, thus avoiding the heat and smells of cooking in the barracks.
   The following estimate has been carefully made upon the basis of current prices.
It contemplates constructing the buildings on the present sites, where foundations
now exist. The first building erected will probably be placed elsewhere, to prevent
putting the company in camp, and if so the estimate should be increased, say, $25,000.
A brick barrack for a light battery (65 men) is now under construction at Fort Ham-
ilton at a contract price exceeding $18,000, and the plan, in my judgment, is much
less suited to our needs than that herewith submitted.

                                             ESTIMATE FOR ONE BARRACK,                                           150 MEN.
Masonry in walls ------ ----.------.....
                             .....-----......----..--.......--.....----........... ..----......--.                                                         $6, 310
Repairing foundations .........---....       .................          ................--..                                                                1,000
Plastering ....                -....---...-                 - -....
                                                                --..-...     --......----....-----................--....-..--.....
                                                                                                                -                                             1,800
                                     ------...--------.......-----...--..............------.......
Floors ----------..................................--                                                                                                             1,718
Windows and doors .---..................---..-...---                                 ....--------..--------- ---..............---------..... ---....----..        1, 480
Roof .-----.....---....- ......------.........................-----..                                        ......
                                                                                                             --....---....------......----.-
                                                                                                    ...-------------..                                            2,900
Stairs ---.......--------..........-----     ...----....------........--.....------......----...----...----                     -----..------......---.......... 500
Veanda ...........-----------..---------....                 ----..............--------------......--------------....
                                                             ----......                                                              -----............----....... 1,920
Painting--....------............----...-----..............----..-----........ --......                                   ......-----.....---......                1,000
Contingencies (say)-----..----.....-.....---.....----......---------........----..-----..--..----......                                          ....-----.       4, 372

            Total-. --------------                             --------------                    --------------                      ----------. 23, 000
   In reply to the latter part of your instructions of July 6, 1885, I will say that the
present barracks were put in good repair last autumn and that they are reported to
me as entirely comfortable even during the recent severe weather.            The officers'
quarters were also repaired and supplied with new heaters, of larger size than those
in use before; and no complaints of discomfort are made this season (except in the
old  mess building, quite unfit for occupation, for which an appropriation has been
asked from Congress).
       Very respectfully, your obedient servant,
                                                                                                                              HENRY L.       ABBOT,
                                                                                       Lieut. Col. of Engineers, Bvt. Brig. Genl.
    The CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,
                                     Washington, D. C.
                             APPENDIX No. 2.



      BATTALION OF ENGINEERS AND DEPOT AT WILLETS POINT.




REPORT OF MAJOR W. R. KING, CORPS OF ENGINEERS, OFFICER IN                     COM-
       MAND, FOR THE FISCAL YEAR ENDING JUNE 30, 1886.

                         BATTALION OF ENGINEERS AND DEPO'I
                     Willets Point, New York Harbor, August 14, 1886.
  GENERAL: I have the honor tO submit the following repdrt on the
Battalion of Engineers and Depot of Engineer property at Willets
Point for the year enrling June 30, 1886.
       Very respectfully, your obedient servant,
                                                   W. R. KING,
                                                 Major of Engineers.
  Brig. Gen. JOHN NEWTON,
       Chief of Engineers, U. 8. A.



                      I.-BATTALION        OF ENGINEERS.

   The law provides for five co mpanies of Engineer troops, having an
authorized maximum strength of 752 enlisted men, officered by details
from the Corps of Engineers. At present only four companies, with a
total strength of 450 enlisted men, are allowed to be recruited.
   The aggregate strength of the Battalion June 30, 18,6, was 17 com-
missioned officers and 396 enlisted men.
   During the past year companies A, B, and C have been stationed a)
Willets Point; Company D exists only in name; Company E has been
stationed at West Point to assist at the practical instruction of cadets
of the Military Academy, in building military bridges, sapping, mining,
and signaling.
   The following is a roster of officers serving with the Battalion June
30, 1886 :
Maj. W. R. King, Corps of Engineers, commanding.
First Lieut. S. W. Roessler, Corps of Engineers, adjutant.
First Lieut. J. L. Lusk, Corps of Engineers, quartermaster.

                                    Company A.

Capt. J. G. D. Knight, Corps of Engineers, commanding company.
First Lieut. H. E. Waterman, Corps of Engineers, with company.      On temporary
duty at Sandy Hook.
Second Lieut. D. duB. Gaillard, Corps of Engineers, with company.
Second Lieut. W. E. Craighill, Corps of Engineers, with company.
                                                                         489
490           REPORT        OF     THE          CHIEF    OF        ENGINEERS,           U.   S.   ARMY.


                                                   Company B.

  Second Lieut. H. M. Chittenden, Corps of Engineers, commanding company.
  Second Lieut. H. Taylor, Corps of Engineers, with company.
  Second Lieut. J. E. Kuhn, Corps of Engineers, with company.

                                                   Company C.

  First Lieut. W. C. Langfitt, Corps of Engineers, commanding company. On tem-
porary duty at Sandy Hook.
  Second Lieut. I. Hale, Corps of Engineers, in temporary command of company.
  Second Lieut. C. E. Gillette, Corps of Engineers, with company.
  Second Lieut. W. L. Sibert, Corps of Engineers, with company.

                                                    Company D.

   First Lieut. S. W. Roessler, Corps of Engineers, commanding company.

                                                    Company E.

  Capt. P. M. Price, Corps of Engineers, commanding company.
  First Lieut. J. G. Warren, Corps of Engineers, with company.
  First Lieut. G. A. Zinn, Corps of Engineers, with company.

   The following table shows the changes that have taken place in the
personnel of the officers during the year:


         Rank.                  Names.               Date.           relieved.or
                                                                    Joined                        Remarks.


Major................     Stanton, W. S....       Aug. 28, 1885     Relieved.....     Order No.    150, U.   S. M. A.,
                                                                                       August 28, 1885.
Captain ..........        Greene, F. V .....      Aug. 28,1885      Joined......           Do.
Firstlieutenant......     Fitch, G. D.            Sept. 26, 1885    Relieved....      Special Order No. 189, A. G. 0.,
                                                                                        August 19, 1885.
Second lieutenant....     Kuhn, J. E........      Sept. 30, 1885    Joined ......     Special Order No. 187, A. G. 0.,
                                                                                        August 17, 1885.
   Do...............      Craighill, W. E....     Oct. 30, 1885 .... do .......            Do.
Firstlieutenant ......    Beach, L. A .......     Nov. 5, 1885 Relieved...            Special Order No. 267, A. G. O.,
                                                                                        November 19, 1885.
    Do............        Black, W. M ......      Jan. 5, 1886 ... .do .......        Order No. 3, U. S. M. A., Janu-
                                                                                       ary 5, 1886.
    Do-..............     Spencer, E. J......     Jan. 7, 1886 ..-. do       ......   Special Order No. 300, A. G. 0.,
                                                                                        December 31, 1885.
Captain......... ..       Greene, F. V...... Jan. 12, 1886         .... do ......     Order No. 10, U. S. M. A., Jan-
                                                                                        uary 12, 1886.
First lieutenant ......   Warren, J. G...... Jan. 15, 1886          Joined......      Order No. 12, U. S. M. A., Jan-
                                                                                        nary 15, 1886.
Second lieutenant....     Sanford, J. C .....     Feb. 12, 1886     Relieved ...      Special Order No. 29, A. G. 0.,
                                                                                        Febuary 4, 1886.
Lieutenant-colonel...     Comstock, C. B.... Mar.18, 1886           Joined......      Special Order No. 16, A. G. O.,
                                                                                        January 20, 1886.
    Do...............     Abbot, H. L......       Mar. 18, 1886     Relieved....           Do.
Major ........-.......    King, W. R        ..    Apr. 26. 1886     Joined ......          Do.
Lieutenant-colonel...     Comstock, C. B...       Apr. 26, 1886     Relieved....           Do.



   Capt. P. M. Price was relieved from command of Company C and
assigned to command of Company E, per Special Order No. 1, Adja-
tant-General's Office, January 2, 1886, and Order No. 12, United States
Military Academy, January 15, 1886.
   First Lieut. G. A. Zinn was relieved from duty with Company B in
Special Order No. 31, Adjutant-General's Office, February 6, 1886, and
assigned to duty with Company E in Order No. 30, United States Mil-
itary Academy, in compliance with Special Order No. 31, Adjutant-Gen-
eral's Office, February 6. 1886.
   Capt. Thomas N. Bailey died at Willets Point at 10.30 a. m. April
20, 1886.
                            APPENDIX                             2-REPORT                           OF MAJOR KING.                                              491
                                                                              RECRUITING.

   During the past year the companies of the Battalion have been re-
cruited partly by enlistments and re-enlistments at Willets Point and
West Point, partly by the assignment of recruits from David's Island,
and partly by special enlistment at a rendezvous of the general recruit-
ing service in New York City.
   The Engineer sergeant detailed under authority conveyed by letter
from the Adjutant-General, United States Army, dated June 2, 1885, to
recruit for the Battalion of Engineers at general recruiting service ren-
dezvous, New York City, was relieved November 13, 1885.
   Under authority conveyed by letter from the Adjutant-General, United
States Army, dated May 24,1886, another Enginieer sergeant was detailed
to report to the superintendent of the general recruiting service to re-
cruit for the Battalion, 50 recruits being required to fill the Battalion up
to the authorized number. He was attached to the rendezvous at No.
116 Chatham street, New York City, where he still remains, and the in-
dications are that he will succeed in procuring the required number of
good men.
   The following is a summary statement of the recruiting, desertions,
and other changes among the enlisted men of the Battalion during the
past year:
Recruits from depot, New York City and David's Island ....-                         - ......-- .....--. --                                            -     .    83
Enlisted in Battalion :
    W illets Point ............       .............................................                                                                        30
    West Point.--............---------------.............---------....--.............---.........---                                                        7
                                                                                                                                                      --         37
Re-enlisted in Battalion :
      Willets       Point       .........-......................-----......      ------..--.........--..--..                                               30
      West      Point          ..........--...-----                               .......-
                                                                                      ----......          ----..---.........   ....---...........--         8
                                                                                                                                                      --         38
By transfer ............--------------------.............................--.........--------........----------.                                                      1
From desertion --....---....----.. ...----     ----...----......---..........---- --- ----....-..............---......                                            8
Discharged by expiration of service- .---.... ...-..                           ....        .... ... .............              .. ..                             38
Discharged for disability--..---.....--......--..--.. .....----....--....--....---..........--....---                                                             8
Discharged by sentence of general court-martial-......- ...-                                       ......         ........ ....                                   7
Discharged by order ............---......--....--......---..-----------.......--....----..........--....                                                         15
Died of disease -..-- ----..........-----..--... .................                  ....     ....     .... ...         .... ....                                     4
Deserted ..------..........-------...........-------...---------                    -....................------------.                                           7

  This last number, though large, is less than 70 per cent. of the cor-
responding number last year.

                                                DUTIES AND INSTRUCTIONS.

   At Willets Point the companies furnished the ordinary police guard
and care for the property in store, as well as received and issued in-
struments,   &c., used by officers in the field.
   The Battalion is equipped and drilled as infantry, and performs reg-
ular garrison duty, target practice, &c., in addition to their special du-
ties as sappers, miners, and pontoniers, and they have continued the
experiments with explosives, fixed and movable torpedoes, electric ex-
ploders, and motors, including the transmission of power to a distance
by electricity.
   The course of instruction is defined in Battalion Orders No. 3, April
27, 1885,* Battalion Orders No. 9, November 23, 1885,t and Post Orders
  nTo.74, April 22, 1886,t copies of which are herewith inclosed.
      * Appended hereto, p. 495.
      t See Appendix No. 1, B and C, report of General Comstock, pp. 477 and 481.
492     REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

  The course is divided into two parts, viz, the summer season and the
winter season. The former comprised a period of seven months, from
May 1 to November 30, and was devoted to outdoor drills and exercises.
The latter comprised a period of five months, from December 1 to April
30, and was devoted to indoor drills and theoretical instruction.

                           SUMMER SEASON.


   Submarine mining.-A weekly detail of officers and non-commissioned
officers received instruction and practice in the details of planting,
operating, and raisieng a group of mines.
   Practicalengineering.-Each company received one month's instruc-
tion and practice in the construction of field fortification and saps to a
reduced scale in the molding-room and in the construction and explo-
sion of a land mine.
   Ponton drills.-Each company received two months' instruction and
practice in these drills, one month being devoted to drills on land, in-
cluding building of trestle bridges, loading the wagons, and putting
together the canvas boats; and one month to drills on water, including
the construction of bridges and boat maneuvers.
   Infantry drills, targetpractice, &c.-Daily infarntry company drills were
had during two months of the season and target practice for four
months.
   Military surveying.-Each officer on company duty who had not al-
ready done so has made and plotted an accurate topographical survey
of at least one square mile of territory in the vicinity of the post. In
addition, the non-commissioned officers and some selected privates have
each made a foot reconnaissance of at least 5 miles in length.

                            WINTER SEASON.


   Submarine mining.-Duringthe winter season the instruction is mainly
confined to the duties of the loading-room, in assembling all the parts
of the torpedo. A weekly detail of officers and non-commissioned of-
ficers has received instruction in these duties.
   Recitations.-The non-commissioned officers and a few selected pri-
vates of each companyform a classfor theoretical instruction, and dur-
ing the winter recitations were held in submarine mining, infantry tac-
tics, pontoniering, field fortifications, and signaling.
   Meteorology.-Meteorological observations were continued for sixty
consecutive days, commencing January 2, 1886. The officers on com-
pany duty and the non-commissioned officers constituted the observers.

      TORPEDO EXPERIMENTS        AT SANDY     HOOK,   NEW   JERSEY.


   Under instruction from the Chief of Engineers, U. S. Army, dated
April 23, 1886, for testing the torpedo system, a grand group of mines
was successfully planted in June, 1886, in the False Hook Channel, Sandy
Hook, where the mines are exposed to the waves of sea and to blows
from passing vessels. After remaining in position for about ten days
the group was raised, except one triple group, which it is intended to
keep in position until subjected to the test of a very heavy sea.
  An officer and five men remain at Sandy Hook in charge of the group.
              APPENDIX     2-REPORT      OF MAJOR KING.               493
                        II.-ENGINEER DEPOT.

               PUBLIC BUILDINGS AND CONSTRUCTIONS.

   The building for instructing the enlisted men of the Battalion of En-
gineers in the theoretical knowledge of electricity and the practical
operations of loading and testing submarine mines, junction boxes, &c.,
and in all the shore duties of the torpedo service, has been completed
and was used during the past win ter. The total cost was $5,562.24, $6000
having beei' esimated for and allowed.         4
   The building wherein are stored the buoyant torpedoes and materials
pertaining to their service has been repaired and practically rebuilt, at
a cost of $525.
   A marine railway for hauling steamer David Bushnell out of the water
for winter care has been completed, at a cost of $2,191.74; $3,000 esti-
mated and allowed therefir. The ship-house for it has not yet been built.
Instead of an inclosed building for the winter protection of the Bush-
mell, it will L)robably be as well to provide simply a light portable roof,
which can be placed over her after she has been hauled out on the
ways.
   IThe large building (shed D) wherein are stored the wagons of the
ponton train has beent reshingled, at a cost of $86 90.
   There is a valuable collection of models and war relics, which, for
want of a better place, is stored in an old frame building, at sunh a dis-
tance from the torpedo laboratory that it is quite inconvenient for
purposes of illustration and instruction, and I would respectfully rec-
ommend that suitable fire proof room-say 1,200 square feet of floor-
space-be lrovided for this collection, either by an addition to the of-
ficer's laboratory building or by a separate building in the immediate
vicinity.
   There are in store nearly two hundred wooden ponton boats,
which would Iever be used again in an active campaign, as they were
built during the last war, and although some of them are in tolerable
preservation, they can only be used safely for ipurposes of instruction.
They now occupy considerable space, and the shedls under which most
of themn are stored were merely (lesigne(ld to plreventthe sun's rays from
warlping and cracking the timnber, and unless better shelter is providled
they will soon be entirely destroyed. I would resplectfully recommend
that these boats be overhiauled, and those of thlenl worth repairing be
placed under cominplete cover fromll rain and sun; the balance should
be broken up, and the boards used for rough fencing, plank walks, or
other purposes for which they are suited.

                          PROPERTY IN     STORE.

  The property in depot, consisting of the bridge equipage and stores
for bridge, engineer, field, and torpelo service, also the astronomical,
surveying, geodetic, drawing, electrical instruments, insulated cable,
&c., for torpedoes, is stored and cared for.

                         WORK OF THE DEPOT.

  The printing, draughting. photographing, lithographing, and binding,
&(., have been done by Engineer soldiers, at a cost of $966.15 for extra-
duty pay.
494         REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

  The printing and bookbinding has been useful to every department
here. Confidential and professional books for the corps, reports, blank
forms, orders, circulars, &c., have been made promptly and with econ-
omy.
  The receipts and issues of instruments during the past year for the
use of officers engaged in surveys and engineering work consisted of
transits, theodolites, chronometers, sextants, barometers, chains, odom-
eters, compasses, (drawing instruments, &c.
  A number of instruments were repaired (luring the year, at a cost of
$1,337.25.
  The instruments in depot are gradual accumulations of those that have
been purchased by many diflerent officers at widely different times and
places, and are therefore of a miscellaneous character, many out of date
and obsolete, which will not admit of interchange of parts for repairs by
taking from unserviceable ones, and the general repairs when made are
done by p!rol)osals from the lowest bidder, and it is difficult to detect
faults which become apparent when they are subject to test in the field.
  If some standard instruments could be decided on, to which all pur-
chases for depot or field should conform, the usefulness of the depot to
the general purpose for which it is intenided, for storage, repair, and is-
sue of instruments, would be much increased, and better satisfaction
given to those receiving them, and greatly increase economy in service.
  The number of really useful instruments cannot be judged from the
returns, and is very much less.

                                  III.-STATEMENT OF FUNDS.
   Congress appropriated for the fiscal year ending June 30, 1886--
For instruction of Battalion, &c ....... .... ...                           ...
                                                                        .......................-                                        $1, 000
For incidental expenses of depot ..........-.........................-.....                                                              3, 000
For repair of instruments .......           - -......     ...... ..........---        --......--....
                                                                                ----....                                                 2, 000

        Total...... ................            ......       ....................                     ............             ....      6, 000
   Of this there has been expended:
For instruction of Battalion, &c...........                             ......          ..........      ...........                   $582 23
For incidental expenses of depot ......                    ................                    ................                       2, 105 72
For repair of instruments ....     ...                   ...      - -. ...-....................
                                                                            .                                                         1, 337 25

                                                        ......----------4, 025 20
                                      -----........------.----.....--..
        Total....-----.......--..--........--------------.........-
  Of the appropriations for fiscal year ending June 30,1887, the follow-
ing sums have been assigned to me for disbursement, viz:
For incidental expenses of depot, &c..................................                                                                  $3, 000
For purchase of materials. ..-.....                        - -.................................. 1, 000
For repair of instruments ....                 ...... ...... ..                  ....     .... ...     ... .... ....       .             2, 000

        Total.......-----........-                                        6, 000
                             ------------.................---.....------..-----.....---
  Which will be applied as contemplated by the law and projects made
in accordance of the same.
  There will be required for the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888:
For incidental expenses of depot, including fuel, lights, chemicals, station-
  ery, extra-duty pay of soldiers necessarily employed as artisans on work
in addition to, and not strictly in the line of, their military duties, such
  as carpentry, smnithing, drangliting, printing, photographing, lithograph-
  ing, engiue-d riving, &c., and forrepairsto public buildings and machinery,
  and unforeseen expenses              ............             .. .....                 ..          ...             .......            $7, 000
For purchase of materials for instruction of engineer troops at Willets
Point in their special duties of sappers, miners, and pontoniers, torpedo
  drill, and signal.ng .................................................                                                                 1,500
                         APPENDIX                2-REPORT                   OF      MAJOR            KING.          495

For purchase and repairs of instruments to be issued to the Corps of Engi-
  neers for use on public works, surveys, &c ...----.                                                              $2,500
For an additional building for storing and preserving the collection of engi-
  neer models and relies already referred to, so as to render the same availa-
  ble for purposes of illustration and instruction ...............--       ..
                                                                        ...---                                     8, 000

       In all ....----------......------......------.........----.................------------ ..........   ----   19,000




  APPENDIX.-COURSE OF INSTRUCTION AND                                       DRILLS, BATTA'ION OF ENGINEERS.

                                                    [Printed Orders, No. 3.1
                                                    BATTALION OF ENGINEERS,
                                    Willets Point, New York Harbor, April 27, 1885.
  The following will be the course of instruction and drills for the Battalion of En-
gineers during the coming season-beginning on May 4 and ending on November 30
(30 weeks).
                       UNITED STATES ENGINEER SCHOOL OF APPLICATION.

  The following assignments to the charge of departments of instruction are an-
nounced. At the close of the session each officer will submit a report upon the work
done in his department, with any recommendations he may desire to make.
       Civil Engineering-Capt. J. G.D. Knight.
       Submarine Mining-Capt. Philip M. Price.
       Practical Astronomy-Capt. Thomas M. Bailey.
       Military Photography-First Lieut. James L. Lusk.
       Military Engineering-Each captain for his own company.
  The following will be the course of instruction in the several departments.

                                               MILITARY ENGINEERING.

   1st. Verbal instruction by the company officers in the nomenclature and dimensions
of the siege battery and model fronts of fortifications, including the reasons therefor.
2d. A course of instruction in the molding-room, including the making of modern
siege batteries and saps upon a scale of 1: 6. This drill will be by company, each in
turn being entitled to the use of the room for one month. A commissioned officer of
the company must always be present. 3d. A full courseof trestle and wooden ponton
drill, including boat maneuvers. 4th. The preparation and firing of a military mine
by each company. 5th. Infantry tactics, including the school of the soldier and of
the compauy. Battalion drills will be had under personal command of the lieutt-nant-
colonel commanding; each captain being occasionally detailed to command at a drill.
6th. Target practice under the authorized system. A commissioned officer will super-
vise all liring. 7th. Military map making. Each lieutenant on company duty who
has not already done so, and each non-commissioned officer and as many selected
privates from each company as practicable, will make a satisfactory foot reconnais-
sance at least 5 miles long, in the vicinity of the post. The instructions laid down in
General Orders No. 12, series of 1868, from these headq narters, will be strictly fol-
lowed, including the contouring. Especial attention will be given to making the scales
correctly; (1) no attempt being made to change the natural length of step in the
field-work; (2) the plot being made in terms of this natural unit; (3) its ablolute
length being determined carefully by pacing several times over a known distance;
and (4) a correct scale being constructed from these data with 100 yards as the unit,
the zero being between the first and second divisions on the left, and the first divis-
ion being subdivided into ten equal parts. The plot will distinctly show the begin-
ning  and e d of the reconnaissance, without any attempt at compromising discrepancies.
   The captains will submit to these headquarters, on or before the deteremiation of
the season, the several maps and drawings, each duly approved by themselves.

                                                    SUBMARINE MINING.

  A weekly detail of two 9ompany officers from different companies will be made, who
will spend seven hours daily on this duty (Saturday and Sunday excepted). They
will be excused from all other duties except dress parades and inspections, and will
be governed by General Orders No. 4, series of 1873, from Battalion headquarters.
496       REPORT OF THE           CHIEF OF       ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

   The company commanders and Battalion staff officers will occasionally be detailed
to relieve Captain Price in the duty of supervisieg these drills.
   A weekly detail will be muade of two non-commissioned officers and of twelve pri-
vates, from the companies not on the roster for special drills in engineering, for one
week. These details will be so arranged as to include, in succession, every man in
the Battalion not especially excused by the coinnianding officer. On certain specified
weeks this detail will be constituted entirely of non-conmmissio ned officers, when special
attention will be given to covering the entire groutnd as nearly as possible.
   In the absence of coltnrlissioned officers, Serg'eant Williamn H. Brown, Company A,
and Lance-Sergeant Henry Warner, Company B, assistant instructors in submarine
mining, will be in general charge of this detail.
   During fatigue hours (exce-pt on Saturday andl Sunday) the men will be instructed
(1) in the duties of the boat service, and (2) in those of the loading-room, as pre-
scribed in the proof edition of the Manual.
   The following system will be observed as closely as the weather permits.            Any
omitted drill will be had on Friday if possible.
   1st. MONDAY. Judgment torpedo drill.-The mapping drill will first be practiced,
then thejludgment firing drill. A few steamers or sailing vessels should be tracked
at every drill, and the diagrarms will be neatly finished and preserved.
   2d. TUESDAY. Placing tihe junction boxes.-This (lrill will be simulated on land
until the principles are fully understood by every member of the detail. It will
then be executed on the river, using the base line between the fort and engineer
wharf. Care must be taken, by providing buoy ropes of sufficient length, to avoid the
loss of anchors.
   3d WEDNESDAY.       PlaZting a triple group of mines.-One officer will act as electri-
cian, and the other will connmmand on the steam-launch; the former, on Monday or
Tuesday, will set up the apparatus completely in the new operating shed, so that
everything shall be in readiness. All the tests used inl planting a gran(l group will be
made. Before the end of the week the miines will be raised an(d alll the apparatus re-
turned to the confidential room. If the weather should prevent the completion of this
work, the same detail of officers will be made for the following week, due credit being
given on the roster.
   4th THURSDAY.      Automatic firing drill -This drill must first be practiced at the
wharf, in the manner prescribed in the Manual. Subsequently it may be combined
with the jiignient drill on the river.
   5th. Daily instruction in rowing.-This drill (weather permitting) will be under
the direction of Lance-Corporal Lane, Company C, assistant instructor in submarine
  ining, and will be had between morning fatigue call amid 8.:t0 a. m.
   45th. In unfavorable weather the detail will be exercised in the duties of the load-
ing-roorn, in the shore duties pertaining to the boat service, and in the use of the dial
telegraph. Verbal instruction will be given respecting the fuzes, explosives, torpedo
material-except that of the operating room -simprile clectrical testing, and the prac-
tical use of the ordinary forms of apparatus for the electrical ignition of mines. This
imay be done in the Torpedo Museum, by reading and elaborating portions of the text of
the Manual.
   On each Saturday the officer in charge will submit the plots of the mapping drills and
a report giving the names of the enlisted inen, what they have been drilled in, and
their classification as to pr)oficiency ; prinited blank forms will be supplied. Also per-
sonal relports fiom each officer showing what he has accomniplished, with notes of his
tests    tnda statement of any difficulty encountered, and any suggestions he may desire
to make.
   Before the end of the season the grand group of mines planted in 1881 will be raised
and replanted, and trial runs and dock trials with the fish torpedo and experiments
with new explosives will be continued under special directions from the lieutenant-
colonel co      ingn
                 imil  .
                                  CIVIL ENGINEERING.

   The following instrumental surveys will begin at once, and officers will be excused
fronm all other duty when detailed for this purpose. The detail will be made by thie
adjutant )uponthe application of Captain Knight from companies on no special roster
in engneering.
   Each lieutenant on company duty, who has not already done so, will make and plot
a careul instrumental survey of at least 1 square mile of ground near the penin-
sula of Great Neck, coinectitig with the formier surveys in that vicinity. The work
will include contours with a surveyor's level.        Ie will lie assisted in the field work
by details of noii-coitm nissioued officers a:nl privates. front his cormpany. The work
will behplott-d on a scale of 12 imche. to the the iile, with (contourpllanes 10 feet apart,
amld niay be executed upon any recougnized s sten pireerred Iby the officer. Good level
benclh-nmnarks should be made anid located on the map, the references being given in a
eolumn of notes. The names of the residents should be recorded. A field azimuth of
                  APPENDIX       2-REPORT         OF MAJOR KING.                     497
one of the lines will be determined astronomically.      Practice with the odometer will
be had between Willets Point and camp. The finished maps will be submitted on or
before the termination of the drill season.
   An extension of the careful hydrographic survey of last season towards the main
channel will be made by the lieutenants on company duty serving their second year
with the Battalion.
   The course in field magnetic observations is for officers serving their second year
with the Battalion, and will be carried out as fully as the facilities at hand will permit.
   Practice in the use of the Repsold base apparatus will be had by officers serving
their second year with the Battalion.
   The course in tidal and current measurements will comprise observatioi;s with the
self-registering tide-gauge, with the electric current-meter, and with double floats.
It will be confined to officers serving their second year with the Battalion, and will
include a full set of observations and a discussion of the same.

                                   FIELD   ASTRONOMY.


  All the lieutenants who have not already completed the course and been excused
from further observations will constitute the observers, being called upon by Captain
Bailey as wanted.     In addition, when officer of the day (except on Sundays), the
weather permitting, they will observe the sun or stars for time. These observations
will be computed at once in the book prepared for the purpose, and the error of the
mean solar chronometer will be distinctly recorded there and on the guard report, where,
in case no observations are taken, the cause should be stated.
  The following system will govern the observations at the observatory. The course
covers two seasons, the first including sextant work, and transit and zenith telescope
work with the instruments in the east wing and on the outer pier ; and the second
including sextant work, practice with the new combined instruments in the west
wing, and with the equatorial. Advantage will be taken of every suitable night for
observing. Officers wishing to use the instruments for special observations or prac-
tice must apply for authority to do so.
  Special note-books will be provided for each officer; which, after the end of the
season and inspection by the commanding officer, will become his personal property.
Suitable blank books will be printed, both for observations and computations; and
these original records will be pasted into the books, thus rendering them valuable
for future reference.
  The computations will receive special attention (1) as to methods employed; (2) as
to the values adopted for the instrumental constants; and (3) as to rejection of doubt-
ful observations. The latter is more than usually important, because knowledge of
the correct result is likely to bias the judgment. The following rules will be strictly
observed: No correction of the original record is to be made subsequently ; if clearly
wrong the observation must be rejected. No rejection of an observation is allowed,
unless (1) it was marked doubtful at the time; (2) it is thrown out by Peirce's crite-
rion; or (3) its discrepancy is so largely in excess of any probable limit as to render
some exceptional cause certain; for instance, a discrepancy of 1 minute in a zenith
telescope latitude. Every rejection under this third case must receive the approval
of the officer charged with supervising the computations.
   The following allowance of time will be made for computations : Three days for a
set of latitude observations with the sextant, for a set of time observations with the
transit, for a longitude by Jupiter's satellites, for the value of a level division or for
a micrometer turn with the zenith telescope; ten days for a longitude by moon cul-
mination, or by lunar distances, or by an occultation by the moon, or for latitude by
the zenith telescope.  THESE LIMITS AS TO TIME MUST BE STRICTLY OBSERVED, AND
DAILY REPORTS WILL BE SUBMITTED IN WRITING TO .'HE INSTRUCTOR EXPLAINING
THE  REASON   OF ANY  DELAY.
   The following will be the ordinary routine of observations with the several instru-
ments :
  Sextant.-After becoming skillful in the use of this instrument upon the sun, ob-
servers will deduce at least one satisfactory latitude by observing a north and a south
star, using the time deduced from an east and a west star, each based on ten altitudes
taken on the same night. Finally, they will deduce one longitude by the method of
lunar distances, using stars and not the sun, computed by Chauvenet's method.     These
observations are not designed for the regular observatory detail, but may be made
when officer of the day or at such other times as may be convenient. They must be
made near the observatory, and the time results must be reported for the Lukens
chronomer. No other record will be accepted The results will be reported to Captain
Bailey and the work done under his direction.
  Transit.-A set of time observations for rating the chronometer will be made about
once a week, observing a star above and a star below the pole for deviation, and
about five south stars for time. Occasionally an observation on a slow circumpolar
        32 E
498      REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

star will be made for determining the collimation constant. Every moon culmina-
tion occurring before 1 a. m. will be observed, until each officer has secured at least
one satisfactory result.
   At first time will be recorded by the instructor; then the observer will take his
own time; lastly, the field chronograph- will be used.
   Zenith telescope.-Observers will first determine the level correction by daylight,
using a distant terrestrial object, or at night using a slow circumpolar star. They
will then find the value of a turn of the micrometer by observing Polaris at elonga-
tion. Lastly, they will observe for latitude, until they have obtained a satisfactory
determination based on three nights' work upon not less than twenty pairs.
   The combined transit and zenith telescopes.--These instruments will be used only by
officers serving their second year with the Battalion, the object being to give famil-
iarity with the latest special patterns in use by the Corps of Engineers.
   Equatorial telescope.-Every practicable occultation of a star of the sixth or higher
magnitude by the dark limb of the moon will be observed; also every eclipse of Jupi-
ter's satellites, either with this instrument or with an astronomical telescope, until
each officer serving his second year has obtained one satisfactory result. Suitable
lists will be prepared in advance, so that no opportunity may be lost.
   Personalequation machine.-Each officer will occasionally take a set of observations
(80 to 100 transits) to determine his personal equation. This work will be done on
cloudy nights. (See Battalion Order No. 3, series of 1882, for form of record.)
   Astronomical azimuth:-Each officer serving his second year will determine an as-
tronomical azimuth accurately, using a large theodolite for the purpose. The results
will be reported in a shape for publication.

                              MILITARY PHOTOGRAPHY.

   The officers' laboratory will be open daily from 1.30 p. m. until 4 p. m. The build-
ing, apparatus, chemicals, &c., will be under the charge of Lieutenant Lusk, Bat-
talion quartermaster, whose duty it is to furnish any desired assistance, and who will
be held responsible for the judicious use of the property.
   Officers are invited to avail themselves of the advantages of the laboratory, making
such arrangements with the officer in charge as shall insure no confusion in his offi-
cial duties or in those of the men under his instruction.
   The instruction of enlisted men will be restricted to one from each company se-
lected from those having special aptitude. They will be detailed singly for one week
in turn, and will receive such instruction as in the judgment of the officer in charge
is best suited to perfect their knowledge of the subject.
   Detail of enlisted men.--Company A, Ichabod F. Crippen, second-class private; Com-
pany B, Charles M. Beer, first-class private; Company C, Robert Sturm, first-class
private.
                              WEST POINT, NEW YORK.

   It is desired that, so far as circumstances will permit, the men of Company E, sta-
tioned at West Point, may receive instructions similar to that of the rest of the Bat-
talion. The company commander at the end of the season will report fully how far
this has been practicable, with any recommendations he may desire to make.
   By order of Lieutenant-Colonel Abbot.
                                                            HARRY F.   HODGES,
                                            First Lieutenant of Engineers, Adjutant.
                          APPENDIX No..3.




REPORT OF THE BOARD ON FORTIFICATIONS OR OR  OTHER DEFENSES,.
APPOINTED BY THE PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES UNDER
THE PROVISIONS OF THE ACT OF CONGRESS APPROVED MARCH 3,
1885. WILLIAM. C. ENDICOTT, SECRETARY OF WAR, PRESIDENT.

                      ORDER OF THE PRESIDENT.

                     EXECUTIVE MANSION, Washington, May 12, 1885.
   Under a provision of an act of Congress entitled "An act making ap-
propriations for fortifications and other works of defense, and for the
armament thereof for the fiscal year ending June thirtieth, eighteen
hundred and eighty-six, and for other purposes," approved March 3,
1885, a Board, to consist of the officers and civilians hereinafter named,
is appointed to " examine and report at what ports fortifications or other-
defenses are most urgently required, the character and kind of defenses
best adapted for each, with reference to armament," and " the utiliza-
tion of torpedoes, mines, or other defensive appliances":
   Hon: William C. Endicott, Secretary of War, president of the Board,
   Brigadier-General Stephen V. Bent, Chief of Ordnance.
   Brigadier-General John Newton, Chief of Engineers.
   Lieutenant-Colonel Henry L. Abbot, Corps of Engineers.
   Captain Charles S. Smith, Ordnance Department.
   Commander V. T. Sampson, U. S. Navy.
   Commander Caspar F. Goodrich, U. S. Navy.
   Mr. Joseph Morgan, jr., of Pennsylvania.
   Mr. Erastus Corning, of New York.
                                                GROVER     CLEVELAND.

   The Board convened by order of the President has the honor to sub-
mit the following report :
   The reports of the Chief of Engineers of the Army have annually
laid before the country the condition of the national defenses, and at-
tention is specially invited to those of 1880, 1881, 1882, and 1884.
   Without enlarging upon this subject, it suffices to state that the coast:
fortifications, which in 1860 were not surpassed by those of any coun-
try for efficiency, either for offense or deftense, and were entirely com-
petent to resist vessels of war of that period, have, since the introduc-
tion of rifled guns of heavy power and of armor plating in the navies
of the world, become unable to cope with modern iron or steel clad
ships of war; far less to prevent their passage into the ports destined
for attack.
   Prior to 1860 the largest gun in service was the 10-inch Rodman
smooth-bore, the energy of whose projectile was 2,000 foot-tons. The
forts of that period, were more than competent to resist its projectile;
                                                                  499
500     REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,              U. S. ARMY.

it should form, therefore, no subject of reproach because at present they
cannot withstand the shock of 20,000, 30,000, and 45,000 foot-tons of
energy, without mentioning the new guns under construction, expected
to deliver 61.000 foot tons of energy. On the other hand, the assump-
tion should not be made that existing fortifications may not be effect-
ive at short range against unarmored or light-armored ships. At many
sites, also, they are of indispensable value as citadels or keeps to secure
the position against attacks by land, and as flanking works for torpedo
lines.
     Some idea of the wonderful change in guns since 1860 may be obtained
from complaring the weights of the projectiles, which, during this period,
have increased about twenty fold. This increase in power of guns ne-
acessitates the use of large masses of armor in important parts of de-
fensive works and largely increases their cost compared with the old
works.
     It is of no advantage to conceal the fact that the ports along our sea-
<coast-a     length of about 4,000 miles, not including Alaska-invite naval
attack; nor that our richest ports, from their greater depth of water
and capacity to admit the largest and most formidable armored ships,
are of all the most defenseless.
     The property at stake exposed to easy capture and destruction would
amount to billions of dollars, and the contributions which could be lev-
ied by a hostile fleet upon our sea-ports should be reckoned at hun-
dreds of millions.
     It is impossible to understand the supineness which has kept this
nation quiet-allowing its floating and shore defenses to become obso-
lete and effete-without making an effort to keep progress with the age,
while other nations, besides constructing powerful navies, have not
considered themselves secure without large expenditures for fortifica-
tions, including armored forts.
     Our nearest neighbor, though reasoning from the past, she should
have no occasion to dread a naval attack from us, has nevertheless con-
structed armored forts at Halifax and Bermuda, both as a refuge for
her fleets and as outposts for offensive operations.
     In the mean time we have acquired great riches and apparently
dreamed that prosperity should inspire friendship and not envy in less
favored peoples-forgetting that riches are a temptation, and that the
plunder of one of our sea-ports might abundantly reimburse an enemy
for the expenses of a war conducted against us.
     Had another policy prevailed and been consistently pursued towards
the formation of a suitable coast defense, we should at the present mo-
ment have nothing more serious to engage our attention than a meas-
ured development in the strength of the works of defense and in the
power of guns, in order to keep pace with the gradual progress in the
,means of attack.
     Unfortunately the immense labor of novel constructions must be un-
dertaken under circumstances where careful workmanship is required
and haste would be impossible. Under the most favorable conditions
a long period would be required to place the defense upon a secure
basis, and who shall guarantee that this can be effected free from com-
plications with foreign powers ? The Gun-Foundry Board has esti-
anated that it would require at least three years to establish proper
plant for the construction of modern guns. It would in all probability
require two years more to get out and prove the first 16-inch gun. That
there may be no delay in mounting the guns as fast as completed, the
work upon the extensive foundations for the gun emplacements, as well
      APPENDIX    3-REPORT      OF BOARD     ON FORTIFICATIONS.       501
as magazines, shell-rooms, engine-rooms, and other constructions nec-
essary for the service of the guns, should be commenced at the earliest
moment.
               WHERE DEFENSES        ARE MOST URGENT.

   The first in the order of the duties imposed upon the Board is to exam-
ine and report at what ports fortifications or other defenses are most
urgently required.
   Preliminary to a decision upon this important matter, it is proper top
discuss briefly the objects to be secured by a defense of the coasts, and
the nature of the attack to which these are most exposed.
   To the last named the answer would be-a naval attack. An attack
by land, if attempted in force, must be resisted by the armies of the
country, and the mode of doing this it is not necessary here to consider.
   The objects against which a naval attack would be directed are-
   First, the important commercial ports, containing, in addition to the
shipping, large magazines of the products of commerce, and which are,
on account of public and private wealth, tempting marks to an enemy.
Such cities are also railroad centers, and their capture by an enemy
would derange, not only the internal commerce by land, but also inter-
fere with the transportation of troops and mnateriel of war; and this
might occur at critical junctures during military operations. And if, in
addition, these places should be the sites of navy-yards, naval stations,
and of depots of military and naval stores, the loss and injury to the
country would be greatly increased.
   In the second place, vessels in the foreign trade must be protected-
this at sea could be performed only by the navy-but when these ar-
rive upon the coast, they should find fortified harbors of refuge pro-
vided for their security.
   The third object of attack and capture would be the vessels employed
in the coasting trade. A glance at the map of the coast will clearly
indicate the dangers to which this commerce is exposed. An enemy
having superior naval power might intercept all communication coast-
wise between New York and the ports of New England, by cruising in
Vineyard and Long Island Sounds. His cruisers watching Sandy
Hook, the mouths of Delaware and Chesapeake Bays, the coasts of
Georgia, and the Carolinas, the Florida straits, and the Gulf coasts,
would subject this trade to such risk of capture that during war it
would be virtually suspended. Nor could this result be prevented by
our Navy, eveni if provided with more numerous and more suitable ves-
sels than past experience would seem to insure, because of the immense
stretch of the coast and of the crowd of fast cruisers and of I)rivateers.
which could be let loose to capture andl destroy. When the country
shall have been provided with a few fast cruisers, their employment
should be in depredating upon the enemy's property and cofmnerce, in-
stead of engaging in a futile attempt to protect the coasting trade overa
line extending for 4,000 miles. Experience has also taught us that a few
Confederate l)rivateers sufficed to annihilate or suspend our commerce
upon the seas, and we should be ready to apply the lesson so taught to
an enemy's commerce.
   By the suspension of the coasting trade the lines of interior naviga-
tion would become of importance. The meaning must be restricted
here to the portions of those lines where a hostile vessel could not easily
penetrate, and hence would only include the route from New York to
Baltimore by canal andl otherwise; that from Norfolk to Beaufort, N.
C., and that from Savannah to the Saint John's River, thiough this last-
named line might be penetrated at several points.
Z02         REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

   The subject of the defense of the coasts has usually been treated upon
the supposition of the existence of a navy not equal to the fleets of the
enemy, but sufficiently numerous to impose upon him the necessity of
,concentration  and the avoidance of large detachments from his force,
ibut this view of the case the Board is not called upon to discuss, for it
-does not exist, and it will, besides, be found in the sequel that some of
the ports named for defense will be strategic rendezvous for fighting
:ships of war, when these shall have been built in adequate numbers for
,operating in force against the enemy.
                         PORTS ARRANGED IN ORDER OF URGENCY.

  1. New York.                              16.   Savannah.
 ,2. San Francisco.                         17.   Galveston.
  3. Boston.                                18.   Portland, Oreg.
  4. The lake ports.                        19.   Pensacola, Fla.
  5. Hampton Roads.                         20.   Wilmington, N. C.
 ,6. New Orleans.                           21.   San Diego, Cal.
 :7. Philadelphia.                          22.   Portsmouth, N. H.
  8. Washington.                            23.   Defenses of Cumberland Sound at
  9. Baltimore.                                     Fort Clinch.
  0. Portland, Me.                          24.   Defenses of ports of the Kennebec
dl.  Rhode Island po rts in Narragansett            River, Maine, at Fort Popham.
       Bay.                                 25.   New Bedford, Mass.
112. Key West.                              26.   Defenses of ports on the Penobscot
13. Charleston, S. C.                               River, Maine, at Fort Knox.
014. Mobile.                                27.   New Haven, Conn.
415. New London.
    The list of ports is not exclusively arranged in the order of commer-
ecial importance, some reference being had to the facility of defending
,certain sites, and the greater or less period of time which this task
mnight demand, Baltimore, Savannah, Wilmington, and others belong

-check
<to the' class where in an emergency obstructions might be improvised to
         temporarily a hostile squadron.
    It is not possible to arrange the smaller ports always in the order of
(importance, also because the necessity of a fortified harbor of refuge
inay be more urgent upon a long stretch of exposed coast, although the
port there situated might be inferior in wealth and importance to others
to which it has been preferred.
    The Board, in limiting the list to the names above, does not wish it to
be understood that there are no other places along the coast which are
..of the importance necessary to justify measures of defense. There are
-others, but the works of defense already existing at some of these, and
the force of any probable attack which would be directed against them,
<do not make it necessary to call particular attention at this time to their
,condition and needs.
    The Board, in stating " at what ports fortifications or other defenses
;are most urgently required," presents the following list:
I.     New York.                            7.    Philadelphia.
-2.    San Francisco.                       8.    Washington.
3.    Boston.                              9.    Baltimore.
4.    The lake ports.                     10.    Portland, Me.
I5.   Hampton Roads.                      11.    Rhode Island    ports in   Narragansett
  o.   New Orleans.                                 Bay.
                   THE DEFENSES AND THEIR ACCESSORIES.

  In the sequel the objects to be gained by the defense of the principal
ports, as well as of others named in this report, will be commented
upon. The Board will now consider " the character and kind of de-
      APPENDIX 3-REPORT          OF BOARD     ON FORTIFICATIONS.       503

fenses best adapted for each, with reference to armament" and "the
titilization of torpedoes, mines, or other defensive appliances," taking
up the subject in the order in which it is presented to it.
   The defenses, as to character and kind with reference to armament,
should be fixed and floating, one or both, according to locality, armed
with powerful cannon needed to repel attack from the most formidable
ships.
    In the phrase "floating defenses" just used, the armored sea-going
ship of the Navy is not referred to. We have none of that kind, and if
hereafter built in sufficient number and power they would act offensively
and not be confined to the defense of ports. The floating defenses mean
floating batteries designed specially for operating in harbors or close to
the land-armored more heavily and armed with heavier guns than any
probable adversary. Of considerably less draught than the armored
sea-going ship, they could, by operating among the shoals, avoid ram-
ming, and even torpedoes. To gain such advantages, speed must be
sacrificed, but it is quite evident that for the defense of harbors and
bays the advantages of extra thickness of armor and of superior power
of gun more than compensate for that loss. These batteries are costly,
and their use should be restricted to cases of necessity ; as, for instance,
where the port is so near to deep water that a bombardment may not
otherwise be prevented; also in localities where the nature of the foun-
dations forbids the construction of fixed defenses, or where the width
of the channel is too great to be well swept from shore batteries. Be-
sides the floating batteries hereinafter specifically recommended, the
Board desires to point out that while not required at present, others
may be useful to guard the eastern end of Long Island Sound and the
approaches on that side to New York, and in Chesapeake Bay as an
outer line of defense to Baltimore, Washington, and Hampton Roads.
    The shore batteries may be armored turrets, revolving or fixed, ar-
mored casemate, and emplacements in barbette. The materials used in
construction for the armor might be either iron or steel, although the
latest experiments indicate the superiority of forged steel plates. While
the Board is of opinion that forged steel plates should be used, it also
recommends that immediate experiments be undertaken to determine
the most suitable armor for turrets and casemates. Earthen parapets
and traverses, sometimes arranged with a core of concrete or rubble
masonry to gain resistance to shot, are generally used for barbette bat-
teries.
    It is not generally considered possible to bar the progress of an ar-
mored fleet by the mere fire of the battery; some obstruction sufficient
to arrest the ships within effective range of the guns is necessary. The
kind of obstruction now relied upon is the torpedo in the form of a sub-
marine mine, and except in special cases exploded by electric currents,
which are so managed that the operator on shore can either ignite the
mine under the ship's bottom or allow the ship to explode it by contact.
In deep charnels the submarine mines are buoyant; in comparatively
shallow waters they are placed upon the bottom; the object in both
cases being to touch or nearly approach the hull of the vessel. Subma-
rine mines are not accessories of the defense, but are essential features,
whenever they can be supplied. Bomb-proof operating rooms and tun-
nels for the conveyance into the water of the electric cables are neces-
sary parts of the system, and must be constructed in advance of the oc-
casion for their use.
  Special batteries of guns are instituted for the defense of the lines
of mines against the attempt of unarmored or light-armored boats to
504             REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

countermine or grapple for their attachments. These guns may be ar-
ranged with electrical connections so as to be discharged by the very
attempt to meddle with the system. The smooth bores of 8 and 10 inch
calibers and the 8-inch converted rifles already in service will be needed
to defend the mines against attempts of this nature; but it would be
advisable to replace them in part with 5, 6, and 8 inch rifles. The guns
thus displaced, together with the 15-inch smooth bores now on hand,
will be usefully employed in the defense of places of minor importance.
   When practicable every mine-field should be commanded by electric
search-lights, so that the enemy's attempts at night to tamper with the
mines may be detected and rendered abortive.
    Movable torpedoes operated from shore stations are still in the experi-
mental stage; and no definite recommendation except for experimental
trials could now be made. The successful operation of these torpedoes
would add another element to the (lefense of the mines.
   Torpedo boats would prove of great use in defeating attempts against
the mines, made either with small or large vessels.
   Heavy batteries and submarine mines are correlative terms of a good
defense from the shore. Without powerful guns in the defense the
armored ships of the enemy would proceed deliberately to the removal
of the mines, either ignoring or silencing the fire of the works, and
without the aid of the mines the enemy's vessels could not generally be
prevented from running past the batteries.
   To serve the mines, operating casemates, cable-tunnels, and electric
search-lights are necessary. An instructed personnel is required for the
placing into position and the service of submarine mines, owing to
the technical nature of the operations. The Battalion of Engineers in-
structed in this duty is now restricted to 400 men. So soon as proper
accommodations can be arranged for them at the )postof Willets Point,
the number should be increased to the limit allowed by law.
   Rapid firing guns also would be of use against the torpedo boats and
the unarmored po-tions of ships, and a certain number should be pro-
vided in the defense. Machine guns for flanking defenses and sweep-
ing mine-fields, for repelling assaults upon the works, and for other pur-
poses, will be necessary.
   The material of which the powerful guns Inee(led in the fixed and
floating (lefenses are to be constructed is also a )propersubject of dis-
cussionii if it is intended to secure strength ,with a minimum of weight,
which the Board deems of much moment, in view of the complication,
weight, and additional cost of the guln-carriages arising from the in-
creased dimensions of the gun, and of other vital consi(lerations.
   Cast iron as material has been advocated on account of supposed
cheapness and facility of manufacture, but the sole method of arriving
at   a   soud     iconiisioii   iin tis1   e.   ct   i;   ai. i   iiu   l
                                                                            a.(alSi.   A cii.riii-
son has been made between breech-loading cast-iron rifles and Kruplp's
steel rifles, which by no means sustains the claims either of superior
economy or facility of manmufacture for a cast-iron gun of power equal
to one made of steel.* On the other hand the difference of weight
   *The following comparison of the weight and power of cast iron and steel guns is
based upon the actual perf)rma,;ce of the United States experimental 12-;ch breech-
loading rifle, cast iron, and the Krupp 12-inch breech-loading rifle, steel, the brown
German prismatic powder being used with both guns.
  Results somewhat more favorable, it is true, have been obtained with the 12-inch
breech-loading rifle, cast iron, from the use of Dnupont's brown prismatic powder, than
given below; but it is fair to assume that results equally favorable would attend the
employment of Dupont's powder with the Krupp 12-inch rifle; consequently the re-
        APPENDIX          3-REPORT             OF    BOARD ON              FORTIFICATIONS.                     505

against the cast iron appears to be 66 per cent. of the weight of the
steel gun, a defect which would greatly interfere with facility of maneu-
ver and rapidity of fire. It would be singular if, after waiting for so
many years with the alleged intention of profiting by the experience of
nations foremost in the manufacture of heavy ordnance, we should begin
the long-neglected defense of the country with accepting a material for
guns which, after having been tried by leading European nations, has
been deliberately rejected in favor of steel. The Board emphatically
recommends steel.
  The great improvement in the quality of steel and in the manufacture
of slow-burning powders, with the resulting increase in the length of
bore and weight of the charge, has already within a few years past led
to a marked increase in the velocity and energy of the l)rojectile, with-
sults obtained with the German powder, which has been actually tested with both
guns, will furnish quite as good a basis for comrparison.
  By virtue of certain well-established principles in gunnery, relative to the simili-
tude of guns, with similarity of loading, it is easy to deduce the caliber and eight
of a piece, of either of the above types, which shall possess a given power, or which
shall have the same power, for instance, as a piece of the other type. In this way we
may reduce our data to the same absolute standard, and thus give our analysis a
strictly quan titive character.

                                                                                                               a .
                     Data.                                Powder.                  .



United States 12-inch B. L. rifle, cast iron;                            Lbs.     Lbs.        Feet.    Tons. Ft-tons.
weight, 54 tons; length of bore, 28 calibers..     German brown.         265       800       1, 709   14. 0  16, 197
Krupp's 12-inch B. L. rifle, steel; weight, 48
tons; length of bore, 32 calibers-....--- .        ...    do ........    357     1, 003      1, 857   17. 3   23, 907


  From the above it appears that the Krupp 12-inch rifle imparts to its projectile,
7,710 foot-tons more energy than the 12-inch cast-iron rifle; and it is this energy
(smashing effect) which is assumed to be the measure of effect against hard armor, as
steel, with which all new types of armored ships are now plated, and is therefore the
material against which guns for coast defense will in future be required to contend.
  The price of the experimental 12-inch rifle, cast iron, was about $540 per ton ; that
of the Krupp 12-inch rifle was probably not more than $1,120 per ton, makintg the
total cost of the first $29,160, and of the other about $53,760. The relative weight of
piece to energy of projectile is, for the 12-inch cast-iron gun, 33 tons, and for the
Krupp 12-inch gun 20.1 tons, or less than two-thirds that of the cast-iron gun. The
energy per pound of powder is 61 foot-tons for the 12-inch cast-iron gun, and 67.2 foot-
tons for the Krupp 12-inch gun.
  Let us now compare these results by a common standard. Under the limitations
imposed in connection with the principle of the similitude of guns, &c., we assume
that the weight of the piece, of the charge, of the projectile, and the energy of the
projectile are directly proportional to the cube of the caliber.
  (1) What will be the caliber, weight of piece, of charge, and of projectile of a cast-
iron gun that shall possess the same energy as the Krupp 12-inch rifle, viz, 23.907
foot-tons.
  From our premises, given and assumed, we deduce the following, viz:


                                                    Charge.         Projectile.        Velocity.        Pressure.
   Caliber.      Lethbore. of      piece. of
                                  eiht


   Inches.        Calibers.         Tons.           Pounds.          Pounds.               Feet.           Tons.
     13. 7           28              79. 7           391              1, 180               1, 709           14


  As has been stated, the price of the 12-inch cast-iron gun was about $540 per ton,
which would give as the cost of this .0-ton gun $43,092. But in the manufacture of
a second gun similar to the 12-inch cast-iron rifle, three separate castings proved fail-
ures. The failure of the first ought to have been foreseen and could have been pre-
506          REPORT        OF THE        CHIEF   OF      ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

out impressing an undue strain upon the walls of the gun, and it is this
condition of the art which has set aside that which at one time promised
to be a useful invention-guns manufactured on the multicharge prin-
ciple, such as the " Haskell" and " Ripley."                     The Board cannot recom-
mend the manufacture or purchase of either of these guns.                              From in-
formation which appears to have been carefully compiled and laid before
the Board the Haskell multicharge gun would much exceed in weight
and cost a single-charge gun of the same power.
  The nature of the projectile to be used will vary with the target.
Common shell of steel or iron carrying large bursting charges will be
effective against the unarmored parts of.vessels.                      Against wrought iron
plates the projectile may be made of chilled cast iron; but hard armor
extacts for its penetration or destruction the use of steel, forged and
vented. The failure of the second occurred by successive transverse fractures while
in the lathe, and the third was ruptured longitudinally while still in the casting-pit.
These failures, even now, are not clearly understood, and their tendency is to largely
increase the uncertainty and risk attendant upon the manufacture of these large cast-
ings, and thus to enhance their cost. It is highly probable, therefore, that the cost
per ton will materially increase for a cast-iron gun of 80 tons weight, and it may not
be far out of the way, perhaps, to assume the cost for such a gun at $600 per ton, or,
say, a total cost of about $43,000. To this sum must be added the increased cost for
the very much larger and heavier carriage required for the service of such a piece,
which will, it is quite safe to say, bring up the aggregate cost fully to that paid for
the Krupp 12-inch rifle, with its mounting.
   But it is important to bear in mind that, as yet, we have no evidence touching the
endurance of cast-iron guns, the experimental 12-inch cast-iron gun having been fired,
up to the present date, only about thirty rounds. And, further, we have no guarantee
whatever that a satisfactory endurance with one cast-iron gun will prove a safe crite-
rion in respect to the endurance of the next one that may be tried, so many and so
great are the uncertainties attendant upon the production of sound, strong castings
of such large mass.
   Let us now solve the inverse problem, viz:
   (2) What will be the caliber, weight of piece, of charge, and projectile of a steel gun
of the Krupp type that shall have the same energy as the 12-inch cast-iron gun, viz,
16,197 foot-tons ?
   In this case we deduce the following :


   Caliber.       bore. of
                Length         Weight
                                piece. of        Charge.     Projectile.   Velocity.   Pressure.


    nches.       Calibers.       Tons.           Pounds.     Pounds.         Feet.       Tons.
      10.5            32            32             242           677         1, 857      17. 3


   At $1,120 per ton, this gun would cost $36,400. But the cost of Krupp's 12-inch
rifle of 37 tons, as given on a price list of 1882, was only $1,012 per ton, so that we
may assume from $32,500 to $36,400 as the cost of the 10-inchgun of 321 tons weight.
   These figures, as compared with the price-$29,160-paid for the 12-inch cast-iron
gun, are quite favorable to the steel gun; the difference in cost is not great, partic-
ularly when it is remembered that cheapness is the chief merit claimed for cast iron,
as an offset to its manifold imperfections.
   It will be observed that the same energy is here obtained with a gun of about one-
half the weight of the cast-iron gun, and which therefore possesses great advantage
with respect to facility of handling, and permits besides of a considerable saving in
weight of charge and projectile.
   Referring again to the failure of the three 12-inch gun castings, the limit of weight
for cast-iron guns would seem to be practically reached with , 12-inch rifle of 54 tons
weight; and their production in quantity, even of that caliber and weight, will un-
questionably seriously delay the development of the steel industry of this country, to
which alone we must have recourse for guns of the highest power, and indeed for guns
of all calibers and of whatever power, where strength, lightness, and facility of hand-
ling are desiderata.
   In conclusion, it may be stated that the prices paid for Armstrong's steel guns, so
far as they have been made public, are less than the figures assumed above as the cost
of guns of Krupp manufacture.
               APPENDIX 3-REPORT OF BOARD ON FORTIFICATIONS.                                                                                             507
tempered. In connection with steel armor piercing projectiles, reference
may be made to a system of manufacture by which steel shot are rolled
of superior quality and true to gauge. So far the process has been
applied only to small calibers, but if successful for larger ones a needed
supply will be obtained at a small cost.
   Among the most important means of conducting an active defense of
the coast is the torpedo boat, which, although recently developed, has
received the sanction of the nations of Europe, each one of which now
possesses a large number of these vessels. Their use will be quite gen-
eral, first, in disturbing blockades and preventing these from being
made close, as no fleet would like to lie over night within striking dis-
tance of a station of these boats; second, in attacking an enemy's ship
enveloped in fog or smoke; third, in relieving a vessel pursued by the
enemy; fourth, in defending the mines by night and day against at-
tempts at countermining, and in many other ways not necessary to re-
capitulate.
   Impressed with the utility of this mode of defense, the Board has
recommended the construction of 150 of these boats, and desires further
to say that in its opinion this service requires a special corps of officers
and men from the Navy trained to their use.
   The self-moving torpedo, one example being the" Whitehead," would
be the main reliance. The star torpedo might be used from launches,
but as in general this service would be of the nature of a forlorn hope,
and liable to fail of success, its principal recommendation would be ease
of improvising and the absence of other suitable means to the end.
   Submarine boats have not passed the experimental stage, and the
Board has at present no recommendation to make in their regard.
  Aerial torpedoes with large charges of high explosives projected in
curved or vertical fire, while they demand consideration, have not yet
arrived at a stage of development demanding practical discussion.

LIST OF PORTS, WITH DESCRIPTION OF FORTIFICATIONS AND OTHER
  DEFENSES WITH REFERENCE TO ARMAMENT, MINES, TORPEDOES,
  ETC.

   (1) New York.-This important port must be fortified at both entrances
in the most thorough manner. Fortifications: Turrets, armored case-
mates, barbette batteries, mortar batteries. Submarine mines will form
a part of the defense. Eighteen torpedo-boats are recommended for
service in this harbor.
                                                                     Proposed armament.


                           Caliber.                                                               Kind.                                  Number.   Remarks.


16-inch.......---......                      ......... .. ........       110-ton guns .---........................                            18   B. L. R.
14-inch ---... ------------------------..                             -   80-ton guns ......-.....--                       ... .....           2   B. L. R.
12-inch----.-----------.........---------...----50-ton guns .----....--....----....--..---------........                                      40   B. L. R.
10-inch ..-------------..---------..                         ----....--.  27-ton guns ....          --...................                     20   B. L. R.
8-inch --...         ..             ..--------------..-------....-----   13-ton guns ......---...                     .....--------.         15   B. L. R.
12-inch.................................                                 Mortars ----------------------------.........................       144   Rifles.



  (2) San Francisco.-Thisis a most exposed point, and, owing to the
width across the channel, difficult to be defended by guns from the
shore. Floating batteries are consequently required to be added to the
defense. Fortifications: Turrets, barbette batteries, mortar batteries.
Submarine mines will form a part of the defense. Eighteen torpedo-
508           REPORT            OF      THE CHIEF                 OF     ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

boats are recommended for service at this harbor. Three floating bat-
teries are recommended for the defense in addition to the land batteries.
                                                    Proposed armament.


                    Caliber.                                                Kind.                           Number.         Remarks.

16-inch.---------------------------........110-ton
16inch ................................
14-inch ................................
                                                                        guns . .   ............ ...
                                                                l 0-ton guns---.-.---.-------
                                                                 80-ton guns .... . . . .. . . . .
                                                                                                             -
                                                                                                                 -
                                                                                                                      101 B.L.
                                                                                                                             B.L.R.   R.
                                                                                                                       4 B. L. R.
                          -------------------
12-inch ................................                         50-ton guns .-... ......... ..---..... .             20 B. L. R.
10-inch .................................                        27-ton guns -...........-... . .....                 71 B. L. R.
8-inch ...........................----------------------------  13-ton guns .........                                       B. L. R.
                                                                                                                       55..........-..
12-inch .........................-----------------------..----  Mortars .-.....--.................--...              128 Rifled.


    (3) Boston.-This port has a wide opening to seaward, with three ap-
proaches, and consequently requires extensive works of defense. Forti-
fications: Turrets, armored casemates, barbette batteries, mortar bat-
teries. Submaiine mines will formi a part of the defense. Eighteen
torpedo-boats are recommended for service here.

                                                    Proposed armament.


                    Caliber.                                               Kind.                            Number.         Remarks.

16-inch ................................    110-ton guns ..........................                   8 B. L. R.
12-inch .......                              50-ton guns ...... ....................                 10 B. L. R.
10-inch ....                                 27-ton guns ........----      ....... .......           15 iB. L. R.
8-inch................................-.-13-ton
8-inch                                             guns------------.
                                                          .......................... --.--- - - - -1010 B.L.R.
12-inch ................. .............     Mortars .-..-.......         ......---.. ....... 1     132 Rifled.


   (4) The Lake ports.-The situation being peculiar, an explanation be-
comes necessary. The treaty of 1817 between the United States and
England limited each party .to an insignificant naval force upon the
Lakes.* At that time the country on both sides was undeveloped;
with the exception of Detroit there was nothing perhaps deserving the
name of town upon the Upper Lakes. Everything has changed ; large
cities as centers of commerce now dot the coasts of the lake, and the
wealth and property liable to capture and destruction are enormous in
amount. In the meanwhile our neighbors over the line have surmounted
the rapids of the Saint Lawrence and the Falls of Niagara by canals
*Arrangement between the United States and Great Britain, made by Richard Rush, esq., act-
  ing as Secretary of the Department of State, and Charles Bagot, His Britannic Majesty's
envoy extraordinary, 4-c., concluded April 28, 1817.
  The naval force to be maintained upon the American lakes by His Majesty and the
Government of the United States shall henceforth be confined to the following vessels
on each side, that is :
  On Lake Ontario, to one vessel, not exceeding 100 tons burden, and armed with one
18-pound cannon.
  On the Upper Lakes, to two vessels, not exceeding like burden each, and armed
with like force.
  On the waters of Lake Champlain, to one vessel, not exceeding like burden, and
armed with like force.
  All other armed vessels on these lakes shall be forthwith dismantled, and no other
vessels of war shall be then built or armed.
  If either party should hereafter be desirous of annulling this stipulation, and should
give notice to that effect to the other party, it shall cease to be binding after the ex-
piration of six months from the date of such notice.
  The naval force so to be limited shall be restricted to such services as will in no
respect interfere with the proper duties of the armed vessels of the other party.
           APPENDIX 3-REPORT OF BOARD ON FORTIFICATIONS.                                                                 509

which, in their present condition, permit the passage of boats of 9 feet
draught, and when the improvements shall have been finished will
have a depth of 14 feet. The present draught will admit many gun-
boats now in the possession of Great Britain, and when the depth of
water is increased armored vessels from the other side of the Atlantic
may float in the waters of Lake Erie. A state of war, therefore, with
that power would at this time, unless something be done to avert the
consequences, involve the lake cities in frightful losses or even dlestruc-
tion. These cities, being upon the shore, could not by land forts be
protected from bombardment. Fort Wayne, on the Detroit River, if
supplied with suitable armament well placed, could, with the assistance
of submarine mines and torpedoes, prohibit a passage into Lake Huron.
The canal at the Sault Ste. Marie would also demand a fort to protect
it from destruction.
   Our commerce on the Upper Lakes is much more extensive than that
of Canada, and doubtless many of the steamers might at a pinch be
converted into light-armed naval vessels. But to do this, with any pros-
pect of anticipating the arrival of British gunboats after the declara-
tion of war, the vessels should be inspected, beginning now, and the in-
spections continued, so that a perfect knowledge might be obtained of
the number and description of all that might be fit for the service de-
signed, and plans of their modification to receive the guns be made and
kept, so that when the vessels are wanted there should be no unneces-
sary delay in pIreparing them for service. It is needless to state that
the guns and other necessary material should also be provided, ready
for use at a moment's warning.
   Upon Lake Ontario the Canadian commerce is superior to ours. Some
protection, however, would be needed here, which, imperfect as it is,
might serve a good purpose. It is proposed to keep in one of the inte-
rior lakes of New York vessels armed with light guns and furnished with
self-moving torpedoes, to be sent when needed, by canal, into Lake On-
tario. Some might be sent to Buffalo for service in the Upper Lakes.
A port of refuge against the superior naval force of England should be
provided in the lower part of Lake Ontario.
   The fort at Rouse's Point is sufficient, with the addition of a few 8-
inch rifles, to secure Lake Champlain from an inroad.
   It may be observed that one or more fortifications on the Saint Law-
rence River would be required, which, in the event of hostilities, could
at once protect our frontier and command the water approaches to the
Lakes. They would be more reliable than an improvised fleet upon Lake
Erie, though they could not wholly take its place.

                                                       Proposed armament.


                           Locality.                                      Caliber.          Kind.         Number.   Remarks.


Fort Wayne .............               .......-- --   .-   ...-..        10-inch.-...   27-ton guns ...        3    B. L. R.
                                                                          8-inch....    13-ton guns...         3    B. L. R.
                                                                          6-inch....     5-ton guns ..         4    B. L. R.
                                                                         10-inch....    Mortars ......         8    Rifled.
Proposed fort on Saint Lawrence River........                       ..   12-inch....    50-ton guns ..         2    B. L. R.
                                                                         10-inch ...    27-ton guns...         6    B. L. R.
                                                                         10-inch ...    Mortars ....           8    Rifled.
Fort Montgomery, Rouse's Point ...-. --.........                          8-inch ..     13-ton guns...         4    B. L. R.
                                                                         10-inch ...    Mortars ......         8    Rifled.
 510                REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

  (5) Hampton Roads.-Fortifications: Turrets, armored casements, bar-
bette batteries, mortar batteries. Submarine mines will form a part of
the defense. Eighteen torpedo-boats are recommended for the service
here and in Chesapeake Bay.
                                                                   Proposed armament.


                            Caliber.                                                           Kind.                                         Number.   Remarks.


16-inch ....----..--......             --........     .......     . 110-ton guns .......--...-..                      ..... ....                   4   B. L. R.
12-inch .................................                            50-ton guns --..----------------..                             j             10   B. L. R.
10-inch .-----........-             ................----.-.--         27-ton guns .---------------------                                          20   B. L. R.
12-inch ....---------.......----...--..-..-..-------.......---      Mortars .......-...--.............-                                           16   Rifled.



   (6) New Orleans.--It being impossible to place submarine mines in the
trunk of the river below the city, but only in the Passes, and as no land
batteries could be built there on account of the want of a foundation, it
is recommended that the defense of the Passes be confided to two float-
ing batteries, submarine mines, and other torpedoes. Twelve torpedo-
boats are recommended for this station.

                       Proposed armamentfor land batteries above the Head of the Passes.


                            Caliber.                                                           Kind.                                     Number.        Remarks.


12-inch                    .......---.....----..--....
         .-----..........---------
8-inch -------............------------
                                  .................
                                                 --------
                                                                    50-ton guns .....----------------....
                                                                    13-ton guns ..-.....-...          ..........-.
                                                                                                                                                 20
                                                                                                                                                 10
                                                                                                                                                       B. L. R.
                                                                                                                                                       B. L. R.



  (7) Philadelphia.-Fortifications:Armored casemates, barbette bat-
teries, mortar batteries. Submarine mines will form a part of the de-
fense.              Six torpedo-boats are recommended for service at this place.
                                                                   Proposed armament.



                            Caliber.                                                           Kind.                                     Number.        Remarks.


12-inch .................................                                                         -----------------
                                                                    50-ton guns ...........................------                                10    B. L. R.
        .................................
10-inch---------------------------                                  27-ton guns ...........................-------                                5    B. L. R.
8-inch ................................                            13-ton guns ............................                                      5    B.L. R.
12-inch ...............................                             Mortars ...................-------------------...--------....            '   16    Rifled.


      (8) Washington.-Fortifications:Barbette batteries. Submarine mines
will form a, part of tho defense.

                                                                   Proposed armament.


                           Caliber.                                                            Kind.                                     Number.        Remarks.

1-nh--------------------                                          -- 5-o         us7B                                                                      .B
12-inch .................................                           50-ton guns                               .............                       7    B. L. ,R.
10-inch .................................                                         ...........................
                                                                    27-ton guns-----------------------                                  --        6    B.L.R.


      (9) Baltimore.-Fortifications:Armored casemates, barbette batter-
ies, mortar batteries.                                          Submarine mines will form a part of the de-
fense.
                APPENDIX                        3-REPORT OF BOARD                                               ON FORTIFICATIONS.                                 511
                                                                           Proposed armament.


                              Caliber.                                                                  Kind.                                   Number.      Remarks.

                         --        ------                              /              -----           ~--            ~~          ^--


12-inch       .....---------------------------                              50-ton guns --..----------......-...----........--------..                 5    B. L. R.
10-inch       ...........................                                   27-ton guns....-- ..-...--...--.......            ...                      5    B. L. R.
8-inch       ..---..........................                               13-ton guns -------------.......      -------------                        5    B. L. R.
12-inch       .................................                             M ortars .....- .........--     ....... ......                            16    Rifled.



   (10) Portland, Me.-Fortifications: Barbette batteries, mortar bat-
teries. Submarine mines will form a part of the idefense. Six torpedo-
boats are recommended for service here.
                                                                           Proposed armament.


                              Caliber.                                                                 Kind.                                    Number.     Remarks.


12-inch---------------------------50-ton guns ...........................
                                                                     ------------   -----                                                              20   B.L. R.
10-inch............................::::::
                    .... ..               27-ton
                                          18-inch guns
                                          13-ton  guns .--..------..-.....------....--......-..--..
                                                        .........................                                                                      10
                                                                                                                                                       10   B. L. R.
                                                                                                                                                            B.L.R.
8-inch -----------                             .- ,-------13-ton guns.----.--------                                                   --------        10   B. L,. II.
12-inch....-......................------                                   i Mortars..------------------........................----------            48    Ritfled.


   (11) Rhode Island ports.-Entrance to Narragansett Bay. Fortifica-
tions: Turret, barbette batteries, mortar batteries. Submarile i i ines
will form a part of the defense. Six torpedo-boats are recommende d for
service in this bay.
                                                                           Proposed armament.

                              Caliber.                                                                  Kind.                                   Number.     Remarks.


16-inch...-..-..-                                                                          guns ..-------...-..----....-----..-.-..----......
                                                                            l....-.......-.......110-ton                                               2    B. L. R.
12-inch .....-...................                     --------                50-ton guns............-------------......-------........               10    B. L. R.
10-inch .........           .......................              -            27-ton guns .........................                                   10    B. L. R.
12-inch......---.......................                                     Mortars .................
                                                                            Mortars...----------------...---.                                         48    Rifled.


  (12) Key West.--This port is in the direct route of the Gulf commerce.
Fortifications: Turret, barbette batteries, mortar batteries. Submarine
mines will form a part of the defense. Six torpedo-boats are recom-
mended for service.
                                                                           Proposed armament.


                              Caliber.                                                                  Kind.                                     Number.   Remarks.


16-inch .-------------...---...---------.....................                110-ton guns.............                                                    2.....B. L. R.
                                                                                                                              ......--------------------------
         .
12-inch ------..-----                  ---------------..                      50-ton guns..-....-----...----....----...---..--.          ------         12 B. L. R.
              ---------------------------
12-inch .................................                                      ortars ...----...----..--..........--------..-.......-----.. i           32 Rifled.



  (13) Charleston, S. C.-It is necessary to provide fortified ports of
refuge along the extended coast line of North and South Carolina and
Georgia. Fortifications: Barbette batteries, mortar batteries. Sub-
marine mines will form a part of the defense. Six torpedo-boats are
recommended for service along the coast.
                                                                           Proposed armament.


                              Caliber.                                                                  Kind.                                   Number.     Remarks.


12-inch ...        ....-.--.---- ..---......                            . 50-ton guns ...........--..     .....---..                                    8   B. L. R.
10-inch- ................-                                           ..---. 27-ton guns ...........-..-............- .                                  4   B. L. R.
12-inch .................................                                   Mortars .....---...---.............-....                                   16   Rifled.
                              """"""""""""""t
512                    REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

   (14) Mobile.-A place of commercial importance and the outlet of the
products of Alabama. Fortifications: Barbette batteries, mortar bat-
teries. Submarine mines will form a part of the defense.
                                                                              Proposed armament.


                                 Caliber.                                                                  Kind.                                  Number.      Remarks.

                 12-nch--------------------5to                                               uns-------            ------ ---------------                 12    IL. R.----
12-inch       .........                                ...            .....    50-ton guns .....-          - -     .-...-..                               12   B.L.R.
8-inch ---....-...--..-..-...-------.                                         13-ton guns ------..----..--...--.------------....                         10   B. L. R.
12-inch ...                                                  :..........         ortars ..................
                                                                               M..................                  ...........                           16   Rifled.



  (15) New London.--Fortifications: Barbette batteries. Submarine
mines will form a part of the defense. Eighteen torpedo-boats are rec-
ommended for service.
                                                                              Proposed armament.


                                 Caliber.                                                                  Kind.                                  Number.      Remarks.


12-inch ................................     50-ton guns ..........................                                                                        4   B. L. R.
10-inch--...........-- ..................... 27-ton guns ..........................                                                                        4   B. L. R.


   (16) Savannah.-Fortifications: Armored casemates, barbette batter-
ies. Submarine mines will form a part of the defense.
                                                                              Proposed armament.


                                 Caliber.                                                                  Kind.                                  Number.      Remarks:


12-inch ....... ..... ....... ...              ...... .                        50-ton guns... .............           .......... -3    B. L. R.
10-inch...........                 ......... ........                          27-ton guns...........................                6 B. L. R.
8-inch .--.         ...-....- ..- --......--- . _                             13-ton guns .....---......................            4 B. L. R.
12-inch ....................---..-                    -                        Mortars..---........--......----..------..........   16 Rifled.



   (17) Galveston.-This place cannot be defended by landworks against
an active bombardment, and fortifications are proposed simply to pre-
vent an enemy's vessel from entering the harbor. Fortifications: Bar-
bette batteries, mortar batteries. Submarine mines will form a part of
the defense. One of the light-draught monitors would be useful to as-
sist in the defense.
                                                                              Proposed armament.


                                 Caliber.                                                                  Kind.                                  Number.      Remarks.


8-inch............................----------..-----                           13-ton guns ......-------...........-----.---....-----..........    ----    8   B. L. R.
12-inch ...............................                                        Mortars ...............                     ..............                 16   Rifled.



  (18) Portland, Oreg., at mouth of the Columbia River and above.-
Fortifications: Barbette batteries, mortar batteries. Submarine mines
will form a part of the defense. Eighteen torpedo-boats are recom-
mended for service along the Northern Pacific coast.
               APPENDIX                      3---REPORT                    OF BOARD                      ON FORTIFICATIONS.                         513
                                                                     Proposed armament.


                            Caliber.                                                             Kind.                               Number.   Remarks.


10-inch   --......               ----........................
10-inch.-----------------------------137-ton                  27-ton guns--------------------------
                                                                     guns .......................                                         12 B. L. R.
                                                                                                                                                   R.
8-inch .................................                     13-ton guns ...........................
                                                                                                                                          71 B. L.
                                                                                                                                           7 B. L. R.
12-inch .................................                     Mortars ..............................                                      32   Rifled.


     (19) Pensacola.-Fortifcations:Barbette batteries.                                                                              Submarine mines
will form a part of the defense.
                                                                     Proposed armament.


                            Caliber.                                                            Kind.                                Number.   Remarks.


12-inch .................................                             50-ton guns...........................                               2   B. L. R.
10-inch .................................                             27-ton guns ----...........----...........                           4   B. L. R.


   (20) Wilmington, N. C., and mouth of Cape Fear River.--Fortifeca-
tions: Armored casemates, barbette batteries. Submarine mines will
form a part of the defense.
                                                                     Proposed armament.


                            Caliber.                                                            Kind.                                Number.   Remarks.


         .................................
12-inch---------------------------                                    50-ton guns ...........................                              4   B. L. R.
10-inch .................................                             27-ton guns...........................                               5   B. L. R.


  (21) San Diego, Cal.-Fortifi atcations: Barbette batteries.                                                                             Submarine
mines will form a part of the defense.
                                                                     Proposed armament.


                             Caliber.                                                           Kind.                                Number.   Remarks.


10-inch--......-------------------------..........................    27-ton guns.........................4                                    B.L.R.


 (22) Portsmouth, N. H.-Fortifications: Barbette batteries.                                                                                        Sub-
marine mines will form a part of the defense.
                                                                     Proposed armament.


                             Caliber.                                                           Kind.                                Number.   Remarks.


12-inch................................50-ton                                guns ---------------.........---------..............         4    B. L. R.
10-inch .................................                             27 ton guns ..........................                              4    B. L. R.


  (23) Defenses of Cumberland Sound at Fort Clinch.-This is the most
southern harbor of importance on the Atlantic coast. Fortifications:
Barbette batteries. Submarine mines will form a part of the defense.
                                                                     Proposed armament.


                             Caliber.                                                           Kind.                                Number.   Remarks.


12-inch ----                        ......                            50-ton guns ---------...... --..             2 B. L. R.
                                                                                                   ----...--...........
10-inch --------.....                                                 27-ton guns..---..-.........     ...... ..    2 B. L. R.

                33 E
514                  REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

  (24) Defenses of ports on the Kennebec River, Maine, at Fort Popham.-
Fortifications: Barbette batteries. Submarine mines will form a part
of the defense.
                                                                       Proposed armament.


                             Caliber.                                                                  Kind.                                 Number.     Remarks.


10-inch................................27-ton                                                        ----------------
                                                                                      guns...........................                               3   B. L. R.



  (25) New Bedford, Mass.-Fortifications:Barbette batteries, mortar
batteries. Submarine mines will form a part of the defense.
                                                                      Proposed armament.



                             Caliber.                                                                 Kind.                                  Number.    Remarks.


8-inch ..................................                                13-ton guns ...-....--..-----.----..............--.                        3   B. L. R.
12-inch .................................                                Mortars --..    ..---.....--     ...... .........                         16   Rifled.



  (26) Defenses of ports on the Penobscot River, Maine, at Fort Knox.-
Fortifications: Barbette batteries. Submarine mines will form a part
of the defense.
                                                                      Proposed armament.


                             Caliber.                                                                Kind.                                   Number.    Remarks.


10-inch...............                    ...............                27-ton guns........................--------------------------              3B.L.R.



  (27) New Haven, Conn.-Fortifications: Barbette batteries, mortar
batteries. Submarine mines will form a part of the defense.

                                                                       Proposed armament.



                            Caliber.                                                                 Kind.                                   Number.    Remarks.

8-inch ..-----------....---.....---..--..-------..........               13-tonguns ..........................                                      3    . . R.
12-inch .................................                                Mortars ----------------.                         -------..                8   Rifled.



                                                                    GUNS              ON HAND.


     The sea-coast guns now available for use are:

                                                        Kind of gun.                                                                 Number.       Description.


Rodman guns, smooth-bore...........----------------.................................                                                          2   20-inch,
    1 o ..................................................................                                                                  308   15-inch.
          Do.           --------------------------------------------------                                                                  998   10-inch.
          Do.................. ----------------------------------------------------
          Do----                          ... ... ..... ..............................                                                      210
                                                                                                                                            21     8-inch.
Parrott guns, rifled .........................                                   .......        .... ......       ...........                38   *300-pounders.
     Do---------------------------------------............................................------------------......................           81   *200-pounders.
     Do ...................               ..........- - ..- .........                               . .         .....
                                                                                                                .            .-             173   *100-pounders.
Converted rifles .........              .... ........... ...... ................                                  ..........            t   210   8-inch.

                                         * Of doubtful strength.
                                         t160 on hand, and 50 to be delivered under contract.
           APPENDIX                 3-REPORT               OF BOARD               ON FORTIFICATIONS.                            515
   Some of these smooth-bore and rifled guns will be used to defend the
torpedo lines, and the remainder may be distributed to existing forts
and batteries, as well as to ports not named in the foregoing reports.
It is probable that with.the addition of two modern rifles of minor cali-
bers at such places, with little additional expense for constructions, the
existing defenses will suffice to secure ports of minor importance from
marauding attacks. For these reasons the smooth-bore guns enumer-
ated above should not be sold. The provisions of the law did not re-
quire the Board to make a report including all places where defenses
might at some future time be required, and the Board has therefore
confined itself to a general mention of this part of the coast defense.
   It is not necessary or expected that the order of urgency should be
strictly followed in the lower part of the list of ports prepared by the
Board, for it islikely that, pending the period at which these ports will
be reached in their order, changes impossible to foresee may occur in
their relative importance and urgency, and such changes may also
modify the extent of the defenses and armament 1proposed inparticular
cases, so that what may be taken from one may be added to another.
   Attention is invited to the following tabular statements based upon
careful study of the local requirements of each port. It has not been
deemed expedient, for prudential and other reasons, to make public the
actual sites of the batteries :
   (1) Estimate for land defenses, exclusive of armament.
   (2) Estimate for armament and mountings.
   (3) Estimate for floating batteries, including armament.
   (4) Estimate for submarine mines and their adjuncts.
   (5) Estimate for torpedo-boats.

                                  Estimate for     land defenses, exclusive of armament.

  [NOTE.-The following estimates are based upon the use of rolled iron for armor plates, because the
penetrations into that material have been the most studied, but in view of the substitution of steel, in
whole or part, for rolled iron the cost for equivalent protection would probably be the same.]


                                                                      Iron, wrought and cast.

Number of guns and mortars wanted at dif- Armor, wrouoht.Structuralmema                                                        Total.
            ferent localities.            Armor, wrought. Structural metal. sorry and                                          cost.
                                                                              earth.

                                                             Tons.        Cost.      Tons.        Cost.


New York City, including both entrances:
   9 2-gun turrets.........                  ................       13, 635 $4,050, 000 2, 925 $450, 000 $1, 800,       000 $6, 300, 000
   30 in casemates -.......                     .......... ........ 13, 050 3, 900, 000 1, 950      390, 000 1, 200,    000 5, 490, 000
   8 on lifts...............................                            ..............    .......   160, 000     640,   000     800, 000
   39 disappearing and non-disappearing ...- .-                                        ..   .-.. ---      ... 1, 560,   000 1, 560, 000
   144 mortars---------------------------------.............................------------...----------.......     288,   000     288, 000

             Total ............          .............      26, 685     7, 950,000    4, 875 1, 000, 000     5, 488, 000 14, 438, 000
San Francisco:
    5 2-gun turrets.........................                 7, 575 2,250,000  1, 625 250, 000 1, 800, 000                    3, 500, 000
   10 on lifts ............................                                           200,000           800, 000              1, 000, 000
   90 disappearing and non-disappearing...::: .......            ::::          :       ---........-- 3, 600, 000              3, 600, 000
   128 mortars .................................. . .. .. .... ..........                               256,000                  256,000
                         128 mortrs-------------------------- -.       .......                         216, 000                  256, 00
          Total ..................              ........     7,575 2, 250, 000 1, 625 450, 000 5,656, 000                     8,356,000

Boston:
   4 2-gun turrets .........................  6, 060 1, 800, 000 1, 300      200, 000                           800,000       2, 800, 000
    10 in casemates...................... 4,350 1, 300, 000             650  130, 000                           400, 0)0      1,830, 000
    15 disappearing and non-disappearing .. .      ...... ...     .....              .
                                                                            ...........                         600, 000         600, 000
    10 barbette ............................. .                                                                 150, 000         150, 000
   132 mortars .............................                  .................                                 264, 000         264, 000

             Total ..........................                            , 100,000    1, 950     330, 000     2, 214,000      5, 644,000
516           REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                                                                                                                 U. S. ARMY.

                     Estimate for land defenses, exclusive of armament--Continued.

                                                                               Iron, wrought and cast.

Number of guns and mortars wanted at dif- Armor, wrought. Structural metal . Cost ofma.
                                                                                                                                                                                                        Total
            ferent localities.                                               sonry and                                                                                                                  cost.
                                                                               earth.

                                                                     Tons.                 Cost.                                 Tons.                    Cost.


The lake ports, including Fort Wayne and
Saint Lawrence River:
   5 in casemates .....---...................              2, 175 $650, 000                                                             325              $65, 000                 $200, 000            $915, 000
   3 on lifts...-----..      ..-            ..............                                                                                                60, 000                  240, 000             300, 000
   14 disappearing and non-disappearing .. .......                                                                                                                                 560, 000             560, 000
   24 mortars .............................                _.._                                                                                                                        48, 000           48, 000
   Land defenses .........................                ......                                                                                                         .         600, 000             600, 000

                                            2, 175  650, 000  325
             Total.---------..--.............-..---...----..-----.                                                                                       125, 000                1, 648, 000          2, 423, 000

Hampton Roads, Va.:
  2 2-gun turrets.......                .................. 3, 030    900, 000                                                           650              100, 000                  400,    000        1, 400, 000
  10 in casemates ......-..............--.                 4, 350 1, 300, 000                                                           650              130, 000                  400,    000        1, 830, 000
  20 disappearing and non-disappearing... ...... ........                                                                             ...........                                  800,    000           800, 000
  16 mortars ................................                                                                                                        ..........
                                                                                                                                                     ..........                     32,    000            32, 000
                                             7,380 2, 200, 000 1, 300
             Total ..---------..----....-..----.........--..--.                                                                                            230, 000              1, 632, 000          4, 062, 000
New Orleans :
   30 disappearing and non-disappearing... .                                                                                                                                 1, 200, 000               1, 200, 00

Philadelphia :
    10 incasemates ........................ 4, 350                                  1, 300, 000                                         650              130, 000                 400, 000            1, 830, 000
    10 disappearing and non-disappearing ........ 3                                                                                                                               400, (00               400, 000
    16 mortars ....................................                                                                                                                                32, 000                32, 000

                                            4, 350 1, 300, 000 650
             Total--------...-...------.....-....--........-----.                                                                                        130, 000                 832, 000            2, 262, 000

Washington:
     13 disappearing --.....                    ...---.......
                                         .........                                      ...........--...                                             ........                     520,000               520, 000
Baltimore :
     5 in casemates ........................       2, 175                                  650, 000                                    325                 65, 000                200, 000              915, 000
    10 disappearing and non-disappearing..-.......                                                                                                         .......                400, 000              400 000
    16 mortars....................... ............                                             ..              ..                .                   .......                           32,000            32,000

             Total------------------------     2, 175
                     .............................                                         650, 000                                    325                65, 000                 632, 000            1, 347, 000

Portland, Me:
   10 on lifts ... .....................   ..   .                                                                           S                          200,
                                                                                                                                                 -......          000             800, 000            1, 000, 000
   30 disappearing and non-disappearing..-    .                                                                                                      .             ...       1, 200, 000              1, 200, 000
   48 mortar a...............................                                                                                        .......         ..........                  96, 000                  96, 000
        48otas-----------------------------
            Total....................                       .......                                                                                      200, 000            2, 096, 000              2, 296, 000

Narragansett Bay, both entrances :
    1 2-gun turret....                                        1, 515
                                              --...................                       450, 000                                     325                50, 000                 200, 000              700, 000
    5 on lifts................................                                                                                                           100, 000                 400, 000              500, 000
   15 disappearing and non-disappearing.                     -                                                                                                                    600, 000              600, 000
   48 mortars .................................                ....                                                                                    .........
                                                                                                                                                     ....  ..                          96, 000           96, 000
                                           1,515   450, 000  325
            Total---..-..--..-------.........--..........-------.                                                                                        150, 000            1, 296, 000              1, 896, 000

                                              62,265 18, 550,
            Total of above 11 ports ...........            - .
                                                               000 11, ° 375 2, 680, 000 23, 214, 000 44, 444, 000

Key West, Fla:
    1 2-gun turret.......................... 1,515                                        457, 000                                    325                 50, 000                 200, 000              700, 000
    5 on lifts .............................                                                                                                             100, 000                 400, 000              500, 000
    5 disappearing and non-disappearing... .- .                                                                                                                                   200, 000              200, 000
   32 mortars...............................                                                                                                                                       64. 000               64, 000
   Repair      .....................................                                                                                                 ......... 200, 000                                 200, 000
            Total---.....----...-...-----.                           1, 515               450, 000                                    325                150, 000            1, 664, 000              1, 664, 000
                                                                                   _, __i             __            '                       -        -------                      --       --    I-         -
Charleston, S. C.:
      4 on lifts ...........................
                                         ...                    ....                                                                                      80, 000                 320, 000              400, 000
      8 disappearing and non-disappearing... .....                                                                                                                                320, 000              320, 000
     16 mortars ............................. ......                                                                                                 .........                     32, 000               32, 000
     Repairs........................................                                                                                                 ..........                   200, 000              200, 000
                                                                 I            -!          --              --            I                       .I                       I   ,

            Total ...............................                                  ..               ...
                                                                                        -- I I                              ..       _...

                                                                                                                                                -
                                                                                                                                                -r
                                                                                                                                                 I        80,     000

                                                                                                                                                                         i        8 72,   000

                                                                                                                                                                                                =I 952,000
                APPENDIX 3-REPORT OF BOARD                                                                              ON FORTIFICATIONS.                                                     517
                            Estimate for land defenses, exclusive of armament-Continued.

                                                                                            Iron, wrough                         it   and cast.

                                                                                                                   Cost of ma-
Number of guns and mortars wanted at dif-                                       Armor, wrought. Structural metal. sonry and                                                                  Total
             ferent localities.                                                                                                                                                               cost.
                                                                                                                     earth.

                                                                                 Tons.                   Cost.                       Tons.                  Cost.


Mobile, Ala.:
     4 on lifts .......--------------------                                                                                                 ... $80, 000      $320,                   000    $400, 000
    18 disappearing and non-disappearing...                                                                                                                    720,
                                                                                                                                                      .... ......                     000     720, 000
    16 mortars ..............................                                                                                                                   32,                   000      32, 000
    Repairs....--....--....--.......--........                                             - ---- - -- .-
                                                                                          -----                                                ......
                                                                                                                                                  ........     300,                   000     300, 000
                  Total .............................                                                                                                        0.
                                                                                                                                                             80, 000         1, 372, 000    1, 453, 000

New London, Conn.:
     4 on lifts..........................                                            .... _.....                                              ..             80, 000           320, 000       400, 000
     4 disappearing and non-disappearing...                                             .
                                                                                      -....     _... - ...                                     .....             ....          160, 000       160, 000
    Repairs..............................                                                   ...                              .         ..                 ------               100, 000       100, 000
                  Total. ..-...-.....................                                                      ...
                                                                                                           /     ...
                                                                                                             .....j.....                                      80, 000          580, 000       660, 000

Savannah, Ga.:
     5 in casemates .......................                             2,175       $650, 000             325    65, 000                                                       200,   000     915,   000
     8 disappearing and non-disappearing... .-- .........-...                                     ..... -..   ......- .                                                        320,   000     320,   000
    16 mortars-..-........                                           . ...            .....
                                                                                 .......-
                                                                                 ................      .-----       ---                                                         32,   000      32,   000
    Repairs ..............................--------------------------------------
                                                                       ......        ...........--------------.                                                                100,   000     100,   000
                  Total- -........................                         .     2, 175                 650, 000                        325                        65, 000     652, 000     1, 367, 000

Galveston, Tex. :
     8 disappearing and non-disappearing - .......                         -....- -.. - --.-......-
                                                                        ....-                                 ..   $320, 000                                                                 $320, 000
     16 mortars..---.....--..------------...--....---.....-------......------.......----.............--------------32, 000                                                                     32, 000
    Keeps-----------------------------------------------                                          --------          200, 000                                                                  200, 000
          Total.................                        ..----..........----..               ..--         ...          .--            ---                 ......               552,000        552,000

Portland, Oreg.:
     12 disappearing and non-disappearing...                     .         - -...-     ----..---..- _ 480, 000                                                                                480, 000
     7 barbette-----------------------------...............................--.-------------.          105, 000                                                                                105, 000
     32 mortars-------..--..---............------------...----....-----......---..-------------64,000                                                                                          64,000
     Keeps...........................---...--.....--.......             --                            200, 000                                                                                200, 000
          Total ...........................                              ...     ......                ....            ..            .....               ....---- ..           849, 000       849, 000
Pensacola, Fla. :
      2 on lifts .................................                                                                                    .....                $40, 000            160, 000       200, 000
      4 disappearing and non-disappearing. - -....        --- -...........                                                                               ...                   160, 000       160, 000
      Repairs....                                  .....-------------                                                                                --------                  200, 000       200, 000
          Total..............................                                    ............----          -....--..                                         40, 000           520, 000       560, 000
Wilmington, N. C. :
    5 in casemates.. -
    2 on lifts ...................
                                        ..  -..  2, 175...------
                                                            $650, 000      .-
                                                                            325      65, 000                                                                                   200, 000       915, 000
                                                                      .......        40, 000                                                                                   160, 000       200, 000
    2 disappearing and non-disappearing...........        .....---- .      .-   ..---------                                                                                     80, 000        80, 000
    Keeps..............................0...     ....... ..........      ....-- ........                                                              -                         200, 000       200, 000
          Total................................2,                                    175                650, 000                      325                  105, 000            640, 000     1, 395, 000
San Diego, Cal. :
    4 disappearing and non-disappearing.... ..----............                                                              .......                  .........                 160, 000       160, 000
      Keeps ........................................                                                ...........---..                                     .......-              100, 000       100, 000

          Total,-..................................-------..                                 --------                        -----                 ......
                                                                                                                                                 ------..                      260, 000        60, 000
Portsmouth, N. H. :
     8 disappearing and non-disappearing .......-.                                            ............                       ..............         ..                     320, 000       320, 000
    Keeps.................................                                                .....       ........                             ......--......                      100, 000       100, 000
          Total..................................                                 .....             . .......                    .            ....         ........-          420,000         420, 000
Defense of Cumberland Sound, at Fort
  Clinch :
     2 on lifts ................................        ..                                    ...........                        .......                    40, 000            160, 000       200, 000
    2 disappearing and non-disappearing ...................                                                                      ....... ..........                             80, 000        80, 000
          Total ..................................                                             ......                         .....                          40, 000           240, 000       280, 000

Defenses of ports on the Kennebec River,
  Me., at Fort Popham:
    3 disappearing and non-disappearing .....--.-.                                            ....---           -           ....-... -...--                            .       120, 000 i     120, 000
IN
518                REPORT OF THE CHIEF                                                              OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

                          Estimate for                land defenses, exclusive of armament-Continued.


                                                                                                            Iron, wrought and cast.

Number of guns and mortars wanted at dif-                                                                                                                                                                        Cost of ma-             Total
            ferent localities.            Armor, wrought.                                                                                                               Structuralmetal.                         sonry and               cost.
                                                                                                                                                                                                                   earth.

                                                                                        Tons.                                 Cost.                                     Tons.I
                                                                                                                                                                        .   .  I                     Cost.


New Bedford, Mass.:
   3 disappearing and non-disappearing....                                                                                                                                                                           $120, 000          $120, 000
   16 mortars ..................-..-..-.                                                68-..                       ..2.300.0                                                                                           32, 000            32, 000
          Total...--..........-..........                                                                                                                                                                             152,000            152,000
                                                                                        ------- --------.
Defenses of ports on the Penobscot River,
  Me., at Fort Knox:
                                                                                        ............ ...
    3 disappearing and non-disappearing.....                                                                                                                            .......                ...                    120, 000           120,000
New Haven, Conn.:
   3 disappearing and non-disappearing ....                                                                                                                              ..... .......... 120, 000                                        120, 000
      8 mortars....................                                    .....                    ------ ----......                                                       ...... ......      16, 000                                         16, 000
      Keeps-..........................                                                                                                                                                ... 100, 000                                        100, 000
                                                                                                        -       -    -        -   -       -   -   -.-       .   .



          Total..............................                                                                                                                            .............                       -         236, 000          236, 000
          Grand total............................                                       68,     130             $20,300,000                                         12, 350 $3,320,000 31, 863, 000 55, 483, 000


                                                    Estimate for                       armament and mountings.


                                                                                                                                                                    Mor-
                                                                                       Guns.
                                                                                                                                                                        tars.
                                                                                                                                                                                                Cost of
                                                                                                                                                                                                     of
                                                                                                                                                                                                Costand               Cost of     Total
                      Locality.                                                                                                                                                                guns and
                                                                                                                                                                                               mortars.              carriages, ! cost.
                                                                            o    0                                   0a                                         o              o
                                                                            a     a1                                                          a
                                                                            4r I                                     cEI i n                                    U           U          I




New York City ;
     Willets Point.................                                6                   10            5                   5                                      48                         $1, 744, 000               $580, 000 $2, 324, 000
     Narrows, Sandy Hook, Coney
        Island            ....               ........             12           2       30           15               10                                  96                                    4, 283, 000           1, 412, 000       5, 695, 000
San Francisco .....................                               10           4       20           71                5                                 128                                    5, 426, 000           1, 787, 000       7, 213, 000
Boston ..........................                                  8                   10           15               10                                 132                                    2,971,000                970, 000       3, 941, 000
Lake ports :
     Fort Wayne.....                         ............                                               3                3                        4                             8                    188, 000           59, 800           247, 800
     Saint Lawrence River............                                                   2               6                                                                       8                    310, 000          100, 000           410, 000
     Fort Montgomery, Rouse's
        Point.......................                                                                                     4                                                      8                 100, 000              30, 000           130, 000
Hampton Roads................                                      4                   10           20                                    ....                  16                             1, 608, 000             534,000         1, 142, 000
New Orleans (Mississippi River) ...                                                    20                            10                                                                        1, 130. 000             380, 000        1, 510, 000
Philadelphia...................                                                        10               5             5                                         16                                   828, 000          274, 000        1,102,000
Washington (Potomac River)........                                                      7            6                                                                                            512, 000             171, 000           683, 000
Baltimore ............................                                                  5            5                5                                         16                                578, 000             190, 000           768, 000
Portland, Me........................                                                   20           10               10                                         48                             1, 784, 000             587, 000        2, 371, 000
Rhode Island ports (Narragansett
  Bay)...................                        .........         2                   10           10                                                          48         .... 1,                   374, 000          450, 000        1, 824, 000
Key West... ....                 ...-.......              ...      2                   10                                                                       32         ....                      976, 000          320, 000        1, 296, 000
Charleston, S. C .....                         ..........                               8               4                                                       16         ....                      636, 000          210, 000           846, 000
Mobile ..                  .                        .                                  12                            10                                         16         ....                      858, 000          284, 000        1, 142, 000
New London .....................
Savannah...................
Galveston .....................
Portland, Oreg. (mouth Columbia
                                                              ...
                                                                           ...          4
                                                                                        3
                                                                                                        4


                                                                                                        6                4
                                                                                                                         8
                                                                                                                                                                16         ...
                                                                                                                                                                                                     308, 000
                                                                                                                                                                                                     492, 000
                                                                                                                                                                                                     232, 000
                                                                                                                                                                                                                       103, 000
                                                                                                                                                                                                                       162, 000
                                                                                                                                                                                                                        75,000
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          411, 000
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          654, 000
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          307, 000
  River).......                .................                                                    12                   7                                      32         ....                      671, 000          219, 000           890, 000
Pensacola ......................                                                            2           4                                                                                            208, 000           71, 000           279, 000
Wilmington, N. C................                                                            4           5                                                                                            335, 000          112, 000           447, 000
San Diego, Cal.................                                                                         4                                                                                            100, 000           36, 000           144, 000
Portsmouth, N. H...............                                                             4.          4                                                                                            308, 000          103, 000           411, 000
Defenses of Cumberland Sound at
  FortClinch.....................-.                                                         2       2                                             .                                                  154,000            52, 000           206, 000
Defenses of ports on the Kennebec
  River, Maine, at Fort Popham.                                                                                                                                     8....
                                                                                                                                                                                                      81, 000           27, 000           108, 000
New Bedford, Mass..----..-..........                                                                                                                                                                 167, 000           53, 000           220, 000
Defenses of ports on the Penobscot
  River, Maine, at Fort Knox...                                                                                                                                                                       81, 000           27, 000           108, 000
New Haven, Conn...................                                                                          .            3....                                                                       103, 000           33, 000           136, 000
                                                              t   --    7          1    -       i    --         I        --           t                 I           -     I-       -       I                     I         .. .    I

                                                                               6 203 222 102                                                      4 700                     24 28, 554, 000                          9, 411, 800       37, 965, 000
          Total

                    ~
                    ------------------"--.444

                                                                       I           I-
               APPENDIX                               3-REPORT                                    OF BOARD ON FORTIFICATIONS.                                                                        519

                                             Estimate for                         floating batteries, including armament.


                                                                                                                               Number of                     Total num-
                                                                                                                               guns each.                            ber         of
                                                                                                                      S
                                                                                                                    Locality.                                          guns.               Cost of ships
                                               Locality.                                                             "and                                                                       a
                                                                                                                                    .. a            .        ,           ,                  armament.




New Orleans...................................-------------------------------------....---                                     2        ...             1        4       ..           2    $8,150, 000 00
San Francisco                     ......................................                                               3            .         2         2   ....             6        6    10, 725, 000 00

          Total      .............................................                                                     5        2             2         3        4           6        8        18, 875,00 00



                                                Estimatefor                           submarine mines and their adjuncts.


                                                                                                                           operating                        Electric lights,
                                                                                 Submarine mines.
                                                                                                                          ro oms, &c.                          complete.

                                                                                                                                                                                                  Grand
                    Seaport.                                                                                                                                                                      total.


                                                                                                                                                                   P                  U

                                                                                560         690        $241, 500           5   $50,               000            20           $120, 000           $411, 500
                                                                                461          589        206, 150           7   120,               000            28            168, 000            494, 150
Boston-           ---................                                           185          215         75, 250            5   50,               000            20            120, 000            245, 250
Lake ports.....................                                                             200
                                                                                            ..           70, 000                40,               000            16             96, 000            206, 000
Hampton    Roads
    ces---...............                                                  ......              00       140, 000                20,               000             8             48, 000            208, 000
Mississippi River..............                                        ......               150          52, 500                30,               000             8             48, 000            130, o00
                                                                                215            35        12, 250              3 30,               000            12             72, 000            114, 250
Washington .....................                                                            ....
                                                                                             150         52,500             5   2 0,              000             8             48, 000            120, 500
Baltimore.....................                                                              .....00      35,000            11   10,               000             4             24, 000             69, 000
Portland.on   ..................                                                             350        122, 500           4    60,               000            16             96, 000            278, 500
Narragansett Bay, both en-
  trances ....................                                                              300         105, 000                20,
                                                                                                                                2 000                             8               48, 000          173, 000
Key Weston........................                                                          150          52, 500           1    10, 000                           4               24, 000           86, 500
Charleston..................... ......                                                      150          52, 500               110, 000                           4               24, 000           86, 500
Mobile.---------------------                                                      .....     300         105, 000            1   15, 000                           4               24, 000          144, 000
New London_..-                                                                              150          52,500               3 45, 000                          12               72, 000          169, 500
Savannah.                        ---                                                        300         105, 000           3 3 45, 000                           12               72, 000          222, 000
Galveston...------------                                                                    150          52, 000           1 1 15, 000                            4               24,000            91, 500
Pensacola-.-.------_                                                                        200          70,000             1 1 15, 000                           4               24, 000          109, 000
Portsmouth ...................                                                              161          56, 350           22   30, 000                           8               48, 000          134, 350
Ten minor ports defended by
  existing works .............                                                                                                                                                                     840, 000

          Total ..........                           ......                1, 421         4, 740      1, 659, 000         50 S 635, 000                      200             1, 200, 000         4, 334, 000
                                                                                  --

                                                                                Estimate for torpedo boats.


                                                                                                                           Torpedo                          gunboats.Torpedo
                                                                                                                                                                  gunboats.
                                                       Locality.                                                                                                                                  Cost.
                                                                                                                           Number Number
                                                                                                                          of groups. of boats.


1.   New York..---.---------......---------.......-..--.---.............--.--.---------                                                  3                        18 .----........ $1, 080, 000
2.   San Francisco -...---.........                       ...........................                                                    3                        18 .......         1,080, 000
3.   Boston.....---.---------...............-----.....--.--.--....................------------------                                     3                        18     .       -   1, 080, 000
4.   The lake ports ..--..---.........----------.....----..--.......------...-----........-----                                                                                  12     720, 000
5.   Hampton Roads ...----....................................                                                                           3                        18          ...... 1, 080, 000
6.   New Orleans .---..------------..-----------..------------                                                                           2                        12                    720, 000
7.   Philadelphia.........................                                   ...............                                             1                         6                    360, 000
8.   Portland, Me ...---...-----                                                                                                         1                         6 ..........         360, 000
9.   Rhode Island ports in Narragansett Bay......---                                               - -......                             1                         6 ........           360, 000
10.   Key West .             -------------------------------------                                                                        1                          6                             360,000
11.   Charleston, S. C ---..---.-----.                             ------------..-----                                                    1                         6 --....-...-                  360, 000
12. New London                  ----....---..-                   ...............................-----                                     3                        18 .....                     1, 080, 000
13. Portland, Oreg ---...---..........-----------.............----..........-....--                                                       3                        18     ..                    1,080, 000

          Total.------..-..                 .-----.....----..---------..------------..-..--....                                         25                       150                      12    9, 720, 000
520     REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

PRACTICAL MEASURES       FOR OBTAINING THE APPLIANCES FOR DE-
                                 FENSE.

   There is no difficulty in procuring from the resources of our own coun-
try all the appliances for defense except guns and steel armor.
   There are two, and only two, methods by which modern guns and
armor can be procured. These are, first, by direct purchase from the
immense establishments now existing abroad, or, second, by domestic
manufacture.
   The workshops of Europe, with all their facilities for turning out this
material, are now fully occupied by the demands upon them. They are,
in fact, expanding every day. Experience has shown that the few ex-
perimental orders already given from this country are filled only after
long delays; and it is impossible to estimate the time required for the
delivery of the large quantities we urgently need. Moreover, war would
at once put a stop to such importations and leave us helpless in the emer-
gency. The disbursement abroad of the large sums involved in these
purchases would not be profitable to this country. On the other hand,
if spent here, they would encourage home industries, promote the na-
tional wealth, and render our defenses independent of other countries.
For these reasons the Board cannot too strongly condemn a resort to
foreign purchases.
   What, then, are the facilities for procuring these supplies in our own
country ?
   None but the best crucible or open-hearth steel, possessing certain
well-known physical qualities, is suitable for gun manufacture; and the
ingots must be forged by hydraulic presses or under hammers of power
far exceeding any here existing. The Board is entirely in favor of
presses.
   After a careful study of the extensive plant required for the produc-
tion of steel-gun forgings and armor-plates of sizes, thicknesses, and
qualities suitable for such manufacture, and after an inspection of our
principal works and foundries, the conclusion is forced upon the Board
that the necessary facilities for the production of such large masses of
steel, and the machines for fashioning this metal into guns and armor,
are not now to be found in this country.
   At the Midvale Steel Works, Philadelphia, at the Cambria Steel
Works, Johnstown, and elsewhere, plant is available for 6-inch and
probably 8-inch forgings of       quality not surpassed by the best made
abroad. But the 8-inch gun is the very smallest recommended for ex-
tensive use in our forts; so that, practically, this plant would have to be
made anew to meet the demand for larger calibers.
   It is clear that to effect the object of the act of Congress under which
this Board was appointed, the manufacture and tempering of steel in
enormous masses must be provided for by Congressional legislation.
   The same can be said of the large and extensive workshops, and tools
for machining the steel.
   The Board, basing its estimates upon the report of the Gun Foundry
Board, considered that, to accomplish the work and accomplish it well,
the plant necessary for making the tempered steel for the parts of guns
up to the largest calibers will cost about $850,000, and that the plant
for fabricating such guns will cost about $900,000-this sum being ex-
clusive of expenditures necessary to arm the Navy.
  The vital question then arises, In what manner can such steel works
and machine shops be best created ?
       APPENDIX       3-REPORT OF BOARD ON FORTIFICATIONS.                           521

   It cannot be expected that even the richest and most flourishing of
our steel works, with millions of capital to uphold it, will venture such
an amount of money in plant, merely in the doubtful hope that the Gov-
ernment may give a contract sufficiently large to save it from loss.
   Business men know that the action of one Congress does not control
the action of subsequent Congresses, and that, unless the appropriation
is made permanent, running through several years, pledging the United
States to such an expenditure, there is no certainty as to the future, and
the risk is far greater than the chances of profit.
   After due consideration of the subject this Board indorses the con-
clusions of the Gun-Foundry Board, contained in the supplementary
report of December 20, 1884, as follows, viz:
  The question whether the fabrication can be better and more economically per-
formed in Government establishments, or by private contract, or by a combined sys
tem has been carefully considered, and the Board has been unable to discover any
reason to modify the unanimous opinion expressed in its report of February 16, 1884,
that " it is more judicious to establish gun factories" ; that there should be " two gun
factories under the control of the Government, and that the Army and Navy should
be provided with separate establishments."
  The requirements of the two services in this respect are sufficiently
distinct to justify two separate establishments, which, in the interests
of the national defense, would be fully occupied for many years to
come-probably long enough to exhaust their capacity for good work.
  An appropriation, therefore, of $1,000,000 for a factory is recom-
mended, and should be made at once, as it would require about two
years to erect and equip it.  The money required for machinery and
completing the guns at the factory could be appropriatedin the following
year, when the forgings would be about ready for delivery.
  Again this Board quotes from and indorses the report of the Gun-
Foundry Board:
  The Board repeats its unanimous opinion " that the steel manufacturers should be
called upon to provide the material," and recommends-
  (1) An appropriation of not less than $15,000,000-one-half for the Army and one-
half for the Navy-to remain available until expended; provided, however, that none
of the money so appropriated shall be expended except in payment for steel accepted
and delivered.
   (2) Proposals to be issued by the War and Navy Departments for bids for the sup-
ply of the steel required by each, rough-bored, rough-turned, tempered, and conform-
ing to specifications. Said proposals shall divide the steel required into two lots.
Each lot shall include all the parts for one-half of the number of guns of each caliber.
Each bid must include all of a lot or lots. Each bidder shall agree to deliver yearly
a specified quantity of each caliber, the time of delivery of the smaller calibers to com-
mence at the expiration of not more than eighteen months, and that of the largest
calibers at the expiration of not more than three years from the date of acceptance of
the contract. Each bidder shall specify the price of the parts for each of the several
calibers. This price may be modified by the Government in equity according to the
current rates of labor and material.
  (3) Bids to be considered must be made by responsible parties, each of which shall
certify and guarantee to erect in the United States a suitable plant capable of making
all the steel required and of finishing it in accordance with the contract.
  From personal intercourse with prominent steel makers in the United States the
Board is in a position to assert that proposals issued on the above basis will be re-
sponded to, but that it will be necessary to appropriate the entire amount recom-
mended in order to induce responsible steel manufacturers to erect and complete the
plants to produce the steel for the guns needed for national defense.
  The above proposition contains only such a guarantee as would be required by
business men embarking in a new and expensive undertaking.
  In the matter of procuring the needful supply of armor, the Board
does not consider that specific recommendations are required. Armor
plates of moderate dimensions can now be fabricated in this country,
and the demand for steel armor for naval purposes, joined to that for
522     REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

guns, and perhaps for turrets, will, it is believed, afford all needful en-
couragement to induce our steel manufacturers to procure the plant.

                   RECAPITULATION OF ESTIMATES.

  The following consolidated estimate presents the cost of defending
our entire sea-coast and lake frontier upon the plan recommended by
the Board; and also that for defending the eleven ports where the ex-
penditure is most urgently required. The cost of machine guns, am-
munition, transportation, and for proving guns and armor is not in-
cluded, because somewhat indefinite in character, although not very
great. The appropriations will be asked for as needed by the proper
Departments :
                                                                                                                                Consolidated estimate.

                                                                                                                               Land defenses.                                       Arma ment.
                                                                                                                                                                                                               fflnaaiirr      Snmrine


                                                                                                                                                                                                         batteries               mines             Torpedo-          Total.
                                                    Port.                                                     Masonry                                                                                   and their              and their            boats.                           b
                                                                                                             and earth - Armor.                          Structural
                                                                                                                                                           metal.
                                                                                                                                                                              Guns and
                                                                                                                                                                               mortars.
                                                                                                                                                                                             Carriages. armament.              adjuncts.                                             C


                                                                                                               work.
     i
1       New York...........................................                                                  $5, 488, 000 $7,950,000 $1, 000,000 $6,027,000 $1, 992, 000 ........... $411, 500 $1, 080, 000                                                       $23, 948,500      H
2       San Francisco...                ...............................                                       5, 656, 00 0       2, 250, 000                450, 000   5, 426, 000 1, 787, 000 $10, 725,000          494, 150    1, 080,000                        27, 868, 150     0
3       Boston ..........................................................                                     2, 214, 000        3,100,000                  330, 000 i 2, 971, 000    970, 000 ........          -   245, 250    1,080,000                         10, 910, 250     0
4       The Lake ports ............                 ..... ...... ....          .....                          1, 648, 000            650, 000               125, 000      598, 000    189, 800 ............          206,000       *720, 000                        4, 136,800
5       Hampton Roads....                  ............................                                       1, 632, 00 0       2, 200, 000                230, 000   1, 608,000     534, 000 ...........           208, 000    1, 080, 000                        7,492, 000
6       New Orleans ...       -- ------------------------................................--                   1, 200, 000 ...............                      ----    1, 130,000     380,000     8,150,000          130,500         720,000                       11, 710, 500
7       Philadelphia ...              ................................                                           832, 00 0       1,300,000                  130, 000 1    828, 000    274, 000 .. ...........        114, 250        360, 000                       3, 838, 250     C
8       Washington ............................................                                                  520, 00 )0 ..            .................               512, 000    171, 000 ..           ......   120, 500 ............                          1, 323, 500
9       Baltimore ...................... ........................                                                632, 00)0           650, 000                65, 000      578, 000    190, 000 ...........            69, 000                -----------....        2, 184, 000     0
10       Portland, Me ..........................................                                               2, 096, 00 )0 ............                    200, 000   1, 784, 000    587, 000 ..........---      .. 278, 500        360, 000                       5, 305, 500
11       Narragansett Bay ......................................                                               1, 296, 00 0           450, 000               150, 000   1,374,000      450, 000 ......-..... 173,000                  360, 000                       4, 253, 000     0
               Total of above 11 ports .............................                                         23, 214, 000 18, 550, 000                     2, 680,    000     22, 836, 000    7, 524, 800 18, 875, 000              2,450, 650      6, 840, 000    102, 970, 450     0
12       Key West ...........................................                                               .1, 064, 000             450, 000                 150,    000         976, 000       320, 000 ...........                  86,500           360, 000      3,406, 500
13       Charleston..............................................                                                 872, 000 ...........-                        80,
                                                                                                                                                               80,
                                                                                                                                                                      000
                                                                                                                                                                      000
                                                                                                                                                                                  636, 000
                                                                                                                                                                                  858, 000
                                                                                                                                                                                                 210, 000 ..........
                                                                                                                                                                                                 284, 000 .....             ... ...
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       86,500           360, 000
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      144, 000 ............
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      2,244,500
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      2, 738, 000
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     z
14       Mobile...................................................                                             1, 372, 000 ..............                                                                                                                                            d
15       New London ............................................                                                  580, 000 ............                        80,    000         308, 000       103, 000 ...            ........     169, 500      1, 080, 000       2, 320, 500
16       Savannah.........................                     .......     .................                        652, 000             650, 000                65, 000         492, 000        162, 000 ........            ...     222, 000 ............           2, 243, 000
17       Galveston..............................................                                                    552, 000 ....................                                232, 000         75, 000 ..                  ..       91,500 ...........                 950, 500
18       Portland, Oreg ...................................                                                         849, 000 ............                    .........           671,000         219, 000        ..---..              100, 000      1, 080, 000       2, 919, 000    H
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     O
19       Pensacola.................                                      ........................                   520, 000                  .........             40, 00       208, 000         71, 000 ...                  ...    109, 000 ...........                948, 000
20       Wilmington, N. C.....                        .............             ....................                640, 000           650, 000                   105, 000       335, 000        112, 000 ..             ....         100, 000                       .........
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      1, 942, 000
21       San Diego ...                ..................................                              ..            260, 000 .................                                   108, 000         36, 000 ............                100, 000 ..............             504, 000
22       Portsmouth, N. H ......................................                                                    420, 000                                                     308, 000        103, 000............                 134, 350 ...........                965, 350   O
23       Cumberland Sound .__..........................................                                             240, 000                                        40, 000      154, 000         52, 000 ............                150, 000 ............               636, 000
24       Kennebec River. ........................................                                                   120, 000 ...........                            ....          81, 000         27, 000. ............                70,000 ............                298, 000   H



25       New Bedford ......                .....................................                                    152, 000 ...               _............                     167, 000         53, 000 ............                150, 000 ...... ..                  522, 000   ©
26       Penobscot River..............................120,                                           ............        000.............                                         81, 000         27, 000 ............                 70, 000 ............               298, 000
27       New Haven ..............................................                                                   236, 000      ........................                       103, 000         33, 000 ............                100, 000 ............               472, 000   y



                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     FH  H




                 Grand total of 27 ports .................................                                    31, 863, 000          20, 300, 000             , 320, 000       28, 554, 000    9, 411, 800     18, 875, 000       4, 334,000        9, 720, 000     126,377, 800

                                                                                                                                   * Torpedo gunboats.
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         12
524         REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

   A comparison can now be made of the estimates for modern works
with those made in 1840, when the old system of coast defense had re-
ceived considerable development and was being pressed toward com-
pletion. The population of the country at that time was 17,000,000,
and the estimate of cost, including the amounts already expended, was
$57,131,541, being at the rate of $3.35 per head.
   The population in 1880 was 50,000,000, and the estimate for the coast
defense is $126,377,800, at the rate of $2.52 per head.
   The valuation of property in 1880 was $43,642,000,000; that of 1840
was about $4,000,000,000, and it is to be seen that the ratio of the esti-
mate for defenses to the wealth of the country at the present time ex-
hibits a still more favorable comparison.
   In 1840 the cost of the line-of-battle ship, then representing the most
formidable means of attack against coast defenses, was about $550,000,
and the cost of the corresponding war ship of the present day is about
$5,000,000. While the ships have increased in cost nine-fold, the esti-
mate of the defenses to resist these has increased only between two and
three fold.
   Certain portions only of the whole amount above indicated as neces-
sary are needed at once, viz:
   A. An appropriation for gun steel sufficient to induce contracting
steel works to prepare for and begin the manufacture of steel forgings
for guns of all calibers, $8,000,000.
   B. An appropriation for a gun factory with plant sufficient to ma-
chine, assemble, and finish the guns, $1,000,000.
   C. An appropriation to inaugurate the building of masonry founda-
tions, engine-rooms, shell-rooms, magazines, &c., necessary to the recep-
tion of the armor, guns, &c., $4,000,000 for the first year and $2,000,-
000 annually thereafter until completed.
   D. An appropriation for armor and structural metal, $2,000,000 an-
nually until completed.
   E. An appropriation for gun-carriages, $1,000,000 annually until
completed.
   F. An appropriation for the building of floating batteries, the type
to be selected by a joint board of Army and Navy officers, $3,000,000
for the first year and $2,000,000 annually until completed.
   G. An appropriation for submarine mines and their adjuncts,
$1,000,000 for the first year and $500,000 annually thereafter until com-
pleted.
   H. An appropriation for building torpedo-boats, $1,500,000 annually
until all are built.
   Summing up these recommendations, the Board presents the follow-
ing project for annual appropriations:
                                                     Appropriationsrecommended.

                                                                                                                              Appropria-       Future annual
                                                Purpose.                                                                      tion for first   appropriations
                                                                                                                                               until work is
                                                                                                                                 year.           completed.


A. Gun metal --
             ....               ..............              ...        ..      .. ---------------------
                                                                                   .. -- ... ...               ....      .     $8, 000, 000 .............
B. Gun factory. ...                     .          ...            ..      ..           ...      .      ...                       1 000, 000 .............
                                                                                                                                 i,
C. Masonry, &c            --......................---                   ...           ..........       .. .   ..        . .      4, 000, 000           $2, 000, 000
D. Armor, &c           ...... ----------------------------------------------
                                                      .....---                                                                   2, 000, 000           2, 000, 000
E. Gun-carriages-..         -. ..-      .. ..      .1.. -                   -......
                                                                               .          ..............      .......           1, 000, 000            1, 000, 000
F. Floating batteries ..- ---.--..----...      ..                           ......         ..  ..   ...                  .       3, 000, 000           2, 000, 000
G. Submarine mines, &c ..------------                                                     ..............                         1, 000, 000              500, 000
H. Torpedo-boats.     ---.    -.-..--.--
                                    .     .......                              .......... ....                                   1, 500, 000           1, 500, 000
       Totals ......       ......         ... -          -... ........                              ...... ..........           21, 500, 000            9, 000, 000
      APPENDIX    3--REPORT     OF BOARD ON FORTIFICATIONS.           525

   After mature consideration, and with all the information before it,
the Board is of opinion and recom mends that the above-named amounts
should be appropriated by Congress without delay, for the purposes
mentioned, and it further states that nothing less will suffice even for
a beginning.
   In order to enable the Department to carry out this large project with-
out delay, it is suggested that the present laws requiring advertising for
bids and making contracts should be materially modified. Contracts
should be made to continue for a series of years,and smaller purchases
should be made in open market. Under the present laws it is impos-
sible at times to carry on the work intrusted to the Department, and
not infrequently unnecessary expenditures arise without accruing ad-
vantages.
                                              WM. C. ENDICOTT,
                            Secretary of War, President of the Board.
                                             S. V. BENEIT,
                   Brigadier-General, Chiefof Ordinance, U. S. Army.
                                               JOHN NEWTON,
                    Brigadier-General, Chief of Engineers, U. S. Army.
                                              HENRY L. ABBOT,
                          Lieutenant-Colonel of Engineers, U. S. Army.
                                               CHAS. S. SMITH,
                                     Captain of Ordnance, U. S. Army.
                                               W. T. SAMPSON,
                                               Commander U. S. Navy.
                                               C. F. GOODRICH,
                                              Commander, U. S. Navy.
                                              Jos. MORGAN, Jr.
                                              ERASTUS CORNING.
  EDW'D MAGUIRE,
      Captainof Engineers, U. S. Army, Secretary of the Board.
  WASHINGTON, D. C., January 16, 1886.
               RIVERS AND HARBORS, ETC.



                                APPENDIX A.



IMPROVEMENT OF RIVERS AND HARBORS IN THE STATES OF MAINE AND
                      NEW HAMPSHIRE.




REPORT OF MAJOR JARED A. SMITH, CORPS OF ENGINEERS, OFFICER
IN CHARGE, FOR THE FISCAL YEAR ENDING JUNE 30, 1886, WITH OTHER
DOCUMENTS RELATING TO THE WORKS.

                                 IMPROVEMENTS.

1. Lubec Channel, Maine.                     7. Kennebunk River, Maine.
2. Bangor Harbor and Penobscot River,        8. Breakwater at mouth of Saco River,
     Maine.                                       Maine.
3. Moose-a-bee Bar, Maine.                   9. Saco River, Maine.
4. Belfast Harbor, Maine.                   10. Portsmouth Harbor, New Hampshire.
5. Rockland Harbor, Maine.                  11. Cocheco River, New Hampshire.
6. Portland Harbor, Maine.

                         EXAMINATION       AND SURVEY.

                               12. Saco River, Maine.




                                UNITED STATES ENGINEER             OFFICE,
                                                Portland, Me., July 26, 1886.
  SIR: I inclose herewith annual reports for the works of river and
harbor improvement in my charge for the fiscal year ending June 30,
1886.
       Very respectfully, your obedient servant,
                                                        JARED A.     SMITH,
                                                           Major of Engineers.
  The CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. A.



                                        A I.

                IMPROVEMENT OF LUBEC CIHIANNEL, MAINE.

  The situation and original condition of this channel was described in
the last annual report, as follows:
  Lubec Channel forms the eastern boundary of the State of Maine, between the town
of Lubec and Campobello Island. For a length of 2 miles (i. e., from about 850 feet
below the " Western Bar Beacon" to the head of " Lubec Narrows") it was obstructed by
                                                                            527
528      REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

barahaving for the most part only 5 feet at mean low water, or 22 feet at mean high
water, the mean rise and fall of the tides being 17 feet, while at extreme low water of
spring tides there was but 1 foot over the shoalest parts. At and near mean low
water, therefore, vessels were unable to pass through this channel, and were forced
to make a detour some 16 miles longer through British waters in order to reach Lubec,
Eastport, Knd the points in Maine on the Saint Croix and Pembroke rivers. The same
loss of time and distance occurred on the return trip; vessels leaving the upper ports,
necessarily about high water, reached the channel near low water.
   At the beginning of the fiscal year a contract was outstanding with
Messrs. Moore & Wright, of Portland, Me., for widening the new chan-
nel by dredging. Work under this contract was completed July 11,
1885, the amount dredged after July 1st being 5,792 cubic yards, scow
measurement. The result of this work has been to add 48 feet to the
width of channel in the lower bend, the depth of entire channel at mean
low water being 12 feet.
   The channel now has a clear width of 200 feet throughout, with a
maximum width of 278 feet at the lower bend.
   The present project, for which estimates were submitted in the annual
reports for 1883 and 1884, contemplates the deepening of the channel
to 15 feet at mean low water, and giving a clear width of 275 feet, with
300 feet at the bends. It has, however, been considered desirable to
apply any available funds in such way as to give the entire width men-
tioned before undertaking the increase in depth, so that the estimate
in the last annual report covered the increased width only.
   To complete that portion of the project for increasing the width of
channel requires the removal of about 69,000 cubic yards of material,
measured in scows. While the channel now gives a depth of 12 feet
at mean low water, the variations are so great that a minimum depth
of 8 feet occurs at extreme low tides. No vessel can pass through
drawing the extreme depth of water, and in such rapid currents as here
obtain in a narrow channel, even the best steamers must have 2 or more
feet of water under their keels to permit their handling with safety.
   The benefits to navigation and to commerce from the improvement
are not local. The channel forms a part of a thoroughfare to and from
the Saint Croix River and the waters of the Passamaquoddy Bay, and
is not only the shortest route and the only channel not exposed to the
open sea, but is the only one in American waters through which vessels
can reach many points on our eastern border.
   During heavy gales many vessels find refuge and anchorage in the
lower part of Quoddy Roads; in such cases, when the wind changes to
the eastward there is no longer any protection, and no escape save by
the Lubec Channel, which must afford a sufficient draught of water at
all times to make it effective. Before the improvement was undertaken
many vessels were thus hemmed in and wrecked. (See Report of Chief
of Enugineers, 1879, Appendix A, page 281.)
   Save for use in the fisheries, the smaller vessels are gradually dis-
appearing fromn the coast, as they cannot compete in the carrying of
freights with vessels of larger capacity, so that deeper channels will be
required in future than those heretofore necessary.
   The recommendations previously made to dredge the channel to a
depth of 15 feet are therefore renewed.
   Owing to the range of tides, the rapid currents and fogs which are
encountered, together with the small amounts heretofore made avail-
able for work in a single season and the remote situation, the average
contract price for dredging in this channel has been 41.4 cents per
cubic yard, scow measurement. The placing and maintenance of nu-
                  APPENDIX A---REPORT OF MAJOR SMITH.                                  529
merous guide riles and other contingent expenses add a considerable
percente a t, the cost.
   The orig mal ~)roject for this improvement, submitted in annual re-
port for 1801), was to give a clear width of 200 feet, throughout, and a
a low water depth of 12 feet. The estimated cost was $48,000 (incor-
rectly printed in report as $47,000). This was made on a basis of 20
cents per cubic yard(, for the material removed from the shoals, and 50
cents, per yard, for material in the narrows; the material in the nar-
rows cost by contract $1 per yard, and the average p'rice for the re-
mainder has cost, by contract, more than twice as much for material
measured in scows as was estimated for the same, in situ. For the
reasons here given, the estimate was successively amended in 1880,
1881, and 1882, the last named placing cost of the original project at
$154,000 (Report of Chief of Engineers, 1882, Appendix A 2, page
487). In 1883 it became apparent that the width of 200 feet was in-
sufficient and that a greater depth was required, owing to the larger
class and greater number of vessels attracted to the route. Upon the
request of the International Steamship Company a project was sub-
mitted increasing the channel width to 275 feet, with an addition of 25
feet at the bends, and deepening the water to 15 feet. The estimated
expense of this increase in width and (lepth. was $113,000 (Report of
Chief of Engineers, 1883, Appendix A 1, page 409). The estimate for
increased width and depth of channel was based upon a price of 35
cents per cubic yard, measured in situ; this price will probably be
found too small, the average price by contract having been heretofore
nearly 42 cents, for material measured in scows, and the latter meas-
urement exceeds that in situ, from 20 per cent. to 30 per cent. It should
be added that the estimates have been necessarily based upon continu-
ous work, the failure of which has tended largely to increase the con-
tract prices, as well as the contingent exlpenses.
   The following appropriations have been made for this work:
                               --
By act of March 3, 1879......-...... .........----------------..--
                                                                ---....--..-       $44, 000
                                                                   ......----....-....-----..
By act ot June 14, 180 ------......-----......----....--                       20, 000
                                                                ----..--......---....
                                            --....--------..--.............------
By act of March 3, 1881......     --....
                                      ....  -.....
                                                --......
                                                     ... ................... 45, 000
By act of August 2, 1882---.......---------                                 -20, 000
                                      ..--...------..---.........--......--....---....--....
By act of J uly 5, 1884 ....------
                             ......--   ---- -..........------......
                                   ------......                      ....... 10, 000
                                                              - -....------
                                                       ......------....
      Total------
           ............-----..........--------
                                ....--
                                     ----...-..---....-                          139, 000
                                                                  -..........-----....--.......
  The total expenditures to June 30, 1886, have been $139,000.
  It is estimated that, to complete the project, there will be required
the following amounts:
To complete the width, dredging 69,000 cubic yards (scow measurement), at
  42 cen s---------
           ....               ----....-----............-------..
                    --......--------....---......                         $28,980
                                                            ....----........----
                                                       --..........----..----
80 guide-piles, at $5 .......................................................             400
Engineering and contingent expenses................-......................             3, 120

      Total for channel 12 feet deep ....................................... 32,500
  The depths in the channel are somewhat irregular, so that, although
but 12 feet of water are available, the amount in places is considerably
greater. To increase this so as to give a low-water depth of 15 feet it is
estimated will require dredging--
240,000 cubic yards, in scow, at 42 cents ........     ....................          $100,800
Dredging Narrows, 21,000 cubic yards, in situ, at $1          ........................ 21,000
140 guiide- piles, at $5 ..-----.....---..--..........---...........
                                                            ...............-----....      700
Engineering and contingent expenses ...............             .......... ........ 12, 500

                                                                                 135,000
      Total....--..--....---..--..----......--.......... ....................--------------....
        34 E
530           REPORT           OF THE             CHIEF             OF    ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

  Of the above amounts $50,000 could be advantageously expended in
one year.
   Lubec Channel is situated in the collection district of Passamaquoddy. The nearest
port of entry is at Eastport, Me., about 3 miles above, at which place Fort Sullivan
is situated. The nearest light-house is on West Quoddy Head, about 4 miles below.
  The appended letter received in reply to inquiries from this office
cover all the commercial statistics which can at present be obtained.

                                                   Money statement.
July 1, 1885, amount available..................                    ......................                                             $3, 039 29
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885 .----.........        .. ............--.                  ----...............                                3, 039 29

Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886 .........                                                         .......           10,000 00


   Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 188                                                           50, 000 00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
     harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.



                                               COMMERCIAL STATISTICS.

                                                  CUSTOM HOUSE, EASTPORT, ME.,
                                                          Collector's Office, April 8, 1886.
Statement of American and .foreign vessels arrired and cleared, imports and exports, and
     number of vessels built in the district duricg the year ending December 31, 1x85.


                                             Shipping.                                                                 Number.          Tonnage.

American vessels arrived from foreign ports ...................................                                                  385       167. 231
American vessels cleared for foreirn norts ................................................                                      426       171, 358
Foreign vessels arrived from foreign ports.........            .............    ...............                                  258        12, 950
Foreign vessels cleared for foreign ports ....................................                                                   258        12, 950
Vessels built................      ......  ....................................                                                    2             16


Value of exports                                                                        ..............                                  $405, :112
Value of imports...... ...... ...... ..................                                   ..................                   576, 651
                                                                                          *                          N. B. NUTT,
                                                                                                                            Collector.



                                                                 A   2.

  IMPROVEMENT OF BANGOR HARBOR AND PENOBSCOT RIVER, MAINE.

  Various improvements have been made to the navigation or the Penob-
scot River since 1870, under appropriations made in the following acts
of Congress:
Act    approved       July 11, 1870..............................
                                                   ----------------..................                                                    $15, 000
Act    approved       March 3, 1871 ...............................................                                                       50,000
Act    aplproved      July 10, 1872.. ...........................................                                                         40,000
Act    approv, d      March 3, 1873...............................................                                                        20, 000
Act    approved       Junie 23, 1874 ............................................                                                          20, 000
Act approved March 3, 1875 ...............................................                                                                25,000
Act approved August 14, 1876 ..........................................                                                                   10,000
Act approved June 1, 1878 ..............................................                                                                  12,000
Act approved March 3, 1879............ ...............                                     .                     .............              6, 000
         Total..............                  ...................                                        ................                196, 000
                APPENDIX A-REPORT              OF MAJOR SMITH.                    531
   On the 1st July, 1880, the entire amount of the above appropriations
had been expended, antd the projects were completed.
   No original project was ever made comprising all the improvements
for which appropriations were made and expended; but various projects
were carried out as the occasion arose. A summary of the work accom-
plished was given in Annual Report for 1880, as follows:
   1. To straightening, deepening, and widening the channel through the several shoals
at Bangor and below for a distance of 3 nmiles, so as to have a width of not less than
200 feet aud a depth of not less than 11 feet at low water (or 25 feet at high water)
in its lowest stages, giving about 14 feet at low water in its ordinary stages.
   2. To breaking up and removing all the sunken ledges and bowlders in the harbor
of Bangor outside the main channel down to the level of the general bed of the river,
including Independence Rock, Gnlliver's Rock, the ledge near steamboat wharf, and
those near Dole's Wharf, Green's Pier Ledge, and a ledge outside of it; also the ledges
and bowlders in front of the wharves at High Head,         The accompanying sketch of
Bangor Harbor shows the several improvements made in that harbor, but not those
below, near Stearn's Mill, in Hampden.
   3. To removing by dredging the middle ground in Bucksport Harbor, 18 miles below
Bangor, to a depth for the most part of 12 feet at meau low water, as shown on the
accompanying sketch of the same.
   The work carried on for the improvement of this river during the fiscal year end-
ing June 30, 1880, has been applied to the completion of the removal of all sunken
ledges in front of High Head Wharves, under an extended contract made August 7,
1878, with Mr. Isaac Hamilton, of Portland, Me. This work was commenced by him
oh the 11th of July, 1479, and continued without interruption until its completion on
the 31st of October, 1879, whereby all the work hitherto projected for the improve-
ment of this river, both at Bangor and Bucksport, has been completed, so that no
further appropriation is asked therefor.
   In the river and harbor act of 1882 a survey was ordered with special
reference to the improvement of the river near Bangor, Me., and a
special report on the subject was printed in Senate Ex. Doc. No. 44,
Forty-eighth Congress, first session (see Report of Chief of Engineers
for 1884, Appendix A, page 476). The improvement was to widen the
channel opposite Bangor, and at Crosby's Narrows, 3J miles below.
The amount estimated to complete the improvement recommended was
$75,000.
   The act of July 5, 1884, appropriated for the purpose the sum of
$20,000. Proposals for the tlredging received and opened on the 28th
of April, 1885, were rejected as too high. Advertisemenits were again
issued Junie 20, 1885, and niew proposals were opened July 13, 1885.
A contract for dlre(lging 40,000 cubic yards, more or less, at 36 cents,
was matle July 20, 1885, with Messrs. Moore & Wright of Port land, Me.
The work was commenced August 15 and completed November 15, 185.
   Under this contract the channel in harbor of Bangor was wilened 100
feet by dredging on the east (Brewer) side for a length of 2,728 feet,
the excavation being made to a depth of 11 feet at extreme low water.
The total amount expended for the purpose has been $19,950.68. The
resulting channel for navigation and anchorage is 300 feet in wi(lth, so
that the handling of vessels can now be accomplished with vastly greater
convenience and safety than before. The numerous rafts of luimber,
sailing vessels, steamers, and tows make it essential that the channel
should be wide, and the completion of the last project is therefore reconm-
mended.
   The further work contemplated consists in completing the widening of
channel at Bangor, and increasing the width at Crosby's Narrows. It
is believed that t ie work may be accomplished for the amount originally
estimated, viz, $75,000, less the amount alpproplriated by act of July 5,
1884, $20,000, thus requiring a further appropriation of $35,000.
532          REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

  The benefit to commerce and navigation from the improvements made
and contemplated is believed to be large, but available statistics are in-
complete. In addition to statistics given, there are many vessels navi-
gating the river no account of which has been obtained.
  An official pamphlet published by the Bangor Board of Trade in 1883
gives very full statistics for that date. (See Report of Chief of Engi-
neers for 1884, Appendix A, page 477.)
  The nearest port of entry for portion of the river here considered is Bangor, Me.
The commercial statistics for the year ending December 31, 1885, are given in the ap-
pended letter from the collector of customs at Bangor, Me.

                                              Money statement.
July 1, 1885, amount available............ ................. ...... ....    -$19, 966 54
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
                                                                        ---    19. 917 22
  outstanding July 1, 185----------......---------....---......--------......--......--.

July 1, 1886, amount available.-.  --.                                                                          49 32
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886 ...................                                      15,000 00

Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887 ....-_ ....... ..... 15, 049 32

rAmount (estimated) required for completion of existing project .......
  Amount that can lbeprotitably expended in fiscal year ending J iune30, 1888
                                                                                                           40, 00) 00
                                                                                                           40,000 00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
     harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.


Abstract of proposals received July 13, 1885, for dredging 40,000 cubic yards, improvement
                                of Bangor Harbor, Maine.

                                                                               Price per cubic
                   Names and addresses of bidders.                              yard measured            Remarks.
                                                                                in   scow.



Boynton Brothers, Boston, Mass.........---- .................                        -       $0 50    Contract     made
                                                             -
Moore & Wright, Portland, Me...................................-0                               36
Bay State Dredging Company....................................                                0 371    July 20, 1885.   -




                                          COMMERCIAL STATISTICS.
                                                                CUSTOM-HOUSE, BANGOR, ME.,
                                                                               Colleclor's Ofice, April 3, 1886.
  SIR: I have the honor to acknowledge the receipt of your letter of the '29th ultimo,
requesting me to furnish you certain information in regard to revenue collected in
this district, exports, imports, entries, and clearances of vessels, &c.                                    In complliance
with your request I give you below, as near as may be, the information you desire
for the year ending December 31, 1885:                                                                                      1
Amount of revenue collected (duties) .................................. $63, 220 29
Value of exports---......-----......-------- --....---......--
                                                           ---......---....---......---------...----------      188, 375 00
Value of imports (dutiable).....----....----------------------.......................----...----------.....     279, 46 00
Value of imports (free)........------......---------------
                                                  ......---....---......----....----..........                  424,9:931 00
American vessels arrived from foreign ports, 5 ................... tons..                                          1,719
Foreign vessels arrived from foreign ports, 16 ..................                                   .do...         2,924
American vessels cleared for foreign ports, 29................                                       do...
                                                                                                  ....           10, 499
Foreign vessels cleared for foreign ports, 26 ......... ............do.*..                                         5, 589
Vessels built, 1 .....---..... --------.............................                            tons net..            117.06
Vessels rebuilt, 1..............--..---.   ----........---...................... do...                                 55.65
  Arrivals and departures coastwise are not reported at the custom-house, as no re-
ports of the movements of coastwise vessels is required by the Department, neither is
the number of crew required to be furnlished in foreign-going vessels.
  By an exanmination of the harbor-master's records t he number of arrivals of vessels
in the coastwise trade during the year appears to be in the near vicinity of 2,000; de-
partures the same, as all vessels leave at the closing of the river.
      Very respectfully,
                                                                                              D. F. DAVIS,
                                                                                                      Collector.
                   APPENDIX A---REPORT OF MAJOR SMITH.                                                               53&

                                                            A 3.

                  IMPROVEMENT OF MOOSE-A-BEC BAR, MAINE.

  Moose-a-bec Reach is a thoroughfare of about 12 miles in length be-
tween the islands and mainland, the western extremity being about 30
miles east of Mount Desert, Maine. By its use the distance navigating
the coast is somewhat shortened, in addition to the great benefit afforded
by a sheltered channel and refuge in storms. The only obstructions to
the safe navigation at all stages of tide are the bar and a few small
ledges at the eastet'i extremity of the reach.
  In the Annual Report of Chief of Engineers for 1880 (page 358, Ap-
pendix A), a project and estimate was submitted for dredging the bar
to obtain 14 feet at mean low water over a width of 200 feet and a
length of about 1,900 feet. The expense was estimated at $28,000. In
1881 and 1882 the project was revised and the estimate for the work
was made $40,000.
  The following appropriations have been made by Congress for carry-
ing on the work:
By act of March 3, 1881 ........                 ----....--...----.....--......    ..--............            $10,000 00
By act of August 2, 1882 .--.............                    --.............       ...... ...           --...... 10, 000 00
By act of July 5, 1884      -..- - -.........................-..-                      --------...-
                                                                              .. -........--   -- ..- - .       10, 000 00

                                        ..------...................................
       Total-- ------------------------------.....................--------------                                30,000 00
       Total expenditures to June 30, 1286..........                          ..............          ......    29,946 34
   On the 20th of June, 1885, proposals were invited for dredging under
the appropriation of July 5, 1884. But two proposals were received.
They were opened on the 13th of July, and a contract was awarded to
Messrs. Moore & Wright, of Portland, Me., at 38 cents per cubic yard,
measured in scows. Under this contract work was commenced July
22, 1885, and was completed September 16, 1885. The amount of ma-
terial removed was 23, 345k cubic yards. The amount expended for
the last fiscal year was $9,973.38.
   By this work the channel was increased in width from 141 feet to 200
feet, thus entirely completing the dredging originally proposed, but
leaving the ledge to be removed in the future. To complete the project
heretofore submitted, the estimate as taken from the last annual report
is $10,000.
   The benefits thus far to the navigation of the coast have been very
great, so that large numbers of vessels, as well as the regular lines of
sea-going steamers, constantly use the new channel.
   It will be readily seen that a channel of 200 feet in width is insufficient
for sailing vessels with adverse winds, and that in the night and in foggy
weather the difficulties are increased.
   It is earnestly desired by the owners and masters of vessels plying the
thoroughfare that the channel over the bar be increased to 300 feet in
width, and that the small ledges in the reach near the bar should be
removed.
   The large amount of commerce to be benefited fully justifies a rec-
ommendation that the increased width be made and the adjacent ledges
removed, as desired.
   When the tides are ebbing a current flows through the channel from
east to west in the direction of its length, but when the flood tide sets
in, a very strong current passes through the old channel across the bar
from southwest to northeast, until a height of about four feet above low
water is reached, when after a short interval the direction of the cur-
rent changes to the same direction as in the ebb tides. This movement
534           REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

of the tides makes the navigation of the channel by sailing vessels in
light winds very difficult.
   The most obvious method of remedying the difficulty is by construct-
ing a small breakwater of riprap stones across the old channel from
Nova's Rocks to the present location of the buoy on Pile of Ballast
Ledge, at the edge of the new channel. The height of the breakwater
needs to be but two feet above low water (the principal strength of the
current being while the water is below that stage). The extreme end
of the breakwater should be raised with large stones, forming a beacon
to replace the buoy which, now marks the ledge.
   Accompanying this report is a map of Moose-a-bec Bar and its imme-
diate surroundings, the soundings being shown only where the water at
mean low stages has a depth of less than 14 feet.
   The area to be dredged to give the channel the width recommended,
the location of the small breakwater and the small ledges to be re-
moved, are all indicated on the map by shading with parallel lines.
   The pier at the end of the breakwater should be made somewhat
larger than indicated in the drawing upon the map. It is possible that
the increased width of the channel may so change the currents as to
obviate the necessity for constructing the breakwater.
   It is proposed to apply any funds appropriated for the purpose, first,
to widening the channel as indicated; second, to removing the small
ledges lettered on the map C, D, EE, F, G, H, and I; and third, to con-
structing the small breakwater, if then found necessary.
   The following estimate is submitted :
To widened channel, 65,000 cubic yards (scow measurement), at 35 cents .. .$22,                                      750
For constructing breakwater and beacon . .......                        ................         ... ..       ..  6, 000
Removing ledges .---....---.......----..-----......----------....- ......------......--...---
                                                                   ------......                            ----
                                                                                             ..-----....---....  10, 000
Engineering surveys and contingent expenses........-----........_..........                                       6, 250

                                                                                                                 45, 000
  The improvement is in the collection district of Machias.                                   The nearest port of entry
is at Machias, Me.           The nearest light-house is Moose Peak.
  The route being a regular thoroughfare to and from numerous ports,
exact statistics are difficult to obtain. Some thousands of vessels and
several regular lines of steamers pass over the route annually. The
appended letter from the collector of customs at Machias, Me., gives the
only exact statistics now attainable.
                                                 MWoney statement.
July 1, 1885 amount available............------------.....----------------....--....---.......--------....--...... -- $10, 027 04
July 1, 18(i, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July i, 1 5.------..- --              ........         .........             ........           ....      9, 973 38

July 1, 1886, amount available---..--..---                                 ----...............................                53 66
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886.... ..                                           ... ........         10, 000 00

Amount avalable for fiscal year ending 30, 1887 .......                              .._...._.........---.               10, 053 66



Abstract oJ proposals received July 13, 1885, for dredging 20,000 cubic yards, improvement
                                of Moose-a-bec Bar, Maine.

                                                                                     Price per cubic
                    Names and addresses of bidders.                                   yard measured                   Remarks.
                                                                                      in scow.

Boynton Brothers, Boston, Mass                -------               ---------                                $045
Moore & W right, Portland, Me-                          --   .      -------.                                  0 38   Contract made
                                                                                                                      July 20, 1885.
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      %
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      14                                 4e             5             4
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      4415              y

                                                                                                                                                                       NN\                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 1174




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          2..
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          ,                              ,                        "




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      3
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      % 1%                      1           1
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              10.8                                                                            I




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       /        5+4                   ./            G5             6i                      84                     .                                  ~                                                                                                                                                        1




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              .1             3./bis                                                                                                                   /                             E1        ,                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               i



                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              i

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           r1"".:                    .64.i"~'                                                                                                                        5                                                          7                           ..-              '05                       S
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              i
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              E




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       24                                                       4'y         4,6           4-             i             75.                    7Z 26a7                                               8.7           2a                                                                                 /                           12

                                                                                                                                                                                       l                                                                                                         as
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          N.                                                 14                I                                     142 d4 31                    38                         5,,                           9               S4.            ".         58.5                                                                                  937t                   1077303                       y           041o                                             2.


                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     bra               34'    4          4.7   y     2446       42434                                                                  44.    4,f                4       4p£4i                       67                                                                                                                                     .G         19.1         11.0              U
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      4               e           3.S                            6      .                                  .4                .          3           .         0                   3                    5                              9j
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   7f
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              E

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             2                                                                      4

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             44                +8 *4.i                   ~                  2           4               1                                                                                          N 4"y         5        5                                                                                         135 6317                                              4                 b   ,3       3        9S]Q.4 u            324
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              C




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                            4,6
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              i

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  9
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          z  4   3        I                         4%                                  +7            4       5.   6            4                  4       Sd.              3b
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   4                   e         +                  &        64                           '                          9'            9                                  g

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                .5                                        30-2.0Cr                                                                  0
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          117/                           12

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  vI7N:
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              f

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           .57                                                                                   4           6                                                        60        .2664,                                                                        ll s                                                                                    P                                                                                                                                                                                                                       4




                                                                                                                                             0.34                                                                                                                                                         (21                  34g4     3        i               44                   *5           46" .
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  13~0



                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                            1                                                                                                                                                                                                                               as
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  K3.1.                                        4   /=
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 cr.'                                                                      6'4        se        i          .),,.               __    ___ __                     "s        a    x                          r                                                            I,




                                                                                                        or....
                                                                                                          1                                                   t.1                                                            ,15                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  pesfIZ 1#
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 Syee4A55A.aOf
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          9
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              .
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 Ig                a *z
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      Lair*1.
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     ee                go
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      th           I9,.
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     d     ep



                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             '                             41.3I               .              ira*~
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                4           g                  7g               9,                                  g                       1
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  1          1)                                                                            ,         1        ii~'        E     X         S    a~         9'         ty                   5.                       1        *L           I:,               Iua       U5d     ti                                    \                115
                                                                                                                                                                                                                             OH
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 I
                                                                                                             E.



                                                                                     0            .                            ~y6*~N133                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             ..                                                                                                                  ! lc..\
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         "                                 1



                                                                                                                                     \32.$                           40                                                                                                                                                                 =/                              1.alU4

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             us*\.                               1                                                              .                                                                9I                          lam                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    Note.
                                  45    \                                                                                                                      IL#
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   OLT~'
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         2T4 soundinzgs showa on                         this
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          map are.a zprsweel?'irtfeet and
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         tenth affect gr/rsa refer to tde plane ca lean sov' As3*r; s'rrr
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        sall the arra, swhicha hare a clear depth . fl4.feet ormre,
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        soeundings'' hare been omitted.
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                hie
                          ,            4E               \                                                                                                       y              11                g4            a             .1                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         Aleswarise a~nd fall ofhtded .. h                                                taJ'gvt
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 to,                                                                                                                                                       41               o
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         .Tae J k Wa lterlinee a reprtree ztea' taus:                                 .,,"y~
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       C2falwae.iet                   3zeeezt contour is         repyweeel              thus'I
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             "     9      r          w                    -    w______
                                                                                                                                                                                   ila'                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         a12                                                          :
                                                                                                                                                                                           n11                                                             /                            1$
                                                                                                                                                                                                      1IQ's*

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       ]rojected .TJnrOreufleltV:
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  ,aaRo9I
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         2) W~de     7#I4t channelto SO0lset, wvlire~szire the resi'eoraxl
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         by dredgrzng of 50,x'00 CYi z. atdre,orJ'54Z73Czmeaerured
                                                                                                                                                                                                 Ig       11                                    g.                                                                                                                     )AS
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        2.) BreaX'it ' Jr andrenoreng ti &eges&r:         C-P EA.. F_
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        2
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        a     .bXand I, ag regsa/bizyv        228 CUCui 57c1I  ofxvaC,.
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        3) .Building9 $onle BeaecolL outBalestZedge, gillrea       re
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                lIg                                                                                                       232 Tons ofrough slit,       dim~ensaio atone
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             d9 2il>z8 ' VBrca7Narer are.?:,zhe old BarC/uamwel gill
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        rr 9 gJuihE 2335 .Tons 'oPf.,    iAik Stone .

         N ILI
-3   1        us                                                                                                                                                                                                         °     1s1       91

          r    .15                     117                  N.                                                                                                                                                                                11                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      If




         (11                                                             t               1       *                         1   S.i                                                                                                                             All         u   13
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     11


                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     2        o.n9'il-Jdincd                           &eca'w.'tol'BrecrXwcdez-
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  )(wio oL,3'1 oj0 .x            760     v   V'wg'it=~.Jctl. ."1:76
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      I?'
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      ,. lzwy




              Us              .*                                             /   5   *1&.1       hr   1"a3      11Z~2           1Ll                                                                                                                                                                          Ar1
                                                                                                        Ult./12u.
                                                                                                                         4%.
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                . .      I :. 37.5   l       |

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   ~                    ,.                                             ...
                     ..       ,                 .                .yam,
                                                                                                                    14
                                                                                                                                                        1L3                        .                                     .aA7lI3.,*
                                                                                                                                                                                                                      10.2              Is4 l
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                18
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    *
                                                                                                                               21                                                                                             9'°                 1j7  14,'Q-"       1ig
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         Cre.# Seeetiaonof BreoIAwerter an           A-B8.
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     .        !.c~tsl:zJ




                                                                                             I.                                                                                                                    11Q                             1
                                            '       '                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        I




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       IMOOSE-A-BEC BAR, JONESPORT,M].

                                                                                                                                                .   .          Scale Ito8000
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 -..   ~.PLANAND0SECTIONSOF
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                            -.           ....
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      r1.




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              PROPOSED BEACON ON BALLAST LEDGE
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     1                                                                                                        1
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                BREAKWATER ACROSS THE OLD CHANNEL
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       781

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      *.11,         rZ 2'J                         b'
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                1




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              i




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        +                               s.   zoopr

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   -
                                                                                             -

                                                                                                                                                                             L11                 W             1f"U                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               --
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      __-_1


                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 M~ANMEF~iANGRAPHIC CO N.Y.
                         APPENDIX A-REPORT OF MAJOR SMITH.                                                                                                  535
                                                       COMMERCIAL STATISTICS.

                                                                           CUSTOM-HOUSE,                            MACHIAS, ME,
                                                      Collector's Ofice, April 8, 1886.
  SIR: In reply to the inquiries contained in your letter of the 29th ultimo, I have
the honor to furnish you the following information in regard to the custom-house
business of this district for the year ending December 31, 1865:
  Amount of revenue collected:
Duties, hospital dues, fines, &c..----.....-.....                 ....-.....................                                                     ..      $306'35
Official fees--...........-
                  -----...---- -----...........------...............----------...----......                                              -.........     1,404 80
Total ..... .--............--............................................-
                                                                  -                                                                                     1,711 15
Value of exportations--.-......         ............................                                                 ...... .... ....                  60,558 11
Value of importations....................................--                                                           ......--....--.....               2, 623 16
Number of American vessels arrived from foreign ports ....................                                                                                         4
Tonnage of same....- .....-
                      -     ... ...... _...................................                                                                                   640
Number of foreign vessels arrived from foreign ports-......................                                                                                     5
Tonnage of same.. -                -......---... ......
                                             --...........------                                          -........--------.............                      967
Number of American vessels cleared for foreign ports................. .....                                                                                   170
Tonnage of same ......--            --..............           ...........-                        ,....       ...........--                               27,665
Number of foreign vessels cleared for foreign ports..............-----......                                                                                       7
Tonnage of same......---------....----....---......                ....................................                                                       967
Number of vessels entered coastwise...............-............            ........                                                                            14
Tonnage of same............ .... ....... .........      .... .... ...... .......                                                                            3,263
Number of vessels cleared coastwise........ ...... ..............-........                                                                                      4
Tonnage of same .---.....- ................--.....                                            .......... --                    -....--   - ....               963
Number of vessels built .......................-................                        .... ....      4
Tonnage of same ...... ...... ...... ..... ....                  ............- ...-....--.        961.74
  As we are not now obliged to keep a record of the number of the brew, I am unable
to give that. As most of the vessels which come into and go from this district are
under coasting license, and not required to enter and clear, the custom-house records
show but a small part of the coastwise business.
  Moose-a-bec Reach is a thoroughfare used by a large fleet of coasting vessels, and
the improvement of the bar must be of great advantage to them and also to the steam-
ers running between Portland and Machiasport.
         Very respectfully,                                                                                                        J. L. PIERCE,
                                                                                                                                                      Collector.
   Maj. JARED A. SMITH,
                Corps of Engineers.



                                                                        A 4.

                        IMPROVEMENT OF BELFAST HARBOR, MAINE.

  Appropriations have been made by Congress for improving this har-
bor as follows:
Act   of   August 14, 1876 ..............----          ....--------......
                                                                  ---.........------------........--....-----....-----         $5, 000
Act   of   June 18, 1878.----..... -......-----......---....
                                                           ------......--......-----...----..            ....----------....-....-------
                                                                                                                               12, 000
Act   of   March 3, 1879 .-----....-------....... ..............-------------.....................
                                                                                    ------------------------ 5, 000
Act   of   June 14, 1880....----..--    ......--......-------......- ...............------........ ...----------------.          3, 000
       Total ....-----------..----...... ------......---....---....---..--......... ....----..........--..-------.....------. 25, 000
  The total amount expended to June 30, 1886, was $22,193.20, leaving a balance of
$2,806.80.
   The work accomplished has been the removal of ledges and shoals
so as to give not less than 10 feet depth at mean low water in the upper
portion of the harbor, and from 11 to 12 feet in the lower portion on the
Belfast side.
   Some deepening of the water on the side of channel opposite Belfast
is desirable, but the amount available has been too small to make it ad-
visable to undertake a contract for that work alone.
536        REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

   A small survey was made in the harbor in January, 1886.
   It is recommended that the available balance be expended for the
purpose indicated, as soon as an opportunity is afforded to do the work
without ,too great an expense for towing dredges to and from the place.
No expenditures except as mentioned are now proposed, so that no ap-
propiation is asked.
   In the autumn of 1885 a small schooner, known as the Waldemar, was
sunk in the harbor. The removal of the wreck was directed by letter
from Office of Chief of Engineers, dated January 25, 1886. .
   Advertisements for proposals were issued on the 10th of February,
1886. On the 22d of March a contract for removing the wreck was
made with Mr. Solon S. Andrews, of Biddeford, Me. The work of re-
moval was completed on the 12th of April, 1886.
   The entire expense of removing the wreck, amounting to $537.12, was
paid from the Treasury under the act of June 14, 1880, making appro-
priation for "'removal of sunken vessels or craft obstructing or en-
dangering navigation." It is, therefore, not included in account of ex-
penditures for this harbor.
  The harbor is situated in the district of Belfast, Me. The nearest port of entry is
at Belfast. No commercial statistics have been received.

                                          Money statement.
July 1, 1885, amount available..............--.               ...----....... ....        .......---..     $2, 843 05
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885 .-..----------....---.-----------....----..--.-------------.......                 36 25
July 1, 1886, amount available........................                   ..... ....          .........     2, 806 80




                                                  A 5.

                  IMPROVEMENT OF ROCKLAND HARBOR, MAINE.

   The river and harbor act of June 14, 1880, appropriated the sum of
$20,000 for improving the harbor at Rockland, Me.
   Later in 1830 four projects were discussed for the construction of
breakwaters for protection of the harbor, the estimated expense for the
plan adopted in 1881 being originally $500,000. This was revised in
1882, making the estimate $550,000. The plan adopted contemplates,
first, the construction of a breakwater running somewhat east of south
from Jameson's Point, a distance of 1,900 feet, and, after the comple-
tion of the first breakwater, to construct a second, commencing at a
point about 1,300 feet southwest of the extremity of the first, and ex-
tending 2,640 feet in a direction slightly west of south to a point known
as .South Ledge (see map opposite page 464, Report of Chief of Engi-
neers, 1881, Appendix A).
   There have been appropriated by Congress for this purpose the fol-
lowing sums, viz:
By act of June 14, 1880 ....     ........    ..    .... ..................      ....... ..-.             $20, 000 00
By act of August 2, 1882 .--...............-----.... --.....--................ ------......               40, 000 00
By act of July 5, 1884--....--............--.........             ...............     ----       ....     40, 000 00
        Total......................--....------......--......--......--......--......                    100,000 00
        The total expenditure to June 30, 1886, has been...                         .......... --.        97, 921 99
                      APPENDIX A-REPORT OF MAJOR SMITH.                                                                      537
  f On the 1st of July, 1885, a contract was outstanding with Mr. Thomas
A. Rowe, of Newton, Mass., for placing stone in the breakwater. Work
under the contract was completed December 31, 1885. There were de-
livered in the breakwater, under the contract mentioned, 39,959 tons of
stone, adding 473 feet to the length of breakwater, thus making the'
total length measured on top, at 5 feet above mean low water, 1,472 feet.
    Correspondence received in this office raises the question of continu-
ing the present breakwater to a greater length, rather than to con-
struct the second one as proposed. The expense need not thereby be
increased. The plan is one which may be better considered when the
present breakwater is near completion. No recommendation for modi-
fication is therefore submitted in this report.
    It is proposed to apply the present small balance of funds, together
with any further appropriations, first, to complete this breakwater as
designed, and second, to construct the further work as already de-
scribed.
    The protection now afforded by the breakwater is greatly dimished
by the fact that it is at present entirely submerged about twelve hours
of each twenty-four, so that the seas pass over itg top. It is very de-
sirable that the breakwater be raised to its entire height as soon as
practicable.
    The breakwaters are not only for the purpose of affording a protection
to the shipping which may visit the harbor of Rockland, but also for
forming a secure harbor of refuge for vessels upon Penobscot Bay and
the adjacent coast. It is therefore for the benefit of the general com-
merce, of which the local statistics indicate but a small part.
The nearest port of entry is Rockland. The collection district is Waldoborough,
Me. The nearest light-house is Owl's Head, 2 miles distant.
  The statistics of entries, &c., at the custom-house are given in a let-
ter, hereto appended, from the collector of the port.

                                               Money statement.
July 1, 1885, amount available ..-----.....--........................--------------------------...----. $17, 312 79
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885.............----------.................--------.........--...       ---       14,390 80

July 1, 1886, amount available...........------------ .........................                                         2, 921 99
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886...................                                                  22,500 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887 ....                                  .............              25, 421 99


   Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1888 100, 000 00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
      harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.



                                           COMMERCIAL STATISTICS.

                                                        CUSTOM-HOUSE, WALDOBOROUGH,                                   ME.,
                                                                                 Collector's Ofice,           April   19. 1886.
  SIR: In conformity with your request, by letter of March 29, 1886, I am able to fur-
nish you information relating to the port of Rockland, as follows, for the year ending
December 31, 1885:
Amount of revenue collected ..-.......                                .-..--..
                                                                   --.....-        .........--.             ....       $, 832 73
Value of importations (about). .,...                         --.  ..---- ......---.... .-....--....                    75, 000 00
Value of exportations   -.......                        ---. ---......-.-----....-...........----.                      Nominal
538                REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.


                                                         Shipping.                                                    No.           Tons.         Crew.

American vessels entered from foreign ports.........................                                              .      8             765. 00         51
Foreign vessels entered from foreign ports ........                      ..................                            368         27, 675. 00     1, 656
American vessels clea ed for foreign ports.................................                                             21          5, 276.00         150
Foreign vessels cleared for foreign ports .......                                     ......    ....... .... ..        369         27, 762. t00    1, 661
Entries, coastwise..........................................................                                             8          1, 109. 00        36
Clearances, coastwise. ....................                               .......         ...    ....   ..               9          2, 979. 00        62
Vessels built in collection district ..........................................                                          6          3, 59. 04 ........


   I should state, perhaps, that the coastwise entries and clearances recorded at the
custom-house convey no accurate impression of the vessels arriving at and departing
from the port of Rockland, the numbers of which cannot be arrived at by any means,
but must reach, I should judge, as high as 4,000 to 6,000. Among these are steamers
of theBoston and Bangor lines, daily in summer, usually four trips per week in winter;
also, the Portland, Mount Desert, Blue Hill, Fox Island, and other steamers.                                                                      The
harbor is spacious, with good water and secure holding ground.
  The breakwater has already improved its security as a harbor of refuge, and when
completed will be of vast advantage, and amply justify the wisdom of its construction.
      Very respectfully,
                                                                                                                      EDWIN SPRAGUE,
                                                                                                                                         Collector.
     JARED A. SMITH, Esq.,
                          Major of Engineers.



                                                                                    A 6.

                               IMPROVEMENT OF PORTLAND HARBOR, MAINE.

  For a full history of the improvement of Portland Harbor, Maine,
previous to 1879, reference is made to Report of Chief of Engineers for
1879, Appendix A, page 255.
  From 1836 to 1879 there was appropriated for this harbor the sum of
$351,447.05.   Since that date the following appropriations have been
made, viz :
By act of March 3, 1881...... ...... ..            - - .......................                                              - .. . $20, 000 00
By act of August 2, 1882 .---.....--.....--...--..
                                              --      - -....-..          -... - -                                --..   .....
                                                                                                                        --          35, 000 00
By act of July 5, 1884..-.... ..........       .................... .... .                                        .......      .. 30,000 00
                                                          ---------- 436,447 05
             Total ..---...........---------..........---..........----........------
Of this amount there had been expended to June 30, 1886, the sum of.... 434, 582 05
  Oni the 1st of July, 1885, an unexpended balance of $8,326. 29 remained
for expenditure.
   No definite complete project has ever been adoptedcovering all the im-
provements, but numerous small improvements have been made from
time to time as they seemed to be required.
   Between the harbor commissioner's line and the channel in the portion
of harbor from Brown's Wharf to Franklin Wharf the bottom has for
some years been in irregular shoals, one of which gave but about 121
feet at mean low water. The shallowness of the water was found to be
a serious obstruction to the movements of loaded vessels. It was also
found that the larger class of steamers using the lower portion of the
harbor were put to inconvenience, delay, and expense, from the lack of
room in deep water. A project to remove the shoals to a depth of 17
feet, and to extend the area heretofore dredged to 21 feet, was submitted
and approved in March, 1886.
  Advertisements for proposals were issued April 10, and the bids re-
ceived were opened May 1, 1886. A contract for doing the work was
let to Mlessrs. Moore & Wright of Portland, Me., at 28 cents per cubic
              APPENDIX A-REPORT OF MAJOR SMITH.                         539
yard measured in situ. The work of dredging was commenced on the
18th of May. The dredging of the upper shoals was completed June
25, and the work of increasing the area giving 21 feet of water was
commenced.        At the end of the fiscal year the total amount removed
under the contract was 19,890 cubic yards.
     On the 7th of May, while acting as inspector, superintending the
dredging, Mr. Carl Berrer, who had been for twelve years employed in
this office as draughtsman and assistant engineer, was so severely ii-
jured by the breaking of a chain on the dredge that he died on the fol-
lowing day. By his death the Government has lost a most faithful and
competent servant, and one who was highly respected wherever known.
     Work under the contract will be completed in two weeks, and will
accomplish all for which recommendations have been heretofore sub-
mitted.
     Although the work of removing the shoals &c., under the last con-
tract 'has been comparatively small, yet its benefits cannot fail to be'
felt byv the greater ease with which loaded vessels may approach the
wharves at low water.
     It has for some years been apparent that the carrying of freights is
much cheaper in large than in small vessels, and that in order to main-
tain the present commerce of Portland, as well as to encourage and fos-
ter new enterprises, a depth of water must be procured in the harbor
which will accommodate at all times the largest transatlantic steamers
and sailing vessels.
     In view of these facts, the board of trade and parties interested have
  taken measures to represent the matter to Congress, with a view to ob-
  taining a depth of 29 feet of water. The necessity for increasing the
  depth of water to at least 27 feet has been urged in letters to this office
from the Dominion Line and Allan Line of steamship companies, of
  which this is the port from October until May.
    'A second improvement, which would add greatly to the convenience
  of vessels entering and leaving, as well as to the ease and security of
  lying at the wharves, is the extension of the breakwater on Stamford's
  Ledge, a distance of 1,000 feet, so that it may reach a depth of 18 feet
  at mean low water close to the point of departure by which the harbor
  is made or cleared.
     I am informed that at certain times the seas setting into the harbor
  are greatly detrimental, and occasionally so hazardous to vessels at the
  lower wharves that they are compelled temporarily to leave and lie at
  anchor. The end of the present breakwater reaches a depth of but 4
  feet at mean low water, and the turning point on its prolongation is
  marked by a buoy. In leaving the harbor it is necessary to find this
  buoy in order to shape a course which shall clear the points of ledges
  beyond. The varying tidal currents often make it difficult to find the
  buoy in fogs or at night, the times at which definite marks are indis-
  pensable, and When it is imprudent to get near the light on the end of
  the breakwater, owing to the shallow water and surrounding ledge.
     In 1873 the channel in the back cove of Portland Harbor was im-
  proved by dredging a portion to a depth of 8 feet at mean low water.
  The desirability of a further increase of width and depth in this channel
  led the city council to consider the subject, and in April, 1886, a peti-
  tion was forwarded to Hon. T. B. Reed, Representative in Congress,
  asking that measures be taken to obtain an appropriation for the pur-
pose. The petition being referred to this office for a report and estimate,
the subject was as fully considered as was practicable without a regular
survey, and the result, with an estimate of cost, was submitted to the
540            REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

Chief of Engineers in a letter dated'May 4,1886 (printed in Senate Re-
port No. 1391, Forty-ninth Congress, first session),- A copy of the letter
is appended, to form part of this report.
   A small map of the harbor of Portland, Me., accompanies this report,
and upon it are indicated the various improvements heretofore made,
and also that for which a project was submitted to Congress at its last
session, as well as further improvements to the channel and breakwater,
which are recommended for future consideration.
   1st. For a channel 500 feet wide and 29 feet deep, approaching the
lower wharves of the harbor. This will require the removal of
635,000 cubic yards in situ, at an estimate of 20 cents per yard......---....------...                                                      $127, 000
Contingencies, say -.....                             .....        ....            ..........         .................                        8, 000

                ........-----------..--...---......--....................---....---......----..........
           Total--                                                                                                                           135, 000
   A project for this improvement was submitted in a letter from this
office, dated December 11,1885; the estimate of cost, however, was based
upon prices lower than have heretofore been obtained. The estimate
here submitted is therefore made on the basis of prices which seem
probable when judged from past experience.
   2d. The dredging a channel 300 feet wide and 25 feet deep is recom-
mended, to connect the deep channel below with deep water in the upper
part of harbor. This will require the removal of
175,000 cubic yards of material, at an estimated cost of 20 cents per cubic
   yard .................----      ------.. ...........................................-------                                          .    $35, 000
                                                                                                      ----
Contingencies, say ......------......--......--......---......--......----....---....--........-------..                                .      3,500
           Total ......-        ................................                                   ..................-
                                                                                                                    -              ..         38, 500
3d. Extending the breakwater 1,000 feet.                                                        It is estimated that this
will require-
75,000 tons of stone (quarry grout) at $1......          ..... .......         ..............                                                $75, 000
913 linear feet of superstructure, at $25 per foot...... ......           ...... - ...... -     -   ...-                                       2,825
Pier for light-house on end of breakwater.........................                        .......                                             12, 000
Engineering and contingent expenses. -         ......---     ..---- ..---               .... ..---.                                           10, 175

           Total ............----------------------....
                                           ......-----......---......--..........---....--..--....--...--....                                120,000
  4th. Dredging channel in Back Cove 300 feet wide and 12 feet deep,
with winding basin:
721 cubic yards in situ, at 25 cents per cubic yard, including all contingencies..- $180, 000
   The harbor is in the collection district of Portland and Falmouth, Me. There is a
light-hous6 on the breakwater, and at Portland Head, 3 miles distant. The harbor is
defended by forts Preble, Gorges, and Scammel, and battery at Portland Head.

                                                              Money statement.
July 1, 1885, amount available..............................-----..----.    $8, 326 29
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1885 ............ .. ........ $1,941 37
July 1, 1886, outstanding liabilities.... -............--.....--   4,519 92
                                                                                                          -                   -             6, 461 29

July 1, 1886, amount available ................                                             1, 865 00
                                                ......-----------------------------.........---------...
                                                                                      -
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886 ...----..-----...... --.....            30,000 00

Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887 ......                                          .. ....         ....   ...        31,865 00

 (Amount  (estimated) required for completion of existing project .....     105, 000 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1888 105, 00 00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
      harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
                             APPENDIX                   A-REPORT OF MAJOR SMITH.                                                               541
Aietract of proposals received May 1, 18S6, for dredging 29,641 cubic yards, and for driv-
                    ing guide-piles for same.-Imnprovement of harbor at Portland, Me.


                                                                     Price per cubic Price per
           Bidders.                         Residence.               yaid measured pile driven                                 Remarks.
                                                                         in situ.    in position.


Robert Hamilton .----. Chebeague,, Me ...                                            $0 31            $25 00
Solomon Sawyer.....    Yarnouth, Me..                                                $ 31             $25 00
Moore & Wright             ......
                       Portland, Me. ..                                                 28             20 00        Contract made May 10, 1886.


                                                        COMMERCIAL                 STATISTICS.

   The following commercial statistics are taken from a letter from the collector of
theport ; additional statistics are given in my report of May 4, 1886, appended, forthe
year ending December 31, 1865:


                                                    Shipping.                                                                 Number.     Tonnage.


Arrivals :
   Foreign .............-.......................................................                                                  273        135,848
   Coastwise .---......-------.......-------------..-------------------------..........................................           481        392, 313
Clearances:
   Foreign... ...                          .. .
                                          -....        .. ........ ..            ..- .............................                397        200, 201
   Coastwise........-----..----.........--------------.............-----------...........---------..--....---...--.........       315        332,401
Vessels built in the district....................................................                                                   3           1, 844


Amount of revenue collected............                            -................   .... ...........         .........      ........ . $782, 591 99
Value of impots ......................................                                                                                    6, 730, 04 00
                                                                                     .----------...........----------..------------...............-
Value of exports .--....----..........................--------------------------..------------------...................................   9, 093, 574 00




IMPROVEMENT                         OF        NAVIGATION IN THE BACK COVE, PORTSMOUTH
                                               HARBOR, NEW HAMPSHIRE.

                                                           UNITED STATES ENGINEER OFFICE,
                                            Portland, le., May 4, 1886.
   GENERAL: In accordance with request in indorsement of the Chief
of Engineers, dated April 21, 1886, upon letter of Hon. T. B. Reed, in-
closing petition froim city governmient of Poitland, Me., I have to sub-
mit the following rel)ort upon the necessity for improvement of navi-
gation in the Back Cove of Portland Harbor, with a project and esti-
mate of cost.
   The petition mentioned recites certain statements regarding the lim-
ited harbor frontage available for miscellaneous purposes of commerce,
and the necessity for making additional room by improving the chan-
nel in what is locally known as Back Cove; these statements are un-
doubtedly correct.
   A reference to the map of Portland and its surroundings will show
that it is situated upon a peninsula, and that owing to various obstacles
the frontage occul)ied by wharves covers only a portion of one side.
The peninsula itself is )rilncilally a high ridge, with bluffs at its ex-
tremities of 150 and 160 feet above the sea level. The growth of the
city is of necessity in a direction away from the lresent harbor, so that
at least one-half of the city and all of the immediate suburbs must be
suppllied witi all heavy articles arriviing by water at a large additional
expense for cartage adl haltndling, which miust be l)aid by consumers of
these articles, wherever located. Wile this no doubt gives employ.
ment to a few trucknmen and laborers, yet it is a tax upon the indus-
tries, thrift, and commerce of the place.
542    %REPORT OF        THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

   The managers of railroads reaching this point have seen this difficulty,
and for their own benefit have completely encircled the city and have
stations on either side, but the natural highway upon the water to the
rear of the city is so poor that it is only used to a very limited extent,
and then with only partial benefit.
    This report has been delayed somewhat in order to obtain reliable
information upon which to base an estimate of probable benefits to be
derived from the improvement, if made.
   I am informed by Mr. M. N. Rich, secretary of the merchant's ex-
change and board of trade, that in the year 1885 there were received
or shipped by sea at this port the following heavy articles, the amount
being given as a close approximation: Coal, 300,000 toils; salt, 27,391,950
pounds; lumber, 39,085,476 feet; lime, 50,000 casks; fish, 81,617 casks;
sugar, 30,828,496 pounds; molasses, 1,292,997 gallons; oils, 25,000 bar-
rels; cement, 21,000 casks; ice, 30,000 tons.
   While absolute figures are not easily obtained in advance it seems
reasonable to estimate that if one-half the coal could be handled on the
opposite side of the city by means of harbor facilities in the Back Cove
it would effect a saving of 25 cents per ton, amounting to an annual
benefit of $37,500 upon this single item.
   The expense of handling other heavy articles would be similarly
affected to a greater or less extent, so that the total benefit could not
fail to be very great.
   Adjacent to the Back Cove and to the city in the town of Deeringis
a nlanufactory of stoneware, pottery, &c. Messrs. Winslow & Co., the
proprietors, have at my request given me a statement of their receipts
and shipments by water, in a letter which is appended hereto. In this
simngle industry the saving upon 14,350 tons of crude materials received,
such as clay, sandl, and coal, is estimated as between $3,000 and $5,000,
being apl)roximately 21 cents to 34 cents per ton.
   A study of the subject makes it apparent that an improvement of the
channel in the Back Cove will result in cheapening the transportation
of a very large amount of material both for local and general consump-
tion.
   I forward in a separate package a Coast-Survey chart of Portland
  larbor, upon which id indicated the location of a marginal way which
the city has un(lertakenl alnd partly constructed, and of flats which are
to be filled. A,harbor commis.xioner's line has been established 200 feet
outside of and l)arallel to the '.marginal way."
   The project recom mended is to deepen and straighten the channel so
that itmiay   have a depth of not less than 12 feet at mean low water,
and so that the inner edge may border the commissioners' line. This
channel nmay at first be made as narrow as 50 feet with a view to sub-
seque nt increase as the increasing traffic and commerce may demand.
A winding basin) should, however, be constructed at the extreme end
to l)ernit the turning of vessels.
   The improvement would consist entirely of dredging, the quantities
for which have been conl)uted as accurately as possible from informa-
tioti at hand, without incurring the expense of a survey.
   Estimating for a channel of 12 feet in ldepth, which will be sufficient
for the present needs, the quantities to be removed are as follows:
For a. channel 50 feet wide, with basin, 200,000 cubic yards.
For a channel 100 feet wide, with Ibasin, 299,500 cubic yards.
For a c(lhunel 150 feet wide, with hasiti, 39(i,000 cubic yards.
For a clhannel 200 feet wide, with bsin, 500(,000 cubic yards.
For a channel l250 feet wide, with lasiu, 617,000 cubic yards.
For a channel 300 feet wide, with basin, 721,000 cubic yards.
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              /
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                            It'                                   e/

To0   a-ccontpci                                                                                                                                                                                        t   3O     t


               1




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       LB          A                       C                  K             .!                  d 0                       .I V L E


                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                ,I                                       .                    .
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                "".._.                               ,-                           .
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         -.                                                                                                         ///II




                                                                    -1

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          _              f           .. -/
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   ...                                 .. .                  -
                                                                             -.
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       "'':::
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             .. \t
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                :3,.
                                                               -4
                                                                                                -4

                                                                                           -z

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  . de
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          ___ISZI~-
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        ____..   i,
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      @~ t / "
                                                                                                                                                                                                                 34-                                                                                                                                                                                                                     o. "%                        -

                                                                                                                   -3                -1

                                                                                                                      -            -3
                                                                                           -4                                  ........

                                                                                                                               -3'
                                                                                       -3
                                                                                       N                               -z                                  .                                                                                      18




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                            3                                                                                               10



                                                          SKETCH OF
               PORTLAND HARBOR,7MAINE,
      SHOWING THE IMPROVEMENTS MADE IN 1866.86                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              14     r
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                3f                                   30/.
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          j,/                16
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     i.~
          ALSO PROJECTED IMPROVEMENTS.                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     3.        6
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           81
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           all1
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             26                 .
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          4                  1
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             11
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     i
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             3                                                                    30I.
       1'/se   areas Jsct1eiZ and            -pewoo,           Y7en- e           8en            WqOv         -0EoZ         6yob.N1y o asAfo                                           /oNE   Y;;   t:
  4cAten - iore          C1oLeJVatrldro: 7kMP'odod Gwouron$ocr zoo 1869-Z , t a det/c of~lOee                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              32
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     Z4



                     N                N                      N   N75*18~N            , 2,
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        2s                                       33               29                       3/


                                                                A            A                               N   1. ?83-84           ,8       4            ,
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  /
        ,A3                                                                                                   1849L9-86..                         ,            ",            ,   22




        , 44 Ir foJN7 ofAiOlnCv             cirIrf                                                           ,.7881            N                                    ~N21Z                                                    -3                                                             4                           36 s                        26                        y                                                     IL
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                6
        yA6   N     ,     a     wlco~r'.e                                                                ~    1886+
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             43                                *.               14..2
          Q    /  i   hW L7 a !CUYN'IItU;6iOeIecNL                                         tie ,,            1873- 7r ,6                                   ,        N                                                                                                             39
                               N.L7     y                  4                                                 188 - 85-               ,"                        ,,       16                                                                                                                      58
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               Z4"




                                                 r                                                   n   188c                  N.         "                         N+tl                                                                                               49
       ",B    ANOa 1 RZed                   '-ng
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           41                                                   1I                     13
             C'-. C/gnnel ino            cec1 Cove             in-        1873 to           cc       lotc otl           ecf    act     coea t                                7ow 'no er.                                                                     18                                                              34                                                                       8
         .. eBrcecXwaNt6               (wOZC/c woes                 conNNwnN'9eel                        1836-38)          w         e ctencd                                 a c JC                                                              z1                                                                              324
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    Z         .1                                                      8




         cemnpZeteol in 18$'- 73 , the .l                            .3eUwa,3e             yo        r isclicCd00.
                                                                                       anal
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   $
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 33
        .Th    c soufldinPN           are   xp           n'e    6.               et                  arer  e$ f4 ,'arrz'eot                                             to       tAooNNCNe     ofuzcozv.
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                            S5/        'i                                                                                                            38     \,        Scale of Feet
        lows- noct&Y
                          9
                           .   .Te     mecrn       rie                   NaZcd fc      Oat           fiNdeJ           is    .9ifoee                   t.
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             48   46
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  1000                         2400

                                            PRO'ECTCO   avEME               .r$
                                                                             /MP
       1)    .Zrecrybt
                  7 q (oaaeZ o- OceocoSC 3co' sera-:7
                                                      2 et dee - $00 wide, tisored frif -':
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        .I2
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      oj             NNNOTE


                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  ~                                                                                                                                                      C,
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          '         ...                                i        ond                 xtieyrs




                           ~ oct i 'warefN~o4.o-2 .&do': $'I~eeA d Ne~a350 WidcGi:fCi A8&J* .. t.                                                                                                                           30        33                                I                       N.                                                                                                                                                feet'a     anal e       tc   'f
      Jn.74xteezecewzc cf &-ecaxwatev1,, 1'a. Lc dis'zcgo ec a1' 7Szt ' et ocd mnosciqdwuv4o.Sie                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   arms!        "Oren           o     rcaotre            tow       datcr-.




                            C/raL ( d PBOGeCoves
               V.Zhj)JrZTe.#e                     f $et dodgy, - 300 - feet  Nde.                                                                                                                                                                                                                        F'ort         Gorges                                                     ,The;l                  ea'         'Le     arc'SNecllot'ties
                                                                                                                                                                                                                       48             465              4z.                                                                                                o10



                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                THE AMER!CAN GRAPHIC CO.,N.Y



         H Exi pt2 v2 49 2
                        APPENDIX A--REPORT                                       OF MAJOR SMITH.                                             543
   If done by contract the price cannot be safely estimated (including
contingent expenses) at less than 25 cents per yard. This will make
the estimated cost as follows:
For   a   channel    50 feet wide ......        ......       ........................                      ----              ..    ...   $50, 000
For   a   channel    100 feet wide -.----.......--------..-----........               ...........--             ............-74,              875
For   a   channel    150 feet wide ............                         .....      ..............                 .
                                                                                                                  ..      .....   ....     99, 000
For   a   channel    200 feet wide ......         ..................                    .......................                          125, 000
For   a   channel    250 feet wide .......................                                  ....-.... .... ....                  ....    154,250
For   a   channel    300 feet wide ....              -..... ........             ........        .... ..           ....-....        ..   180, 230
   The channel of 300 feet in width is probably as small as will meet the
ultimate requirements, and if this can be done by a machine and tug
owned by the Government the cost would be greatly reduced, besides
leaving the plant for use at other places. For this I would submit the
following estimate, viz:
For dredge scow and tug ..-----...... ----....---...... ----......----.... --..................--------                                  $50, 000
Removing 721,000 cubic yards, at 10 cents                .. ....... ---...     ......    --. ....     ...                                 72, 100

           Total ....--------..........--.--------------..............................................                                    122, 100
   Experience and observation indicate that the prices last given are
ample to cover every expense when the work is done by labor and ma-
chinery employed directly by the Government.
   If from the total amount the value of machinery left on hand for sale,
or for use at other places be deducted, the cost of the entire improve-
ment may be fairly estimated not to exceed $100,000.
         Very respectfully, your obedient servant,
                                                                                                 JARED A.                  SMITI,
                                                                                                          Major of Engineers.
     Brig. Gen. JOHN NEWTON,
                 Chief of Engineers, U. S. A.



                                                        Money statement.

SAm'ount appropriated by an act approved August 5,1886                                              ..........       .........            $26, 250
Amnountavailable for fiscal year ending June 30(, 187 .... ....................                                                           26, 250
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project .......                                                                   153, 750
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1888.                                                               50, 000




                                                                      A 7.

                      IMPROVEMENT OF KENNEBUNK RIVER, MAINE.

   A history of this improvement was briefly stated in the last Annual
Report. No appropriation has been made for the improvement since
1881. No work was carriedl on during the last fiscal year, and(l no further
improvements are at present contemllatetl. A balance of $336.34 of
the appropriation for the work remains unexpended, with which small
repairs may be made should they be found necessary.
   Improvements at this lplace were begun under an act of Congress of
1798. The work subsequently built consisted of two stone piers, sup-
plemented by crib-work and wings for holding the sand.
544        REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

  The entire amount appropriated for improvement of Kennebunk River
from 1870 to 1881 was $21,000. Of this there has been expended to the
30th June, 1886, $20,660.66.
  The river lies in the collection district of Kennebunk.                               The nearest port of eitry
is Kennebunk.
  There are no commercial statistics at present available to report.

                                        Money statement.
July 1, 1885, amount available              ....       ...... ....      ...........................          -$336      34
July 1, 1886, amount available         .............            .....      ........................                 336 34




                                                        A 8.
               BREAKWATER AT MOUTH OF SACO RIVER, MAINE.

  The olject of this work is to prevent the sand from drifting across
the mouth of the river and forming a bar, and also to enable the cur-
rents to scour and maintain a deeper channel in the bar previously
form ed.
  The original project for this work was undertaken in 1866, and in 1873
all the work then contemplated had been completed.
  A full history of the improvement to that date is included in the An-
nual Report of Chief of Engineers for 1874, Appendix Y, page 34.
  Under the act of Congress approved August 2, 1882, a survey was
made in the summer of 1883, and it being found that the work thus far
completed was insufficient             for
                               the purpose, a further plan was submitted
in the Annual Report for 1884. The project submitted comprised the
following:
1. Raising the breakwater to height of 15 feet above low water, making a
     width of 12 feet on top, and replacing injured parts.................------.                              $70,000
2. Dredging in channel to 5 feet at mean low water                ...      .................                    11,500
3. Extending breakwater to Sharp's Ledlge ................................                                     220, 000
4. For stone wing-darn or jetty on south side of channel ..................                                          5,000
     Total .... ..................      . ..... . . ..... ........ ..  .......... ... . 356, 500
  For this work there was appropriated by act of July 5, 1884, $15,000.
Of this amount there has been expended to June 30, 1886, the sum of
$14,973.64.
  On the 1st of July, 1885, a contract for delivering stone in the break-
water, made October 20, 1884, with Messrs. Hamilton & Soule, of Clhe-
beague, Me., was still incomplete. Work under t his contract, commenced
in May, 1885, was concluded September 28, 1885. The amount of stone
placed in the breakwater during the last fiscal year was 7,2804 tons, and
216 cubic feet of ashlar on outer end. Under this contract the re-enforce-
melnts and repall~s to the         .breakwater..I were compl..        du for a distaice of
510 feet from the outer end, and considerable stone was                                   over        dlelposited
an additional distance of 175 feet. Owing to the settling of stone in
the sand, as well as 1,artial displacement by the sea, the quantities re-
quired to complete the repairs of the breakwater are found to be ap-
proximately 25 per cent. more than was originally estimated by figuring
on exact dimensions. The average cost under the last contract, includ-
ing all contingent expenses of enginleering , &c., is in excess of $1.41
per ton. The amount still required to complete the first part of the
                          APPENDIX           A-REPORT OF MAJOR SMITH.                                                                      545
project is therefore amended as follows: 52,000 tons of stone in break-
water, at $1.42 per ton, $73,840. The entire sum could be profitably ex-
pended in the next fiscal year.
   The cities of Biddeford and Saco, about 5 miles from the mouth of
the river, are manufacturing places of considerable importance, and
upon the navigation of the river the prosperity of these places largely
depends.
   It is believed that no good channel can be maintained across the bar
until the current can be limited and confined by constructing the jetty
opposite the breakwater.
   The jetty is at present a much more important factor, in deepening the
bar at the mouth, than any other work, and it should be undertaken as
soon as practicable.
   The deposition of stone in the jetty, or breakwater, is of such a char-
acter that the amount which may be profitably done in any fiscal year
is only limited by the available funds.
   It is recommended that $100,000 be appropriated for the next fiscal
year for constructing the .jetty and continuing work upon the break-
water.
   Only approximate statistics of the commerce of Saco and Biddeford
have been received. The deputy collector of customs at Saco estimates
that at least 25 per cent. is saved in freights on all articles which come
by water, and that large amounts of cotton, coal, and other merchan-
dise now moved by rail would go by water with great advantage were
the facilities sufficient.
  The statistics appended hereto are furnished from the office of the
collector of customs for year ending December 31, 1885.

                                                 Money statement.
July 1, 1885, amount available.-.......------............-----.---.................                                                  $10,293 60
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885..---.-----..---.....................--.. ....... ----.....                                                 10,267 24

July 1, 1886, amount available......-            -      ......................                                       ......   ....        26 36
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886 .................                                                                  12, 500 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887....................                                                             12,526 36

 ( Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project. -... -.... 347, 840 00
   Amount that can be profitably expendedin fiscal year ending June 30,1888 100, 000 00
     Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
 ,     harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.



                                             COMMERCIAL STATISTICS.
Arrival of vessels -........ ............                      ............                    .....--.... --........                       270
Departures    .....--..----....               ...........                ----....   --......   ...................                          270


                                                     Imports by water.
Coal......---...----........      .....--.....----......----..----......-----.--....-----.......--------......---.. tons..               40, 000
Moulding sand .... ......-               -.....- -.....- -..... ......        -        - -.....- -.. .... .... do....                     7, 000
Cotton ................             ............--------------.....        .................--------......-  --- bales..                  8, 750
Pig-iron ..............            ...... ---.... ...... ................-                            --- ..... tons..
                                                                                                     .....                                4,000
Iron pipe ............              ........             ...................                      ..........        do....                4, 000
Paving stones .........-----      .. ---.......... ..-----.... ..                        --...... .........        do....                    456
Pitch ....................                ...............                ......-..............                  barrels..-                   150
Gravel..... ................... ...................................        tons..                                                           250
Lime ........ ................. ......  ..... ....... ..... ....... .... casks..                                                         8,000
Cement ...........................        .......
                                              ...      .....            barrels..                                                        2, 500
          35 E
546            REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

Ashes ............              .............---                            ............
                                                                  ..--..---......                    .......   bushels.               3,000
Paper ------..--....----.....-------                                                                       --......--............
                                                                                                                     rolls..
                                                                       -----......----......------......------------......--            300
                                              ...... ---....--
Timber ......-----......-------....------------                                                                      tons..
                                                                    --......--..---------- ----.....---......---............            102
Plaster ----............--------............---............-----------.....----............-----------..---...... do....              1,500
Paints, oil, lead, &c .----..-------......--------........----------......................-----...------.... do....                     150

                                                      Exports by water.
Stone-----..............-----         ----.....---------......--..- .......--...------
                                   ......--                                                      --
                                                                                         --....--......-- tons..   10, 000
Ice .....--------............--.....
                              ------    ------......-----....--...... ----......-----......---........... do....   10,000
Bricks ......................................-----.-------..........                                  number.. 2, 000, 000




                                                                   A g.

                                IMPROVEMENT OF SACO RIVER, MAINE.

  Under the requirements of the river and harbor act of July 5, 1884,
a preliminary examination was made, and a report submitted by Col. C.
E. Blunt, dated September 1, 1884. A survey was subsequently made
to the towns of Biddeford and Saco, Me., and a report and estimate for
the improvements considered necessary was made by Col. C. E. Blunt,
dated October 16, 1885.
  These reports were printed in House Ex. Doc. No. 37, Forty-ninth
Congress, first session, and are appended hereto.
  Of the amount of $50,000 therein estimated for the improvement of
the river, $25,000 could be profitably expended in the fiscal year ending
June 30, 1888.


                                                   COMMERCIAL STATISTICS.

  The following statistics of the commerce of the river have been received from the
collector of the port of Saco, year ending December 31, 1885 :


                                                          Shipping.                                                                  Number.

Arrivals, coastwise .--..---.................------------------..............---..---....---..--------........---...............         200
Clearances, coastwise--..--.---.............-...................................................                                         200
Foreign ..............................             ......     ...........---------------. ............................     -    -3




  It is believed that an increased commerce on the water will immediately follow in-
creased facilities.therefor.



                                                                   A      Io.

           IMPROVEMENT OF PORTSMOUTH HARBOR, NEW HAMPSHIRE.

  The harbor of Portsmouth is situated near the mouth of the Piscataqua
River, on the dividing line between Maine and New Hampshire. The
mean rise and fall of tides is 8-, feet, the extreme variations being, of
course, considerably greater. A small map accompanies this report,
showing the general situation of the harbor and the connecting bays and
rivers. A glance at the map will indicate that a large area of water is
affected by the tides, which must pass and repass through Portsmouth
Harbor. The currents, therefore, sweep up and down the harbor with
                                                                  Sketch
                                                  Showing                situation of

                     PORTSMOUTH                                                            HARBOR.N.H.
                                                  AND           CONNECTIONS               WITH


                 PISCATAQUA                                       AND              COCHECO RIVERS,

      GREAT BAY , EXETER AND LAMPREY RIVER

                                        AND LITTLE HARBOR.

                         Compiled             from~        j/     Coet        8tui'vey-        and    $f&ate           Cacrrts.
                                                         Seale           :120.O00.

                                                                     U       FA'nreeer     Orce,              Porthetd,3e.JekdyLMdB6


                                       To    accompanny      trnnual 7.epor/                    for        Portj'moLat t aror,
                                       aot        C   ochero Mive r, fo,                   t'AZ           yeca endw enyJu et               J   I   t'/




           bQI                         k~asAK,
                          /                                              /
77/7/                                                               .,/*                                                .

                                                       /~          lV
          /7./
 //   ,
                                                           /
                         /             /777.7/,' /~A                aksn                                   ,7
                                                                                                          /7Z
                 /'/iZ            ,,                                                                      /   /                        /




                                                                                                      /                           7
                                                                                                                                  //

                 7                                                                        '7                                  /
                              /             ///                              ///                 //////




                                                                                                                  THE AMERICAN GRAPHIC CO.,N.Y.
              APPENDIX A-REPORT          OF MAJOR SMITH.               547
great rapidity. Over much of the distance the channel is comparatively
narrow, while the strong currents are diverted from side to side by bends
in the channel and the projecting ledges which are found on either
hand. The difficulties encountered in meeting these strong currents may
be inferred from the expressive name which is applied to one of the
projecting points of ledge over which the waters rush until the buoy
is perpetually driven beneath. This is known as " Pull-and-be-damned
Point," and a similar name might fitly be applied to other angles in the
channel.
    Within the harbor, and greatly in the way of vessels passing or ap-
proaching the navy-yard, was a ledge known as " Gangway Rocks," hav-
ing but 9.7 feet of water at extreme low tides. At times the water
passed over the ledge as over a submerged dam with a force so great
that vessels of deep draught could only avoid being forced upon the
rock by giving it a wide berth in passing.
    When it is remembered that on one side of the harbor is located the
United States navy-yard, and that two fortifications and other works
have been undertaken for its defense, and that more than one-half the
vessels arriving pass through the harbor to points on the connecting
waters above, it will be seen that the reduction of these difficulties to a
minimum is a matter of some importance.
    The plan heretofore adopted for remedying the difficulties has been
the following:
    1st. Constructing a breakwater across the side channel between Great
Island and Goat Island. This was completed in 1880, but has since
been reinforced by receiving the stone excavated trom Gangway Rock.
    2d. Removing Gangway Rock to a depth of 20 feet at mean low water.
The depth was restricted to 20 feet, owing to the expense attending a
greater depth.
    3d. Removing to 10 feet at mean low water the ledge on the point of
Badger's Island.
    The entire cost originally estimated was $150,000. From 1879 to 1886
there has been appropriated for the work the sum of $92,000. Of this
amount there was expended up to June 30, 1886, $91,991.28.
    On the 1st of July, 1885, a contract was outstanding with Mr. George
W. Townsend, of Boston, for the removal of 808 cubic yards of Gang-
way Rock. The work was pushed forward during the summer of 1885
until it become necessary to suspend in November. Operations were
resumed April 20, and work under the contract was satisfactorily com-
pleted on the 19th of June, 1886. There still remains to be removed the
amount of 632 cubic yards to complete the improvement at Gangway
Rock as projected. Until the entire amount can be removed little or no
benefit can be experienced from that which is already accomplished, for
the smaller area of ledge, with its edges nearly vertical, is quite as dan-
gerous an ol)stacle as the larger area with its less abrupt sides.
    The estimated expense to complete the removal to a depth of 20 feet
is, including engineering, &c., $20,000.
    It is believed that a greater depth upon Gangway Rock would be very
desirable, as it lies olpposite the navy-yard and directly in the way of
large vessels, which will necessarily have in future a great draught of
water.
    In the further removal of rock from the point of Badger's Island, it is
believed that it will be found advisable to make the depth of water suf-
ficiently great to insure the unobstructed passage of the largest vessels
navigating the river at the lowest stages of the tide.
548               REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

  As it is not likely that funds will be available sufficient to undertake
the last-mentioned work for one or more years, no estimate for the in-
creased quantity is here submitted. It is proposed to apply any funds
which may become available for improving the harbor, first, to com-
pleting the removal of ""Gangway Rock." Meantime the proper depth to
which it may be desirable to remove the ledge at Badger's Island, and
perhaps also at '" Pull-and-be-damned Point," may be more fully consid-
ered.
    The last annual report placed the estimate to complete the project at
$30,000. This was based upon the last contract price, which was ex-
ceptionally low. The remaining part of "Gangway Rock" is compara-
tively small in amount and so situated as to be more expensive than
heretofore, the average depth to remove being less. It is therefore be-
lieved that the original estimate of $30 per cubic yard is more prudent.
This would require, including the usual contingencies for engineering,
surveys, &c., $40,000 to complete the project.
   Portsmouth is a port of entry. The light-houses are the harbor light at Fort Con-
stitution and Whale's Back at the entrance.
   The defenses of the harbor are all incomplete works: Fort Constitution and an
open battery on the west side, and Fort McClary and an open battery on the east side

                                                                   Money statement.
July 1, 1885, amount available .----......-..........--................. ...... $15, 211 00"
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1,1885 ......----..................--................--.....  15,202 28
July 1, 1886, amount available .......... .............................-----------------------------------------     8 72
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886 ..................-                                       . 15, 000 00


{Amount
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887....--..............
           (estimated) required for completion of existing project .----......
   Amopnt that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1888
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
                                                                                                                             15,008 72
                                                                                                                             25,000 00
                                                                                                                             25, 000 00
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.


                                                              COMMERCIAL STATISTICS.

  The following information has been received from the collector of customs for
Portsmouth :

                                                          Shipping.                                              Nltumber.    Tonnage.


Foreign :
    Arrivals-----------------------------------------------------------                                                 57          6, 202
    Clearances ...............................................................                                          54          6,129
Coastwise arrivals and clearances ......                               ..- ...................................         760         20, 865
Amount of revenue collected ...............................................                                                    $1, 200 35
Value of importations........................................................26,                                                   420 11




                                                                                   A       1.




                     IMPROVEMENT OF COCHECO RIVER, NEW HAMPSHIRE.

     A reference to the map accompanying annual reports for Portsmouth
Harbor and Cocheco River will indicate the situation of this river and
its connections with other navigable waters.
  The Cocheco is a branch of the Piscataqua, which reaches the ocean
through the harbor of Portsmouth, N. H. At Dover, N. H., a fall in
                             APPENDIX A--REPORT OF MAJOR SMITH.                                                                                549
the river limits navigation to that point where the mean rise and fall
of the tides is 61 feet.
I The river below Dover is really a part of the tidal arm of the sea.
Its entire length subject to tides is approximately 3 miles, its mouth
being about 13 miles from the Atlantic Ocean by way of the Piscataqua
River.
   From Dover to the lower narrows, a distance of about 1 miles, the
river was originally much obstructed by bowlders, ledges, and shoals.
   In 1870 an examinatio p of the river was made and certain plans,
since adopted and carried out as the necessity arose, have so far in-
creased the commerce of the river that the present facilities are insuffi-
cient for its accommodation. In a recent examination of the river,
passing from Dover to Portsmouth on a tug, I observed six heavily
laden schooners, estimated at from 200 to 400 tons each, all awaiting a
favorable tide to proceed up the river to Dover.
   The following appropriations were made for improvement of the
Cocheco River, up to 1878:
                                                   ----------......-------....-------....
July 4, 1836 ......------......------......----....--......------.                                                  --......-----......       $5, 000
March 3, 1837----....----......---.....-----..--------....----.... ----....---......----
                                                                                   ------...............-----....-------                         5, 000
March 3, 1871......---------....----......--.........................-------..--...............                                                10, 000
June 10, 1872 ...-----...---....-...----...--......--.. ------..................-----......---...-------.....------       ----...........----- 10, 000
             ......----..........
March 3, 1873------                                     ..........           ......................                           ......--....   10, 000
               ......--------.....--------........---
June 23, 1874------                                    ..-....-----                   -----..........---------................
                                                                                                                  --------......--.... 10, 000
March 3, 1875...........---------------------......-------............--......---....................--.....                          25,000
                    ....------------....----..........
'August 14, 1876-----                                            --------......-...... --......----......------.......-----.....-----. 14, 000
June 18, 1878 ----.....-----........-.................-----
                .                                           -----------.........----- ----------..                         ------.. 6, 000

            Total....-------....----......---.... --....--------------............----......           .........--..........                  95, 000
   All the improvements which had been previously contemplated were
completed in November, 1878.
    The new facilities thus afforded attracted a great number of vessels
of large size, to replace the fiat-boats and scows which: had been previ-
ously employed.                                                   '
   The urgent need of further improvements was so represented by the
Board of Trade that, by the act of August 2, 1882, Congress appropri-
ated $28,000 for the purpose. This was applied to making a cut-off
channel through Alley's Point; and widening to 60 feet, and deepening
to 5 feet, the channel through Trickey's and Clement's- Point shoals.
This work was essentially completed in November, 1883.
    The act of July 5, 1884, appropriated $28,000 for completing the im-
provement. Referring to this appropriation, the last Annual Report
states:
   As soon as possible after it became available a careful examination, including bor-
ings, was made of the upper channel. The new estimate based thereon proved that
the necessary improvement ,could not be executed with the available funds.
    An additional estimate of $19,000, to complete the project, was there-
fore submitted.
    On the 1st of July, 1885, a contract was outstanding with Thomas
Symonds, of Leominster, Mass., for removing hard pan, bowlders, and
rock. Work under the.contract was completed September 9,1885. The
amdunt of solid rock removed after July 1, being 829 cubic yards.
This completes the channel to near the Steam mill Wharf to a depth of
 .5 feet, and a width varying from 50 feet to 60 feet. While a draught of
5 feet at mean low water is of vast benefit to the place, and has made
the channel navigable nearly to Dover for vessels of 600 tons, or even
more, at extreme high water, yet the timle for such navigation is lim-
ited to very short intervals near the highest stages.
550      REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S ARMY.

    The bridge across the Piscataqua river near Portmouth Harbor has its
draw very narrow and badly arranged, so that it is generally a very in-
convenient, slow, and tedious process to pass vessels through, In pass-
ing through the draw with the tide it is, in general, necessary to moor
the vessel and allow it to drop through the narrow space stern fore-
most, requiring great pains to accomplish it without injury. Although
not on the Cocheco River, the bridge is so intimately related to that
branch that it is here mentioned as one of the serious obstructions to
that navigation.
    Vessels of the largest draught now have to be lightered a short dis-
tance in order to reach the wharves in the city of Dover.
    I am informed by a committee of the Board of Trade that Dover is
becoming a city of extensive manufactures-it is already larger than
Portsmouth in population and assessed valuation; that in the last year
nearly one hundred vessels arrived at its wharves; that cargoes of coal,
or other heavy freights arriving in vessels, have to be in part lightered
to the wharves at an expense of 35 cents per ton; that two vessels have
arrived with cotton from the South; and that it would be greatly to the
interest of the extensive cotton and woolen mills to obtain all their raw
materials by water, were the facilities sufficient to enable them to do so;
that, owing to the expense of delays and lightering, a considerable part
of the coal and other heavy freights now arrives by rail at an increased
,expense over rates by water with a good channel; that, owing to the
facilities already created, new vessels are being yearly built for that
traffic.
    The following extract from Report No. 1994, House of Representatives,
Forty-ninth Congress, first session, gives so complete a statement of the
business interests involved that it is quoted in this connection:
The city of Dover is situated at the head of tide-water and navigation on the Cocheco
River. It is the largest and most important place between Haverhill on the south,
Portland on the northeast, and Manchester on the northwest.       It is the county seat
of the'county of Strafford, and contains the various county buildings and the county
offices.
  The population of the city is now nearly 15,000, and the valuation for taxable pur-
poses is between $10,000,000 and $11,000,000, exclusive of the public property. The
city has public property in real estate of the value of $250,000.
  The Cocheco River is navigable for vessels of 600 tons burden and drawing 10 to 12i
feet of water, and a. large commerce is carried on in coal, grain, lime, cement, and
other heavy merchandise. There are 100 arrivals per annum, at the wharves, of ves-
sels from the British provinces and all along the Atlantic coast. When the projected
improvements of the channel are completed there can be no doubt the river business
will be of such dimensions as to require custom-house accommodations.
In postal rank and business the city ranks as second in the State.
  The Cocheco Manufacuring C o pauy has       capital of $1,500,000.   It has five mills,
from five to seven stories high, engaged in the manufacture of cotton cloths, of which
it turns out 32,000,000 yards per annum. It is connected with the Cocheco Print
Works, which prints 40,000,000 yards per annum. Together they use 12,000 bales of
cotton per annum, employ 2,000 hands, and have a monthly pay-roll of $50,000.
  The Sawyer Woolen Mills consume 2,600,000 pounds of wool each year, employ 450
to 500 hands, and produce goods annually of the value of $1,200,000.
  The shoe manufacturing industry of the city is larger than in any other city of the
State, employing 1,300 hands, with a monthly pay-roll of some $40,000.
  There are also numerous small industries of great importance and magnitude in the
aggregate.
   The interests involved indicate the necessity of increasing the width
and depth of the channel at least to such an extent that any vessel
which may pass over the Piscataqua River to the Cocheco may con-
tinue on to Dover without obstruction or necessity for lightering. One
foot added to the depth of the channel adds two hours for each tide to
                         APPENDIX              A-REPORT                OF MAJOR SMITH.                                          551
the time in which a vessel of any draught greater than 5 feet may be
taken up or down the river.
   The improvemen t required to complete the present project is to deepen
the channel from Collins' Steam mill Wharf to the Packet Landing, so as
to give a depth of 5 feet at mean low water.
   The widths of the channel cuts are, in general, about 60 feet, though
in places they are but 50 feet. While these widths form a navigable
channel, they are not sufficient to permit vessels of any size to pass
each other safely, nor to permit of convenient handling.
   The total amount appropriated from 1836 to 1886 has been $151,000.
Of this amount there was expended previous to June 30, 1886, $150,973.64.
   It is believed that in future it will be found necessary to increase the
depth of channel and to make the widths of cuts as great as 75 feet. No
estimate for this work is, however, here submitted, as it is considered
better to complete the work heretofore outlined before undertaking new
projects. (See map with last Annual Report.)
   Portsmouth is the nearest port of entry to the city of Dover.

                                                    Money statement.
July 1, 1885, amount available........................................                                                  $9, 804 41
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885............................                 ............ ....                                  9,792 29

July 1, 1886, amount available..---------------................................-------------------------....                 12 12
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886 ..---.............                                                   10, 000 00

Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887....--.......-......                                               10, 012 12

I Amount (estimated)   required for completion of existing project ........                                             9, 000 00
   Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year endingJune 30, 1888                                             9, 000 00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
     harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.



                                               COMMERCIAL STATISTICS.

   The following commercial statistics for the city of Dover have been received:
Number of vessels arrived and cleared ....................................                                       100
Coal received by water..---.......... .           ......                 _......................tons..       25,000
Coal received by rail.-.--...... ---......--...............               .........--           . do....      7, 700
Lime, &c., received by water ..................               .........          .......         casks..     12, 000
Lumber Deceived by water ....--..................              ......         .....      ......    feet.. 2,500, 000
Shingles received by water .--.....--..... ...........................                               .... 8,000, 000
Clapboards received by water ... -.......... ......                   _....                 .
                                                                                 ..... ...........          750, 000

  The other articles received and shipped in the last year, for which water trans-
portation would have been largely used with a good channel, are the following:
                     ---....
Cotton . ---..........                    ......    tons.. 3, 100   Leather and hides.........                            tons..- 3, 050
White cloth.--..---..--.......                     .. do... 1,000   Grain ............-...                        ...... do... 3,575
Wool .......................                          do... 1,300   Flour...................do...                                 1,550
Groceries -..... -...........                        do... 5, 100   Iron and hardware ..........                           do..   1,582
Meats.        ................                        do... 1,250   Paints, &c ................                         .. do...     450
Kerosene ......               ...........             do...   650   Salt, coarse.........                    ........      do...     350
Oils .......          ................               do...    120   Machinery ..........                        ........ do...       300
Starch ......................                         do...   110   Marble ......................                          do...     100
Fertilizers ..................                        do...    75   Prints         ..        ...............               do... 3,300
Boots and shoes ..                      ..... .... do... 2, 100     Woolens ....................                           do...     600
Belting .......                ......           ..    do...   400   Iron manufactures .........                            do..--    150
Miscellaneous ...........               ...... do... 1,500
552          REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

                                           A    12.
                  PRELIMINARY EXAMINATION OF SACO RIVER, MAINE.

                                     UNITED      STATES ENGINEER OFFICE,
                                     Portland, Me., September 1, 1884.
   GENERAL: The act of Congress approved July 5, 1884, for the im-
provement of rivers and harbors, &c., provided for a survey of Saco
River, Maine, and the preliminary examination required by the law
having been assigned to me, I have the honor to submit the following
report:
   Expenditures have already been made at this locality by the United
States for piers at various points of the channel and a breakwater at
the mouth. Certain sunken rocks and ledges have also been removed.
   A survey at the entrance of the river, including the breakwater, was
made in 1883, having been provided for in the river and harbor act
passed August 2, 1882. A project and estimate based upon this survey
were made and submitted to Congress January 8, 1884. (See Senate
Ex. Doc. No. 44, Forty-eighth Congress, first session.) An appropria-
tion of $15,000, for improving the breakwater, was made by the river
and harbor act approved July 5, 1884.
   This survey developed the fact that dredging was required at the
mouth of the river, and estimate therefor was made. Although it was
then known that improvement above the mouth was desired, no survey
or estimate was then made therefor, as it could not be properly done
under the law. Undoubtedly the survey now called for is intended to
cover the upper part of the river.
   Mr. Carl Berrer, draughtsman and acting assistant engineer, has ex-
amined the river under my instructions and obtained from sundry par-
ties their views of what is wanted. Mr. Berrer's report is submitted
herewith. I also transmit a copy of a tabular statement handed me by
Mr. Thomas Quinby, of Biddeford, giving certain commercial and man-
ufacturing statistics.
   Saco and Biddeford (the latter an important manufacturing town)lie
at the head of navigation of the Saco River. I consider the river
worthy of additional improvement in the interest of the business of
these towns, and respectfully recommend that a survey be made as a
basis for a project and estimates for the improvement desired. This
survey will probably cost $200.
   The drawing referred to by Mr. Berrer is transmitted to-day in a sep-
arain        n.


        Respectfully submitted.
                                                             CHAS. E.    BLUNT,
                                                            Colonel of Engineers.
        Brig. Gen. JOHN NEWTON,
            Chief of Engineers, U. S.A.



                  REPORT OF MR. CARL BERRER,   ACTING ASSISTANT ENGINEER.

                                               UNITED STATES ENGINEER OFFICE,
                                                       Portland,Me., August 15, 1884.
  COLONEL: I have the honor-to submit the following report upon the preliminary
examination of Saco River, Maine, made August 11, in pursuance to your instructions:
  The head of tide-water of Saco River is at the adjoining towns of Saco and Bidde-
ford, and the improvements asked for are below these places.
                     APPENDIX          A-REPORT              OF   MAJOR SMITH.               553

   From the entrance to Saco River, near the shore-end of Saco River Breakwater, up
to the wharves at Saco and Biddeford, there is a channel of 6 feet depth at mean low
water, or about 141 feet at mean high water, and of sufficient width, except at the
following places, marked with corresponding letters on the accompanying sketch.
   At "a" the 6-foot channel is closed by a sand bar of a length of about 500 feet, with
a depth of only 4 feet at mean low water.
   At " b" (between Little Islands) the channel, which is very narrow at this place, is
obstructed by a ledge in mid-channel with less than 4 feet at mean low water on its
shoalest point ; between "c" and "d" (from the head of Thunder Island to the foot of
Cow Island) the channel for a distance of about 1,800 feet is irregular, with a least
depth of 4+ feet at mean low water; between "e" and "f" (at the head of Cow Island)
the channel is narrow, and has a least depth of only 31 feet at mean low water; at
"4g," below the principal wharves, a part of the shoal, consisting of sand and sawdust,
is desired to be removed, so as to give a width of 200feet, in order to allow vessels to
turn.
   A depth of not less than 6 feet at mean low water is to be obtained over all the
above-named shoal places.
   To insure the permanency of the channel at the head and north of Cow Island the
channel south of this island might be advantageously closed by a dam, as shown at

  The pier (No. 2) at the head of Thunder Island needs repairing, and its top should
be raised above extreme high water.
  The principal imports are coal and cotton. Full statistics will be furnished by Mr.
Thomas Quinby, agent of Pepperell Manufacturing Company, the largest cotton-mill
at Biddeford.
  The places where improvements are desired were pointed out to me by steamer and
tow-boat captains.
       Very respectfully, your obedient servant,
                                                                                 CARL BERRER.
  Col. C. E. BLUNT,
       Corps of Engineers, U. S. A.


RIVER    COMMERCE       OF   SACO AND BIDDEFORD, MAINE, FOR THE SEASON OF 1883 (APRIL
                                          15 TO DECEMBER 1).

    [Received from Mr. Thomas Quinby, agent of Saco Water Power Company, August 30, 1884.]

  The following articles were received by sundry manufacturing companies and other
consignees during the season:


               Articles.                      Quantity.              Articles.          Quantity.

Coal......----------------------tons.            33, 813                                   tons..    216
                                                           Gravel--...............--------....---..---.
Sand ......---------------------   do...             691   Lime ....................... .casks..  8, 000
Cotton ........................ bales..           8, 750   Cement .......  --.............
                                                                           .              do ...  2, 500
Iron ..................      ......tons..         2, 466   Plaster -........  ............tons.   1,500
            ----
Paving .---..
            ... ....         -......
                         .....     do .-...          456   Ashes ........- .........   bushels..  3, 000
Pitch ........................ barrels..-            108   Timber....................... tons..      102
Paper..........................rolls..               300   Ice ... .. ................... do....  6,000


  Mr. Quinby also gives the names of forty or fifty schooners engaged in the trade,
and states that there are quite a number of others.




                             SURVEY OF SACO RIVER, MAINE.

                                         UNITED STATES ENGINEER                  OFFICE,
                                                            Portland,A31e., October 16, 1885.
   SIR: I have the honor to submit herewith report of the survey of
Saco River, Maine, made under instructions of the Department and in
compliance with the act of Congress approved July 5, 1884, for the im-
provementof rivers and harbors, &c., it being accompanied by a tracing*
                                                  *Omitted.
554      REPORT      OF THR CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

(sent separately by to day's mail) on a large scale, showing the results
of the work, and indicating the improvement suggested ; a small sketch*
of the river is also sent.   It can advantageously be printed with the
report.    Mr. C. Berrer, acting assistant engineer, has executed the
work under my direction.     His report to me, which is approved, is sub-
mitted herewith as part of my own.      The shoal ground at the river en-
trance is not included in the estimate now given, as that was made and
submitted with my report relating to the repairs of the breakwater in
1883.
  With regard to the importance of the improvements now proposed in
comparison with that on the breakwater, which has already been be-
gun, I am constrained to shy that it seems to me that the latter should
take precedence.   I do not think that it would be advisable to make
two separate appropriations for this river or divide the expenditure of
one into two parts. Any sum likely to be appropriated next session for
the Saco River should, in my judgment, be expended exclusively for
the breakwater.
  I accordingly do not recommend the appropriation or expenditure of
any money for next year for the improvements suggested in this report.
(My annual report for the breakwater asks for $50,000 for the continu-
ation of that work.)
  I have not succeeded in obtaining any special statistics of the com-
merce of Saco and Biddeford.       They are important manufacturing
towns, but a large proportion of all goods needed there have come, and
will continue to come, by railroad entirely, irrespective of any river im-
provements.
  Respectfully submitted.
                                                      C. E. BLUNT,
                                                   Colonel of Engineers.
  The CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. A.



                REPORT OF MR. CARL BERRER, ASSISTANT ENGINEER.

                                           UNITED STATES     ENGINEER OFFICE,
                                                       Portland, Me., October 15, 1885.
  COLONEL: I have the honor to submit the following report upon the survey of Saco
River, Maine, made in pursuance of verbal orders received from you:
  The field work was commenced December 16, 1884, but had to be suspended Decem-
ber 18, on account of ice; it was again commenced May 27, and completed June 10,
1885. The result of the survey is embodied in the maps (scale 1 : 2,000), also herewith
submitted, together with a sketch of the navigble part of the river (scale 1 : 15,000).
  The soundings, numbering 6,300, were taken on ranges established on shore, each
sounding being located by a transit angle from a fixed line. The triangulation sta-
tions were marked, where possible, by holes drilled in ledges. The soundings are re-
ferred to a plane of mean low water, determined by tide observations taken during
the survey, but I was told that at the time the river was above its usual summer level.
   Two permanent bench-marks (positions shown on map) were established, 8.917 feet
and 6.40 feet, respectively, above the plane of low water of this survey. The character
of the material forming the several shoals to be excavated was ascertained in many
places. It consists, at or near Little Islands, of sand and gravel, rocks and some logs;
above pier 2, of sand and gravel, slabs, logs, and sawdust.
   Saco River is navigable for a distance of 5 miles from its mouth to the adjoining
towns of Saco and Biddeford, at the head of tide-water.
   A continuous channel with not less than 6 feet of water at mean low tide is asked
for. At present the only serious obstructions in the channel are at and near Little
Islands and from the head of Thunder Island to the town wharves. The survey
was, therefore, confined to those two localities.
   * Omitted; printed in House Ex. Doc. No. 37, Forty-ninth Congress, first session.
                         APPENDIX A-REPOPT                              OF MAJOR SMITH.                                 555
   The shoals at the mouth of the river are to be removed by the work now in prog-
ress there. (See report on Saco Breakwater, 1883.)
   From the shore end of the breakwater the channel is of good width and of not less
than 6 feet depth at mean low water up to Chandler's Point; a bar with 42 feet ob-
structs the channel from this point to Little Islands. Between the Little Islands a
ledge with only 2.9 feet at mean low water over its shoalest point greatly endangers
navigation. Above this place the channel is narrow, and needs widening and straight-
ening. The river here is very wide, and in order to confine the current and keep the
dredged channel open a submerged jetty (A) of the following dimensions-height
above mean low water 3 feet; width on top 3 feet-with slide slopes of 45 degrees, built
of rubble-stone-is projected from Little Islands to the north shore.
   From Johnston's Wharf to the head of Thunder Island the 6-foot channel is con-
tinuous, and of sufficient width, except in a place marked C on sketch, where an ob-
struction (probably a portion of pier 2) in mid-channel should be removed.
   Above the head of Thunder Island the river widens considerably, the 6-foot curve
ends, and continuous dredging is required up to the brick-yard. Material, sand and
gravel.
   At Cow Island the channel is crooked and of insufficient depth, and has to be
straightened and deepened. Above Cow Island a part of the large shoal (dry at half
tide) is proposed to be removed, to enable vessels to come up to the wharves.
   The narrow, crooked channel south of Cow Island, which is of no practical use, is
proposed to be closed by a submerged jetty (B), built of rubble-stone; dimensions:
height, 5 feet above low water; width on top, 5 feet, with side slopes of 45 degrees.
   The large shoal off the wharves in mid-river, consisting of sand and gravel, slabs
and edgings, and logs and sawdust, has existed for a long time, and has not mate-
rially changed in late years; it was created before the dam between Saco and Factory
Island was constructed. The river, rising back in the White Mountains, during spring
freshets carried large quantities of sand, and more particularly logs, sawdust, and other
refuse, from the saw-mills above with it. The currents of the two branches of the
river, meeting just below Factory Island, created strong eddies, whereby the material
was deposited. Since said dam was built comparatively little water comes down this
(north) branch of the river, the main body of water going through the southerly
branch with a strong current. There is also, lately, much less mill refuse thrown into
the river than formerly. It is therefore believed that, with the aid of the submerged
jetty (B), the improvement projected at this place will be permanent.
   Ten piers were built at different times between Saco and the mouth of the river.
Their object was to prevent (sailing) vessels from striking the dangerous rocky points
upon which they were erected. Four of these piers (Nos. 2, 7, 8, and 9, rebuilt in
1873 and 1874) are now in existence; the others have disappeared and need not be re-
placed. All merchant vessels now make use of tow-boats in ascending and descend-
ing the river, and therefore have less difficulty in keeping clear of the projecting
ledge points.
   Pier No. 2, at the head of Thunder Island, is considerable damaged by ice and by
vessels running against it ; its top is covered at high water, and as almost all naviga-
tion is carried on at or near high water, it is, in its present condition, of no benefit
and is even dangerous. If the channel above be dredged as projected, there will be
no difficulty in avoiding the ledge point which it marks, and its entire removal is
recommended. Pier No. 7 is in good condition. Pier No. 8, at Ferry Narrows, through
which the current runs very strong, is built over a dangerous ledge and should be-
preserved. It needs new oak planking at its lower end, also new cap and cross tim-
bers. Pier No. 9, at Jordan's Point, does not require any repairs at present.

                                                            ESTIMATE.

Dredging above and below Little Islands, 16,160 cubic yards, at 40 cents per
  cubic yard in situ ....------.................--------------......------....---...... ..........------..--------     6, 464
Ledge excavations at Little Island, 214 cubic yards, at $20 per cubic yard---....                                      4, 280
Submerged jetty A, 2,500 tons of rubble-stone, at $2. ...                                                              2, 500
Dredging between pier 2 and wharves, 110,000 cubic yards, at 25 cents per
  cubic yard in situ ..........................................                               ..............          27,500
Submerged jetty B, 2,200 tons of rubble-stone, at $1......     ....            ...                                     2, 200
Repair and removal of piers, incidentals, contingencies, &c ..................                                         7, 056
         Total...........................................................                                      ....   50, 000,
         Very respectfully, your obedient servant,
                                                                                              CARL BERRER,
                             C. E.                     BLUNting                       ACol. Assistant Engineer.
         Corps of Engineers, U. 8. A.
                            APPENDIX                B.



    IMPROVEMENT OF HARBORS AND RIVERS IN MASSACHUSETTS:




REPORT OF MAJOR GEORGE L. GILLESPIE, CORPS OF ENGINEERS, BVT.
LT. COL., U. S. A., OFFICER IN CHARGE, FOR THE FISCAL YEAR END-
ING JUNE 30, 1886, WITH OTHER DOCUMENTS RELATING TO THE
  WORK.
                              IMPROVEMENTS.

1. Newburyport Harbor, Massachusetts.          6. Provincetown Harbor, Massachusetts.
2. Merrimac River, Massachusetts.              7. Lynn Harbor, Massachusetts.
3. Scituate Harbor, Massachusetts.             8. Malden River, Massachusetts.
4. Boston Harbor, Massachusetts.               9. Harbor of Refuge at Sandy Bay, Cape
5. Plymouth Harbor, Massachusetts.                 Ann, Massachusetts.




                             UNITED STATES ENGINEER                 OFFICE,
                                                   Boston, Mass., July 24, 1886.
  GENERAL: I have the honor to transmit herewith the annual reports
for the fiscal year ending June 30, 1886, of the improvement of rivers
and harbors which are in my charge.
       Very respectfully, your obedient servant,
                                                    G.   L. GILLESPIE,
          "                                              Major of Engineers,
                                                          Bvt. Lt. Col., U. S A.
  Brig. Gen. JOHN NEWTON,
          Chief of Engineers, U. S. A.



                                        B I.

     IMPROVEMENT OF NEWBURYPORT HARBOR, MASSACHUSETTS.

  I relieved Maj. C. W. Raymond, Corps of Engineers, of the charge of
this work, February 4th, 1886, in accordance with Special Orders No.
16, Adjutant-General's Office, dated January 20, 1886.
  The object of this improvement is to create at the outer bar a per-
manent channel 1,000 feet wide at its entrance, with a least depth of 17
feet at mean low water, or 241 feet at mean high water, so that vessels
of as large draught as can reach Newburyport, may enter the river..
Previous to the commencement of the work there was on the bar a
depth of about 7 feet at mean low water.
                                                                             557,
558       REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

   The project is to build out from the shores north and south of the
harbor outlet, two converging rubble-stone jetties so located as to give
proper direction to the channel, and by scour of the resulting currents
to produce and maintain the desired depth. The location of these jet-
ties is shown on the map in the Report of the Chief of Engineers for the
year 1884. Their form and dimensions are shown on the map in the
report for 1881. The channel at the eastern entrance will be 1,000 feet
wide and will be embraced by parallel sections of tht two jetties, each
1,000 feet long. The project also contemplates the protection of the
shores in the vicinity of the jetties, if necessary, and the construction
of a dike across the basin of Plum Island, to prevent the opening of a
new channel, should the outer beach be broken through. The location
and details of construction of the dike are shown on the map in the
Report of the Chief of Engineers for the year 1883.
   The cost of this improvement was originally estimated to be $365,000.
This, however, did not include the cost of the dike, the construction of
which was not contemplated when the original estimate was made.
The dike was estimated to cost $10,000, making the total estimate
$375,000.
* For this improvement the following appropriations have been made
by Congress:
By   the river and harbor act of June 14, 1880...... .................. ..-.. $50, 000
By   the river and harbor act of March 3, 1881............................     40, 000
By   the river and harbor act of August 2,1882 .............................   40,000
By   the river and harbor act of July 5, 1884 ..............................   40, 000
       Total..--.....--.........-------....---.....................................   170,000
   The amount expended to June 30, 1885, was $160,131.86.
   The condition of the work June 30, 1885, was as follows:
    Work under the following contracts was in progress:
   1. With Mr. C. H. Edwards, of Boston, Mass., contract dated Sep-
tember, 17, 1884, to deliver in the north and south jetties 17,000 tons,
more or less, of rubble stone. There had been delivered, under this
contract, 16,8202-tons.
   2. With Mr. G. W. Townsend, of Boston, Mass., i contract dated
September 17, 1884, for removing three sunken ledges in tlfe harbor
channels. One ledge had been partly removed.
    The Plum Island dike had been completed as far as was at that time
prudent. A central opening, 300 feet wide and 2 feet deep at mean low
water, was still unclosed. No work has been done on this dike during
the year, and none'is expected to be necessary during the coming year.
The work remains in good order, and large quantities of sand are re-
tained in the basin.
   Mr. Townsend completed his contract in September, 1885; 52 cubic
yards of stone were removed from the three ledges, over which there
is now 9 feet at mean low water.
   Mr. Edwards completed his contract in August, 1885, having deliv-
ered, during the fiscal year, 1,872.720 tons, or a total, under his contract,
of 18,692.1920 tons, of which 17,656.360 tons were placed in the north
jetty, and the balance in the south jetty.
   The north jetty was 2,640 feet long ; of this, 1,540 feet was completed;
the remainder was a core, raised approximately to the plain of mean
low water. During the year this core was extetnded 35 feet, and "lev-
elled up" over its whole length. The jetty is now 2,675 feet long, 1,540
feet of full section and the balance a core, all in good order.
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     _~~__                       ____
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               ~___                       ____. __ _~____
                                                            I
                        10
                                                                         /                                                                      r I'         oo       eert        tar           nuI        te.       dd   ;   feet'   A,,or ,.ra   hghw~ter   antd
                                                                                                                                             -SO9foe         for frone hmAo' wot,'
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              Entrance of
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     NEWBURYPORT     HARBOR,                                          MASS.
                     ]ell

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        PLAN
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          SHOWING      CONDITION                 OF IMPROVEMENT
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       June 1886
BLACK                                         /   i
                                                       n




                                                                20
                                                                         r


                                                                                           1      73                                3E7\+1               '
                                                                                                                                                                  c



                                                                                                                                                                             10    /                                                                                                           Seale       of    Plan    (1   eooo)
                                 uo                                 "/                                                                         2''           4    ~                        1           3             23                                                                                           00low20030001Pa


                                                                                     ,   51       i1     4   5
                                                                -
                 8      «    -trjti,"-



                                                                             -                                                 12                                                                                                                                     M   Er   A   N   L   OW                      ATE        R

                                           (   1~J23 (24}  .-        18
                                                                                 s
                                                                                         i9.i
                                                                                           ' __        14~ 13
                                                                                                       )o-           +Q
                                                                                                                          22
                                                                                                                            0.
                                                                                                                           ]"
                                                                                                                                    15
                                                                                                                                         .
                                                                                                                                              l-4.
                                                                                                                                                 2   -
                                                                                                                                                         0
                                                                                                                                                             /-                         f4--c         t10                                T


                                                                                                                 r   1
                                                                                                                     :     -            124v             1                                     21

                                                                                                                                                                  a           -4



                                         Ru S ad
                                               8                         0               .0                                         0                                                                            I




   '9    d
                                                                                                                                                                        P4


                                                                                                                                                                        ti




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               THALWEGS FROM GORGE TO                    OCEAK

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          18s6

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          1885
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           -    ----      1880
                        I. S. Enineer              Officee
                                      Boston , Mass. huly 24. 1886.
                        To accompnainy anual report of

                                                                         Major of                            n.ineers. Bvt.Lf. Col.US.A.
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   . ..             .0
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      THE AMERICAN GRAPHIC CO.,N.Y,
             2
H Exl pt         v2 49 2
        APPENDIX     B--REPORT OF LIEUT.-COL.         GILLESPIE.      559
   The south jetty was 1,300 feet long, of which 1,077 feet were fully
completed; the balance was a core, which was approximately at the
height of mean low water. During the fiscal year this core was "lev-
eled up" throughout its whole length. No increase in length of jetty *
was made. The work remains in good order.
   The sand-catch in rear of the south jetty was 572 feet long, with 606
feet of spurs or jetties. During the year, 444 feet of this sand-catch
were repaired and refilled, and 245 feet of new work, with 294 feet of
spurs, were built. This new work was a double wire fence filled with
sea-weed. So long as the sea-weed remained damp, it served its pur-
pose very well, but when it became dry it was easily displaced by the
wind, and the sand-catch became powerless to stop the drifting sand.
    Proposals have been invited (to be opened July 15) for the rebuild-
ing of this sand-catch in a more substantial manner, of timber, brush,
and stone.
    During the latter part of the fiscal year a survey was made covering
the area from the gorge between Salisbury Point and Plum Island, to
the jetties and in front of the jetties to the outside 15-foot curve. This
survey shows that a navigable 12-foot channel exists through the bar,
generally 300 feet wide, and nowhere less than 200 feet wide. The
depth, as shown by the survey of June, 1885, was a little over 9 feet;
this increased depth is most encouraging for the improvements in prog-
ress.
    The chart accompanying this report shows the condition of the chan-
nel across the bar along the line of deepest water, which is the existing
navigable channel, and the improvement in depth over that of last year.
    A comparison between the surveys of 1885 and 1886 shows that the
shore-line outside the jetties has not essentially altered. Within the
jetties the high and low water lines remain practically unchanged on
the Salisbury Beach side. At the most southerly point of the cove, just
inside of the south jetty, the high-water line has advanced about 150
feet, thus strengthening this weak part of Plum Island. The remain-
der of the high-water line to the gorge section and the low-water line
show no material change. The distance from the gorge section along
the 9-foot channel of 1885, to the outside 18-foot curve, was 5,300 feet.
From the same point along the 12-foot channel of 1886, to the outside
18-foot curve, the distance is only 4,900 feet.
    This difference is caused by the straightening of the channel, which
at the bar has moved about 500 feet southward, and by so much nearer
the proposed true axis, and also by the westward advance of the ex-
terior 18-foot curve.
    A comparison of the "Thalwegs" of 1880, 1885, and 1886 shows the
extensive excavations made by the currents on the bar proper, part of
the material apparently having been deposited by the flood-current in
rear of the bat-.
    The freshets of the river during the year have not been in excess of
the average high-water stages, and were not characterized by unusally
  high velocities. The apparent increased action of the jetties during the
year can, therefore', be accounted for only on the probable supposition
that the jetties have become more consolidated by settling and filling
with sand, and thus better able to direct the currents at low stages.
    The balance available July 1, 1886, $3,242.46, is not sufficient to con-
tinue the improvements beyond the repair of the sand-catch.
  The amount required for the completion of the existing project is
$205,000, all of which can be profitably expended during the fiscal year
560              REPORT                OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

ending June 30, 1888. If such an appropriation is made it is proposed
to apply it to the rapid simultaneous construction of both jetties.
  This work is located in the collection district of Newburyport, Mass., of which
Newburyport is the port of entry. The nearest light-house is on Plum Island, at the
entrance to the harbor.
  The accompanying commercial statistics for the fiscal year ending
June 30, 1886, have been furnished by the collectors of customs for
Newburyport, Mass.
                                                             Money statement.
July 1, 1885, amount available .......................................... $9,868 14
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885-...............
                                       --      ......................... 6, 625 68
July 1, 1886, amount available..........................................                                                               3,242 46
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886..-..................                                                               37,500 00

Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887................-------------------....                                          40,742 46
    Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project.-.-.167,500 00
    Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1888 167, 500 00
    Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
     harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.


                                                       COMMERCIAL                 STATISTICS.

                                                                        CUSTOM-HOUSE,                    NEWBURYPORT, MASS.,
                                                       Collector's Office, July 12, 1886.
  SIR: In reply to yours of May 25, 1886, 1 would report "commercial statistics " show-
ing the amount of revenue collected, number of entrances and clearances, tonnage
and character of the same, foreign and domestic, during the fiscal year ending June
30, 1886.
  Amount of revenue collected, $1,996.32.

                                                          Vessels.                                                              Number.    Tons.


Foreign trade, entered--...-------..--..-....---.......--------..---.......----.------------...........-..--------...........         20    2, 801
Foreign trade, cleared ........ .........   ......... -....... ....                ..
                                                                 .. ................                                                  31    4, 304
Domestic trade, entered .................    .................      ..... ............
                                                                ......                                                               290   91, 630
Domestic trade, cleared---......           ............--
                                 ...........              .......
                                                               ..........--
                                                                         --.... .......                                              288   89, 240
The fisheries, entered .............................................................                                                  77    1, 649
The fisheries, cleared ....-- ............ .........                       .. ........
                                                   .............--..........                                                          78    4, 304


   No particular change has taken place in the situation of the harbor and its neces-
sities since last report in 1885 ; therefore no other particular suggestions are offered.
           I am, very respectfully, yours, &c.,
                                                                                                                   DANIEL P.       PIKE.
                                                                                                                            Deputy Colleclor.
   Maj. G. L. GILLESPIE,
           Corps of Engineers, Bvt. Lieut. Col., U. S. A.




                                                                          B     2.

                 IMPROVEMENT OF MERRIMAC RIVER, MASSACHUSETTS.

    I relieved Maj. C. W. Raymond, Corps of Engineers, U. S. A., of the
charge of this work, February 4, 1886, in accordance with Special Or-
ders No. 16, Adjutant-Generas Office, dated January 20, 1886.
  The object of this work is the improvement of the channel of the river
from its mouth, near Plum Island Light, to the head of the Upper Falls,
           APPENDIX B-REPORT                             OF LIEUT.-COL. GILLESPIE.                       561
a distance of 211 miles. Previous to its commencement the channel was
narrow and crooked in several places, and much obstructed by bowlders,
ledges, shoals, and the remains of old crib-work and piers.
   The project was adopted in 1870 and modified in 1874. It provides
for a channel of navigable width, its various parts having the following
depths at high water of ordinary stages of the river: From the mouth
near Plum Island Light to Deer Island Bridge, 16J feet; from the Deer
Island Bridge up to Haverhill Bridge, 12 feet; thence to the foot of
Mitchell's Falls, 10 feet; thence to the head of the Upper Falls, not
less than 41 feet, with the mill-water at Lawrence running.
   The cost of the improvement under the amended project of 1874 was
estimated to be $47,000.
   The following appropriations have been made for this work by Con-
gress:
By acts from July 11, 1870, t          June 18, 1878..$..            - .......................        $132, 000
By the river and harbor act of March 3, 1879...................- .........                               5,000
By the river and harbor act of June 14, 1880 ....................-......                                12, 000
By the river and harbor act of March 3, 1881........ ....-.. ..-..--.. ..     .                          9, 000
By the river and harbor act of August 2, 1882 .-..-......--...............                               9,000
By the river and harbor act of July 5, 1884.............     ........... ......                          3,500
      Total .......... .". . .................           ........ ....
                                            ..............                                             170, 500
   The total amount expended to June 30, 1885, was $169,910.81.
   The condition of the improvement June 30, 1885, was as follows:
   The channel from the mouth of the river to the head of the Upper
Falls had been completed in accordance with the amended project.
   The excess of expenditure over the estimate was caused by the re-
moval of rocks and other obstructions whose existence was unknown, or
whose removal was not contemplated when the original estimate was
made, and by the making of surveys and examinations not provided for
in the estimate.
   No operations were in progress during the fiscal year ending June 30,
1886. The balance available July 1, 1886, $299.04, will be used in in-
specting the improvement from time to time.
   Certain additional improvements are needed for this lower part of the
river, and are recommended as follows :
1. Remove sunken rocks and shoals from the falls above Haverhill .......... $1, 500
2. Remove the " Boilers" in Newburyport Harbor to a depth of 5 feet at mean
    low water, estimated to contain 350 cubic yards, at $25..................
                                                                ------                                   8,750
Contingencies ......   ......     ......    ................             ......   .................      1,250

      Total....             ...       ........... ................
                                             ........                        ............ ........      11,500

  To extend the improvement so that the depth of water obtained
through Mitchell's Falls can be carried to Lawrence (a distance of 5
miles from the head of the falls) was in 1882 estimated to cost, for dredg-
ing through Gage's Shoal and Andover Bar, and removing bowlders and
ledges, $11,000.
  Or for the improvement of the channel from its mouth at Plum Island
to Lawrence (a distance of 261 miles) would require an additional ap-
propriation of $22,500.
  For the purposes above mentioned this amount could be profitably
expended during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888.
  This work is located in the collection district of Newburyport, Mass., of which
Newburyport is the nearest port of entry. The nearest light-house is the Plum
Island Lights and the Newburyport Upper Harbor lights.
        36 E
562         REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

                                                   Money statement.
July 1, 188, aiuount available...... ---....--...-----......        ..................                               $589 19
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 185.....-- ---....----------------......-------------..-------..                                290 15

July 1, 1886, amount available--...----------------......----.                                     ----
                                                                                           ...---.-----....           299 04

 (Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project .... ....                                         22, 500 00
j Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1888                                       22,500 00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
 (   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.




                                                              B 3"
            IMPROVEMENT OF SCITUATE HARBOR, MASSACHUSETTS.

   I relieved Maj. C. W. Raymond, Corps of Engineers, U. S. A., of
the charge of this work, February 4, 1886, in accordance with Special
Orders No. 16, Adjutant-General's Office, dated January 20, 1886.
   The object of this improvement is to create a harbor of refuge for
vessels when eastward of Boston.
   At the commencement of the improvement the harbor had a low-
water area of about 57 acres, over 6 acres of which there was a depth
of at least 3 feet at mean low water. It was open to the action of east-
erly winds.
   The project adopted in 1880 is to build two breakwaters; (one from
" Cedar Point," on the north side of the entrance, and the other from
the point of the " First cliff" on the south side); and to deepen the
area inclosed and in front of the entrance by dredging.
   The breakwaters are to be of rubble stone and are to be 20 feet wide
on top, which is in a plane 4 feet above mean high water, except at
the outer ends, which are raised 6 feet higher, so as to be conspicuous
guides for entrance.
   The dredging proposed (covering a channel length of 2,700 feet) will
require the removal of 500,000 cubic yards, and will give a depth of 15
feet at mean low water in the entrance channels; from 12 to 15 feet be-
tween the breakwaters; 12 feet immediately in rear of the south break-
water, and 10 feet for the main harbor basin.
   The estimated cost of the breakwaters was $100,000, and of the drdtg-
ing $190,000, or a total of $290,000 for this improvement.
   In aid of this project the following appropriations have been made
by Congress, viz:
By the river and harbor act of June 14, 1880...-..........................                                           $7,500
                                                 -
By the river and harbor act of March 3, 1881 ......-......        ....................                               10, 000
By the river and harbor act of August 2, 1882 -................               _ ............                         10,000
By the river and harbor act of July 5, 1884......................---------------------...                            10, 000
            ....----.........------......--..
       Total----                                ---------------------.........--------------.......-----...--...      37, 500

  The     total amount expended to June 30, 1885, was $37,108.54.
  The     condition of the improvement June 30, 1885, was as follows :
  The     north breakwater had been constructed to its full height for a
length    of 720 feet, about 15,000 tons of rubble-stone having been put in
place. The south breakwater had not been commenced. A portion of
the beach between Cedar Point and the land had been protected by a
                                                                                             I                             Z9                          J                                                        '       2                  -        n                                                                                                                                           Iv.
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     .>0;




                                                                                                                          0         5                   02                           -                                                                                                                  2                                                   )             2.o       A
                                                                                                                                                                        a




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  '3                   10.,1-              *.




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                21.o         ?3

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     ;s



                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   )                                                             Y- z
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              a               /\                                                210

                                                                                             6-
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   OLD       S 0VW
                                                                                                  a                            '9                          '           /3                          '

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   i          9.                 13.    l            18,




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              .1

                                                       -40S                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     19
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    r%
                                                            _                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  a4                                   1                                                        4'y
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         ii                       sg,   '        .




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           N


                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       -        /O
                                                                                                                                                           8A                            1.2                            4-
                                                            -                                                                                                                                                                                                               Oa                1i,




                                                                -                                                                                                                         I                                                pg                 r_             t                                                  ,




                                                                            5               Z     2                            9                               2                     1"       ,                 A-5     9        32-13V             14.
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    9                                -Z
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     6         1-s1'3)0.1./                                                     0.y                                                                                                             13.                    /2.            12.                    13.,




                                                   S                        1
                                                                                            ,p.
                                                                                             13   _       .-




                                                                                                                     -3ts3.,
                                                                                                                    l.         -
                                                                                                                                   4.'"   1
                                                                                                                                                  1k    3g
                                                                                                                                                                   L3       35
                                                                                                                                                                                          1        k            5
                                                                                                                                                                                                                        48  j
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     4.1       1"                  5
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       1"5.3X                      o




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   2
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               y    l




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                            S,
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    2-- 5               r
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               P- LrlLO                     k-              j~                  16




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  . I?'
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 /U  /
                                                                                                                                   357(                                                                9 59                                                                                                    B
                                                                                                                                                                                          Z'           -                     .                 °5             t                  13                            0        2           t
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                Id,
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 .0~             19
                                                       _"           .   _        _                                        "          3        °         354                                                                                                   567           0        1s        ?.                  2    .           "       46

                                                                                                  0            .3 331. 1
                                                                                                                                                       tf"f                 3 °               3        /     5 Q                 t         7 1"           '            3             7         2               2 .                  3 -
                                                                                                                                                                                                           7_5                        9)3                          .             i                                                   3.                                                                                                                                                                             ti3
                                                                                                                                                               O6            .                3a                                                        %.             .5                $             9               "5               3       -                                                                                                                               186

                                                         21                                                                         7                                   7-65(35"o                                   2-               6                                      '6       ,              Z      '    2       .

                                                                        149                                                                                            7                                                                            6              1                 1.9                            2333"
                                                                                                                                                                                  2.5                                             JO'S                                                   h~~~131 s                                          .
                                    -2.                                                                                                                    99                    *.   3                             ,            03                     .16            -                                       6
                                         7                                                                                 3I                                                                                                                                                                                                                   y

                                                                                                                         1,
                                                                                                                          /1.7                3.                   '         4
                                                                                                                                                                             9.0                                                 0 98
                                                                                                                               6              3                                                                                                                                              2.0
                                                                                                                                                                             1.y                                                                                                              1n                                                3"i
                   -7.                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       67                                                      74              2p            23
                          8                   2.
                                                                                                                                          2                7                                       g                     (4-                                  1.9                                          031
                                                                                           1,3          .331)0                                     0                                                                93
                                                                                                               6.9 (0,25
                                                                                                           2p .71Z
                                                                                                  .3 36j.03Z
                   -      2                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      2.3                                                                        ,   20.,
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        °o                   &3



                                                                                                                                                                   26_
                                                                            .3       - _     _                                 .6.1                                                                        24
      -_
           3-
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           1     &   0



                                                   1,.      .                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               9                                                                                                                                        14,\
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 o,           .
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                18       o   2




                                     21"
                                     2                                                                                             -?                                            32~                       1.'3)z                                                                                              2n       esr(                        033313      2 3(613
                          5"         ~"




                                                                                                                               -                   _                    _

                   -. 3              2
                                             /d
                                                                            VI
                                                                                                                                    ~ 2/~~
                                                                                                                                   06.                                                        ~                     Y.               3 3                L s~ i 3 ,                                                          53


                               -.    ' "




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           SCITUATE                                    HARBOR . MASS.
                                                                                           _ _        '        ':        -
                                                                                                                          --
                                                                                                                                    - -
                                                                                                                                    ----
                                                                                                                                                   -               -                        c7             ? * ,r                333i 33(                     . 33W      '033"     s c '   1                                                    i n2 Peet3            1
                                                                                                                                   ° '\           -$       _ _'                  -
                                                                                                                                                                                         d.d
                                                                                                                                                                                          ad
                                                                                                                                                                                               c'.'Pt
                                                                                                                                                                                                           13fr,33' ,ur'v.-.s
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     m/                              0 93for
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              o.-,du ea.
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  ch 87wae
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             iu'ooter                                                                                                                                   P1 an
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                showing                condition                                of                   improvement
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                            June                   30. 1886

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                            SCALE                  OF            PLAN                       (1:6000)

                                                                                                                                                                                                           Major of Eninieers, Bvt Lt (o. US.A.


                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             ;
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 -HE    AIMElCP(;        . GPF:_ :CO..N.Y.

1 Exlpt2 v2 49 2
              APPENDIX             B--REPORT OF LIEUT.-COL.                                  GILLESPIE.                563
brush and stone bulkhead 45 feet long, in front of which was a stone
apron 10 feet wide and 385 feet long.
   For temporary relief to commerce, a channel 1,600 feet long, 100 feet
wide, and 5 feet deep at mean low water, starting at a point 300 feet
east of the north end of the proposed south break water, had been cut
as far westward as the " Deep Hole," where an inner basin had been
prepared, 200 feet by 160 feet, with 7 feet depth at mean low water.
  No work of improvement was done during the year, but a survey was
made the latter part of June, 1886, which shows that the dredged chan-
nel and basin have not materially changed since the completion of the
work in June, 1885. The 5-foot channel is generally more than 100 feet
wide, although at a point opposite the proposed south breakwater it is
for a length of 150 feet only 50 feet wide, of the full depth (5 feet). The
remainder of the width is about half a foot shoaler.
  The balance on hand July 1, 1886, is $165.60, not sufficient to continue
the improvement. It will be applied to inspecting the condition of the
improvement from time to time.
   "Harbor Rocks" should be removed. They form an obstruction
marked by a buoy, about 500 feet east by south from the outer end of
the south breakwater, and near the southern edge of the dredged
channel.
  They consist of several detached rocks, covering an area of about 50
feet square; they project about li feet above mean low water, and to
reduce them to the plane of the bed of the sea in the vicinity will re-
quire the removal of 108 tons of stone, estimated to cost $648.
   To complete the project will require an appropriation of $252,500, of
which amount $100,000 could be profitably expended during the fiscal
year ending June 30, 1888. This sum, if appropriated, it is proposed to
expend in continuing the approved project as follows:
Build south breakwater, 20,000 tons, at $2.15 ...--....--.....--.....---.........                                     $43, 000
                                                                     -----------------------------
Remove harbor rocks, 108 tons, at $6 ......--------........................                                                648
Enlarge basin to eight acres, 10 feet deep, and channel to 150 feet wide and
  10 feet deep, at mean low water, 160,000 yards, at 30 cents................                                          48, 000
Contingencies .---................-----------------......-----.......----.....................---------------------..   8, 352

                                                                                                                   100, 000
  This work is located in the collection district of Plymouth, Mass. The nearest port
of entry is Plymouth, Mass. The nearest light-house is Minot's Ledge Light, distant
about 5 miles.
  The accompanying commercial statistics for the fiscal year ending
June 30, 1886, have been furnished by the collector of customs at Ply-
mouth, Mass.
                           Money statement.
July 1, 1885, amount available                   ................       ..........       ...............           $391 46
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885------......----....--..--......--------------......................--....------          225 86
July 1, 1886, amount available............ ............................                                             165 60
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886....................-                                         10, 000 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887......
                                                     --............
                                                            -10,165                                                        60

   Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project---..-- 242,500 00
   Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1888 100, 000 00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
564           REPORT               OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

                                                   COMMERCIAL STATISTICS.

                                                                            CUSTOM-HOUSE, PLYMOUTH, MASS.,
                                                         Collector's Office, June 25, 1886.
   SIR : I answer to your request for " detailed" information for " Scituate Harbor"
I answer that personally I have but little knowledge of it, as it is some 25 miles dis-
tant from this port, but from information gathered from deputies and others I am
enabled to present the following report:
   There is belonging to the port 4 vessels, ranging from 6 to 10 tons burden, that are
engaged in mossing and fishing, producing annually about $35,000 worth of Irish
moss (as it is called), and $4,000 worth of fish.
   There is landed annually about 12 cargoes of lumber and 10 of coal, and about 100
sail of small size vessels, such as yachts, &c., harbor there in the course of the season.
   The channel dredged by Government does not fill up, and the Government works
stood well the heavy storms of the last winter.
   There is no manufacturing interests of consequence at the port, the business being
mostly agricultural. Its value as a harbor of refuge is quite uncertain, but should a
ship in distress within the bay be so fortunate as to enter the harbor, the saving of
life and property in this one instance would far outweigh all the costs of construction.
   We do not feel competent to (as asked) offer any suggestions for future improve-
ments, knowing that engineering skill and practical knowledge far outweigh theories.
       Very respectfully, your obedient servant,
                                                                                         SAMUEL H.   DOTEN,
                                                                                            Collector of Custom8.
   G. L. GILLESPIE,
            Major of Engineers, Bvt. Lieut. Col., U. S. A.



                                                                     B 4.

                IMPROVEMENT OF BOSTON HARBOR, MASSACHUSETTS.

  I relieved Maj. C. W. Raymond, Corps of Engineers, of the charge
of this work February 4, 1886, in accordance with Special Orders No.
16, Adjutant-General's Office, dated January 20, 1886.
    The object of this improvement is, first, to preseve the harbor by
protecting the islands and headlands, and, second, to improve it by
widening, straightening, and deepening the channels.
   The projects adopted for this purpose since 1866 have been mainly
in accordance with the recommendations of the United States commis-
sioners, whose labors terminated during that year.
   The works of preservation consist of sea-walls, aprons, jetties, &c.,
which protect the shores of the islands and headlands, prevent addi-
tional wash into the channels, control the tidal scour, and preserve the
full height of anchorage shelter for vessels in the roadsteads.
   The works of improvement have been by dredging and blasting, by
which means many dangerous rocks and shoals have been removed.
   The following sums have been appropriated by Congress for this im-
provement since 1866:
By acts from March 2, 1867, to March 3, 1879--..                      ----            ......----- .....---. $1, 331,000
By act of June 14, 1880 ($30,000 to be expended in Boston Harbor; $22,500
  at the mouth of Charles River, in said harbor, and up to Watertown;
  $17,500 at the mouth of the Mystic River, in said harbor, and $5,000
  from said harbor to Nantasket Beach) ........                            ...                 ...       ...     75,000
By act of March 3, 1881 ($40,000 to be expended in said harbor; $35,000
  at the mouth of Charles River, in said harbor, and up to Watertown;
  $20,000 in said harbor, at mouth of Mystic River, and $5,000 from said
harbor to Nantasket Beach)....                     -..-.....        ...... .... ....        .... .....         100, 000
By act passed August 2, 1882, for completing improvement ..............                                          96, 500
By act of July 5, 1884..............................................                                              5, 000
        Total............................................................                                 1,607,500
   The total amount expended to June 30, 1885, was $1,598,971.01.
        APPENDIX     B-REPORT      OF   LIEUT.-COL.   GILLESPIE.      565

                       WORKS OF PRESERVATION.

    The condition of the works of preservation on June 30, 1885, was as
follows, viz:
    Point Allerton.--This point, at the southeast entrance of the harbor,
was protected by a granite sea-wall 1,202 feet in length. It was com-
pleted in 1873. Its concrete foundation, for a distance of 1,005 feet,
was protected by an apron and eight jetties of granite rubble-stone.
The work was generally in good order. Some of the joints required re-
pointing. During the year no work has been done on this wall. In
November and December, 1885, and in January, 1886, severe storms
cut the bluff and beach to the west of the wall. To more fully protect
this part of the bluff the wall should be extended to the westward
about 150 feet; this is estimated to cost, with proper riprap aproning
at its west end, $15,000. The beach further west, along Stony Beach,
Telegraph Hill, and Wind-Mill Point, shows signs of abrasion, but no
immediate danger to the channel is anticipated from this wear.
    Great Brewster Island.-This island, on the north side of the en-
trance to the main ship-channel, was protected by a granite sea-wall
2,840 feet in length, which was completed in 1869. It was in fair order.
Some stones, at the southeast angle of the wall, were loose and re-
quired resetting, and about 300 feet of the coping course required re-
setting; these repairs were estimated to cost $3,000. During the year,
no work was done on the wall, and it now remains in essentially the
same condition as on July 1, 1885.
    George's Island was protected by a granite sea-wall, with rip-rap ex-
tensions at the south and west ends.
   The sea-wall is 2,150 feet long, and it and the southern rip-rap, ,600
feet long, were completed about 1835. The western rip-rap, which is
450 feet long, was built in 1884-'85. The sea-wdll and ripraps were in
good order on June 30, 1885. No work was done on them during the
year. During the winter of 1885-'86 the unprotected western shore-line
of this island, in front of the Government buildings, was considerably
abraded; the high-water line was moved back, in places nearly 20 feet.
This shore-line, 1,400 feet long, should be protected by a light sea-wall,
which is estimated to cost $35,000. Some minor repairs are needed to
the sea-wall; these are estimated to cost $100.
    Lovell's Islcnd.--The western shore of this island was protected by a
rubble-stone apron, built in 1873, repaired and extended in 1884. It is
975 feet long. The northern shore was covered by a granite sea-wall,
built in 1843, and repaired in 1878. It is 750 feet long. The eastern
shore was protected by a granite sea-wall, 800 feet in length, completed
in 1869; and by rubble-stone aprons between the northern and eastern
sea-wall, 1,440 feet long, and south of the east sea-wall one 1,330 feet
long. Those walls and aprons were in good order June 30, 1885. No
work was done on them during the fiscal year. The storms of the winter
of 1865-'66 caused the southern part of the western riprap to settle and
move seaward slightly. It is, however, now as efficient a protection as
ever, and requires no immediate repair. The north sea-wall and both of
the eastern ripraps are in good order.
   The eastern sea-wall was considerably injured; about 200 feet of the
coping stones on its north end and the cobble-stone paving in rear of
this portion of the wall were displaced and thrown, some in front and
some in rear of the wall. This part of the wall requires additional relief
to conform to the main part of the wall. These repairs are estimated
to cost, including contingencies, $6,000. The southern shore of the
566     REPORT OF    THE   CHIEF   OF ENGINEERS,     U. S. ARMY.

island has suffered some considerable abrasion, but no repair is recom-
mended at present, as the study of the survey of this part of the harbor
has not yet been completed.
   Gallop's Island.-The western, northern, and eastern shores of this
island at the close of 1871 had been protected by a granite sea-wall
1,7851 feet long, and by an apron (covering also the foundation of the
sea-wall) 3,050 feet long. Both the sea-wall and apron were in good
order June 30, 1885. No work was done on them during the fiscal year.
To more completely protect the northwestern bluff of this island the sea-
wall should be extended about 150 feet to the southward. This, it is
estimate(d, will cost $7,500. The present sea-wall and riprap shore pro-
tection are in good order.
   Deer Island.-The three prominent heads of this island had been pro-
tected by granite sea-walls originally built about 1827. They are of the
following lengths: The north head wall 1,740 feet; the middle head 840
feet, and the south head 380 feet. In 1865 and 1869 these walls were
partly rebuilt, and in the weakest places were backed with concrete.
All these walls were originally built dry, and they have from time
to time required repairs. On the 30th of June, 1885, the necessary re-
pairs were estimated to cost $150. These repairs were made in Octo-
ber, 1885. No other work was in progress during the fiscal year. The
present condition of these walls is as follows: The north head wall is in
fair order; in the middle head wall about 50 feet of the paving in rear
of the wall, near its northern end, requires relaying, and 105 feet of the
coping stones, near the southern end, must be reset (the stones have
been thrown off the wall and the paving in rear of them injured) ; these
repairs will cost, it is estimated, $750. At the south head wall, near
its northern extremity, about 75 feet of the wall has been demolished
by the winter storms, and requires entire rebuilding, and, for an addi-
tional length of 60 feet, one or two courses require resetting. These re-
pairs are estimated to cost $3,000, but in view of the value of this south
head in the defense of the harbor it would seem better policy to rebuild
this wall, which would cost, for 250 feet of new wall at $75 per foot, and
including about 10 per cent. for contingencies, $20,000.
   Long Island.-The north head of this island was protected by a gran-
ite sea-wall 2,0814 feet long, completed in 1874. The foundation of the
sea-wall and its southern and western ends are protected by an apron
of rubble-stone aggregating 1,375.feet in length. This apron was built
in 1874 and extended in 1884. All was. in fair order June 30, 1885, at
which date it was estimated to cost $400 to make some repairs to the
pointing of the masonry. During the fiscal year no operations were in
progress. The present condition of the work is as follows: The wall
and riprap are in good order, but some repointing should be done,
which is estimated to cost $1,000, and the southeastern riprap shore
protection should be extended 250 feet. This is estimated to cost $2,000.
   Rainsford Island.-The north head of this island had been protected
by a dry granite wall 1,500 feet long, originally built in 1840, arid ex-
tensively repaired in 1884-'85. It was in excellent order June 30, 1885.
No work was done on it during the fiscal year, and none is anticipated
to be necessary during the year ending June 30, 1888.
   Castle Island.-This island had been protected by a dry granite sea-
wall 3,300 feet long, built in 1835, and a high riprap extension of it to
the southwest 300 feet long, built about 1865. June 30, 1885, the riprap
shore protection was in good order, and the wall required some repairs,
which were estimated to cost $350. No work was done during the fiscal
year. The present condition of the work is as follows: The riprap is
           APPENDIX   B--REPORT OF LIEUT.-COL. GILLESPIE.           567
in good order, but about 100 feet of the sea-wall has undermined and
requires taking down and relaying. - This will cost, it is estimated,
$1,000.
   Governor's Island.-The bluffs and shore-line of this island have never
been protected. They stand, however, in very important relations to
the main ship channel at the Upper and Lower Middles. In addition to
this the bluffs are occupied by important heavy batteries for the de-
fense of the inner harbor and the navy-yard. Serious abrasions of these
bluffs have been in progress for some years. The two main bluffs, the
east and south, should at once be protected by light sea-walls. That at
the east battery will be 500 feet long, and is estimated to cost $30,000;
the south bluff wall should be 1,800 feet long, and is estimated to cost
$50;000.
                       WORKS   OF IMPROVEMENT.

   The condition of the works of improvement on June 30, 1885, was as
follows:
    The main ship-channel had been widened, straightened, and deepened
by dredging and the removal of sunken rocks so that it was nowhere
less than 600 feet wide and 23 feet deep at mean low water; originally
it was but 100 feet wide and 18 feet deep.
   In effecting this improvement to the main ship-channel dredging and
blasting was done at the following places (reference being had to the
plan of the harbor accompanying Report of the Chief of Engineers for
the year 1883):
   At Nashe's Rock Shoal, during the years 1876-'78, 365 yards of ledge
were removed.
   At Kelly's Rock and Shoals, during the years 1869 to 1879, 222 cubic
yards of ledge were removed.
    Tower, Corwin, and Channel rocks were removed during the years
1867-'75; they aggregated 608 cubic yards.
   From the west end of Brewster Spit, during the years 1874-'76, 29,226
cubic yards of sand and gravel were dredged and 954 cubic yards of
ledge were removed.
   At Lovell's Island, from the southeast and southwest points, 267,2941
cubic yards were dredged during the years 1867-'77.
   At Castle Island Bar and Shoals, opposite the lower middle, during the
years 1880 and 1883, 36,957 yards were dredged and 20 tons of rock
were removed.
   At the Lower Middle. 1874-'75, State and Palmyra rocks were removed.
They aggregated 62 cubic yards.
   At the Upper Middle, during the years 1870 to 1876, 268,278k cubic
yards were dredged and 118- cubic yards of ledge were removed.
   At Anchorage Shoal, during the years 1879 to 1882, 65,327 cubic yards
were dredged.
   At Man-of-War Shoal, 85,917 yards were dredged in the years 1878-'80.
   At Mystic River Shoal, during the years 1879-'82, 82,082 cubic yards
were removed.
   This improved main ship-channel extends through the lower and up-
per harbors.
   The improvements along it in the lower harbor, with the exception of
the dredging at Great Brewster Spit, have been apparently permanent.
The exact condition of this part of the channel will be shown by, and
any project for its further improvement based upon, the results of the
survey made during the last year, the notes of which are not yet fully
plotted.
568           REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

   In the upper harbor the improvements of the channel have been per-
manent and show no.deterioration.       The original project of 1867 pro-
vided for a channel in this part of the harbor 1,000 feet wide and 23
feet deep. This project has been carried out so far that the channel is
now 600 feet wide only and 23 feet deep. It should be at once widened
to 800 feet, which it is estimated will require the dredging of 253,200
cubic yards (scow measurement), at a cost of. $128,000.
   In addition to these improvements of the main ship-channel through
the upper and lower harbors dredging and blasting had been done in
the following tributary channels:
   1. Charles River.-The original project for the improvement of this
river consisted in straightening, widening, and deepening the channel,
first, from its mouth up to the Western Avenue Bridge (a distance of
about 44 miles), so that there should be a minimum depth of 7 feet at
mean low water, with a width of 200 feet; second, from Western
Avenue Bridge to Market Street Bridge (34 miles), so that the least
width should be 80 feet, and the least depth 6 feet at mean low water;
and third, from Market Street Bridge up to the dam at the head of
tide-water (14 miles) so that the least width, should be 60 feet and the
least depth 2 feet at mean low water.
   The original estimated cost of this improvement'was $85,000. This
estimate was revised in 1881 and then made $1 25,000.
   The following amounts were specialiy appropriated for this improve-
ment:
By act of June 14, 180.....------..--- ---......------......-- .....----...--..- ------....- ..--..---..--......----   $22, 500
                                                                              ----...----. ---
By act of March 3, 1881----...-..----.....----..---..---......--- ............-----......                     ..----    35, 000
         Total ...............................................................                                          57,500
   The total amount expended to June 30, 1885, was $55,398.18.
   The condition of the improvement on the 30th June, 1885, was as fol-
lows :
   The projected improvement had been completed from the mouth of
the river up to the Arsenal Street Bridge, a distance of 74 miles. Work
was stopped at this point for the reason that the draws and piers of this
bridge do not conform to the projected channel above it; 127,971 cubic
yards were dredged during the years 1880-'84.
   No work was done during the fiscal year. This improvement, so far
as completed, is not regarded as an important benefit to commerce, for
the reasons given in the Report of the Chief of Engineers for the year
1884.
   The balance, available July 1, 1886, $2,018.49, is not sufficient to con-
tinue the improvement, and will be expended in surveys and examina-
tions of the work.
   To complete the improvement to the head of tide-water, in accordance
with the existing project, will require the expenditure of $116,000.      Of
this amount $50,000 could be expended to advantage during the fiscal
year ending June 30, 1888, in continuing the improvement above Ar-
senal Street Bridge, provided the draws of the two bridges on that part
of the river are rebuilt, to conform to the projected channel.
   2. Hingham Harbor.-The original project for the improvement of this
harbor was made in 1874; it provided for a channel 100 feet wide and 8
feet deep at mean low water up to the wharves in Hingham. The cost
was estimated to be $10,000. By the act of 1875, in the appropriation
for Boston Harbor, it was provided that not exceeding $10,000 should
be spent in Hingham Harbor. During the years 1875-'76 and 1884 25,160
            APPENDIX            B -REPORT             OF LIEUT.-COL. GILLESPIE.                            569
cubic yards were dredged and 83 cnubic yards of ledge were removed, at
a cost of $9,316.58, and the projected improvement was completed.
  3. Nantasket Beach Channel.'-The project adopted in 1880 was to
widen and deepen the channel, so that it should not be less than 100
feet wide and 94 feet deep at mean low water. During the years 1881
and 1883, 41,922 cubic yards were dredged, and 54 yards of ledge were
removed; completing the proposed improvement.
  4. Channel between Nix's                    JlatJ
                                    and Long Island.-In 1883, 19,8991
cubic yards were dredged at this point, by which a channel 12 feet deep
at mean low water, and 200 feet wide was obtained. This is a very im-
portant interior channel, and its usefulness in connection with the mean
ship-channel will be much enhanced when its width and depth have
been increased, and its proper direction determined after study of the
new survey.
  5. Barrel Bock.-An obstruction on the north side of Broad Sound
was removed in 1869; it contained 116 cubic yards.
   During the fiscal year ending June 30, 1886, operations have been
limited to the following:
   Repair of Deer Island sea-walls, noted above, and hydrographic sur-
vey of a portion of the lower harbor. This survey was authorized by
Department letter of August 6, 1884. It was to include portions of the
main ship-channel south of Boston Light, Brewster Bar and its slopes,
the Narrows, Nix's Mate bar, and the flats west of Lovell's Island. The
survey was commenced May 29, 1885, and the field-work was closed
November, 1885. Reduction of soundings, drift studies, &c., were made
during the winter, and the plotting of the notes was commenced in May,
1886, and continued as rapidly as the reduced office force would permit.
No results can be as yet deduced from this survey, and it may be found
necessary to slightly extend the lines of soundings running northwest
from Nix's Mate, for the purpose of determining more accurately the
direction to be given to the new channel on that side.
   A complete study of the condition and requirements of the main
ship-channel would necessitate a survey of the channel near the upper
and lower middles; this is estimated to cost $3,000, and should be done
as soon as funds are available.
  The balance available July 1, 1886, is $3,976.41, and will be applied
to the completion of the chart of the late survey.
  The amounts recommended for expenditure for Boston Harbor dur-
ing the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888, are as follows, viz :
For extension of the sea-wall at Point Allerton, 150 feet, at $100.......-....                          $15, 000
For repair of Great Brewster wall ..----..........                  ......           ...........          3, 000
For extension of George's Island sea-wall, 1,400 feet.--..--..-                          --..........    35, 000
For repair of George's Island sea-wall--------
                                          ......-----------..---......--...------....                        100
For repair of Lovell's Island east sea-wall.---...           ........---.........              ......     6, 000
For extension of Gallop's Island sea-wall ..................                     .............            7, 500
For repair of middle head-wall, Deer Island ..........                       ................                750
For rebuilding south head-wall, Deer Island, 250 feet..-...........                          ......      20,000
For extending riprap shore protection at Long Island .................                                    2,000
For repair of Long Island sea-wall........... ..........................                                  1,000
                                                            ------------------------
For repair of Castle Island sea-wall..........-----------....... ................                         1,000
For protection of east bluff at Governor's Island, 500 feet, at $60...........                           30, 000
For protection of south bluff of Governor's Island, 1,800 feet. ... ..            ....                   50, 000
For continuing the project of improvement of the main ship-channel, by re-
  moving 253,200 yards at the Upper and Lower Middles, making it 800 feet
  wide and 23 feet deep at mean low water.----------....------------------                              128, 000
For survey of Upper and Lower Middles .-..............        ......... ......                            3, 000
For contingencies............................................            .......                         17, 650

        Total ......--------..------......
                           ......---....--............---..........................                          000
                                                                                                        32-------0,
570            REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

   The several works completed and projected for the improvement of
this harbor are located in the collection district of Boston and Charles-
town, Mass.                   Boston is the port of entry.
  The accompanying commercial statistics for the fiscal year ending
June 30, 1886, have been furnished by the collector of customs at Bos-
ton, Mass.:
                           Money statement.
July 1, 1885, amount available .......--......                            .... ---   ....----.......             ....---....              $8, 528 99
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1885...           --...... ..........--.                                    $4,537 58
July 1, 1886, outstanding liabilities -......----.-----...---.                                                  -15 00
                                                                                                                                           4,552 58

July 1, 1886, amount available..---...---................ ...........--......----.                                                         3,976 41
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886...----------...                                                                        56, 250 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887 ......                                                 -.... --.         -....      60, 226 41

   Amount (estimated) required for complItion of existing project ........ 263,750 00
   Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal yearending June30,1888 264, 000 00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
     harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.



                                                          COMMERCIAL     STATISTICS.


                                                                          CUSTOM-HousE,                      BOSTON,                   MASS.,
                                                       Collector's Ofice, July 20, 1886.
   SIR: In compliance with your request of May 25, I inclose report of the transac-
tions of commerce and navigation at this port during the fiscal year ending June 30,
1886.
  The records of that time in this office were not consolidated until to-day.
  In noticing your further request, I can only wish you such success in your efforts
as will make this port the most safe and desirable on the Atlantic coast.
       Very respectfully, etc.,
                                                                                                        L.     SALTONSTALL,
                                                                                                                                        Collector.
   LieNt. Col. G. L. GILLESPIE,
                    Engineer Coyrs, U. S. A.



TRANSACTIONS OF COMMERCE AND NAVIGATION AT THE PORT OF                                                                 BOSTON               DURING
                  THE FISCAL YEAR ENDING JUNE 30, 1886.

Importations:
    Merchandise, value ...........................................                                                             $58, 43, 707 00
    Coin and bullion..............................                                 . ...............                                     121,995 00
Domestic exportations:
    Merchandise ------....
                  ......     ------........--....----     ..........----.....----..--..--------......------                      53, 428, 513 00
    Coin and bullion .............................                 ......................                                              1,000 00
Foreign exportations (re-exports):
    Merchandise .....             ..............              ................                     ......                                670,555 00
    Coin and bullion .................                   ..................--..........---                                                    None.
Vessels arrived from foreign ports :
      Number        .......           ................................                    ...........                                      2,592
    Tonnage..................................................                                                                          1,183, 067
Vessels cleared for foreign ports:
    Number.... ---              ................................                  .............                                            2,498
    Tonnage.--..----.....                       ---................ ..................                            ..                   1,918,911
Total custom collections :
    From all sources.-. ..........................................                                                             $21,079,311 36
Hospital dues included in above...................................                                                                     424 73
         APPENDIX      B-REPORT        OF LIEUT.-COL. GILLESPIE.                   571
                                       B 5.
      IMPROVEMENTS OF PLYMOUTH HARBOR, MASSACHUSETTS.

  I relieved Maj. C. W. Raymond, Corps of Engineers, U. S. A., of the
charge of this work February 4, 1886, in accordance with Special Orders
No. 16, Adjutant-General's Office, dated January 20, 1886.
  The object of this improvement is to protect the harbor by the pres-
ervation of Long Beach and to deepen and widen the channels of ap-
proach to the wharves at Plymouth.
   The preservation of Long Beach has been carefully attended to for
many years, as the existence of the harbor depends on it, and from
the nature of the work it can at no time be considered completed and
permanent; small annual appropriations are necessary t immediately
repair any damage caused by storms.
   The various devices employed for this purpose are described in the
Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1877.
   The project for the improvement of the main channel was originally
adopted in 1875. It provided for straightening the channel so that its
total length would be 2,286 feet, gave it a width of 100 feet and a depth
of 6 feet at mean low water. This project was ,modified in 1877 so as
to include the dredging of a basin 866 feet long, 150 feet wide and 8
feet deep in front of the city wharves. This modified project was esti-
mated to cost $41,500. The project was again modified in 1884. It
was then proposed to dredge the channel to a depth of 9 feet at mean
low water, widen it to 150 feet, and round off its junctions with the
main ship-channel and the basin. In 1885 it was proposed to deepen
the basin to 9 feet at mean low water.
   This modified project required the excavation of 81,000 cubic yaris
(scow measurement), and was originally estimated to cost $27,000.
   This amount was revised in 1885, in accordance with the low prices
for dredging then current, and the cost of the work was then estimated
to be $22,500.
   Before improvement the channel to the town wharves was about 6
inches deep at mean low water.
   From 1866 to 1884, inclusive, the following allotments or appropria-
tions were made for this improvement:
Amount allotted in 1866 from appropriations made July 2, 1864, for har-
bors on the Atlantic coast .-..-.----         ....-- ..- .-.-----         $8, 300
Amount allotted, act of July 25, 1868 .........---------..-------.........--.
                                                                .---. ....  7,500
Byiriver and harbor act of July 11, 1870 ..-..-........................    10,000
                           March 3, 1871...      ................ ... ....
                                                -..                              10, 000
                                                                      ......--.. 2, 500
                           June 10, 1872 .........--.....-----......-----
                           March 3, 1873 ...............................          3, 000
                                                                    ---    5,000
                           June 23, 174 .......----.....----------......---........
                           March 3, 1875...............................   10,000
                           June 18, 1878 ................................  5,000
                           March 3, 1879.............................. c  3,500
                           June 14, 1880 ................... .........   10,000
                           March 3, 1881.....-----...................... 10, 000
                                                                         14,000
                           August 2, 1882..--...-----....---.....-----......--....
                           July 5, 1884_ ....................   ..........-- .   10, 000

     Total ...------...--..--------..........--                    108,800
                                   ------............-----......--....----.......---
  Of which amount there had been expended to June 30, 1885:
For beach protection ................................................... 70, 329, 75
For dredging .--..--....................---------                   .... 35, 152 75
                                     -----....--............-----------....
     Total         -................
                -......           .....
                                      ......            ...... 105,482 50
                                               .. .........
                                             .....
  The condition of the improvement June 30, 1885, was as follows:
  Long Beach was essentially in good order.
  572          REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

     The dredged channel was 90 feet wide and 9 feet deep, with rounded
  junctions at the basin and main channels.
     The basin originally dredged to 8 feet depth had shoaled to an aver-
  age depth of 7 feet. This shoaling was caused by the lowering of
  Town Brook immediately after the basin was excavated, and no in-
  crease of shoaling has been discovered since that time.
     During the fiscal year ending June 30, 1886, operations have been
  confined to repairing Long Beach. The storm of December 26, 1885,
  caused extensive damage to the southerly part of the beach. At nine
  different points, from Eel River Bridge to a point 4,000 feet north of it,
  large breaches were made in the beach. The sand and gravel thus cut
  out by the sea was thrown into Eel River, damming it up, and threaten-
  ing to give it an outlet directly into the sea to the consequent injury of
  the harbor. Private parties removed those dams and re established
  the original course of the stream. The gaps in the beach were filled
  with brush and stone bulkheads (under direction of this office), aggre-
  gating 476 feet in length, with 22 jetties, each 15 feet long.
     These bulkheads consist of a triple row of 7 by 7-inch posts, 9 feet
  long, set generally 4 feet into the sand and 5 feet apart. They are
  braced, top and bottom, in both horizontal directions, by 2 by 3 inch
  strips spiked on.
     Spurs or jetties 15 feet long, and the same distance apart, similarly
  built, project from the front and rear. The bulkheads and spurs are
  filled with brush, which is loaded with bowlders taken from the beach.
  An apron of bowlders about 5 feet wide is placed at the outer end of
  the spurs, extending the whole length of the bulkhead.
     A survey of the beach covering that portion repaired during the year,
  and connecting with previous surveys of the northern end of the beach,
  was made during the latter part of June, 1886. The resultant chart
  accompanies this report.
     The whole length of beach is now in good order.
     The balance available July 1, 1886 ($1,059.69) it is proposed to reserve
  for any urgent necessary repairs of Long Beach that may occur.
     To complete the modified project will require the appropriation of
  $21,500, all of which could be profitably expended during the fiscal year
  ending June 30, 1888, in the following manner:
  Widening the channel to 150 feet and deepening it to 9 feet, 44,574 cubic
    yards...      ......      ...    ...... ......       ...--      ......
                                                                 ----..              ..   .......                -..............      . $13,500
  Deepening the basin to 9 feet, 20,000 cubic yards--------------..------..------.                                                             6, 000
  Contingencies .----...--------.....------.....------
                                               .....----......------...........----                   ......-------..---...------......        2, 000

                                               ....-----------------......------------..........
        Total ..................----------.....--                                                21, 500
    This work is located in the collection district of Plymouth, Mass., of which Ply-
* mouth is the port of entry.                        The nearest light-houses are the Plymouth (Gurnet)
  lights, about 5 miles from Plymouth, and Duxbury Pier Light, distant about 2 miles.
    The accompanying commercial statistics for the fiscal year ending
  June 30, 1886, have been furnished by the collector of customs for the
  port of Plymouth, Mass.
                             Money statement.
  July 1, 1885, amount available.......................... .        ...  .. ...... $3, 317 50
  July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
    liabilities outstanding July 1, 1885 ....--.......... --.......... $1, 900 63
  July 1, 1886, outstanding liabilities ............                         ..............                             357 L8
                                                                                                                                          2,   t57   81

  July 1, 1886, amount available...... ...... ..............................                                                              1,059 69
  Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886 ....-   --......
                                                            -....        ....-                                                            6, 000 00
  Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887...                                          ...............                       7, 059 69
.__.____r -.   -   -                                                                                                    ._.__ _                                                                                                                  -                            --             - - - -                            __                                         C_~I
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           --                                                                                                                                                           I                                           1-

                                                                          lxi
                                                                                                                   ua                                                                                     11 I                                                                                                                                PLYMOUTH                                                                             HARBOR                                                                         -MASS.
                           w~w.                                    ;s                                 --    >,-               -                uw.
                                                                                                                                                             13                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 Plan                                            loea ion                                     oi
                                                           240
                                                                              "~   I~:


                                                                                   14t
                                                                                            2;W

                                                                                            $T7   7
                                                                                                           I.'W.
                                                                                                                         ?



                                                                                                                        16        rt
                                                                                                                                                                                L .w.
                                                                                                                                                                                                                      C5
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        H.W.                                                                                                                          work                   of preservation
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   showinr

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                and           improvenuent                                                e

                                                                                                                                                                  :                          50         S2 ::               227          .w                                                                                                                                                              LONG                               IBEACH


                                                                                                                                                                       92                          50            52               227
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         SCALE                OF   PLAN% (1:12,000)
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      SCALE        OF   PR     0PFIZE                                                                             t00                        Sou                  14a                        squ                        '_   y                             "Sao                         iom,    Fr,




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          S              00            200          000          4201.   140R1201Al(1:2400)
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   5o   to    0o   0         4A s   0o 0o   70        o. V IITIoAL (1'h80)
                                                                                                                                                                                                           I
                                                                                                                                                                                      I                    I                                                                                                                                                                                  AM ulb,c,&,e2Zf,                               eooorarnwerkror k lkhotooos OOif                                                      pooooo              4,        ;??o7(
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                Ietweweoo         V h,                                                               (ptllE~su-n                          rrcZ Urittes                                C'l        rftrraurr7-           l,'         a
                                                                                                                                                                                      r r

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           I2        5k, Sfoone-'7afl Wih oooooCoo
                                                                                                                                                                      r2   t                ;.            7!t...                          V1.
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     y    7Y}
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             l,ovtoo        and   brus7h y rooo
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                IoS1ooo 6ooooboo7crt - /YlOt '
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   f;'

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                187,          f~r~r.Ho
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     in
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             .o-      botot                 ;    to         %h


                                                                                                                                                                      16        .47               90                  200                       U. S.Eu       ineer      Office
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   O        o, douoot'-io
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       tri -             1 rzr-              fote          b,-h     Ltn             85'Y.
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   Bosfon ,viass.                    Jjulv24 . 1886.                                                                                                                                               1 0
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               f
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                To accoiipain       aynual report                   eo                                                                                          Af           .K               Ok        t    ), ?      xl
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    - loh
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        ta-   4          t7sri
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 -.          B                                                                         l

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                            rXo'o-
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             .Ai.                        ,.            u'tlkh       ecar           .-    7       .       ,        'o          n'f          f       fs     i       !'             is         ;.    '7     -:    '   7         t:'




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    follfh         orots,                     .,                                                  1.0,,

                                  mean JI              7
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   Mor              of    mniuecno,       LBvit. Col.U7S.A.                                                                Noro tho r fS                                           l:    oT moo               -        oootl,-d                  4xion
                                  /7  -/L-x-%<-            1   e                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              ,zcrv       s    po'r      rto    1 o 78f'Cstc                        -                                                         ,-- x'oo
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             Julxe          made
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                            ootd           Li foo ' ,..'

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          i


                                                                                                  '-Ar
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   -----------------------------------
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        -- 4         .
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                -------      t-------

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              ',                                  K               T



                                        1                          1    ;~~                                                                              7                 -'



                       0                                                                                                                             0
                                                                                   6 Feet    YcFvt                 ._..r.-             .rGTN     .                \
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           jtjf IrE.?
                                                                                                                                                                                                           FLATS                  D A RT         _L            T      'LVA TWEI                                          00           <"0.                ~       -             ;T---



                                   ",       \     1,                          WI I T E            Fl, AT S                                               ,
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  .                           -       -   -   -       --    -   --      --




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     ornnGRAPHI
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               THMERICA      UC.,N.r
        H Exl pt2 v2 49 2
                       APPENDIX                            B-REPORT OF LIEUT.-COL. GILLESPIE.                                                                                                          573
    Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project........ $15, 500 00
    Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1883 15,500 00
    Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
      harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.


                                                                           COMMERCIAL STATISTICS.

                                                                                                                CUSTOM-HOUSE, PLYMOUTH, MASS.,
                                                                  Collector's Office, June 30, 1886.
  SIR: I have the honor to forward to you a report of receipts and disbursements of
revenue at this port, the amount of merchandise in bond, domestic arrivals and clear-
ances, composition of cargoes, arrival and departure of all vessels for a harbor and
otherwise, estimated number of passengers by steamers, &c., estimate amount of an-
nual business of the port, and Government property here located, and other statistics
that may be of possible value to you in your official estimates.
Revenue:
    Official collections from all sources........---....................... $------         30, 901 25
    Disbursements ...................   .................................                    2,442 43
              Net amount ......                                ................                     ......              ......             .................---                                28, 458 82
Foreign imports:
                                                                                                                                                                                                    Pounds.
         Rivet rods......_................_...                                                                                                                2,130,302                   .
         Basic steel ............          .......... .
                                                      ..........                                                              ...... .. .... ........ ....    1,874,205
         Salt ---------- ----------------......--...- -.                                                                           --.----.----------..    --     22,400
         W ool ............                          ......            ......            ......       .....          ......          ..      .. .       ..        ... .       -.....      .           2, 778


      Total....................---......----...--                                                              --.........----...... ....--....-----....                                       4,039, 685
Foreign exports :
         Cordage               .....................................                                                          ......................                                                 76,848
Remaining in bond:
         Rivet rods ......                        ......           ....                  ---       ----.............                      ......--....
                                                                                                                                                 --......                 ........             1, 344, 228


                                                                                Articles.
                                                                                                                                                                                        No. of
                                                                                                                                                                                       cargoes.       Tons.


                                                                 DOMESTIC IMPORTS.
Coal . ..............................................                                                     .....--..........................                                                    65      17, 680
Scrap-iron .......                                  .............
                                               ----.........                     ....      ......          .............                 .. ...............                                    12       2, 091
Lumber.........................................................................................                                                                                                24       4, 000
Fish .......            .................                            .........        ......       .... ...............................                                                         9          300
Hay ...............                   ...      ....          ..................                          .....................................                                                  9          670
Molding sand................................................................                                                                                                                    1          200
Granite.............................................................................                                                                                                            2          200
Tar ..             ....      . .......  ..     .....             ............          .          ......................................                                                        1          150
Miscellaneous (by packets, steamers, &c.) .-------.......................................                                                                                                      90      12, 000

           Total ........................................                                                                             .             ...........                               213      37, 291

                                                                DOMESTIC EXPORTS.
Wood .............                     .......       ...................             .......                  ....   .....        ...................                                          10         700
Nails ...................                                   .........
                                                                 ........... ...............                            ..........................                                              9         650
Fish ...........              .....................................................................                                                                                             2         175
Barrels ................................................................                                                                                                                        4          70
Gravel ............................                                            ..... .........                       .........................                                                 43       3, 800

           Total .......................                                         .....                          ..............                    .............                                68       5, 395


                                                                                                  SUMMARY.

Number of cargoes : imports and exports. ........                       .......         ...
                                                                                         ...           ...    ....      281
Tons of merchandise : imports and exports....4........................                                              42, 686
Arriving and sailing of all vessels for harbor and other purposes, estimated
  num ber ...... ............    ......-............             ...-..         ...........                ..  .. . 2, 300
Number of passengers arriving and departing by steamers, packets, &c., es-
  timated ......................            ....................                          ..............            45,000

                                                                                BONDED WAREHOUSES.
  There are seven bonaea warehouses, in which are stored foreign goods now in bond,
all in charge of Government.
574         , REPORT     OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

                          GOVERNMENT PROPERTY AT THIS PORT.

   One double light-house at Gurnet Head.
   One single light-house at Duxbury Pier.
   One first-class life-saving station at the Gurnet.
   One first-class life-saving station at Manomet Point.
   One rented custom-house, with furniture, records and files dating from 1773 to date.
   One rented post-office and contents.
   All thus far enumerated is property in Government hands at this port, all of which
is directly benefited by Government surveys and appropriations.
   As this is the first and probably the only statement we shall have the honor to
forward to you, we have taken the liberty to add to it the business statistics of the
port, by which you will see that it is largely dependent on its harbor facilities, and
that appropriations and surveys by Government have been turned to good account,
and that there is still room for further improvement.
                               MANUFACTURING      INDUSTR Y.

   The aggregate capital of twenty-two of the principal manufactories amounts to
$2,017,000, manufacturing cordage, cottons, woolens, duck, iron, nails, tacks and
rivets, zinc, castings, and other staple goods, valued annually, $3,372,000.
   The aggregate banking capital is $3,335,377.      All this capital receives a direct
benefit from the improvements and protection of this harbor by the General Govern-
ment.
   Through the fostering care of the Government and the deepening and widening of its
channel it has already become a noted sea side resort, and the steadily increasing
number of visitors for business and pleasure by steamers from Boston and elsewhere
that are daily landed here gives the best evidence that what has thus far been ac-
complished by Government is, as it should be, well appreciated in all its parts, and of
great benefit not only to the town, but to the community at large.
   As the Department calls for "suggestions," we would respectfully suggest that Long
Beach, that forms the protection of Plymouth Inner Harbor, was severely injured in
the storms of the last winter; and whatever is dlone for the benefit of this harbor,
Long Beach should be the first object of attention, as without it our harbor would be
but an open "sea-way," and thus become useless to navigation and an injury to the
town almost beyond estimation. We would suggest that if the appropriation of
$6,000 now before the House should be granted, that so far as is wanted it should be
used for this especial object.
   The channel cut by the Government requires more width and depth to make it the
more useful, but Long Beach is of the most importance. We only make the above
suggestions from the fact they are called for, as we believe that Government engi-
neers are the best and only sure evidence in all cases where needed.
       Very respectfully, your obedient servant,
                                                               SAMUEL H.   DOTEN,
                                                                  Collector of Customs.
  G.   L.   GILLESPIE,
        Major of Engineers, Bvt. Lieut. Col., U. S. A.




                                           B 6.

       IMPROVEMENT OF PROVINCETOWN HARBOR, MASSACHUSETTS.

  I relieved Maj. C. W. Raymond, Corps of Engineers, U. S. Army, of
the charge of this work February 4, 1886, in accordance with Special
Orders No. 16, Adjutant-General's Office, January 20, 1886.
   The object of this improvement is to preserve one of the most valua-
ble harbors of refuge on the Atlantic coast. The entire commerce of
New England and a very large local fishing interest is directly bene-
fited by its maintenance. It is situated at the extremity of Cape Cod,
and its existence depends entirely on the preservation of the sandy
beaches inclosing it.
  The project for its improvement was adopted in 1866, and modified
in 1869, 1872, and 1873. It consists in the construction of detached
              APPENDIX B-REPORT                               OF LIEUT.-COL. GILLESPIE.                                      575
bulkheads of wood and stone, jetties of wood and brush, dikes, sand-
catch fences, and the extensive planting of beach grass-all for the
sole purpose of preventing or arresting the movement of the sand by
the winds and waves. A full history of these improvements will be
found in the Annual Reports of the Chief of Engineers for the years
1876 and 1879.
   While the harbor on the east side covering East Harbor and the salt
meadow has been made secure by dikes and bulkheads constructed by
the Government and by the State, the west side has been left com-
paratively unimproved, except at the eastern extreme end of Long Point
and at Lancy's Harbor, adjacent to Abel Hill. Between these two last
points there is but a slight fringe of beach separating the harbor from
the ocean on the outside, through which the seas frequently penetrate,
threatening extensive crevasses in this natural bulkhead. These sea
encroachments tend to level the beach as well as to open swales through
it, and it would be a wise policy to commence at an early day an im-
provement which will have for its object to unite Long Point with the
mainland at Stevens Point by a substantial timber and stone dike,
which will oppose a strong front to the sea action and assist in building
up the intervening flats. An estimate for this improvement accompa-
nies this report.
   Since 1866 the allotments or appropriations for this harbor have been
as follows:
Amount allotted in 1866 for appropriation made for harbors on the Atlan-
  tic coast by act June 28, 1864 .---.... _ ..          . .        ... . .. .......                   $30,000 00
Appropriated by act of June 23, 1866....................-------------------..---------..........--.. - 43,068 44
Appropriated by act of July 28, 1866 ....................................                                8,000 00
Allotted from appropriation, river and harbor act of April 10, 1869.......                              8, 910 00
Appropriated by act of-
     March 3, 171......----..........--......-----                    ....          ...........----........            6, 000 00
     June 10, 172......--------......----......-------......---......--......---.........---.......5,000                           00
     March 3, 1873---....---.....--.....................--......--...---..----......                            ---------  6,000   00
     June 23, 1874---..---------------.................----.......------......----.......-     ---....---............      6,000   00
     March 3, 1875....---..---..--....--..---.--..--.....-----......-----  ........................------------            5,000   00
     August 14, 1876--..-----..--.....-.....---..----...----.. .....------.....--------..-...............                  4,000   00
     June 18, 1878...........------------.......---............------......------------......----......------......        1,000   00
     March 3, 1879.........----...--------------......----............--------......---......------......---..------....
                                                                                                                      ---- 1,000   00
     June 14, 1880....-------..---..       ----..-----......---......----..--..... .---...---......----.....                 500   00
     March 3, 1881...........--------......------.....-------..---.---.....-----...........----------------......          5,000   00
     August 2, 1882.---.....----.....---.....------..---....----...............------......- --....               ---.     5,000   00
     July 5, 1884......------......-----------......---..................---------............---------........        2, 000 00
                       ......---...------...--...-----......--
      Total ......-----------......------                      ----............      136,478 44
                                                                      -.........-----.-----.
  The amount expended to June 30, 1885, was $135,924.59.
   The condition of the improvement June 30, 1885, was as follows (see
accompanying map):
   Long Point.-This long, narrow, low point forms the southwestern
limit of the harbor. It had been protected on the southeast or outside
by bulkheads, groins, and aprons, built of rubble-stone. These were all
generally in good order. No work was done here during the year end-
ing June 30, 1886. The advance of the point in a southeast and iorth-
east direction is very marked. The bulkhead should be backed up
with small granite chips and brush, to retain the sand thrown up, and
about 600 tons of additional large stone is required to "level up" the
bulkhead.
   Beach Point.-This beach lies between the main and East Harbors.
It had been thoroughly protected by bulkheads and jetties and was in
excellent order. No work has been done here during the year, and none
probably will be necessary during the next year. This beach has steadily
576          REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                                          U. S. ARMY.

improved in height and strength since the State dike closing East Har-
bor entrance was completed in 1870.
    High Head Dike.-This dike was in good order. It is situated at the
head of East Harbor, between it and the " Salt Meadow." It was built
in 1869, for the purpose of arresting the rush of the sea should it break
through at the " Cove Section." No work was done on it during the
year and none probably will be needed during the next year.
    Cove Section, a narrow, low part of the outer beach at the head of
the " Salt Meadow." The beach here had continued to increase in width
and height. No work was done here during the year, and none proba-
bly will be needed during the next year.
    Abel Hill Dike, a dike built to prevent a rush of water from " Lancy's
Harbor" over House Point Island Flats into the main harbor. The
dike was in good order. During the year ending June 30, 1886, no
work was done. The brush bulkheads to the southward of Abel Hill
Dike should be repaired and extended about 50 feet on its southern
end. This is estimated to cost $200.
   House Point Island .Flats.-These flats have for many years been
steadily moving to the southeast, to the manifest injury of the harbor.
In November, 1885, House Point Island was swept away by a violent
storm. No work of preservation was done during the year. A survey
of these flats and the adjacent harbor was in progress during the year.
The field-work was closed in February, 1886, as no more funds were
then available. The information gained by the survey, in connection
with a late personal examination of the flats, enable me to say that no
project for the preservation of the harbor will be effective, or give
promise of permanency, which does not involve the construction of a
strong dike from Stevens Point, across the flats, to near Lobster Point,
a distance of one mile approximately. Such a dike, with the improve-
ments already made at Long Point, would effectually seal the harbor
against storm encroachments, and would cause such extensive sand
accumulations on the northwest side as to raise the flats above the
plane of any known tides. It should be located along the high-ground
on the east side, and should be constructed of a double row of piles
filled with brush and stone. It is estimated to cost $15 per running
foot, or an aggregate of $80,000.
   The accompanying chart shows the location and dimensions of the
proposed dike.
   The balance available July 1, 1886, is $4.54, not sufficient to continue
the improvement.
   During the year ending June 30, 1888, the following sums could be
expended to advantage:
The construction of 5,200 feet of timber dike, connecting Stevens and
  Lobster points, at $15 per foot.---..--...------..-------------..---..---...-------$78, 000
To complete the backing of the Long Point breakwater. ................---               3,800
To restore the height of the Long Point breakwater, 600 tons, at $3.....                1, 800
To complete survey ---..-----------------                  --------......---------.....--.....------....       500
To repair and extend bulkheads at Abel Hill 50 feet, at $4 ..............                                      200
For immediate repair of probable storm damages.... .... ...... .... ....                                       700
Contingencies......----......-----....... ......--....... ........... ......... .                           8, 000
      Total----..... ......------....--......
                            ----              ---------......---......---------......--......--.............. 93,000
  Provincetown is a port of entry in the collection district of Barnstable, Mass.
The nearest light-houses are Long Point and Wood End lights.
  The accompanying letter of the deputy collector at the port of Prov-
incetown furnishes the commercial statistics for the fiscal year ending
June 30, 1886.
-                                ~ I s - -L---~P
                                 --                        --r~l------------------ ----------
                                                   ~ C ~C_' I IL I                                                              I------r_
                                                                                                                               ill F -I_-                    _I        -L -~     ----CP---
                                                                                                                                                                                         L ----
                                                                                                                                                                                        3i- IL---L        - --
                                                                                                                                                                                                    ~L --IU-~-LC~rBB
                                                                                                                                                                                              ^l-- ----                               I~p~ - _-                     _.I
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              L_-LL--             -lIIIIL                 sCi------
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          --                 ~t -- ----            --- ---1117-UI-
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   ~ ~ pi Ilb -LICIO-C          ~P-



                                                             TT                                                            O
                                              v      A-,A                                                                             CEA                                                                                                    PR OVINCETOWN                                                            HARBOR                                      ,   MASS.
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          Sketch showing location of workR of
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         improveitent completed ani                                                                                                           proposed
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  d a .. Bruhl looPA,4ood oo-odelooo at ibo~er'toa, beti/ltj a                                                  1873- 7.
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        yb,                  S..oyaa. at              0 y.       Pead ,d,           boo/r r               i   .59-3870.
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              ,      _Bush         aced   piuutzk      &1        lAecnns.         brr,sh         ",'e!&-              ar                 nd   e/<,rrc-




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              (1.              t oaaoroorsof
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          1ttPfootie.D bui2lt in18-18(19.
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          e             S.    Sta.ne         A dalo          ad and            groaw a .oLLoao                   P                buil        -ii.s iV-.188¢.
                    z                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             lak    Plank ooklecTad dj lofnt                     ao t Gog f           ln-    t       d 4iiFPIvrYVb                        r    o     1871,
                    'I                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               7rt           1).laratatt               r    7   rsk      from    ,Stevens                Pt.         1.;           .I   aintej            ?2t.    andi/         rs




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              1'h,       .tAbeLd l
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        .D, Dkeae          io1J71-1872.   Aait
                                  S                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        s(14 oatch-sooos oo,,Boooooa         enaoAbo1     11Kil bail'? in 1885.
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        1 , P oosed       ZYyke 1010.00000      Seer   foa'   7e 79 and Lo0,3re   19
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              -Beach pooas oos     Afoo t jsbold at bn     (I de, fdf" r rl   i .
                                      zb'.                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 SCALE.Of MAP             (0.AOO            )




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 /L3/

                    F16
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             / /     No..f
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     f       jf           9dos            a                P
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  rarswd "--sod                      e-- f'
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       U                                                                                           ow    wcti;         acld     .9,
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   tr~~v                                                      lrcue                hity       rvn'tet".




                                                                              PROPO SED DYKE BETWEEN                                               STEVENS                   POINT AND                                      POINT
                                                                                                                                                                                                                       LOBSTER
                                                                                                              O   X00 9 -0000ao 600        00 oo       00     000   11oo001m00o             00   ro   Iso 1500    1   1700e   1roo"
                                                                                                                                                                                                                          HORIZONTA SCALE =1: 600o
                                                                                   .. .
                                                                                    p
                                                                                          - .-
                                                                                                 0    0
                                                                                                             10
                                                                                                                  1
                                                                                                                      15       to
                                                                                                                               15
                                                                                                                                       25
                                                                                                                                            . .-
                                                                                                                                            50t
                                                                                                                                                        i i , T r r r - ,, -;T
                                                                                                                                                       30
                                                                                                                                                             to
                                                                                                                                                                  35
                                                                                                                                                                       "rT   I
                                                                                                                                                                                 30'   40        45
                                                                                                                                                                                                 5     5         55      SCARE  O V'ERTICAS AND DETAILS 1:2001
        SPRIN             lHOOH
                              WATER




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               I                   rr;
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             ''i                   -'--'                          .,'*
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   C19
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    r
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             re
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             o
        M    EAMN LOW WATER
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               I                                                       1QW~A~~9
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             _,,3m ~MtAW
        L ,-,----                                                                                                                      B     O     ----      T------0- -           --
                                                                                                                                       g    p      r    yy




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       M.HK.W.                                          M.H.W.                                   MH..                                                  M.H.W.



                                IT. S.En ineer Office
                                             Boston, Mass. July 24.1886                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         -BRUSH




                                Toro                         ccompany annual.ol.                     .. A.                                                                                                                                       t   f       I J              I                                                             ...                               i ..
                                                      Major of Enmineers, Bvt.Lt. Col. U.S.A.


                                                                                                                                                                                   PLAN
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             -FRONTd       LEVATrO N                                                                           SE CTION

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              -      -                  _....




    THE AMERICAN GRAPHIC CO.,N.Y.




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              B      213.
             APPENDIX B-REPORT                      OF LIEUT.-COL. GILLESPIE.                                57 7
                                           Money statement.
                                       --- ----...............
July 1, 1885, amount available..........................                                                  $553 85
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
    outstanding July 1, 185...........            ............    ......................                    549 31

July 1, 1886, amount available.------..----....---..........---......---......-------..                      4 54
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886.....                  ....--.......                   3,000 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887... ...... ...... ...                          .    3, 004 54
 (Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project-....----...                            90, 000 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1888                             90, 000 00
{   Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
     harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.



                                         COMMERCIAL STATISTICS.

                                                             DEPUTY   COLLECTOR'S OFFICE,
                                                  Port of Provincetown, June 30, 1886.
  SIR: In compliance with your directions of the 27th ultimo, I would state the
amount of revenue collected at this office for the year ending this day was $708.24.
                                                                                                             Tons.
Number of foreign entries at this office, 32..................................                              2,704
Number of foreign clearances, 34..-......       ..           -......................-.......        2,886
Number of coastwise clearances, 8......---................................------------------------.   810
Number of entrances of merchandise in bond ........................                          ......     34
  Including 142 sail vessels and 1 steamer belonging to this port, whose aggregate.
tonnage is 12,541 tons, the number of vessels that entered and departed from this port
during the year was, as nearly as could be estimated, 7,000.
  The estimated value of commerce and navigation that sought shelter in Province-
town Harbor during the ,past year was $18,500,000.
      Respectfully,
                                                                                           JAMES GIFFORD,
                                                                                              Deputy Collector.
    F. B. Goss, Esq.,
         Collector of Customs, Barnstable.




                                                     B 7.
                IMPROVEMENT OF LYNN HARBOR, MASSACHUSETTS.

  I relieved Maj. C. W. Raymond, Corps of Engineers, U. S. Army, of
the charge of this work February 4, 1886, in accordance with Special
Orders, No. 16, Adjutant-General's Office, dated January 20, 1886.
  The object of the improvement is to obtain an increased depth of
water and a more direct and wider channel of approach to the city
wharves. Before the improvement there was about 6 feet at mean lpw
water in the channels which were narrow and crooked.
  The project was adopted in 1884. It provides for the excavations of
a channel 200 feet wide and 10 feet deep at mean low water, from a point
near and east of the White Rocks to deep water opposite Little Nahant,
or 3,610 feet in length of this the lower channel. The upper channel,
6,450 feet in length, extends from deep water opposite Sand Point to
the Lynn Harbor line, with the same width and depth. It is supposed
that the upper or western part of the upper channel will have to be
maintained by occasional dredging. To aid in keeping the lower chan-
nel open, a training-wall is proposed, which is to join the land at Little
Nahant if experience shows that its construction is necessary.
           37 E
578         REPORT            OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

   The cost of this improvement was originally estimated to be $145,000.
This estimate was revised in 1885, and the total cost was then stated
to be $157,000-an increase of $12,000, due to an additional amount
of dredging found to be necessary in rounding off the junctions of the
dredged channels with deep water, in providing slopes for the sides of
the dredged channels, and to provide for surveys and inspections.
   But one appropriation has been made for this work, viz:
By river and harbor act of August 2, 1882 .-----..----......-----..---...............                                     $60,000 00
The amount expended to J une 30, 1885, was ........           ..... ....       ...    ..                                   50, 209 06
   The condition of the improvement on June 30, 1885, was as follows:
   The lower channel, 3,610 feet long, had been dredged to a width of 200
feet and a depth of 10 feet at mean low water, from near White Rocks
to deep water opposite Little Nahant; and the upper channel, 6,450
feet long, had been dredged 100 feet wide and 10 feet deep at mean low
water, from deep water opposite Sand Point to the Lynn Harbor line.
About 170,500 cubic yards were removed by contract, which was closed
December 20, 1884.
   No operations were in progress during the fiscal year ending June 30,
1886, but close comparative surveys were made of the dredged areas,
by which it appears that no material change has taken place in the
channels, although in one or two places a slight decrease in width of
channel is noticed, owing to the falling in of the side slopes, or to in-
juries caused by vessels getting aground.
   To complete the work, including the training-wall, would require the
appropriation of $97,000. But it seems more desirable to repair and
complete the upper channel to its full width and depth, and to await
further developments before building the wall. To effect this will re-
quire the removal of about 160,000 cubic yards of material at an esti-
mated cost of $32,000.
   This work could be advantageously done during the fiscal year ending
June 30, 1888, and for this purpose the following appropriations are
recommended, viz:
For removal of 160,000 cubic yards of material from the upper channel,
making it 200 feet wide and 10 feet deep at mean low water, at 20 cents.                                                    $32, 000
Contingencies ----...---.----.-              -..---------------.--------..----.........                                        3, 000

      Total ----..--....------..-...----...---.................................-----------------------------.                 35,000
  The balance available July 1, 1886, is $7,035.09, part of which will be
required for surveys, &c., leaving $30,000 to be appropriated to com-
plete the work so far as now recommended.
  Lynn is a port of entry in the Marblehead collection district.                                                 The nearest light-
house is Egg Rock (Nahant) Light, distant about 3 miles.
  The accompanying commercial statistics for the fiscal year ending
June 30, 1886, have been furnished by the collector of customs for the
port of Marblehead, Massachusetts.
                                                 Money statement.
                                                   --.....-
July 1, 1885, amount available -----------......---........                               -----......---......             $9, 790 94
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885 ..   .....................................    .                                                  2,755 85

July 1, 1886, amount available....--..----..---...---.....----....------......
                                                                            ------........------....                        7, 035 09
                                                 ..................----.
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886--                                                                        6, 000 00

Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887 ............                                                 ....    13, 035 09
    ---
    -                                                                                   --------
                                                                                            --- ---                    ---
                                                                                                      ~ ~------------~----I-------    I                   -I--            __                                                                 ~         I         - --I-'~                                           ----------- ~--------~-- -                              --                                                                 __
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           *-~
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         --.--                                                                                                                       ----- -----~---




                                                                                                                                               LYNN                            HARBOR,                                                   MASS.
               1.
                                                                                                                                                                      Map o                     f     the dredged
                            10-
                                                                                                                                                          UPPER                                       CHANN E L
                                                                                                                                                                 as surveyed in June 1886
                                                  87                                                                                                                     (see SUBSKETCH                                 aft c-d)

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      Pt.      i"1
                                                                                                                                                                                       (Scale                1:50001
                                                                                                                                      50   0   tu   oo   20
                                                                                                                                                               .-30
                                                                                                                                                              a..         On.
                                                                                                                                                                      inna..     ,..
                                                                                                                                                                               400
                                                                                                                                                                                        ... _   50o
                                                                                                                                                                                                      n...     .....,
                                                                                                                                                                                                                  00o
                                                                                                                                                                                                                           a..
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   700           Soo
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       1000.,.1.00
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       1300900
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               ..
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                HO
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     1....,. et
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        n
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       __

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     1000
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                            _

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          I0ooFrt   100       too




                                       %,~             ~
                                                0.1
                                                 .     0     \.   Qj _          \

                                                                  *
                                                                      N    ~
                                                                          II.




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  Wofe.      The soundirnr are expressed in feet and tenofh
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         and refer to ntean low water; add 9,feet "for mean
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          hiyl wafer.     The full  lites, thus -   are tze limh's
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          of the proposed channel(upper) 200 feet wide andlOft.
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          deep at m.. 1.       The areas shoaler than 10 Ofeet
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           wifthn these li'u      ar linekhaded thus
     U. S.E-n ineer   Office                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 The loer  channel has been dredgt-ed
                    Boson       , Mass. Juily 24.1886.                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    200feet wide     and 10 feet deep at 'n. Lw. (se                                                              /7                             IC
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         ,ju.bsketch  at a-b)
    To accomanyn anual                                     Bepv oi.U.,                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       The broken 2line from a-Pe on ubske c .........
                               7Major of   En ineers, Bvt.Lt. Col.         US.A.
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          shows location of the (ra.im g wall poposed by
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          the  -Board  of 1Entineers. April 10. 1884.
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                            Mean Lou WaterLine shown t            -us ..-.. ..                                              LYNN
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     SUBSKETCH
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               HARBOR
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              6 feet curve........                                                                    Showin,        location       of channels                              pss   P(
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   i
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   m
                                                                                                                                                                                                        I
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           10         .        ..                            M . ... ..-... ....
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          harbor C'orm.sioners                 Line        o   .   .     ....                                       SS CA LE 1:5 0,0 0o 0
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             0            ['    .              0lllllll.ll
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              1..
                                                                                                                                                                                TRlE                          MERIDLAu N


                      -                                                   ~~~--------     I~~~------~~~                       ---
                                                                                                                               ~-    --- -                    - -I -. -~~----'"---
                                                                                                                                                                        -~^ ~~~~~------?l~iT~"
                                                                                                                                                                                   "---~                                                                   __    _    _         _   _     _   _     _   _   _   _    _   _   _   _   _   _   __      _      _    _    _    _   _       _----   ~~~~-
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               _   _   _      _    _   _    _      _   _   _    I   ___________________________________.~r-

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    THE AMERICAN GRAPHIC CO.,N.Y.
    pt2 v2 49 2
H Exl
                 APPENDIX                                  B-REPORT OF LIEUT.-COL.                                GILLESPIE.                        579
   Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project ........                                                                     $91, 000 00
   Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,188                                                                     30,000 00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
     harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.



                                                               COMMERCIAL STATISTICS.


Number of vessels arriving from foreign ports during the year ending June
   30, 1886 .---...----..--..-......                           ......---......--           ---......--...........--.........-----...... 26
Gross tonnage of said vessels ..-....- ... ...... ...-..-     ...                                                      -               .....        2,647
Value of merchandise imported in said vessels .--......................                                                                            $9, 641
Amount of revenue collected in Lynn during the fiscal year ending June
30, 1886------........................$1,343
Number of coastwise arrivals during the year ----........................... 415
Amount of coastwise tonnage--...... .................................                                                                              82, 585
Value of merchandise brought to Lynn in coastwise vessels............                                                                            $774, 500
This amount of $774, 500 includes these items:
               ---....--.....---...........-----------........----------..-
Coal......-------.--.....                                                                      -..--....--------....------.                      $590,000
Lumber---...----..........------..... ...------...--...............-------..........------------..------..                                         90, 000
Fire-wood ..-----.....----......-----
                                   ..-----.....---------......----------............ .......------.....------......-                                3,500
Lime and cement ....---- .....----.. -----------....---.............--------.....-------....----......                                             36,000
Stone, sand, and bricks ................................................                                                                           15, 000
Miscellaneous, hay, tiles, water-pipes, paving and crossing stones, drain
   pipes      ......----........................-...----                           ...........---.....--             ......-----....               40, 000

                 .....----...----....----...---..............-------------------..
           Total---                                                                                          ------------.............----.       774,500




                                                                           B 8.

                   IMPROVEMENT OF MALDEN RIVER,                                                            MASSACHUSETTS.

   I relieved Maj. C. W. Raymond, Corps of Engineers, U. S. Army, or
the charge of this work February 4, 1886, in accordance with Special
Orders, No. 16, Adjutant-General's Office, dated January 20, 1886.
   The object of the improvement is to increase the width and depth of
the river channel from its mouth up to the second draw-bridge in Mal-
den.
   Previous to the improvement there was a navigable depth of barely
7 feet at mean low water (the mean rise and fall of the tides is 9.8 feet),
and the ch anel was narrow and crooked.
   The p     ect was originally proposed in 1880. It contemplated the
excavation of a channel 100 feet wide and 12 feet deep at mean high
water up to the second draw-bridge, with two cut-offs, one east of the
island, near the junction of The Malden and Mystic rivers, and the
other through the marsh land, about half a mile above.
   This project was modified in 1882, when it was proposed to excavate
a channel, following the natural bed of the river, which should have a
depth of 12 feet at mean high water 100 feet wide, up to the draw-
bridge in Malden, and 75 feet wide thence to the second draw-bridge,
near the rubber works.
   The cost of the adopted project was estimated to be $40,000.
By the river and harbor act of August 2, 1882, Congress appropriated for this
  work ........----.....---.........-...                                                                                   ........ $10,000
Total amount expended to June 30, 385 ....--........-....                                                          .......... ...... 10,000
580        REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

  The condition of the work June 30, 1885, was as follows :
   Thirty thousand eight hundred and eleven and a half cubic yards
(measured in scows) had been removed from the natural channel of the
river from its mouth to the draw-bridge in Malden, a distance of 1.
miles. The channel had a least width of 50 feet (it was 70 feet wide at
turns) and a depth of 12 feet at mean high water.
  No work was done during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1886.
   There was no balance available July 1, 1886.
   To insure reasonable permanency to this improvement the cut-offs
proposed in the original, but not included in the existing, project
should be executed, and the banks should be revetted.
  To complete the improvement in accordance with the existing project
will require an appropriation of $37,000. This is $7,000 in excess of
the original estimate, and is caused by unanticipated difficulties in dis-
posing of the dredged material and by increased quantities to be
dredged to provide slopes to the banks, which were not provided for in
the original estimate.
  If this amount is appropriated it can be expended to advantage
during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1885, in completing the existing
project.
   This work is located in the collection district of Boston. The nearest port of entry
is Boston, Mass. The nearest light-house is Long Island Head Light, in Boston
Harbor.
                                   Money statement.

 (Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project-........ $37,000 00
I Amount that can be protitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1888 37,000 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867




                                        B 9.
   HARBOR OF REFUGE AT SANDY BAY, CAPE ANN, MASSACHUSETTS.

   I relieved Maj. C. W. Raymond, Corps of Engineers, U. S. Army, of
the charge of this work February 4, 1886, in accordance with Special Or-
ders, No. 16, Adjutant-General's Office, dated January 20, 1886.
   The object of the work is the construction of a "National Harbor of
Refuge of the first class."
   No project for this improvement has been adopted definitely.
   The cost of the improvement, as determined by the preliminary pro-
ject of November 28, 1883, is $4,000,000. This estimate was increased
by The Board of Engineers to which it was submitted to $5,000,000;
and they also estimated that not less than $2,500,000 would be required
for buoy age, lighting, and defense of the harbor.
   The preliminary operations and the condition of the work June 30,
1885, were as follows:
   The river and harbor act of August 2, 1882, provided-
   That the Secretary of War is hereby directed, at his discretion, to cause examina-
tions or surveys, or both, and estimates of cost of improvements proper, to be made at
the following points, namely: *         * Sandy Bay, Rockport, Mass., with a view
to the construction of a breakwater for a harbor of refuge.
  By order dated August 11, 1882, the Chief of Engineers directed Col.
George Thom to make a preliminary examination and submit an esti-
mate of the probable cost of such survey, and whether " said harbor
           APPENDIX    B-REPORT         OF LIEUT.-COL. GILLESPIE.              581
* * * is worthy of improvement, and that the work is a public ne-
cessity."
  General Thom's report, dated October 7, 1882, states that the bay
was worthy of improvement and the work one of public necessity.
  The Chief of Engineers, on April 24, 1883, directed Maj. C. W. Ray-
mond, Corps of Engineers, to prepare plans and estimates for this work.
  Major Raymond reported, November 28, 1883, a project for a break-
water, with rubble-stone mound, surmounted by a vertical wall of
masonry. The cost was estimated at $4,000,000.
  In the river and harbor act of July 5, 1884, the sum of $100,000 was
appropriate d for this work, with the proviso-
  That a Board of three Engineers, to be appointed by the Secretary of War, shall
decide that this point is the best location on the coast between Boston and Portland
for such a harbor, that shall serve all the uses for which it may be needed.
   The Board of Engineers constituted July 28, 1884, under the provis-
ions of the act of 1884, submitted reports, dated August 23, 1884, and
December 11, 1884. The decision of. the Board was that Sandy Bay
was the best location on the coast, between Boston and Portland, for a
harbor of refuge of the first class, and also that the plans recommended
for the breakwater by Major Raymond were the best that could be
adopted.
   On April 15, 1885, interested parties asked the honorable the Secre-
tary of War to direct operations to be commenced. They stated that
the expenditure of the sum available would more clearly mark Avery's
Ledge, which would be "a very substantial benefit to commerce," and
if more funds were provided "one end of the breakwater would be
already corn pleted."
   The subject was referred to the local engineer, who stated that the
construction of a pier on the ledge, "extending above high water, would,
without doubt, be a benefit to navigation, whether a breakwater is or
is not built in the future."
   On May 5, 1885, the Chief of Engineers submitted this report to the
Secretary of War, and recommended that the local engineer be called
upon "for a project of the pier on Avery's Ledge, the said pier to form
the beginning of a breakwater at Sandy Bay, should additional appro-
priations be made by Congress for continuing its construction in the
future."
   The recommendation was approved by the Secretary of War, and
May 20, 1885, Major Raymond submitted a project for a solid stone
pier 30 feet in diameter, rising to 12 feet above high water, and to cost
$46,000.
   On June 25, 1885, The Board of Engineers reported that the form
and dimensions of the pier proposed by Major Raymond would have
sufficient stability, but believed that the cost would be reduced by
building the lower part of it of concrete in situ inside of a cast-iron
ring.
   These several reports were submitted to the Secretary of War, and
on the 6th of July, 1885, the work of building a pier to mark the site
of the ledge, as well as to form one terminus of the proposed break-
water, was ordered to be commenced.
   Surveys and preparations of the project were in progress until Sep-
tember 10, 1885, when it was proposed to place on Avery's Ledge two
large blocks of concrete which should weigh 371 tons. They were to
be constructed on shore, and when dry placed on the ledge. This
structure was to extend to the level of half tide, and was to be sur-
mounted by an iron spindle. It was estimated to cost $6,000. The
582    REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

balance of the funds it was proposed to expend in the construction of
a portion of the rubble base of the breakwater, commencing 140 feet
from the initial point and extending northward along the axis of the
breakwater for a distance of about 1,282 feet. The top of this rubble
base was to be 40 feet wide, and in a plane 22 feet below low water.
   This project was approved by the Chief of Engineers September 15,
1885, except that it was directed that the concrete blocks should not
rise higher than the level of one foot below mean low water.
   On September 25, 1885, proposals were invited for placing 122,000
tons of rubble-stone in the breakwater.
   Six large buoys for service in connection with the placing of the con-
crete blocks were moored round Avery's Ledge by contract awarded
August 3, 1885.
   Ranges on the salvages for guiding the dumping of the stone were
also established.
   On October 26, 1885, the proposals invited for rubble-stone were
opened. Eight bids were received, the highest $1.67 per ton, the low-
est 58.3 cents. On October 30, 1885, a contract was entered into with
the lowest bidder, the Rockport and Pigeon Hill Granite Companies,
Chas. S. Rogers, receiver. Work was commenced by the contractors
in November, 1885, and during the fiscal year they delivered 49,762
tons, all of which was dumped between stations 340 and 1275.
   On March 8, 1886, proposals were invited for building and placing
on Avery's Ledge a concrete block to weigh approximately 168 tons.
Bids were opened April 15, 1886. Only one bid was received, that of
Mr. B. G. Bailey, of New York, which was for $7,707. The proposal
was not of the required form, and the justification of the guarantors
was not complete; it was rejected.
   As the season was too far advanced to readvertise the work, or to
admit of the construction of a sufficiently hardened block in timne for
its sinking before the approach of the variable weather of autumn, the
plan of this kind of base for the pier was abandoned, and it was de-
termined to substitute for it a spindle, which was absolutely required
to give a permanent range for the convenience of the contractors in
dumping stone.
   On March 11, 1886, proposals were invited for a wrought-ironm spindle
8 inches in diameter. The bids received were opened March 22, and the
contract awarded to the lowest bidder, the Bridgewater Iroi and Steel
Company. Their bid was for 54 cents per pournd. The spindle was de-
livered April 15, 1886.
   On May 25, 1886, sealed )proposalswere opened for drilling a hole in
Avery's Ledge and erecting therein the iron spindle. This work was
approved and the contract awarded by Department letter of May 28,
1886, to the second lowest bidder, Mr. George W. Townsend, of Boston,
Mass., with whom on the 9th of June, 1886, a formal written contract
was executed for this work.
   Work ulnder this contract was commenced June 18, but the contractor
was unable to complete the work during the fiscal year, owing to un-
favorable weather. The contract is still in force.
   An apprehension having arisen that it might be impracticable to drill
the hole in the rock for the accommodation of the spindle, it was de-
cided to make an attempt to sink a cast iron ring, 23 feet in diameter
and 6 feet high, around the initial point, to be filled with concrete and
to form an antuchiorae for the spindle as well as to furnish the base of
the future pier. The great desire was to secure the erection of the
                                                                              OF                MAP            'C          5




                                                                                                                                                     36




                                                                                                                                           77




                                                                                                                                                24                   6

                                                                                                                               +   -
                                                                                                                                                      «       fie.             .\




                                                                                                                                       HALIBU
                                                                                                                                        POINT


       THE        ATLANTIC                                COAST

                                                                                                                                                                                        .r


       FROM PORTSMOUTH                                                    .   H.




         TO       S   CITUAT              l      ,   MASS.




                                        MILES,
                                                                                                         CAPE       NEDQItK


                         STATUTE




                         uAU7'    CAL   MILES.




                                                                                                              BOON    it
=NEW         p_



                                                                                                                                                                           SISHOF




                                                                                                                                                          '    LANE




                                                                      D




                                                                                   PORTSMOUTH




                                                                                                                                                                                        NS




                                                                                                                                                                           CVVIIi




                                                                                                      ISLES    or    SHOALw
                                                                                                                                                                         FIGE"O:


                                                                                                                                                                           IMI      .    C
                                                               LITTLE BOAR'd         $0.1




                                                             GREAT   BOAR'S NO.



                                                                                                                                                               PIGEO]
                                                          HAMPTON
                                                                                                                                                                         cow

                                                                                                                                                                HARRC

                                                     0




                        At[RA1,




                                                         NEWBURYPORT
                APPENDIX                   B-REPORT                       OF LIEUT.-COL.                          GILLESPIE.                        583

spindle, the construction of the pier being only a secondary considera-
tion. This plan was likewise approved by the Department May 14, and
immediately thereafter a contract was awarded to Messrs. G. W. and
F. Smith, of South Boston, the lowest bidders, for the construction of
the iron shell at 3 cents per pound, delivered at Rockport, by July 15;
and several minor contracts were made for the delivery of concrete
material and of the timber for making shears and other appliances.
Work was immediately started on all these contracts, and good prog-
ress has been made in perfecting arrangements for the work.
   The balance available July 1, 1886, was $57,817.43. It will be ap-
plied to the completion of the existing contract for rubble-stone, to the
building of the pier on Avery's ledge, and in marking the location of
this submerged pier by an iron spindle.
   In continuation of the rubble mound substructure of the breakwater
during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888, $500,000 could be advan-
tageously expended.
   Sandy Bay is situated in the collection district of Gloucester, Mass. The nearest
light-house is Straitsmouth Light, situated on the northeast end o Straitsmouth
Island, at the southeast side of the entrance to the bay.
   A letter from the collector of customs at Gloucester, Mass., which gives the com-
mercial statistics of this district for the fiscal year ending June 30, 1886, is annexed.

                                                            Money statement.
July 1, 18-5, amount available                            ----..----.--..
                                                            ---.----.----.        -----   $..95, 659 97
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1885 ......-------.....-            ... ... $25, 284 80
July 1, 1886, outstanding liabilities..---...............------.....---....    12, 557 74
                                                                                           37, 842 54

                                                                                            -----. 57, 817 43
July 1, 1886, amount available.---------............--------......--..------....--........---....
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1885 ....................                            100, 000 00

Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887 ...........--......                                                                     157, 817 43

  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1888 500, 000 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.




Abstract of proposals for rubble-stone for Sandy Bay Breakwater, Massachusetts, opened
             October 26, 1885, by Maj. C. W. Raymond, Corps of Engineers.


                                                                                                                                               Price per
No.                                                       Names of bidders.                                                                    ton of 2,000
                                                                                                                                                pounds.

  1   Rockport Granite Company and Pigeon Hill Granite Company ......................                                                              $0 58,
  2   Charles li. Ed wards          .........................................................                                                         68
  3   John Cam eron ................                      ............... .. ............ ................                                            7211
  4   Charles W. Parker and Isaac A. Sylvester .-------..--.. __...................................                                                   87
  5   George E. Runyon ..----...                ........--.....................--------------------...---------------..................--..           90
  6   Samuel R. Cumming and M. J. Dady ........................-------------------------.......................                                       99
  7   Charles Guidet .....................................                               . ---------------.. ...                                    1 51
  8   David V. Howell .............................---------------------------------..................................                              1 67


  Contract was awarded to the Rockport and Pigeon Hill Granite Companies with
the approval of the Chief of Engineers,
584            REPORT             OF      THE CHIEF           OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

Abstract of proposalsfor drilling hole in Avery's Ledge, Sandy Bay, Cape Ann, Massachu-
  setts, and inserting an iron spindle therein, opened May 24, 1886, by Maj. G. L. Gillespie
  Corps of Engineers.


                                                                    Gross
No.                       Names of bidders.                       sums bid                                     Remarks.
                                                                  for work.

  1
  2 William E. Chapman ...............-   .......                      $1, 275
  3 Adoniram Fairchild ...............--        ..                        425            Proposal withdrawn by permission.
  4 Hugh Bowen..................................                          965
  5 Edward McDonald............................                         3, 000
    George W. Townsend ........................                           900


' Contract was awarded to George W. Townsend, with the approval of the Chief of
Engineers.



                                                  COMMERCIAL STATISTICS.

                                       CUSTOM-HOUSE, GLOUCESTER, MASS.,
                                                     Collector's Ofice, July 7, 1886.
SSI : As requested in your favor of May 25, I send you the following statistics in re
gard to this district:
Tonnage of district, 495 vessels, 31,437 tons.
Number of vessels entered from foreign countries ......- _.. -... ..                                   ..........         128
Number of vessels cleared to foreign countries ...                       ......-................                          113
Number of vessels' registers and enrollments granted ......                           ..........-.....                     98
Number of vessels' licenses ............   ..................-----------            ......-----..........                 504
Value of irports-                --........................
Duties on imports......----......--............
                                                .........................
                                                               ...........................--..
                                                                                                                -....$109,236
                                                                                                            -....
                                                                                                                             $13, 827
Number of vessels boarded by inspectors ...                               __
                                                                         ..........              ...........     .....- -.     3, 400
I (These are nearly all the vessels in the foreign and coastwise trade, as many of our
local fishermen are not boarded.)
  There is about 50 sail of vessels (fishing and coasting) owned at Rockport (Sandy
Bay), and they have 3 or 4 foreign arrivals each year from Nova Scotia.
  A sum of money could be expended to good advantage in Gloucester Harbor in
making improvements and removing rocks.
       Respectfully,
                                                                  D. S. PRESSON,
                                                                            Collector.
  Maj. G. L. GILLESPIE.
                               APPENDIX C



IMPROVEMENT OF HARBORS AND RIVERS ON THE SOUTHERN COAST OF
    MASSACHUSETTS AND IN RHODE ISLAND AND CONNECTICUT.




REPORT O+ LIE UTENANT-COLONEL GEORGE H. ELLIOT, CORPS OF EN-
GINEERS, OFFICER IN CHARGE, FOR THE FISCAL YEAR ENDING JUNE
30, 1886, WITH OTHER DOCUMENTS RELATING TO THE WORKS.

                               IMPROVEMENTS.

1. Harbor of Refuge at Hyannis, Massa-     10. Warren River, Rhode Island.
      chusetts.                            11. Newport Harbor, Rhode Island.
2. Harbor of Refuge at Nantucket, Massa-   12. Harbor of Refuge at Block Island,
      chusetts.                                  Rhode Island.
3. Wood's Holl Harbor, Massachusetts.      13. Little Narragansett Bay, Rhode Isl-
4. Westport Harbor, Massachusetts.               and.
5. Wareham Harbor, Massachusetts.          14. Harbor of Refuge at Stonington, Con-
6. Taunton River, Massachusetts.                 necticut.
7. Pawtucket River, Rhode Island.          15. Pawcatuck River, Rhode Island and
8. Providence River and Narragansett             Connecticut.
     Bay, Rhode Island.                    16. Removing sunken vessels or craft ob-
9. Green Jacket Shoal, Providence River,        structing or endangering navigation.
     Rhode Island.




                       ENGINEER OFFICE, UNITED STATES ARMY,
                                              Newport, R. L, July 28, 1886.
  GENERAL: I have the honor to submit herewith annual reports for
the year ending June 30, 1886, for river and harbor works in my charge.
  I was assisted auring the year by Assistant Engineer Norman W.
Eayrs.
       Very respectfully, your obedient servant,
                                                   GEORGE H.      ELLIOT,
                                                     Lieut. Col. of Engineers.
  Brig. Gen JOHN NEWTON,
                         Chief of Engineers, U. S. A.



                                      C I.

          HARBOR OF REFUGE AT HYANNIS, MASSACHUSETTS.

  The harbor of Hyannis lies on the south shore of Cape Cod, about 15
miles to the westward of the heel of the cape, and is an important har-
bor of refuge. The mean rise and fall of the tide is about 34 feet.
                                                                          585
586           REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

                                             ORIGINAL CONDITION.

  Before improvement it was an open roadstead, exposed to southerly
storms.
                                         PLANS OF IMPROVEMENT.

   In the years 1827-'38 a breakwater of riprap granite 1,170 feet long
was constructed, covering an anchorage of about 175 acres, the entrance
to which has a depth of about 15- feet. It was not as strongly built as
we would now build a breakwater in a locality of like exposure, and in
the years 1852-'82 extensive repairs were made in increasing the width
of its base and the size of the stone forming its sides and top.
   The depth of water inside the breakwater is insufficient for many ves-
Sels that seek the harbor for refuge, and the river and harbor act of
July 5, 188-, provided for a preliminary examination and survey of the
harbor, with a view of deepening it. The reports in the case, with a
plat and an estimate of the cost ($45,743.20), were printed in House Ex.
Doc.No. 96, Forty -eighth Congress, second session, and may also be found
in the Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1885, Vol. I, pages 560 and
619-'21. The commencement of this work has been approved by Con-
gress making an appropriation of $ 10,000 therefor in the act of August
5, 1886.
               AMOUNT EXPENDED AND RESULTS TO JUNE 30, 1886.

  No work has been in progress during the last fiscal year. The amount
expended on this work has been $123,276.77, and the breakwater has
been completed according to the original project and the subsequent
plans for strengthening it.

OPERATIONS                CONTEMPLATED                     FOR THE FISCAL                      YEAR ENDING JUNE
                                                          30, 1887.

  The execution of the project before referred to, of deepening the an-
chorage area inside the breakwater, will be commenced at the eastern
end of the anchorage, and the full width of the area p)roposed to be
deepened will be carried to the westward as far as the appropriation of
August 5, 1886, will allow.
Hyannis Harbor is in the Barnstable collection district, and Barnstable is the nearest
port of entry. The amount of revenue collected in the last fiscal year was $1,670.92.
The main value of the harbor is for a harbor of refuge. The nearest light-house is
Hyannis Light; the nearest fortification is the fort at Clark's Point, New Bedford,
Mass.
                                                   Money statement.
July 1, 1885, amount available .......      ......
                                                ..--....--.....
                                                            ......---......    $105 48
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885 ...----. -- .....    --..
                                                  ..       --..   - -..
                                                              --...... --....... 24 67

July 1, 1886, amount available ...... .................................-----------------------------------------..      80 81
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886 ..................                                                10,000 00
                                                                   .. 10,080 81
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887................---


SAmount
(Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project -----.      35, 662 00
        that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending Jnne 30, i888 35, 662 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
      harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
                    APPENDIX                   C--REPORT                    OF          LIEUT.-COL.                           ELLIOT.                     587
                                                    COMMERCIAL                   STATISTICS.

                                                                                                                       HYANNIS, June 21, 1886.
  SIR: I have the honor to report the receipt of your letter of the 17th, and have
gathered the following statistics, in compliance with your request, for the year 1885:
                                                                  IMPORTS.

Coal .....-....---...----......                                                                       -----
                                             .........-----------------...--....---...--................  tons.                                           8, 000
Lumber .--...---.----......-----......--------.----.......-------...------..---...-..--.....------                         feet. 1, 750, 000
                    ---....---..........----.........-------
Cotton....-----.. .........                                      -------..---                                           bales.
                                                                                                     ..----------------....           1,000
Grain ....----.-....- --...-- ---- ..--    ..--....
                                               --            --...---..---- .----...
                                                                                ........ -- -...... - -...- ....----bushels.        108, 000
Lime -------......--.....--.......-------............--      ---........--....---....-------........-----..--... barrels.                500
Hay ....------....---....--.. --..----....--..--......
                                                -------------................--..                                               bales.
                                                                                                                        -....--........                       300

                                                                  EXPORTS.

Fish, iced ......---....................--..-.....                                               ....
                                                                                            ..------             .........
                                                                                                              ---..                      barrels.        42, 000
Schooners harboring during year ..............                                                  ...........-.                            ... ...          1,600
      English....-----------........................................................                                                                         150
      American ......------------......-------......------............-------------..........------....                            ---...--........       1, 450
      Draught .--..... -...........        --..---------------.         .--............              ---- feet.        3 to 15
      Tonnage ...----....-..-......--------------......-----......------......----...-......---..----............ 25 to 1,000
Steamers harboring during year ........................................                                                                                       210
      Tonnage         ....-----...........                ..          --.....-......-   -       ......        ......         ............             75 to   500
                                                ........
      Draught .------.....--......----...------ ------------....-----....--...                                   -.--..        -----...... feet.        6 to 13
  There would probably be a larger n umber of vessels harbor here if the harbor inside
the breakwater was dredged.
      Very respectfully,
                                                                                                              ALONZO                  F.    LOTHROP,
                                                                                                  Keeper of Hyannis Light Station.
   Lieut. Col. GEORGE H.                       ELLIOT.




                                                                       C 2.

                HARBOR OF REFUGE AT NANTUCKET, MASSACHUSETTS.

   Nantucket Harbor is the only one between the harbors of Martha's
Vineyard (Vineyard Haven and Edgartown) and Provincetown, a dis-
tance of about 100 miles, except the small harbor of Hyannis, on the
other (the north) side of Nantucket Sound, the navigation of which is
intricate and dangerous by reason of numerous shoals. Nantucket
Harbor has deep water inside, and the object of the improvement is to
make it a harbor of refuge for vessels plying between ports north and
south of Cape Cod, estimated at 50,000 annually. In the memorial to
Congress on which the first appropriation for this harbor of refuge was
based it was stated that more than 500 vessels had been wrecked in
the vicinity of the island.
  The mean rise and fall of the tide is about 3 feet.

                                                   ORIGINAL CONDITION.

  Before           the commencement of the present works there was a shoal
about 1-          miles in width outside the entrance, through which shoal the
channel           or line of best water was only about 6 feet deep, and very
crooked,          and subject to changes in location.

                                                  PLANS OF- THE WORKS.

  The present approved project is to construct jetties of rilprap stone
projecting from either side of the present entrance to the harbor for the
588      REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

purpose of concentrating the strength of the tidal currents and exca-
vating a channel of 15 feet depth by scour, and, at the places where the
full depth required will not be reached by this means, to complete the
work by dredging. A plan of the works may be found in the Report
of the Chief of Engineers for 1885, Vol. I, page 578.

          AMOUNT EXPENDED AND RESULTS TO JUNE          30, 1885.

  The amount expended on this project up to the close of the fiscal year
ending June 30, 1885, including liabilities outstanding at that date, was
$100,211.25, and the result was the construction of the west jetty to a
point 3,955 feet from the shore.

            OPERATIONS DURING THE LAST FISCAL YEAR.

   At the beginning of the last fiscal year no work was in progress. My
project for the location of the east jetty and the completion of the works
required for making Nantucket Harbor a harbor of refuge for vessels
of 15 feet draught and less, with certain modifications proposed by the
Board of Engineers for Fortifications and River and Harbor Improve-
ments, having been approved by the Chief of Engineers, advertisements
were issued for proposals for furnishing riprap granite for commenc-
ing the construction of the east jetty and placing the same in the jetty.
The proposals received and the terms of the contract will be found in
the appended table.
   In September, 1885, the right of way to and from the east jetty by
land, the right to connect it with the shore, and to erect temporary
buildings for public purposes at the root of the jetty were obtained
and placed on record in the office of the register of deeds at Nantucket.
Work on the jetty commenced April 29, and continued until the end of
the fiscal year, when it was still in progress. The amount of stone de-
livered during the fiscal year was 2,000 tons.
   Careful surveys were made in June last of the bottom of the entrance
to the harbor to determine what effect, if any, the west jetty alone had
produced on the bar, reports having been received that the water had
aeepened and that vessels experienced much less difficulty last spring
than formerly in crossing the bar at low tide. Our survey fully con-
firmed these reports.
   The lighting of the end of the west jetty, which, until the two jetties
are completed and a lighthouse is erected on one of them, will be a source
of danger to vessels entering and leaving the port at night, was faith-
fully attended to during the year.
   Mr. Thomas A. Churbuck was local inspector of the work of construc-
tion of the east jetty.

AMOUNT    EXPENDED DURING THE LAST FISCAL YEAR            AND RESULTS
                       TO JUNE 30, 1886.

  The amount expended during the last fiscal year, including liabilities
outstanding June 30, 1886, was $5,620.87. The east jetty was com-
menced and fully completed to a distance of 120 feet from the initial
point on the shore, which is the outer end of the middle of the three
northwest spurs built on Coatue Beach some years ago, and the founda-
tion was laid and the jetty partially completed for an additional distance
of 100 feet. The crossing of the deep flood-tide channel, which ran near
                APPENDIX          C-REPORT              OF LIEUT.-COL. ELLIOT.            589
and parallel to the shore of Coatue, made the construction of this part
of the jetty comparatively slow.
   Although but little, if any, effect had been expected before the two
jetties should have been extended until they should become parallel
and contract the channel to the width contemplated, viz, 1,000 feet, it
was found in the survey just referred to that on a line from Brant Point
to the present end of the west jetty the least depth of water was nearly
1J feet greater than at the time of our previous survey, and vessels
had less difficulty in entering and leaving the harbor.
   It is believed that the channel depth would already be much greater
except for the " Hog Backs," or slight elevations of the bottom, covered
with strong sea-weed which protects the sand from scour. When the
channel has become somewhat more contracted by the extension of the
east jetty, I design to harrow the bottom in the line of deepest water
by the aid of a steamer, for the purpose of breaking up the roots of this
sea-weed and stirring up the sand in order to facilitate the action of
the strengthened tidal current upon it. The indications are that in this
way a considerable deepening of the water in the channel will be pro-
duced long before the final contraction of the channel to the width con-
templated for it.

WORK REQUIRED TO BE                       DONE       TO COMPLETE    THE    EXISTING PRO-
                                                    JECT.                                      .
  The work required to be done to complete the existing project is the
completion of the east and west jetties, and the excavation by dredging
of so much of the channel as will not be excavated by tidal scour.

OPERATIONS            CONTEMPLATED               FOR THE FISCAL     YEAR ENDING          JUNE
                                                 30, 1887.

   It is proposed to devote the small remainder on hand July 1, 1886,
and the appropriation made by the act of August 5, 1886, to the exten-
sion, as far as possible, of the east jetty.
  Nantucket is in the Nantucket collection district, and is a port of entry. The
amount of revenue collected in the last fiscal year was $185.02. The value of the har-
bor is mainly as a harbor of refuge. The nearest light-houses are Nantucket Cliff and
Brant Point lights. The nearest fortification is the fort at Clark's Point, New Bed-
ford, Mass.
                                           Money statement.

July 1, 1885, amount available ............................            .........      $9, 788 75
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1885................ .......... $3, 048 81
July 1, 1886, outstanding liabilities ..........................          2, 572 06
                                                                                       5, 620 87
                                                                                       S

July 1, 1886, amount available----................. ......................             4,167 88
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886 :..................                15, 000 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887 ........---- ....--...--..----. 19,167 88

  SAmount (estimated) required for completion of existing project--......-.. 250,000 00
   Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1888 100, 000 00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
590               REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

Abstract of proposals for furnishing riprap granite for the east jetty at Nantucket, Mass.,
  and placing the same in thejetty, received at Engineer Office, United States Army, Newport,
 ,RB. I., in response to advertisement dated September 26, 1885, and opened at 12 o'clock,
  noon, on the 17th October, 1885.



No.                    Name and address of bidder.                              Price per                               Remarks.
                                                                                   ton.


    1         Chas. H. Edwards, Quincy, Mass............                              $1   96       Work to be commenced within one
    2         John A. Bouker, Jersey City, N. J...- ..-         ..-                    2   37     month after signing of contract, except
    3         Wm. H. Molthrop & Co., New London, Conn.                                 2   47     otherwise agreed in writing, and to be
    4         James Scully, Groton, Conn ..--...----...........                        2   50     finished on or before June 30, 1886.
    5         James V. Luce, East Lyme, Conn......-.....                               2   78



  Contract awarded to C. H. Edwards, with the approval of the Chief of Engineers,
and dated October 26, 1885. Time of commencement extended to April 1, 1886, and
time of completion to August 31, 1886.



                                                        COMMERCIAL STATISTICS.

                                                                             CUSTOM-HOUSE, NANTUCKET, MASS.,
                                                                                      Collector's Ofice, June 30, 1886.
  SIR: In compliance with your letter of June 17, 1886, I inclose you herewith; a
statement of imports into this port during the last fiscal year; also a statement of
tonnage. The amount of revenue collected at this office during the past year aggre-
gates the sum $185.02.
      I have the honor to remain your obedient servant,
                                                                                                        ALBERT A.             GARDNER,
                                                                                                                                  Collector.
   Lieut. Col. GEORGE H. ELLIOT.




                        Aggregate amount of imports for                          the year ending June 30, 1886.

Coal, hard .----..--.....-----.......----.....--- tons..         8, 750         Brick ............             ......     number..                255, 000
Coal, gas .....................                       do...         200         Lime .......................                casks..                    800
Railroad sleepers ...........                     pieces..       3, 500         Cement .......................                do....                   270
Grain .............             .......         bushels.-       27, 000         Wood........................                 cords..                   541
Flour...................                        barrels..        4, 500         Salt ..............---         ..........  pounds..               145, 550
Hay ... .................                           tons..          175         General merchandise..............ons..                              4, 500
Lumber . ...............                .........    feet.. 1, 800, 000


  About 218 vessels entered our harbor during the past year of the following classi-
fication :

   No.                                                       Class.                                                       Average            Average
                                                                                                                           draft.             size.

                                                                                                                             Feet.               Tons.
        112     Schooners .............................................                          ..     ..........                   8                   115
         28     Sloops ............................                                   .............. ..........    ...               6                    45
         23     Steamers ............................................................                                                7                   400
          7     Barges.............................................................                                                  6                   100
         48     Yachts, of various sizes, and rigs.................................                                       .......      .......



              Very respectfully,
                                                                                                        ALBERT A.             GARDNER,
                                                                                                                                  Collector.
            APPENDIX       C--REPORT       OF LIEUT.-COL.       ELLIOT.             591
                                         C 3.
    IMPROVEMENT OF HARBOR OF WOOD'S HOLL, MASSACHUSETTS.

   This harbor is on the north side of Vineyard Sound, and is divided
into Great Harbor and Little Harbor. The name " Wood's Holl " is
also applied to the adjoining strait which connects Vineyard Sound
with Buzzard's Bay. The site of the works now under construction is
Great Harbor, Wood's Holl. The rise and'fall of the tide is about 2
feet.
                              ORIGINAL     CONDITION.

  Before improvement, the site of the present works was a submerged
point of land extending from the shore of the harbor.

                           PLANS OF IMPROVEMENT.

  The adopted project for the improvement of Great Harbor, Wood's
Holl, was for the construction of retaining-walls on the shore, a hollow
pier and wharves for the use of the United States Fish Commission, and
to serve also as a coaling station for vessels of the Revenue Marine and
other branches of the public service, and as a iarbor of refuge. A plan
of the works may be found in the Report of the -Chief of Engineers for
1884, Vol. I,page 598.

         AMOUNT EXPENDED AND RESULTS TO JUNE 30,                       1885.

   The amount expended on these works to June 30, 1885, including
liabilities outstanding at that date, was $77,842.66 The retaining and
pier walls and the dredging of the interior of the hollow pier and the
berths for public vessels had been completed, and the coal, the west,
and the cross wharves had been essentially completed.

              OPERATIONS DURING THE LAST FISCAL YEAR.

7For
year.
        want of funds no workhas been in progress during the last fiscal


WORK REQUIRED TO BE DONE TO COMPLETE THE EXISTING PROJECT.

  The work required for the completion of the project for the improve-
ment of Great Harbor, Wood's Holl, is the construction of the south
and east wharves. In the strait of Wood's Holl there is a large and
dangerous rock which is to be removed.

OPERATIONS       CONTEMPLATED         FOR THE      FISCAL YEAR ENDING JUNE
                                      30, 1887.

   It is proposed to devote the small remainder on hand July 1, 1886,
and the appropriation made by the act of August 5, 1886, to the con-
struction of the south and east wharves, and the removal of the dan-
gerous rock in the strait of Wood's Holl, just referred to.
  Wood's Holl is in the Barnstable collection district. New Bedford is the nearest
port of entry. The amount of revenue collected in the last fiscal year was at Barn-
stable $1,670.92, and at New Bedford $48,3b1.08.    The nearest light-house is Nobsa
Light; the nearest fortification is the fort at Clark's Point, New Bedford, Mass.
592      REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

                                   Money statement.
July 1,1885, amount available .........................................    $64 00
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885 ...............--
                                          ... .. ....................----
                                                                        ..  17 05
July 1, 1886, amount available ------------------.-.-----------------..                 46 95
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886 .-----..----         .          14, 500 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887 ..--........----.....        14, 546 95



                               COMMERCIAL     STATISTICS.

                                                  PACIFIC GUANO COMPANY,
                                                     Wood's Holl, Mass, June 30, 1886.
DEAR SIR: In reply to your favor of the 17th instant, we send the following state-
ment in regard to the commerce and navigation of this place.
There have been received during the past year-

                              Articles.                                Quantity.     No.of

Coal----
      ........................................---------------------------..----...........------------
                                                                                   6,500tons..      21
Barrels ...........................................................-.
                                                                 -  -------        1,300 barrels     6
Lumber .........................................................--------------     565,000feet       4
Hay, lime, brick, spiles, and wharf material . ........................    ....................----  4


and there have been received and shipped 128 cargoes phosphate rock, brimstone,
nitrate of soda, fish scrap, and other fertilizing materials and completed fertilizers,
aggregating 49,000 tons, in sailing vessels of from 100 to 1,200 tons, and one foreign
steamer of 2,600 tons.
   There have also been shipped 3,000 barrels of fish and other general merchandise
and produce by lines of steamers to New Bedford, Martha's Vineyard, and Nantucket
besides all the materials and supplies which Martha's Vineyard and Nantucket re-
ceive from the interior via the Old Colony Railroad.
  Our harbors are in constant use throughout the year by fishing vessels, yachts,
coasters, and wrecking steamers as a harbor of refuge.
      Yours, truly,
                                                                      ASA SHIVERICK.
  Lieut. Col. GEORGE ELLIOT.



                                          C4.

        IMPROVEMENT OF WESTPORT HARBOR, MASSACHUSETTS.

   Westport Harbor is an estuary of a bay lying between Narragansett
Bay, Rhode Island, and Buzzard's Bay, Massachusetts. This is a new
work, and no appropriation had been made for it until, by act approved
August 5, 1886, Congress appropriated $1,000 "for sand-fence." The
late General Warren, then in charge of this district, in reporting, De-

                                                            4"
cember 12, 1878, on the survey which he had made in accordance with
section 2 of the act of June 18, 1878, stated that the wearing of Horse
Neck Point (on the north side of the entrance) could be prevented jby
small sand-catch jetties, and these could be gradually prolonged so as
to narrow the space opposite and increase the average depth" (of the
channel); and named $1,000 as the amount that could reasonably be
expended in this way. It is supposed, therefore, that the $1,000 ap
propriated by the act of August 5, 1886, are intended for the construc-
tion of the sand-catch jetties recommended by the late General Warren,
and the funds will be expended accordingly.
                                   Money statement.
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 18s6 .-.................             $1,000 00
          APPENDIX    C-REPORT OF LIEUT.-COL. ELLIOT.              593
                                  C 5.

       IMPROVEMENT OF WAREHAM HARBOR, MASSACHUSETTS.

  This harbor is an estuary at the head of Buzzard's Bay. The object
of the improvement is to deepen and widen the channel leading from
Buzzard's Bay to Wareham; the industries of which and of several
towns in the vicinity with which it is connected by rail are chiefly the
manufactures of iron, and depend largely on transportation by water of
the material used therein. The commerce of Wareham is carried on in
sailing vessels, and the channel is to be made a beating channel for
such vessels. Another object of the improvement is in the raising of
Long Beach, over which the sands from the bay were washed into the
harbor. The mean rise and fall of the tide is 4 feet.

                         ORIGINAL CONDITION.

  Before improvement the ruling depth in the harbor was about 7 feet
at mean low water in a narrow and very crooked channel. Long Beach,
a narrow sand-spit at the mouth of the harbor, was washed and abraded
by the waves and currents at high water, and the material was carried
into and shoaled the channel inside.

                       PLANS OF IMPROVEMENT.

  The original approved project of 1871 for the improvement, and its
subsequent modifications, provides for a channel 250 feet wide and 10
feet deep at mean low water from Barney's Point down to the entrance
to the harbor. Above Barney's Point the width of the channel is to be
350 feet, with the same depth--10 feet-as below that point. The plan
includes also the raising and strengthening of Long Beach, of which a
large portion was submerged at low water, to carry it above the storm
waves and currents and to hold it there, in order to prevent the filling
of the improved channel above by material abraded from the beach.
   A plat of Wareham Harbor, showing the lines of the channel now
being excavated, may be found in the Annual Report of the Chief of
Engineers for 1885, Vol. I, page 586.

        AMOUNT EXPENDED       AND RESULTS TO JUNE 30, 1885.

   The total amount expended on the improvement up to the close of
the fiscal year ending June 30, 1885, including liabilities outstanding
at that date, was *56,467.43, and the result was % channel through and
above the upper bar to the wharves with a width of not less than 100
feet and a depth of 10 feet at meany low water. A large part of the work
on the lower reaches of the channel had been done and the river oppo-
site the wharves had been deepened to 9 feet below mean low water.
Long Beach was raised above high-water storm-tides, except in a few
places, so that the major part of the wash of sand into the improved
channel inside the beach had been stopped.

              OPERATIONS DURING THE LAST FISCAL YEAR.

  At the beginning of the last fiscal year the work of dredging the
chanluel was in progress under the contract with the Atlantic Dredg-
ing Company, of Brooklyn, N. Y., which was described in the last an-
       38 E
594         REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

nual report. It continued to August 5, 1885, when the contract was
completed. The amount of material removed from the beginning of the
fiscal year was 43,444 cubic yards of dredged material and 2.24 cubic
yards of bowlders, all of which was carried to the dumping-ground be-
tween AbiePs Ledge and Dry Ledge, in Buzzard's Bay. New bounds
were placed to mark the channel-lines of the entire improvement, and
small repairs were made during the year to the stone and brush pro-
tective works at Long Beach damaged by the storms of the winter of
1885-'86.
   The lumber of the old sand-catch fence at Long Beach, destroyed in
the great storm of January 9. was sold at auction March 31, after due
advertisement, and the proceeds were deposited in the Treasury.
   Mr. Thomas A. Churbuck was local inspector of the work.

AMOUNT         EXPENDED           DURING               LAST FISCAL YEAR AND                                      RESULTS       TO
                                               JUNE 30, 1886.
   The amount expended during the last fiscal year was $8,485.21. The
channel in the upper part of the harbor in front of the wharves was
carried to its full width and completed, and about one-half of the first
reach below the wharves was excavated to its full depth of 10 feet be-
low mean low water. This reach includes the heaviest cutting in the
entire improvement. The ruling depth of the approaches to Wareham
has now been increased from 7 to 9 feet, and the channel has been
greatly widened in all the reaches, especially in the main reach below
the wharves. Vessels of larger draught can be carried to Wareham than
formerly, and the increase in width of channel is already a great help to
all vessels in beating in and out of the harbor.

WORK REQUIRED TO BE DONE TO COMPLETE THE EXISTING PROJECT.

  The work required to complete the existing project is the excavation
of the channel to its full Width and depth from the point to which it
was carried by the last contract down to the deep water above Long
Beach. There will also be required the expenditure of a few hundred
dollars more in the further building up of Long Beach.

OPERATIONS           CONTEYIPLATED                   FOR THE                   FISCAL YEAR ENDING JUNE
                                                      30, 1887.
  It is proposed to devote the small remainder on hand July 1, 1886,
and the appropriation made by the act of August 5, 1886, to carrying
on the work according to the approved project as far as the funds will
admit.
   Wareham is in the New Bedford collection district. New Bedford is the nearest
port of entry. The amount of revenue collected in the last fiscal year was $48,381.08.
The nearest light-houses are Bird's Island and Wing's Neck lights. The nearest for-
tification is the fort at Clark's Point, New Bedford, Mass.

                                             Money statement.
July 1, 1885, amount available .-                -......---......--.........                ---..---........--.....      $8, 532 67
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885           .._ ... ...............                    .... ....      .....      ...     ....    8, 4s5 21

July 1, 1886, amount available ...................................                                              .....        47 4
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886 ......-.............                                                  15,000 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887 ...........-.....                                                  15, 047 46
            APPENDIX        C--REPORT          OF LIEUT.-COL. ELLIOT.               595
  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project ...... .       $4, 050 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1888      4, 050 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.


                                COMMERCIAL STATISTICS.

                                                      WAREHAM, MASS., July 10, 1886.
  SIR: Replying to your inquiry referring to the commercial statistics of Wareham
Harbor, I have the honor to write that I learn of no such changes in its commerce
since the date of my advices to you in that respect of last year as will materially
alter the carefully prepared statements that appear in your official reports for 1884
and 1885 upon the impro-ement of this harbor. An increase of commerce in some
staple articles is apparent here, but it is not an equivalent for the decrease incident to
the general depression inthe manufacture of iron commodities. The commerce of this
port has plainly been stimulated by the intended improvements in its navigation, but
the benefits and great utility of these improvements cannot be realized fully until
the completion of the work throughout as projected.
       Very respectfully,
                                                                  GERARD C. TOBEY.
  GEORGE H.    ELLIOT,
          Lieut. Col. of Engineers, U. S. A.




                                          C 6.

           IMPROVEMENT OF TAUNTON RIVER, MASSACHUSETTS.

   This river rises in Norfolk County, Massachusetts, and empties into
Mount Hope Bay, a name given to that part of Narragansett Bay lying
mainly in Massachusetts. It is about 44 miles in length, measured
along its course.
   The object of the improvement is to deepen and widen the channel
leading to the city of Taunton, at the head of navigation, which requires
large quantities of coal, iron, clay, moldings, sand, and other heavy
articles for its extensive manufactures, dependent largely on water
transportation, so that vessels of 11 feet draught can reach the city at
high water. The rise and fall of the tide before improvement was 54
feet at Dighton and 3.4 feet at Taunton.

                               ORIGINAL CONDITION.

  In its original condition the channel was narrow and obstructed by
bowlders, and from Berkley Bridge to Taunton the depth was not, in
places, more than 5 feet at mean high water. A vessel of 30 tons
burden was as large as could go up to Taunton.

                            PLANS     OF IMPROVEMENT.

  The approved project of 1871 and its subsequent modifications pro-
vides for a channel 60 feet wide and 11 feet deep from Weir Bridge to
the ship-yard; a channel 80 feet wide (100 feet at the bends) and 11 feet
deep from the ship-yard down to and through the Needles and Briggs's
Shoal; thence to Berkley Bridge a channel of the same width and 12
feet deep, and from Berkley Bridge to the deep water at Dighton the
channel was to be 100 feet wide and 12 feet deep. The depths are esti-
mated from high water. The ledge which crosses the bottom of the
596     REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

river at Peter's Point, and the numerous bowlders which lay on the
bottom and sides of the channel from Taunton to Dighton were to be
removed.
  A plat of the river, showing the improved channel, was published
in the Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1884, page 606.

         AMOUNT EXPENDED      AND RESULTS     TO JUNE 30, 1885.

   The amount expended on the improvement of the river up to the close
of the fiscal year ending June 30, 1885, including liabilities outstanding
at that date, was $134,470.44.
   With the exception that but 40 feet of the 60 feet of width could only
be dredged between the bridge at Weir and the ship-yard on account of
interfering with private property, and that on account of the hardness
and depth of the material at the sides the 80-foot channel was not, in
all cases, dredged to its full width, the channel down to Berkley Bridge
had been completed.
   The major part of dredging below the bridge had been done, but this
part of the channel still lacked in width at some places. The channel
had been cleared of bowlders from Taunton down to Berkley Bridge.
The work of uncovering the ledge at Peter's Point preparatory to its
removal had been commenced.

           OPERATIONS DURING       THE LAST FISCAL YEAR.

   At the beginning of the last fiscal year work was in progress under
a contract with J. H. Fenner, of Jersey City, N. J., described in the
last Annual Report, for cutting a channel 12 feet deep and 100 feet wide
through the ledge at Peter's Point, and excavating by dredging a chan-
nel of the same dimensions between the upper part of "The Nook" and
Dighton. The work of uncovering the ledge at Peter's Point by re-
moving the overlying bowlders and gravel was completed in August,
1885, when a very careful survey was made to determine the cubic con-
tents of the prism of rock to be excavated, to serve as a basis for pay-
ment to the contractor when the ledge work should be completed. The
blasting and removal of the ledge was then commenced, arid has con-
tinued until the end of the fiscal year with the exception of a suspen-
sion during the winter on account of ice, and other suspensions by rea-
son of damages to the contractor's plant. The major part of the mate-
rial blasted in the eastern half of the channel has been dredged, and
deposited in the form of a half-tide dam running from Reuben's Island
to the west shore of the river, with the view of accelerating the current
in the dredged channel off and above Dighton and preventing depos-
its in this part of the channel. During the year surveys were made of
the channel between Church's Wharf and Berkley Bridge, of Pioneer
Rock and the shoal at the mouth of Three-mile River, and examinations
were made of the channel at "Burt's Turn" and between North Digh-
ton and Weir. The contract with Mr. Fenner has been extended, with
the approval of the Chief of Engineers, to September 1, 1886. Mr. C.
O. Abell was the local inspector of the work.

AMOUNT    EXPENDED DU'RING THE LAST FISCAL YEAR,          AND   RESULTS
                        TO JUNE 30, 1886.

  The amount expended during the last fiscal year, including liabilities
outstanding June 30, 1886, was $2,917.95. All of the bowlders and
gravel overlying the ledge at Peter's Point within the lines of the pro-
                  APPENDIX             C-REPORT                    OF LIEUT.-COL.                  ELLIOT.               597
posed channel have been removed; the work of blasting the ledge has
been nearly completedl; the major part of the broken rock has been
removed by dredging, and the half-tide dam between Reuben's Island
and the west shore of the river has been essentially completed. The
ruling depth of water in the river has been increased from 5 to 11 feet
at mean high water, and vessels of 11 feet draught can now reach Taun-
ton, at the head of navigation.

WORK REQUIRED TO BE DONE TO COMPLETE THE EXISTING PROJECT

  There remains to be done to complete the existing project the com-
pletion of the removal of the ledge at Peter's Point; the completion of
the dredging of the channel between Berkley Bridge and Dighton, and
widening and deepening at a few points above the bridge, for all of
which it is hoped the funds now available will be sufficient.

OPERATIONS               CONTEMPLATED                  FOR          THE     FISCAL YEAR ENDING JUNE
                                                      30, 1887.

   It is proposed to devote the remainder on hand July 1, 1886, to the
completion of the removal of the ledge at Peter's Point, and to the en-
largement by dredging of the remainder of the channel between Dighton
and Berkley Bridge as well as above the bridge.
                                                                                                                                  \
  Taunton River is in the Fall River collection district. Fall River is the nearest port
of entry. The amount of revenue c)llected in the last fiscal year was $16,645. The
nearest light-house is the Borden Flat light-house. The nearest fortification is Fort
Adams, Newport Harbor, Rhode Island.

                                                  Money statement.

July 1, 1885, amount available....--.....                  ..--.........         ..................            $22, 529 56
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
   liabilities outstanding July 1, 1885-...                          .....--.........               $2, 130 46
July 1, 1886, outstanding liabilities..-..............-.........                                        787 49
                                                                                                                 2, 917 95

July 1, 1886, amount available-..                     ............                    ................              19,611 61




                                             COMMERCIAL STATISTICS.

                                                        TAUNTON, July 10, 1886.
DEAR SIR: In reply to yours of the 9th we will inclose to you the following com-
mercial statistics:


                   Articles.                      Quantity.                         Articles.                        Quantity.

Lumber .................. ..... feet..            11, 000,   000    Metals of all kinds .......... tons..               39, 000
Grain ..................             .bushels..    1, 238,   000    Cotton       .. .............. bales..              25, 500
Flour ...        .................... barrels..        40,   000    Molding-sand .............       ..... tons..       22, 000
Coal ... .......                   . .. tons..        240,   000    Clay................. ........... . tons. .         28, 000
All other kinds of merchandise .tons..                 20,   000


  There are owned in Taunton forty-four schooners, whose total carrying capacity is
nearly 35,000 tons. There are also belonging to Taunton nine coal barges with a total
carrying capacity of 10,000 tons. A large part of the above vessels and all the barges
go to Taunton with a part and in many cases with a full cargo. In addition to this
there are four large boats constantly employed on the river and one or two pleasure
boats and barges.
598      REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

  The population of Taunton has increased about 1,200 in the last year, and the busi-
ness on the river is constantly increasing.
  In addition to the above allow us to say that previous to February of the current
year the channel which has been deepened and widened-since the commencement of
the last improvement on the river, has not filled in to any extent. In February last
this section of country was visited by a terrible flood, being the most severe of any-
thing of the kind for at least one hundred years. After the flood etnt down, it was
found that in many places (one in particular a short way below Weir Village) the
channel had been filled in 2 or 3 feet. We hope these shoals may be removed as quickly
as possible and that the channel in the bends of the ri ver may be widened.
      Yours, truly,
                                                             STAPLES &   PHILLIPS.
  Col. GEO. H. ELLIOT.




                                        C   7   .
         IMPROVEMENT OF PAWTUCKET RIVER, RHODE ISLAND.

   The navigable part of the Pawtucket (or Seekonk) River, an arm o
Providence River, extends from Providence to Pawtucket, a city which
has a population of about 23,000, and extensive manufactures, depending
largely on water transportation. The object of the improvement is to
widen and deepen the channel leading to Pawtucket, so that vessels of
12 feet draught can reach that city at mean low water. The mean rise
and fall of the tide is about 5 feet.
                             ORIGINAL CONDITION.

  Before improvement, the channel in the river had a ruling depth of
about 5 feet at mean low water.
                          PLANS OF IMPROVEMENT.

  The original project as modified in 1883 provides for the excavation
by dredging of a channel 100 feet wide and 12 feet deep at mean low
water from the deep water above Red Bridge to the ledge opposite
Grant & Co.'s Wharf at Pawtucket; thence, the deepening by blasting
of the channel through the ledge to Pawtucket Bridge to the same
depth and 40 feet wide.
  A plat of the river showing the lines of the proposed channel was
published in the Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1884, page
608.
         AMOUNT EXPENDED AND RESULTS TO JUNE 30,                     1885.
  The amount expended to June 30, 1885, was $52,718.44. The channel
had been excavated under the original project to a width of 75 feet and
a ruling depth of 7 feet at mean low water. A contract had been made
for deepening and widening this channel according to the modified plan
of 1883, but the work had not been commenced.
             OPERATIONS DURING THE LAST FISCAL YEAR.

  At the beginning of the last fiscal year no work was in progress. ' A
contract, described in the last Annual Report, had been made in Octo-
ber, 1884, with Elijah Brainard and Thomas H. Benton, of New York,
for dredging a channel 12 feet deep and 100 feet wide from the deep
water just above Red Bridge as far towards the city of Pawtucket as
the available funds would pay for, but the work was not to be com-
menced until the old Washington Bridge across the river near its
                 APPENDIX           C.-REPORT              OF LIEUT.-COL.             ELLIOT.               599
mouth, which formed such an obstruction to navigation as would inter-
fere with the passage of tows of the dredged material, should be, re-
moved. This delayed the commencement of the woIk till August 7,
1885, from which time it was continued until December 7, when the work
was suspended for the winter by ice, and it was resumed on ApriL.9,
1886. The time of completion of the contract was extended by author-
ity of the Chief of Engineers to June 7, 1886. It was completed May
28, 1886, 212,734.57 cubic yards of material having been removed dur-
ing the fiscal year. In November, 1885, a series of observations of the
rise and fall of the tide at Pawtucket was made for future determina-
tions of the effect of the enlargement of the water-way on the tides art
that place. Mr. John S. Engs, jr., was the local inspector of the work.
AMOUNT         EXPENDED DURING THE LAST FISCAL YEAR,                                          AND RESULTS
                            TO JUNE 30, 1880.

  The amount expended during the last fiscal year, including liabilities
outstanding June 30, 1886, was $49,241.02. The new channel, 12 feet
deep and 100 feet wide with wide enlargements at the bends, has been
carried from its mouth at the deep water just above Red Bridge, a dis-
tance of about 8,740 feet, or to a point.about 1,000 feet above a line
drawn from Bucklin Island to Swan Point Wharf.
  This completed portion of the channel is already a great benefit to
the commerce of the river and gives much satisfaction.  A ruling depth
of about 6 feet can be carried from the upper end of our present work
to Pawtucket.
WORK REQUIRED TO BE DONE TO COMPLETE THE EXISTING PROJECT.

  The work yet to be done is to excavate by dredging the channel 12
feet deep and 100 feet wide from the point to which the last contract
carried it to a point opposite Grant & Company's Wharf, and from
thence to Pawtucket Bridge to deepen the channel through the ledge
to the same depth with a width of 40 feet.
OPERATIONS CONTEMPLATED                            FOR THE          FISCAL YEAR ENDING JUNE
                                                    30, 1887.
   It is proposed to devote the small remainder on hand July 1, 1886,
and the appropriation made by the act of August 5, 1886, to the exca-
vation by dredging of the upper reaches of the new channel, and, if the
funds will admit, to the commencement of the work on the ledge which
lies in the channel off Pawtucket.
  Pawtucket is in the collection district of Providence, and that port is the nearest
port of entry. The amount of revenue collected at Providence in the last fiscal year
was $180,933.       The nearest light-house is Sassafras Point Light.                    The nearest fortifi-
cations are Fort Adams, Newport, Rhode Island, and the fort on Dutch Island, Rhode
Island.
                                              Money statement.
                                                                                                  $49, 287 52
July 1, 1885, amount available .----..-----....... ------ ------.... ----.....-------.......--------..------......
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive
  of liabilities outstanding July 1, 1885............. ....... $49, 217 27
July 1, 1886, outstanding liabilities ......-......--..-.....-.                            23 75
                                                                                                       49,241 02

July 1, 1886, amount available ---- ---....-------.............--.--..-..------.       ....-----....       46 50
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886 .....-..-----......                                 30, 000 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887 ....----....-----......                          30,046 50
600             REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

   Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project .- . $302, 478 00
   Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1886 75, 000 00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
     harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.


                                                            MERCIAL STATISTICS.

                                                            PAWTUCKET BUSINESS MEN'S ASSOCIATION,
                                                            Pawtucket, July 20, 1886.
   DEAR SIR: Your letter of the 17th ultimo to the President of this association in
relation to improvements of Pawtucket River was received in due time. In his
absence I will simply state the statistics collected by the committee from this asso-
ciation in 1883 were substantially accurate, and correct for the last year if about 10.
per cent. be added to the same.
       Yours, very respectfully,
                                                               A. K. GOODWIN,
                                  Vice PresidentPawtucket Business Men's Association.
   Lieut. Col. GEORGE II.ELLIOT,
              Corps of Engineers, U. S. A.




    COMMUNICATIONS FROM THE PAWTUCKET, R. I.,                                                     BUSINESS MEN'S ASSOCIATION.


                                                                            1.
                                                                                             PAWTUCKET, R. I.,               June 14, 1883.
  DEAR SIR: Your favor of May 22, addressed to the Pawtucket Business Men's As-
sociation, was duly received, and the undersigned, a committee appointed by said
association to obtain the information desired, most respectfully submit the following
statistics of the commerce in Pawtucket River for the year 1882:

                                                                   IMPORTS.


                 Articles.                                Quantity.                                           Articles.                  Quantity.


Coal ....-.....--..--............. tons.                      86, 000            Ammonia water .............           barrels.              210, 000
Iron. -............. .... .......   do..                       5, 300            Lime          ......      .. ... ........  do..               2, 500
Gravel.........--..............do.                                300            Cement .....--.................            do..              15, 000
Clay ..........................     do..                           50            Long lumber.... .....                  ...feet - 9,         000, 000
North River stone ...............   do.                           500            Short lumber, as shingles, laths, clap-
Paving-stone.................do..                                 240              boards, &c..                  ................ 3,        000, 000
Brick.................................                     2,000, 000            Spool lumber (about) .........feet.. 2,                    000, 000



   The above merchandise was received chiefly by barges and sailing vessels carrying
from 150 to 600 tons each, and drawing from 71 to 11 feet of water.
   The number of water-craft passed through the draw-bridges for the year 1882 was
as follows :


                                                              Class.                                                                     Number.


Steamboats..........               ...........  ........... ................................                            ........                 402
Tow boats --....---....................             ----.........
                                                 ....                .... .................            .................           ...           760
Sailing vessels ....................           ...... ........        ... ... .....          .... ..... ..................                       413
Sail-boats ...........                                         ..
                                    .. ...........................                    .............................. . ...                       248
Miscellaneous.........................................................................                                                           458
         Total..................               ...             ............................................                                    2,281


  We would call attention to the fact that the commerce upon the river is steadily
increasing; also that extensive manufacturing establishments are now being erected
upon the banks of the river, which will greatly increase the commerce upon the same,
and in order to meet the demand for transportation in large barges and sailing vessels
             APPENDIX       C-REPORT          OF   LIEUT.-COL.     ELLIOT.           601
increased facilities to navigate the Pawtucket River should be made by widening and
deepening the channel and removing the obstructions.
  We wish especially to call attention to an obstruction known as Seal Rock, lying
nearly in the middle of the channel of the river at the head of navigation, and we
hope that such recomumendation will be made as will cause its removal.
  All of which is most respectfully submitted.
                                                                 GEO. F.   NEWELL,
                                                                 GEO. P. GRANT,
                                                                HENRY E. JENKS,
                                                                             Con mittee.
  GEORGE H.     ELLIOT,
         Lieut. Col. of Engineers, U. S, A.




                                                           PAWTUCKET, August 2, 1883.
   DEAR SIR: We, the undersigned committee, beg leave to submit the following sup-
plemental report in accordance with your request to furnish additional information
respecting the commerce and manufactures that would be benefited by further im-
provement of the Pawtucket River.
   Pawtucket, situated at the head of navigation, 4 miles above Providence, becomes
a distributing point for merchandise to supply an extensive inland tradc. Among
the towns which draw more or less of their supplies from Pawtucket may be men-
tioned East Providence, Seekonk, Rehoboth. Attleboro', Mansfield, Wrentham, Frank-
lin, Cumberland, Lincoln, Smithfield, and North Providence.
   Pawtucket naturally commands the trade of the territory for half the distance to
Boston and entire valley of the Blackstone River. One hundred and thirty trains
over Boston and Providence, the Providence and Worcester, and the New York and
New England Railroads pass through this place daily. Its convenience for transporta-
tion by rail, the facility with which its citizens can reach all the large centers of
business, together with its manufacturing and mechanical industries, have attracted
people from various parts of the world to settle here.
   The growth of Pawtucket has been rapidly increasing. In 1N65 there were 5,000
inhabitants; at the present time, 1883, there are between 23,000 and 25,000. If we
include the immediate villages of Central Falls, Valley Falls, Lonsdale, and Sayles-
ville, we may safely say we have a population of upward of 35,000.
   Within these limits there is a great variety and a vast amount of manufacturing
and mechanical industries carried on, and from which the General Government has in
years past received large revenues. They paid during the fiscal year ending June 30,
1866, $636,691.98 into the office of the assessors for internal revenue for the first dis-
trict of Rhode Island.
   The revenue from the Pawtucket post-office for the fiscal year ending December 31,
1882, was $12,298.28, which will give you some idea of the business which is transacted
here at the present time.
   Pawtucket is largely a manufacturing community, and in the extent and variety
of its manufactures is not surpassed by any place of equal size in the United States.
It contains some of the largest establishments of their kind which are to be found in
the country, among which may be mentioned the Conant Thread (ompany, manufact-
urers of the J. & P. Coats spool cotton, with a capital of $3,000,000, and employing
over 2,000 operatives, and consuming in the single item of coal 20,000 tons annually.
   The W. F. & F. C. Sayles bleacheries, with their manufacturing establishments,
employ over 1,500 hands, and their consumption of coal per annum is 15,000 tons.
   The Rhode Island Horse Shoe Company, situated in Valley Falls, in the immediate
vicinity of this place, is the largest of its kind in the world, and calls for a transpor-
tation of 150 tons per day, with a consumption of 12,000 tons of coal per annum.
   Without entering further into detail, we would add that not less than $25,000,000
are invested in the different manufacturing industries, all of which could not fail of
being benefited by the removal of the obstructions and the improvement of the chan-
nel of the Pawtucket River.
   The specific improvements needed to put the river in proper condition are the re-
moval of the obstructions at the Railroad and Washington bridges, the straighten-
ing, widening, and deepening of the channel, so that when completed it shall have a
width of 150 to 200 feet and a depth of 12 feet at low water; also the removal of Seal
Rock, near the head of navigation.
   Provision has been made by the State government for the removal of the present
Washington Bridge and the obstructions under the same, making a depth of water of
not less than 15 feet at low water; also providing for five commissioners, to be ap-
pointed by the State, the town of East Providence, and the city of Providence, to
execute the foregoing provision, build a bridge in the place of the present Washing-
602     REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

ton Bridge, with a draw having two openings of 80 feet in width, and two years'
time has been allowed the commissioners for the completion of the work. Commis-
sioners have already been appointed by the State and the town of East Providence.
  All of which is most respectfully submitted.
                                                         GEO. E. NEWELL,
                                                         GEO. P. GRANT,
                                                         HENRY F.    JENKS,
                              Committtee of Pawtucket Business Men's Association.
  GEORGE H.   ELLIOT,
         Lieut. Col. U. S. Engineers.




                                           C 8.
IMPROVEMENT OF PROVIDENCE RIVER AND NARRAGANSET BAY, RHODE
                                          ISLAND.

   Providence River is an estuary of Narragansett Bay. The object of
its improvement is to furnish a 'wide and deep channel for European
and coastwise commerce from the ocean to Providence, a city of about
125,000 inhabitants, largely engaged in manufactures, and a port of
entry for an extensive region of country with which it is connected by
railroads. The mean rise and fall of the tide is 4.7 feet.
                               ORIGINAL CONDITION.
  Before the improvement of the river was commenced, in 1853, many
shoals obstructed navigation and at one point in the channel-a place
called ' The Crook "-the available low-water depth was but 41 feet.
                            PLANS OF IMPROVEMENT.
   There was expended between 1852 and the 30th June, 1882, $290,459.34
in deepening the channel, first to 9 feet, then to 12 feet, then to 14 feet,
and again to 23 feet, as the increasing sizes of vessels and the growing
commerce of Providence demanded. Bulkhead Rock was also removed
during this period to a depth of 20 feet .below mean low water.
  The approved project of 1878, modified in 1882, under which we are
now working, provides for a channel 25 feet deep and 300 feet wide,
suitable for large ocean vessels, extending from Fox Point, in the city
of Providence, to the deep water of Narragansett Bay, and for an an-
chorage-basin between Fox and Field's Points of the following dimen-
sion, in cross-section, viz:
         300 feet wide, 25 feet deep.
         600 feet wide, 20 feet deep.
         725 feet wide, 18 feet deep.
         940 feet wide, 12 feet deep.
       1, 060 feet wide,   6 feet deep.
   The 25-foot channel has been laid out in straight reaches (with en-
largements at the angles) with a view to lighting them by range or lead-
ing lights, such as are used in similar cases in Cheasapeake Bay, Dela-
ware River, and other localities, if it should be found necessary.
   A plat of Providence River, showing the improved channel, was pub-
lished in the Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1884, page 622.
        AMOUNT EXPENDED AND RESULTS TO JUNE 30, 1885.
  The amount-expended on the present project up to the close of the
fiscal year ending June 30, 1885, including liabilities outstanding at
that date, was $210,180.96. At that date about one-half of the excava-
tion required for the anchorage-basin above Field's Point had been
done. Bulkhead Rock had been removed and the condition of the six
                        APPENDIX                      C--REPORT                 OF LIEUT.-COL. ELLIOT.                                          603

straight reaches into which the 25-foot channel, 300 feet wide, is divided
was as follows : The Fox Point, the Sassafras Point, the Field's Point,
the Pomham and the Pawtuxet reaches had been completed, and the
lowest, the Gaspee Reach, had been excavated to a width of 200 feet.
                           OPERATIONS                      DURING THE LAST FISCAL YEAR.
  For want of funds no work has been in progress during the last fiscal
year.
WORK REQUIRED TO BE DONE TO COMPLETE THE EXISTING PROJECT.
   To complete the 25-foot channel 300 feet wide, to the deep water of
Narragansett Bay, there remains the increasing to 300 feet the 200 feet
of width already excavated in the lowest (the Gaspee) reach. There
also remains for the completion of the existing project the remainder
of the excavation of the anchorage-basin betwen
                                         between Fox and Field's Points.
OPERATIONS CONTEMPLATED                                                FOR THE FISCAL YEAR ENDING JUNE
                                30, 1887.
  It is proposed to devote the small remainder on hand July 1, 1886,
and the appropriation made by the act of Augqst 5, 1886, to the com-
pletion of the dredging required in the Gaspee Reach, and to continuing
the excavation of the anchorage-basin above Field's Point.
   Providence River is in the collection district of Providence, which is a port of entry.
The amount of revenue collected in the last fiscal year was $180,933. The nearest
light-houses are the six light-houses in Providence River. The nearest fortifications
are fort on Dutch Island, and Fort Adams, Rhode Island.
                                                                  Money statement.
July 1, 1885, amount available....--......................                                                  .----.......--.    -        $3, 419 67
July 1, 1886, amornt expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885--..---------........---..----.......-----......-------------------.......                                         749 93
July 1, 1886, amount available -----                                                   --         ..        -------                        2,669 74
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886-...................                                                                  30,000 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887....-      - --...
                                                         - -......  - -- ..-                                                       ..   32, 669 74

 ( Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project --........
                                                                       ---    205, 000 00
) Amount that can be profitably  expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1888 100,000 00
   Submitted in complance with requirements of section 2 of river and
     harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.


                                                           COMMERCIAL             STATISTICS.


                                                PROVIDENCE             BOARD OF TRADE, SECRETARY'S OFFICE,
                                                    Providence, R. I., June 22, 1886.
    DEAR SIR: In reply to yours of the 17th, I beg leave to make reply as follows:
  The whole number of arrivals at this port from foreign countries during the year
1885 was 86, of which 27 only were American, bringing-

                         Articles.                                 Quanti-
                                                                    ties.
                                                                                                       Articles.                            Quanti-
                                                                                                                                             ties.

Lumber .---........--------......--------.......... feet..        2, 562, 000     Logwood.....................pounds..                      5, 341, 000
Shingles.... ..             .........................             2,443,100       Brimstone....-................. tons..                            680
Laths ................................                            6, 868, 000     Molasses .--...--.. ..--..........         gallons..          54, 976
Pickets .....................                              ....       38, 000     Potatoes.----.....    ..      ......--....bushels..           12,102
Piling......                                          pieces..        14, 200     Coffee--..--.....    --....
                                                                                                           .........         pounds..           17, 057
Wood.-.....-                                   ...    cords..          1, 866     Hides -..             ...-..     ..-...--   ...----- .           184
Salt----
     ....... -                           ...         pounds..     8, 293, 269

Amount of duties collected................                                ................................             ............. $189, 335 10
Amount of tonnage dues ...................................................................                                                     348 45
  604                REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

      There were also received-


                                                          Articles.                                                       Quantities.       Mode of trans-
                                                                                                                                             portation.


  Cotton ........................................................               bales..                                         245, 607    Water and rail.
  Wool .........................................................                 do....                                         130, 849        Do.
  Flour ........................................................              barrels.                                          269, 277        Do.
  Corn ......................................................                bushels..                                       1, 671, 580        Do.
  Coal ............................................................              tons..                                         870, 147    W ater.
  Lumber ....................................................................... feet..                                     37,142,208          Do.


                                                                                   TONNAGE.
                                                                                                                                           - -
                                                                 Description.                                                               No.       Tons.


  Sail vessels .......................................................................                                                       109      13, 300.14
  Steam vessels                               ..................................................                                              38      24, 945. 28



    The above figures are as near as I can get them, and I have no means of separating
  the receipts by water and rail.
               Yours, &c.,                                                                                                           F. P. LITTLE,
                                                                                                                                               Secretary.
      To Lieut. Col. GEORGE H.                                    ELLIOT.



                                                     LETTER OF MR. GEORGE R. PHILLIPS.

                                                                                                    PROVIDENCE, R. I., June 18, 1886.
     DEAR SIR: Your favor of the 17th instant received, and contents noted. The for-
  eign importations to the port of Providence for the year 1885 are as follows :


                            Articles.                                     Quantity.                             A rtlcles.                           Quantity.


  Lumber.....................feet..                                        2, 562, 000   Logwoood ..................                  pounds..        5, 341, 000   I


  Laths...........................do...                                    6, 686, 000   Brimstone....................                   tons..               680   I




- Shingles . .................                                             2, 431, 000   Molasses ...................                 gallons..           54, 976
  Pickets ............---------               ---.... ..                       38, 000   Potatoes.........                ........    bushels..           12, 102
  Wood...........              ..............        cords.,.                   1, 866   Coffee.................                      pounds..            17, 057
  Piling.........................                   pieces..                    1, 420   Salt ...........................                do ..        8, 293, 269   1




      The domestic importations were as follows, with some exceptions not reported :


                            Articles.                                     Quantity.                              Articles.                           Quantity.


  Coal........................tons..                                          870,147    Beef........................pounds..                        21, 707, 906
  Cotton ........................                         bales..             245, 607   Oil............ .............                  barrels..         88, 688
  Wool.......-..................do..                                          130, 349   Liquors ....................                     do....         108, 757
  Flour......................                         barrels..               269, 277   Iron and steel ...........                    pounds..      44, 316, 511
  Corn .---.....................                     bushels..             1, 671, 580   Lumber........................                    feet..    37, 142, 208



      There has been an increase in many of the importations over last year.                                                                        It is to be
  hoped that               the General Government will take some notice of the request of many of
  our citizens to have Green Jacket Shoal taken away. It is a great barrier to naviga-
  tion, and the space could be used to advantage as anchorage-ground.
         Very truly, yours,
                                                              GEORGE R. PHILLIPS.
      GEORGE H. ELLIOT,
         Lieutenant-Colonel of Engineers.
            APPENDIX      C-REPORT OF LIEUT.-COL. ELLIOT.                          605

                                         C 9.
REMOVAL OF GREEN JACKET SHOAL, PROVIDENCE RIVER, RHODE ISLAND.

   Green Jacket Shoal is in that part of Providence River which consti-
tutes the harbor of Providence. It lies off the wharves on the south
front of the city, and occupies a part of the harbor that is required for
anchorage purposes.
   This is a new work, and no appropriation had been made for it until
by the act of August 5, 1886, Congress authorized its commencement by
making an appropriation of $26,250 therefor.
   My report of January 10, 1885, of the survey of the shoal, the plat,
and the estimate of the cost of the work ($112,346.25) on which the ap-
propriation was founded, were published in the Annual Report of the
Chief of Engineers for 1885, Vol. I, pages 598-602.
   It is proposed, with the appropriation of August 5, 1886, to commence
the work by removing that part of the shoal where additional anchorage
is most required.
  Green Jacket Shoal is in the collection district of Providence, which is a port of
entry. The amount of revenue collected during the last fiscal year was $180,933. The
nearest light-houses are the six light-houses in Providence River. The nearest forti-
fications are fort on Dutch Island and Fort Adams, Rhode Island.

                           COMMERCIAL STATISTICS.

   For the commercial statistics, see report of the improvement of Prov-
idence River and Narragansett Bay, Rhode Island, Appendix.
                                    Money statement.
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886...........-......          $26,250 00

 (Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project.. ......     86,096 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1888   50, 000 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.



                                         C 'o.

            IMPROVEMENT OF WARREN RIVER, RHODE ISLAND.
   Warren River is an arm of Narragansett Bay north of the harbor or
Bristol. This is a new work and no appropriation had been made for
it until by act approved August 5, 1886, Congress appropriated $5,000
for the improvement of the river. In my report, January 12, 1885, of
the survey made in accordance with the act of July 5, 1884, I stated
that the obstructions to navigation were a rocky reef below Little Isl-
and, and a submerged bowlder near mid-channel opposite the lower
wharf of the town of Warren, and recommended that this bowlder and
the reef referred to be removed as far as it could be done with an ex-
penditure of $5,000 for both purposes. They are doubtless the improve-
ment appropriated for by act of August 5, 1886, and the funds will be
expended accordingly.
   A plat of Warren River was published in the Annual Report of the
Chief of Engineers for 1885, Vol. I, page 630.
                                    Money statement.
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886....................          5, 000 00
606     REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.


                                  C II.

        IMPROVEMENT OF NEWPORT HARBOR, RHODE ISLAND.

  This harbor is at the mouth of the main entrance to Narragansett Bay.
These waters during summer and winter constitute a harbor of refuge
for our European and coastwise commerce quite equal in every respect
to that of New York Harbor, and are even more accessible. The ob-
jects of the improvement are to widen and deepen the southern (the
main) entrance to the harbor, and to enlarge its capacity for vessels seek-
ing refuge in storms, by increasing the area and depth of the anchor-
age within it. The mean rise and fall of the tide is about 33 feet.

                         ORIGINAL    CONDITION.

  Before improvement the capacity of the inner harbor was limited by
shoals, and it was not adequate to the number and size of vessels seek-
ing it for refuge. The southern (the main) entrance was obstructed by
a bar which stretched out from Goat Island, and. the general business
wharves of the city could not be reached at low tide by vessels draw-
ing more than 8 feet.
                       PLANS OF IMPROVEMENT.

   The original project and its modifications under which we are now
working are substantially as follows:
   Deepening the southern entrance to 15 feet at mean low water, and
widening it by dredging Goat Island Spit northward to a line drawn
from the dolphin which marks the spit to clear the permanent dock at
Fort Adams by 100 feet; the excavation of a channel 750 feet wide and
15 feet deep at mean low water around and to the eastward of this dol-
phin; excavating to 13 feet at mean low water the area included be-
tween the 13-foot curve on the west, a line drawn from the southwest
corner of Perry Mill Wharf to Lime Rock on the south, the harbor-line
on the east, and a line drawn parallel to and 50 feet from the City wharf
on the north; excavating to 10 feet at mean low water the area north-
west of a line drawn from Lime Rock through the spindle which is in the
southeast part of the harbor; the excavation of a channel 10 feet deep
at mean low water along and outside the harbor line south to a point
opposite the gas company's wharf, and the construction of jetties on the
western shore of Goat Island to arrest the drift of littoral sand and gravel
into the southern entrance.
   A plat of Newport Harbor, showing the plans of the work, was pub-
lished in the Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1885, Vol.
I, page 604.

        AMOUNT EXPENDED        AND RESULTS     TO JUNE 30, 1885.

  The amount expended up to the close of the fiscal year ending June
30, 1885, includling liabilities outstanding at that date, was $86,966.66,
with the following results: Of the area to be dredged to 13 feet within
the harbor, abouttwo-thirds had been completed, except at a few places
in the northern part of the harbor where the material was found too
hard for the dredge in use at the time. and except that a bulkhead was
left in the extreme northeast part of the harbor to protect an anchorage
          APPENDIX C-REPORT          OF LIEUT.-COL. ELLIOT.          607
for small vessels. The channel along and outside the harbor line south
to a point opposite the gas company's wharf and the 15-foot channel
750 feet wide around and to the eastward of the dolphin on Goat Isl-
and Spit had been completed. Of the 460 feet (about) of increase of
width to be made between the 15-foot curves at the southern entrance
by dredging the spit south of Goat Island, 224 feet had been gained.
           OPERATIONS     DURING THE LAST FISCAL YEAR.
  At the beginning of the last fiscal year the work of widening the south-
ern entrance to the harbor by dredging Goat Island Spit to a depth of
15 feet at mean low water was in progress under a contract with the
Hartford Dredging Company, of Hartford, Conn.,which was described
in the last Annual Report, and the time of completion'of which was ex-
tended to October 1, 1885. The contract was completed September 8,
1885, and the amount of material removed during the fiscal year was
20,184.54 cubic yards. Mr. John S. Engs, jr., from July 1 to August 1,
1885, and Capt. B. F. Case, from August 1 to September 8, were local
inspectors of the work.
   Several bowlders were removed from the bed of the harbor, and the
stone jetty on the southwest shore of Goat Island was raised and re-
paired in a very substantial manner and extended to a distance of 133
feet from the shore.
AMOUNT EXPENDED DURING THE LAST FISCAL YEAR, AND RESULTS
                    TO JUNE 30, 1886.

   The amount expended during the last fiscal year was $5,853.38, and
the result was the further widening of the 15-foot depth at the south-
ern entrance by 180 feet, or to within 56 feet of the p)roposed northern
limit of this channel, viz, a line drawn from the dolphin which marks
the Goat Island Spit to clear the permanent dock at Fort Adams by 100
feet, and the effectual stopping for the present of the supply of littoral
sand and gravel from the outside of Goat Island into the southern en-
trance by the extension and raising of the jetty on the southwest shore
of the island. When the northwest angle between this jetty and the
shore has been filled and the sand and gravel commence to be washed
around its end, another jetty further northward on this shore will be
required, but this will probably not occur for many years to come. The
southern entrance is completed with the exception of the small amount
of work above mentioned, and it is now wide and safe for vessels of15
feet draught. Of the total area to be deepened within the harbor (about
90 acres) about one half has been completed.
WORK REQUIRED TO BE DONE TO COMPLETE THE EXISTING PROJECT.

  The work required to be done to complete the existing project is the
small remainder of the cutting away of the spit south of Goat Island
to 15 feet depth, the remainder of the excavation within'the harbor of
the anchorage area of 13 feet depth, and the excavation, also within the
harbor, of the anchorage area of 10 feet depth; also the building of
additional jetties outside of Goat Island whenever they may be required
to arrest the drift of littoral saud and gravel into the harbor entrance.
OPERATIONS    CONTEMPLATED      FOR THE FISCAL YEAR ENDING JUNE
                                 30. 1887.
  It is proposed to devote the small remainder on hand July 1, 1886,
and the appropriation made by the act of August 5, 1886, to the com-
608               REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

pletion of the deepening to 15 feet below mean low water of the spit
south of Goat Island to the northern limit before stated; to the exten-
sion of the anchorage area within the harbor of 13 feet depth, and if the
funds will allow, to the commencement of the extension, also within the
harbor, of the anchorage area of 10 feet depth. It is also proposed to
do a small amount of dredging at the end of the wharf at Fort Adams,
at which supplies for the fort are landed.
  Newport is in the collection district of Newport, and is a port of entry. The amount
of revenue collected in the last fiscal year was $1,622.81. The nearest light-houses
are Lime Rock and Newport (Goat Island) lights. The nearest fortification is Fort
Adams, Newport, R. I.
                                  Money statement.
July 1, 1885, amount available.----..... ............     ....------...... .... .... ....                                                             $6, 235 37
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885. --.--..-----             .. --              .----.----.-..----.                                                            5, 853 38
July 1, 1886, amount available...---.... ...... ............ .........--- ....                                                                            381 99
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886 .....           .. ....--....                                                                      15. 000 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887..... .... ......-.-.                                                                            15, 381 99
 ( Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project....- -....- 52, 000 00
J Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1888 30,000 00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.


                                                             COMMERCIAL                   STATISTICS.


                                                                                              CUSTOM-HOUSE,                      NEWPORT, R. I.,
                                                        Collector's Ofice, July 13, 1886.
  SIR: I have the honor to acknowledge the receipt of your letters of the 17th ultimo.
  During the year ending June 30, 1886, about 5,000 vessels of all classes have arrived
at this port, either for a harbor or to discharge cargoes; this includes steam and sail
vessels engaged in the coasting trade, fisheries, and yachting.
  During the year ending June 30, 1886, 11 vessels have arrived at this port from for-
eign ports and discharged their cargoes; 13 vessels have cleared from this port for for-
eign ports. The cargoes from foreign ports consisted of-


                                                           Articles.                                                                    Quantity.      Value.


Spruce boards ......            .....     .............            ....          .- .... -................                    :feet..   1, 216, 993    $12, 827   31
Spruce laths...................                       ...........................                                          pieces..        115, 700      1,707    72
Hemlock boards ..........-....                      ....--....              .......................                         . feet..        20, 349         142   44
Pine boards ......................---
                                  .......             ......           .. ....            ..... ...............               do....        62, 896         814   17
Shingles ....             --...............................              .......         ......       ....      ..........                 461,000          876   25



    During the same year there has been landed at this port, say:


                         Articlbs.                                  Quantity.                                    Articles.                            Quantity.


Coal...........                    .... .......           tons..       48, 000            Brick .....................          ...     ...              4, 500, 000
Shingles ............................                              4, 500, 000            Lumber........................feet..                         11, 500, 000
Laths................................                              9, 000, 000            Hay .....................             ..... tons..                 1, 000
Lime ...........                    ..........         barrels.. I     12, 500            Grain ..       .... ................ bushels.                    350, 000
Cement ............                      .... ......... do...           8, 500



    The amount of revenue collected in this district from duties on imports, tonnage
tax, inspection of steam vessels, and miscellaneous receipts during the year ending
June 30, 1886, was $1,622.81, the decrease from previous years being on account of
changes in the law abolishing certain fees, &c.
                 APPENDIX              C-REPORT            OF         LIEUT.-COL.                   ELLIOT.            609
  There are 128 vessels owned and hailing from this port, viz, 107 sail, 21 steam, the
tonnage of which amounts to : Gross tonnage, 5,64415o1-; net tonnage, 4,522- 0 .a-show-
ing an increase over that of year ending June 30, 1885, and which will be still further
increased in a few weeks by the addition of the fine new schooner James C. Clifford,
                                      358
gross tonnage, 377,;    net tonnage,      -f-, which has just been built in Boston to
hail from this port; and also by the addition of the new ferry-boat Conanicut, which
has just been launched. The tonnage of the largest vessel is 708 1 o gross, 673 -o net;
                                 -
that of the smallest vessel, 2-oo5 gross, 2- 0 net. The largest vessel draws 13 feet
when loaded. Trusting these statistics are sufficient for your purpose,
       I remain, respectfully,
                                                                J. H. COZZENS,
                                                                             Collector.
  Lieut. Col. GEORGE              H.   ELLIOT.



      LETTER       OF TIIE      SUPERVISOR        OF   THE     OLD COLONY                       STEAMBOAT   COMPANY.


                     OLD COLONY STEAMBOAT COMPANY, FALL RIVER LINE,
                                                     Newport, R. i., July 10, 1886.
  DEAR SIR: In reply to your inquiry of the 17th ult. am pleased to inform you that
the steamers of this line carried between New York and Fall River, via Newport,
250,000 tons of merchandise and 255,000 passengers during the year ending May 31,
1886.
       Yours truly,
                                                             GEORGE PEIRCE,
                                                                        Supervisor.
  Lieut. Col. GEORGE H. ELLIOT.



LETTER OF 'tiHE         SUPERINTENDENT OF TILE NEWPORT AND WICKFORD RAILROAD AND
                                     STEAMBOAT COMPANY.

                                                        SUPERINTENDENT'S OFFICE,
                NEWPORT          AND       WICKFORD    RAILROAD               AND STEAMBOAT             COMPANY,
                                                        Newport, B. I., July 20, 1886.
  SIR: In reply to yours of yesterday I have to say that our business for the year
1885, as reported to our board of directors, was as follows:

                                            Source of revenue.                                                   Amount.

From 68,945 1-2 passengers...........................................................................            $50, 684   47
From carrying United States mails ...................................................                              8, 947   56
From freights (mainly local) .............................................................                         3, 808   12
From Adams Express Company .....................................................................                   1, 425   82
      Total for the year................                .....................................                     64, 865 97

        Yours, truly,
                                                                                                   THEO. WARREN,
                                                                                                        Superintendent.
  Col. GEORGE H.             ELLIOT.



                                                       C    12.
            HARBOR OF REFUGE AT BLOCK ISLAND, RHODE ISLAND.

   This island is a part of the State of Rhode Island. It is 14 miles east
of Montauk Point, the eastern end of Long Island, and its nearest point
is about 10 miles from the mainland. Besides the wants of the mackerel
fishing fleet and the general coast navigation, the island is an important
point on our shores for ocean navigation. It has a signal station, con-
nected by submarine telegraph with the mainland. Vessels are pass-
          39 E
610     REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

ing the island at all times and on all sides of it, and its position renders
it of national importance. The object of the improvement is to furnish
a harbor of refuge-for vessels engaged in foreign and coastwise com-
merce. The mean rise and fall of the tide is about 3 feet.
                         ORIGINAL CONDITION.

  Before the construction of the present   harbor of refuge Block Island
had no harbor which afforded protection    for decked vessels. The only
ones used were open boats, which on        the approach of storms were
hauled up on the beach by oxen. The        largest of these boats were of
about 10 tons burden.
                         PLANS OF THE WORKS.

   The original project and its subsequent modifications provided for a
harbor of refuge on the eastern side of the island, consisting of an inner
harbor or basin for small vessels and an exterior harbor for large ones.
The basin was to be about 250 by 300 feet in area and inclosed, with the
exception of an opening of 80 feet in width. Tlie exterior harbor was
to be formed by a riprap breakwater, which has been built. About 300
feet from the sea end of this breakwater, which is 1,900 feet long, a gap
200 feet long was left for the convenience of vessels. The present pro-
ject contemplates the filling of this gap, which was found to let in too
much sea in stormy weather. A plat of Block Island, showing the posi-
tion of the harbor of refuge and a l)lan of the works, may be found in
the Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1885, Vol. I, page 612-613.
   On the 8th December, 1884, the Senate of the United States directed
that report be made of the necessity and cost of enlarging the inner
harbor of refuge. The report, which was accompanied by plans and an
estimate of the cost ($46,189), was printed in Senate Ex. 1)oc. No. 27,
Forty-eighth Congress, second session, and may also be found in the Re-
port of the Chief of Engineers for 1885, Vol. I, page 610. The commence-
ment of this work has been approved by Congress making an appropri-
ation of $12,000 therefor in the act of August 5, 1886.
        AMOUNT EXPENDED        AND RESULTS      TO JUNE 30, 1885.

  The total expenditure up to June 30, 1885, including liabilities out-
standing at that date, was $318,925.09. The inner harbor and the main
breakwater, built in prolongation of the eastern side of the inner harbor
and extending 1,900 feet from the shore, were constructed in the years
1870 to 1879, inclusive. The utility of the work at once became appar-
ent. In stormy weather the inner harbor, especially, was filled with fish-
ermen and coasters, and it soon became necessary to increase its depth
from 7 feet, to which it had been dredged in the first instance, to 9 feet
at mean low water. In 1883 a strong jetty was built out from the cliff
to the eastward of the inner harbor, and a masonry wall was constructed
on the inside of the crib work forming the eastern side of the inner har-
bor. The major part of the sea which formerly came into the outer har-
bor through the gap in the main breakwater in easterly storms had, at
the beginning of the last fiscal year, been stopped by the partial filling
of the gap.
            OPERATIONS DURING THE LAST FISCAL YEAR.

  At the beginning of the last fiscal year thIe work of filling the gap
in the main breakwater was in progress unlder a contract with James
           APPENDIX    C--REPORT     OF LIEUT.-COL.   ELLIOT.        611
Scully, of Groton, Conn., described in the last annual report, for fur-
nishing riprap granite and pllacing the same in the gap. The contract
was completed August 27, 1885, 2,376 tons of stone having been laid in
the gap since the beginning of the fiscal year. In addition to this, the
inside of the foot of the inner harbor east wall was covered with sand
and clay to protect the pile foundation of this wall from the teredo; a
stout wooden barrier was built on the east side of the inner harbor to
prevent the wash of sand and gravel into the harbor in easterly storms,
and ring-bolts were placed in the east side of the harbor for mooring
fishing and other vessels using the harbor for refuge.
   A survey was made of a rel)resentative portion of the main break-
wa-er, a greater portion of which has now for many years been ex-
posed to the full force of the waves of the Atlantic, to see what had
been the degrading effect of these waves. This breakwater was con-
structed of riprap granite. The width at tol) (which is 6 feet above
mean high water) was 25 feet, the outer slope was 1 on 2, and the inner
slope was 1 on 1. It was found that the inner and outer angles of the
top had been rounded off and the width at top had been somewhat
reduced, but the height along the axis of the breakwater had been
diminished but little, and the breakwater is now as efficient a barrier
against the sea as when it was constructed, and it could, if necessary,
be placed in its original condition with but little cost.
   Mr. Andrew Ri. Elliot was local inspector of the work.

AMOUNT EXPENDED       DURING    THE LAST FISCAL YEAR      AND RESULTS
                               TO JUNE 30. 1886.

   The amount expended during the last fiscal year was $5,438.79. The
filling in the gap in the main breakwater was carried to the height of
about 1 feet above mean high water, and at the close of the work under
the last contract about one-half of the total amount of stone required
for the completion of this work had been delivered and placed in the
gap. The good effects of this filling, although incoml)lete, have already
been noticed, and vessels, both in the outer and inner harbor, lie more
quietly at their moorings in easterly storms than before.

                    THE WHARF AT BLOCK ISLAND.

   I respectfully renew my suggestion of last year respecting the Gov-
ernment wharf on the land side of the inner harbor of refuge at Block
Island, and recommend that it be turned over to the town of New Shore-
ham, the corporate name of Block Island, for the public use of said town.
   Before the works which form the harbor of refuge at Block Island were
commenced there was, as has before been stated, no harbor at the island,
nor was any wharf practicable on account of the exposure of its shores,
and the small vessels there used were hauled out on the beach by oxen.
During the construction of the sides of the inner harbor, which were
formed of cribs of wood filled in with stone, and after they had advanced
far enough to afford protection to a wharf, a small one was constructed
by the United States on the land side of this harbor for temporary pur-
poses of construction. Since the completion of the inner harbor the use
of this wharf by the Government has been very slight, but all the passen-
gers, now many thousands annually, and all the freight to and from the
island, have always used, and continue to use, this wharf, except that
in the summer months a steamer from the mainland lands its passengers
612         REPORT OF THE CHIEF                       OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

at a small private wharf in the outer harbor, but this latter wharf can-
not be used at other seasons on account of the exposure of the outer
harbor.
   The wharf in the inner harbor, a narrow wooden wharf, is now in a
dilapidated and dangerous condition, but the United States has now
and prospectively so little use for it as not to warrant an estimate for
its repair or reconstruction, which would cost about $2,500.
                I
   For the eason that this wharf occupies the only site available for a
wharf inside the inner harbor of refuge, and outside this harbor the
shore is too much exposed to the sea for any other. the continuance of
its use by the inhabitants of the island is neceqsary, but as the case
now stands they consider that, being a Government wharf, they have
no right to repair it. I therefore recommend that the following pro-
vision be attached to the item for Block Island in the next river and
harbor bill:
  Provided, That the wharf on the land side of the inner harbor may be turned over
to the town of New Shoreham for the public use of said town, but no tolls or charges
shall ever be exacted fbr the use of said wharf by public vessels of the United States
or freight carried in such vessels.

    The location of this wharf may be seen in the plat published at page
413 of the Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1885.

WORK REQUIRED TO BE DONE TO COMPLETE                                    THE EXISTING PROJECT.

  The work required to be done to complete the existing project is the
completion of the filling of the gap to its fill height of 6 feet above
mean high water and its full width at top of 25 feet and the enlarge-
ment of the inner harbor of refuge.

OPERATIONS CONTEMPLATED FOR THE                                  FISCAL YEAR ENDING JUNE
                                                30, 1887.

  It is proposed to devote the small remainder on hand July 1, 1886,
and the appropriation made by the act of August 5, 1886, to carrying
on the filling of the gap in the main breakwater as far as the funds
provided for it will admit and to the commencement of the enlarge-
ment of the inner harbor.
  Block Island is in the Newport collection district, and Newport is the nearest port
of entry. There is no duty collected at the island. The value of the harbor is mainly
as a harbor of refuge. There are four lights at the island: the north and south lights *
and the breakwater lights. The nearest fortification is Fort Adams, Newport, R. I.

                                          Money statement.
July 1, 1885, amount available .........           .... ..........               .... ........ ....  $6, 074 91
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885- ......................                 -......................          .5,438 79

July 1, 1886, amount available .............. . ...-.... ...... .........
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886 ...                                ..............20, 636 12
                                                                                                        000 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887 ...................                         20,636 12

i Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project........                          50, 189 00
  Amount that.can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1888                      50, 189 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
     harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
                      APPENDIX C-REPORT                                        OF LIEUT.-COL. ELLIOT.                                              613
                                                    COMMERCIAL STATISTICS.

                                                                                       BLOCK ISLAND,                  R. I., June 30, 1886.
   SIR : In accordance with your request of the 17th instant, relative to the furnishing
you with amounts of merchandise received and exported from Block Island, and the
amount of vessels making use of our harbors, &c., for the year ending December 31,
1885; would respectfully make the following report, which is based upon the best in-
formation obtainable, and which I think is not far from correct:

Amount of merchandise received and exported from Block Island during the year ending
                                  December 31, 1885.


                                                                Articles.                                                                      Quantity.


Coal received.............                           ....................................                                    ..... tons..            5,000
Iron received................            ...          ........ ...............         ..........       .................            do...              200
Grain received . ....         ..................... . .............                               .....  ...........       .. bushels.              11, 000
Lumber received---...--......      ...............-----              .................                     ..         ....... ....  feet.       3, 500, 000
General merchandise, not incladed in the above, shipped and received............ tons.                                                              15, 000


                                                     Arrival and departure of vessels.

Steamers, from 50 to 1, 000 tons. ....   ..... ........ ........... ....... ......                                     .....    .... ......         1,850
Sailing vessels, from 10 to 200 tons, from 2 to 10 feet draught ............                                                   .............      112, 000

   These figures cover all vessels that make Block Island Bay Harbor.
   All of which is respectfully submitted.
                                                                                                                           NICHOLAS             BALL.
   Lieunt. Col. GEORGE H. ELLIOT,
                       Corps of Engineers, U. S. A.




                                                                          C 13.

IMPROVEMENT                        OF       LITTLE             NARRAGANSETT                          BAY, RHODE                      ISLAND AND
                                                               CONNECTICUT.

   Little Narragansett Bay. lies on the north side of the eastern entrance
from the ocean into Long Island Sound; Pawcatuck River, upon which
is situated the important commercial and manufacturing town of West-
erly, R. I., empties into the eastern side of the bay, and has been im-
proved by the United States. The object of the improvement of Little
Narragansett Bay was to deepen the approach from Long Island Sound
to Westerly.
   The mean rise and fall of the tide is 2.63 feet.

                                                       ORIGINAL CONDITION.

The navigable draught of water through the bay before improvement
was about 4( feet at mean low water.

                                                    PLAN OF IMPROVEMENT.

   The project of 1878 for the improvement of the bay provided for a
channel 200 feet wide and 71 feet deep at mean low water from the en-
trance to the bay to the mouth of the Pawcatuck, and the removal of
the bowlers which then obstructed navigation and any others which
the excavation of the channel might develop. Subsequently, it was de-
termined to clear away sonme large bowlders which interfered with steam-
614         REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

boat navigation between this channel and Watch Hill Landing. The
estimated cost of the improvement was $51,000.
  A plat of Little Narragansett Bay, showing the improved channel,
was published in the Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1879,
page 314.
                             AMOUNT EXPENDED                         AND RESULTS.

   The. project was completed in the fiscal year 1883-'84. The main
channel as projected was excavated to its full width and depth, and
many bowlders were removed from the Watch Hill Channel. Vessels
drawing 10 feet of water can now reach the mouth of the Pawcatuck
River at high water, but the full benefit of the improvement cannot be
utilized until further deepening of that river to enable vessels of the
same draught to reach Westerly.
   A report on the further improvementof the Pawcatuck was submitted
September 19, 1884, in compliance with the river and harbor act of Con-
gress of July 5, 1881, which was printed as House Ex. Doc. No. 153,
Forty eighth Congress, second session, and is also contained in the Re-
port of the Chief of Engineers for 1885, Vol. 1, page 623.
   The remainder of the last appropriation for Little Narragansett Bay
is reserved for comparative surveys of Sandy Point, at the entrance to
the bay, which seems to be affected by the construction of the break-
water in Stonington Harbor, and for range-marks on Pawcatuck Point
to guide through the new channel. The total cost of the completed
improvement was $35,856.96.
  Little Narragansett Bay is in the collection (listrict of Providence and Stonington,
the dividiing line passing through the bay. Providence and S onington are the near-
est ports of entry. The revenue collected in the last fiscal year was: Providence,
$10,933; Stonington, $1,7:15.69. The nearest light-houses are the Stonington and
Wati-h Hill lights. "'Thenearest fortification is Fort Trumull, New London, Conn.

                                              Money statement.
July 1, 185, amount availale               .....     ..........          --......      -----..................   $143   04
July 1, 1886, amount available---......---....-......------------......----......-----....--..........            143 04




                                                         C 14.
               HARBOR OF REFUGE AT STONINGTON, CONNECTICUT.
  Stonington Harbor lies on the north side of the eastern entrance from
the ocean into Long Island Sound, and the main object of the improve-
ment is to furnish a harbor of refuge for vessels entering and leaving
this entrance to the sounld. The mean rise and fall of the tide is about
24 feet.
                                         ORIGINAL                 CONDITION.

  Originally it was an open bay, unprotected from southerly storms,
and obstructed by a shoal having a low-water depth of but 6 feet at the
shoalest part. This shoal nearly filled the inner harbor, and left but a
narrow channel on either side of a depth insufficient to permit vessels
of 12 feet draught to reach the upper wharves at low water.
                                        PLANS        OF THE WORK.

  A short breakwater was constructed in the years 1828-'31, at a cost
of $34,766.65 for the protection of the commerce of the town of Stoning-
          APPENDIX    C-REPORT OF LIEUT.-COL. ELLIOT.                 615
ton. The enlarged project of 1871 for the improvement of Stonington
Harbor and its subsequent modification, under which work is now car-
ried on, embraced dredging in the upper harbor and the construction
of two breakwaters in the outer harbor. One of these, the western, was
to be built out from Wanmphassuck Point, the southwestern limit of the
harbor, and to extend about 2,000 feet; and the other, the eastern, was
to extend from the vicinity, of Bartlett's Reef to the Middle Ground.
The western breakwater was completed in 1880, at a cost of $103,190.
The amount expended in dredging in the upper harbor was about
$45,000. The position of the western end of the eastern breakwater has
not been determined, but it will probably be found necessary, in order
to afford all the protection desired, to extend the breakwater at least
until it intersects a range from Stonington Light to the middle of Wico-
pessit Island. It may then be found desirable to carry it still further,
possibly to the range from Stonington Light to the eastern end of
Fisher's Island.
   A plat of this harbor, showing the position of the breakwaters, was
published in the Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1884, page
632.
          AMOUNT EXPENDED AND RESULTS TO JUNE 30, 1885.

  The amount expended upon the eastern breakwater up to the close
of the fiscal year ending June 30, 1885, including liabilities outstanding
at that (late, was $89,575.98, and its length at that date was 1,850 feet.

            OPERATIONS DURING       THE LAST FISCAL     YEAR.

  For want of funds no work has been in progress during the last fiscal
year.
WORK REQUIRED TO BE DONE TO COMPLETE            THE EXISTING PROJECT.

   The work required to be done is to finish the construction of the
eastern breakwater. In case it be found that sufficient protection to
the harbor of refuge has been afforded when the range from Stonington
Light to the middle of Wicopessit Island is reached, which will proba-
bly be the case, the length of breakwater yet to be built is about 720
feet.
   By reason of the great danger to the large passenger steamers of the
Stonington Line (New York and Boston), which the western end of the
breakwater now is, especially in foggy and thick weather, and will be un-
til it is completed and a light-house and fog-signal are erected upon it,
it is very desirable that the whole amount necessary to finish the break-
water be granted in one appropriation.
   The completion of this work will afford a thoroughly protected an-
chorage for vessels drawing 18 feet of water, and a harbor of refuge for
the immense commerce which daily passes between Long Island Sound
and the eastward.

OPERATIONS    CONTEMPLATED       FOR THE     FISCAL YEAR   ENDING JUNE
                                 30, 1887.

   It is prop)osed to devote the small remainder on hand July 1, 1886,
and the appropriation made by the act of August 5, 1886, to the exten-
sion of the east breakwater as far as the funds will allow.
616       REPORT OF THE            CHIEF      OF ENGINEERS,           U. S. ARMY.

  Stonington Harbor is in the Stonington collection district, and is a port of entry.
The amount of revenue collected in the last fiscal year was $1,735.69.   The principal
value of the harbor is as a harbor of refuge. The nearest lights are Stonington Light
and Latimer's Reef Light. The nearest fortification is Fort Trumbull, New London
Harbor, Connecticut.
                                    Money statement.
July 1, 1885, amount available.................... .............. ......                 $424 02
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885...----------
                                   ------ -----   - ---.. -- -----      --.
                                                                   ----...                123 70

July 1, 1886, amount available-----..................--.....-----..................
                                                                           --              300 32
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886.... ..............                  20, 00 C00

Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887 ......-....- -....        ... 20,300 32

  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project... _...  -            33, 000 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1888           33,000 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.


                                 COMMERCIAL      STATISTICS.

                                             CUSTOM-HOUSE,        STONINGTON, CONN.,
                                                      Collector's Ofice, July 1, 1886.
  SIR: In reply to your favor of June 17, I herewith respectfully furnish commercial
statistics for this port:
Number of vessels entering from foreign ports ........ -..- ....  ...-.                          6
Number of vessels cleared for foreign ports.-.........-..............                            6
Value of merchandise imported ............. ......---.....            .                $4,
                                                                                       $--- 877 30
Value of merchandise exported.-       -            -..-..."_....
                                                   ----            -.                      $100 00
Amount duties collected .-----...........................................                $968 81
M iscellaneous ......................................................                 $766 88
Entrance and clearance steamers. ........       .........................                   650
Estimated value cargoes coastwise received .----.........  ........--...---.. $34, 900, 000 00
Estimated value cargoes coastwise shipped...-                    .... ...... $33, 100, 000 00
                                                     ....--..-....
Value product fisheries...-.......... ..................... ........              $135,000 08
Number vessels seeking harbor for refuge ....................           .. ..            2, 100
Number of vessels registered in district ......         -......-..............              105
Tonnage ...------------------------------......             ------
                                                  --..-----....       tons..         6,448.15
Estimated tonnage of freight received and forwarded from wharf of
Stoningtou Steamboat Company for year ending June 30, 1886..tons..                    600, 000
       Very respectfully,
                                                                    H. N. TRUMBULL,
                                                                                      Collector
  George H. ELLIOT,
     Lientenant Colonel of Engineers, U. S. A.




                                            C I5.

IMPROVEMENT OF PAWCATUCK                    RIVER, RHODE ISLAND AND CONNEC-
                                           TICUT'.

   The navigable part of Pawcatuck River extends from the important
manufacturing town of Westerly to Little Narragansett Bay, into which
it empties. The approach to the river is through Stonington outer
harbor and Little Narragansett Bay, and the object of the improve-
ment is to deepen the river channel to the depth to which the channel
through the bay has been dredged by the United Stetes, and also to
widen it.
   The mean rise and fall of the tide is 2,0 feet at the mouth of the
river, and 2--o feet at Westerly.
            APPENDIX C--REPORT             OF LIEUT.-COL. ELLIOT.                     61T
                              ORIGINAL CONDITION.

Before improvement the channel was crooked and obstructed by nu-
merous shoals, on some of which there was but 14 feet at mean low
water.
                           PLANS OF IMPROVEMENT.

  By means of appropriations made in the years 1871-'75, the river was
improved by the United States by the excavation of a channel 5- feet
deep at mean low water and 75 feet wide below the wharves, and from
35 to 40 feet wide between the lower and the upper wharves. My re-
port of a resurvey of the river made in compliance with the river and
harbor act of July 5, 1881, which was accompanied by a plat and an
estimate of cost ($38,637.50), and was published in the Report of the
Chief of Engineers for 1885, Vol. I,, pages 623-625, recommended the
further widening of the channel to 100 feet below the wharves and by
an additional width of two cuts of an ordinary dredging-machine, or
about 40 feet, between the lower and the upper wharves ; also the deep-
ening of the entire channel to 8 feet at mean low water.
  The commencement of this work has been approved by Congress.
making an appropriation of $12,000 therefor in the river and harbor
act of August 5, 1886.
         AMOUNT EXPENDED AND RESULTS TO JUNE 30,                          1885.
  The amount expended on the original project was $50,000, and it was
completed.
OPERATIONS       CONTEMPLATED         FOR THE        FISCAL YEAR        ENDING JUNE
                                       30, 1887.
  It is proposed to commence the work of widening and deepening the
channel according to the enlarged project at the deep water near Lot-
tery, and to carry it as far towards Westerly as the funds will admit,
and also to afford such relief as the commerce of the river may require
at the shoalest places in advance of the main work.
  Pawcatuck River is in the collection districts of Providence and Stonington, the
dividing line passing through the river. Providence and Stonington are the nearest
ports of entry. The revenue collected in the last fiscal year was: Providence, $180,-
933; Stonington, $1,735.69. The nearest light-houses are the Stonington and Watch
Hill lights. The nearest fortification is Fort Trumbull, New London, Conn.

                                  Money statement.
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886................--..         $12, 000 00.


  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1888      26, 637 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.


                               COMMERCIAL     STATISTICS.

                                                WESTERLY, R. I., June 28, 1886.
  DEAR SIR: I   inclose statement of commerce, &c., on our river, furnished me by
Captain Greenman, a reliable gentleman. I regret that I have not time to put the
matter in better shape.
      Yors, respectfnully,
                                                          CHARLES PERRIN,
                                                   Secretary Business Men's Association.
  Colonel ELLIOT.
618          REPORT           OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                                    U. S. ARMY.

-STATEMENT OF BUSINESS DONE ON THE PAWCATUCK                                   RIVER DURING THE YEAR                    1885.

Coal brought, all in sail vessels .-...-.......                       ......          ......         ..... tons..       18, 373
Iron brought, all in sail vessels...... .... ......                              ..... .....        --...... do...          650
Grain ...............................................                               ...........         bushels..       44,400
Lumber--...-----...... --....-------------........-------
                                                       .....---..-----...-----...................----.       feet.. 3, 972, 017
Bricks.-----------------------......                  -- -----..                 ....--.-------------------.           351,000
Sand............-------......----......---....................                 .........        ..... tons..              695
Stone out of river-------..----.......------------------.....----.....------..........do...                            4,575
   Vessels towed and sailed in and out with full cargoes, 203, drawing from 5 to 71
feet of water, which is the extreme draught, except at high spring tides. Thirty-one
vessels arriving in Stonington with lumber, drawing from 8 to 11 feet, which cargoes
had to be taken in scows to Westerly.
  Passengers by steamer Westerly under my command, 4,050.
  Steamer Sadie, running between Westerly and Watch Hill, making from two to
four trips daily for three months.
  Steamer Julia runs between Westerly and Norwich, one trip daily, for three months.
The passengers I have no means of ascertaining the number.
                                                                                           WILLIAM GREENMAN.




                                                           C i6.
REMOVING SUNKEN VESSELS OR CRAFT OBSTRUCTING OR ENDANGER-
                      ING NAVIGATION.

   Wreck of iron steamship Perkiomen, sunk by collision in the Atlantic
Ocean, off Cape Cod, July 16, 1885. By direction of the Department I
made report on this wreck September 4, 1885. The legal notice to all
persons interested that if the wreck should not be removed within thirty
days it would be pronounced derelict and be removed by the United
States was published in newspapers, and personal notice was also
sent by mail to the several owners of the vessel and cargo. On the 21st
September advertisements were issued for poposals to remove the wreck,
and copies were also sent by mail to all wreckers and contractors for
removing sunken vessels the addresses of whom could be discovered.
The proposals received and the terms of the contract with Mr. William
E. Chapman, of Brooklyn, N. Y., the lowest bidder, will be found in
the appended table.
   The preparatory work of placing mooring-buoys was commenced No-
vember 5, but the work of blasting the wreck was not begun until the
18th of the month. By reason of storms and high waves at the site of
the wreck, which was on the edge of Nantucket Shoals, about 3 miles
northeast from Pollock Rip light-ship, and of strong currents endan-
gering the lives of the submarine divers, it was found that on an aver-
age but about one day in six was it practicable to carry on the work of
blasting the wreck. After three extensions of ten, ten, and thirty
days, respectively, the wreck was finally removed to the required depth
of 35 feet below mean low water on the 13th of January, 1886.
   The specifications for the contract required the contractor to save,
during the removal of the wreck to the depth required, all parts of the
wreck, her cargo, &c., that in the judgment of the inspector in charge
of the work were valuable, and, considering the state of the weather
and of the sea, could be saved. The winter of 1885-'86 was an excep-
tionally severe one off Cape Cod, and the weather proving so unfavora-
ble for work at the' site of the wreck, the judgment of the inspector
under the circumstances was that nothing of value other than the two
heavy anchors and a portion of the chain could be saved from the wreck
-during the time provided in the contract, except with the certainty of
             APPENDIX        C-REPORT          OF   LIEUT.-COL.       ELLIOT.            619
an unwarrantable'delay in the removal of the wreck itself. When the
full depth required by the contract had been attained the saving of the
anchors and the portion of the chain judged recoverable not having been
done, as directed, it was insisted on, and after waiting at Hyannis with
steamer    and appliances for the work for several days for suitable
weather, the contractor asked permission to be relieved from the ex-
pense of further attempts at their recovery, and instead to be allowed
to pay their estimated value by having it deducted from the contract
price. This was approved by the Department. and $422.50, the esti-
mated value of the anchors and the portion of the chain judged by
the inspector to be recoverable, and $105, the expense to the United
States for local superintendent, &c., from the time for completion of the
work as provided in the contract until its actual completion, were de-
ducted from the contract price. Mr. Hiram W. Phillips was local in-
spector for the removal of the wreck.
Amount of contract----...-----...-......-----.......------....-......-----.....--.....            $7,480 00
                                                 .------......------------..--...--.........----- 6,952 50
Amount paid to contractor .------..--..............
Surveys, salary of inspector, advertising, and other expenses connected with
  the wreck ....---------------------.....................----..----.....------------..              766 67

   Wreck of schooner Almon Bacon, sunk in the Atlantic Ocean, off Point
Judith, R. I., November 5, 1885.       By direction of the Department I
made a report on this wreck on the9th November, 1885. The thirty days'
notice to all persons interested required by law was published under
ldate of November 18, and personal notice was also sent by mail to the
owners andl underwriters. The masts were taken out of the vessel De-
ember 11, at t he instance of the owners, by a wrecking schooner, assisted
by the United States revenue cutter Dexter, and all danger to naviga-
tion was thereby removed.
Amount expended for advertising---------------------..-------........----             $6 75
                                                                                --....--..-..

   Wreck of schooners Mott Haven and Willie De Wolf, sunk by collision
in the Atlantic Ocean, off the entrance to Narragansett Bay, December
25, 1885. By direction of the Department report was made of these
wrecks December 29, but no action by the War Department became
necessary. The Willie De Wolf drifted to the shore of Block Island at
Clay Head, where it did not endanger passing vessels, and the masts
of the Mott Haven were taken out at the instance of the owners by a
wrecking schooner, assisted by the United States revenue cutter Dex-
ter, on the 30th December, removing all danger to navigation.
Amount expended for telegrams ---...----....
                                      ----....--..--
                                                 ----....----........-----....          $0 99

   In concluding this part of my annual report which refers to the re-
moval of obstructions to navigation, I desire earnestly to invite atten-
tion to certain disadvantages to the interests of the United States in
the present laws on the subject. Section 4 of the river and harbor act
of June 14, 1880, reads as follows:
  Whenever hereafter the navigation of any river, lake, harbor, or bay, or other nav-
igable water of the United States shall be obstructed or endangered by any sunken
vessel or water-craft, it shall be the duty of the Secretary of War, upon satisfactory
information thereof, to cause reasonable notice, of not less than thirty days, to be
given, personally or by publication, at least once a week, in the newspaper published
nearest the locality of such sunken vessel or craft, to all persons interested in such
vessel or craft or in the cargo thereof, of the purpose of said Secretary, unless such vessel
or craft shall be removed as soon thereafter as practicable by the parties interested
therein, to cause the same to be removed. If such sunken vessel or craft and cargo
shall not be removed by the parties interested therein as soon as practicable after
the date of the giving of such notice by publication, or after such personal service
620      REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

of notice, as the case may be, such sunken vessel or craft shall be treated as aban-
doned and derelict, and the Secretary of War shall proceed to remove the same.
Such sunken vessel or craft and cargo and all property therein when so removed
shall, after reasonable notice of the time and place of sale, be sold to the highest
bidder or bidders for cash, and the proceeds of such sales shall be deposited in the
Treasury of the United States to the credit of a fund for the removal of such obstruc-
tions to navigation, under the direction of the Secretary of War, and to be paid out
for that purpose on his requisition therefor. The provisions of this act shall apply to
all such wrecks whether removed under this act or under any other act of Congress.;
Such sum of money as may be necessary to execute this section of this act is hereby
appropriated, out of any money in the Treasury of the United States not otherwise
appropriated, to be paid out on the requisition of the Secretary of War.
  In the river and harbor act of August 2, 1882,it was provided-
  That the power and authority granted to the Secretary of War under and by vir-
tue of section 4 of the act of Congress approved June 14, 1880, relating to wrecks and
sunken vessels, he and the same are hereby enlarged so that the Secretary of War
may, in his discretion, sell and dispose of any such sunken craft, vessel, or cargo, or
property therein, before the raising or removal thereof, according to the same regu-
lations that are in the same act prescribed for 1he sale of the same after the removal
thereof; and all laws and parts of laws inconsistent herewith are hereby repealed.
   The first of the above acts provides for the removal of the wreck at
the expense of the United States and its sale after removal, but by rea-
son of the depth of water at the site of the wreck, it is often the case
that only a portion of the wreck, perhaps the masts, or the masts and
upper works, are dangerous to p)assing vessels, and it is not necessary,
in order to provide for safe navigation, to remove the entire wreck. In
other cases, after a wreck has laid submerged during the length of time
the law requires before it can be considered abandoned by its owners
and pronounced derelict, the wrecked property is not worth the expense
of raising and saving it. This is by reason of the time required, and
the cost of the vessels and machinery and the hire of submarine divers
engaged in the business of wrecking.
   These considerations, among others, doubtless led to the law of 1882,
which authorizes the sale of the wreck before removal; but for the rea-
son just mentioned, that the abandoned wreck is not worth the cost of
removal (else it would not be left derelict by the owners), the removal
must still, in some way, be at the expense of the United States.
   It is possible that the latter law contemplated the combining in one
contract both the removal and the sale of the wreck; that is, that the con-
tractor for the removal should take the wreck, or what he can save of
it, in part payment for his work; but it has been considered that neither
of the laws referred to, or both together, warrant a departure from the
general laws governing public contracts and sales. Under these laws the
removal must be done by the lowest bidder and the sale must be made to
the highest bidder, and the removal and the sale must be separately
provided for. In other words, the law of 1882 not being practical, it
h, s been decided that the removal of a wreck and the saving of what
can be saved must be done under a separate contract, and that the sale
of the saved property must be made aj'ttr removal, as provided in the
law of 1880.
   Specifications for removing wrecks now require, therefore, that the
contractor shall raise and save the entire wreck, or specified parts of
the wreck, or, as it is often impossible to decide beforehand what can
be saved, sometimes he is required to save all of the parts of the wreck
that in the judgment of the United States inspector in charge of the re-
moval of the wreck are valuable and (considering the state of the
weather and of the sea at the time) can be saved.
            APPENDIX      C--REPORT OF LIEUT.-COL. ELLIOT.                       621
   But the uncertainties and delays in the work of removal of wrecks by
efforts to save property, and the dangers and expenses attending the
business of wrecking are so great, that any requirement, however slight,
for saving property in the contract for removal of a wreck adds enor-
mously to the cost of the removal and out of all proportion to the
value of the property saved; and rather than to include in the contract
any requirement to save anything whatever, it would often be cheaper
and better for the public interests to cointract simply to destroy the
vessel by blasting it by dynamite or other explosives down to the re-
quired depth, leaving the debris scattered over the bottom of the sea.
   Still there is in almost every wrecked and abandoned vessel some-
thing of value that can probably be saved-it may be only the masts
and rigging or the anchors and chain-and the United States should in
some way get the value of it, to offset in part and as much as possible
the cost of removing the wreck.
   What can be saved depends          "o
                                    much on the state of the weather and
of the sea and on the judgment of how much of danger the vessels and
other plant of the contractor and the lives of his divers and other work-
men shall be subjected to at different stages of the removal of the wreck,
that no one will buy what the winds and the waves may enable another
person with diverse interests (the contractor for the removal of the
danger to navigation) to raise and save.
   It is evident, therefore, since it costs in many cases more than it
comes to for the United States to save wrecked property for the pur-
pose of selling it after removal, that the sale should be made before re-
moval, as contemplated in the act of 1882, and that that law should be
enlarged so that the contractor for the removal of the wreck, or so much
of it as may be necessary, may be required to purchase beforehand what-
ever there may be of value'that he can save without delaying the re-
moval beyond the contract time. The difficulty in this case is to pro-
vide for competition for the purchase as well as for the removal.
   This can only be done by providing in the specifications for the removal
that whatever he can save shall belong to the contractor for the removal.
The bidders for the removal would then reduce their competitive bids
by the value of what can be saved, or rather by the value of what they
think they can save, and the bidders for this kind of work (professional
wreckers) are the best judges of what can be saved, and what its value
when saved is likely to be.
   It would not be safe, however, to vest the complete ownership in
property saved under such a contract in the contractor until he had
finally and completely removed all parts of the wreck that are above
the depth required for safe navigation, depending on the locality of the
wreck; and until the completion of his contract and the acceptance of
his work he should be required to store the property as public property
at some designated place on shore.
   In consideration of the foregoing I beg leave to suggest that the
following provision be inserted in the next river and harbor bill:
  The power and authqrity granted to the Secretary of War by section 4 of the act
of Congress approved June 14, 1880, relating to wrecks and sunken vessels, enlarged
by the act of August 2, 1882, are hereby further enlarged, so that in any case of the
removal under contract, after due public notice, of any abandoned and derelict ves-
sel, or portion of such vessel, obstructing any of the navigable waters of the United
States, the conditions of such notice and contract may, if the public interests will
be subserved thereby, include the stipulation that any parts of such vessel, her cargo,
and other property therein, that he can save shall become the property of the con-
622        REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

tractor: Provided, That the ownership of such saved parts shall not be vested in the
contractor until he has fully completed the removal of the obstruction and'afl other
duties under his contract according to the terms and conditions of the contract.

Abstract of proposals for removing wreck of steamship Perkionen, received in response to.
  advertisement dated September 21, 1885, and opened at Engineer Ofice, United States
  Army, Newport, R. I., at 12 o'clock noon on Thursday, October 23,1885.


No.          Name and address of bidder.              Price.                  Remarks.


1     William E. Chapman, Brooklyn, N. Y........     $7, 480 00     Work to be commenced within ten
2     Adoniram Fairchild, West Stratford, Conn....    9, 500 00   days from signing of contract, andto
3     Atlantic and GnuhWrecking Company, Somers       9, 900 00   be completed within forty days (not
       Point, N. J.                                               including Sundays) from day of com-
                                                                  mencement.



  With the approval of the Chief of Engineers, the contract was awarded to William
E. Chapnman, of Brooklyn, N. Y., the lowest bidder, at $7,480. Date of contract,
November 4, 1885.
                                 APPENDIX D.



IMPROVEMENT OF CONNECTICUT RIVER, MASSACHUSETTS AND CON-
  NECTICUT, AND OF RIVERS AND HARBORS ON LONG ISLAND SOUND.
  CONNECTICUT AND NEW YORK.




REPORT OF LIEUTENANT-COLONEL D. C. HOUSTON, CORPS OF E17GT-
NEERS, OFFICER IN CHARGE, FOR THE FISCAL YEAR ENDING JUNE
30, 1886, WITH OTHER DOCUMIENTS RELATING TO THE WORKS.

                                  IMPROVEMENTS.

1.   Connecticut River, Massachusetts and   11.   Southport Harbor, Connecticut.
        Connecticut.                         12.   Norwalk Harbor, Connecticut.
2.   Thames River, Connecticut.             13.   Port Chester Harbor, New York.
3.   New London Harbor, Connecticut.        14.   New Rochelle Harbor, New York.
4.   Clinton Harbor, Connecticut.           15.   Echo Harbor, New Rochelle, New
5.   New Haven Harbor, Connecticut.                 York.
6.   Breakwater at New Haven, Connecti-     16.   Mamaroneck Harbor, New York.
         cut.                                17.   Greenport Harbor, New York.
7.   Milford Harbor, Connecticut.           18.   Port Jefferson Harbor, New York.
8.   Housatonic River, Connecticut.         19.   Flushing Bay, New York.
9    Bridgeport Harbor, Connecticut.        20.   East Chester Creek, New York.
10.   Black Rock Harbor, Connecticut.




                                UNITED       STATES ENGINEER OFFICE,
                                            New York, July 30, 1886.
  GENERAL: I have the honor to transmit herewith my annual reports
upon river and harbor works in my charge for the fiscal year ending
June 30, 1886.
      Very respectfully, your obedient servant,
                                                             D.   U.   HOUSTON,
                                                        Lieut. Col. of Engineers.
      Brig. Gen. JOHN NEWTON,
          Chief of Engineers, U. S. A.



                                         D   I.

IMPROVEMENT          OF THE     CONNECTICUT RIVER, MASSACHUSETTS                  AND
                                  CONNECTICUT.

  This river rises in the northern part of New Hampshire, flows in a
general southerly course between the States of New Hampshire and
Vermont, crossing the States of Massachusetts and Connecticut, and
                                                                            623
'6~4       REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

empties into Long Island Sound at Saybrook Point, Connecticut. It is
divided naturally into two parts, Hartford, at the head of navigation,
being the point of division, and appropriations by Congress have always
specified in which parts of the river the money was to be expended.
  The divisions are as follows:
  1. Above Hartford, Connecticut.-Embracing a length of about 66
miles, from Hartford, Conn., to Miller's Falls, Mass.
  2. Below Hartford, Connecticut.-Embracing a length of about 50
miles, from Hartford to Long Island Sound.

                        (I)      ABOVE      HARTFORD, CONNECTICUT.

  Miller's Falls, Mass., is at the head of possible navigation of the Con-
necticut River. From this point down to Holyoke, Mass., a distance of
about 32 miles, the river is susceptible of improvement, but it cannbt
be used now on account of a dam and falls at Holyoke, which entirely
obstruct navigation. The lockage required to lift boats from the lower
to the upper levels at Holyoke is abou t 60 feet. From Holyoke, Mass.,
to Enfield Falls, Conn., a distance of 18 miles, there is a fair channel of
4 to 5 feet depth at low water, which could be made 8 feet deep. Enfield
Fall's, or Rapids, cover a stretch of river about 5 miles long, having a
fall of about 32 feet at low water. The bed is rocky and very uneven,
and the slope not uniform, but consisting of a succession of long, shal-
low reaches, separated by rapids. From the foot of Enfield Falls to
Hartford, a distance of 11 miles, the river has a broad, sandy bed, with
a depth of 3 to 4 feet at low water. Under a charter from the State of
Connecticut, granted in May, 1824, the Connecticut River Company has
constructed a canal with locks around Enfield Falls; the locks are 80
feet long, 18 feet wide, and 44 feet deep. The canal is chiefly used for
water-power; the company collects toll from vessels using it.
  Following is a list of the places where work has been done by the
United States, with distances above the wagon bridge at Hartford :
                                                                                                                                             Miles.
Barber's Landing       .............   .......................                                                  ".....................           4
Farmington River ...... ..........................                                       ........              ....     ..    ....... ....       5
Strong'sIsland....................            ...............                        ............................                            .   6
cantic River ....................                  .. ----.....   ......   ......----      ........              .......     ..... .... -       7


                                 PROJECTS FOR IMPROVEMENT.

   In 1871 a project was approved ' for giving an increased depth to the
channel by the construction of wing-dams and by dredging." All the
work done in this part of the river has been done under this project;
it consists of dredging at Barber's Landing, and constructing wing-
dams at Barber's Landing, Farmington River, Strong's Island, and Scan-
tic River, at different times from 1871 to 1881. In 1878 a project for
constructing a larger canal around Enfield Falls was submitted. and
modified in 1880. (See Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1881,
Part I, page 566.) It provides for a canal around Enfield Falls, on the
east bank of the river, extending down to the mouth of the Hockanum
River, opposite Hartford. The levels were to be 10 feet deep at low
water and 120 feet wide at the water line; the locks to be 200 feet long,
55 feet wide, and 8 feet deep over the miter-sills at low water. The
esitmated cost of this work was $1,322,805, but it was considered not
advisable to begin construction with a less sum than $450,000.
                  APPENDIX            D-REPORT                 OF     LIEUT.-COL.              HOUSTON.                          625
    OPERATIONS DURING THE FISCAL YEAR ENDING JUNE                                                                  30, 1886.

  The available funds were not sufficient to begin work under the pro-
ject and nothing was done.
                            PRESENT CONDITION                        OF IMPROVEMENT.

   It is reported that the current has cut behind one of the wing-dams
at Farmington River; the other dams are in fair condition. The avail-
able depth from Hartford up to Scantic River, as far up as any improve-
ment has been made, is about 3 feet at ordinary summer stage of the
river.
                                           PROPOSED OPERATIONS.

   Such work as may be required for the repair and maintenance of the
wing-dams and of the existing channel will be made with funds now
available. No other work is contemplated, unless an appropriation
sufficient to begin the canal around Enfield Falls is made; $450,000
would be required for this.
   Appropriations for improving the Connecticut River above Hartford,
Conn., have been made as follows, viz:

     Date.                                                  Application.                                                      Amount.


July 11, 1870                                                                                                             (     $20, 000
MJunear.3, 1871       ams at Scantic River, Strong's Island, Farmington River, and Barber'sI                                     20, 000
une 1                Landing; dredging at Barber's Landing, and surveys.                                                        20, 000
June 14, 1880     J                                                                                                              15, 000

                         Total..................                             ....................---------------......          100, 000


    Of these amounts the following balances are yet unexpended:
From appropriation of June 10o,1872, for "improving the Connecticut River
   on or above Eufield Falls"--                           ...........-------------
                                              ....---....---....                   --------------....
                                                                             ....---........                             $10,   702 92
From appropriation of June 14, 1880, for " improving the Connecticut River
   between Hartford and Holyoke" ................................. .                                                      13,410 80


                                              COMMERCIAL STATISTICS.
  The commerce of the river above Hartford is not large, on account of the inmpossi-
bility of navigating it, except with very small boats. When the water is high a good
deal of freight is sent this way which at other times goes by rail. Were the river
improved as proposed, this traffic would be very large, as the greater part of the heavy
freight used in and near the manufacturing towns of Springfield, Holyoke, Chicopee,
and Miller's Falls would be brought by water.

                                                  Money statement.
July 1, 1885, amount available.------------..........----....--...------..                 ............--$24, 372 72
                                                                                       ---...--..
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  ouitstanding July 1, 1885............ ..................................                                                      259 00
July 1, 1886, amount available...........................................                                                 24, 113 72



                             (2)    BELOW HARTFORD, CONNECTICUT.

    The Connecticut River below Hartford is a large stream, for the first
21 miles flowing in a winding course, for the most part through alluvial
meadows, which are overflowed at high water, and which consist of a
             40 E
626           REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                                                                             U. S. ARMY.

light sandy soil, easily undermined. For the remaining 29 miles, to
Long Island Sound, at Saybrook Point, the course is straighter, the
banks more permanent and generally harder.
   A gauge has been established at Hartford, whose zero is the lowest
stage that the water is known to have reached. The usual low-water
stage of the river in summer is about 1 foot on this gauge. Spring
freshets ordinarily rise to 20 feet; the highest recorded stage of water
is 29 feet.
   The average tide at Saybrook is 31 feet; at Hartford it is about 1
foot, though when the river stands above 5 feet on the H artford gauge
the tide there is not perceptible. The slope of the river from Hartford
to Saybrook averages .0458 feet per mile. The bed of the river, through
the alluvial meadows, within 10 miles of Hartford, is constantly chang-
ing from the undermining of the banks; it is said that in places it has
changed its position a half a mile within the memory of man. The
bars in this part of the river, after being dredged, form again during
spring freshets and ice-jams, so that some of them require annual dredg-
ing, others less frequently. This part of the river was improved by
corporations and private parties at various times between 1800 and
1870; several small piers, to deepen the water in shoal places, were
built in this way; some of these are now covered by new banks; the
channel has shifted to the opposite side of some, and others have been
dredged out, because they had come to be obstacles. The depth sought
by these works was 6 feet at low water.
   The following list gives the names of the several bars whew work by
the United States has been done, with their distance, by course of
channel, below the Hartford Wagon Bridge.

                         Locality.                                Miles.                                         Locality.                                   Miles.


Hartford Bar ..-.........................   14 Dividend Bar....-..... ..........        ......                                                                   12
Clay Banks Bar-..... ..............--------...
                                            2  Pistol Point Bar.. ..--..... .......-....                                                                         15
Pratt's Ferry or Naubuc Bar .............   54                       --
                                               Mouse Island Bar ...............    ..            ..                                                              20k
Press Barn Barnr .......................... 6  Chester Rock....- -......- -.....--         ....-                                                                 38
Glastonbury Bar..........................   9  Saybrook Bar (at mouth) ----.          ~.-----...-.                                                               50



                                           PROJECTS FOR IMPROVEMENT.

   The first project for improvement by the United States was made in
1867; it proposed securing a channel 200 feet wide and 8 feet deep at
low water, from Hartford to Long Island Sound, by dredging the bars,
protecting the banks, and deepening the channel across Saybrook Bar,
at an estimated cost of $64,310. Work was carried on under this pro-
ject until 1879, the cost being largely increased by repeated dredging
of the same bars, when an amended scheme was submitted by Lieut. Col.
G. K. Warren, Corps of Engineers. (See Annual Report of Chief of
Engineers for 1880, Part 1, pages 396-422.) This scheme contemplated
securing a channel 200 feet wide and 9 feet deep at low water by means
of riprap wing-dams, and mattress work on the concave banks, at a cost
estimated as follows:
                                                  .--.....------............................-----------.
Hartford Bar..--..-------- ------............-----..---                                                                                                     $33, 464
Clay Banks Bar...........-    ...............         ....... ...........               .............                                                        69,116
Pratt's Ferry or Naubuc Bar..........---------....----......----......--..---......------.... -----....                                                      64, 735
Press Barn Bar...........-                      .........               ..        ................                 ......        ..........        .    .    41, 140
Glastoubury Bar              ...........               ........     .......................                                 ........          ......        114, 92"2
Dividend Bar .........                           ........ .............                              .........         ...............                        7, 110
         Total........                .......      ......     .......        .... .      .....          ....     ..... ......          .       ......   . 330, 487
               APPENDIX            D-REPORT                   OF        LIEUT.-COL. HOUSTON.                            627

   The estimate did not provide for improvement of Pistol Point and.
Mouse Island bars, where dredging has since been needed, nor for the-
extension of the Saybrook jetties and dredging between them, which
has since been found necessary; nor did it include any amount for the-
annual dredging which has consumed a large part of the appropriations.
made since. It is evident, therefore, that the contemplated works could.
not be completed with the balance of the estimate.
   Under this project, extended to include the necessary work at Say-
brook by the close of the last fiscal year, a training wall of riprap
3,698 feet long had been built at Hartford Bar, and a wing-dam at
Glastonbury Bar 5,300 feet long, both to 3 feet above low water; the-
east jetty at Saybrook had been extended to the 12-foot curve, and the-
west jetty nearly to the 16-foot curve, and a channel 120 feet wide and.
12 feet deep at mean low water had been dredged between them, be-
sides maintaining the required depth in the upper part of the river be-
low Hartford, by annual dredging, at a cost of from $5,000 to $10,000>
each year. One hundred and thirty-five thousand dollars have been ap-
propriated for this part of the river since the project was approved, in-
cluding $5,000 ordered by the appropriation act to be expended in
dredging in Salmon River, a tributary 20 miles below Hartford. Of
this amount only $73,000 have been applied to that part of the improve-
ment provided for in the partial estimate of $330,487.

   OPERATIONS              DURING THE FISCAL YEAR ENDING JUNE 30, 1886:

   The west jetty at Saybrook was extended to the 16-foot curve--work
done by hired labor under ]etter of authority from the Chief of Engi-
neers, dated October 25, 1884; 1,542 tons of stone were delivered, build-
ing about 90 feet of the work. The total extension built under this-
authority is 320 feet, requiring 10,382 tons of stone, costing $1.16 per-
ton. A small gap in the west jetty was closed by the use of 40 addi-
tional tons of stone. Work was completed in September, 1885.
   The dredging which was in progress at the beginning of the fiscal
year, under an agreement with C. C. Goodrich, to dredge on the bars as-
required, at 10 cents per cubic yard, was completed July 15, 1885.
   The amounts of material dredged during July were as follows:
                                                                                                                Cubic yards.
At Press Barn Bar ............                   ........   ...... ..    ............................                  5, 679
At Naubuc or Pratt's Ferry Bar............................................                                             4, 51
At Hartford Bar .--..-----..----........----......           ....................-.........--....                      3, 86
        Total..----- ......----......----.......... ....          ....---------------------....---....--...----....----....
                                                                                                       ----.......        14,054
  This, in addition to 34,135 cubic yards previously dredged, makes
48,189 cubic yards dredged under this agreement. The channels were
all made 75 feet wide, with 9 feet clear depth at low water.
  During the spring freshets of 1886 several of these shoals formed
again, and under letter of authority from the Chief of Engineers, March
25, 1886, an agreement was entered into with C. C. Goodrich, of Hart-
ford, dated April 2, 1886, to dredge about 10,000 cubic yards at the rate
of 10 cents per yard. The entire amount, 10,000 cubic yards, was
dredged from Hartford Bar between May 3 and May 20, making a
channel 9 feet deep at mean low water and from 22 to 44 feet wide
work under this agreement stopped on account of exhaustion of funds.
Mr. Goodrich has continued dredging at Hartford Bar and other bars.
without expense to, or authority from, the United States; it is under-
stood that this work is done by Mr. Goodrich at the request of the Hart-
3'28           REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

ford and New York Transportation Company to make it possible for
their boats to pass up and down the river.

                              PRESENT                  CONDITION                      OF       IMPROVEMENT.


   The training-walls, or wing-dams, at Hartford Bar and Glastonbury
Bar have been built; the east jetty at Saybrook has been extended to
the 12-foot curve, the west jetty to the 16 foot curve, and a channel 12
feet deep has been dredged between them. The dredging done by the
United States and by the Transportation Company has, it is understood,
made a narrow channel of 9 feet depth up to Hartford through the
,shoals formed by the spring freshets.

                                                   PROPOSED                     OPERATIONS.


   The object of first importance under the existing project is the main-
tenance of the required depth of 9 feet by annual dredging, and future
appropriations should be applied to that, unless they are made largely
in excess of what is needed for such work. Experience with the wing-
dams already Iuilt indicates that they will not maintain the channels
without frequent dredging, and it seems advisable to postpone the con-
struction of others at present. The appropriation estimated for the en-
suing year is intended for dredging to maintain the required depth on
the bars between Hartford and Middletown, at Haddam Island, and
between the Say brook jetties; for such repairs of the wing-dams already
built as may become necessary, and for raising and reinforcing the east
jetty at Saybrook.
  Appropriations for the improvement of Connecticut River below Hart-
ford, Conn., have been made as follows, viz:

       Date.                                                            Application.                                                                     Amount.


March2, 1867       Survey...---------..--------------------.............------......                                                                       Unknown.
                                                                                                          -----......---------------...............................
July 11, 1870      Dredging at Mouse Island, Pistol Point, and Pratt's Ferry; piling at
                     Hartford .....                                          ------------------                                                                     $20, 000
March 3, 1871      Dredging at Hartford, Claybanks, Pier I, Pier J, Pratt's Ferry, Glaston-
                     bury, Pistol Point, and Chester Rock------..---...--..-...----.........-----------.....---..--.                                                 35, 000
June 10, 1872      Dredging at Pistol Point and Pratt's Ferry: Saybrook jetty .....----.........                                                                     40, 000
March 3, 1873      Dredging at Hartford, Pratt's Ferry, and Glastonbury: Saybrook jetty...                                                                           20, 000
June 23,1874       Dredging at Hartford, Pratt's Ferry, and Saybrook: Saybrook jetties -....--.                                                                      20, 000
March3, 1875       Dredging at Glastonbury, Hartford, and Pratt's Ferry: Saybrook jetties.                                                                           20, 000
Aug. 14, 1876      Dredging at Glastonbury, Hartford, and Pratt's Ferry: Saybrook jetties,
                     Salmon River dredging .....-                        ..-    --....--......................                           ..-                         20, 000
           1878    Compensation for previous dredging ........-.................                                                     ........                         4, 203
June 18,   1878    Saybrook jetties, and survey from Hartford to Rocky Hill ....-......                                                        ....                  30, 000
March 3,   1879    Dredging Glastonbury, Hartford, and Press Barn .......--.........---- ..---.                                                                      10, 000
June 14,   1880    Dredging at Glastonbury, and Hartford ; Saybrook jetties ................                                                                         10, 000
March 3,   1881    Dredging at Glastonbury, Pratt's Ferry, and Hartford ; Glastonbury pier,
                     and Saybrook jetties...... ...............................................                                                                      30, 000
Aug.     2, 1882   Dredging at Glastonburv, Claybanks, Pratt's Ferry, Press Barn, Dividend,
                     Pistol Point, Hartford, Salmon River, dredging ; Hartford dike .....--....                                                                      45, 000
July     5, 1884   Dredging at Hartford, Claybanks, Pratt's Ferry, Press Barn, Glastonbury,
                     Dividend, Pistol Point, Mouse Island, and between jetties at Saybrook;
                     extending west jetty at Saybrook...--- .-- -                                         -      -----------             ----.. -..-.                35, 000

                             Total................                  .............            .....--.......           ... . ....        ......--...           $339, 203


  The Connecticut River is in the collection district of Middletown. By the course
of the river the distance from Holyoke, Mass., to Hartford, Conn., is about 34 miles,
,Saybrook
and from Hartford to Long Island Sound about 50 miles. There is a light-house on
           Point, on the west shore of the river, at its mouth, and another at the end
of the west jetty.
   Fort Trumbull, New London Harbor, Conn., about 16 miles east from Saybrook
Point, is the nearest work of defense.
                   APPENDIX         D-REPORT                         OF   LIEUT -COL. HOUSTON.                            629

                                                   Money statement.
July 1, 1885, amount available ....--......----....................---......                                       $5, 813 51
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885....-..-----....----....----...--..--......---.....--........                             5, 813 51

Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886 ..................                                              26, 250 00

   Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project........ 169, 000 0
   Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1888 25, 000 00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
     harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.


                                             COMMERCIAL STATISTICS.

  The following information concerning the commerce of the Connecticut River be-
low Hartford is furnished by the courtesy of the collector of customs at Middletown :
                                                              CUSTOM-HOUSE, MIDDLETOWN,                      CONN.,
                                                          Collector's Office, July 12, 1886.
   SIR: The inclosed report, compiled from answers to inquiries and from the records
of this office, is believed to be a fair exhibit of the commerce on the Connecticut River
for the past fiscal year; but the collection of customs, though apparently related to
it, has truly no connection with it, being derived almost wholly from the internal
inland transportation business from New York and trade with Canada.
   The report made this day to the Bureau of Navigation shows a total of 100 ves-
selA and 14,000 tons gross tonnage. The river is important, not only to Connecticut,
but to the States north of it, to which many of the products landed at Hartford are
finally transported, and if the river were fully improved coal could be furnished to the.
towns in Massachusetts adjacent to the river at nearly $1 per ton less than at present.
       Very respectfully,
                                                                   GEO. W. BURKE,
                                                                            Special Deputy.
   Col. D. C. HOUSTON, U. S. A.


Summary statement of commerce on the Connecticut River, includingport of Hartford and?
               all below to mouth of river, in the district of Middletown.

                                                                                                  Tons       of    Estimated
                 For year ending June 30, 1886.                           Number     Tonnge.      2,000 lbs.f      Estimvalue
                                                                                                                            o
                                                                                                  carried.          cargoes.


Entries, foreign sail .............................                              1          100             150          $1,200
Clearances, foreign sail............................. .                         1           100
Entries, coastwise steamers ----..--........ ...........                      370      789, 300
                                                    - .
Clearances, coastwise steamers .-----................-...--                   370      789, 300          77, 600    30, 175, 000
Clearancries        Coastwise, sail, and other craft           ...          2, 600     520, 000      910, 000        2, 300,
                                                                                                                        600, 00
                                                                                                                             04
Clearances                                                  .2,               600      520, 000      390, 000        1,
        Totals ..................        ................                   5, 942   2,618,800     1,377, 750       34,076,200


   Total amount of customs collected, $298,883.51.
   Chief articles of commerce: Stone, coal, lumber; manufactures of cotton, wool,
iron, britannia tin, &c.; grain, flour, feed, miscellaneous foreign goods.
   About half of the above freight goes to and from Hartford; the other half belongs
to the towns below.




                                                               D 2.

                       IMPROVEMENT OF THAMES RIVER, CONNECTICUT.

    This river is formed by the confluence of the Yantic and Shetucket
rivers at Norwich, Conn., and extends southward as a tidal stream 15
miles, to Long Island Sound. For 11 miles above its mouth the channel
is from 16 to 80 feet deep, averaging over 30 feet for the first 4 miles.
430           REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

JF'or 3 miles below Norwich the available depth in 1829 was but 5 feet
:at low water, where now there is 10 feet depth. The work.of improve-
~ient has been virtually confined to a stretch of 3- miles below Norwich.
IEistories of the improvements may be found in the Annual Reports of
the Chief of Engineers, 1873, page 981; and 1879, Part I, page 331.

                                    PROJECTS FOR IMPROVEMENT.

   The first definite project for improving this river was approved in
1836. It provided for a channel 100 feet wide and 14 feet deep at high
water, to be obtained by dredging, by constructing eleven piers or wing-
dains, and by adding to the three already built wings extending up
and down stream, converting them into T-walls. The desired results
were obtained, but shoals subsequently formed, and in 1866, and again
in 1873, it became necessary to deepen and widen the channel by dredg-
ing. In 1878, after more shoaling, it was decided to make the channel
14 feet deep at low water instead of at high water, which would increase
the depth 3 feet. This afforded only temporary relief; the shoaling con-
tinued, and in 1882 the project was further modified, under recommen-
dation of Major Barlow, Corps of Engineers, approved by the Board of
Engineers, by providing for the construction of five dikes or training
-walls along the outer sides of the channel curves, with the addition of
low walls on the inner sides should they be found necessary, the width
.of  water-way between them increasing from 300 feet at Thamesville, I
anile below Norwich, to 480 feet at the lower wall. At the same time
the projected width of the channel was increased to 200 feet. The im-
provement was to extend over the first 3, miles below Norwich.
      OPERATION              DURING THE FISCAL YEAR ENDING                                          JUNE 30, 1886.

    The dike on the east side of the channel at Long Rock, about 2 miles
below Norwich, which was nearly completed in the previous year, was
finished in July, 1885, 691 tons of riprap stone being delivered. Shoal-
ing occurred along the line of the Long Rock Dike previous to its con-
struction, so that the amount of stone required (11,945 tons) was much
less than estimated (20,000 tons), and with the approval of the Chief of
  Engineers, work was begun on the Rolling Mill Dike, about 1 miles
"below  Norwich, by the contractor for the Long Rock Dike, Charles H.
Edwards, of Boston, Mass., under an extension of his contract of Oc-
<tober 15, 1884. Work was continued until October 24, 1885, when the
,contract was declared completed, 8,000 tons having been 'delivered in
Ithe Rolling Mill Dike, building 1,026 linear feet of the middle part of
this dike to full dimensions, i. e., 3 feet wide on top, the top at mean
high-water level, and side slopes of 1 on 1; 105 tons of stone were also
used in July, 1885, in partial repair of the Trading Cove Dike, which
had settled.
    The total amount of stone delivered under this contract was:
                                                                                                                           Tons.
Long Rock Dike, complete--..-------....----.......--------......---....-----..........--------....--......-----.... --    11, 945
Trading Cove Dike, repairs---..-----..------...----....--.......----------....--......-----......----....---....-......       105
Rolling Mill Dike, beginning--------- ---------------------------------                                                   8,000

          Total- .---..--------....------....------.               ----------..-----------...........----........         20, 050
  Of this amount 11,254 tons were delivered in the previous fiscal year.
The material was riprap stone, partly granite, partly Connecticut River
sandstone.
                    APPENDIX                    D-REPORT                            OF LIEUT.-COL. HOUSTON.                                                       631
During May, 1886, an examination of the river near Norwich was
made.
                           PRESENT                   CONDITION                      OF THE IMPROVEMENT.


   Of the five dikes provided for in the project, the three furthest down-
stream have been constructed at cost as follows:

                                                                                                                              Numnberof                        Cost,
                     Location of dike.                             Location of dike.Date
                                                                                of
                                                                         completion.       dike. of
                                                                                         Length                                 ne
                                                                                                                              tsof.rip-f              exclusive of
                                                                              completion.                  die.                     rap.
                                                                                                                                                        supervis-
                                                                                                                                                         ion, &c.


                                                                                                           Feet.
Mohegan, 32 miles below Norwich .........                                                    1883             2, 988             Pile-dike.                $23, 686 00
Trading above, 2j miles below Norwich ......                                                 1882             2, 370                 17, 207                21, 113 05
Long Rock, 2 miles below Norwich ..........                                                  1885             2, 800                 11, 945                12, 781 15



  The next in order, the Rolling Mill Dike, 1 - miles below Norwich, and
planned to be 4,350 feet long, has been begun, 1,026 feet having been
built, commencing at the south end of the old " sand pier," about the
middle of the dike, and extending southward.
  The upper dike, one-half mile below Norwich, planned to be 1,050 feet
long, has not been begun.
   The Mohegan Dike and the Trading Cove Dike need slight repairs,
the former being crushed by ice at its upper end, the latter having set-
tied.
   The channel, which had an available depth of not less than 12 feet
at mean low water for a width of 60 feet or over, has shoaled during
the spring freshets, so that the available depth over the worst bars is
from 9.5 to 11.5 feet.
                                                       PROPOSED                      OPERATIONS.

  The funds now available are not sufficient to begin work with, but
they will probably be enough to make such repairs as are needed at once.
In order to secure the best attainable results the system of training-
walls now in course of construction should be completed rapidly. One
hundred thousand dollars can be profitably expended on this work and
on the necessary dredging during the year ending June 30, 1888.
  Appropriations for improvement of Thames River have been made
as follows, viz:

   Date.                                                                       Application.                                                                    Amount.


Mar.    3, 1821        Removal of obstructions placed during war of 1812...........................                                                                 $150
Mar.    2,1828         Survey .............---------------------------------------------....................................... .......                               150
July    4, 1836        Piers and dredging .......................                        .......... ...........-- ............          .                         10, 000
Mar.     3,1837 ..... do.---.........                     ....            .. .................
                                                                       ---....                         ..................... .........                            20,000
July    7, 1838         .. do------------..---------------------------------------------10,                                                                           000
June   23, 1866        Dredging and survey ...... .. .....     ..      ...    -.............................                                                      10, 000
Mar.    3, 1867        Dredging . ...--....--....... ..................... .............            ................                                              72,000
Mar. 3,1871            ---. do-------------                              ------------------------------------------                                               15,000
June   103,1872 ...... do            ...............--................... ...                             .............        .. ...............                 10, 000
June   18, 1878 ..         do ..--           -------....
                                          ------...          ---....
                                                                -- .. ---.......      ..........                   ................                               10, 000
Mar.    3, 1879            do .----........--...---- .........                            ............ ...............                      .............         12, 000
June   14, 1880 Dredging and training-walls .....                                   ................. .....................                            ... .      22, 500
Mar.    3,1881 ..... do                   ..............-----.--.............------.......................------------------------------.........                 30, 000
Aug.    2, 1882 Training-walls. .---..................... ..                                  .........           .........................                      *35, 000
July
July       1884-.....do----------------------------------------------------
        5, 1884
        5,         ...... do                    ............                   ................. .............                              ...... ......        *25, 000
                                                                                                                                                                  25,00
                               Total.--..--...-----                         --...-----....                                                   -      ....----- 281, 800
                                                       * Appropriated for present project.
632         REPORT          OF THE CHIEF                 OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

  Thames River is in the collection district of New London. The near-
est light-house is at the mouth of the river, on the west shore. Forts
Trumbull and Griswold overlook the mouth of the river from either
shore.


                                         COMMERCIAL         STATISTICS.


  No record of arrivals and departures of vessels is kept, and it has been impractica-
ble to obtain any statistics of the commerce of this river.
  Norwich, at the head of the river, is a distributing point for coal and supplies to
a large interior manufacturing district, principally along the line of the Norwich
and Worcester Railroad.
  A line of freight steamers makes trips nearly daily between Norwich and New York.



                                               Money statement.
July 1, 1885, amount available........-------............ ...... ................                  --   $17, 252 30
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1885 ....... .                  ......-......-..          $12, 499 95
July 1, 1886, outstanding liabilities......-----------......---......----------....----....       64 04
                                                                                                          12, 563 99

July 1, 1886, amount available ...................................-----                               .    4, 688 31
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886..................- .                                   22,500 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887.---....................                             27,188 31
  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project..- - -.--- 105, 50 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1888 100, 000 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.


Abstract of contractfor improving Thames Rirer, Connecticut, in force during the fiscal
                              year ending June 30, 1886.


Name and address of con-          Date                                           Price              Remark.
       tractor.                                         Subject.                per ton.

Charles H. Edwards,Bos-        Oct. 15, 1884    Delivery of riprap stone.         $1 07    Completed October 24,
  ton, Mass.                                                                !               1885.



                                                       D 3.

           IMPROVEMENT OF NEW LONDON HARBOR, CONNECTICUT.

  New London Harbor is that part of the Thames River which lies in
front of the city of New London, extending from Winthrop's Point to
Long Island Sound, a distance of about 3 miles. It has good anchor-
age-ground, and a channel from 30 to 50 feet deep and a quarter of a
mile wide extending up above Winthrop's Point. It is one of the best
harbors on the Atlantic coast. No improvements of importance have
ever been needed, and none were undertaken until 1880.

                                PROJECTS FOR IMPROVEMENT.
  In 1878, shortly after the completion of the New London Northern
Railroad Wharf, it was recommended that the United States undertake
                    APPENDIX        D-REPORT OF LIEUT -COL. HOUSTON.                                                          633

the removal, to a depth of 16 feet at mean low water, of a shoal of sand
and bowlders lying east of this wharf, at an estimated cost of $6,800;
when this project was adopted, under the appropriation of June 14,
1880, it was decided to limit the area of dredging to the southern part
of the shoal; subsequently, in 1882, this was modified so that the dredged
area should be that part of the shoal southwest of a line running south-
southeast from a point 600 feet above the south end of the wharf. The
depth in this part of the shoal varied from 6 to 15 feet.
   In 1881, after the first work had been done, it was found that the
material was much more difficult to handle than had been supposed,
and a new estimate was made, increasing the cost to $24,000. Of this
amount $17,800 have been appropriated; 20,360 cubic yards of sand
and stones, and 519 cubic yards of bowlders have been removed. The
original estimate provided for removal of 37,000 cubic yards of sand
and gravel, and 125 cubic yards of bowlders; showing that the propor-
tion of bowlders is much greater than was expected. These bowlders
have ranged in size from one-fourth cubic yard to 5 cubic yards, and
have frequently required blasting.

  OPERATIONS DURING                             THE FISCAL YEAR ENDING                                 JUNE 30, 1886.

  The available funds were not sufficient to begin operations with.                                                             An
examination of the shoal was made in May, 1886.

                           PRESENT              CONDITION               OF IMPROVEMENT.

  The required depth of 16 feet at mean low water has been made over
nearly the whole area to be dredged, the part still requiring dredging
being a wedge-shaped area about 50 feet wide and 200 feet long, lying
southeast of the work already done. No work has been done within 75
feet of the wharf, improvement inside that limit being considered as of
a private nature. The examination of May, 1886, showed that the
dredged area has retained its depth.

                                           PROPOSED OPERATIONS.

   If the balance of the estimate ($6,200) be appropriated, it will be ap-
plied to the completion of the projected work on the shoal east of the
railroad wharf, for which it will undoubtedly be sufficient. The work
already done has made the east side of the wharf quite easy of access,
and has been of great value to vessels loading and unloading there.
   Appropriations to date for this harbor have been made as follows,
viz :

   Date.                                                       Application.                                                 Amount.


June   14,   1880     Dredging   shoal   east   of railroad wharf... .....---            ...... . ......-.........            $2,   500
Mar.    3,   1881    'Dredging   shoal   east   of railroad wharf ...................                  .................       4,   300
Aug.    2,   1882     Dredging   shoal   east   of railroad wharf......... ..............................                      9,   000
July    5,   1884     Dredging   shoal   east   of railroad wharf ......................                  .._ ...........      2,   000
                         Total ...............-----------------------------------------------........                         17, 800


  New London, the port of entry for the collection district of New London, is situated
about 2.5 miles from Long Island Sound. The harbor is formed by the mouth of the
Thames River.
  New London light-house is located at the entrance to the harbor, on the west shore,
Forts Trumbull and Griswold command the harbor from either side.
634             REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

                                                           Money statement.
July 1, 1885, amount available..... ............   ....     ...---.....       ......                                                      -$160 64
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885----....---....---.......--......................---....                                                                160 64
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886.....--...-
                                                           -                                                              .....-.         2, 000 00
   Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project-.........                                                               4, 200 00
   Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1888                                                             4, 200 00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
     harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.


                                                      COMMERCIAL                STATISTICS.

  For the following statistics of commerce of the port of New London I am indebted
to the courtesy of the collector of the port :

                                                                                                                No. of        Total         Value of
                                                                                                               vessels.     tonnage.        cargoes.


Foreign entries..............................................                                         . ..--         18        3,651          $101,773
Foreign clearances.........................---- ..                      ..... ........--   -..-----......             1           128 .. --.
Coastwise entries.---..-...-----------------------..................................
                                                                              ------------..----....--
                                                                                        ..--           ..--.         51        8, 729 .........
Coastwise clearances................-----------------------......--------------..............                       117       24, 808 .........



   Customs collected, $10,648.28.
   Chief articles of foreign commerce, log wood, bay rum, rum, molasses, and fertili-'
zers.
   In addition to the above there is much domestic commerce, of which no record is
kept. A line of large freight and passenger steamers make trips to and from New
York daily. A steamer runs daily to Greenport, Long Island, N. Y., and return, and
in summer asteamer makes three trips weekly between Hartford, New London, and
Sag Harbor. During the summer the harbor is much frequented by pleasure boats of
all sizes.



                                                                        D 4.
                    IMPROVEMENT OF CLINTON HARBOR, CONNECTICUT.

   Clinton Harbor is on the north shore of Long Island Sound, about 10
miles west of the Connecticut River. It consists of an open, shallow
bay, and of the mouth of the Hammonasset River, a tidal stream which
flows easterly in front of the town wharves and empties into the bay.
For three-fourths of a mile above its mouth the river is separated from
the bay by a narrow strip of sand and marsh. About forty-five years
ago a break was made through this strip, one-half mile above the mouth
of the river, which diverted a considerable part of the tides, and since
then two shoals have formed, one just inside the river's mouth, with 4.5
feet of water, and one out in the bay, shortly before reaching the deep
water of the sound, with a depth of 4 feet. It is said that formerly there
were depths of from 8 to 12 feet on both these bars, and that shoaling
occurred soon after the breach was made.

                                           PROJECTS FOR IMPROVEMENT.

  The first survey of this harbor was made in 1881, and a project for
improvement submitted and adopted in 1882, which consisted in closing
the breach by a riprap stone dike, and after sufficient time had elapsed,
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                T-0- -                   N




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                -            O           N




               7I~t1&.
                    -
                                                                                                        II                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   r.I




                                 "I
                               3""                                                                                                                                                                        7~c
     3.0                .                    S.




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    ,....-
                                                                                                             0.2
                                                                                                             A      TJ\                   .             "'i
                                                                                                                                                                                      -                         {   DUI    T,,1'!        I=8




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                I         *                     )~Z~7~
                                                                                               V                                                                                                                                                                                       -   ,!       t   ,1-'                             r

                                                  *   O   V "oV-                                                         -"   ____                            i   "   . -     r u.         Iq ",tm                    -     3 '          _Y _                           -                                                  fr
                                                                                                                                                                              4
                                                                                                                                                                             ~~ir                                                                       si
                                                           "!       O   1   1
                                                                            0 00                                                                    r_                                                                30                                     /                     /       /              1            \                             !                                 _ _ __ __

                                                                                                   Cc               1~lQA     it'                  1N
                                                                                                                                                                            ,ZEE                                                                r        4


                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         r
                                                                                                                                                                                      .,                                                                         .,9.
                                                                                                                                              r"                  0                  'at

                                                                                                                                                                                                          I.l         i             .,
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   6
                                                                                           e       4~lha-t
                                                                                                                                                                                                 .5
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           ROCK                .   .




                                                                                                                 - of/
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 -                                 H   M     O~       T
                               -t   ok       e3




                             e S1t
                            ;tc
                                u g,
                                       ,f-

4   v    ;c
~OYOt'..4
   4   #V4~.




                                                                                                                                                                                             /        f                                         )k---
                                                                                                                                    1jw

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                            .. .           "-12


                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           i
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         5             O       U   N       D
                                                                                                                                                                                                  6




         c4A


                                                      Chi
                                         of4u     4&4L          4 4


                                                      (                                                                                                                                                                   G
                            &n.uv. e                      ., .r,.,                 ,   .                                                                                                              .
S--Exi          v2492                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      THE AMERICAN GRAPHIC CO.,N.Y.
H Exl pt2 v2 49 2                                               -            -p2
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    --                   ----              -   ----
             APPENDIX             D-REPORT                         OF LIEUT.-COL.                      HOUSTON            .635

if the desired depth was not restored by the increased tidal flow, to
dredge channels 100 feet wide and 6 feet deep at mean low water through
the two shoals. Three thousand dollars was estimated as the cost of the
dike and $10,000 as the cost of the whole project, including the dredg-
ing. (See Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1882, Part I,
page 630.)
  OPERATIONS            DURING TIlE FISCAL YEAR ENDING JUNE 30, 1886.

The available funds were not sufficient to continue the improvement.
An examination of the harbor was made in September, 1885.
                  PRESENT CONDITION                                 OF THE IMPROVEMENT.

   The dike was built in 1883, using 1,574 tons of riprap granite, and
costing, exclusive of superintendence, $2,219.34. The recent examina-
tion shows that it has settled an average of about 2 feet, and will re-
quire 500 tons of stone to bring it up) to full height; also, that no ma-
terial change has taken place in the channel since the completion of the
dike. It seems now fairly well established that the increase of tidal flow
will not scour the channel to the desired depth without some dredging.

                                        PROPOSED OPERATIONS.

  It is p)roposed to complete the project by dredging a channel 100 feet
wide and 6 feet deep at mean low water through the two shoals in the
harbor as soon as the estimated funds, $7,000, are appropriated.
  Appropriations to date for this harbor have been made as follows, viz:

    Date.                                                     Application.                                              Amount.


Mar. 3, 1881 Survey .........                  ..................................................                           *$500
Aug.
Ag.
     2, 1882 Construction
     2, 1882 Constuction      of
                              of dike
                                 dike           ------------------------------------------------
                                             ..................................................
                                                                                           ....                             3, 00@
                                                                                                                            3,
                                                                                                                               000

                     Total --..-----------                                                          ..------...........     3,500

                            * Allotment from general appropriation for surveys.

  Clinton Harbor, Connecticut, is in the collection district of Middletown, on the
north shore of Long Island Sound, 9 miles west of the mouth of the Connecticut River.
The nearest light-house is on Falkner's Island,     miles southwest. Fort Trumbull,
New London Harbor, Connecticut, is 23 miles east, and is the nearest work of defense.

                                               Money statement.
July 1, 1885, amount available ................... ....................                                                 $306 73
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1 85-.---------------------------------------------
                          5                                                                                                54 00

July 1, 1886i, amount available ------....----... -----------------------....-----....
                                                                       .                                                  252 73

Amionnt(estimated) required for conplction of existing project--.--.-                                                 7, 000 00
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1888                                            7, 000 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.


                                             COMMERCIAL                    STATISTICS.

  For the following statistics I am indebted to the courtesy of the collector of customs
at Middletown, Conn. :
     Number of vessels entered and cleared ...                                             -.....   -
                                                                                               ............    - --.
                                                                                                               ..                30
     Tonnage (total) ......--....-                          . .......
                                                           ..       .........
                                                                   -..    ..........
                                                                                 .......                                   3,000
   Value of cargoes . . ... ..................  ........       ............ $24,000
                                                         .......
  Chief articles of commerce are coal, wood, and oysters.
  The greater part of the commerce of Clinton is carried on by rail.
636     REPORT OF THE      CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.


                                  D 5.
       IMPROVEMENT OF NEW HAVEN HARBOR, CONNECTICUT.

   New Haven Harbor is a bay on the north shore of Long Island Sound,
extending about 4 miles inland, and from 1 to 2 miles wide. The Mill
and Quinnipiac rivers empty into the head of the harbor. These rivers
are of no commercial importance, except for tidal navigation about a
mile above their mouths. The harbor channel is from 400 feet to 1
.mile in width, with mud and sand flats on either side. When the Gov-
ernment began work in this harbor in 1867, the available low-water
depth above Fort Hale-about half-way up the harbor-was 9 feet. Op-
posite Fqrt Hale it was 18 feet or over, but a short distance below was
a bar of soft mud extendiug across the harbor, with depths from 13 to
15 feet. The mouth of the' harbor was obstructed by several sunken
rocks.
                    PROJECTS FOR IMPROVEMENT.

  Several plans for removal of some of the rocks at the entrance have been
proposed and undertaken with indifferent success. The removal of the
harbor light to Southwest Ledge, and the completion of the present plan
for breakwaters, will obviate the necessity of further work on the rocks.
  The first project for deepening the channel of this harbor provided
for making 13 feet depth at mean low water up to the city wharves.
This was begun, and the required depth obtained in 1871. In 1872 and
1873 the bar below Fort Hale (about 2 miles below the city of New
Haven) was dredged 16 feet deep, but on account of the very soft nature
of the material the channel nearly filled up in a few months. Greater
depth in the upper harbor was desired, and in 1875-'77 a project was
proposed and adopted, providing for a channel 16 feet deep above Fort
Hale. To increase the depth over the Fort Hale Bar, it was proposed
in 1879 to contract the channel there by means of a dike from Sandy
Point, on the west side of the harbor. This plan being recommended by
Board of Engineers for Fortifications and River and Harbor Improve-
ments, and being approved by the Chief of Engineers, work upon it was
begun in 1883. The dike was to consist of a channel arm parallel to the
channel and connected with the west shore at Sandy Point.

  OPERATIONS DURING THE FISCAL YEAR ENDING JUNE 30, 1886.

  Dredging was done by hired labor and by contract to enlarge the
water-way under Tomlinson's Bridge, and to widen the channel above
Long Wharf, in order to afford anchorage to light-draught vessels with-
out blocking the main channel. Work by hired labor was begun Au-
gust 10, at which time Tomlinson's Bridge was being partially rebuilt.
Two old piers and part of the east abutment of the old bridge were
removed, and an area extending about 120 feet across the channel and
30 feet above and below the bridge was dredged 18 feet deep. The
material removed consisted of masonry, riprap, sand, gravel, mud, logs,
and old crib-work, amounting to 3,116 cubic yards measured in place,
and costing 75 cents per cubic yard. The channel from Tomlinson's
Bridge to the Sewer Dock was widened on the east side from 40 to 120
feet, the depth made being 12 feet at mean low water; 20,000 cubic
yards of mudl were removed. Advertisement by circular was made,
proposals were received, and September 9 a contract was made with
Henry Du Bois' Sons, of New York, to dredge about 50,000 cubic yards
                  APPENDIX              D-REPORT                   OF       LIEUT.-COL.                 HOUSTON.                      637
at the rate of 81 cents per cubic yard. Work was begun immediately,
and was completed October 9, 1885, 44,192 cubic yards of mud having
been removed. The channel was widened 80 feet on the east side from
opposite the Sewer Dock to and around the bend opposite Long Wharf,
making 13 feet depth at mean low water; and on the west side of the
channel, half way between the Sewer Dock and the Canal Railroad
Dock, an anchorage basin, 400 feet by 200 feet, was dredged 8 feet deep.
                            PRESENT CONDITION OF IMPROVEMENT.

  The available depth over Fort Hale Bar is about 13 feet at mean low
water. Above this there is a 16-foot channel up to Tomlinson's Bridge,
with width from 400 to 600 feet. Just below the Sewer Dock, on the
west side of the channel, is an anchorage basin of about 2 acres area
and 8 feet deep, and on the east side of the channel above Long Wharf
an additional width of about 100 feet has been dredged 12 feet deep or
over. The shore-arm, 2,140 feet long, and 254 feet of the channel-arm
of the Sandy Point Dike, have been built; 1,294 feet of the inner end
of the shore-arm are built of riprap stone; the rest is of close piling,
with longitudinal timbers and cross ties, 8 feet wide over all, and filled
with stone. All the timber work is creosoted.
                                                    PROPOSED OPERATIONS.

  The project for deepening the channel across the Fort Hale Bar,
which consists of a dike from the west shore (already begun) and dredg-
ing, ought to be completed as soon as possible. The work could readily
be done in one year, and $100,000 is estimated for finishing the dike,
and for the necessary dredging.
   Appropriations for the improvement of New Haven Harbor have been
made, as follows, viz:
   Date.                                                        Application.                                                        Amount.


Aug.   30, 1852    Removal of middle rock, not expended until 1867 .....                          .....................               $6, 000
July   11, 1870    R em oval of rocks .... . . . .          . .. ....         ...............             ......         ...          15, 000
Mar.    3, 1871    Dredging (13 feet) above Fort Hale---...---------..--.......---...--........---------..---------.......            40, 000
June   10, 1872    Dredging (16 feet) above Fort Hale, removal of rocks ........................                                      35, 000
Mar.    3, 1873    Dredging (16 feet) above Fort Hale .....--                     -.--         --...--....-....--..--           .     25, 000
Mar.    3, 1875    Dredging (13 feet) above Leng Wharf.............                      ...............               ...            10, 000
June   18, 1878    Dredging (16 feet) Long Wharf to Fort Hale.........................                                                25, 000
Mar.    3, 1879    Dredging (16 feet) above Long Wharf .--..--......---.........................                                      15, 000
June   14, 1880    Dredging (16 feet) above Long Wharf .......                  ..............................-                       15,000
Mar.    3, 1881    Dredging (16 feet) Long Wharf to Fort Hale                 .......         ..... . ........ ..........             15, 000
Aug.    2,1882     Dike opposite Fort Hale---.....................................          ......--........         .......          30, 000
July    5, 1884    Dredging (18, 12, and 8 feet) above Long Wharf ---------    ....                              ---
                                                                                                ..........------......       --       10, 000

                          Total .................                    ...
                                                                    .............           .......           .............          241, 000


  New Haven, the port of entry for the collection district of New Haven, is situated '
at the head of New Haven Harbor, about 31 miles from Long Island Sound.                                                              There
is a light-house on Southwest Ledge, at the mouth of the harbor.                                                  Fort Hale, 2 miles
below the city, commands the channel.
                                                      Money statement.
July 1, 1885, amount available ................................................... $10,276 82
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1885 ................          ....   $9, 850 58
July 1, 1886, outstanding liabilities .............     ......  .....       290 00
                                                                                                                                10, 140 58

July 1, 1886, amount available................                                      ...........................                      136 24
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886 ................                                                           . 20, 000 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887..................                                                         20,136 24
638              REPORT              OF       THE         CHIEF                    OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

   SAmount (estimated) required for completion of existing project..-..-. -  $80, 000 00
   Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1888 80, 000 00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
     harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.



Abstract of proposals received and opened at 11 a. m., September 7, 1885, dredging in New
                               Haven Harbor, Connecticut.


                                                                                                                                      Price      Cost of
No.                                   Names and addresses of bidders.                                                               per cubic 50,000 cubic
                                                                                                                                      yard.      yards.

   1    H. N. and A. J. Beardsley, Bridgeport, Conn .........--..                 ..------
                                                                                --.....                                                    $0 092           $4, 750
   2    William H. Taylor, jr., Jersey City, N. J..... ........................                                                               11 i           5, 500
   3    *Henry Du Bois' Sons, New York, N. Y..................................                                                                  08           4,250

   * Contract awarded to Henry Du Bois' Sons, dated September 9, 1885, and completed October 9, 1885,




                                                       COMMERCIAL STATISTICS.

  The following statement of commerce of the port of New Haven is furnished by
the courtesy of the collector of customs:

                                                         FOREIGN COMMERCE.


                                                                                                                                                          rueofof
                                                                                                                                                      iValue
                                                                                                                                    Number.             cargoes.

Vessels entered ...... .......................................................                                                                  50     $560, 794 45
Vessels cleared .....................             ........................................                                                      19       82,125 06

   Duties and miscellaneous receipts, $261,974.49.

   The total amount of merchandise in weight received by water, not including coal,
iron, and lumber, is 389,912 tons; and the chief articles of commerce consist of sugar,
molasses, rum, coal, iron, lumber, potatoes, and various other products in large quan-
tities.
                                                        DOMESTIC COMMERCE.
Steamers entered and cleared..............................................                                                                                 2, 720
Sailing vessels and barges entered and cleared .............................                                                                               7, 240

                                                  RECEIPTS OF MERCHANDISE.
Coal, 711,283 tons ............................................                                                                 value..               $3,200,773
Iron, 82,000 tons .............................................                                                                   do....               1,476,000
Lumber .........................................-...........                                                                     do-....  2, 500, 000
Miscellaneous ......                  .                          .........
                                                      ................            .........                     ..........       do....- 68, 056, 339
Shipment of merchandise .........                                  .... ...............                             ........     do....  57,215,830

           Total...............                                .................    .........................                                        132,448, 942

                                                            RECAPITULATION.
Value of merchandise imported .............................                                                                ...........                 $560,794
Value of merchandise exported ........................................                                                                                    82, 125
Value of merchandise received coastwise ..............................                                                                               68, 056, 339
Value of merchandise shipped coastwise ...........                      ................                                                 ....        57, 215, 830
Coal, iron, and lumber ................................................                                                                               7, 176,773

           Total...........                   ....         .          ...............................                                                133, 091,861
             APPENDIX            D-REPORT OF LIEUT.-COL. HOUSTON.                                             639
                                                          D 6.

   CONSTRUCTION OF BREAKWATER AT NEW HAVEN, CONNECTICUT.
                                                     PROJECT.
    The importance of a harbor of refuge at the entrance to New Haven
Harbor had been urged by memorials to Congress, and set forth in an-
nual reports of the Chief of Engineers, when, March 3, 1879, the first
appropription was made for the construction of a breakwater. The sub-
ject was referred to the Board of Engineers for Fortifications and for
River and Harbor Improvements, who presented to the Chief of En-
gineers, on November 24, 1879, a project, which was approved by the
Secretary of War January 31, 1880, and is printed in full in the Annual
Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1880, Part I, pages 448-456. The
project provides for the construction of two detached breakwaters at
the entrance to New Haven Harbor, to form a harbor of refuge for ves-
sels of 20-feet draught. The easterly breakwater is to extend from the
light-house on Southwest Ledge to Quixes Reef, 3,300 feet. The west-
erly one is to commence in the vicinity of Luddington Rock and to ex-
tend about 4,200 feet in a northwesterly direction. Its location and
length have not yet been exactly determined. Both breakwaters were
to be of riprap granite, reaching 6 feet above mean high water, 12 feet
wide on top, with side slopes of 1 on 3 on the outside and 2 on 3 on the
inside. The average height of the east breakwater above bottom is 32
feet; that of the west breakwater will be 28 feet.
    The cost was estimated as follows :
        Locality.                                          Work performed.                                 Amount.


Iast breakwater -.......   328, 900 cubic yards in work, at $2 ................................              $657, 800
West breakwater......      326, 667 cubic yards in work, at $2           ...............................      653, 334
      Total.....         ...........
                    -----------------------------------------------------------------
                                      .         ............................                                1,311,134

   A modification in the cross-section was proposed by the officer in
charge, and approved by the Chief of Engineers February 14, 1880, mak-
ing the outer slope 1 on 2 and the inner slope 1 on 1. This would re-
duce the estimate for the east breakwater to $480,000, but as the loca-
tion and length of the west breakwater are not definitely fixed, its cost
may be greater than was estimated, and it has been thought advisable
to retain the total estimate first given, viz, $1,311,134.
    OPERATIONS DURING THE FISCAL YEAR ENDING JUNE 30, 1886.
  No work has been done on the breakwater, the funds available being
insufficient to resume operations with. Cross-sections of the completed
part of the east breakwater were made in June, 1886.
                               PRESENT CONDITION OF WORK.
  The east breakwater is now 2,147 feet long, being nearly two-thirds
of its projected length. It contains 189,898 tons of granite, and has
cost, including contingencies, about $100 per linear foot.
                                       PROPOSED OPERATIONS.
  In their report of November 24, 1879, submitting the project, the
Board of Engineers expressed " the opinion that after the completion
of a certain portion of the easterly breakwater the westerly one should
be promptly commenced." It would seem advisable to commence the
westerly breakwater now, and to continue work on the easterly one at
640            REPORT                   OF THE CHIEF                     OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

the same time. For work on the two breakwaters $500,000 could be
profitably expended during the ensuing fiscal year.
   Appropriations for the New Haven Breakwater have been made as
follows, viz:

                                        Application.                                              Extent. Amount.                Date.


                                                                                                       Feet.
Building breakwater........                                     ...........
                                                 ................                               ..       3481     $30, 000   March 3,1879.
      Do ....................................                          ....................              342       30, 000   June 14,1880.
      Do .............                                   .....---.
                                              ............-.                     .............           535       60, OCO   M arch 3,1881.
      Do ........................................................                                        592       60,000    August 2, 1882.
      Do...............................................                                   ..-.......     330       40,000    July 5,1884.

                 Total...............             ... ......         .....   .........                  2,147    220,000


  New Haven, the port of entry for the collection district of New Haven, is situated
at the head of New Haven Harbor, about 4 miles north of the breawater. There is a
light-house on Southwest Ledge, the west terminus of the east breakwater, and Fort
Hale, 2 miles north from the breakwater, commands New Haven Harbor.
                                  Money statement.
July 1, 1885, amounrt available ........................       .............        .                                           $3, 032 49
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1885 ....-.-.--------- .        . $1, 476 63
July 1, 1886, outstanding liabilities.......... ...... .......               140 00
                                                                                                                                   1, 616 63
July 1, 1886, amount available ................ .....................                                                            1,415 86
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886 .........                                                    ...... ..       75, 000 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887 .... .............                                                        76, 415 86

 (Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project.. ....1, 016, 134 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June
       30, 1888........................                                                                                        500,000 00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
     harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.


                                                                     D       7.
                   IMPROVEMENT OF MILFORD HARBOR, CONNECTICUT.
                                                GENERAL DESCRIPTION.
   This harbor is on the iorth shore of Long Island Sound, about 9
miles southwest of New Haven, Conn. It consists of a broad, open bay,
from the head of which a small tidal stream extends three-quarters of
a mile inland, to the Milford wharves.
   The original depth on the bar at the mouth of the river was 2 feet at
mean low water, and in some places between there and the upper
wharves the channel ran nearly bare.
                                          PROJECTS FOR IMPROVEMENT.
    The first project, adopted in 1872, provided for-
1. A riprap breakwater from Welch's Point, on the east side of the mouth of
    the harbor.... ...............             ................. ....  .... $67, 000
2. Protecting the bluffs on the east shore from erosion, by means of small
       stone jetties .. -.........              ................-......                                    ..... ...... ....- 5, 500
                                                                                                       "......
3. Dredging 4 feet deep and 100 feet wide across the bar at the mouth of the
    river .............---...... .....................               ...... .......... .....------- 6,250
4. A jetty on the east side of the channel to prevent the dredged area filling,
   Sand to confine the action of the tide.................................                          5, 000
Superintendence.........................................................                            1,250
          Total.................................................... .. ........                             . .       ...     ..    85, 000
_L~                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               ____




                                                                                                                                                                          0111             -t   o'v   '         L~   iJ/)IZ            /TO)   Y   e    C     Cn




                                                                                                                                                                                            S41            iw 3           8,6.


                                                                                                                                                           50K                        o                   ~oh          jopo            500o             2000




                                                                                                                                                                                                             '
                                                                                                                                                                                                            4v


                                                                                                                                                                                                      4'




          AK4.u 'frW14V   t1 toe 1o                1~~16753       a                1S1   yw        f,¢       to/vtcw   l ww     '     .

S~?t44A4Vq /U4-*,4                -f           %i2 4 b~     4 ~9S5.9




                                                                                                   6_
                                                                                                                                      .9       .               . .. " ....




                                                            9   ...                                                    .-   .   . .        .       . .   ...    ..           2        ..




                                                       .f
                                                   i




                                                                                                                                                5-


               Wj




           F"I




           J              i




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      'I 6
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       412

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      18
      r




               O




                                                                                                                                                                     221 ...

                                                                                                                                                                                                          0 0
                          r'ii^        L       S




                          1S8n




                                  M        y




                                                                                                                                           V
                                                                                                                                      S
                                                                               .
                                                                                       i:




                                                                           /       -           r

                                                                      ii
                                                            9                            !'
                                                                i2i5
                                                                                       18 21
                                                                                                         V                                                                       9-                                           U~   u




                                                                                                                                                                                                      Wit.~t           co.    o!

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         c




THE AMERICAN GRAPHIC CO.,N.Y
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        H Exl pt2 v2 49 2
              APPENDIX                 D-REPORT OF LIEUT.-COL. HOUSTON.                                                                      641

  This project, except the breakwater, was completed in 1881, and in
1882 a channel 40 to 60 feet wide and 4 feet deep had been extended up
the stream to the village wharves. In 1881 Major Barlow made an es-
timate for dredging a channel 8 feet deep and 100 feet wide through the
bar at the mouth of the river, at a cost of $11,000; $5,000 has been ex-
pended towards this channel. In 1882 a survey for a breakwater and
harbor of refuge was made, and plans and estimates of cost submitted.
(See Annual Report of Chief of Engineers for 1882, Part I, page 632.)

   OPERATIONS DURING                             THE FISCAL YEAR ENDING JUNE 30, 1886.

The funds available were not sufficient to continue the improvement.
An examination of the mouth of the river and of the bar just below was
made in September, 1885.

                           PRESENT CONDITION                                 OF IMPROVEMENT.

   The channel of 4 feet depth at mean low water was made 60 feet wide
for two-thirds of the way from the mouth of the river to the upper
wharves, and 40 feet wide the rest of the way; it is in good condition,
with no material changes.
   The channel across the bar, made 8 feet deep and 65 feet wide, has
filled slightly, 7 feet being about its available depth now. The jetties
need some repairs.
                                             PROPOSED                   OPERATIONS.

  Whenever funds become available, it will be desirable to complete
the 8-foot channel through the bar to the projected width of 100 feet;
$6,000, the remainder of the estimated cost, could be profitably expended
on this work in the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888.
  Appropriations for Milford Harbor have been made as follows, viz:

    Date.                                                          Application.                                                            Amount.

June   10, 1872   Survey .-----.---...-------..---..---------...-----------...--..--........-----------------....................            $1, 500
June   23, 1874   Jetties on east shore .--.....---...........               .... ..............                  .... ......... ....         5, 000
Mar.    3, 1875   Long Jetty and dredging mouth of river .                                     .......
                                                                                           ........................                   .      13, 000
June   18, 1878   Dredging to Town Wharf --..--......---.....--.......-----.....--...................                                        10, 000
June   14,1880    Dredging above Town Wharf and below Merwin's Wharf ..................                                                       5,000
Mar.    3, 1881   Survey for breakwater .-.... ..- ....-                    .. .....-.-.........                ....---.......-- .               100
Aug.    2, 1882   Dredging (8 feet) below Merwin's Wharf . ..                           ...--............. ..............                     5, 000

                         Total.----.--................          ... ......................                   .................               39,600


  Milford Harbor, Connecticut, is in the collection district of New Haven ; it is about
9 miles west from Fort Hale, New Haven Harbor. The nearest light-house is on
Stratford Point, 4 miles to the westward.
   Excepting the oyster business, which is conducted on rather a large scale, and one
fish-oil works, the harbor is only of local importance.

                                                       Money statement.
July 1, 1885, amount available....................                                            ...................                         $269 29
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885 ......................------......-----......----....--....                                                       28 27

July 1, 1886, amount available............................                                                    ..........                    241 02
  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project........                                                                  6,000 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended infiscal yearending June 30, 1i88                                                                6, 000 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
      41 E
642                REPORT OF THE CHIEF                                                 OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

                                                              COMMERCIAL                    STATISTICS.


  The following statement of commerce of Milford Harbor is supplied through the
courtesy of the collector of customs at New Haven:


                                               Vessels entered and cleared.                                                                        Number.
                                                                                                                                                                              Total
                                                                                                                                                                             tonnage.


Steamers ............       ....       ........         ...........             ....   .........       .......................                                    450          13,500
Sailing vesels ..............................................................                                                                                     221          11, 840



Value of cargoes received .--.....           ...........                        ..      ........        .......    .. ..... ......               ........          .......   $100, 450
Value of cargoes shipped ......-...................                                         ...      .... . ..............................                                    100,000
    The chief articles of commerce are oysters, fertilizers, fish-oil, and coal.




                                                                                     D 8.
                     IMPROVEMENT OF HOUSATONIC RIVER, CONNECTICUT.

   The Housatonic is a long, shallow river, running southward through
Massachusetts and Connecticut, and emptying into Long Island Sound
just east of Stratford Point, about 15 miles southwest of New Haven.
At Derby, 13 miles above its mouth, it receives the discharge of the
Naugatuck, a small, rapid river. This point, which has been regarded
as the head of navigation, is nearly the head of tide-water; about 1
mile above there is a dam across the Housatonlic River, furnishing large
water-power.     For at least 5 miles below Derby the water is always
fresh.
    The original depth on the worst bars in the river, 6 in number,varied
from 3.5 to 4.5 feet at mean low water; there was also a bar across the
river's mouth, with about 4 feet low-water depth.
                                                   PROJECT FOR IMPROVEMENT.

  In 1871 a project for the improvement of the river was submitted,
which provided for a channel 100 feet wide and 7 feet deep at low wa-
ter from Derby to Long Island Sound, to be secured by means of jetties
and dredging in the river, and by dredging over the bar at the mouth
after the location had been protected by a breakwater from Milford
beach, on the east shore at the mouth.
  The estimated cost was as follows:
Jetty at Sow and Pigs Reef..---........                                                ....        .......       ....................                 ....                    $4, 000
Removing Drew's Rock, 357 cubicjyards                                                  .........................                             .....-....                        2, 000
Dredging inside the bar.................................                                                                         ..................                           18, 486
Dredging on the bar at the mouth.. - ......... ..............                                                                    ..     ......               .
                                                                                                                                                            ...         .     12, 000
Construction of breakwater at month....................................                                                                                                      368, 475

              Total ........ .-------------.---.....-------........--.....
                                                                  ------...----..----......                                                                 ----........404,961
   This project was subsequently modified to admit of a jetty connecting
Drew's Rock with the west bank, and in 1879 Major Barlow presented
an estimate of $12,000 for a riprap jetty to take the place of the break-
water at the mouth of the river; in 1882 this estimate was altered to
about $20,000, and has been incorporated into the estimate for com-
pleting the project; the jetty contemplated was 6,000 feet long, rising
only to low-water level.
          .    _                                                    _




                             3,-V"-e               30,      1$86.




0             0                    a.Ai"aco          'S.                         4000                5,




                                         0
                                    /.
                                     k
                                   A:,




                                                                                                           o

                                                                                                               .         o




                                                                                                                                                                                     12                        I



                                                                                                                                                                             -           i
                                                                                                                                                                                                                I
                                                                                                                                                        6

                                                                                                                                                                                                                /
                                                                                                                   to
                                                                                                                                      19                 1


                                                                                                                                                             r
                                                                                                                              ,to

                                                                                                                                                                                     S       I
                                                                                                                             o      oi                  /
                                                                                                                                                    I
                                                                                                                                                    o




                                                                                                                                                                                                          /.       0
                                                                                      I .,                                                                                           S I
                ~ ~ ~rn-r                           ~                                                                        • "'fi
                                                                                                                                     . :".,
                                                                                                                                           .   !'                                                                  4
                                                                                                                                 's -.
                   S~c




                                                                                                                                      .:
                                    .~t~     rr            185.~bax
                                                                                             9i~


                                                                                                                                                                             g           I
                                                           88&
                                                                                                                                                                             9       ;                    /'

                                                                                                                                                                                                               CO
    So
     n3Liy               1    l'        3;eVaSt   ,ovv
                                                    o




                   4     Al~e/._

                                                                                                                                                                                                 //


                                                                                                                                                                           ;./:'                      O


                                                                                                                                                                        .        "

                                                                                                                                                                             Nr      /


                                                                                                                                                                      .. /




                                                                                                                                                                       "         .
4 MSO         /Wih0            OM1441                    QtZCtGV                .3I




                                                                                                                                                                 C,
                                                                                                                                               0

                                                                                                                        S1




        "~I~~tlz~                                                       AOle~




                         I"         "    .                                       e-          Sf~   nLZec




                                                                                                                                                                        THE AMERICAN GRAPHIC CO.,N.Y.

H Exl pt2 v2 49 2
                       APPENDIX                        D-REPORT                             OF LIEUT.-COL.                                  HOUSTON.                            643
     OPERATIONS                            DURING THE FISCAL YEAR ENDING JUNE 30, 1886.

  The material of which the bar at the mouth of the river consists is
considered excellent for oyster-beds, and at intervals for several years
offers have been made by oyster-growers to dredge more or less of this
bar free of expense to the United States, they to have the material
dredged ; the work to be done as a harbor improvement under direction of
the Engineer officer in charge. With the approval of the Secretary of
War a contract of this kind was entered into with Lewis & Merwin, of
Stratford, Conn., to dredge a channel 35 feet wide and 7 feet deep at
mean low water through the bar. Work was begun July 29 aid finished
September 9, 1885, a channel of the required dimensions and 2,000 feet
long having been made, and 14,394 cubic yards of sand, gravel, and
shells having lbeen removed. February 1, 1886, another contract of the
same nature was made with the same parties to make a channel 9 feet
deep and 70 wide; work under this contract began June 17, 3,418 cubie
yards being dredged before the close of the fiscal year.
  An examination of the outer bar was made in October, 1885, and an
examination of the bars in the river was begun in June, 1886.
                                      PRESENT CONDITION OF IMPROVEMENT.

   Though the bars in the river have been repeatedly dredged to 7 feet
depth at mean low water, the present available depth on them is only
from 5 to 6 feet.
                                                             PROPOSED OPERATIONS.

  Should sufficient appropriations be made, the breakwater at the mouth
of the river will be built, Drew's Rock will be removed, and the channel
in the river will be deepened wherever the bars have formed again.
The estimated cost of this work is $30,000; it could be done to advan-
tage in a single year.
  Appropriations for the Housatonic River have been made as follows,
viz:
     Date.                                                                              Application.                                                                         Amount.


July    11, 1870 Survey -.-- ...---                        .----... ......-- ...... ....................................                                                       $2, 70
Mar.     3,1871 Sow and Pigs Jetty,dredging -.......................................                                                                                           15,000
June    10, 1872 Drew'sRock Jetty, dredging ...............................................                                                                                    15, 000
Mar.     3,1873 Dredging .....                         ...... ..-.. ...-..                    .....-       ....-.............                        ..............            10, 000
June    23,1874 ..... do . ...                   .. .........---....                 ........              ......             ......................                           10, 000
Mar.     3,1875 Dredging by hired labor..-..                                          .-----.- ....-.......--              ...           ... ........         .......           5, 000
June    18, 1878 Dredging .---... . .............                                        ......---       ....          .- ..- .---.....                .. ......        .       5, 000
June    14, 1880 .....      do ...........                      ........................................................                                                        2,000
Mar.     3,1881 ...... do.........----...............................................................                                                                           2,000
A ug.    2,1882 ...........................................................................                                                                                     2, 000
July     5, 1884 ---.......                ......        --...................           .....................                      .......................                     2, 500
                                   Total.----..            .......-......................
                                                         ---...                                                       ....        .......     .    ..............              71, 200


  The Housatonic River is the boundary between the collection districts of New Haven
and Fairfield. The nearest light-house is on Stratford Point, at the mouth of the river,
and the nearest work of defense is Fort Hale, New Haven Harbor, about 13 miles east.
                                                                        Money statement.
July 1, 1885, amount available......................................$4,495                                                                                                         85
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1,1885.... ........               ...................... .......                                                                                         1,155 03
July 1, 1886, amount available......................................                                                                                                        3, 340 82
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886................                                                                                                          5, 000 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887...........                                                                                      .......               8, 340 82
644             REPORT OF THE                                    CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

T  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project -........  $25, 000 00
   Amount that canbe profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1888 25,000 00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.


                                                             COMMERCIAL            STATISTICS.


  The following statement of commerce of this river is supplied through the courtesy
of the collector of customs at New Haven:


                                   Vessels entered and cleared.                                                 Number.    Total. Vabe of
                                                                                                                          Tonnage. Cargo.


Steam ers.....              ....        ...-..               .    ..   ....       ...   ..    ..     ......          78     11,700
            -
Sailin vessels.. .....................................                                       ...........            217     38, 600....
Received ...........               ..                                                                                      ......-        108,000
                                                                                                                                         $308, 000..................................
Shipped    -..-                                                               .                                                      .     108, 000
        Total ............................................                                           ...........                          416, 000



  A regular steamboat line has been recently established between Derby and New
York, and it is believed that the value of freight received and shipped will be largely
increased during the ensuing year.




                                                                              D 9.
                IMPROVEMENT OF BRIDGEPORT HARBOR, CONNECTICUT.

  This harbor extends nearly 3 miles inland from the north shore of
Long Island Sound, its width of about 1 mile at the mouth decreasing
to 200 feet between opposite wharves at the upper.end.
  The channel, even in the widest part, is comparatively narrow. Be-
fore the first work by the United States was done at this harbor the
depth over the bar was about 5 feet at low water, equivalent to 11.5 feet
at high water.
                                                 PROJECTS FOR IMPROVEMENT.

  In 1871 a project was submitted for a channel 200 feet wide and 14
feet deep at mean low water and for a breakwater from Long Beach to
arrest the littoral movement of sand. As finally adopted, the depth of
the channel was made 12 feet, and a riprap jetty was substituted for
the breakwater. This had been completed in 1882, the channel being
dredged 300 feet wide or more, when a project. was adopted to make a
width of 600 feet between the inner beacon and the Naugatuck Rail-
road Wharf, to be used as a harbor of refuge. The estimated cost was
$60,000, of which $15,000 have been appropriated.
    OPERATIONS DURING THE FISCAL YEAR ENDING JUNE 30, 1886.

[ The funds available were insufficient for continuing the improvement.
  An examination of the harbor was made in September, 1885.
                                   PRESENT CONDITION                                OF IMPROVEMENT.

  The 12-foot channel over the outer bar is but 75 feet wide, the 11-foot
channel is over 200 feet wide. Thence to the inner bar and across
                   APPENDIX D--REPORT                                                OF LIEUT.-COL. HOUSTON.                                                        645
that to the inner beacon the width is 300 feet or more. Above the in-
ner beacon the channel width is 300 to 450 feet, but in many places are
shoals, some with as little as 91 feet depth. Above the Naugatuck
Railroad Wharf this shoaling seems to be all across the channel ; below
that wharf it is principally on the west side.
                                                       PROPOSED OPERATIONS.
  With future appropriations it is proposed to continue the project of
widening the channel between the inner beacon and the Naugatuck
Railroad Wharf, in order to provide a refuge for vessels driven in by
stress of weather without blocking up the main channel. If the shoals
in the upper harbor have increased since the examination of last Sep-
tember, it will be necessary to redredge such places.
  Appropriations for the improvement of Bridgeport Harbor have been
made as follows, viz:

     Date.                                                                   Application.                                                                      Amount.


July     4, 1836      Dredging outer bars ............               ...............................                                   ............               $10, 000
Aug.    30,1852       Dredging outer and inner bars..................                                          ........................                            10, 000
June    23, 1866      Survey ..........   ............                            ...............................                                              Unknown.
July    11, 1870      Survey .          -              .........................................                                                  .. ..        Unknown.
Mar.     3,1871       Dredging and 521 feetol jetty.....................................                                                                ..         20, 000
June    10, 1872      Dredging and 859 feet of jetty ..............                                                   ..................                           40, 000
Mar.     3,1873       Dredging inner bar and upper harbor .....................................                                                                    30, 000
June    23, 1874      Dredging, bridge to Long Island Sound (9 feet) ...............................                                                               20, 000
Mar.     3, 1875      Dredging, bridge to Long island Sound (12 feet)...............                                                            .......            15, 000
Aug.    14, 1876      Dredging upper harbor (9 feet) ......                                                       ................                                 10, 000
June    18, 1878      Dredging above bridge and outer bar (9 and 12 feet) ......................                                                                   10, 000
Mar.     3, 1879      Dredging, bridge to Long Island Sound (12 feet) . ..                                           ..... .............                ..         10, 000
June    14, 1880      Dredging, bridge to Long Island Sound (12 feet) ............................                                                                 10, 000
Mar.     3, 1881      Dredging above inner beacon (12 feet)....................................                                                                    10, 000
Aug.     2, 1882      Dredging between inner beacon and railroad wharf (12 feet) ..............                                                                    10, 000
July     5, 1884      Dredging between inner beacon and railroad wharf (12 feet) ..............                                                                     5, 000
                               Total.............................            ......................................                                                210,000


  Bridgeport, the port of entry for the collection district of Fairfield, is situated
about 2 miles from Long Island Sound, at the head of Bridgeport Harbor.      There is
a light-house at the entrance to the harbor, and Fort Hale, New Haven Harbor, the
nearest work of defense, is 18 miles east.

                                                                  Money statement.
July 1, 1885, amount available..............  .................   ......                                                                                        $792 78
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
   outstanding July 1, 1885..............................................                                                                                         619 30

July 1, 1886, amount available....... ...................................                                                                                         173 48
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886 ..                                                                     ..... ......      ....              20, 000 00

Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887 .................                                                                                       20,173 48

 (Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project........                                                                                      25, 000 00
   Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1888                                                                                 25,000 00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
1   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.



                                                            COMMERCIAL STATISTICS.

The following statement is supplied by the courtesy of the collector of customs:
Foreign commerce:
      Vessels arrived .....                .......            .........           ... ..                ......... .............             ..    10
      Tonnage ......................................-..................                                                                        1,365
      Vessels cleared... ......                        ..............................                                           .... ......        8
      Tonnage.....-                ................                     ..................................                                     1,103
          Value of imports ................                                            ........     ........................                                  $10, 019 56
          Customs collectod ... ...........                                                 ....................             .........                       . $2, 075 55
646          REPORT            OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

]Domestic     commerce:
      Estimated value of cargoes received ...                                  . ...........               ....        ......     $38, 457, 500 00
   Estimated value of cargoes shipped .... ..........................  38, 707, 500 00
    Estimated number of vessels entering harbor for refuge ...... ....           1, 200
For the following statement of domestic commerce, I am indebted to the harbor
master of Bridgeport:
Number of arrivals of vessels:
   Steamers --------------------------------...............--...                                   ------..........................
                                                                                                            ----------.....----..... ----        4,703
   Schooners .----.....----... ----..... ...... ..............                                 ... ..........--            ----......            1, 800
    Sloops----
            .-------...---------..
                               ..---..---....---........---..-----......----........ ..----...--------.... 3,600
    Coal barges and canal boats------...------..................---....-- ------...-                       5, 223
Principal freights received:
     Lumber -----....................                   ..........................- --------                                    eet..       23,785,000
     Coal--............-----------........---------..............................---------------------------...tons..                          214,063
     Iron ......-------....-----..........----....----......-----..------ .....---..----....---....------....  tons.                            18, 541
Other merchandise, principally building and manufacturing materials,
  about......................         -----..................---..........---.... tons..
                                ----....                                                                                                        25,000
  Vessels carrying 209,000 tons of coal took refuge in this harbor during the year.
Two lines of steamers run daily between Bridgeport and New York, anl one line be-
tween Bridgeport and Port Jefferson.




                                                                 D io.

            IMPROVEMENT OF BLACK ROCK HARBOR, CONNECTICUT.

   This harbor, 1- miles long from northeast to southwest and from 300
to 2,500 feet wide, lies between the mainland on the west and Fair-
weather Island on the east, and includes the navigable part of Cedar
Creek, a small tidal inlet which extends up into the western part of the
city of Bridgeport and affords a water communication of great value to
several large manufactories in its immediate neighborhood. It is in the
interest of the city of Bridgeport that the improvement of Black Rock
Harbor is desired.
   The depth in the lower part of the harbor is from 6 to 12 feet at mean
low water, and before work was done in Cedar Creek the depthi was from
2 to 4 feet in a narrow and crooked channel.
   The head of the harbor was separated from Long Island Sound on the
southeast by a broad, flat sand-bar, which was bare at about half tide
and joined Fairweather Island with the main shore.
                                     PROJECTS FOR IMPROVEMENT.

   Between 1836 and 1838, $21,550 were spent in constructing a sea-wall
across a breach in the southern part of Fairweather Island. In 1882 a
survey of the harbor was ordered by Congress, which was made and a
project for improvement was submitted December 12, 1883. This pro-
ject provided, first, for protecting the upper plart of the harbor from the
sea by building a breakwater over the bar north of Fairweather Island,
to be about a half-mile long and 6 feet wide at the top, which was to be
34 feet above mean high water, or 10 feet above low water; second, for
making a'channel 80 feet wide and 6 feet deep at mean low water, about
3,300 feet long, extending up Cedar Creek. The total estimated cost
was $80,000.
   OPERATIONS DURING THE FISCAL YEAR ENDING JUNE 30, 1886.

  Work on the breakwater was in progress at the beginning of the
year, 4,974 tonis of stone having been put into the work. The contract
             APPENDIX          D-REPORT OF LIEUT.-COL. HOUSTON.                                        647

was completed in October, 1885, 5,440 tons being delivered since July 1,
making a total of 10,414 tons under the contract. The breakwater was
built to its full length, 2,744 feet, in order to prevent the current from
cutting a channel over the bar; its cross section is still considerably
less, both in height and width, than projected. The cost of the work
so far done, exclusive of superintendence, is $12,705.08.
   The rate per ton for riprap granite for this work ($1.22) was exceed-
ingly low, being less than one-half the estimated rate.
   An examination of the harbor was made in September, 1885.

                       PRESENT CONDITION                 OF IMPROVEMENT.

  The breakwater to connect Fairweather Island with the mainland is
built to its full length, with diminished cross-section. The channel,
dredged 35 feet wide and 6 feet deep in the spring of 1885, has filled
somewhat, as was expected; it is now navigable at low water to ves-
sels of 44 feet draught. The sea-wall, built in 1836-38 across a breach
near the south end of Fairweather Island, is still effective in keeping
the sea from washing over into the harbor; it needs some repair.

                                   PROPOSED OPERATIONS.

  With future appropriations it is proposed to complete the project for
making a channel 80 feet wide and 6 feet deep at mean low water to ex-
tend up Cedar Creek as far as the Forge Company's dock. This work
could be advantageously completed in one year, and an appropriation
of $20,000 is estimated for that purpose.
  The only appropriation made for improving this harbor was made by
act approved July 5, 1884--$20,000.
  Black Rock Harbor is in the Fairfield collection district, of which Bridgeport is the
port of entry. There is a light-house at the harbor entrance; Fort Hale, New Haven
Harbor, the nearest work of defense, is 20 miles east.

                                          Money statement.
July 1, 1885, amount available ......-............................                               $9,972 76
July 1, 1866, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885.---..--...--..----.........---..--..--...-..-...--..--......-----.      9, 168 56
July 1, 1886, amount available .............. . ...... .... ...... .. ....                            804 20
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886 .....--..----....--...                          5, 000 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887 ...................                         5,804 20
  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project---------55, 000 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1888                     20, 000 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.


Abstract of contractfor improving Black Rock Harbor, Connecticut, in force during fiscal
                               year ending June 30, 1886.


Name and address of         Date.                 Subject.             Price             Remarks.
     contractor.                                                       per ton.           Remarks.

John A. Bonker, New       Mar. 26, 1885   Delivery of riprap granite     $1 22    Completed in October, 1885.
  York, N. Y.
648      REPORT OF THE CHIEF            OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

                             COMMERCIAL STATISTICS.

  For the following statement concerning commerce in the vicinity of Cedar Creek,
Black Rock Harbor, I am indebted to the courtesy of the harbor master at Bridgeport.
  There areten manufacturing Concerns located here, most of them quite large; three
of them report receipts amounting to'21,900 tons; the others would probably increase
this amount to 40,000 tons. Rather more than half of this amount is unloaded at
Bridgeport and hauled to the works; it will all be received at Cedar Creek when the
proposed improvements are completed.




                                      D II.

         IMPROVEMENT OF SOUTHPORT HARBOR, CONNECTICUT.

   This harbor consists of the mouth of a small stream called Mill River,
and of a broad, shallow bay on the north shore of Long Island Sound
about 7 miles west of Bridgeport. Before any Government work was
done on this harbor the navigable low-water depth was less than 2 feet,
and the channel was in danger of becoming quite filled by drift sand
from the beach to the east.
   The mean rise of tide is 6.6 feet.
   A history of work on this harbor up to 1879 may be found in the
Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1879, Part I, page 355.

                       PROJECTS FOR IMPROVEMENT.

   The first project, adopted in 1827, provided for a stone breakwater ex-.
tending southward 1,420 feet from the sand beach on the east side of
the harbor, and for a dike extending 1,450 feet northward from the
head of the breakwater, the object being to confine the water to the
main channel and to prevent sand drifting in from the eastward. This
was completed in 1838.
   In 1875 the breakwater was repaired, and was built 2 feet higher, and
in the same year, after a survey was made, Major Barlow submitted a
project for dredging a channel 50 feet wide and 4 feet deep at mean low
water from the wharves to Long Island Sound. This project, adopted
in 1876, was extended in 1880 so as to make the channel 100 feet wide;
it was virtually completed in 1883, the channel being made 95 feet wide
from Long Island Sound to the end of the breakwater, 80 feet wide
from there to White Rock; above White Rock instead of widening the
channel it was prolonged in a Y at the special request of those interested
in the harbor, there being no reason to the contrary.

   OPERATIONS DURING THE FISCAL YEAR ENDING JUNE 30, 1886.

  No work was done; an examination of the channel was made in Sep-
tember, 1885.

                 PRESENT CONDITION OF IMPROVEMENT.

  The breakwater and dike are both in fair condition, with no urgent
need of repairs. The examination of September last showed that there
had been no material changes in the channel, and that it had an avail-
able depth of 4 feet at mean low water as far as dredged.
                                                                                 S44414 30,1S6.


                                      500                o                      Soo         5050                          200        60




e4AL4
    4
      u.e4A     4*           O .- to w.,a n wv . w                      w t            .O

                ew~~b                        Ro~r,
                                   t~Oc~l/toM~~t                  u~a~L                         ~                   p0
                                                                                                                                               ' r
                                                                                                                                          R j 'I
                 ~o ~cz
                ~ht~cu~       /tiR,           .6i    t                  ~                            5
                                                                                                                                          0




                                                                                 I&Aaani




                     _   .
                                         ..         ._   1   ..     .       .     ..        _   w~




                             oNG                    is             AIV                 o                       su         n     D




                                                                                                         6,0    acca     wp o        44 4
                                                                                                                                                     L c     o




                                                                                                                                W4                         &-4   4-0-i.




         ._r.                                                       I                                                                                                     R~B
                                                                                                                                                                            T,.V
    H Exi pt2 v2 49 2                                                                                                                                          SRAPHIC
                                                                                                                                                       THEAMERIOAN   C
               APPENDIX                     D-REPORT                          OF LIEUT.-COL.                                HOUSTON.                     649

                                                   PROPOSED OPERATIONS.

   The approved project is completed, and no repairs or further im-
provement are required at present.
   Appropriations for improving Southport Harbor have been made as
follows, viz :

    Date.                                                               Application.                                                                Amount.


Mar. 2, 1829      Breakwater, dike, and dredging...........................                                                     ............         $6, 097 00
July 3,1832        Completing breakwatemand dike, building beacons, and a small amount                                                                4,490 23
July 4, 1836        of dredging                                                                                                                       1,500 00
Mar. 3, 1837         of dredging.                                                                                                                     1, 000 00
July 11, 1870     Examination and report.....................................................                                                       Unknown.
Mar. 3, 1875      Repairs on breakwater ..........................                        ...... .-..         .....           ........       ....     5, 000 00
Aug. 14,1876      Repairs on dike and dredging .                    .........           ........................... ..........                        5, 000 00
June 14, 1880     Dredging upper harbor................................................                                                               2, 500 00
Mar. 3, 1881      Dredging on bar .................................                                    .......................                        2, 500 00
Aug. 2, 1882      Dredging upper harbor............................                                         ..................                        3, 000 011

                            Total...................                                                   ..............................                31,087 2&


  Southport Harbor is in the Fairfield collection district, about 6 miles west of Bridge-
port, which is the port of entry. The nearest light-house is on Penfield's Reef, 3J
miles east of the harbor. Fort Hale, New Haven Harbor, 24 miles east, is the nearest
work of defense.
                                                            Money statement.
July 1, 1885, amount available.................................................... $159 07
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885 ......     -...................... ...........    ......  79 47
July 1, 1886, amount available ................................................                                                                         79 60


                                                       COMMERCIAL STATISTICS.

  The following statement of commerce of Southport HarlUor is supplied by the cour-
tesy of the collector of customs at Bridgeport:
Vessels arriving and departing ...........................................                                                                                190
Tonnage..........................................................                                                                                      11,100
Chief articles of commerce:
    Coal ................   ....... ...."..........                                         ...           ...... ........... tons..                     6, 000
     Lumber .... ................   ......................                 ..    ..........    feet.. 150, 000
     Produce and general merchandise : Value of produce, &c., shipped from
       this harbor estimated at ....... .....              .... ..........    ................        225, 000




                                                                          D 12.

              IMPROVEMENT OF NORWALK HARBOR, CONNECTICUT.

  Norwalk Harbor, or River, is a tidal estuary with a narrow channel
extending about 3 miles up from Long Island Sound to the town of
Norwalk; above Norwalk the river is a small fresh-water stream.
South Norwalk is on the west bank of the river, 1J miles below Nor-
walk; at this point the river is crossed by two bridges, the lower one a
wagon bridge, and the other, 450 feet above, the bridge of the New York,
New Haven and Hartford Railroad. In 1867 a company was incorpo-
rated under the laws of the State of Connecticut for the improvement
of this river; little work was done, and when the improvement was un.
dertaken by the United States, the low-water depth to South Norwalk
was a feet, and to Norwalk but 1 foot.
650          REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                                                                    U. S. ARMY.

                                  PROJECTS FOR IMPROVEMENT.

  The first project for improving this harbor was based on a survey
made in 1871; it provided for dredging a channel from Long Island
Sound to the wharves at Norwalk, 100 feet wide and 6 feet deep at
mean low water, at an estimated cost of $34,000.
  In 1881 the project was modified to admit of making a depth of 8 feet
below South Norwalk. The latest estimate, made to include the cost
of this modification and of a large amount of dredging already required
to maintain the channel, places the total cost, from the time of com-
mencement, at $84,000.

   OPERATIONS DURING THE FISCAL YEAR ENDING JUNE                                                                                 30, 1886.
   At the beginning of the fiscal year dredging between Gregory's Point
and the wagon bridge at South Norwalk was in progress, under con-
tract with H. N. Beardsley, dated March 27, 1885, to dredge to 8 feet
depth at mean low water at the rate of 9J cents per cubic yard; 15,464
cubic yards had been removed. The contract was completed July 18,
1885, 19,360 cubic yards additional being dredged, making a total un-
der this contract of 34,824 cubic yards, costinig, exclusive of supervision
and contingencies, $3,438.87. The narrow parts of the 8-foot channel be-
low South Norwalk were widened on the west side by from 40 to 80 feet,
for a distance of about 4,600 feet below the wagon bridge. An exami-
nation of the harbor below South Norwalk was made in September,
1885.
                           PRESENT CONDITION                            OF IMPROVEMENT.

  The channel below South Norwalk, which has been dredged 8 feet
deep and 100 feet wide, is somewhat short of the full dimensions, ow-
ing to mud filling in the old cut on the east side of the channel; it has,
however, the required depth on the west part of the channel. Above
South Norwalk the channel has been made 60 to 100 feet wide and 6
feet deep, and is believed to be in navigable condition.

                                        PROPOSED OPERATIONS.

   The estimated amount required to complete the existing project is
$10.000, which could be advantageously expended in a single year in
widening and straightening the channel.
   Smaller appropriations will be required from time to time to main-
tain the channel after completion.
   Appropriations for the improvement of Norwalk Harbor have been
made as follows, viz:

     Date.                                                   Application.                                                                   Amount.


Mar.    3, 1829   Survey ..........        .....     ........           .............................                             ..... .       $80 00
Mar.    3,1871        .do ....            .. ...     . .        ....       .............                ..................                   1, 166 66
June 10, 1872     Dredging (6fe)        above South Norwalk....... .............................                                            10, 000 00
                                        ..
Mar. 3,1873 .....do.......................  .....................                   ...................                                     10,000 00
June 23, 1874    do     ...............................................             .....................                                   10, 000 00
Mar. 3, 1875 Dredging (6 feet) below South Norwalk ....................................                                                      7, 000 00
June 18,1878      . ....   do...............................................................                                    ......       6,000 00
Mar. 3,1879        Dredging     (6 feet) above and below South Norwalk ...............       ..............   . 10, 000                            00
June 14,1880       Dredging      (8 feet) below South Norwalk .............       ............      .........    5,000                             00
Mar. 3, 1881       Dredging      (8 feet) below, and (6 feet) above South Norwalk..................              5, 000                            00
Aug. 2,1882       Dredging     (6 feet) above South Norwalk..............           ...... ...........          5, 000                            00
July    5,1884     Dredging (8 feet) below South Norwalk ..................................                                                  5, 000 00
                           Total..........         .......        ..........                     ..............              ......         74, 246 66
                   APPENDIX               D-REPORT                   OF LIEUT.-COL.                    HOUSTON.                      651
  Norwalk is in the Fairfield collection district, and is about 11 miles west of Bridge-
port. Norwalk light-house is on Sheffield's Island, at the entrance to the harbor. The
nearest works of defense are the fortifications at Throg's Neck, 29 miles west.

                                                       Money statement.
July 1, 1885, amount available...--........................---.....---......                                                 $3, 713 34
July 1, 1-86, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885.------. ..---..----.----.-           ..... .. ...- .                                                2,960 12

July 1, 1886, amount available ..-..----.........  ---................-- ..---.                                                 753 22
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886 --..--....--..--........                                                   3,000 00

Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887 -...................                                                    3,753 22

   SAmount        (estimated) required for completion of existing project..--------......
    Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1888
                                                                                                                              7,000 00
                                                                                                                              7, 000 00
    Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
      harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.



Abstract of contract for improving Norwalk Harbor, Conn., in force during the fiscal year
                                  ending June 30, 1886.


         Name and address of contractor.                             Date.             Subject.          Price per           Remark.


H. N. Beardsley, Bridgeport, Conn ........                      Mar. 27,1885        Dredging...                $0. 09      Completed
                                                                                                                          Jul3 18, 1885.


                                                  COMMERCIAL             STATISTICS.

  The following statement of commerce of Norwalk Harbor is furnished by courtesy
of the collector of customs at Bridgeport:
Vessels arriving and departing:
    Steamers----     ......--------....---......--------......--------..---------........---....----......................            1,660
    Sailing vessels-------    .......-----......---------....-----...---------....--......-......--......-------....---....      --      590
    Barges .----... ----....--...............--------------.. ---......                  ..----....-----..... ---.......-----...         550
Freights received:
    Coal.......---------.... --......---......
                                          -------...--..--- ----------....-----......---                  ........       tons..     108, 240
    Iron- ......                    .       ....        .         .      .      ..                      ---...           do....       5,280
    Lumber .-------------------------------......                                 -----------....                   ---- feet.. 37,871,947
    General merchandise ............                                 ..........                          .       ......  tons..      64, 278
Freights shipped :
    Lumber------ ......---------......------.....---------....---...........................-----------...                feet..     4P, 000
    Ice ...-----------------------...----------------------...                                                           tons..      15,000
    General merchandise ..                                   .......               ..              ....                  do....      58,530




                                                                  D I3.

               IMPROVEMENT OF PORT CHESTER HARBOR, NEW YORK.

   This harbor consists of the lower part of the Byram River and of a
bay at its mouth which opens into Long Island Sound. This part of the
river is the dividing line between the States of New York and Connecti-
cut. It is navigable up to the Port Chester Bridge, a little miore than
a mile above its mouth. Before improvement the depth below the
wharves was in some places as little as 1 foot at mean low water. The
mean rise of tide is 7.4 feet.
652         REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

                                  PROJECTS FOR                  IMPROVEMENT.

  The first project, adopted in 1871, provided for the removal of two
rocks: Sunken Rock, at the entrance to the bay, with 5.7 feet low-water
depth, to be removed to 11 feet depth, and Salt Rock, about 1,000 feet
above the river's mouth, partly bare at low water, to be removed to 9
feet depth; also a breakwater 400 feet long at Byram Point, estimated
to cost as follows:
Sunken Rock, 1,474.5 cubic yards, at $40 ....                 ..........    ........                               $58, 980
Salt Rock, 316.3 cubic yards, at $40.......................................                                         12, 652
Breakwater at Byram Point ............            ...... ..... ..... ......                       ....... . ....    25, 000
        Total ......---......------......----------....--....--......---................----....-----..........     96,632
  Under this project Salt Rock was removed. No further work was
done until 1884, when a survey of the channel was made under appro-
priation of August 2, 1882, and a project for making it from 60 to 100
feet wide and 3 feet deep at mean low water from the bay to the vicinity
of the wharves was submitted and approved. This channel was com-
pleted in May, 1885.
   OPERATIONS DURING THE FISCAL YEAR ENDING JUNE 30, 1886.

  Examinations made in October, 1885, and in April, 1886, showed that
there were some lumps in the channel near the mouth of the river, and
that the irregularities of the previous dredging have not leveled them-
selves off as was expected. Citizens interested in the harbor laid great
stress upon the importance of making the channel bottom along the dock
front level, because their vessels lie aground at low tide. Therefore,
with the approval of the Chief of Engineers, it was decided to spend the
remainder of the appropriation in removing these lumps and in straight-
ening and leveling the channel in front of the wharves, as well as ex-
tending it to the bridge. It was difficult to estimate the cost per cubic
yard of such work, and a dredge with necessary appliances was hired
under contract.
  Advertisement was made, proposals were opened May 8, and a con-
tract dated May 15, 1886, was entered into with M. K. Pidgeon, of New
York, for furnishing a suitable dredge, tug, scows, with crews and nec-
essary appliances, at the rate of $83 per day of ten hours.
   Up to the close of the fiscal Sear 3,096 cubic yards of sand and gravel
had been removed in 2954 hours' work, straightening and leveling the
channel in the river, and removing lumps from the channel, both in the
river and in the bay. The work is still in progress.
                         PRESENT CONDITION                       OF IMPROVEMENT.

  Salt Rock has been effectually removed; no work has been done upon
Sunken Rock. An available channel 2) feet deep at,mean low water
and nearly 10 feet at high water, has been made up to the upper wharves.
The completion of the present contract will leave this channel 40 feet
wide, with the bottom as nearly level as may be.
                                         PROPOSED OPERATIONS.

  The removal of Sunken Rock to a depth of 11i feet at mean low water
will be undertaken in accordance with the project when funds are ap-
propriated for that purpose. No other improvement of this harbor
seems to be required at present.
              APPENDIX                 D--REPORT                             OF LIEUT.-COL. HOUSTON.                                                                653

Appropriations for the improvement of Port Chester Harbor: New
York, have been made as follows, viz:

      Date.                                                               Application.                                                                           Amount.

June 10, 1872 .-      Removing Salt Rock. -$12,                                                                                                                         000
August 2, 1882.       Dredging in Byram River ................                              ....................
                                                                                                             .-.                 ....           ......              15, 000

                            Total .....................-----------------------------------------------....-------......                                             27,000



  Port Chester Harbor is in the collection district of New York. The nearest light-
house is on Great Captain's Island, 1 miles east of the mouth of the harbor. The
nearest work of defense is at Throg's Neck, about 15 miles southwest.

                                                       Money statement.
July 1, 1885, amount available.... ........                 -....
                                                             ..... ......  ............    $4,913 18
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1885----------.   ...---------.              $2, 403 56
July 1, 1886, outstanding liabilities ...................          .......          942 54
                                                                                            3,346 10
July 1,1886, amount available                          ..----....................................                                                                1,567 08

  SAmount     (estimated) required for completion of existing project....
   Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1888
                                                                                                                                            ....             69, 632 00
                                                                                                                                                                20, 000 00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
     harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.



Abstract of proposals for dredge, scows, tug, and necessary appliances for dredging in Port
                     Chester Harbor, New York, opened May 8, 1886.


                                                                                                                                                                Rate per
No.                                         Name and address of bidders.                                                                                        day of 10
                                                                                                                                                                 working
                                                                                                                                                                  hours.

  1   The Hartford Dredging Company, Hartford, Conn ..................................                                                                             $125 00
  2   M. K. Pidgeon, 60 South street, New York ......................................                                                                                83 00


   Contract entered into with M. K. Pidgeon, May 15, 1886,                                                         in progress.

                                                  COMMERCIAL STATISTICS.

The following statistics of commerce are kindly furnished by Mr. William P.
Abendroth, of Port Chester:

                                    ARRIVALS AND DEPARTURES                                  OF VESSELS.
Steamers.     ....       .......    ....     ......     ..............................                                 ......          .       .        ....         156
Tow-boats, &c......    ...... ............................         ...................                                                                                 150
Barges, canal-boats, &c...... ..............................              ............                                                                                 140
Sailing vessels..........................................................                                                                                           . 167
Total tons of freight received and shipped .......................          ...........                                                                            81, 000
   The chief articles of commerce are iron, coal, building materials, manufactures, and
general merchandise.
654     REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.


                                   D 14.

      IMPROVEMENT OF HARBOR AT NEW ROCHELLE, NEW YORK.

   New Rochelle Harbor is situated at the western end of Long Island
Sound, on its north shore, about 10 miles west of the boundary line
between the States of New York and Connecticut. The harbor lies off
the southerly part of the town of New Rochelle, and Echo Harbor' is off
the northerly part.
   New Rochelle Harbor consists of rather narrow and circuitous pas-
sages between several rocky islands and reefs, which shelter it from
rough weather. It had originally an available depth, of 8 to 9 feet at
mean low water; there were two rocks near the channel-way whose re-
itoval was desired, and the narrowness of the deep-water channel ren-
dered it difficult for vessels to turn.
                     PROJECTS FOR IMPROVEMENT.

   Up to 1880 Echo Harbor was the port for New Rochelle. In that year
a survey was ordered and made, and in the report of January 28, 1881, a
project for improvement was submitted, contemplating the removal of
Corning Rock to 12 feet depth, of Rock C to 9 feet depth, the dredging of a
channel 100 feet wide and 8 feet deep at mean low water around the
south end of Glen Island to connect with the channel around the north
end of that island, and the removal of about 300 cubic yards of a reef
at the entrance to this dredged channel, at an estimated cost of $40,825.
The object of the dredging was to allow vessels to pass around the island
instead of having to turn in the narrow channel. No modification of
this project has been made. In 1881 the channel around Glen Island
was dredged 100 feet wide and 6 feet deep, and work was begun under a
contract to remove the reef at the channel entrance to 8 feet depth. This
contract provided for payment of $9,000, to be made only when the reef
was removed to the required depth. The contract was twice extended,
and in 1883 work was abandoned by the contractor while parts of the
,rock were still from 1 to li feet above the plane of removal. In 1883
Corning Rock was removed to 12 feet depth by hired labor, at a cost of
abott $34 per cubic yard; a large bowlder was removed from near Da-
vid's Island wharf, and 10.6 cubic yards of loose rock were removed
from the reef at the entrance to the dredged channel, making a depth
of 7.5 feet there.
  OPERATIONS DURING       THE FISCAL YEAR ENDING JUNE 30,           1886.
  No work has been done.      An examination of the channel dredged in
1881 was made.
               PRESENT CONDITION       OF IMPROVEMENT.

   An examination last fall showed that the dredged channel retained
its depth of 6 feet at mean low water. The depth over the reef at the
entrance to this channel is 7.5 feet. Corning rock has been removed to
a depth of 12 feet, and is no longer a source of danger. No work has
been done upon Rock C.
                        PROPOSED OPERATIONS.

   It is proposed to apply the funds now available towards the comple-
tion of the project, of which the following remains to be done:
   (1) Removal of Rock C to a 9-foot depth.
                          _                          -L~~----~_                        __ ------- ----                                                          . ------- ---- ---
                                                                                                                                                            ----------                                                           --



                           erev          ,o4         cj'eec         C            t&,       to~




                                                *s/n.!




                           atwSc~f a                                               OV
                                                                             O.A '~ee


                                                 5    C~Q      0,       18   8    6


                          trrrrt                                        X.t------                                 i9




                                                                                                                                                                                             10.i




M   t   -r*   +   Vlrr       J     .   tr     ccQ    fALrel            O    ,0114     r     7sran   .




                                                                                                                                                                                                    \   ..     '
  of tt4
C,     / t4
      'm~ox'~t            &~w      4O  ttQ
                                   W-o-tult.,         d47to                                                                                                                                                          '



                                                                                                                                                                                                                     c.




                                                                                                                                                                                                    '    /                   l



                                                                                                                                                                                             //


                                                                                                                                                                                             /      /




                                                                                                                                              8.Z




                                                                                                                       "                                     20                                              /"7

                                                                                                                                       '4'6


                                                                                                                                              MACHAUX aOCK
                                                                                                                  15.x.




                                                                                                                                                    i*-iN
                                                                                                                                  ig~e              ,




                                                                                                     12'                                                                  \("'


                                                                                                            23.
                                                                                                                                                                        2''




                                                                                                                                  i.     o




                                                                                                           SwrEPS12
                                                                                                                                               l        O ESLNUZIE
                                                                                                             62.                         \\     ,




                                                                                                             SI5.




                                                                                                                                                                                 /

                                                                                                                           35




                                                                                                                            157




                                                                                                                                15 .

                                                                                                                                                                  12'




                                                                                                                                                                                     inwd.       e~e of!           &11~L1L




                                                                                                                                                                                                  THE AMERICAN GRAPHIC CO.,N.Y.

H Ext pt2 v2 49 2
             APPENDIX D-REPORT OF LIEUT.-COL. HOUSTON.                                                               655

   (2) Making the dredged channel 8 feet deep. It is now 6 feet.
   (3) Deepening the reef at the entrance to the dredged channel to 8
feet. It has already been removed to 7.5 feet.
  The sum of $5,825, in addition to the amount available, is estimated to
complete this project.
   Appropriations for the improvement of New Rochelle Harbor have
been made as follows, viz:

        Date.                                               Application.                                        Amount.


March 3, 1881 ......    Dredging and partial removal of rock at mouth of Glen Island Channel                        $20, 000
August 2, 1882......    Removal of Corning Rock ...........................................--------- ------------    15, 000

      Total--.----
      Total .........          -------------------                .....          ---            .. -----.      !... 35,004
                                                                                                                    35,000

  New Rochelle Harbor is in the collection district of New York. The nearest light-
house is on Execution Rock. The fortifications at Throg's Neck, 7 miles west, are the
nearest works of defense.

                                                     Money statement.

July 1, 1885, amount available .--............--..............                                 .. --. $18, 210 61
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885-----.... ...-----...--.....--....--..-----....-..--..--..---...--......         704 24

July 1,1886, amount available------                                --------
                             ......----....---...--...........----------....                                  17, 506 37

Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project----------..........                             5, 825 00
  Submitted in compliancewith requirements of section 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.



                                               COMMERCIAL STATISTICS.

  The chief articles of commerce are coal, lumber, building materials, &c., for local
use. A market steamer makes about 150 trips per year to and from New York, and
about 250 sailing vessels enter per year.
  Glen Island, New Rochelle Harbor, is a popular resort in summer, and excursion
steamers make hourly trips to and from New York.
  This includes the commerce of Echo Harbor, where most of the freight is received.




                                                          D i5.

      IMPROVEMENT OF ECHO HARBOR, NEW ROCHELLE, NEW YORK.

  This is a bay on the north shore of Long Island Sound, about 22 miles'
by water from the Battery at New York.
  It is landlocked except on the southeast, and has a good anchorage;
until the beginning of the improvement of New Rochelle Harbor, in
1881, it was the only port of the town of New Rochelle. The depth in
the bay varies from 6 to 15 feet at mean low water, though the low-water
channel up to the wharves is only from 1 to 2 feet deep.
  The mean rise of the tide is 7.3 feet.
656            REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

                                      PROJECTS FOR IMPROVEMENT.

The first project, submitted December 20, 1875, provided for the re-
moval of two rocky reefs from the channel, viz:
(1) Sheepshead Reef, lying midway between Echo Island and Duck Point,
    which had 1.6 feet of water upon it at low tide. This was to be removed
    to a depth of 9 feet at low water, which required the excavation of 872.5
      cubic yards of rock, costing-----------------------------...............................--                                  $21, 201 75
(2) Start Rock, which projected about 2 feet above low water, and lay in
    the channel 120 feet from Beaufort Point. This was to be removed to 6
    feet below low water, requiring the excavation of 370 cubic yards of
    rock, costing.----...--- ..------------.---..-------. -----------...                                                              12,672 50
Contingencies .---..----------------..................-------------..........--...------..................                             5,01 13
         Total......---....-----------.. .....--.-------......---         --......-----....----....---....--......-----....--..       38,955 38
  A modification of the project made in 1878, provides for removing
Start Rock to 7 feet depth instead of 6 feet. This depth over Start
Rock was gained in January, 1880, and in 1881-'83 506 cubic yards were
removed from the southern part of Sheepshead Reef, making 9 feet
depth.
    OPERATIONS DURING THE FISCAL YEAR ENDING JUNE 30, 1886.

    The money available was not enough to continue the projected work
and nothing was done.                          An examination of the rocks in the harbor was
made in October, 1885.

                           PRESENT CONDITION OF IMPROVEMENT.

    Start Rock has been removed to the required depth, 7 feet, at mean
low water, and about one-half of Sheepshead Reef has been removed
to 9 feet depth. The condition of the channel is otherwise about the
same as before the improvement, no other work having been done.
                                            PROPOSED OPERATIONS.

  With future appropriations the removal of Sheepshead Reef will be
completed. Twenty-two thousand dollars have been appropriated for
this project; with the balance of the estimate, $17,000, the project could
be advantageously completed in a single year.
  Appropriations for improving Echo Harbor, New Rochelle, N. Y., have
been made as follows, viz:

             Date.                                                   Application.                                                     Amount.

June 18, 1878............. Removal of Start Rock ....- ..............................                                                    $10, 000
March 3, 1879.................----     do .-------.   ..............-- ....         .......................--                              3, 000
June 14, 1880.............        Removal of Sheepshead Rock-                  ..
                                                                            --...           ........          .......                      3, 000
March 3, 1881..................do          ...------------------------------------------....                                      .        3,000
August 2, 1882........ ...         ......--...... ...  ..........   ..... ..... .......................---....                             3, 000

        Total...................................----------------......---------------------.........                                      22, 000


  Echo Harbor is in the collection district of New York. The nearest light-house is
on Execution Rock. The fortifications at Throg's Neck, 7 miles to the westward, are
the nearest works of defense.

                                           COMMERCIAL STATISTICS.

  The commerce of this harbor is that of New Rochelle, and is included
in the statement for New Rochelle Harbor.
            APPENDIX        D-REPORT                  OF LIEUT.-COL. HOUSTON.                657
                                     Money statement.
July 1, 1885, amount available         ............
                                             ----            ---.     -.-   ..---.       $3,361 87
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885--.....-------...
                                       ...........................---......                 105 00
July 1, 1886, amount available .--..............---...       ......   ...........    .    3,256 87

  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1888             17, 000 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.



                                                  D 16.

           IMPROVEMENT OF MAMARONECK HARBOR, NEW YORK.

   Mamaroneck Harbor, on the north shore of Long Island Sound, about
5 miles west of the Connecticut State line, consists of an open, shallow
bay and a narrow tidal-inlet about a mile long. The channel to the old
steamboat wharf (about half-way up the inlet) had a depth of 5 feet at
mean low water; from there to the upper wharves the depths gradually
decreased to 1 foot. Near its mouth the inlet was obstructed by several
rocks. The mean rise of tide at Mamaroneck is about 8 feet.

                           PROJECTS FOR IMPROVEMENT.

  A survey of the harbor was made in 1881, and a project for improve-
ment was submitted and adopted providing for the removal of Round
Rock to a depth of 4 feet and five other rocks to a depth of 7 feet; for
dredging a channel 7 feet deep and 100 feet wide from the sound to the
old steamboat wharf, and thence, 4 feet deep and 80 feet wide, to the
upper wharves, and for closing the small channel east of Grassy Knoll,
at an estimated cost of $43,000. In 1881 Round Rock was removed to
a depth of 4 feet, and Bush Rock and Inner Steamboat Rock to 7 feet
at mean low water, at a cost of $13,000, not including supervision and
contingencies.

   OPERATIONS DURING THE FISCAL YEAR ENDING JUNE 30, 1886.

  The available funds were not sufficient to continue work under the
project. An examination of part of the harbor was made in October,
1885.
                   ,PRESENT CONDITION OF IMPROVEMENT.

  The available depth of channel has not changed since the original
survey. The removal of three rocks has made the upper harbor much
easier and safer of access.

                               PROPOSED OPERATIONS.

  It is proposed, when funds are appropriated for the purpose, to com-
plete the existing project by removing the other dangerous rocks and
by dredging in the channel. This could be completed to advantage in
a single year.
        42 E
658         REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

  Appropriations for improving Mamaroneck Harbor have been made
as follows, viz:

    Date.                                                    Application.                                                                             Amount.

Mar.   3,1881   Survey ..................                                    .....           ......................                                       $500
Aug.   2,1882   Removal of rocks......        ..................................                                               ....... ....   ...       15, 000

                       Total..............................                                          .....................                       ---     15, 500


   Mamaroneck Harbor is in the collection district of New York; its commerce is mainly
of local importance. The nearest light-house is on Execution Rock, about 4 miles south;
the fortifications at Throg's Neck, 9 miles southwest, are the nearest works of defense.

                                              Money statement.
July 1, 1885, amount available .........................................                                                                              $301 23
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885...............                               ......       ............                     ......           ....             77 00

July 1, 1886, amount available ................................                                                                     .....              224 23
SAmount (estimated) required for completion of existing project ........                                                                           28,000 00
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1888                                                                          28,000 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.


                                            COMMERCIAL STATISTICS.

  I am indebted to the collector of customs at New York for the following informa-
tion about the commerce of Mamaroneck.
  No record is kept of the arrival and departure of vessels. A market steamer makes
about 150 trips per year to and from New York. About 150 vessels of different kinds
arrive per year with domestic cargoes.



                                                              D        i7.

                IMPROVEMENT OF GREENPORT HARBOR, NEW YORK.

  This harbor is a roadstead near the east end of Long Island, lying
between the north prong of Long Island on the nothwest and Shelter
Island on the southeast and south. Its anchorage ground is exposed to
storms from the northeast and east. A sand-spit, called Joshua's Point,
formerly protected the little bay at Greenport from easterly storms, but
of late years this has worn away rapidly, and the sand has been carried
into the bay. The mean rise of tide is 2.4 feet.

                                 PROJECT FOR IMPROVEMENT.

  In 1881 a survey was ordered, and, with the report, a plan and esti-
mates were submitted for a breakwater extending southeasterly from
Joshua's Point. This project, as adopted, consisted of a riprap break-
water, about 1,700 feet long, extending from high-water mark to the 18-
foot curve; to be built 3 feet above mean high-water level, with top
width of 5 feet and side slopes of 1 on 1, and to contain about 23,000 tons
of stone. Its estimated cost was $46,000. Work under this project.was
begun in 1883, and in that and the two following years 1,233 linear feet
of the breakwater were built.
                                                                                                                                                                                                                             ~1                                                                                                                  m




                                             O         N
                                  A




                                                                                                                                                               3j4n4 30, 1$S6.

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             4e       otee1   Caps
                                                                                                                                                              5 .c . .                                                                                                                          Slip       RoeK




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 so
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        we

                                                                        ROCK   (REMOVED)




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 J3v)    i 4 tAOf*4&   0440            4
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           ,o.



                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           1                                                                                        J




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           1              '/2                     1_                                            3

                      .       -



                                         .




                                                                                6-'6.6~I)NNER     STEAMBOAT R.
                                                                                             (R~r
                                                                                                R-OVEKO)                                        PoP'S         ROCKS
                                                                                                                                            iri
                                                                                   5.0
                                                                                         "';LITTLE        NANHODI

                                                                                         NABIS   N   NHOOK



                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         LHEN

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         ISLAND
                                                                                                                                            8.5                                              8.4
                                                                                                                                                               3




                                                                                                                                                                                                   9.2      S9.
                                                                                    / f .9
                                                                                   .;"k                                               )ouTrER      STEAMBOAT             R.
                                                                                    /I
C) .   n          ,ovrv
                  4  44   X                      S.   4fl
                                                                                                                93-
                                                                                    6
                                                                                                                                                        0.I                                                       It.%




                                                                                                         i0.5
                                                                                                                                                                                   It.   "                                                rI..5
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        9,                  H
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        c

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        Q
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        C)
                                                                                                            t         t..T                t.4                                   r""-




                                                                                                           BSLACK            TOM"------                                                      '"
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  -   '

                                                                                                     1

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                y.4
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                y
                                                                                                                         +3.1
                                                                                                                                                                         13.2


                                                                                                                                                                                                  I NRN
                                             QC*"AA               sk.     .

                                                                                                 L         O            N        G                                                       SI-I        P    ROCK
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  ,9.2                          7
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                WEST     ROCK
                                  ob;~                      r;o   Ipj
                                                                                                                                                                                A4 N                                                                          l4L




                                                                                                                                                                                                                         S    O           U               N         D
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 $AUII6_RCO,.              ...



       Hxt            24
H   EX-1   -pt2   v2          49         2                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       THE      G RAPtI
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    AMERICAN            CO.,N.Y
                       APPENDIX                      D -REPORT                         OF LIEUT.-COL. HOUSTON.                                                  659
      OPERATIONS DURING THE FISCAL YEAR ENDING JUNE 30, 1886.

  The available funds were insufficient to continue construction, and no
work was done. An examination of the harbor was made in September,
1885.
                                      PRESENT                   CONDITION                        OF IMPROVEMENT.

  The breakwater has been made 1,233 feet long, which carries it out
to a depth of 10.5 feet at mean low water. Eleven thousand three hun-
dred and seventy-three tons of riprap granite have been used in its con-
struction. It is in good condition as far as completed. No material
changes of depth in the harbor have occurred since the original survey.

                                                           PROPOSED OPERATIONS.

  With future appropriations the breakwater will be completed, as pro-
jected, to the 18-foot curve. Twenty thousand dollars have been ap-
propriated for this work; the remainder of the estimate, $26,000, could
be profitably expended in completing the breakwater in one year.
  Appropriations for improving Greenport Harbor, New York, have
been made as follows, viz :

        Date.                                                                     Application.                                                               Amount.


Mar.        3, 1881 Survey...---.-----......---...-.....-------.....-------...................-------------------....-------..........--.......---.  --           $500
Aug.        2,1882 Expended on breakwater ...................                                     ........ .....        ..-....        .....--.......   .       10, 000
July        5, 1884 ...... do --.--.------...----.....-------.......----......-----.......-------..........---------------------......................          10, 000
                                    Total--....---. ---....               --. ----------......         ... ...--    -----.....            .........             20, 500


   Greenport is a port of delivery in the collection district of Sag Harbor. The nearest
light-house is on Long Beach Point, 3 miles to the eastward. The nearest work of
defense in Fort Trumbull, New London Harbor, Connecticut, 21 miles distant in a
straight line.
                                                                    Money statement.
July 1, 1885, amount available........----....------------------...--...-----.........                                                                       $300 78
July 1, 1886, amount available .............                                                     ..-.. -           ---..
                                                                                                           ....................                               300 78
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886 ...................                                                                                      5, 000 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887 ...---...........----                                                                           .     5, 300 78

      Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project ........                                                                              21,000 00
      Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1888                                                                            21, 000 00
      Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
  (     harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.



                                                               COMMERCIAL STATISTICS.

  The following statement of commerce of Greenport Harbor is furnished by the court-
esy of the surveyor of customs at that port:


                                                           Class.                                                                 Arrivals.               Departures.


Steamers .................................................................                                                              1, 828                   1, 830
Sailing-vessels ............................................................                                                            1, 120                   1, 125



      Chief articles of commerce, fishing products and local supplies.
660            REPORT                 OF        THE            CHIEF                 OF           ENGINEERS, U.         S. ARMY.


                                                                                D         I8.

            IMPROVEMENT OF PORT JEFFERSON HARBOR, NEW YORK.

   This harbor is a large landlocked bay, on the north side of Long
Island, in a direct line about 60 miles east of New York, and nearly
opposite Bridgeport, Conn. Its high-water area, with that of its shallow
tributaries, Setauket Harbor and Conscience Bay, is about 2J square
miles, and the width of the outlet is but 450 feet.  Port Jefferson lies
at the head of the harbor, nearly 2 miles from the outlet, and there is a
depth of 12 feet or more at low water to within 300 feet of the wharves,
over nearly the whole width of the harbor. Originally there was a bar
just outside the outlet, with a depth of 3 feet at mean low water, over
which the tide ebbed and flowed very rapidly.
                                             PROJECTS FOR IMPROVEMENT.

   A survey of the harbor was made in 1853, but the first work done was
under a project submitted in 1871 for building a breakwater or jetty on
the east side of the entrance, and for dredging a channel 200 feet wide
and 7 feet deep. This jetty was built 1,052 feet long in 1873, and in
1875, under a modification of the project, a similar jetty was begun on
the west side of the entrance. In 1877 the project was again modified
so as to increase the depth of the contemplated channel from 7 to 8
feet, and to reduce the width from 200 to 100 feet. From that date until
1883 both jetties have been extended, and the channel of the projected
dimensions has been dredged.
    OPERATIONS DURING THE FISCAL YEAR ENDING JUNE                                                                                     30, 1886.
No work was done.                                        An examination of the harbor was made in
November, 1885.
                         PRESENT CONDITION OF THE IMPROVEMENT.

   The east jetty is 1,390 feet long, ending in 10 feet of water; the west
jetty is 940 feet long, ending in 6.5 feet of water. Both jetties are in
fair condition.   The dredged channel retains nearly its depth of 8 feet
at mean low water.
                                                     PROPOSED OPERATIONS.

   The amount estimated for the completion of the project was reached
by the last appropriation, made August 2, 1882, and the project itself
is completed. Whether the depth gained will be permanent or not can
only be told by time. No further operations are proposed at present.
   Appropriations for improving Port Jefferson Harbor, New York, have
been made as follows, viz:

     Date.                                                                     Application.                                                             Amount.

Mar.     3, 1871     Applied to east jetty ......-...................................................                                                    $15, 000
June 10, 1872       ...... do .......................................................                                       .    .            .           15, 000
Mar. 3,1875          Applied to east and west jetties ....................................                                                                15, 000
Aug. 14, 1876        Applied to east jetty and dredging .......                            ...................                               ..            6, 000
June 18, 1878        Applied to both jetties .................. .....            .......--            ---..-...-.....                          .           8, 000
Mar. 3, 1879         Applied to dredging ......                          ............................                           .........                  5, 000
June 14, 1880        Applied to both jetties . .                           .........................................                        .........      3, 000
Mar. 3, 1881 Applied to east jetty.............                               ........................                 .............    ..                . 4, 000
Aug. 2, 1882 ...... do ..............................................................                                              .......                  8,000
                             Total ...................................................................                                                    79, 000
                                                                                                                               1*q   ta~           aow              m'e fl       M




                               )/$




                             SCALE          OF
                                               30,




                                                     FEET7
                                                          185         6
                                                                                                                 /
a0    o   e o   34 e    0ag o joo                                 546                            to




            ~O~XN~o~~qg         tgrmeavv             ow         ''u'.dtet              ~a3                                -1               -   -         '   ---;                          --;~--
                 9Thw-wt~~'            t~                 ~               e..6.22, .i''.
                                       L.                           GL4           T.                  Lt.




                               I           L         ON                   G            151 -A                    N
                                                                                                                      O


                        18,                                                                                                                        ,Y Q
                                     , -                         --
                                ...- -         -              . . --
                                                   ..- -         - -- --- --
                                                             ..           .. ..
                                                     .... ..
                                       ..
                                 .=
                       9 ...
                                                                                                                                                         "                            i$


     /            6




                                                                                                                                                                             9   ..




                                                                                             .
                                                                                       l
                                                                                       6
                                                                                        I
                                                                                            ;




                                                                                                            HA
                                                                                                                     FA



                                                                                                                                                             THE AMERICkN GAPHIC CD.,N.Y,
     (i ExI pl2 v2 49 2
                APPENDIX                  D--REPORT                      OF LIEUT.-COL. HOUSTON.                                     661
   Port Jeffers.on is a port of delivery in the collection district of New York. There
is a light-house on Old Field Point, 1+ miles west of the harbor entrance. Fort Hale,
New Haven Harbor, Connecticut, 23 miles distant, is the nearest work of defense.
                                                         Money statement.
July 1, 1885, amount available ...----............ --..--..----.....- -............... $475 06
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885 ----..----............. .----..............--......--....     90 70

July 1, 1886, amount available.----..--..--....                                  ..........................               .....    384 36



                                                   COMMERCIAL                STATISTICS.


   The following facts, relating to commerce at Port Jefferson, are furnished by the
surveyor of customs, forwarded through the collector at New York:
   Chief articles of commerce: Wood, hay, and garden produce.
   "There are about 3,000 tons of coal landed here in a year. Hundreds of yachts and
coasting vessels put in here during the year for refuge. There is a steamer running
from here to Bridgeport, making one and a half trips daily."
   Sixty-seven vessels, net tonnage 6,415, are enrolled at this port.




                                                                     D        g9.

                       IMPROVEMENT OF FLUSHING BAY, NEW YORK.

   Flushing Bay is on the north shore of Long Island, about 14 miles
by water from the Battery at New York. The town of Flushing is on
the east bank of Flushing Creek, a quarter of a mile from the head of
the bay. The bay is about a mile wide and 2 miles long; the bottom is
of soft mud, nearly level, the depth in the original channel being not
much greater than elsewhere. In 1861 there was a depth of 5 feet at
low water in the channel leading up to Flushing, and in 1879 but 3.9
feet. The mean rise of tide is 7.1 feet.
                                       PROJECTS FOR IMPROVEMENT.

   A survey of Flushing Bay was made in 1879, and a project for im-
provement was proposed and adopted, providing for the construction
of dikes extending across the westerly part of the mouth of the bay and
up on the west side of the channel to Flushing, in order to form a large
tidal basin whose waters should ebb and flow through a narrow chan-
nel, with dredging to maintain a channel 6 feet deep at mean low
water.
   The estimated cost of carrying out this project was as follows:
Constructing        4,400 linear feet of pile-dike, at $10 per foot ..        ............ $44, 000
Constructing        7,800 linear feet of pile-dike, at $9 per foot. ..................      70,200
Constructing        900 linear feet of pile-dike, at $7.50 per foot..................        6, 750
Constructing         3,600 linear feet of single piling, at $3.70 per foot............. 13, 320
For 83,000 cubic yards dredging, at 20 cents per cubid yard ...............                                                       16,600
Contingencies....... ..... ...... ........  ..................................                                                    22,630

       Total....-----.............---------------...--..----------......-----......              --------..............           173,500
  All the timber work of the dikes was to be creosoted. Up to June
30, 1880, 3,057 linear feet of pile-dike were constructed on the west side
of the channel from the head of the bay.                                                   Subsequent appropriations
have been expended in dredging.
662           REPORT OF               THE CHIEF                 OF      ENGINEERS, U.                    S. ARMY.

     OPERATIONS DURING THE FISCAL YEAR ENDING JUNE .30, 1886.

  No dredging nor dike construction was done, the available funds be-
ing insufficient. In August, 1885, 3 barrel beacons were placed on the
dike to mark its position at extreme high water; cost, $120.50.
  An examination of the bay was made in October, 1885.

                          PRESENT CONDITION OF IMPROVEMENT.

  Of the proposed 16,700 linear feet of dike 3,057 feet have been built.
The channels leading up the bay to the wharves have been twice
dredged. At the time of the examination in October last they were in
good condition, with an available depth of 6 feet.

                                          PROPOSED OPERATIONS.

   Until the dikes are completed dredging will be needed frequently,
probably annually, to maintain the channel.       If appropriations are
made more than is urgently needed for dredging, it is proposed to con-
tinue the construction of dikes as provided for in the project.
   Appropriations for improving Flushing Bay, New York, have been
made as follows, viz:

      Date.                                                 Application.                                                   Amount.

Mar. 3, 1879       Construction of dike ........................................................            $20, 000
June 14, 1880      Dredging ........................                     ......                 ............15, 000
                                                                              ......................
M ar. 3,1881      ....do ........------.....          .......   .....                      .......---........ 10,000
                                                                                        .......
                                                                        .. .... -............
Aug. 2,1882       .-.....do ---------..------------------------..                --..-.. --------.....         5, 000
July 5, 1884      ...... do   ..------------------------------------------                                    10, 000
                         Total-------..---------------....................------------------------..................---       60, 000


  Flushing Bay is in the collection district of New York. The nearest light-house is
on North Brother Island. Fort Schuyler, New York Harbor, is the nearest work of
defense.
                                                   Money statement.
July 1, 1885, amount available ............. ........................ ...                                                  $699 02
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
                                                    ....-----------....
  outstanding July 1, 1885 .---........----------................                                                            326 55

                                                                                                       372 47
July 1, 1886, amount available .......................................----------------------------------------
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886                                          --..--........
                                                                                                   10, 000 00

Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887 ...................                                                 10,372 47

     Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project----.---.. 103, 500 00
     Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscalyear ending June30,1888 35, 000 00
     Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
I     harbor acts of 1866 and 1867



                                              COMMERCIAL             STATISTICS.


  For the following information concerning the commerce of Flushing I am indebted
to the collector of customs at New York.
  No record of arrival and departure of vessels is kept. The chief articles of com-
merce are coal, lumber, and general merchandise.
  "Flushing Bay, situated opposite the eastern limits of the city of New York, is
growing in commercial importance, owing to the needed facilities for the discharge of
cargoes at New York, and may in the near future become an important adjunct thereto,
forming a part of that port. The marine commercial business is transacted at New
York. No approximate estimate of vessels visiting the bay can be given."
             APPENDIX            )--REPORT OF                 LIEUT.-COL.              HOUSTON.            663

                                                   D 20.
             IMPROVEMENT OF EAST CHESTER CREEK, NEW YORK.

   East Chester Creek is a small tidal stream emptying into East Ches-
ter, or Pelham Bay. The bay is on the north shore of Long Island
Sound, at its western end, being just east of Throg's Neck, and 20 miles
by water from the Battery at New York. The mean rise of tide is 7.1
feet.
   A reef of bowlders close to the course of vessels passing through the
draw of Pelham Bridge (near the mouth of the creek) made the entrance
dangerous. The depth for the first half mile, up to Goose Island, was
rather over 7 feet at high water, from there to the Town Dock, 1 miles
from the mounth, the high-water depth was nearly the same, and from
the Town Dock up to Lockwood's, 24 miles from the mouth, it was less
than 7 feet.
                               PROJECTS FOR IMPROVEMENT.

   The project for improvement, adopted ip 1872, provided for making
a channel 9 feet deep at high water from Pelham Bridge to a point about
3,000 feet above Lockwood's, a distance of about 3 miles, by removing
bowlders and gravel from near the draw of Pelham Bridge; dredging a
channel west of Goose Island, 125 feet wide and 1,500 feet long, and
dredging a cut 100 feet wide and 1,000 feet long from the Town Dock up
to the first bend; thence extending it by an easy curve through marsh
and some rock cutting to Lockwood's, a stretch in which the natural
bed of the stream was very winding; a cut 3,000 feet long, 100 feet
wide, and 9 feet deep was to be made above Lockwood's to serve both
as channel and tidal basin ; the project also provided for diking parts
of the channel. A modification of this project, submitted in 1873, con-
sisted of proposed timber dikes, to confine the channel on both banks
from above Town Dock to near Pelham Bridge; aggregate length 5,800
feet. The cost of the work was estimated as follows:
Basin, purchase of site, 18 acres, at $150 .--.. -- .        . . - -..
                                                          ..-.-         . -             -----.-.-        $2, 700
Excavation to level of mnea n low water, 200,000 cubic yards, at 40 cents......            -              0,000
Excavation of cut, 60,000 cubic yards, at 40 cents ..........              ......-- .. ..     ....       24, 000
Diking and revetting banks of cut.- -            ------.
                                                     ..               ---..---....                       12, 000
Engineering and contingencies         -.... ....-........  ...........           ......    ...-- .
                                                                                                --       17, 800

               .
        Total------- ----.         ----   .----.      ----.    ----   ----   ..----.      ----.   ----   136, 500


  The first work done under this project was in 1877. Since that time
the channel throtgh the marsh and rock just below Lockwood's has
been made 100 feet wide and 9 feet deep at mean high water, the chan-
nel west of Goose Island has been dredged 125 feet wide and 9 feet
deep at mean high water, the bowlders in the vicinity of Pelham Bridge
draw have been removed, the channel just above and under the new
draw-bridge on the Boston road at Lockwood's has been dredged out, a
channel about 2,000 feet long and 9 feet deep at mean high water has
been dredged from Pell Point up to Town Dock, the width being 40 to
45 feet, gradually increasing to 90 feet at Town Dock, and 1,235 linear
feet of diking have been built.
   OPERATIONS DURING                  THE FISCAL YEAR ENDING JUNE 30, 1886.

The available fnnds were insufficient for resuming work, and nothing
was done.
664         REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

                        PRESENT CONDITION OF IMPROVEMENT.

   There is now a depth of about 9 feet at mean high water in a narrow
channel all the way up to Lockwood's; above that no work has been
done.
                                       PROPOSED OPERATIONS.

   To complete the project there yet remains the widening of the chan-
nel to 100 feet and protecting it by construction of 4,565 feet of timber
dikes; also the dredging of a tidal basin above Lockwood's, which can
very properly be deferred until the improvements below are completed.
About 30,000 cubic yards of dredging could be done and one-half of the
proposed diking built conveniently in a single year at a cost of about
$20,000.
   Appropriations for improving East Chester Creek have been made as
follows, viz :

        Date.                                       Application.                                          Amount.

March 3, 1873- ......   Cutting through marsh and rock and diking (in 1877)... ...........                  $25, 000
March 3,1875 .......    Dredging under Boston Road Bridge and at Goose Island.............                   12, 000
June 18, 1878 .......   Dredging near Lockwood's, Goose Island, and Pelham Bridge .......                    10, 000
March 3,1879.....        Dredging 40-90 feet wide from Pell Point to Town Dock .............                    500
June 14, 18801 - -                                                                                            3, 500

      Total........     ............              ................ ...     .......................---        54, 000


  East Chester Creek is in the collection district of New York. The nearest light-
house is on the Stepping Stones, 3 miles southeast of the mouth of the creek; the
nearest work of defense is Fort Schuyler, Throg's Neck, about 3J miles south.



                                        COMMERCIAL STATISTICS.

  No record of arrivals and departures of vessels is kept, and it has been impracticable
to procure any accurate statement of commerce.
annually, bringing lumber, coal, and building materials.
                                                               'Probably
                                                              some 50 or 75 vessels enter
   No market produce is shipped from East Chester Creek.



                                          Money statement.
July 1, 1885, amount available ..........................................                                  $81 50
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885......-....-....-....-...........................                                 32 60
July 1, 1886, amount available.........--...........---......................                                 48 90
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886................ ....                                 11 , 000 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887 ....................                              10, 048 90

  Amount (estimated.) required for completion of existing project-....... 72,500 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1888 20, 000 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
                                                                                   r---                                                                                                                                   ..   _._




                                                                                                                                                                                                                               /F



                                                                                               ,



                                                                                               b
                                                                                                   y                                                           /




                                                                                                                                                                   gvc
                                                                                                                                                                              /



                                                                                                                                                                                  TS
                                                                                                                                                                                                                I;
                                                                                                                                                                                                                ii
                                                                                                                                                                                                                I




                                                                                               ar                                                 °

                                                                                                                                                                          f                                                     I

                                                 'o. oV




                                                                                                                                                                    p, N


                                                                                                                                                      -                                                  4


                                                                                                                                    )4       44

         DREDGED-    1877




                                                                                                                               4
                                                                                                            Thv444 9 0                                                                                                          i



        TOWN        DOCK




                                             1883




                                                                                                             LONG




                                                                                                                                                           -~----T--                        -   .    -:--4--
                                                                                                                  1'0           0                           4




DR




                                          7.4             14.o
                                       61-J


                                                            I1.O
                                      .o
                                                                                                                         . k        nu       t.~.              '4Q ,              i1.Zo             W   c-4.    ..      Z ro-        v   u   r.

                                           5.o                               5.o
                                                                                                                    9    q.4Ab               4            .X        414                                        443XA.

                            PC
                                                                                                        JC   .o     ,.         n:   a    a                c:.      ate.           Z    .1           aX.X




                                                                       A4y




                     ea~&ecjtcteGR~




                     e.-~




                                  M404   -
                                       50404o                    200    0      4000       Sooo feet
                                                                                                    J   I    /mie




                                                                                          44       ~GCC~I'
                                                                                                       9401                              ~
                                                                                                                                        A
                                                                                                                                                                      ;t ,,VaAL/.:




H Exl pt2 v2 49 2
                                APPENDIX E.



IMPROVEMENT OF HUDSON RIVER AND OF HARBORS OF RONDOUT AND
  SAUGERTIES, NEW YORK-REMOVING OBSTRUCTIONS IN EAST RIVER
  AND HELL GATE-IMPROVEMENT OF RIVERS AND HARBORS IN THE
  VICINITY OF NEW YORK AND IN NORTHERN NEW JERSEY-IMPROVE-
  MENT OF ENTRANCE TO NEW YORK HARBOR.



REPORT OF LIE UTENANT-COLONEL WALTER MCFARLAND, CORPS OF
ENGINEERS, OFFICER IN CHARGE, FOR THE FISCAL YEAR ENDING
JUNE 30, 1886, WITH OTHER DOCUMENTS RELATING TO THE WORK.

                                 IMPROVEMENTS.
1.   Hudson River, New York.               14. Shrewsbury River, New Jersey.
2.   Harbor at Saugerties, New York.       15. Harbor at Keyport, New Jersey.
3.   Harbor at Rondout, New York.          16. Mattawan Creek, New Jersey.
4.   Harlem River, New York.               17. Cheesequakes Creek, New Jersey.
5.   Removing obstructions in East Rivei   18. Raritan Bay, New Jersey.
        and Hell Gate, New York.            19. Raritan River, New Jersey.
6.   Newtown Creek, New York.              20. South River, New Jersey,
7.   Buttermilk Channel, New York.         21. Woodbridge Creek, New Jersey.
8.   Gowanus Bay, New York.                22. Rahway River, New Jersey.
9.   Gedney's Channel, New York.           23. Elizabeth River, New Jersey.
10.   Sheepshead Bay, New York.             24. Channel between Staten Island and
11.   Canarsie Bay, New York.                     New Jersey.
12.   Sumpawanus Inlet, New York.           25. Passaic River, New Jersey.
13.   Manasqnuan River, New Jersey.




                   ENGINEER OFFICE, UNITED STATES ARMY,
                                  New York, N. Y., October 20, 1886.
  GENERAL: I have the honor to transmit herewith my annual reports
upon the river and harbor works in my charge for the fiscal year end-
ing June 30, 1886.
         Very respectfully, your obedient servant,
                                                  WALTER MCFARLAND,
                                                     Lieut. Col. of Engineers.
  Brig. Gen. JAMES C. DUANE,
              Chief of Engineers, U. S. A.



                                        E i.

             IMPROVEMENT OF THE HUDSON RIVER, NEW YORK.

   My last annual report contained a history of this improvement, in-
cluding original reports, accompanied by two sketches showing its pres-
ent condition. This may be found in the Aunnual Report of the Chief
of Engineers for 1885, Part I, page 677.
                                                                        665
666     REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

   The only part of the Hudson River which has been improved is the
stretch beginning at the head of navigation at Troy, N. Y., about 6 miles
above Albany, and extending down the river to New Baltimore, about
14 miles below Albany, the total distance being a little over 20 miles
by river.
   While there has always been enough water below New Baltimore for
navigation, this upper section of the river, so far as its history is known
to us, has always been obstructed by bars and shoals, due to the exist-
ence of numerous islands and sloughs, and to the dispersion of the
river water over too great an area.
   Prior to 1831, when the jurisdiction of the Federal Government over
these waters had been confirmed by judicial decision, the State of New
York had made efforts to improve the navigation of this part of the
river. Since 1831 the improvement of the Hudson River has been con-
ducted both by the State of New York and by the General Government,
both building and repairing dikes and doing such dredging as seemed
necessary. In the last few years, however, the dike work has been left
almost exclusively to the General Government, while the State of New
York has done most of the dredging required.
   The general system of improvement has been the same throughout,
viz, the excavation of the channel by dredging and contracting the
channel by jetties and dikes.
   But prior to 1831, up to which time the work had been chiefly re-
stiicted to the construction of jetties and dredging, no permanent re-
sults had been obtained.
   After 1831 the United States began the present general system of im-
provement by contracting the channel by means of longitudinal dikes,
intended to aid in scouring the bars and shoals instead of using spur-
jetties.
   Under this system the United States constructed two dikes in 1835-
'36-'37-'38.
   Then followed a long interval of time in which nothing was done by
the United States except in 1852; but in 1863 the State of New York
took up the improvement on the general plan adopted by the United
States in 1831, viz, substituting the system of longitudinal dikes instead
of the jetty system, and between 1863 and 1867 built 6 important longi-
tudinal dikes. (Annual Report of 1885, page 678.)
   Out of the amount appropriated by act of Congress, approved June
28, 1864, the sum of $33,000 was allotted for the improvement of the
Hudson River; and by act of Congress, approved June 23, 1866, the
sum of $50;000 was appropriated for the improvement.
   In April, 1866, Lieut. Col. (now Brig. Gen.) John Newton, Corps of
Engineers, was placed in charge of the improvement, and remained in
charge until the 1st of April, 1884.
   In November, 1866, General Newton submitted a project for the im-
provement of the 20 miles of river between New Baltimore and Troy,
which mayv h found in Annual Rpnnrt of the (hief of Engineers for 1 R,
Part I, page 678; and, on the strength of his report, a systematic im-
provement of the river was begun and has been continued up to the
present time.
   The project was to secure a navigable channel 11 feet deep at mean
low water from New Baltimore to Albany, and 9 feet deep at mean
low water from Albany to Troy. The following description of it is taken
from the report of the Board of Engineers March 5, 1880 (see Annual
Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1885, Part I, page 690):
  First. A system of longitudinal dikes to confine the current sufficiently to allow
the ebb and flow of the tidal current to keep the channel clear. These dikes to be
          APPENDIX     E-REPORT         OF   LIEUT.-COL.     McFARLAND.           667
gradually brought nearer together from New Baltimore towards Troy, so as to assist
the entrance of the flood cllrrent and increase its height, their height to be kept ap-
proximately at the level of the tidal high water so as not to confine the freshets, the
exact level, however, being left to be determined by experience as the work progresses.
   Second. That the dredge be used so far as necessary to open the channels above de-
scribed, which the current should not be allowed to do, except very gradually lest
accumulations dangerous to navigation be formed below.
   Third. Keeping, as far as p)racticablle, the side r-servoirs open to the passage of
tidal currents by gaps at their lower extremities in order to increase the tidal flow.
   Fourth. Dumping all dredged materials in secure places, where it cannot be moved
back into the channel by the current.
   Fifth. Constructing the dikes of timber and stone, in a manner to secure their per-
manency, at a minimum cost, the details varying with the locality, to be left to the
discretion of the local engineer, to be so designed as to admit of having an increased
height given to the dikes, if necessary.
   Sixth. To protect, when necessary, the banks and islands against the abrading ac-
tion of the current's revetments.
   Seventh. That limits, beyond which no encroachments upon the channel should be
made, be prescribed, and that any such encroachments be reported to the engineer in
charge.
   The estimated cost of the improvement was $862,297.75, but after
more reliable data had been obtained, in 1866 and 1867, a second esti-
mate was made increasing the estimate $122,006.72, making the total
estimated cost $984,304.47. This estimate was again increased in 1882
by $78,000, for the completion of existing works, a large amount of the
appropriation intended for construction having been spent on repairs;
and again in 1884 by $16,000, for the removal of a hitherto unknown
rock in the overslough channel at Van Wie's Point, which brought the
total estimate up to $1,078,304.47, although the amounts given inl the
annual reports, as the estimated cost of the improvement from 1868 to
1881, have been erroneously printed $984,304.47, and from 1882 to 1886
as $1,062,304.47.
   Of this amount $1,027,288 had been appropriated up to June 30, 1885,
when the available channel depth between New Baltimore and Albany
was 10 feet, except at one point, Beacon Island, where there was a
depth of 8.8 feet; and 8 feet could be carried from Albany to Troy ex-
cept at Coville's Folly and Patroon's Island, where there were 7.8 and
7.5 feet respectively at low water.
   These bars it has been reported have been subsequently dredged by
the State of New York.
   The gradual and steady increase in the navigable depths obtained
during the improvement of the Hudson River are very marked.
   In 1819 the available channel depth betweon New Baltimore and
Albany was 4 feet at mean low water; in 1867 it was 7h feet; in 1878 and
1879 it was 81 feet; in 1885, 10 feet, except at the spot muentioned, which
was subsequently dredged by the State. A table showing the depths
from 1819 to 1879 may be found onmpage 691, Annual Report of the
Chief of Engineers for 1885.
   The improvement, as was originally expected , has also clhange( the
tides of the Hudson.
   In the report of the Board of Engineers March 5, 1880 (Annlual Re-
port of the Chief of Engineers for 183,5, page 691), is stated:
  The tidal rise of the upper portion of the Hudson was many years ago 1.2 feet at
Troy, 2.3 feet at Albany, and 3.7 at New Baltimore. The project of improvement
adopted aims at increasing the tidal rise above New Baltimore, so as to gain, if possi-
ble, 1 foot at each of the places named. By doing so the rise will be lengthened, the
ebb shortened, and the depth improved.
668          REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

   On the next page of the report (692) is stated :
  Tidal observations [presumably in 1880] give-
                                                                                                                           Feet.
At New Baltimore a rise of                    -....---................--............                        ............    3.43
At Coeymans (1.7 miles above) a rise of ..-.......-......                              ....................                 2. 86
At Castleton (4 miles above Coeymans) a rise of.........---               ...................                               2.55
At Albany (9 miles above Castleton) a rise of ....-...--.......................                                             2.32
At Troy (5 miles above Albany) a rise of .................               .................                                  2.00
  No work in the river has been done by the United States since 1884,
except to make a complete survey from Troy to New Baltimore, the report
on which may be found in last year's Annual Report.
  The work remaining to be done under the original project is: The
completion of the dike from Staats to Campbell's Island Dike, and from
Schermerhorn Island to Shad Island; the proposed improvement be-
tween Shad Island and Mull's Plaat, New Baltimore; the improvement
at Willow Island; the construction of a new dike to complete the line
below Nine-Mile Tree, the extension of the dike at Mull's Plaat, and the
removal of overslough rock at Van Wie's Point.
  The estimated cost of the completion of these works, by General New-
ton, in 1882, was $78,000, exclusive of the overslough rock, which was
estimated in 1884 to cost $16,000, making a total required for the com-
pletion of the project of $94,000.
  The act approved August 5, 1886, reads, "=Improving the Hudson
River, New York, for continuing the improvements, $26,250, of which
$15,000 may be used for a rock in the channel at Van Wie's Point";
which amount, with the $30,000 appropriation of July 5, 1884, makes a
total amount available for the present fiscal year of $56,250.
  But the dikes are in such a dilapidated condition in many places that
the whole of this amount will have to be applied to the repair of exist-
ing works instead of beginning new ones.
  In addition to this amount yet to be expended, more than $35,000
have been already expended up to the present time upon repairs of the
works; so that really over $91,000 out of the total appropriations in-
tended for original construction will have been necessarily expended on
repairs of existing works when the present money available is spent,
and this amount properly belongs to the construction fund yet to be
appropriated.
  It is recommended that the amount of $78,000, estimated for the com -
pletion of the project in 1882, by General Newton, be appropriated, and
also the $16,000, estimated to be required for the removal of the rock at
Van Wie's Point; making a total of $94,000.

                                             COMMERCIAL STATISTICS.

Value of imports for the fiscal year ending June 30, 1886...-.                           -..-       -...... $490, 103 00
Duties collected thereon ..........................   _.                    ._.    .     .      .........           85,862 21
There are enrolled and licensed at this port vessels with a tonnage of ..                                           68, 696 76

                                             AMOUNTS       APPROPRIATED.


        Date.           (    Amount.               Date.           Amount.                Date.                     Amount.

June 28, 1864.......        $33, 000 00     June 23, 1874 ...... $4Q; 000 00      By act approved.
Juneo 23, 1866.......        50, 000 00     March 3, 1875-......   40, 000 00     July 5, 1864. -..--..               $30, 000 00
March 3, 1867 ......        305,188 00      August 14,1876....     50, 000 00     August5, 1886...                     26, 250 00
July 25, 1868 .......        85, 000 00     June 18, 1878 ......   70, 000 )00
April 10, 1869 ......        89,100    00   March 3, 1879...-..    30, 000 00       Total ....-..--....             1, 053, 538 00
July 11, 1870 .......        40, 000   00   June 14, 1880 ...-.    20, 000 00     Amount expended
March 3, 1871 ......         40, 000   00   March 8, 1881....      15, 000 00     to close of fiscal
June 10, 1872.......         40, 000   00   By act passed.                        year ending June
March 3, 1873......          40, 000 00     August 2, 1882 . ...   10, 000 00      30, 1886 ...                       998, 808 96
             APPENDIX                 E--REPORT OF LIEUT.-COL. MCFARLAND.                                                                   669
                                                        Money statement.
July 1, 1885, amount available ....................--...............                                                       .....      $31, 570 74
Received from sales of fuel--............................................                                                                  39 36

                                                                                                                                       31,610 10
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885----                      ..........--.-------.........--.......
                          .........---....---.....------                               ----                                             3,091 70
July 1, 1886, amount available......................................                                                                  28,518 40
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886 .........--.......                                                                 26, 250 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887 ...................                                                             54,768 40
   Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project.... _ -                                                             94, 000 00
   Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June30, 1888                                                          35, 000 00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of section                                                  2    of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.



                                                                     E 2.

                IMPROVEMENT OF SAUGERTIES HARBOR, NEW YORK.

   The harbor of Saugerties is on the west bank of the Hudson River,
about 95 miles above New York, and is formed by the mouth of Esopus
Creek. Some works of improvement have already been attempted by
the inhabitants, but no permanent benefit has been derived from them.
In 1883 a survey with a view to its improvement, ordered by act of
Congress passed August 2, 1882, was made under direction of General
Newton, whose report, dated November 28, 1883, may be found in the
Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1884, Part I, page 716.
   This report shows that the mouth of the creek is obstructed by a bar
1,100 feet long, lying between the 6-foot curve in the Hudson and the
6-foot curve in the creek, with a minimum depth upon it of 3 feet at mean
low water.
   Two projects for the improvement of this harbor were submitted, both
providing for a channel 7 feet deep at mean low water and 100 feet wide,
to be obtained by constructing parallel dikes and by dredging a chan-
nel between them; but the question which method would best accom-
plish the purpose was to be left until further examination could be made.
   A sketch showing the two plans proposed was printed in Senate Ex.
Doc. No. 57, Forty-eighth Congress, first session.
   The estimates were as follows:
                                                               FIRST PLAN.
20,628* cubic yards at 35 cents .... ---..                            ............               .................                     $7, 219 80
North dike, 2,100 feet long, at $8......                              ......-....-....               ...............                   16, 800 00
South dike, 2,800 feet long, at $8-----........... ..............                                        ...-.-            ..-    .    22, 400 00
         Total ......-----..------..---.......-----...---....----...                     ....................----....                 46,419 80
                                                             SECOND PLAN.

Dredging a channel 2,500 feet long, 100 feet wide, and 7 feet deep at mean
low water, 55,654 cubic yards, in situ., at 25 cents ........... ........ $13, 913 50
North dike, 2,600 feet, at $8 .......................................                                                          ....   22, 800 00
South dike, 800 feet, at $8 ...--..-.-....               .........                          ..........                 .     .....     6,400 00

         Total ............................................................                                                            43,113 50
                         * Erroneously stated in original report to be $5,338.28.
670          REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

   The act of Congress approved July 5, 1884, appropriated $5,000 for
the improvement of this harbor; but in view of the fact that the State
of New York had undertaken to make some improvements there, it was
decided not to begin work at once, but to wait until a further examina-
tion was made, and until it could be ascertained what plan of improve-
ment had been decided upon by the State authorities.
   By act of Congress approved August 5, 1886, the United States ap-
propriated a further sum of $15,000 for this work; making the total
amount available $19,955.95.
   During the past year the State authorities have excavated 29,000 cubic
yards of material from the bar at the mouth of the creek, giving a chan-
nel 8 feet deep at mean low water and about 200 feet wide from the 8-
foot curve in the Hudson River across the bar to the 8-foot curve inside
the mouth of the creek.
   This channel, however, leads directly out into the Hudson, at right
angles to the shore line, and across the lines of both the north dikes
proposed by General Newton, which both run in a gradual curve down-
stream, on the same general principle of construction as the Rondout
dikes. It may, therefore, be necessary to first apply the available funds
to beginning one of the proposed south dikes, after further examina-
tion determines which of them it is best to adopt.
   A carefully prepared statement of the commerce of Saugerties may be
found on page 717, Part I, Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1883,
since which date none has been received.
  This work is in the collection district of Albany, N. Y., which is the nearest port of
entry. The nearest light-house is at the mouth of Esopus Creek.
Amount appropriated --.......          -......              .......... ........-----......   .....   . $20, 000 00
Amount expended........ ................                    ..............................                   44 05

                                             Money statement.
July 1, 1885, amount available..........................................                              $ 4,955 95
July 1, 1886, amount available    .....---..
                                      --............. , ..............                                   4,955 95
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886 .................                                    15,000 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887 ...................                               19, 955 95
  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project-....       26, 419 80
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1888 15, 000 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.



                                                        E 3.

          IMPROVEMENT OF THE HARBOR AT RONDOUT, NEW YORK.
   Roudut Harb,,                is at thc mouth of Rondout, Creek, on the west bank
of the Hudson River, between 80 and 90 miles above New York. The
creek is a tidal stream for 3 miles above its mouth. Prior to 1871 im-
provements had been made by private persons and corporations, but
no permanent benefits had been derived from them. A survey of the
harbor was made by the Government in 1869, erroneously printed in
last year's report to be 1871, with a view to its permanent improvement,
when it was found that there was an available depth of about 7 feet in
the channel. The project based upon this survey provided for the forma-
tion and maintenance of a channel at the mouth of the creek 100 feet
             APPENDIX           E-REPORT                OF LIEUT.-COL.                           MCFARLAND.                      671.
wide and 14 feet deep, to be obtained by means of dredging and diking.
Two parallel channel dikes were to be built outward toward and into
the Hudson on a gentle curve down-stream, with a branch dike running
upstream along the Hudson from the outer end of the north dike to
protect it'from running ice. The estimated cost of this work was as
follows :
Building the north dike, 748 yards long........ ...................                                   ..... $41,600 00
Building the branch dike, 640 yards long............................                                         34,400 00
Building the south dike, 1,277 yards long .---..--.......                ............ ......                 59,600 00
Dredging a channel 3,000 feet long, 100 feet wide, and 14 feet deep at low
water, 48,000 cubic yards, at 30 cents.... ..............................                                   14,400 00
Contingencies.........................-----..-----...
                                      ----                 ......----------....------....----...---...--     22,500 00

        Total..........           ..........       ..........            ........     ...    ............        ....       172,500 00
   The final length of the north and south dikes was, however, to be de-
termined by the effects which they produced in the removal of the bar
as they were gradually extended outward. In 1872, by reason of a re-
duction in the estimated length of the dikes, their estimated cost was
reduced to $104,000. The project was essentially completed in 1880,
and a history of the improvement with sketches may be found in the
Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1881, Part I, page 494.
   At that date the north dike was about 2,200 feet long, the branch
dike running up the Hudson was about 1,000 feet long, the south dike
was about 2,800 feet long, with a spur to the light-house 330 feet long,
and a depth of 13J feet at low water had been obtained between the
dikes.
   The appropriation of $2,000 approved August 2, 1882, was applied to
repairs. The dikes were refilled with stone where needed, fender-piles
were placed at the outer end of the north dike, and 600 feet of the
south dike was raised to the level of high water. The balance of this
appropriation available July 1, 1884, was $706.03, which, with the ap-
propriation of $1,000, approved July 5, 1884, was applied to cutting off
150 feet of the outer end of the south dike, and to dredging the chan-
nel and putting spring-piles along the dike.
   Although the project was practically completed, it was stated in my
last Annual Report that the $10,000 still to be appropriated under the
original estimate could be profitably expended in repairing the dikes
and in widening the channel between them.
   Of this amount $2,500 was appropriated by act approved August 5,
1886, leaving a balance of $7,500 still to be appropriated.
   This amount will be applied to dredging and repairing the dikes, if
necessary.
   Appropriations for the improvement of Rondout Harbor have been
made as follows:
By act approved June 10, 1872--------.....--...............-----------------......--.......-------. $10, 000 00
By act approved March 3, 1873 .................                              .........-        ...-..       ....--      .    20,000 00
Amount allotted June 8, 1875:
     From repairs of harbors on Atlantic coast ..........                                    ................                   762 18
     From contingencies of rivers and harbors, &c.......................                                                        237 82
By act approved August 14, 1876................ ........................                                                     30, 000 00
By act approved June 18, 1878 ._...     -.............. .... .... ............                                               30, 000 00
By act passed August 2, 1882 .---.....                  ..................................                                    2, 000 00
By act approved July 5, 1884_................................-..........                                                      1,000 00
By act approved August 5, 1886 ..............       .................----...---.                                              2,500 00
               ......--....---....----....-----..........-----......----.....----....--..........
        Total-------                                                                                                         96,500 00
        Amount expended.--..--
                           ....-..-.......----..--....--..........---..........                                              93, 939 64
In the original report upon this harbor in 1869 (see Annual Report of
Chief of Engineers for 1869, page 394) it is stated " the amount of cornm-
672          REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,-U. S. ARMY.

merce and navigation to be benefited by the improvement of naviga-
tion would be annually from $70,000,000 to $80,000,000. This is as near
as could be estimated from the data available."
   No statement of commerce has been received since this date; and
when it has been asked for, reference has been made to this statement.
   Rondout is the headquarters of the largest cement works in this
country. It is also the principal summer shipping point of the Dela-
ware and Hudson Canal Company's coal on the Hudson River.
   The effect of this improvement has been to allow vessels to pass up
to and down from the wharves at Rondout, without having to lighter
in and out over the bar, as was the case formerly.
  Rondout is in the collection district of New York. The nearest works of defense
are those of New York Harbor. Amount of revenue collected at the port of New York
during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1886, $132,536,402.02.

                                             Money statement.
July 1, 1885, amount available...----....----....-------...---------..-----------............--..--..       $60 36
July 1, 1886, amount available ...........................----..........                                     60 36
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886 .-.--                                 - ....-..- - .   2, 500 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887 .-.-..............                                  2, 560 36
  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project ....                             .. :.   7, 500 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal yearending June 30, 1888                               7,500 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.



                                                        E 4.
                IMPROVEMENT OF THE HARLEM RIVER, NEW YORK.

   No work has been done on this improvement during the past year,
and its history is somewhat as follows:
   Congress, by the second section of "An act making appropriations
for the repair, preservation, and completion of certain public works on
rivers and harbors, and for other purposes," approved June 23,1874, di-
rected that the Secretary of War should "cause examinations or sur-
veys, or both, to be made," among other places, " at Harlem River, from
Randall's Island, by way of Spuyten Duyvil Creek, to Hudson River,
New York."
   This survey was, by direction of the Chief of Engineers, placed in
charge of Lieut. Col. (now Brig. Gen.) John Newton, Corps of Engineers,
whose report, dated February 18, 1875, was published in House Ex.
Doc. No. 75, Part 9, second session Forty-second Congress, and is to be
found at page 224 of the Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for
1875, T' T1,,, TT
      Part    II.
   A supplementary report, made February 10, 1876, is printed in the
Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1876, Part I, page 246.
   The act of Congress relating to rivers and harbors approved March
3, 1881, provided also, among other things, for "completing survey of
Harlem River and through the Harlem Kills to the East River, New
York." The report on this survey was made by General Newton under
date of October 8, 1881, and is to be found in the Report of the Chief of
Engineers for 1882, Part I, page 656.
        APPENDIX    E-REPORT       OF   LIEUT.-COL.   MCFARLAND.       673

   The difficult point in the improvement of the Harlem River is the
connection of that river with the Hudson; Spuyten Duyvil Creek, which
forms the natural water connection, being both narrow and crooked.
General Newton's survey covered four lines along which this connection
might be made.
   1. By way of Sherman's Creek to Inwood or Tubby Hook, on the
Hudson.
   2. From Sherman's Creek to a bend of Spuyten Duyvil Creek, near
Johnson's Foundry.                                                       !a
   3. By a cut through Dyckman's Meadows to the Spuyten Duyvil.
   4. Through Spuyten Duyvil Creek by way of Kingsbridge.
   The estimates of cost showed that the route by way of a cut through
Dyckman's Meadows would be the least expensive, and that route was
accordingly recommended. The proposed lines of improvement, as laid
down by the engineer in charge in his annual report for 1882, are as fol-
lows:
   (1) Below the Harlem or Third Avenue Bridge the outer pier and
bulkhead lines, as laid down by the park department, are adopted.
   (2) Above the Third Avenue Bridge to the entrance of Dyckman's
Cut into the Harlem River the exterior pier and bulkhead lines are laid
down 400 feet apart.
   (3) The line following Dyckman's Cut through Dyckman's Meadows
will pass for a part of the way through solid rock; and it is here that the
principal cost of the undertaking must be encountered. This part is to
be made 350 feet wide. It would have been preferable to establish it at
400 feet, but the additional amount of rock excavation was the obstacle.
   (4) The remainder of the line to the Hudson River will follow as
nearly as possible the course of the Spuyten Duyvil, and the width will
be 400 feet.
   As the difference in the heights and times of tides between the East
and North rivers after the connection is made between the Harlem and
the Hudson will be the cause of the currents upon which reliance is
placed to keep open the channel, it is desirable that the cross-section
of the channel be kept as uniform as possible in order to avoid the un-
necessary resistances to the flow of the water which would be caused by
any contraction of the water-way.
   The contraction of the proposed cut through Dyckman's Meadows
will be more than counterbalanced by the natural channel through
Spuyten Duyvil by the way of Kingsbridge, which is left open; and the
contraction caused by the piers and embankments of the High Bridge,
which carries the Croton aqueduct across the Harlem River, should be
counteracted by deepening the channels between the piers and abut-
ments. Observations of the tides affecting these waters show that
there is not a free exchange of tides between Harlem River and Spuyten
Duyvil Creek, but that there is practically a divide somewhere near Ford-
ham Bridge between the tides flowing from the East River into the Har-
lem River, and from the Hudson River into Spuyten Duyvil Creek. Com-
paring the tides of the Harlem River at Fordham Bridge with those of
the Hudson River at the mouth of Spuyten Dayvil Creek, it is found:
   (1)- That the level of mean high water in the Hudson is nearly 1 foot
(.961) lower than it is in the Harlem.
   (2) That the mean rise and fall of the tide in the Hudson is 2.12 feet
less than it is in the Harlem.
   (3) That the mean duration of the rise of tides in the Hudson is 36
minutes shorter, the mean duration of the fall 36 minutes longer, and
the mean duration of slackwater 20 minutes longer than in the Harlem.
      43 E
'674    REPORT   OF   THE CHIEF    OF   ENGINEERS,   U. S. ARMY.

   (4) The mean level of the Hudson at the mouth of Spuyten Duyvil
Creek is .265 of a foot lower than at Fordham Bridge.
   (5) High water occurs 1 hour and 34 minutes earlier in the Hudson
than in the Harlem.
   From these facts it follows that while there will at different times be
a flow towards either river, the preponderance of flow will be towards
the Hudson; and the scour will go that way, so that, if a cut for the
free passage of the tides be made, the opening into the Hudson will be-
come the mouth of the cut.
   The estimated cost of making the connection by a cut through Dyck-
man's Meadows, as given by General Newton in his report for 1882, is
$2,100.000.
   This estimate does not provide for the improvement of the channel of
the Harlem River between this proposed cut and the mouth of the Har-
lem River.
   The estimated cost of improving this part of the river, as given in
General Newton's report for 1875, was about $600,000. Total for the
improvement of the Harlem River between the Hudson and the East
rivers, $2,700,000.
   The estimated cost of opening the, channel from the Harlem River to
the East River by way of the Harlem Kills, making it 300 feet wide and
15 feet deep at low water, was about $2,200,000. This survey was or-
dered by act of Congress approved March 3, 1881, and the report upon
it is to be found in the Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for
1882, Part I, page 656.
   By act of Congress relating to river and harbor improvements, ap-
proved June 18, 1878, there was appropriated " for the improvement of
Harlem River, New York, $300,000; but this sum is not to be available
until the right of way for this work is secured to the United States, free
of cost"; and by act approved March 3, 1879, there was appropriated
" for improving Harlem River, New York, $100,000; but this appropri-
ation is made subject to the provisions and limitations contained in the
act of June 18, 1878, relating to said Harlem River improvement and
the right of way therefor."
   As under the restrictions of these two appropriations no part of them
could be expended towards beginning this improvement until the right
of way was secured to the United States without cost, an allotment was
made from the appropriations for " Examinations, surveys, and contin-
gencies of rivers and harbors" for the purpose of making surveys to as-
certain whose lands would be crossed or touched upon by the proposed
work; and, this being done, letters were addressed by General Newton
to the various property-holders concerned, asking if they would cede to
the United States the land needed for the purposes of this improvement.
As very few signified their willingness to do so, measures were taken by
persons interested in the improvement to have a bill introduced in the
New York State legislature to provide for appointing a commission to
assess benefits and damages, and to condemn such land as may be nec-
essary for the proposed work.
   This bill having become a law, detailed maps and descriptions of each
piece of property to be affected by the proposed work were prepared
for submission to the Supreme Court of the State, this step being nec-
essary before commissioners could be appointed. In October, 1879,
three commissioners were appointed by the Supreme Court for this
purpose; but they had not proceeded far with their work when they
found it necessary to apply to the legislature for increased powers to
           APPENDIX        E-REPORT            OF    LIEUT.-COL.        MCFARLAND.             675
enable them to more efficiently discharge their duties. Their report
was completed and was presented to the Supreme Court in 1882, where
final action is to be taken. Great opposition to the recommendation
of the commissioners has been made by some of the property-owners af-
fected, and efforts are being made to have the original act under which
the assessments are made revoked by the State legislature.
   The beginning of this improvement awaits, as it has for the last eight
years, the settlement of this question.
This work is in the collection district of New York. Nearest port of entry, New
York City. Nearest light-house, Blackwell's Island Light.
Amount of revenue collected at the port of New York during the fiscal year ending
June 30, 1886, $132,536,402.02.

                                        Money statement.
July 1, 1885, amount available . - -   ----.--                                            $..
                                                                                      .$400,      000
July 1, 1886, amount available . -.......................................                    400, 000
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887----....---            --.--..         400, 000

  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project --........
                                                                     -                   2, 300, 000
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of ri.ver and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.




                                                E 5.

REMOVING OBSTRUCTIONS IN EAST RIVER AND HELL GATE, NEW YORK.

   The charge of this improvement was retained by General Newton,
with Lieutenant-Colonel McFarland and Lieutenant Derby as assistants,
until the last day of December, 1885, when it was transferred by him to
Lieut. Col. Walter McFarland, Corps of Engineers. General Newton's
annual report gives in detail the operations on Flood Rock, Hell Gate, up
to the date of the final explosion October 10, 1885. The operations subse-
quent to that date will be reported upon here, although partly occurring
during General Newton's charge.
   C wing to the economy effected in the cost of the final blast, chiefly
by the substitution of rackarock for Dynamite No. 1, a halance of up-
wards of $100,000 remained on hand from the appropriation of July 5,
1884, and specifications for the removal of so much of the debris of the
reef as these limited funds would permit were drawn up and the work
was advertised at once.
  The total amount of broken rock to be removed from the reef to give
the depth of 26 feet at mean low water, called for by the present project
of improvement, is estimated to be about 294,000 tons. The funds avail.
able were sufficient only for the removal of about 30,000 tons, a little
more than one-tenth of the whole. This was not enough to produce a
depth of 26 feet over any part of the reef of sufficient width to be of any
immediate benefit to navigation, as it is impracticable to work upon the
eastern side of the reef adjoining the eastern channel, which is now the
most used and has become the main channel, because that channel is
overcrowded with passing traffic, and the strongest tide in Hell Gate
runs with great violence across that part of the reef.
   It was therefore thought advisable to adopt the suggestion of Lieu-
tenant Derby and to expend the available funds in dredging the dan-
gerous reefs known as the Negro Heads and Hen and Chickens to a depth
676        REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

of 18 feet at mean low water, and to cut off to the same depth a spur
projecting from the northwest side of Flood Rock proper. Under this
application of the funds it would be possible to obtain a through chan-
nel between Flood Rock and Mill Rock of nearly, if not quite, the same
width between the 18-foot contour as the present eastern or main chan-
nel (400 feet), and of a depth sufficient for nine-tenths of the vessels
passing through Hell Gate.
  After the completion of this channel the main body of the reef can be
advantageously removed to the proposed depth of 26 feet by starting
on the eastern side of the 18-foot channel and working over gradually
toward the eastern or main channel, so that by the time the latter is
reached its currents will have been so far reduced and the navigation
of Hell Gate so far simplified as to make it comparatively safe for the
dredges to work where they cannot work at all at present.
  The bids for the work on the 18-foot channel were opened October 21,
1885, and the contract was awarded to the Atlantic Dredging Company,
of Brooklyn.
  The contractor began work November 4. He has done his work with
great energy and good judgment, and at the close of the fiscal year had
removed 28,622 tons. The contract was subsequently completed, and a
good 18-foot channel from 350 to 400 feet wide was secured between
Flood Rock and the Mill Rocks. The 12-foot channel was 150 feet wider
than this.
  The following is a detailed statement of the work done up to June 30,
1886:



       Number of machine.          c        ba i     n    ,             c        w     do              t        co
                                       ti      ie             ds   th                    e             it   h




   I. Packard's No. 6t-i.ne            159      33       1, 507$$            97       8, 280    15, 585. 820    81.17    $0.110
  I. Packard's No. 5....-......         14                   966$             3          190k       500. 067    35. 72    0. 079
III. Morris & Cummings's No.6.         151               1, 337$$            75       4,118$     7,695.258      50.96     0.112
IV.   Ross & anford, No. 6   i     w         th98
                                               26        1, 009e$           84        5, 700    4, 841.167      39. 04    0.252
      Total ....................       422      59       3, 950$$           259      18, 288$   28, 622 312--.........0. 134



   The costthfeof     surface blasting, which was done by the contractor,
is extremely small, averaging only 13 cents per ton, and shows that
this item does not deserve nearly the consideration it has received
heretofore. It is interesting to note that the dredge numbered 1 in
                                     e
the above table, which is th samemachine            that did the bulk of the
work of removing Hallet's Point, has averaged 81.2 tons per day, where-
as th erecords  ;Sh a+h      hn+heverage for the first six months on Hallet's
Point was only 50.4 tons, indicating that the rock is better broken up
at Flood Rock than it was at Hallet's Point. Considering the low cost
of the surface blasting which had been previously regarded as a doubt-
ful element, it is apparent that future contracts on Flood Rock should
be let at very much reduced prices.
   The accompanying Table II shows the amount and cost of the work
done at Flood Rock during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1886.
  Great difficulty having been experienced at Hallet's Point in keeping
the dredges from working too deep in some places, and leaving pro-
         APPENDIX      E-REPORT        OF    LIEUT.-COL.    MCFARLAND.        677
jections above the bottom in others, the inspection of the contractor's
work on Flood Rock has been conducted with great care, 7,188 sound-
ings having been taken and platted, and each cut made by the dredges
having been repeatedly examined with the horizontal sweep. As work
of this character in Hell Gate is fraught with difficulties, great credit
is due to Lieutenant Derby and his assistants, G. W. Kuehnle and J.
M. Gore, surveyors, for the skill and energy with which they conducted
this work.
    Complete surveys have also been made during the year of the whole
of Flood Rock Reef immediately after the blast, and of Heel Tap, and
preparations have been made for surveying Frying Pan and Pot Rock,
neither of which reefs has been examined since the last work was
done upon them by the drill-scow some years ago.
    Since March 1 a continuous record of the tides has been kept with
the self-registering tide-gauge, and those observations are now being
reduced.
    All the buildings and the plant used in the mining operations at Flood
Rock, which were hurriedly brought over to Astoria just before the ex-
plosion, have been carefully assorted and stored, but on account of the
dampness of the atmosphere in that vicinity the machinery requires con-
stant attention to keep it from deteriorating.
    The accompanying Table III shows the amount and cost of the work
done by the United States steam drill-scow during the fiscal year.
    As the appropriation of July 5, 1884, was limited in its application to
work on Flood Rock, the Drill Scow has remained idle at her berth at
Mill Rock throughout the whole year, with the exception of a period of
thirty-four day s immediately after the blast at the Flood Rock, when
she was employed in raising broken stone from the reef by means of
divers and sling chains. This work was discontinued December 1, at the
beginning of freezing weather, and has not been resumed this season,
the contractor having occupied all the available space on the reef with
his dredges.
   Broken rock cannot be picked up by divers in Hell Gate for much
less than $2.50 per ton, and, from the progress made by the contractor's
dredges so far, it is probable that the next contract will be let at a price
considerably below this. It will, therefore, not be profitable to employ
the drill-scow on Flood Rock again until the dredges have progressed
so far as to have reduced the reef generally to a depth of 26 feet and
over, when divers can be employed to good advantage in removing the
small projecting points of rock left behind by the dredges, which these
machines cannot pick up without raising a large amount of neighboring
rock and thus adding unnecessarily to the cost of the work.
    In the meanwhile it is to be hoped that future appropriations will ad-
mit of the drill-scows being used for the purpose for which she was
designed on the other Hell Gate Reefs, as the cost of maintaining her in
order while idle is considerable.
  The work is in the collection district of New York. The nearest port of entry is
New York   City. The amount of revenue collected dhlring the year ending June 30,
        32
1886, $1 ,536,402.02. The amount of commerce and navigation benefited by the
completion of this work, about $4,000,000 daily.

                                ORIGINAL    ESTIMATE.


  Removing reefs at Hell Gate and Diamond and Coenties reefs, $5, 139, 120.
678              REPORT OF THE CHIEF                                  OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

                                                       AMOUNT APPROPRIATED.


                   Date of act.                          Amount.                                 Date of act.                                            Amount.


July 25, 1868 ........................                   $85, 000   00    July 5, 1884..........- ...........                                            $360, 000 00
April 10, 1869 ............                     ....     178, 300   00    August 5. 1886... ............                                                  112, 500 00
July 11, 1870 ...............                ".....      250, 000   00    Received from other sources....                                        ..         3, 667 13
March 3, 1871...................                         250, 000   00
June 10, 1872..................                          225, 000   00                                                                                  3, 664, 467 13
March 3, 1873.................                           225, 000   00    Deduct amount reverted
June 23, 1874 .................                          225, 000   00     to United States Treas-
March 3, 1875..................                          250, 000   00     ury ................... $3, 158 55
August 14, 1876.....                 ..........          250, 000   00    Deduct amount allotted
June 18,1878......................                       350, 000   00     to Harlem River.......11, 000 00
March 3,1879 ......................                      250, 000   00                                                                                     14, 158 55
June 14, 1880.......................                     200, 000   00
March 3, 1881.......................                     200, 000   00                                                                                  3, 650, 308 58
May 4, 1882...................                            50, 000   OC
*August 2, 1882................                          200, 000   00    Amount expended to date .........                                             3, 467, 331 89

                                                           * Date of passage.

Amounts expended during the year ending June 30, 1886:
  Flood Rock. ..........................................................                                                                                 $193, 437 23
  Steam drilling-scow...........................................                                 ..................        ...        ......                7, 618 60

                                                                                                                                                          206, 055 83
                                                         Money statement.
July 1, 1885, amount available . ........                                  ..........................                                                 $'267, 949 74
Received from sales of fuel................                                    .................                                 .      ......                29 25

                                                                                                                                                       267, 978 99
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive
  of liabilities outstanding July 1, 1885 ............... .....     $197, 502 30
July 1, 1886, outstanding liabilities.... ...............      ....   29, 828 35
                                                                                                                                                       227, 330 65

July 1, 1886, amount available......-
                               -      ..-......-                                     -           ..................                                      40, 648 34
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886......                                                                  .........                    112, 500 00

Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887.................                                                                                 153, 148 34

  SAmount (estimated) required for completion of existing project ..... 1, 488, 840 67
   Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June
       30, 1888.....................                            ...............................                                                        500, 000 00
I Submitted            in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
  . harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.



Abstract of proposals for removing broken rock front Flood Rock Reef, Hell Gate, New York,
                                  opened October 21, 1885.



No.                                  Name and address of bidders.                                                         Price per                   Cost of 30,000
                                                                                                                             ton.                         tons.


  1     The American Dredging Company, Philadelphia, Pa ...........                                                                    3 9on             $117, 000 00
  2     P. Sandford Ross, Jersey City, N. J   .... .-.-......              - .......                                                   3 48 !             104, 400 00
  3     The Harbor Improvement Company, New York, N. Y ...............                                                                 3 49               104, 700 00
  4     Morris & Cummings Dredging Company, New York, N. Y..........                                                                   3 38               101,400 00
  5     Atlantic)-Dredging
        -----      --      Company, Brooklyn, N. Y .......................                                                             3 19                95, 700 00


   The contract was awarded to the Atlantic Dredging Company.
                                                                                                                      *
                    APPENDIX                      E -REPORT                           OF   LIEUT.-COL. 'MCFARLAND.                                            679


                                                                                 TABLE II.

Tabulated statement of the amount and cost of work done at Flood Rock, Hell Gate, East
                  River, New Iork,  for fiscal year ending June 30, 1686.



                                                   Number of Number of                                                            Cost of re-
                                                    shifts of    tons of    Cost of                             Cost of            moving               Total cost.
                                                   eight hours broken rock materials.                           wages.             broken
                                                    worked.     removed.                                                            rock.


                                                                            Tons.
Pumping ....................                               533. 625 -.........               $2,141 39         $1,409 22          ...........              $3, 550 61
Final blast..................                           4, 739. 375 .          .....         87, 981 37        13, 909 92         ...........             101, 891 29
Care of plant .............                             2, 640.125 ............               1, 805 90         5, 802 70         ............              7, 608 60
Removal of broken rock by
    hired labor...............                           . 911. 375            558.1              397 85         1,964 36           ...........             2, 362 21
Removal of broken rock un-
  der contract............                         ..        ......      28, 622. 312       ............         ............      $91, 305 04             91, 305 04
Inspection and resurvey ....                            1, 589. 5       ............                 267 10      5, 266 04        ..............            5, 533 14
Superintendence and office
  expenses....................                          1, 678. 125     ...........            1, 280 73         7, 351 90          .............           8, 632 63

           Total ..............                    12, 092. 125          29, 180. 412         93, 874 34       35, 704 14             91, 305 04          220, 883 52


    Of the expenses here reported there are liabilities aggregating $29,805.81 outstanding June 30.
    The entire cost of the final blast, including pumping, and expenditures made during fiscal year 1885,
is $111,248.




                                                                             TABLE III.

Tabulated statement of the amount and cost of work done by the United States steam drill-
                       scow for thefiscal year ending Jun 30, 1886.

                                                                        Number of
                                                                         shifts of    umer                     Cost of                Cost of
                                                                           hthours
                                                                        Work, &c.  tons of ro                 materials.              wages.            Total cost.
                                                                         worked.     removed.


                                                                                                Tons.
Experiments with grapple..................................$105                                                               00   .............             $105    00
Additions to plant...............................................                                                 1, 044     46   ..........               1, 044   46
Examination of reef after final blast.....                              5                          .. ...     ........            "$105     00              "105    00
Removing broken rock from Flood Rock.                                911. 375                    558. 1                397   85      1, 964 36            *2, 362   21
Materials on hand .......................                         .................                                    650   65   ..                          650   65
Maintenance while idle .................                             993. 25                                           311   81      2,80293               3,114    74
           Total.........................1,                                    959. 625          558. 1          2, 509 77              4, 872 29          7, 382 06

                                                                      * Charged to Flood Rock.
    Of the expenses here reported there are liabilities aggregating $22.54 outstanding June 30.




                                                                   COMMERCIAL              STATISTICS.

                    Value of imports, exports, and duties collected at port of New York.


                                                                                                               Exports.
                   Year ending June 30-                                          Imports.                                                               Duties.
                                                                                                    Domestic.                Foreign.


1883........................................                                 $508, 70), 476        $362, 571, 653            $21,166, 859           $146, 581, 223 14
1884. .......................                           ........        ..    486, 355, 355         363, 055, 394             21, 557, 810           133, 866, 902 91
1885.......................................406,                                    035, 435         349, 939, 225             17, 828, 096           125, 313, 677 43
680            REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

                    Tabulated statement of the commerce of the port of New York.

                                                                                              VESSELS ENTERED.


                          Year.                                     American.                                         Foreign.                    Total.


                                                                N   o.                Tons.                 No.               Tons.       No.         Tons.


1883..................... ..................                     1,9 00         1, 035, 078             4, 352            5,413,159      6, 252      6, 448, 831
1884.............            .......................... 1,8369                  1, 006, 556             4, 197            4,652,315      6, 066      5,658,871
1885........................                   ................. 1,691             930, 444             4, 133            4, 729, 289    5, 824      5, 659, 733


                                                                                              VESSELS CLEARED.


                          Year.                                     American.                                         Foreign.                    Total.

                                                                No.                Tons.                    No.             Tons.         No.         Tons.
                                                                 i        -.. .. .   . . .           i-..             . i. .
1883-.......  .............................. 1,501 904, 272                                             4, 376           5, 423, 418     5, 879      6, 327, 690
1884................. ...................... 1,442 839, 762                                             4, 094           4, 584, 196     5, 538      5, 423, 958
1885........................................i 1, 273                                  770, 109          4, 031           4, 670, 615     5, 304      5, 440, 724



Number and tonniage of steam and sailing vessels, barges and canal-boats belonging to the
                               port of New York.

               Sailing vessels.           Steam vessels.                      Barges.                              Canal-boats.                   Total.

Years.
              No.         Tons.          No.        Tons.            No.                Tons.                    No.           Tons.       No.        Tons.
                                                                          . .. . ..     .        .          I.    .       .      .

1883....      2, 451 505. 559. 55          978 336, 327, 35              441          86, 446. 49                 201!        20, 442. (08 4, 0711 948, 775. 47
1884....      2, 488 512, 401.33        1, 044 361, 438, 82              454          90, 715. 19                 209         21, 196. 78 4, 195! 985, 752. 84
1885.....     2, 437 513, 908. 12       1, 028, 364, 169. 58             465          93,407. 05                  2091        21, 178. 54 4,1391 992, 663.29




REPORT OF BRIG4DIER-GENERAL JOHN  NEWTON                                                                                      UPON REMOVAL                 OF
                       FLOOD ROCK.


                                                   OFFICE OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,
                                                                     *Washington, D. C., August 25, 1886.
   SIR: At the close of the last fiscal year the work of undermining
Flood Rock and drilling the 3-inch holes for the reception of the charges
for the final blast had been completed, and the work of cleaning up the
four miles of galleries and making the final preparations for receiving
the explosives and charging the mine was in progress; the contracts
for the delivery of 240,399 pounds of rackarock and 48,537 pounds of
dynamite had been executed with the Rendrock Powder Company and
R.    T. Warren, respectively; andi the contract for the 58,337 copper
cartridge-cases had been awarded the Rendrock Powder Company; but,
owing to some misunderstanding as to the thickness of the metal to be
used, this contract was not signed until July 16, 1885.
  It had been decided to select rackarock as the principal explosive
for the blast, on account of the absolute safety with which it could be
stored; its greater safety in handling as compared with dynamite; its
greater density (1.7 to 1.4), and its cheapness, the price bid being 234
cents per pound as against 43 cents, the lowest bid received for dynamite
from companies having the facilities for furnishing the explosives in
the quantities required.
        APPENDIX     E-REPORT      OF   LIEUT.-COL.   MCFARLAND.       681
    The specifications required that the rackarock should have a strength
only of 90 per cent. that of No. 1 dynamite when fired under water and
measured by the method in use at the Engineer School of Application
at Willets Point. But suchcare was taken by the contractors in select-
ing their materials and such benefits derived from the careful determi-
nation made at Willets Point experimentally, and from the analysis of
the exact proportions of oil and chlorate to be used, as well as the thor-
oughness of the mixing of these ingredients, that the 71 samples tested
showed an average strength of 109 per cent. that of dynamite No. 1, no
sample falling below 99 per cent.
    All of these tests, except the chemical analysis made by the chemist
of the Rendrock Powder Company, were the personal work of Lieut.
Col. H. L. Abbot, Corps of Engineers, commanding the Engineer School
of Application, whose report is submitted herewith.
    The reef to be destroyed consisted of the whole of the middle reef in
Hell Gate, comprising Flood Rock proper and the reefs known as
the Negro Heads, Hen and Chickens, and Gridiron. A narrow strip of
Flood Rock was bare at high water, and isolated projections of other
reefs mentioned were visible at low water. The present project of im-
provement contemplates making a depth of 26 feet at mean low water
over the entire area occupied by the reef, which is about 9 acres. Asit
involved but little extra cost, however, the charge was so placed as to
break the rock to a depth of 30 feet mean low water, so that, should the
necesities of commerce demand this extra depth at any time, it can be
obtained by dredging.
    The method adopted for the removal of the reef consisted in sinking
a shaft on the highest point and running a sufficient number of galle-
ries from the foot of this shaft, under the reef, to enable charges of ex-
plosives to be so placed as to break up the whole reef at one blast.
    This method is not considered an economical one for the removal of
submarine reefs under ordinary circumstances.        But in a crowded chan-
nel like Hell Gate, where the engineer must be prepared for constantly
recurring collisions, working from the surface is beset with unusual dif-
ficulties and uncertainties; thus the Hell Gate drill-scow, designed for
use on the smaller reefs whose location forbids the tunneling method,
has been run into more than once with sufficient force to wreck the col-
liding vessel and to seriously cripple the drill-scow.
    However, as each reef that is removed helps greatly to reduce the
current and so to simplify navigation as to enable pilots to keep control
of their vessels and avoid collisions, the uncertainty of doing econom-
ical work from the surface in Hell Gate is rapidly disappearing.
    The total amount expended on Flood Rock from June 7, 1875, when
the sinking of the shaft was commenced, to October 12, 1885, when all
hands were paid off, is $1,061,953.18.
    The distribution bf this expenditure among the various branches of
the work, and the amount of work done, are set forth in the accompa-
nying tabular statements.
   It is not practicable to run tunnels under the bed of a river through
treacherous rock, keeping as near the water as possible, at the same cost
as ordinary tunneling; but to show the improvement made in such work
since the Hallet's Point explosion in 1876, it is only necessary to say that
the total cost of breaking up the reef at Flood Rock per cubic yard of
rock originally in the reef above the plane of 26 feet below mean low
water is 56 per cent. less than the same item for Ballet's Point, and the
total cost per cubic yard of rock actually brokers is 65 per cent. less.
682    REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

   Work was commenced sinking the shaft at Flood Rock June 7, 1875,
and the whole mine could have been completed in four years; but owing
to the insufficiency of the appropriations, it was not finished until June
25, 1885.
   The total amount of rock excavated from the mine was 80,231.94 cu-
bic yards, arild the total length of galleries driven, averaging 10 feet by
10 feet in cross-section, was 21,668.88 feet.
   June 30, 1885, the force at the mine was reduced to a gang of 26 men,
selected from amongst all the employds on the rolls, for the responsible
duty of loading into the mine the 288,936 pounds of explosives required
for the blast. It had been decided that safety could be best secured by
limiting the amount of explosives to be loaded to about 6,000 pounds per
day, so as to avoid all haste and confnsion and permit closer supervision.
   The packing-rooms for loading the cartridges and preparing them to
be taken down into the mine were located on a dike built by the United
States between Great and Little Mill Rocks, about 1,000 feet from Flood
Rock, and on board the United States steam-drill scow moored at the
dock at Mill Rock.
   As rackarock, which had been selected for the blast after a prolonged
series of experiments, is absolutely inexplosive so long as its two ingre-
dients are not mixed, the contract called for its delivery in large quan-
tities of 100,000 pounds. The first shipment was received July 22, and
stored, the chlorate of potash in sheds at one end of the dike, and the
di-nitro-benzol at the other, the mixing-house being about half way be-
tween them, convenient to the dock.
   The danger of keeping large quantities of dynamite on hand within a
few hundred yards of the tenement houses of a populous city like New
York was duly appreciated, and the quantity to be delivered by the
contractor was, therefore, limited to a week's supply, which was de-
livered sealed in copper cartridges, and stored under water in the river,
where the chances of an accidental explosion were a minimum, and
where the results of such an accident, should one occur, would be re-
duced by the tamping of the water to local effects only. The contractor
made his first delivery of dynamite July 29, and the first 2,500 cartridge-
cases having been received July 25, on July 30 everything was in readi-
ness to begin charging the mine. The process was as follows:
   A keg of chlorate of potash was brought down from the storehouse
at one en'd of the dike and 56 pounds weighed out and carried into the
mixing-house, passed rapidly through a sieve, and spread out in a large
lead-lined trough. At the same time a barrel of the di-nitro-benzol oil
was tapped at the other end of the dike, 144 pounds weighed out and
carried to the mixing-house and sprinkled with a large watering-can
over the chlorate in the trough. The two ingredients were then thor-
oughly mixed by stirring with wooden hoes. The mixing requires but
a few minutes' time, when the explosive is ready for use. It has the
appearance of very light brown Slugar, and a strong odor o hbitter al-
monds.
   From the mixing-trough the rackarock was passed to the small troughs
of the packers, standing at a narrow table along one side of the mixing-
house, who rapidly packed it into the long copper cartridges intended
for tL e mine.
   These cartridges (Fig. 1), of which 44,175 were used, were 2 feet long
and 24 inches in diameter, and were made of sheet-copper only 0.005
of inch thick and tinned on the inside. They were adopted, after ex-
tended experiment, asbeing the best possible envelope for the trans-
mission of symnlpathetic explosions, and having stood well for three
f=

     FIG.4   FrI. I            F I   G. 2




N,




                      FIG. $




                                            TE   AMIRON4   oAPHIC   CO,V.
        APPENDIX    E-REPORT       OF   LIEUT.-COL. MCFARLAND.         683

months the action of sea-water on the outside and that of rackarock on
the inside.
   The tin cases used at Hallet's Point could not be used at Flood Rock,
as they would not stand the exposure to the action of the salt water in
the drill-holes for so long a period as that required to charge the mine.
Owing to the extreme thinness of the copper used, however, the Flood
Rock cartridges cost materially less than the tin ones. To assist in
preventing the cartridges from sliding out of the drill-holes, nearly all
of which opened downwards, four wire prongs (shown in Fig. 1) were
soldered to their bottoms, which held the cartridge in place by pressing
against the sides of the drill-holes. This device could not be relied
upon altogether, however, experience at Hallet's Point having shown
that it was liable to fail, on account of the breaking of the prongs, three
cartridges having fallen to the ground in consequence. In all cases, there-
fore, the last cartridges put into the hole was solidly wedged in place
with small pine wedges. Notwithstanding this precaution, however,
one cartridge was dropped at Flood Rock. One of the miners, on leaving
off work at night, having failed to securely wedge the mouth of the hole,
the prongs on one of the cartridges gave way during the night, allow-
ing it to slide out of the hole, and fall to the ground, a distance of about
10 feet. This was the only occurrence of the kind throughout the
loading.
   The rackarock was loaded into these cartridge-cases through a copper
funnel and packed with a wooden rammer. When filled they contained
about 5.72 pounds of rackarock. In addition a small primer, consisting
of a thirty-grain fulminate cap and one ounce of No. 1 dynamite put
loosely into a stout copper shell (Fig. 11), tightly worked and sealed, was
buried in the rackarock about four inches from the end of the can. The
office of this primer was to transmit the explosion throughout the
length of the charge in the drill-holes, which in many cases were as much
as 12 feet deep.
   This method of securing the explosion of long, narrow charges of such
inert explosives as rackarock was devised at Flood Rock, and its effi-
ciency thoroughly tested by a complete series of experiments, which
were reported at the close of the last fiscal year.
   Without it rackarock would have been rejected at Flood Rock on ac-
count of the uncertainty of continuing the explosion to the bottom of
the hole.
   As fast as the cartridges could be filled they were thoroughly wiped
off and passed across the mixing room to a table along the opposite
wall, where their lids were securely soldered on by the use of a fusible
alloy melting at 160 ° F., and a soldering-iron heated by a jet of exhaust
steam to a temperature of 2120. As neither dynamite nor rackarock are
exploded by a temperature less than 3600, a sufficient margin for safety
was allowed.
   This process was invented for the occasion at Flood Rock, the vola-
tility of the nitro-benzol and its extremely penetrating character pre-
venting the use of any other method of closure.
   The tightness of the soldering of every cartridge was thoroughly
tested, and the cartridges were then stood up in boxes divided into com-
partments, as shown in Fig. III. As fast as filled, these boxes, con-
taining 20 cartridges, were carried out and delivered by the contractor's
men to the inspector's gang aboard the drill-scow, who critically ex-
amined each cartridge, covered the solder on the lid with wax to pro-
tect it from the action of the salt water, and completed the contents of
each box by adding six dynamite cartridges, described below, a suitable
684       REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

number of small pine wedges, and a bunch of tin tags corresponding in
number with the cartridges in the box.
   The dynamite cartridges, 14,162 of which were used,were 24 inches in
diameter and 15 inches long (Fig. IV). They were packed by the con-
tractor at his works at Tom's River, N. J., under the supervision of an
inspector, and delivered at Mill Rock ready for use, except that into
each one a 30-grain fultninate cap had to be inserted and the can re-
sealed with wax. The object of this cap was to insure an explosion of
the first order when the charge was fired by sympathy. The boxes of
cartridges were loaded on a tug-boat four at a time, and taken over to
Flood Rock, and lowered at once into the mine, and loaded into the drill-
holes. In this way no considerable quantity of explosive was kept on
hand anywhere above ground; so that, had an explosion occurred at
any time, it would only have been sufficiently great to wreck the works,
without spreading destruction through the upper part of New York,
City and the village of Astoria.
   The force of twenty men, in the mine, under the supervision of an
overseer, was divided into three gangs, each in charge of a foreman,
and each gang subdivided into squads of two men each; each squad
worked by itself, and was composed of the same men throughout the
season.
  Every drill-hole in the mine had previously been located, plotted,
and numbered by the surveying party, and the proper charge for each
hole had been computed.        The foremen were furnished with small
printed sheets, prepared by the surveyor, giving the number of the holes
to be loaded by each squad and the number of cartridges required in
each hole. Each squad carried its own cartridges, one boxful at a time,
from the foot of the shaft to the heading to which it was assigned; the
cartridges were shoved home with a wooden rod, and, as each cartridge
went in, a corresponding tin tag, taken from the powder-box, was strung
on a wire with the tin tag bearing the number of the drill-hole. The
bunches of tags thus formed were collected by the foremen, and turned
in to the surveyor, who thus verified the charge put in each hole, and
kept an accurate account of the distribution of all the explosive in the
1ine.
   In all cases the last cartridge put in each hole was dynamite, the
range of sympathetic explosion for this material having been accurately
determined by a series of experiments reported in the Annual Report of
the Chief of Engineers for 1885. The end of the cartridge was allowed
to project from the drill-hole a distance of about 6 inches, that it might
receive the full effect of the blow from the primary charge intended to
fire it. It was solidly wedged in this position with pine wedges.
   Where the galleries were low, the drill-holes in the roof could be
reached from the floor, but, as the top of the galleries followed in a gen-
eral way the surface of the rock, their height varied from 5 feet to 33
feet, and special provision had to be made for reaching the high holes.
  This was accomplished by the use of sectional saIffols, mounted on the
mine cars and rolled along on a portable track; their height could be
altered in a few minutes to any elevation wanted.
   With the exception of a little inconvenience caused on several occa-
sions by the non-arrival of the supply of dynamite when due, the work
of loading the drill-holes progressed with the utmost smoothness and reg-
ularity from July 30 to its completion, September 28.
   But one unforeseen difficulty occurred during the whole work. Not-
withstanding the test that the copper cartridges had been subjected to,
it was discovered towards the end that some of them were corroded. On
        APPENDIX    E-REPORT       OF LIEUT.-COL.    MCFARLAND.       685

  nvestigation it was found that some of the water that leaked into the
mine through the drill-holes was strongly charged with sulphur, which
rapidly attacked the copper cartridges. From the locations in which
this effect was found to be the most pronounced it is believed that the
sullphur came from the ashes used for filling in behind the sea wall in
constructing the small island on which the plant was located, and pos-
sibly also from the wrecks of coal barges, many of which have been lost
on the reef.
   The trouble was discovered before any great damage was done, and
a remedy was readily found by coating the cartridge with a wax made
of resin, beeswax, and tallow, put on hot; but, although only 536 car-
tridges were seriously damaged, the question of the integrity of the car-
tridge was of such vital importance that it was deemed prudent to take
out in all 7,759, both rackarock and dynamite.
   The labor of withdrawing such a number of charges from the drill-
holes, dipping them in melted wax, and replacing them, besides being
an exceedingly delicate operation, made an amount of extra work, at a
time when all hands were fully occupied, that added immensely to the
difficulty of the final preparations.
   When the loading was completed, the charge consisted of 240,399
pounds of rackarock and 42,331 pounds of dynamite, distributed over
the whole nine acres of the reef in proportion to the volume of rock plus
one-fourth the volume of water overhead.
   Where the rock was very hard it was allowed 25 per cent. extra, and
where exceptionally soft a reduction of 25 per cent. was made. The num-
ber of cubic yards of rock to be broken by the blast was 270,716.7, so
that the charge was at the rate of 1.04 pounds per cubic yard.
   The charge at the final blast at Hallet's Point in 1876 was 0.79 pounds
per cubic yard; but an increase was deemed necessary at Flood Rock,
because the thickness of the roof was much greater, and because the
amount of rock excavated from the galleries was 2.7 times less in pro-
portion to the amount of rock to be broken by the blast than at Hallet's
Point, and consequently the whole of the reef had to be lifted to allow
it to break, instead of getting the breaking effect of a fall, as at Hal-
let's Point.
   When work of this kind was first undertaken at Hell Gate it was be-
lieved to be possible to make an excavation below the reef capable of
receiving all the debris from the roof and pillars, and so gain at once the
required depth of water. But on account of the seamy and treacherous
nature of the rock of which the Hell Gate reefs are composed it is found
that when the excavation becomes very large an inordinate amount of
expensive timbering has to be done, as the falling of a single large
block of stone from the roof (a very common occurrence in ordinary
mining and tunneling) might result in flooding the whole mine in a few
minutes. Besides, as broken stone takes up much more space than the
same amount of rock before it is broken (at Hallet's Point the ratio was
1.45), to make certain of having the required depth immediately after
the blast it would be necessary to excavate at least twice as much rock
from the mine as it was intended to break up by the final blast. The
average thickness of the roof at Flood Rock was 18.86 feet.
   As this kind of excavation is necessarily costly, the ultimate cost of
the result produced would be exceedingly high. It was, therefore, early
decided in the course of. the work at Hallet's Point to excavate only a
relatively small amount (0.78 yard per yard of roof), but to thoroughly
break up the roof by the final blast and remove so much of the d6bris
as might be necessary by dredging.
686     REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,              U. S. ARMY.

   The expectations of the engineer were so well fulfilled in this case,
and such good results were obtained with the dredging, that it was de-
cided to make a still further saving of expense at Flood Rock by an ex-
tension of the same policy, and during the later years of the work the
excavation was limited as much as possible, only such galleries being
run as were necessary to admit of the drill-holes for the explosives being
properly distributed.
   The excavation at Flood Rock, therefore, amounted to 0.296 cubic
yard only per cubic yard broken by the final blast, and instead of any
greater depth on the reef being looked for after the blast, it had been
computed that there should be a shoaling averaging several feet over
the whole reef.
   In all the work done in Hell Gate the near proximity of tall buildings
ih New York City and on Ward's and Blackwell's islands had to be con-
stantly borne in mind. It had already been well settled by the experience
acquired at Hallet's Point, that a large factor controlling the shock trans-
mitted through the ground is the size of the individual charges, and
that no fear need be felt in firing even as large a blast as 288,936 pounds
at Flood Rock, provided it be sufficiently distributed. It was, therefore,
tried as far as possible to limit the charges to 25 pounds per drill-hole,
though in a few cases charges as great as 37 pounds could not be avoided.
The average charge was 22.5 pounds.
   The drilling of holes of sufficient size to hold such charges, slanting
upwards into the roof, was a work of exceptional difficulty that had to
be met with the invention of special appliances; 13,023 such holes were
drilled, aggregating 113,102.15 feet in length. Only 12,561 of these
holes were actually charge(l, a considerable number having to be re-
jected on account of the pressure of the water flowing in them being so
great as to prevent their being used.
   The arrangements for firing simultaneously this large number of
charges were reduced to great simplicity. Elaborate experiments (re-
ported last year) were made early in the season to determine with cer-
tainty to what extent sympathetic explosion could be relied on in firing
the mine, and it was decided to dispense with connecting wires to the
drill-holes entirely, it having been ascertained that the explosion of a
charge of 10 pounds of dynamite under water will fire with certainty any
number of other charges of dynamite packed solidly in thin elastic en-
velopes within a radius of 27 feet. Primary charges of 10 pounds of
dynamite were therefore placed at intervals of 25 feet along the galleries
from which the holes were drilled, and these primary charges only were
connected with the batteries. There were 591 of them, arranged on 24
different circuits.
   They consisted of two 24 inch by 24 inch thin copper cartridges solidly
packed with dynamite, lashed on horizontal timbers from 3 to 12 feet
above the floor, according to the height of the gallery; each cartridge
also containing a 30-grain fulminate cap. On the top of the two cart-
ridges a smaii primer was lashed, made of stiff brass, containing the
platinum fuse fastened to the wires connected with the battery and half
a pound of dynamite put in loose.
   In locating the primary charges care was taken to have alternate
charges on different circuits, so that in the event of a failure of any
circuit its charges would nevertheless explode by sympathy, being
within less than 27 feet of four other primaries on three other circuits,
and part of the dynamite being solidly packed in thin elastic envelopes.
The dynamite in the brass primers was put in loose, because in this
shape it is but little affected by water, and it was difficult to make cer-
                   BATTERY            BATT ERY




                             io . S



                                                 THE AMRRIOr SUAPNO Otr


N Ex1 p2 v2 49 2
        APPENDIX    E-REPORT       OF LIEUT.-COL.      MCFARLAND.       687
tain of the tightness of the packing of the wires in the neck of the
primer.
    The circuits were made without joints, the wires being cut to the
proper length and the platinum bridge soldered directly to them, and
the gutta-percha insulation of the wire was carried over the whole fuze.
Twenty-one of these circuits contained 25 fuzes, each connected with
wires 52 feet long, of No. 18 copper insulated to No. 9, with lead wires
at each end of the circuit, 600 feet long, of No. 12 copper, insulated
to No. 9 A wire gauge.         The remaining three circuits contained 22
fuzes, each connected with wires 106 feet long, and having lead wires
of 950 feet; these circuits, intended for the extreme northern portion of
the work, were nearly a mile in length. The bridges of the fuzes were
of pure platinum wire 0.0005 of an inch thick. They had a resistance
of 1.73 ohms cold and 2.76 ohms when heated to the exploding point.
It required a current of 0.615 amperes to explode them when connected
in series.
    The number of fuzes and the amount of wire in each circuit were so
adjusted that at the instant of explosion all should have the same re-
resistance, 77.43 ohms.
    These values were determined in advance by the engineers of the
work.
    The circuits were made to order by the Laflin & Rand Powder Com-
pany, under the personal supervision of Mr.     11. Julius Smith, who also
made the fuzes for the Hallet's Point blast. Mr. Smith kindly volun-
teered to assist in laying the wires in the mine, and rendered valuable
assistance in this delicate and tedious work. The wires were laid in
about 26 hours, under the personal direction of Lieutenant Derby, by
four gangs made up of the most intelligent of the miners.
    The battery used in firing the mine was furnished by E. S. Greeley &
Co., and consisted of 60 bichromate cells coupled in series. The plates
were 6 inches by 9 inches, four carbon and three zinc in each cell, sep-
arated by only one-fourth of an inch. The electromotive force of the
cells was between 1.95 and 2.07 volts; the internal resistance was less
than 0.01 ohms. The battery was of sufficient power to send through
every fuze a current just double that computed to be necessary to fire it.
    On account of the grave objection to having any joints in the wires
under water, and the great advantage of having no resistance between
the battery and the point of separation of the different circuits, the lead
wires from each circuit led directly t( the battery, which was located at
the head of the shaft on top of the rock.
    The arrangement of the circuit closer is shown in Fig. 5. Two large
  mercury cups formed the poles of the battery. One of these cups re-
ceived the ends of the twenty-four lead wires, and the other was con-
nected by a heavy band of copper with the mercury in a stout iron cup,
in which sat a thin glass tumbler, also containing mercury. A stout cop-
  per strip connected the mercury in this glass with that in another mer-
  cury cup which received the twventy-four return wires.
    The circuit was closed by breaking the thin glass, and allowing the mer-
  cury in it to mix with that in the iron cup. A l.ong quarter-inch iron rod,
  terminating at its upper end in a small disc, was passed through a hole
  in the roof of the battery house, and stood up in the thin glass tumbler
  with its point resting on the bottom of it. A thirty-grain fulminate fuze
  was laid on the disc, and fastened to it with wax a few inches above
the roof of the battery house, and was fired by means of a small bat-
tery at Astoria. The blow struck by the fuze on the disc and trans-
688     REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

mitted by the iron rod had been found by experiment to be so sharp as
to reduce the glass tumbler to dust without splashing the mercury.
   The mine was fired from a point on the Astoria shore, about 1,000 feet
away, at 11h 13m 50 s standard time, October 10, 1885.
   Three instantaneous photographs were taken under the direction of
Lieut. Col. H. L. Abbot, Corps of Engineers, at different periods of the
upheaval. The first of these, taken two-tenths of a second after the
closing of the circuit, shows the water rising nearly uniformly over the
whole site of the reef, and illustrates well both the completeness of the
explosion and the simultaneity of the action of the separate charges.
As was expected, there was no loud report, no severe shock through the
earth, and no scattering of the dbris.
   Lieutenant-Colonel Abbot's report on the transmission of the vibra-
tion through the earth is submitted herewith.
   Examinations of the reef were commenced the next day, and it was
inspected on six successive tides by an experienced diver. He reported
the bottom broken in large blocks, separated by cracks, but not turned
over with ragged edges on top. In many cases the cracks were large
enough for him to crawl into.
   A survey of the whole reef was commenced at once and has since
been completed. It shows that the surface of the whole reef has been
altered, proving the reef to be shattered, and the changes are nowhere
greater than at the most remote corner of the reef, where the bottom
has been raised 10 feet.
   Thanks to thp use of rackarock instead of dynamite, and the utilization
of sympathetic explosion instead of wires and fuzes for firing the mine,
and the savings effected in many details, a balance of about $100;000
from the appropriation of July 5, 1884, for firing the mine remained
available to commence the dredging.
   It was decided to apply this sum in such a way as to produce the
greatest immediate benefit to navigation, which was in reducing the
dangerous reefs known as the Negro Heads and Hen and Chickens to a
depth of 18 feet at mean low water, a depth sufficient for at least 90
per cent. of the vessels passing through Hell Gate, and giving an
effective width of 350 feet to the Middle Channel, previously too narrow
and tortuous to be used by any but the smallest vessels.
   Bids were at once called for on advertised specifications, and a con-
tract entered into with the Atlantic Dredging Company, of Brooklyn, for
the removal of about 30,000 tons ofrock, at $3.19 per ton, the contractor
to do his own surface blasting. This price was considered satisfactory,
the first part of the work being the most difficult, on account of the
blocks of stone on the surface being the largest, as they are the furthest
away from the drill-holes containing the explosives.
   The third contract on Hallet's Point, let on the same terms as to sur-
face blasting as the Flood Rock contract, was made at $3.39 per ton.
   It will be seen from the report of Lieut. Col. Walter McFarland, Ap-
pendix E 5, that at the close of the fiscal year the contract had been
nearly completed, 28,622.312 tons of rock having been removed.
   The reef had been attacked in four different places, and so far from
any exceptional difficulty with the dredging having been encountered,
the progress made is unprecedented, the largest of the dredges having
averaged up to May 1 80.5 tons per working day, while on Hallet's Point
the same machine only averaged 50.4 tons for a like period. The cost
of the surface' blasting done by the contractor up to June 30, 1886,
amounted to only 13.4 cents per ton of rock removed.
                                    -
               - --
                                IMPROVEMENT
                                                                                                                                                                      --                                    __
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        N
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               -~-L~-                            __
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                1
                                                                      or
EAST RIVER                                                        Als                   HELL GATE
                                          NEW YORK
                                                            REMOVAL                OF

                             FLOOD ROCK,                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    GRZAT
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               RocMIL
SKETCH SHOWINS                THE LSURFACE OF THE REEF                                                          AND            LOCAT/ON
                              or GALLEs/IES ,,P, a'.


       to       accompany
                 Anrmtce.aO Redort. of                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        t       sr4
BR/G. GEN.JOHN NEWrTON, Cirtr   or EGNERS                                                                                                                                                                                                                 AND
                                    BVT MAJ. Ge..                                            UA.A
                                                              /886
                                                            SCALE          /000.                                                    f ,TL              ,LROCK                                                                                                                                                                             .        ,
                                                                                                                                        Lirr..
                                                                                                                                          •,   MrL u..Ro. c, ..
                                                                                                                                               -..                                                                                            \


                                                                                                                             ,,                   .                                   *.--                                                                           ..                                                                                          ..                                        ,




                                                                                                                                    I .                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           ..

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              (2r




                                                                                             0                           N.............
                                                                                                                                      .                                                                 -                 ,.,                                                                                 .-.-                                                                                     "
                                                                                                                             N R.            H E A           s                                                                                                                                                              . ( . ..               ....-..                                    f,


                                                                             --                             !~L~.                                                    .._ _                   ..      -           I-,=3I
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          <;                                                  ,                             C                                                                      - ....                              .,-'--,
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                t                                                                  r            ,
                              t.--,




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  iic~
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 C

                                        P   -      ---
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    10
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 C
                                        40
                                            P1-         -
                                                                                                                                                                                 0                   S----------



                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                            ccD                                  O..
                                                                                                        E+CJ1U
                                                                                                            --
                                                                                                                         D
                                                                                                                                    1


                                                                                                                 -                                      -.       -                                                                                  -!-



                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               ~
                                                                                                                                                                                     ' G . 1 Do]i o
                                                1 ...             I


                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              7-3~~01lO

                                                             '(I4&fEU 01Q
                                                             IA--Y~C                                                         ,---
                                                                                                                                     IUI uiVClFGJ;8V
                                                                                                                                             ils                                                                 1
                                                                                                                                                                                                                         l    r--'--
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  tls~tj  _-u~




                        L    -- "                                                                                         crie~IT~LoEoi                                                                                                ,1,l
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  EZfO                        ooo                         i OQ.A
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                --t2-1
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       Bonnrn
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          eHIf-4I                      1=          #(*)
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               r:m?"
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                ti
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       r   TIT
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           +Afz-
                                                  Q                                     b8                                St            Dtn i t                                  plo             f




                                                                                                                                                                                                 :a+
                                                                                                                                                                                                       lI

                                                                                                                                                                                                                              JI                   1
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    I                1    I       .       I           I       %

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          1,1I.Uj
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           U      7LU
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        ,        .,I      r    1   ,1.1#'I
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         ti
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               11.1




                                    3
                I----
                                    r
                                                                                             r'


                                                                                             l'
                                                                                                        t
                                                                                                       1W            I
                                                                                                                          c,1c?~r
                                                                                                                            ' -V         I                   L
                                                                                                                                                                                 ac~eo=
                                                                                                                                                                                 11              L i        --   .
                                                                                                                                                                                                                     1   'L
                                                                                                                                                                                                                              ~01 DL
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  -  I             M             i        s
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              on
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      I                   /       I(
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       C)
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       [
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                            _
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    ,         4-tea
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           t mic-
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             =.la a
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 V+!    "        L"    !fI
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           L                w.LrI
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 '




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               . ..r       I     IC
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         i




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  , I " --
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  a
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      .+




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           II
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                .. ,.



                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                            I
           /   H-
                                     ti
                                    -1                       f 76 If                       ThD
                                                                                        (joh-t
                                                                                               Ic itooTb-~
                                                                                                       mv                           i        lo       N--             i      1 -        6p1 :Y m                                   '     1          d~oZpe~ok11
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             A                                F                                                     +,*      W        -- %.,ow -- T7Tff
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    i-~-                                         aI
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              -       I                 '




                                                                                                                                                                                                     4.
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    1




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              OaL
                                                                                                  .-                                                             !I                                                                     ,I,
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              29
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               I
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 cb           o                   ©          c        ra
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           4,
                                                                                                                                                                      r-,I r'                m I     , In                " I                       I,


                                                                                          M197r
                                                                                     :QjG3~,                                                                                                                                                   o r Oi LO                                                                        r
                                                                                                                                                                      I                                                                                          O

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             r                    .                /                                                    r 1
                                                                                                                                                                      ~-1
                                                                                                                                                                                                                         'l            LI~u        -'-'1
                        r"          1ir~                                                                                                                                                                                           OI                  I                                      ?           I
                                                  14iAcr-%eIrN1                                                                                                       At               .JMt             1vIL~             U            1 "71u
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              tnnI        w      '       +1                   L       L      Y1
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       iT   i       ;00                                     '7        389 j            1   t    0             44       !         6
                    4                                                                                            k-wMV.                               I I LI)1 7
                                                                                                                                                        4    A~
                                                                                                                                                                                  LM Li rl              I I -7i                        I Li)       LI Lt2 1.~Jjw-'1                                                    L                  30
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          ri
                                                                                         j.rtc          ri                iirt~~                  3~[~~                                                     .v                 "




   .41!'   H'A 0/
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              3 2
                                                 7           t2                                                                                                           ii~g        b5     i       ~t~ ~               24             45        Z6;




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           I--AMRICAWGRAPHCQN.Y.
                                                     IMPROVEMENT

                  EAST RIVER                                       AND            HELL GATE
                                                       NEW YORK
                      SKETrCH SHOWING THE OR/6/NAL AND PRESENT CONDITION                                                   OF
                                                     HELL GATE

                            to accompazny AnnruacL Report. of
                      BRIG. G£N.JOHN NLEWTON.                                     Cvr,, or E                       wNS R s
                                                     BVTAAJ: GN. U.S.A.
                                                       OcroDER /886

                                                            ScAL      1.
                           1,40~       ~!   irs---
                                                      _~~Li    ~
                                                       _FgoZ-;lt~-
                                                             *u _-cr:~-
                                                                          ~   -
                                                                                   71
                                                                                  -,-
                                                                                          P
                                                                                        -- r-   -'^--
                                                                                                _-      :
                                                                                                            loot
                                                                                                               7
                                                                                                             - '
                                                                                                                    .
                                                                                                                     V-"   c
                                                                                                                               -
                                                                                                                                   ---   1




44-
                                                                                                                                                                                       C         ha
                                                                                                                                                                           t i                                                                                 Al4 4
                  C                                                                                                                                                    S
                      4, f
                                                                                                                                                                 -1%
                                   4




                                                                                                                                                           di1
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     ex~
                                                                                                                                                  M4                                                                                            Tap       ft




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           d~a:;o~gi~onS~E10




                                                            &Cheese
                                                                              EAS T                                 R /I VER


                                                                                                                                                           C"


                                                     14 E



                  cHAN                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      0
CA     ,ST


                                                                                                                                                                            £LECTRIC
                                                                                                                                                                                                                  Feef                                                          CA,
                                                                                                                                                                                                           Rem ovecL io26ftt.




                                                                                                                                             1.        0         R
                                                                                                                        S                                                                                                                             0




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          o
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                (n



                                                                                                                                                                                           C o rakeA
                                                                                                                                                                                           'ca   .~f



                                                                                                                                                                                                                         oonR0




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                            e
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     ZZ,
                                                                                                                                                                                                                             Y   d
                                                                                                                                                                                                                         N




             - Sot~ndingr refer to Mean Low Water at H/azlet s Pt. -                                                                                                                                   e"totrd   tog.
                                                                                                                                                                                                                  6




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 THE AMERICAN GRAPHIC CO.,N.Y,

H Exi pt2 v2 49 2
        APPENDIX E-REPORT          OF LIEUT.-COL. MCFARLAND.          68

    It is estimated that the total amount of broken rock to be removed to
give a clear depth of 26 feet at mean low water over the whole reef is
294,000 tons, which should be removed in about three years if no delay
is caused by lack of appropriations.
    As any sort of an accident in the handling of the large quantity of
explosive used at Flood Rock would probably have resulted in the loss
o' the whole work, it is evident that the success achieved is attributable
to   the faithfulness and intelligence of every employ6 on the roll, every
one of whom had important and responsible duties to perform.
    The services of Nicholas Terry, overseer; Edward Matthews, Peter
Boyle, and John Wills, foremen; and James Quigley, recorder, are
specially worthy of mention.
    Mr. J. M. Gore and W. L. Quinn, overseers of the drill-scow, ren-
dered valuable services as inspectors; and Mr. G. W. Kuehnle, sur-
veyor, in addition to his regular work, performed a variety of duties
most creditably.
   As Chief of Engineers my duties confined me for the most part to
my station in Washington; and Col. Walter McFarland, who oblig-
ingly consented to assist me in the closing operations at the reef, was
compelled, in deference to the proper care of the numerous works in his
charge, to be frequently absent, the result being that the actual over-
sight of the preparations for the explosion fell upon Lieut. G. McC.
Derby, of the Corps of Engineers; and I know no one who could have
performed the difficult task with more skill and conscientious care.
   Respectfully submitted.
                                              JOHN NEWTON,
                                                        Brig. Gen.,
                                                     Ohief of Engineers.
  The CHIEF OF ENGINEERS.
      44 E
        Tabulated statement of the amount and cost of work done at Flood Rock, Hell Gate, East River, New York, from June 7, 1875, to October 10, 1885.


                                                                                                                                                                    Cost of mining
                                                          Cost of plant.            Cost ofrepairs to              Operating expenses                                 80,231.94 cubic
                                      Number                                                                                                                          yards of rock in      Cost of                     Cost of
                                                                                                                                                                      galleries 10 by       drilling
                                                                                                                                                                                                                Cost i main
     Nature of work.                                                                                                                                Totales.                                                   of final tenance                       Total cost.
                                     of
                                     of8shifts
                                         hourrs                                                             .                                     expenses.           10 feet.              for final
                                                                                                                                                                                                                blast.   while                                                 0I'd
                                      worked.                                           .                                       i       a•                                                    blast.~
                                                                                                                                                                i
                                                                                                                                                                                             i          .                             idle.
                                                                                                                                                                     Total.   Perubic                                                                                          0
                                                                                                                                                                               yard.
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               O
Sea-wall and foundation. 25, 521. 875 $2, 918 26 $14, 458 65 ...                                                     ....                  $17, 376 91$15, 759 74
                                                                                                                                           $...........                          $0. 196 $1, 617 16 ...............                                 ..........
Drilling .............               107, 502      24, 970 04 4,819 39 $19,672 55$26,841                        37 $42, 90244 $248, 974 70 368, 180 4 308, 240 26                 3.841 59,940 23 ....................         ..........
Blasting ......           .......      4, 634. 125 ..........................                            117    28 86,989 35 11,588 081 98, 694 71 98, 694 71                     1. 23    ...
Hauling............                   52, 052. 125 2, 036 78 4, 597 85 1, 961 52 4, 936                         75 10, 772 00, 97, 128 46 121, 433 36 121,433 36                  1. 513 .......      ..........         ..... .........
Hoisting . ...........                 3, 892. 75 7,535 21 4, 477 20 1, 433 41 1, 816                           33 9,219 46      8, 059 14  32, 540 75 32, 540 75                 0. 405 !........ -..........   .......              ...                         .....
Dumping .........                 ... 5, 867. 875 2, 997 85                   604 32 1, 022 62 1, 680           33 4, 681 01     6, 788 47  17,774 60 17, 774 60                  0.221.................                                      ............                     0
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               O
Pumping. -....-......                  8, 488. 625 10, 020 68 3, 459 73 4, 004 42 7, 740                        43 27, 882 44 16, 508 56    69, 616 26 59, 557 50                 0.742      6,115      24 $3,943 52..........                         ..       ....
Ventilating ....             .... 1, 389. 75 1, 374 30                        853 44    454 70           663    16 5, 848 17     2, 218 79  11, 412 56 10, 349 04                 0.129      1, 063     52.............                         .............
Timbering...... ......                 3, 569. 625 ...         ..............              .............             2, 183 99   7,582 19    9,766 18 8, 843 42                   0.11          922     76 ....         .........                     ...........
Transportation. .....                  7,988. 625 15, 383 92 ..........              6,153 86 5, 787            02 5,694 44 20, 151 68      53,170 92 51, 309 76                  0. 639     1, 861     16........              .................
Surveying ..           ..              8, 259. 875........ .......... 129 45                              42    12      472 26 27, 283 151 27, 926 98 24,016 98                   0.30       3,910      00 ......              .............
Maintenance of plant,
  while idle..         .......... 10, 818. 125 ................                  ... 2, 755 36 11, 819          72 9, 266 66        19, 082 08      42, 923 82   ..    ......                                -         $42, 923 82..........                                   z

Final blast .............              5,816. 125 .........            ...... ...     ........                  .. 91,185 83        16,118 65      107,304 48 ......... ..........          .......          107,304 48 ..----       --....                                        tt

Office expenses               and                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              ItCi
  superintendence ...... 19, 210. 625 ........                            1, 242 47       16 50 7, 150          65 14, 545 65       60, 905 89      83, 861 16 76,056 80          0. 948     7, 804 36          ...........                      ..........               ..   t4
         Total ...........          265, 012. 12567, 237 04 34, 513 05 37,604 39 68, 595 16 311, 643 70 542, 389 84 1, 061, 983 18 824,576 92                                    10.277    83,234 41111, 248 00 42,923 82 $1,061, 983 18


                                                                           Cost of drilling per linear foot: 2-inch hole, $0. 316; 3-inch hole, $0. 53.

Number of feet of galleries driven....................                         ..............                     21, 668..88       Number of pounds of explosives used in mining (principally dynamite
Number of cubic yards of rock mined ...                         . ................................   ....         80,231.94          No. 2).....................      ...                                 ................      . .. 184, 407,125
Number of 2-inch holes drilled.................................                                                      235, 318       Number of pounds of explosives used per cubic yard mined ................                                2. 29
Number of 2-inch holes fired.... .............................                            ..........                 223, 545       Number of 3-inch holes drilled for the final blast.- - .....                     ............          13, 023
Number of feet of 2-inch holes drilled .............................                                             974, 446. 42       Number of feet of 3.-inch holes drilled .............................                             113,102. 15
Number of feet drilled per cubic yard mined.............................                                               12. 14       Number of feet of 3-inch holes drilled per machine per shift of eight hours.                            20. 32
Number of feet drilled per machine per shift ...........                              ..........                       29. 8        Number of cubic yards broken by final blast ...... ..................                             270, 716. 7
         APPENDIX       E-REPORT OF LIEUT.-COL.                MCFARLAND.            691
     THE EARTH WAVE AT THE DESTRUCTION OF FLOOD ROCK.
                      BY LIEUTENANT-COLONEL HENRY L. ABBOT,
               Corps of Engineers, Brevet Brigadier-General, U. S. Army.

                                        CONTENTS.
  Letter of transmittal.
  Report of General Abbot.
  A. The explosion at Hallets Point in 1876, by General Abbot.
  B. Velocity of transmission of earth waves, by General Abbot.
  C. Seismographic observations at Astoria in 1885, by Captain Knight.
  D. Determination of the instant of explosion in 1885, by Captain Bailey.
  E. Photographs taken at Astoria in 1885, by First Lieutenant Lusk.
                                    ILLUSTRATIONS.

  Plate I. Electrical connections.
  Plate II. Seismographs at Astoria.
  Plate III. Map of vicinity of Flood Rock.



                               LETTER OF   TRANSMITTAL.


                                           WILLETS POINT, N. Y., December 29, 1885.
  GENERAL: I have the honor to transmit herewith my report upon the observations,
undertaken by your direction, to determine the rate of transmission of the earth wave
caused by the recent Flood Rock explosion. * * *
      Very respectfully, your obedient servant,
                                                                 HENRY L. ABBOT,
                                                               Lieutt. Col. of Engineers.
  Brig. Gen. JOHN NEWTON,
                  Chief of Engineers.


    REPORT   OF   LIEUTENANT-COLONEL     HENRY L.    ABBOT,   CORPS OF ENGINEERS.


                           WILLETS POINT, NEW YORK HARBOR, December 15, 1885.
Brig. Gen. JOHN NEWTON,
             Chief of Engineers:
   GENERAL: I have the honor to submit the following as my report upon the observa-
tions undertaken by your direction to determine the rate of transmission of the earth
tremor caused by the recent explosion at Flood Rock, and upon the arrangements for
securing photographs of the upheaval. In this connection I would respectfully refer
to the appended papers marked A and B, giving the results of similar observations
made at the destruction of the Hallets Point reef in 1876, and at various torpedo ex-
plosions, which.will obviate the necessity of many details in this report.
                             PRELIMINARY    PREPARATIONS.


  The most delicate and trustworthy form of seismoscope available was the mercury
arrangement employed in 1876. Four of that pattern were prepared by Captain
Knight from condemned surveying instruments in depot at Willets Point. The mag-
nifying power of the observing telescopes was about 18 diameters. The object to be
observed was the reflection of the cross-hairs of a similar telescope (of which the eye-
piece was removed to assist in focussing). These telescopes were secured to a wooden
frame, with an artificial horizon of mercury resting between them upon solid earth.
At Willets Point use was also made of a Thomson reflecting galvanometer mounted
upon a solid pier in the electrical observatory.
   As the observation of 1876 had sufficiently shown that the rate of transmission of
the earth wave is much too rapid for satisfactory measurements in the near vicinity
of the explosion, none were attempted directly at Astoria; but an approximate result
was secured by an electrical device described below, and Captain Knight obtained
some interesting data upon the intensity and direction of the shock, for which refer-
ence should be made to his report, appended and marked C.
  To secure the highest precision in such observations, the explosion must print its
own time record upon local chronographs in an electric circuit connecting the ob-
serving stations; and each observer must print the instant of arrival of the tremor
upon his own chronograph sheet by an electrical key. Through the kindness of the
692      REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

officers of the Western Union Telegraph Company and of the Long Island Railroad,
who placed their lines and offices at my disposal for the purpose without, charge to
the Government, this method was employed at all my stations except Willets Point.
   To render observations at that station of value, and to extend the use of the same
method to volunteer observers throughout the entire district affected by the shock,
who might be able to determine with precision the error of their chronometers, special
care was taken to determine the absolute time of the explosion. Captain Bailey was
charged with this duty, and his report, appended and marked D, shows that the work
was successfully accomplished with a probable error not exceeding half a second.
To assist the observers of the Geological Survey and their co-operators in eliminating
errors in time determinations, that office was informed that the beats of thd break-
circuit chronometer, which had recorded automatically the instant of firing the mine,
would be sent to the Western Union Telegraph office in New York City immediately
after the explosion, for transmission to such places as might be arranged for with the
officers of the company. No advantage was taken of this offer.
   In respect to photographic views of the explosion, it was well understood that many
would be taken by ameteur and professional observers, and the limited facilities of
the School of Application at Willet's Point (only three cameras suitable for this pur-
pose) were therefore devoted to the first instants of the explosion, which not only
possessed the highest scientific interest, but which also would afford conclusive evi-
dence as to the general or partial nature of the explosion. These three cameras were
accordingly arranged to be operated electrically, the slides being released by the ex-
plosion of fuzes at times recorded on the chronograph. The first picture was taken
automatically, by the same key and motion which exploded the mine; the others
were taken at will by Lieutenant Lnsk, in charge of the photographic party, whose
report is appended and marked E. A fourth camera was kindly loaned to Sergeant
von Sothen, Company C, Battalion of Engineers, by Mr. J. F. Wieners, jr., of College
Point, and was operated by him in the usual manner, under iustructions to secure a
view at the instant of maximum display.

                               OBSERVING STATIONS.

   The outlying stations occupied by officers of the Battalion of Engineers on Long
Island were Willets Point, Pearsalls, Bay Shore, and Patchogue, the latter three con
nected by telegraph with the firing station at'Astoria. At West Point, First Lieut.
Wallace Mott, Eighth Infantry, in charge under Professor Michie, of the astronomical
observatory, assisted by First Lieutenant Beach, Corps of Engineers, and First Lieu-
tenant Stuart, Ordnance Department, co-operated.
   The precise Long Island stations were selected after a personal inspection by Cap-
tain Knight, to secure so far as possible exemption'from deceptive earth tremors.
The general distances were chosen according to my best judgment, guided by the re-
searches made in 1876, and reported in Appendix A. The formula resulting there-
from (for a magnifying power of 12 diameters) is the following, in which D denotes
the distance in miles separating the initial disturbance from the instrument, and C
the weight of dynamite No. 1 in pounds:


                                        \1.63/

  The charge at Flood Rock being 240,399 pounds of rackarock and 48,537 pounds of
dynamite No. 1, equivalent to about 310,000 pounds of the latter, this formula indi-
cates that the tremor should be detected with a magnifying power of 12 diameters at
a limiting distance of at least 129 miles.

                           ELECTRICAL SYSTEM ADOPTED.

   The electrical connections will be understood from the accompanying plate.
  ,The main line extended from earth at West Point to earth at Patchogue on Long
Island, the battery (dynamo machines) being intermediate at the New York office of
the Western Union Telegraph Company.
   At each observing station (except Astoria) the current flowed continuously through
the coils of a 150-ohm relay, thus keeping all the local circuits open. A break in the
main circuit closed these local circuits, each consisting of 5 small Grove cells work-
ing through a Morse register, and thus made a mark on the moving fillets. Each ob-
server at the seismoscope in the vicinity held a close-circuit key in his hand and thus
could make a mark on his own fillet at pleasure. The officer acting as electrician re-
mained at the telegraph station and regulated the apparatus, according to a prear-
ranged programme.
         APPENDIX       E-REPORT         OF LIEUT.-COL.        MCFARLAND.           693

   At Astoria the circuits were as follows: The main line passed through the contact
points of a 50-ohm relay held together by a local battery of two Grove cells-which
traversed its coils, those of a second 50-ohm relay controlling an open circuit, a break-
circuit chronometer No. 1499, by Negus, a break-circuit key and a set of closed con-
tact points on the firing key. The breaks of the chronometer were thus printed at all
of the observing stations; and also on a local chronograph connected with the contact
points of the second 50-ohm relay, a local battery of three cells furnishing the need-
ful current.     By this' arrangement not only were the seconds of the chronometer
printed at all the observing stations, but warning signals could be sent at will from
Astoria by using the break-circuit key; and the explosion was recorded throughout the
line by the first movement of the firing key.
   This firing key controlled two other circuits-one to explode the mine, and the other
to take a photograph of the rock instantly thereafter.
   The firing circuit extended from earth at the Astoria station through 20 Grove cells,
the firing key, a submarine cable to the fuze at Flood Rock (arranged to break a glass
of mercury and thus close to the great battery circuit), and thence to earth. The only
break being at the firing key, a motion of one-eighth of an inch effected the explosion.
   The photograph circuit was closed by the same motion of the firing key, but at a
later instant, by a simple mechanical arrangement. Lest this arrangement should not
give enough retardation to secure a picture after the effects of the explosion became
visible, a relay was introduced to take advantage of its armature time. When its con-
tact points came together, the circuit of 10 Grove cells was closed through a fuze hold-
ing the camera slide, and also through the chronograph. This chronograph being a
Morse register with an indenting point, the increase of battery power from three cells
to ten cells made a deeper mark, which was easily distinguished from that caused by
the first motion of the firing key. Lieutenant Lusk held a special key operating the
other cameras and took the subsequent pictures at will, recording their times by the
10-cell battery on the chronograph, as will readily be understood from the plate.

                                    THE EXPLOSION.


   The parties at the outlying stations, each consisting of two officers and six enlisted
men of the Battalion, proceeded by rail to their posts on October 9. In accordance
with your instructions issued upon the application of the civil authorities at Astoria,
Captain Price, with his Company C of the Battalion of Engineers, aggregating 125 men,
embarked with myself and the observers and assistants for duty at Astoria on the same
evening on the steamboat Castleton, and we spent the night on board. Early on the
morning of October 10, the work of laying the connecting wires (nearly a mile and a
half long) and of setting up the batteries and electrical apparatus was begun, and by
the efficient assistance of First Lieutenant Roessler, Sergeant Brown, Lance-Sergeant
Warner, and the detail of privates, was completed about 10 a. m. Captain Knight
had by this time arranged his own apparatus. First Lieutenant Lusk assisted by Ser-
geant von Sothen, had established the four cameras in the best positions. Everything
with us was ready for the explosion.
   Certain volunteer observers who failed in securing results have criticised in an
unfriendly spirit the delay of less than fourteen minutes which occurred in firing the
mine. If they had comprehended how this unavoidable delay on the rock endangered
the success of the official measurements intrusted to me, they would doubtless have
taken a more charitable view of the matter. Everything with us was staked on over
one hundred miles of busy telegraph wires remaining free from interruption. Any
impatient operator on the line who might imagine that the explosion was over, had
it in his power unwittingly, by breaking in upon us, to destroy not one but all our
observations on the main line from Patchogue to West Point. I had begun to despair
of success everywhere except at Willets Point. For that place I felt secure ; because
the precaution had been taken to station two officers at each instrument, with in-
structions to relieve each other, if necessary, and continue observing until the tremor
came, or until a telegram was received at Whitestone (2j miles distant) announcing
the deferring of the explosion. A mounted soldier had been stationed there in readi-
ness to convey the message, so manifest was the possibility of a long delay in so com-
plicated a series of operations as the firing of this mine. It is to be regretted that
similar precautions were not taken elsewhere. Work of this nature cannot in practice
be regulated with the precision of the transit of a fixed star.
   At length the last party left the rock; and immediately thereafter, at llh. 13m.
50.2s. mean solar time of the 75th meridian, the mine was fired by little Miss Mary
Newton, who pressed the key with the quick and self-possessed motion necessary to
ensure the success of all our electrical arrangements; no one could have done it
better, and never before was unstable equilibrium between natural forces illustrated
upon so grand a scale through human agency.
694      REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF                   ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

                          RESULTS OF THE MEASUREMENTS.

   The following is a summary of the reports of the several parties acting under my
direction, with such other data as have been furnished by friends or made public,
respecting the rate of transmission of the earth wave. They are arranged in the order
of increasing distance from the explosion upon two lines-one extending eastward
across the drift formation of Long Island, and the other northward through the solid
rock underlying that region.
   Experience at the Hallet's Point explosion had shown the necessity of having two
officers at each outlying station, one to attend to the electrical arrangements and
communicate with Astoria, and the other to use the seismoscope at the best place in
the vicinity to which electrical connections could readily be extended. As the high-
est interest attached to the more distant stations, the officers senior in rank were as-
signed to them. All did their work admirably and were completely successful.
   The distances from Flood Rock to all the stations at which observations are dis-
cussed in this report (except that to Willets Point, taken directly from the Coast Sur-
vey chart), were kindly furnished by that office, the exact positions of the Long
Island railroad stations with respect to the general topography being identified from
Colton's large map of Long Island. These distances may therefore be accepted as
known with exceptional precision.
   Willets Point.--Distance,8 33 miles; officers at astronomical observatory, Lieuten-
ant Chittenden and Lieutenant Taylor; officers at the torpedo laboratory, Lieuten-
ant Gillette and Lieutenant Sibert; distance between these stations, about a quarter
of a mile. They were connected by telegraph wires, so that the standard chronome-
ter printed seconds on both chronographs.
   The observations at the astronomical observatory were made with the same form of
mercury seismoscope that was used elsewhere; those at the torpedo laboratory were
made with a delicate Thomson's reflecting galvanometer placed on a solid pier dis-
connected from the building, the needle being rendered specially sensitive to tremors
by being thrown slightly out of level. I hoped to obtain an approximate measure of
the duration of the earth tremor from this instrument, by noting (1) the angular
swing and the duration of the disturbance caused by the explosion; and (2) the du-
ration of an equal angular swing caused artificially immediately thereafter. The
difference between these times should measure approximately the duration of the
earth tremor. The following extracts from the reports of the officers give all needful
details:
   Lieutenant Chittenden (in charge at astronomical observatory) reports:
   "At the astronomical observatory arrangements were made to note the arrival of
the shock upon the chronograph used there in astronomical observations.
   "As the explosion was expected to take place at 11 a. m., I started the chronograph
at 10.45 a. m. to allow for any difference of watch times. This was about 12 hours
and 8 minutes sidereal time.
   "For the purpose of marking a particular minute on the chronograph and on the
register at the laboratory, I threw the chronometer out of the circuit for five seconds
at five seconds past the 13th minute, again at thirty seconds past the same minute,
and again at five seconds past the 17th minute. After the tremor from the explosion
had passed, I noted the last minute recorded on the chronograph before it was stopped.
Its number was thirty-seven. These times were carefully noted, and I thus had three
independent means of determining the minute in which the record of the arrival of
the tremor was made.
   " The rest of the time I watched the chronograph steadily, to see -that it continued
to work all right. I was looking at the pen point at the time of the arrival of the
tremor. All I noticed was a slight shock to the building, and simultaneously with it
a distinct rumbling sound, audible, I should say, for three seconds. At almost the
same instant that I felt the shock I noticed that Lieutenant Taylor had recorded its
arrival on the chronograph. Lieutenant Taylor made four separate records on the
chronograph, which he numbered one, two, three, and four, and which are explained
in his report. I numbered them on the chronograph as he called them out to me.
The uncorrected times, as taken from the chronograph record, were:


                                   No.       Sidereal time.

                                             h.    m.     s.
                               1........     12     35   32.3
                               2.........    12     35   44. O0
                               3..........   12 [35      51.4
                               4........
                                      12 36 52. 8
         APPENDIX       E-REPORT         OF LIEUT.-COL.        MCFARLAND.           695
    "The Lukens time of the explosion, as given me by Captain Bailey, was 12h. 35m.
23.8s. The time from the explosion until the arrival of the tremor at Willets Point
was, therefore, 8.5 seconds."
    Lieutenant Taylor (at astronomical observatory) reports:
    "The basin of mercury was placed on the zenith telescope pier in the east end of
the observatory, and this gave a very firm base, and one which from its good connec-
tion with the ground would show a very slight tremor.
    " The first mark made by me on the chronograph records the time that I observed
the first arrival of the tremor. The second was when the wires became visible again.
The third was when I thought there was a slight increase in amplitude of the vibra-
tion. Oflthis I am not at all certain, as even at this time the wires were vibrating so
rapidly that it was very difficult to tell whether there was a slight increase or not.
The fourth mark was made when the wires were perfectly still. The shock appeared
to reach its maximum intensity instantly; but of this I am not positive, for as soon
as the shock caused the mercury to move at all the wires instantly disappeared from
view, and the tremor may have increased in violence after it arrived and before the
wires again became visible. It certainly did not arrive gradually.
    "I do not think that the wires vibrated off the field of view, but they vibrated so
rapidly that they could not be seen except as a sort of a blur over the field.' It was
about twelve seconds before they became quiet enough to be distinguishable at all.
    " From this time until they were perfectly still they appeared to settle quite grad-
ually, but with less and less rapidity as they came nearer to rest, except at the time
marked by my third break. I think it more than probable that I was mistaken about
there being an increase, for the reason given above. If there was any increase it was
very slight.
    "' The wires vibrated the whole time as if there were a succession of shocks rapidly
following each other. It appeared as if the mercury basin was tipped rapidly back-
wards and forwards, this appearance being much more perceptible about the time the
wires first became visible than it was just before the mercury became still.
    "The wires finally became perfectly still in about one minute and twenty seconds
after the first shock. As my instrument was perfectly protected from any wind, and
great care had been taken to prevent any one being near the observatory to cause
any disturbance, I believe that this is very near the exact time that there was any
movement in the mercury.
    "The sound, which was distinctly heard, was sort of a low, rumbling noise, and it
seemed to arrive at the same instant as the first shock. "
    Lieutenant Sibert (at the torpedo laboratory) reports:
    "The instrument used was an ordinary Thomson reflecting galvanometer set very
delicately so that the slightest jar would cause the mirror to swing. The instrument
was mounted on a pier resting on the firm earth and entirely disconnected from the
building. Epochs were recorded by breaking the cicuit of a Morse register, con-
nected through a relay with the Lukens chronometer circuit at the astronomical ob-
servatory. The objects of the observations were to determine the duration of the
shock, and roughly the rate of transmission. The first of these was accomplished by
noting the time from the first motion of the mirror until it came to rest; this first
swing was the maximum observed. Hence by giving the mirror the same swing and
noting the time that it took to come to rest, and taking the difference between this
time and the time it took the mirror to come to rest from the shock, .we arrive at the
duration.
    "The adjustment of the instrument for delicate work of this nature was found to
be different from that for electric current observations; for if the mirror hung per-
fectly free, the only way for the earth tremor to be transmitted to it would be through
the whole length of the suspending fiber. Practical experiment showed that a point
of contact of the fiber other than the point of support was necessary for delicate work.
The instrument was not adjusted as delicately as possible, for fear the light would be
thrown off the scale and the maximum reading not obtained.           To render this less
likely to occur, two scales were used placed end to end so that the light fell at their
junction.
    " I marked five epochs on the register, lettered A, B, C, F, and G; the following is
a copy of the notes written immediately after the observation was over.
    " Light stood at 363 on right-hand scale.
   "(A) Time of first motion of mirror, the light swung back to about the 210 division,
making about 153 divisions.
    " (B) It seemed to remain swinging to the 250 division (giving 113 divisions) for a
second or so, then gradually lessened to its are at epoch C.
   " (C) The mirror from this epoch seemed to continue swinging to the same small
angle to epoch F.
  "(F) From F the mirror gradually stopped swinging.
  " (G) The motion ceased at G.
696      REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

    "I heard a rumbling sound about a second before I saw any motion of the mirror,
whichmakes me believe that the instrument was not delicate enough to catch the
first tremors caused by the explosion, which of course would make the result as to ve-
locity of transmission and duration of shock too small. Assuming that the instrument
corded the first tremor, the way in which each successive wave affected the mirror,
that is whether it iicreased or decreased its amplitude of swing, would in my opinion
render the result as to duration uncertain. In experiments made afterwards to de-
termine the time it took the mirror to come to rest from a swing of 153 divisions, I
noticed that when the amplitude of swing began to be quite small, the mirror settled
much faster than it did in the case of the explosion, which showed that there was
a slight vibration of the earth for some time after the main shock passed. These
small vibrations would probably have had little effect upon the mirror settling from
a swing of considerable amplitude. If these slight tremors continued long enough to
be the only cause of the motion of the needle just before it came to rest, thus elimi-
nating the effect that any previous interferences might have had upon the amplitude
of swing, then the questicn of duration would be approximately solved."
   Lieutenant Gillette (in charge at the torpedo laboratory) reports:
    " The local circuit was run by five Grove cells, the key being as far removed from
the galvanometer as possible, and the wires twisted together so as to effect the chro-
nometer the least.
    "' The fractions of seconds on the record were measured with a glass scale reading
to tenths (hundredths were estimated). The even minute was received by dial tele-
graph from the observatory.
    "The five epochs were:

                                 Epochs.              Time.


                                              H        H.M    S.
                             A    ..........     12     35    32.65
                             B   ..........    i 12     35    45.20
                             C    ..........-
                                        -        12     36    13.00
                             F   ..........   .  12     36    43.15
                             G    .......... 12         37    03.95



  " The Lukens time of explosion as given by Captain Bailey was 12h. 35m. 13.78s.
  "This gives a time of transmission of 8.87 sidereal seconds, or 8.85 mean solar sec-
ends.
    " Six observations were made immediately after the explosion to determine the nor-
mal time for the mirror to corm to rest after a swing equal to that due to the shock.
'The required swing was give rby a pocket knife held for a moment near the instru-
ment, epochs being recorded and measured as before. The mean of these observations
after applying Pierce's criterion was 28.74 seconds. The duration of swing caused by
the shock (A to G) being 91.30 seconds, we have for the duration of the tremor 62.56
mean solar.seconds.
    "While watching the register I distinctly realized that the shock had passed
 (whether I heard it or felt it I am unable to say) at least a second before any record
was made on the register by the observer. I am inclined to think that it was the
sound transmitted by the earth, and that the sound vibrations were different from and
preceded what is known as the earth tremor. The phenomenon could scarcely be
accounted for by lack of delicacy in the instrument, which, though not adjusted to
its highest attainable delicacy, was really extremely sensitive to anything of the
nature of a shaking of the ground. It was adjusted so as to be swung 15 divisions by
a man jumping on the ground in the vicinity of the building. As the explosion swung
it over 150 divisions, it certainly should have been moved by a very trifling earth
tremor."
    Pearsalls,Long Island.-Distance 16.78 miles; officers, Lieutenant Hale and Lieu-
tenant Gaillard. Lieutenant Hale, in charge, reports:
    " On Saturday morning the wires were laid to the spot selected for the seismometer,
distant from the telegraph office about 900 feet on the branch road to Long Beach,
over which trains have been discontinued. The interval between the two tracks is
used as a foot-path, and the ground is solid and well adapted to the purpose. The
location is isolated.
    " Lieutenant Gaillard imbedded his mercury dish firmly in the earth, obtaining an
excellent contact.
    " When the register recorded the explosion I marked it, and as soon as satisfied of
its identity signaled Lieutenant Gaillard as agreed; the tremor reached him just
after the signal. He was therefore watching intently and is satisfied as to the accu-
racy of his record. His records of the phases of the disturbance were marked as
they came, and when compared agreed with his record.
             APPENDIX         E-REPORT              OF    LIEUT.-COL. MCFARLAND.           697
  " The clicking of the instruments and other noises about the railroad station pre-
vented my hearing the explosion, but both Lieutenant Gaillard and Sergeant Doyle
heard it, and their independent estimates placed the arrival of the sound at about a
second later than that of the tremor.
  "Before seeing Lieutenant Gaillard, I measured and recorded the intervals marked
on the register paper. Subsequent comparison showed that our records corresponded
perfectly.  He observed no disturbance except that of the explosion, and there were
no extra marks on the register paper.
  " Following is a table showing the different intervals:


                      No.                   Intervals.                   Time   from
                                                                          explosion.

                                                                            M.     S.
                          1   Beginning of tremor.................          0    06.59
                          2   Image reappears in mercury ..........0             24. 93
                          3   Probable end of disturbance produced
                                by explosion .........--... ..              1    51.01
                          4   End of slight uniform disturbance .... 2           47. 52
                          5   Last observation......--.............-------- 3    24.66


     "The total length of the disturbance would therefore be 1 minute 44.42 seconds,
  and the interval between the explosion and the arrival of the tremor, 6.59 seconds."
     Lieutenant Gaillard reports:
     " The place selected for my instrument was quite hard and firm, being of yellow
  clay which was brought there to form the road bed. I took my pocket knife and
  carefully cut a hole in the earth just large enough for my artificial horizon, and ground
  it firmly into this hole..
     "As soon as my flagman notified me that the charge had been fired, and before I
had time to answer him, my wires disappeared out of sight, but not instantly. A
very small time, possibly 0.2 of a second, elapsed before they disappeared, but it was
too small for me to tap the key. This disappearance was followed very closely) I
estimate the time as about one second, but Sergeant Doyle thinks it was between
one-half second and a second) by a low rumbling sound as of very distant thunder.
I recorded the reappearance of the wires by a tap number 2 on key. Between taps
2 and 3 I noticed a gradual decrease in intensity, which I have attempted to show in
my curve. From taps 3 to 4 the vibrations of my cross hairs appeared almost con-
stant, being faint but extremely rapid. From 4 to 5 the vibrations died away gradu-
ally. Few of the people around felt the shock or heard the sound, and I hardly know
if I would have felt it unless assisted by my mercury as to the exact instant. I think
I am safe in asserting that the shock was entirely different from any I have observed
before; and on this same morning and with apparatus set up in exactly the same
manner, I had observed trains, wagons, carts, and persons walking and jumping.
     "As regards taps 4 and 5, they were so long after the others that it seems quite
probable that the shock ended at tap 3, and that the wind blowing against my seis-
moscope box caused the faint vibrations I observed after it. I cannot say whether
the wind was blowing at the time of these observations, but I know that a stiff and
varying breeze was blowing in five minutes afterwards, and that during its continu-
ance my mercury would not come to absolute rest."
     Bay Shore, Long Island.-Distance, 36.65 miles; officers, Lieutenants Langfitt and
Waterman. Lieutenant Langfitt, in charge, thus describes his station :
     "I watched the register paper, and lettered the marks coming from Astoria and
numbered those made by Lieutenant Waterman. Whenever he closed his circuit a
line of enlisted men properly posted gave me warning. Follo wing this nomenclature,
G on the register paper marks the warning ticks; H, the explosion mark. Marks 7,
8, 9, 10, and 11 are those made by the observer during the passage of the tremor; No.
12 marks an unknown tremor. The following are the recorded intervals, correct, it
is believed, to within half a tenth of a second:
                                                                                     Seconds.
From beginning of explosion mark (H) to first arrival of tremor (7) (wires in-
  visible)   ..........               ------ ...------......
                                      ....                     ----       --......        12.95
From first arrival of tremor to when wires became visible again (7e).........     0.50
From this last point to supposed end of tremor (10), (the disturbance reported
  as uniformly subsiding) ............................................           34.63
From supposed end of tremor to point of absolute rest of mercury (11)..- ...--
                                                                            ..-. 65. 50
Total duration of tremor to supposed end ...................                     35. 13
Total duration to point of absolute rest......-............................. 100.63
  "It would seem that these results as to duration are liable to error from at least two
causes, one being the reflection of the mercury from the sides of the vessel, and the
608      REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

orher due to wind shaking the trees in the vicinity. The instrument was placed
about 400 feet from the railroad track, in a piece of woods composed of second-growth
trees of 20 to 30 feet in height, with underbrush between them. The soil was sandy.
The top loam was removed to a depth of 6 or 8 inches, and the mercury dish was
placed on the more compact soil beneath. There was no appearance of rock any-
where in the vicinity. The surrounding country had a very gentle and uniform rise
from the shore. Lieutenant Waterman reports that the wind shaking the trees in the
vicinity rarely left his mercury entirely at rest. The tent was not used. All light
was excluded from the mercury dish, except that coming through the observed tele-
scope."
   Lieutenant Waterman, who used the seismoscope, reports :
   " Imade numerous useless marks before the disturbance due to the explosion arrived.
This latter however was evident when it came.
   " The plane of my instruments was nearly at right angles to theline joining the sta-
tion with Astoria. All light, except that coming through the telescope whose field
of view I was to observe, was cut off from the mercury by a paper covering. The re-
flection of this field thus stood out brightly on a dark background.
   " The first shock due to the explosion was so violent that I distinctly heard the mer-
cury splash against the side 'of the dish. Mark No. 7 of the register corresponds to
this time. I held the key down for a time since determined as one-half a second.
During this half a second I thought I could distinguish at least three successive
waves. The second one of these appeared to me to give the maximum displacement.
Though the cross wires of the observed field became entirely invisible, the bright spot
surrounding them was never entirely out of sight.
   " I have designated the end of mark No. 7 as No. 7e.
   "Just after 7e the crosswires became visible, and the displacement had fallen to
about one-half of its maximum value. From this point the displacement decreased
uniformly to mark No. 10, which marks its apparent termination. A curve of the
varying displacements, corresponding to the different register time marks, would
have a cusp point and maximum ordinate not more than a quarter of a second after
the first arrival. At the end of one-half a second, the ordinate would be about one-
half of the maximum displacement. From this point to mark No. 10, a period of 34.6
seconds, the curve would assume the form of a right line, its ordinates uniformly de-
creasing until zero at the time corresponding to mark 10.
   "Mark No. 10 of the register paper indicates a position of supposed rest. The shak-
ing of trees in my vicinity rarely left the mercury entirely stationary. Mark No. 11
corresponds to a position of entire rest.
   "The numbering employed above corresponds to the numbers placed after the marks
on the register paper by Lieutenant Langfitt, the electrician."
   Patchogue, Long Island.-Distance, 48.52 miles; officers, Lieutenant Spencer and
Lieutenant Zinn. Lieutenant Spencer, in charge, reports:
   "My observing station was alongside (east of) a creek flowing through a swamp, and
several locations tried proved so unstable as to be worthless. T'he station finally
selected was about 120 yards east of the creek mentioned, and about 300 yards north
of the railroad.
    'The mercury was constantly watched from the time of Lieutenant Zinn's receipt of
directions to get ready (about 10h. 50m.75th meridian) until the receipt of a message
from him that the chronometer was out of circuit-a period of one-half hour.
   "During this time nine (9) signals were sent, four before the register was started.
These signals marked the beginning and maximum of an increased vibration (there was
a constant movement of the mercury), the settling of which was so gentle as to pre-
vent a notation of the end. Two more signals marking similar epochs were recorded.
These signals were sent because of a doubt as to the vibrations reaching me with any
marked intensity. The amplitude of vibration was in all cases small, not over three
times the apparent diameter of the reflected wires.
   "The true shock was unmistakable, the wires disappearing or seen only in their ex-
treme positions near the edge of the field of view. My impression isthat they moved
over about three-quarters of the field of view and attained this maximum separation
before I was even aware of a beginning.
   "'The register firing time was 12h. 35m. 54.8s. ; the beginning and apparent maximum
of vibration, 12h. 36m. 10.2s.; the appearance 'of the wires within easily observable
limits (say a total amplitude of ten times the diameter of the reflected wires), 12h.
6m. 31.1s.; the return to a normal state, 12h. 37m. 04.1s.
   " It is thus seen that the shock reached Patchogue from Flood Rock in 15.4 seconds;
that the mercury remained violently agitated for about 20 seconds; and that it re-
sumed its normal state about 30 seconds thereafter.
   "To Lieutenant Zinn credit is due for the perfect operation of the electrical appa-
ratus; to the enlisted men of the party for good behavior and efficient service. My
thanks are extended to the station agent and the operator at Patchogue for their
voluntary assistance in perfecting our arrangements throughout."
          APPENDIX       E-REPORT         OF    LIEUT.-COL. MCFARLAND.                699

   Lieutenant Zinn reports his operations as follows, sufficiently showing that the elec-
trical arrangements worked perfectly under his careful management:
   " I acted as electrician of the party sent to Patchogue, L. I., under charge of Lieu-
tenant Spencer.
   "'About 8 a. m. I made the electrical connections as shown on the accompanying
diagram, except those at the observer's key, and set up 5 Grove cells except putting
in the nitric acid; this I did about 10 o'clock. The circuits were then tested-the
office circuit by putting my relay in a derived circuit of the main line, and the outer
one by closing the observer's key; both worked properly; the register gave clear
strong impressions; the paper moved smoothly.
   ' After I received the telegram to get ready, I inserted the relay in the main line.
In a few moments the second ticks began to come. I tried the register again and found
it worked all right. When the seconds were interrupted by a series of     (lashes,I started
the register; the dashes were recorded clearly. I watched the paper closely, marking
all extra ticks by letters near the margin of the paper, and rolling it up as it came out.
When the ticks ceased, I stopped the register and broke the connections."
   Goat Island, Newport, R. I.-Distance 144.89 miles. Commander W. T. Sampson,
U. S. Navy, informs me that he observed a mercury seismoscope, placed on the con-
crete basement floor of a building of the Torpedo Station, with a telescope having a
magnifying power of about 15 diameters. The earth wave was unmistakable.              It ar-
rived at llh. 14m. 49s., and ceased at llh. 16m. 03s., mean solar time of the 75th me-
ridian. The error of the chronometer was determined with precision by direct com-
parison with the time signal sent at noon from the Naval Observatory at Washington.
He observed only one maximum during the passage of the waves.
   Harvard College. Cambridge, Mass.-Distance 182.62 miles. The observations at this
station were reported to the American Academy of Arts and Sciences, by Prof. W. A.
Rogers, who made them. A r6sume of his paper appeared in Science, No. 142, Vol.
VI, and also in the Daily Advertiser. From these reports the following abstract has
been compiled:
   Professor Rogers observed a well-defined streak upon the surface of a dish of mer-
cury, placed on the bed of the comparator in the cellar of the west wing of the ob-
servatory, which is separated from the building and is very stable. A sharp point of
this streak was watched through a microscope, having a quarter of an inch objective,
with a magnifying power of about 750 diameters.
   Although annoyed by the passage of an ice wagon at about the same time, he thinks
there can be no reasonable doubt that the reported tremors were the result of the ex-
plosion. The first occurred at 11h. 17m. 30s. ; a second and more violent commotion
was observed 10 or 15 seconds later, when the rumble of the ice wagon was heard at
a distance of about 1,000 to 1,300 feet. A third even greater disturbance occurred at
a like interval after the second; at 1lh. 18m. 15s. the entire surface of the mercury
under the objective appeared to sway back and forth over a space certainly as great
as one five-hundredth of an inch. This continued 8 or 10 seconds, and at the end of
about 20 seconds there was an almost entire subsidence of the commotion. From this
instant the recurring disturbances gradually diminished, and at llh. 20m. they had
entirely ceased. At this time the ice wagon was directly opposite the observatory.
These times are all referred to the standard 75th meridian.
   On the following day, an ice wagon was started from nearly opposite the observa-
tory and driven rapidly away. Only a very slight tremor of the mercury was observed
while the cart was traversing a distance of 750 feet, and it then ceased.
   Professor Rogers states that the waves of disturbance certainly increased in ampli-
tude until 11h. 18m. 15s., and gradually diminished after that time; the intervals be-
tween waves appeared to be about 15 seconds. He is.not quite certain whether there
were three or four waves preceding the.one having the greatest amplitude. The
direction of movement of the streak was on a line about 150 from the meridian ; i. e.,
north of east and south of west.
   West Point, N. Y.-Distance 42.34 miles; officers, Lieutenant Mott, Eighth Infan-
try; Lieutenant Beach, Corps of Engineers; Lieutenant Stuart, Ordnance Depart-
ment. These officers kindly co-operated with us, thus permitting a comparison be-
tween the rate of transmission through the rocky strata extending northward from
Astoria, and that through Long Island drift.
   Lieutenant Mott reports:
   "I had three seismometer% arranged for these observations. Numbers 1 and 2 were
placed on the tops of the transit piers, and No. 3 was mounted between, with the
mercury resting on the pier foundation where the Nadir basin of the transit belongs.
They were all sufficiently sensitive to show the jars produced by striking on the rock
with a crowbar 200 feet away. Passing trains gave no perceptible tremors. Elec-
trical connections were so made that the chronometer used at the scene of the explo-
sion recorded on the observatory chronograph. I observed with instrument No. 2,
and held the key for breaking local current to chronograph; Lieutenant Beach, Corps
700                  REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

of Engineers, observed with No. 1; and Lieutenant Stuart, Ordnance Corps, observed
with No. 3.
  "I made the record of my own observations on the chronograph; and to enable the
others to get the time, I had Mr. Grunow and the soldier assistant alternate in call-
ing out the seconds, as they were ticked off by the observatory clock.
  "We commenced observing at 11 o'clock. After observing some 10 or 15 minutes, the
reflected image in my apparatus suddenly commenced moving from side to side with
such rapidity as to give a confused and rapidly vibrating field of view. The extent
of motion was probably a tenth or twelfth the field of view.
  "These vibrations commenced suddenly, and continued to flow along uniformly
without breaks or interruptions for about a minute, and then to gradually and uni-
formly grow less and less until all became perfectly quiet.
   "I observed no noise during the presence of these tremors. Young Mr. Grunow, who
was in the basement of the building, heard a noise about quarter after eleven which
he took to be the rumbling of a train, but after thought it might be connected with
the Hell Gate explosion. Professor Bass also states that while in the academic build-
ing he heard a rumbling which brought to mind the explosion, and upon looking at
his watch fixed the time at 14 or 15 minutes after eleven. This rumbling was also
heard at Glen Cove, L. I.; and, I believe, by Mr. O. H. Rockwell, at Tarrytown, on
the Hudson.
   " The clock was set going for this occasion; its error was not determined, as I thought
the comparison with the Flood Rock chronometer would be sufficient. I have reduced
the clock times to those of the chronometer; and the results of the observations, and
the power of the observing instruments, I give in the following tables. I also send
copies of reports of the other two observers.

                  TABLE I.-Magnifying powers and field of view of observing instruments.


                                                                                                                           Magnifyr         Field.         Observer.
                                                                                                                       ing   power.



No. 1.........................................................                                                                        16    20 7'     Lieutenant Beach.
No. 2 ........................................................                                                                        31    10 5'     Lieutenant Mott.
No. 3 ....................................                              ...................                                           36    00 46'    Lieutenant Stuart.



                                                          TABLE II.--Result of observations.


                                                                                                                                    Mott.            Beach.      Stuart.

                                                                                                                               h.     m. 8.      h.   m. 8.      h.   m. s.
Tremors end .............                    .......................                                                           12     37 24.2    12   37 15. 9   12   37 38. 0
Tremors begin ......................................                                                                           12     36 8.4     12   36 5.7     12   36 5.7
Instant of explosion.......................                                                   ..........................       12     35 54. 8   12   35 54. 8   12   35 54. 8

Interval..........................................................                                                                       13.6            10. 9           10. 9
Duration .......................................................                                                                       1 15.8          1 10.2          1 32.3


                                                      12h. 37m. 57s. chronometer                             ticked together.
                                                      llh. 16m. 29s. clock
                                                                      Clock.       Chronometer.
                                                                 llh. 14m. 38s. = 12h. 36m. 5. 7s.
                                                                 llh, 15m 48s. = 12h. 37m. 15. 9s.
                                                                 11h. 16m. 10s. = 12h. 37m. 3. 8s.

  " In adjusting these intervals I have to say that my record of first arrival being
recorded on the chronograph is necessarily late. Some little time is required to settle
in your mind that the tremors are certainly present, in addition to the time taken to
reach and press the key. I considered when I made the record that I was probably a
second late in nmaking it. The other observers had the time called off, requiring them
to make a sort of mental estimate of the time of beginning; and I believe the tend-
ency to be to go too far back, that is, make the instant too early. Mr. Stuart in his
report places the instant between the 38th and 39th seconds, and in taking as he does
the 38th as the instant, he anticipates the event by some fraction of a second. In
my report to Colonel Michie I arranged the results making the interval 11.8 seconds.
I believe a better adjustment would result by giving my observations twice the weight
of each of the others, thus making the interval 12+ seconds."
         APPENDIX       E-REPORT         OF   LIEUT.-COL.      MCFARLAND.           701
   Lieutenant Beach reports :
   "The vibrations began at 11h. 14m. 38s., and reached the maximum almost imme-
diately, and continued uniformly until 15m. 20s., when they began to decrease until at
15m. 33s. they were quite faint; and from this point they were merely noticeable un-
til 15m. 48s., when nothing more could be perceived. The maximum vibration was
about one-fifteenth of the radius on each side, and the changes at 15m. 20s. and 15m.
33s., were not gradual but comparatively abrupt."
   Lieutenant Stuart reports:
   " My record of time was taken from the count of the assistant. Very minute but
sensible tremors occasionally occurred, but suddenly the wires disappeared from view,
and in their place was a dimness caused by the rapidly vibrating reflection from the
mercury surface. This occurred between llh. 14m. 38s. and 14m. 39s., and the dis-
turbance seemed to reach.its maximum value at once, and to continue with undimin-
ished intensity till 15m. 20s., after which it decreased uniformly till, at 15m. 47s., it
had nearly disappeared; but I believe I observed a faint tremor, not apparent before
the disturbance began, till 16m. 10s. The amplitude of the vibrations was about one-
tenth the radius of the field of view on each side of the center.
   " The vibrations above described were very distinct, and their amplitude was prob-
ably one hundred times as great as that of the ordinary tremors observed before and
after this occurrence."
   Litchfield Observatory of Hamilton College, Clinton, N. Y.-Distance, 174.37 miles.
Prof. C. H. F. Peters, the director, has kindly furnished me with a copy of the re-
port upon his observations, to which the great distance of his station and his well-
known skill as an observer give an exceptional value. He states:
   " I made arrangements for observing the time, if any effect should be sensible here,
by the trembling produced on the surface of quicksilver. It seemed to me necessary
not to rely upon one single apparatus, in order to make sure whether any motion
that might be perceived was accidental to the apparatus, or produced by a shaking
of the soil of wider range. I could dispose two vessels of mercury on two different
isolated piers. These piers are imbedded to the depth of several feet in a very hard,
richly agglomerate-bearing clay that overlies here the so-called red shale rock.
   " Outside disturbance, as in the cities (from wagons, &c.), was not to be feared in
our comparatively quiet country place. The nearest railroad is 1l miles distant, and
no trains were passing at that hour.

    " By providing the transit with a Bohnenberger eye-piece, and pointing it to the
nadir observing the reflected wires, we had the one apparatus. The transit (made
by Wurdemann) has an aperture of 2+ inches; its magnifying power with this eye-
piece is about 45, The mean time clock, Bond No. 185, stands in convenient neigh-
borhood for seeing and hearing the seconds' beats. My assistant, Mr. Charles A.
Borst, observed here.
    " Another basin with mercury was placed upon the pier of the 4-inch Steinheil
refractor in the southwest dome, the entrance to which is from a computing room
that on the opposite side has a door leading to a small cabinet. To the post of this
latter door a telescope of '2 inches aperture, magnifying power about 25, was fixed
so that the light of a lamp reflected from °the mercury basin could be observed through
it.   It was inclined under an angle of 7 o to the horizon. The eye-tube could not be
drawn out quite sufficiently for a sharp focus at that distance, but experiments
showed that a very slight knocking of the pier with a pencil was perceptible by one
or more neat black waves running through the field. Near me I had the sidereal
chronometer, Bond No. 207, that beats half seconds.
    "The door between the transit and computing rooms was closed, but we were in
calling distance, so that when one of the observers needed to rest his eye for a moment,
or to check his count of the beat, the other was attentively looking into his tele-
scope. This provision proved very useful on account of the prolonged time, as we
                                                        h
were at our posts beginning to look a little before 11 Om.
    "The mercury had been quite     calm all the while, until a first wave was seen rush-
                              h   m
ing through the field at 12 31 103 beats, chronometer (precisely at the beat), fol-
lowed by several others in quick succession. Again at 12h 32m 80 or 81 beats, chro-
nometer, I observed a strong quivering, a more irregular and confused motion of the
mercury.
    " Mr. Borst noted a sudden disappearance of the reflected image of the wires be-
tween the clock beats 30$ and 318, so that his observation was 23 12m 30.58 o'clock.
    "At the same time the patch of light arising from the illumination of wires through
the eye-piece and diffused reflection from the mercury surface began to move, and he
saw it swinging to and fro for some little while.
    " Chronometer and clock were compared by coincidence of beats as follows:
                  m                             m
    Before: 2bh 53 35' mean time clock-= 12"h 12 538 siderial
                                                     s
                                                              chronometer.
    After: 23 20m 35' mean time clock = 12 39m 57.5 siderial chronometer.
702           REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

   "From this the chronometer    m
                                    time
                                       s
                                          of my observation may be reduced directly to
clock time, and we find 12h 31 51.5 chronometer = 23h 12m 30.38      clock.
   " The agreement with Mr. Borst's observation, viz, 23h 12m 30.58 clock, is so    close
                                                                                  s
that in part it must be attributed to chance; we take the mean, 23h 12m 30.4 clock,
which hardly can be in error by more than - 0.58.
   "The clock has a very small rate, and its correction to mean time at 23h Om was
+-                                                             h
    27.43. This gives for the time of the observation, 23 12m 57.838 Hamilton h
lege mean time, and as our longitude is 50 1' 37.45" from Greenwich, 11 14' 35.38
                                                                                    Col-
standard time. There is no reason to attribute the commotion observed here to any
local cause ; it seems to have been the explosion of Flood Rock, at the distance of
170 miles."
   Upon receipt of this paper I wrote to Professor Peters to request further informa-
tion as to the nature and duration of earth tremor, which the intermediate observa-
tions at West Point had left no doubt was caused by the explosion. He replied :
   " In answer to your last inquiry, I make the following statement : After having
written down 3 (103) I continued to count the chronometer beats without removing
my eye from the telescope, and saw several more waves passing through the field,
following the first, of which the time was noted; in the next few (perhaps 10) sec-
onds I heard my assistant in the adjoining room breaking out in loud astonishment;
it was the swinginging to and fro of the reflex of light, following after the sudden dis-
appearance of the reflected wires, that convinced him Hell Gate was there and caused
the exclamation. I lost thereby my count, and had to look down at the chronometer,
which time I used for writing down also the minute. From 10 to 15 seconds I may
have thus lost. Putting my eye again to the telescope, the mercury seemed to be
calm; but while I continued to look my eyesight got dim, as I fancied; I winked
and squeezed the eyelids together for seeing more distinctly; and after a little, that
is to say, after several seconds, I became convinced that the mercury surface was in
uproar. I noted the time of this, when it appeared to be at its height, as 80 or 81
beats. This instant, as you see, is therefore only a rough estimate. How long the
motion of the mercury continued after that I did not wait to see; that it was there
already, perhaps some 10 seconds before, though less strong, I believe. There was
certainly a lull in the motion between 31m 103b and 32m 80b chronometer, but how
long I cannot tell; it was less than 49 seconds anyhow, and may have been 30 seconds
or even 20 seconds. Much importance, besides, cannot be attributed to the duration
of this lull, as that depends upon the length of time the mercury remains oscillating
after the .receipt of the shock. I am unable to give more precisely the beginning of
the second motion, which was much heavier than the first, as I have described."

                                             DISCUSSION OF THE RESULTS.

  To avoid any possible cavil as to the element of distance, I requested an accurate
statement from the Coast Survey Office, forwarding a tracing of Colton's large scale
map of Long Island to aid in identifying from the neighboring shore line the exact
position of the railroad stations occupied by my parties. Professor Schott kindly
furnished the following table, and also tie tracing which has been used in preparing
Plate III :

                                                                                                                           Azimuth of
                                                                                                                           Azdirection
                                                                       Geodetic position of
                                                                       observing stations.                  Distance       fre      od
                                                                                                                 .... d    from Flood
                            Stations.                                                                       toRckiFlood          to sta-
                                                                                                                           Rockcounted
                                                                                                                      in.tion,
                                                                                                                  klOmei from S. round
                                                                       Latitude.         Longitude.                         by W.


                                                                       O    I    I   I     0   I    II

Flood Rock, New. York............................                      40   46   41. 4    73   56   17. 6 ....             ..............
Pearsalls, Long Island ..               ...............     ........   40   39   18       73   39   45            27.01             300.3
Bay Shore, Long Island ..... ...............                           40   43   28       73   14   36            58. 99            275. 6
Patchogue, Long Island ..........................                      40   45   51       73   00   49            78. 08            370. 8
Goat Island, Rhode Island...........                 .............     41   29   36       71   19   39           233. 17            249. 2
Harvard College Observatory, Massachusetts .....                       42   22   53       71   07   44           293. 99            231. 8
West Point Observatory, New York ..............                        41   23   28       73   57   21            68. 08            178. 8
Hamilton College Observatory, New York .........                       43   03   17       75   24   21           280. 62            154. 8
Princeton College Observatory, New Jersey ......                       40   20   54       74   39   17            77. 20             52. 0


   "Accompanying this is a tracing of the rock and of the adjacent shore, taken from
'a new topographical survey just completed."
   The mercury seismoscope (with a telescope of sutfficient power) indicates accurately
the'instant of the arrival of the earth wave; but it fails to reveal with precision the
               APPENDIX        E-REPORT                 OF LIEUT.-COL.                    MCFARLAND.                    703

duration of its passage, because an unknown and very sensible time is required for
the mercury to come to rest after all motion of the earth has ceased. The galvanom-
eter observations at Willets Point were ordered to determine, if possible, an empirical
correction for this defect. The mercury there was agitated for 80.5 seconds; the gal-
vanometer (see Lieutenant Gillette's report above) indicated that the earth was in
motion for 62.5 seconds. This points to a subtractive cofrrection of about 18 seconds
to eliminate the time lost in coming to rest. As the observers report that the earth
tremor appeared to subside uniformly and gradually, and as they all used similar mer-
cury vessels, I have applied this correction where the telescopes did not differ mate-
rially from 20 in magnifying power. These figures are presented in the sixth column
of the following table, which exhibits in a consolidated form the more important of
the data given above.
                           Data at the Flood Rock explosion.

                                                                Earth wave.                    --

                                                  o                               o                 _
               Stations.                      Q            d
                                                          ,.           "          E .                          Remarks.




  EASTERLY COURSE THROUGH"

                                    Miles.                Sec.        Sec.        Sec.
Willets Point................        8.33..       14        8.8..8..2......80   ..... ..            0.98    By galvanometer.
                                                                                                            By mercury.
Pearsalls.........   ......... .... 16.78         14        6.6         104              86         2.54
Bay Shore.   ...          .......   36.65         18       13.0         35(?) ..         ...        2.82
Patchogue.................48.52                   19       15.4          54              36         3.15
Goat Island ................       144.89         15-      58.8            74            56         2.46
Harvard Observatory.........       182. 68    750         219. 8           95+ .......              0.83
  NORTHERLY COURSE THROUGH
            ROCK.
                                              31           13. 6           76            58         3. 11   Lieutenant Mott.
West Point....................      42.34     16           10.9            70            52         3.88    Lieutenant Beach.
                                              36           10. 9           92   ......              3. 88   Lieutenant Stuart.
Litchfield Observatory.....174. 37                         45.      ..........
                                                                            ..                      3. 88   Professor Peters.



   These observations indicate: (1) An extraordinary velocity of wave translation in
both directions-which confirms my deduction from the Hallet's Point and certain
torpedo explosions, that "the more violent the initial shock the higher is the veloc-
ity of transmission." At Flood Rock the charge was about six times as large as at
Hallet's Point, and the velocity was from two to three times as great, over essentially
the same route. (2) The uniformity of velocity to the northward, where the strata
consists largely of homogeneous gneiss rock, and where the velocity even for 175 miles
exceeded 20,000 feet per second. (3) The varying velocity which appeared to character-
ize the wave moving to the eastward, through the drift formation of Long Island.
Here there seems to have been a gradual increase of velocity, followed by a decrease
as the wave advanced-but on the whole a decidedly less rapid rate is indicated than
in traversing solid rock, as might be expected in media of varying density and elas-
ticity. The result, although not inconsistent with the Hallet's Point observations, was
not discovered from them, except as to the decrease in velocity as the wave disap-
peared. This is the only point where the four deductions from the earlier observa-
tions are modified by this later and more accurately observed explosion (see Appen-
dix B).
   The very slow rate of movement to Willets Point is so surpris ing that it has re-
ceived the closest scrutiny, but the evidence seems to establish its correctness. The
latter rests (1) upon the determination of the absolute instant of explosion (see Ap-
pendix D); and (2) upon the observed arrival of the tremor, closely verified by the
galvanometer observations. The resulting velocity is also roughly con rmed by the
observations at Astoria, as will be explained in discussing the photographs.
   The Flood Rock explosion appears to have caused a continuous earth ti emor, which,
observed under a magnifying power of about 18, lasted about one minute throughout the
whole region covered by the observations, the maximnum disturbance leading the ad-
vance, or nearly so, for at least 50 miles. At extreme ranges the tremor appears to
have broken up into successive waves, with well-marked intervals between them.
These facts, the instantaneous nature of the explosion shown by the photographs, and
the varying rates of advance through strata not homogeneous, appear to warrant the
conclusion that the oscillation followed different routes to any given point-some near
 704          REPORT            OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

the surface, and others at greater depths, where more dense and elastic strata pro-
duced changes in the direction of the wave front and yielded higher velocities.
   The whole subject is evidently too complex to warrant definite conclusions as to the
velocity of ordinary earthquake waves, where the intensity of the original disturbance
must always remain unknown. The results derived by Captain Knight from his ob-
servations at Astoria are in accordance with this view. (See C.)
                                                   THE PHOTOGRAPHS.

  Referring now to the photographs (see Appendix E for details), the first two views
show that ignition by sympathy was transmitted so rapidly as to be practically in-
stantaneous over the entire area of the rock, and that no failure occurred in any of
the galleries. In a word, they demonstrate the entire success of this new method of
ignition.
  The following computation fixes the epochs of these pictures, and of the explosion
itself as well, referred to the chronograph record at Astoria. The first motion of the
key is taken as the zero of time:
                                    Instant of explosion.
                                                                                                                 Seconds.
                                -
Movement of the firing key-. .-.-.         ...-   _....      .........-
                                                             _.                                                     0.02
Action of circuit closer at Flood Rock ...................... ................                                      0. 10
         Explosion after first motion of key .....................................                                  0. 12
                                        Retardationof chronograph record.
                                                                                                                 Seconds.
Movement of firing key (breaking circuit) .............                                      ....                 0.00
                                                                                                     ...............
Relay armature time .....-.......... ........-                   ......     ....-.................           .... 0. 05
Register armature time.....................................................                                       0. 10

      Record after first motion of key .....                                            ..... 0. 15
                                                                   ..............................
  Hence the explosion occurred 0.03 of a second before the record-or practically at
the same instant.
                              Time of automaticphotograph.
                                                                                            Seconds.
Movement of firing key ..............................................                          0. 03
Retarding relay armature time.......... ...........                                   ........................      0. 15
Drop of shutter to middle of exposure.......................................................                        0. 13
                                                                                                               0.31
Deduct retardation of explosion, above.                           ........
                                                                 ....                 .................... ....0.12
        Time after explosion ................................................        0.19
                                                                                     0.

   The register record shows that Lieutenant Lusk's first attempt (which failed to give
a picture) was made 0.17 of a second after the automatic picture, and that his success-
ful photograph was taken 0.25 of a second still later.
   Hence the actual epochs of these pictures after the explosion, closely determined,
are 0.2 and 0.6 of a second, respectively. The epoch of Sergeant von Sothen's picture,
roughly deduced from the increase in height of the jet as compared with those of the
other two, is about two seconds. The extreme height was reached probably about a
second later.
   An interesting result was obtained, accidentally, by the method used for recording
these times. The actual chronograph record was as follows: First indent (recording
automatic photograph), a smooth line .13 of a second long; interval, .06 of a second;
second indent, three dots covering .11 of a second; interval of .12 of a second; third
indent, three dots covering .13 of a second. The length of the second's mark on the
fillet was about 1 inch, rendering these small periods easily measurable. They indi-
cate that the first picture was taken at or before the arrival of the earth fremor, and
that the others were taken during its passage. The distance to the rock being about
1,100 feet, this would suggest that the wave was moving with a velocity of about 1
mile per second, or much less than that with which it reached all the stations beyond
Willets Point. But little weight can be accorded to this inference, because the wave
velocity is much too high, and the instant of explosionr too uncertain, to permit a pre-
cise determination of so small a difference of time; still the result, so far as it goes,
is confirmatory of the Willets Point record, and of a rate of horizontal advance in
the vicinity of the mine much more sluggish than at greater distances.
       Very respectfully, your obedient servant,
                                                                                   HENRY L. ABBOT,
                                                                             Lieut. Colonel of Engineers,
                                                                                 Brevet Brig. General, U. 8.A.
     EX rLPOLCK       X PLOSION        Ptfai   1.


        PIlood Rock




             7
1Ferrten i     mronTed.Budi 'z
             YeNi'K6 rte.

    _                      ~      __
3
                                                                                                                                                0                    O
       5taLon        .TUi

       Z54rof'met
CThS&LLt           t.43Ys   u 6/
                       a tNaJE
7 f se oi e"s r "oyet Js'i      l briiZ-                                                                                                       S/~k    n         r
eofr l7cucd o ,r.n aolrt&h soot/L                                   S.dirnz   Ki
                                                                                                                                         dist-trt          ,02"5         <'




                       0
A.reyP       crcaaz Fdtog riacti"                d t    c           dw~CnI-


Me  %ctwer   LpClt    .c    n   zr   "   du   northr.       c~c,?
                                                                                                                                                                                                           m


                                                                                                       -4                                                                                                  xx



                                                                                                                                                                                                           r
                                                                                                                                                                                                           I-"
                                                                                                                                              526                                                          o1
                                                                                                                                                                                                           N"
                                                                                                                                                                                                           0
                                                                                                                              S.AL
                                                                                                                                     6

                                                                                                                                         1o.    6     36
                                                                                                                                         S.
                                                                                        SCAcL}




                                                                                                                                                                                    J




                                                                                   a'   ,   t   ??t   1J    o   f   (f




                                                                                                                         o0                                  t                6on   t7 :



                                         J/d't      I(Ofri




                                                                                                                                                                                    THEAMERICAN   CO,N.Y
                                                                                                                                                                                             GRAPHIC
4
X
                                                                                                             O
N)

     I

N)                            o715.         ht 2b,?
(0
                             tadn=.I   I                                                                     r-



                                                                                                             0
                                                                                                             2

                                                                                    &tou fi

                                                              ~Sfdz4n1*
                                                                                              , Sta   7n
                                                                                                       z
                                                          I   (Z.wr.-   r   .   o



                             .frV




                                       C'




                         4
                       Al/

         A~s T~        ~ORJA
                  NV




                                               SCALIE or FEET
                                            j j_                  200                         vo




                                                                                            GRAMIC O.,N.Y.
                                                                                    THEAMERICAN
5
          APPENDIX          E-REPORT            OF LIEUT.-COL.           MCFARLAND.   70O

                 A.     -SHOCK      OF THE EXPLOSION     AT   HALLET'S   POINT.'

                      *[By Bvt. Brig. Gen. Henry L. Abbot, Major of Engineers.]

   In June, 1876, Prof. J. W. Mallet, of the University of Virginia, addressed a com--
munication to the Secretary of the Smithsonian Institution, suggesting that advan-
tage should be taken of the great blast at Hallet's Point to revise the experimental
results obtained by his father and himself many years ago respecting the rate of trans-
mission through the earth's crust of an artificially produced impulse analogous to an
earthquake shock. Professor Henry referred this paper to the Chief of Engineers,
who forwarded it for report to General Newton, in charge of the works at Hallet's.
Point. That officer stated that he would cordially co-operate in the proposed obser-
vations, but that from want of time he could not give them personal attention. Gen-
eral Humphreys then issued instructions placing the matter in my charge, and
authorizing the employment of the officers and enlisted men of the Battalion of En-
gineers, and the use of such instruments, insulated wire, &d., as might be available
at the School of Submarine Mining at Willet's Point.
   My attention had already been drawn to the subject in a general way by the vibra-
tions produced by ordinary torpedo explosions, which are often noticeable at distances
exceeding a mile. Professor Mallet kindly loaned several volumes containing reports
of his father to the Royal Society upon Earthquakes, and verbally explained the seis-
mometer used in the investigation mentioned in his communication to Professor Henry.
The same general method has been carried out in the measurements upon the Hallet's
Point explosion, with such improvements as the progress of science has suggested.

                                    PRELIMINARY     PREPARATIONS.

  No funds were available for the purchase of instruments: but the Engineer Depot
contains many worn out and condemned articles, and from them, with the assistance
of Captain Livermore, the seismometers described below were improvised. The need-
ful registers, batteries, relays, keys, chronometers, &c., and the means of accurately
adjusting and rating them were on hand, and require no special mention.

                                          SEISMOMETERS.

   If an ordinary artificial horizon of mercury be placed on solid ground remote from the
vicinityof trees, passing vehicles, or other causes of accidental vibrations, and the re-
flection of some convenient object from the surface of the mercury beclosely watched,
any tremor in the latter is instantly detected. By using a microscope the delicacy
of the instrument is increased ; and by varying the magnifying power, a wide range of:
sensitiveness is secured. Such a variation is desirable when stations at different dis-
tances are to be occupied, because an unnecessary sensitiveness increases the danger
of losing the observation from an accidental tremor.
   Two kinds of these seismometers were employed. One, which will be designated
as type A, was made by attaching a black silk thread to one of the glasses of the arti-
ficial horizon cover, and observing its reflection by a sextant telescope mounted on a,
small tripod. The magnifying power employed in this case was about six diameters...
   For more distant stations, the telescope of a railroad transit, having a magnifying
power of about 12 diameters, was used, and, to avoid placing it at an inconvenient
distance from the mercury, the reflection of the cross hairs of another similar tele--
scope with the eye-piece removed was observed. This type will be designated as B.
A man walking at a distance of 10 feet, or a horse trotting at a distance of 300 feet,.
shakes the ground sufficiently to be readily detected with this arrangement.

                            EMPIRICAL FORMUL1E        AND   CONSTANTS.

  To select stations for the observers judiciously, in the absence of any data upon an
explosion of so exceptional a character, a rough investigation of the laws governing
the transmission of such impulses was undertaken. Denoting by S the tremor caus-
ing the minimum disturbance of the mercury, which could be detected by the type of
instrument to be employed; by D, the distance separating the instrument from the
initial disturbance causing S; and by C, the weight of the explosive, it is plain that
we have the equation:
                              (L)            s --

  Experiments were first directed to determining the function of D entering the sec-
ond member. To do this, it was necessary to find the values of D corresponding to a
  * Read before the National Academy of Sciences on October 18, 1876, and before the
Essayons Club of the Corps of Engineers on November 14, 1876.
       45 E
706      REPORT OF THE CHIEF                OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

series of artificial disturbances that could be precisely regulated, and that were of the
-same nature as that resulting from the explosion, which, since dynamite was to be
used, might safely be assimilated to a blow. No better plan suggested itself than to
make use of the fall of a heavy body through small known heights, in which case
the shock might be assumed to be directly proportional to the work performed, i. e.,
the height.
   Accordingly a cart was so arranged that a 13-inch shot, weighing 283 pounds, could
be dropped precisely 2 feet or 4 feet, as desired, giving a blow. respectively, of 566
:and 1,132 foot-pounds. Instruments of type A and B were placed side by side upon a
solid road, and the cart was moved further and further until the tremors caused by
dropping the shot through these heights could only be just perceived, thus giving for
each instrument two values of D corresponding to known shocks. A path running
near sustaining walls, and over a drain 20 feet below the surface, gave another set of
numerical values differing slightly from the first, but following the same law. Other
values were found by dropping stones of known weight through known heights.
   A discussion of these observations indicated that where the vis viva of the shot
at impact varies proportionally with D'2 similar tremors affect the seismometer:
Hence :
                                (2)             s_.f (C)
                                                     D1.2

  The form of the function of C could best be determined by firing small charges of
dynamite, bedded in the ground, at different distances, and noting when they gave a
tremor just perceptible. This was done with the following results:
   Type A just detects the tremor due to 2 ounces at 660 feet, failing for 1 ounce. and
plainly detects the tremor due to 8 ounces at 1,480 feet, failing with a much less
quantity.
   Type B plainly detects the tremor due to 2 ounces at 1,480 feet, failing for 1 ounce.
A cartridge of 8 ounces gives, at this distance, a continuous vibration lasting about
2 seconds, and 12 ounces one lasting for 3f seconds. At 660 feet the shock of 1 ounce
is very noticeable.
   These figures, considering the rough nature of the data, point to the square root of
C as the desired function, giving the law:

                          (3)                   s:   VC
                                                     D1.2

  Hence, substituting the numerical values found for the two types of seismometer
employed, the units being the mile and the pound, we have:

                          (4)         Type A    D=            C
                                                            3.26

                          (5)         Type B    D= 1V
                                                            1.63
   These empirical formulae were roughly tested by the vibrations caused by the tor-
pedoes exploded this summer during the prosecution of the submarine minining trials
now in progress at Willets Point, namely:
   (1) A charge of 200 pounds of dynamite, submerged 30 feet under   -n iron target, was
fired on August 18. By Eq. (5) it should give a noticeable tremor at a distance of 6
miles. Captain Livermore distinctly detected it with an instrument of the B type at
a station 5 miles away.
   (2) A charge of 100 pounds of dynamite, submerged 12 feet, was fired on September 2.
It should have been perceived, according to Eq. (4) and (5), at extreme ranges of 2.5
miles and 4.5 miles, respectively. Observers at 2.3 miles and 4.1 miles failed to detect
it, but the exact instant of the explosion was unknown to them, and the wind and other
conditions were unfavorable to so delicate observations'n othat day.
   In fine, then, I considered that a more judicious selection of stations for the great
blast could be made by regarding the indications of these formnla than by any other
method.
                                SELECTION   OF STATIONS.

  As the charge at Hallet's Point was to be about 50,000 pounds of dynamite, the for-
mule indicated 33 miles and 59 miles, respectively, as the distances for the extreme
stations for seismometers of types A and B.
  It was needful, however, to bear in mind that the mine was made up of thousands
of small charges, and that this distribution might probably reduce the tremor. This
         APPENDIX       E-REPORT OF LIEUT.-COL.                MCFARLAND.           707
fact, together with the importance of securing distinct observations at the few stations
it would be possible to occupy, led me to prefer to err on the safe side.
   The geographical situation of Hallet's Point with respect to land and water was
also to be considered, since it was desirable to detect any difference due to the nature
of the route traversed by the vibration.
   The telegraph system in the vicinity was also a matter of primary importance.
Upon Long Island this is under the control of the Western Union Telegraph Company,
but the railroad companies have the right to send train messages. Both corporations
freely extended every facility in their power without charge, doing, indeed, more
than I had asked to promote the excess of the experiments. To the Western Union,
particularly, acknowledgments are due, for not only was the assistance of the operators
freely granted, but special line-men, even, were sent out to insure the good condition
of the wires.
   Finally, five stations were selected. Three, Fresh Pond Junction, Jamaica, and
Sprin field Junction, were on a land Toute extending in a southeast direction across
Long Island, and were in telegraphic communication with Astoria, near Hallet's Point.
Willet's Point lay to the eastward, nearly in the direction of East River, and offered
a good water route. Lastly, West Point, to the north, was distant 52 miles-i. e., was
nearly at the extreme range indicated by the formula for the most sensitive seismom-
eter. Lieutenant Bass, Corps of Engineers, stationed at that post, kindly volunteered
to observe there with a very powerful telescope, but the storm compelled him to change
his plan, and to use one of type A, which, as predicted by the formula, failed to detect
any vibration.
                                TIME   DETERMINATIONS.


   The plan employed by General Newton to explode the mine was the following:
The charges were divided into 23 groups, for each of which a separate voltaic battery
was provided. The circuits of these batteries were each complete except at one point.
Here breaks existed between a set of mercury cups on a table and corresponding
brass points on a drop above. This drop was held up by a cord, suspended from a small
can containing a charge of dynamite and a fuze. When, at the appointed time, the
latter was exploded by an auxiliary battery the drop fell, and, simultaneously closing
all the circuits, fired the mine. General Newton kindly provided an extra mercury
cup and point for my use, and thus gave me an opportunity of causing the explosion
to automatically register itself at the three stations to which an electrical circuit
could be carried.
   All the wires on Long Island are worked by batteries in the Western Union build-
ing in New York City. A multiple cable carries the circuit across East River, near
Hunter's Point, and one core is thence extended in a loop to Astoria to work that office.
For my observations the current was sent from New York to Astoria, and thence along
a single wire to the three inland stations selected, viz: Fresh Pond Junction, distant
about 5 miles; Jamaica, distant about 9 miles; and Springfield Junction, distant about
13 miles from the mine. The wire was put to earth beyond the instrument at the
latter station.
   At each of these three stations the line-wire passed through the coils of a relay
arranged to close a local circuit when the current passed. These local circuits each
contained a battery and a Morse register. Independent circuits containing the same
battery and register were arranged at each of the stations, to be closed at will by a
key in the hand of the observer at the seismometer, who took post at the best position
in the vicinity for obtaining good results, care being taken to secure a solid support
for the mercury and the minimum danger of interruption from passing vehicles, &c.
   At Astoria the main-line circuit was worked like a local by a special battery; that
is, it was attached to the contact points of a relay, and remained open except when
this relay was acted upon by an auxiliary battery. The latter battery (10 cells Le-
clanchd) was placed at the firing station, with one pole to earth. The other pole
was connected to a line of insulated torpedo cable, laid on the ground for the purpose.
The current on leaving the battery passed first through a break-circuit plug in the
hands of the observer; thence through the coils of a relay, working a local circuit
for recording the exact instant of the explosion; thence to the mercury cup at the
mine, where was situated the break, to be closed by the drop at the explosion; thence
to the coils of the relay at the Astoria office, and thence to earth.
   The break at the drop was thus the only one in this auxiliary circuit, and it was
closed by the same motion and at the identical time when the firing batteries ex-
ploded the 3,680 fuzes. The effect was instantly to work the two relays of the auxil-
iary circuit. The one at the firing station registered the time; the one at the Astoria
office closed the main line, and thus sent a current from the New York battery through
the relays at the three stations, making a mark on each of the register papers. As
soon as the observer at the firing station perceived that the mine had exploded he
withdrew the break-circuit plug, all the relay contact points on the main line opened,
708       REPORT     OF   THE CHIEF       OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

and the register papers were each ready to receive the marks caused by the key of the
observer at the adjacent seismomneter as he noted the tremor of the mercury.
   By this syst em the explosion recorded itself at each of the three stations with only
the error due to three armature times, which probably did not exceed two-tenths of
a second, and even this small error was balanced by the time spent by the observers
in closing their keys. Great care was given to securing a regular movement of the
paper on the registers, and elaborate measurements, made just before and after the
explosion, show that this object was attained with a probable error not in any case
exceeding two-tenths of a second. The most exact accuracy is, therefore, claimed for
these measurements.
   The stations at Willets Point and West Point, not being on telegraph circuits, re-
quired different arrangements. As no tremor was detected at the latter place, the
details for it possess no interest. Those for Willets Point, however, are important,
because the rate of transmission noted is surprising. Two good sidereal chronometers
were employed. One is permanently kept in the astronomical observatory there, and
its rate is known. The other was carried very carefully by boat to and from Hallet's
Point, where it was used in making the absolute time marks on the register paper at
the firing station. Careful comparisons were made at 6 a. m. and 6 p. m. of the day
of the explosion and again at 10 a. m. of the following day. They showed a dis-
crepancy in the rates of only .4 seconds in twelve hours, proving that the latter re-
mained sensibly unchanged during the three hours intervening between the blast and
the second comparison.
  The observations at Willets Point were made in the observatory with a sensitive
seismometer and Morse register, the absolute time being directly referred to the standard
chronometer. By this method a very close measurement of the time required for the
tremor to pass to Willets Point was secured, the error being probably a small fraction
of a second.
                           DETAILS OF THE    OBSERVATIONS.


  The mine was exploded on September 24, 1876, at precisely 2h. 50m. 12.6s. of New
York mean solar time. This determination is correct within a small fraction of a
second, and may serve to give value to observations made by other observers, who
took the precaution to accurately note the instant of feeling the tremor and to ascer-
tain the error of their time-pieces.
  The following is a summary of the reports of the officers of Engineers who made
the observations at the several stations, arranged in the order of their increasing
distances from the mine.

LIEUTENANT YOUNG, AT FRESH POND JUNCTION-(distant 5.134 miles from the mine.)

   By an unfortunate accident the register was not running at this station; and the
time results being noted by a watch are only approximate. Lieutenant Young re-
ports: "Very shortly after the mine signal we felt quite a distinct tremor in the
ground under us, and at the same time heard a low rumbling sound exactly similar to
the first sounds heard after the explosion of a dynamite torpedo. The time between
the mine signal and the tremor was about seven seconds; and the duration of the
tremor as shown by the seismometer was about sixty-three seconds. The rumbling
sensation lasted several seconds.

    LIEUTENANT GRIFFIN AT WILLETS POINT-(distant 8.33 miles from the mine.)

   These observations were perfectly successful.       Lieutenant Griffin was provided
with an instrument of the B type. He reports:
   "The first evidence of the explosion was a sudden and very violent shaking of the
mercury. The maximum effect seemed to be reached at once, and not gradually; but,
as the first shake was so violent, it is possible that the maximum may not have been
instantly attained, for a slight increase or diminution in the disturbance could not
possibly have been perceived at that time.
   '"The motion of the mercury subsided quite rapidly to a regular vibration, which
lasted for several seconds.
   "The vibration as it appeared in the mercury may be shown by the following curve
(Plate II)." This is designed to indicate that for some time it was impossible to dis-
tinguish any distinctive feature of the vibration, except the fact that it was violent.
Then it gradually began to subside. This subsidence increased in rapidity up to a
certain point and then decreased. After this the mercury settled down very gradually.
   " I thought I heard the noise of the explosion simultaneously with the first vibra-
tion.   It sounded something like a torpedo, but more muffled, and with more of a
                                       * Omitted.
          APPENDIX       E-REPORT         OF LIEUT.-COL.        MCFARLAND.           709
rumble, and, so to speak, roar to it.  In this I may possibly have been mistaken, as
none of the bystanders noticed it."
  Measurements on the register paper showed that the first tremor was noted at 5.3
seconds after the explosion ; that the violent agitation continued for 37.1 seconds, and
that it continued perceptible for 35.2 seconds more; making a total period of 72.3
seconds during which the mercury was sensibly shaken.

      LIEUTENANT KINGMAN, AT JAMAICA-(distant 9,333 miles from the mine.)

   Everything at this station worked admirably. The instruments were placed in an
old foundry, where the earth was very hard. Lieutenant Kingman reports: "A click
of the armature informed me that the circuit had been closed at Hallet's Point. Fol-
lowing this came the vibration of the earth-sharp, strong, and unmistakable. The
vibration was distinguishable for a period of about 30 seconds, decreasing'in violence
from the first, and growing less and less, until finally it could no longer be detected.
If I were to represent the intensity of the shock by a curve, it would take a form like
the right-hand figure on Plate II,* the ordinates being the intensity and the abscissas
the time. There was a short period of intense vibration, which decreased rapidly
at first, and then slowly and uniformly to zero.
   °"Accompanying the shock was a low rumbling sound of about three or four sec-
onds' duration, which was distinctly heard by me, and also by a portion of theby-
standers; there were some, however, who did not hear it. The sound and the shock
came together, and the sound was loudest when the vibration was at its maximum.
Though I listened intently for more than a minute after the explosion, no other
sound of this character was heard ; and I am satisfied that it must have been caused
by the mine, for it was entirely similar to the sound of a torpedo when heard at a dis-
tance.
   " In preparing to observe the shake I had focused my telescope on the reflected
image of a horse-hair fastened to the glass cover of my artificial horizon. This image
happened to be placed in the direction of wave propagation.      On the arrival of the
shock this image became distorted into an undulating line. The undulations seemed
to start from the end towards Hallet's Point and run along the hair and then return,
causing the image to present the appearance shown on the left-hand figure of Plate
II.* It could be distinctly seen in each of its different positions. "
   The registerpaper showed that the interval between the explosion and the arrival
of the tremor was 10.9 seconds ; and that the latter continued 23.5 seconds--the in-
strument being of type A.

LIEUTENANT LEACH, AT SPRINGFIELD JUNCTION--(distant 12,769 miles from the mine. )

   Here, too, the observations were everything which could be desired. The instru-
ment was of the B type, which, it will be remembered, is doubly as sensitive as that
used at Jamaica, and the same as that used at Willets Point. Lieutenant Leach re-
ports :
   " The soil in the vicinity of my station is a light sand, with a top soil not more than
six inches in thickness.
  The place selected for the instrument was in a lane where the travel had been suf-
ficient to kill the grass, and firmly pack the top-soil, but not to clit through it.
  I removed a little loose earth with a shovel, and then ground the artificial horizon
into a firm contact with the solid earth.
  As soon as the warning message was received, I put the line to ground east, and
connected my local wires to the relay and battery in the telegraph office. I then went
to the instrument, repeated the tests, and at three and a half minutes before the ap-
pointed time, set the register in motion.
  At 2.51 p. m. by my watch a click, or rather a series of clicks, were heard on the
register. This was the signal communicated by the firing of the mine, and its record
on the paper was exactly like two " a's" of the Morse code. Five seconds after, an-
other mark was registered on the paper, the cause of which must have been an acci-
dental closing of the main line or of my key-which, I am unable to say. About
thirteen (12.7) seconds after the firing signal the shock reached my station. As indi-
cated by the seismometer, it was very violent, and seemed to attain its maximum in-
stantaneously.
  The amplitude of the vibration of the reflected image of the object wire was very
much greater than the extent of my field, across which the rapidly vibrating wire
images appeared but a thick haze.
  For this reason I am unable to give a positive opinion as to the violence of the
shock when at its greatest intensity, which would readily result were the greatest
amplitude known.
                                     * Omitted.
710      REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

  But from the time the limits of vibration came within the field, I studied them as
closely as the circuihstances would permit.
  The instant that I saw the wires re-enter the field is'given by my 2d mark at 19
seconds after the firing signal, and the end of the vibration is indicated by my 3d
mark at 31.67 seconds from the firing signal. During this interval my conception of
the subsidence is represented by the following curve (Plate II).*
  The full line represents the portion of the vibration which was in the field, and
which I was able to observe. I have completed the curve according to the same law,
and think it may be accepted as a close approximation to the greatest intensity, and
subsequent decrease, up to the time at which I began to note the vibrations them-
selves.
  The vibrations showed most unmistakably the peculiar wave oscillation which has
been so frequently noticed in connection with shocks produced by exploding dyna-
mite.
  I think the distance of the instrument from the explosion was far within its limit
for that shock, and believe it could not have failed to register the latter at two and
a half or three times the distance.
  The time at which the sound reached my station was not recorded, as the rain beat-
ing upon the tent prevented me from hearing it; but I had instructed my men, and
had requested the bystanders, to listen sharply for it. A mean of their opinions would
indicate that some sound certainly reached us; but the original wave had probably
been completely dissipated, leaving only a superposition of echoes. At any rate, the
result was a low rumbling sound which gradually increased to a maximum, and then
as gradually died away. A large majority of those who were listening declared that
they heard it.
  The cause of the two letters, and of the subsequent mark (forming the letter T) to
which Lieutenant Leach refers is curious. They are duplicated on the Jamaica record,
and Lieutenant Young noticed their sound at his station. The paper at the firing
station showed a continuous mark for the whole time occupied by the "A A." These
facts prove that the tremor of the earth at the Astoria office, about 800 yards from
the mine, was sufficiently violent to move the contact point of the relay ; and the ex-
plosion thus actually sent a message consisting of the three letters A. A. T. down the
line. The diagram (Plate II)* is a fac simile of the register records at the three sta-
tions, carefully plotted to a scale. The mark at the firing station, 1.1 seconds long,
began at the closing of the circuit by the fall of the drop; it ceased when the circuit
was broken by the withdrawal of the plug in the hands of the observer, which oc-
curred when the jet apparently had reached about half its extreme height (125 feet).
No better evidence of the instantaneous nature of the explosion can be desired.

               LIEUTENANT BASS AT WEST POINT-DISTANT 52 MILES.

   Lieutenant Bass had intended to observe with a magnifying power of twenty di-
ameters, but the storm forced him to make use of a smaller glass having only a power
of five.
   He selected an admirable station among the hills, resting the mercury upon a ledge
of solid rock, and observed intently for forty minutes in a pouring rain, thus estab-
lishing that no tremor observable with his instrument extended to that distance.
This result, as already stated, confirms the accuracy of the empirical formula which
indicates 33 miles as the limit. Probably a power of twenty would have detected a
tremor.
                            ANALYSIS    OF THE RESULTS.

  The measurements upon the tremor caused by the blast at Hhllet's Point, just de-
scribed in detail, indicate a rate of movement far in excess of that reported by Mr.
Mallet, and higher than might be anticipated from existing data upon the velocity of
sound through solids. The most careful attention was, therefore, given to eliminat-
ing all possible causes of error. The distances were taken by Lieutenant Leach from
the manuscript maps of the railroad surveys, drawn upon a large scale, and from the
published coast survey maps, and may be depended upon as nearly correct. The
time measurements, as already explained, are certainly inferior in precision to none
that have ever been attempted in this kind of investigation. The following consoli-
dated table, which exhibits the results in a form convenient for reference and com-
parison, must, therefore, be accepted as trustworthy, although in some respects sur-
prising.
                                       * Omitted.
          APPENDIX E-REPORT                      OF LIEUT.-COL.             MFARLAND.              711

                                 Distance                       Tremor of earth-            Velocity of
                                from mine.                                                transmission.
          Station.                               Type of
                                               instrument.   Arrived in     Lasted for      Feet per
                                  Miles.                      seconds.       seconds.        second.

Fresh Pond Junction........           5. 134           A.           7. 0?        63. 0?            3873 ?
Willets Point ...............         8. 33            B.           5. 3         72. 3             8300
Jamaica..-..................          9. 333           A.          10. 9         23. 5             4521
Springfield Junction .......         12. 769           B.          12. 7         19.0              5309



   Certain observations upon the shocks produced by dynamite torpedoes, made be-
fore the blast at Hallet's Point was fired, also indicate a very high rate of transmis-
sion.
   Thus, on August 18, Captain Livermore, of the Engineers, made observations upon
the explosion of a 200-pound dynamite torpedo, planted 30 feet under a floating iron
target in 42 feet water off Willets Point. His station was 5 miles distant, nearly in
the prolongation of Little Neck Bay. He perceived the tremor distinctly with an in-
strument of the B type, reporting as follows: " The first indication of the explosion
was given by the seismometer. The second was by the appearance of the jet of water
to privates Newburg and Jones, the jet being at full height (110 feet) when first seen.
The mercury continued to vibrate after these men had called 'time' for at least one
second. The disturbance was equal to that from a stone, the size of a man's head,
dropped from a height of 6 feet at a distance of 15 feet; but the duration was very
different, having an increasing and decreasing phase, very perceptible."
   The second of firing the torpedo was noted upon a chonometer with which Captain
Livermore's watch was compared before and after the explosion; and the beginning
of the tremor was noted on this watch. The difference proved to be about five sec-
onds, which was much less than had been anticipated. Still, the fact of the tremor
being felt before the jet had subsided, established the substantial accuracy of the
record.
    In like manner the time required for the tremor caused by a 100-pound dynamite
torpedo to reach Fort Schuyler, across East River,was noted a few days later by Lieu-
tenant Greene, of the Engineers. On this occasion the explosion was made to record
itself with precision, through an insulated torpedo cable, in a manner similar to that
used at Hallet's Point; and the result indicated 4,800 feet per second as the rate of
transmission of the shock.
    Notwithstanding all this evidence, I sought to find a satisfactory reason to account
for the extraordinary discrepancy between my results and those of Mr. Mallet, whose
reputation in earthquake investigations, both as an observer and as a theorist, is so
well established. He reported the velocity of transmission of artificial impulses to
be in sand, 8"25 feet; in discontinuous and much shattered granite, 1,306 feet; and in
more solid granite, 1,665 feet per second. Also, from observations upon the explosion
of large mines of powder in the quarries at Holyhead, he states: " The mean lowest
rate of wave transit in these rocks through measured ranges of from 5,038 to 6,582
feet was 1,089 feet per second; and the mean highest, 1,352 feet per second; and the
general mean 1,320 feet per second." As all my data referred to explosions of dyna-
mite, and his to gunpowder, I finally determined to try one experiment with the latter.
    Accordingly on October 10, I fired a charge of 70 pounds of mortar powder in a
wooden torpedo case, 5 feet below the surface in 13 feet of water. Captain Miller
and Lieutenant Kingman, of the Engineers, were stationed at a distance of about a
mile, the former with a telescope and key to close a register circuit when he saw the
flash of a gun, to be fired by the same current which exploded the torpedo, and the
latter with a seismometer of type A and a key to close the circuit when the mercury
became agitated. The observation was perfectly successful, the time of transmission
being 5.8 seconds for 7,200 feet, indicating a velocity of 1,240 feet per second. Hence,
since 2,100 feet of the route lay through water, this gunpowder explosion accorded
fairly with the gunpowder results obtained by Mr. Mallet.
    At first sight these facts would seem to indicate that the shock given by an explo-
sion of dynamite is transmitted much faster than one from an explosion of gunpow-
der. Although the character of the impulse is widely different in the two cases, such
a proposition certainly cannot be accepted without further evidence, although it is
not novel. In a note to Silliman's Physics, it is stated : " Rev. E. S. Earnshaw, of
Sheffield, England," lately brings good evidence, both mathematical and physical, to
show that the accepted views stated in ¢ 343 are correct only for sounds having no
very great difference of intensity. The velocity of sounds of all kinds is a certain
function depending upon the rapidity and length of vibration. In the case of violent
thunder, the numerical value of this function becomes much greater than for ordinary
     *London, Edinburgh,and Dublin Phil. Mag.from June, July, September, t860.
712          REPORT              OF THE        CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                                U. S. ARMY.

-sounds. These, and other remarkable conclusions, are sustained by mathematical
'reasoning. The author of the memoir also cites evidence to show that the crash of
  violent thunder claps has been often heard almost simultaneously with the flash of
  lightning, although the stroke fell several miles distant." Captain Handbury, of
the Engineers, also informs me that on bne occasion when approaching a battery at
 'drill, about a third of a mile distant, he heard the explosion of the gun and distinctly
-after it, probably as much as a second, the command to fire. This occurred at West
Point, N. Y. A similar fact was noted on Perry's second voyage.
    Nevertheless, since these observations have revealed the fact that the tremor con-
-sists of a long-continued succession of earth waves lasting for many seconds, I am
mnore inclined to accept a suggestion of Lieutenant Kingman, who noticed at the
  gunpowder explosion that the movement was very slight, and only continued for an
  instant, showing that his seismometer was near the limit of its range. He suggests
  that if there be a gradual increase followed by'a gradual decrease in the amplitude
  of the earth waves, a delicate seismometer will detect the arrival sooner than one less
sensitive. In other words, the vibrations will begin sooner, as well as last longer,
for such an instrument. This would apparently reduce the time of transit, and thus
increase the measured velocity, when instruments of high power are employed, as at
  Willets Point and Springfield Junction.
     In fine, the extraordinary duration of the vibrations produced by these dynamite
explosions, and especially by that of the great blast as noted at Willets Point, to
  which the shock had both a water and a land route, is certainly a novel feature in
artificial impulses; and, in connection with the hardly less estraordinary velocity of
the general wave front, well merits attention. The latter is the more surprising, be-
cause Long Island geologically belongs to ,the drift formation, and is, of course, far
  from homogeneous in structure. It is, therefore, proposed to continue the investiga-
tion next spring, taking advantage of certain torpedo explosions which will be re-
quired in prosecuting the course of experiment now in progress at the School of Sub-
anarine Mining at Willets Point.


                   B. -ON    THE VELOCITY            OF TRANSMISSION              OF EARTH               WAVES.*

                    By Bvt. Brig. Gen. H. L. ABBOT, nmajor, Corps of Engineers.

    Believing at the date of my first paper that the data secured at the Hallets Point
 ,explosion demonstrated she necessity for more exact and comprehensive knowledge
<nf  the subject, I have during the past season taken advantage of the facilities of-
fered   by large subaqueous explosions at the School of Submarine Mining at Willets
:Point to continue the investigation, and on October 23, 1877, I read a second paper
before the National Academy of Sciences, giving the results thus obtained. As only
a brief abstract of this paper has appeared in print, I propose now to give a summary
,of.the conclusions suggested by the whole series of experiments.
    Limited space forbids any detailed explanation here of the method adopted for
.measuring the time of transmission of the shocks; especially as this is fully given in
any printed paper, together with the notes of the observers in full. Suffice it to say
that the instant of explosion and the time of arrival of the tremors were electrically
recorded on the same moving paper with extreme precision. The following table ex-
Shibits the data: * * *

                                                                          i                .   ITremor of mer-
                                                                                               Scury.                 Velocity of
       S   Date.            Observer.          Cause of shock.                                                         trasumis-
                                                                              c                Arrived     Lasted      sion.
                                                                                  S              in.         for.

                                                                         Miles.                  Sees.       ees.     Feetper see.
      SAug.18,1876                                     t
                        Capt.Livcrmore 200 bs. dynamite.                 C i                     S          ... ...      5,280
  2 Sept. 24,1876       Lieut. Young .. Hallet's Point ex..              5.134        A.          7         63 -         3, 873 ±
  3    Sept. 24,1876    Lieut. Griffin ....... do.......         ..      8. 330       B.          5. 3      72. 3         8, 300
4 Sept. 24,1876        Lieut.Kingman ..-.. do ............    9.333               A.           10.9         23.5         4, 521
5 Sept. 24,1876        Lieut. Leach ..    do ----- -...--... 12. 769              B.           12.7         19.0         5, 309
6 Oct. 10, 1876        Lieut. Kingman. 70 pounds powder..' 1.360                  A.            5.8        Inst.         1,240
 .8 Sept.
7
    Sept.
             6,1877 ...
              6,1877
                            do   ........    400 lbs. dynamite
                        Lieut. Leach..-..... do.............
                                                                   -..   1. 169    A.             1. 8       7. 8         3, 428
                                                                         1. 169    B.            0. 7       17.   8       8, 814
   9 Sept.   12, 1877   Lieut. Griffin .. 200 lbs. dynamite ..           1. 340    A.            1.05        8.   8       6, 730
  10 Sept.   12,1877    Lieut. Leach....      do .--.....    ....        1. 340    B-            0. 81      17.   1       8, 730
11 Sept.    121877     Lieut. Griffin ... 70 poundspowder.              1. 340    A.            1.27        4.   8       5, 559
12 Sept.    12,1877    Lieut. Leach .... do ............                1.340     B.            0. 84      15.   1       8, 415

 *Extracts from an article in the American Journal of Science and Arts, Vol. XV,
March, 1878.
             APPENDIX            E-REPORT               OF LIEUT.-COL.                MCFARLAND.                   713

   Mr. Mallet's results were reported many years ago to the Royal Society, and un-
questionably are to be accepted as exhibiting the velocities due to his initial shocks
and given by the method which he employed. * * * The following are his figures :
Velocity, in feet, per second in sand .........................-----------------------------..--...--..----......---   825
Velocity, in feet, per second in discontinuous and much shattered granite ....                                       1,306
Velocity, in feet, per second in more solid granite..... ......                            ..............            1,665
Velocity, in feet, per second in quarries at Holyhead (mean) ---.....                                  ..........    1,320
   The extraordinary differences between these rates and those measured at the Hal-
let's Point explosion, and the apparent discrepancies of the latter among themselves,
led me to so plan the new observations as to throw light upon two points: 1st. Does
a telescope of high power detect a tremor in the mercury in advance of the one firsf
revealed by a lower power ? 2d. Is there a difference in the rate of transmission o
the shocks due to differences in the intensity of th einitial explosion ?
   The method adopted was to station two observers near each other at a carefully
selected inland position, each observing a mercury seismometer, and holding in his
hand the key of an accurate Morse register to record the instant of arrival and the
duration of The tremor. These seis nometers were the same instruments used at the
Hallet's Point explosion. They differed from each other only in the optical power of
the telescope, that designated A in the table having a magnifying power of 6, and
that marked B of 12.
   A fuze in the electrical circuit which fired the torpedo was bedded in the cartridge
of a field-gun directed toward the observers, and as a very powerful battery was
used, the two explosions were absolutely simultaneous.                            A third observer, holding
in his hand a key which closed the circuit of both registers, observed the muzzle
of this gun with a good telescope, and recorded the flash electrically with precision.
The observers were all officers of the Corps of Engineers accustomed to delicate ob-
servations. The distance traversed by the shock was measured by triangulation.
   Ths observations of September 6 and September 12, 1877, marked 7 to 12, and suf-
ficiently explained in the foregoing table, answered the query relative to optical
power decisively in the affirmative, and, as may be seen from the table, the earlier ob-
servations singly anil collectively suggest the same conclusion. The mean velocity
given by the six observations with type A is 4,225 feet per second, while that given
by the same number with type B is 7,475 feet per second. There can, therefore, be
no doubt that the first tremor of the mercury is of too feeble intensity to be detected
with a magnifsing power of 6.       Hence, as the first tremor determines the true rate
of transmission of the shock, the rejection of all the observations made with type A
follows as a matter of course. They are valuable as exhibiting the rate of advance
of waves having a certain intensity, but they do not reveal the velocity of the lead-
ing tremor. Indeed, it is not impossible that a power above 12 might have detected
a still earlier tremor, or, in other words, have indicated velocities of transmission
exceeding those in the table.
   These conclusions are so novel and important that certain additional evidence will
be given, furnished by the notes of the observers recorded at the time and without
consultation.
   Lieutenant Leach, using a power of 12, recorded of the second observation of Sep-
tember 12 (No. 12), "The gunpowder wave was peculiar, in having a much more
gradual increase than has been observed in dynamite shocks. I should say it was at
least two seconds in attaining a maximum, whereas the dynamite usually reaches its
maximum in a very small fraction of a second."
   Lieutenant Griffin, who used a power of 6, recorded of the same shock (No. 11),
 " The gunpowder disturbance remained constant for a perceptible interval, instead
of immediately decreasing, as is the case with dynamite."
   It will be noticed that the shock of October 10, 1876 (No. 6), was caused by the ex-
plosion of 70 pounds of gunpowder-the same charge which was fired on September
12, 1877, and to which these records refer-but that the duration of the tremor was
much less. The reason is that the initial earth waves were far more violent in the
latter case, when the torpedo lay on the bottom in 30 feet of water, than in the for-
mer, when the charge was only submerged 5 feet in water 13 feet deep, and thus ex-
pended much of its energy in throwing a huge jet of water 330 feet into the air.
    Thus it will be seen that these records, and the velocities observed on the two days,
all tend to confirm the idea that a slow-burning explosive, like gunpowder, generates
a series of gradualiv increasing tremors which, at a distance of a mile, are at first
quite invisible with the less sensitive seismometer; and are only detected by it when
near their maximum intensity. If Lieutenant Leach's estimate of time for the arri-.
val of the maximum wave be accepted, we have, therefore, for the first mile:
                                 SPower of 12 gives 8,415 feet per second.
                     Deep torpedo) Power of 6 gives 5,559 feet per second.
                     (70 pounds.)  Estimated minimum 2,489 feet per second.
                                               power gives
                  Shallow torpedo           Actual minimum               1,240 feet per eod.
                    (70 pounds)              power gives                                       secod.
714         REPORT OF THE CHIEF                OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

  Without wishing to attach undue weight to these records, they appear to me to
suggest a possible explanation of the discrepancies between the results obtained by
Mr. Mallet and myself.      *   *       *
   As to the second query, Whether the rate varies with the intensity of the initial
shock the data, although less decisive, certainly suggests an affirmative answer.
The evidence afforded by No. 6 and No. 11 has been already pointed out. For a power
of 12 the table shows that for the first mile :
  400 pounds of dynamite give 8,814 feet per second.
  200 pounds of dynamite give 8,730 feet per second.
    70 pounds of powder (deep), 8,415 feet per second.
  If it be admitted also that the velocity of the wave diminishes with its advance,
all the data become accordant. Thus:
  200 pounds of dynamite give for 1 ii ile, 8,730 feet per second.
  200 pounds of dynamite give for 5 miles, 5,280 feet per second.
   50,000 pounds of dynamite give for 8 miles, 8,300 feet per second.
  50,000 pounds of dynamite give for 13+ miles, 5,300 feet pet second. "
   In fine, I believe that the following general conclusions are suggested by these
measurements: (1) A high magnifying power of telescope is essential in seismomeric
observations. (2) The more violent the initial shock the higher is the velocity of
transmission. (3) This velocity diminishes as the general wave advances. (4) The
movements of the earth's crust are complex, consisting of many short waves, first in-
creasing and then decreasing in amplitude; and, with a detonating explosive, the
interval between the first wave and the maximum wave, at any station, is shorter
than with a slow-burning explosive.
        *          *                *           a             *            *    *

   In fine, my own opinion is that in this, as in all physical investigations, the more
thoroughly the ground is covered the greater will be the number of important facts
developed; and that complex rather than simple phenomena should be expected. It
is quite impossible to ascribe the discrepancy between Mr. Mallet's results and those
here described to inaccuracy of observation. Differences in the material traversed
by the waves and in the method of observing may possibly explain them.




                  C.-SEISMOGRAPHIC           OBSERVATIONS AT ASTORIA.

                       [Report of Capt. J. G. D. Knight, Corps of Engineers.]

   I have to report the following duties performed by me in connection with seismo,
graphic observations of the explosion at Flood Rock, October 10, 1885.
   In compliance with S. O. No. 151, current series, from Headquarters Corps of En-
gineers, U. S. A., on September 29, 1885, I examined and reported upon the suitability
as observation stations of Patchogue, Babylon, and Springfield, on the Long Island
Railway.
   I prepared four sets of telescopes used by the observation parties at Patchogue,
Bay Shore, Pearsall's and the astronomical observatory at Willets Point. The ar-
rangement was in principle that used for observing at Springfield Junction, L. I.,
the effect of the explosion at Hallett's Point, September 24, 1876, consisting of two
telescopes, the eye-piece of one renioved and the image of its cross-hairs reflected by
an artificial horizon through the other telescope to the observer. The magnifying
powers of the observing telescopes were respectively nineteen, eighteen, fourteen and
fourteen, as determined to the nearest unit by observing with the unaided eye the
number of divisions on a stadia covered by one or more divisions of the same as seen
with the other eye assisted by the telescope in question.
   I prepared crude seismographs of three forms, which were set up in the vicinity of
Flood Rock: (1) after the design of Mr. Robert Mallet, white pine cylinders all 4
inches in length, 1.5, 1.0, 0.75, 0.50, and 0.37 inches in diameter. The latter were
blown down and hence not used, and difficulty was experienced in one case in trying
to make the next smaller size stand. These cylinders rested on wooden strips 22
inches long, 1l inches high and 1l inches wide, partially imbedded in sand to prevent
movement of cylinders after having been overturned. It would have been better
had each cylinder rested on a shorter cylinlder of equal diameter with its own, the
shorter cylinder securely fastened to the strip, and the sand brought up to the level
of the top of the shorter cylinder to prevent movement of cylinders also, in cases
where they fell on the strips: (2) flat blocks hollowed out in the middle to hold mer-
cury, with radial grooves falling as they left the bowl and ending in cylindrical holes,
the latter and the inclination of the grooves to prevent the return to the central reser-
          APPENDIK      E-REPORT           OF LIEUT.-COL.         McFARLAND.        715
voir of mercury once ejected therefrom: (3) iron wires 21 inches long and one-tenth or
an inch in diameter, pointed at top, fastened in blocks at the bottom, each wire
weighted with two leaden bullets one-half inch in diameter, touching one another 1
inch from top of wire. It was proposed to have the points mark any motion communi-
cated to them in paraffine; but the latter having been found too hard, a mixture of
lard and tallow was countersunk in a block supported above the wire of one seis-
mograph, and, owing to an accident, lard alone above the wire of the other. A score
of 4 inch was registered on the first, set up on the Hallet's Point light-tower; and one
of about I inch on the second, at station V1 (see Plate III);      but when taking the
instruments to pieces for repacking I failed to note the azimuth of the scores.
   On Plate III is marked the locations at which these three forms of seismographs
were set up. At station I on the light-tower, 236 feet high, the superintendent in
charge kindly placed one of each form. The others of type II, two in number, were
set up at points "M ;" and one of type III, at the point " W."           At other stations
only type I was used. Station VII was used at the last moment, in the hope of being
able with irppromptu means to approximately determine the height to which the
water was raised by the explosion. The greatest height observed was estimated to
be 286 feet.
   All stations other than numbers I and VII were on a filling of from 3 to 6 feet of
earth over marsh-sod.
   The results obtained by the seismographs of types I and II are shown on Plate II.
On this is represented each instrument as it would be if revolved in a horizontal
plane until the plotted magnetic bearings of Flood Rock flagstaff, as determined at
each station, coincide; distances given are from this staff. When multiplied by ten
grains the figures on the mercury seismographs will give the amount of mercury
found in the corresponding holes. Cylinders marked with a cross remained standing
after the explosion. On page 612, vol. VII, Encyclopaedia Britannica, 9th edition, is
given Professor Haughton's approximate formula for determining, with the aid of the
seismograph of type I, the velocity of the earth wave :

                               15b + 2 16a2
                         v       12a          g Va2+b2 (1-cos 0)

where a is the altitude and b the diameter of the base of the cylinder, and 0 the angle
formed by the side and a line drawn through the center of gravity to the extremity
of the base. Applying this to the various cylinders used, it is found that velocities
of 3.6, 2.4, 1.8, and 1.2 feet per second are necessary to overturn the cylinders of the
four larger sizes.
  I fail to see what inference can be drawn from the results, as plotted; cylinders of
larger sizes fell, while smaller ones remained standing; and the directions in which
those which fell rested after so doing vary, though the motion of the light-tower
doubtless rendered registers of seismographs thereon discordant with those of others
on terra firma. The two mercury seismographs not on the tower harmonize to some
extent, in showing a flow of mercury in directions at right angles to the direction of
Flood Rock from their stations.



                D.-DETERMINATION        OF THE INSTANT OF EXPLOSION.

                   [Report of Capt. Thomas N. Bailey, Corps of Engineers.]

   I have the honor to submit the following report concerning time determinations,
in connection with seismoscopic observations on the occasion of the recent explosion
at Flood Rock.
   As all the observing stations under your charge, except Willets Point, were con-
nected by telegraph with Astoria, the measurement of the interval between the time
of explosion and the time of arrival of the shock at the former stations required
simply the difference of readings recorded by special Morse registers at each station.
At Willets Point it was necessary to determine this interval by comparisons of chrono-
meters; one being transported to and from Astoria and compared, before and after
the explosion, with another chronometer at Willets Point. The chronometer used at
Willets Point was Lukens No. 141, the standard of the observatory.     The astronomi-
cal work of the season just terminating shows that its rate has been reasonably
uniform for five months.
   The chronometer transported and used at Astoria was Negus No. 1,499, which had
been selected from others on account of its uniformity of rate shown by daily com-
parisons with the Lukens since September 25, 1885. Both of these were sidereal
chronometers supplied with the Negus break-circuit attachment.
716         REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

  Lieutenants Chittenden and Taylor, Corps of Engineers, determined the error of
the Lukens by astronomical observations taken on the night preceding and on the
night following the explosion. The Buff and Berger transit (focal length 39 inches,
clear aperture 3 inches) and the Hipp chronoraph were used.

                                                   Time results.


                                                                                    October 9.        October 10.


Number of time stars--..--....-----....     --.-----..
                                                  .....------.... -...--..
                                                                      .....
                                                                        ..............--        6               7
Value of c............................................................ .....               + 1.55           +1.54
Value of a...........................................................      ...             -0.33              0.19
                                                                                                            ---
Lukens slow, seconds.....................................................I                  60. 38           61.32
At sidereal time, hours.............................            ..........   ....           20. 76           20. 61



  The comparisons of Lukens with Negus were made by ear, direct, and also through
a third chronometer as a check.
  The following were the last comparison before and the first one after the explosion :
                                                                                                    Sidereal time.
October 9, Negus fast of Lukens, 28.2 seconds at ........ -...                    17h. 43m.
                                                                               .---..
October 10, Negus fast of Lukens, 31.5 seconds at...... ...........        ..... 15h. 45m.
   The interval between the explosion and the last comparison was about three hours-
   In transporting the Negus, the usual precautions were taken to avoid as far as
practicable a disturbance of rate. Comparisons before and subsequent to the explo-
sion show that its rate was not sensibly affected by its transportation.
   The key record of explosion was at 12h. 35m. 54.8s. Negus chronometer time.
From the foregoing data we have the following computed results:
   Rate of Lukens, October 9-10; 0.039 second per hour, losing.
   Rate of Negus on Lukens, October 9-10; 0.150 second per hour, gaining
   Lukens time of explosion, 12h 35m 23.88, October 10.
   Mean solar time of explosion, 75th meridian, 11h. 13m. 50.2 S, October 10.
   In this last result, the longitude of Willets Point enters with full weight ; that used
was 4h. 55m . 07.668. west from Greenwich.
   About one hour after the explosion Professor Waldo, of Yale, kindly furnished me
with the following comparisons taken by him between his watch and our Negus No.
1499.
   The watch indicated 75th meridian mean time, and the Professor writes: " I assume
that my watch's error was not over one second."
                                          hegus 1499.              Watch.
                                                        .           m          s.
                                          13hj48m 46.58 =   12 46       30.0
                             13h 49m 16.58.-- 12 27m 00.0s.
  From the above comparisons may be deduced llh. 13m. 5038 as the 75th meridian
mean time of explosior.; thus giving an interesting and independent check on the re-
sult previously deduced from our own direct observations.



                               E.-PHOTOGRAPIIS TAKEN AT ASTORIA.

                          [Report of First Lieut. J. L. Lusk, Corps of Engineers.]

   I have the honor to submit the following report upon the work of the photographic
laboratory in connection with the explosion of Flood Rock on October 10, 1885.
   At the time orders were received to prepare to take views of the explosion there
were in the laboratory only two cameras suitable for that purpose. Two others were
kindly loaned; one by E. & H. T. Anthony & Co., the other by Mr. Jacob Wieners,
jr., of College Point, Long Island.
   Three of the available cameras were fitted with light drop shutters, each supported
by a thread attached to a fuze. The fuze was so placed in an electrical circuit that
the closing of a key would explode it and thus break the thread and drop the shutter.
The fourth camera was fitted with a Prosch shutter, arranged to expose the plate on
the pulling of a delicate trigger.
   On reaching Astoria on the morning of the explosion a reconnoissance was made
to determine whether or not a better point of view could be found than the one pro-
visionally adopted: i. e., the firing point. The latter presented an unobstructed view
         APPENDIX E--REPORT             OF LIEUT.-COL. MCFARLAND.                 717

of the area to be photographed, and allowed the use of short and easily protected
electrical circuits. Its sole disadvantage lay in its nearness to Flood Rock, which, it
was known, would render it impossible to catch a view of both ends of the disturbed
water on one plate. The only other practicable position at Astoria was on a roof, of
the use of which I had the refusal, where the vibration due to the explosion would
probably have interfered with the action of the shutters. The firing point was accord-
ingly adopted; and in order to best show the progress of the explosion, the cameras
were so placed and adjusted that each plate would show the northeast end of the
disturbed area. The four instruments were placed in line about 1,130 feet from the
tall hoisting-frame on Flood Rock, and each was focused on the frame.
  Numbering the cameras in order from left to right, the fuze of No. 1 was so con-
nected with the firing circuit of the mine as to be exploded by the same key and the
same action of closing, a short delay being effected (1) by causing the moving part of
the key to traverse a slightly greater arc in closing the camera circuit than in com-
pleting that to the mine; and (2) by the interposition of a relay. Nos. 2 and 3 were
arranged to be fired at will by an independent key, the time of making and breaking
each circuit being recorded on a chronograph register, as was the case with No. 1.
No. 4 was not connected with the chronograph. Nos. 1, 3, and 4 gave satisfactory
views of the explosion; while the plate in No. 2 was not exposed, due to some irregu-
larity in the explosion of the fuze, which blew the thread violently forward and
jammed it in a crevice of the shutter-case.
  Exposure No. 1, made at about 0.2 seconds after the closing of the mine circuit,
shows that the camera itself was steady at that instant, but that the earth wave had
reached a point not more than 175 feet distant. Exposure No. 3, at 0.6 seconds after
closing the mine circuit, shows that the camera was steady and that the more violent
portion of the earth wave had passed. Exposure No. 4 shows the hoisting-frame lifted
about 30 feet into the air, and the tallest jet with a height of 160 feet. There was a
marked increase in the height of the jets after the exposure of No. 4, the last avail-
able plate.
  As soon as practicable after the explosion the absolute lengths of the exposures
were measured by Professor Pickering's method of photographing a freely falling sil-
vered ball. The results are:
                                 For No. 1, 0.034 seconds.
                                 For No. 3, 0.05 seconds.
                                 For No. 4, 0.02 seconds.
  A comparison of the views taken with one obtained by Lieut. John Millis, Corps of
Engineers, from the top of the electric-light tower at Hell Gate, indicates that most
of the talljets rose in a fringe closely surrounding the unsubmerged part of the rock,
and extending out not farther than the 12-foot contour, as shown on the map con-
tained in the report of the Chief of Engineers for 1882.
   It is a matter of regret that the stock of cameras fitted for work of the kind under
consideration was so limited as to prevent the securing of at least six views of the
water in motion.
  Other views were taken showing the appearance of Flood Rock before and after the
mine was fired; the best of these, with the three views of the explosion, constitute a
set of five negatives, prints from which have been submitted to the Battalion com-
mander.



                                         E   6.

             IMPROVEMENT OF NEWTOWN CREEK, NEW YORK,

   Newtown Creek is a sluggish stream, about 4 miles long, running
through the eastern part of Brooklyn and emptying into the East River
opposite Thirty-fourth street, New York.
  In 1857 it had a depth of about 17 feet, which had decreased in 1880
to about 121 feet at low water, from its mouth up to the Vernon Avenue
Bridge, a distance of 1,100 feet, its width for this distance being about
240 feet. Thence it gradually decreased in width and depth, until at
the head of navigation, where Metropolitan avenue crosses it, there was
a low-water depth of about 4 feet and a width of about 100 feet.
  A survey of this creek with a view to its improvement was ordered
by act of Congress approved March 3, 1879, and was made under Gen-
718           REPORT OF THE CHIEF                         OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

eral Newton's direction, and reported upon by him January 31, 1880*
The project which he presented provided for dredging a channel from
the mouth of the creek to Vernon Avenue Bridge, 200 feet wide and from
18 to 21 feet deep at low water, requiring the removal of 145,000 cubic
yards of material chiefly mud, the cost of which was estimated at $36,250.
  Work under this project was begun in 1880, but by reason of in-
increased cost of dredging, the estimated cost was increased to $44,050.
   Under act of Congress passed August 2, 1852, another survey was
made under direction of Major Gillespie, whose report is dated Decem-
ber 26, 18,3. His project provided for carrying the improvement from
the Vernon Avenue Bridge up to the head of navigation in both
branches of the creek. The estimated cost for executing this project
was as follows:
To excavate a channel 18 feet deep and 175 feet wide, from Vernon Avenue
  Bridge to the Central Oil Works, 143,500 cubic yards excavation, at 30
  cents .......................................                                                                            $43,050
Thence, 15 feet deep and from 125 to 150 feet wide, to Queens County Oil
  Works, 101,600 cubic yards excavation, at 35 cents ...--..... ..... ......                                                35, 560
Thence, 12 feet deep and from 125 to 150 feet wide, to Nichols Chemical
  Works, 52,600 cubic yards excavation, at 40 cents......           ................                                        21, 040
Thence, 10 feet deep and from 100 to 125 feet wide, to the heads of naviga-
  tion on both branches, 231,600 cubic yards excavation, at 40 cents.....                                            ...    92, 640
Contingencies .----...........--                  -........---..   ..........   ..............------..   ....-....          19, 229

                                                                                                                           211, 519
To which must be added the revised estimate for work,below Vernon Avenue
  Bridge, before given.........---......------......-----......-----......-----..........---..........                      44, 050

         Total estimated cost of improving Newtown Creek..................                                                 255, 569
   Up to June 30, 1986, $45,000 of this amount had been appropriated;
and, with it, the channel below the Vernon Avenue Bridge had been
given a depth of 18 feet, with a width varying from 75 feet at the
bridge to 150 feet at the mouth of the creek ; and channels 10 feet deep
and from 50 to 200 feet in width had been dredged from Covert's Dock
up to the bridge at Metropolitan avenue and Grand street on the west
branch, and to Grand Street Bridge on the east branch, the distances
being about 3,000 and 1,000 feet, respectively.
   The act of Congress approved August 5, 1886, appropriated $37,500
for the improvement, but directed that $9,375 should be expended on
the west branch between Maspeth avenue (Covert's Dock) and what is
called the Dual Bridge, at Grand street and Metropolitan avenue; $9,375
on the main branch between easterly Grand Street Bridge and Metro-
politan avenue; and the balance on the lower end from Maspeth avenue
to the mouth.
   The two former amounts will be applied as directed, and the remain-
der of this appropriation, as well as the remainder of the appropriation
of August 5, 1884, will be applied to widening the channel below Ver-
non Avenue Bridge, to widening and straightening the approaches to
the Penny Bridge, where very awkward bends occur; and, finally, to
beginning the improvement up stream from Vernon Avenue Bridge.
   The rise and fall of tide in the creek is about 4.5 feet, but the bed of
the creek has no natural slope. It is the receptacle for all the refuse
from the sewers, factories, refineries, and slaughter houses of the east
of Brooklyn. Constant deposits are, therefore, forming in it, especially
at the upper end, from these causes and from the caving-in of the un-
protected banks, which consist of marsh mud.
  To remedy this difficulty annual dredging will be required until the
banks are protected by bulkheads throughout their whole length.
                APPENDIX                    E--REPORT                   OF LIEUT.-COL. McFARLAND.                                                    719
   The commerce of the creek is so large that this improvement should
be pushed at least 3 miles up as soon as possible; and $100,000 can be
well applied there in the next fiscal year.
   No statement of commerce has been received for this fiscal year;
from the bridge tender's statement, the daily average of times the draw
is opened is about the same number as last year, 130.
   Many of the ships going above the bridge could load to a draught of
from 20 to 23 feet; but they can take on only a part of their load tsay
to 16 feet draught) in the creek, and then finish it at the wharves in deep-
er water in the East River.

                                                       AMOUNTS APPROPRIATED.


      Date.                                                             Application.                                                               Amount.

June 14, 1880 Dredging below Vernon Avenue Bridge -----..--........                                                 .......................         $10, 000
Aug. 2,1882 ......      do.   ...............        ...........       .........           ..................................                        15,000
July 5, 1884 Part applied above Vernon Avenue Bridge.......                                               ...............................            20, 000
Aug. 5, 1886 ..........     .    ...................             ..............................                                ............          37, 500
                               Total .. ......
                                            .                . . ..........          ........ .                     ...   ....       ...   ...       82, 500

   Amount expended to end of year ending June 30, 1886, $38,690.47.




                                                       COMMERCIAL STATISTICS.

  No statement of the commerce of Newtown Creek has been received for the fiscal
year ending June 30, 1886, but a complete statement may be found in the Annual Re-
port of the Chief of Engineers for 1884, part I, Page 727.
  This work is in the collection district of New York. Nearest port of entry, New
York City; nearest light-house, Blackwell's Island Light; nearest fort, Fort Colum-
bus.
  Amount of revenue collected at the port of New York during the fiscal year ending
June 30, 1886, $132,536,402.02.

                                                            ORIGINAL ESTIMATE.

For dredging from mouth of creek to head of navigation...............                                                                             $236,340
Contingencies ....                    ......
                                        .                   .....        ....      .......      .................                .......            19,229

           Total-..................                       .......          .....        .....    .... ....            ... ..      ........-        255, 569




                                                            Money statement.
July 1, 1885, amount available              ...--.        .--..........                  .... $7, 419 96
                                                                                      ".......
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885 ................        ..............       .............          1, 110 43
July 1, 1886, amount available ....                                 ....................                                   ......           .     6, 309 53
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886 ..................                                                                            37,500 00

Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887..                                                        .............                     43 809 53

  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project........ 173,069 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1888 100, 000 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
 ( harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
720     REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.


                                   E 7.

        IMPROVEMENT OF BUTTERMILK CHANNEL, NEW YORK.

   Governor's Island lies opposite the Battery at New York, in the mouth
of the East River, at its junction with the harbor. The channel on the
north side of the island is the widest and deepest, and may be called
the main channel. The channel between Governor's island and the
city of Brooklyn is known as Buttermilk Channel.
    This channel is obstructed by three shoals.
    1. A mid-channel shoal, lying above and northeasterly of Governor's
Island, which originally had a least depth of 91 feet over it at mean low
water.
   2. A shoal putting out from Red Hook Point, and extending up the
eastern side of the channel to the entrance of the Atlantic Basin, with
a least depth of about 5 feet over it at mean low water.
    3. A shoal putting out from the southern side of Governor's Island
towards the Red Hook Shoal, which is partly dry at mean low water.
    A crooked channel about 700 feet wide and 30 feet deep lies between
the two latter shoals.
    Between the first-mentioned shoal and Governor's Island to the west
of it is a narrow channel with 26 feet water in it, and between this shoal
and Brooklyn, east of it, there was originally a narrow channel of the
same depth, widened now to about 900 feet.
   The line of docks and wharves from the Brooklyn Bridge down to
the mouth of the Atlantic Basin, on the Brooklyn side, is one of the
most important in New York Harbor; and this part of the river, ex-
tending from the Brooklyn Bridge to Governor's Island, is regarded by
pilots and masters of vessels as the most difficult place in New York
waters to carry a vessel through safely, not excepting Hell Gate in its
present condition, on account of the enormous traffic passing not only up
and down, but across the stream.
   Tows, tugs, small steamers, and small craft generally, in passing up
and down this part of the East River, hug the New York side, forcing
the larger class of Sound steamers, ocean steamers, and sea-going ships
in tow of tugs, to keep over towards the shoal at the upper point of
Governor's Island; and if, as is often the case, these large vessels are
obliged to stop in order to avoid collision with ferry-boats, sloops, and
canal-boat tows, they are liable to drift upon this shoal.
   Based upon the representation of shipping merchants whose business
lay along the Brooklyn wharves lying between Wall Street Ferry and
the Atlantic Basin, a survey of this shoal was ordered in 1872, and a
project for its improvement was adopted in 1880.
   This provided for the removal, to a depth of 26 feet at mean low water,
of such parts of the eastern side of the shoal as came within 850 feet
of the Brooklyn wharves.
   A brief history of this improvement, with a sketch, will be found in
the Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1885, Part I, page 670.
   The estimated cost of this improvement was $140,000, which provided
for the removal of 570,000 cubic yards of material, at the rate of 23
cents per cubic yard, with 12 per cent. for contingencies.
   The first appropriation for this work was made June 14, 1880, since
which time other appropriations have been made and the work has been
carried on up to November 3, 1884, during which time 466,276 cubic
yards of material have been removed; but owing to the distance from
the place of excavation to the place where the dredged-material had to
              APPENDIX E-REPORT                                    OF LIEUT.-COL. McFARLAND.                                             721
be dumped, which is outside of Sandy Hook, a distance of about 20
miles, the prices bid for the work have been more than 50 per cent.
greater than had been anticipated, and the estimated cost of the im-
provement had to be increased, therefore, to $210,000, of which $190,000
had been appropriated up to June 30, 1886.
   With this amount the channel has been deepened certainly to 24 feet,
and it is believed to a full depth of 26 feet, at mean low water, though
this has not yet been determined by actual survey over the proposed
width of 850 feet, which includes the original crest of the shoal, so that
outside of the lines of dredging there should be no less depth than 17
feet at mean low water. But the last survey, made in June, 1884,
showed that a material shoaling had taken place on parts of the un-
dredged portions of the shoal since the first work was done, amounting
at that time to about 37,000 cubic yards which reduced the depths on
the shoal outside of the line of dredging to 13 feet at mean low water,
instead of 17, as it should have been.
   This shoaling is probably due to the fact that the city authorities
have a scow anchored on the shoal, to which tugs, steam-lighters, and
small steamers transfer their ashes, and during this transfer a part of
the ashes falls overboard between the steamboat and the scow.
   The recommendation was made in my last annual report that the
width of this channel should be increased from 850 to 1,150 feet, unless,
indeed, it was decided to remove the whole shoal to a depth of 26 feet;
and $50,000 was recommended for beginning the further widening of
the channel.
   When the last detailed survey of this shoal was made in June, 1884,
it appeared that the excavation of about 336,057 cubic yards of material
would be required for the removal of the whole shoal, of which 30,097
cubic yards have since been taken out under a contract made in 1884.
This would leave 305,960 cubic yards yet to be taken out, which at 50
cents per cubic yard would cost about $150,000 without contingencies.
   In view, however, of the shoaling which has occurred here during
the piogress of the work, judging from the experiences from 1880 to
1884, it is advisable to increase this estimate by $20,000, making a total
of $170,000 required for the removal of the whole shoal.
   The large and increasing traffic of this part of the river certainly war-
rants the removal of the whole shoal.
   The appropriation of $56,250 made by act of Congress approved Au-
gust 5, 1886, will be applied to the removal of the shoal by dredging,
and $50,000 is asked for continuing the improvement next year.
   A statement of the commerce of Buttermilk Channel may be found
in the Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1884, Part I, page
703, but it does not give any idea of the passing traffic of this channel,
   Appropriations for the improvement of Buttermilk Channel, New
York, have been made as fillows :

   Date.                                                       Application.                                                      Amount.


June   14, 1880 Dredging ....-...................                    .............                  ....... ..................-                          $60,000 00
Mar.    3,1881--.....do ...----....---............-------------     ..---.-----.......------------...................---------                            60, 000 0
Aug.    2,1882 ..--...do .--..........---..........---------------------------------------................                                                60, 000 00
July    5,1884   .... do .....----......----------------------------------------------                                                                    10, 000 00
Aug.    5,1.886 ..... do ....----.-----.----...      -........---.....---------.....----....---..----....---....--------------------....................  56,250 00

                       Total---....-.........     .............................
                                             ........                                ... . .......                                 246,250 00
                     Amount expended .......-...   ..--.......-..-....-...-......-..--............                                 189, 775 03

            46 E
722            REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

  This work is in the collection district of New York. The nearest port of entry is
New York City, and the nearest work of defense, Fort Columbus, New York Harbor.
  Amouit of revenue collected at the port of New York during the fiscal year ending
June 30, 1886, $132,536,402.02.
                                                   Money statement.
July 1, 1885, amount available                     ---..--.........----.......              ....                .........            $324 97

July 1, 1886, amount available .----...........-----...------.... .....---------..........---.....-----                               324 97
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886. ...............                                                               56,250 00

Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887.... ..... ......                                                  ....      56, 574 97

   Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project......
   Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1-88
                                                                                                                                 11:,50, 000 00
                                                                                                                                      750 00

   Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
     harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.




                                                              E 8.

                          IMPROVEMENT OF GOWANUS BAY, NEW YORK.

   Gowanus Bay, which is a part of New York Harbor, lies at the mouth
of Gowanus Creek, on the southwestern side of the city of Brooklyn.
The depth of water in the channel of Gowanus Bay and Creek was
originally only from. 7 to 12 feet at mean low water, which was wholly in-
sufficient for the wants of vessels employed in the commerce of the dis-
trict. A survey of it was made in 1880, and a project for its improve-
ment was submitted in January, 1881.
   This was, briefly, to dredge a channel between the pier lines estab-
lished by the commissioners appointed by the State of New York in 1875,
from the bay up the creek to Hamilton Avenue Bridge, 18 feet deep at
mean low water, with a width of 200 feet, except for the upper few hun-
dred feet, near the bridge, where the width was to be gradually reduced
from 200 feet to 100 feet. The total length of the proposed channel was
about 9,000 feet. The estimate for the improvement was:
530,000 cubic yards of dredging, at 30 cents per cubic yard..........                              ------------....              159, 000 00
Contingencies ....--------...--..---......--........-------.---.......--.-- ------..................---.                          23,850 00

         Total---..--..............---..--------          --.....---......   -------......----------......--......------......   182,850 00
  This proposed channel, however, did not coincide with the natural
channel at the mouth of the creek, for the pier line established by the
commission crossed the natural channel at that point, and the land under
water inside ot it had become private property.
  The owners of this property, Messrs. Beard & Robinson, were anx-
ious, nevertheless, to have the natural channel improved, instead of
having the new one formed outside of the established pier line; but as
this could not be done unless they surrendered their right to build out to
the pier line, they signed a paper relinquishing their right to build out
piers which should interfere with the channel so long as that channel
should exist: and the Maritime Association of New York at the same
time petitioned that the old channel should be kept open. As improv-
ing this channel alone would not, however, help the wharves on the op-
posite or southerly side of the creek, General Newton recommended
that the natural channel should be dredged from the Hamilton Avenue
Bridge down to the southwest corner of the Erie Basin; and that from
that point two channels should be dredged, one running northerly along
           APPENDIX         E-REPORT            OF    LIEUT.-COL.    MCFARLAND.         723

the west side of the Erie Basin to deep water near Red Hook; and the
other, running southerly along the wharves on the south side of the
bay, towards Bay Ridge.
  Both of these channels were to be 200 feet wide and 18 feet deep at
mean low water. This project required for its execution a larger amount
of work than the original scheme called for, namely :
The excavation of 583,530 cubic yards of material, which at 30 cents per
  cubic yard, would cost .....--..--..
                              ----.. --..                        $175, 059 00
                                                     ..---...--....-------....
                                       .----------..........--....---
Contingencies, 10 per cent .......... .---..---....--..-..----.   -.........--
                                                                           ......   17, 505 90

       Total ......------------........------
                                      ......---......----......  ----...... 192, 564 90
                                                       ----..........----....
   The legal measures necessary for securing the right of way across
Beard & Robinson's property, at the mouth of the creek, were not
completed satisfactorily until May, 1883, and therefore no work was
done across the ground in question, although a channel 100 feet wide
had been dredged up to this point from Red Hook and up the creek for
about 2,000 feet, and the southern channel running towards Bay Ridge
had been begun.
   No appropriation for this work has been made since that of July 5,
1884, and no work has been done upon it since December 20, 1884. At
that time the condition of the channels was as follows:
   What may be called the Red Hook Channel, running around the Erie
Basin to the mouth of the creek, had been completed for its full width
and depth, and the channel of the creek had been widened to 200 feet
and had been carried about half way up the creek to a point 2,100 feet
below the Hamilton Avenue Bridge. What may be termed the Bay
Ridge Channel, lying south of the mouth of the creek, had been begun
at its outer or southern end and had been carried up with full depth and
width to a point 2,000 feet south of the mouth of the creek.
   The following work yet remains to be done under the ofiginal project:
The completion of the channel up the creek 2,100 feet to Hamilton Ave-
nue Bridge, and the extension of the Southern or Bay Ridge Channel
up 2,000 feet further northward, so as to connect with the Red Hook
Channel at the mouth of the creek.
   A sketch of the condition of this improvement June 30, 1885, may be
found in the Annual Report of Chief of Engineers for 1885, page 672,,
Part I.
   Under the existing estimate of $192,564.90, only $65,000 had been
apropriated up to June 30, 1886.
   The present project ought to be completed. For, apart from the com
merce done up the creek and along the Erie Basin, the channel from Bay
Ridge to Red Hook is serviceable to passing vessels, for it lies in a
bight in which it is stated not only that there is a much longer slack-
water than in the main channel outside of the Red Hook Flats, but also
that, on account of the eddy formed by the bight, the tide in it makes
half an hour earlier than the tide in the main channel, and all tugs and
light-draught vessels take advantage of this (say vessels drawing up to 10
feet at mean low water and 15 feet at high water). So soon as the South
Channel is deepened to 18 feet at low water vessels drawing from 16 to
20 feet will be enabled to pass.
   It is very desirable that enough money be appropriated to complete
this improvement; $50,000 could be profitably expended upon it in the
next iscal year.
  A statement of the commerce will be found, from 1880 to 1884, in the
Annual Report of Chief of Engineers for 1884, Part I, page 707, which
gives a fair statement of the commerce of the district; but it is very
724           REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

difficult to obtain accurate figures, especially as regards the passing
commerce I have called attention to.
   There is a slight shoaling around the southwest corner of the Erie
Basin, which will be further examined and if necessary redredged.

                                                           APPROPRIATIONS.


    Date.                                                          Application.                                                             Amount.


Mar.    30, 1881   Dredging................----------.--------------....--...-......----.......-------..-.......----------------            $40, 000 00
Aug.     2, 1882   .... do ...-----.--....-------..--..------..---..............-----..........------------------..............              20, 000 00
July     5,1884    .... do .......-----..........--...----....------------------------------...-----....--------.........................     5, 000 00
A ug.    5,1886      - do . ..................-............
                   ....                                                                                                                          500 00
                                                                                                                                              7,7..................................
                                                                                                                                              72,500 00

                          Amount expended---------------------------................................-.                                       64, 832 26



  Gowanus Bay is in the collection district of New York City. Nearest light, Robbins
Reef.
Nearest work of defense, the fort on Governor's Island, 1 mile to the northward.
  Amount of revenue collected at the port of New York during fiscal year ending June
30, 1886, $132,536,402.02.
                                                          Money statement.
July 1, 1885, amount available..........................................                                                                     $167 74
                                                                                       ----------
July 1, 1886, amount available ------------------------------......................................   167 74
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886. ..................                              7,500 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887 ...................                                                                   7,667 74

 ( Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project. ........ 120, 064 90
   Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1888 50, 000 00
   Siubmitted in compliance with requirement of section 2 of river and
      harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.



                                                                       E g.

                   IMPROVEMENT OF GEDNEY'S CHANNEL, NEW YORK.

   Gedney's Channel is the main channel across the Ocean Bar, lying at
the entrance to New York harbor, about 3 miles outside of Sandy Hook
and east by north from it. Sandy Hook lies about 9 miles outside of
and nearly south from the Narrows, which is the name given to the
strait separating the nearest points of Long Island and Staten Island,
and the Narrows are about 7 miles south from the Battery at the lower
end of the city of New York. The Narrows are about 1 mile wide.
That part of New York Harbor lying outside of the Narrows is com-
monly known as the Lower Bay.
   From the Narrows northward to New York City there is no water
less than 6 fathoms (36 feet) deep in the main channel.
  The Lower Bay is a large tidal basin, with an area of about 100 square
miles, estimating inside or nothward and westward of a line drawn from
Sandy Hook to Coney Island.
  The western end of the bay formed by Sandy Hook, the adjacent
Jersey shore, and Staten Island, is known as Raritan Bay, and the
southern part of it inside of the peninsula of Sandy Hook is known as
Sandy Hook Bay, or more commonly as the Horseshoe.
       APPENDIX     E--REPORT     OF LIEUT.-COL.    MCFARLAND.      725

   From the northeast around by the east to south-southeast, the Lower
Bay is open to the full sweep of the Atlantic Ocean.
  From the Narrows to the northern point of Sandy Hook is about 9
miles ; but the shortest distance across the bay, from the point of Sandy '
Hook to Coney Island, is 7 miles. The water cross-section on this line
at mean low water is about 790,000 square feet, through which the mean
velocity is stated to be 1.6 feet per second; but the maximum velocities
are approximately stated to be twice as great (Board of Engineers'
Report for 1884).
   At the Narrows the channel is about 1 mile wide and 70 feet deep,
with depths in it of over 100 feet.
   Below the Narrows there is one main channel, commonly known as
the Main Ship Channel, running southward to a point about 1 mile west
of the upper end of Sandy Hook; thence turning at right angles north-
ward and eastward for four miles to the head of Gedney's Channel; and
thence through Gedney's Channel east to the deep waters of the ocean.
   But along and inside the above mentioned cross-section of 7 miles
between Sandy Hook and Coney Island there is a bar with five distinct
channels running through it seaward and eastward, of varying depths.
   They lie in the following order, beginning at the northward:
   1. The Coney Island Channel.-In which the navigable depth at mean
low water is 10 feet.
   2. The Fourteen-FootChannel.-In which the navigable depth at mean
low water is 15 feet.
   3. The East Channel.-In which the navigable depth of water is 19 feet.
   4. The Swash Channel.- Through which 23 feet can be carried at mean
low water in a narrow channel, but in which are two lumps over which
there is a depth of only 21.9 feet.
   5. The Main Ship- Channel.-In which 24 feet can be carried through
channels with lumps in them, with depths of 23.3 feet over them at
mean low water.
   These five channels are separated by shoals with from 4 to 18 feet of
water upon them at mean low water.
   The first three of these channels head directly out into the open sea;
but the two latter converge into an area of about 2 miles square, lying
north and east of Sandy Hook, which has a depth in it of 30 feet of
water, and over, and from this deep area, seaward and eastward of it,
two channels lead out into the open sea over the outer bar, the northern-
most known as Gedney's, the southernmost as the South Channel, both
of which have about 24 feet in them at mean low water.
   Gedney's Channel is the widest and straightest of the two, and is
therefore used by all the large vessels.
   The Swash Channel is really a cut-off from the Main Ship-Channel,
leaving it about 6 miles below the Narrows, and joining it again at the
western end of Gedney's Channel.
   Apart from being shoaler, the Swash is much narrower than the Main
Ship-Channel.
   The distance from the Battery, at New York, to30-foot soundings out-
side the bar in Gedney's Channel is 22 miles; and by the Swash it is 18
miles or from the Narrows 15 and 11 miles respectively.
   The Main Ship-Channel has a depth of 30 feet at mean low water
through its entire length, with these exceptions, namely :
   (1) At a point 8 miles below the Narrows, commonly known as the
Knolls, where the channel passes between Flynn's Knoll on the east,
and a corresponding lump or knoll on the west; here there is a shoal
about 2 miles long between the 30-foot contours and 2,000 feet long be-
726          REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

tween the 24-foot contours, with a minimum depth upon it of 23.3 feet
at mean low water. On either side of the crest of this shoal is a narrow
crooked channel with over 24 feet of water in it; but neither is wide
enough for the deepest draught vessels to work through.
   (2) The second point at which there is less than 30 feet of water is in
Gedney's Channel and in the western approach to it from the Main Ship-
Channel.
   In Gedney's Channel proper, this spring, there was a bar 4,500 feet
long between the 30-foot contours, with a minimum depth on it at
mean low water of 23.8 feet for a width of 800 feet on the north side,
and a minimum depth of 21.9 feet for 200 feet south of this. This has
since been deepened by dredging.
   The western approach to Gedney's Channel from the Main Ship-
Channel has also a less depth than 30 feet, being obstructed by a bar
2,000 feet long, with a depth on it of about 28 feet.
   A comparison of the survey made by Major G. L. Gillespie, Corps of
Engineers, in 1884 (see Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for
1885, pages 776 to 785), with those previously made, shows that the
changes which have occurred in the channels since 1835 have been
very slight.
   The 24-foot curves of the Main, Swash, East, and Fourteen-Foot chan-
nels have all moved slightly westward and southward, but still em-
brace about the same areas of shoals.
   But while, in 1635, bars with less than 24 feet on them extended com-
pletely across Gedney's, the Main Ship, and the Swash channels, these
bars, at the time-of Colonel Gillespie's survey in 1884 had nearly dis-
appeared, leaving in each case only spots where there was less than
24 feet of water.
   For fifty years, then, it will be seen that the natural tidal scour,
which is strong enough at the Narrows to maintain a channel a mile
wide, with depths of 100 feet in it, has been only able below the Nar-
rows to maintain a 30-foot channel, with two spots in it where there is
24 feet depth.
   From current observations, taken, by Colonel Gillespie in 1884, it ap-
pears that a good deal of the ebb volume from the Narrows passes to
the northward of the south side of the Swash Channel, and that a large
part of the Raritan Bay ebb volume passes between the south side of
the Knolls and Sandy Hook, leaving a wedge-shaped area at their junc.
tion near the Knolls, over which the rate of current is reduced about
one-half, and where a part of the current passes directly across the
channel instead of along its axis.
   This is also true of the flood tide; on the flood there is the same dimi-
nution of rate across this area, and a part of the tide crosses the chan-
nel at right angles. Some of the velocities observed by Colonel Gilles-
pie in 1884 in these channels are as follows:

                                                                                             Maximum        Maximum
                                     Localities.                                             ebb (miles    flood (miles
                                                                                             per hour).     per hour.)


In the Swash Channel, abreast of the Romer Beacon .--......................                       1.60              1.21
In Main Ship-Channel on the Knolls.---....................................                         0. 80             0. 65
Close off the point of Sandy Hook, and due north of it .. - ---.....             -
                                                                           ....- ... .. -.         2. 22    1. 70 to 1. 20
In the deep hole haltf-way between Sandy Hook and Gedney's........----..--.                        2.00              1.50
In Gedney's Channel ...-------------------------------------------------                           1.60              1.30


  Both in the Swash and in Gedney's Channel the ebb current is nearly
parallel with the axis of the channels, and from the measurements so
              AFPENDIX               E-REPORT                  OF LIEUT.-COL. MCFARLAND.                                      727

far taken the relative ebb velocities in both channels appear to be the
same, but the flood in Gedney's Channel appears to exceed that of the
Swash Channel by 0.09 miles per hour.
   In the spring of 1872, Brig. Gen. (then Lieut. Col.) John Newton,
Corps of Engineers, had a series of current observations taken in the
Lower Bay, with the following results:

                                                                                                               Surface      Bottom
                                                  Place.                                                      velocity, velocity,
                                                                                                               in miles in miles
                                                                                                              per hour. per hour.


Fourteen-foot Channel.....---.--..----------..-..---......---..............-------------...---...--.-------.......  2. 20      0.40
East Channel-------..-------..-..-----.........----...-.....---.........--------..-....--....--..-----------------1.65         0.90
Swash Channel ...---............----- ....      ..--      --.. ..-........                  --..
                                                                                    --.. .......-..........    ...  2.00       0.40
Main Channel ....------        ......                .......------------------------------------...                 2. 40      0. 80
Close to and due north of the point of Sandy Hook ...............                                        .....    .


   These observations were stated to have been taken at the maximum
velocity of the ebb tide, but no observations were taken either at the
Knolls or in Gedney's Channel.
   The current velocities given by the Coast Survey charts are, for
the channels over the outer bar: Flood, 1.4; ebb, 2.2 miles per hour.
Main Ship-Channel: Flood, 1.1; ebb, 2 miles per hour. The rates re-
sulting from these three sets of observations differ so much that it is
evident that there must have been some local or temporary conditions
affecting them, and they do not therefore furnish the means of making
an accurate or even an approximate estimate of the amount of tidal
flow in and out of the harbor, or even of the direction of its motion.
   The agencies tending to diminish the navigable depths through the
channels of the Lower Bay of New York are, briefly-
   (1) The movement of sand westward along the south shore of Long
Island, and northward along the outer shore of New Jersey and Sandy
Hook.
   (2) Wave action, which picks up the material from the shoals and
deposits it in deeper water, when the wave action itself is lost.
   (3) Sediment, in the drainage water from the land.
   (4) The deposit of dredged material or garbage.
   But in view of the fact that during fifty years there has been a ten-
dency in the channels to deepen rather than to shoal, these agencies
seem to have been arrested or counteracted by the natural scour.
   Gedney's Channel is 24 miles from Sandy Hook Beach and 44 from
Long Island.
   The ebb current through it is almost exactly parallel with the axis of
the channel, but the flood appears to have a more northerly direction.
   The material composing the bottom is large, coarse sand and gravel,
like that on the Sandy Hook Beach; while that on the Coney Island
Beach is fine sand.
   There are no shoals outside of Gedney's Channel, and the heaviest
wave action comes from the direction of the ocean.
   As yet no trace of sediment that looks like that of lanud drainage has
been found in Gedney's Channel, although it is found in the deep hole
directly inside and west of it.
   The dredging in Gedney's Channel since February has failed to show
any trace of dumped material or garbage.
   New York Harbor has two dumping places designated by and con-
trolled by the State of New York; one in the Sound, and one about 2
miles north-northeast of the outer end of Gedney's Channel, and about
3 miles south of Fire Island Inlet, on the Long Island Beach.
728     REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

   The observation of the assistant engineer and inspectors employed
upon Gedney's Channel since February of this year shows that at least
90 per cent. of the dredged material coming through the Narrows in
the dump-scows from New York Harbor is taken out through the three
channels north of the Swash; and this for the simple reason that it is
from 4 to 6 miles shorter through these channels to the dumping point
than by the Swash. Once in a while, in a heavy cross wind, and
against a tide, a tow of dump-scows is unable to keep to the north of
the Romer Shoal, and has to come down the Swash; but, then, after
passing the Romer they head up again northward of Gedney's Channel
to the dumping-ground.
   So it may be said that the only two shoal places in the Main Channel
leading out of New York by way of Sandy Hook which are in the Main
Ship Channel at the Knolls and in Gedney's Channel, respectively, never
have a dump-scow pass over them.
   In the case of being caught in a storm, and having to dump " short,"
or doing so to save time, which undoubtedly occurs at times, this would
be done to the northward of the Main Ship, Gedney's, and the Swash
channels.
   It seems to be the general opinion that most of the illegal dumping
is done at night above the Narrows, generally on or along the edge of
the Red Hook and Comunnipaw flats.
   The above are briefly the chief physical characteristics of the Lower
Bay of New York.
   The largest steamships running out of New York at present draw
28 feet loaded, but few load down to this depth.
   Major Gillespie, in 1884, reported that the deepest-draught vessel that
had ever entered New York Harbor was the Spanish frigate Numancia,
which drew 28 feet 8 inches, but that she had to wait for a spying tide
to cross the bar.
   The minimum depth of water in the Main Ship Channel at mean low
water in February, 1886, was 23.3 feet, to which must be added 4.8 feet
for mean rise of tide, which would give a minimum depth of 28.1 feet at
mean high water, or only one-tenth of a foot more than the draught of
the largest ocean steamers at present.
   Slack water at Sandy Hook averages about 40 minutes, so that the
vessels of deep draught have only 40 minutes in which to cross the bar
in Gedney's Channel, and to pass the Knolls, 7 miles above it.
   It is common to see vessels passing over the bar with a wake 500 to
1,000 feet long behind them of material churned up from the bottom by
their propeller blades. A vessel too close to the bottom will not steer
either, but sheers from side to side, and is liable to run out of the best
water. This occurred with the Aurania in April of this year when com-
ing in. While making the turn at the Knolls she took a sheer, and the
anchor had to be dropped in order to prevent her from running aground.
Heince the story arose that she had run aground. Thirty feet at mean
low water appears to be the depth which is required to cnable the largest
ocean steamships to come in with 2 feet to spare below their boctoms.
   Up to July 5, 1884, no money had ever been appropriated for the im-
provement of the Lower Bay and its channels, and no work had been
done. But on that date, without any preliminary examination, survey,
or report, an appropriation of $200,000 was made by Congress for
"deepening Gedney's Channel, New York Harbor."
Maj. G. L. Gillespie, Corps of Engineers, then in charge of the New
York Harbor improvement, by direction of the Chief of Engineers, im-
mediately began an extended survey of the Lower Bay and its channels,
            APPENDIX            E-REPORT                OF LIEUT.-COL.                      MCFARLAND.                  729
which was completed during the autumn of 1884; and on December 6,
1884, he made a formal report to the Chief of Engineers, with accom-
panying maps and plans.
   The report is published in the Annual Report of the Chief of Engi-
neers for 1885, Part I, pages 775 to 783.
   The report stated that there had been no shoaling in the channels of
the Lower Bay since 1835. That, on the contrary, the channel depths
has slightly increased, as was also indicated by the Coast Survey charts
of 1881 and 1883.
    The growth of Sandy Hook was explained, showing that between 1752
and 1868 the northern point of the Hook advanced 5,400 feet north-
ward. That from 1868 to 1884 it had "1progressively receded, until it
had reached the position of 1835, with an added western extension of
1,200 feet."
    The recession of the Hook made no appreciable changes in the depths
of the channels near it.
  SBorings to the depth of 3 feet below the bottom were made in the
channels and on the surrounding shoals, and current observations were
made in the Swash Channel, Main Ship-Channel below the head of the
Swash, and in Gedney's Channel.
   Among the maps prepared was a comparative map, showing the 24-
foot curves in 1835, 1855, 1881, and 1884.
   After a description of the channels and the material forming them
Major Gillespie then stated:
   (1) That it had been proven for the last fifty years that the ebb scour
would maintain achannel across the bar between Sandy Hook and Coney
Island from 21 to 23) feet deep at mean low water.
   (2) That the surest way to increase this depth would be to contract
the width of the water-way by means of a low dike extending from near
Coney Island towards Sandy Hook, thereby diverting a part of the ebb
current from the 'more northerly channels across the bar, and directing
it into the main channel, so as to secure an increased scour there; but
as a work of this kind would be very expensive, and as the law relating
to the appropriation specified that the $200,000 should be applied to
"deepening Gedney's Channel," it was deemed inexpedient to attempt
to deepen it in any other way than by dredging; a method which had
proved successful on the sea-bars at the mouth of the Tyne and of other
European rivers.
   In his report he said:
  I do not know that the cut once opened will be self-maintaining, but the present
appropriation being small, it is well enough to experiment with it, and if the experi-
ment is moderately successful the use of large sums for contraction by stone structures
may be avoided, and the annual appropriation for maintenance placed at a low figure.
  Major Gillespie's estimates were as follows:
  For deepening Gedney's Channel and the Main Ship-Channel at the
Knolls to 30 feet at mean low water and making these channels 1,000
feet wide.
                                           I.   GEDNEY'S         CHANNEL.

Excavating a channel 1,000 feet wide, 30 feet deep, at mean low water,
  700,000 cubic yards, at 50 cents--------......--------......         ---......--....---.........--...       --
                                                                                                          ..--------. 350, 000

                                                II.   MAIN CHANNEL.


Excavating a channel 1,000 feet wide and 30 feet deep, at mean low water,
through the Knolls, 1,550,000 cubic yards, at 40 cents.----....----.........                                       620,000
        Total ...................... ........................-
                                                     -......                                              ....      970, 000
730         REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

  But he states that in the above estimate no allowance is made for ir-
regularities of cutting, or for increase of bulk, should the material be
measured in scows, and that this increase would amount to 30 per cent.
for a 30 foot channel.
  Actual experience in dredging from February, 1886, to June 24, 1886,
shows this increase to be roughly as 55 to 40, so that to Major Gilles-
pie's estimate should be added in round numbers $150,000 for Gedney's
Channel, and $250,000 for the Knolls, making the totals-
Gedney's Channel .---------.....------......---......----------
                                             ......------.....-----......-----.....---......--......      $500, 000
The main channel       ....----......---....  --.....   .........      ..        ... - ..- ......          870, 000
        Total......----..------..        ...-----------------------------------
                                                                     .........                ...----..   1,370,000

  This is the amount required at Major Gillespie's estimate of 50 cents
per cubic yard in Gedney's Channel and 40 cents per yard in the Main
Channel.
  From the experience gained in this year's work it is believed that with
the construction of proper plant the work would not cost more than one-
half of these amounts.
  Major Gillespie's report was referred to the Board of Engineers for
Fortifications and for River and Harbor Improvements December 10,
1884, and their report may be found in the Annual Report of the Chief
of Engineers for 1885, Part I, pages 783 to 787.
  After examining the questions involved, they briefly recommended-
  As a general plan for improving the entrance to New York Harbor so as to give 30
feet from New York to the ocean, the construction of a half-tide stone dike running
about south-southeast from Coney Island to such a distance as may be found neces-
sary, and probably not less than four miles; the protection of the head of Sandy
Hook, and the dredging of a 30-foot channel 1,000-feet wide from deep water near
Sandy Hook to deep water below the Narrows, also the immediate drwdging of a chan-
nel 1,000 feet wide and 28 feet deep, through the shoal west of Flynn's Knoll, as soon
as Congress shall furnish the funds. Also, that the existing appropriation be applied
to dredging Gedney's Channel to a depth of 28 feet.
   The total estimated cost of this improvement was from $5,000,000 to
$6,000,000.
   The purpose of the dike, as before stated, is to turn into the main
channel a part of the ebb current which now flows over the neighbor-
ing shoals without reducing the volume of tidal flow in and out of the
harbor. For this reason the dike is at first to be brought up only to
the low-water level, and subsequently, should it become necessary, to
the level of half-tide.
   In order to accomplish the purpose for which it is designed, it is not
necessary, as has been feared in some quarters, that the dike should be
made to close the minor channels through the bar between Coney Island
and Sandy Hook. As stated, however, in the report of the Board of
Engineers, to whom the question was referred, the exact extent of con-
struction necessary for securing the result desired can be determined
only by trial, as was done at the mouth of the Mississippi, and as is
done in all important works of harbor improvement. The report was
approved by the Chief of Engineers; and Major Gillespie was directed
to advertise for deepening Gedney's Channel under the existing appro-
priation.
   The exposed position and frequent storms on the bar, the great depth
of water, and other unfavorable conditions, made it a difficult matter to
decide upon the best mode of deepening Gedney's Channel.
   It was not expected that ordinary clam-shell and dipper dredges could
be used there to advantage, and therefore in drawing up the specifica-
tions for the work provisos were inserted requiring bidders to furnish
        APPENDIX E-REPORT          OF LIEUT.-COL. MCFARLAND.          731
plans and descriptions of the plant they proposed to use, and also a pro-
viso that, if after the plant had been in use a reasonable time, and had
not obtained good results, the contract should be annulled, and the
contractor should be reimbursed a fair amount for his outlay.
   Bids for this work were opened January 15, 1885.
   The lowest bidder was the firm of Morris & Cumings, who proposed
to do the work at 35 cents per cubic yard, with clam-shell dredges and
centrifugal pumps.
   But apart from the fact that the bid of Morris & Cumings was irreg-
ular, there was a bid from Roy Stone, of New York, for deepening the
channel by means of what he termed " hydraulic plowing," a process
which consists in stirring up the material composing the bottom by
means of a strong jet of water thrown against the sandy bottom during
the ebb tide, which the projector thought was strong enough in Ged-
ney's Channel to carry away the material so loosened.
   As Mr. Stone's offer carried with it no obligation of payment on the
part of the Government, unless he should deepen the channel to 28 feet
for a width of 200 feet to begin with, and as it was certain that the ordi-
nary means of dredging could not be successfully used in a place so
much exposed to sea-action as Gedney's Channel is, it was decided to
accept Mr. Stone's bid; but as very little confidence was felt in the
success of this process, though it seemed expedient to give it a trial,
the time for completing his contract was limited to June 1, 1885, and,
if at that time satisfactory results had not been obtained, the contract
was o be annulled without any payment being made to the contractor.
   A contract to this effect was therefore entered into with Mr. Stone,
February 7, 1885, and on the 24th of March work under it was begun.
   From the outset the method was unsuccessful, and after a short time
an induction pipe was substituted for the water jets, which was expected
to draw the material up to the surface of the water and thereby give it
a better chance of being carried off by the current.
   This, however, proved no more successful than the first method, and
on the 14th of May, 1885, Mr. Stone was released from the contract at
his own request. No money was paid him by the Government.
   Major Gillespie immediately wrote to Morris & Cumings to ask if
they wished to enter into a contract under their bid of January, but
they refused, and the work was readvertised May 21, 1885, and propo-
sals were again opened June 23, 1885. An abstract of the bids may be
found in the Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1885, Part I,
page 772.
   The prices of the bids varied from 33 cents to $1.50 per cubic yard.
   Mr. Stone was again the lowest bidder, at 33 cents, but from being un-
able to prove his ability to execute the contract, his bid was thrown out.
   The second lowest bid was that of the Atlantic Dredging Company,
at 47 cents per cubic yard. Their method was not specific; the date of
commencement too remote, and the time for the completion of the con-
tract not given.
   The same may be said of the third lowest bid, that of Michael Mur-
ray, at 53 cents per cubic yard, except that his individual responsibility
did not seem as good as that of the Atlantic Dredging Company. These
two bids were therefore thrown out, and the contract was awarded, with
the approval of the Chief of Engineers, to the next lowest bidder, Elijah
Brainard, at 54 cents per cubic yard.
   Mr. Brainard proposed to put upon the work, within two weeks of
signing the contract, three clam-shell dredges, with a capacity of 4,000
cubic yards per day, and further, to build and put on within three months
732     REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

of the date of opening the bids a hydraulic-pump excavator, with an
estimated capacity of 2,500 yards per day.
    The contract with Mr. Brainard was signed July 25,1885, but as it was
found impracticable to keep a scow alongside of the clam-shell dredges
in the rough water on the bar, it was not thought advisable to attempt
to put them at work. On the 26th of September, 1885, the hydraulic
excavator was ready and began work.
    The following is a brief description of this excavator:
    In the after end of a large dredging dump-scow is placed a centrif-
ugal pump, with an estimated discharge when making 280 revolutions
of 16,000 gallons per minute through a 16-inch pipe.
    An iron suction-pipe 16 inches in diameter and trussed to give it
strength is connected with a universal joint set on the stem of the scow.
From the universal joint the pipe is connected n ith the pump by flexi-
ble india-rubber tubing reinforced with steel springs. This tubing al-
lows for the play of the universal joint during the pitching and rolling
of the boat.
    The suction-pipe, 68 feet long, is raised up from and let down upon
the bottom by falls attached to derrick frames extending over the end
of the scow when resting on the bottom. In 30 feet water it lies at an
angle of about 450, and when triced up it is parallel with the surface
of the water.
    At the lower end of the pipe in an iron frame, 6 feet by 8 feet, and
about 1I feet deep, which prevents the end of the suction-pipe from
touching the bottom. The mouth of the pipe is led into the center of
this frame and is raised about 9 inches above its bottom. The lower
side of this frame is fitted with iron teeth which are supposed to loosen
the material on the bottom. The mouth of the suction is protected by
an iron grating with openings in it 5 inches square.
    From the pump the water and material raised are forced through a
16-inch iron discharge pipe leading over the centers of the pockets or
bins which hold the material; over each pocket there is T pipe leading
downwards, fitted with a flanged door, so that any one pocket can be
filled independently of the rest.
    The scow itself is about 120 feet long, 40 feet wide, and draws from
'11 to 12 feet loaded; its full carrying capacity is 694 cubic yards.
    In going out to or in from the dumping ground the suction-pipe is
disconnected at a socket-hinge a few feet outboard from the universal
joint, and is triced securely to the derrick-frame overhanging the end
of the scow.
    The scow is not self-propelling, but is towed by a powerful steam-tug,
which can make about 8 miles per hour with the scow in favorable
weather with the tide.
    On arriving at the channel the scow is towed up and down it at from
    mile to 2 miles per hour; and when the pockets are filled with solid
material the scow -is towed out to 90 feet water, in the vicinity of Sandy
Hook lightship, and the material dumped through center doors in the
bottoms of the bins.
    It was expected by the contractor that this machine would raise from
10 to 20 per cent. of solid material, which would correspond to 2,000 to
3,000 cubic yards per day. The amount actually raised was less than
5 per cent.
    The machine, however, was largely experimental, and, as is the case
with all new and untried machines, was subject to frequent break-
downs.
         APPENDIX       E-REPORT          OF LIEUT.-COL.       MCFARLAND.           733
  Its work was also begun too late in the season, when storms became
frequent.
  Beginning September 26, 1885, only 57 hours and 40 minutes actual
pumping was done up to December 23, 1885, when, in a storm, going out
to the dumping ground, the A-frames, derrick-frames, and suction-pipe
were carried away, and the excavator had to be laid up for repairs. In
the 57 hours 40 minutes pumping 6,411 cubic yards of solid material
were excavated.
  The repairs consisted in replacing the old engine with a new one of
double power, the derrick-frames were rebuilt and strengthened, the
suction-pipe was reinforced with a truss, condensers were put in, and
various minor repairs and improvements were made, and the excavator
was ready for work again February 24, 1886.
  Meanwhile, under date of January 2, 1886, Major Gillespie notified
the contractor by the following letter that the plant did not come up to
the capacity called for by the specifications:
                                             UNITED   STATES ENGINEER     OFFICE,
                                                             New York, January ., 1886.
   SIR: By your contract, dated July 31, 1885, you are required to furnish a plant for
use in Gedney's Channel capable of removing 3,000 cubic yards of material per diem,
and are also required to complete your contract by June 30, 1886. Five months have
now elapsed, and your plant has scarcely gotten beyond the experimental stage; the
trials you have given it indicate pretty conclusively that it has not a maximum ca-
pacity beyond 1,000 cubic yards per diem. This result is far below the expectations
of the contract, and I hereby give you notice that if you do not have in readiness by
April 1 next an increased plant capable of removing daily the quantity required by
the contract, this office will feel itself authorized to go into open market and supply
the deficiency, charging to you all the expenses of such charter over and above the
contract price of removal embodied in your contract.
       Very truly,
                                                                    G. L. GILLESPIE,
                                                                        U. S. Engineers.
  Mt. ELIJAH BRAINARD,
             Con tractorfor Gedney's Channel Imnprovenmen t.

  Mr. Brainard replied, in the following letter:
                                                          NEW YORK, January 5, 1886.
  DEAR SIR : Yours of the 2d instant, relative to my contract for improving Gedney's
Channel, is received.    It is my intention to work additional plant after April 1, 1886,
said plant to be of the same design as the one now used and to be of more than
double its capacity. Construction of same will be commenced immediately, and
completed on or about March 15, 18?86.     With the experience already had I have no
hesitation in saying that without doubt the new plant will be capable of excavating
from 3,000 to 3,500 cubic yards per diem. It will be of the most improved construction.
Expect to complete repairs on our present plant this week, and be ready to again
start on the work Monday. Will also place on the work, on or about January 15, ad-
ditional plant, the one formerly used in Charleston Harbor, South Carolina.
       Very respectfully yours,
                                                               ELIJAH BRAINARD,
                                                                                    B.
  Col. G. L. GILLESPIE,
         United States Engineers.

   Plans and specifications for the new plant were immediately got up
by Mr. Brainard and contracts let for the work on it.
   Owing to bad weather in the winter months, and to the natural de-
lays to be expected in the construction of such a large and complicated
machine, it was not finally finished until May 29, 1886.
   This excavator, which will be known as excavator No. 2, is a larger
and improved form of No. 1; the hull was especially built for the pur-
pose; its dimensions are 152 feet by 44 feet, and it draws about 16 feet
 734                REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

loaded; it is scow built, with 6 pockets and bottom dump-valves. The
pump is similar to that on No. 1, but it is set about x feet lower. The
capacity of the pump, as estimated by its makers, is 36,000 gallons per
minute, through a 22-inch suction and a 22-inch discharge-pipe.
   Her loaded capacity is 1,055 cubic yards when fill. She is not self-
propelling, but is towed as No. 1.
  Meanwhile, Mr. Brainard's statement that he would put the self-pro-
peller Howard upon the work, in addition to the other plant, was not
verified till May 9.
  The Howard, which was working last season on Charleston Bar, is a
self-propelling steam barge, about 110 feet by 32 feet, and draws about
10 feet. An Edwards pump, capacity unknown, is set low amidships.
There are two suctions, one on each side, 9 inches in,diameter.
  The load is carried on an upper deck forward, in bins, which dump
through side doors. Her full loaded capacity is about 175 cubic yards.
  The following is a detailed statement of the work of the three exca-
vators since they commenced work under this contract:
                                                                         EXCAVATOR No. 1.



                                 Month.                                        Cubic yards           Actual time             Time lost by Time lost by
                                                                                excavated.            pumping.                 repairs.     storms.


                          1885.                                     Hrs. Min. Days. Brs. Days.Hrs.
September .-----------..    ---------...--..
                            ....           ----.....--..-..--. 70     3   25     2   00    1   00
                                                             1, 377  21 00     15
October..------..-...----....---..-----..-.....-------....-----------.............   00    4 00
November.....               ... .. ................ 1,146
                          .......                                     7   31    19   00    2  00
December ---..----..----... ..--------------..............---..--....
                                                             3, 818  25   44   18 00       2 00
                           1886.
January ......----....-----------..----...----......-.....--..---............--..--------....--....--
                                                                              300
February.... .. . ........-----                                               22   00
                                     .....................................--......--       6 00
                                                          4,595
March..--.......------..........----...----..----------....------.......--
                                                                  33  33   .............. 17  4
April....--------...-...--                 ..---...-----
                           ..---
                              .................-----.     6, 563  64  54       1   28     15 30
May .........-..... ........... --............           16,410  127 10    ..... .....     7 16
June ......................................---       .   12,289  111 24        6   00      7 00
July .... .........--......        .. ............--- .  17,667  124  18       5 00        2 00

          Total .................................63,935                                                  518       59          ..



                                                                        EXCAVATOR NO. 2.


                          1886.
                              ---------------------..
May ------------------..............                       862.7                                           3      44                 2     00
June .----..--------.----           .....        ...--. 21,385                                           109      54                 6     00               2      00
July..---...............     .......... ...--........ . 22,447                                            88      27                11     00               1      00

          Total---...--..------..--....---.--..----------.......-----.......      44, 684.7              202        5------------.................


                                                                               HOWARD.



                        1886.
May--    ...-------------------------------------                                  5,717.88              91       18                71 00                   2      00
June ------------------------...--------.                                         12, 484. 65           125       48                4  00                   2      00
July..-------..     ----.. --..---
                  --....           --..----------.......                          11,378.87             133       51                3 00                    1      00

          Total...............-------------------------.........---29,                 581. 40          350       57            ...................


                                                             RECAPITULATION.
                                                                                                                                                              Cubic yards.
Excavator No. 1 --..---..-----...------.......-----........---------....--------......-----......---........-------......-------------------.................     63, 935.0
Excavator No. 2 .--.. .......................... .........................                                                     ..................44, 684.7
Excavator Howard ..........-...--        .....               .... ............                 ......     ............. ............ 29, 581. 4
          Total to July 31, 1886 .......... .---.
                                             ...........                                      ..... ..              ........                         ... 138, 201.1
             APPENDIX E-REPORT OF LIEUT.-COL. MCFARLAND.                                                                               735
   From the 23d of December to the 23d of February no record was
kept of the days on which Excavator No. 1 could have worked; but
judging from the wind velocities there were 24 days of south southwest
to northeast winds on which she could not have worked, irrespective of
heavy blows from northwest and running ice.,
   The record shows that the maxium capacity of the plant, so far, is as
follows :
                                                                                                                                Cubic yards.
No. 1 ....         -   --......   --      --......-.-......--...
                                                              .........                                    ---           ----   ....   1,196
No. 2 .... --- -------------------
No.2-----                                                                       ---------------------------
                                                                          -------                        ....                          1,996
                                                                                                                                       1,996
Howard       ---                       -----------------------....................................................................      664


         Total.....--...------------..-- ------------------------.. --..------------............                                       3,856
in a working day of about fifteen hours; that the Excavator No. 1 can
excavate and dump two loads of about 550 yards in that time, about
half the time being devoted to actual pumping and the other half to
going out to the work and returning, going out to the dump and back,
and in turning at the ends of the cut, and that her average pumping
when in good order is 2.4 cubic yards per minute.
   Excavator No. 2 will excavate under favorable circumstances two
loads of nearly 1,000 yards each, in the same time, and her average
pumping when in good order is between 4 and 5 cubic yards per minute.
  Both of them appear to lack engine and boiler power, No 2 especially.
  It was expected that the engine of No. 1 would average about 80
revolutions per minute, and it rarely gets over 70, even with the help
of a blower.
  No. 2 was expected to average 75 revolutions, and it rarely gets over
52, even with the help of a blower. It is noticed that a few extra revo-
lutions make a most marked increase in the percentage of solid ma-
terial.
  For too many reasons to give here in detail, no even approximately
fair idea has been obtained of the relative percentage of solid material
and water raised. It is safe to say that it has never run 5 per cent. of
solid for a continuous hour on the estimated capacity of the pumps.
The moment the suction is dropped on the bottom the volume of the
discharge decreases about one-third, and, if the suction chokes at all
with solid material, the discharge dwindles down to a small stream.
  The break-downs on excavators 1 and 2 since February have been
almost all connected with pumps and suctions, the suctions especially,
the breaks usually occurring near the shoe, or near the universal joint;
the flexible rubber tubing connecting the universal joints with the
pumps have also given a great deal of trouble, as, apart from the ordi-
nary wear and tear, they buckled very much.
  Much time was also lost in experiments to find the right height to
keep the lower ends of the suctions above the bottom, and also the
heights above the bottom at which the gratings should be placed; it
was found, in either case, that a difference of one inch would increase
or decrease the flow of solid materially.
   The self-propeller Howard can excavate and dump in a working day
of 15 hours as high as four loads, of a little over 150 cubic yards each,
pumped in 6 hours actual pumping, which gives about 1.7 cubic yards
per minute.
  The Howard has worked more steadily and can work in a heavier sea
than the other two excavators. Her repairs have been confined almost
entirely to the engine, boiler, and suctions ; but she has this advantage
over the other two, that the suctions can be repaired very easily, some-
736     REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

times without leaving the dredging ground. She has the same lack of
engine and boiler power that the other two have.
   Her pump does not choke as readily as the others. This was specially
noticeable when pumping on the mussel-bed on the south side of the
channel. The two large excavators choked continually, which necessi-
tated raising the suctions off the bottom for half a minute or more at a
time, while the Howard's pump did not choke more than usual.
   The mode of conducting the work has been as follows:
   Four spar-buoys were placed on the north side of the channel to be
dredged, located by sextant angles to the Centennial tower on Coney
Island, the Romer Beacon on the Romer Shoal, and the Main Light of
Sandy Hook; the geographical position of these fixed points on shore
was obtained from the Coast Survey. On account of side winds, cross
tides, wave action, and passing vessels it was not possible to confine the
operations of the excavators to any accurate alignment.
   When work was resumed in March the excavator was at first con-
fined to a space 300 feet wide south of this line of buoys, which was
subsequently increased to 400 feet. Over this area the excavator was
towed up and down the channdl at a rate varying from half a mile to
2 miles per hour, according to tide and wind.
   It was expected that the very small amount of material taken out in
crossing over the bar each time in connection with the devious course
of the excavators, owing to wind and tide, would counteract any ten-
dency to excavate more deeply in one place than in another; this ex-
pectation has been borne out fully, the soundings taken showing the
same general contours which existed before dredging commenced, with
increased depths over them, but with no greater unevenness.
   When the Howard was put upon the work, May 9, the same system
was kept up; and both plants were confined to the 400-foot area south
of the northern line of buoys. When excavator No. 2 was put upon
the work, May 29, it was manifest that the three excavators could not
work in such a narrow space, on so short a bar, and therefore a second
line of four buoys was located on the southern side of the channel to
mark the southern limit, and the excavators were allowed to work on
both sides of the channel, confining their operations to a space 400 feet
wide on the channel side north of the southern line of buoys, and to
the same space as before on the northern side of the channel, south of
the northern line of buoys.
   The two lines of buoys were placed 1,100 feet apart, because as the
proposed width to be given to Gedney's Channel was 1,000 feet, and it
was not practicable to work nearer to the buoys than 50 feet on ac-
count of the danger of the excavator continually fouling or carrying
away the buoys with their suctions, it was necessary to set the buoys
50 feet outside the channel lines. The reason for going over to the
south side of the channel, and leaving untouched a width of 200 feet
in the middle, was that the southern side of the bar was the shoalest
part of it; and the central part the deepest; and also that at the
western end of the bar on the south side, a large bed of live mussels
extended out into the channel for a width of 400 feet in the widest
place, and a length of about 1,200 feet along the channel. It was
thought that this bed had the effect of checking the natural scour, and
that if removed it would give the currents a better chance of scouring.
   Up to July 12, therefore, the excavator was kept on these two 400-
foot areas, south of the north line and north of the south line of buoys,
respectively, when soundings with the lead-line showed increased
depth on both sides of the channel, giving practically a 26-foot channel
        APPENDIX    E-REPORT      OF LIEUT.-COL.    MCFARLAND.       73
on the north 400 feet, and a 24-foot channel on the south 400 feet, they
intervening space between them having a depth of nearly 25 feet.
   The excavators were, therefore, taken off the north side and set to-
work on the middle 200 feet, as nearly as practicable, and when it be-
came necessary to turn out of this area in order to pass each other, or.
passing vessels, they were required to keep on the southern side of the
channel, as being the shoalest.
   The soundings in continuation of those taken on the 12th of July,,
which should have been made on the 13th and 14th, but which could
not be then made on account of bad weather, were taken on the 19th
and 20th, and showed that the middle 200 feet had been excavated to
depth of 25.3 feet in the shoalest place. The excavators were, there.,-
fore, directed to work on the whole width of 600 feet north of the south-
ern line of buoys. It was expected to get another set-of soundings be-
fore the close of July, but the weather was too hazy to obtain sextant
angles.
   At the close of July, therefore, there was a channel 700 feet wide and
26 feet deep, measured with a lead-line, and with one spot in it of 25.3
feet deep on the north side of Gedney's Channel, where a minimum
depth of 23.7 had originally existed; and on the southern 300 feet of the
width of 1,000 feet proposed to be dredged there was a least depth of
23.9 feet where a depth of 21.8 had previously existed, both being re:-
duced to the common plane of reference used by the Coast Survey.
   The excavators have not worked at. night. On good working days:
they have left their anchorage in the Horseshoe at Sandy Hook, from,,
half past 3 to half past 4 in the morning, so as to get to the bar at day--
light; and after working through the daylight hours, have returned tos
their anchorage at any time from half past 7 to half past 10 in the even-
ing, after they had dumped their last load; so that their average work--
ing day may be estimated at fifteen hours.
   As the excavator started out at different times in the morning, came.
in at different times at night, and started for the dumping-ground at dif-
ferent times, and as in many cases where the excavators could work its
would have been impossible on account of the sea to put an inspector-
across from one excavator to another in a small boat, it was necessary to-
keep one inspector on each excavator whose duty it was to keep a rec-
ord of the pumping, delays, repairs, time lost in going out to the dump-
ing-ground, and of the kind of material removed, and also to keep the-
excavator within the proper ranges, to measure the loads, and to see-
that the material was dumped in the proper place. From March 26 tog
the end of July, Maurice Kingsley, the assistant engineer in local charge-
of the work, went down to the channel in the United States steam-tug.
Humphreys on an average three days a week, to superintend the work,..
to see that the buoys were in position, and when necessary to take sound-
ings.
   The material excavated up to July 31 shows that the bottom differs.
from the description of it given in Major Gillespie's report of December
6, 1884, only in these respects, namely: That the live mussel-bed extends.
into the channel on the south side, as mentioned before in this report y
that there is a layer of d6bris of dead mussels and broken shells extend-
ing from the live bed across the channel to the north side; and that there-
are a few pieces of material larger than Major Gillespie's borings couldi
show with the size of pipe used.
   When dredging was begun this spring on the north side of thecichamn
nel it was noticed that the pumps brought up, near the western end of
the channel, a mixture of sand and the shells of dead mussels broken
      47 E
'738    REPORT OF THE       CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

up into fine pieces. In one place the d6bris was so fine that it is a blue
mud, remainiing in suspension a very long time; and, when looked at
through a magnifying glass, proving to be only the finest imaginable
particles of mussel-shells. Just to the east of this area of mussel mud,
as it may be called, the excavators bring up a yellow mud of the same
kind. Both have an exceedingly offensive smell.
   On commencing work on the south side of the channel a bed of live
mussels was found extending out into the channel northward about 400
feet, and eastward and westward about 1,200 feet, commencing at the
western end of the channel and running east. This is evidently the
continuation northward of the mussel-bed southeast of Black Can Buoy
No. 3, mentioned in Major Gillespie's report of 1884, but which his bor-
ings did not locate so far to the northward.
    The bed appeared to be from 6 to 10 inches thick, underlaid with
"pea gravel," to which the mussels adhered. Large bunches were
brought up by the pumps, with from 10 to 50 mussels in a bunch, and
some of very large size. The bed was so thick that in a load of the ex-
cavator Howard, one of the after bins, which holds about 30 cubic yards,
must have had no less than 5 cubic yards in it of live mussels. By
July 12 large live mussels had almost entirely disappeared; once in
awhile a bunch was brought up between that date and the 31stof July,
but very rarely. The mussel debris and mussel mud have continued to
be brought up. One of the Sandy Hook pilots, whose pilotage dates
back to 1834, stated to Mr. Kingsley, the local assistant, that he re-
membered when this live mussel-bed extended the whole way across
Gedney's Channel; but that since then the northern part had been de-
stroyed by propellors churning it up in passing over it. This is very
likely to be the case.
    The deepest water has been for many years on the north side of Ged-
ney's Channel. The mid-channel buoy at the western end of Gedney's
has not been, up to July 31, in mid-channel, but about 300 feet to the
southward, giving a width of about 700 feet on the north side and 300
feet on the south side between the 23-foot contours.
    All of the deep-draught steamers and vessels keep to the northern side
of this buoy, and a line drawn east from a point 100 feet north of this
buoy along the axis of the channel would just about strike the northern
edge of the live mussel-bed when the dredging upon it began, which is
just about the southernmost line that deep-draught vessels take in going
out or coming in through the channel.
    Apart from the mussel-bed, and mixed in with the mussel d6bris, the
material in Gedney's Channel consists of a layer of sharp quartz sand,
varying in color from almost white to a ruddy orange. There appears
to be no regularity in its color, except that the sand on the eastern end
of the bar is of a darker color than that on the western end. Interspersed
slightly with this sand is a small round water-worn quartz gravel, which
on other parts of the bar becomes a gravel from the size of a pea to the
size of a goose's egg. The majority of this gravel, perhaps 70 per cent.,
is what has been called " pea-gravel."
    On resuming work in March, 1886, this gravel was found at the west-
ern end of the bar, and only coarse sand was found at the eastern end;
but since then it has varied a good deal, and from what has been shown
during the progress of the work there appear to be alternate layers of
gravel and sand, extending over the bar, without any very definite loca-
tion and without having any very regular depths. Up to July 31, 1886,
it was noticed that the material was gradually becoming finer as the
depth increased, but since that time the material became heavier again,
       APPENDIX     E-REPORT      OF LIEUT.-COL.    MCFARLAND.       739
and at the present time of writing has been getting lighter, and it ap-
pears to be the case that the material in Gedney's Channel as a rule is
somewhat lighter in the middle and at the eastern end than it is at the
western end and on the sides.
   No evidence whatever has been found of the mud dumps and (lumped
material so often spoken of by newspapers and persons unacquainted
with the channel, except a few large cinders scattered along it, which
have been thrown overboard by passing steamers.
   Sandy Hook pilots state that they often stop ocean steamers from
dumping their ashes overboard in the channels when going out, and
on the 2d of July, 1886, John Parsons, inspector of the excavator How-
ard, saw ashes being dumped overboard from the steamer Bempton, of.
London, as she passed through Gedney's Channel out to sea at 11.30
a. m. He called the attention of the crew of the Howard to it, in order
to have witnesses. The steamer is not one of the regular transatlantic
lines, and has not returned to this port since.
   The amount of cinder dredged up is so small that no accurate esti-
mate could be made of it; but it is safe to say that out of 138,000 cubic
yards of material excavated from Gedney's Channel up to July 31, 1886,
the total amount of cinder was not more than 50 cubic yards. It is
pumped up all over the bar, and no large deposit is found in any one
place.
   A few pieces of water-worn sandstone have been pumped up of very
irregular shapes, the largest which have passed through the pumps be-
ing 13 by 8 by 5 inches. All the large pieces have passed through or
blocked the pumps, when the gratings over the mouth of the suctions
have been disarranged. Nothing can now get through them over 5
inches cube.
   The gratings and pumps have been choked with this large material
several times, and there is undoubtedly more of it than is pumped up.
   Fish, shell-fish, shells, and marine animals are brought up in large
quantities, and usually there are from 1 to 3 bushels of small crabs
brought up and (lumped in each load.
   It is well to mention that since July 31 little bunches of very small
mussels have been brought up in noticeable quantities on the space
formerly covered with the live mussel-bed, indicating a new growth since
the first dredging was done over it.
   There are strong indications that the channel is underlaid at the
eastern end with blue clay at from 33 to 35 feet below mean low water.
Whenever the suctions are dropped a little too soon at the western end,
starting eastward, pieces of compact blue clay are brought up. The
western end of Gedney's pitches down into a deep hole, 40 feet deep
and over, almost perpendicularly, and it is on the edge of this deep hole
that the clay is found; but it is evidently a very old formation and en-
tirely different from the soft mud of which the bottom of the deep hole
is composed.
   At a rough estimate, over 60 per cent. of the material of large size,
where the surface is rough, is over-grown to a more or less extent with
sea-growth of various sorts, indicating that the stones have not had
sufficient scour or wear to prevent such growth, and it may, therefore,
be assumed that they have lain in Gedney's Channel a long time.
   It has been found that there is sufficient room in Gedney's Channel
to work the three excavators at the same time, except just at high water
on Thursdays and Saturdays, when the North Atlantic fleet of steamers
passes over the bar, when one and sometimes two of the machines
have to be laid off for half an hour or an hour.
740             REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

    The two large excavators, which are towed, have been at a great dis-
advantage, on account of the length of tow-line needed in the usually
heavy swell of Gedney's Channel. The length taken up by the largest
is:
                                                                                                                   Feet.
Excavator (including suction-pipe)..----..----..........                           ------..----..----.     180
Tow-line ...               .......................... . . . .....                             --- .....
                                                                                   . ...-. .......      .. 600
Tug .........---.......-----------...........--          -..----...---....------     .................--....         120

                                                                                                                    900
                                                  ...........------.............----------- -----......---......-------......
          Total......------ ---------......-----......--......------
   In a side wind, cross-tide or cross-sea, in order to keep the excavator
from sagging down outside the line of buoys, it is common for the whole
tow to take up a width of 400 or 500 feet of the channel. At least four
self-propelling machines could work more advantageously than the two
non-self-propelling machines now at work. However, by good manage-
ment on the part of the tugs, and on the part of the pilots of vessels, no
collision had occurred up to July 31, although there were times when
euch collisions seemed inevitable.
   One great trouble has been that steamers would not keep down the
channel from end to end, but would run in and out of it from the south-
ern side and eastern end across the line of buoys marking the southern
side, forcing the excavators off the line, and carrying away the buoys.
This has caused extra expense to the contractors and extra work for the
Engineers.
                                             SOUNDING BENCH-MARKS.

   Maj. G. L. Gillespie's survey of the Lower Bay in 1884 was made in
two parts, referred to different gauges, the sounding being located by
sextant angles to shore points whose geographical position had been
established by the United States Coast Survey, the soundings being
taken by a lead-line. The soundings taken east and south of a broken
line drawn from Sandy Hook to the head of the Swash Channel and
thence to Coney Island were referred to mean low water as established
by the Coast Survey and marked on the guage on the Engineer Dock at
Sandy Hook. The soundings taken west and north of this line towards
the Narrows were referred to mean low water on the gauge near Fort
Wadsworth, at the Narrows, sometimes called the Fort Tompkins gauge,
used by both the Engineers and by the Coast Survey. The soundings
which overlapped and have been replotted as a test, show only a differ-
ence of one-tenth of a foot between the two parts of the survey, proving
that the mean planes to which the soundings were referred were prac-
tically the same. In Major Gillespie's survey of 1884 mean low water
on the Engineer's gauge at Sandy Hook was obtained from the Coast
Survey, which gave the plane of mean low water as 21.945 feet below
a bench-mark on the main light at Sandy Hook, which is described as
follows:
    Copper spike, with cross in its head, driven up to its head into the wall, a few inches
to the westward of the northwest a~ngle, and 91 inches above the ledge, or a little
above 2 feet above ground. The width of the side of the octagon at the bench-mark
is 11 feet 101 inches, and 5 feet 51 inches shove the bench-mark in another ledge, where
the diameter of the tower is reduced.
  This gave the mean low-water level on the gauge on the Engineer Dock
at Sandy Hook, as then established, of 2.8i feet above zero.
  During Major Gillespie's survey of 1884 tidal observations were kept
up almost daily, from August 21 to November 28, which, however, gave
a mean level differing from that of the Coast Survey plane, viz, 2.985
feet above the zero of the gauge, or a plane 0.125 feet above the Coast
         APPENDIX     E-REPORT        OF   LIEUT.-COL.     MCFARLAND.         741
Survey plane. The soundings shown upon Major Gillespie's maps, south
and east of the line mentioned above, were all referred to the Coast Sur-
vey plane.
   In order to facilitate work this year, it became necessary to have a
bench-mark nearer the gauge than the main light is, and one was there-
fore established during the survey, described as follows:
  On the corner of foundation of derrick known as derrick "spud," which is situated
510 feet east of the southeastern end of Engineer office at Sandy Hook.
   The elevation of this bench-mark is 10.593 feet above mean low water
at the Engineer Dock, as established by the Coast Survey, and conse-
quently 10.468 feet above the plane of mean low water established from
Major Gillespie's observations from August 21 to November 28, 1884.
It is well here to remark that from the records of this office it appears
that the low-water plane to which the fort at Sandy Hook is referred
does not correspond with that established by the Coast Survey, but is
0.75 of a foot below it.
   In conducting the work this year a gauge-reader has taken daily
readings, except on Sundays, from May till July 31, on the gauge at the
Engineer Dock at Sandy Hook, and a clock-gauge was also established
there to take continuous observations. The gauge was read at ten-
minute intervals from 7 a. m. until 6 p. m.
   The soundings taken in the channel in June and July, 1886, were
taken from the Engineer tug General A. A. Humphreys with a lead-line.
The line was marked in feet and half feet, and its length was checked
by a standard steel tape before and after use, so as to correct for stretch-
ing or shrinkage of the line. While not in use the line was kept in fresh
sea-water.
   In taking the soundings the line was read to the nearest half foot,
and the results recorded and then reduced to mean low water on the
Sandy Hook gauge.
   The difficulties of taking soundings in Gedney's Channel are great,
owing to the fog and haze shutting out the fixed points on the shore
to which sextant angles are taken to locate the soundings, and owing
to bad weather or to the strength of the Atlantic swell.
  The average wave in Gedney's Channel from March to July 31, this year
has been about 4 feet from crest to trough; and the excavators worked
in waves up to 5 and 6 feet high from crest to trough. Except at the end
of February and in the early part of March of this year there had been
up to July 31 no serious storms; and during the time of dredging,
there have been no storms from the south, southeast, east, or north-
east, the points from which the full force of the Atlantic wave is felt
in Gedney's Channel, which have been at all serious.
   What small blows have come from these quarters have been too
short in duration to create serious wave action; but on the other hand,
during that time the testimony of my assistants and of the inspectors
employed upon the work is that on only two days has there been a less
sea than half a foot from crest to trough. Sometimes the ground-
swell succeeding heavy weather in the Atlantic has not time to sub-
side before the ground-swell of a new storm makes.
   The two sets of soundings, taken June 24 and 26, and July 12, 19,
and 20, were taken in waves averaging from 1 to 2 feet from crest to
trough-, and the reason for the long interval between July 12 and 19
was, that about one-third of the proposed soundings were taken July
12, and none other could be taken till July 19 on account of the swell,
although the excavator could work easily in it.
742     REPORT     OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

   There have been many complaints through the newspapers, princi-
pally of steamers running aground in the main channels leading out of
New York Harbor. But from the testimony of my assistant and of the
inspectors in charge of the excavators, who have given special atten-
tion to this subject, it appears that only one steamer ran aground in
these channels between March and July 31, and this was the Saint
Laurent. Coming up the Swash Channel, on the 16th of June, during a
heavy fog, she kept too far to the westward, and ran upon a well-known
shoal point putting out towards the channel from the westward, which
is over 500 feet west of the south line of the channel usually taken by
steamers.
   At the lower end of the Swash Channel it is necessary to make quite
a sharp turn to the northward in order to get into Gedney's Channel,
and the turn from the Main Ship-Channel into Gedney's Channel is even
shorter. More room should be given for vessels at these points.
   Our experience shows that the work of dredging this channel can be
accomplished by means of hydraulic excavators, though those now in
use may be improved upon.
   One very serious disadvantage to the work has been that the excava-
tion has not been done fast enough. Sufficient plant should be put on
when further work is ordered to take out not less than 100,000 cubic
yards per month.
   With the experience gained this season there is no doubt that such
an amount can be taken out monthly from April until November, if
proper machines are built for the work. It is well known what the nec-
essary form of machine is for dredging in Gedney's Channel and in the
inner channels, and what the cost of the work ought to be. Therefore,
in the event of our not being able to coritract the work yet remaining
to be done at reasonable rates, it would seem to be expedient for the
Government to build its own machines and to do its own work.
   The act of Congress approved August 5, 1886, contains the following
item:
Improving New York Harbor, New York: To secure a 30-foot channel at mean low
water at Sandy Hook entrance of the harbor, upon such a plan as the Secretary of
War may approve, $750,000.
  As this covers the whole channel distance between deep water inside
New York Harbor and deep water outside the outer bar, it necessarily
includes Gedney's Channel, and it is expected that a part of this ap-
propriation will be applied to it.
  It is important that a very thorough test of the practicability of
keeping Gedney's Channel open by dredging alone at a reasonable out-
lay should be made before any other method of increasing the chan-
nel depth is undertaken.
   The question of course ig whether the annual filling there will be too
great to justify annual dredging.
  This can only be determined by careful surveys made before and after
the dredging is done; such surveys as the report shows have been made
during the progress of the work, and these surveys will be repeated jn
the spring.
  It is unfortunate that through the inadequacy of the machines em-
ployed a greater depth has not been gained; but this was unavoidable,
for there were no hydraulic machines in the country capable of doing
this work when it was first undertaken, and they, therefore, had to be
built for the purpose, and they necessarily suffered from the imperfec-
tions which affect all experimental machines.
j                                                                                                                  '.0 06R
                                                                                                                   73!58
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       -    -         -          -- ----                  7
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                7f       56G
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          73              .



                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     v-8°11

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                            W




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                IMPROVENENT OF1
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           lE DNIE                                                                      S (II\ANNli
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    NI \v                                                                        RKH IIARHOR                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  I/

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                SHOWING SOUNDINGS 'AKIN AT THE TIME OF                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                            ,\_
    40 30                                                                           3 .s
                                                                                                                                                                             _-      -20.-
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                MAJOR GILLESPIIE S                                                                                                        ISURVEY
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             40 3o

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               18 841
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           420
                                                                                                                                                                       224          5.
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     17 4
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        /
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       /%
                                                                                                                                                             ZSI                   "211                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           1         -
                                                                                                                                                          286120)                                                                                1                                                                                                                                                                                   Scale 1:7500                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     .4 1A
                                                                                                                                                                                   3211
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          MInO
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             I          U   ou   Soo 400 5 nn                    o    ino A O900                 nO0
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        -160^nar
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               of.
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               o0                                                                                                                                                     _2'9
                                                  291                          4414
                                                                                                                                                                                  213                      20'4


                                                   22 8
                                                                               33V
                                                                                                                                                                                                           ' U2
                                                   28.0                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    130 l08            1801 1 0                                                                         9.33             3 3v.      8    1.3         45.              465      46.                  .7          46.8              473               468                                     45.9         4.8
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  461
                                                                               347                                                                                                '216                     204

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                1931                  200                                                            4457
                                                                                                                                                                       21.3                            205                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      41 +1
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                            20^,                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          19      53
                       192                 o              q,0     3!0                              213g o           4S        47 0         40)7           236                21-3                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         IY                                         18.6
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    Lga                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     45.0
                       1ss
                                                                  34~6          ~
                                                                               3444
                                                                                                            )5     '2           4);.)                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     193                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               41.6

                       20.'                                                                                                                                                                            Z 0z
                                                                                                                                                                                                          2                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       46 0
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  19   8
                                                                                                                                                              i,                                           21'2                                                                              2     0         0                                                                                        2.t
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             462

                        20-0                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               20                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           462
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      208
                                                                                                                                                                                                           2'                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           20 1
                                                           16                       3              3               115               4                    I        0                                                                                                                                             21)7                                                                             21"1                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  ?ll.
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        201                                                                                                                                                  47 0                                                                                    408
                                                                                                                    417                                                                                                                                                                   221U                                                                                                                                                                                             21 6
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          6917
                            1 .2                                                                                                                                       21 9
                                                                                                                                                                                                                     no)
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      4                                                                                                                          221                                                                   21                                 211                                                                                                                                          204
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        21 f.                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                '170
                                                                                    3    1                                      .H                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        'L16                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   50o-S
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   2"8                  N°4 li                                                                             o                                                                                                2I                                                                                                                                                                                                                                            zoo                              T"
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        \                                      210                                                                                                                                                                                    230                     212                                                                                      '14                                                                         19.                                                                         475
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              28                                                                1                                               221                                  25                                                                                                                                                                                                                21.0                                205                                                                                                                                                                                                  50
                                                                                                                                                                                                                    "3'r)92,o                                                                                                                             723                                                                                                                       51.
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              2l                                                 9.11721                                                                                                                                         21919                                                             47"
                                                                                                                                                                                                                     4 2      )5J3.         5
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     "3.3                                                                                                 7                                 22
                                                                                                                        4&      4&A                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             3
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   4452;
                            210                                   6                17 31                                                                                                            '38                                                                 2...3                                                                                                               2)2                                                                                                                                                              2:5 22C4                           221)
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  22I0                                                        "'        22                                                                                                                 221'
                                                                       42.1                  3                          413      4°4                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                476                                                                    523
                                                                                         3313                                                                                                                   .            3 2    641.         '      46              28 '2                                    31     2                                           :t                           "2                                                                                      2 G2                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       2      14
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       -
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    , 4.....
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       :-,2                            t                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   2                                                                                         23.             .2
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    46 9
                                                                                                                         "2 7                   3t                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                i                          2: t°'                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    521
                                                                       2                                                                                                                            "L437* _13
                                                                                                                                                                                                            31 "G44 'Jr61                                              25 0                                                                                              23                      a              43                         '.."                                           s'                                             :J"                                                                                                                                                21 02
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          2&u?
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  05
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       I
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      '4 74 A                                                                                                               2 t~n                       It                                                                                                             2L2                                                                                                                                                                                                     "117         .                                                       464
                                                                                    35.1                                      t30          3      73IX?
                                                                                                                                                                                                                         y    .     248                    63             '                                                          '23                                                                                                                                                                                      I9 3                            234                                                                                                                                           24'
        2;0                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          2'T'                           '0"-                                                        -22
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               rT                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    7,d                                               23
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                            ,                       8G1_.,                                      237                  \.284
                                                   .734         337                                                                  39                                                                                                               26                                                                                                                       b4"2              :6         24.4             65G-6"23               24').2236                                  l-,              .
              25 .8                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                4 %5.1.8

                                                                                   :1, 4
                                                                                   is6
                                                                                        3"t            7o

                                                                                                                   1          14gV 1!
                                                                                                                              47
                                                                                                                                  .184
                                                                                                                                                  ,       478                                      257
                                                                                                                                                                                                    . .o7
                                                                                                                                                                                                   244        '    ,2 4 4.
                                                                                                                                                                                                                         '   clii)             2+ .
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               41                 _      ;t
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       244.1.
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       'E38-         i4.4'
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       T                                                                         2240
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  0        242'0'                 8                          245.          28'263          '42424F ...- '"/    ',/46                                  ""-42:.1                                                                   2b7        212
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                            20.
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           0323"                                    2u4
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                24-'.40,
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      6                    \
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   344t7                                                                                                            4
                                                                                                                                                                                              G
                                                                                                                                                                                               G-i)
                                                                                                                                                                                               25
                                                                                                                                                                                                           '4 2$50
                                                                                                                                                                                                                4-
                                                                                                                                                                                                                       2.4                  kR42
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              258
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 '200
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       "-7:t( + ..t : t'
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               22:,.G21
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              : " 1 2
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     ... c226.,                   \20....
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                ,,+ 'o-84'
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    Zd t.,                  _               "
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     + tno-----L4......... ..,4
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           ,.=.. ...        '445 '".-'
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                            "2....1  *'V                                                  :5 "              ""-j-.
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     .
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  281           Q..t
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               ,.                           1;              &.
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     82              5   3
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      2201
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        2607.82.8                                                                                     tS )1                    :.1"                                                  'L.-                                                                                                                                                             _Hl       _   Y1K
                                                                                                                                                                                                       z                Z4 "LR28.6 / ,
                                                                                                                                                                                                                     ZAAQ                                             Z8.6 2b8 6.t27.1                                                                        283        24.        p                                                                                      '4&l1)                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                2                                                  42044
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        4'                            42 2
                                                                                                 9 4        .133                                                                                                                                                                                                                   {....                  16              9                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      . ...                                                     74                                                                                                                                                                                     4
                                            3      31837           387         7                                                                                                                   L1 .8                            '4 .,        A:         27                               .%.-.."2585-                                                                                        12                                                    1.o24
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         12                                                                  I-8
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 250                                                :7
                                     327                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  ".7..4    2;,                                           I".!                       _-_ 2Ib21i0.
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     .. 26:...                            2-4]                          Mi)'             /."/.'                                  3                                                                   ...                        -Ph
                                                                                                                                                                                          -: 26'2-' 48O 4.                                                                    1 6G
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        4 Py8 "6'6                                 jn           2      1       247-                 S8 &\25U
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         441)3             ,;     248
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                '!         I                                            o                                                                                                                     6                                                                      e                                                                             S4                                    l           348                                                     44        o
                                                                                                                                                                                               " 2                           2"0     -G -       1 24u            5.        .6                                                        .7¢''b27                         248 24              2'263 ,-'".o                        2.1'                  228 .                                                                                         I/                                                   o.    7lzZ-.i4                                                                                                                                 ...

                                                                                                                                                                                              2,                                            .               'L i-..L9
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                            i4                      8
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         2866448 -25 63      62              .2.28                                             24                                                               4.242                                                     ,.,                                 .               .2.                                                                                                                                                                                               .6                               \\                 3z
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        470

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             1
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              2W"6     200,                                                             23                                              , 24 ++,
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          201;2d                                     2.1      5        . ?7 .-
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  1i- l304-,=,1 26
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          "g1,t27)32...                                 7.                                                                                                                                                      380
                                                                                                                                                                                                       32            8"b ".."3'                           t 'L 3' \42.
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      \ 243         ""      24                                                       26 23U'44n                                          24                      34                        21VL'4)    0
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              .l,
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              7
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                2b 2
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               •
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                            2                                                                                         z-.z                 '                                                                46 S                          45
                                                                                                                                                                                               'L4
                                                                                                                                                                                              '48
                                                                                                                                                                                                    AG          /
                                                                                                                                                                                                                      P28   "q''1
                                                                                                                                                                                                                          230
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                'L4 3      t0 31 07~~
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                            ,
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           L,:1
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           230~~P
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             -
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               P.1
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                272620
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    i.I          e -
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          I;
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                            2           4         G 2
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   24.)3
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 '4 26
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                            e~
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      2..7
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      2ri                 "
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    '4
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      (          I1:6.I                                    :-
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  r
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             = +..                                  -],'-       :H,                                                                                                                                                     140
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             1.

                                                                                        L.' Z344                                                                                                                                                       S7                                           °17                     Y74                                   266                       2           "t )"
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                            E7206                                                       60       '      '532.625
                                                                                                                                                                                                            3           322.j               -24S                               4                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      2                     E0                                                                                                                                                                                                  46'S
                                                                                                                                                                                                                        +6
                                                                                                                                                                                                                      2267243                                                              2)7                         ".33
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         21.               s                                                2A6 4.!($'s-..323243'2:r$3
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       )2.1     .1       \                            26 'L                                                                                                                     M G -E.              .ta                            P ,10.                                                                                                                                                                                                      34.7
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                2 Ll.$1 t
                                                                                                                                                                                                       4            2 2212  2               )Y 22)7'7                     24              86                 26                U           G?26E'0                   2452                           24"i       f,6Rt                                         .4                                                     lt b
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    283                                                   7.'                                         376                                                            Y00
                                                                                         29-Y                                                                                                                                       23                                               '                 t1'                                                         180              244.26-                '148 24     "                               '                                         G382                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        41;)
                                   '292                                                   23-                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             27167:                                     320C                                             237'                                                                324B92r

                                    29 8                                   "   """""          26                                                                                          234                        '               '02224
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    )L
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  19.9
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   21)7
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          34 0                                                                             t
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              I                                                                                       5
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                            242                                                                                                     ..                                                                                                                                                                    380u1                       2 12                                                                                                                                                                                  45.&
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 22'2                                                                                                       4't                                                                                                      .y S                                                                                                                                 3, 6                                                    U
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 30.7       30
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  47 p
                                                                                                                                                                    ,44                            2                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     46-2
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      _4')                            5)                                                                                                                                                       366( 224
                                                                                                                                                                                         21                                         21                                             21)2428                                                                                                                        '442                                '442                                                             ..- '-
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        24.           .       .6 '48)
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 .t8   E.. 2046
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              6                            .244                                                                                                              :4                                                                                                                                                                                             4f))                   4
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  2t87                                         2962223                                              8.41124."                                                                   724 z1 1{''_'                     4_324 n.2,                              ----            5102                   6                             R)                                                 33 22774                                                                                            32                                                                                                                                                                                                                  46 4
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                            45"1              .
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           'L1         3281                     1414                                         I-    _                            ..
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      223                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 5 I                                                 \ 2 846:1                                308
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   242;                                          _,Y                                  /                       23'6                     'L3-0                                                                                                                              (1e~
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     3V'.sl~
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               ::1)1                                  306                        3      7           L
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         48   4
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                228..40E423.                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 4,2 1.7                     '~3                                                                                                       )4                                                                                                                         4    3                4:.'
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 2..1.4.230
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      Cb-r                                                      /,2                                                             2                                      .1;3                                                                                                                                                                                                          304
       !!2,                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         $


                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      :;               31 -7
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      -" 1                                        z                                  /                                                 Z3                           'til                    2
              at2                                                                                                                           230                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           634                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           46 7
                                                                -l74                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                            4                 07                                                 .1)        :c                                         314
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                -. ~213                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     .18
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     3                                                            32462                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     28                                1 38         41
                      H98                                                                                                                 231                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          'd0   8                                                                                                                    23.:.
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    :0                                                                                                                                                      'n.       230880                   309030311 .. 8              181:0.                o30St
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               31.                    34
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      uc e2                                                                                                                                                                                                          38.         3    343
                                                                                                            2J u
                       21                                 17 2                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              287                     241                                         L      4
                                                                                                                               G41                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       26                                                                              41                               234 23
                                                                                                            e3 3                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           232
                        282                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     29
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                236G                                            36
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               81:.6                                                            34 -
                                                                       f                                                     24 G                                                                                                                                                    21'7
                                                          2S
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              224                                           a
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                            .32 3
                                                          Z6 7                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      28U-                                       3     )6
                            2)4
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              232                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 -*---                       4029
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                2-1 0
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              23      a3                                                                                              iLE.                        \                                                                                                                                                                  22)1,           31 07S                                     -- 165 -                                    v
I.02                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    2)-23                                                                                                                                                               2                                       224
                             289
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    46      0
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              2z3                                                                                                                222              .8 .                                                                                                                                                                                  :t3
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     '42 3                    22
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               .5 (1                                                                                                                                                                                              4.7                                                                     47 6
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         l een                                                                                                                                                                                                                3                                     .18
                                                                                                       TIDES                                                                      Government Dcl                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           '32e
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           23Z                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          4.0
                                                                       SObsrvationt2mad'                                 by 1     S.       Eqineers)                                 Sandy Hook                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           22Ka
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             2.')
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          2288
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              0
                                                                                                             "*    184.                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    460
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      a62
                                     High. Water) Mean interval alte' peceding                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          a5                          4s.a
                                                                                                                                                                                         xlhl              Ill
                                     Low    ..    Transit of the Muoon
                                     Mea. Rise and Fall of Tides                                                                                                                           4.              '71 ft
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                46 0
                                                            Sprir    Tides                                                                                                                 5.              73..
                                                                                                                                                                                           3.              78..                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     Note
                                                                                                       Neap

                                                                                                   Soundi lf's                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              The channel proposed to be dredged is bounded by
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                            dotted blue lines and the A"qineer buoysJ mrlfin
                                               Sournaqngs are express.ved in feet & tenths . &-refer-                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       the channel are designat ed by blue clot a nd munbers                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      To accompany A4nnual Report for 1886.
                                               to a4feart low Water at Sandy Ho1ok - CS.CoseSWVurreyfa1e-
                                               The 24 feet CYzr've is shw1 n thlus

                                                     '6
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  Lieut. C'o. of'Engiu' rs lSAi
                                                    30                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               7l56"                                           o,
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           73 s7

C~,-------;-~,______L______                                       ~_;_~___(UiJD                                                  ___________~_______________~____________                                                                                                                                                                                     ___~_____~_~~~~__ ~__ ~____..._...~1.~~ - --                                                                                                                                                                          --
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    ~----------                                      -- ---                            ---- C-                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         "}8
----------
~                                    -                                                                                                                                                        -~~~~~-~-   ----        ~---                       ---       ~~--~-                                                         II
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        -~~~~~-                              ---    ~~~--     I          I
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   --------
                                                             73 58'                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    73| 57




                                                                                                                                            IM PROVEME N'T OF
40 30                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     40 30


                                                                                                                    (EDNEYS                                           CHANNEL                                                                                                                                                                                               t//i
                                                                                                                                        NEW                                      HARBOR
                                                                                                                                                                               ,YORK                                                                                                                                                                    \\

                                                                                                                                  SHOWING SOUNDINGS TAKEN BY
                                                                                                            ASSISTANT ENGINEER MAURICE KINGSLEY
                                                                                                                                                 JULY 12~H" 2OT"1886                          .                                                                                                                                                                                ~-
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               --
                                                                                                                                                         Scale 1:7500
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             7/ /              \\
                                                                                                                                                                                                             7.
                                                                                                             W07 0 o 100 2 .ao   4u   .0o         one           Io0                         oou                  o0                              5000ft.

                                                                                            -
                                                                                                            1                                                         -------------------
                                                                       4                        13




                                                                                  37.
                                                                      41          43,   3
                                                                           17    !
                                                                                fi


                        299




                                                              'or,


                              3::6       3-K     ;C1                        442
                                                             5966

                                                      43';                   133
                                                                            43:
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      *4'                  277         308        3;
                                                             411:                                                                                                                                                 i$j.1                                    Zraa
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      L~
                                                                                 In Is
                                                \41                         4,9 +.2
                                                                                       36.8
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                            .4-*
                                                      0-                                                                                                                                                                        370Y1D t         z x10      r74-711               .1Z         Z~;      9 29 3
                                                                            :*7.4-              6                                                                                                                                                  2       NI                       .R8   ---    37
                                                                                                                                                                                                             2            :-3         '      7    7        37,                ?           ._ 3.1 a

                                                                                                                                                                                                                      2L7r
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          317- ;92 2-7
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       2         I      ?
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                1323

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    ^I0
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                            311               314           3
                                                                                                                                                                                                             ,,,0         .2                   ^.Gb9-.'                     271 .         2       9 \ 3
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                ?\1Z?
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             6                    ,


                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  ?                                                                         q                  3       3,e       3' 9
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       _0s r91Y
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             L
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  3174.                         ]'1o    7
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                            310           34       1
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      .56
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          4.67
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          24-179
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 3.;
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             ~iI ..                     3
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        331        W
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                S
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        319




                                                                                                                                                                        Notes
                                                                                                                                            The Channel proposed to be dredged is bounded byf                                                                                                                                            Souzndinqg
                                               rides
                                                                                                     Goernment   pock                       dotted blue lines and the Engineer huoys markirt
                                                                                                       Sandy io11                           the Channel a      're deseqated by blue dots & numbers.                                                                         Soundings are exopressred irt, feet and      tenths
                      HighWat.er     Mean inlerval after precedin                                      virh. aLXn.
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             and     refer to a plane of MeanLow Water / af Of a
                   I, ow        'lli  t n7it of the Moon                                               XII 1 LIm.                           The local/ons of the Channel buoys set br'the Lghthouse                                                                          fbot above the Coast Survcy plane at  aundy look
                    Meanu Riso and Fall of Tides                                                         4 .71 ft.                          Department to mark Gednejs Chantel were chaqLed                                                                                   The 24 fee curve is showrn thuS.
0'29                                                                                                                                       since Colonel (illespier survey of 1814. They are shoun                                                                              .. 26                                                                                                        40"29
                                           .. Spirijg Tides                                             .5 .73 ..                           on this sheet as located July   20. /888.
                                              .. Neap Tides                                              3. 78 ..                                                                                                                                                                          30           ..
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           3JO
                    Obstrsvaions made by U. S Eroineers in I884
                                                                                                                                                  To accomputny             Annual Report for /g86



                                                                                                                                                               73x8Let .Colvnel                   of Engineer. L:d.C                                                                                .73             .                                                                 CoLuN0    e*0




  H Exl pt2 v2 49 2
I                                                                                                                   ____~________II___~~______~                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       ~                               ~                       -I


                                                                                    g' 11'
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         IMPROVEMENT


                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           GEDNEY'S                                                                                                CHANNEL
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 NEW YORK                                                             HARBOR
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         MAP                   OF      PART                    OF THE


                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       COPIED                     FROM
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        MAJOR                        GILLESPIE'5                              SURVEY                                   OF         1884.
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               INCLUDING
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  SURVEY or GEDNEYS CHANNEL
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      made July iZ9to 20h 1886 by
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       Maurice KinsleyC.E.
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                = r                ;-
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             r - t
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           ,.,-.
                                                         HOFFMAN~SALZ                                                                  OONA4000                                   *00                                                                                                                                                                                     004:
                                                                                                                                                                                                                              -1                                        a                           -                 ~                       ~                         :~~~

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          ..
                       14#1000tl4
                             titl4


                                       t4            "                    044                                                                                                   -D.'2f                                                              4                            i"                                                                           .".-                                                                                                                                            ,,.,.1:

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 1:10:/1                                                                                                t.,                                                or                                       4a0
                                                                                                        4.00                                     z (
                                                                                                                                             28 tta       5.-.-_                                                     -                    -.         -          "Iso                                                                                                     Ott                                                                        %     ' fz                                   i             1.
                                                          36d91                                                                    94a )SD                                                                                            4                       1t .._                                 1140!0'!                                                                                                                                       1
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    I tt !          14
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    1
                                                                                                                                           M40110301"01004/,                                                                              J/140                                                                                                                                                                                       //                                                                                                                       ii
                                                                     48410                                                                                                                                                                                                                            -ILQ-Ila.23.                                                                                                                                           ot 000la
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      00 19 100
                                                          lot
                                                                                             44                     031'81
                                                                                                                     M'1                           p}4               "'
                                                                                                                                                                   ( ' II D
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  i.41
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           3 Ki1 0                      004
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         [[__,,_000t                                                                                                                                             00    00.0                                                                                                                               aa10
                                                                      M2 +1!O.100141te                                                                actLAN.124t !f                                                                            t03
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          141tot200                          '                               00,. _--                                1           6           I        t4 US                    .                146-IIS    ISS-Ii2.-.-G21 <t0f4^                                                                                                   iS
                                                 °                                   49 . 0

                                                                                                                                                                    044 N 12 1 4)to                                                       . 4            0                                                                       oto03                                                                                                                                                                                  0 10ot S 8 1. " U '+. 24 ii a8                                                          al1 100I ll             40   1-10 I
                                                                                                                                                   J                45         43 11 064                                       g94
                                                                                                                                                                                                                         )i28 0041                                      01g40
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        11    66 00 I                                          15 L                           0\to._l14
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 _i24                                           23                                  0    99         L0-a                      0t.o                              0 13--
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             K 099           0
                                                                                                                                                                                      0..            0                                               44                    0 004                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         L3O'] tto
                                                                                                                                                                                              0L0                                          044                                                                    00Io 1 t 1'!togtn                                                                                                                                                                            4123 8II
                                                                           *
                                                                                    >100
                                                                                      rotf1                                                                    0y        aa 00         4t . o000 0.                                                                                                 Rl0.0 04 01 4     4                                                                               L410Z400
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           to4
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           ]                                                                  L4toI
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              a.
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              45 3LL                                                           3
                                                                           ass ]61                                                                                                toL1o
                                                                                                                                                                                                0-2Eo                                          p 9 1,0300                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       21-3                fI000
                                                          ill                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           .40 ,0.it..a44o
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 1441a                                                                                                                                         .        u-
                                      i!                 aa. 3        00.00               000                   3S2     af t
                                                                                                                                                                          L
                                                                                                                                                                                  N'coo                                                          5-5
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           l Fe1tt}
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 o, lSo ul                                         44 004
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              39tlp21
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  20                           o40                                        6a             il            al       L             o4E} f                         200       S00 00                           a,0
                                            21   a
                                                                                             000f1                  L 9            84
                                                                                                                                 43 04b0t 8   4L                              , 30
                                                                                                                                                                                 40I)      O      ol f $ "000b.D1$0
                                                                                                                                                                                                            gf/f4                                                  s.4!
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      .. r                       lot-.                                            \
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                            R          43ott
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         39           E!
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               tl
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   86                  28                       ib
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     1                           -
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    6.
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                9       "        O~

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                I                                     Llo2f                                                                                              000]}                                                                                                                   4121
                                                                                                                                                                    r..
                                                                                                                                                               00~~~I~                                               0014, to -0300                                     .
                         040/34'4
                         100                                  s*ta
                                                             16j                          So            4)              D !8                           001 400019 '~1}I'                                  1't                                            ,,,0R123tot                                Ott                        4              10142 114 lo t1                               at                                        ,Odtoo             21                   0041              00J40.
          044                                        i       i
                                                                                         3E0t841itaO
                                                                                                     110                                zo aE.                                                        \
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      110
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             /i'            ,                                  d!.
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                0.0
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              04.0
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          !           L1               a
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           og ..o                    26000;
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           L8202s6t93
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    318     oof
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              10
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 000300 6                                                        53
                                    16431                                                                       4 11 ]2                  4        31t'4                  .00 t 0011                                  IL                    !1o!05                                                                                                                                                                    01 04     0001001 l46                                                                                                                 340                                        t
                               Ri            R               4615t4 K                                                            24Li                                              \ .                                 10                        R                 i8                     I.                               18O                                         tlot                            t1            IS3039                                                                      10           03n
                                     1caafs                                                             2J     o1I,. l                                              9                                                                                                             000a~                                                                                   Ito                                         f     / a"0                                                                                                                        401 33 4!
                                                                                    no                    00.02005                                                             {3P/.o                                                      41.                                                                                                001                                       00                                        000
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               1s1300   303
                               00 B                  00                    8010                         \L .\o 0 1                                                       21      t14,0                                                                        l4.ts                            01                                             10\                                                                                             003             II(                   16
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       Ht 000.00 3 05                                                          1




                                                                          q              4
                                                                                              I         00.1
                                                                                                         ',j
                                                                                                             ~
                                                                                                             f1 2Ott3a4
                                                                                                            oo    ott
                                                                                                                    o141
                                                                                                                        b t9 ""^,.
                                                                                                                              11
                                                                                                                               totit                                                    6o        .,                          t t
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      14L4
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        34         tf            49,
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                            4.9
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        l044 01*6
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               164                                    11o1.
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      .- -                            54
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                19.8000
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          AV!;Dp
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                D                                                          440044
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           4.3.
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               81
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          4013 041
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       1



                  000                       00- /0tl                 2104           ( 4024318a                                                                                                                                                               14-ate.3
                                                                                                                                                                                        1-00                219                                                             .4.4                                                                                         000
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          44                          oo
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      10
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      +so

                                                                                                                                                                                                                         \\           330                                     00                                     So                                       _            ,,,                                       II                                           000                                          sil                                 )                            329,



                                                                                                   4a0                                  00                           44                           0104                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 0
                        22'L         t,41                        1 t.                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                            .L                                                                                ,.
                                                                                                                                                                                  4                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        ,                           001                          2tt439                                                                                                 axe +o              m,+
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         2                                          41
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      40

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    214                                                                                                                                                                    110.04004
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   200
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  213                                                       1
                                                                                                  16                               rti        It6               d                                Llt        1f                                               20!                          /IS acE3                                                                                                                                                                                  Ia
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             000
                                                     .001          Oi :Oj                                                                                      00l.0                               tor oro ..000
                                                                                                                                                                                               000 01           t                     0t0                                                                                                -                                             0!                            0
                                                                                    90134                                                '1                .00
                                                                                                                                                            00E    ~~ 3
                                                                                                                                                              i10,IR                                ~-"i10'S . ~ "11j)O~
                                                                                                                                                                                                                      y .,.
                                                                                                                                                                                                                      It 7/ 3       040D f001j/4                                                                                          0                040                         001041)4I                                           44314a5
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                            00008
                                                                                                                            L3.f         'I            Lb                 ."""k164!
                                                                                                                                                                                                        m~
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           L                                                        43 Z04               1 39o                004          i6. l~a              0 t24 t6 y
        201 g                                                a483 ~0                                                                                         3                                             o      00.
                                                                                                                                                                                                                            4
                                                                                                                                                                                                                              t2I
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  a}     'lt 1
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 2L.3           26                         J.y4
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             El  \       ,,, 6
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       t044
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          00      N 6 220
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  ~       -4~t0.
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        L0 66                        22               2101f
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   2
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                41.   010 "14
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                            If.1]G1
                              404,                             0 ,                                                                                     ~~'0                                                     ,0-0                                                                                                                                                              t                        -. "'"'                                                                                                                                                                                         3tjl
           000.          0 oo
                            0 1!,!1                                                           I, 0                           ,.                                                            :           1-o4,&                                                                                                                                                                          ... '1,                     ..Z'm          iC 000         00        01
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               2 0110 4 0u p0' 41 /1 G 4 01,0 0:! 0 0 000 0a s4 4 0
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           ]sE


                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          as
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    all           {

          000g                  0 4              00.34 00                                             a100l                             tat40                   a             04.3                                                                                                             0.                                                                                                                          O3     0                      0q

                                                 ur~~
                                                  30                  24 1                              614                              4                 i        ~r
                                                                                                                                                                   j,, 01.3144L01}4040
                                                                                                                                                                              r                                                                                                                                                                           ,                           0*0-                                                                                                    005 000                         I186                         t ooG~                                                  :'
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 3Yo
                               2i'               1(/                                                                                          10                ..4Pa-. 't.-...,,    14<                                                                                                                            10               4'0 0                                                                                                      a             00000
                                                                                                                             2a a
                                                                                                                                                           04J....
                                                                                                                                                        SL000                                                                                                                                                                         366l-
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   .01                    101                                                                                          310                 -

                                                                                                                                                        13                 03      4w.._
                                                                                                                                                                                   000                                                                       Ito            04{tom0000                                                                                                                                                         00.3                                                                                                                                                              340
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         de.*                                                                   ,ao*
                   004 001
                       .4 00.4                            f900            \.              00210130O
                                                                                         Ott  44340'1!0
                                                                                                                                                                                                                     1                     5o
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     36i                          O                 1              294
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    i                                                                                                                                                                                                                    6                                484                     304;
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   as 4044




                                                             a;2                                                                                                                  tLI
                                                                                                                                                                               0034                                                                                                                                                                               143                         000~
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   1402014
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                ro't500oss                                                              o3                                                   4                                                               I111-
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                304


                                                                                                                                                                                      noe,                                                           C4                                     4(1t.
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  001.500]430 f.'16.                                        14111 .R
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        63109                                           1.4.*      .4 6
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                i; .1t                                                        0                                                                                                4!               04

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     36                                                      10-                4            l.--c-~I-
                        2+S
                                                                 la                                                                      001                                      (238 0201024 0041                                                      043                    34001.                         \     ('i                                                                                    41                                 011p81.0)03109
                                 7 ,0
                                 000     0S
                                  t10014SE4*                               4,1 10.103401
                                                                           4004a~                                                                                                 10ro
                                                                                                                                                                                      a0

                                                                                                                                                                                                                 o ar
                                                                                                                                                                                                                  (                                          0'tto
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             01-.4             1444
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             I0,o 000'O3OO404o1114a04.1.
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           00-.0)
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          4384t 0 9 1                 C4
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          4 0 0 0 0 0t05 4
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       U 'B
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    1
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         00                                                413
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                0                  e
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  35

                                02     L                                      ol     1Gl
                                                                                      011                                                                                          31                                                 <.1.40. no              040                         o             4.. 422.1HI34900
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     L                                                                                 003toot        2:.0701   t06 016
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           2140000    ' 004                                                                             00413 m                                                                                                               0'   400E

                                     0 4 ,d-
                                t0 4131si                001 441 70
                                                000~il 400~                  0 01Q                                                                                                                                                              00                          - !           CI         a0a                                          401                 ]2 204 120s4 a                                        ?1S0           '1 G 1042                                                                                         444                                    000
                                      too    440L       410       0'4 ,14'0W. <li!
                                                          404044411443
                                                                                                                                              404I~                                        0000
                                                                                                                                                                                                                Y                 2
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       0003                                           031 4L                                                                                ~         4r,           '04                01
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         1.01                                                        0
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           0             30
                                                                                XL I~~~~Oi                                                                                                         b~                         a                                                                                                                                                       Spot                                                             u                                                       r
                               430.                                    K1''04 .00
                                                                      00.4                 14                                                                       .1 010
                                                                                                                                                                         G                       ott i                                O                                                                    20.1                                                                       1 33f 4                       u       0                                 10                                                                                           0000
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                            4_04 I. s6
                       259           23420
                                                                           \0JA         0 23.4                                                                      .,-.                i&!.     141                          1                                     ]             +                             al2.oV                                                                                      6    ?      ta "t0          96                                          2                                                                 5    3
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                            0401046                                                                                            t00                                                                                        443                                   2l11 4 06z 6 f3 1r.
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             0000.y
                                            4'1                                01                                                                                                                                                                                                                       010.So.400                                                                                                00-0\ { t t04.Ig. j (p41
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 0
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         31               -058
                                                                                                                                   K.V.                                                                                                                                               "                   a 4 . ~ Nt041 °.a0t6.1                                                                           ato2oN.03 t I att 0. o~40. 001                                                       00040 Nx4,0I                                                              330b
                 25            2S41L!-0
                               23                        1       y    Yi            lJ
                                                                                                   j 4                                                               1.1'
                                                                                                                                                                                      , lb                 LLt/o,                                                                                           0\                 040
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     2524                                             003 201 21
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         r J$'
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           too
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          I.9




                                                              2340             o, 4               o         40 (14                      31t!<' 13                                                                                                                                                                          0.44                   lK-!
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   *or                                0L4                       040        409                          230a 040
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          42

              401 0001                                                                            01e3                                                                                                          j!            /004416                    43                                                                3    000      300,0
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          E5                                                                001is          -L2'o                443                                       24' o        400 45         321. a                                                                                     st
                                                                 26X,_033
                                                                       0000430e04S,
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   00.i0'444
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              3400214i
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             2P.0004
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           0 400040ll 2 1 Z34340 44
                 266           Eggoo 444                     t 020 th                                                            *'21!*d4                                             i41X09                                                                                                            - /                                       t 8 561 40f.13040 400 3                                       31S 3. 2'o                                                             <40 1.641                    3     600.
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               tomu


                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      G.
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     .4                                                                                                 2d6           040     406
                                     32'3                                            4.4                        L                                                        00;4                                                                   I                                                     3 }i -401 233341 33         3001     00'                                                                                                          n1'/(J,440,+\J 0 1 '1
        45.01G                          2L3.6}3                                                                             1
                                                                                                                            s}a1                                                                  !                                                                                                          1, 3 252 4 J.0424                 0 42400                                                                                                     404L~              3 44                                                                                                  .
                                330           3003040
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     1         04.0         1     2 10
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       046.rt240.44                                                                                                                      2443                             2440404                                      44.1                                                V-             11IL

                                          dt039040                                                                      0043001
                                                                                                                                                                                                                         '                                                                      1 }G  t53
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           0002      430.                                                                                                                     231                                                                           4P0s
                                               0-60                                                                   1060        0                                                                                                                                                                  J6                                                                                                                                                                                               1                                                    3,a
                                      0431 4'r 31                                                                     G4
                                                                                                                      000           801                                                                                                                                                          14S
                                                                                                                                                                                                                     6 3)
                               41                                                                                   4     4      4'3a4
                                                                                                                                                                                                           4"f0.0                                                                              14't3o...>;0                              04                                   21-0                                                                      40 L 4 t.1                  ."6 0013                                         00416 00 1
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  re
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  SSo


                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      zt


                       J0..4q440a                                                                  040.                                            9                     9                        4                                                                                                                                                   10.4                             o 19                 as.       .10 40400084 '13 /'1                               1.0234H5o 510
           4 00                      0'4-2$21                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    0'         0S:. '0                                     7431 I 1 4,43 0 3 ('6 11 A1- 1 7 39 4                                                                                                     5
                                         J4
                                       413                                 404                                                          ash.                                      0a46{,..                                                                 t.                   Sal                      1                 \00                                                        4oO
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     1403
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          24'30
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           "4.004                                                                                             324.'
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 4404d
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           3
        E44246              41
                            291      407                                                                                                                                                                                                       000-Il                                                                                         t               0334                llt20n.8.x1.6 3 22.104
                         2'    2 .13       00                                                 * 41.6.2±3010                                                                                       41                                  02D00a.+Lt                                       \0                                                                                                                11400,                                                                          401                                                                                                330
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          0 1'
                                                                                                    as*L1.1                                                                                     'S                                                                  1                                              \ 1                                                                          fn oo 01       2                                                    15El                                                             39L                                                                        5




                                                                                                                                        0004
                                                                                                                                          24                             e 2936                   (                  ,"                                                                                             0                .r a 05 0 '0 4                                                    8.026                                                  2 1t .               b ?24%                                    0                         0




                                                          T IDE                S.                                                        o0s           o            t.                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               SOUNDI NGS.
                                                                                                                                             7'        29m
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               Scre of/ eet                                                                                                                                                   Sounod ro'<gsored4ex                            #o.'ssed ito                                 .Ct'0'tand               te       ,4t1,,oa,              "!refer
        High     Water              Mean interval after preceding                                                                   .
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        to /Wecan Lo.,                                             rLo                   C~dAooeShroe Ldoocn, .1>,                                                     /qllooh
        Low       ..             Transit                 of the Moon .                            ...                                             133 44'
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               Scale         of ,r,-.(es                                                                                                                               Thoej                 eel curve esro                            4/oorr_               r4ts
        MeanOt   Rise a.nd      Fall of                  Tides        .        .     .    .       .             .       .          .         4.8 feet

                                                     .Spring Tides . .                                  .           .        .     .          S.6 .,
                                                 . Neap Tides                            .        .         .       .        .     .         4.0                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  30     ..              ..                 ....                                           .


                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     To accompan3 y Annuj.zzL Revortfor/ 1                                                                                              86

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     N ote

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       Lieu L.               Ccot, of                            £n tee'r,USA
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              The
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        b/ar I,,
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        a/'   -des:
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         Ch/.,-L
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              eo       47444

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               'zo'rd hi, /uis'
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 pO'/roNposed '
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    a 1.4                jtr ''
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             a';,.z
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              C Lbe 444414414/
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              344b4os
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               4 44447
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    ,r/cr*,,q
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         .1/e
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                            '00b1'cnc

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             (    hr
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 dholo by dot/ri
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               /nsin,,o
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              i
    I                                                                                                                                                                                                                    I                                                                                                                                         _                                       _                          _                                 _                                                -                                                                                                     r_-r                       -
              APPENDIX E-REPORT                                                         OF LIEUT.-COL.     MCFARLAND.            743
   The Gedney's Channel improvement has been conducted under the
personal supervision of Assistant Engineer Maurice Kingsley, whose
energy and industry in laying out the work, watching all its details,
directing the action of the excavators, collecting valuable information,
and making the necessary soundings and surveys under many difficul-
ties and discouragements entitle him to the strongest commendation.
  This work is in the collection district of New York.                                                  Nearest light-house, Sandy
Hook Light. The nearest fort is the fort at Sandy Hook.
Amount of revenue collected at the port of New York during the year ending June
30, 1886, $132,536,402.02.
                                                           AMOUNT                       APPROPRIATED.

By act of July 5, 1884             .....--...........................................                                     $200, 000 00,
Amount expended to date........................-..................                                                   ..     40, 812 51



                                                                  Money statement.
July 1, 1885, amount available.......................................            $168, 469 35
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive
  of liabilities outstanding July 1, 1885 ....................        $27,281 86
July 1, 1886, outstanding liabilities ........................         27,115 37
                                                                                                                             54,397 2<3

July 1, 1886, amount available ........................................                                                    132,072 12
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886 ..............-----------------...                                      750,000 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887..................                                                    882,072 12

 (Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project ......                                                   6,000,000 00
j Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June
     30, 1888-------------------------------------------................................................--------..        1,000,000 00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
     harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.




                                                                                        E Io.
                     IMPROVEMENT OF SHEEPSHEAD BAY, NEW YORK.

   Sheepshead Bay, Long Island, is a small tidal bay on the west side of
Rockaway Inlet, running from it westward for 2 miles to the village of
Gravesend, inside and parallel to the Coney Island Beach.
   Its mouth, where it connects with Rockaway Inlet, is subject to ma-
terial changes, from the making and cutting away of the beach and
from the changes in the location of the shoals outside, owing to storms.
Its width varies from 100 to 1,000 feet, and its depth from 2 to 10 feet at
mean low water.
   The first survey, with a view to its improvement, was made under
direction of General John Newton, Corps of Engineers, in 1879, whose
report may be found on page 400, Annual Report of the Chief of En-
gineers for 1879; date of original report February 7, 1879.
   The project for its improvement provides for diking the channel and
connecting it with Rockaway Inlet, at a cost of $100,000 (incorrectly
printed in Annual Report of the Chief Engineers as $10,000).        Subse-
quently it was proposed to connect Sheepshead Bay with Dead Horse
Inlet instead of with Rockaway Inlet.
   The first appropriation for this improvement was made June 14, 188(
744       REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

($3,000), but General Newton, on page 515 Annual Report of the Chief
®fEngineers for 1880, states as follows:
  The position and even existence of this outlet will depend upon the advance of Rock-
away Inlet, which is now advancing westerly at the rate af 264 feet per year.
  The total estimate for this improvement is about $100,000, and for this reason and
the one cited above, I would respectfully recommend awaiting developments and
euther appropriations.
  By act of March 3, 1881, $5,000 more was appropriated, making a
total amount available June 30, 1881, of $8,000; but no work was done
up to the close of the fiscal year.
   No appropriation was made and no work was done during the fiscal
year ending June 30, 1882. A survey was made during this year, which
developed marked changes in the shoals westward of the mouth, and,
based upon it, General Newton suggested making the outlet from Sheeps-
head Bay through Dead Horse Inlet instead of through Rockaway Inlet.
   Two estimates of the cost of doing this were furnished, as follows:
                                               (I.)
Cut to connect Shlieepshead Bay with Dead Horse Inlet, 100 feet wide, 6 feet
  deep at mean low water; 52,000 cubic yards, at 35 cents .................. $18, 200
x,200 feet of creosoted diking to sustain bend in cut, at $6-.-:.-....'.."..  37,200
7,500 feet of creosoted diking for interior channels, at $5..........37,500
      Total of first estimate.............
                            ---------------------------------------.-.-..-...   62,900
                                               (II.)
Out to connect Sheepshead Bay with Dead Horse Inlet, 100 feet wide, to 6 feet
deep at mean low water; 52,000 cubic yards, at 35 cents..................      18,200
Dredging interior channel; 40,000 cubic yards, at 40 cents..................    16,000

      Total of second estimate..............               ..   ......          34,200


a~mount
   By act of August 2, 1882, $3,000 was appropriated, making a total
          available of $11,000, less about $650 spent on surveys.
   On the 22d of September, 1882, a contract, at 45 cents per cubic yard,
was awarded to H. N. and A. J. Beardsley for dredging the proposed new
channel into Dead Horse Inlet, but the property-owners represented that
the present outlet was sufficient, and that it would be of more benefit to
increase the depth in the inner bay. After a good deal of correspondence,
it was decided to make the cut to Dead Horse Inlet a little to the north-
ward of the cut originally laid out.. It was to be 40 feet wide and 5 feet
deep at mean low water.
   The contract was commenced November 5, 1883, and was completed
iDecember 22, 1883. Twenty thousand yards were excavated and
iplaced on the northern side of the cut, behind a bulkhead built along
the line of the cut, at the cost, jointly, of the property-holders and the
contractor.
   On the 5th of July, 1884, a further appropriation was made of $5,000,
and sealed proposals were opened September 15, 1884, for continuing
the dredging in the cut and widening it to 100 feet, with a depth of 6
feet at mean low water.
   The contract was let to the Atlantic Dredging Company, the lowest
bidder, at 134 cents per cubic yard.
   Work under this contract was begun August 29, 1885, and continued
mntil January 13, 1886, in which time 21,256 cubic yards of material
ihad been excavated, increasing the total width of the cut to nearly 100
feet.
   A recent examination shows that the last cut holds its depth well;
bout that the northern 40 feet of width has shoaled from .05 to 2 feet.
   The direct passage into Rockaway Inlet has opened again during the
                APPENDIX                 E-REPORT OF LIEUT.-COL. MCFARLAND.                                                             745
winter, and it is probable that if this is not kept closed there will not
be enough tide through the new inlet to keep it open, as the natural
scour is through the old channel.
   The $5,000 appropriated August 5, 1886, will be applied probably to
dredging the north side of the new channel to a depth of 5 feet, and also
to dredging off the points of two small bars which have formed at each
end of the cut, and if this does not exhaust the appropriation the re-
mainder may be applied to closing the old channel by diking.
   There appears to have been some error in the statistics of Sheepshead
Bay, furnished by one of its residents in 1884, and upon which state-
ments of the amount of commerce likely to be benefited by its improve-
ment have been based.
   Inquiry made during the present season shows that the place has no
commerce, and that the large amounts of material reported as belong-
ing to the commerce of the place, if brought there at all, was brought
for the construction and use of hotels and private residences, by rail and
by wagon, from Brooklyn, and that the bay was not and could not be
used for this purpose on account of its shallowness.
   The vessels and boats which make use of this harbor draw less than
4 feet of water, for which the present channel is amply sufficient.
   The question of the improvement of the inner bay' is purely a local
one, as its object is to improve the boating facilities of the bay which
lies inside of Coney Island, for the benefit of Gravesend and the large
hotels on Coney Island.
   There appears to be no necessity at present for making further ap-
propriations for this bay.
                                                                APPROPRIATIONS.


     Date.                                                                 Application.                                              Amount.


June 14,1880 Dredging ... ...............................................................                                               $3, 000
Mar. 3,1881             ......
                   do------........................---.............................................          ------------                 5,000
Aug. 2,1882 ...... do .....................................................................                -----------                   3,000
July 5, 1884 ..... do---..........-------....--....................---------------............---------...............---........        5, 000
Aug. 5,1886 ----------------------------------...                                      ------------------------------                    5..........
                                                                                                                                         5,000

                              Total ......................................--------.--.-------------                                     21,000

   Amount expended to June 30, 1886, $15,716.27.

  This work is in the collection district of New York, which is the nearest port of
entry. Nearest light-house, Fort Tompkins Light. Nearest fort, Fort Hamilton.
Amount of revenue collected at the port of New York during the fiscal year ending
June 30, 1886, $132,536,402.02.
                                                                       ESTIMATE.
Original estimate of 1879..............------..-....--.....--..........----....------....----......                                  $100,000
Revised estimates of 1882 ......---......----......-------....---......----....---......----...---..-.                                 62,900
Revised estimates of 1882 .................................                               .
                                                                                     ......-   .......                                 34,200


                                                             Money statement.
July 1, 1885, amount available..........................................                                                            $4,967 83
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
   outstanding July 1, 1885...-----------------                                                                                     4,684 10
July 1, 1886, amount available .............                                               .........................          .        283 73
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886---
                                                   .----....-....-----....--......                                                  5,000 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887---------....-----....--....--.......                                          5,283 73

  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project........                                                            13, 200 00
  *Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscalyearendingJune30, 1888                                                           10, 000 00
1 Submitted in              compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
( harbor acts               of 1866 and 1867.
746     REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.


                                  E ii.
             IMPROVEMENT OF CANARSIE BAY, NEW YORK.

  Canarsie Bay is the name given to a shoal tidal bay forming the north-
western part of Jamaica Bay on the south side of Long Island, whose
waters flow into the Atlantic Ocean through Rockaway Inlet.
  Canarsie is practically an eastern suburb of the city of Brooklyn,
and the terminus of the Brooklyn, Rockaway and Jamaica Bay Rail-
road. From Canarsie, during the summer months, two boats make trips
to Rockaway Beach.
  The first survey of it by the United States Government, with a view
to its improvement, was made under direction of General (then Col.)
John Newton, Corps of Engineers, in 1879, and the results may be found
in Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1879, page 400.
  The scheme of improvement, proposed in the report, is briefly to make
a navigable channel from the shore at Canarsie Landing to the good
navigable channel in Jamaica Bay, a distance of about 3,500 feet.
  The depth of this channel was to be 6 feet at mean low water, which
was to be obtained by contracting it by means of two pile-dikes, 8 feet
wide, filled in with stone, as it was not believed that dredged channels
.would remain permanently open. The estimated cost of this project
was $88,000. The rise and fall of tide here is 4.7 feet, and the low-water
depth is 4.5 feet.
  The first appropriation for the work was that of June 14, 1880,
$10,000; and a contract was let November 11, 1880, to Henry Du Bois &
Sons, for the construction of the outer 1,000 feet of the north dike, from
the deep channel in Jamaica Bay towards Canarsie Landing. This con-
tract was completed June 27, 1881, and it was proposed to apply further
appropriations to the construction of the south dike, which, commenc-
ing close to the outer end of the north dike, was to run up to Canarsie
landing. This was designed to be of sheet-piling, strongly braced, the
estimated cost being $14,000.
   By act of March 3, 1881, the sum of 5,000 was appropriated, but it
was not deemed sufficient to commence the dike, and therefore it was
not expended during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1882.
   By act of August 2, 1882, $3,000 was appropriated, which brought
the available balance up to over $8,000, which was not enough to justify
beginning the diking; and in view of the little chance of sufficient
funds for this purpose being soon appropriated, it was deemed advisable
to apply the available funds to dredging; proposals for this work were
therefore called for, and were opened September 22, 1882, and the work
was let to the lowest bidder, Elijah Brainard, at 48 cents per cubic yard.
   This contract was not begun till February 8, 1883, and it was finished
March 31, 1883, during which time 9,726 cubic yards were removed from
the channel, giving a channel 6 feet deep at mean low water, and from
50 to 75 feet wide, from the outer end of the dike to the Canarsie Land-
ing. Narrow cuts were also made at the wharf, and the outer end of
the dike was protected by building and sinking a crib 15 feet square.
   No work was done during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1884.
   By act of July 5, 1884, the sum of $5,000 was appropriated for this
work, under which a contract was let to Henry Du Bois & Sons, Septem-
ber 17, 1884, for contiinuing the dredging at 35 cents per cubic yard, and
for extending the north dike eastward 50 feet, at $29.37 per linear foot.
Work under this contract was begun October 9, and was completed
        APPENDIX     E-REPORT      OF LIEUT.-COL.     MCFARLAND.       747
November 6, 1884, during which time the proposed eastern extension or
50 feet of dike was completed, and 7,535 cubic yards of material were re-
moved from the channel. At the close of the contract the channel was
125 feet wide at the outer end and 50 feet at the Canarsie Landing.
   On page 739, Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1885, Part
I, Colonel Gillespie, then in charge, makes the recommendation that
$25,000 be appropriated for the continuation of the improvement, to be
applied to the construction of 300 feet of the south dike, to the extension
eastward of the north dike 250 feet, and to the widening to 100 feet of
the western end of the channel towards Canarsie Landing.
   No funds have been available nor has any work been done during the
fiscal year ending June 30, 18860 $10,000 was appropriated by act of
August 5,1886.
   A recent examination shows that a material change has taken place
in the channel, and that it might be well to modify the last project.
   A shoal constituting a serious obstruction has been formed from north-
east to southwest across the head of the north dike, which throws the
ebb current directly across to the head of a sand island on the south
side of the channel. The head and north side of this island have been
cut away, and a sand point, extending out towards the north dike, has
formed a bar across the channel about two-thirds of the way down the
dike. On both of these bars there is 4.5 feet at mean low water; but om
account of the short turns, the channels through them are only avail.
able for a 4-foot draught. It is reported that both of these bars formed
this spring when the ice was running.
   The current from that part of Jamaica Bay which lies north and north-
east of Canarsie crosses the channel to Canarise at right angles, and
this channel cannot be expected to remain open unless the current is
deflected along its axis by means of diking such as was originally pro-
posed by General Newton. Every year until that is done there will be
more or less shoaling, and especially around the head and foot of the
north dike.
   From all accounts the running ice on the ebb is very heavy at times
in Jamaica Bay, and it is an open question if sheet-piling would with-
stand it. It might be better, therefore, to substitute a pile dike 5 feet
wide, which could be built for from $5 to $8 per foot if creosoted timber is
not used. The teredo can have little effect in the shoal brackish waters
of Jamaica Bay, and it is worth while trying uncreosoted piles.
   The $10,000 appropriated by act of August 5, 1886, will therefore be
applied to the construction of the southern dike, to be built of two rows
of piles, not creosoted, 5 feet apart, the space between them to be filled
with stone.
   Canarsie, apart from being the terminus of the Brooklyn, Rockaway
and Jamaica Bay Railroad, from which people transship by steamer to
Rockaway Beach, has a large fishing industry.
   Jamaica Bay is most favorable for oyster culture, and most of the
oysters are sent to New York by boat or by wagon from Canarsie. It is
stated that 500,000 bushels of oysters, 10,000 bushels of clams, and
$10,000 worth of blue-fish are shipped from there annually, and that
there are over 200 vessels and open boats engaged in the trade, drawing
from 1 to 5 feet water.
   Two steamers make six trips a day from Canarsie to Rockaway dur-
ing the summer, each drawing about 4 feet water; and the Edith Peck
makes four or five trips a day the year roundL to Barren Island, her
draught being nearly 4 feet.
748            REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                                                                       U. S. ARMY.

   As a northwesterly wind often makes a fall of level in the bay of from
1 to 1.5 feet below mean low water, it would seem that 6 feet at mean
low water at least should be maintained in the improved channel.
   Original estimate for dikes of creosoted timber, $88,000.

                                                          AMOUNTS         APPROPRIATED.


                                 Date.                                                             Application.                                          Amount.


June 14, 1880 ..........                  .......................             Diking .....              ................                          ...      $10, 000
March 3, 1881 ........                        .................                Dredging      --.....-......                                 ...              5,000
August 2, 1882..........                   ....................           .   -. . do   .           .         ..      .................                      3,000
July 5, 1885.......................................                           Dredging and diking.................                                           5,000
       Total....................................                                                              ................            .....             23,000

  Amount expended, $22,800.89.

  This work is in the collection district of New York, which is the nearest port of
entry. Nearest light-house, Fort Tompkins Light. Nearest fort, Fort Hamilton.
Amount of revenue collected at the port of New York for the fiscal year ending Jane
30, 1886, $132,536,402.02.
                                                                    Money statement.
July 1, 1885, amount available........................................                                                                                   $486 74
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885.............................     .............                                                                                  287 63
July 1, 1886, amount available.................................   ....                                                                                     199 11
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886...................                                                                                   10,000 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887....................                                                                               10, 199 11

   Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1888 25, 000 00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
     harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.



                                                                         E 12.

                   IMPROVEMENT OF SUMPAWANUS INLET, NEW YORK.

  Sumpawanus Inlet, known originally and on the Coast Survey charts
as Sumpwams Creek, is a small creek on the south side of Long Island,
emptying into the Great South Bay, near Babylon.
  It.lies about 36 miles east of New York City, 15 miles east of the
western end of Great South Bay, and nearly double as much from the
eastern end.
  Fire Island Inlet, through which most of the waters of Great South
Bay pass into the Atlantic Ocean, lies south-southeast about 6 miles di-
rect, but 11 miles by the channel.
  The inlet is a tidal creek. from 100 to 200 feet wide, running up to the
town of Babylon, Long Island, which is situated 1 mile north of the
mouth. It is crossed there by a dam, which forms a reservoir for the
fresh water of a small creek which supplies the town with water.
  The mean rise and fall of tides at the mouth of the inlet is only 1.3
feet, and the bottom of the bay and of the inlet is soft mud.
  The first survey of Sumpawanus Creek was ordered by act of Con-
gress approved June 14, 1880; and was made during the fall of 1880
under direction of General (then Col.) John Newton, Corps of En-
        APPENDIX    E-REPORT       OF LIEUT.-COL.    MCFARLAND.       749
gineers. His report may be found on page 653, Annual Report of the
Chief of Engineers for 1881, Part I.
   The project based upon this survey, was briefly to dredge a channel
150 feet wide and 5 feet deep, at mean low water, from the 5-foot curve
in the bay to the steamboat dock at the mouth of the creek, a distance
of about 1,500 feet, and thence 5 feet deep and 100 feet wide up the
inlet to the town of Babylon, a distance of about 3,500 feet. The esti-
mated cost of the improvemeht was $23,115.
   The mean range of tides at the mouth of the inlet being only 1.3 feet,
there was practically no scour. The depth of water in the proposed
channel at the time of the survey was from 1 to 3 feet in the inlet, and
from 3 to 5 feet outside.
    It was not believed that diking would assist this improvement; and
inquiry showed that the depth of water both outside and inside the in-
let had materially diminished in late years.
   By act of Congress approved March 3, 1881, $5,000 was appropriated
for this improvement; but nothing was done during the years ending
June 30, 1881, and June 30, 1882, because the amount was too small to
warrant beginning the work.
    By act of August 2, 1882, a further sum of $2,000 was appropriated;
and proposals were called for and were opened September 22, 1882, for
dredging outside the mouth of the inlet.
   John McDermott was the lowest bidder, at 69 cents per cubic yard,
and a contract for the work was entered into with him. Work was
begun April 9, 1883, and was closed May 17, 1883, during which time
9,481 cubic yards of material had been removed.
   This gave a channel not less than 75 feet wide. and 5 feet deep up
to the steamboat wharf, from a point 750 feet outside of and southeast
of it, and single cuts 25 feet wide were made to the northeast and west
sides of the wharf, in order to facilitate the landing of steamboats.
   The estimated cost of dredging in the original project was 30 cents
per cubic yard; but Colonel Gillespie, in his annual report fQr 1883,
Part I, page 568, of the Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers, esti-
mates that the future dredging would not cost less than 50 cents per
cubic yard, and therefore made a modification of the original report,
estimating the cost of the dredging at $40,000, of which $7,000 have
been appropriated.
   No appropriations have been made since that of August 2, 1882, and
no work has been done since the close of McDermott's contract on May
17, 1883.
   A recent examination shows that the channel is in much the same
condition as after the work of 1883, except that the expected shoaling
spoken of by General Newton in his preliminary report is continually
taking place.
   The cut itself has shoaled about half a foot, and the flat outside about
the same, giving about 5 feet in the dredged channel, but only 4 to 41
feet outside, except in a small channel which has been kept open by the
passing steamboats.
   The commerce of Sumpawanus Creek is peculiar. Babylon, 1 mile
above the mouth of the inlet, is a small town of 3,000 to 5,000 inhabit-
ants, and depends almost entirely upon the summer trade of the hotels
and cottages along the north shore of Great South Bay, and upon the
hotels on Fire Island Beach.
   To Fire Island Beach, in summer, three steamers run daily, drawing
from 4 to 5 feet of water.
750             REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U S. ARMY.

   The actual commerce of Babylon by water has been decreasing from
all accounts; for the reason, first, that the Long Island Railroad has
taken away the sea-going business; and second, that the depth of water
has decreased too much for sea-going vessels, even of light draught, to
enter. Babylon itself has improved immensely, and has become a fash-
ionable summer resort. At present the commerce of Babylon is carried
on by three steamboats, drawing from 4 to 5 feet, running in summer to
Fire Island Beach; three schooners, drawing from 5 to 5, feet, bringing
brick, lime, lumber, and other heavy freight to Babylon the year round;
one hundred sloops and pleasure boats, drawing from 1 to 2 feet of water,
taking out sailing and fishing parties during the summer; of which
seven or eight remain in use during the winter fishing and taking oys-
ters and clams to Patchogue, Sayville, and New York.
   No oysters are brought to Babylon from the bay, and only a few clams
in the summer for home consumption.
   No statement of commerce appears in the annual reports, except in
two letters dated May 16, 1883 (presumably), one furnished by a gentle-
man of the name of Sammis from Patchogue, who has large interests
in Babylon; and another furnished by the United States inspector at
that time, who has evidently made the mistake of including the whole
commerce of the Great South Bay in the commerce of Sumpawanus
Creek and Babylon.
   The commerce of the creek, in my judgment, only warrants the dredg-
ing of a 5 foot channel from the 5-foot curve in the bay to the steam-
boat wharf for the use of the steamers, and so that the few schooners
which come in can come up to the wharf without the expense of light-
erage.
   So far as the extension of the improvement from the steamboat dock
up the inlet is concerned, I see no reason to continue it.
   From all accounts the shoals in the bay kill the sea so entirely that
the pleasure boats can lie in the mouth of the creek in all weathers, and
the freighting interest is too small to warrant the cost of the improve-
ment.
   The original estimate of the work was $23,115.
   The modified estimate is $40,000, of which $7,000 has been appropri-
ated. $10,000 can be profitably expended in giving a 5-foot channel out
into the bay for the use of steamboats, but [ think that the work is
more a matter of private interest than work that should be undertaken
by the Government.
   Revised estimate for dredging channel, $40,000.
                                                            AMOUNTS                APPROPRIATED.



      Date.                                                                       Application.                                    Amount.


M ar. 3, 1881          Dredging.......................................                                ........................       $5, 000
Aug. 2, 1882           Dredging...............................................................-----                                   2,000

                                                                                                                                       7, 000

Amount expended ......................-------------------------....................----                                          . $6,918 12

  This work is in the collection district of New York, which is the nearest port of en-
try. Nearest light-house, Fire Island Light; nearest fort, Fort Hamilton. Amount
of revenue collected at the port of New York during the fiscal year ending June 30,
1886, $132,536,402.02.
              APPENDIX              E-REPORT                    OF LIEUT.-COL.               MCFARLAND.               751
                                                   Money statement.
July 1, 1885, amount available........-    -------....----......-----..........-......
                                                                               ---                                  $106 93
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
    outstanding July 1,1881----....----....---......-------------------......---...--....-------....---....-          25 05
July 1, 1886, amount available......                     ....       ............    -.    ... --.....   .....   .     81 88



{
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887 ...................

    Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project-........33, 000 00
    Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1888 10, 000 00
    Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
                                                                                                                      81 88




      harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.




                                                                E       13.

            IMPROVEMENT OF THE MANASQUAN RIVER, NEW JERSEY.

   The Manasquan River, New Jersey, empties into the Atlantic Ocean
midway between Sandy Hook and Barnegat Inlet, which are about 50
miles apart.
   For the first 3 miles up from the mouth it consists of a tidal estuary
about one-third of a mile in width. For the next 2 miles it contracts to
a width of from 100 to 150 feet; above this it opens out into a second
basin 2 miles long and one-fourth mile in width. The depth of the lower
basin is from 4 to 5 feet; the depth of the upper basin is from 3 to 4 feet
at mean low water. The mean rise and fall of tide in the lower basin,
near the mouth, is said to be about 2 feet, and at the head of the upper
basin is zero, in ordinary weather.
   The Manasquan, with its tributaries, drains an area of over 80 square
miles.
   The mouth has been, and is still, obstructed by movable bars and
shoals of shifting sand, which are influenced by heavy storms.
   The depth of water on these bars has varied in the last eight years
from 1 to 4 feet at mean low water. Once during that time, after a heavy
storm, the outlet was entirely closed.
   The first survey of this river, with a view to its improvement, was
made by Captain Ludlow, in 1878, under direction of Col. J. N. Macomb,
Corps of Engineers, the report on which may be found on page 463 of
the Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1879, Part I.
   The commerce of the river at that time was practically nothing, but
it was expected to increase if a stable outlet could be procured by arti-
ficial means, and it was also expected that it would be uged as a harbor
of refuge for small coasting and fishing vessels when they were pre-
vented by storms from making a safe harbor at Sandy Hook or Barne-
gat Inlet.
   It was proposed to make a straight cut from the river into the ocean
across the bar at the mouth, the cut to be about 200 feet wide and not
less than 6 feet deep at mean low water and to be protected by parallel
jetties, and a basin was to be dredged inside the jetties about 2,000 feet
long, 200 feet wide, and 5 feet deep. The jetties were each to be built
of two rows of piles, creosoted, and the spaces between the piles were
to be filled with stone. Twelve thousand dollars was also to be expended
for the removal of wrecks and snags. The total estimated cost of the
project was $52,120.
752      REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                     U. S   ARMY.

  This project was referred for discussion to the Board of Engineers for
Fortifications and River and Harbor Improvements. Their report may
be found on page 548 of Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1880, Part I.
  Briefly, they reported that the project was insufficient to secure any
permanent results; that the jetties, instead of being carried out to the
shore-line, would have at least to be carried out to the 2-fathom curve;
that they would have to be of a more stable form of construction; and
that, at a rough estimate, the total cost of the improvement required to
give a harbor of refuge such as Colonel Macomb proposed would be from
$200,000 to $260,000. Their conclusions are as follows:
The Board are of the opinion that the piers, as recommended in the project sub-
mitted, will not avail to keep open a good entrance from the seaward; that the piers
will require further extension at great cost; and that the passage of vessels through
such a long narrow outer entrance to reach the inner harbor, even if the depth be
sufficient, will not be safe during a heavy storm.
  The inner harbor, for which an estimate for deepening has been submitted by the
local engineer, may require some works of contraction to preserve its depth.
  The cost, however, will probably be small, and has not been considered for want of
the requisite data.
  The Board are by no means satisfied that the uses to which the harbor, improved
as in the project, could be put would prove of much public benefit.
  A harbor of refuge is probably needed along this coast, but it should be sufficiently
deep and spacious to admit the larger classes of coasting vessels. Such harbor could
be constructed only upon a plan modified considerably from the one presented, and
at much greater cost.
  As, however, $12,000 had been appropriated by the act approved
March 3, 1879, the Board were of the opinion that Colonel Macomb's
project, with certain modifications of construction, should be carried out,
with a view only to straightening the channel at the mouth through
the sand-bar, which then ran across it from the south beach.
  Bids were accordingly opened, after due advertisement, and a con-
tract was entered into with C. F. Drake, April 18, 1879, for beginning
the construction of the dikes. The contractor failed to commence
operations, the contract was annulled, and no work was done that
year.
  On the 14th of June, 1880, an additional appropriation of $20,000
was made; and, under date of June 9, 1880, the question of the im-
provement of Manasquan River was referred to Lieut. Col. N. Michler,
Corps of Engineers, who had relieved Colonel Macomb, for report.
The report may be found on page 712, Annual Report of Chief of En-
gineers for 1881, Part I.
  Colonel Michler's report emphasizes that of the Board of Engineers,
and states besides-
  That since this subject was first discussed the facilities of communication and
transportation to and from the valley have been very much increased within the last
few months; in fact, all difficulties removed by the extension of the Long Branch
Division of the Jersey Central Railroad to and across the Manasquan River as far as
Point Pleasant.
  The road crosses the river over a pile bridge about 1 mile above its mouth. The
construction of this road obviates to a great degree the necessity for the proposed im-
provemient, as now the lack of communication is supplied.
  He also stated it to be his opinion that, if a harbor of refuge were
necessary at that point, it could not be constructed without great ex-
pense, not at all proportionate to its utility or importance.
  Further, that, "should it be decided to attempt some plan and pros-
ecute it towards its completion, the general lines of dikes as proposed
by Colonel Macomb, as described in his report and in that of the Board
of Engineers, might be successfully adopted," with certain modifica.
        APPENDIX    E-REPORT       OF LIEUT.-COL. MCFARLAND.          753
tions of construction ; but that there was every chance of a storm de-
molishing the whole structure, or of a single gale changing the entire
nature and position of the inlet under discussion; so that no safe esti-
mate could be made of the probable final cost.
    Colonel Michler's project was approved by the Chief of Engineers,
and, after due advertisement, a contract was let for the construction of
the north jetty to Henry Du Bois & Son; but, owing to the lateness of
the season, work was not begun until June 17, 1881.
    WVork on the construction of the north jetty was continued from that
date up to March 8, 1882, when the contract was closed. The total
length of the jetty, when the contract was closed, was 1,515 feet.
    This jetty, starting from a point of salt marsh, known as Stump
Point, and running in a general southeasterly direction, closed entirely
the old outlet of 1879 to the northward, and turned the current of the
river almost directly along its inner side of the jetty seaward. The
scour on the inner side of the jetty, near the outer end, necessitated its
reinforcement by a crib 130 feet long, and the whole line of diking was
protected by fascine mats, and riprap on the river face, and bags of sand
on the inner side.
    Spur-dams of plank, fascines, and sand-bags were also built at right
angles to the line of the dike on the north side to arrest the sand, and
relieve the dike from the pressure produced by the emptying and filling
of the tidal reservoir above.
    Upon the completion of the work, the depth of the water on the outer
bar was approximately 4 feet at low water, and the channel was par-
allel with the axis of the dike.
    A sum of $40,000 was estimated as necessary for extending the north
jetty 255 feet seaward, to its full projected extent, and to build 905 feet
of jetty on the south side.
    A sketch of the condition of the improvement June 30, 1882, with de-
tails of the construction of the jetty, may be found opposite page 702,
Annual Report of the Chief of Enginersfor 1882, Part I.
    On the 2d of August, 1882, a further sum of $7,000 was appropriated
for the improvement; making the total available, including the balance
of the old appropriation $8,500.
    A contract was let in October, 1882, to Stephen A. Kelly for the con-
struction of part of the south jetty. Operations were begun under this
contract in November, 1882, and were closed June 30, 1883, during
which time 475 feet of the jetty had been completed.
    The outer end of the south jetty starts at a point 100 feet inside the
outer end of the north jetty, and 200 feet from it to the southward.
For the first 100 feet inward it is parallel to the north jetty; but the
inner end of the second 100 feet is 240 feet from the north jetty; the re-
maining 275 feet inwards is thrown back from the channel to the south-
ward, so as to prevent the cutting of the beach behind the jetty, and
deflect the current towards the center of the channel. The outer 200
feet of this jetty is formed by two rows of piles sawed off at 1 foot
above mean high water, set 12 feet apart from "inside to outside," the
space between being filled with stone. Over the remaining 275 feet the
jetty is only 5 feet wide.
    It was reported, at the close of the year 1883, that the condition of
the improvement was satisfactory, and the extension of the north jetty
500 feet seaward, and the south jetty 300 feet seaward and 300 feet
shoreward, was recommended, the estimated cost of which was $33,000.
    No appropriation has been made, and no work his been done since
June 30, 1883.
      48E
754     REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

   In 1884 it was reported that there had not been less than from 24 to
3 feet at mean low water on the bar since the construction of the jetties,
but that a shoal inside them, starting from the inner end of the north
jetty, was making rapidly to the southward, throwing the currents at
half-tide towards the south side of the channel, which resulted in cutting
round back of the inner end of the south jetty; and. to prevent a breach
from being made in the beach back of the south jetty, an appropriation
of $30,000 was urged for extending the south jetty shoreward 300 feet,
and for repairing it; for extending the north jetty 300 feet seaward;
and for dredging part of the shoal putting out from the inner end of the
north jetty.
   In 1885 an examination showed that there was a depth over the bar
of 3 feet at mean low water, that the shoal at the inner end of the north
jetty had materially increased to the southward, and consequently that
the deep.water channel had been still further thrown forward towards
the south bank, and an appropriation of $25,000 was asked for to ex-
tend both jetties seaward 300 feet, to extend the south jetty shoreward
100 feet, and to dredge the inner shoal so as to bring the channel more
in a line with the axis of the jetties.
   No money has been available and no work has been done during the
fiscal year ending June 30, 1886.
   A recent examination, however, shows the condition of the improve-
ment to be very unsatisfactory, and proves conclusively the correctness
of the opinions of the Board of Engineers in 1879, and of Colonel Mich-
ler in 1880, mentioned above; and also had sufficient money been ap-
propriated for the extension of the shore-arm of the south jetty, asked
for in 1884, that many of the present bad features might have been
averted.
   The beach has made out on the north side of the north jetty till the
mean high-water mark is only 20 feet inside it, and the high-water shore-
line on the south side has made past the outer end of the south jetty,
as originally predicted by the Board of Engineers.
   Across the mouth, and distant about 200 feet seaward of the outer end
of the north jetty, is a bar parallel with the beach, a-wash at low water,
extending some 500 feet north of the north jetty, and 200 feet south of
the south jetty. Between it and the shore-line there is a channel around
the north and south ends of the shoal with about 2 feet of water over
it at mean low water.
   The shoal putting out southward from the shore end of the north jetty
has increased till at mean low water it is bare within about 30 feet of
the inner end of the south jetty; and the larger part of it is about 2 feet
out of water at low water.                              ,
   This has thrown the deep-water channel over to the southward, so
that the inner portion of the south pier, which is deflected over to the
southward, is in the deepest water of the channel; the filling is all
washed out; and the mean low-water line of the south shore runs about
150 feet inside the inner end of the jetty. A deep hole has been scoured
out under this 150 feet of the inner end. The current is then deflected
across the channel almost at right angles towards the north jetty; and a
deep hole with from 10 to 12 feet of water scoured along its face, grad-
ually diminishing in depth towards the outer end, to about 5 feet.
   The outer end of the south jetty is covered with sand which has come
over into the channel, forming a beach inside it 20 feet wide at mean
low water.
   The channel now from the ocean into the bay may be fairly said to be
in worse condition than at the time of the survey of 1879.
               APPENDIX      E---REPORT OF LIEUT.-COL. MCFARLAND.                                     755
   The ground taken originally that Manasquan could be used aa a har-
bor of refuge is no more tenable now than when the Board of Engi-
neers decided against it in 1879. It has now no more commerce than
in 1879, and the plea that its improvement was necessary to get local
products to New York is stated to be unsound since the extension of the
Long Branch Railroad. But the question comes up, shall the present
works be allowed to go to ruin, and probably (if the piling and crib
work begins to break away, as it undoubtedly will shortly) block up
forever any ingress to or egress from the river.
    By extending the shore end of the south jetty, not on the present line,
but on a line nearly parallel to the norty jetty, it is reasonable to ex-
pect that the increased scour will cut a channel again through the sand
bar at the inner end of the north jetty, and that the extension of both
jetties seaward from 300 to 400 feet will scour out the outer bar; and
that the channel, so obtained, will remain for a number of years.
    It seems advisable, at all events, that an accurate survey be made of
the condition of the improvement on which an estimate can be made of
the cost of a modified project. The survey would cost about $300.
    While not believing the improvement any more necessary to com-
merce than the Board of Engineers, to save the existing work I should
also recommend such an appropriation as would give at least as good
an entrance to the harbor as existed in 1879, unless the cost is found to
be excessive.
    In case it is decided to continue the improvement as a result of this
survey, the whole amount of money asked for should be appropriated
at once, in order to save further deterioration of the existing works and
channel.
  Manasquan River is in the collection district of Perth Amboy, N. J., which is the
nearest port of entry. Nearest light-house, Barnegat Light. Nearest fort, fort at
Sandy Hook, New Jersey. Amount of revenue collected at the port of Perth Amboy
during the fiscal year ending June 30,1886, $31,067.65.
Original estimate of 1879 for jetties and dredging.......................... $52,120
Additional estimate of 1882................................................ 19,880

       Total                                                                                        72,
                ......-----.....----......-----..................--....--....-......----....-....-.....   000


                                             APPROPRIATIONS.



                                    Date.                                        Application.      Amount.


March 3, 1879 .................................................       .      NorthJetty              $12, 000
June 14, 1880....                    .... ................................ )            ""            20, 000
August 2, 1882 ............................................................     South Jetty...         7,000
                                                                                      39, 000
      Total ........................................... ......................................

  Amount expended to June 30, 1886, $39,000.




                                            Money statement.

SAmount (estimated) required for completion of existing project.......                         $33, 000 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
756     REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.


                                  E   14.

        IMPROVEMENT OF SHREWSBURY RIVER, NEW JERSEY.

   The Shrewsbury River is a large shallow estuary in north eastern New
Jersey, entering the lower bay of New York at the junction of the penin-
sula of Sandy Hook with the mainland, about 1 mile due north from the
lights on Navesink Highlands.
   Its land drainage area is about 120 square miles. The lower part,
running from the mouth for 3 miles up to Rocky Point, just below Sea-
bright, is about 1,200 feet wide. For this distance it runs parallel with
the coast line of the Atlantic Ocean, and is only separated from it by a
sandy beach from 200 to 1,000 feet in width.
    From this point it divides into two branches, one known as the South
Branch, keeping more or leis parallel with the beach for about 2 miles
further to the southward, when it opens into a large bay called Pleas-
ure Bay, 4 miles long and half a mile wide. The head of navigation
on the South Branch is Branchport, situated on a little creek leading
into the southern side of the bay. The distance from the forks to
Branchport is about 6 miles.
   The other fork, known as the North Fork, strikes away from the
south at right angles to the westward at Rocky Point, with a width of
about 1,000 feet for the first mile up to Oceanic Wharf, when it opens
out into another land-locked bay called North Shrewsbury. This bay
is about the same size as the one at the head of the South Fork, viz, 5
by one-half miles.
   It is stated by Colonel Kurtz that in 1779 to 1782 the two branches
discharged directly into the Atlantic Ocean, opposite the mouth of the
North Fork, and had no outlet into Sandy Hook Bay.
   Opposite the Navesink Highlands the ocean beach is narrowest, and
it has often been broken through, to the detriment of the lower part of
the channel. Since the construction of the New Jersey Southern Rail-
road along the crest of the beach, in 1865, these breaks have been less
frequent and less damaging to the channel, the railroad company hav-
ing strengthened the weakest part of the beach by jetties and bulk-
heads.
   When the question of the improvement of this river came up in 1870
its mouth was closed by a bar with from 3 to 4 feet of water on it.
Above this, both up the main river and up the two branches to where
they enter the large bays, were shoals with from 3 to 4 feet of water on
them, separated by stretches of water from 6 to 13 feet deep.
   The commerce of the Shrewsbury River has never experienced any
trouble in its passage through these bays, but only in the parts of the
river leading out of them.
   The emptying and filling of these large tidal basins create swift ebb
and flood currents in the river, with shifting bars. The material is tUn-
stable sand, and appears to be .especially subject to ice action in winter.
The river is practically closed by ice for about four mouths in the year.
   A bad break in the beach in 1853, which damaged the lower channel,
was made the subject of a special report to the Chief of Engineers by
Lieut. M. Harrison; but it was not until 1870, after the citizens had
spent $2,000 in dredging, that the Federal Government took steps for
the improvement of the Shrewsbury River.
   In 1870 the first survey of the river was made, under direction of
Lieutenant-Colonel Kurtz, Corps of Engineers, and his project for its
improvement may be found in Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers
              APPENDIX              E-REPORT                      OF LIEUT.-COL.                MCFARLAND.                757
for 1871, page 703. This project was, briefly, to dredge the existing
shoals, at an estimated cost of $14,000.
   Fourteen thousand dollars was.appropriated for this purpose in 1871,
and work under this project was carried on in 1871, 1872, and 1873; but
it was found more expensive than had been expected, and a further
sum of $5,000 was appropriated.
   In 1876 a partial survey was made, and a new scheme of improve-
ment, by diking and dredging was made, the cost being estimated at
$19,000; but no money was appropriated for it, and no work done be-
tween 1873 and 1878.
   In 1878 an extended survey was made by Captain Ludlow, Corps of
Engineers, under direction of Col. J. N. Macomb, Corps of Engineers, and
the following scheme was proposed (see Report of the Chief of Engineers
for 1879, pages 405-411): It provided for obtaining, by dredging and
by contracting the wider portions of the river by the use of dikes, chan-
nels 6 feet deep at mean low water and from 200 to 300 feet wide, extend-
ing from the 6-foot curve at the mouth in Sandy Hook Bay up to the
6-foot curves on both branches in the bays above. At that time the
minimum depth in the channel across the bar was 2.9 feet, and above
the same depths could be carried over the shoals of the upper rivers.
   Two estimates of cost were submitted, one of $134,686, and another
of $163,091. The report was submitted to a Board of Engineers, who,
on February 7, 1879, proposed the following modification:
1. South Slhrewsbury:
      Estimate, Captain Ludlow's project.-..                                          .
                                                                                . .....        .         -             $39, 683
       To which add cost of Dike H.....................................------------------------------------..            8,400
                                                                                                                        48,083
            Deduct for dredging ......                 ..............................----------------....                1,000

          Total for South Shrewsbury ......-.....------------.------....---....-----..--....----.........               47, 083
2. North Shrewsbury:
        Estimate...-- ---------------    "-----------------------------.--                                              39,103
        Improvement of ebb-channel below Highlands.................-------------------....                              55,900

               Total    .-   --   .......           -----.
                                                        .....--           .     .     .---.--    .    .-    .-..   .   142,086

   In 1879 and 1880 pile and stone dikes were built at the north and
south Shrewsbury branches, contracting their width, and dredging was
carried on in the North Branch.
 * In 1880 and 1881 a dike was built at the head of the South Branch,
and dredging was carried on from Seabright to Pleasure Bay, at the
head of the South Branch. It was found that just above Seabright
Bridge a bar of hardpan crossed the channel, which increased the ex-
pense of dredging materially.
   In 1880, 1881, and 1882 a dike 4,021 feet long was built at the mouth
on the east bank of the river, so as to close up Spermaceti Bay. In 1882
and 1883 dredging was done along the dike and across the bar, and also
in the South Branch. Work was suspended in October, 1883, for the
want of funds, and no work has been done since. At that date the con-
dition of the improvement is stated by Colonel Gillespie, Corps of En-
gineers (Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1885), to have been
as follows:
  From the mouth to Highlands Bridge.-A pile-dike was built from Crane Point to
opposite Cove Point at the entrance, 4,021 feet long, with widths varying from 5 to 8
feet. A channel was dredged across the bar 2,100 feet long, 75 feet wide, and 6 feet
deep, mean low water, and a channel was dredged from Island Beach to Highlands
Bridge 1,800 feet long, 25 to 100 feet wide, and 6 feet deep. The completion of the
project for this section requires the bar and Island Beach channels to be widened to
300 feet.
758      REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

   North Branch.-The dike on the right bank from Lower Rocky Point to Barley
Point was completed for a length of 1,885 feet, with two openings for use by small
boats belonging to property-holders on the south side, and the channel at Lower
Rocky Point dredged to a width of 75 feet (since increased to 200 feet by current
action) giving 6 feet depth. From Barley Point to Oceanic Wharf, at Oceanic, a
channel near Barley Point was dredged 1,300 feet long, 100 feet wide, and 6 feet deep.
This has since shoaled to 4 feet and less; and near Oceanic Wharf a channel 600 feet
long and 100 feet wide and 6 feet deep. The dike on the right bank not having been
finished, frequent shoalings have occurred opposite Barley Point, requiring many
dredgings over the same ground. The completion of the improvement in this reach
requires the construction of 1,940 feet of diking on the right bank below Barley Point,
and the widening of the channel at and above Barley Point to 150 feet.
   South Branch.-The dike on the left bank connecting with that on North Branch,
1,856 feet, was built, and a channel from entrance to Bellevue Dock 2,000 feet
long, 100 feet wide and 6 feet deep, was dredged. Immediately above Seabright
Bridge a channel was blasted through rock and cemented gravel, 400 feet long, 60
feet wide, and 7 feet deep. At the entrance to Pleasure Bay the dike on the left bank
springing from Gunning Island, 1,513 feet long, and that on the right bank of Sedge
Island, 503 feet long, were built, and the channel between them, 3,500 feet long, 150
feet wide, and 6 feet deep, was dredged. The completion of the project requires the
channel from the entrance to Bellevue to be widened to 300 feet. The South Branch
is quite wide at the junction of the North Branch and is so subject to shoaling that
resort must be had every few years to the dredge. Almost two years have now
elapsed since the work of improvement was suspended, and while there has been no
complaint of shoal water in the main stem and in the South Branch to the interrup-
tion of navigation, a late examination shows that there has been a marked shoaling
in the North Branch, opposite upper Barley Point, owing to the unobstructed flow
of the tides through the interval left in Dike C, projected for the right bank of the
North Branch. (See chart, page 698, Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers, 1881,
Part I.)
   The shoal which has formed at upper Barley Point has barely 3+ feet over it at
mean low water, and in order to get relief from this obstruction the owners of the
steamboats plying between Red Bank and New York City have been compelled to
open a channel through it at their own expense. The amount so expended is stated
ta be $1,400.
  In the above description an accidental omission is made of 598 feet
of dike built on the North Branch of the Shrewsbury on the right bank
from Barley Point down-stream towards the 1,885 feet of diking built
up-stream from the forks of the two branches, giving a total amount
of 2,483 feet of diking built on the North Fork.
   An examination made after the 30th of June, 1886, shows that there
is sufficient water for the existing commerce at any stage of water, ex-
cept on an exceptionally low tide, at the following points:
   1. Main river, from the mouth to the junction of the two branches qt
Rocky Point.-The channel is following the dike more closely than it
used to do, and a clear 6 feet at mean low water can now be found
within 50 or 100 feet of it, until about 300 feet from the lower end,
where only 5 feet can be carried out into the Horseshoe or Sandy Hook
Bay.
   The last dredging done was not carried along the lower end of the
dike, but diverged from it towards the west, crossing a bar which origi-
nally put out from the shore to the westward below the end of the dike,
and during the past three years this cut has gradually been filling up
on tihe western side, but cutting out to the eastward towards the dike.
It is probable if the dike were carried 300 feet further into 12 feet
water that this bar would entirely disappear.
   2. North  Shrewsbury.-Five     feet can be carried through an intricate
channel from Rocky Point up to Oceanic Wharf; but owing to the cen-
ter, 1,900 feet, of the projected dike not being finished, the whole effect
of the proposed contraction is at present lost. At the last contract
prices the completion of this work would cost about $10,000.
  3. South Shrewsbury.-Fourand one-half feet can be carried at mean
low water through this channel; but there are two points, (1) Bellevue
Shoal and (2) Gunning Island, where the channel is very narrow, and it
           APPENDIX            E-REPORT OF LIEUT.-COL. MCFARLAND.                                                                  759
is almost impossible for the steamers to carry more than 4 feet through
them.
   The improvement of the Bellevue Shoal is simply a matter of dredg-
ing, perhaps 5,000 cubic yards, at 25 cents per yard, which would give
a channel 100 feet wide and 5 feet deep.
   The Gunning Island Shoal, since the dikes have been built, has been
moving over from west to east, making a very inconvenient bend, and
$1,000 would cut off this so as to give a fair 5-foot channel.
   But before a permanent scour can be established it will be necessary
to build a dike across from the lower end of Gunning Island to themain-
land, so as to close entirely the old western channel and throw the whole
current into the east channel.
   During a recent examination of this river the owners and agents of
the four steamboats plying up the two branches were seen, and the
points mentioned are the only points of difficulty they spoke of.
   They express their satisfaction with the past improvements, and es-
pecially with the effects of the dikes.
   As the heavy freighting season is almost past, and the ice next spring
will undoubtedly make changes in the channels; and as*the navigation
of this river has been quite satisfactory since March of this year, the
channels having increased in width and depth since spring, it will be best
not to undertake any other work here this fall. But, as soon as the ice
breaks up in the spring, an examination of the river should be made to
ascertain what changes may have taken place. The last appropriation
will be applied to diking or dredging in either branch as may be found
most expedient; and a further appropriation of $15,000 should be made
for the completion of the North Branch Dike, and for such dredging as
may be necessary, and for the construction of the Gunning Island Dike
and the extension of the dike at the mouth. This would apparently
be sufficientfor the existing and prospective commerce of the Shrewsbury
River at present.
   The majority of the commerce of the Shrewsbury is carried in four
steamboats, two running daily from New York up the North Branch to
Red Bank, and two from New York up the South Branch to Branchport.
The Sea Bird and the Albertina run up the North Branch, drawing 5 feet
and 4 feet, respectively, and the City of Long Branch and Helen run up
the South Fork, drawing each from 4 to 4.5 feet, according to freights.
    From what could be learned the commerce had not increased very
materially in the past three years, although it increased rapidly from
1879 to 1883.
    The commerce, however, is sufficient to warrant the carrying out of
the project as presented in this report. The mean rise and fall of tides
in the Shrewsbury is 5 feet at the mouth, 3 feet at Highlands Bridge,
2 feet at Red Bank, on the North Branch; 2 feet at Seabright, on the
South Branch, in Pleasure Bay, and at Branchport is 1.3 feet.
  This work is in the collection district of Perth Amboy, New Jersey, which is the
nearest port of entry. Nearest light-house, Navesink lights. Nearest fort, fort at
Sandy Hook, N. J.    Amount of revenue collected at the port of Perth Amboy during
the fiscal year ending June 30, 1886, $31,067.65.
                                           AMOUNTS APPROPRIATED.


   Date.                                                  Application.                                                           Amount.


                Survey  ......................  ^ ...........      ............           ....       .......      ...... I         $1, 500
Aug.  3. 1852
Mar. 30, 1871   Dr edging        ..          _f                                                                                    14,000
M r. 3, 1873    Dredging Project of 1870............          ....        ...     ...   ..................                   .     1    0

                      Total of old project........................                                             -............ 20, 500
760          REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

                                                            EXISTING PROJECT.


    Date.                                                                 Application.                                Amount.


June   18,1878 Diking.             .             .---------------------------------                  ------------.--.. $18,000
Mar.       1879 ......
        3, 1880   ..   do .....................-                                    .........- ...-- --  --  -- ...     10, 000
                                                                                                                             000
June   14,             do.----------------------------------------------------------30,
Mar.    3, 1881 ...... do--------                --------------------------------------------------                      86, 000
Aug.    2,1882 Dredging ....................................................................                            80,  000
Aug.    2, 1882   Dredging----------------------------------------------------                          ------    f     30, 000

                           Total                                                             ...........
                                             -------------------------------------------------------                   174, 000

  Amount expended, $173,778.30.



                                                             Money statement.
July 1, 1885, amount available...... ....................................                                             $577 20
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885........................................                                                     355 50
July 1, 1886, amount available'.........................................221                                                 70
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886 ..... .......                                     ......      10,000 00

Amount.available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887 ...................                                        10,221 70

  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project........                                         40, 000 00
  Amountthatcanbeprofitablyexpended in fiscal year ending June30, 1888                                           40, 000 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
       harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.



                                                                          E 15.

                  IMPROVEMENT OF KEYPORT HARBOR, NEW JERSEY.

   Keyport Harbor lies at the mouth of the Mattawan Creek, on the south
side of Raritan Bay, 5 miles east of the mouth of the Raritan River,
and 21 miles southwest of the Battery, New York Harbor. There is no
real harbor or anchorage here; and at the time of the survey of this
harbor, in 1872, there was an average depth of about 4 feet at mean low
water in the bight leading up to the wharves.
   The town of Keyport. lies on the east sid.e of the creek and harbor.
In 1866 a channel 6 feet deep was dredged by private parties from the
bay up to the wharves.
   A survey of the harbor, by the United States Government, was made
under direction of Col. John Newton, Corps of Engineers, in the fall
of 1872, when four steamers drawing from 5 to 7 feet, and a number of
schooners and vessels drawing up to 7 feet, were using the harbor and
doing a business valued at nearly $3,000,000, the traffic being princi-
pally to and from New York.
   Borings showed that the bottom of the harbor consisted of hard clay
and fine sand, and that the maximum velocity of the tidal current was
only half a knot per hour,which was inadequate to effect the stability of
the river bottom.
   The mean rise and fall of tides at Keyport is about 5 feet.
   It was believed that an improvement of the channel by dredging would
be permanent, and a project was made and approved for dredging a chan-
nel 200 feet wide, about 4,700 feet long, and 8 feet deep at mean low wa-
ter, from the steamboat wharf out to the 8-foot curve of the bay; the
               APPENDIX E-REPORT OF LIEUT.-COL. MCFARLAND.                                                                                   761
estimated cost of this was $30,475. No money was appropriated for this
purpose, however, until August 2, 1882, when the full estimated amount
was appropriated, and a channel was dredged in 1882-'83, 5,000 feet long
and 8 feet deep, from the steamboat dock to the 8-foot curve in the bay,
with a uniform width of 200 feet, except in a short reach between the
steamboat dock and the wharf of the New York and Freehold Railroad,
where it was only 160 feet wide.
   It was found between 1872 and 1882 that a material shoaling had
taken place in the channel, which made it necessary to increase the orig-
inal estimate, $10,000, and this was recommended by Colonel Gillespie
in 1884.
  There are at present three steamboats making round trips daily to
New York, one having a draught of 8 feet, the other two of 6 feet.
   In 1884 the value of the exports and imports had increased from $3,-
000,000 in 1872 to $5,650 000 and the commerce appears to be still on
the increase. The improvement has been of great benefit to the port,
enabling vessels to get in there at any stage of tide. The expenditure
of $10,000 for completing the improvement is recommended.
  This work is in the collection district of Amboy, the nearest port of entry Perth
Amboy, N. J. Nearest light-house, Great Beds Light, in Raritan Bay. Nearest fort,
fort at Sandy Hook, New Jersey. Amount of revenue collected at the port of Perth
Perth Amboy, N. J., during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1886, $31,067.65.
Original estimate of 1873---.......-------------.....----......------......-----......------......---....---....-...... $30, 475
Additional estimate of 1884..................-----------------.. ......---.....--..-......-----.... 10, 000

          Total....-----------....--......---------.....---......--......------.....------....--......----.....-------....---....   ..     40,475

                                                               APPROPRIATIONS.



     Date.                                                           Application.                                                         Amount.


Aug. 2, 1882.        Dredging                ................ ..      ....................           ..     ...............         -      $30,475

  Amount expended to June 30, 1886, $29,523.01




                                                              Money statement.
                                                                         ----...... $982 19
July 1, 185, amount available---------------....---------....--......--......-----....--............
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885 .............................................              30 20
July 1, 1886, amount available.-----------------------------------..                                                                       951 99
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887 ...................                                                                  951 99


   Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1888                                                           10, 000 00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.



                                                                      E         6.
                    IMPROVEMENT OF MATTAWAN CREEK, NEW JERSEY.

  Mattawan, sometimes called Middletown, Creek is a small stream in
New Jersey, about 5 miles long, emptying into Raritan Bay at Keyport,
which lies on its east bank, at its mouth, about 5 miles east of the Rari-
tan River. It is navigable for 2 miles from its mouth up to the Long
762           REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

Branch Railroad crossing. Its width is from 100 to 150 feet. There is
scarcely any land drainage into it, and it is essentially a tidal estuary.
   The commerce of the creek is carried on chiefly by means of sloops
and schooners of from 4 to 7 feet draught, and by one steamer drawing
5 feet, which makes daily trips in summer from New York up to the
railroad bridge crossing.
   Prior to its improvement the channel was obstructed by mud flats
and shoals with from 2 to 3 feet of water on them. The mean rise and
fall of tide is about 5 feet.
   A survey of the creek was made in 1880, under act of Congress ap-
proved June 14, 1880, and a scheme of improvement was recommended
(see Report of the Chief of Engineers 1881, Part I, page 721), which was
as follows:
  To form a channel by dredging 4 feet deep at mean low water and 100 feet wide
from the mouth up to Winkson Creek, a distance of 1 mile; thence to the head of
navigation at the Long Branch Railroad Bridge 4 feet at mean low water and 75 feet
wide.
The estimated cost of this was, 48,000 cubic yards, at 60 cents.............. $28,800
Contingencies .-------------.-. --.---...---   -- --.---.... ... ...--....      4,320
         Total ......------------------......-------............-..................----------------.................    ....    33.120
   The first appropriation for this improvement was made March 3, 1881,
$15,000. And in that year a contract for dredging was let to John Van
Patten, at 48 cents per cubic yard, under which work was carried on up
to June 28,1882, when a channel 100 feet wide and 4 feet deep had been
obtained from the mouth up to Winkson's Creek, and a channel 50 feet
wide and 4 feet deep from Winkson's Creek up to the brick-yards, and
thence up to the steamboat wharf at the head of navigation, one 25 feet
wide and 4 feet deep. The total amount of material excavated was 25,630
cubic yards.
   August 2, 1882, a further appropriation of $6,000 was made, with
which the channel was increased to 60 feet in width up to a point 600
feet above the brick-yards, and to 30 feet in width up to the head of nav-
igation; and a basin was dug opposite the steamboat landing to facili-
tate her turning round. The total amount removed under this contract
was 8,897 cubic yards. No work has been done since this contract was
closed, May 14, 1883.
   Under the original estimate 13,473 cubic yards of excavation is yet
required to complete the project, estimated to cost $9,000; but there
appears to be no necessity for further improvements at present, though
it would doubtless be a convenience, especially to the steamboat, if the
greater width at first proposed were given to the upper part of the
channel. The large sloops and schooners employed in the brick busi-
ness are of such draught that they must go up and down at nearly high
water, and the steamer is also a tidal boat. They all draw too much
water to get up and down with anything less than a half tide. 1 do not,
therefore, recommend any further appropriation for this creek until
some material shoaling takes place in it, or until the amount of its com-
merce increases to such an extent as to justify it.
   The commerce of Mattawan Creek consists of farm produce carried to
New York by the steamboat and of bricks carried from the brick-works
in sloops and schooners.
   Its amount and value was estimated in 1882 and 1883 to be-
14,000, 000 brick ............................................                                            ......       ...... $70, 000
Sundries ............              .....................................                           ............           ...    80, 000
         Total ...............................................................                                                  150, 000
               APPENDIX                E-REPORT                              OF LIEUT.-COL. MCFARLAND.                                  763
  This work is in the collection district of Perth Amboy, N. J., which is the nearest
port of entry; nearest light-house, Great Beds Light in Raritan Bay; nearest fort,
fort at Sandy Hook, New Jersey. Amount of revenue collected at the port of Perth
Amboy during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1886, $31,067.65. Original estimate,
$33,120.
                                                      AMOUNTS                 APPROPRIATED.



       Date.                                                               Application.                                               Amount.


Mar. 31, 1881      Dredging ......--.....                   ..-. .--...      --...-........   .....................................    $15, 000
Aug.     2, 1882   ...... o   ..........                  ............ ...........................................                       6,000

                        Total .....................................................................                                     21,000

  Amount expended, $21,000.


                                                            MIoney statement.
  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project........ $12,120 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
       harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.



                                                                            E17.

               IMPROVEMENT OF CHEESEQUAKES CREEK, NEW JERSEY.

    Cheesequakes Creek, called Cheese Creek on the Coast Survey charts,
is a small, crooked tidal stream, rising in New Jersey, and entering Rar-
itan Bay on the south shore 2 miles east of South Amboy. Its length
is a trifle over 34 miles, and it averages about 100 feet in width. It is
bounded on both sides by marsh lands, and little surface water drains
into it.
    Prior to the first improvement a bar had formed across the mouth,
which had gradually increased into a sand bank, or beach, putting out
from the east bank, and throwing the mouth a quarter of a mile to the
westward through a channel parallel with the general shore-line.
    At the time of the first survey, in 1879, the mouth of this opening
was obstructed by a bar with only 1 feet water on it at mean low
water.
    Above its mouth, up to the head of navigation at Whitehead's, 31
miles distant, there was 4 feet water and over for three.quarters of the
distance, the rest of the stream being obstructed with bars, with a depth
of water of 14 feet or more over them at mean low water.
    The mean rise and fall of tide in the creek is 5.1 feet.
    The commerce of the creek then (as now) consisted in exports of clay,
sand, brick, wood, &c., valued at $60,000, and the imports at $50,000
per year. This was carried on in sloops and schooners drawing from 5
to 7 feet.
    The first survey was ordered by act of March 3, 1879, and was made
under direction of Brig. Gen. (then Col.) John Newton, Corps of Engi-
neers, in the fall of 1879.
    The reportof this survey and the accompanying project may be found
in the Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1880, page 525,
Part I.
   The scheme of improvement proposed was to obtain a depth of at
least 4 feet at mean low water from Raritan Bay to Whitehead's Dock,
a distance of 34 miles.
764           REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

  The existing mouth of the creek was to be closed by sheet piling, and
a new mouth was to be formed by cutting a channel 5 feet deep through
the sand-bar into the bay at right angles to the shore line. This chan-
nel was to be protected by stone jetties, with wooden substructures,
placed 200 feet apart, parallel to each other, and extending out into the
bay to the 5-foot curve a distance of about 1,601) feet. Above the mouth
the channel was to be deepened to 4 feet by dredging, and where nec-
essary the width was to be contracted by pile revetments.
  The estimated cost of this was as follows:

                 Locality.                                               Object.                                           Amount.


At mouth of creek.................    3,000 linear feet of timber foundation for jetties, at $4..                           $12, 000
                                      10,000 cubic yards of stone in jetties, at $1.75 .........                             17, 500
                                      50,000 cubic yards of dredging between jetties, at 16                                   8,000
                                        cents.
                                      550 linear feet of pile-dike, at $6 ......................                              3, 300
Cut from New Landing to For-          6,000 cubic yards of dredging, at 27 cents .........                                    1, 620
man's Dock.                          32,000 cubic yards of dredging, at 16 cents .............  ---                          5,120
                                      1,000 linear feet of pile-dike, at $6 ......................                            6, 000
Cut above Forman's Dock.........      4,000 cubic yards of dredging, at 27 cents ..........                                   1, 080
                                      23,000 cubic yards of dredging, at 16 cents .............                               3, 680
                                      300 linear feet of pile-dike, at $6         ..................                          1, 800
Deepening channel to Whitehead's      11,000 cubic yards of dredging, at 16 cents .............                               1,760
  Dock.
At mouth of creek-........   ..- ..   200 linear feet of pile-dike, at $6--------------------........................ --      1,200
Deepening channel of Stump Creek      15,000 cubic yards of dredging, at 16 cents .............                               2,400
                                      Engineering and contingencies, 15 per cent............                                  9,819

                                              Total cost of improvement ..................                                   75, 279



   The first appropriation made for the improvement of the creek under
this project was that of June 14, 1880, $20,000; but no work was done
during the fiscal years ending June 30, 1880, and June 30, 1881. March
3, 1881, a further sum of $5,000 was appropriated; and bids were asked
for and opened July 31, 1881, for dredging the new outlet, closing the
old outlet, and the partial construction of jetties at the mouth, but the
prices bid were deemed too high, and it was finally decided to wait for
a further appropriation before beginning work. No work was there-
fore done during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1882.
   The act of August 2, 1882, appropriated the sum of $15,000; making
the total amount available for this improvement nearly $40,000.
   Proposals were therefore invited by public advertisement, and opened
September 22, 1882, for dredging the new channel, building the jetties,
and for closing the old channel by sheet-piling.
   The lowest bidder was Samuel R. Cummings; and his bid being
thought reasonable, a contract with him was entered into upon the ap-
proval of the Secretary of War.
   Work under this contract was begun in December, 1882, and was con-
tinued up to November 6, 1883, with the following results:
   The eastern jetty was completed for a distance of 925 feet, the west-
ern for a distance of 995 feet.   A channel 1,600 feet long was dredged
through the sand-bar for a width of 200 feet, with a depth of 5 feet at
mean low water, in the middle 100 feet of it. This dredging extended
about 500 feet beyond the outer end of the jetties to the 5-foot curve in
Raritan Bay, and extended up to the 5-foot curve in the creek.
   The old opening of the creek to the westward was closed with a sheet-
pile revetment 532 feet in length. The changing of the course of this
outlet necessitated the county putting in a new bridge and rebuilding
the turnpike. The above work exhausted the appropriation, with the
exception of a small amount, which was spent in the spring of 1884 in
             APPENDIX E-REPORT                          OF LIEUT.-COL. MCFARLAND.                             765
repairing the sheet-piling, which was damaged by high water in a heavy
northeasterly gale.
   No appropriations have been made since, and no further work has
been done there.
   The condition of the improvement in the summer of 1886 was very
satisfactory.    The sheet-piling and jetties needed no repairs, and the
channel between the jetties had only shoaled about 6 inches, giving
4.5 of water instead of 5 feet in two places, one at the upper end and one
just outside them.
   It seems a difficult matter to arrive at the actual commerce of the
creek. Persons living upon it have since 1879 variously estimated its
value from $110,000 to $216,00( per year, while the tonnage appears
from their statements to be about 50,000 tons per year. At all events
the improvement, while being a great help to the commerce of the
creek, has not materially increased it.
   In the Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1885, page 744,
Part I, it is stated that the facilities for navigation in 1885 were ample
for the commerce of the creek.
   I fully concur in this statement, and therefore do not recommend any
further appropriation at present.
  This work is in the collection district of Amboy, N. J. Nearest port of entry, Perth
Amboy, N. J.   Nearest light-house, Great Beds Light in Raritan Bay. Nearest fort,
fort at Sandy Hook, New Jersey. Amount of revenue collected at the port of Perth
Amboy during the fiscal year eniding June 30, 1886, $31,067.65.
Original estimate for dredging, diking, and jetties ......................                          $75,279 00
Revised estimate for dredging, diking, and jetties (1885) ................                           90, 000 00

                                                APPROPRIATIONS.



     Date.                                              Application.                                      Amount.


ane      880.
  r.3, 1 1881   Dredging, jetties, and timber bulkhead.........-                    ....             .             000
                                                                                                            $20,5, 000
Aug. 2, 1882.-........do ...-----------...-------------------------------------------------------...         15, 000

                                                                                                             40, 000

  Amount expended, $40,000.




                                             Money statement.
July 1, 1885, amount available .........................................                                     $1 52
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885.-.............................................                                     1 52
  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project........                                 50,000 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
     harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.



                                                       E I8.
                   IMPROVEMENT OF RARITAN BAY, NEW JERSEY.

   Raritan Bay forms the western part of the large triangular bay in-
closed between Sandy Hook, the New Jersey shore, and Staten Island,
the eastern part of which is commonly known to New Yorkers as the
Lower Bay, as it lies just outside of or below New York Harbor, which
766        REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

is the name given to the inner body of water on which the city of New
York is situated.
   The Raritan River flows into it at its extreme western end, passing
between Perth Amboy and South Amboy, andit is connected with New-
ark Bay by the Arthur Kill, or Staten Island Sound, which separates
Staten Island, which belongs to the State of New York, from the New
Jersey shore, and joins Raritan Bay at Perth Amboy.
   The bay varies in depth from 30 to 5 feet, decreasing gradually towards
its western and southern sides.
   The natural channel leading out of it, after passing the Great Beds
Light, at the junction of Staten Island Sound and the Raritan River,
does not follow the middle of the bay, but hugs the Staten Island shore
for about 4 miles to Seguine Point, situated about half a mile east
of Prince's Bay Light; thence it runs southeastwardly towards the inner
point of Sandy Hook for about 2 miles, crossing a shoal which puts
out from the Staten Island shore to the southward.
   Previous to the survey made by the Government in 1880, 18 feet at
mean low water could be carried from Perth Amboy to Great Beds
Light in the channel, while there was not less than 21 feet of water
from Great Beds Light to Seguine Point; but from Seguine Point to
deep water in the outer bay only 144 feet of water could be carried
across the shoal.
   The width of this shoal between the 21-foot curves was about 8,000
feet.
   Through the middle of the bay south of this channel, that is, from
Great Beds Light directly towards Sandy Hook, only 11 feet water could
be carried over the shoals.
   The above depths all refer to mean low water.
   A survey of this bay was ordered in 1880 with the view of ascertain-
ing the practicability of securing a greater depth of water from the main
ship channel in the lower bay to the wharves at Perth Amboy, as ves-
sels were often much delayed- in crossing the shoal east of Seguine
Point.
   This survey was made under direction of Lieutenant-Colonel Michler,
Corps of Engineers, in 1880, whose report may be found in the Annual
Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1881, Part I, pages 717 to 719.
   This report recommended dredging a channel 300 feet wide and 21
feet deep at mean low water, from Seguine Point southeastward to the
deeper waters of the bay outside, requiring the removal of-
460,000 cubic yards of material, at 25 cents-..............................            . $115, 000
Contingencies                                                                 -----            11,500
                   ------...................--------..............---....--.....--..............

      Total estimated cost ..............................................                   126,500
  Owing to the diminution of the velocity of the ebb current after leav-
ing Seguine Point and to its unfavorable direction, as it crosses the
proposed channel at an angle of about 450, it was not expected that
the dredged channel would remain permanently open; but as no other
means of obtaining a permanent channel, by diking, &c., was deemed
practicable, the project was decided on and approved.
  The mean rise and fall of the tide is the same in Raritan Bay as at
Sandy Hook, namely, 4.8 feet.
  The first appropriation made for this project was that of March 3, 1881,
$50,000.
   Under it the work of dredging was let to the Atlantic Dredging Com-
panyin 1881, at 28 cents per cubic yard, and operations were commenced
in October, 1881, and continued to June 17, 1882, in which time 166,346
              APPENDIX                 E-REPORT OF LIEUT.-COL. MCFARLAND.                                                    767
cubic yards had been excavated, giving a channel through the shoals
21 feet deep and 105 feet wide.
  Under date of August 2, 1882, a further appropriation of $50,000 was
made.
  The contract was again awarded to the Atlantic Dredging Company
in the fall of 1882, at 22 cents per cubic yard, under which work was
carried on up till October 31, 1883, in which time 202,226 cubic yards
were excavated, which increased the width of the channel to 240 feet,
except at the western end, where, for 2,000 feet, it only had a width of
200 feet.
   By act of July 5, 1884, $20,000 was appropriated for this work. The
Atlantic Dredging Company was again the successful bidder, and a
contract was entered into with it at 16 cents per cubic yard. This con-
tract was closed December 13, 1884; under it 112,657 cubic yards of
material were excavated, of which 2,403 cubic yards were not dumped
where required and were therefore not paid for.
   The total amounts appropriated to June 30, 1884, amounted to-
Act of March 31, 1881...............................                                       .................               $50, 000
Act of August 2, 1882................................................                                                 .     50,000
Act of July 5, 1884 ....--------....------....---......--------....--......------......-----......-----....---......--..    20,000
          Total............................................................                                                120,000
   With this amount, a total of 481,329 cubic yards of material had been
excavated from the channel.
   It was believed, when dredging stopped, that a full width of 300 feet,
21 feet deep, had been obtained across the shoal; but no survey of the
channel was possible up to May, 1885, when it was found that the side
slopes of the cut had run into the channel, giving a clear depth of 21
feet for only 200 feet in the narrowest place, and an average width of
over 250 feet.
   An examination made during the summer of 1886 showed that no
material shoaling had taken place since the survey of May, 1885.
   In the Annual Report of Chief of Engineers for 1885, Part I, page
758, Colonel Gillespie, then in charge, estimated that to give this chan-
nel its full width of 300 feet would necessitate the removal of 80,000
cubic yards of material.
   The original project of 1881 contemplated the excavation of this chan-
nel only; but Colonel Gillespie in his annual reports of 1883, '84, and
'85, calls attention to two other shoals in the bay, west of Great Beds
Light; one in the channel leading up to South Amboy, on the Raritan,
and the other leading up to Perth Amboy on Staten Island Sound.
    The shoal in the channel leading up to Perth Amboy is a middle
ground, having a channel on each side of it, thd eastern one being the
best; but only from 18 to 19 feet of water can be carried through it. It
is also narrow in places and crooked.
    Colonel Gillespie recommended, therefore, that a straight channel
300 feet wide and 21 feet deep should be dredged from deep water near
Great Beds Light through the east end of this shoal to deep water at
Ward's Point, opposite Perth Amboy. (Report of Chief of Engineers,
1885, Part I, page 758.)
    This, with the 21-foot channel dredged outside of Seguine Point,
would give a continuous 21-foot channel from the main ship-channel in
New York Bay to the wharves at Perth Amboy.
    The amount of material required to be removed was estimated to be
  150,000 cubic yards.
    On the same page of the same report Colonel Gillespie calls attention
to a shoal lying between South Amboy and Great Beds Light, on which
 768           REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

there is only 12J feet of water. And in order to give the large tow-boats
running from New York up the Raritan sufficient water he recommended
the excavation of a channel through this shoal 4,500 feet long, 300 feet
wide, and 15 feet deep. The amount of excavation required to dredge
this channel he estimated at 150,000 cubic yards.
   The cost of dredging these two channels and the 80,000 yards of the
side slopes of the cut outside of Seguine Point he estimated at a total
of $114,000.
   No money was appropriated or work done during the fiscal year end-
ing June 30, 1886.
   By act of August 5, 1886, an appropriation of $37,500 was made for
the improvement of Raritan Bay.
   Navigation through the channel leading eastward from Seguine
Point is unquestionably easier and better than through the channels up
to Perth and South Aniboy, inside of the Great Beds Light.
  Almost all the deep-draught trade of the, Amboys is restricted to
Perth Amboy, and vessels and steamers drawing up to 20J feet load and
unload at its docks. Its trade is so large and constant the year around
that it would seem better to apply the present appropriation to widen-
ing and deepening the channel from Great Beds Light to Perth Amboy,
rather than to apply it to widening the Seguine Point Channel or the
South Amboy Channel.
  As no survey of this part of the bay has been made since 1880, and as
undoubtedly there have been some changes in the channels since then,
a careful survey of the upper part of Raritan Bay should now be made
from Great Beds Light to deep water off the docks at Perth and South
Amboy, in order to determine the necessary lines of dredging in the
channels, and the quantities of material required to be removed, and
this and future appropriations should be applied: first, to the widening
and deepening of the Perth Amboy Channel; second, to the South
Amboy Channel, and last to the Seguine Point Channel.
  The coal and iron trade of both the Amboys is very large; that of
Perth Amboy especially so. In 1884, 116,000 tons of iron ore were im-
posted, besides 30,923 tons of miscellaneous freight, and the exports
amounted to:
                                                                                                                             Tons.
Coal.-- --------------                ------                                      -1,946,129
                                                                   ....--....-......---......-----......-......
                                                      . ......-------
Steel rails------
            ......---------....----......-------....-......--------....-----......-......--......-....-....-......           80, 709
         ...--------------------------------------------......
Pig-iron----                                                                                         ------...... --......   89,959
Grain and merchandise..................................................                                                      29,194
   And in 1885 the total number of tons shipped from Perth Amboy is
stated to be 7,127,352 tons, with a valuation of $37,627,332.
   A good deal of improper dumping of dredged material has been and
is still done in Raritan Bay, to the detriment of the channels and oyster
grounds.
   All the material dredged from the channels of the bay and the rivers
leading into them should be taken outside of Sandy Hook and dumped;
but although a great deal of dredging has been carried on by private
parties around Raritan Bay this summer, none of the men who have
been employed on the Gedney's Channel improvement for many months
has ever seen a tow of dump scows from the Raritan pass out by the
Hook.
   The lights around Raritan Bay are numerous: Great Beds Light
(fixed red), at the junction of the Kill and Raritan; Prince's Bay Light
(white flash), one-half a mile west of Seguine Point; Connover and
Chapel Hill beacons, on the south shore of the bay; the range lights for
               APPENDIX                 E--REPORT OF LIEUT -COL                                        MCFARLAND.                769
the north and south Main Ship-Channel; Bay Side and Wilson's Beacon,
range lights for passing Sandy Hook in the main channel going east and
west; Elm Tree Beacon and New Dorp range lights, for the Swash Chan-
nel, besides the Sandy Hook lights.
Amount appropriated                    .. _...-..---.....................-...---......                                    $120, 000 00
                ....------....---......-------...---....---....----......---------....---....-------....--------..-....
Amount expended----                                                                                                        119, 307 25
  This work is in the collection district of Perth Amboy, which is the nearest port of
entry ; nearest light-house, Prince's Bay ; nearest fort, fort at Sandy Hook. Amount
of revenue collected during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1886, $31,067.65.

                  r                                           Money statement.
July 1, 1886, amount available .-.... ........----....-------------------...............---....-----....                      $724 70
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885 .......................-------------------------- -..--...---.......-......                          31 95
July 1, 1886, amount available--........................................                                                      692 75
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886 --... ,..............                                                   37,500 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887...................                                                    38,192 75

   Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project........                                                  76,500 00
   Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal yearending June30, 1888.                                               75, 000 00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
     harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.




                                                                            E        ig.

                IMPROVEMENT OF THE RARITAN RIVER, NEW JERSEY.

   The Raritan is one of the largest rivers in New Jersey, running through
the center of the State in a very tortuous course towards the east and
emptying into Raritan Bay at its head, near the outlet of the Arthur
Kill, or Staten Island Sound.
   Perth Amboy is situated on the north bank, at the mouth, and South
Amboy on the southern bank.
   The head of navigation on the Raritan River is New Brunswick, sit-
nated 12J miles above the mouth, although small boats can get up 5
miles further, to where the river is crossed by a dam which feeds the
Delaware and Raritan Canal.
   The river is tidal up to the dam.
   The Delatare and Raritan Canal, the eastern eld of which is at New
Brunswick and the western end at Bordentown, form, with the Raritan
River, a connecting link of water navigation between the cities of New
York and Philadelphia.
   So far as is known, the first survey of the Raritan River was made by
Maj. Hartman Bache in 1836, being a part of the survey made "for the
improvement of New Brunswick Harbor," and a project of improve-
ment was formed, for the execution of which $7,000 were appropriated
by act of July 4, 1836, and $6,963, act of March 3, 1837.
   The details of the project and improvement are not on record in this
office.
   No work was done after this until 1878.
   A survey of the river from New Brunswick to the mouth was ordered
by act of June 10, 1872, and was made under direction of General
(then Lieut. Col.) John Newton, Corps of Engineers, in 1873. His re-
port may be found in Annual Report of Chief of Engineers for 1874,
page 172, Part II.
        49 E
770             REPORT OF THE CHIEF                                   OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

  The survey showed that, for the first 2J miles up from the mouth,
20 feet of water or over could be carried, but for the next 21 miles,
over two shoals called the Stakes and Middle Ground, only 6 to 7 feet
could be carried in places, with depths between them of 14 to 15 feet.
The width of the river up to the head of the Middle Ground averaged
half a mile, and the bottom was shifting sand, gravel, and mud.
  For the next 3 miles, up to the mouth of South River (emptying into
the Raritan 8J miles above the mouth from the southward), the river
deepens and narrows gradually, till it is about 350 feet wide.                                                                      From
the mouth of South River to New Brunswick it runs over rocky bars,
with average depths of 8 feet and minimum depths of 7 feet, separated
by stretches of water from 10 to 15 feet in depth. The width of the
river is about 350 feet. The above depths refer to mean low water.
   The tide at the mouth of the Raritan had a mean rise and fall of about
4.9 feet, or one-tenth more than at Sandy Hook, while at New Bruns-
wick the mean rise and fall was 5.16 feet.
   The flood tide at South Amboy had a maximum velocity of 1.05 nau-
tical miles per hour, gradually diminishing as it went up to New Bruns-
wick.
   The maximum ebb current was 1.60 nautical miles per hour at South
Amboy, and diminished in swiftness somewhat at the upper part of the
river, but increased materially in duration.
   The water of the river is fresh at New Brunswick.
   As only 8 feet of water could be carried through the Raritan Canal,
this seemed to fix the limit of depth which should be given to the river
below, but as the superintendent of the canal stated that they were
going to increase the depth to 10 feet, so as to make a through connec-
tion with the Chesapeake and Delaware Canal, which had a depth of
10 feet, the officer in charge thought it best to submit two estimates,
which were as follows:

                           Object and locality.                                          Quantity and rate.                     Amount.


A.-Bstimate of cost for permanent improvement for an I
8-foot channel at mean low water (rock excavation ex-
  tending to a depth of 10 feet at mean low water).

Gravel, sand, and mud shoal below New Brunswick                                52,700 cubic yards, at 35 cents...                $18, 445 00
  locks.
Rocks, 300 feet below New Brunswick locks............         ----------       2,399 cubic yards ...............                  76,768    00
Ledge of rock 3,300 feet above Martin's Dock .........                         17,504 cubic yards ..............                 542, 624   00
Reef of rocks opposite Martin's Dock ..................                        4,672 cubic yards ...............                 182, 208   00
Reef of rocks covered with sand near Whitehead's Dock.                         11,509 cubic yards                . .             497, 188   80
Middle Ground-----------------------------
                   ..........................................                  55,505 cubic yards, at 35 cents.                   19, 444   25
Stakes --------....................--------..-------...................        15,528 cubic yards, at 35 cents...                  5, 434   80
Dikes..............--.................--------....................             11,400 feet, at $12.48 per running                142,272    00
                                                                                  foot.
            ....................--.--.............
Contingencies------------------                           ---------            15 per cent. of the above ........                222, 657 73

                                                                                                                               1, 707, 042 58
         B.-For a 10-foot channel at mean low water.

Dredging tidal basin-------............---------------------.......................      648,000 cubic yards, at 40 cents..      259, 200   00
Shoal commencing 160 feet below New Brunswick locks. 225,051 cubic yards, at 35 cents..                                           78,767    85
Rocks  300 feet below New Brunswick locks ...........
    _-76,                                                                                2,399 cubic yards ............               768   00
Ledge of rocks 3,300 feet above Martin's Dock -.........                                 17,504 cubic yards ......-....          542, 624   00
Reef of rocks opposite Martin's Dock..................                                   4,672 cubic yards -.........      .     182, 208   00
Shoal below Widman's Dock                  ....................                      .-  14,400 cubic yards, at 35 cents..         5, 040   00
Reef bf rocks, covered with sand, near Whitehead's                                       11,509 cubic yards ..............       497,188    80
  Dock.
Middle Ground ..........---------------------------------............................... 55,555 cubic yards, at 35 cents...       19, 444 25
Stakes .....................................--.-....                                     15,528 cubic yards, at 35 cents...        5, 434 80
Dike.....-----------------------------------------11,400                                         feet long, at $13.50 per        153,900 00
                                                                                           running foot.
Contingencies .........................-..............                                   15 per  cent. of the above........      273, 086 35
                                                                                                                               2, 093, 662 05
         APPENDIX    E-REPORT OF LIEUT.-COL.          ACFARLAND.       77f
     The tidal basin referred to was to be excavated in the river above the
. New Brunswick locks. General Newton made the inquiry in his report
  whether, as only $200,000 of this estimate would be expended up to a
point just above the mouth of the SoUth River (Whitehead's Dock),
the Government should spend nearly $2,000,000 for the rest of the im-
provement (4 miles long) above, or whether the canal company should
push the mouth of their canal down to Whitehead's Dock.
     In 1871 the commerce of the Raritan Canal was 3,053,857 tons, with
  a value of $40,476,436.90.
     The first appropriation made for this improvement was that of June
18, 1878, $200,000. Under this a contract was let to the lowest bidder,
  Henry Du Bois Sons, for the construction of 12,800 linear feet of pile
diking at the Middle Ground and Stakes. As the timber was required
to be creosoted, it was not till May, 1879, that the contractor commenced
work, and by the close of the fiscal year 1,410 linear feet of the Middle
Ground Dike (No. 2) had been completed, and 146 feet of Dike No. 3 at
the Stakes.
     In the fall of 1878 dredges, hired by the hour, were set at work on the
shoals at the Middle Ground and the Stakes, and by December 42,663
cubic yards of sand, gravel, shells, &c., were removed. The dredges
were put on again in April, 1879, and by the close of the fiscal year had
removed 99,58L cubic yards of material.
     In June, 1879, a dredge wasput on the river near Whitehead's Dock,
and removed during the month 5,170 cubic yards of blue and red shale,
bowlders, and very compact blue clay.
     A small Government drill-scow was also put in order, and borings
were made above Whitehead's Dock to test the amount of rock required
to be removed from the channel.
     By act of March 3, 1879, the sum of $60,000 was appropriated, mak-
ing $114,733.89 available June 30, 1879.
     With this amount the contractors for Dikes Nos. 1, 2, and 3, having
obtained an extension of their contract, completed these dikes by De-
cember, 1879. The total lengths of the dikes as completed up to that
time was 12,639 feet, though erroneously printed in the Annual Report
for that year as much less.
     On October 15, 1879, a contract was let to William H. Wood for the
extension of Dike No. 2 eastward 2,200 feet, and for the construction
of a dike in the deep bend opposite Crab Island, known as Dike A.
     Work on the former dike commenced in June, 1880, and up to the
close of the fiscal year, 1888 piles had been driven. Dike A was com-
menced April 15, 1880, and by the close of the fiscal year it had been
completed; its total length being 2,600.6 feet.
     Dredging at the Stakes continued until the last of November, 1879,
when 178,865 cubic yards had been excavated, making the total amount
dredged from the shoals at that point of 268,315 cubic yards. The mate-
rial was clay, sand, gravel, and shells, generally quite compact.
    In December, 1879, the dredges were put to work on the Middle Ground,
and continued until ice formed in the winter, during which time 23,850
cubic yards had been removed, making the total amount dredged from
this shoal 76,644 cubic yards.
     The dumping-grounds previously used had been quite filled up, and
it became necessary to handle the material over a second time and de-
posit it behind the dikes.
     The dredging, which had been begun in June, just above Whitehead's
Sand Dock, in what is known as Rocky Reach, was continued up to the
772          REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

last of October, 1879, when 28,281 cubic yards of red and blue shale,
small bowlders, and blue clay had been excavated.
   On the resumption of work in February, 1880, the dredges were em-
plbyed removing the rock which had been brdken up by the blasts of the
previous fall, and at the close of operations in May they had removed
10,125 cubic yards, of which about 7,000 cubic yards was broken rock.
The material was deposited along the shores inside of lines previously
established, close to the banks.
   The small drill-scow completed the work of drilling test holes from
Whitehead's Sand Dock up to New Brunswick. The results of these
borings, added to the knowledge obtained in the survey of 1878, formed
the basis for a revised estimate of cost for excavating a channel of 10
feet, and 12 feet deep, from above Whitehoad's Sand Dock up to the
canal lock at New Brunswick, as follows:
   For excavating a channel 200 feet wide and 12 feet deep at mean low
water, from 1,000 feet above Whitehead's Sand Dock to canal lock at
New Brunswick:

                     Locality.                                                                 Object and rate.                    Amount.


From 1,000 feet above Whitehead's Sand Dock                                    47,000 cubic yards of dredging, at $1........         $47, 000
  to Lawrence Creek.
From Lawrence Creek to 100 feet above Mar.                                     106,000 cubic yards of dredging, at $1 . .....        106, 000
  tin's Dock.I
From 1,000 feet above Martin's Dock to end of                                  2,600 linear feet of crib dike, at $15 ..........     39,   000
  Steamboat Dock.                                                              74,200 cubic yardsof rock excavation, at$10.         742,   000
                                                                               184,000 cubic yards of dredging, at $1......         184,   000
From end of Steamboat Dock to canal lock ...                                   94,100 cubic yards of rock excavation, at $10.       941,   000
                                                                               27,800 cubic yards of dredging, at $1 .....           27,   800
                                                                               Contingencies, engineering, &c. ..........           313,   020

     Total      ............................................................                                                       2, 399,820



   For excavating a channel 200 feet wide and 10 feet deep at mean low
water from 1,000 feet above Whitehead's Sand Dock to the canal lock
at New Brunswick:

                    Locality.                                                                  Object and rate.                    Amount.


From 1,000 feet above Whitehead's Sand Dock                                    21,500 cubic yards of dredging, at $1 ........       $21, 500
  to Lawrence Creek.
From Lawrence Creek to 1, 000 feet above                                       45,800 cubic yards of dredging, at $1 ........        45,800
  Martin's Dock.
From 1, 000 feet above Martin's Dock to end                                    2,800 linear feet of crib dike, at $15..........(     39, 000
  of Steamboat Dock.                                                           138,300 cubic yards of dredging, at $1 .....         138, 300
                                                                               4,700 cubic yards of rock excavation, at $15          70, 500
From end of Steambot Dock to canal lock                                .       56,800 cubic yards of rock excavation, at $15.-      568, 000
                                                                               27,800 cubic yards of dredging, at $1 ........        27, 800
                                                                               Contingencies, engineering, &c. ............         136, 635

                                        . ...................
     Total ........... ... ..............                                                                ...          . . ... 1,047 535
                                                                                                               ..........



   After completing the borings and removing some large bowiders from
the channel a little above Martin's Dock the scow was taken to the reef
above Whitehead's Sand Dock, and kept at work till December break-
ing up the rook. The rock broken up by it was only partially removed.
On March 15, 1880, the scow was again put on the reef, and between
that time and the suspension of work in the early part of May it raised
and removed from the channel 1,484 cubic yards of broken rock.
  By act approved June 14, 1880, $100,000 was appropriated, of which
$70,000 was by law to be expended in the removal of rocks at White-
        APPENDIX     E-REPORT      OF LIEUT.-COL.     MCFARLAND.        773
head's Sand Dock (Rocky Reach), and $30,000 for dredging the shoals
at the Middle Ground.
    Under the contract with William H. Wood of October 15, 1879, in
force July 1, 1880, 2,052- feet of the extension of the south dike (B) were
completed by the 15th of September, 1880, and the contract closed.
    On October 15, 1880, a contract was made with John Van Patten for
dredging a cut on the Middle Ground 200 feet wide, 12 feet deep at
mean low water, and 5,300 feet in length, but the contract had not been
finished at the close of the fiscal year.
    The drill-scow resumed work on the Rocky Reach above Whitehead's
Sand Dock in August 1880, and continued work till November 25, 1880,
when the scow was laid up for the winter.
    Operations were commenced again in the latter part of March, 1881,
and were in progress at the close of the fiscal year, but as the blasted
rock was allowed to accumulate in large quantities before being dredged,
no idea could be given of the increased width obtained.
    By act of March 3, 1881, $25,000 was appropriated, of which sum
 $20,000 was to be expended on the rocks at Whitehead's Sand Dock,
 " and $5,000 at the South Channel, between Crab Island and South
Amboy."
    Under the contract with John Van Patten, dated October 15, 1880,
dredging was continued on the channel at the Middle Ground up to No-
vember. 1881, when the contract was closed; 57,700 cubic yards of ma-
terial were removed during the contract, and gave a channel 130 feet
wide, 12 feet deep at mean low water, and 5,300 feet in length.
    Blasting and drilling with the scow on Rocky Reach, above White-
head's Sand Dock, was continued throughout the year except in mid-
winter, and on October 15, 1881, a dredge was put on to assist in re-
moving the broken rock. Operations were continued with this dredge,
except in the winter, from October to the close of the fiscal year.
    The amount of work done was 3,004 cubic yards removed by the
drill scow, and 13,508 by the dredge. This work gave a channel through
Rocky Reach 12 feet deep, 75 feet wide, and 1,000 feet long.
    With the allotment of $5,000 for the south channel, a dredge was
put onto the work in November, 1881, and worked until December 31,
1881, removing 7,825 cubic yards of material.
   By act of August 2, 1882, $25,000 was appropriated. Of this $10,000
was allotted for the improvement of South Channel.
    Work under this appropriation consisted in widening the channel at
Rocky Reach, and was continued throughout the year, except when
laid up for the winter. During this time 4,397 cubic yards of rock were
removed by the drill-scow, 5,745 cubic yards by the dredge, and also
2,919 cubic yards of clay, 1,074 of shale, and 1,217 cubic yards of sand
and gravel. The rock (except that taken up in May, 1882, and which
was used for filling Dikes B and C in the South River improvement)
was placed on the left bank of the river.
   This work increased the width of the cut 59 feet, giving this channel,
June 30, 1883, a.total width of 134 feet, a depth of 12 feet at mean low
water, and a length from deep water above to deep water below of
about 1,000 feet.
   With the allotment of $10,000 for the South Channel a contract was
let October 2, 1882, to James D. Leary to'dredge a cut, at 13 cents per
yard, in the South Channel between " Crab Island and Kearney's Dock,"
                          0
100 feet wide and 5 feet leep at mean low water. The contractor com-
menced work October, 1882, but had to suspend operations from Decem-
774     REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

ber to March, 1883. The contract was in progress June 30, 1883, when
46,740 cubic yards had been removed, making a channel 2,520 feet long
for the full depth and width.
  'This channel commences at the lower end of Dike B, about midway
across to the south bank of the river, and then runs parallel to the gen-
eral incurve of the shore up to the head of Dike 1, where it joins again
the main channel. It was designed by this channel to give egress to
the commerce doing business on the southern side of the river and
which was shut off by the dikes from the main channel.
   No appropriation was made in 1883, but with the amount available
June 30, 1883, $15,979.47, work was continued in dredging the South
Channel under contract with J. D. Leary up till August 6, 1883, during
which time 6,929 cubic yards of material were excavated. This carried
the upper end of the cut to abreast of Such's Dock and gave it a total
length of 4,000 feet; it was 100 feet wide and 5- feet deep at mean low
water. To complete this channel it will have to be extended 9,000 feet
more up-stream in water a little over 1 foot deep at mean low water.
   Work on Rocky Reach was continued with the drill-scow till Decem-
ber 20, during which time 3,173 cubic yards of rock were drilled, blasted,
and removed. The rock was placed in the dike at the mouth of South
River. This gave a channel width of 160 feet, with the exception of a
few loose stones on the bottom which could not be removed before the
suspension of the work.
   By act of July 5, 1881, $35,000 was appropriated for continuing the
improvement.
   Under this appropriation work was resumed with the drill-scow on
Rocky Reach; and at the close of the fiscal year ending June 30, 1885,
the cut had been blasted out to its full width of 200 feet, except for a
strip 700 feet long, and 20 feet wide at the lower end, but not all the
blasted stone had been removed to full depth of 12 feet for more than
a little over 160 feet. The work of its removal was going on at the close
of the fiscal year.
   On Septerber 29, 1884, authority was given to dredge a small chan-
nel into Carman's(now Achman's) Wharf, behind Dike No.3, as the water
front had shoaled, owing to the construction of the dike; and a channel
was dug up to it 500 feet long, 50 feet wide, and 6 feet deep at mean
low water from the main channel.
   In May, 1485, the dredge was removed to Bishop's Dock, about half
a mile below the canal dock, at New Brunswick, to dredge through a
shoal which had formed opposite to it during the winter, and a channel
was opened through it 128 feet long, 100 feet wide, and 9 feet deep.
   No money was appropriated in 1885.
   With the balance of the appropriation of 1884 work was continued
with. the drill scow up to September 19, 1885, on Rocky Reach, during
which time 6,392 cubic yards of rock were excavated.
   The channel was drilled and blasted, and the material removed, for
the full width of 200 feet throughout, except for a strip 20 feet wide nand
150 feet long at the lower end. There yet remains this to be blasted,
and the ddebris to be removed.
   The appropriation of $26,250 approved August 5, 1886, will be ap-
plied to this, and in extending the improvement above it 10 feet deep,
by dredging and blasting up-stream towards New Brunswick.
   The condition of the improvement at present is as follows:
   The proposed dikes have been completed fron the mouth up to the
mouth of South River, and a channel with a depth of not less than 11,
              APPENDIX E-REPORT                             OF LIEUT.-COL.                 MCFARLAND.                    775
feet at mean low water has been obtained for a width of 200 feet over
"The Stakes" Shoal, and for a width of 130 feet over the Middle Ground
Shoal. The dikes are in good condition, except the lower 800 feet of
DikeB, which has settled about 2- feet, but it is not thought worth while
to repair it at present.
   A South Channel, 4,000 feet long, 100 feet wide, and 5- feet deep, has
been excavated south and east of dikes 1, 2, and 3 to relieve the com-
merce which cannot pass them into the main channel.
   There yet remains on this lower part of the river to widen the chan-
nel at the Middle Ground Shoal 70 feet, to 12 feet in depth, and to con-
tinue the South Channel for 9,000 feet up-stream, 100 feet wide and 5j
deep.
   On the upper part of the river, above the mouth of the South River,
the only large work undertaken has been the blasting a channel 12 feet
deep and 200 feet wide through Rocky Reach Bar, above Whitehead's
Sand Dock, which is about 1,000 feet in length. This has practically
been completed.
   Above Rocky Reach no work has been done except to remove a few
bowlders and dredging a short channel through a shoal formed during
the winter of 1885.
   The channel from Rocky Reach up to New Brunswick remains in about
the same condition it was in when the first survey was made in 187,2, when
the depth in the channel varied from 7 to 12 feet at mean low water.
   The Delaware and Raritan Canal has never been deepened to 10 feet,
as originally stated to General Newton it would be.
   The statement furnished by the superintendent of the steam towing
of the Delaware and Raritan Canal Company, Mr. Chase (to be found
in Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1885, Part I, page 762),
giving the commerce of the Raritan River in 1884 as 3,838,987 tons,
shows little increase in its commerce since 1871, if any, as it must be re-
membered this estimate includes 2,258,853 tons received and shipped
from South Amboy, situated at its mouth, which did not pass up or
down the river at all, and may be said to belong to an entirely different
improvement-Raritan Bay.
   Taken from Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers, the statements
of commerce, furnished entirely by the Delaware and Raritan Canal
Company, show as follows:


                    Year.                         Total value         Freight on          Freight on         Freight, South
                                                    freight.         Raritan Canal.      Raritan River.         Amboy.


                                                                        Tons.               Tons.                   Tons.
1871.................................             $47,476,436          3,053, 857 .....................               ........
1880.................................-                           ---.......
                                                            ... .... . . .. . . . . .. . . . .. . . . . . .
1881.................................                                  1, 527, 579  .............        ............
1882 ...............................................                   1,280,141 ..............................
1883-.......... ...........           ......... -..-..-...... .        1,682,325 ................                     2,308,961
1884.................................              37, 209, 804        1, 118, 118              416, 016              2, 258, 853

  * This statement is given in the Annual Reports for 1885, but evidently refers to the calendar year of
1884. In this year the South Amboy trade of 2,258,853 tons had a value of $10,000,000.

  The tonnage of the Delaware and Raritan Canal has decreased one-third, it Will be
seen, from 1871 to 1884. This is probably due to the coal which originally went through
the canal now being shipped by rail to the Amboys, and thence loaded into large
sea-going vessels.
  The commerce of the river is carried on in vessels drawing from 4 to 14 feet, and
certainly warrants giving a 10-foot channel from South Rivei- up, and a 12-foot chan-
nel from that point down to the.mouth.
 776                  REPORT OF THE CHIEF                                                    OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

                                                                           APPROPRIATIONS.
                                                                         [For old project of 1836.]
     Date of act.                                                                  Application.                                                                                   Amount.

July         4, 1836        Unknown ................................................................                                                             .       .              $7, 000
Mar.         3,1837         Unknown..........          ..................................................                                                                                6, 963

                                      Total ...........................................                                                    ..............                                13, 963

                                                                   [For present project of 1872.]

June        18,1878 Building dikes and dredging..............................                                                                 ................
                                                                                                                                                      .         .                 $200, 000      00
Mar.         3, 1879 Building dikes, dredging, and blasting                                               ...................................                                      60, 000      00
June        14, 1880 Blasting at Rocky Reach, and dredging.................................                                                                                       100, 000      00
Mar.         3,1881  Blasting and dredging at Rocky Reach, and dredging South Channel....                                                                                          25,000       00
Aug.         2,1882     .... do .........                                     ....           ....................................                                                  25, 000      00
Aug.         5,1884 Blasting and dredging at Rocky Reach ...............................                                                                                           35, 000      00
Aug.         5,1886 ........................................................................                                                                                       26, 250      00

                                       Total .............                               .          ....                                      ...........                         *..471,250 00

                             Amount expended ...................................................                                                                                    444, 562 02
                             Estimated cost of present project..........................................                                                                         2, 093, 662 05
                             Still to be appropriated................................................                                                                            1, 622, 412 05
         * Of this, $15,000 was applied to South Channel, which did not come into the original estimate.

   This work is in the collection district of Amboy. Nearest port of entry, Perth Am-
boy; nearest light-house, Great Beds Light, Raritan Bay. Amount of revenue col-
lected at the port of Perth Amboy during the year ending June 30, 1886, $31,067.65.
                                  ,                                      Money statement.
July 1, 1885, amount available.......................................                                                                                                        $10,727 41
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
   outstanding July 1, 1885........................                    ..............                                                                                            10,109 43
July 1, 1886, amount available.... _............_...............-......                                                                                                             617 98
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886 .................                                                                                                            26,250 0(
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887 ..                                                                                ......                                  26, 867 98

     (Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project.   1, 622, 412 05
      Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June
I     30, 1888.........................................-.............     100,000 00
         Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
     t     harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.


Statement showing the tonnage, valuation, 4 c., of the commerce of the Raritan River, Newr
                                                                                    .Jersey.
                                                                                                 4.4               444-
                                                                                               O.p  n                       .                     ,,                              It

                             Shippers.
                                                                                +
                                                                               aQ
                                                                                        pU "
                                                                                                    m p'
                                                                                                                          A                   n
                                                                                                                                                  '
                                                                                                                                                                       b U.
                                                                                                                                                                       n
                                                                                                                                                                                        U"
                                                                                                                                                                                        F

                                                                                               P4
                                                                             Tons.             Tons.                                      Tons.                       Tons.            Tons.
Delaware and Raritan Canal Company..                                        16, 764             601, 714          ....... .          -                        -        -    -           214, 122
Sout.h Amboy..........................                                                       2, 122, 213                                                                0..................
South River Canal                .....
New Brunswick Dock ..................
                                       .....   2,500
                                                    ...
                                                                                                    21, 300              1, 000
                                                                                                                 ..........
                                                                                                                                        4, 000
                                                                                                                                ..........
                                                                                                                                               110, 000
                                                                                                                                                     ...
                                                                                                                                                               000
                                                                                                                                                            12,000
                                                                                                                                                                                            1,
Sayre & Fisher ......................         10, 000                                                             S..................           90,000   ..........
                                                                                                                 .... . ... -....... . . .....                 50
C. & W. Whitehead ...................
Middlesex Fire-brick Company ........... ....      ..
                                                                                             ............
                                                                                               50, 000
                                                                                                7, 000
Roberts Brothers.........................                                                            2,800


Phoenix Brick Company .............                                       ..-                                    .......... i. ............... ...                                     .......
Ridgway & Brother..................                                       .......                    3, 800       -,-. ........- - .-- .. 21,000 i..........
F. A. Ostrander................................
Raritan River Company ....................
                                                                                                     5, 000
                                                                                                     3, 000       -------..               .........
                                                                                                                                  ...........
                                                                                                                                          15,000 ..........----
                                                                                                                                        i..........
Raritan llollow-brick Company........ .......                                                       10, 000
American Fire.brick Company...                                  .. ........                          5, 000
Thomas Acker & Company ....................                                                          3, 000
Edgar & Compton .......                    ...................                                       5, 000             .250                                            4, 500           4, 500
Edgar & Brother.............................                                                        10, 000
Martin's Dock ........................                                         100                         300
Terrence Cherry......................                                          500              .....
                                                                                             ......                     ........                               1 0..
                                                                                                                                                                  ,000 .... -                -
Watson Fire brick Company.....
T. & H. Valentine.......................
                                                               ..........                            1, 000            -..
                                                                                                                       -.                                      10 000 I..........
                                                                                                                                                            .. 1.......
                                                                                                    10, 000
            Total .............                   ...    ..       . ..      29, 864          2,861, 127                1, 000                4, 250                   275, 000         233, 122
                  APPENDIX                    E-REPORT                         OF     LIEUT.-COL.                 MCFARLAND.                   777
                            Statement showing the tonnage, valuati,), ,ec.-Continued.

                                                                       m                                                                  w
                                                                                                                             4.
                         Shippers.I                                        c                                                              0;,C
                                                                                                         z                   A
                                                                                                                                          '5


                                                                      Tons.            Tons.                      Feet.
Delaware and Raritan Canal Company..                                 212, 603        1, 045, 203                      7    25 to 200 $25,000, 000
South Amboy.......................                                   103,251         2, 225, 464       15, 349       10   100 to 300 10, 000, 000
South River Canal ..................                                      .....           139, 800.........           5    25 to 100     417, 000
New Brunswick Dock ...........................                                             12,000 ....                7          100     100, 000
Sayre & Fisher..................................                                          100,000 .....               9    50 to 300     350, 000
C. & W. Whitehead....                          .................                           50,000 ......  .           8    50 to 250     100, 000
Middlesex Fire-brick Company .......                                 ........              10, 000...               6      25 to 100      20, 000
Roberts Brothers ......................                              _....                  2,800 .......           6      25 to 100      10, 000
Phenix Brick Company ......................                                                14, 000                  6      25 to 100      45, 000
Ridgway & Brother.......................                                                    3,800..... ..           6      25 to 100      10, 000
F. A. Ostrander ...............................                                             5,000 ..                6      25 to 100      15, 000
Raritan River Company .....................                                                3, 000                   6      25 to 100      10,000
Raritan Hollow-brick Company...............                                                30,0000 ........       . 7     100 to 200     125, 000
American Fire-brick Company....................                                            20,000.......            8     100 to 200     100,000
Thomas Acker & Oompany............                                ..                        3, 000     ........     7     100 to 200      10,000
Edgar & Compton ..........................                                                  5, 000.                   7   100 to 200      10,000
Edgar & Brother..............................
Martin's Dock .            .............................
Terrence Cherry ........................                                ..
                                                                                .             400........
                                                                                           10, 000 .

                                                                                            9,750.
                                                                                                                      8
                                                                                                                      7
                                                                                                                      7
                                                                                                                          100 to 200
                                                                                                                          100 to 200
                                                                                                                          100 to 250
                                                                                                                                          25, 000
                                                                                                                                           1,500
                                                                                                                                          65, 000
Watson Fire-brick Company.......                                 .........                 11,000.                    7   100 to 250     115, 000
J. & H. Valentine..........................                                                20, 000                    7   100 to 250      45, 000

         Total ............................                          315, 854        3,720,217         ........                       36, 573, 500
                                                                                                                          -------

                                                                               E    20.

                           IMPROVEMENT OF SOUTH RIVER, NEW JERSEY.

   South River, New Jersey, draining a country 30 miles long and 10
miles wide, is a small tidal stream entering the Raritan River from the
south about 81 miles above South Amboy and 4 miles below New Bruns-
wick. Its width varies from 100 to 500 feet for the first 10 miles up.
The bottom is sand and clay, and the river is obstructed by frequent
bars with from 2 to 5 feet of water upon them, separating short stretches
of water from 7 to 12 feet deep. The mean rise and fall of tides at Lit-
tle Washington is 5.3 feet.
   The stream runs for most of the distance through low marsh lands,
and is as crooked as most marsh streams. At a point 21 miles above
its mouth South River is only about 4,000 feet distant from a point on
the Raritan River, 1 miles below their junction. In order to avoid this
circuitous route to and from the towns lying on this river, a cut or canal
about 80 feet wide across this narrow neck was made in 1831 by the
New Jersey Transportation Company, which practically saves 3 miles
of transportation. It was intended to make this cut 6 feet deep, but
this depth was never attained.
   The village of Little Washington, about half a mile above the head
of this canal, was and is now the head of steamboat navigation on the
South River.
   The first survey by the general Government, made with a view to the
improvement of this river, wals ordered by act of Congress approved
July 11, 1870, and the survey was made under direction of Lieut. Col.
J. D. Kurtz, Corps of Engineers, in 1870. His report may be found in
the Annual Report Chief of Engineers for 1871, page 698.
   The project of improvement based upon this survey provided for ob-
taining, by dredging, a 6-foot channel from the mouth of the canal
778         REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

up to the town of Little Washington.                                  The estimated cost of this
was:
Deepening the cut to 6 feet, 21,233 cubic yards, at 35 cents................ $7, 431 55
Opening a channel through the shoals between the head of the canal and
Little Washington, 14,444 cubic yards, at 35 cents .--------------------5, 055 40
Making an oblique cut into the Raritan (so as to prevent shoaling at the
mouth), 3,333 cubic yards, at 35 cents..................................     1,166 55

        Total .....---....----------......------......----.....----....----............-----------..     13, 653 50
   The business of the river was stated to be large, consisting of manu-
factures of tobacco, snuff and cigars, whisky, rubber, spices, flour, &c.,
to the value of $1,254,543.55 annually, besides the product of a number
of brick factories, which turned out 72,000,000 brick a year.
   The first appropriation for the improvement under this project was
made March 3, 1871, $15,000, but, owing to the failure of a contractor,
work was not commenced till 1872, when a channel 6 feet deep was
dredged through the canal, but the banks fell in and partly filled up
the cut, and it was redredged in 1872-'73.
   Under date of March 3, 1873, a further appropriation of $5,000 was
made, and the dredging was continued. Upon the completion of this
work the cut had a depth of 6 feet again. From this time nothing fur-
ther was done on the river until 1879, when a resurvey was ordered by
act of March 3, 1879, which was made under direction of General (then
Col.) John Newton, Corps of Engineers.
   Based upon this survey a project was made to form a channel by means
of dredging and diking, including a cut across the neck of a long bend
in the river above Little Washington, up to Old Bridge, a total distance
of 6 miles from the mouth of the canal. .The depth to be obtained was
8 feet from the mouth of the canal to Little Washington, 6 feet from that
point up to Bissett's brick-yard, about 31 miles above the mouth, and 4
feet from there up to Old Bridge.
   The estimated cost of this was-
From Raritan to Bissett's... ....................................                                        $149, 150
From Bissett's to Old Bridge..............................................                                 20, 150
Contingencies----....-----.... ----.... --......----......-- ....----....-............................     25,395
     Total....     .--...------------------------.-.----..
                                 .  .    .  .     .     .                       .    ...------....         194,695
  The project also contemplated closing the old main channel below
Pettit's brick-yard, half a mile below the head of the canal, so as to
throw the whole current into the canal instead of having it pass through
two outlets into the Raritan; and to change the position of the mouth
so as to have the canal enter the Raritan moredown-stream than before.
By act of June 14, 1880, $40,000 were appropriated for this work.
   Upon inquiry it was found that the newly proposed direction of the
mouth df the cut would interfere with private property, and much time
was spent in trying to adjust- the matter. Eventually, Messrs Sayre
& Fisher, owning a brick-yard at the junction of the Raritan River and
the canral, offered to allow the Government to cut off the corner of their
dock on condition of protecting the bank cut off by piling (see page 660,
Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1881, Part I).
  in the mean time the cut, or canal, had shoaled to a depth of 3J feet
in places. Owing to the delay in making out the deeds transferring this
point of land to the United States, no work was done on this improve-
ment during the fiscal years ending June 30, 1881, and June 30, 1882.
By act of Congress approved March 3, 1881, $6,000 more was appro-
priated, and $10,000 by act of Congress of August 2, 1882.
        APPENDIX    E-REPORT OF LIEUT.-COL.         MCFARLAND.       779
   On July 20,1882, proposals were openedfor diking and dredging at the
entrance of the canal into the Raritan River. A sketch of the proposed
improvement may be found in Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers
for 1882, Part I, page 678.
   The proposals were not considered satisfactory, and the work was re-
advertised, and on October 2, 1882, a contract was let to Henry Da Bois
Sons for removing and rebuilding the corner of Sayre & Fisher's
Wharf, constructing six dikes-A, B. C, D, E, and F-whose total length
was 5,800 feet (for sketch, see Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers
for 1885) and dredging about 6,232 cubic yards of material.
   Under the terms of this contract the contractor was not to fill dikes
A, B, and C with stone, as it was expected to till them with the stone re-
moved from Rocky Reach in the Raritan River.
    At the close of the fiscal year ending June 30, 1883, the corner of
Sayre & Fisher's Dock had been rebuilt, Dike A had been completed
for 352 feet, B for 621 feet, C for 275 feet, D for 1,551 feet; and Dike B
had been filled with stone for 40 feet, Dike C for 122 feet.
   The contract for dike construction and dredging, owing to unavoidable
delays, had to be extended to October 31, 1883, under it; Dike E, meas-
uring 1,320 feet, was completed in July; Dike F, extending from the head
of the canal up to the right bank to and across Little Ditch below Littlb
Washington, measuring 1,797 feet, was completed in September, 1883,
and the contract closed.
    The closing of Little Ditch was authorized by the Secretary of War,
August 23, 1883.
    The contractor did no dredging, as it was found the scows would not
hold the sand.
    The steam-drill scow at work on the Raritan River was sent up dur-
ing the year to the channel above Little Washington, and pumped up
2,222 cubic yards of material, making a cut 300 feet long, 40 feet wide,
and 6 feet deep, giving a channel through that part of the shoal 130
feet wide. Three thousand and seventy-three cubic yards of broken
stone, blasted from Rocky Reach in the Raritan River were placed in
dikes A, B and C, completing their filling for 292 linear feet. .The
width of the natural channel between the dikes built at the north end
or outlet of the canal into the Raritan River and between the natural
banks is 150 feet.
   No funds were available and no money was spent during the fiscal
year ending June 30, 1884; but 1,200 cubic yards of broken stone, taken
from the Raritan River at Rocky, Reach, were placed in the dikes.
    No money has been available and no work done during the fiscal year
ending June 30, 1886, except that some more of the stone excavated
from Rocky Reach in the Raritan River has been placed in the dikes.
    An examination recently made shows that the channel fror Little
Washington to the head of the canal has improved, there being nowhere
a depth of less than 7 feet at mean low water. A shoal with 7 feet of
water on it has formed at the junction of the old channel and the head
of the canal; but it does not affect the channel down to the canal.
   The mouth of the canal has scoured out to a depth of 10j feet, the
scour being principally along the dike on the left bank; but the middle
part of the canal has not improved in depth. Six feet can be carried
through it at mean low water, but there are bars and shoals with 5.5
feet of water on them putting out into the stream, which make it almost
impossible to get 6 feet of water through them; and the banks of the
canal above the (likes are being undermined and are cutting away rap-
idly.
780         REPORT OF THE                        CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

   It will unquestionably become necessary before closing the main
channel below Pettit's, and forcing the whole strength of the ebb and
flood through the canal, to extend the present diking up to its head, a
distance of about 2,000 feet, on each side of the canal.
   If this were done, and the old cut closed, the natural scour would an -
doubtedly maintain a 7 or 8 foot channel, and probably excavate it.
   There is little use of extending the improvement up-stream until the
canal is given a fixed depth of 6 feet or over.
   All the traffic from Pettit's comes through the canal, and there is no
trade below Pettit's down to the old mouth, so that the closing of the
channel would not damage anybody's interest.
   The commerce of the river is undoubtedly large for so small a stream;
but it has not increased materially since 1872.
   The freight alone, in 1871, was given a value of $1,254 ,543, but in
1885 the freight and vessels were valued at $1,852,000; and the brick.
making interest, which, in 1871, was estimated at 72,000,000 yearly, was
in 1884 only estimated at 50,000,000. The commerce of this river is
done in sloops and schooners of from 4 to 7 feet draught.
   Five thousand dollars was appropriated by act of Congress August
5, 1886, and will be expended upon the dikes on each side of the canal
towards its head, or to dredging in the canal if it should become neces-
sary.
  This work is in the collection district of Amboy. The nearest port of entry, Perth
Amboy, N. J.    Nearest light house, Great Beds Light, in Raritan Bay, New Jersey.,
Nearest fort, fort at Sandy Hook, New Jersey. Amount of revenue collected at the
port of Perth Amboy during the fiscal year ending 4une 30, 1886, $31,067.65.
  Original estimate for project of 1879, $194,695.

                                                    APPROPRIATIONS.

                                                 [For old project of 1871.}

              Date of act.                                                   Application.                                          Amount.


M arch 3,1871.......................... Dredging..........................       ...     .I                                        $15,000 00
M arch 3, 1873................................do .........................................
                                                                                   ----                                              5,000 00

      Total ............................
                                ------                               .                     ---- -- --
                                                                                        ...-----
                                                                             .............--------------               --.          20, 000 00
      Amount expended      ..............................................-----------------------------------------------------..    20, 000 00


                                              [For new project of 1879.]


June 14,3,
March      1881 .
          1880...--  ----         ... . For
                                         ... diking
                                                d    .6,and dredging- ...-------                                                        000 00
                                                                                                                                   $40, 000 00
March
A                                               d o ,... .. .. .0,... .000... .. .00. .
        3,1881--..-----....-------------........................................1----------------,
  u gu st 2,1882. . . . . . . . .   ... ......                                                                                          000 00
August 2,1882 ............................. .........................------.---------                                                  ,000 00
                                                                                                                                    10...
August 5, 1886------------------- ------- ------.. --- ---------..--------------                                                     5, 000 00
    Total...
         4.    ...                                                               .. ....                                            61, 000 00
      Amount expended to date         -      -    ....   :. :.. ..
                                                                 -                 ......-                     ----.....            55,638 73



                                                 Money statement.
July 1, 1885, amount available......
                              --     ..............--....-....                                       ......-......                  $382 63
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive o    liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885.---.....---......----......---......-
                                                    -......--..
                                                             --....      ....-
                                                                   -......-                                                           21 36
July 1, 1886, amount available--------                        --......--......361 27
                              .....----......--.......--------....-------..----....
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886----------------...................
                                                                     --    5,000 00


 {
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30. 1887....------------....-----......--......
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project-..
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1888
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
                                                                                                                                   5, 361 27
                                                                                                                             133, 695 00
                                                                                                                               25,000 00
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
          APPENDIX        E-REPORT            OF LIEUT.-COL.         MCFARLAIND.            781


                                              E   21.

           IMPROVEMENT OF WOODBRIDGE CREEK, NEW JERSEY.

   Woodbridge Creek is a small tidal creek, about 5 miles long, emptying
into the Arthur Kill, or Staten Island Sound, on the west bank, 2 miles
above and north of Perth Amboy, N. J.
   It is navigable for 2J miles above the mouth, up to which point it
averages 100 feet in width. There is little land drainage into it. The
stream itself is crooked, and runs for the most of its length through flat
marshes.
  It is, commercially, the most important tributary of Staten Island
Sound, on account of the extensive and valuable fire-clay beds adjacent
to it. On its banks are 7 fire-brick and tile factories, with several docks
at which fire-clay is loaded into vessels for export. The commerce of
the creek is done entirely in schooners and sloops drawing from 5 to
10 feet. The rise and fall of tide is 5 feet approximately.
   The first survey, with a view to its improvement, was ordered by act
of Congress approved June 18, 1878. The survey was made under di-
rection of Col. J. N. Macomb, Corps of Engineers, in the fall of 1878,
and reported upon December 27, 1878. It may be found in Annual Re-
port of the Chief of Engineers for 1879, Part I, page 478.
   The report showed that the commerce of the creek extended 2 miles
up from the mouth to the Salamander Dock with varying depths of
from 71 to 15 feet at mean high water, corresponding to 24 feet and 10
feet at mean low water, the worst two shoals being at the mouth and
from Valentine's Dock to the Salamander Dock. It was, therefore, pro-
posed to open a channel 12 feet deep at mean high water, 80 feet wide
from the mouth to Valentine's Dock, and 80 feet wide and 10 feet deep
from Valentine's Dock to the Salamander Dock, which lies next to and
above the Town Dock; also, to contract the channel just below the
Town Dock by a 500-foot dike. This was estimated to cost as follows:
29,012 cubic yards dredging, at 30 cents.................................               $8, 703 60
500 linear feet pile-dike, at $4----------...........................................    2,000 00
                                                               1,605 54
Contingencies .................-------..-...-----......--......-............--
                                                                      12.309 14
       Total---------------------..................-.----------------------........---..
In addition to this there was a contingent estimate for continuing the
  12-foot channel up to the Salamander, 5,000 cubic yards, costing........               1,500 00

       Total estimated cost of project........................-....-......--
                                                                   - .. 13,809 14
   At that (late the tonnage of fire brick and clay leaving the creek was
109,367 tons in the year, and the receipts 5,200 tons.
   The first appropriation for this improvement was made March 3, 1879
($4,000), which was applied to widening and deepening the channel
above Valentine's Dock and building a pile revetment on the north
bank.
   June 14, 1880, an appropriation of $5,000 was made. Under this a
contract for dredging was let to Elijah Brainard, at 58a cents per cubic
yard, and 7,022 cubic yards were excavated from the bar at the mouth
and from the channel up to Boynton's Dock by November 24, 1880,when
the appropriation was exhausted.
   The Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1881, Part I, page
708, Colonel Michler, Corps of Engineers, then in charge, states that
12,554 cubic yards had been removed up to June 30. 1881, with the $9,000
appropriated up to that time, out of a total of 34,000 cubic yards called
for by the original estimate, and that the dredging had cost very much
782             REPORT OF TIE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

more per cubic yard than was originally estimated, so that it was note
probable that the project could be completed with less than $14,000
more than had been already appropriated,.making the total estimated
cost of executing 'the project $23,000 instead of a little over $13,000.
  Under the appropriation of $5,000, made by act of Congress approved
March 3, 1881, a contract was entered into with John Van Patten at 65
cents per cubic yard for dredging. Work under this contract was begun
September 12, 1881, and was completed November 10, 1881, during
which time 7,324 cubic yards of material were excavated. The work con-
sisted of widening and deepening to 12 feet the channel already dredged
up to just above Anderson's Dock, 1 mile above the mouth.
  By act of Cofigress of August 2, 1882, $5,000 more was appropriated,
and under it a contract for dredging was let to Elijah Brainard at 65
cents per cubic yard. Work was begun December 18, 1882, and the con-
tract was completed January 17, 1883. The amount excavated was 6,880
cubic yards, leaving 7,242 cubic yards to be excavated to complete the
existing project.
  This gave a 12-foot channel, 80 feet wide, from the mouth up to a little
beyond Cutter's Dock; thence to Valentine's Dock, 12 feet deep and 25
feet wide; thence to the head of navigation, Salamander Dock, just
above the Town Dock, a channel 80 feet wide and 9 feet deep. The
above depths refer all to mean high water ; and a dike 516 feet on the
north bank had also been completed. The estimate for the completion
of the project Was $9,000. No work was done in 1884 and none in 1885,
when the cost of the completion of the project was estimated at $10,000.
No work has been done since 1883, nor has any money been appropri-
ated.
  An examination made in the summer of 1886 shows that the channels
have not shoaled since 1883, when the last dredging was done.
  The commerce of the creek has not improved of late years, the ton-
nage being in 1885 120,000 tons, against an average of 126,000 tons per
year for the ten years ending 1878.
   In view of this, and of the fact that the commerce of the river can
be done on the existing water, no further appropriation is recommended
at present.
  Woodbridge Creek is in the collection district of Perth Amboy, N. J., which is the
nearest port of entry; nearest light-house, Great Beds Light, in Raritan Bay; nearest
fort, fort at Sandy Hook, New Jersey Amount of revenue collected at the port of
Perth Amboy during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1886, $31,067.65.
                                                 REVISED ESTIMATE                     OF 1883.

For dredging a channel 80 feet wide and 12 feet deep, mean high water,
  and 4,800 feet long, and constructing a timber dike 516 feet long ...... $29, 000 00
                                                    AMOUNTS           APPROPRIATED.


                        Date.                            i                            Application.                                      Amount.


March 3, 1879------------------------.......................... Dredging and diking.............................                               000
                                                                                                                                               0,


June 14, 1880...........................                             Dredging ....................................                . .       5, 000
M arch 3, 1881.......................                         ........   do ..........             ...... .......... ......... ....         5,000
August 2, 1882 ................................                          do .-.........................................                     5, 000

                                   '                                                                                                j      19, 000


   Amount expended, $19,000.
                                                         Money statement.
    Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project- ..... $10,000 00
    Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
     harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
        APPENDIX E-REPORT          OF LIEUT.-COL.    MCFARLAND.       783
                                   E 22.
           IMPROVEMENT OF RAHWAY RIVER, NEW JERSEY.

   The Rahway River is formed by the junction, at the town of Rahway,
N. J., of two small streams; thence it runs in an easterly direction, as
a tidal river, 5 miles, to the Arthur Kill, or Staten Island Sound, which
it enters about 2 miles south of the village of Elizabethport.
   The town of Rahway is at the head of navigation. The width of the
stream at the mouth is about 350 feet, gradually narrowing to 150 feet
at the head of navigation. The depth at the mouth prior to the first
improvement was about 13 feet at mean high water, gradually shoaling
to 8 feet at Bricktown, 4 miles up, and thence gradually shoaling to 4
feet to the head of navigation.
   The mean rise and fall of the tide is said to be 5.3 feet near the mouth
and 4 feet at the Milton Avenue Bridge, in the town of Rabhway. The
banks of the river are low and the surrounding country up to Rahway
consists of salt marsh.
   The commerce of the river consisted, in 1878, of coal, lumber, and
sundries, estimated at 120,500 tons annually, with a value of $987,000.
   The first survey with a view to the improvement of this river was
made in 1878 under direction of Col. J. N. Macomb, Corps of Engineers.
   The report upon this survey may be found in Annual Report of the
Chief of Engineers for 1879, page 483, Part I.
   The report took the ground that from the mouth up to Bricktown, a
distance of 3. miles, there was sufficient water for the requirements of
navigation; but in order to accommodate commerce from Bricktown up
to Rahway, it was proposed to dredge a channel 125 feet wide and 8
feet deep at mean high water from Bricktown to Milton Avenue Bridge,
a distance of a little more than a mile; and thence to the head of navi-
gation at Main Street Bridge, a quarter of a mile further up,-to dredge
a channel 8 feet deep at mean high water and 100 feet wide.
   The estimated amount of excavation required for this work was
65,642 cubic yards of mud, sand, and gravel, with a few bowlders, which
at 50 cents per yard would cost $32,821, to which was added $500 for
excavating one bowlder in the channel at Bricktown and another about
600 feet above Long Branch Railroad Bridge; add for contingencies
$3,332, making the total cost of improvement $36,653.
   The first appropriation for this improvement was approved March 3,
1879, $10,000.
   And in the autumn of 1879 a cbntract was let to E. G. Brown for
dredging a channel 75 feet wide and 7 feet deep at mean high water
from Edgar's Dock, half way between Bricktown and Milton Avenue
Bridge, towards the head of navigation.
   Work under this contract was begun October 4, 1879, and was con-
tinued up to November 22, 1879, when operations were suspended for
the winter. Up to this date 2,733 cubic yards of material had been ex-
cavated, giving the proposed increase of width and depth of channel for
400 feet up-stream from the point of beginning.
   Work was not recommenced in the spring of 1880 by Mr. Brown, and
the contract was therefore annulled.
   By act approved June 14, 1880, $10,000 more was appropriated for
this work, making a total amount available June 30, 1880, of nealy
 $18,000.
   And bids were asked for continuing the. dredging. Only two bids
were received, and both were rejected, and the work was readvertised.
Bids, under the second advertisement, were opened October 25, 1880,
784           REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

and a contract was awarded at 85- cents per cubic yard to John Van
Patten.
    Owing to the lateness of the season work could not be began until
April 16, 1881; and it was continued to September 10, 1881, when the
contract was closed. Under it there had been excavated 9,337 cubic
yards of sand, gravel, and mud, and the 7-foot channel had been ex-
tended up t' Tappan's Dock.
    An appropriation of $10,000 was made by act of March 3, 1881; and
bids were opened for continuing the dredging October 18,1881. William
Chamberlain was the lowest bidder, at 63 cents per cubic yard, and a
contract was awarded to him.
    Owing again to the lateness of the season work was not commenced
till May 6, 1882. It was continued till August 28, 1882, during which
time 13,943 cubic yards of material had been excavated, giving a chan-
nel 50,feet wide and 7 feet deep at mean high water up to a point 200
feet above the Milton Avenue Drawbridge, with a channel on each side
of the draw-pier.
    It was estimated on June 30, 1882, that the total amount of material
to be excavated under the original project would be increased from
65,642 cubic yards to 90,000 cubic yards.
    This increase was said to be due to the filling in of the channel from
the sides, shoaling from freshets, and from the difference between scow
and place measurement; and which increased the total estimated cost
from $37,000 to $66,250, of which $30,000 had been appropriated up to
June 30, 1882.
    By act approved August 2, 1882, a further sum of $7,000 was appro-
priated; and bids for continuing the dredging were opened, after ad-
vertisement, September 22, 1882. The contract was awarded to the
lowest bidder, Mr. William Chamberlain, at 78 cents per cubic yard.
    Work under this contract was not begun until June 1, 1883, and was
continued up August 31, 1883, during which time 8,309 cubic yards of
material were excavated.
    At the close of the work a channel had been carried from the upper
end of the last contract 50 feet wide and between 7 and 8 feet deep up
to a point 850'feet above the Milton Avenue Bridge, and the channel
leading to Chamberlain's Dock had been widened and deepened.
    An improved channel, therefore, of not less than 7 feet in depth and
not less than 50 feet in width, had been obtained up to within 550 feet
of the Main Street Bridge, which was the head of navigation.
    No money has been appropriated since August 2, 1882, and no work
has been done since August 31, 1883.
    The total amount appropriated up to June 30, 1886, for this improve-
ment is $37,000, with which a total of 34,322 cubic yards have been ex-
cavated from the channel, leaving an estimated amount of 55,000 cubic
yards still to be excavated under the original project of 55,000 cubic
yards, estimated in 1882 lto cost 65 cents per cubic yard, or $35,750.
    Judging from the last contract price, it will cost 13 cents per cubic
yard more than this, or 78 cents per cubic yard.
    The commerce of the river does not seem to have been increased,
though the improvement has been a great benefit to shippers.
                                                                                Tons.
In   1879   the commerce of the river was reported as.. ....................... 120,500
In   1880   (not given).
In   1>81   the commerce of the river was reported as.......................... 68, 500
In   1882   the commerce of the river was reported as......................... 49,000
In   1883   the commerce of the river was reported as.......................... 51, 000
In   1884   the commerce of the river was reported as.......................... 48, 500
In   1885   no material change from 1884.
             APPENDIX E-REPORT                           OF LIEUT.-COL. MCFARLAND.                              785
   In the Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1885 it is stated
that--
  As small sailing craft and canal barges alone use the upper portion of the river, for
which the existing depths of water are ample, no appropriation is recommended for
further improvements.
  I fully concur in this opinion.
  The mouth of the Rahway River is situated on Staten Island Sound,
about 9 miles above Great Beds Light, in Raritan Bay, and about 4
miles below the light at the entrance of Newark Bay.
  This work is in the collection district of Perth Amboy, N. J., which is the nearest
port of entry. The nearest fort is Fort'Tompkins, Staten Island. Amount of revenue
collected at the port of Perth Amboy during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1886, was
$31,067.65.
Original estimate of 1878.................................................. $36, 653
Modified estimate of 1882..................................................                                   66,250

                                              APPROPRIATIONS.


    Date.                                                Application.                                        Amount.


Mar.    3,1879 Dredging ..................................................................                    $10,000
June    4,1880 .....- do ......................................................................                10,000
Mar.    3,1881 ..... do... ---------------------                               ---------------------------     10,000
Aug     2,1882 ...... do .....................................................                                  7,000

                                                                                                               37, 000

  Amount expended to June 30, 1886, $36,820.40.



                                               Money statement.
July 1, 1885, amount available..........................................                                     $200 70
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1,1885.............................................                                         21 10
July 1, 1886, amount available..........................................                                      179 60
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887...................                                      179 60
   Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project........ 29,250 00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
     harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.



                                                         E 23.
            IMPROVEMENT OF THE ELIZABETH RIVER, NEW JERSEY.

   The Elizabeth Hiver, New Jersey, enters the Arthur Kill, or Staten
Island Sound, at Elizabeth port, half mile south of the lower and south-
ern end of Newark Bay. It should more properly be termed a creek, as
it has very litile land drainage entering it, and consists of a sluggish
tidal stream averaging 75 feet in width for nearly the first 4 miles up,
where a dam crosses the river and cuts off the land drainage water com-
ing from its head.
   The first survey of this stream was made in 1878, under direction
of Col. J. N. Macomb, Corps of Engineers, and extended about 21 miles
up from the mouth to the Broad Street Bridge, in the city of Elizabeth,
N.J.
       50 E
786    REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF           ENGINEERS, U. S ARMY.

  The dam above mentioned lies about 1 mile above this bridge; the
mean rise and fall of the tide at the mouth of the river is stated to be
4.7 feet, and at the Broad Street Bridge to be 3.4 feet.
  At the time of the survey the depth at imean high water at the mouth
was about 8.5 feet, and the depth at Broad Street Bridge, and in quite
a long reach below it, was from 3 feet to 3.5 at mean high water.
  It was stated that material shoaling had taken l)lace in the river dur-
ing the 20 years previous to the survey, and that from 5 to 6 feet of
water had existed up to Broad Street Bridge, instead of 3 to 3.5 feet, as
at the time of the survey; that this shoaling was partly due to one-
quarter of the fresh water volume being lost by the construction of the
water-works dam, and partly on account of the discharge of the whole
sewage of Elizabeth and of the gas works into the stream.
  The commerce of the river in 1870 was stated to amount to 125,000
tons per year, carried in canal boats and market vessels drawing from 3
to 5 feet; but since that time it has been far less.
   The details of the survey and the project accoinpaniy hig it may be
found on page 481, Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1879, Part I.
   The prqject was briefly to dredge a channel 60 feet wide to a depth of
7 feet at mean high water from the mouth of the Broad Street Bridge,
a distance of 2.7 miles,which would require the removal of 44,000 cubic
yards of gravel, mud, sand, and small stones, at an estimated cost of 50
cents per cubic yard; which with 15 per cent. added for contingencies
would cost $25,530.
   By act of Congress approved March 3,1879, an appropriation of $7,500
was made for the improvement; and, under it, dredging was begun un-
der a contract awarded on September 19, 1879, to E. G. Brown, at 37
cents per cubic yard, and was continued until December 20, 1879,when
work was suspended for the winter. Work was resumed under the con-
tract on February 24, 1880, and was still being carried on at the close
of the fiscal year ending June 30, 1880, on which date a continuous
channel about 60 feet wide and 7 feet deep at mean high water had been
carried up to the foot of John street, 4,110 feet above the place of begin-
ning.
   On the 14th of June an additional appropriation of $7,500 was made,
and a contract was entered into with Thomas H. Benton to continue
the dredging at $1.05 per cubic yard. Operations under this contract
were begun October 1, 1880, and were carried on until November 27,
1880, when work was suspended for the winter.
   The work was resumed March 14, 1881, and was continued until April
26, 1881, when the available funds were exhausted and the contract
was closed.
   During the year, '9,200 cubic yards of material were excavated and
placed on theadjacent river banks, making the total amount excavated to
that date 21,078 cubic yards, which carried the channel up stream from
the place of beginning to a point about 150 feet below the South Street
Bridge.
   As the first contract had been carried out, as it was claimed, at a loss
to the contractor, and as the second year's work had been done at the
rate of $1.05 per cubic yard, it was estimnated that the remainder of the
improvement, requiring the excavation of 23,:322 cubic yards of ma-
terial, would cost about $28,160.
   The river and harbor act of March 3,1881. appropriated $4,000 for the
improvement of this river, and proposals for further dredging were
opened June 16,1881 ,after l)ublic advertisement, and a contract awarded
to Thomas H. Benton, the lowest responsible bidder, at $1.05 per cubio
yard.
              APPENDIX E-REPORT                                      OF LIEUT.-COL.                                    MCFARLAND.                             787
   Work under this contract was commenced July 18, 1881, and by
August 25, 1881, when 3,335 cubic yards had been excavated, the funds.
were exhausted and the contract was closed; at this time a 7-foot chan-
nel had been carried up to the iron draw-bridge at South street, above
the gas-works.
   The amount remaining to be excavated under the original estimate
was 19,987 cubic yards, which, on July 30, 1882, was estimated to cost
$24,134, including contingencies.
   By act of Congress approved August 2, 1882, the sum of $8,000 was
appropriated for continuing the improvement; and, after advertise-
ment, bids were opened September 22, 1882, for further dredging. The
lowest bidder was F. C. Somers, at 64 cents per cubic yard. The con-
tract was awarded to him; but operations were not begun until May
26, 1883. Work was continued from that dte up to August 21, 1883,
during which time 11,094 cubic yards of material had been excavated,
and which carried the improved channel up to near the Bridge Street
Bridge, with a width of about 50 feet and a depth of 7 feet, mean high
water.
   No work has been done since August, 21, 1883, and, in the Annual
Report for 1884, Part I, page 748, it is stated that "the original proj.
ect is completed so far as the present wants of commerce require, and
the stream now affords ample depth for all the vessels or boats which
use it."
   I fully concur in this statement.
   The tonnage of the stream since the beginning of the improvement
has run from 20,000 to 30,000 tons per year, and the cause of the shoal-
ing of the upper part of the river is entirely due to the refuse from the
sewers and gas-works of the city. No appropriation, therefore, is asked
for a further improvement.
   The modified estimate of cost of this improvement amounted to
$43.160, of which $27,000 has been appropriated.
  Elizabeth is in the collection district of Newark, N. J. Nearest light-house, New-
ark Bay; nearest fort, Fort Tompkins. Amount of revenue collected at the port of
Newark, N.J., during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1886, $2,326.70.
Original estimate of 1878, for dredging ..................................... $25, 530
Additional estimate of 1882, for dredging ................................     17, 63G
         Total ..............              ......        . ...               ...................................                                            43,160
                                                         APPROPRIATIONS.


     Date.                                                         Application.                                                                           Amount.

Mar. 3, 1879        Dredging ...                     ......................                                                          ........                  7,500
                                                                                                                                                             $...
                                                                                                                                                             $.............
June 14, 1880      ..     ...     .....             .....................................................                                                      7,500
Mar. 3, 1881 ...... do .....................                              ...........                      ....   ...........                   .......       4,000
Aug. 2, 1882 ..     ...      ...........                 ............--                    .............                  ...............                     8,000
                          Total ....................................                              .............................                              27, 000

  Amount expended to June 30, 1886, $26,419.16.


                                                    Money statement.
July 1, 1885, amount available.                      .               . .....            ............................                                ..    $601 64
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities                                                                                  pg
  outstanding July 1, 1885 ..........................................                                                                                       20 80
July 1, 1886, amount available......................................                                                                                       580 84
   Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project........ 16,160 00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
     harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
788     REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.


                                  E 24.

IMPROVEMVENT OF THE CHANNEL BETWEEN STATEN ISLAND AND NEW
                          JERSEY.

   The channel between Staten Island and New Jersey is a tidal stream,
one part of which, passing by the north of Staten Island, connects
New York Harbor with Newark Bay, while the other part, passing west
of Staten Island, connects Newark Bay with Raritan Bay at Perth Am-
boy. Its total length is about 16 miles.
   The northern part, which extends from New York Harbor at Cummu-
nipaw to Elizabethport, N.J., at the mouth of Newark Bay, a distance of
31 miles, is known as the Kill von Kull. The other, or western part,
extending from Elizabethport to Raritan Bay at Perth Amboy, a dis-
tance of 12) miles, is known as the Arthur Kill, or Staten Island Sound.
   The Kill von Kull receives the waters of the Hackensack and Passaic
rivers, which empty into it through Newark Bay; and Staten Island
Sound receives the waters of the Elizabeth and Rahway rivers, and of
Woodbridge Creek.
   The flood tide, passing from Raritan Bay up through Staten Island
Sound, meets the flood tide coming from New York Harbor through the
Kill von Kull at a point a little west of Elizabeth port.
   The depth of water in this channel, before the first improvement was
made in it, varied from 13 to 40 feet, except of in one stretch of about
1. miles, lying east of the city of Elizabethport, where the waters of
Newark Bay join those (f the Kills almost at right angles to their
natural course.
   This meeting of the tidal waves at Elizabethport, and the meeting of
the currents of the Kills and of Newark Bay, had formed a shoal nearly
8,000 feet long, with a minimum depth over it of 9 feet at mean low
water.
   The channel across it was narrow, besides having two right-angle
bends, one at the Stake Light, and one at Shooter's Island.
   The channel through the Kills forms a most important water-way be-
tween New York, the Raritan River, the Amboys, and intermediate
points. It is not affected by wave action, so that it is practically a tidal
canal.
   Almost all the commerce of the Delaware and Raritan Canal passes
through it, besides a large proportion of the trade of Perth Amboy and
the coal shipments of Elizabethport.
   The commerce is carried on in large tows and in sailing vessels draw-
ing as much as 15 feet.
   The first survey for improvement of this water-way was ordered by act
of Congress approved June 10, 1872, and it was made in 1872-'73, under
direction of General (then Lieut. Col.) John Newton, Corps of Engineers.
   His report may be found on page 943, Annual Report of the Chief of
Engineers for 1873.
   Two projects, based upon this survey, were submitted, one for the
creation and maintenance of a channel 150 feet wide and 16 feet deep
running north of Shooter's Island by means of parallel dikes and dredg-
ing between them, which was expected to be permanent, and the other
for a dredged channel south of Shooter's Island, on the lines of the ex-
isting channel, and 300 feet wide and 16 feet deep. It was, however,
believed that this channel would not maintain its depth.
             APPENDIX               E-REPORT                      OF LIEUT.-COL. MCFARLAND.                                 789
   The estimated cost of these projects was as follows:
                                 ESTIMATE FOR PERMANENT IMPROVEMENT.

Dredging a channel 150 feet wide and 16 feet deep at mean low water,
400,000 cubic yards, at 30 cents             ..
                                          "....          . . ... . . ..       ..   $120,000
Diking about 17,000 linear feet .............................
                                   -                                  ............  265,400
Contingencies, 15 per cent .-...                           ....      . ...........            ....     .....    _..        57,810

         Total.... .           .-------------------------
                                                     ..   .                      ..   .       .        -....          .   443,210
                                ESTIMATE FOR TEMPORARY IMPROVEMENT.

Dredging a channel 8,000 feet long, 300 feet wide, to a depth of 16 feet at
mean low water, 557,947 cubic yards, at 30 cents-----....------...                                ----....... -$167,       384
Contingencies, 15 per cent .......--------.----....-....-..........-----------------..----......-----....--......--.... 25, 107

         Total.---------------------------------------------------....                                                    192,491
   The former project was approved by the Chief of Engineers, and under
the appropriation of $50,000, approved June 23, 1874, a contract was
let to J. D. Leary, at $18.94 per linear foot, for beginning the southern
dike, starting on the south shore of the Staten Island Sound directly
opposite Elizabethport, and running eastward.
   Work on this contract was begun November 7, 1874, and was closed
May 5, 1875, in which time 2,237 linear feet of dike had been built.
   To permit the access of oyster-boats to the space behind the dike an
opening was left in it.
  Opposition to General Newton's project was manifested about the time the dike
was commenced on the part of the oystermen, on the ground that it interfered with
their business. General Newton, however, offered to leave openings in the south
dike from space to space to permit the passage of oyster boats. One opening has
already been left for that purpose. The most important opposition to it, however,
was manifested by the company engaged in the transportation of freight, in amount
about 5,000,000 tons, through the Delaware and Raritan Canal.
  These interests procured the passage of resolutions by the New York legislature,
January 22, 1875, protesting against the projected mode of improvement of the Kill
von Kull, &c., and requesting the "Senators and Representatives from New York in
the Congress of the United States to obtain a modification of the plan of said improve-
ment."
  (See Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1876, Part I, page
255.)
  Following, and presumably in consequence of these resolutions, Con-
gress, by section 3 of act approved March 3, 1875, made provision for
the appointment of a Board " to examine and report a plan for the im-
provement of the channel between Staten Island and New Jersey."
   Their report may be found on page 252 of Annual Report of the Chief
of Engineers for 1876, Part I.
  The Board wereof the opinion that General Newton's project was sound,
and was the only way to maintain a permanent channel; but in view of
the fact that the commerce of the river had diminished of late years,
and that certain changes had taken place in the shipping points, they
thought that it was only necessary at that time to secure a depth of
about 11 feet by dredging along the general lines of the original chan-
nel south of Shooter's Island. The proposed width of this channel was
500 feet, and the estimated cost was:
Dredging, 230,000 cubic yards, at 16 cents...............................                                                 $36, 800
Contingencies 10 per cent..  ..   ...-.......                ........                     _          -
                                                                                                  ...-...-     ...          3,680
         Total...... ......................................................                                                40,480
An appropriation of $10,000 was made by act of Congress approved
August 14, 1876; but no work was done during the fiscal year, or dur-
790            REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

ing the fiscal years ending June 30, 1877, and June 30, 1878. By act of
June 18, 1878, a further sum of $25,000 was appropriated, but no work
was done during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1879.
   The act of June 14, 1880, appropriated $29,000 for the improvement,
making the total amount then available for the improvement on June
30, 1880, $52,006.37.
   A project for the expenditure of the money was made by Col. N.
Michler, Corps of Engineers, June 28, 1880, and was forwarded to the
'Chief of Engineers.
   It was referred by him to the Board of Fortifications and River and
Harbor Improvements, whose report may be found in Annual Report of
the Chief of Engineers for 1881, Part I, page 693.
   Their report concurred in the previous reports of General Newton
and of the special Board of April, 1875, but the Board stated that the
commerce of the Kills had increased since 1875, so as to warrant an in-
creased channel depth, and they therefore proposed to dredge a deeper
channel from Elizabethport eastward to the deep water of the Kill von
Kull on the lines of the existing channel to the south of Shooter's Island,
the channel to be 400 feet wide and 12 feet deep at the sides at mean
low water, with an extra depth of 1 foot for 100" feet in width on each
side of the axial line of the channel, so that there would be at mean low
water a depth of 13 feet over the middle 200 feet of the channel and 12
feet on the outer 100 feet on each side.
    In addition to this dredging, if it were found necessary to confine and
direct the current, parallel dikes were to be built on opposite sides of
the channel at two places; one pair about 1,500 feet long near Eliza-
bethport and one pair just west of Shooter's Island.
    The estimated cost of this project was as follows:
For a channel 400 feet wide and 12 feet deep, at mean low water, 232,900
  cubic yards (in place) of dredging, at 35 cents ......................... $81, 515
For an additional depth of 1 foot for a width of 200 feet, 117,300 cubic yards
  (in place) of dredging, at 30 cents ...---------------                                     35,190

                                                                                            116, 705
C ontingencies-------------------......------------------....-.......----.....-----......     9,000

       Total     .......................-----.-------.................----.........         125,705

  The (likes were estimated to cost $60,000, bringing up the total es-
timated cost of the proposed improvement to $185,000.
  This project was approved, and bids for dredging were opened No-
vember 30, 1880, and a contract was awarded to 1Viessrs. Morris &
Cumings, the lowest bidders, at 19J cents per cubic yard. Work under
this contract was begun December 22, 1880, and with the exception of
a stoppage of about two months in the winter, it was continued up to
the close of the fiscal year, during which time 101,368 cubic yards of
material had been removed, giving a channel from 50 to 200 feet wide
and 13 feet deep, extending from deep water east of Shooter's Island to
a point 700 feet west of the Corner Stake Light and up to the eastern
end of dike built in 1874 and 1875.
  No appropriation was made (luring the fiscal year ending June 30,
1881, but there was a balance of the previous appropriation available
of $28,538.84 at that (late; and work under the contract with Morris &
Cumings was continued up to December 2, 1881, when the contract
was closed. During this time 116,931 cubic yards of material were re-
moved, making the total amount removed under that contract 218,299
cubic yards.
       APPENDIX     E-REPORT      OF   LIEUT.-COL.   MCFARLAND.      791
   This gave the channel a width of 200 feet and a depth of 13 feet to the
eastward of Shooter's Islandl, and on the western side 200 feet wide and
13 feet deep.
   During the dredging the character of the bottom was found to vary
considerably in different parts of the channel.
   In the vicinity of the Corner Stake Light there was a bed of com-
pacted sand, gravel, shingle swith bowlders ocasionally imbedded in it,
and the same torination without the bowlders was found at a point
opposite Elizabeth )ort.
   Through the rest of the channel and east of Shooter's Island the bot-
tom was soft mulld.
   No work was done up to the close of the fiscal year hnding June 30,
1882, after the Morris & Cumings contract was completed.
   By act of Congress passed August 2, 1882, $40,000 were appropriated
for this work.
   Bids for continuing the dredging were opened September 22, 1882,
and the contract was awarded to Morris & Cumings, the lowest re-
sponsible bidders, at 231 cents per yard. Work under it was begun
October 16, 1882, and the contract was close:t May 16, 1883; during
which time 158,637 cubic yards of material was removed from the chan-
nel. This completed the projected dredging.
   A channel 400 feet wide and 13 feet deep for the central 200 feet, and
12 feet deep for 100 feet on each side, had been obtained from the deep
water in the Kill von Kull east of Shooter's Island to deep water in
the Arthur Kill off Elizabethport. But in the Annual Report of the
Chief of Engineers for 1883, page 575, it was recommended that the
depth should be increased to 13 feet for the full width of 400 feet. The
estimated amount of material to be removed to do this was 50,000 yards,
for which $25,000 was asked.
   No work was done during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1884.
   By act of Congress approved July 5, 1884, $10,000 were appropriated,
and proposals for continuing dredging were opened September 17, 1884.
   The contract was awarded to Messrs. Brainard & Benton, the lowest
bidders, at 20 cents per cubic yard. They began work October 6 and
finished it December 26, 1884, during which time 44,953 cubic yards
were removed from the channel, and the existing channel widened to
400 feet, with a depth of 13 to 14 feet around the bend at the Stake
Light, and from Shooter's Island eastward to the Kill von Kull.
   In the Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1884 and 1885 the
construction of Dike B, on the north side of the channel off Eliza-
bethport (see sketch in Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for
1881, Part I, page 696), was advocated in order to check the deposits
forming con tin ually around the Stake Light. A careful examination of
the Annual Reports and maps shows that the shoaling in this channel,
considering the natural tendency to it, caused by the meeting of tides
and currents in it, is singularly small.
   A recent examination shows, practically, no change of depth since
the last dredging.
   The opposition to the building of the dike in 1878 was so determined
that it is probable that similar opposition would arise if the construc-
tion of Dike B were begun.
   The channel does not appear to be shoaling, and appears to be of
ample depth for existing commerce. Its width, however, is not quite
sufficient at two points, one at the bend off the Stake Light, and the
other just east of Shooter's Island.
   When the large Raritan River tows, of from 25 to 50 canal-boats, 5
abreast, get to these points, if there is much other commerce passing,
792                REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

there is almost always delay and trouble, and the channel here ought
to be widened by dredging.
  The construction of the dikes may be deferred until it is absolutely
certain that they are required.
  The appropriation of August 5, 1886, of $15,000 will be applied to
widening the channel at these two points.
  The commerce of this channel is very large. It is estimated that be-
tween 2,500,000 and 3,000,000 tons of coal are shipped yearly from
Elizabethport, and that 5,750,000 tons of the Raritan Canal and Perth
Amboy trade passes it, besides an immense amount of other freight.
  A detailed statement may be found in Annual Report of the Chief of
Engineers for 1884, page 744.
  This last fiscal year the steamboat passenger traffic has been very
much larger than usual. An appropriation of $15,000 is recommended
for continuing the improvement.
                                                                       APPROPRIATED.

                             Date.                                                                  Application.                             Amount.

June 23,1874......................Diking..........................................                                                             $50, 000
August 14, 1876....... ................                            Dredging..................................                                   10.000
June 18, 1878...................._.....do........................                                                      .............            15,000
June 14, 1880 ....................                                    do
                                                           .............     .........          .................................               29, 000
August 2,1882 ....................                       ..... do ...    ...................................                         1          40,000
July 5,1884.................................do ......................................                                                           10, 000
                                                                             Total........................                   . ..........      154, 000

   Amount expended, $154,000.
   NOTE.-The $50,000 appropriated June 23, 1874, was expended in diking, so that of the revised esti.
mate of 1881 only $104,000 have been appropriated, leaving $91,000 to be appropriated for the existing
project.
    This work is in the collection district of New York, which is the nearest port of
entry. Nearest light-house, Bergen Point Light. Nearest fort, Fort Tompkins.
Amount of revenue collected at the port of New York for fiscal year ending June 30,
1886, $132,536,402.02.
Original estimate, 1873 .....................                                                      ..........                                $443,210
Revised estimate, 1881 ..............................                                                              .......                    185,705



                                                                  Money statement.
July 1, 1885, amount available........................................                                                                        $397 47
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
outstanding July 1, 1885..........................              ....................                                                          397 47
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886 ...................                                                                      15,000 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887....................                                                                   15,000 00

    Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project .......                                                                  91,000 00
    Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1888                                                              35,000 00
    Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
      harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.


                                                                                E 25.
                           IMPROVEMENT OF PASSAIC RIVER, NEW JERSEY.

  The Passaic is one of the most important riv'ers of New Jersey, pass-
ing through the large manufacturing towns of Paterson, Dundee, Pas-
saic, Belleville, and Newark. Its course is very crooked down to Passaic,
whence its direction is generally southeast to the mouth below Newark,
where its junction with the Hackensack, coming from the north, forms
what is known as Newark Bay. The lower end of Newark Bay has two
outlets, one the Kill von Kull, towards the east, connecting it with New
            APPENDIX            E-REPORT                        OF LIEUT.-COL. MCFARLAND.                                            793
York Harbor, and the other, the Arthur Kill, or Staten Island Sound,
towards the south, connecting it with Raritan Bay.
   The Passaic is a tidal stream for 13 miles above the mouth, up to
Dundee Dam, 1 mile above Passaic. This dam was built by a private
company some years ago for the purpose of securing uninterrupted
water communication from Newark up to Paterson by means of a canal
around some heavy shoals. The canal has never been opened to traffic,
and is, as well as the reservoir above the dam, only used for water-
power.
   The city of Newark is situated about 4 miles above the mouth of the
Passaic.
   Since 1 80 the appropriations for this river have been divided, one
part being applied to that part of the river above Newark, and the other
to that part of the river below Newark, including the channel through
Newark Bay. The dividing line between these two improvements is
the Pennsylvania Railroad Bridge at Market streetin the city of Newark.
   (1) Above Newark, New Jersey.-the first survey of this part of the river
was ordered by act of March 3,1871, and was made in 1872 under direc-
tion of General (then Lieut. Col.) John Newton, Corps of Engineers.
The report on this survey may be found in Annual Report Chief of En-
gineers for 1872, page 805.
   The condition of the river at that time from Clark's Spool Factory,
above the Pennsylvania Railroad Bridge, up to Passaic, was a shallow,
rocky stream, with shifting sand and gravel bars interspersed with
bowlders. The depth of water over these bars gave only 21 to 3 feet at
mean low water, the range of tide at Passaic being 3 feet, and at New-
ark 4.7 feet. These bars were separated by pools and reaches having
from 8 to 10 feet water on them.
   The worst of these bars were:
                                                                                                                               Distance
                                                                                                                           above Pennsyl-
                                             Locality.                                                                      ania Railroad
                                                                                                                               Bridge.


Middle Bar, in the city of Newark........                         ............................                    feet..             9,000
Belleville Bar . ................................                                   ..................           miles..   I              3
Rutherford Park Bar........................................................do ...                                                         O6
Holsman's Bar.......................
                              ..........................................do....                                                            7


   There were other minor bars above Holsman's.
   The project based upon this survey was to obtain by dikes and
dredging, from the spool factory in Newark up to the head of naviga-
tion, a channel 100 feet wide and 6 feet deep at mean low water. The
estimated cost of this work was:
                                                                                                         6
                              Locality.                                                                  Application.             Amount,


Middle Bar ................................................ Dredging ....................            $936
      Do ................................................   Diking .....................           66,375
Belleville Bar......................................        Dredging...................            15, 501
Rutherford Park Bar ..................................            o ....................... 14,112
Holaman's Bar and other small bars......................... do ............             .. .....   12,000
                                                            Contingencies ...............        * 15, 000

       Total ........................               ..........................................                                      123, 924


   In addition to this estimate, which was called that for "limited" im-
provements, a second estimate was given for extended improvements of
$251,359, the first estimate being for a " partial" remedy for the ob-
stacles to navigation, the second a "thorough" remedy.
794    REPORT    OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

   The first appropriation for the improvement of the river was made
by act of June 10, 1872, $25,000, and under it, after advertisement, a
contract was let to Morris & Cumings, November 22, 1872, for dredging
at Belleville Bar, and work was begun in the spring of 1873. On coinm-
mencing work, outcroppings of bed rock of indurated sandstone and
shale were encountered in many places, and up to the close of the fisqal
year ending June 30, 1873, only 4,719 cubic yards of material had been
removed. This was placed along the eastern side of the channel
dredged, so as to form a dike parallel with the channel. The material
removed was used in building 750 feet of dike.
   By act of June 10, 1873, $25,000 was appropriated, and, after adver-
tisement, proposals were opened for dredging the bar at Rutherford
Park. The lowest bidder was James Caler, and a contract was made
with him for opening a cut through the bar 2,900 feet long, 50 feet wide,
and 6 feet deep.
   The contract in force with Morris & Cumings for dredging the Belle-
ville Bar at the close of the fiscal year ending June 30, 1873, was
extended first to December 31, 1873, and again to June 30, 1874, and
at the close of the fiscal year they had removed 5,8201 cubic yards of
stone and bowlders, and 3,8074 cubic yards of sand and gravel. The
contractor was not required under the contract to take out solid rock,
but as very much of this, consisting of indurated sandstone and shale,
was found as the work progressed, a small scow was purchased in
August, 1873, by the Government and fitted with one of the steam
drilling engines used in connection with the drilling and blasting at
Hell Gate and put on the work. So far as was known June 30, 1874,
all the rock had been broken up by the scow and mostly removed, but
no survey had been made.
   On Rutherford Park Bar work was continued throughout the year,
except during the winter. At the close of the fiscal year the work was
nearly completed, so the contract was extended to September 1, 1874.
Bed rock of the same character as in Belleville Bar was found on Ruth-
erford Park Bar, and some surface blasting was necessary.
   By act approved June 23, 1874, $20,000 was appropriated for continu-
ing the improvement.
   Early in the fiscal year ending June 30, 1875, Morris & Cumings fin-
ished their contract of November 22, 1872, for dredging the Belleville
Bar, having made a cut through it 2,300 feet long and 7.5 feet deep.
The upper 1,800 feet of the cut was 75 feet wide, from which point it
gradually widened to 120 feet at the lower end.
   The work at Rutherford Park Bar was also completed in December,
1874, under the contract with James Caler, the total length of the cut
being 2,900 feet, with a width of 50 feet, and a depth of 6 feet at mean
low water.
   The drill-scow, worked by hired labor, removed one large rock and
several small bowlders from the channel opposite Passaic.
   Under date of March 3, 1875, $20,000 was appropriated for continu-
ing the improvement, and the drill-scow was set at work early in the
fiscal year ending June 30, 1)76, removing some rock and bowlders in the
channel at the Belleville Bar. The burning of the Midland Railroad
Bridge August 1, 1875, caused a shoaling of the river both above and
in the draw-span.
   The drill scow also d(lid a little work on Rutherford Park Bar, consist-
ing of blasting off projecting points of rock. After this, the scow was
taken to Holsman's Bar, and commenced removing the stone from the
reef, followed by a dredge hired by the day. This work continued up
to the close of the fiscal year ending June 30, 1876, when a cut 40 feet
        APPENDIX    E-REPORT OF LIEUT.-COL. MCFARLAND.                 795
wide at bottom, 1,300 feet long, and 6 feet deep at mean low water had
been excavated through the reef.
   A small bar above Holsman's, 300 feet long, was also excavated by the
dredge.
   By act of August 14, 1876, $10,000 was appropriated for continuing
the improvement, but as it did not become avai able until April 1, 1877,
little was accomplished dluring the fical year ending June 30, 1877.
   In May, 1877, the drill-scow was taken to Belleville and Rutherford
Park bars to remove bowlders and loose stones from the sides of the cuts,
and up to the close of the fiscal year 395 cubic yards of material had
been removed, clearing up 6-5 feet of channel, and the same class of
work was carried on over these bars during 1877 and 1878. A small
shoal near the Erie Railroad Bridge was also removed.
   June 18, 1878, an appropriation of $10.000 was made, and the drill-
scow was set to work in August, 1878, near the bridgeof the Midland Rail-
road, and removed a quantity of railroad iron, ties, and stone, which ob-
structed the channel and draw of the bridge. The cuts through Hols.
man's and other bars down to and through the Erie Railroad Bridge
were widened 60 feet at the bottom with a dredge hired by-the hour,
the amount of material removed being 5,200 cubic yards of sand and
gravel and 270 cubic yards of clay. After this work was done the dredge
went down to the Midland Railroad Bridge, and removed 1,440 cubic
yards of clay and stone from the channel and draw of the bridge.
    During the months of April and May, 1879, the drill-scow removed
470 cubic yards of bowlders from the river near Passaic.
    By act of Congress applroved March 3, 1879, $2,000 was appropriated
for the improvement, making a balance available June 30, 1879, of
$4,562.69.
    By act of June 14, 1880, $2,000 more was made available.
    During the fiscal year ending June 30, 1880, the only operations con-
sisted in making a channel 40 feet wide and 240 feet long through a
gravel, bowlder, and stone bar opposite the Lodi Chemical Dock, about
1 mile above Passaic, with the drill-scow, and removing an old pier of
the New York, Lake Erie and WesterniRailroad Bridge, which obstructed
navigation, the railroad company agreeing to pay for the latter work.
    Based upon the recommendation of General Newton, in 1879, a sur-
vey of the Passaic from the Midland Railroad Bridge to the mouth was
made, and to which part of the funds available June 30, 1879, were ap-
plied.
    At this date, June 30, 1880, General Newton (page 538, Annual Re-
port Chief of Engineers, for 1880, Part I) states that a clear 6-foot
channel had been obtained from the Midland Railroad Bridge to Pas-
saic; 75 to 120 feet wide at Belleville Bar and 7.5 feet deep; 75 feet wide
at Rutherford Park Bar and 6 feet (leep; 60 feet wide at Holsman's Bar
and 6 feet deep, and that the dike at Belleville was 1,800 feet long.
    During the fiscal years ending June 30, 1881 and 1882, no work was
done.
    By act of August 2, 1882, $7,000 was appropriated, making the
amount available at that date, with the balance of the old appropria-
tion, $9,452.62.
    No work was done during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1883. But
an examination of the river in the spring of 1883 showed that from the
Midland to the Erie Railroad Bridge, a distance of about 2 miles, there
had been shoaling of the channel; and sealed proposals, atter adver-
tisement, were opened July 23, 1883, for dredging a 7.5-foot channel
through these shoals, 100 feet wide. The work was let to Mr. Frank
796            REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

Pidgeon, jr., the lowest bidder, at 382 cents per yard. Work was corn
menced September 4, 1883, and was completed December 9,1883, (luring
which time 19,190 cubic yards of sand and gravel were excavated.
   Two cuts were made, one 1,400 feet long, 60 feet wide, and 7.5 feet
deep, above Clark's Spool Factory Dock, and one above Point Pleasant,
abreast of Lime Kiln Dock, 2,370 feet long, the upper part 60 feet wide
and the lower 75 feet wide.
   During this fiscal year a survey of the Passaic River, with a view to
its improvement from Dundee to Paterson, N. J., was made under act
of August 2, 1882, and a report submitted April 10, 1884.
   By act of July 5, 1884, $3,000 were appropriated, and bids were
opened for the widening to 75 feet of Middle Bar and Limekiln Bar,
dredged the previous year to 601)feet.
   Richard Parrott was the lowest bidder, at 49 cents per cubic yard; but
owing to the lateness of the season, work was not commenced under his
contract till June 10, 1885. At the close of the fiscal year the channel
at Limekiln Bar had been widened to 75 feet by the excavation of 1,945
cubic yards of material.
   The contract was completed early in the fiscal year ending June 30,
1886, after the channel at Middle Bar had been, widened to 75 feet, by
the excavation of 1,029 cubic yards of material. Some bowlders in the
draws of the Midland Railroad Bridge were also excavated.
   The recommendation was made last year for $5,000 to extend the 7.5-
foot channel down to the Erie Railroad Bridge at Newark, and $2,250
was appropriated by act of August 5, 1886.
   A recent examination shows the channels to be in good condition,
and, in view of the smallness of the appropriation and the lateness of
the season, it would be better to wait till next spring to see if the ice
during the winter makes any marked changes in the channels before
deciding where to apply the appropriation.,
   The extension of the bulkheads along the water-fronts of the city of
Newark seem to render unnecessary the dike projected at Middle Bar.
   In 1882 a project was started to put a dam across the river at Belle-
ville to protect the interests of the water supply of Jersey City, but the
matter has been in the hands of the courts for several years and noth-
ing has been decided.
   The commerce of the Upper Passaic above Centre Street Bridge is
considerable, consisting in brick, coal, lumber, lime, cement, sulphur,
building-stone, ice, and sundries.
   The trade has materially increased of late years, and reference may
be had to the commercial statistics published in Annual Report Chief
of Engineers for 1884, Part I, page 739.
                                                               APPROPRIATIONS.

   Date.                                                                Application.                                                                   Amount.


June 10,     1872   Dredging at Belleville Bar ...............................................                    $25, 000
Mar. 3,      1873   Dredging at Rutherford Park Bar ..................                                              25, 000
                                                                                               ...........................
June 23,     1874   Dredging on all the bars above Belleville ...-..-.......................                        20000
Mar. 3,      1875   Removing bowlders at Rutherford Park and Belleville.................... . -                     20, 000
Aug. 14,     1876   Removing bowlders at Rutherford Park and Belleville...                                          10, 000         ..........
June 18, 1878        Dredging at Holsman's Bar and removing obstructions...                                                         .....                 10,000
Mar.    3,   1879    Dredging above Passaic                  ..........................                      ...................                           2, 000
June   14,   1880    Dredging between Midland & Erie Railroad Bridge .....................                                                                 2,009
Aug.    2,   1882   ...... do.........................................                            ..........            .........           ........       7, 000
July    5,   1884   ...... do ....................                        .............................................                                    3, 000
Aug.    5,   1886    Allotment................................................................                                                             2, 250

                             Total ......................                                 ...              ......................                        126, 250

Amount expended, $123,762.04.
            APPENDIX E-REPORT                          OF LIEUT.-COL.                              MCFARLAND.                797
                                            Money statement.
July 1, 1885, amount available-- .--......-......---.....-......---............---------------....                     $2,272 26
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885 .......                     -....................             .    ...- .   .....-   ....
                                                                                                                --      2,034 30
July 1, 1886, amount available ..........................................                                                   237 96
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886 ......---......----........                                          2, 250 00

Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887 ...................                                               2,487 96

  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project..-.....                                                7,512 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended inu fiscal year ending June 30,1888                                            7, 512 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
     harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (2) Below Newark, New Jersey.-In a project of operations submitted
April 18, 1879, for the Passaic River, it was recommended by General
(then Col.) John Newton, Corps of Engineers, that a survey of the
river should be made from the Midland Railroad Bridge to the mouth,
as no survey of it had been made by the Engineer Department up to
that time, except for a short distance below the Midland Railroad
Bridge.
   The project was approved by the Chief of Engineers May 9.1879, and
the survey was made under General Newton it. that year. The report upon
the survey can be found in Annual Report Chief of Engineers for 1880,
page 537. Soon after the report was made the Board of Trade of New-
ark urged the deepening of the channel from the Pennsylvania Railroad
Bridge to the mouth of the river, a distance of about 4 miles, and over
which there existed at that time a minimum depth of about 7 feet in a
narrow channel. As the commerce of Newark seemed to warrant a
depth of 10 feet in the channel, General Newton submitted the follow-
ing estimate for obtaining and maintaining a channel 200 feet wide and
10 feet deep at mean low water from the Pennsylvania Railroad Bridge
to the mouth of the river in Newark Bay, as follows:

               Locality.                                                    Application.                                Amount.


From Pennsylvania Railroad Bridge            28,000 cubic yards of dredging, at 20 cents ..........                          $5, 600
  to Zinc Works.                             1,500 linear feet of dike, at $8 .....................                          12, 000
                                            100,000 cubic yards dredging, at 20 cents ...........                            20, 000
From Zinc Works to Toll Bridge ...          1,200 linear feet of dike, at $8....................                              9,600
                                            4.800 linear feet of pile dike at $7.50 ...............                     .    36, 000
                                            168,000 cubic yards dredging, at 20 cents...........                             32, 600
From TollFrom
           Bridge to   N~ewark   Bay.   -   4,300 feet
                                                  feet of
                                            4,000         pile dike,
                                                       of pile       at $9........................
                                                               dike, at $12.........................
                                                                                                                             38,700
                                                                                                                             48, 000
                                            Contingencies, engineering, &c....................                               30, 375

                                                 Total ....................................                                 232, 870


   The proposed line of dike from the mouth into Newark Bay did not
follow the old channel to the westward of Passaic Light, but swung out
from the right bank in a gentle curve to the north and east of the light,
which would not only increase the scour from the Passaic and Hacken-
sack along the new channel, but reach the deep water of Newark Bay
sooner.
   By the act of June 14, 1880, $30,000 were appropriated for this im-
provement; and, after advertisement, bids were opened for the con-
struction of 2,000 feet of the dike at the mouth, to be built of two
rows of creosoted piles, set 8 feet apart from center to center and filled
with stone, the piles to have a penetration of 20 feet, and a contract
was let to the lowest bidder, Henry Du Bois Sons, at $9.25 per linear
foot of dike.
798     REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

   Work commenced November 26, 1880, and 2,002k linear feet of it was
com)leted May 10, 1881. It was built in two sections, one of 1,143 and
the other of 8594 feet, wyith a space of 4074 feet between them, where its
line crossed the old channel.
   By act of March 3, 1881, $50,000 was appropriated, but it was decided
not to commence dredging the channel along the dike till the whole
2,000 feet of dike should be completed. As soon as the contract for
diking was closed, a contract was let, after advertisement, to Mr. E. M.
Payn for dredging the channel along the line of the dike into Newark
Bay, at 13.9 cents per cubic yard.
   The dredging was begun May 23, 1881, and by the close of the fiscal
year 19,263 cubic yards of material had been excavated, giving a chan-
nel 50 feet wide and 10 feet deep from the 8 foot curve in the river to
the deep water in Newark Bay. This contract was closed August 24,
1881, and under it a total of 55,990 cubic yards had been excavated,
giving a channel 10 feet deep and 125 feet wide.
   On June 23, 1881, proposals were opened, after advertisement, for con-
tinuing the extension of the dike, and the contract was awarded to
Henry Du Bois Sons, at $13.25 per linear foot. Work was commenced
under this contract October 22, 1881, and closed January 31, 1882, dur-
ing which time 2,0034 feet of dike was completed, giving ita total length
of 4,0051 feet.
   Bids were opened October 18, 1881, for further dredging in the chan-
nel, and the contract awarded to Elijah Brainard, the lowest bidder, at
104 cents per cubic yarn. Work under this contract commenced No-
vember 14, 1881, and, with a three mou(nths' suspension in winter on ac-
count of ice, was still in progress at the close of the fiscal year ending
June 30, 1882, during which time 97,853 cubic yards of material were
excavated, giving a channel 200 feet wide and 10 feet deep from the
deep water of the bay 3,900 feet up-stream. Work under this contract
continued up to November 26, 1882, when the contract was closed. The
total amount of material excavated under it was 173,986 cubic yards,
which carried the channel with full width and depth from the bay
through the draws of the Newark and New York Railroad Bridge, and
the outlet into the bay was widened to 400 feet for a few hundred feet.
   The act of August 2, 1882, al)pprolpriattd $43,000 for continuing the
improvement, and, after advertisement, sealed proposals were opened
September 1, 1882, for continuing dredging, and the contract was
awarded to the lowest bidders, Morris & Cumings, at 224 cents per
yard. Work was begun October 23, 1882, and continued up to and was
still in progress at the close of the fiscal year ending June 30, 1883,
the amount of material removed up to that time being 55,007 cubic
yards.
   In order to give shipping the immediate benefit of the improved chan-
nel, the width originally l)roposed of '200 feet was reduced to 130 feet
for a distance of 1,000 feet above        Newark and New York Railroad
                                         .the
Bridge, and to 100 feet for a further distance of 6,000 feet up-stream.
   Up to the close of this fiscal year, under the different con tracts, a total
of 284,992 cubic yards of material had been removed from the channel
since the beginning of the work, and ihe original amount estimated to
give a 10-foot channel 200 feet widle from the mouth up to the Pennsyl-
vania Railroad Bridge was 291,000 cubic yards, measured in place;
but owing to the material being measured in scows and to having to dig
a little below the depth and the side slopes, the original estimate, it is
stated on page 573, Annual Report Chief of Engineers for 1883, Part I,
would have to be largely increased.
          APPENDIX E-REPORT                                      OF LIEUT.-COL. MCFARLAND.                                 799
   No appropriation was made during the fiscal year ending June 30,
1884, but with the balance of the appropriation of -1882 work was con-
tinued under the contract with Morris & Cumings up to May 27, 1884,
when the contract exp)ired. Since June 30, 1883, to that date 110,221
cubic yards of material were excavated, making a total number of yards
removed from the channel under it of 165,228. With this a channel 10
feet deep and from 100 to 125 feet wide had been carried up-stream
from the end of last year's work to the Pennsylvania Bridge.
   During the winter of 1883-'84 the shore end of the dike was damaged
by ice, and $391.40 were spent on its repair by hired labor.
   In his annual report for 1884 Colonel Gillespie (then in charge) esti-
mates that the completion of the existing project for dredging a 200-foot
channel in the river 10 feet deep and building 5,000 feet of dike opposite
the zinc works would cost $85,000, but he calls attention to the fact that
shoals existed in Newark Bay with less water on them than in' the
dredged channel of the river, and that if the 10 foot channel were ex-
tended down the bay the cost would be, approximately-
8,000 feet of pile-diking, at $12 ............................................ $96,000
100,000 cubic yards dredging, at 25 cents.....    ...........................   25,000

      Total--------......--......----............------------....------...------------------...........-----....--.....   121,000
and that therefore $150,000 (exclusive of the $25,000 appropriated by
act of July 5, 1884) was asked for to complete a channel 200 feet wide and
10 feet deep in the river and through the shoals in the bay.
   This appropriation of July 5, 1884, was wholly applied to the bay.
   After advertisement, sealed proposals were opened September 17,1884,
and a contract was awarded to Henry 1)u Bois Sons, the lowest bidder,
for building 700 feet, more or less, of dike extension, at $18 per foot, and
for dredging 70,000 cubic yards, more or less, from the shoal in Newark
Bay.
   Work on the extension of the dike commenced November 13, 1881,
and 699 feet had been completed by May 15, 1885, when the contract was
closed. This extension gave the dike a total completed length of 4,705
feet.
   Du Bois's contract for dredging was extended to September 1, 1885,
and on the 30th of June, 1885, 34,509 cubic yards of material had been
excavated, giving a channel through the shoal of 10 feet deep at mean
low water, 100 feet wide, and 2,000 feet -long.
   The dike, at a point about 2,000 feet from the shore end, was dam-
aged during the winter by an ice-jam, and arrangements were being
made to have it repaired by the contractors.
   No appropriation was made during the year ending June 30, 1886, but
with the balance of the appropriation of 1884 dredging the shoal in the
bay was coutinued under the contract in force up to December 19, 1885,
during which time 28,056 cubic yards were excavated, making a total
excavated from this shoal under the contract of 62,565 cubic yards, and
giving a channel through the shoal of 2,000 feet long, 200 feet wide, and
10 feet deep, so that 10 feet at mean low water could be carried up to
Newark Bay and up the Passaic River to the Pennsylvania Railroad
Bridge in Newark.,
   The repairs necessary to the dike mentioned in 1885 were made by
hired labor at a cost of $1,309.65. Of the existing project, at the close
of the fiscal year ending June 30, 1886, the following work remained to
be done:
   Extension of the dike in Newark Bay 7,300 feet, and a light extension
1,000 feet long built at the head of the dike to protect the bank.
800              REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

       The dike in the river opposite the zinc works, 5,000 feet long, has not
been commencel, and the channel from the Newark and New York
Railroad Bridge up to the Pennsylvania Railroad Bridge, which now has
a width of from 100 to 130 feet, should be dredged to full width of 200
feet. The estimated cost of this work is given in 1884 as $125,000.
  A recent examination shows the dike and the channels to be in good
condition, and the allotment of $24,000 from the appropriation of
August 5, 1886, for this part of the river and the bay will be applied to
extending the dike in Newark Bay southward, at ruling rates hereto-
fore.         This amount should build about 1,000 feet, and leave a little over
for any contingencies that may arise.
  The city of Newark has a population of 150,000 persons and has 1,400
manufacturing establishments.
The commerce of the river has slightly increased since the improve-
ment commenced, and is done mostly in vessels drawing over 10 feet,
and steamboats.
  In 1882, 22,000 vessels passed the draw of the Newark and New York Railroad, with
freight worth $1,000,000.
  In 1883, 20,581 vessels passed the draw of the Newark and New York Railroad, with
freight worth $1,000,000.
  In 1884, 22,986 vessels passed the draw of the Newark and New York Railroad, with
freight worth $1,200,000.
       During the past two years it has been said to be about the same.
                                                                 APPROPRIATIONS.


        Date.                                                             Application.                               Amount.


June 14,1880...         Building 4,006 feet of dike at the mouth ...................................                    $30, 000
March 8, 1881..         Dredging at the mouth and up the river...................      ............                      50,000
August 2, 1882          Dredging in the river....                                                                        43, 000
July 5, 1884....        Building 699 feet of dike at mouth and dredging in Newark Bay.....          .                    25, 000
August 5, 1886. Allotment .........                         ...........................................                     24, 000
                                                                                                                        172, 000

SAmount expended, $147,427.18.

       The original estimate was $232,875.
  But this did not include the $121,000 estimated to be required in the
modified estimate of 1884 for continuing the improvement through the
shoal in Newark Bay.
  Passaic River is in the collection district of Newark, which is the nearest port of
entry; nearest light-house, Passaic Light, at the lower end of the dike in Newark
Bay. Fort Tompkins is the nearest fort. Amount of revenue collected during the
fiscal year ending June 30, 1886, $2,326.70.

                                                              Money statement.
July     1,   1885,   amount    available..............................                                   ......    6,711       12
July 1, 1886, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1885..-........-..........................---------......                                     6,138 30

                                                           ------------
July 1, 1886, amount available...-..-....................................    572 82
Amount appropriated by act approved August 5, 1886 ....-----------...............
                                                                      -   24,000 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1887....................                                          24,572 82
   Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project........                                          181,875 00
   Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1888 125, 000 00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
     harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
                                             INDEX.

                                                                                            Page.
                                SUBJECT.

                                                                                  Part I.   Part IL Part III.

                                     A.
Advisory Harbor Commission at Philadelphia.........                              123            849
Ahnapee Harbor, Wis., improvement of...............                              297                      1662
Alabama River, improvement of......................                              201           1171
Allegheny River, Pa., improvement of                    ................         273                      1544
Allegheny River, look and dam at Herr's Island.......                            273                      1545
Alpena Harbor, Mich., improvement of ...............                             321 .                    1825
Altamaha River, Ga., improvement of                     ...... .........         186           1105
Amite River, La., improvement of...................                              213           1239
Annapolis Harbor, Md., improvement of .............                              134            877
Ann, Cape, Mass., construction of harbor of refuge at
  Rockport ..............                            .........................    67 580
Apalachicola Bay, Fla., improvement of............193                                          1140
Apalachicola River, Fla., improvement of ............                            196           1153
Appomattox River, Va., improvement of.............                               150            958
Aqueduct bridge across Potomac at Georgetown, exam-
  ination of..........................................                           148            931
Aransas Pass and Bay, Tex., improvement of                        .........      226           1330
Archer's Hope River, Va., improvement of ............                            152            962
Arkansas River, from Fort Gibson to Wichita, survey
  of ...............................................                             244           1391
Arkansas River, from Little Rock to its mouth, survey
  of ..........................................                                  244           1389
Arkansas River, at Pine Bluff, improvement of........                            238           1375
Arkansas River, operations of snag-boats on ..........                           238           1371
Ashland Harbof, Wis., in Ashland Bay, Lake Superior,
examination and survey of.........................  301                                                  1674
Ashley River, S. C., improvement of                  ..................
                                                     179                                       1080
Ashtabula Harbor, Ohio, improvement of .............                             337                      1871
Au Sable Harbor, Mich., improvement of .............                             321                      1825
                  -B.


Baltimore, defenses of ...............................               28
Baltimore Harbor, improvement of entrance to........ 133                                       874
Bangor Harbor, Me., improvement of.................                  55 530
Battalion of Engineers ...............................               53 489
Bay of Superior, Wis., improvement of.............                  288                                   1632
Bayou Bartholomew, La. and Ark., improvement of... 231                                         1353
Bayou Black, La., improvement of ............                      217
                                                       ..-----------------.....                1261
Bayou Bmuf, La., improvement of ....................                231                        1354
Bayou Courtableau, La., improvement of............. 218                                        1263
Bayou D'Arbonne, La., improvement of ...............                             232           1356
Bayou La Fourche, La., improvement of.............. 219                                        1266
Bayou Macon, La., improvement of ...............                                 232           1355
Bayou Pierre, La., survey of ......................... 229                                     1343
Bayou Teche, connecting with Grand Lake............ 216                                        1259
Bayou Teche, La., improvement of .................                               215           1245
Bayou Terrebonne, La., improvement of.............                               219           1264
Beaufort, N. C., to New Berne, inland navigation be-
   tween, improvement of..........................                               163           983
Beaufort, N. C., defenses of........................                              33
Beaufort Harbor, N. C., improvement of ..............                            164           986
                                                                                                      1
2                                                    INDEX.


                                                                                                Page.
                               SUBJECT.

                                                                                Part I.     Part II. Part III.

Belfast Harbor, Me., improvement of..............       . 56 535
Belle River, Mich., ice harbor at .................... .324                                                   1837
Big Black River, Miss.,  improvement   of..............   236                                    •1365
Big Hatchie River, Tenn., improvement of ........... 236                                          1366
Big Sandy River, W. Va. and Ky., improvement of.... 284                                                       1618
Big Sunflower River, Miss., improvement of ..........     234                                     1359
Biloxi, Miss., improvement of harbor at ....209                                                   1205
Black Lake Harbor, Mich., improvement of........ ..                             314                           1768
Black River, Ark. and La., improvement of ..........                            230               1351
Black River, Ark. and Mo., improvement of.........                              240               1377
Black River Harbor, Ohio, improvement of...........                             333                           1861
Black Rock Harbor, Conn., improvement of ..........                              87 646
Black Warrior River, Ala., improvement of...........                            208               1199
Blackwater River, Va., improvement of......                      ........       152                961
Block Island, R. I., construction of harbor of refrge at.                        77 609
Board of Engineers, special, on fortifications, &c ......                           499
Board of Engineers for Fortifications and for River
  and Harbor Improvements...... .......             ....            -......      48
Bmuf River, La., improvement of .................                               231                1354
Boston, Mass., defenses of..............                   ...........           12
Boston Harbor, Mass., improvement of.... ......                             .    63 564
Brazos River, Tex., improvement of mouth of.........                            225                1327
Brazos Santiago, Tex., improvement of harbor at......                           226                1334
Breton Bay, Md., improvement of...................                              140                 901
Bridge, Aqueduct, at Georgetown, D. C., examination of.                         148                 931
Bridge, new, across Potomac River at Washington, D.
  C., plans for........................................892
Bridge across Alabama River at Selma, Ala........... 370                                                      2136
Bridge across Mississippi River at Keithsburg, Ill..... 369                                                   2111
Bridge across Mississippi River at Minneapolis, Minn.. 369                                                    2111
Bridge across Ohio River at Cairo, Ill................. 369                                                   2116
Bridge across Ohio River at Henderson, Ky..........       370                                                 2137
Bridging navigable waters of the United States....... 369                                                     2111
Bridgeport Harbor, Conn., improvement of............ 86 644
Broad Creek, Del., improvement of ................        128                                       863
Broadkiln River, Del., improvement of..............       128                                       862
Brown, Fort, Tex., protection of river bank at........ 227                                         1386
Brunswick Harbor, Ga., improvement of ...........      .. 187                                      1112
Buckbannon River, W. Va., improvement of.... ......       286                                                 1624
Buffalo Bayou, Tex., improvement of..................     225                                      1325
Buffalo Harbor, N. Y., improvement of................340                                                      1881
Burlington Harbor, Vt., improvement of.............349                                                        1903
Buttermilk Channel, New York Harbor, improvement
  of .........         ...............................     97 720

                                    C.
Cahaba River, Ala., improvement of ...............      202                                        1173
Calcasieu River and Pass, La., improvement of....... 220                                           1276
Caloosahatchee River, Fla., improvement of .......... 196                                          1152
Calumet Harbor, Ill., improvement of................307                                     I             1   1704
Calumet River, improvement of ....................      308                                                   1707
Canal at the Cascades, Columbia River, Oreg., con-
  struction of................. .................. 358                                                        1942
Canal at Des Moines Rapids, Mississippi River........ 253                                          1465
Canal, Hennepin, additional surveys for.............309                                                       1708
Canal, Louisville and Portland, operating and main-
  taining.....................            ............  277                                                   1574
Canal, Muscle Shoals, Tennessee River, construction of. 265                                                   1510
Canal, Saint Clair Flats, Mich............. .....                         ..    324                           1837
Canal, Saint Mary's Falls, Mich ..   . ...........                              319                           1783
Canarsie Bay, N. Y., improvement of ................                            101   746
Cane River, La., improvement of...................230                                              1349
                                                    INDEX.                                                      3

                                                                                                Page.
                             SUBJECT.

                                                                                    Part I.     Part II. Part III.

Caney Fork River, Tenn., improvement of ............                                269                      1523
Cape Ann, Mass., construction of harbor of refuge at
  Rockport     .............------------------------------                           67             580
Cape Fear Diver, N. C., improvement of, below Wil-
          ....-......-............................
  mington---                                         ....                           168            1000
Cape Fear River, N. C., improvement of, from Wil-
  mington to Fayetteville .......................                                   166             995
Cedar Keys Harbor, Fla., improvement of.............                                195            1148
Cedar River, Mich., improvement at mouth of .......                                 293                      1650
Channel between Staten Island and New Jersey, im-
  provement of ....................................                                 110   788
Charenton Canal, Saint Mary's Parish, La., improve-
ment of...........               ........................                          216            1259
Charleston, S. C., defenses of....            ..           .....                     34
Charleston Harbor, S. C., improvement of .      .                                   176            1063
Charlevoix Harbor, Mich., improvement of ...........                                309               .      1755
Charlotte Harbor, N. Y., improvement of ..                         ---...........   342                      1887
Chattahoochee River, Ala. and Ga., improvement of... 200                                           1168
Cheboygan Harbor, Mich., improvement of........... 320                                                       1824
Cheesequakes Creek, N. J., improvement of........... 106                                  763
Chehalis River, Wash., improvement of. .............                        364                              2009
Chesapeake Bay, removals of wrecks in ..............                        135                     878
Chester River, Md., at Kent Island Narrows, improve-
  ment of...........................................                        130                     866
Chester River, Md., from Spry's Lauding to Crumpton,
  improvement of....                               ........................ 130                     8t66
Chicago Harbor, Ill., impiovement of.................306                                                     1701
Chickahominy River, Va., improvement of.                                    145                    920
Chippewa River, Wis., improvement of.............. 258                                            1486
Chippewa River at Yellow Banks, Wis., improvement
  of.................................................                       259                   1488
Choctawhatchee River, Fla. and Ala., improvement of. 203                                          1176
Choptank River, Md., improvement of ...............                         131                    868
Cincinnati, Ohio, construction of ice harbor near..... 275                                                   1549
Clearwater River, Idaho, improvement of Lower..... 360                                                       1952
Cleveland Harbor, Ohio, improvement of............                          394                              1863
Clinch River, Tenn., improvement of................268                                                       1521
Clinton Harbor, Conn., improvement of................ 83                                  634
Clinton River, Mich., improvement of entrance to.... 32.5                                                    1842
Coanjok Bay, N. C., improvement of.................                         154                     965
Cocheco River, N. H., improvement of...............                          59           548
Cohansey Creek. N. J., improvement of..............                         122                     847
Colorado River, Cal. Nev. and AriS., improvement of.. 356                                                    1929
Columbia River, Oreg., construction of canal at the
  Cascades ....................................                             358                              1942
Columbia River, Oreg., defenses of ..................                        47
Columbia River, Lower, Oreg., improvement of....... 357                                                      1938
Columbia River, Oreg., improvement of mouth of...... 360                                                     1971
Columbia River, Upper, and Snake River, Oreg., im-
  provement of ....................................                         359                              1949
Columbia River, above mouth of Snake River, survey of 360                                                    1953
Columbia River, Oreg., water-gauges on Lower........ 365                                                     2010
Conecuh-Escambia River,Fla. and Ala., improvement of 203                                          1175
Conneaut Harbor, Ohio, improvement of .............                         338                              1873
Connecticut River, above Hartford, Conn., improve-
  ment of ..-              -......................................           81           623
Connecticut River, below Hartford, Conn., improve-t
  ment of...........................................                         82           625
Contentnia Creek, N. C., improvement of............. 159                                           973
Coosa River, Ala. and Ga., improvement of...........                        200                   1165
Coosawattee River, Ga., improvement of.............                         199                   1165
4                                            INDEX.


                                                                                  Page.
                          SUBJECT.
                                                                      Part I.     Part II.   Part III.

Coos Bay, Oreg., improvement of entrance to ......                    361                         1989
Coquille River, Oreg., improvement of mouth of......                  362                        2003
Corsica Creek, Md., improvement of..................                  131             867
Courtableau Bayou, La., improvement of .............                  218            1263
Cowlitz River, Wash., &c., improvement of...........                  359                         1952
Cumberland River, above the mouth of the Jellico, Ky.,
improvement of-......-...............-....--         ....--- ....    267                         1517
Cumberland River, Ky., South Fork of, improvement of.                 270                         1525
Cumberland River, Tenn. and Ky., improvement of.. .                   266                         1515
Cumberland Sound, Fla. and Ga., defenses of .........                  37
Cumberland Sound, Fla. and Ga., improvement of en-
trance to ..........................................                 189            1118
Currituck Sound, improvement of ....................                  154             965
Cypress Bayou, Tex. and La., improvement of ........                  229            1347

                               D.
Dan River, Va. and N. C., improvement of......               ......   146              925
D'Arbonne Bayou, La., improvement of...............                   232             1356
Davis Island, lock and dam, Ohio River, operating and
  care of ............................................                272                         1540
Defenses of the northern frontier.....................5
Defenses, sea-coast and lake frontier, general remarks
  on and estimates for................................                  4
Delaware Breakwater Harbor, improvement of ........                   119              839
Delaware Bay, construction of ice-harbor.at head of...                118              834
Delaware Bay and River, removal of wrecks from.....                   123              847
Delaware River:
    between Trenton and its mouth, improvement of..                   113              801
    at Schooner Ledge, improvement of ..............                  115              828
    near Cherry Island Flats, improvement of........                  115              829
Des Moines Rapids Canal, Mississippi River, operating
  and care of-.....................................     -             254             1468
Des Moines Rapids Canal, Mississippi River, dry
  dock at.............................................                254             1477
Des Moines Rapids, Mississippi River, improvement at.                 253             1465
Detroit River, Mich., improvement of -------------                    326                         1842
Dorcheat Bayou, La., improvement of ................                  230             1350
Dry Tortugas Harbor, Fla., defenses at...............39
Dubuque, Iowa, improvement of harbor at............                   252             1424
Dubuque, Iowa, ice-harbor at .....................                    252             1426
Duck Creek, Del., improvement of....................126                                859
Duck River, Tenn., improvement of..................269                                            1523
Duluth Harbor, Minn., improvement of...............                   287                         1627
Dunkirk Harbor, N. Y., improvement of ..............   338                                        1874
Duties and rank of officers of the Corps of Engineers. 375
                                E.
Eagle Harbor, Mich., improvement of           ................        291                         1643
East Chester Creek, N. Y., improvement of-----............             91   663
East River, N. Y., removal of obstructions from.......                 95   675
Echo Harbor, New Rochelle, N. Y., improvement of...                    89   655
Edenton Bay, N. C., improvement of................                    154              963
Edisto River, S. C., improvement of..................                 179             1082
Elizabeth River, N. J., improvement of...............                 110   785
Elk River, W. Va., improvement of ..................                  281                         1598
Engineer depot and post at Willets Point.............                  52   471
Engineers, battalion of....    - -   .       ..-----------             53   489
Engineers, Board of, for Fortifications and for River
    and Harbor Improvements...................               ......    48
Engineers, School of Application at Willets Point, N.Y. 52                  471
Erie Harbor, Pa., improvement of ........     ......... 339                                       1879
                                                   INDEX.                                               5

                                                                                       Page.
                            SUBJECT.
                                                                           Part I.     Part II.   Part IIL

Escambia River, Ala., and Fla.. improvement of- .... 203                                   1175
Estimates for surveys and examinations, and contin-
  gencies of rivers and harbors...................--------------------.... 365
Explorations and reconnaissances in military divisions
                      ------------------------------ 372
  and departments.................................
Explorations and reconnaissances, estimates for, in
  military divisions and departments........373
                                  F.
Fairport Harbor (Grand River), Ohio, improvement of.                     336                          1868
Falls of Saint Anthony, Minn., preservation of .......                   255              1479
Falls of the Ohio River, improvement of, navigation at                   276                          1569
Feather River, Cal., improvement of .................                    355                          1926
Fernandina and Saint John's River, Fla., deepening
  the inside passage between ........................ 190                                 1124
Fishways at Great Falls of Potomac River...........368                 2061
                                                          199     1162
Flint River, Ga., improvement of .................------------------....
Flushing Bay, N. Y., improvement of.................91        661
Fort Brown, Tex., protection of river bank at........ 227         1336
Fortifications, report of special board on............... 50 499
Fox and Wisconsin rivers, improvement of .........        304          1686
Frankford Creek, Pa., improvement of...... ........       116      829
Frankfort Harbor, Mich., improvement of............310                 1737
French Broad River, N. C., improvement of ........... 147          929
French Broad River, Tenn., improvement of.......... 268                1520
                                  G.
Galveston, Tex., defenses of ..........................                   45
Galveston Bay, ship channel in, improvement of ......                    224              1322
Galveston Harbor, Tex., improvement of entrance to .                     223              1291
Gasconade River, Mo., improvement of ...............                     247              1396
Gedney's Channel, New York Harbor, N.Y............                         98    724
Georgetown and Washington harbors, D. C., improve-
  ment of ..........................................                     135               879
Georgetown Harbor, S. C., improvement of...........                      172              1027
Qoose Rapids, Red River of the North, Minn. and Dak.                     262              1500
Gowanus Bay, N. Y., improvement of...... ...........                      98 722
Grand Haven Harbor, Mich., improvement of.........                       314                          1766
Grand Marais, Mich., harbor of refuge at..............                   292                          1646
Grand Marais, Minn., improvement of, harbor at ......                    289                          1637
Grand River, Mich., improvement of .........                  ....... 314                             1766
Grass River, N. Y., improvement of, at Massena ....... 347           1898
Great Kanawha River, W. Va., improvement of...... 279                1589
Great Kanawha River, W. Va., construction of harbor
                                                        275          1550
  of refuge at mouth of ............................--------------------------.
Great Pee Dee River, S. C., improvement of ...........  169     1017
Great Sodus Harbor, N. Y., improvement of............ 344            1890
Green Bay, Wis.. improvement of harbor at............   296          1658
Green Jacket Shoal, Providence River, R. I., removal of 75 605
Greenport Harbor, N. Y., improvement of .............    90 658
Guyandotte River, W. Va., improvement of............ 285             1622
                                  H.
Hampton Roads, Va., defenses of..................30
Harbor of refuge, Block Island, R. I., construction of.                    77 609
Harbor of refuge, Bell River, Mich., construction of...                   324                         1837
Harbor of refuge near Cincinnati, Ohio, construction of.                  275                         1549
Harbor of refuge, Grand Marais, Mich.................                     292                         1646
Harbor of refuge, Great Kanawha River, W. Va., con-
struction of ...............     ....................                    275                         1549
                                                      INDEX.


                                                                                         Page.
                              SUBJECT.Pae
                                                                           Part I.       Part II.   Part III.

Harbor of refuge, Lake Pepin, Mississippi River, con-
struction of........................................251                                1422,1424
Harbor of refuge, Milwaukee Bay, construction of ....                     301                           1679
Harbor of refuge, Portage Lake, Lake Michigan, con-
  struction of -----------------------------------
                         ..                                               310                           1758
Harbor of refuge, Sand Beach, Lake Huron ..........                       322                           1829
Harbor of refuge, Sandy Bay, Cape Ann, Mass., con-
  struction of.....................................                        67 580
Harbor of refuge, Stonington, Conn., construction of.                      78 614
Harbor of refuge, Sturgeon Bay Canal, Wis., construc-
  tion of............................................                     296                           1660
Harbor of refuge, Wood's Holl, Mass., construction of.                     69 591
Harlem River, N. Y., improvement of.................                       94 672
Hay Lake Channel, Saint Mary's River, Mich., im-
  provement of ......................................                     318                           1777
Hell Gate, N. Y., improvement of navigation at.......                      95    675
Hennepin Canal, additional surveys of....                       .....     309                           1708
Hiawassee River, Tenn., improvement of                -........           267                           1519
Horn Island Pass, Miss., improvement of ..                                210               1206
Housatonic River, Conn., improvement of .............  85                        642
Hudson River, N. Y., improvement of-.... ..            92                        665
Humboldt Bay and Harbor, Cal., improvement of....... 353                                                1919
Huron Harbor, Ohio, improvement of..                  .............
                                                      332                                               1858
Hyannis Harbor, Mass., improvement of..                68..........              585
                                  I.
Ice-harbor at Belle River, Mich., construction of ...... 324                                            1837
Ice-harbor, near Cincinnati, Ohio, construction of-..... 275                                            1549
Ice-harbor at head of Delaware Bay..................118                                      834
Ice-harbor at Dubuque, Iowa........................-----------. 252                         1426
Ice-harbor at Marcus Hook, Pa., construction of-...... 117                                   832
Ice-harbor at mouth of Muskingum River.............274                                                  1546
Ice-harbor at New Castle, Del......            ....         ..            125                858
Illinois River, improvement of..   .......                                308                           1705
                                       ----------------
Indian River, Del., improvement of...........                             129                864
Inland navigation from New Berne to Beaufort, N. C.,
   improvement of......---................----........                    163                983
Inside passage between Fernandina and Saint John's
   River, Fla., improvement of...... ..................                   190               1124
                                 J.
James River, Va., improvement of ....................                     137                887
Jetties at South Pass of the Mississippi River, inspec-
  tion of.............-......................      . .....
                                                     .... 212                               1225
Jonesport, Me., improvement of Moos-a-bec Bar at ....      55 533
                                  K.
Kanawha River, Great, improvement of ....-.......... 279                                                1589
Kanawaha River, Great, construction of harbor of
refuge at mouth of.................................                          275                       1550
Kanawha River, Little, improvement of.. ....                                  285                       1623
Kennebec River, Me., defenses of .....................                          8
Kennebunk River, Me., improvement                     ..............
                                                    of--------------           57 543
Kenosha Harbor, Wis., improvement of...............                           303                       1684
Kent Island Narrows, Md., improvement of.----------130                                       866
Kentucky River, Ky., improvement of-......-......--                  --- .... 282                       1603
Kentucky River, Ky., operating and keeping in repair
lock and dams on..................................                           283                       1610
Kewaunee Harbor, Mich., improvement of............ 297                                                  1663
                                            INDEX.


                                                                                Page.
                          SUBJECT.

                                                                   Part I.      Part II. Part III.

Keyport Harbor, N. J., improvement of ...............              105 760
Key West, Fla., defenses of........................38
Key West, Fla., improvement of harbor at...... ......              194             1144
                             L.
La Fourche Bayou, La., improvement of............                  219             1266
La Grange Bayou, Fla., improvement of .............                204             1178
Lake Bisteneau, La., improvement of................                230             1350
Lake City, Minn., construction of harbor of refuge at..            251             1424
Lake Huron, harbor of refuge on, at Sand Beach, Mich.              322,                       1829
Lakes, northern and northwestern, issue of charts of..             371
L'Anguille River, Ark, improvement of ..............               243             1388
Laws of Forty-ninth Congress, first session, affecting
  Corps of Engineers.............................                  395
Leonardtown Harbor, Md., improvement of ...........                140              901
Lewes, Del., construction of piers at ................             118              836
Little Harbor, at Portsmouth, N. H., improvement of..               59
Little Kanawha River, W. Va., improvement of ......                285                        1623
Little Narragansett Bay, R. I., and Conn., improve-
  ment of...........................................                78 613
Little Sodus Harbor, N. Y., improvement of..........               344                        1891
Little Tennessee River, improvement of............270                                         1524
Loggy Bayou, La., improvement of...................                230              1350
Louisville and Portland Canal, operating and main-
  taining .......................................                  277                        1574
Lower Clearwater River, Idaho, improvement of          --......-   360                        1952
Lower Willamette and Columbia rivers, Oreg., im-
provement of......................................357                                        1938
Lubec Channel, Me., improvement of .................   54 527
Ludington Harbor, Mich., improvement of............ 312                                       1761
Lynn Harbor, Mass., improvement of................. 65 577
                             1'.

Malden River, Mass., improvement of..           ..........          66    579
Mamaroneck Harbor. N. Y., improvement of........                    90    657
Manasquan River, N. J., improvement of.............                102    751
Manatee River, Fla., improvement of...............                 195             1150
Manistee Harbor, Mich., improvement of.............                311                        1759
Manistique Harbor, Mich., improvement of.........                  293                        1649
Manitowoc Harbor, Wis., improvement of.............                299                        1667
Mantua Creek, N. J., improvement of................                121              844
Maps, military and geographical, preparation of......              371
Marcus Hook, Pa., improvement of ice-harbor at......               117              832
Marquette Harbor, Mich., improvement of ............               291                        1645
Matagorda Bay, Tex., improvement of entrance to...                 225             1328
Mattaponi River, Va., improvement of ................              143              915
Mattawan Creek, N. J., improvement of..............                105    761
Maurice River, N. J., improvement of ...............               124              855
Meeker's Island, Minn., lock and dam at.............               257             1485
Meherrin River, N. C., improvement of...............               155              965
Menomonee Harbor, Mich. and Wis., improvement of . 294                                        1652
Merrimac River, Mass., improvement of ..............                61    560
Michigan City Harbor, Ind., improvement of..........               316                        1774
Military and geographical maps printed ..............              371
Milford Harbor, Conn., improvement of ..............                85 640
Milwaukee Bay, construction of harbor of refuge at...              301                        1679
Milwaukee Harbor, Wis., improvement of ............                302                        1680
Minnesota River, Minn., improvement of ............                260             1494
Mispillion Creek, Del., improvement of...............              127              861
Mississippi (Lower) and Missouri rivers, operations of
snag-boats on----...........-....    ...............              244                        1393
8                                                               INDEX.


                                                                                                            Page.
                                     SUBJECT.

                                                                                               Part I.     Part II. Part III.

Mississippi River:
    above Falls of Saint Anthony, improvement of....                                           256             1483
    at Des Moines Rapids, improvement of ...........                                           253             1465
    at Dubuque, Iowa, improvement of                                 -------------             252             1424
    at Falls of Saint Anthony, improvement of--  ....----....                                  255             1479
    at Lake Pepin, construction of harbor of refuge-..                                         251         1422,1424
    at Meeker's Island, Minn., construction of lock and
      dam...........................................                                           257             1485
    at Rock Island Rapids, improvement of ..-........                                          252             1427
    between the mouths of the Illinois and Ohio rivers,
          improvement of.............---                  -----------                          249
       from Des Moines Rapids to mouth of Illinois River,
         improvement of .................-..............                                       249,251         1422
       from Saint Paul to Des Moines Rapids, improve-
         ment of.....................------.---.----             .                             250             1412
       improvement of South Pass, inspection of ........                                       212             1225
       reservoir at sources of--.... ...-           _.--........                               363             1501
       snag-boats on, operations of......                        ................              244             1393
    Upper, operations of snag-boats on---------...............      250                                        1403
    water-gauges on .........................-                   -
                                                               .... 237                                        1368
Mississippi River Commission, report of..............-247                                                                2143
Mississippi Sound, defense of.............42
Missouri River :
    between Sioux City and Fort Benton, improve-
      ment of-------------------------
               ..................................-------            248
    snag-boats on, operations of.-------------------245                                                        1394
Missouri River Commission, report of.---.------------ 248                                                                2167
Mobile, Ala., defenses of............................-.              41
Mobile Harbor, Ala., improvement of--...-..........                 205                                        1183
Mollumne River, Cal., improvement oft...........                    355                                                  1924
Monbngahela River, improvement of. .                                     .    ....             273                       1542
Monongahela River, operating and care of lock and
dam No. 9- ...............       ..-------             _.._..----                             273                       1543
Monroe Harbor, Mich., improvement                             ----------------- 326                                      1847
Moose-a-bee Bar, Jonesport, Me., improvement of.....                                            55 533
Mount Vernon, Va., improvemeat of channel at.......                                            139              899
Movable dam at Davis Island, Ohio River                                 ------------           272                       1540
Muscle Shoals Canal, Tennessee River, construction of.                                         265                       1510
MuskegonHarbor, Mich., improvement of ............                                             313                       1764
Muskingum River, construction of ice-harbor at-......                                          274                       1546
Muskingum River, Ohio, improvement of..........--..                                            274                       1547
Muskingum River, Ohio, examination and survey of..                                             276                       1551
                                          N.
Nantucket Harbor, Mass., improvement of                                  ............           68   587
Narragansett Bay, defenses of--... .                                               .-..          14
Narragansett Bay, R. I., improvement of ..............                                          74 602
Neabsco Creek, Va., improvement of
Neches River, Tex., improvement of...... .....
                                                               ..........                      140              901
                                                                                               222             1288
Neuse River, N. C., improvement of- ......                                                     162979
New Bedford, Mass., defenses of...                               .-       .----------           14
New Berne and Beaufort, N. C., inland navigation be-
  tween, improvement of .------------------------                                          .   163              983
Newburyport Harbor, Mass., improvement of .........                                             60   557
New Castle, Del., ice-harbor at---.......................            ---                       125              858
New Haven Harbor, Conn., construction of break-
           ......----------......---......-----------......---......---------......---......
  water at-----                                                                                 84   639
New Haven Harbor, Conn., defenses of ................                                           17
New Haven Harbor, Conn., improvement of--------                            ......... L.         84   636
New London Harbor, Conn., defenses of...............                                            15
New London Harbor, Conn., improvement of..........                                              83   632
New Orleans, La., defenses of .......................                                           42
                                                     INDEX.                                          9

                                                                                     Page.
                                 SUBJECT.
                                                                          Part I.    Part II. Part III.

Newport Harbor, R. I., improvement of..............75                          606
New River, N. C., improvement of....................                     165             991
New River, Va., and W. Va., improvement of......... 281                                            1599
New Rochelle Harbor, N. Y., improvement at.........        89 654
Newtown Creek, N. Y., improvement of.....................  96 717
New York Harbor, defenses of........................17
New York Harbor, Gedney's Channel in, improvement
  of .............................................         98 724
Niagara River, N. Y., improvement of.................341                                           1884
Nomini Creek, Va., improvement of................         141                            903
Nootsack River, Wash., improvement of............364                                              2007
Norfolk Harbor, Va,, and its approaches, improvement
  of ............................                    .... 148                            951
Northern frontier, defenses of                ........................     5
Northern and Northwestern Lakes, issue of charts of.. 371
North Landing River, Va., and N. C., improvement of. 153                                 962
North River Bar, Currituck Sound, N. C., improve-
  ment of.-..........................                                    154             965
Norwalk Harbor, Conn., improvement of...........       88                      649
Nottaway River, Va., improvement of ................  151                                961
Noxubee River, Miss., improvement of................208                                 1201
                                             0.
Oakland Harbor, Cal., improvement of................350                                            1907
Oak Orchard Harbor, N. Y., improvement of.......... 342                                            1886
Obstructions to navigation, remarks on removal of... 81                        619
Ocmulgee River, Ga., improvement of................198                                  1159
Oconee River, Ga., improvement of .................     198                             1161
Oconto Harbor, Wis., improvement of............'....294                                           1653
Office of the Chief of Engineers...................... 374
Officers of the Corps of Engineers, number of duties of   3
Ogdensburg Harbor, N. Y., improvement of........... 346                                            1895
Ohio River, construction of ice-harbor, near Cincin-
  nati....    .........................................                  275                       1549
Ohio River, Davis Island lock and dam.............     272                                        1540
Ohio River, improvement of Indiana Chute at Falls of 276                                          1572
Ohio River, improvement of.........................    271                                        1528
Ohio River, improvement of falls of .................. 276                                        1569
Olcott Harbor, N. Y., improvement of ...............   341                                        1885
Old Town Creek, Miss., improvement of..............    208                              1200
Ontonagon Harbor, Mich., improvement of .........                        290                       1641
Oostenaula River, Ga., improvement of ............                       199            1165
Osage River, Mo. and Kans., improvement of .........                     246            1395
Oswego Harbor, N. Y., improvement of..............                       345                       1892
Otter Creek, Vt., improvement of ..................                      350                       1905
Ouachita River, La. and Ark., improvement of ......                      230            1351

                                        P.
Pamplico River, N. C., improvement of ..............                     156             966
Pamunky River, Va., improvement of .............                         144             917
Pascagoula River, Miss., improvement of .............                    209            1203
Pascagoul River, Miss., from Moss Point to anchor-
  age in bay, examination and survey of.............                     211            1215
Passaic River, N. J., above Newark, improvement of...-                   111 793
Passaic River, N. J., below Newark, improvement of                   -   112 797
Pass Cavallo Inlet, Tex., improvement of .............                   225            1328
Patapsco River, Md., improvement of ...............                      133             874
Pawcatuck River, R. I., improvement of.............80                        616
Pawtucket River, R. I., improvement of ..............                     73   598
Pearl River, Miss., improvement of, between Edinburg
  and Carthage............-....................211                                      1214
10                                                       INDEX.


                                                                                           Page.
                                  SUBJECT.

                                                                                Part I.    Part II.   Part III.

Pearl River, Miss., improvement of, below Jackson .... 210                                    1207
Pearl River, Miss., improvement of, from Jackson to
  Carthage ..........................................                210                      1212
Pease Creek,Fla., improvement of .........                           195                      1146
Pee Dee River, Great, S. C., improvement of ..........               169                      1017
Penobscot River, Me., defenses of.... ............... .....            7.
Penobscot River, Me., improvement of .................                55 530
Pensacola Harbor, Fla., defenses of.                   .............  40
Pensacola Harbor, Fla., improvement of......                       .........
                                                                     204                      1179
Pensaukee Harbor, Mich., improvement of............. 295                                                  1656
Pentwater Harbor, Mich., improvement of.....                         312                                  1762
Philadelphia Advisory Harbor Commission..........123                                           849
Philadelphia, Pa., defenses of........................25
Pier at Lewes, Del., construction of...............                  118                       836
Plattsburg Harbor, N. Y., improvement of............                 348                                  1902
Plymouth Harbor, Mass., improvement of............64                      571
Portage Lake, Mich., construction of harbor of refuge
   at ................................................               310                                  1758
Port Chester Harbor, N. Y., improvement of..........                  88 651
Port Clinton Harbor, Ohio, improvement of ..........                 329                                  1854
Port Jefferson Harbor, L. I., N. Y., improvement of...                90 660
Portland Harbor, Me., defenses of.....................                 8
Portland Harbor, Me., improvement of ............                     57 538
Portsmouth Harbor, N. H., defenses of................                 10
Portsmouth Harbor, N. H., improvement of..........58,546, 541
Port-warden's line at Philadelphia ...................               123                       849
Port Washington Harbor, Wis., improvement of...... 300                                                    1672
Post and depot at Willets Point ...................                             52   471
Potomac River, improvement of, in vicinity of Wash-
ington, D. C.................     .................                           136             881
Potomac River, fish-ways at Great Falls of...........368                                                  2061
Potomac River at Mount Vernon .                           ......               139             899
Providence River, R. I., improvement of............     74                           602
Proviicetown Harbor, Mass., improvement of......... 65                               574
Public buildings and grounds, District of Columbia.... 368                                                2075
Pultneyville Harber, N. Y., improvement of........... 343                                                 1889
                          R.
Raccoon River, N. J., improvement of...               ........                 121             844
Racine Harbor, Wis,, improvement of ................                           30                         1682
Rahway River, N. J., improvement of...........109                                    783
Rancocas River, N. J., improvement of...............                           120             841
Rank and duties, officers of Engineers ................                        375
Rappahannock River, Va., improvement of.... .....                              142             906
Raritan Bay, N.J., improvement of .................                            106 765
Raritan River, N. J., improvement of.................                          107 769
Reconnaissances and explorations and estimates for...                          372
Red River, La., improvement of..................227                                           1337
Red River of the North, improvement of...... .......                           261            1496
Red River of the North, construction of lock and dam
  at Goose Rapids         ............................                         262            1500
Red wood Harbor, Cal., improvement of ..............                           352                        1914
Reservoirs at sources of the Mississippi River and its
  tributaries, construction of....              ......       ............      263            1501
Reservoirs at sources of the Mississippi River and its
  tributaries, surveys for.............................                        264           1507
Rio Grande, Tex., protection of river banks at Fort
  Brown .......................................                                227           1336
River and harbor improvements..                       ................          53
Roanoke River, N. C., improvement of                               .....       147             927
Rock Island Rapids, Mississippi River, improvement at. 252                                   1427
Rockland Harbor, Me., improvement of..............56                                 536
Rocky River, Ohio, improvement of..................334                                                    1862
                                                                    INDEX.                                       11

                                                                                                  Page.
                                           SUBJECT.
                                                                                      Part I.     Part II. Part. III.

Romerly Marsh, Ga., improvement of water-route
   through ......------.....................................   --------               185            1102
Rondout Harbor, N. Y., improvement of.............                                     94 670
Rouse's Point, N. Y., construction of breakwater at...                                348                        1899
                                                  S.
Sabine Pass, Tex., improvement of                    .............                  221              1278
Sabine River, La. and Tex., improvement of.......... 222                                             1287
Sackett's Harbor, N. Y., improvement of .............                               346                          1894
Saco River, Me., breakwater at mouth of .............                                58     546
Saco River, Me., examination and survey of ..........                                60     552
Sacramento River, Cal., improvement of .............                                355                          1926
Saginaw River, Mich., improvement of ...............                                322                          1826
Saint Anthony, preservation of Falls of...............255                                            1479
Saint Augustine Creek, Ga., improvement of..........185                                              1102
Saint Augustine, Fla., defenses of ...................                               38
Saint Clair Flats Ship-canal, Mich., repairs of ........                            324                         1837
Saint Clair Flats Ship-canal, Mich., operating and care
  of........... ................................                                    325                         1838
Saint Croix River, Wis. and Minn., improvement of... 259                                             1490
Saint Francis River, Ark., improvement of ...........                               242              1382
Saint Jerome's Creek, Md., improvement of harbor                                                      904
  at ....................................                                       ..- 141
Saint John's River and Fernandina, Fla., deepening                                                   1124
  inside passage between........................... 1
Saint John's River, Fla., improvement of bar at mouth
  of................................................                                190              1125
Saint John's River, Fla., Upper, improvement of...... 191                                            1133
Saint Jones River, Del., improvement of.............. 126                                             860
Saint Joseph's Harbor, Mich., improvement of........ 316                                                         1771
Saint Mary's Falls Canal and Saint Mary's River,
  Mich., improvement of............................                                 319                          1783
Saint Mary's Falls Canal, Mich., dry-dock at .........                              320                          1823
Saint Mary's Falls Canal, Mich., operating canal at... 319                                                       1809
Saint Mary's River, Mich., improvement of Hay Lake
  Channel. ..........................                      ............- . .        318                          1777
Salem River, N. J., improvement of .................                                122               846
Saline River, Ark.,"improvement of ...........                              ......  243              1387
Salkiehatchie River, S. C., improvement of ..........                               180              1084
Sand Beach, Mich., Lake Huron, harbor of refuge at.. 322                                                         1829
San Diego, Cal., defenses of..........................                               45
San Diego Harbor, Cal., improvement of...---.......... 353                                                       1917
Sandusky City Harbor, Ohio, improvement of......... 3:30                                                         1855
Sandusky River, Ohio, improvement of ..............                                 331                          1857
Sandy Bay, Cape Ann, Mass., harbor of refuge at...... 67                                    580
San Francisco, Cal., defenses of ......................                              45
San Francisco Harbor, Cal., removal of wreck from.... 352                                                        1915
San Joaquin River, Cal., improvement of.............                                354                          1921
Santee River, S. C., improvement of......                         ..........        173              1030
Saugatuck Harbor, Mich., improvement of ............                                315                          1769
Saugerties Harbor, N. Y., improvement of............93                                      669
Savannah, Ga., defenses of .......................                                   36
Savannah River and Harbor, Ga., improvement of ....                                   181            1087
Savannah River, Ga., above Augusta, improvement of..                                  184            1100
Savannah River, Ga., below Augusta, improvement
  of .............................................                                    183            1098
School of Application, Battalion of Engineers.........                                 53 489
Schuylkill River, Pa., improvement of .. .                                   ......   116             830
Scituate Harbor, Mass., improvement of -............                                   62 562
Scuppernong River, N. C., improvement of ...........                                  158             969
Sea-coast and lake frontier defenses, general remarks
  on and estimates for..............................                                   4
12                                             INDEX.


                                                                                          Page.
                          SUBJECT.

                                                                               Part I.    Part II. Part III.

Sheboygan Harbor, Wis., improvement of.............                           299                       1670
Sheepshead Bay, N.Y., improvement of ...--.-....... -                         100   743
Shenandoah River, Va. and W. Va., improvement of...                           139             891
Shrewsbury River N. J., improvement of..............                          103   756
Skagit River, Wash., improvement of.................                          364                       2007
Snag-boats on the Arkansas, operations of...........238                                      1371
Snag-boats on the Lower Mississippi and Missouri,
  operations of..     ............................                            244            1393
Snake River, Wash., improvement of ................                           359                       1949
Snohomish River, Wash., improvement of ............                           364                       2007
Snoqualmie River, Wash., improvement of......                  .              364                       2007
Sodus Harbor, N. Y., Great, improvement of .........                          344                       1890-
Sodus Harbor, N. Y., Little, improvement of ..........                        344                       1891
South Forked Deer River, Tenn., improvements of ...                           237            1367
South Haven Harbor, Mich., improvement of .........                           315                       1770
South Pass, Mississippi River, inspection of improve-
  ment at. ......--  ......---...................-...---......                212            1225
Southport Harbor, Conn., improvement of ............                           87   648
South River, N. J., improvement of.... ...............                        108   777
Staten Island, N. Y., improvement of New Jersey
  Channel .         .      .        .      .          .                 .     110   788
Staunton River, Va., improvement of........                                   145   146   922,924
Steele's Bayou, Miss., improvement of.........235                                            1363
Steilaquamish River, Wash., improvement of ........                         4 364                       2007
Stockholm, Wis., construction of harbor of refuge at ..                       251            1422
Stonington Harbor, Conn., improvement of                  ...........          78   614
Sturgeon Bay Canal, Wis., harbor of refuge at ........                        296                       1660
Sumpawanus Inlet, L. I., N. Y., improvement of ......                         102   748
Sunflower River, Miss., improvement of.......234                                            1359
Superior Bay, Wis., improvement of ..                ........                 288                       1632
Survey of Northern and Northwestern lakes, issue of
  charts of...._................ ..........            .........              371
Surveys and examinations for improvement of rivers
  and harbors, estimates for .........................                        365
Surveys, additional, for Hennepin Canal..............                         309                       1708
Susquehanna River, near Havre de Grace, Md., im-
  provement of .....................................                          129             864
Suwanee River, Fla., improvement of ................                          194            1143
Swanton Harbor, Vt., improvement of......                                     348                       1901
                               T.
Tallahatchie River, Miss., improvement of ...             ......              234            1361
Tallapoosa River, Ala., improvement of......       .........                  201            1172
Tampa Bay, Fla., improvement of ..................                            192            1137
Tampa Bay, Fla., removal of wreck from........ ...                           199             1159
Tangipahoa River, La., improvement of ..............                         213             1241
Tar River, N. C., improvement of..........                                   156              966
Taunton River, Mass., improvement of......                 ..........          72   595
Tchefuncte River, La., improvement of ...............                         214            1242
Tchula Lake, Miss., improvement of ..................                         234            1360
Teche Bayou, La., connection with Grand Lake, at
  Charenton.........................................                          216            1259
Teche Bayou, La., improvement of ...................                          215            1245
Tennessee River, above Chattanooga, improvement of.                           264                       1509
Tennessee River, below Chattanooga, improvement of.                           265                       1510
Tennessee River, Little, improvement of ..............                        270                       1524
Tensas River, La., improvement of....-.............                           232            1355
Terrebonne Bayou, La., improvement of ...............                         219            1264
Tickfaw River, La., improvement of..................                          215            1244
Thames River, Conn., improvement of ..........                                 82   629
Thunder Bay Harbor, Mich ..........................                           321                       1825
Ticonderoga River, N. Y., improvement of              ............            350                       1905
                                                       INDEX.                                      13

                                                                                  Page.
                                    SUBJECT.

                                                                       Part I.    Part II. Part III.

Toledo Harbor, Ohio, improvement of ..............               ..   327                         1349
Tombigbee River, Ala., improvement of .............                   206            1196
Torpedo defense.....................................                   50
Totusky River, Va., himprovement of.......... ........                142             913
Tradewater River, Ky., improvement of..-....            -.......      284                         1617
Trent River, N. C., improvement of...................                 160             976
Trinity River, Tex., improvement of..................                 224            1323
Two Rivers Harbor, Wis., improvement of               .  ....         298                         1665
                                         'I.
Umpqua River, Oreg., improvement of ................                  363                        2005
Upper Columbia and Snake rivers, Oreg. and Wash.,
improvements of .................................                    359                         1949
Upper Mississippi River, operations of snag-boats on..                250            1403
Upper Thoroughfare, Deal's Island, and main.........                  132             870
Upper Willamette River, Oreg., improvement of......                   258                        1940
Urbana Creek, Va., improvement of ..................                  143             914
                                          V.
Vermillion Harbor, Ohio, improvement of ............                  332                        1859
Volusia Bar, Lake George, Fla., improvement of ......                 192            1135
                                        we
Wabash River, Ind., improvement of................. 277                                          1582
Waccemaw River, N. C., improvement of ............. 170                             1022
Wachita River, Ark. and La., improvement of ........                  230           1351
Wacissa River, Fla., examination and survey of....... 212                           1220
Wappoo Cut, S. C., improvement of..............178                                  1077
Wareham Harbor, Mass., improvement of. ............                    70   593
Warren River, R. I., improvement of ................                   75   605
Warrior River, Ala., improvement of.................                  206           1193
Washington Aqueduct, D. C .......................                     365                        2013
Washington, D. C., defenses of......................                   29
Washington and Georgetown harbors, D. C., improve-
ment of.......................................                       135            879
Washington, D. C., improvement of Potomac River at. 136                              881
Washington, D. C., increasing water supply of ....... 366                                   2021, 2043
Wateree River, S. C. improvement of................. 174                            1053
Water-gauges on Mississippi River and its tributaries. 237                          1368
Water-gauges on Columbia River, Oreg., and tribu-
taries......................                      .................. 365                        2010
Waukegan Harbor, Ill., improvement of .............                   303                        1685
Westport Harbor, Mass., improvement of.............70                       592
White River, Ark., improvement of.. .................. 240                          1378
White River, Ark., above Buffalo Shoals, improve-
mentof...........................................                    241           1381
White River Harbor, Mich., improvement of ......... 313                                          1763
White River, Ind., improvement of...................                  279                        1586
Wicomico River, Md., improvement of...............                    132            869
Willamette River, Lower, Oreg., improvement of ..... 357                                         1938
Willamette River, Upper, Oreg., improvement of ..                     358                        1940
Willets Point, N. Y., engineer post and depot at......                 53   489
Wilmington Harbor, Cal., improvement of............351                                           1911
Wilmington Harbor, Del., improvement of............124                               857
Wilmington, N. C., defenses of. ..........................             34
Wilson Harbor, N. Y., improvement of ................                 341                        1885
Wisconsin and Fox rivers, improvement of ........... 304                                         1686
Withlacoochee River, Fla., improvement of.......... 197                             1155
Woodbridge Creek, N. J., improvement of........... 109                      781
14                                         INDEX.


                                                                           Page.
                          SUBJECT.

                                                                 Part I.   Part II.   Part III.

Woodbury Creek, N. J., improvement of.............. 121                        843
Wood's Holl Harbor, Mass., improvement of
Wrecks in Cape Fear River, removal of ..............
                                                    ..........
                                                       69 591
                                                      175                     1060
Wrecks in Chesapeake Bay, removal of...............135                         878
Wrecks in Delaware Bay and River, removal of ...... 123                        847
Wrecks in Fairport Harbor, Ohio, removal of......... 339                                  1876
Wrecks in New Orleans Harbor, La.,'removal of....     223                     120
Wrecks in North Carolina and Virginia, removal of... 159                       970
Wreck in San Francisco Harbor, Cal., removal of..... 352                                  1915
Wreck in Scuppernong River, N. C., removal of....... 159                       970
Wreck in Tampa Bay, Fla., removal of...............197                        1157
Wrecks off Cape Cod, removal of.....................80    618
Wreck off entrance to Narragansett Bay..............81    619
                             V.
Yadkin River, N. C., improvement of.................             157           967
Yalabusha River, Miss., improvement of..............             235          1362
Yaquina Bay, Oreg., improvement of entrance to .....             362                      1998
Yazoo River, Miss., improvement of ......      ..........        233          1357
Yellowstone River, improvement of ..................             249          1399
York River, Va., improvement of.....................             144           918


                                               O
